1. Podcasts
  2. Game Scoop!
  3. Game Scoop! 877: Phantom Blade Zero & Modern Warfare 4
Game Scoop!

30 Oct 2026 · 1h 5m · 24 chapters

Episode artwork

Game Scoop! 877: Phantom Blade Zero & Modern Warfare 4

In short

The IGN GameScoop episode discusses recent releases and reviews, focusing on Phantom Blade Zero (called “Chinese Onimusha”), Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 (campaign praised; multiplayer mixed; DMZ praised), plus broader talk about Zelda/GTA coming soon, game release volume, and Xbox hardware sales/studio closures.

Guests

Justin Davis (IGN host/regular; plays campaigns; comments on CoD and other games), Tom Marks (IGN reviewer/host; provides Phantom Blade Zero and CoD context; discusses Game of the Year outlook), plus the main host Damon (not a guest).

Key claims

Phantom Blade Zero is a forgiving action game with bell-based fast travel where enemies don’t respawn; bosses let you restart at the last phase after death. Modern Warfare 4’s campaign is tight and high-production (e.g., nightclub gun-fu, rooftop/car chases, gore effects, snow fist fight). IGN scores: Phantom Blade Zero 9/10; Modern Warfare 4 7; DMZ 8. Xbox console sales are “constrained by supply” despite apparent availability; Xbox studio closures are described as “borderline apocalyptic” optics.

Notable examples

bell fast travel behavior; multi-phase boss respawn; CoD nightclub mission blood splatter; World of Warcraft Forever beta campfire buff; Dispatch voice acting/soundtrack; horror picks like Resident Evil Requiem, Inside, Shadowgate.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Gaming's Diverse Landscape

Explore the multifaceted nature of contemporary gaming experiences.

“It moves between cozy, chaotic, and everything in between.”
1:16

A Remarkable Year for Gaming

Discuss the impressive number of game releases in a short time frame.

“Hell must have frozen over because I'm playing Call of Duty and really liking it.”
1:42

Phantom Blade Zero Overview

An introduction to Phantom Blade Zero and its comparisons to Onimusha.

“But first, let's talk about Phantom Blade Zero.”
2:17

Gameplay Mechanics of Phantom Blade Zero

Dive into the gameplay experience and mechanics of Phantom Blade Zero.

“No, I mean, like, I think that's not a terrible way to boil it down.”
3:05

The Unique Approach of Phantom Blade Zero

Discuss the game's design choices that differentiate it from Souls-like games.

“Like I said, they have the same premise.”
7:10

The Developer's Impact

Explore the significance of the developers behind Phantom Blade Zero.

“with a bunch of interesting stuff and that they're not all gotcha games, right?”
10:44

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 Discussion

A thorough discussion of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4, its campaign, and multiplayer.

“Upfront payment of$45 for three months, 90 for six months, or 180 for 12 months, plan required.”
14:00

Modern Warfare 4: A Comeback Story

Discussion on the resurgence of the Modern Warfare franchise and its campaigns.

“I guess people have been playing Call of Duty for recent years.”
16:52

Game Release Recap: A Flood of Titles

Recap of recent game releases and their ratings over the last few months.

“And that's included with this an unprecedented run of releases that began in August.”
18:08

The Challenge of Keeping Up with Games

Hosts discuss the overwhelming number of games released and the struggle to keep up.

“It's cool that so many high-quality games came out on the other.”
Show all 24 chapters
20:06

Game Award Predictions and Personal Favorites

Discussion on Game of the Year contenders and personal favorite games.

“And it's like, well, we switched to a 10 point scale from a hundred in 2020.”
22:34

World of Warcraft Forever: A Closer Look

Deep dive into the features and experience of World of Warcraft Forever.

“It's like, no, this is just a great video game that you can play.”
25:07

Return to Dispatch: An Underrated Gem

Reflection on the game's quality and its potential for awards recognition.

“But we're not going to just rush to 60 and put a score on it.”
28:00

Dispatch Game Discussion

Exploration of the game Dispatch, its episodic nature, and voice acting quality.

“like my main game and then like a lean back, like, you know, kind of a second game.”
31:20

Xbox Sales and Strategy

Analysis of Xbox hardware sales, leadership changes, and future strategies.

“I like a good commentary track in a video game.”
37:00

Exclusivity and Consumer Confidence

Discussion on the implications of game exclusivity for Xbox and consumer trust.

“But like, it's been a, it's been a very rough stretch for quite a while now.”
42:00

Listener Check-In: Halloween and Artistic Projects

The hosts check in with listeners and discuss Halloween-themed art contributions.

“Okay, let's check in with the listeners.”
44:24

Favorite Halloween Games

The crew shares their favorite spooky games to play during Halloween.

“It's funny you should ask that, Bryson, because I had every intention of replaying Resident Evil Requiem again this Halloween season because I've unlocked Infinite Ammo.”
46:24

Personal Horror Game Experiences

The hosts discuss their experiences with horror games and haunted houses.

“Tom, any spooky games you'd like to play this time of year?”
49:26

Dungeon Crawler Carl Game Adaptation Ideas

Listeners suggest how the book 'Dungeon Crawler Carl' could be adapted into a video game.

“what game do you think it should be like?”
51:24

Video Game 20 Questions: A Spooky Challenge

The hosts engage in a game of 20 Questions focusing on spooky video games.

“So, like, Carl's basically the only human character in the entire dungeon.”
56:00

Exploring Dead Space Concepts

Discussion around the aspects and elements of Dead Space games.

“looking more like gears of war one or dead space right yep yeah dead space is a much better answer think it's been Gears 1.”
57:51

Multiplayer Modes in Horror Games

Debate about multiplayer features in various horror games.

“here in California, but Visceral is no more.”
1:00:04

Personal Experiences with Horror

Hosts share their personal experiences and preferences regarding horror games and films.

“Whereas I think I could play Dead Space because it's like, well, this couldn't happen.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Game Scoop!, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Justin Davis: Gaming today isn't one thing. It moves between cozy, chaotic, and everything in between. One minute you're exploring something slow and immersive, the next you're in a fast-paced match. And somewhere in there, you might be creating, streaming, or just seeing where the session goes. That's why Alienware systems are built with the performance to handle all of it. With NVIDIA GeForce RTX, it delivers powerful graphics that bring every world to life while optimizing battery life. So whether you're playing, creating, or jumping between both, everything runs the way it should. No interruptions, no slowing down.

0:29Justin Davis: You don't have to adjust how you play. You just keep gaming your way, however that looks in the moment. Be more alien at Alienware.com slash GameYourWay.

0:43Justin Davis: What's up, everybody? Welcome to IGN Game Spook. I'm your host. Ha ha, it's me. I know you thought Dungeon Crawler Carl was guest hosting Game Spook this year, but nope, it's me. And this is just my Halloween costume this year. So I'm also joined by Justin Davis. Spook! And Tom Marks is here. Hello! Thank you for joining us, Tom. Sam is working away from home, unable to call in this week or next, so he'll be away a couple episodes, but then he'll be back in time to talk about Zelda. So we've got a great show for you this week, some spooky treats coming up in a little bit. Hell must have frozen over because I'm playing Call of Duty and really liking it.

1:19Justin Davis: And then I also think it's time to fully acknowledge just this unprecedented run of releases we've been enjoying since August till now, and it's still not over yet as we go into November. By my count, not even looking at an exhaustive list of games that have come out, I think there are 24 great games that have been released in fewer than 16 weeks. It's been an incredible run. Yeah, yeah, it's been an incredible run. But first, let's talk about Phantom Blade Zero. It's another one of these great games that has been released recently, and I've been playing it a lot. I like it a lot. We gave it a 9 out of 10, and the best way to describe it, and I don't mean this in a derogatory way at all, it's just, it's Chinese Onimusha.

1:59Justin Davis: It is Chinese Onimusha. It's very, very similar. It plays exactly the same as Onimusha. It has the same premise, but it's based on Chinese, you know, mythology and folklore and wuxia martial arts style. So this is a really cool game. Before I get into it, Tom, is there, you want to, is there anything you want to sort of like point out from the IG interview? No, I mean, like, I think that's not a terrible way to boil it down. The interesting thing about this game for me was a lot of the trailers made me think it was Souls-y. I don't know if that's just like the color palette, the tone, the lighting, I don't know specifically, but it is really not that.

2:38It's like a very forgiving, not easy, but I know that's a whole conversation about it, but it's a very forgiving action game. It's an action game that wants to just empower you rather than beat you down. And I think that that's pretty cool that we have stuff like that still, because I definitely, I like Souls games, but I think that the industry sort of overcorrected for a period of time into making everything that style of combat. And I dig that we have this really great year of action games where we can have Phantom Blade and Onimusha and these faster paced things coming out too. Yeah, there's definitely this kind of like third, you know, for a long time, like action games or sort of sword games had to either be, you know, a Souls-like or they had to be like a Devil May Cry-like and really be focused on like this kind of climax action.

3:25And like they're showing us games like Onimusha and Phantom Blade Zero are showing us this third path of, you know, it's almost a little bit more old school, but with like a modern, you know, modern sensibility of like, it's just a, you know, just run around slash guys up. Yep.

3:40Justin Davis: Like I said, they have the same premise. In both games, Onimusha and Phantom Blade Zero, you're a lone swordsman who has died and come back, and there's a darkness spreading, turning people into monsters. That's the premise to both games. It's just a different setting. And then the moment-to-moment gameplay in Phantom Blade Zero is you explore. Not huge open areas, pretty smaller areas on kind of linear branching paths. Explore, find some items, find the currency that you use to upgrade your abilities and weapons. Come to a town, take on a couple quests, go off on the quests, defeat a boss, get a new weapon, rinse and repeat.

4:15Justin Davis: Oh, and there's frequent bells scattered around. And this is where you set up fast travel points. you save your game and then you replenish your health and your health potions and here's a very important part of this whole thing when you tap that bell the enemies don't respond okay they do not respond so that's what tom was saying it's not that kind of game it's not a souls die game so oh and also when you die you don't drop your you don't drop your stuff and have to worry about going back to get it again so much more it's really not that the the the big thing that our reviewer Travis Northup also pointed out as like, I think he has a whole, he has a wrote a whole feature about this, a whole opinion piece recently.

4:54Like that is all about how the bosses in this game, when you die, you just respond at the last phase of the boss. So you can have these multi-phase fights and get two phases in and die. And you don't have to replay the first two phases and how much he really loved that because it let them get more creative with those later phases in a way that didn't feel frustrating. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I do, I've heard like, Like, you know, Damon, I don't know how far you're in it yet. Like, it's definitely not an easy game. So I don't want to kind of like mislead. Like, we'll still sort of press you and challenge you, but just isn't trying to be that, you know, carry on that Dark Souls torch.

5:30Justin Davis: Yeah. No, I'm enjoying it. And I'm not the world's greatest gamer. And I like it a lot. Deep into it, really cool enemy designs. The combat is fun. I will say there's these like brutal sort of execution animations, but there aren't very many of them. So you end up seeing them over and over and over again. So I could have used some more variety there. I like the map. It's kind of like a like a oil painting or something. It's maybe like what a map might have looked like in ancient China. And sometimes you can see where you want to go, but it isn't clear how to get there. So there's some thinking you have to do about that.

6:01Justin Davis: Also, when you encounter something that you either can't get through yet or can't get to yet, it will automatically add that to your map as a red icon. And then later on, if you find the item that you need to get there or to open up that door, it will turn it green indicating that it's now time to go back there and to get that item or get past that gate so i like that's just a quality of life feature that's cool too that's cool and then we should also acknowledge this comes from s game which is a developer i don't think anyone wasn't like a worldwide well-known developer before phantom blade zero but here they are with just a you know a world-class triple a super polished very impressive looking action adventure game and they well another i mean we're seeing more and more like just you know chinese game developers.

6:40I mean, look, like, you know, China's been making great video games for a long time, but not necessarily like going toe to toe in the big sort of AAA, the high budget, you know, action adventure category, like the, you know, Black Myth Wukong sort of was sort of like the welcoming party or like the Vanguard for this. And now they're just, they're just everywhere. Like it was half of, half of what we saw at opening night live was, you know, big AAA games coming out of China and just a really, really exciting category with a bunch of interesting stuff and that they're not all gotcha games, right?

7:14But, you know, sort of full budget AAA single player action adventure games. It's great to see.

7:19Justin Davis: Yeah, this one looked great in trailers and I'm happy to report that it turned out really, really well. This is what I've been playing and this is what I'll probably be playing for the next week until Zelda arrives. Because Zelda is only one week away now, if anybody is aware of that. I don't know. I feel like once you hit October, the year someone hits fast forward on the year I'm very deeply curious on what non you know, non old heads like me think about the Ocarina of Time remake which I note like we have a really interesting preview that we put together. I know we did two previews Tom, who was it that did the it wasn't, Simon was the one that did know the game inside and out.

8:00Logan Plant knew the game inside and out and Simon Carty had never played the original before and we had two different takes which is great because logan logan i think replays that game once a year literally and and then simon coming in fresh is you know you don't get that perspective a lot yeah and so that's what i'm most curious to see like obviously i know like ocarina you know if someone wants to call it the greatest game ever made i wouldn't argue with them like very excited to replay it very excited to play it in in you know sort of new high resolution and see the elements that are changed and are evolved but um but the perspective of zelda fans that didn't grow up with it like i would just be really really curious to see how that goes over yeah like you were saying

8:41Justin Davis: maybe last week how younger gamers may have only played the breath of the wild style yeah no i mean i i like that's what like my daughter's 12 and zelda's her favorite franchise and she's been princess zelda for halloween and has posters on her wall and she is not interested in this game she watched the preview and she's like oh like what did she describe she's like oh that seems old like but not not like visually but just like oh you can't like go there like you see this yeah yeah like she's like i she's like why doesn't she was watching a preview of like in the cave or in this dungeon it's like why doesn't you just climb up there and i'm like well you can't and she's like oh i don't care about it then i like i literally don't think she's gonna play it like so you know but i don't know how widespread that opinion is let's see that'll be an interesting dialogue once the game is out.

9:27Justin Davis: One week to go.

9:33Justin Davis: Right now, all of Mint Mobile's plans are$15 per month, even unlimited. So free yourself from big wireless and their gimmicks and gotchas and switch to Mint for high-speed data and coverage on the T-Mobile 5G network. Isn't that right, Seth? Definitely going to be trying out Mint Mobile switching over. Get that three months for$15 a month. That is nothing. $15, you can't buy anything in this day and age for$15. It is a pretty excellent deal, especially for mobile service. I mostly use it to just scroll on social media and click things that I like anyway. So why am I paying like several hundred dollars a month to do that?

10:15Justin Davis: Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right with premium wireless for$15 a month. All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. You can even bring your current phone and your number. Choose from three, six, or 12-month plans and say goodbye to a monthly bill. To get your new wireless plan for just$15 a month, go to mintmobile.com slash gamescoop. That's mintmobile.com slash gamescoop. Cut your wireless bill to$15 a month at mintmobile.com slash gamescoop. That's it. There's no catch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months, 90 for six months, or 180 for 12 months, plan required.

10:51Justin Davis: $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigs may slow when network is busy. Includes up to 20 gigs hotspot. Capable device required. Availability, speed, and coverage varies. cmentmobile.com Okay, Call of Duty Modern Warfare 4 is also out. Ultimately, we gave that one a 7, although I think Simon Carty did that review. and when he yeah simon simon cardi reviewed the campaign and the multiplayer together and gave that a seven really liked the campaign thought the multiplayer was a little bit lacking and then we also had a separate review of just the dmz mode a standalone review of that from jared green which he gave an eight so he really liked that and he came at that review sort of from the context of like all right call of duty fans are going to play call of duty and they want to know about call of duty stuff which is what that other cardi's review was but then as a extraction shooter fan more than a call of duty fan is this worth your time as an extraction shooter because it is basically its own game within call of duty and he came to the conclusion that yeah it's like a really good addition to that genre yeah this is a good time to point out we've rebooted our review crew series with modern warfare or call of duty uh modern warfare 4 and review crew is where we get our ig and reviewers together with reviewers from other outlets and and creators and youtube channels to discuss the game and their reviews.

12:12Justin Davis: And we had Simon Carty for the IGN review, Jared Green to do the DMZ portion, and then we had Rihanna Manuel Pena from Gamertag Radio all to discuss it. So it's an hour-long episode. We really dive into it. And Tom, man, Jared really knows the stuff about extraction shooters. Like, that dude knows extraction shooters for sure. Yeah, he goes deep on a lot of genres because we also had him review the Heroes of Might and Magic, like, reboot old-school version. and he like was going deep on late 90s, early 2000s, like Euro jank games also. He's got depth. And we should point out like just before our commentaries, just to get ahead of it, like seven is good on the IGN scale.

12:51Good video game. Like, so, you know, like I won't abide people in the comments saying like, oh, the mixed reviews are negative opinion from IGN. Like, no, seven is good.

13:01Justin Davis: Seven is good. And also I think, you know, if he were just reviewing the campaign, it probably would have been a little bit higher because the campaign's really good. I think everyone seems to agree. I was trying to think, this might be the first Call of Duty I've played since Modern Warfare 2, which was 2009, maybe. So it's interesting. It's like a six or seven hour campaign and it's just really tight, super exciting. They never take their foot off the gas and it's always just throwing new stuff at you. As someone who hasn't played Call of Duty in a long time, I'm surprised. First, I was taken aback by this, just the presentation and the...

13:34Justin Davis: I mean, aside from GTA 6, there's probably not a game that has the production values of this out there right now. It's really incredible. And it's also much less about, you know, just general boots on the ground, military, you know, gunfight skirmishes. They're always shaking it up with like a nightclub, John Wick-style gun-fu level. And then there's a chase across rooftops and a car chase where you're hanging out the window. And I don't know, they're just constantly mixing it up, never doing the same type of level twice. It's really exciting. I guess people have been playing Call of Duty for recent years.

14:05Justin Davis: Maybe they're not too surprised by all that. But as someone who hasn't played it in a long time, I was very pleasantly surprised. Well, it was also a little bit of a question mark for Modern Warfare specifically. Since Modern Warfare 3, that campaign was a notorious sort of... Yeah, it was a train wreck of a thing because it was like they weren't actually expecting that to be the Call of Duty that year. And they sort of just slapped it together from the multiplayer stuff. And it really was not good. So for this, you know, maybe it's a surprise to you because you haven't been keeping up. But I think also it was just like a sigh of relief that Modern Warfare kind of made a comeback for the end of this little story arc.

14:45Yeah.

14:45Justin Davis: Seems like they were able to salvage it in the end. Yeah. Justin, you've been playing Call of Duty in recent years, or at least the campaign? Yeah, I usually play through the campaigns. I've not played Modern Warfare 4 yet, but, you know, I will. the campaign is always a good time and that's definitely like you know i'm in a privileged position of like you know not everybody wants to pay 70 to play a you know play a six or seven hour campaign but um but you know they're always consistently polished i mean damon i would imagine that you would actually have a good time if you were to go back and play some previous call of duty campaigns as well um you'd probably really enjoy them i mean we and by the way i'm aware that this is a deeply sort of like unpopular opinion but the last like really memorable campaign for me that like i was like i love love it was infinite warfare the one set in space and had um kit harrington was you know a key character in that game and like you know it was it was a little bit of like a boondoggle for activision and infinite warfare was meant to be like a new sort of like mainline call of duty spin off and was like so so poorly received that they're just like now we're not going to do that after all but like but i really liked it and i thought the campaign was really good.

15:54Yeah.

15:55Justin Davis: A couple of details I want to point out that nightclub mission. There's really good blood splatter. You know that I like my gore effects. There's great blood splatter in this game on the walls and on the glass. You can shoot through glass and it won't shatter the whole pane. They'll just be like a jagged circle with cracks coming out of it. It looks, it's a really nice effect in there too. There's a fist fight in the snow where their hair is gradually accumulating snow on the top of their heads. Again, it's these production values that really go way, way over the top. It's awesome. And I like the story.

16:25Justin Davis: The story is very engaging. And it's cool that, you know, you start out, you're playing with this South Korean military company that has U.S. troops embedded in them. And they totally, you know, the way the best war, you know, movies and stories are able to give you the sense of the brotherhood that forms between these soldiers. They totally, they pull that off with this story here too. And there's multiple villains. And there's a female villain that's really great. It's a good time. Cool. I recommend it. It's a Dami game. Modern Warfare 4.

16:59Justin Davis: And that's included with this an unprecedented run of releases that began in August. So I want to just recap here. This is not even an exhaustive list of everything that's come out. This is just most of the stuff that's relevant to this show. Dami games and adjacent, you might call them. So looking back over the past few weeks and months, in August, we got Marvel Tocon, which is a 9 out of 10. Madden 27. I don't play football, but it was an 8 this year, so it's a great Madden this year. Mortal Shell 2 got an 8. Star Wars Zero Company got a 9. Gallipoli got a 9. The Blood of Don Walker got a 9.

17:28Justin Davis: And Onimusha got a 10. That was just in August. In September, we got Orbitals, which got an 8. Valheim was a 10. Fire Emblem was a 10. Control Resonant was an 8. And Silent Hill Townfall was an 8. In October, the Ghost of Yote DLC was an 8. Star Wars Galactic Racer was an 8. Ace Combat 8 was a 9. The Dragon's Dogma DLC was an 8. Gears of War I-Day was a 9. Castlevania was an 8. a little underrated. Planet Zoo 2 was a 9. Warhammer Bolt Gun 2 was an 8. Final Fantasy Resonance was an 8. And Phantom Blade 0 was a 9. And still to come next month, not to mention the Call of Duty, which has a great campaign, and then we've got Zelda and GTA.

18:04Justin Davis: That's 24 games that I just mentioned in fewer than 16 weeks. Ugh, gosh. I mean, yeah. On the one hand. What a time. It's cool that so many high-quality games came out on the other. Nobody has any time to play this amount of games. no i keep like my pile of shame i guess you know there's no shame in it but like you know my pile of shame just keeps growing like you know every night i'm like you know what do i want to play tonight what do i want to get through like you know continue sticking with something that i already started or try something new and like you know blood of dawn walker is like definitely a victim of that for me and honestly like i had forgotten about like i'll go back to it and play it eventually because it's very much a justin game but like star wars zero company i'm like oh yeah like that that came and went and was well loved and beloved but then it's like you know you just if you if you're someone that really wants to try to keep up with this hobby at all you have no choice but to kind of just blitz through this stuff yeah well i mean even even on star wars star wars got zero company and galactic racer in a really short span and are both great not just great like games but star wars games fun for star wars fans specifically and and yeah it's even even when you go into niches it's there's so much choice it's it's kind of nuts and there's also on top of zelda crimson desert got a huge dlc as we're recording this i think it's just launching right now and there's uh there's there's so much world of warcraft forever finally fully launches next week.

19:33It's nuts. It is a nuts period of time.

19:36Justin Davis: I mean, Thomas, someone who has eyes on almost all reviews that come through IGN, can you remember a time that was this densely packed with quality releases in a fairly short amount of time? Maybe not in such a short amount of time, because that's been the story of this year is bursts, right? We've given six tens this year so far, and both of them, which is not wildly above average since we switched to the 10 point scale. I think that's the thing that people miss a lot is they're like, well, IGN gives a lot more tens nowadays than they used to. And it's like, well, we switched to a 10 point scale from a hundred in 2020.

20:10And since then we have given more tens because we're not giving 9.8s, we're just giving tens. So that's some context there. But of the six tens we gave, three of them came in, I think it was May and they were all within three weeks of each other and then in august to september three of them came within three weeks of each other and that's like not a thing we plan that's not there's no conspiracy behind that it's just that there were these bursts of things and then these very long dead patches and i think it's similar now like we're getting these bursts of games and then gta comes out and releases sort of just stop for the entire rest of the year yeah yeah yeah and it's getting to be about that time

20:55Justin Davis: to start thinking about Game of the Year stuff. Tom, I think we can share that IGN is one of the outlets that votes on the Game Awards that are hosted in December. Yeah, we're part of the jury. Yeah, people are starting to put those in. Personally, my personal Game of the Year remains Resident Evil Requiem in spite of everything that's been coming out. Do you have, so far, what your Game of the Year is in your head, Tom? Oh, man. It's so hard. Like, honestly, I don't think I do yet. I think I'm going to be waiting for Zelda and GTA before I even really know where I'm at with all of that. Because the other notable thing is like last year was also a really, really good year for games.

21:37There was a lot of amazing stuff that came out, but sort of the tenor of the entire last half of the year was like Claire Obscure was a front runner. It was a very popular choice for a lot of people. This year, I don't feel like we have, I mean, Zelda and GTA are not out yet, but up until this point, I don't feel like we have any sort of clear cut front runner yet. And I'm really fascinated to see how some of the voting starts to shake out as we get into it over the next couple of months. Yeah, I think that Galactic Racer is a dark horse. I don't think you're wrong. I think a lot of people really love that game.

22:15Justin Davis: Paris says it is his game of the year. Man, I don't know. I don't know. I mean, you didn't ask me, Damon, but like now I'm reflecting. on it if you were about to ask me next like it's very it's very hard which like that's a coward's choice like i want to name a game um but it's like like a big reason so many of these games are backlogged for me now is i just got completely sucked into the world of warcraft forever beta that was you know it's closed down the game comes out next week but the beta was you know pretty open and like it's so good and that team at blizzard absolutely understood the assignment And like I've talked before on GameScoop, I get a little bit agitated about how games like WoW or Fortnite or Minecraft get talked about more as kind of like platforms and as actual like really good video games.

23:02It's like, no, this is just a great video game that you can play. And like, WoW, it's an unbelievable achievement what they've done with WoW forever of like the headline stuff of like we added new raids and we added new dungeons. It's like, okay, cool. Like, yeah, that's great. But it's like, there are so many tiny little things like no part of this world has gone kind of like untouched of like, because this is, this is world of Warcraft from 20 years ago, but like sort of, you know, updated and brought up to a little bit more of a modern standard. And so I, I'm actually not a wow obsessive. I dip in and out of it.

23:40I've not been playing it for 20 years. So I had to like check my memory. I'm like, I don't remember this quest. Like, is this quest new? and sure enough it's like 95 % of the starting zone is the same but they added like one or two new little things and added one or two new memories and like you know one or two new little mini bosses for you to kill and like every single aspect of the game got touched I saw a video on YouTube of there's this totally out of the way tavern that like doesn't really serve a purpose it's actually kind of hard to find players didn't find it for days and it's just there it's just tucked away in the game world just to add flavor.

24:15And there's tons of stuff like that, like new fish that you can catch and new fishing rewards. So the team that's working on this game just completely got that. It's not just about box ticking, like, hey, let's add nine new dungeons and add new playable races, but just enriching the flavor of the world and really taking to heart this feeling of horizontal progression of like making it about the journey and you don't just want players, you know, getting stronger and stronger forever. And like, I ended up, man, I don't even know if I want to know how many hours I put into the beta because it was a lot.

24:53And it might be my personal game of the year so far, but caveating that I have backlogged many, many games that I know will be just in games. So, you know, I deserve some time too. To that end, with that philosophy, we're actually taking a sort of different tact with the review of World of Warcraft Forever where we're taking it a little bit slower and we're going to have some opinions around launch and at launch and of what our reviewers played of the beta and all that. But we're not going to just rush to 60 and put a score on it. Like that's just not how you should play that game. It's not the point of the experience.

25:28Like you said, it's about the journey. So we're going to take that one a little slower. It's so good. It's so good. They're so clever about like they added a new, you know, campfire system where you can create a campfire anywhere in the world and then other players can come sit around that campfire and they get a buff. They get a little buff that makes them stronger, but only if they sit there for 60 seconds. And so they're not forcing players. You're forced to meet other players and you're forced to group up, but just kind of trying to find natural... Of course, because what you're going to do is you're going to chat with somebody for a second, right?

26:00Like, hey, how are you? What quest are you on? Yada, yada. So just little details like that that really shows that they understand how people are kind of playing this game and nudging them to interact with the world in the way that they want them to is like i just i don't have enough good things to say about it i i think if i had to choose right now it would be between mina the hollower and big walk for me yeah which is like the big walk was one of the most magical experiences i had this year by far i played through that game with a consistent group and then mina was just mina mina i fear is going to get lost in a lot of end of year conversations because it came out earlier in the year, but that game was really phenomenal.

26:40Justin Davis: Yeah, I think Sam would agree with you on Mina. Sam reviewed it and gave it a 10. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I also played, man, I had already, there's so many games coming out that like, Order of the Sinking Star is the new game from The Witness developer, Jonathan Bloss, like his big new puzzle game. And I put a decent number of hours into that too. And I think I'm a smart guy, but it's like, I'm not 100 % sure. I'm like even smart enough for that game. Like it really, it's like, if you're a puzzle game sicko, like you're going to be in absolute heaven with it, but it is, it is it's very, very, very hard.

27:16Justin Davis: So probably not smart enough for the witness. So I think it's considerably more sort of challenging from just a moment to moment, like puzzle gameplay than the witnesses, but like, but just like so well done, Like just this idea of like, you know, block pushing puzzles, Sokoban puzzles. They've been in video games forever for, you know, 40 years now. And it's like that done to the absolute highest degree possible, you know, is like there's for a certain number of people. It's like this is like going to be a dream game for them. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, to briefly touch on a game that was out last year that I played this year, Justin, you said you've returned to dispatch.

27:56Yeah, I started. I like to have like a couple of games going at once. like my main game and then like a lean back, like, you know, kind of a second game. And I went back to dispatch because I didn't dispatch went out episodically. Right. It was released episodically. Yeah. So it's like, I played the first four or five episodes and then didn't finish it. Cause I think, I think the episodes weren't out yet. And so I decided to start it over and it really reaffirmed for me. Like this game is excellent. Like this game is really, really, really great. And like, I want to make sure that it's not kind of like lost in the shuffle as well.

28:28The soundtrack is so good. it has to be nominated for sort of music awards. I'm sure it's going to get performance award or nominations as well, because there's some of the best voice acting performances that we've had all year for sure. In that one. Oh,

28:41Justin Davis: I guess this probably came out with like last December, right? So it would be eligible for this year's. Uh, I think there was, there was something about that. I need to look it up, but it was, it started coming out before the eligibility cutoff for 2025 game awards and finished after. I didn't realize it had started that early. I thought it was later than this. It says the first, I don't know how many episodes, but October 22nd is what Google says. Yeah. 2025. And then I think it ended in December. So it like went over and I think is eligible this year as a result. Yeah. I love this game. Aaron Paul is great in it.

29:18Justin Davis: And I, another one reason I liked it is because it takes place in my backyard in Torrance, California. Tom, were you saying also that you kind of wish it was just a TV show that you could just watch? yeah yeah that was that was my I really really enjoyed dispatch I didn't finish it because I did just sort of wish I could sit back and watch it as a show I was watching invincible I think at the same time as this coming out and it just made me kind of wish it was a show not that I didn't like you know the the dispatching mini game of it in I I like but I was never I guess part of this is like I was never huge into telltale games didn't dislike them just didn't get obsessed with them either.

29:58And so I think it almost could have been just a show and I would have liked it just as much. Probably. I do think it needs to be, it either needs to be more interactive or like not interactive. Cause you'll go like, I've only replayed the first couple of episodes and it's like, you'll go like, I don't know, five minutes or more without making a decision. And so it's like, I start to lean back and relax. And then suddenly it like needs me to do something. And I have three seconds to answer and I'm like, I have to like pick, you know, I'm playing on mouse and keyboard. I have to like lean back over my, you know, fumble with the controls and not hit the wrong thing.

30:31So it's like, then it slightly stresses me out. I'm like on edge watching these cut scenes because I feel like I need to be ready to react if the moment calls for it. So it's like they either need to just drop it and just let you watch, you know, these 30 minute cut scenes or they need to be more interactive than they are right now if they were to do a second season. Yeah. Yeah. And to its credit, there is a mode that is like a less interaction mode. Just watch the game. Yeah. Yeah, pretty much. I don't think it's like full hands off or anything, but there is some sort of flexibility there at least, which is nice that they included that.

31:04Justin Davis: I think I feel the opposite of Tom. I wish I could just play the minigame. I wish they had a standalone game that was just the dispatch minigame because I thought that was super fun. It's totally good. It's better than it needs to be and has more depth than you think it's going to. And they just put out commentary tracks for this. So good time to revisit this. I like a good commentary track in a video game. I remember when they did that in the orange box.

31:32Justin Davis: Okay, let's go over a headline from this week. Asha Sharma insists there is more demand than consoles available as Xbox hardware sales continue to plummet. Hmm. Hmm. During the three months ending September 30th, overall Xbox revenue declined 2 % year over year, although that's an improvement on the 10 % decline the previous quarter. But Xbox hardware sales fell 14%. Xbox hardware sales down 14%. I guess I don't know if that's compared to the previous quarter or year over year, but they're down. And Asha says this, quote, console sales remain constrained by supply with more demand than consoles available.

32:12Justin Davis: We're working to get more consoles into players' hands. I don't know if this is just magical thinking or what, because if you look on Amazon or Best Buy or Target or Xbox.com right now, you can buy an xbox so i don't know that's what i was gonna i was i was gonna go to amazon.com and see if there was an xbox series x for sale um i don't wait how much are these consoles supposed to cost right now i can't even remember anymore because eight hundred dollars now for the series one terabyte you can buy a one terabyte series x for eight hundred dollars on amazon which if that's the msrp then hey there you go yeah but so i don't what is she is she just saying something hoping no one will look on amazon.com i mean you know i don't know like there's there's there's levels of truthiness to anything right like i would believe that maybe there are some retailers somewhere that are like you know maybe xbox would be happy if they had you know their retail channels a little bit more saturated with hardware than they're able to right now but like but you know if you can buy one on xbox.com and you can buy one on amazon.com then i would say it's pretty pretty readily available yeah i don't know what asher's on about there thomas been a while since you've been on the show there's been lots of changes at xbox this year new leadership lots of layoffs you know studios leaving projects canceled what's your sort of uh what's your sort of read on on xbox these days um i mean not great the not not to like harp on them it's it's hard to say i i guess i'll put it this way the studio closures and that sort of thing are blanket tragic regardless of any market conditions going on or business decisions being made and the validity of them people are losing their jobs amazing studios are being shut down it's sucks right That is sort of the headline here for me.

34:09It's so hard to say whether these decisions from a business standpoint are good or bad when we're clearly in the middle of whatever their strategy is. And they have some vision that I don't fully grasp, but that they are working towards. And maybe that vision is just really radically different from what Xbox is doing right now. and that's causing all sorts of pain as they transform into that. But the optics of it are at least like borderline apocalyptic looking in, right? Like all of these studios are closing. There's all this sort of turmoil happening that doesn't look good. And they're basically just saying we have a strategy that we're going towards and it's causing these things to happen.

34:59And so I don't know. I'm not a smart enough business person to say they're doing the wrong thing here, but I can at least look at the fallout of what their choices are and be really sad that all of these studios are being impacted in the way that they are, especially after five, six, seven years ago, when they just started buying up all these studios and there was so much optimism about Xbox first party and them building this legacy. And then now for them basically to just be like, actually, we shouldn't have done any of this we're selling all of these off is pretty brutal yeah yeah i mean they have to be getting close to like you know if you're a consumer like okay you think an xbox is worth the money you don't think an xbox is worth the money like that's one thing right like they're kind of they're kind of you know having trouble competing in the market that way but i i do this is a total like gut check like this isn't based off any empirical data but like my feeling is that they're close to this kind of tipping point of like if there's not consumer confidence in Xbox period as a brand, then it's like, then that's when they're in, like, they're in real trouble then of like, why would I, like, if, if, if people start to get the idea in their head of like, Ooh, like this game library I've built up might go away or like, you know, maybe I don't want to be amassing my digital games on this platform, or maybe I need, you know, I'm concerned about what's going to happen to this sort of like, you know, investment in time and money that I've made into this ecosystem over the years, like that becomes kind of like borderline unrecoverable.

36:33And, um, I don't, I don't know that they are there yet, but like, if not, they're surely getting close. Um, and, and that's when, like, I don't know, I don't know how you pull out of that kind of tailspin if they do reach that state. I mean, and I, and I, again, I've said it on the show before, I'll say it again. The Xbox series X is my console of choice. So I say it, you know, with love and care and consideration. And I want to see a healthy and thriving Xbox in the market. But like, it's been a, it's been a very rough stretch for quite a while now.

37:06Justin Davis: It's not really a secret formula. If you have a good console with a good, you know, library of exclusive games and your console is affordable, that's kind of the, all the really the elements that you need there, but. It is. You have to have games on your console that people want to play. and they cannot play anywhere else. Otherwise, there is no reason to buy the console. Yeah, and that's the other part of this is like that, what you just said and them sort of kind of taking back some of the exclusivity that they gave up over the years is probably objectively good business decision-making and also objectively bad for gamers as an ecosystem to not just be able to play the games where they want, how they want.

37:51And so I'm very torn on that as well because I think they're probably doing the right thing for them, but I don't like exclusivity as a concept. Just like I would like these things to be available to whoever wants to play them in whatever capacity they can.

38:04Justin Davis: Yeah, but do you hold that against Nintendo? No, no. So again, Nintendo should never, as from a business standpoint, Nintendo should never give up their exclusives. They should never put Mario on another system ever. I am very realistic about that. I wish that Nintendo would, that I could play Mario on my computer. Yes. Like as a gamer, I wish I could do that. I wish I didn't have to buy a new Nintendo system every eight years that just to play the Mario and Zelda games that I want to play. But I also am very realistic about the fact that they should never stop doing that if they want to keep making the money that they're making.

38:45There's a couple, okay. A couple of things here. One, once you've, once you've let that genie out of the bottle, it's hard to put it back in the bottle of like we're gonna put our games on playstation and be like matt never mind like you know but like so now like they're catching more heat for that decision than sony who has never put their games on another platform right because they open that door back up and now you know now they're trying to walk back through this one way though though sony did sony did catch a little bit of heat of it for it for not bringing their games to pc anymore yeah but not not to the same degree i don't think it's fair to say the other consideration here this is less relevant in the Switch and Switch 2 generation, but for a long time, Nintendo at least had a credible argument of like there was a marriage of hardware and software, right?

39:27Right. Like Nintendo's trying to do something, right? With the Nintendo Switch or the Wii U and the Wii and like all of their hardware, you know, it's like they, you know, the Nintendo 64 controller was like specifically designed for like Mario 64. So they at least, like you have, the exclusivity argument carries less water when you have this genericized box that plays video games and then your controller has the same button mapping and same layout as the other guy's controller, then it's like you don't really have a credible argument for why your game is exclusive to that platform. And Nintendo at least was trying to marry kind of like software design and game design with hardware design.

40:06And then that's still sometimes true. Like they have the pseudo mouse controls on the Switch too, but it's less true these days than it was 10 or 15 years ago. but their hardware is not generic though. The Switch Pro controller works on Steam, right? So there is, to that extent, any game that runs with it can have a Switch Pro controller on a Switch could run on a PC hypothetically. And so I think that's what you're saying, right? Of like, those barriers are being broken down too. Yeah, but it was hard to, like when we were in the heyday of like the Wii generation and the Wii U was a piece of junk, but like even back then, it's like they were making games that could not be played, you know, in the vision and intent that they wanted to on any other hardware.

40:50So, you know, they were marching to their own drum and still are in some ways.

40:56Justin Davis: Sometimes I wonder, like, it would be interesting if, remember the NES Classic and the SNES Classic? What if Nintendo announced a software version of that game collection and it's coming to Steam? Yeah, right. It's just interesting to me. I don't know, maybe nobody would care because it's so easy to emulate all those games or or maybe maybe they'd be find huge success for just being able to access these classic super nintendo games on steam i don't know but they'd sell it you know the nes classic was you know 80 if it was released today it'd be you know 140 or whatever it would cost and like you know that's that's like you know they would not sell it for that much money on steam that's for sure there's clearly a market around those you know the toy story collection just came out there's been the the disney classics collections And those are, in my eyes, very much Nintendo games, even if they aren't strictly Nintendo games, because you played a lot of those on Super Nintendo and stuff.

41:50And those are doing well on Steam as collections.

41:53Justin Davis: Yep, yep. There's the Castlevania Anniversary Collection and the Mega Man Legacy Collections in there, too. So, yeah. Yeah.

42:07Justin Davis: Okay, let's check in with the listeners. Hey, listeners. Listeners, remember you can always reach us at the email address gamescoop at itunes.com, just like John in Wigan England did, who says, Hi, Damon. Happy Halloween to you and the Omega Cops. Here is a little something I've been working on in the evenings to unwind after work. It's been a fun little project, and I hope you all like it. Oh, Jobert, I did send this to you. Hopefully you have this ready to go. I G-chatted this to you. Here it is. It says, it's hand-drawn using a trusty mouse. None of that AI slop for me. I've been watching Scoop for over a decade now.

42:37Justin Davis: You can never fail to cheer me up. You all remain in consistent comfort in an increasingly unpredictable and crazy world. So here we are at Goose Camp, and Justin is wearing a power glove and roasting Sonic the Hedgehog over the fire. Hold on. Hold on. I didn't condemn that. Appropriately. Appropriately. We've got, you know, I like how it says, welcome to Goose Camp, established 2006. That's accurate. You've got Rick from Splatterhouse in there, sneaking around the woods. And for the head, if you scroll down, Joe, I don't know why Nick's is just a head. just ahead on a box. He's poking at it like it's probably a Metal Gear Solid box.

43:15Yeah, I guess so.

43:15Justin Davis: And then if you scroll all the way to the top from right there, Jobert, you can see Pear atop the tree in his tunic. There he is. Okay. Drawn with a mouse. That is impressive. It says, no AI slop here. Well, nicely job, John, in England. That was really good. Wow, this is amazing. Thank you, John. I think I'm going to print that out, hang it up. Yeah. I want that on my desk in the office. Look at the goose. Look at the goose in the middle. Wait, who's in the back there above your head? Above me. I can't. Well, there's a boo. Next to the boo. Yeah. Who is that? Oh, I didn't know. Yeah. Who's. Oh yeah.

43:51Justin Davis: Who is that? Who's picking up? Who's picking up from behind the tree? I don't know. Is that, is that supposed to be Tal? I was going to say maybe. If that's Tal, then John has been listening for a long time. Yeah. Write in and let us know. Okay. This is Bryson from Indiana who says, I hope you're all enjoying the spooky season. It's my favorite time of the year. Always gives me another excuse to replay my favorite horror games. Horror is by far my favorite genre. I was curious what horror or spooky games the crew likes to play around Halloween. It's funny you should ask that, Bryson, because I had every intention of replaying Resident Evil Requiem again this Halloween season because I've unlocked Infinite Ammo.

44:33Justin Davis: Again, my game of the year. I really wanted to do that. But there's just been too many games coming out. When I get a game early, I feel obligated to play it before release so that we can discuss it here on GameScoop. So I've been playing Phantom Blade Zero and Final Fantasy Resonance and Control Resonance and all this stuff. Now spooky season has kind of gotten away from me. But I wanted to play that. And then there are a few that I return to regularly. I like to play Inside around this time of year. And then on the more retro side, I like to do Shadowgate, which Scoop Nation knows is one of my all-time favorites.

45:02Justin Davis: Not explicitly a horror game, but you're exploring a spooky castle and there are ghosts and skeletons. and also Maniac Mansion which funnily enough the angry video game nerd just put up an episode about Maniac Mansion I can't believe he hadn't done that game already but just put up a Maniac Mansion episode and it's great so check that out Justin you don't really like spooky games so I don't know you probably aren't looking to play I don't think I have fall video game tradition I mean definitely not like oh every year I gotta play this but like when it gets to be fall season I find myself wanting to play Costume Quest like that's a very fall you know, fall themed game, but I'm a little bit more of like a, like a winter break kind of guy as I usually end up like my tradition is like super Metroid gets played, but it's not even like, Oh, it's winter break time to play super Metroid.

45:46It's usually like it's day nine or so of winter break. And I'm starting to get a little bored. And then that's when it's like, okay, well, here we go. Time to, you know, time to spend an afternoon on this. It just kind of, just kind of happens. You leave me, if you leave Justin alone long enough,

46:00Justin Davis: He'll play Super Metroid. Super Metroid's getting played. Hey, Metroid Ravenous is coming up in January. Man, I can't believe it. It's so soon. Man, the games, it's not like they stop in next year. It's like Jan, Feb, March are pretty stacked too. Yeah, they stop for December, but then it's right back into it in January. Yeah, this year was definitely, or this period was definitely like a crater left by GTA where everything was either right before it or right after it. Yeah. Tom, any spooky games you'd like to play this time of year? no i am a total wimp when it comes to horror i don't watch horror movies i don't play horror games i played i did the review of our outer wilds echoes of the eye dlc which sort of dips a toe into spooky horror uh amnesia sort of hiding from monsters chasing you thing and even that was like i don't want to play this like it was that was enough for me um so i i'm not a horror person unfortunately no me neither i respect it to be clear i i just it's just not for me stresses me out man yeah you can man the the the grace sections of resident evil requiem are they they were all they they tested my my own limits someone who why would why would someone want to make themselves feel that way on purpose well i want to not feel that way look damon i don't know about you i like having a good time i do too being scared can also be a good time but justin now i have unlimited ammo so i want to just i mean that's what i mean like that sounds like a good time yeah see i like roller coasters though so i don't know maybe it's i don't know what specifically it is for me man well i i do not like haunted houses i did that like you know it's a it's a very teenage thing to do it's especially in the midwest it's like you know go to a haunted house and go to a haunted barn or haunted you know corn maze and like some of them have reputations for just being like really intense and over the top and then some are a little bit more tame and it's like i did that a few times with my friends and I'm like no thank you I will stay home and well never mind I can't say what you you all go and have a good time I will stay at the party uh one season when I was in high school I worked on a haunted house outside of Kansas City and it was like area 51 themed I don't remember the name of it this is I mean maybe I'm sure all there's there's levels of like professionalism in in haunted houses and this was the 90s I would just show up and there's a a like a bin of masks pick a mask and then they would assign you to a room and literally just this is your room when people come through just scare them jump out and scare them and then at the end of the night they would hand me 25 in cash great what a great job that's what it was working at a haunted house outside kent city in 1995 probably i mean we got chased i was in a haunted haunted barn or whatever it was it wasn't a house and it wasn't a maze so i think it was a Anyway, we got chased with chainsaws.

48:55There was a man chasing us with a chainsaw. And I'm pretty sure now, in hindsight, it was a chainsaw. He had a chainsaw in his hand, and it was doing the chainsaw thing. But there surely must not have been a chain on it.

49:08Justin Davis: Yeah, I think you took the chain off. It's a heavy piece of metal. They're swinging at you. Yes, yes. That's 100 % what was happening. I'm like, I don't want this. I don't need this. All right. This is Rob who is living in Sydney but is from Detroit. Rob asks, if Dungeon Crawler Carl was adapted into a video game, what game do you think it should be like? Rob says, I would love it if it was a top-down action RPG with team building and character swapping. And if you're a ranged attacker, it would have a twin stick shooter mechanic. So Link to the Past plus Diablo plus Dead Nation. That's Rob's idea.

49:42Yeah, my band immediately went to, like, Gauntlet. Gauntlet, that's interesting. or top down-ish in general I think you should play as the system AI and then it should be like Dungeon Keeper like you're designing the dungeon floors that's actually a really good

49:58Justin Davis: idea yeah so no spoilers but Tom, Carl goes into this dungeon and it's run by an AI and the AI has its own personality so yeah that's actually a really interesting idea Justin, I've given this a lot of thought my thought was that it should be it should play like Baldur's Gate 3 that's sort of you know hardcore RPG with your you have a party very chatty party lots of talking but the premise should be that you you're not Carl you're another crawler in the same dungeon as Carl so you're in dungeon crawler world earth you you enter the dungeon from somewhere else you can create your character be whoever you want to be from wherever you enter the dungeon you start at level one you know floor one level one play through build your party and there would be reasons for you to meet to encounter Carl from time to time.

50:44Justin Davis: Tom, Carl is very much he wants to help people. He wants to save as many people as he can. So there would be reasons for you to like your stories to interact. And then Justin, Jeff Hayes, the narrator of the book, can be the dungeon AI messing with you as you play. That's sort of like what I envision for a big AAA version of Dungeon Crawler Carl. What's the name of the little goat merchant guys? Were they babkas? Is that what they are? I think so, yeah. Anyway, you could make a pretty good like someone that just runs a shop in that world too yeah another good one well that's a that's a that's a fun idea and that's a fun question and now i want that video game and that game is being merchandised or that book is being merchandised out the wazoo so well i feel like imagine that there will probably be a video game announcement soon any of these games would be much easier to pull off than the live action tv show because i don't know i can't believe i cannot believe it's live action and not animated tom like on the second or third floor they everyone chooses a new race.

51:40Justin Davis: So, like, Carl's basically the only human character in the entire dungeon. So, like, imagine what they're gonna have to do, like, with effects and CGI. And a talking cat. A talking cat is one of the main characters, but then there's also a talking goat person. Like, I don't know. You know, I never thought anybody would be able to adapt One Piece into a live-action show, and they did okay with that, so... We'll see. That's true. We'll see.

52:09Justin Davis: Uh, fingers crossed. All right, that brings us to video game 20 questions, and our suggestion this week comes from Matt Jones, overlord of the superfans. Shout out to Matt. It's been a while since we've heard from him. Uh, no big, uh, stories or anecdotes to share this time, so we'll just let the questioning begin. Is this game thematic for the time of year that it is? Yes. So, finally, you waited until Sam was not on to finally give us a spooky or a fall game. Yep. Okay. uh justin i i notoriously tense up and and don't know what to do in situations like this that's fine i'm happy i'm happy to carry and then you can just i'll backpack you through this okay okay okay then let's do uh is this like n64 generation or before no okay okay okay modern-ish game um modern-ish yeah was this game made in japan no okay uh that eliminates all the resident evils and all the silent hills and a lot of a lot of those japanese horror games yeah is this game first person no okay that's a fun question though that gets that gets rid of like the amnesias and such yeah okay um yeah but but the thing that's gonna make this tricky is i actually don't know you know horror games that well yeah i mean okay is this game is this game 2d no that's five not limbo not inside i'm wondering if it's like not not little was it nightmare creatures little nightmare little nightmares yeah is this game like like near like a narrative, you know, like a narrative choice game.

53:58I'm like, I'm thinking like until dawn sort of those or the walking dead or walking dead. Yeah.

54:05Justin Davis: No, it is not a game like that. Okay. Okay. I, I also feel like I didn't ask if it was a horror game. I asked if it was like season seasonally. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And so I don't think, I mean, we've had costume quests before, so I don't think it's that, but it could be like a night in the woods is another game that I would have named during the fall game segment. Is this a horror game? Yes. Yeah. I know we're burning a second question on it. No, no, no, it's good. It's good. Okay. Was this game released within the last 10 years? No. Okay, so pre-2016 but post-N64. Yeah. west not japanese made not first person yeah not but also not 2d yeah this is like a tough window for me to think about third person explicitly horror game in the third dimension

55:09um i mean i don't know you could you could i mean we've made the argument on game scoop before that gears of war one is kind of like a whore is more of a horror game before the franchise turned hard into action yeah do you shoot guns in this game yes oh okay it's funny my my brain just goes to like half-life two ravenhole yeah but that's not i don't think that's a horror game yeah no no no it's not but that section is man oh it's also not it's also not first person we know it's not first person so it's it's a third person game that you shoot guns yep and it's and it's a horror game yeah that's tricky does this game take place on earth no that's 10 ah looking and we're looking looking more like gears of war one or dead space right yep yeah dead space is a much better answer think it's been Gears 1.

56:12Yeah, that's where my brain's going is one of those. Does this game, I don't know how you want to narrow it, or like Alien Isolation, although that's first person. Alien Isolation's first person. Does it helpful to know if it takes place on a spaceship? Does that give us anything besides dead space? I don't know. Not really. Okay. Does this game take place on a spaceship? Yes. We got to be careful here, Tom. Yeah. I know. I know. What's the isn't the guy's name Isaac or what's the name of the I don't know. Isaac I think is correct. Yeah. And doesn't he what's he's got his gun that like slices.

56:48Can you slice limbs off things. You can slice limbs off of enemies. Yes. That's is does this game have a gun where you slice limbs off of enemies. Yes. Ah. Is this the first game in a series. No. Oh good. That was a gotcha. Get as nice. okay so there was Dead Space and Dead Space 2 and then was there a Dead Space 3? there was a 3 yeah there was and then there's obviously the remake but that came out within the last 10 years yeah so is was this game the second game in the series? yes is it Dead Space 2? Dead Space 2 yeah got the game without ever having played the game

57:33Justin Davis: it's a very good game yeah and the third one really veers away from horror much more into action. That could have been a hint as well. Dead Space 2, great game. I wish the remake of the original was so good. I wish we could have gotten a remake of this one. If anyone was going to ask, this was developed by Visceral here in California, but Visceral is no more. Viscerals. Did you know that the chapter titles of the original Dead Space are an Easter egg? That if you take the first letter of all the chapter titles, then it gives away a major story beat of the game really it's i'm not gonna it it tells you about like well i don't even i can't even spoil it more than that but like the first names of each chapter title area are a big hint about the nature of what's going on in the game they did that with the second season of better call saul i think it's the second season the first letters of each episode spell out frings back yeah that's very similar to the dead space thing yeah also it had some kind of a multiplayer modes.

58:34Justin Davis: If you, so if you ask the question about multiplayer, that could have tripped you up too. That was right in the peak era of like bolted on random multiplayer modes. Yeah, exactly. That'd be a good feature. I mean, there's no time to do any of this stuff. The best tacked on multiplayer modes. It's just like, yeah, best or worst or weirdest or like, you know, like I would, I would read that. I mean, people liked the multiplayer in Uncharted 3, right? And, and thinking, and the last of us, I think people liked it. I played, I played a lot. I played quite a bit of Uncharted 3 multiplayer. Actually, it was pretty good it had fat drake in it wasn't bioshock 2's multiplayer supposed to be pretty good that one i never played i never played that i heard okay things about but that's exactly another one where you could very easily be like bioshock 2 had multiplayer yeah i played multiplayer uh metroid prime pinball does that count played it with chris kohler but are you aren't you just alternating i don't even remember how it works now i don't i can't i don't even remember what the rules are okay but he was very i just moved to san francisco and he was very nice to me and i'll always remember that tom you probably didn't play dead space 2 not being a horror guy no no i played a bit of the first one but i never went for the rest of the series i also didn't replay the i cannot remember the name of its spiritual successor recently uh that was apparently not not great calisto protocol yeah calisto protocol yeah yeah i think it was pretty well received wasn't it i thought i thought it was like yeah it was it was not the second coming people were hoping for yeah it just felt very derivative of dead space that's all are you aware that there's a very notable uh self eye surgery scene in this game no gosh yeah it's just thank you that's the other thing i can't do is like i try i got one episode into the pit and i was like i cannot do this show so yeah the dead space sounds like there's no thank you there's certain things i mean i guess every human is like this but like certain triggers of like i actually don't mind you know it's like oh justin doesn't like horror things whatever but like that's not actually i don't mind ghosts like because ghosts aren't real um but like slasher stuff really like the movie i think the last horror movie where i'm like i'm done with this genre was like the strangers that movie messed me up man because it's like that could happen someone could come your house and invade your house and that could happen.

1:00:54Whereas I think I could play Dead Space because it's like, well, this couldn't happen. Yeah, and my blind spot is actually some of the things that are okay is some of the Resident Evil games. Resident Evil 4 I loved. Resident Evil 2 and 3 remakes I really, really enjoyed. Those were different enough from whatever that trigger is for me that it didn't bother me. Yeah, I can't do any slasher stuff.

1:01:18Justin Davis: Well, nicely job. Dead Space 2 thank you for the suggestion Matt Jones viewers and listeners if you have your own suggestions for video game 20 questions email them to me at the email address gamescoop at igin.com and that's all the scoops the spooks that we have for you this week oh man my bandana came off thank you to Justin thank you to Tom thank you to Jobert working behind the scenes and adding all of the fun spooky decorations on our mortises here I think that it just really took the show to another level where'd David go? wait who is this? who is that? oh wait oh Oh, it's Damon. Okay. It's still me, Justin.

1:01:51Justin Davis: It's still me. My name is Damon. This is IGN Game Scoop, and we're out. And the night when the cold wind blows, no one cares, nobody knows. I don't want to be buried in a pet cemetery. I don't want to live my life again. I don't want to be buried In a pet cemetery I don't want to live my life again I lack object permanence. You cover your face and I'm like, I don't know who's hosting this show anymore. And I did a thing on the 20 questions. I helped. Yeah, no, it was awesome. I always I'm very happy to increase my win rate versus Sam. I was telling Tom it doesn't there's very few chances for that to happen because we're always on together.

1:02:50Justin Davis: Justin, I'm having dinner with CJ tonight. Oh, nice. Tell him hello. I will. And I'll see you. We'll do in-person scoop in two weeks. Cool. Exciting. Later, guys. All right. Bye, y 'all. See you guys.

From the publisher

Welcome back to IGN Game Scoop!, the #1 video game podcast! This week your Omega Cops -- Daemon Hatfield, Justin Davis, and Tom Marks -- are discussing Phantom Blade Zero, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4, Ocarina of Time, Dispatch, and more. And, of course, they play Video Game 20 Questions.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Game Scoop!

All episodes