1. Podcasts
  2. Good Bad Billionaire
  3. Jack Dorsey: Twitter squared
Good Bad Billionaire

26 Oct 2026 · 42m · 16 chapters

Episode artwork

Jack Dorsey: Twitter squared

In short

BBC World Service “Good Bad Billionaire” episode on Jack Dorsey—how he helped create Twitter (now X) and later built Square/Block, plus the controversies and impact of both platforms.

Guest backgrounds

No guests appear; the hosts are Simon Jack and Zing Singh, discussing Dorsey’s life and business history.

Key claims

Dorsey is portrayed as an “accidental” billionaire and unusually unfocused, yet a brilliant coder. Twitter’s early features (at-sign, RT, hashtags, “tweet”) are said to have been invented by users. Dorsey’s management distractions contributed to his being replaced as Twitter CEO in 2008. Square’s success is credited to smartphone-enabled card payments.

Notable examples

First tweet “just setting up my Twitter” (March 2006); South by Southwest 2007 ambassador screens; Square’s iPhone dongle; Square’s 2.75% transaction fee; Twitter blocking Hunter Biden links (Oct 2020) and banning Donald Trump (Jan 2021); Dorsey’s later BitChat and Bitcoin advocacy.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

4:16

Jack's Early Life and Influences

Explore Jack Dorsey's childhood and early influences shaping his career.

“Between them, they set up three different businesses.”
7:01

Early Career and First Ventures

Discover Jack's early programming career and his first entrepreneurial ventures.

“His parents had given him an IBM PC Junior when he was just eight, and then a Macintosh by Apple three years later.”
10:42

Transition to Odeo and Twitter

Learn about the transition from Odeo to the creation of Twitter.

“But then Jack found himself unceremoniously fired by the very guy they'd hired just as the dot-com bubble burst.”
13:13

The Genesis of Twitter

Understand how Twitter was conceptualized and developed by Jack and his team.

“So clearly he was still keeping a toe dipped in the coding world.”
14:00

The Origins of Twitter

Learn about the founding and early development of Twitter and its key figures.

“Now, the social media site was founded in 2006 by Evan Noah Jack and another tech entrepreneur, Biz Stone, an ODO employee who was also a friend of Jack's and had some experience in search engines.”
17:36

The Rise of Twitter Users

Discover how Twitter's user base grew rapidly and the significance of South by Southwest.

“people whom Jack described as really good at Twitter and really popular folks.”
18:56

Challenges and Leadership Changes

Understand the challenges Jack Dorsey faced and the leadership changes at Twitter.

“Two years later, by 2010, it had more than 100 million.”
21:34

Jack Dorsey's Journey to Billionaire Status

Explore how Jack Dorsey transitioned from millionaire to billionaire through Square.

“Being removed was still like being punched in the stomach, according to Dorsey.”
26:50

The Evolution of Dorsey and Square

Learn about the growth of Square and Dorsey's leadership role in the fintech space.

“Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market.”
28:00

Jack Dorsey's Dual Roles

Exploring Jack Dorsey's leadership at Twitter and Square, as well as his unique management style.

“a bit like sort of Google and Facebook became Meta and Alphabet.”
Show all 16 chapters
30:10

Controversies and Decisions

Discussion around major controversies during Dorsey's tenure and his decisions regarding Twitter and Musk.

“And these two events are said to be factors in Elon Musk's desire to take over the platform in the name of free speech, she said, which he did in 2022.”
32:21

Assessing Dorsey's Controversial Legacy

Analyzing the controversies surrounding Dorsey and Twitter's impact on public discourse and censorship.

“inspired apparently by the late Apple founder Steve Jobs.”
36:29

Evaluating Jack Dorsey's Power and Influence

Examining Dorsey's power dynamics and his impact through Twitter and Square.

“And, you know, banning Trump following the Capitol riots was a big moment and that provoked a lot of criticism, particularly from people like Elon Musk, who ended up taking it over in the name, he said, of free speech.”
40:35

Final Thoughts on Twitter's Impact

Reflecting on Twitter's evolution, Dorsey's role, and audience engagement with the platform.

“they are in a vanishingly small group of people in the world.”
42:01

Listener Feedback and Reflections

The hosts share listener Chris Pitchford's thoughts on various billionaires and their impacts.

“Don't forget to include your name as we may read out your message on a future episode.”
43:16

Introduction of Mo Ibrahim

The hosts introduce Mo Ibrahim, a transformative figure in mobile networks in Africa.

“well thank you and if you haven't heard the episode that Chris is referring to do go and check it out that is Chuck Feeney essentially invented duty-free shopping so who do we have on the next episode?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Good Bad Billionaire, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Zing Tsjeng: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Zing Tsjeng: goals, or appetite for investing. Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales. And somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in. An all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system.

1:09Zing Tsjeng: Try for free today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

1:28Simon Jack: It's March 2006 and we're in an open plan office at 164 South Park Avenue, San Francisco.

1:34Zing Tsjeng: A man is hunched over his laptop typing. He's going to write five words. Well, four of them are words. The fifth is more a collection of consonants. Nonetheless, he's quite happy about what he's written. 20 letters, all lowercase, no punctuation. This is a sentence that will change the world.

1:50Simon Jack: It's the first post on a new website. a website that will be viewed over and over again by billions of people. It'll be used by presidents and prime ministers, superstars and space agencies, your local pub and your national police force, as well as by thousands and thousands of bots. People will use it to complain directly to their internet provider, and they'll also use it to complain to everyone else about their internet provider. It'll inspire riots and spark revolutions. Years later, one man will take it over and change its name. There will be over 10 trillion more posts after this one. The one being posted right now that simply says, just setting up my Twitter.

2:30Zing Tsjeng: Welcome to Good Bad Billionaire from the BBC World Service. Each episode we pick a billionaire and we find out how they made their money.

2:36Simon Jack: We take them from zero to their first million and then on from a million to a billion.

2:40Zing Tsjeng: I'm Simon Jack, I'm the BBC's business editor.

2:42Simon Jack: And I'm Zing Singh and I'm a journalist, author and podcaster.

2:44Zing Tsjeng: And this episode's billionaire is almost, I would describe as kind of an accidental billionaire.

2:50Simon Jack: He's certainly one of the most unfocused billionaires we've ever had on the show. Yeah. The tech bro who built Twitter is Jack Dorsey and he's the one who sent the first ever tweet before they were even cold tweets. He's currently worth around seven and a half billion dollars.

3:05Zing Tsjeng: He is one of the founders of the social media site that used to be called Twitter is now called X. and he also founded a small business payments company that used to be called Square and is now called Block. Now, he's most famous for Twitter,

3:17Simon Jack: but he has definitely made more money from Square.

3:20Zing Tsjeng: He's notoriously a minimalist, said to live a Spartan lifestyle, taking multiple ice baths a day and eating only one meal.

3:27Simon Jack: Oh, I don't think I could live with that. Well, he's also gone through quite a few different looks. He's been the nose-ringed punk. He's been the clean-shaven founder. And now he's the long-bearded billionaire in a tie-dye top with a very large S-shaped tattoo on his left arm.

3:41Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, he's also toyed with a few different careers, trying massage therapy and dressmaking. But tech has always eventually drawn him back.

3:49Simon Jack: But one thing is for sure, he is a brilliant coder who built much of the technology that has made him rich.

3:54Zing Tsjeng: And he believes technology can change the world for good. Whether his products have or not, we will ask you to judge.

4:00Simon Jack: But now let's take Jack Dorsey from zero to his first million.

4:15Zing Tsjeng: Jack Dorsey was born in November 1976 in St. Louis in the Midwest state of Missouri. Both his parents were entrepreneurial. Between them, they set up three different businesses.

4:25Simon Jack: The first was a pizza restaurant that Jack's father, Tim, co-founded. And he met Jack's mother, Marsha, because she was the first waitress he hired. And he left the business because dating staff was against his own rules.

4:36Zing Tsjeng: Later on, Tim set up a company that manufactured a scientific device called a mass spectrometer. Marsha would set up a coffee shop where teenage Jack occasionally worked as a barista, which kind of fits with his image, actually.

4:47Simon Jack: Exactly. And Jack has said that working in his mum's small business was actually an influence on him setting up Square because he wanted to make payment systems easier for small merchants like baristas and coffee shops.

4:58Zing Tsjeng: Now, looking at his childhood, there are a few aspects that would seem to point to the things he would go on to do, both with Twitter and with Square. For one, he had a speech impediment. His response was to be less chatty than most kids. Also try to improve his communication skills by joining the debate team and the speech club at Bishop Duborg, his fee paying Catholic high school. Interesting in a way, if speech is your problem, that you found a website where no one has to say anything. It's basically text rather than speech.

5:25Simon Jack: Exactly. But also at the same time, a platform that arguably allows people to say anything they want. Well, Jack also identified as a minimalist from an early age. Despite being the oldest of three sons, he chose to have the smallest bedroom, much to the surprise of his parents and parents all over the world, I think. Twitter, which was initially referred to as a micro-blogging site with those 140 character updates, those don't exist anymore, could also be seen as minimalist in one sense.

5:52Zing Tsjeng: Jack was also obsessed with maps as a kid. Meanwhile, Jack's father, Tim, had the hobby of listening to CB radio. Now, CB radio, they're basically two-way radio. You use radio waves for personal communications. And Tim liked to drive down to the Mississippi River and listen to barges communicating with each other. And sometimes he'd take Jack along.

6:10Simon Jack: So sort of lurking on the CB radio airwaves, much like many of us would on Twitter later on.

6:15Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, look, if you're just watching what people are up to, what's going on.

6:18Simon Jack: Exactly. Well, Jack found it all incredibly boring. But he was interested in the police scanner his dad used because of all the information it was providing about how police cars, taxis and ambulances moved around the city. It was like a live data map of the whole place and Jack wanted to create a programme to track this data onto an actual map and that is why he started learning to code.

6:39Zing Tsjeng: And he became obsessed with this little project, forgetting to eat or sleep. He said that it felt great to build something that enabled him to see the city and that it was the start of his interest in translating the physical world into the virtual or the digital world.

6:52Simon Jack: Like many of our other tech billionaires, Jack was helped by the fact he was in the right place at the right time, with crucially access to the right kit.

7:00Zing Tsjeng: Yes, we've come across this before, haven't we? Access to computers. His parents had given him an IBM PC Junior when he was just eight, and then a Macintosh by Apple three years later. And in his childhood, St. Louis was actually a bit of a tech hub. You might not think so, but it was. Big technology companies like McDonnell Douglas, Southwestern Bell were headquartered there. There was a well-known e-zine by and for hackers base there that began in 1985, which is pretty early for this kind of stuff. Plus, the local university allowed residents to use its computer network. So that meant Jack could access the internet years before most other people could, even before the World Wide Web was even launched in 1991.

7:39Simon Jack: It was via this very same university network that Jack taught himself coding. As an 11-year-old, he'd watch programmers share their code on something called Internet Relay Chat, an early way of having live online text conversations.

7:52Zing Tsjeng: So he's a prodigy and by high school he was creating programmes that could be used to dispatch taxis or couriers. So he sounds a bit like a typical tech geek at this point, but a friend has described him as one of the more popular, unpopular guys in school. He was into punk bands, he excelled at drawing, and his mum apparently still has an item that combines these passions, a picture he drew of Kurt Cobain, lead singer of Nirvana, who were very big in the 90s.

8:17Simon Jack: Well, in 1992 at 15, Jack gets an internship at a local software company that archived documents onto CD-ROM. I remember them. Someone from the company was in Jack's mum, Marsha's coffee shop, and happened to tell her that they were desperate for new programmers. She mentioned her son's love of computers, and soon Jack turned up at the company and introduced himself to the owner, a guy called Jim McKelvey.

8:39Zing Tsjeng: Now, according to McKelvey himself, the meeting was pretty inauspicious. He told Jack to wait, forgot about him for 45 minutes, then turned around and saw him in the exact same position he left in 45 minutes earlier. But Jim took Jack on anyway as an intern. And this was the start of a pretty important relationship for both of them.

8:56Simon Jack: Jack was soon impressing Jim with his coding. He also had foresight, realising, like Jim, that they needed to migrate the business online and even making that happen. So when Jim hired new staff and they asked what their job title would be, he'd say assistant to a summer intern.

9:11Zing Tsjeng: That's really good. I like that.

9:12Simon Jack: He'd tell them to do everything, in his words, the kid told them to do.

9:17Zing Tsjeng: So, yes, Jack clearly showing a prodigious talent at a very young age, noticed by Jim, who will come back into this story a bit later on. But Jack's skills kept improving and he enrolled at the University of Missouri in nearby Roller.

9:29Simon Jack: That university is now called the Missouri University of Science and Technology. And Jack unsurprisingly studied computer science and maths there. He still had this interest in dispatch software. and in his junior year, he discovered the website of a company called Dispatch Management Services, which managed bicycle messengers in New York. He wanted to know who ran the company, so he hacked into the site to find out, then contacted its owner, Greg Kidd, to tell him there was a security hole in his site and that he was good at writing dispatch software. So I found your problem and now I can fix it.

9:59Simon Jack: Thank you very much.

10:00Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, well, Greg was irritated but impressed and he hired Jack to come to New York and work as one of his site's lead programmers with Jack transferring to NYU, New York University. And Jack developed software to run a new system that was designed to enable bike messengers to bid for jobs, which sounds a bit like, you know, a kind of proto Uber maybe.

10:20Simon Jack: Yeah, well, it just goes to show that there's nothing new under the sun. Jack and Greg became close. And in 1999, at the height of the dot-com bubble, the pair moved to San Francisco to launch a new company for dispatching couriers online. Jack, of course, like so many of our billionaires, dropped out of college before his final semester. But then things did not go as they so often do in these stories. Jack and Greg raised the money. They hired a CEO. But then Jack found himself unceremoniously fired by the very guy they'd hired just as the dot-com bubble burst.

10:50Zing Tsjeng: Tough one. Jack was apparently too intent on perfecting the software and was not focused enough on money, on sales. So in 2002 at 26, Jack returned to St. Louis with his tail between his legs, did a bit of coding for his dad's company. He studied botanical illustration, but he found his wrists aching from years of coding and he found himself in need of a massage therapist.

11:12Simon Jack: This is when massage therapy became his next unlikely obsession. He undertook a thousand hours of training in this field and wanted to return to California and offer services to all the other programmers there who'd spent their careers hunched uncomfortably over a laptop. I mean, that sounds good to me.

11:29Zing Tsjeng: But back in San Francisco, he discovered he was not the first person to have this idea. The city was overrun with massage therapists.

11:35Simon Jack: Jack had moved into a literal shed in his old friend Greg Kidd's garden. And Greg helped him out again by hiring him to look after his young daughter in exchange for a room and board while he got back on his feet. Now, Jack at this point was a guy in his mid-twenties. He was a techie. He had a little bit of a punk look going on. You know, spiky hair, nose ring, earrings in both ears. Might have seemed like the world's most unlikely childminder. But Greg says he was great with his daughter because he was able to focus and be present.

12:03Zing Tsjeng: And he was also spending the nights getting back into programming, picking up various short-term coding jobs. But he was thinking of another career change. This time he wanted to be, wait for it, a dressmaker. He enrolled in a fashion class and began designing and sewing clothes. He even made various skirts.

12:19Simon Jack: I really wonder what a skirt made by the founder of Twitter looks like.

12:24Zing Tsjeng: I know. I've met Jack Dorsey a couple of times. And what this story kind of reflects is he gives off this rather off-air demeanour, like he's sort of looking up and da-da-da.

12:34Simon Jack: Away with the fairies.

12:35Zing Tsjeng: Well, sort of, you know, thinking about hundreds of different things at the same time. And you said earlier, was he the least focused billionaire? Now, you know, I don't know whether he's just got that gift and maybe some of it's a bit of a, you know, an act. There's a little bit of performative eccentricity going on here, maybe. But one thing that's clear is he's a coding genius.

12:55Simon Jack: Well, it seems like he's a much more focused programmer than he was a dressmaker. Because around the same time he had this aspiration to get into fashion, he also seems to have restyled himself. He lost his piercings, he shaved himself. And he also sent a CV to a company called Odeo, whom he'd heard were looking for programmers. So clearly he was still keeping a toe dipped in the coding world.

13:16Zing Tsjeng: Now, Odeo were a podcasting company. While Jack had absolutely no interest in podcasts, hello Jack, if you're listening, he did think that one of the founders looked cool when he saw him in his neighbourhood. Now, Odeo's founders, Evan Williams and Noah Glass, also liked Jack's new look. Like him, they were college dropouts who thought of themselves as rebels, if you like. So in spite of the excessive minimalism of Jack's resume, which listed his name only as Jack, Evan and Noah hired him.

13:42Simon Jack: As it turned out, they also weren't really that interested in podcasting. Hi, Evan. Hi, Noah. Lovely to meet you if you're listening. They'd envisaged their company as a directory of existing podcasts. But when Apple launched their version of iTunes with a podcast store, they knew the idea was doomed. So they needed to think of a new one fast. What happened next was Twitter.

14:01Zing Tsjeng: Now, the social media site was founded in 2006 by Evan Noah Jack and another tech entrepreneur, Biz Stone, an ODO employee who was also a friend of Jack's and had some experience in search engines. How exactly Twitter happened depends on which of those four you ask.

14:17Simon Jack: Jack's version goes back to a project he'd built six years earlier called Status with a dot between the T and the U, which enabled him to post short statuses about what he was doing to his friends via email on his BlackBerry. Back then, he'd sent one update from a local park telling friends he was at the bison paddock. And after he got no responses, he decided that no one had a BlackBerry and no one cared and he shelved the whole idea. But in 2006, people had started having smartphones. SMS technology with short messaging was ubiquitous and social media was already up and running. There was MySpace, there was LiveJournal.

14:51Simon Jack: They both had millions of users. So in other words, the world was ready to read other people's statuses.

14:56Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, the story goes that Jack shared the idea with his Twitter co-founders at another park while sitting on a children's slide as the group ate Mexican food and they took it from there.

15:05Simon Jack: Now, Noah Glass and Evan Williams have complained that their and especially Noah's role in the founding of Twitter has been minimised. Noah certainly came up with the name Twitter, or Twitter without vowels as they were initially calling it, and all the founders provided important input.

15:20Zing Tsjeng: But quite a lot does appear to have come straight from Jack. From minimalist statuses and design this notion of updates from wherever you are or about wherever you are and early on Evan even called Jack the genius behind the Twitter idea and he didn't even seem to think Twitter was going to be that big actually Evan was more interested in turning Odeo into a business incubator meaning he didn't have time to run Twitter so in spite of Jack's lack of experience managing anything Evan was happy to make him CEO and in 2011 Evan told Vanity Fair I thought it's risk because he'd never been a manager.

15:53Zing Tsjeng: But Twitter wasn't a huge deal at the time. And I thought, he's got the vision. He's got the technical chops. Let's put him in charge.

15:59Simon Jack: In just two weeks, alongside one other coder, Jack built the whole basis for the entire site. In March 2006, the first tweet was posted from his account, at Jack, which I think he still has today. He wrote, just setting up my Twitter in all lower case because he says he's a fan of the poet E.E. Cummings, who wrote exclusively in lower case.

16:18Zing Tsjeng: Very interesting that. But for a while, no one took much notice. The original version of Twitter was basically a white page that looked a bit like a search engine and asked, what's your status? Which Jack has since said wasn't a great question.

16:30Simon Jack: But Jack kept iterating. He refining the idea, making it better. The design improved, the backend improved. And the question also improved from what's your status to what are you doing to what's happening? This is a much better way of getting people to post because the answer could be literally whatever the users were thinking about.

16:47Zing Tsjeng: And Jack has since explained almost everything that you'd see on Twitter in the first few years was actually invented by its users. The at sign, for example, before usernames was the usage they noticed and adopted. RT, retweet in front of retweets, came from users before Twitter made it part of the functionality. The same was true of hashtags and even the use of the word tweet came from the users.

17:08Simon Jack: So in one sense, a very user-generated platform.

17:11Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, and under Jack, Twitter was constantly responding to its users and evolving to become a better product. but early on it hardly had any users to learn from. It took an event exactly one year after launch in March 2007 to really boost Twitter's profile.

17:25Simon Jack: In the lobby at the annual Austin, Texas Music and Software Festival South by Southwest, Twitter paid for giant screens to broadcast the tweets of a dozen specially selected ambassadors in attendance, people whom Jack described as really good at Twitter and really popular folks. Twitter became the talk of the festival. It got written about in the press. people started using it. And remember, this is around the same time Facebook has become huge. So people are really scouring the landscape for the next big thing in social media.

17:54Zing Tsjeng: And sure enough, investment in Twitter followed with a series A, that's the first round of funding, raising up to$5 million in 2007. The next round of funding brought in$15 million the next year.

18:06Simon Jack: Jack's salary at the time is not known. And in later years, he took only a symbolic $1.40 paycheck as a nod to the original character limit. Remember, it's 140 characters. But as usual with our billionaires, the real worth came from ownership and Jack is thought to have had a 20 % share of the company at this point in time. So with around 20 million investor in Twitter, Jack's share was definitely worth millions. So we can say that in 2008, Jack Dorsey was a millionaire.

18:46Zing Tsjeng: So how did Jack Dorsey go from millionaire to billionaire? Well, this was a period of extraordinary growth for social media in general and for Twitter in particular. In 2008, the service had 1.3 million users. Two years later, by 2010, it had more than 100 million. And 87 % of Americans knew what Twitter was. So when do you think you signed up for Twitter? I can't remember. I'm actually going to get on to it now. because it usually says member since. Oh, that's a good idea.

19:13Simon Jack: Yeah, let's get the phones out.

19:17Zing Tsjeng: Oh, wow. Oh, OK, you go first.

19:19Simon Jack: OK, so I joined in November 2006. What?

19:26Zing Tsjeng: I wasn't, I was really slow. I joined April 2009.

19:31Simon Jack: Wow, I'm an early adopter. Because you're younger than me, you see.

19:34Zing Tsjeng: That's the problem. That's the thing.

19:35Simon Jack: Also, bear in mind that I was, I think at this point just about to start university so I had a lot of spare time on my hands.

19:42Zing Tsjeng: The thing is that it soon became clear even though I was a late adopter compared to you that news and things that going you know you know being a journalist you need to know what's going on and a lot of what was going on was being talked about on Twitter so you know it felt like something you couldn't ignore certainly.

20:01Simon Jack: It became a kind of watering hole for journalists and people in the media and also politicians, I think.

20:07Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. And in those days, you didn't get so many links or so much commercial stuff. It really was people posting thoughts, ideas, stories of their own, but it's certainly not the arena that it is today.

20:19Simon Jack: No, it did feel in some ways like you were just dunking your head into a river of humanity. Yeah. Just channeling everyone's thoughts all the time.

20:28Zing Tsjeng: Now it feels like you're dunking your head into a river of something else. so you know it definitely felt like place you needed to be you know to see and be seen particularly for journalists and i think that one of the compulsions which made it such a success yeah

20:42Simon Jack: i mean it was intoxicating it was so addictive i remember having to check it compulsively and at one point i had a friend who had to undergo hypnotherapy in order to wean himself from his addiction to twitter so i do think you know this amount of extraordinary growth makes perfect sense to me.

20:59Zing Tsjeng: And actually that growth turned out to be too rapid for the small team there to manage. In the first couple of years there were problems with the whole system going down a lot. Jack seemed ill-equipped as a manager to handle this kind of rapid expansion. Employees there became frustrated that he was regularly distracted by his hobbies, leaving work early to practice yoga or continue his dressmaking lessons.

21:19Simon Jack: The hobbyist billionaire, that's another way to describe him. Evan Williams is said to have given him an ultimatum. You can either be a dressmaker or the CEO of Twitter, but you can't be both. Soon, Jack was neither, with Evan replacing him as CEO in 2008.

21:35Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, Dorsey has always said that it felt like Evan's company in any way to him, that he was a new guy with a good idea, and that he wouldn't be strong in his own conviction, because Evan, in his mind, was the older, wiser one, Jack has said. Being removed was still like being punched in the stomach, according to Dorsey.

21:51Simon Jack: Jack still had his ownership stake, but as it turns out, Twitter was not the product that made Jack Dorsey a billionaire. It took a new idea, a new project and a new partnership to do that and to prove that Jack was no one hit wonder.

22:04Zing Tsjeng: And this is where Jim McKelvey, that St. Louis entrepreneur we met earlier who gave Jack an internship, re-enters this story. He and Jack had stayed in touch over the years. They'd had a chat about how Jim had been unable to take a payment from an overseas client because he had no way of accepting their credit card. So the pair saw an opportunity to make it possible for anyone with a smartphone to accept card payments. and this is another moment where sort of the technology of the time, the evolution of smartphones, so the hardware presents another opportunity.

22:34Simon Jack: Exactly. And it's funny because I remember this transition between people needing to have card machines, complicated equipment, and now you can just tap on someone's phone and pay them straight away.

22:46Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. So together, Jack and Jim founded Square, a mobile payment solution in 2009. Jack focused on the software, Jim on the hardware. The result, Square's small white card reader with a dongle that plugged into an iPhone. And that has been the, you know, the saviour of many. If you go to a fair or a car boot sale, exactly. You can basically set up and you're going to have a full payment system just in your pocket. You know, small businesses often only accepted cash at the time. Car payment services were, you know, a bit of a technological stretch. And now they're putting that right in their hands.

23:22Simon Jack: I mean, it definitely accelerated the move towards cashless societies.

23:26Zing Tsjeng: I mean, how much cash have you got on you right now?

23:29Simon Jack: Literally nothing. I don't even have a wallet on me right now.

23:31Zing Tsjeng: I don't, me neither. I've got no wallet, no cash.

23:33Simon Jack: Well, there you go. The triumph of Square in the end. Interestingly, and I didn't know the behind the scenes of how these companies work, Square charged 2.75 % of transactions. That is a little higher than typical card charges at the time, but obviously the barrier to entry is a lot lower. And Jack, as with his$1.40 salary at Twitter, would take a nominal$2.75 salary at Square. And as soon as the funding rounds launched, the business became one of Silicon Valley's biggest fintech success stories. An expert called Square's angel investment round the hottest I've ever seen. People knew immediately how much this kind of technology was going to be worth.

24:09Simon Jack: That pre-launch round of funding took in 10 million. It had the company valued at 40 million. And of course, the product kept iterating. For example, that dongle became an app, so you no longer needed the dongle at all.

24:20Zing Tsjeng: You didn't even need the hardware at all. Meanwhile, Square had expanded from just a payment solution to a broader suite, if you like, of fintech products for small businesses. These days, it offers loans, payroll, stock, cryptocurrency trading, even physical debit cards now.

24:34Simon Jack: And it also launched the hugely successful Cash App in North America in 2013. This is pretty much ubiquitous across North America. And it began a significant, although short-lived, partnership with Starbucks soon after.

24:46Zing Tsjeng: By that point, Jack was already a billionaire. After various rounds of venture capital funding at Square, Forbes included Jack in their billionaire list for the first time in 2012. At the time, Square was valued at$3.2 billion, with Jack's stake worth$845 million. If you add that to his stake in Twitter, that was valued around$350 million, gave Jack a net worth of$1.1 billion. So he'd made it. In 2012, Jack Dorsey was a billionaire.

25:42Zing Tsjeng: www.xarxl.com This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of AXA XL.

26:16Zing Tsjeng: for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made.

26:21Simon Jack: This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Cheers to fall savings at Whole Foods Market, home of higher ingredient standards. This Halloween, share chocolates and candies made without that spooky high fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a berry chantilly cake, ready to cook pizza, no antibiotics ever chicken wings, and sushi made fresh daily. Fall gatherings never tasted better. Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market.

26:58Simon Jack: So let's take Jack beyond a billion. Twitter may not have been the thing that pushed him over the billion mark, but he did make a billion from the company when it went public in 2013. This was a hugely successful IPO. Twitter's value rose 73 % on the very first day of trading. And that meant the company was worth$31 billion and Jack's then 4 % share was worth another billion.

27:22Zing Tsjeng: Square then went public with an IPO in 2015 when Dorsey's total fortune was estimated at$2.2 billion. But actually the Square IPO was a bit of a disappointment with the market price somewhat short of the expected valuation, meaning Jack's estimated wealth dipped by some$800 million.

27:37Simon Jack: But the company saw good growth after that. There was a setback during COVID-19. But in spite of that, Jack made a pledge during the pandemic to give away a billion dollars to COVID relief and other causes. He's actually tracked his giving online and so far has made good on about 75 % of that promise. So not bad going.

27:54Zing Tsjeng: Not bad going. He's also remained in charge of Square as the company has made some big moves, including rebranding as Block in 2021, a bit like sort of Google and Facebook became Meta and Alphabet. So it becomes a parent company to lots of different things.

28:09Simon Jack: The name change also coincided with another big move, acquiring the Australian buy now, pay later tech firm Afterpay. This is kind of like the Aussie version of Klarna. And he bought that for$29 billion. That's a hell of an acquisition. $29 billion, that's big. Dorsey now, funnily enough, styles himself as blockhead rather than CEO. So he's got a bit of a sense of humour about himself. But he was also CEO of another company during this period.

28:34Zing Tsjeng: Yes, amazingly, he returned to lead Twitter in 2015. By this point, Twitter, you could argue, was at its peak as a cultural force. You know, celebrities, royals, presidents, Justin Bieber was using it and it was credited as playing a key role in the Arab Spring. It had 2 ,000 employees, 200 million active users and was valued at$16 billion.

28:56Simon Jack: So it's pretty unusual that at CEO, a man often criticised in his first term at the company for his lack of focus on the job, was running both Twitter and Square at the same time. I mean, Elon Musk, for instance, runs multiple companies. He's very much in a party of one when it comes to that.

29:12Zing Tsjeng: Usually shareholders want, you know, the shareholders of one company want your total focus on that thing. And actually, when I met Jack Dorsey was at the time when he was running both Twitter and Square. and everyone was just sort of amazed. How can you do these two things? You know, he seemed to run them both pretty well. Of course, Elon Musk will end up running and renaming Twitter and we've covered all that in our episode on him. Do check that out. Jack Dorsey had actually left Twitter for a second time though by the time Musk rolled up to the office with a sink and a terrible pun in 2022.

29:45Simon Jack: Yeah, I remember that. The pun was let that sink in and that was why he carried a kitchen sink in. I mean, not as funny, objectively speaking, as calling yourself blockhead like Jack Dorsey did. No. Jack had brought some stability and a significant rise in the stock price to Twitter when he returned. But eventually, investors, as you say, did become concerned about him concurrently running Square, and they asked him to step down from that company. Instead, he quit Twitter and not Square in 2021, saying in a letter to staff that it was entirely his decision.

30:14Zing Tsjeng: He'd been through some pretty major controversies at the site in the preceding years, including that interesting decision to ban Donald Trump after the Capitol riots of January 2021 and Twitter blocking content relating to allegations about Joe Biden's son Hunter during the 2020 election period. And these two events are said to be factors in Elon Musk's desire to take over the platform in the name of free speech, she said, which he did in 2022.

30:39Simon Jack: Interestingly, at the time, Jack Dorsey chose to keep his shares in the Musk-owned venture rather than taking the near$1 billion Musk offered for them. And he still holds stock in the company.

30:49Zing Tsjeng: That's quite unusual to do that in business terms, usually saying, why would I leave a billion dollars when I'm not in control anymore? So I think having a passive investment like that, it's actually pretty rare. The other reason why it's quite surprising is that it's widely thought at the time that Musk had overpaid for Twitter because he sort of said that he had the money to take it private and his hand was sort of forced by the Securities and Exchange Commission who said, you put something out there, you've got to follow through with it, you've made this promise, you've got to do it now. And everyone thought, actually, he bought it at a too higher price.

31:21Zing Tsjeng: That makes it doubly surprising that Jack Dorsey left his money in there.

31:24Simon Jack: And also Twitter, at the time, I think people were already saying, was kind of on the way out.

31:29Zing Tsjeng: Well, Jack has since launched a peer-to-peer messaging app called BitChat. I think it's Bitch. I think it's BitChat rather than Bitchat. Bitchat. And he's become a major advocate of Bitcoin. So you get definitely Bitchat.

31:44Simon Jack: So that's where he is today. And it's now time for us to judge Jack Dorsey. This is a bit of fun that we usually do at the end of every episode where we award people marks out of 10 billionaire categories like wealth, legacy and power. So let's begin with wealth. He's kind of surprisingly rather low on the billionaire wealth stakes, I think.

32:04Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, seven and a half billion dollars is the current total, we think. down from a peak of£12.5 billion in 2021. But we also look in this category at sort of how they spend it. Do they flash their cash around? And Jack Dorsey, definitely on the minimalist side here, inspired apparently by the late Apple founder Steve Jobs. Jack only owns a handful of pieces of furniture. The New Yorker reported he carries no briefcase or folder, has no desk at work. When people give him books, he says he gives them away, then downloads the e-book, which he usually deletes from his iPad after he's finished.

32:38Simon Jack: I mean, I don't want to cast aspersions, but this seems like a miserable way to live.

32:42Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. I must say that I'm the same with books. Once I've read a book, I'll give it away. But I don't go to the extent of downloading the e-book and then deleting it on my iPad after I've finished.

32:51Simon Jack: That feels like a statement to me.

32:53Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, that is a statement. He's given some money to charity?

32:55Simon Jack: Yeah, he's given away$795 million, which is not to be sneezed at.

33:00Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. So somewhere, you know, he's$7.5 billion. He's not entry level. He's a bit higher than that. You know, we've had people who's crept on with a billion and a bit. I'm going to give him four for wealth.

33:12Simon Jack: Oh, I think I would give him maybe a bit less, like three, because even though he definitely isn't one of those who have crept in with maybe like$1.1 billion,

33:21Zing Tsjeng: for someone in tech, he's nowhere near the big leagues

33:24Simon Jack: like Musk or Zuckerberg.

33:26Zing Tsjeng: Okay, four for me, three for you. Controversy, controversy. Well, Twitter in itself is quite controversial, right? Yes. Or X, give it its current name.

33:36Simon Jack: Well, I mean, even in Dorsey's time, it was the kind of platform that gave people jobs, won them jobs, but also lost them in spectacular fashion. I mean, I remember reading the book So You've Been Publicly Shamed by a journalist called John Ronson. And he spends time with people who have been cancelled, lost careers, lost families, all because of an unfortunate thing that they happened to tweet, which then went viral.

34:00Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. And it became such a hotbed. Some people say, I've just got to pull my head out of it. And, you know, a lot of people, I think, start conflating Twitter or X with the real world. If you're in it, it feels like the real world. And sometimes you have to remind people, listen, you know, it isn't the real world.

34:19Simon Jack: Yeah. Well, the amount of discourse, I think, that it generated single handedly for one platform was just remarkable in both good ways. You know, people attribute the Arab spring uprisings to it, you know, spreading of democratic ideas and values. But also, it felt like every single day on Twitter, there was a villain of the day. And it could be anybody. It could be you. It could be your dad. It could be a friend of yours. And everyone in the world would pal on and make fun of them. And I think in that sense, it generated a lot of discord and a lot of division in a way that other platforms just simply didn't manage to do.

34:54Simon Jack: Facebook was peer to peer, whereas Twitter was like broadcasting to the whole world.

34:59Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, and I think there's a reason, for example, that some countries, Australia leading the way, put in age limits for social media, because things like bullying, trolling, all that kind of stuff became an issue, which is kind of, you know, really making, you know, particularly younger people's mental health really suffer.

35:16Simon Jack: It's interesting because there was also criticism across the political spectrum, left and right, that Twitter had failed to police this kind of harmful content. And actually, if you look at the research that Twitter was producing on itself, they found that the algorithms amplified voices on the right. So, you know, it really, in many ways, was not a perfect platform.

35:35Zing Tsjeng: There was, of course, also that big controversy about the 2020 US election. So in October 2020, Twitter began blocking users from sharing links to a pair of New York Post articles about Hunter Biden. Within hours, members of Congress said they would subpoena Jack Dorsey to explain that decision. According to insiders, Dorsey wasn't involved in that decision. And he posted on Twitter that blocking link sharing with no context from the company as to why was unacceptable.

35:59Simon Jack: It kind of strikes me that in many ways we talk about Dorsey being the accidental billionaire. And he's sort of like the accidental Twitter founder. He created this tool, this platform with the best of intentions for letting people know what was going on in the world without realising that it could become this huge instrument to create political division. You know, so fears across the political spectrum, create this huge controversy around censorship. You know, he didn't really understand what he had created.

36:27Zing Tsjeng: Well, in fact, he's been sort of criticised for his leadership style, delegating sort of the big decisions like you've just been discussing to subordinates in part so he can get on with his personal passions like massage therapy and dressmaking. And, you know, banning Trump following the Capitol riots was a big moment and that provoked a lot of criticism, particularly from people like Elon Musk, who ended up taking it over in the name, he said, of free speech.

36:50Simon Jack: So I think he actually scores quite highly on controversy.

36:53Zing Tsjeng: Well, yeah, I mean, I don't think he would probably be, you know, he sort of stumbled into an enormous amount of controversy. But his creation, I think, is very controversial. So I'd score him pretty high. I'd say seven or eight. What do you reckon?

37:04Simon Jack: Oh, I would probably say eight or nine.

37:07Zing Tsjeng: OK.

37:07Simon Jack: Maybe eight out of ten.

37:08Zing Tsjeng: I think we're scoring Twitter rather than Dorsey. But I think as long as we make that clear. OK, I'm going to go seven.

37:14Simon Jack: OK, well, I think I would still give Jack Dorsey eight out of ten. because if he was maybe a little bit more focused, maybe he would have understood his creation, but instead he kind of Dr. Frankensteined the whole thing. He has to surely bear some responsibility for this.

37:30Zing Tsjeng: Okay, seven from me, eight from you. Power, everything we've just discussed demonstrate that Twitter's pretty powerful. Exactly. And also, he's a big figure. We always say that to make one multi-billion dollar company is amazing, to make more than one. But he's got Square as well, or Block as it's now known. So within those circles, he's pretty powerful. Is he the kind of person, I think if he wanted to, I think he could exert more power than he actually does. But, you know, my impression of him was that he's not the kind of person who wants to call the President of the United States or wants to exert an enormous amount of influence.

38:07Zing Tsjeng: I would say power-wise, I think X is still powerful.

38:10Simon Jack: Yes, it is.

38:11Zing Tsjeng: But Dorsey himself, less so. If I put those two together, I'm going to give him a five.

38:16Simon Jack: You know, the more I think about it, the more Jack Dorsey reminds me a little bit of Dr. Victor Frankenstein. He's created Frankenstein's monster, and that's the thing that everyone's running scared of. But really, Dr. Frankenstein should kind of... He wasn't particularly scary himself. He wasn't scary himself, but he did create the thing that everyone got scared of. So I think when it comes to power, I'm going to give him a 6 out of 10. I think he could wield, as you say, far more power than he actually ended up.

38:41Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. I mean, you know, the change of the political outlook on the site since Elon Musk took over demonstrates some of this. You know, he's probably got more power than he chooses to wield, is the way we'll put it, shall we? Yes. So what did I say? Five and you said six. And legacy?

38:56Simon Jack: When he dies, he will die as the creator of Twitter.

39:00Zing Tsjeng: Yeah. Okay. That's on that happy thought. Hope you're listening, Jack. Well, he doesn't.

39:06Simon Jack: He famously doesn't like podcasts.

39:07Zing Tsjeng: No, he doesn't like, or he's not. Yeah. Listen, it was one of the most influential communication platforms in history. So if you look at what Twitter, now X has kind of spawned. So, for example, in the old days, a tweet from Donald Trump could change, you know, financial markets. And he now posts on his own social media, you know, inspired, obviously, by Twitter and X. You know, a post on that can change oil prices. It's as powerful as a missile in many ways.

39:38Simon Jack: I mean, it did pioneer a whole new form of messaging and communication online, right?

39:43Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, for sure. So I think the legacy is pretty huge, actually, on this one.

39:48Simon Jack: I mean, just even putting aside Twitter, when you think about what Square did, there was a time, and younger listeners may not remember this, but you genuinely had to pay in cash. And I think companies like Square, obviously now called Block, really just changed how we use cash, how we interact with people in stores. I mean, it democratised the whole system of payment.

40:11Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, it sure did. It gave enormous power. As you say, think of the car boot sale. Think of the coconut shire at the local Fahit or something. Whatever it is, you can now take electronic payments. And Square, now Block, was behind a lot of that. So, yeah, I think legacy is massive, actually. I'm going to say nine.

40:30Simon Jack: Oh, yeah. I like that. I think nine out of ten. I think, as you say, the kind of people who can start not one but two and multiple billion dollar companies, they are in a vanishingly small group of people in the world.

40:44Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, nine for both of us. So, final reflections on Twitter, X?

40:49Simon Jack: I will say that in its heyday, Twitter was so much fun.

40:52Zing Tsjeng: Yeah.

40:53Simon Jack: It was hilarious.

40:54Zing Tsjeng: Yeah, well, you were on early. You were 2006, right? Yeah. And I didn't join in 2009. Well, you know, you can let us know what you think of this podcast. We're both on it. Yeah. Your handle is? Miss Zing, no underscore, all one word. And mine's at BBC, capitalised Simon Jack. So, you can get in touch with that. It was a lot of fun. And there are times when you want to sort of pull out of it because it can get pretty, you know, it can get pretty hostile. You know, it can be pretty unpleasant. But I still, I think if you're a journalist, you can't afford not to be on it. I keep tabs on, you know, my colleagues and rivals.

41:28Zing Tsjeng: Your frenemies. Yeah, my frenemies, exactly. It still feels to me like somewhere you've got to peek at from time to time.

41:35Simon Jack: And also it was a very funny place to be on. At its height, I still have a folder of screenshots of the funniest tweets I've ever seen.

41:42Zing Tsjeng: People can be hilarious. And basically the satirical jokes you get on there about events of the day can be absolutely brilliant. So that's what we think. The question is, is Jack Dorsey good, bad or just another billionaire? We want to hear your thoughts. Email goodbadbillionaire, that's all one word, at bbc.com. Or drop us a text or WhatsApp to 001 917 686 1176.

42:06Simon Jack: Don't forget to include your name as we may read out your message on a future episode. Speaking of feedback, avid listener Chris Pitchford in London has been in touch to share his thoughts and he says, I love the Alan Sugar episode. However, I think he's just a billionaire. Yes, he's entrepreneurial, but aren't all billionaires. I also felt he was in the right place at the right time with a sky dish deal.

42:25Zing Tsjeng: Chris goes on to say, I also love Sheryl Sandberg. Again, very intelligent lady and I admire how she monetised Facebook and Google, but to the deficit of publishing. So for that reason, I feel she's a bad billionaire. As it's my industry, these tech people have squeezed. But that doesn't stop me from admiring her.

42:41Simon Jack: He also adds, Marcus Person is just a billionaire, but what a game he designed. My kids love it and schools have sessions on the game. He's talking about the game Minecraft.

42:49Zing Tsjeng: But Chris's favourite, he says, of all the podcasts, and I believe I've listened to every single one, thank you for that, Chris, is Chuck Finney. What a man. He's everything any good businessman aspires to be. It's him who inspired me to look at our company's philanthropic position. we'll be looking to put through university an inner city kid who wants to get into tech and we will employ them during their time at university so it's a win-win therefore I see Chuck as a good billionaire keep up the good work I thoroughly enjoy listening when I'm travelling well thank you and if you haven't heard the episode that Chris is referring to do go and check it out that is Chuck Feeney essentially invented duty-free shopping so who do we have on the next episode?

43:29Zing Tsjeng: somebody who basically transformed sub-Saharan Africa by introducing mobile networks there at a time when other investors, other banks, did not think that Africa represented a good bad.

43:41Simon Jack: His name is Mo Ibrahim. He is the founder of CellTel, one of the first mobile phone networks in sub-Saharan Africa. And he describes himself as a reluctant entrepreneur who wanted to become a scientist.

43:52Zing Tsjeng: And he gave his name to the Ibrahim Index, which ranks African countries on good governance, which is something that was particularly close to his heart. So that is Mo Ibrahim next up on Good Bad Billionaire.

44:04Simon Jack: Good Bad Billionaire is a BBC Studios production for the BBC World Service. It's produced by Mark Ward. The editor is Paul Smith.

44:11Zing Tsjeng: For the BBC World Service, the senior podcast producer is Sarah Green and the commissioning editor is John Manel. www.acsa .xl.com Axa XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of Axa XL.

From the publisher

Jack Dorsey founded a social media behemoth, but made more cash from card payments. He built Twitter, but was removed as CEO, before going on to found fintech firm Square.

BBC business editor Simon Jack and journalist Zing Tsjeng uncover Dorsey’s unusual billionaire biography. He was a kid with a speech impediment who created a website that changed the way the world communicated. Despite being a brilliant coder, he nearly left the tech industry twice. He first retrained as a massage therapist, and then as a dressmaker.

Good Bad Billionaire is the podcast that explores the lives of the super-rich and famous, tracking their wealth, philanthropy, business ethics, and success. There are leaders who made their money in Silicon Valley, on Wall Street and in high street fashion. From iconic celebrities and CEOs to titans of technology, the podcast unravels tales of fortune, power, economics, ambition and moral responsibility. Simon and Zing put their subjects to the test with a playful, totally unscientific scorecard — then hand the verdict over to you: are they good, bad, or simply billionaires? Here's how to contact the team: email [email protected] or send a text or WhatsApp to +1 (917) 686-1176. Find out more about the show and read our privacy notice at www.bbcworldservice.com/goodbadbillionaire.

More from Good Bad Billionaire

All episodes