1. Podcasts
  2. Front Burner
  3. The Dems won big, but what comes next?
Front Burner

5 Nov 2026 · 29m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

The Dems won big, but what comes next?

In short

After Democrats’ midterm sweep, the episode analyzes why the results happened and what comes next for Trump, Republicans, Democrats, and Canada—covering election integrity, cost-of-living drivers, opposition to the Iran war, and backlash against data centers.

Guest backgrounds

David A. Graham, U.S. politics reporter for The Atlantic, based in North Carolina.

Key claims

The election wasn’t “rigged” because Democrats won decisively (“too big to rig”); Trump largely accepted results due to lack of votes and limited interference. Voters blamed Trump for high prices, opposed the Iran war, and rejected data centers (notably via ballot initiatives). Young men and Latino voters shifted back toward Democrats, suggesting “free agents” rather than fixed party loyalty. Trump will likely govern via executive power and vetoes, not be chastened, and may escalate priorities (including Iran and tariffs). Republican establishment responsibility is questioned for enabling Trump.

Notable examples

North Carolina gerrymandering backfiring; Democrats gaining state House control and Senate gains; Mississippi Senate race still undecided; DOJ subpoenas tied to alleged Dan Sullivan name-recruitment scheme; Truth Social defense of data centers; J.D. Vance’s claim that Iran was the key loss; DeSantis pivoting against data centers.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Midterm Election Analysis

An examination of the Democratic victories in the midterms and the implications for North Carolina.

“Today, in the wake of the Democratic sweep of the midterms, a deeper look at how we got here.”
1:34

Midterm Election Analysis

An examination of the Democratic victories in the midterms and the implications for North Carolina.

“The small business owners watching their livelihoods disappear because of tariffs.”
2:15

Gerrymandering Effects

Discussion about gerrymandering in North Carolina and its impact on election outcomes.

“As you say, we have a Senate candidate who won, which was widely expected.”
3:50

Election Integrity Concerns

Insights on election integrity issues and Trump’s acceptance of the midterm results.

“And we don't have enough final results to know, but it seems like many of these races may have ended up actually costing Republican seats at worst and at best coming out as a wash for them.”
4:52

Key Issues in Voter Sentiment

Exploration of key issues like cost of living and corruption that influenced voter decisions.

“Hey, look, bottom line is they were not able in many cases to get the votes.”
7:15

Data Centers and Voter Backlash

Discussion on how opposition to data centers reflects broader voter anxieties.

“And I think corruption is also really at the top of voters' lists.”
9:18

Republican Realignment and Future Challenges

Analyzes the implications of the election results for Republican leaders and potential realignments.

“It's been really interesting to watch Ron DeSantis, even the last few weeks before the election.”
15:22

Demographic Shifts in Voting

Discussion on changing demographics and their impact on elections.

“There were all kinds of interesting demographic shifts that are coming out now.”
17:06

Trump's Governance Style

Exploration of how Donald Trump might govern in the future.

“agents went for somebody else do you see this realignment that we've seen um as something durable for the Democrats or like just maybe to your point, is it is it just incredibly fickle?”
19:22

Trump's Legacy Considerations

Analysis of how Trump's legacy might influence his future actions.

“but he is going to have to reckon with oversight and, and, you know, Democrats, you got Democrats coming out last night saying, you know, this official statements like lawyer up and subpoenas.”
Show all 14 chapters
21:38

Republican Party Dynamics

Discussion on the Republican Party's internal conflicts and future.

“or physical projects like a ballroom, like an arch, like these kinds of things.”
24:24

Democrats' Internal Conflicts

Examination of the Democratic Party's struggles and successes.

“And I think seeing somebody like Ron DeSantis look for another path or seeing J.D.”
28:01

Impact of Midterm Results on U.S.-Canada Relations

Explore how the recent midterm elections might influence U.S.-Canada relations and tariff policies.

“Of course, Democrats should match the districts where they are.”
29:54

Trump's Response to Pressure on Tariffs

Discuss potential reactions from Trump regarding tariffs in light of midterm election outcomes.

“Does it put him under more pressure when it comes to tariffs?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Front Burner, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01You know what they say. Good things come to those who shop early, especially when we're talking early Black Friday deals and lows. Get up to 50 % off select major appliances. Plus, get free delivery, haul away, installation, and parts on purchases of$896 or more. Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's. In-store and online. Valid through 12-2 while supplies last. Selection varies by location.

0:31This is a CBC Podcast.

0:44David A. Graham: Hey everybody, it's Jamie. Today, in the wake of the Democratic sweep of the midterms, a deeper look at how we got here. From the war in Iran to data centres. And what could come next from a rejected Republican Party and a blue Congress, including for Canada. I've got David A. Graham with me. He covers U.S. politics for The Atlantic.

1:09David A. Graham: David, it's great to have you. Thanks so much for being here. Oh, thank you for having me. So we covered a lot of the top-line news late last night related to today's results. But given that you are in North Carolina, a state that had not voted for a Democratic senator since 2008, I believe, and voted one in last night. This campaign was powered by you, the people of North Carolina. And together, we're standing up for the people Washington has let down. The small business owners watching their livelihoods disappear because of tariffs. The people who need health care and are terrified of seeing the federal government take it away.

1:52the farmers getting crushed by the cost of fertilizer and diesel because of this never-ending war.

1:59David A. Graham: This is a state where there was all kinds of gerrymandering concerns as well related to the state's electoral map and the redrawing of the electoral map. Talk to me a little bit about what you saw in North Carolina in particular. Yeah, I mean, I think North Carolina is a good representation of a lot of the national dynamics. As you say, we have a Senate candidate who won, which was widely expected. He was favored for a long time. But we also have in the House a lot of races that are not yet called. But it looks like Democrats may actually end up with a majority of the House seats in the state.

2:32And this is a state that was heavily gerrymandered for a long time to create more Republican seats. At President Trump's behest, state Republicans gerrymandered it even more. And it seemed like they may be overreaching in some cases. But we have people We have a former Speaker of the State House who drew a district basically for himself who looks like we'll lose. The head of the National Republican Committee to elect members of the House looks likely to lose. And then if you look further down the ballot, I mean, there's more of this. We have court candidates who are Democrats winning. You have Democrats flipping control of the State House of Representatives, which they haven't had since the 2010 election.

3:10You see them making gains in the Senate. And so I think you see that across the board. Democrats are winning at the top of the ticket, but also further down. There's this wave that is washing over Republican candidates at every level.

3:21David A. Graham: And just on the gerrymandering stuff, am I right to say that the kind of futility of the gerrymandering is not just happening in North Carolina, right? There are other states, heavily gerrymandered states where it just didn't didn't seem to matter. Yeah, exactly. Or it seems to have, in some cases, have backfired a little bit because you only, you know, Republicans only have so many voters to divide and they have to spread them more thinly to gerrymander. They were also working on assumptions of a kind of an electorate that looked like 2024. And we don't have enough final results to know, but it seems like many of these races may have ended up actually costing Republican seats at worst and at best coming out as a wash for them.

4:11David A. Graham: I want to dig in to what we do know about the electorate a little bit more with you in a couple of minutes. But first, I want to do election integrity with you first, because it's just something that you spend so much time covering. And we had you on the show a while back to talk about Trump's incursions into U.S. elections administration and some of the concerns that you had about the integrity of the process itself. There were fears that Trump may send federal law enforcement to polling places or that allegations of voter fraud could be used to manufacture grounds to challenge election results or delay certification.

4:42David A. Graham: And most significantly, that there was a world in which the president would simply refuse to recognize the outcome of an unfavorable election. Now that we've seen the election take place, were you surprised by how quickly Trump accepted these results? Hey, look, bottom line is they were not able in many cases to get the votes. And I think the Democrats did a good job. I think it came down to a phrase we've seen around for a few cycles now is too big to rig. And I think that's what happened. This wasn't like a close election. It wasn't a situation where there was one Senate seat. There was the hinge point, which is a scenario that some people thought was likely.

5:23So we saw on election night, the New York Times called Trump and Trump seemed to understand the scale of the victory, said he was ready to work with Democrats. That's we could still see some litigation on races as we speak. The Mississippi Senate race is still undecided. It looks very close. I'm sure that you're going to have lawyers from both parties pouring into that race, which is pretty common in a situation like that. But we didn't see any of those worse things. And I would say, you know, in the days leading up to the election, we saw the Justice Department bringing lots of cases, trying to intervene in state election disputes.

5:55The Justice Department is issuing a new wave of subpoenas. They stem from an ongoing criminal investigation into alleged efforts by Democrats to recruit a candidate with the same name as incumbent Senator Dan Sullivan. Which raised a lot of hackles. But in terms of what happened on Election Day, we didn't see physical interference. We haven't seen a lot of frivolous lawsuits. And I think we see Republicans basically throwing up their hands and saying, yeah, we lost. It's bad out there. And there's not it's not a question of fraud. Mm-hmm.

6:25David A. Graham: Some of the early exit polling is pretty interesting, you know, when trying to explain how they lost and how they lost as enormously as they did. The cost of living was a major factor for nearly nine in 10 voters, with roughly two-thirds placing the blame at the feet of Trump for high prices. Other issues that appear to have proved decisive are Trump-related corruption, considerable opposition to the administration's decision to pursue a war in Iran. It is also the case that local ballot initiatives on data center moratoriums passed by an overwhelming 43 to 1 margin across the country. I just when you look at the whole issue set and these trends in the opinion and priorities of the voting public, what do you see as like the primary drivers of the election result?

7:14You know, I do think that cost of living is a big issue for so many people. And I think that's a particularly tough issue for Trump because he won on that substantially in 2024, promised he would do something about it, found himself either uninterested in fighting inflation or unable to fight it, and in fact made it worse by fighting the war in Iran. So there's a kind of connection there. And I think corruption is also really at the top of voters' lists. And that encompasses a lot of things. That gets to, you know, hidden donations to the ballroom and all, you know, crypto and all of these different things that Trump has been involved in.

7:51And I think it touches on this idea of elites getting wealthy while many people are struggling. So it also connects to the affordability concerns. And frankly, so does the data center question. This is one where Trump inserted himself almost needlessly into an issue in favor of data centers, despite widespread public opposition. President Trump is defending data centers. In this Truth Social post, the president said the only reason to oppose data centers is if communities wanted to end up, quote, backwards and poor. And I think that probably did not help a lot of Republican candidates, given how uniformly voters seem to be against data centers.

8:29David A. Graham: Yeah. Do you see that as like a real repudiation of the kind of Silicon Valley techno billionaires? Yeah, I mean, I think when people are mad at data centers, it's partly because that is what they can physically be mad at. You can't be mad at AI. It's, you know, it's abstract and there's no physical version of it, but you can be mad at a data center in your neighborhood. And so people want to stop those as a way of expressing their anxieties about AI and expressing anxieties about how it might affect their employment and affect the economy. So I think that's an important symbol for a lot of voters.

9:03David A. Graham: It strikes me on this issue that the most rich and powerful people on the planet not only had their main guy rebuked in Trump, they also had kind of the backbone of their entire future business plan rebuked. I mean, how do you think we might see the Republican leaders and these business leaders who backed them kind of realign on something like data center or something that seems so incredibly toxic? it. It's been really interesting to watch Ron DeSantis, even the last few weeks before the election. And this is somebody, you know, governor of Florida, who had a pretty, a very hyped run for president in 2024, and fell apart fairly quickly and with questions about his political instincts.

9:45But you could see him understanding a while out that data centers were going to be bad and sort of turning against them and becoming a critic of them. And you see him today kind of trying to claim the mantle of the party and present an alternative to Trump, I think, and say, look, These things haven't worked. It's a lot harder for Elon Musk, for example, who spent hundreds of millions of dollars on this race and depends heavily on the AI industry, or some of these big companies to figure out quite how they're going to turn that. And I think they have a real public relations question of, you know, if they're not going to have a lot of allies on Capitol Hill, how are they going to convince voters that they are actually a force for good?

10:24And they're going to have to kind of go back to the drawing board for that, I think.

10:27David A. Graham: Worth noting, I saw a pretty prominent tech leader here in Canada post today that this was an opportunity for Canada, what with our open land and cold winters. They're not very popular here either.

10:54David A. Graham: J.D. Vance put out this, I think, pretty interesting statement on Wednesday where he essentially said, among other things, that the voters who voted for Trump and him in 2024 came out. but a lot of them voted for Democrats. And he said that the number one issue the Republicans lost on was the war in Iran. I just what what was J.D. Vance doing in this statement in your estimation? I mean, great question. Super interesting statement. I think Vance is doing a few things. One of them is trying to reframe the loss in ways that are maybe a little bit more palatable for Republicans, but mostly helpful for his political future.

11:39Vance can't go out there and say, you're right, voters were really mad about corruption because my boss is a crook. And he can't say, you know, there's only so much he can say on affordability issue. I think that talking about Iran is a way for him to distract from those issues and point something that really is unpopular and also something that he thinks he can stake out a claim to having opposed from the start. But to do that, he kind of, you know, it's really turning on a major Trump policy priority, and it's hard to read it as anything other than a swipe at Trump. I'll be curious to see how Trump himself takes it.

12:11David A. Graham: Yeah, I mean, how do you think he's going to take it? Because he's also saying that they failed on a focus on the cost of living and that they should have put America first more, that they should change their relationship with Israel. I mean, he kind of, it seemed to me, like threw his boss under the bus in a pretty obvious way. Yeah, I'm shocked by it. And I mean, Trump's reactions can be unpredictable, but I assume Trump will at some point recognize that people are reading that statement that way, even if he doesn't take it that way, and he's going to have to feel like he has to push back. Mr.

12:45President, Vice President Vance says the reason Republicans lost the war, lost last night was the war in Iran. Well, I think it's largely true because it drove the gasoline up a little bit short term. And probably that's probably it's true. But at the same time, if I had it to do again, I'd have to do it again because long term, it's the only answer. You can't let Iran have a nuclear weapon. The other interesting thing was seeing Donald Trump Jr., who my colleagues at The Atlantic have reported oppose the Iran war and has been vocal about that privately, also signed on to the statement and said this is 100 percent correct.

13:21And so there's an interesting like the Kremlinology inside the people close to Trump is really interesting. I guess the other question to me is, will this work for J.D. Vance? I think it's really tough when you're the vice president and a vice president who's there really entirely by virtue of Trump's patronage to also separate yourself from a war that Trump started and has been run by his administration. That's a really tricky balancing act. it would require a kind of political agility that I think very few people have and we haven't seen from J.D. Vance. But we'll see if he can manage that.

14:07The holidays are busy enough without worrying about missed calls or customers. But just because you're swamped doesn't mean people stop calling. And if nobody picks up, that call goes to your competitor. That's why over 90 ,000 companies choose Quo, the business phone built for busy teams. Smart call routing sends calls to the right person. Shared numbers let your team cover for each other. And an AI agent picks up when nobody can, capturing every lead so nothing falls through the cracks. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free. Plus, get 20 % off your first six months when you go to quo.com slash tech.

14:47That's Q-U-O dot com slash tech. I'm Adrienne Arsenault, CBC News' chief correspondent and your host for When It All Went Wrong. It's an investigative podcast about the people who get hurt when the systems meant to protect us fail. It features original reporting from some of Canada's best journalists. Each series unravels the moment it all went wrong, not by accident, not from poor planning, but because someone chose to do wrong and others chose to do nothing. Find and follow When It All Went Wrong wherever you get your podcasts.

15:22David A. Graham: There were all kinds of interesting demographic shifts that are coming out now. Latino voters, black men, younger voters, particularly younger men. And these were all groups central to the historic coalition that managed to put Trump in office in 2024. And just in two years, it's kind of definitively eroded. I just want to drill down on young men because no single group, it appears, shifted more than these guys. Dems were up 38 points with this group. And this was the group that was really at the center of the Trump strategy for so long. What do you think specifically happened here? And I would start by going back and pointing.

16:04I mean, Joe Biden did very well with young men in 2020. So we saw this group as the heart of the presidential race in 2020. We saw the heart of the race in 2024 swinging towards Trump. And now we see it swinging back in this election. And so, I mean, one thing that tells me is this is a really unsettled group and they're not strongly affiliated with anyone. You know, there was so much kind of sociological analysis of what was going on with these voters and questions about whether this is reaction to woke and to DEI and and about masculinity and about, you know, Democrats being feminized. And we, you know, we saw Republican candidates sort of using this playbook against James Tallarico in Texas, you know, saying he was, you know, he was a vegan and suggesting he was transgender, all these sort of attempts to play crudely on these things.

16:51um i think part of it is these voters are are not strongly affiliated but they care about the same things that a lot of people do they care about cost of living they oppose wars you know they they follow trump because he said he would he would beat inflation and keep us out of wars and those are the two things he did exactly the opposite of those two things and so these free

17:10David A. Graham: agents went for somebody else do you see this realignment that we've seen um as something durable for the Democrats or like just maybe to your point, is it is it just incredibly fickle? I think it's going to be fickle for now. I mean, I would say the same for Latino voters who for a long time were considered mostly Democratic demographic, swung hard to Trump in 2024 and swung back. And I think what that tells me is that they're not it's not that they were Democrats all along and they had a sort of aberrant cycle. It's that they are not committed. And I think as the the Hispanic population of the U.S.

17:49grows, it's just hard to speak monolithically about those voters, too. As we saw from the results, you know, Hispanic voters in Texas are different from Hispanic voters in Florida. They're simply not, you know, we can't really talk about them in the same way.

18:02David A. Graham: I want to ask you about how you think Donald Trump is going to govern now. He spoke to CBS about the tremendous power of the presidency and the use of executive power, executive orders and vetoes. I think he had like some kind of presser today, right? And he also said that he could use the veto. Look, I mean, I'll get along probably with the Democrats unless they want to be destructive, but have the power of the veto. So if we don't like what they're doing, they've already called and they want to talk about things and that's fine. How do you think we're going to see him govern from here on? It's an interesting question to know, like, what it looks like when Trump doesn't have Congress because he's used Congress so sparingly in the first two years.

18:42And, you know, when I say he's used them. He treats them as not a co-equal branch, but as kind of his subsidiaries. Basically, Republicans with two years passed one big bill, and that was it. One big, beautiful bill, as they called it. So it's not like there's been a lot of legislation moving, and they've been unable or unwilling to do some of the things he wanted, like to overhaul the voting system. So I suspect that he will try to do many of the same things. He will simply rule in this kind of quasi-monarchical way. He will use executive orders. He will try to make the executive branch do a lot of things.

19:14And he has managed in his first two terms, first two years of the term to get a lot of power away from Congress to pry things away. And I think that sets him up well to try the same thing for the next two years. but he is going to have to reckon with oversight and, and, you know, Democrats, you got Democrats coming out last night saying, you know, this official statements like lawyer up and subpoenas. So, you know, they're certainly going to make things difficult for him and, and bog him down. Although how effective that will be, I think, you know, we'll have to wait and see.

19:45David A. Graham: By all accounts, I think it's fair to say that Trump is like a very legacy conscious person, uh, of conscious of the way he'd like to be remembered. There's a world in which he's now remembered in a way as the president responsible for one of the most disastrous nights in modern history of the Republican Party. Right. And I guess there are several ways that he might handle that. He may decide to accelerate on all fronts, move to accelerate the war in Iran to ensure he's remembered as the American president that went to war in Iran and won it. Right. Or he listens to this rebuke and decides to change course, I suppose.

20:23David A. Graham: If you were to forecast, I'm reluctant to try to get you to get inside the head of Donald Trump. But if you were to forecast what we're likely to see from him over the next year or so, which version do you think is more likely? I don't think he's likely to be chastened. That's about as far as I feel like I can safely predict, but that's it's simply not a move we've seen from him at any moment. We see him occasionally making nice with Democrats on specific issues, but but to see a major shift, I think would be not something in keeping with his character. um you know part of trump's mentality he is very legacy conscious but also i think partly by virtue that he his view is kind of he can never fail he can only be failed and so that's why we saw him saying on election night if i was on the ballot we would have run in a one in a landslide it's always somebody else's fault and i you know he doesn't have a lot of institutional uh commitment to the republican party and so a huge defeat for the republican party is a problem for him i think only insofar as it imperils his ability to do what he wants and his ability to build his legacy.

21:33We often see presidents who are lame ducks like this, focusing on things that are either foreign policy, like the war in Iran, or physical projects like a ballroom, like an arch, like these kinds of things. The triumphal arc military complex is going to have tremendous drone capability. I would say sniper or shooter capability. its height, its platforms, its storage capacity is incredible. It's right smack in the middle of everything. So it's very important for our military. But from a beautification standpoint, it'll be the most beautiful arc in the world. The trick is the Democrats are going to be really eager to stop all of those things.

22:14They will probably at least go through gesture of unfunding the war in Iran. They will certainly go after the ballroom. They will go after the arch. And so there's going to be a lot of clashing over those kind of symbolic things that otherwise a lame duck president might be able to just focus his energy on.

22:40You know, this is so disastrous for the party itself.

22:45David A. Graham: And I just I imagine that there are Republicans who have been increasingly uncomfortable with Trump or who have been pushed out of the party who will look at these results and say, this is what we warned you about. That Trump was always a liability and that he was corrosive to the party and that the Republican establishment should have never allowed itself to become completely subordinate to him. But I guess there's a question of responsibility here for them as well. The Republican establishment accommodated Trump. They helped build the coalition that we have now talked about that is broken apart.

23:17David A. Graham: And many of these same establishment Republicans supported the agenda, whether we're talking about the war in Iran or data centers or the party's proximity to some of the wealthiest interests in the country. How much responsibility do you think the Republican establishment bears for this result? You know, coming out of the 2012 election, Republicans were in this real soul searching phase and they were talking about we need to change our entire agenda. We need to be more open to minorities. We need to think about immigration reform. We, you know, we need to in many ways just moderate. We need to become more, more liberal or this is a little bit more liberal.

23:54and Trump offered an alternative which was no you don't we're going to double down on these things and the Republicans are in this weird trap now where they can't win with Trump and they can't win without him you know he won in 2016 narrowly he obviously won in 2024 but he lost in 2020 he led the party to defeat this year and again and he led to underwhelming performance in 22 and defeat in 2018 so time and again they're in this bond in this sort of trap with him and I mean And who are the Republican critics of Trump is an interesting question. And I think seeing somebody like Ron DeSantis look for another path or seeing J.D.

24:32Vance try to separate himself a little bit is interesting. But a lot of the people who have been most critical of Trump, I mean, some of them have left the party. They're independents. They're Democrats. Others of them stuck around in the hopes that they could somehow build an identity or limit him. And those are the people who have lost. Lindsey Graham.

24:50David A. Graham: Exactly. A lot of those people, they either lost in previous elections, they were tired because they felt like they couldn't win, or they lost in washouts like last night, where the more moderate people are the ones who lose. And what you're left with is the most extreme elements of the party still in office. Since we're on the topic of soul searching, I would like to get your thoughts on the Democrats. This has been a generally difficult decade for the party. Considerable internal conflict, uncertainty around their identity, skepticism about whether or not the party had fallen out of step with younger voters and the working class.

25:20David A. Graham: But these results, I don't know, maybe they signal a change here. You now have a generation of millennials, in some cases, I think even some Gen Z leaders coming into power, leaders that were kind of raised and came up in the era of Obama and Bernie Sanders. I'm thinking of John Ossoff, El-Sayed, AOC, Mamdani, Angie Nixon, Rob Sand, James Tallarico. And do you see like a through line or a consistent message from all these voices? Can we say any particular version of the Democratic Party won last night? Is there something that you see that unites them? Part of the trick for Democrats is that several parts of the party won last night.

25:59And so it kind of it's a good it's the right problem you want to have if you're the Democrats, but it's still a problem. Victories of people like El-Sayed is going, you know, that will lead the left wing of the party to say, look, what we're doing works. We need more of these people. But when you have a majority this size, that's partly because there are a lot of people who were elected in districts that voted for Trump, in districts that typically would go Republican. And those are going to be more moderate candidates. So you're going to have a real push-pull inside the caucus between those two wings of the party.

26:29David A. Graham: Right. I do think we have this younger crop. I mean, you think about El-Sayed, you think about Ossoff. These people are so much better at speaking to cameras and appearing relatable than, I don't know, Chuck Schumer or Dick Durbin, some of these older senators who are around. But they're not all on the same page politically. And so I think that will be an interesting area for conflict. Right, because I guess the people that backed al-Sayed will point to his win and say, look at what the progressive wing did. And then there will be people who backed Ossoff and Tellurico. And they will say, look at what these guys did.

27:05You know, there are people who look at Rob Sand and say, look, this guy was saying was distancing himself from the party. He would be Republican in many states. Yeah, exactly. I don't think that either party does a good job of solving problems. We should end their special legal privileges that they have given themselves. we should give independence an equal right to participate it shouldn't just be picking the

27:23David A. Graham: lesser of two evils on the ballot so if you had a choice would you actually be an independent rather than a democrat i would love to do that it's not realistic right because you we all know as voters right but if you could i would love to do i would love to do that i would love to do that and you know tallarico is a little bit of that too so you know one thing we saw after the you we saw elections where Zoran Mamdani won, but also where Abigail Spanberger won for governor in Virginia. And at the time, you know, some of the analysis after that was, well, maybe this shows that the Democrats don't actually need one message.

27:58They can run different ways in different places. And in some places, that's a really, in cases, that's a really intuitive point. Of course, Democrats should match the districts where they are. And I think that worked well for them. This election, in a presidential election, you know, you do kind of have to pick one candidate and that will be tricky for them.

28:15David A. Graham: We're a Canadian podcast, so I feel like I have to ask you about Canada. Tariffs are so top of mind for us. And now that the Democrats control the Senate and the House, do you think anything actually changes for us here? You know, with control, Democrats might be able to claw some things back. They could pass other legislation, but would Trump sign it? Unclear. And also, I mean, the Democratic Party has become much more tariff friendly than it has been for decades too. In some ways, this is a shift. And Democrats are fine with tariffs. They want them more targeted. They want them more narrow. They don't want to use them in the same kind of punitive way that Trump has, but they don't oppose tariffs per se.

29:00And they had a little bit of limited power over foreign policy. So I can imagine Democrats, you know, hauling in the U.S. trade representative and hauling in the Commerce Secretary and the Treasury Secretary to push on these things. But I don't know what they'll be able to achieve or how high a priority will be for them.

29:19David A. Graham: Yeah, I question the priority part too. You know, the former U.S. ambassador to Canada called on U.S. lawmakers to kind of begin this formal reconciliation process with Canada. But, you know, I don't know if that's kind of anywhere near the top of their list right now. Yeah, I think if you ask Democrats, they will say, Of course, we should have a better relationship with Canada. This is ridiculous, but it's very effective. When you get down to the policy, I don't think it's going to be top of mind. And, and, you know, there's the question of what they can actually do insofar as it is. Do you think these midterm results change anything for the negotiations with the Trump administration, though?

29:54David A. Graham: Does it put him under more pressure when it comes to tariffs? It's a really good question. And I don't know. Part of this is that Trump can be so defiant and sort of oppositional in cases that even when he's getting that kind of pressure, he may push back against it or he may say you know i do what i want i don't i don't care what this is i think there's a you know you could plausibly suggest also that a trump who doesn't have to face voters again and who's already seen his party get a catastrophic defeat is gonna totally just go to town on all of his priorities so just as he might push hard on the war in iran he might push even harder on tariffs and and take out his frustration on canada for example I don't know if that'll happen, but I certainly wouldn't be surprised.

30:39David A. Graham: Well, maybe that's a good place for us to end. David, this is great. Thank you. Thank you for coming by. It's really great to have you. Of course. My pleasure.

30:55David A. Graham: All right. That is all for today. I'm Jamie Poisson. Thanks so much for listening. Talk to you tomorrow.

31:08For more CBC Podcasts, go to cbc.ca slash podcasts.

From the publisher


In the wake of the Democratic sweep of the U.S. midterms, we take a deeper look at the factors that got us here, from Iran to data centres. We also examine what could come next from a rejected Republican Party and a blue Congress.


David A. Graham joins us. He's a staff writer at The Atlantic and the author of The Project: How Project 2025 Is Reshaping America.


For transcripts of Front Burner, please visit: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/frontburner/transcripts 

More from Front Burner

All episodes