


CBC Front Burner breaks down Canada’s federal budget “Masters of Our Own Destiny,” focusing on major bets: a $36B investment tax break (productivity mega deduction), affordability supports (enhanced groceries/essentials benefit, changes to Canada workers benefit, and gas tax suspension), clean electricity electrification funding, defense and space/rocket capacity, and an $11B homelessness plan to end homelessness within 10 years.
Aaron Wary, senior writer with CBC’s Parliamentary Bureau (“budget whisperer”).
the mega deduction is the centerpiece (about $36B foregone revenue over five years; aimed at a claimed $22B annual boost to economic activity), but critics question who benefits and whether affordability improves.
debate with Avi Lewis/Francois-Philippe Champagne over “mega deduction” vs grocery bill; electrification to double electricity capacity in 25 years; $1.5B for community recreational facilities; free museums under 25; deficit projections largely unchanged (with oil-price windfall noted).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the newly unveiled federal budget and its major proposals.
“A$36 billion tax break to kickstart a so-called investment super cycle, a number of cost of living supports, a pledge to end homelessness within a decade.”
Exploring initial reactions to the budget's title and its implications.
“I want to start by just getting your initial reactions.”
Insights into who benefits from the budget, including business owners and investors.
“but at the same time deal with this other major challenge, that rupture in the sort of world order that Mark Carney has talked a lot about.”
Breakdown of the productivity mega deduction and its significance in the budget.
“This is the single largest line item in the budget.”
Discussion on the impact of the budget on small and medium-sized businesses.
“You know, the gate, I don't know if it's a bet, but the calculation they're making is essentially that doing this will drive economic growth in such a fashion that it'll be worth it.”
Examination of measures in the budget aimed at improving affordability for Canadians.
“Yeah, I mean, I think the government would say they are putting a fair bit into supports.”
Discussion on criticisms raised about the budget's focus on investment over direct affordability measures.
“I mean, I saw Avi Lewis saying today that today's budget is Christmas come early for CEOs, foreign investors, and arms dealers.”
Exploration of the potential for an antitrust agenda to address affordability issues.
“And in some cases, I suspect the government would say, well, we can't, you know, make the war in Iran not happen.”
Explore the tension between business interests and affordability concerns in Canada.
“And I think that's, you know, people have been having these arguments, you know, particularly in the grocery sector for a while now.”
Discover the intriguing story of a cult in a small Canadian town.
“The kind of place where nothing much happens and folks like it that way.”
Discussion on Carney's climate initiatives alongside military spending.
“The government would point to its plans for a massive electrification of the grid.”
Examine the government's ambitious goals for homelessness and community facilities.
“I'm going to do a small rapid fire round to just run through a couple of other sort of random things that people might just be interested in in this budget.”
Discuss the implications of new spending on the federal budget deficit.
“How much will this new spending drive up the deficit?”
Explore the potential impacts of oil prices and economic sustainability on the budget.
“a lot of revenue that came from exporting oil at those high prices.”
Evaluate the government's claim of shared prosperity against electoral expectations.
“I mean, I think that's the idea of like sort of shared prosperity is very much, I think, an idea that was kind of associated with the Trudeau government.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Front Burner, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01A little early, a lot to like. Lowe's early Black Friday deals are still going strong. Get up to two free select power tools with a purchase of a select DeWalt, Craftsman, or Cobalt battery kit. Plus, get up to 70 % off select smart home products. Savings this good deserve to be in your cart. Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's. In-store and online. Valid through 1125. While supplies last, selection varies by location. Free tools vary based on battery kit purchased. This is a CBC Podcast.
0:37Hey everyone, I'm Jamie Poisson.
0:45The federal budget was unveiled Thursday afternoon and it laid out some of the big bets the government plans on making over the coming years. A$36 billion tax break to kickstart a so-called investment super cycle, a number of cost of living supports, a pledge to end homelessness within a decade. But those bets also raise some uncomfortable questions. Can we really fast track huge nation building projects and still hit our climate goals? What will this amount of spending do to the deficit? And will any of this actually make life more affordable for Canadians? Here to break this all down with me is Aaron Wary, a senior writer with the CBC's Parliamentary Bureau and our resident budget whisperer.
1:27Aaron, hello. Hey. Thank you for being here. Anytime. I want to start by just getting your initial reactions. This budget is called Masters of Our Own Destiny. Do you think that's an accurate title? Would you like to pick a different title?
1:43Aaron Wherry: I've never named a budget and I would not pretend to know how. You know, it's evocative. Mark Kearney loves a good historical reference and Masters of Our Destiny is a bit of a twist on Maître Chenou, the Masters in Our Own House, the sort of rallying cry from the quiet revolution in Quebec in the 1960s. He's been using that phrase a fair bit, actually, going back to when he was first running for liberal leader. I think it, you know, it speaks to kind of a moment. It speaks to sort of this desire for control and sovereignty. Obviously, a lot depends now on sort of whether the measures within the budget, you know, kind of live up to that idea.
2:31Just tell me the story that this government is trying to convey with the budget and with this plan. top line. So they, it's an interesting term of phrase. They talk about it in terms of ambitious, but also pragmatic. They're big on, as I said, this idea of sovereignty, of investing in people, in terms of sort of the tension between immediate affordability concerns and the long-term economic challenge
3:00Aaron Wherry: that the country's facing and the economic agenda that Mark Carney wants to implement. He talks about a boost today and a bridge to tomorrow. So there's a lot of, I guess, elements to it. But it's, I think, trying to balance those two things. One is people are really concerned about the cost of living and trying to do some things to deal with that. but at the same time deal with this other major challenge, that rupture in the sort of world order that Mark Carney has talked a lot about. Well, let's talk about how they might be doing that, right? I guess leading up to this budget, everyone from climate groups to small business owners were releasing statements outlining what they wanted to see.
3:50Who got what they wanted? Who are the big winners here?
3:54Aaron Wherry: I think people who are business owners, people who are investors, people who are concerned about wanting to grow the Canadian economy, I think that is, you know, if you look at it simply in dollars and cents, a lot of the new dollars in this budget go towards those things. Towards the, we're going to talk about it, but the productivity mega deduction towards clean energy, clean electricity in particular. I think that's sort of the big splashiest part. I mean, the federal government, I think, would argue that they want, you know, ultimately all Canadians to see themselves in this budget. And there are certainly, you know, dozens of policies within this budget.
4:43It's hard to sort of wrap it up into just a couple sentences. But I think the challenge they'll have going forward is to make that kind of large macroeconomic agenda make it work in a way that people feel like they're included in benefiting from it. Since you brought it up, let's do the productivity mega deduction. This is the single largest line item in the budget. It was announced earlier this year. We talked about it on the show when Carney was holding his big investment summit this fall. But just like remind people what that is in the kind of simplest terms possible. Yeah. So essentially it is a tax measure that allows businesses to write off investment in their own businesses right away.
5:29Aaron Wherry: It's essentially a significant tax break on new investment in your business. So expanding it, buy new equipment, you know, those sorts of things. And it's not cheap. It's about$36 billion in foregone revenue over the first five years. But it is kind of the centerpiece now of the fiscal policy portion of trying to supercharge the Canadian economy and build out this more sovereign national economy. You know, obviously the Carney government is doing a lot in terms of regulatory changes, in terms of speeding up project approvals, those sorts of things. But this is now, you know, they call it mega for a reason, I guess.
6:15Aaron Wherry: This is kind of the big piece of it in terms of tax policy. A quarter of all new spending, right? Yeah. If you look at at least just the new spending within this budget, it's about 25%. It is not a small item. You know, the gate, I don't know if it's a bet, but the calculation they're making is essentially that doing this will drive economic growth in such a fashion that it'll be worth it. You know, they're talking about ultimately realizing a$22 billion boost to economic activity every year. So that's essentially the calculation they're making is that, you know, giving this tax break to business owners, to investors is going to pay off in a sort of supercharged Canadian economy.
7:09Is there a sense that this will help small and medium-sized businesses? You know, I raise this in part because the Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses is not, like, overly happy with this budget today. Yeah, I think that's an interesting question, because if you actually read the budget, the government itself makes a point of saying all businesses, all sizes of businesses can benefit. And I think that is one of the things people are going to be watching is exactly how widespread this deduction is used or can be used or is actually benefiting people. And to what degree does the government need to maybe do more?
7:51And there are, I should say, there are other measures within the investment section of the budget that are geared towards boosting investment and may, you know, cover more businesses ultimately. But I think that is another thing that people will end up watching for is how widespread the take up is and how widespread the benefits are. Yeah. It was interesting to see the CFIB specifically talk about the fact, though, that they wanted more to help address the trade war, like businesses hurt by the tariffs, and they didn't see that in this budget, apparently. Yeah, I mean, I think the government would say they are putting a fair bit into supports.
8:38Some of it is previously announced funding that they've put into supports for businesses and workers. But I think if this trade war continues to grind on, you know, perhaps for as much as two more years, what more does, like, where are the gaps? Where are the spots where the government hasn't quite covered off enough?
8:57Aaron Wherry: where are the businesses that aren't benefiting from all of these programs and where does the government have to kind of step in with new measures.
9:12Let's do the affordability stuff. I think this will be really top of mind for a lot of people, what most people listening probably care the most about. Take me through some of the affordability measures that are in this, kind of the other half of what the government is trying to do with this budget. Yeah. So there's sort of two principal pieces on the affordability side of things. One is the groceries and essentials benefit is being topped up and enhanced. And the other is some changes they're making to the Canada workers benefit. These are, I think you could call them essentially income supports that in particular benefit low income households.
9:53So these are, you know, sort of targeted supports meant to deal with those affordability concerns. There's also the gas tax suspension that they have already previously announced. It gets included in this budget. So that's sort of the main, I think, pieces of the affordability response is sort of tied up in those three policies. I think it's, you know, there's a much larger conversation to
10:19Aaron Wherry: be had about what more they could be doing on affordability. But I think that's, at this point, that seems to be where they're kind of resting. You know, now, granted, I should say, the government would say, look, we've done a bunch of policies and a bunch of measures over the last 18 months. These are the newest things we're introducing. These are the latest steps we're taking. But I think it's, you know, as this kind of cost of living situation or crisis continues to sort of grind on. There's again another situation where it's like, well, what more do you need to do? Well, tell me what more people think that they could do.
10:55I mean, I saw Avi Lewis saying today that today's budget is Christmas come early for CEOs, foreign investors, and arms dealers. We'll talk a little bit about some of the military investment that this budget is also building on a little bit. Francois-Philippe Champagne, the finance minister, actually got into kind of like an argument with Avi Lewis today on television.
11:20Aaron Wherry: Let's do a panel. You guys repaired the set last year when the front fell off. Where is the mega deduction on my grocery bill? Largely about kind of these bread and butter affordability issues. And that one measure, the one measure of the mega deduction is 50 percent more than all of the affordability measures combined. Just flesh out for me the argument that Lewis and I imagine many others are making here. Yeah. So Lewis, I think, is taking aim, you know, at this investment agenda and saying, well, who's going to benefit from it? And essentially making the argument that it's mainly people who are well off at this point and that there's not enough being done for people who essentially aren't well off.
11:59I do think that is, you know, something to keep an eye on. I think, you know, both politically and practically in terms of policy. Politically, I think you see it a bit in the U.S. results in the midterms. And look, American politics and Canadian politics aren't exactly the same. But when people aren't getting ahead, when there's concerns about affordability, if it seems like other people are getting are doing really well, it's that can feed into resentment and that, you know, can build a sort of populist argument for sort of targeting these measures and saying, well, who's really benefiting and why are they benefiting?
12:37And on the policy side, you know, so the government can do these sort of targeted supports, they can, you know, take essentially temporary measures like the gas tax suspension. But I think maybe we're sort of edging up to a larger conversation.
12:56Aaron Wherry: Okay, well, what else can you do to actually improve prices? Like you're dealing with the symptoms, people don't have enough money, but can you do anything to deal with the causes? And in some cases, I suspect the government would say, well, we can't, you know, make the war in Iran not happen. We can't, you know, control the world. But there is a part of the budget where they talk about more choice in everyday life. So they're talking about, you know, banking, telecommunications, grocery stores. These measures that it would be interesting to see where they go with it and how far they can go with it and whether that's sort of the next phase of the affordability conversation is do you need to deal with actual competition in the marketplace?
13:41And is that the solution to at least some of what we're facing? Right. That could be read as a kind of antitrust agenda that's possibly coming in an attempt to kind of break up some of these monopolies. That would, I guess, the argument would be then drive prices down. Yeah. Yeah. And I think that's, you know, people have been having these arguments, you know, particularly in the grocery sector for a while now.
14:08Aaron Wherry: You know, Carney's seen, I think Carney, you know, fairly is seen as a kind of pro-business, pro-investment prime minister running a kind of pro-business government. And the flip side of that will be is if business starts to be blamed for affordability concerns or seeming to benefit too much, does that cause them to have to kind of correct for that?
14:38Support comes from WISE, the smart way to manage the currencies you need around the globe. Fed up with losing out to hidden fees when you send money abroad with your everyday bank? Choose the smart way. Wise. You can count on the exchange rate you'd usually find on Google. No unwelcome surprises. Plus, ditch that where's my money feeling. Most transfers arrive in under 20 seconds. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees. Be smart. Get wise. Download the Wise app today. T's and C's apply. Richmound, Saskatchewan. Population 118. The kind of place where nothing much happens and folks like it that way.
15:18But all that changed when some strangers rolled into town. Cult Queen of Canada tells the wild story of what happens when a cult sets up shop in a sleepy community. The six-part series from CBC Podcasts just won double gold at the Signal Awards. Cult Queen of Canada. Listen now wherever you get your podcasts. LESLIE KENDRICK Carney has also been criticized for selling himself as a climate leader and then pursuing a resource extraction agenda and building pipelines, right? The government would point to its plans for a massive electrification of the grid. But are we getting any more details in this budget about what that actually looks like?
15:57We did get some. Of the major new spending items, line items in this budget, one of the biggest ones is around clean electricity.
16:06Aaron Wherry: It's in part built around extending and expanding some existing investment tax credits. There's some money there for emerging technologies. So a couple of things. The government has put electrification right at the center of its climate agenda. But it is also said, you know, with reason that Canada needs to double, essentially double its electricity capacity over the next 25 years. and the financial crunch there is going to be that somebody has to pay to expand that capacity. And if you don't want that to fall on rate payers or on provincial utilities, then the federal government's going to have to step in and provide some support.
16:53Aaron Wherry: And so I think there's some significant funding in this budget, but I think the next piece is going to be, well, where and how does the federal government sort of step in to kind of backstop the provinces and utilities on this? I just want to come back to the military for a moment. I was reading in the Globe and Mail that the government is actually spending less on the military this year than they did in 2025. But that is not to say that they aren't investing massively in the military. They've overseen the biggest increase in defense spending since World War II. But we were reading the defense portion.
17:29And I'll just say one thing about the budget that is always kind of fun and interesting is that I often learn about stuff that I didn't know about before, like even if it had been previously announced. I completely miss the news that was announced in the spring that we are hoping to develop the capacity to launch rockets to carry satellites into space. This is, so this is, I will say, this is like, to me, evidence of how much this government is doing and how fast that it can make a commitment to send things to space. And a very smart host of a daily news podcast can be like, oh, I didn't notice, I didn't hear about that.
18:08Entirely fairly, because there's just so much going on that it's hard to keep track. It's actually possible that it says more about me than anything else.
18:27Um, homelessness. There is a pledge in this budget to end homelessness in 10 years. Very ambitious thing to pledge. And just take me through how they plan to do that.
18:41Aaron Wherry: So it's a number of programs or a number of initiatives, I guess, totaling up to, I believe it's about$11 billion. A lot of the money going to what they say is going to be building new transitional and supportive housing. It's an obviously ambitious goal. And I think it's fair to say that the Trudeau government's attempts to deal with homelessness ran into some pretty serious challenges coming out of the pandemic. It's funny, it's not going to be something that necessarily gets thrown into the affordability conversation. But I think it is, it strikes me as one of those issues where homelessness is so salient to people who live particularly in cities, big cities, that I can imagine this responding to something that people see coming out of the pandemic and see on a daily basis and want and think something should be done about.
19:34And so we'll see in a decade, I guess, whether they've met their goal. It's always hard to measure these things because, you know, 10 years from now, we will have had at least two more elections.
19:47Aaron Wherry: But it's an interesting step for a government that maybe hasn't, you know, has been seen as not necessarily wanting to focus on social issues or social programs, that they've kind of taken this on and set a pretty ambitious goal around it. I'm going to do a small rapid fire round to just run through a couple of other sort of random things that people might just be interested in in this budget. There's one point five billion dollars earmarked over nine years to construct and rehabilitate community recreational facilities. So like hockey rings across the country. If you make forty five thousand dollars in the arts on original creative works, you will not have to pay taxes on that money.
20:35So that's kind of cool for artists. And free national museums for anyone under 25.
20:42Aaron Wherry: And stamps are now$2. They're now$2. I think why? Because Canada Post kind of doesn't have a lot of cash right now. Is that why they've gone up? I mean, I'm sure this would help. So now you've got to pay$2 for stamps, but you can go to a museum if you're under 25 for free. All right, let's do the deficit. How much will this new spending drive up the deficit? Is that a concern? Are people concerned about that? So the debate about whether it's a concern is a larger one. But surprisingly, for all of this spending, the budget deficit essentially stays where it was. It actually ends up markedly lower for the previous fiscal year, the one that ended last spring.
21:32Aaron Wherry: but the rest of the deficits going out for the next four years are basically the same that's you know roughly between well they go from 62 billion in the current fiscal year to 53 billion in 29 2030 those are i think it would be fair to say relatively large deficits compared to what we were used to before the pandemic. They aren't, by a strict definition of fiscal sustainability, they aren't unsustainable. The government's not in a fiscal crisis. But there are, you know, look, the federal conservatives will always criticize the government for its budget deficits. We asked the prime minister to keep his promise from the election to lower the debt to GDP ratio so that our debt no longer gobbles up so much of the resources needed for health care and other Mesa basic benefits.
22:30Instead, the prime minister has officially broken that promise today.
22:35Aaron Wherry: Their primary criticism of this budget is that it's spending too much, that the public debt is adding up, that with the combination of the larger public debt that the federal government now has, particularly after the pandemic and rising interest rates, It's that public debt charges, that's the amount of money the federal government spends every year to service its debt. That amount of money is going up and that it's becoming a number that the federal government just shouldn't be spending, that this is just eating up too much of the budget. Just on that point, one of the reasons why the deficit was lower than expected this year was because of high oil prices caused by the war in the Middle East and kind of the windfall that that created.
23:19a lot of revenue that came from exporting oil at those high prices. Just what happens if and when the Strait of Hormuz opens back up and prices go down? Like how much of this plan is kind of predicated on oil prices staying high? And is that kind of some of what people are worried about here? So the oil price itself might not be a huge concern going forward because if you go deep
23:45Aaron Wherry: into the annexes of a federal budget, it will show you the oil prices they have projected outward. And if you look at the oil prices they've projected outward, they're pretty low compared to where they are now. So a drop in the price of oil probably wouldn't be necessarily a massive crisis for the federal budget. But there's always some concern that it's not leaving itself enough room, the federal government that is, to respond to a major crisis, to respond to some kind of massive economic shock. You know, if, heaven forbid, we face something like the pandemic again, could we spend as much as you would expect the federal government to?
24:27Aaron Wherry: And I think that's a real conversation to have in terms of how to manage the deficit. Should the federal government be trying to rein things in even more. You know, the federal government, the Carney government's argument is that it has scaled back the amount of spending that goes into the sort of day-to-day functioning of government. And so what it's borrowing for is what they call capital spending, which is spending that will grow the size of the economy. And that that's, you know, sort of a productive thing to borrow money for. Right. But there is going to be that conversation kind of lurking in the background of, okay, we may have some pretty significant fiscal pressures in the next while, in the next sort of medium to long term.
25:11Aaron Wherry: Are we set up to deal with that? And I guess, too, when can we expect to see returns from that investment, right? Yeah, I think that's the biggest piece of this for the Carney government is the idea of being masters of our destiny. I think, you know, people probably can get behind that. The idea that the Canadian economy, even before Donald Trump, that it needed to be jolted and reformed and re-energized, I think lots of people will agree with that. But, you know, on the electoral cycle, you know, looking ahead to a federal election, maybe in 2029, is the is the Carney government going to be able to point to results?
25:59Aaron Wherry: Is it going to be able to say, look at that thing that got built? Look at this thing that is under construction. Look at our, you know, look at the GDP numbers. Look at employment. is it going to be able to show enough results to justify this spending in an election campaign? Because some of these big changes are just going to take time. Like, you know, investment doesn't just snap into place and big things don't just get built overnight. So can they sort of, you know, find proof points over the next few years to make the argument that this big agenda is working? Right. And are kind of everyday people feeling those results?
26:38Or are they translating into results for them? Yes. I mean, I think that's the idea of like sort of shared prosperity is very much, I think, an idea that was kind of associated with the Trudeau government.
26:51Aaron Wherry: But I think you hear a bit of it from the Carney government now in terms of like, look, we're not just doing this for the sake of doing it. We're not just doing it for the sake of GDP or, you know, we want everyone will benefit from this. But again, they'll have to show that. And if they don't, then, you know, you can see the arguments that will come back at them, both from the conservatives and the NDP, the conservatives saying you spent a bunch of money and it didn't achieve much. And the NDP saying your spending priorities were all in the wrong direction. Well, there you go, Aaron. You said earlier that you can't sum up a budget in a couple of sentences, which we didn't, but we did it in under 30 minutes, I think.
27:33So not bad. Okay. Thank you very much.
27:37Aaron Wherry: Anytime.
27:44All right. That is all for today. Front Burner was produced this week by Joytha Shankgupta, Kevin Sexton, Mitchell Stewart, Matthew Almha, Ali Janes, and Mackenzie Cameron. Our YouTube producer is John Lee. Our music is by Joseph Shabison. Our senior producer is Imogen Burchard. Our executive producer is Nick McCabe-Locos. And I'm Jamie Poisson. Have a great weekend and talk to you next week.
The federal budget was unveiled Thursday afternoon, and it lays out some of the big bets the Carney government plans on making in the years ahead. A $36-billion tax break to kickstart an “investment supercycle”. A number of affordability measures. A plan to end homelessness within a decade.
But those bets also raise some uncomfortable questions.
Can we really fast track huge nation building projects and still hit our climate goals? How much debt are we taking on to pay for it all? And will any of this actually make life more affordable?
CBC senior parliamentary writer Aaron Wherry was in the budget lockup, and he’s here to break it all down.
For transcripts of Front Burner, please visit: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/frontburner/transcripts