1. Podcasts
  2. Front Burner
  3. Republicans, Islamophobia and the midterms
Front Burner

3 Nov 2026 · 25m · 10 chapters

Episode artwork

Republicans, Islamophobia and the midterms

In short

Islamophobia in U.S. midterm politics, focusing on how Republican candidates weaponize Muslim identity to attack Democratic figures, especially Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, and how this creates “contingent citizenship” for Muslim Americans.

Guest backgrounds

Mustafa Bayoumi, professor of English at Brooklyn College; author of How Does It Feel to Be a Problem? being young and Arab in America.

Key claims

Islamophobic attacks have “gone absolutely insane,” rely on myth-making, and are used to suppress discussion of policy. The Muslim Brotherhood accusation is portrayed as misleading and fear-based (“Muslim” + “brotherhood”). Birtherism logic persists: a birth certificate is treated as insufficient because whiteness is assumed to equal Americanness. Both parties can fail Muslim Americans through an “asterisk” approach.

Notable examples

Trump calling El-Sayed “Abdul Ramadan” and alleging he’s a “vicious, violent jihadist”; Tim Scott claiming El-Sayed’s parents funded Osama bin Laden; Ted Cruz linking him to the Muslim Brotherhood; Bernie Moreno questioning his fitness. Attacks also discussed against Ilhan Omar (citizenship/investigation after a home search) and RFK Jr.’s anti-Arab “no Nobel prizes” claims. El-Sayed’s “Best Dad” bracelet and FBI/local alerts illustrate personal costs.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:16

Islamophobia in Republican Politics

Discussing the rise of Islamophobia in the midterm elections and its implications.

“The guy in Michigan is pretty bad, too, I must say.”
1:35

Attacks on Abdul El-Sayed

Analysis of the Republican attacks against Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed.

“Mustafa, it's a real pleasure to have you.”
3:20

Historical Context of Religious Intolerance

Examining the historical context of religious intolerance in American politics.

“They actually help fund Osama bin Laden.”
5:28

Racial Dynamics of Americanness

Exploring how racial and cultural identity affect perceptions of Americanness.

“I mean, the latest polls have al-Sayed up.”
8:13

Comparison of Political Styles

Comparison between political approaches of Abdul El-Sayed and Zoran Mamdani.

“Well, I'm pretty sure that Laura Loomer does not speak Arabic.”
14:01

The Political Dynamics of Stevens' Defection

Discusses the motivations and implications behind Stevens' support for Mike Rogers over El-Sayed.

“And the idea that one has to only be palatable and nice, I think that there's a politics behind that demand at the same time.”
16:39

The Impact of Islamophobia on Muslim Citizenship

Explores the implications of Islamophobia on the citizenship status of Muslim Americans.

“Another kind of primary target of these Islamophobic attacks has been Minnesota Congresswoman Ilhan Omar.”
19:21

Cultural Perceptions and Arab Identity

Examines cultural perceptions about Arabs and the response to anti-Arab rhetoric.

“Now everybody loves Zohran, but at the time, Chuck Schumer wouldn't even meet with him, nor Cory Booker.”
22:31

The Personal Cost of Politics

Highlights the emotional toll of public life on Muslim Americans through Abdul al-Sayed's experience.

“And then there are people who are claiming a space to say, look, I am a human being.”
23:23

Recognizing the Humanity of Muslim Americans

Calls for acknowledgment of the full humanity and struggles of Muslim Americans in the face of prejudice.

“We've spent a lot of time during this conversation talking about Islamophobia and racism as like a national issue, about it affecting groups of people in the aggregate.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Front Burner, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Get ready for a brand new season of Dragon's Den with a new full-time dragon. Drew Scott from Property Brothers. Thursdays at 8, 8.30 Newfoundland. Stream now on CBC and CBC Gem. Brought to you in part by AWS. This is a CBC Podcast.

0:22Hey, I'm Jamie Poisson.

0:30The guy in Michigan is pretty bad, too, I must say. Mohammed, as I call him. Actually, his middle name is Mohammed. You know, if you have any question about somebody from that part of the world's name, just call him Mohammed. You'll be right. 64 % of the time, you'll be right. That was Donald Trump on the midterm campaign trail referring to Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic Senate candidate in Michigan. For much of his political life, Trump has been accused of exploiting racial and cultural resentment. And yet, in the last election, he made inroads with some of the very communities his rhetoric has so often targeted.

1:09Now, as the country heads to the midterms, we take a closer look at how Islamophobia has been weaponized by Republican candidates and leadership. Mustafa Bayoumi is a professor of English at Brooklyn College and the author of How Does It Feel to Be a Problem? being young and Arab in America, and he is our guest today.

1:35Mustafa, it's a real pleasure to have you. Thank you so much for being here.

1:38Moustafa Bayoumi: Thank you. I'm honored to be here. Why don't we begin with some of what you have been seeing in these last few weeks and months as it relates to Islamophobia. Do you feel like it's been particularly virulent? Does this feel like a departure of standard American politics, an accelerated version of it, maybe? Or do you see this as kind of like the beginning of something new? The term off the hook comes to mind. It's gone absolutely insane. The levels of hatred, the levels of just pure, unadulterated myth-making around anybody who has a Muslim name, the racist assumptions that are being battered around.

2:21Moustafa Bayoumi: It does follow a trajectory. We've seen this before, especially within the Republican Party, but this seems to a different degree than we've seen before. Much of it has been centered on Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic Senate candidate in Michigan. You'd think that their campaign might want to mention gas or groceries, But instead, they just want to point to me and be like, he's Muslim. Y 'all, let me just tell you, I am Muslim. Al-Sayed is a Michigan-born epidemiologist of Egyptian ancestry, and both his background and his Muslim faith have become the subject of this kind of relentless Republican attack.

3:03And as we recently talked about on the show, let me go through some examples here. Trump has called him a vicious, violent jihadist and misnamed him. Abdul Ramadan. Senator Tim Scott has accused his parents of funding Osama bin Laden. They don't just flirt with terrorism. They actually help fund Osama bin Laden. Ted Cruz has suggested that if he is correct, that al-Zayed is a passionate supporter of the Muslim Brotherhood and were elected and placed on the Senate Intelligence Committee. There is a very real risk that Americans will die as a result. Senator Bernie Moreno has questioned his fitness for office.

3:44Do you think he understands that concept that our rights come from God Almighty? That Jesus came here for our salvation? He should be nowhere near Washington, D.C. And this is just kind of like a sample size that I've gone through. What is it about al-Sayed in particular that you think has roused this specific kind of response?

4:08Moustafa Bayoumi: Well, I think for one thing, he seems to me a very talented, progressive minded politician. And so on one level, it's a fear from the Republican Party that they have to take down all of the progressive minded politicians, especially, you know, in the Senate. This is his is a key seat for sure. But added to that, and probably even more important, is, of course, his identity. What's interesting to me is that he's not running on his identity. He's running on a platform. But they're trying to discourage any conversation around the platform and then focus instead on the myths that surround his identity from a basically, essentially racist Republican point of view.

4:50Moustafa Bayoumi: And I think it's also something that we've seen. And again, we've seen it before with Muslims, but we've seen it even in the past in American history. I mean, for a long time, Catholics were also considered to be dangerous fifth columnists, but they've reached acceptance in the United States. And also with Jewish people. For a long time, Jewish people were also seen as, you know, the ones who were bringing in communism onto the shores of the United States. And now Jewish people are fully accepted, I think, within American political establishment. So it's something that we have seen before, but to see it in an era that's supposedly more enlightened is completely discouraging.

5:27Are you seeing any signs that the strategy is gaining traction, that it's been working, I guess? I mean, the latest polls have al-Sayed up. I kind of see the range between plus four to plus 11.

5:41Moustafa Bayoumi: I don't think that it's working. I mean, I think that it certainly solidifies a base that's already predisposed to Islamophobic ideas, but they're not the ones who are going to vote for Abdul Sayyid anyways in the first place. And, you know, if we see Donald Trump kind of, you know, trying over and over again to rile up his base on an Islamophobic platform, we also see dwindling support for Donald Trump. So it seems to me like a flailing strategy ultimately in the end. A central attack against al-Sayed is this attempt to associate him with the Muslim Brotherhood, a transnational organization which originates in his parents' home nation of Egypt.

6:22There have been these repeated demands that al-Sayed disavow the organization despite no established evidence that he has any real connection to it. Anyone with that record of support for jihadists would be screened and unable to get a seat on an airplane. They certainly should not give him a seat in the United States Senate. Abdul El-Sayed, the son-in-law of a leading member of several brotherhood groups, won Michigan's Democrat primary for U.S. Senate. He asked the new Muslim Brotherhood, excuse me, head, Morrissey, in Egypt to defund the police there, too. What do you make of this nexus drawn between al-Sayed and the group?

7:07And what do you make of the way it's being invoked here? Why has it become, to them, such a useful political accusation?

7:15Moustafa Bayoumi: Yeah, I'm really glad you asked this question because it's, I think, a very, again, it's a very mythical treatment of an organization. Whatever you think of the Muslim Brotherhood, they were democratically elected to lead Egypt in post-revolution. And during that time, as a student, Abdullah Sayyid signed on to a letter that said that they should follow through by making civil society, you know, a more fair and equal place by purging the old regime elements from the government. That seems to me to be actually a quite reasonable demand that has nothing to do with extremist ideology. It has to do with forging a future for a state.

7:54Moustafa Bayoumi: But the key point of that was that that letter was in Arabic. And I don't think people like Laura Loomer, who started, you know, the association that Abdul Sayyid is part of the Muslim Brotherhood. She's the Trump confidant who is extremely Islamophobic and very right wing. So how did we get to this point where we have a full blown Muslim Brotherhood supporter about to win potentially a United States Senate seat? Well, I'm pretty sure that Laura Loomer does not speak Arabic. So I don't know, you know, what truth value she has in this question. And I think it's just a way in which you can put two words together, Muslim and brotherhood.

8:35Moustafa Bayoumi: it sounds really scary to the American people, and that association then just takes over. But, you know, actually, the Muslim Brotherhood, the mainstream of the Muslim Brotherhood, renounced violence all the way back in the 1970s. They essentially have gained their support through kind of social service network within the country of Egypt over many years. So they don't really match, I think, what people are believing that they are in the United States. But isn't that exactly how these kinds of racist attacks work.

9:14Some people listening to this might remember Donald Trump was one of the people credited with having kind of mainstreamed the racist birtherism myth around former U.S. President Barack Obama, questioning whether he was born in the U.S. demanding that he produce a birth certificate. More than a decade later, we're now seeing the case prosecuted against al-Sayed's identity, I think, but in a different way this time around. Abdul has a birth certificate. The birth certificate says he's a citizen of America. There's like an acknowledgement that al-Sayed was born in the U.S., but arguing that birth alone does not confer Americanness.

9:55I'm thinking, for example, of this clip from a recent rally in Michigan where the father of a 9-11 hero is standing beside Trump, and he's saying... You know what? A birth certificate doesn't make you an American.

10:11He demonstrates with his view of what our world should look like that he's not an American. He's anti-American. What do you make of that through line between Trump's birtherism in 2011 and what we're seeing today?

10:26Moustafa Bayoumi: Yeah, that's a great question. I mean, I think, for one thing, I just want to be 100 % clear, a birth certificate does make you American, for one thing. But the implication, I think, in that statement, and all the way going back to the birtherism movement, is that what makes you American in their eyes is your white skin. And people who don't have white skin have to prove their Americanness instead of having it assumed. And this is what they're saying. And the way that you can prove your Americanness is that you have to just satisfy whatever the demands that they have of you. So it's actually a completely demobilizing, dehumanizing demand from a right-wing, white-centered political point of view.

11:16Moustafa Bayoumi: And I think that we've seen very clearly that that's the base that Donald Trump has been appealing to since the very beginning of his entry into politics. It predates even his time in the White House. I mean, we saw it all the way going back to when he was leading the charge against the Central Park Five. And I know that they were innocent of the allegations against them as well. A reporter asked me whether or not I had any compassion or feeling for the people that did it. Do I have hatred for them? I said, of course I hate these people. And let's all hate these people because maybe hate is what we need if we're going to get something done.

11:49Another comparison that I've seen lately is one that's being drawn between New York City Mayor Zoran Mamdani and al-Sayed. Mamdani has, of course, also suffered racism and Islamophobia. But you're also now seeing this kind of argument emerge that Zoran approaches politics in a fashion that's more like palatable for the American audience and that al-Sayed is too arrogant, too angry, too combative or kind of lacks the necessary political grace possessed by, you know, the always smiling, telegenic Mamdani. You know who else is really arrogant? The guy from Michigan I've been watching. Maybe worth noting here, former Democratic Senate candidate and now defector Haley Stevens, who turned on El-Sayed in quite a spectacular fashion this weekend and endorsed his Republican challenger, talked about him getting angrier and angrier.

12:42When trying to explain why she flipped her vote, Meghan McCain, the conservative commentator, is also among those who've suggested El-Sayed needs to be more like Zoran. I just what do you make of the comparison between these two men and what's kind of implicit in that? Well, for one thing, I think these are kinds of ways that they're always trying to, I would say, discipline people of color and scold them in certain kinds of ways.

13:06Moustafa Bayoumi: So using one person of color against another, to me, doesn't seem particularly progressive. It doesn't seem particularly astute, because there are different contexts that they're working in as well. And so I think that someone like Abdullah Sayed, you know, he actually, to my ear, speaks a very Michigan kind of centered language. You know, I grew up in Canada. I grew up actually in Kingston, so eastern Ontario. But I had friends, you know, all the way into Windsor as well. And we used to go down to Michigan quite often. And, you know, I'm familiar with the sort of Arab American community of Michigan.

13:43Moustafa Bayoumi: And I think that he reflects that spirit very aptly. aptly. Zohran Mandani, I think, is really a very obviously talented politician. And his community that he's leading is the New York City community. They're different. They come out of different milieus. They're going to speak different languages. And the idea that one has to only be palatable and nice, I think that there's a politics behind that demand at the same time. And I think we should be very clear about understanding what those political demands being made of people like El-Sayed are. I just want to stick with the Stevens drama for just a moment.

14:21You know, she, as we just talked about, kind of framed her defection around the fact that El-Sayed is, as she sees it, divisive, angry, hateful, permissive in some way of anti-Semitism. My vote for Senate is going to be with Mike Rogers. And I will tell you why. Because we have to stand with country. We can't stand with hate. We can't stand with Hassan Piker. But she has now thrown her support behind Mike Rogers, a man who is running one of the most extreme Senate campaigns that we've seen. I think that's fair to say in modern American history. Trump just last night said that he would love her to join the Republican Party.

15:03Actually, I think that could happen. And then he immediately pivoted into a riff about al-Sayed being a jihadist. And I guess the question here is, like, have you worked out how Stevens is able to justify this case that she's making about al-Sayed with her own tolerance of hate in the case of both Trump and Mike Rogers?

15:23Moustafa Bayoumi: There was about a 15 minute interview with her on CNN yesterday. She was completely, I think, incoherent and unable to provide an answer as to why she changed her mind. I was there and just, you know, alone with my thoughts. I was writing things out. And look, this level of anger and the things that we are seeing, look, we all want Democrats to win. So I think that there's something else going on here. And to me, I think what's really happening is I see it as that she's setting herself up for a kind of post-elected office life, probably one that's firmly in the pro-Israel camp, you know, as a media pundit or what have you.

16:07Moustafa Bayoumi: You know, that's fine. But to attempt to take down the entire Democratic Party to do so at the same time, I mean, I think that's despicable, frankly.

16:37Brought to you in part by AWS. Another kind of primary target of these Islamophobic attacks has been Minnesota Congresswoman Ilhan Omar. I love this Ilhan Omar, whatever the hell it is, with the little shoe, the little turban. I love it. She comes to our country and she's always complaining about... The Trump administration is now investigating her immigration history following a search of her home. and the investigation could, I guess, potentially lead to an effort to revoke her citizenship and deport her. We were talking about Mamdani earlier. When he was running, Trump questioned his citizenship too, and Republican lawmakers called for him to be denaturalized and deported.

17:21I just, what kind of message does this send to other naturalized Americans?

17:26Moustafa Bayoumi: It sends a terrible message. And I think that one of the things that we should be taking note of is that these are all self-identified Muslim Americans as well. And I think really what it's saying is that Muslim American citizenship, as far as certain members of the political classes operate, Muslim American citizenship, unlike other people's citizenship, it's contingent upon their succumbing to the dictates of those in power. I think that's terrible. It's like setting up two different versions of citizenship. And it's something that you see coming very much from the Republicans. But we've also seen it even in the past from the Democrats.

18:08Moustafa Bayoumi: I mean, there was a time in 2016, for example, when Bill Clinton got up on stage during the Democratic National Convention and very, very paternalistically, you know, starts lecturing Muslim Americans saying, If you're a Muslim and you love America and freedom and you hate terror, stay here and help us win and make a future together. We want you. If, if, if, you know, as if Muslim Americans need to prove their bona fides for being American at every step, while other Americans don't have to do the same thing. That level of contingent citizenship, I think, is something that shadows and plagues Muslim Americans.

18:50Moustafa Bayoumi: And it's a feature of what 21st century Islamophobia and really racism looks like. We've been talking about this broader Republican election strategy that we're seeing right now. But what about the Democratic Party and the rule that it might be playing right now, whether or not they're participating in this campaign or whether you feel the party leadership has sufficiently stood up on behalf of their colleagues, kind of suffering these attacks? Yeah, I mean, just go back to when we had the recent election of Zohran Mamdani again to bring him up. Now everybody loves Zohran, but at the time, Chuck Schumer wouldn't even meet with him, nor Cory Booker.

19:27Moustafa Bayoumi: He was the one who got the nomination, and you saw the main leadership of his own party ignoring him. You know, I think, again, this is not the party that is saying that Muslim Americans are fully members of our party. There's always a kind of like asterisk by their names. And I think that that betrays Muslim Americans deeply at the core. and it also illustrates that the democratic party i think needs to wake up and understand that they have to protect the rights of all of the citizens of the country uh even when it might seem inconvenient and i think the muslim american politicians themselves are leading the way for that so what's actually i find very interesting is the ways in which the muslim american political class is emerging in this time of heightened islamophobia as a way to counter all this Islamophobia and the rest of the political establishment, I think, needs to wake up to that.

20:37I think part of the point that's being made here today is that these kinds of racist ideas are not kind of simply present in the political domain. They live in like the broader culture that can show up in all kinds of ways. I also wanted to ask you about some comments made by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. at a campaign stop, again, in Michigan recently. This is the U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services. And he said there are 500 million Arabs in the world, and yet they don't produce science. They don't win the Nobel Prize. They don't win the field prize. They don't win the Wolf Prize. They don't produce literature.

21:13They used to produce. They were the first. These are kind of de-civilizational claims. They're categorically false, but they're also cultural ideas. And when you hear a national leader making that kind of claim, what do you hear in a statement like that? What purpose does it serve?

21:30Moustafa Bayoumi: Yeah, I mean, I think it illustrates, for one thing, a kind of deep anti-intellectualism of our leaders. You know, I mean, RFK Jr. is also somebody who believes the long debunked theory that, you know, vaccines are the cause for autism. And then to project a kind of anti-intellectualism on another large group of people, when really I think it illustrates your own lack of engagement with the world of ideas. Unfortunately, it has still too much currency in American popular culture. But I think, again, that's all the more reason why it's more and more important to recognize the ways in which Muslim Americans, Arab Americans are claiming their space, their rightful space in American culture.

22:24Moustafa Bayoumi: So I think that this is really, it's a battle that we're all engaged in. And it's really a battle between, I don't want to sound so simplistic, but there are these sort of dark forces that are just trying to shut down conversation, shut down people, use these boogeyman arguments like, you know, Arabs don't do this or don't do that. And then there are people who are claiming a space to say, look, I am a human being. My people are humans. Here's how we live our lives. In my estimation, the choice between those two is actually a very simple one. To that point, Abdul Al-Sayed, there was this profile of him published recently in The New Yorker, and it included this moment that I've been thinking about a lot.

23:06But the writer noticed a bracelet among his things, and it read, Best Dad. And when asked about it, El-Sayed actually began to cry, explaining that his daughters had made it for him and that he worried his decision to run for office may have compromised the safety of his wife and children. There have been alerts from the FBI and local law enforcement. We've spent a lot of time during this conversation talking about Islamophobia and racism as like a national issue, about it affecting groups of people in the aggregate. But ultimately, it's personal as well, right? and people have to deal with this in the kind of intimate, quiet corners of their lives.

23:40And when you think about someone like Abdul al-Sayed, what do you think is the personal cost of this kind of politics?

23:46Moustafa Bayoumi: I think that's a really great question. And I think it's something that every Muslim American, especially ones who are in the public eye, every Muslim American is familiar with that pressure, that stress. It might not be to the same degree as what Abdul al-Sayed is going through right now, But that knowledge that there's always lurking in the background and sometimes very present in the foreground, a force that is willing and waiting to confront you with the most base kind of assumptions about yourself that you don't believe. And it takes a psychological toll. I mean, when I read that too, that profile, and I read that part of the profile, I myself started tearing up because I understand exactly those same kinds of pressures.

24:33Moustafa Bayoumi: These are not abstractions. These are the ways that people are actually living their lives. And there are extraordinary and sometimes dangerous consequences to this. And I think that it's really, it's high time that we recognize not just the dangers, but the full humanity of our fellow Muslim Americans in this country. My name is Aburrahman Mohamed Sayyid. And that name, that name is just as American as Mike or Donald or whatever JD stands for. Mustafa, thank you so much for this. It was really wonderful talking to you. Thank you, Jamie. It was really a pleasure.

25:20All right, that is all for today. I'm Jamie Poisson. Thanks so much for listening. Talk to you tomorrow.

25:35For more CBC Podcasts, go to cbc.ca slash podcasts.

From the publisher

As the U.S. voters head to the midterm polls, Republican candidates and leaders are targeting Muslim and Arab Americans casting them as suspect, questioning their loyalties, and their place in American life.


Much of this has centred on Michigan Democratic candidate Abdul El-Sayed, and Minnesota Democratic congresswoman Ilhan Omar, but they are not alone.


Today, we take a closer look at Islamophobia on the Republican campaign trail and ask how anti-Muslim fear, skepticism and hate can be cultivated and used for political ends. 


Moustafa Bayoumi is a professor of English at Brooklyn College and the author of 'How Does It Feel to Be a Problem?: Being Young and Arab in America.' He's our guest today.


For transcripts of Front Burner, please visit: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/frontburner/transcripts 

More from Front Burner

All episodes