1. Podcasts
  2. Front Burner
  3. Pete Hegseth survives impeachment, for now
Front Burner

11 Nov 2026 · 28m · 10 chapters

Episode artwork

Pete Hegseth survives impeachment, for now

In short

A CBC discussion of U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s impeachment attempt. Outgoing Republican Rep. Thomas Massie introduced eight impeachment articles; House Republicans halted the process for now, but the speaker argues it could resume with a future Democrat-controlled House.

Guest backgrounds

David Smith, Washington Bureau Chief for The Guardian.

Key claims

Massie accuses Hegseth of unlawful war powers violations and other abuses tied to the Iran war and other Trump-era military operations. The episode also argues Hegseth became the top target due to the Iran war’s political fallout and his highly visible, loyal “machismo” persona.

Notable examples

Iran war without congressional authorization; alleged failure to withdraw and exceeding War Powers Resolution deadlines; rollback of civilian-casualty protections, including an attack on an Iranian school killing over 100 schoolgirls; extrajudicial killings in drug enforcement strikes on boats; threats/retaliation against Sen. Mark Kelly; alleged kidnapping of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro under a narcotics-law pretext; unlawful Yemen campaign.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:46

Background on Pete Hegseth's Controversial Tenure

Explores the controversies surrounding Pete Hegseth's time as Defense Secretary.

“Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Tuesday as he faced questions about an extraordinary attempt to impeach him.”
2:10

The Impeachment Attempt Explained

Discussion on the articles of impeachment introduced against Hegseth.

“With us today is David Smith, the Guardian's Washington Bureau Chief.”
3:15

Detailed Articles of Impeachment

In-depth look at the specific accusations against Hegseth.

“Given all of that, I do want to get into the articles of impeachment and like the accusations that are being made against Hegseth here.”
6:38

Consequences of the Iran War

Examining the implications of the Iran War and its impact on politics.

“And that, of course, centers on Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro and that entire military operation in January.”
8:15

The Role of Hegseth and Others in Military Policies

Analysis of Hegseth's actions and the responses from his peers.

“— There's been so much discussion about the consequences of these midterm elections for the Trump administration.”
12:18

Public Perception and Political Ramifications

Discussion on how Hegseth's actions are viewed by the public and political consequences.

“I mean, in his press conference on Tuesday morning, Hegseth was pretty defiant.”
14:00

The Dynamics of Political Accountability

Explore the complexities surrounding cabinet impeachment and accountability to Congress.

“I suspect Donald Trump was not too happy about that comment, although publicly he did not denounce it and kind of agreed with it.”
17:17

Impeachment: Historical Context and Current Implications

A discussion on the rarity of cabinet impeachments and the implications for Pete Hegseth.

“Only two cabinet secretaries in American history have faced impeachment.”
22:46

Comparing Political Landscapes: Lessons from the Past

Analyze parallels between past administrations and the current political climate regarding accountability and war.

“And just before the 2006 midterms, Bush was adamant that Rumsfeld would continue in his role.”
28:00

The Implications of Stephen Miller's Appointment

Discussing the potential consequences of Stephen Miller's appointment as chief of staff.

“Certainly the appointment of Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff is a warning sign.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Front Burner, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:28Good news for anyone who's bad at waiting. This is a CBC Podcast.

0:37Hi, I'm Jamie Poisson.

0:46These are not high crimes. This is the job. And it's the job well done. That was U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Tuesday as he faced questions about an extraordinary attempt to impeach him. Hegseth has had a deeply polarizing tenure as the U.S. Defense Secretary. There was the controversy over a signal chat in which sensitive military information was shared, the removal of senior military leaders, the questions surrounding the Pentagon's treatment of women and officers from minority backgrounds, and his constant forays into the culture wars. And now there is growing scrutiny of the Trump administration's military operations, including the war in Iran, a series of deadly strikes in the Caribbean and the capture of the Venezuelan president and his wife.

1:35Through all of it, Hegseth has remained defiant as ever, with Donald Trump standing faithfully behind him. But this week, the mounting pressure against Hegseth reached a new apex. Outgoing Republican Congressman Thomas Massey introduced eight articles of impeachment against the Defense Secretary. In a vote Tuesday night, House Republicans halted the impeachment process, for now. Because with the incoming Democrat majorities, Hegseth's troubles are far from over. So what exactly is Hegseth accused of? And how is it that he became the primary target for impeachment? With us today is David Smith, the Guardian's Washington Bureau Chief.

2:22David, hey, it's really great to have you on the show. Thanks so much for being here. Oh, thanks for having me. First, I just want to timestamp this conversation. We are talking at 1 p.m. Eastern time before this vote on whether to move forward with these articles of impeachment. But even if it fails, this attempt to impeach Hegseth is likely not over. And thus, this conversation remains relevant, right? Yeah, this may just be the beginning where at the end of this particular Congress, Thomas Massey is departing. But in the next Congress, impeachment motions that are there do not die, they can carry on.

2:57Or of course, you could see an entirely new attempt to impeach Pete Hexeth once the Democrats have a big House majority. I think he will remain target number one. It'll still be difficult to get through the new Senate, but I do suspect this issue is not going away. Given all of that, I do want to get into the articles of impeachment and like the accusations that are being made against Hegseth here. On Monday afternoon, Massey took to the House floor and introduced articles of impeachment against Hegseth, accusing him of a series of abuses of power and violations of law related to the American war in Iran and several other military operations overseen by the Trump administration.

3:39Peter Brian Hegseth thus warrants impeachment and trial, removal from office and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust or profit under the United States. Can you walk me through the case that you heard him making yesterday? Yeah, Massey set out a very comprehensive case against Pete Hegseth. The first three articles relate to the Iran war. Number one is just the notion of starting the Iran war without congressional authorization. Secretary Hegseth abused the powers of his high office through the following means, executing an unlawful order to commence hostilities despite the absence of a declaration of war.

4:24Number two is then ignoring congressional directives to withdraw from Iran. So that's quite related. The third article is exceeding the War Powers Resolution deadlines. You know, there's a 60-day window under the War Powers Resolution, but the military operations persisted beyond then. And then various other articles as well. The fourth article is a rollback of civilian casualty protections and the striking of civilians And one example of that was the attack on an Iranian school. Over 100 schoolgirls killed in a series of strikes. President Trump has suggested the U.S. may not be responsible, while Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth says the Pentagon is still investigating exactly what happened.

5:13An official briefed on the initial review tells PBS NewsHour the strike was likely American. Such conduct reflects not merely a failure of judgment, but an extraordinary abuse of the powers entrusted to the Secretary of Defense. and a profound disregard for the civilians his department was obligated to protect. The fifth article is extrajudicial killings in drug enforcement operations. And that in particular, of course, relates to these strikes on boats allegedly containing drug traffickers in the Pacific and the Caribbean. Secretary Hegseth arrogated to himself and the executive branch the roles of judge, jury and executioner and asserted a unilateral power to determine who may live and who may die.

5:59And then Article 6 is suppressing free speech and retaliating against a lawmaker. That relates to the case of U.S. Senator Mark Kelly, who allegedly questioned military orders and Hegs have threatened to retaliate against him and demote him and take away his pension. Using the powers of his office, Secretary Hegseth retaliated against and sought to intimidate United States Senator Mark Kelly for his statement through a scheme or course of conduct intended to interfere with Congress's constitutional authority to oversee the executive branch. And then Article 7 is the kidnapping of a foreign leader.

6:41And that, of course, centers on Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro and that entire military operation in January. An act of war against a sovereign country executed under the guise of narcotics law enforcement, though in actuality intended to assert U.S. control over Venezuela's oil reserves. In doing so, he gambled the lives of army. And then the eighth article is an unlawful military campaign in Yemen, which, again, in violation of congressional war powers and reporting requirements. Yeah. Which one of those do you think are most consequential? I think Iran is front and center because that war has been so devastating and has not worked out as Donald Trump and Pete Hegseth promised.

7:30It's had huge global consequences, of course, with energy prices. Even Trump's own Vice President J.D. Vance said the Iran war is what cost Republicans in last week's midterm elections. But I would not overlook Article 5, the extrajudicial killings in drug enforcement operations, these strikes on boats in the Pacific and the Caribbean, because that one might be less complicated than the Iran case. It might be simpler for the House and Senate to really pinpoint Hexeth on this and say, you know, there was no American or international law that justified these attacks, which almost certainly killed innocent people.

8:15— There's been so much discussion about the consequences of these midterm elections for the Trump administration. And really, it's Hegseth, more than anyone else, associated with this government that has come into focus as a candidate for impeachment so far. And I just, how is it that among his peers in the Trump government, you think Hegseth so quickly did that? emerged as like a uniquely dangerous force in need of removal. And this even goes back to the midterm election campaign. I know me and my colleagues at The Guardian when we were visiting various states, interviewing voters, completely unprompted.

9:04Hexth's name often came up as like the personification of what they saw was all that was wrong with the Trump administration and its overreach. And I think part of that, again, is the centrality of the Iran war. It's unusual for foreign policy to play such a prominent role in a US election, but people really felt the consequences of it at the gas pump and in food prices and farmers suffered from diesel and fertilizer costs, partly also perhaps because He is such a big personality. You know, he's out there with these vainglorious videos doing military exercises and press-ups and doing speeches talking about...

9:48No fatties, no d***, no beardos, no weirdos, no wimps, no radicals. Calling for the testosterone levels of the troops to be measured. Ensuring you have the right testosterone levels to operate at your absolute best. Incredibly loyal and some would say sycophantic to Donald Trump. Never had a better commander in chief, full stop. I get to watch him every single day. He lives and breathes America first. And it's the honor of a lifetime to be his secretary of war. And really personifying this machismo, this hyper masculine culture that the Trump administration cultivated. Simply put, the ideological clowns are out.

10:31The patriotic cowboys are in with testosterone testing on top. So, yeah, I think it's a target rich environment. I'm sure Democrats and their supporters would like to impeach many cabinet members for various reasons, not least Robert Kennedy Jr. But but somehow Pete Hegseth came to the top of the list. I saw Democratic House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries refer to Hegsath as the architect of the Iran war. Pete Hegsath has abused his power, undermined America's national security, and he's the architect of the reckless and costly failed war of choice in Iran. Do you think it's believable that Hegsath is the architect behind the war?

11:17Yeah, it's a good question. And I have seen commentary in recent days, arguing that, hang on a minute, if we impeach Hexeth, well, surely he was only following the orders of the boss, Donald Trump, and therefore by implication, Trump should be impeached as well for waging the Iran war, because ultimately, the decision did rest with him. And there's been some reporting suggesting that Trump gave the go ahead after being persuaded by Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel. So, yeah, I think there's a reasonable debate to be had about that. Hexer has certainly been an enthusiastic enforcer and a cheerleader for the war.

11:57And there was a notable moment a few months ago when Trump sort of half jokingly, but not really, suggested that it was Hexth's idea or, you know, he'd been the ultimate one to sort of say, go ahead and do it. And therefore, he would carry the can for it. Pete, I think you were the first one to speak up. And you said, let's do it because you can't let them have a nuclear weapon. I mean, in his press conference on Tuesday morning, Hegseth was pretty defiant. He made a number of arguments. I stand behind every one of these operations. I was proud to execute them and I would do it again tomorrow.

12:37And he argued that impeaching him would amount to putting American soldiers on trial. Put the secretary on trial today and the men and women who carried out those orders tomorrow. If they want to come for the warriors, they're going to have to come through me. But he also made that argument, right, that each of the decisions he made was directed by the president. Iran, the cartels, Maduro, Yemen, everyone was a lawful operation ordered by the commander in chief, then ordered by myself, notified to Congress and executed by American warriors who did their jobs. What about other people who have been instrumental in shaping these policies?

13:22Marco Rubio, J.D. Vance. Rubio in particular has been kind of all over Iran and the U.S. military's actions across Latin America, including a potential military action in Cuba. Why not target either of these guys? J.D. Vance was not a fan of this war from the beginning. And in more or less subtle ways, he's allowed that to be known. And of course, it certainly came out in public last week after the midterm results. Vance was quick to go on social media, saying the Iran war was the reason that we lost these elections. You can have a debate about, you know, was it worth it to lose control of the Senate for six years.

14:02I suspect Donald Trump was not too happy about that comment, although publicly he did not denounce it and kind of agreed with it. A couple of days ago, your vice president, J.D. Vance, wrote a social media post where he says, the reason we lost is the war, meaning Iran. And he said things in that post about Israel. So you agree with his analysis? I don't disagree with it. That whole perception has given Vance some plausible deniability around the war, Although certainly if he runs for president in 28, I'm sure Democrats will hammer him for it anyway, given that he was vice president and he has had to defend it at times.

14:38And Marco Rubio perhaps is even more skillful, I think, at keeping these things at arm's length. I mean, sure, when he has to, he defends the Iran war. I think what the president expresses to you is incredible confidence that if we needed to do something militarily, we would have the ability to do it. And we really we have everything we need to be successful, but we would prefer to do it peacefully. But all the signals are that he's much more engaged with the Western Hemisphere and manages to link himself to the perceived success of Venezuela, which the administration likes to boast about, and other things happening in Latin America.

15:22And I think the perception at least is that Iran is more a Trump-Hexeth operation, and that Russia and Ukraine is dealt more by Jared Kushner and Steve Wyckoff. And somehow, even though he has about 100 jobs, as the memes tell us, Marco Rubio is not so involved in those. In addition to that, I think, you know, some Democrats and others, despite everything, still have that hope or suspicion that Marco Rubio is somehow still a bit more of a normal guy, more of an establishment Republican. Sure, he's working for Trump, but he's not quite as wild and outrageous as Exeth. And so they're relatively at peace with having him in that position.

16:41We'll be right back.

16:49As a kid in the early 2000s, I joined a scrappy new video site called YouTube. We were girls creating content for other girls, but with our growing success came new rules from the man in charge. There was no reason to believe that anything dangerous was going on. No reason until he was taken away in handcuffs. I'm Lauren White, and from CBC's split screen, this is There Goes My Childhood, available now on CBC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts. Only two cabinet secretaries in American history have faced impeachment. One in 1876, actually, over a corruption scandal, and then the other one was a Biden appointee over charges related to immigration enforcement.

17:32Neither was removed for office, and many listening to this will recall the two-time impeachment of Trump from his first term. He was also not removed from office. I just why is impeachment of a cabinet secretary so rare a president as well? Is it the case the cabinet secretaries are ultimately accountable to the president rather than Congress? Yes, I think so. It's a heavy lift to get it done. And it's derided by critics as a stunt, which is what Hegseth said at his press briefing. And perhaps there have not been that many that have committed such outrageous conduct that it's been been warranted, although I suspect the list could have been longer.

18:13It is hard to get it done to the Senate where you require a two thirds majority. And yeah, I suspect they felt usually energy should go elsewhere. I mean, I think even in this case, the paradox is that impeachment might be the best thing that can happen to Pete Hegseth in terms of saving his job. Because a few weeks ago, there was speculation that Donald Trump might fire him as a scapegoat for the Iran war as a way of distancing Trump himself from it. But now, the spectacle of impeachment, with probably all Democrats voting for it, I think is precisely the thing that would make Trump turn around and say, I'm standing by this guy.

18:59I'm not going to allow him to be the victim of a witch hunt, of the weaponization of the deep state and so on. It will actually generate sympathy for Hegseth in right-wing circles and might paradoxically actually rescue his job. Oh, that's really interesting to hear you say that because I was listening to Senator Ted Cruz basically lay the groundwork, I thought, for a resignation or a firing. He said... Either Hegseth is going to step down, either he will resign voluntarily or Trump will fire him. Or if that does not happen, I think it is extremely likely, if not certain, that the House will impeach him because on the face of it, the votes are there.

19:38That's really interesting to hear you say that you think that that's unlikely if this impeachment moves forward. Yeah. And it comes with a caveat that a week ago, everyone was saying Susie Wiles might quit. Oh, no, she's completely safe. And then she was gone as the White House chief of staff. So yeah, it's a very dangerous game predicting anything that Donald Trump will do, of course. Right. Trying to ascribe any kind of rationale. Fair, fair. I want to ask about Thomas Massey here because he's compelling. This is someone who was once very aligned with Trump and the broader MAGA movement, but who has increasingly broken with the president and become one of his most persistent critics.

20:16He's now facing the end of his congressional career having lost his primary to a Trump-backed challenger. And he's using, I guess, what's left of his time in office to force this vote on impeaching the defense secretary. Is there something almost existential about what he's doing here? Is this a politician who has concluded that he has very little left to lose and is now willing to use whatever kind of institutional leverage he has to challenge the president? Yes, I think that's part of it, because it does seem quite early to be doing this, straight after the midterms. But Thomas Massey's on his way out and wants to make a last stand, perhaps, and try and get it on the record that perhaps, you know, Hexerth will be impeached by the House, even if he survives in the Senate.

21:03It makes an important statement that he should not be allowed to have carried out these actions with impunity in the view of Massey and others. I wonder also if Massey, though, has an eye on the future, like what's the next step in his career? There has been some speculation he might even run for president as some kind of independent figure or libertarian, or could he join forces with the likes of Tucker Carlson and Marjorie Taylor Greene in some sort of America First movement? You know, that strand of the Republican Party that remains isolationist and anti-war and feels betrayed by Trump. And it's certainly deeply questioning of the relationship with Israel.

21:51Massey also made headlines with his stand on the Epstein files, of course. I suspect we've probably not heard the last of him. And this will be some useful publicity for whatever's next in his career. I hope he addresses the eight articles and doesn't get up and misquote the Bible in Quentin Tarantino fashion and do some pull-ups and, you know, call everybody fat and gay, like, for being for this impeachment. Like, I may have just given you half his speech. I don't know.

22:33In thinking of an analog for this moment, I'm immediately made to think of 2006 and then President George W. Bush's dismissal of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, one of the American leaders most implicated in the deeply unpopular war in Iraq. And just before the 2006 midterms, Bush was adamant that Rumsfeld would continue in his role. I have strong confidence in Donald Rumsfeld. I hear the voices and I read the front page and I know the speculation. But I'm the decider and I decide what is best. And what's best is for Don Rumsfeld to remain as the secretary of defense. But following Republican losses, Rumsfeld was gone rather quickly.

23:13Do you see similarities between that moment and this moment today or differences? And if so, what are they? Yeah, I think that's a good parallel because the Iraq war was such a disaster and there was that demand from the electorate for accountability. And the defense secretary, you know, one of those neocons really promoting it was a natural choice there. Six years. It's been quite a time. It recalls to mind the statement by Winston Churchill, something to the effect that I have benefited greatly from criticism. And at no time have I suffered a lack thereof. If things play out the same way, and if Pete Hegseth loses his job, I think that will be an obvious echo, one being Iraq, the other Iran.

24:07I mean, as for the differences, I guess, you know, everything is different about the Donald Trump presidency. And he's he actually tried less hard even than George W. Bush to make a case for why this war is is happening in the first place. It's obviously also a different kind of war in terms of far fewer US ground troops and far fewer casualties. I'm sure Donald Rumsfeld's defenders would say, even if you disagreed with him, he was a man of substance and there was intellectual reasoning behind what he was doing. Hexner seems somewhat lightweight by comparison, perhaps zealous in terms of his Christian nationalism, but otherwise a former Fox News TV host.

24:54And that journey from Rumsfeld to Hexner perhaps says a lot about the trajectory of American politics over two decades. In terms of blowback and political consequences, what lessons do you think the Trump White House could, in theory, take from the example provided by the Bush White House? Yeah, it's a good question. And of course, for a start, they won't because we often hear Donald Trump denounce the Iraq war and the Bush years. And a member of the Bush family, of course, even voted for the Democrat in the recent Texas Senate election. And even on Monday, Trump was again making this comparison of how many people died in Vietnam and Iraq and how low the total is in Iran, he would say.

25:44There were moments, I guess, when the Bush administration worked with Democrats on immigration and other issues. There seems very little sign of Donald Trump's Republican Party doing that with Stephen Miller as chief of staff. It seems to be preparing for all out war for the next couple of years in terms of congressional hearings and oversight. It has been a strange feature of recent years how the Trump presidency has made even some Democrats nostalgic for the Bush era. And George W. Bush has been partially rehabilitated as a cuddly figure, sort of hugging Michelle Obama and so on. But I think one has to be careful about that because the Bush years were not so golden and the Iraq war was a catastrophe that shaped much of the 21st century.

26:35And, you know, you could certainly argue some things that happened during Bush, along with others, created exactly the conditions that gave rise to Trump.

26:47You know, we've talked on the show about the possibility that there's a world in which Trump interprets the midterm results as a reason to moderate, to recognize that voters have become dissatisfied with some of his priorities or basically all of his priorities and to make adjustments accordingly. On immigration, for example, he suggested that this could be possible, kind of softening his tone in a recent 60 Minutes interview. But there's another possibility here, right, that he sees the result as a reason to accelerate, to pursue his agenda more forcefully, to demonstrate there he remains in control.

27:19And on this, many will point to the appointment of Stephen Miller to chief of staff, maybe the most radical accelerationist member of his inner circle. And people will point to Iran as something that this administration could try to accelerate, to try and prove the point that they could win it once and for all. Looking at things, which of these possibilities do you feel is most likely? I think we're more likely to see Trump go even more MAGA and even more imperial. His philosophy since his business days was, you know, never surrender, just fight back harder. And we've seen that kind of rhetoric from him and Pete Hegseth and others.

28:00Certainly the appointment of Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff is a warning sign. And, you know, there are a lot of indications that with Miller on board, it's all about further expanding executive authority, even beyond what we saw in the first two years when Congress was really pushed aside. We've heard the Attorney General, Todd Blanche, already warning Democrats that if they go too far investigating, they could face prosecution from the Justice Department. We've heard indications is that Trump might issue more pardons. This does not sound like a man who's willing to, at the age of 80, suddenly moderate and tone it down and give us peace in our time with handshakes with Democrats.

28:53And when you just hear his speeches, he seems more and more isolated, more and more like a cornered animal who might lash out at any moment. And certainly there are commentators I've spoken to who fear that a lame duck Donald Trump in his final two years without control of Congress is perhaps going to be more dangerous and reckless than ever. Okay. That feels like a good place for us to end. David, thank you so much for this. It's really great to have you. Thank you.

29:33All right, that is all for today. I'm Jamie Poisson. Thanks so much for listening. Talk to you tomorrow.

29:49For more CBC Podcasts, go to cbc.ca slash podcasts.

From the publisher

On Monday afternoon, Republican congressman Thomas Massie took to the house floor to introduce eight articles of impeachment against the U.S. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth, accusing him of a series of abuses of power and violations of the law related to the American war in Iran, an allegedly illegal war in Yemen, strikes in the Caribbean, and the capture of the Venezuelan President Nicholas Maduro, among other violations. 


On Tuesday evening House Republicans halted the impeachment process, for now. But with Democrats poised to take control of Congress in January, this is far from over. 


So, what exactly is Pete Hegseth accused of? And how did he become the Trump administration's primary target for impeachment? 

With us today is David Smith, The Guardian's Washington bureau chief. 


For transcripts of Front Burner, please visit: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/frontburner/transcripts 

More from Front Burner

All episodes