Scotland in dreamland – Football Weekly

19 Nov 2025 · 59 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Notes: Football Weekly - Scotland in Dreamland

Episode Overview In this episode of Football Weekly, hosted by Max Rushden, the panel discusses Scotland's thrilling qualification for the World Cup after a dramatic win against Denmark. The guests include Barry Glendenning, Ali Maxwell, and Sanny Rudravajhala, who share their insights and emotional reactions to the match and Scotland's journey in football.

Key Highlights

Scotland's World Cup Qualification

  • Match Result: Scotland 4 - Denmark 2
  • Significant Moments:
  • Andy Robertson's emotional post-match interview, recalling his friend Diogo Jota.
  • Scott McTominay’s memorable overhead kick.
  • Kieran Tierney's incredible curling goal, which was pivotal in the match.

Emotional Reactions

  • Fans expressed a mix of joy and disbelief at Scotland's qualification after so many years.
  • Personal anecdotes from fans reflected on past disappointments in Scottish football, creating a sense of catharsis with this win.
  • Guests shared their own experiences, with Barry stating he felt a connection to the emotional rollercoaster of Scotland’s history in football.

Analysis of the Match

  • The panel discussed the overall gameplay, highlighting:
  • Scotland’s shaky moments despite leading, including Denmark's temporary comeback.
  • The controversial red card for Denmark, which led to tactical changes by Scotland’s manager, Steve Clarke.
  • The quality of goals scored by Scotland, placing McLean's goal among the best in Scottish football history.

Player Performances

  • Notable mentions:
  • Kenny McLean: Criticized previously, but redeemed himself with a stunning goal.
  • John McGinn: His actions during the match sparked discussions about the team's dynamics.
  • Andy Robertson: A key player who struggled in the match but displayed emotional depth in interviews post-game.

Reflections on Steve Clarke

  • The panel recognized Clarke's achievement in leading Scotland to their first World Cup since 1998.
  • Discussion included the potential for Scotland’s performance in the World Cup and predictions for their group stage matches.

Wales' Performance

  • A brief mention of Wales’ impressive 7-1 victory over North Macedonia, which also secured a favorable playoff draw.
  • Ellis James shared his excitement about Wales’ performance but acknowledged that Scotland’s victory overshadowed it in media coverage.

Curacao's Historic Qualification

  • Curacao and Panama's qualification for the World Cup was highlighted, marking a historic moment for smaller footballing nations.

Felix White's Book Segment

  • Felix White, a guest, discussed his book “Whatever Will Be Will Be,” which reflects on his experiences with football and life, touching on themes of loss and community in football.
  • The book captures the essence of lower league football, exploring the connections and stories found in the game beyond just the scores.

Conclusion

  • The episode ended with reflections on the emotional and cultural significance of football for fans, celebrating the highs and lows that come with supporting national teams.

Key Takeaways

  • Scotland’s qualification was a moment of joy and relief for fans, marking the end of a long wait.
  • Emotional narratives surrounding football create strong community bonds among supporters.
  • The panel's discussions highlighted the importance of legacy, hope, and the unpredictable nature of football.

---

This episode effectively combined humor, nostalgia, and deep emotional insights, capturing the essence of what football means to fans, particularly in the context of national pride and identity.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This is The Guardian.

0:30Frankly, the way they played, there was no guarantee of them managing that. But it doesn't matter. The Titan Army will be there, led by Andy Robertson. And if the final moments didn't move you, his post-match interview talking about Diogo Jota will. And we haven't even mentioned Scott McTominay's overhead kick. Elsewhere, Wales score seven, bracket seven, to give them a favourable playoff draw. Panama and Curaçao qualify. We might have a minute for EFL, but we probably won't, before writer, singer, broadcaster, Felix White of the Maccabees' tail-enders, amongst other things, will come on to talk about his new book, Whatever Will Be Will Be.

0:57It's brilliant. We'll answer your questions and that's today's Guardian Football Weekly.

1:08On the panel today, Barry Glendening, welcome. Hi Max. From Not The Top 20 pod, Ali Maxwell, hello. Hello. Sani Rudrovadzian, welcome. Hello. And I'm excited about this. Barster Jim, Jim Burke. Morning my friends. There's all vibes today Mike, there's all vibes. oh yeah the analysis is just bones oh I mean let me read a couple of messages we've got David says I genuinely cannot tell you Max I was 9 when David Seaman saved Gary McAllister's penalty 11 when Morocco thrashed us in Saint-Etienne and then spent my entire teenage years and adult life dealing with failure glorious failures and ignominious failures decades of last minute winners for the other team playing well but losing goal difference snatching victory from us of watching World Cups with jealousy of listening to Barney Ronnaie, wondering if winning the World Cup is even a good thing.

2:00I'm 40 next year, and on this night, it all seemed worth it. A beautiful, joyous, ridiculous, mad, brilliant game of football that a nation will never forget. Incredible goals. What a campaign. What a game. So incredibly un-Scottish. God, football, what a game. And Scott says, Max, I've never, ever messaged, but I have to. I'm 32. I was five when Scotland last made it to a World Cup. And that was the biggest relief of my life. I've watched it since the early 2000s. I was there at Hampden in 07 when Italy robbed us. I can't stop crying. Every time I say we're going to the World Cup, I burst into tears again.

2:33Work tomorrow may be tough, but this is the best night of following Scotland. We're going to the fucking World Cup. So Scotland 4, Denmark 2. Where do we start, Jim? How are you? How are you? Mate, just to echo that first one, the last time you were in the World Cup for me was two marriages, two countries and three cities ago.

3:00There's a context right there. Mate, I never thought it was going to happen, ever. And the thing is, the way we did the campaign, it was really quite a short campaign, you know, the way the fixtures were. We started well against Denmark and Belarus and then we just kept getting worse, you know because when we beat Greece 3-1 it was like a real robbery because we got outplayed for an hour so you know I think I said to you earlier there's a reason you don't ever hear the expression luck of the Scottish right we don't get that stuff but last night oh my god the only thing is I have to say anybody that follows me in blue sky my account did get hacked

3:52somebody may have criticised Steve Clark somebody the person who ever hacked it did say Kenny fucking McLean at one point right and that was before the goal honestly I was absolutely buzzing really I ended up staying up to about one o 'clock that I was so I was just buzzing absolutely buzzing there's this there's that's this thing you're right when when a game makes you so breathless you can't sleep but obviously it's the daytime for me and i was just consuming this content like the the bbc scotland tv commentary which is steve thompson with james mcfadden and mcfadden's like he's done him he's done him like when kenny mcclain's shot of the radio comms is alistair and michael stewart is absolutely amazing it's just amazing and there is something barry about that Kenny McLean strike, there is a view from behind the goal where all his teammates are slowly realising that they are definitely going to the World Cup.

4:52It is an amazing moment. Yeah, I think it was Stephen Thompson who spotted Schmeichel off his line and shouted, shoot, shoot, he's done him, he's done him. And at this point, people watching the screen didn't realise just where Kasper Schmeichel was. and McLean, who I was less than complimentary about when he came on to replace Ben Gannondalk on the group chat as well. I apologise, Kenny. I think, I mean, I loved that game and I'm delighted for Scotland. And of the many highlights last night, I think one of my favourite was John McGinn's post-match interview where he said that Kenny McLean takes a lot of criticism.

5:42Some of it isn't deserved.

5:49I just had a big laugh at that. Whether it was an intentional dig or a bit of fun or just he didn't quite realise what he was saying, I don't know. But what a goal that was. I mean, three of those goals last night, with apologies to Lauren Shanklin, They've got to be in the top four Scottish goals of all time. I suppose Archie Gemmell's probably still number one, is he? But the three that weren't Shanklins were just brilliant goals. And I thought Scotland were going to blow it again, even after Denmark had a man sent off. And I was not in any way comfortable for them until Kenny McLean scored that brilliant, brilliant goal.

6:36I mean, if he does nothing else again in his career, and there's a very good chance he will do nothing else again in his career, he will always have that. Just watch it on a loop for the rest of his life, show the grandkids, et cetera, and so on. Fantastic. I mean, I was almost as chuffed last night for Scotland as I was when Troy Parrott scored that late late winner on Sunday. just delighted for them. Yeah, I was weeping in a cafe in Melbourne, just like when I couldn't believe, I couldn't believe Tierneys went in. And then I couldn't believe, when Kenny McLean hit the ball, Ali, there's this, I mean, of all the videos, there's, I think, Copper90 tweeted out, that's where I saw it.

7:18And David Squires was texting me going, he was yelling at Kenny McLean to play Che Adams in, which is the right pass. But there's one in this pub, this packed pub somewhere in Scotland, there's this one bloke going, what are you doing? and then suddenly it just erupts. It's just like, oh, it's just the timing is priceless. Yeah, I mean, that's probably because Kenny McLean attempted to dribble past a defender, which I can't remember seeing him do in at least 10 years of playing championship football for Norwich. I certainly haven't seen him do anything like that. I mean, when I thought of top Scotland goals in my own memory, as Baz was talking there, I thought James McFadden might get his second mention of the pod so far for that amazing goal in France.

8:03And I suppose I think back to 1998, which I think everyone has their favourite World Cup, don't they? And inevitably it's either the first one that you remember when you fell in love with football and 1998 was that for me. I had the VHS of all the goals from all the games and the very first game was Brazil-Scotland. And so, you know, also with the surname Maxwell, there's a lot of Scottish in my extended family and ancestry. So just echoing what everyone else has said, kind of couldn't quite believe the quality of the goals as it happened and just want to say that Kieran Tierney sent Scotland to the World Cup.

8:44I think it's worth saying that amidst all of this, it was Tierney's goal and what an unbelievable connection to get the curl on it. One of the reverse angles just shows how nicely it bent into the corner. Kieran Tierney's shot was the most important of all, really. And I'm really, really delighted for him. Yeah, because he's had a really tough time, hasn't he, recently. A friend of mine, Fraser, he texted me, we watched Scotland's last game on our gap year, you'll be pleased to know, Barca Jim. Very on brand, you know, on the East Coast of Australia. And he was like, I can't believe it's been this long.

9:23I've had to wait this long to see Scotland. He's one of those English guys who, when he talks to his parents, he goes totally Scottish. You know, that's, you know. Another moment, Sandy, we've got to talk about Andy Robertson. Afterwards, talking about Diogo Jota, he said, I've been in bits today. I had my mate Diogo Jota in my head all day. We spoke so much about the World Cup. We always discuss what it'd be like going to a World Cup. I know he'll be somewhere smiling over me tonight. I couldn't get him out of my head today. I'm just so glad it's ended this way. And like, if you weren't weeping at just, you know, the delight of the celebration, that really was such a moment, I thought.

9:56yeah that that was wonderful and in fact all the players who came and had post-match interviews on the touchline were were excellent as well but yeah really touching moment i mean andy robertson in in the game i mean the thing that really stood out for me as far as playing was when he had loads of space at about 10 yards of space on the left flank and it was 2-2 and it's like hooked a ball out for a goal kick and you're just like what on earth are you doing out of all the players who've got that great delivery that was just absolutely awful um and yeah i don't think he had a particularly great game but then you know especially as a you know I've got no Scottish blood in in my ancestry as far as I know but um I suppose you inevitably think wider and then think about how he must be going getting on in general and then all the Liverpool players as well and that's something we've touched on the pod before but yeah it kind of gave an extra bit of context and the fact yeah he was in bits and he said he was he was keeping it from his teammates there as well.

10:52He's not only having to deal with, I think he was saying about how he dreamt about going to the World Cup with Diogo. They both talked about it, right? He's kept all that from his teammates. He's one of the senior pros. He's had to bottle all that up. And you could see, yeah, he was so emotional. You could see him kind of welling up. And yeah, fair play to him for being so honest. And in that moment, kind of having the presence of mind to articulate that. And I'm sure that would have resonated, you know, not just with Liverpool fans of his teammates, but anyone kind of struggling with grief and how it kind of takes up a part of you, even when you're in your highest moments, lowest moments, it's always there.

11:30And I think what he said really will resonate with a lot of people and fair play to him. And yeah, thoroughly deserving of going through to the World Cup. Brilliant. And look, we're 12 minutes in, Jim, and we haven't mentioned a Scotsman scoring an overhead kick. Like a brilliant one at that. The thing is, you were saying, Barry, about the Archie Gemmell goal. I've got issues with that goal because it was effectively a consolation goal in the overall scheme of things. And I was petrified that McTominay's goal was going to not mean anything. Because I think to be a truly great goal has got to mean something.

12:05So that was another aspect. But I didn't realise there was arguably going to be two better goals than that scored after it. But just one other thing that we've not touched on yet. John McGinn he bought that red card didn't he? Oh yeah Wow Wow Have you banished this morning right? Oh my God I mean at first it looked a stonewaller then you looked at it again you're like that wow wow we absolutely got away with one then but again that was for me that was going to play into the narrative even when we get a fortunate red card we still can't go over the line. And I just can't believe so many of these narratives went out the window.

12:49Still buzzing. No apology for it. Absolutely buzzing. And actually Ali, that's true, isn't it? Because Denmark actually sort of got better with 10 men. And then even when Scotland scored, you were like, okay, Schenberg scored. This is done. And then for Denmark to equalise again, you were like, you can't believe that. You're sitting there going, how have they balls this up? And like, objectively, Scotland were lousy. There was a moment when I know they score early, so then they're going to sit back. But it was like Denmark had 17 shots and Scotland won. They didn't really do anything apart from just score some brilliant goals.

13:20Yeah. Well, look, football is at its best when there is as much jeopardy on it as possible. And in order to get to these situations, you do need the qualifying campaigns. You need the international breaks that lead up to it. And, you know, obviously doing the England pod, I am pro-international football, pro-international breaks where some others aren't. But I think if you're a real casual, general international break hater and you watch this and the Ireland game and anything else that comes and you don't appreciate that you need the build-up and you need the football to be played in order to enjoy these moments, which are better than anything league football can provide.

13:58I really believe that. Cup finals, European cup finals, you can rank those wherever you want. But when it comes to the international stage and these moments, and then you have the major tournaments on top, which of course can ramp up even higher. So I think that there's also a specific way that football looks, even at a very, very high level, when both teams have so much riding on it and the nerves are so visible and tangible and, you know, team shape and tactical systems broadly go out the window. and that's my favourite kind of football and that's kind of what we saw here and I think even, you know, the poor lad, was it Hulman who's sliced clearance set up the shot from Tierney.

14:39Clearly, to say that was a horror mistake would be wrong. Tierney still had to score from 25 yards but I guarantee you he and probably a lot of Danish people have been watching that on loop thinking, mate, you're a central midfielder. Why could you not just volley that ball away? And that kind of sums it all up, I think. No, you're absolutely right. I was really watching that. And I think he might have been the guy that gave it away to McLean as well. And you think, oh, poor bloke. Because he's definitely kicked the ball better than that in his life than he did. I think it was just the scuffed clearance of a very tired man.

15:14Yeah. But, yeah, he will not be feeling good about that today. So, Barry, what does this say about Steve Clarke? I mean, even in the WhatsApp group, there was so much stick for Steve Clarke. Classic Steve Clarke, park the bus, this is always going to happen. And yet he's the first manager to take Scotland to a World Cup since 98. Yeah. And the first to take three tournaments as well. Third major tournament under him. It was remarkable to see how happy he was after the game. He's in a nation of dour old men. He is the dour old man. a dour old man, other dour old men doffed their caps to. And he was beside himself with delight, more or less told BBC Radio that he'd be going on the piss for the next three days.

16:07And why not three months? Because I've got nothing to do for the next three months.

16:16He strikes me as a fellow who likes a pint or a dram. At some point, it will be interesting to see, and it's far too early to mention this. I probably shouldn't even mention it, but I can envisage a scenario where Scotland go to the World Cup, play unbelievably defensively in their group games and come home having lost all three of them or however many it is. But he certainly, I presume there's a case for him being Scotland's most successful ever manager, if he isn't outright their most successful ever manager. And to get them to a World Cup after so long is a tremendous achievement, even if at one point last night I was just shouting at the telly.

17:06But he did make a very good call. When that Danish player got sent off, he immediately brought on two strikers. And I went, oh, thank God. He's done something proactive. I just thought I'd go on the leading Danish tabloid newspaper, BT, just to see if John McGinn's got the treatment Peter Crouch got in Trinidad and Tobago. He's a pariah over there. But thankfully, I can tell you that John McGinn has survived any criticism. And it's all been aimed at Brian Reamer, who's been described as confused and the defeats of Scotland embarrassing. And Christian Erikson not pleased as well. he was left on the bench and not used at all and has pointed, you know, asked Brian about why he was left there.

17:48So McGinn, you've got away with it. Then the Danish press are all, it's all turned on Rehmer. So it could have been Steve Clarke and instead it's Rehmer who's getting the abuse there from the Danish media. So there's one, there's a turn up for the books. Jim, I want to go back to the, just the greatest bits, the Tierney and the McLean goal. You don't have to pick one, but I just want to know like the feeling when Tierney's running up to strike that ball, and it goes there? Because you said to me, if my neighbours didn't know I'm Scottish, they do now. I like that. Well, the thing is, right, I changed my broadband, right, Swim and Sky, so you get a little delay.

18:27It comes, so it's streaming. So I started off the game with no notifications. It went to 1-0, straight on with my live score, right? Because I just, my heart was going whatever. For some reason, I didn't get the notification ahead of time on the Tierney goal. Right. So I'm just sitting there watching it. I'm thinking, well, nothing's going to happen here. So I got the kind of, I got double bubble, if you like. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I just straight out the chair and I screamed. And as I say, I think about five or six streets away they would have heard me. You know, it was just amazing. And because it's here as well, being a Celtic fan, obviously, I get an extra little bit.

19:08But really, I didn't need any more. It was so, and then the Kenny McLean goal, sweet baby Jesus of the orphans I just I got the notification for that and I thought well that's it's not from there it's got to go out there, it's got to go and then and of course Smychel just that I love that bit when a keeper gets lobbed because he almost it's like the Simpsons thing if you freeze frame it you can see the bit where his heart actually dry, you can see his face where he realises he's, shit, I am not getting this. And that's just another one of those little, there were just so, so many beautiful, beautiful, beautiful moments.

19:54And we don't, as Scotland fans, that's not something we often get to say. And I enjoyed, well, in hindsight, I enjoyed every single minute of it. Imagine telling Jim from 1998 that there'd be a dystopian future where he could find out that Scotland had scored one minute before they'd actually scored

20:15it's a very good point Barry you mentioned on the other day on your voice note about you know how Ireland will be good for the World Cup and you know it's always a cliche about how good the Tartan Army are I mean I remember being at Euro 96 being at England Scotland standing next to them and sort of being in awe of how they had no inhibition they could sing status quo at half time where all the sort of po-faced England fans stood around not knowing what to do but there is no doubt they will be a positive force, the Tartan army at this. Absolutely. And whatever cities are lucky enough to have them will love them because they're just an incredibly lovable, raucous, vibrant, likeable bunch.

20:58Good for the proclaimers as well. I mean, I don't know if they wrote a letter for America for this specifically, but they'll do well out of that. I can't help it. Does anyone else think, and maybe this is a controversial thing to think, but actually freed from desire is brilliant like like it is it is well but i i mean i mean i remember it from like post a levels holiday to turkey going i don't think this is going to stand the test of time but when the ireland fans were doing it and when the scotland fans were doing it and just the way sort of obviously there are lots of good you know yes sir i can boogie was great that was obviously it's brilliant but i mean i'm happy to be shouted down i think it works ali well yeah I was in France in Euro 2016 and my mate is a Northern Irishman and we went to two or three of their games together.

21:47So, I mean, those are some of the best moments I've ever had watching football and celebrating with football fans with the old Will Grigg. So, yeah, at that stage, very unironically, I think it was magnificent. I've probably done a whole range of emotions towards that song at this point. Summer of 2021, following England at the Euros. that was played after some of the big wins. And yeah, I think it's massively overdone and I don't like it when a song is sort of squeezed every inch out of it as it is. And I'd like to see something else come in to replace it. But I have had a number of moments of being 10 points deep when your team has just won a very significant football match and that comes on and you don't stand there and go, I wish they played something else.

22:29You just absolutely go for it. So yeah. It trumps sweet Caroline for me. I mean, that's, you know, if we're fighting between, what the DJ is going to play. Is there anyone else, Jim, before we let you go to just have a lie down that deserves a mention? I mean, all the players do, of course, but is there anything that sticks in your mind? Other than, I think, Gilmore. You know, we weren't really... Nobody really was out through injury. So that's our squad. And I think you did say it, Barry, and you're right. I'm not going to the World Cup with any kind of confidence that we're going to do anything.

23:05but do you know what? It doesn't matter. I mean, we're there. As I said earlier, my wife's daughter, she's 21 next December. The plan was to go to New York for her birthday. I suggested tentatively last night that why don't we make the American trip in the summer? I got a look that suggested that's not happening but who could be crook? I'm at least going to get to one. I'm going to do my damnness to get to one of the games because at 62, let's be honest, the chances of me being around the next time we get to the World Cup are pretty bloody slim. Make sure you get full support, Jim. You don't want to be another wife on when the tournament starts.

23:54I'm looking forward to Jim's struggles with and getting to grips with dynamic pricing.

24:05Oh, so just... How much? Well done, Jim. We'll let you have a lie down. Max, before you let Jim go, can we get an adjudication on the Trevor Sinclair scale for the McTominay overhead kick? I had it at about a seven, you know, because I think Barry made some good points in the WhatsApp group that it doesn't... You know, to fly into the top corner is the dream, but the connection is very good. You know, he does have to move himself acrobatically quickly. there are lots of positives with it but you know if it's not flying high into the net it can never be above a seven I would suggest fair fair yeah I suppose so cheers Jim thanks for your time mate cheers guys Jim Burke host of the RGC podcast a Celtic podcast which stands for right good I'll let you fill in the rest and we'll be back in just a second with an Ellis James voice note

25:06Welcome to part two of the Guardian Football Weekly. So, I don't know about anyone else. I switched off Wales at 4-1 and just sort of messaged Ellis saying, look, can I have a voice note? And then I checked again and it was 7-1. And again, we all thought it would be pretty tough. Here is, before we get to the panel, here is Ellis James. Obviously, the headlines go to Scotland. and very rare that a 7-1 win gets overshadowed by the exploits of another team. Congratulations to Scotland, obviously. I cannot stop watching Scotland limbs videos. People thinking they're going to film the final whistle and then filming a goal from behind the halfway line.

Read the full transcript

25:50Anyway, Wales 7, North Macedonia 1. What a night, man. After Craig Bellamy's first game against Turkey, he said, right, watch that, remember that, that's the worst we're going to play. That hasn't proven to be the case. And the thing with Bellamy, he's a very, very inspiring, engaging talker, the way he speaks about football. And if you run with it, and I have run with it, I find it quite motivating, right? But eventually, after some quite poor performances Or after some, how shall I say, unorthodox selection decisions You think, okay, what's really going on here? Everything he kind of promised It all came true in one game Now I was really worried about Northamastonia I was in Lichtenstein on Saturday And we were absolutely abject against I think literally the worst team in the world and we huffed and we puffed and we ended up winning 1-0.

26:53And he played one holding mid against Belgium and he plays two against Lichtenstein, who were a team made up of students. They both get booked. So we're without our first choice midfield against North Mastonia, who hadn't lost a game in the campaign, had only conceded three calls, taken points off Belgium. And you're like poor Josh Ian in midfield on his own and you're worrying about when we played Armenia and to Page in qualification for Euro 2024. And we just got absolutely overran in midfield. And I thought, we're going to get, this could be bad. And he chooses, he goes for all out attacks.

27:31We've got Dan James, Brendan Johnson, Harry Wilson and David Brooks. And we just purred from the first minute. I mean, Harry Wilson was exceptional. And Bale himself has said, you know, there is no other Gareth Bale. and so the responsibility for scoring goals is going to have to be spread across the team he is the talisman though Wilson, when he's not fit we really, really miss him and if he scored a hat-trick I mean he was just fantastic but we haven't scored seven goals against anyone since before I was born so that was against Malta in 1978 and you know, it's the playoffs we haven't qualified outright Playoffs are very, very difficult to negotiate Obviously we qualified for the last World Cup Via the playoffs, beating Ukraine in the final Having beaten Austria in the semi We failed to qualify for Euro 2024 In the playoff route because we lost to Poland on penalties So now, being in pot 2 Which is what last night guaranteed As opposed to pot 4 Does make things easier So we're either going to play Albania, Bosnia, Kosovo, the Republic of Ireland in Cardiff and that's huge for us because we do seem to find another gear when we're playing at the Cardiff City Stadium under the lights.

28:52I mean, the final is daunting. It could be Italy, it could be Denmark, Turkey, Ukraine, I mean, or one of the top four teams, Northern Ireland, North Macedonia, Romania or Sweden. But then Ashley Williams, he said on the telly last night, he said, who's going to fancy playing us after we've scored seven goals? Because I'm childish and nervous and superstitious, I read once that Donald Trump thinks that every human body is a sort of finite amount of heartbeats, and so that if you do exercise and you raise your heart rate, you're actually shortening your life because you're going to run out of heartbeats.

29:32I feel like that about Welsh goals. I feel like we've scored our goals now. We've had our seven, and we're probably not going to score until 2028. The one thing I would say is I wish we could carry on. I wish we were playing next week and we could carry this momentum on because I've never seen anything like it. And I am on cloud nine. Thank you, Ellis James. And I hadn't heard the finite heartbeats of Donald Trump. But I agree with you about using up your goals. Never win 7-1 when you only need to win 2-1. But still 7-1 all the same. And Ali, it was, I mean, Ellis has summed it up pretty well, but it was a great performance.

30:11They played unbelievably well, Wales, and this is really significant for them for a few reasons. But after what Ireland did the other night, which was clearly more dramatic, more memorable, and obviously what Scotland did last night, clearly more dramatic, more memorable, and secured them a spot of the World Cup rather than a slightly more beneficial draw in a playoff. Wales sort of end up yeah down the pecking order in terms of stories but I think it's worth pointing out that this was their best performance by miles under Craig Bellamy at a point where they really really needed it against a North Macedonia side that had only conceded three goals in seven qualifying games they scored seven against them and a bit like with the Scotland goals albeit in a different way you're finding it hard to work out which is the best of the goals that Wales scored because some of the passing and movement and speed in front of the ball, speed of passing, interplay, finishing was excellent.

31:12Brennan Johnson had his best game in a Welsh shirt for a long time, has not necessarily been the superstar that maybe fans would want him to be for them, but was brilliant and set up Brooks for the second goal, scored a rasper from 20 yards himself into the top corner for the third. The fourth goal was a beautiful team move that involved Johnson and Wilson and Dan James finishing it off. And then Harry Wilson, who ends up with a hat-trick, two of them from the penalty spot and one of them a trademark Harry Wilson free kick. It's just a brilliant, brilliant night, I think. As you say, all Wales fans that I spoke to were expecting a cagey affair because even the games against the minnows of the group, they've been like pulling teeth, really.

31:51Bellamy made some pretty big calls here. Left out Sorba Thomas, who, albeit he's not as big a name as some of the attackers that started ahead of him, has been clearly Wales' best player under Bellamy in the last year or so. Kiefer Moore's injured for this one. And I worried that, you know, it was going to be one of those games where they were going to be against a deep block, slinging a lot of crosses in and without big Kiefer to head them in. But they didn't. They just took a different approach and sliced through North Macedonia. So yeah, big players stepping up when they needed to for Wales.

32:19And I think Bellamy as well justified with, he's been very clear that he's trying to raise the ceiling of the team. And in his eyes, that means playing in a different way, in a much more attacking, technical fluid attacking style which isn't necessarily what's defined the best Wales teams before and I think there's been some scepticism because frankly the results particularly in the last well in the last three months he hasn't had much to show for it he hasn't had much justification for what he's trying to do and he absolutely has that now so still work to do of course and it is a more favourable draw than it could have been but there's still some teams that they would probably prefer to avoid out of the four that they could be drawn against I would put Albania at the top of the list for them to avoid having seen them play England twice recently they're a pretty strong team and I think they can play Ireland as well can't they so that would be pretty lively Italy, Denmark, Turkey Ukraine will be at home to one of Romania, Sweden North Macedonia Northern Ireland and then Poland, Wales Czechia, Slovakia will be at home to Republic of Ireland Albania, Bosnia or Kosovo Austria went through automatically they got a late equaliser at home to Bosnia they haven't been for the World Cup since 1998 the glory days of Tony Polster.

33:31Was Polster still playing in 98? Still the only Austrian player that everyone knows apart from Marko Arnortovic. Northern Ireland beat Luxembourg 1-0. First international goal for Spurs' Jamie Donnelly. That was on Monday there in the playoffs, of course. Germany thrashed Slovakia 6-0. Some of their goals were absolutely brilliant, by the way. Netherlands put four past Lithuania. So that's sort of Europe done. We've got Paul Watson on tomorrow to steer us through the big international headlines. But you did point out, Ali, So, you know, Curaçao will be the smallest ever side to qualify for a World Cup.

34:04They got a draw in Jamaica. And those scenes as well, if you've seen the full-time whistle. I just love watching just grown-ups get so invested in this thing. It's just amazing. And it's a wonderful moment for them, isn't it? Yeah, absolutely incredible. Obviously, with the US and Mexico and Canada automatically qualifying as hosts, that kind of opened the door in the CONCACAF region. And the expanded tournament, of course, as well. Just delighted for the Bakuna brothers who represent Curacao. And I've seen play a lot of football in the English football pyramid, both of them based out in Turkey now.

34:41But, you know, they will be absolute heroes, glorified forever, as they should be. The previous smallest country to qualify for the tournament was Iceland. So Curacao now have that. And their manager, improbably to me anyway, is Dick Advocat, who I did not realise were still managing at any level. And then Haiti as well. A drink managing a drink, isn't that? That is good, isn't it? A drink managing a drink to take them to the World Cup. That's really impressive. Well, as Barca Jim pointed out earlier, last night we had two drinks and a hat qualifying for the World Cup. Panama, Curacao and Scotch.

35:20The sad news, if you like, is that he beat or they beat Steve McLaren's Jamaica sending them into a playoff. It's fair to say the reaction in Jamaica has been pretty angry and Steve McLaren swiftly resigned, so we'll not be taking them into the playoffs and nor to the World Cup if they get there. His quote was, leadership is a service. Tonight, I think the best thing I can do is stepping aside. They will succeed in March. Thank you, Jamaica. It's been an honour. One love to you all. That is a direct quote as reported by Laurie Whitwell. And then lastly, the other big story, which I know you'll hear more about tomorrow, but is Haiti, who have qualified for the World Cup.

36:00It's not their first, but they have qualified. And they did so playing their home game, as it was, in Curaçao, because they haven't played a home game in four years as the country is under cartel rule. And they've got some amazing stories in that squad as well. So, yeah, really, what a few days it has been for international football. And, yeah, could not have loved it anymore. Reno Gattuso must be absolutely raging to see all these countries qualify after his trade on Friday about the injustice of it all. Everyone conspiring to keep Italy out by letting these riffraff into the competition. Well, we will never complain about an international break again because it has been absolutely brilliant.

36:46As I said, Paul Watson on tomorrow to flesh out those stories. And that'll do for part two. Felix White will join us in just a second. He's written a book called Whatever Will Be, Will Be, and he'll tell us all about it in just a second.

37:06Welcome to part three of the Guardian Football Weekly. Let's welcome Felix White of the Maccabees, Tailenders, books, amongst many other things. How are you, Felix? Very good. Very happy to be on Guardian Football Weekly, guys. I've been listening for years. I've been even accosting Barry in pubs years ago in Brixton. So, yeah, I'm very flattered to be on the show. Thank you, guys. You're one of those, what's Barry like in real life, people? As he told the story. As he told you that story, Barry, have you told everyone that story? I just saw him. I was the other side of a bar in Brixton, and I saw a personality glowing from the other side of that said bar.

37:45And then I was trying to work out what that charisma was. I was like, oh, my God, it's Barry Glenn Denning. so I sort of shuffled over and I think we had two or three pints and we talked about Gaza and something else we talked about, oh Dean Windus have you just done a Dean Windus documentary Barry I think you've done this really good documentary I would say documentary is pushing it a bit but yes interview but what happened was Felix asked me if I was Barry Glendening and we got chatting and then just to be polite I feigned interest in him. And I said, oh, so what do you do? And he said, I'm a musician.

38:23And I went, oh, right, OK. Are you in a band or anything? And he said, yeah, yeah, I'm in a band. And I said, what would I have heard of this band? And he went, I'm in the Maccabees. And I just sort of went, oh, right, OK. Although, to be fair, Felix, you know, he did have a pint with Kylie Minogue and Michael Hutchins once and didn't know who they were either. so you know so you're in pretty good company that's so good about your book um your book is called whatever will be will be um it is i've i think it's brilliant thank you beautifully written uh how would you describe it what what what is it yeah uh well yeah like that's a good question actually it's something i didn't think about writing until last year when i was on tour a little bit lost felt like i needed somewhere to be and i realized penriff were playing down the road and it turned out that it was the extra preliminary round of the FA Cup.

39:20And the thing that you might be aware of if you go and watch very lower league football or non-league football is sometimes when you're in the middle of nowhere, you cannot get Ubers or cars. So I couldn't get out of Penrith to the festival and I had an hour to do it to get to stage. And I ended up begging for a lift with the chairman of Penrith, Billy Williams, who got me in his car and got me to stage. And when I was in his car, I suddenly thought, this is the beginning of a road trip adventure. And I'm at the very first round of the FA Cup. And it suddenly became sort of interesting to me that you could tell the entire story of English football in 15 rounds.

39:57It's something we all know it and we all do the trope quite often that the FA Cup, anyone can win it. But actually, there is something profound about the fact that the FA Cup starts somewhere like Penrith that ends at Palace. so that ended up becoming the scope of the story and then finding, trying to not, almost not write about the football at all. There's the odd description of the odd goal but it's more an articulation about the stories behind the places, what football means, why we love what we love and trying to accurately describe what it's like going to watch football in all these places.

40:28I mean, there's so many moments in this book. There's a moment where you are, you know, you talk about football management games in a way that I feel totally seen. Really? way that you you bond with this guy jake over reading out the wikipedia of a footballer and guessing who it is and it's linvoid primus and i'm like oh my this is literally sort of my existence on a page do you know what i mean oh my god when i saw the list of clubs i knew it was linvoid primus before it was revealed to be linvoid primus but this is the thing like i think with a certain type of person as you well know you don't need to know any you could base an entire friendship for like 40 years on just saying things like Linvoy Primus.

41:09You might not even need to know that much about their life. So I became a realisation of me and Jake that if we didn't have Linvoy Primus, I'm not sure we would have been such close friends. That sounds insane. But we used to, with the lights out in buses, we used to just name clubs and footballs. That's sort of become popularised since, hasn't it? Again, there's even a podcast where you do that. but yeah there's so many things like that football play play by mail football manager I don't know if you guys remember the play by mail is amazing I have a vague recollection of play by mail where literally you had people's phone numbers and you would just ring up you were the manager of what part like this or you'd ring up somebody another human and buy a footballer like Max I was I was eight I was eight and I had access to the phone numbers of all these people across the country assuming they managed Man United or Levski Sofia or whoever it is.

42:05And you could just randomly phone them up and have these very private conversations with grown men who tell me, in future, can you not refer to yourself as manager of Partick Thistle because my wife doesn't approve of the game? Say you're a work colleague. So I have all these covert conversations with men. But then again, that became like sort of articulation about how football does communicate something between a child and an adult and reverse. And there was something quite sweet about that as well, which sort of goes throughout the book. Felix, you didn't do the traditional thing of sticking with a winning team all the way to the final and following whoever beat them and so on and so on.

42:46You just picked a collection of random matches for each round. I thought you captured the essence of Dolich Hamlet beautifully, by the way. I'm a reasonably regular visitor there. but was there a particular reason for that? Was it just a logistics thing or? Yeah, no, I had the classic idea that everyone does, but I'll follow the winner. But then when I did a few rounds and realised, oh, this is a book and a publisher, I'll speak to a publisher, they were like, well, if you get Man City in the third round, then it's not going to be a very good book, is it? And I thought, oh. So at the risk, so it just became an exercise in just finding the right stories in each round.

43:28When you say, Barry, when you say I've got the essence of Dunwich Hamlet, do you mean that? Because I felt it's so easy with Dunwich Hamlet to sort of write it off as a sort of fashionista thing. And I tried to write that in a little bit, but there was like almost, because in that lower league football, there's like something amazing about football at that level, where because the crowds aren't as big, you're a bit more isolated to the actual experience of who's watching it. And I think in lots of grounds at that space, you realise, oh, it's a bit of a community centre of a place for people to go that don't have anywhere else to go, a sort of collection of people.

44:03I know Hamlet has become a bit sort of cooler than that, but it sort of has all the mergings of all that stuff together, doesn't it, Hamlet? Yeah, I love it up there. It's like a 25-minute walk to Champion Hill for me. But it is quite a funny place because there's loads of young couples with Tarquin is in tow in his big off-road buggy and there's the various sections. But as you point out, they have the big sign up, everyone in our house is equal. I think that's what it says. But yeah, it's a top place. Hi Felix. I've never been so sure that almost every listener of Football Weekly will enjoy a book and specifically this one, having read it yesterday, They hoovered it up, no less, on the train.

44:56I think the structure of it, I was reflecting on why I was so desperate to whiz through it. The writing itself and the stories, the vulnerability is incredible. But I think the structure of it really helps as well, because I think a lot of people like me will be reading it, kind of knowing what happened to various teams involved in last year's FA Cup, but sort of can't quite remember. and so you really want to get through it and get to the next chapter and get to the end of the current one. The way that you wrote about loving football as a child, the way that you wrote about loving football and what it means to you now as an adult is incredible and I know a lot of people listening will resonate with that.

45:34The Championship Manager stuff, as Max said, really could not have been more a reflection of my childhood. Steve Claridge, race is clear. It's a friendship. He rounds the keeper but somehow misses. You're like, how's that happen? And it'd wait for 10 minutes, wouldn't it? Yeah, but also, you know my mum died when I was young and the way that you wrote about the specifics of childhood grief and its kind of long tail into adulthood I think was just incredible so it did kind of yeah not the stuffing out of me but in a good way and to top it all off written by a guy that my brother and I practically worship because the Maccabees have been our favourite band since 2007 and still are to this day who we listen to every time we're in the car together including over the weekend uh whose farewell gig i went to we went to and and the recent comeback as well at all points east so yeah a lot a lot of feelings nice to meet you i want to nice to meet you too i want to clip that all up and put it on the back of the paperback actually ali if that's all right everything you just said that is so sweet joe that's so lovely man and yet especially just quickly about the um about my mum though when i was young that became a sort of exploration on why i support fulham and that was something that i really wasn't sure i was going to say in the book because I do genuinely have still quite a lot of shame and guilt that I supported Chelsea when I was about seven, eight, nine.

46:55And I made a conscious decision, having been told by football that the original sin, the only sin is that you cannot change clubs. Once you have a club, you have a club. But because my mum was from Palestine and my dad not really interested in football from the Isle of Wight I hadn't been handed a football team but my mum and uncle were from Palestine and moved a lot around in the Middle East and my uncle had decided because realizing as we all sort of do that football communicates more than most other things this is who I am this is where I belong this is where I'm from and he was desperate to be from a place so he just decided for no reason like pinning a tail on a donkey type thing that he supported wolves never being he's from Palestine and then and then my mum because she had because she uh had heard that her dad now lived in Bromley West said that she supported West Brom because she thought they were the same thing and like even though obviously that's like really funny it also spoke to their total displacement and not being from a place so then it became interesting to me that when I was young, they hadn't handed me a club and my uncle took me to Chelsea and I'd felt like I sported Chelsea, but something didn't feel right.

48:16And I begged my dad to go somewhere. And when Fulham were in the bottom tier, he took me to Fulham just because I was begging him to go to a place. And he thought, oh, it's an inverted commas, nice club. And something about Fulham Football Club and Craven Cottage when I went there, I genuinely think the place spoke to me and it said this is a place that will hold your loss disappointment hurts this is a place that you can come and do your feeling and you will not be judged and it's going to be a sort of safe spot for you and then that has become really interesting to me decades later that my mum was seriously ill when she was about to die of having MS and I would have moments when I would go to Fulham and I would be actually hoping that they'd lose I wouldn't be telling anyone but I'd have this weird guilty thing but I would be like almost like an addict thinking god I hope we can see the last minute win a loser here sort of things they score and then I realized after after time that Fulham was giving me a sort of very um digestible version of the feeling that I was trying to process the feeling of loss that like funereal feeling or that that kind of sense of everyone aligning with your insides.

49:30So that became really interesting to me that I chose Fulham because I needed it at that time. And I think more often than not, we get told that we get given clubs and lots of people do by families, but actually often people are choosing a club for a certain reason. And I think there are subconscious reasons those clubs speak to you in different ways for things you're looking for as a child. And I genuinely think that's what Fulham gave me. Felix you got in early to give your nephew to lumber him with Fulham as well and there's a beautiful line in the book so I think he must be 8 now but one of the games he went to last season was Fulham getting beaten by Palace in the quarter final of the cup and you gave your nephew Jett a Fulham jersey every year of his life and you have a line in the book He said, instead of giving Jet Fulham shirts, I should have just handed him a big box of sadness.

50:31Fantastic. A pre-packaged one, just have it all now. Yeah, that was like... And then when they lost against Palace, that seemed to be young Jet's first real encounter with genuine crushing disappointment. And there'll be plenty more of that for him, I'm sure in the years to come. Oh, yeah, there will be. Yeah. But when that happened, he was really staring into the void. And as you know, because we got beat 3-0, there was like about 10 minutes to really process the reality of what happened. So just watching him, watching him deal with it for the first time, the way football tells you, something's going to happen in front of you that you are going to feel very betrayed by, but there's nothing you're going to be able to do to affect it.

51:16You'll just have to sit there and watch it. And how football does that again and again against you and the first time it happens to you as a child, it's really like you're sort of looking around going like, what, is no one going to, I don't understand. Like no one's going to change that for me type thing. You can't believe that it's played out as it has. But the thing with Jett was it became interesting to me is that because he doesn't have the reasons for choosing Fulham that I did and he's just been handed it, he desperately wants Fulham to win. So suddenly now I find watching Fulham unbearable because I need Fulham to win for Jett.

51:49Do you know what I mean? I need him to be happy. So it made me feel a bit like, oh, this must be what it's like being a parent or almost witnessing your own wants. Because actually, that's what happens so often in relationships or whatever, especially people, you know, people that become islands a little bit. They don't necessarily commit to more domesticised situations or relationships because they say, oh, I don't want it. It's not, you know, X, Y and Z is wrong with it. But actually, they probably want it so badly. so I started thinking about my my want for Fulham to lose and thinking actually that was probably because it was unbearable to me to need them to win in fact so I'm getting psychoanalytical now but yeah that's sort of all these trails the book takes Felix um I haven't read the book yet but just based on what you were saying there did you did you kind of let on what you were doing like as you got through the rounds like because you know I do a lot of lower league and non-league stuff and it's always a bit of a sell when I'm trying to like get something for sky for example because you know we're all premier league but then you go and you see so much heart and you see what a football club means and the belonging there and then you you get you get the red carpet I get a little bit you know and you you get to meet everyone really easily and stuff and you meet all these crazy characters did you kind of go in completely blind and not tell anyone or did you kind of go hey guys I'm gonna be here I'm doing this I would I would do you know what I had that experience this year when I went to Brackley because BBC had me at half time to do something and that was amazing like having the red carpet thing for that but um no I think the whole purpose of the book was that I was trying to be almost anonymous so I was trying to really just watch people and like tell what the experience was so there's nothing there's none of that like as the rounds went on it was tempting to be like oh so I'll see if I can get press for x-rays but you want to sort of be in the mix and seeing it so especially in those low like a lot of those low league games I'm almost trying to like hide myself in a corner and just watch these sort of strange interactions that play out and people that don't know each other at the start of a game and then at 4.45 they've got this whole history of complex interactions between each other and or like dislike or like for whatever like the thing I always think about in Penrith is there was this in the second half of the game between Penrith and Pickering even though it's playing out the two dugouts just became obsessed um with who had possession of a spare ball so you'd have like so the assistant would be like holding the ball behind his back and then the other manager was sent his assistant to go and try and knock the ball out of that assistant's hand to get it back and they were having this sort of like scrabble for the ball so i didn't have the red carpet uh like you sanny but um maybe maybe we can go to lower league in the future we can you can show me the smoked salmon sandwiches.

54:36Yeah, I should say, by the way, that the red carpet in Lower League, there isn't even a carpet. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's not red. The sponsor's lounge at best might be just a random porter cabin with a little, like, electric heater. Love it. I mean, you're also not a rock star, Sanny. I hate to say it. It's true. That Sky Sports microphone, you're a great car, great responsibility. That's true. I mean, I don't know, like, if you feel lucky about this, but like for the FA Cup final to be what it was and to be Palace winning it. And, you know, we started this pod with just talking about that half of us were in tears and I'm not even a Scot, I'm not Scottish at all, but you know, I'm sitting in a cafe in Melbourne, like crying when Kenny McLean scored that the same.

55:19I've watched, I've watched so many videos of that full-time whistle when Palace win, just to see what it means. This whole generate, this whole fan base who've never won anything before and just seeing the disbelief. Like, and at the time, and like when you write about it, you're clearly just there going, this is amazing. I don't know if part of you is going, God, that is great for the book, that City haven't, you know, Man City haven't beaten Liverpool 2-0. You know, like, it's perfect for you, right? Well, yeah, do you know what? It was like, it's so, it's interesting, because at the time I wasn't, I was just so jealous.

55:51But then when I reflected on it, I was like, oh, that, the book would have not been, like, it wouldn't have been a very good book if Man City had won it, because the whole essence of the book is like searching for that magic. So if Palace hadn't won that tournament, it would have been a very flat ending to the book. And honestly, being inside with those Palace fans, that is the most supernatural thing I've ever seen in my life. When I think back to it, you know, when you see old American videos of like gospel churches and people were just weeping or like wailing, shouting Jesus. And they're all in their own little private universes.

56:27But together, like, you know, like these exorcisms. like when I think about it it was like that but in a very sort of southeast London way people um not knowing what having a feeling but not only they had never had before in their lives but their parents their grandparents etc had never had before and simultaneously not knowing what to do with it but being completely overwhelmed um with feeling so uh yeah that was that when I think about that and it's a trope that gets used a lot but it was it did make you think oh football is religious it genuinely was a religious experience where they were almost communicating with all the people that hadn't seen that and especially because that Palestine was so good and they looked like for some weird reason I don't know because the kits at the moment are sort of throwbacks in a way but because of what they were and they looked like the 1990 team to me it looks like you're watching Ian Wright and Mark Bright a little bit it's almost like do you know what I mean?

57:26You could put a sketch over them and they looked, felt very similar. So there was all kinds of like synergies that that was, yeah, yeah, beautiful day. I mean, I haven't forgiven that 99 team for knocking Cambridge out of the quarterfinals unjustly. A Jeff Thomas mishit. Worse than his chip. Worse than that chip that went wide, but it's okay, you know. Was that on that run? Cambridge got a quarterfinals in that run. Because Cambridge were quite, was that Dion Dublin? Two years running. That was the John Beck. Wow. It was. John Beck, Dion Dublin's Cambridge. You know, I've talked about that enough, Felix.

57:55we don't the listeners don't need this again hey the book is called whatever will be will be wherever you buy your books but thank you so much Felix it's a great read and I encourage everyone to go and buy it and read it thank you Felix thank you and just quickly to say I love your show it's incredible so I listen to it all the time without fail so yeah nice one which one which one yeah I normally do the previews this one we're doing right now you can listen to all the other ones as well if you like Felix but that is great we appreciate it it's nice it's nice to it's nice to hear that and that'll do for everyone as well so thank you Felix thank you Barry thank you thank you Ali thank you very much cheers Sani cheers thank you Football Weekly is produced by Tayo Papula our executive producer is Phil Maynard we'll be back tomorrow

58:56Thank you.

From the publisher
Max Rushden is joined by Barry Glendenning, Ali Maxwell and Sanny Rudravajhala to discuss Scotland’s incredible last-gasp winning goals against Denmark that took them to the World Cup. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/footballweeklypod. Watch us on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@FootballWeeklyPodcast

More from Football Weekly

All 212 episodes
Scotland in dreamland – Football Weekly Football Weekly · 59 min
Listen in VO