


Canada’s first national security strategy in over 20 years, framed by Mark Carney’s “Fortress Canada,” emphasizing military buildup, intelligence expansion, Arctic protection, and new defense/economic partnerships.
Lloyd Axworthy, former Canadian foreign minister and retired chair of the World Refugee and Migration Council; previously involved in foreign affairs and disarmament efforts.
Axworthy argues the plan over-militarizes and underemphasizes “human security” risks like climate change, epidemics, AI governance, and nuclear arms expansion. He says Canada’s “global affairs” capacity was hollowed out (especially under Stephen Harper), reducing diplomacy and disarmament work. He criticizes entanglement with U.S. systems (e.g., 90% of army information systems on American platforms; Palantir contracts; U.S.-controlled F-35 “black box”).
Arctic planning bypassing Indigenous participation; partnerships with UAE/Saudi Arabia/Turkey despite human-rights concerns; NATO spending targets (5% by 2035) while cutting development/diplomacy/climate budgets; calls for an Arctic Security Council and stronger UN/ICC/autonomous-weapons regulation.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the significance of Canada's new national security strategy.
“For the first time in 22 years, Canada has released a new national security strategy.”
Lloyd Axworthy discusses the implications of the new strategy.
“My guest today is former foreign minister and retired chair of the World Refugee and Migration Council, Lloyd Axworthy.”
Exploration of the document's purpose and the shift in Canadian direction.
“Well, it goes back to the election 18 months ago, where the new Carney government committed that they would have a new sort of set of propositions, papers on defense, on foreign policy, on trade.”
Axworthy critiques the focus of Canada's defense policy and its implications.
“And I think there's no reason we shouldn't up some of our intelligence capacity.”
Analysis of Mark Carney’s approach and the militarization of Canada's defense.
“What is more dangerous today than increasing nuclear weapons?”
Discussion on Canada's international partnerships and their ethical implications.
“I mean, if you can negotiate with the United Arab Emirates, which is pouring massive weaponry into Sudan to support a conflict.”
Axworthy responds to the argument for increasing military expenditure.
“And to me, the fundamental kind of Canadian equation for a very long time is the balancing, beginning with NATO, where Lester Pearson was a major sponsor, and Canada was a major player in setting up a defense alliance.”
Discussion on Canada’s security priorities and entanglements with the U.S.
“And maybe let's start with the military buildup.”
Axworthy reflects on shifts in American politics and their impact on Canada.
“Even the so-called F-35s, the black box that determines where they go, is controlled by the Americans.”
Explore the changing political landscape in the U.S. and its implications for Canada.
“but he's a monster with declining powers.”
Discuss the effectiveness of international institutions and Canada's role in global security.
“These institutions that you are advocating for, we're talking about the United Nations, the International Criminal Court.”
Examine the potential risks and necessary reforms for Canada's foreign policy direction.
“And I'm simply saying, similar right now, we have the situation where the United Nations is holding a major convention in later November on autonomous weapons.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Front Burner, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01You know what they say. Good things come to those who shop early, especially when we're talking early Black Friday deals and lows. Get up to 50 % off select major appliances. Plus, get free delivery, haul away, installation, and parts on purchases of$896 or more. Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's. In-store and online. Valid through 12-2 while supplies last. Selection varies by location.
0:31This is a CBC Podcast.
0:36Hey everybody, I'm Jamie Poisson.
0:46For the first time in 22 years, Canada has released a new national security strategy. The 13-page document lays out the government's goals and priorities for, as they put it, a stronger Canada. It covers everything from military spending and protecting the Arctic to bolstering Canada's intelligence services and vaccine procurement. In his message to Canadians, Mark Carney writes, threats once thought distant are now immediate and proximate. The international rules-based order is under threat. The open global trading system is deeply challenged. What were once strengths, our strong connections and deep integration with other countries have become vulnerabilities.
1:25But as Canada puts up its defenses, is it losing sight of itself? My guest today is former foreign minister and retired chair of the World Refugee and Migration Council, Lloyd Axworthy. He wrote a piece for the Toronto Star headlined, Mark Carney has flipped the plan on how to protect Canada. And here is why I'm concerned.
1:55Mr. Axworthy, thank you so much for coming on to this show. It's a real privilege to have you here.
2:00Lloyd Axworthy: Well, I appreciate the invitation. Thank you. This is the first national security plan to be put out by the federal government in over 20 years. Before we get into the details, I just wonder if you could tell me what purpose does this kind of document or policy guide fulfill? Like, what is it meant to do? Well, it goes back to the election 18 months ago, where the new Carney government committed that they would have a new sort of set of propositions, papers on defense, on foreign policy, on trade. And it's taken this long to actually get a piece of paper written. And that's why it's so important, because it does pull together, I think, what we're seeing as a major shift in Canadian direction.
2:45Lloyd Axworthy: direction. And I think it's missing some very key elements. I want to get into those elements with you, but some of our international partners tend to release something like this far more often, right? Why have we not released one in 20 years? Why has it taken so long? I think there's been a hollowing out of our global affairs groupings. I mean, I think we, under Harper and then following and Trudeau, we just didn't put a lot of investment, not so much into non-military issues, but into people. I know from my own experience, when I was in foreign affairs, I mean, I had top flight, smart, active men and women who could really, whether we were renegotiating a treaty on landmines or whether we were trying to broker things in NATO.
3:38Lloyd Axworthy: In the meantime, I think it's also you have a prime minister who brought to the job a very narrow bandwidth of what he thinks Canada needs to do, not arguing with the idea that we can put more money into our defense structure. And I think there's no reason we shouldn't up some of our intelligence capacity. But to basically say security is only based upon some foreign threat, which is not identified. Is it Russia? Is it the United States? Is it men from the moon? And it doesn't deal with what I consider and a lot of Canadians consider to be equally strong security risks. What is more dangerous today than increasing nuclear weapons?
4:20Lloyd Axworthy: And it's the expansion of the whole nuclear arms race is underway. Just for people who are not familiar with the strategy that Mark Carney has put out or he just put out, I just wonder if you could describe what it is that the prime minister is trying to articulate, what his strategy is. I believe you've referred to the approach as Fortress Canada. Yeah, I think he's basing it on two fundamentals. One, that we will become a major military state. For the first time in 40 years, nearly 40 years, Canada arrived at a NATO summit with our defence investments and capacity on a clear upward trajectory.
4:58Already hit NATO's 2 % target. We're on a clear path to 5 % by 2035. We are announcing Canada's first ever defence industrial strategy. It's a bold plan to get our armed forces what they need, when they need it. It's a bold plan to scale Canadian defence companies and to put hundreds of billions of dollars...
5:20Lloyd Axworthy: We've kind of tripled or quadrupled the defence budget, and that really means that our economy and purchasing as a country, it's going to be, I mean, do we really want to have an identity as an arms merchant, as who we are as Canadians. And secondly, is on the whole idea that we have to establish new trade economic relationships. We aim to be both principled and pragmatic. Principled in our commitment to fundamental values and pragmatic in recognizing that progress is often incremental, that interests diverge, that not every partner will share all of our values. While Mr. Carney used the word value pragmatism, There's no values to it.
6:03Lloyd Axworthy: I mean, if you can negotiate with the United Arab Emirates, which is pouring massive weaponry into Sudan to support a conflict. The prime minister welcoming the crown prince of Abu Dhabi to Canada, he agreed to cooperate on defense, including joint military exercises and training, and they signed a new economic agreement. Or with the Saudis. We are building partnerships with the kingdom of Saudi Arabia, harnessing the ambitions of our nations to catalyze greater security, prosperity and opportunity for both our peoples. Or with Turkey. Canada is building deeper partnerships with reliable partners that create new opportunities for us both.
6:45And in Turkey, we have an exceptional partner.
6:49Lloyd Axworthy: And he keeps saying, well, human rights are something of the past. It's nostalgic. It's not up to us to deal with it. Well, if you let those things go, then you're weakening the international order. You have drawn a comparison between this plan and Make America Great Again, which I think might surprise some people. I just, can you take me through the parallels that you see here? Well, as you know, so much of what's happened in the United States political system is the MAGA group and the people around that kind of hardliners were that the way in which the United States should change who they are is by simply saying we're the biggest, toughest, strongest person on the block, and we can bully simply by our power and our might.
7:31Lloyd Axworthy: And I think Canada is being more subtle, but it's basically saying all that counts right now is economic growth and militarization. They forget that so much of our security isn't dependent just on how we flex our muscles. It also depends on how we are able to sort of support efforts to control climate catastrophes, to control epidemics, to control the threat of AI to humanity. Well, it's not even mentioned. It's only mentioned in the sense that these are things we have to improve upon, not that we need to have some guardrails. And to me, the fundamental kind of Canadian equation for a very long time is the balancing, beginning with NATO, where Lester Pearson was a major sponsor, and Canada was a major player in setting up a defense alliance.
8:23Lloyd Axworthy: But we also began working on how do we broker and prevent wars and how do we negotiate and mediate conflicts and how do we protect civilians? And that's not part of the agenda in this paper.
8:48I'd like, if you don't mind, to push back on some of your argument a little bit, interrogate it a bit. And maybe let's start with the military buildup. Of course, Canada is spending an enormous amount of money on our military buildup, the largest expenditure since World War II. But hasn't the last couple of years taught us that dealing with Trump 2.0, threatening to annex us, watching a war of aggression in Ukraine, seeing what China and Russia are doing in the Arctic, hasn't it taught us that we need to potentially prepare for the worst and address our vulnerabilities as a country?
9:26Lloyd Axworthy: I have no argument with, particularly in the Arctic, of upgrading it. And that's an argument I've always used, is how you're doing and what are you doing. I mean, number one, 60 % of the population in the Arctic is indigenous, and they're not being involved in any of the kind of planning or development or programming. We have an interesting program called the Rangers, where Inuit men and women sort of provide a kind of front line of surveillance and so on. but decisions about what we're going to do in the Arctic is being made in downtown Ottawa and the Defense Department headquarters. I mean, I've been arguing that what we need to do is have an Arctic Security Council that would be replicated of the Arctic Council, where we do have participation of all the major countries in the Arctic, but also the indigenous governments as well.
10:18Lloyd Axworthy: It's how you're doing it. As a result, a lot of the people in the North feel bypassed. They don't see any benefit. And I think also we're kind of, so far, very vague about exactly what we're going to do up there. I mean, do we really want to put huge investments into submarines when the whole modern warfare is shifting into drones and other kinds of weaponry that we're not particularly good at? The government's announced, well, we're going to start building drones. But it's more to it than that. It's also who is going to operate them. And the Ukrainians have showed an incredible capacity to set up small units of people, not the big regiments, not the big tank brigades, but actually smaller groups of mobile troops that can use the drone systems.
11:02Lloyd Axworthy: So it's a very different kind of equation. And I don't see that being reflected in our defense discussions. And just what about our promise to hit the 5 % GDP spending for NATO, which is an international institution and alliance? Do you not see that as an important thing for the country to do? How do you measure your defense capacity by saying 5 % of your GDP? I mean, that was something that Donald Trump sort of clocked on NATO and said, if you really want to be my friend and show cooperation, it's 5%. Well, I mean, that means that we're going to be quadrupling our expenditures. And to pay for them, what are we doing?
11:43Lloyd Axworthy: We're cutting our budgets on international development. We're cutting our budgets on diplomacy. We're cutting our budgets on protecting climate issues. The things that are, in fact, important in offsetting these threats and these risks. And here to me is one of the really serious concerns. While we're talking about how do we militarize, we're also becoming increasingly more entangled with the American Pentagon systems of communications and digital management. I mean, warfare today isn't just about tanks and planes. It's also about communication. It's also about information systems. And so the Canadian Army, 90 % of its information systems are run by American-based digital platforms.
12:37Lloyd Axworthy: The major strategic force that we have in the army has hired Palantir, which is an American company very close to Trump, run by Peter Thiel, who's a kind of anti-democratic thug. But we're giving them contract after contract. And so what's happening is, well, we're talking about how we are doing this for sovereign reasons. We're actually entangling ourselves even more closely. and I've written a piece about whose finger is on the on and off switch. Even the so-called F-35s, the black box that determines where they go, is controlled by the Americans. What about the argument that the cold hearth truth is, right now we live in this world of big powers and aggression and Canada has no choice but to make deals with all of these countries to kind of diversify our economy here.
13:39Lloyd Axworthy: It's not the first time that we've lived in a world with great powers. I mean, we came out of the Second World War, having fought for six years against great, great powers. For the last couple of years, and certainly Mr. Carney's government has played on, that our fearsome sort of monster in the room is Donald Trump. And there's no question he's a monster, but he's a monster with declining powers. And I think clearly in the last elections of this week, there's a whole new shift in the American political system. And our problem is that we have to get our act together and start rethinking what we're doing simply to take account of that very major kind of tectonic shift.
14:26Lloyd Axworthy: It's not just the Democrats coming in. It's the kind of people they elected, people who are talking about how to deal with climate, about health care, about immigration, about preventing wars. So you've got a very different cast of characters now in Washington. And frankly, I think that, I mean, clearly we have to be watchable with Mr. Trump. and he's got Stephen Miller, who's kind of the ghoul of the gilded Oval Office, you know, to play it. In the wake of huge Republican losses in the midterm elections, a major shakeup in the White House. President Donald Trump replacing Susie Wiles, his chief of staff, for almost two years, with her deputy Stephen Miller, effective Monday.
15:07Stephen's been with me from the beginning. He gets it very good politically.
15:11Lloyd Axworthy: But I think they're going to become simply increasingly caricatures. I mean, Trump has some levers. There's no doubt about it. But there's no doubt that the control of both houses of the Congress, and particularly the shift in, I think, public attitudes, means there's an opening for us to start dealing with those Americans who we have closer kinds of ideals with, and also have some value-based commitments internationally. And that's part of this larger world trend I talked about. We've now seen a significant shift from the far-right, autocratic, might-makes-right kind of politics into something that where we're now electing people is that it's got to be balanced.
15:55Lloyd Axworthy: And that's what I'm arguing for, is that Canada has to restore the balance between supporting its military, committing to economic growth and sharing that growth, but at the same time, engaging in rebuilding international guardrails, treaties, in order to put some strength on great powers and to start doing things that have real risk attachment in terms of weaponry, in terms of it. Instead, we are going in the opposite direction.
16:53of$896 or more. Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's. In-store and online. Valid through 12-2 while supplies last. Selection varies by location. Big Little Lies compelled millions of readers with its story of a group of women in a wealthy beachside town who cover up a suspicious death. The TV adaptation made it into even more of a phenomenon with the help of its star-studded cast, which included Meryl Streep, Nicole Kidman, and Reese Witherspoon. Now The Big Little Lies universe is back. The sequel takes place 10 years after the original story and starts with the anonymous delivery of A Severed Finger.
17:33Author Leon Moriarty joined me to talk all about it. Check out that conversation on Bookends with Matea Roach wherever you get your podcasts. These institutions that you are advocating for, we're talking about the United Nations, the International Criminal Court. A lot of people probably feel like they lack the teeth or the enforcement mechanisms to adequately protect against threats or hold certain powers accountable. Do you think that they're wrong to see them that way?
18:04Lloyd Axworthy: Yeah, well, a lot of the people in our academic systems and in our punditry, you know, have kind of bought into this kind of Hobbesian world of right makes right. But it doesn't work. Since the United States, going back to George Bush, has been flexing its muscles, what's it gain? I mean, it's to kind of inflate prices around the world for all kinds of things. To me, there's always been a school of thought in this country, certainly in the States and in Europe. You know, I guess you call the realpolitik, going back to the 19th century. Great powers run the world. Well, I don't agree with that.
18:46Lloyd Axworthy: And we never have a foreign policy that bought into that. We said, yes, we are full participants in strengthening our capacity to deal militarily. I think that diminished substantially coming from a Harper to the Trudeau governments. And sure, it has to be rebuilt in a modern way. But it doesn't mean to say that we can flex muscles now. I think we have to be collaborative. We have to, the whole point of the UA and the whole point of the Commonwealth, the whole point of the courts is they're dealing with issues that can't be dealt with by individual countries, as powerful as I think they may be.
19:29This national security plan, though, it does have the stated goal of strengthening partnerships with Europe, as well as countries in the Asia-Pacific and Middle East. The budget that just released includes a commitment of billions of dollars to extended and expand our support for defending Eastern Europe's Eastern flank against Russia.
19:50Doesn't all of that demonstrate a willingness for international cooperation here?
19:55Lloyd Axworthy: What are we cooperating on? Are we cooperating in helping to put in place some kind of agreements about the way in which AI is going to be regulated? Or is it going to be kind of an open free-for-all because Mr. Trump decides that that's the way it should be? Are we doing something collaboratively about the massive impacts of climate change? In fact, Canada is increasingly receding in its commitments. We're now agreeing that we won't meet our emissions controls until well into the 2030s. So I'm not saying it's either or. The question is, you can walk and chew gum at the same time. Earlier when you said that you would like this government to focus on the things that really have consequences, I mean, I imagine climate change is one of them.
20:47I just wonder if you could take me through a few more specifics of what you think they should be doing that they're not doing in this strategy and elsewhere.
20:54Lloyd Axworthy: We have been a very reluctant, hesitant partner in the Western Hemisphere. Mr. Trump and his crowd are talking about running the chemosphere. It's going to be the Don Roe Doctrine. And as a result, they feel free to go and bomb ships in the Caribbean. They feel free to attack any country. They're talking about, let's take over Cuba because Marco Rubio doesn't like them and his constituency in southern Florida doesn't like them. I mean, we have to say, we spent a lot of time trying to build institutions in the hemisphere to say, hey, folks, there's a lot of things that we can do together. We can help promote democracy.
21:39Lloyd Axworthy: I was part of a mission for the OAS that Canada led in terms of developing a democratic system in Peru. That was the kind of thing the Canadians did well. And I'm simply saying, similar right now, we have the situation where the United Nations is holding a major convention in later November on autonomous weapons. The drones that everybody's building increasingly can be controlled by AI systems. No human judgment whatsoever. And we're talking about putting them up into space. In other words, I think we kind of open the sluice gates, and in some cases there's a rationale. I mean, if Iran says, as they're saying now, well, we weren't prepared to do nuclear weapons before.
22:34Lloyd Axworthy: We signed an agreement with the Obama administration, but now we have to. Who's following? The Saudis are saying, well, if the Iranians have it, we need it too, and the Turks need it too, and the Ukrainians need it too. All of a sudden you have a world full of nuclear weapons out of control. It's those kinds of things that we should be working at. Not to the exclusion of rebuilding much of our military capacity. I think there's a lot of things that we could be doing. But the one thing I would like us to see is a shift in our military policy. Our military brass get their training at Fort Hood. They buy the Pentagon strategy.
23:15Lloyd Axworthy: I'd like to see Canadian military having a far more independent view about their role.
23:32Mr. Axford, I wonder if I could ask you, kind of at the beginning of this conversation, you suggested that the foreign service here in Canada just doesn't have the same kind of caliber of people. that it did when you were working in it. I mean, you are presenting today a very ambitious vision for Canadian foreign policy. I mean, do you think that even if they wanted to, the Foreign Service today is capable of that?
24:00Lloyd Axworthy: I think it has to be rebuilt. But let me go back. It's not just Mr. Carney. I think the hollowing out really started with Stephen Harper, who basically wasn't interested in the UN, and wasn't interested in human security, wasn't interested in international sort of agreements. And as a result, they shut down things. We used to have a very active unit in global affairs on disarmament. We had an ambassador of disarmament whose job was to be involved in all the discussions. What can we do? How can we help? But now disarmament is the part of a package of eight files held by our ambassador in Geneva.
24:42Lloyd Axworthy: So we don't show up. We don't have a policy. I'm seeing the most incredibly active, smart diplomats working with us on things like the Landmines Treaty and Small Orange Treaties and the International Court. But most of those units have been disbanded. We're not even giving money anymore to help eliminate landmines. I wonder if I could pitch forward here, maybe like another 20 years, which is the amount of time since that last security strategy. What is it that you are most concerned about that could happen if Canada heads down the trajectory that it's currently on without addressing much of what you feel like it needs to address?
25:26Lloyd Axworthy: Well, I would begin with what I would think would be most disturbing is that the reputation, the integrity, the capacity of Canada to be a collaborative player, not just on trade issues, but on disarmament issues, on prevention of what we call the responsibility to protect idea, would be diminished or non-existent. and we would simply become, I guess what you call a military-industrial complex. Part of our identity as a country, I think, starts with our constitution, peace, order, and good government. Peace is a word that's never used anymore in Ottawa circles. It's just not there. And so I'm saying, let's think about what kind of world do we want to live in?
26:16Lloyd Axworthy: We can't live in a world in which we are a fortress unto ourselves. Isn't it kind of strange that Mr. Carney, who has basically been on an airplane virtually 75 % of the time, has never gone to Brazil to talk to Lula? Here is the major leader in the southern part of the globe, interested in protecting the Amazon forest. We have a boreal forest. We have an absolute kind of total sinking of our interest. But I don't see him on a plane going to talk to them. At the Commonwealth meetings this last week, they were talking about climate change. We weren't. We were talking about trade. Mr. Axworthy, thank you very much for coming on.
27:02It was really such a pleasure to talk to you. Thank you.
27:05Lloyd Axworthy: It was my pleasure. Thank you.
27:15All right. That is all for today. I'm Jamie Plesson. Thanks so much for listening. Talk to you tomorrow.
For the first time in 22 years, Canada has released a new national security strategy. The 13-page document lays out the government’s goals and priorities for, as they put it, a “stronger Canada”. It covers everything from military spending and protecting the Arctic to bolstering Canada’s intelligence services and vaccine procurement.
But as Canada puts up its defences, is it losing sight of itself? Our guest, former Foreign Affairs Minister and retired chair of the World Refugee and Migration Council, Lloyd Axworthy, wrote a piece for the Toronto Star headlined, “Mark Carney has flipped the plan on how to protect Canada and here is why I’m concerned.”
For transcripts of Front Burner, please visit: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/frontburner/transcripts