Aubrey Plaza

19 Aug 2025 · 1 h 10 min · 32 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode is a celebrity interview centered on Aubrey Plaza’s life and career, with a major focus on her Parks and Recreation experience and her new film Honey Don’t. Key claims and notable examples include: Plaza describes chronic grief after losing her husband, comparing it to an “ocean of awfulness” with “monster people” always present, referencing the horror movie The Gorge. She explains her childhood in Wilmington, Delaware, including performing at the Wilmington Drama League, getting her period on stage during The Crucible, and later getting the “ugly stepsister” role in Cinderella, which she says taught her comedy is where the power is. She recounts arriving in New York in 2002 to study at UCB, then faxing her resume to SNL departments and getting an SNL page internship; she says she was encouraged to leave after making up tour facts (e.g., a cold studio explained by penguins from 1956). She and Margaret Qualley discuss their Honey Don’t dynamic (suave detective vs cool cop), and Plaza’s Parks arc: April’s “secret” is she cares deeply while pretending she doesn’t.

Guests

Aubrey Plaza (host/subject) and Margaret Qualley (guest).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Margaret Qualley Introduces Aubrey

0:00 to 0:55

Margaret Qualley shares her admiration for Aubrey Plaza and their dynamic.

“Chronic migraine, 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more, can make me feel like a spectator in my own life.”

Margaret Qualley Introduces Aubrey

2:17 to 4:14

Margaret Qualley shares her admiration for Aubrey Plaza and their dynamic.

“Just add ice, concentrate, and top it off with your favorite mixer like water, lemonade, or even coconut milk.”

Discussing 'Honey Don't' and Their Dynamic

4:14 to 8:07

The hosts discuss the film 'Honey Don't' and the characters played by Aubrey and Margaret.

“So, like, dogs come and greet you at the door, but cats just kind of chill and wait for you to come to them.”

Aubrey Plaza's Unique Character Traits

8:07 to 11:45

Conversation about Aubrey's portrayal of characters and her deeper qualities.

“But the secret to that character and Aubrey is that she cares very deeply.”

Grief and Personal Struggles

11:45 to 13:46

Aubrey opens up about her personal struggles and the concept of grief.

“So you've had this terrible, terrible, tragic year.”

Light Moments and Reflections

13:46 to 14:00

Aubrey and the hosts share light-hearted moments and reflections on various topics.

Beauty and Horses Discussion

14:00 to 14:33

The conversation begins with a humorous take on beauty and horses.

“the more beautiful you are, the more spaced out your eyes are.”

Aubrey's Childhood Reflections

14:33 to 15:40

Aubrey Plaza discusses her shy childhood and early experiences with imagination.

“Because I feel, I feel like I, I, I, I think horses are beautiful and they're a little bit scary to me and I'm like, I respect them.”

Growing Up in Delaware

15:40 to 17:21

Aubrey shares anecdotes about her upbringing in Wilmington, Delaware.

“I was definitely around a lot of people.”

Meeting Joe Biden

17:21 to 18:29

Aubrey recounts a memorable encounter with Joe Biden during a White House visit.

“There was, we were getting a tour of his office and of the White House, right?”
Show all 32 chapters

Experiences in Theater

18:29 to 19:54

Aubrey shares her experiences performing in theater during her childhood.

“It's like a hotel room used for a million years.”

Transition to Comedy

19:54 to 21:44

Aubrey discusses how a role as the ugly stepsister in Cinderella sparked her interest in comedy.

“Like you're like, you're like, I'm fully realized.”

Life in New York City

21:44 to 23:21

The conversation turns to Aubrey's life and experiences upon moving to New York City.

“I was like, and you were like studying in, didn't taking classes at the same time you were doing both.”

Getting an Internship at SNL

23:21 to 26:16

Aubrey explains how she secured an internship at Saturday Night Live through a faxed resume.

“Where do you live when you're in the dorms?”

Behind the Scenes at SNL

26:16 to 28:07

Aubrey provides insights into the workings of SNL's design department and her tasks there.

“And then on a Friday night on the week of the 2005 season, I got a call from the design department.”

Behind the Scenes of Comedy Tours

28:07 to 30:18

Aubrey recalls her experiences working behind the scenes, including giving tours and the unique facts she made up about the studio.

“And so there's really only Wednesday to Saturday and then they have to like figure out all the sets in between.”

Getting Hired at Parks and Rec

30:18 to 34:25

Aubrey shares her journey of landing a role on Parks and Rec during a chaotic week of auditions and meetings.

“Okay, then you get your, like, doing comedy, doing shows, and we meet not on SNL, even though we're in the same building, but we meet on the set of Parks and Rec.”

Character Development and Growth

34:25 to 36:58

The hosts discuss the evolution of Aubrey's character, April, and the journey of growth throughout the show.

Chemistry Between Characters

36:58 to 39:28

Aubrey and Amy talk about the organic chemistry between April and Andy, leading to unexpected romantic developments.

“Like he had such a like little kid energy and he was so, he just was like very willing to like, let's just try things.”

Memorable Wedding Scene

39:28 to 42:00

The hosts reflect on the emotional impact and memorable moments during the wedding scene for April and Andy.

“We were like under that main table for a while.”

Emotional Scenes and Vows

42:00 to 43:23

The guests share their experiences of emotional scenes during filming.

“Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis.”

Discussion on Parks and Rec

45:13 to 46:55

The hosts discuss rewatching Parks and Rec and share funny anecdotes.

“I mean, I guess like when do you watch, have you rewatched Parks and Rec?”

Guest Stars and Fun Memories

46:56 to 49:17

Aubrey shares her experiences with guest stars on the set of Parks and Rec.

“I remember like that episode with April and Ron, that very first thing.”

Chris Bosh Prank Story

49:18 to 52:44

Aubrey recounts a humorous prank involving basketball player Chris Bosh.

“That was always like lurking in the shadows.”

Love for Basketball

52:45 to 54:28

Aubrey discusses her passion for basketball and her background in the sport.

“you're a big Liberty fan and many other teams.”

Aubrey's Acting Career Overview

54:29 to 55:41

The hosts explore Aubrey's extensive acting career and her notable roles.

“You've been in, like, incredible Black Bear.”

Witch Themes in Aubrey's Work

55:42 to 56:01

Aubrey discusses her connection to witch themes in her roles and writings.

“I mean, a lot of people think that you were playing yourself in Parks and Rec, but is it true that you were actually playing yourself in Agatha?”

Exploring Witchcraft in Aubrey's Life

56:01 to 1:03:20

Aubrey discusses her connection to witches and her new book.

“That was the closest, the most blurred the lines have ever gotten for me.”

Aubrey's Directing Aspirations

1:03:21 to 1:05:18

Aubrey shares her experiences with directing and her future aspirations.

“Or, like, you know, the honey don't thing to me, honestly, was, like, mind-blowing that a Coen brother wanted to work with me.”

Comfort Movies and Laughter

1:05:19 to 1:10:04

Discussion about favorite comfort movies and what makes them laugh.

“But now it feels weird that it goes away.”

Remembering Jeff Bain and Aubrey Plaza's Films

1:10:04 to 1:10:53

Explore the impactful films made by Aubrey Plaza and her husband.

“And today's Polar Plunge, I just want to talk and just remind people of the beautiful films that Aubrey Plaza and her late husband, Jeff Bain, made together.”

Important Resource for Mental Health

1:12:20 to 1:12:46

Learn about the National Suicide and Crisis Prevention Lifeline.

“Checking Allstate first could save you hundreds on car insurance.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Chronic migraine, 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more, can make me feel like a spectator in my own life. Botox, onabotulinum toxin A, prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It's the number one prescribed branded chronic migraine preventive treatment. Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Allerge your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition.

0:30Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue, and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS Lou Gehrig's disease, myasthenia gravis or Lambert-Eaton syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. Why wait? Ask your doctor, visit BotoxChronicMigraine.com, or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.

1:04Hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of Good Hang. Thank you for being here. We had, well, look, we're keeping the Parks and Rec hits coming because we had Adam Scott last week. And we have the great, beautiful and wonderful Aubrey Plaza joining us. Aubrey, who many of you have wanted to hear from, is here and we couldn't be more excited. And we talk about a lot of things today. We talk about how we first met on a playground. We talk about her time as an NBC page and why she got fired. We talk about her love of basketball. And we talk about her new movie, honey don't which is in theaters this week uh and so there's just so much good stuff and we're very glad that she was here and that you're here listening and we always start our episodes the same way we try to find someone that knows our guests know something about them and has a question for them and we are talking to a great actress today you know her from the substance and made and many other great films and her beautiful dancing and it is the beautiful and talented Margaret Qualley.

2:10Margaret, hello. This episode is brought to you by Starbucks. With Starbucks Refreshers Concentrate, you can personalize every pour and make it your own right at home. Just add ice, concentrate, and top it off with your favorite mixer like water, lemonade, or even coconut milk. For an easy to make, refreshing way to uplift any part of your day with three delicious flavors, strawberry acai, mango dragon fruit, and lime watermelon. Picking a favorite might be the hardest part. Starbucks refreshers concentrate. Find it in the coffee aisle and make it yours at home.

2:49Where are we talking to you from? I'm home. I'm home and I'm in a hallway. Okay, perfect. Yeah. It's really good to see you. And I know you're doing press. I love your podcast, by the way. I've been listening to it. It's so good. Thanks, Margaret. Today is a very special day because we have really our most requested guest coming on today. Like it's, you know, people have really, really wanted to hear from and hear me and Aubrey talk about a lot of things. And I'm just so psyched she's here. might be the most like unanimously loved person ever like yeah even like my dad's really not like you know he he's like barely has a phone he doesn't have a tv but like when i when he found out i was doing a movie with aubrey he was like oh i fucking love her like man she's so funny like Like, he's so, he was so excited.

3:58Like, she reached my dad. She's got the dads. But she's got everybody. Yeah. I just, I just love her. I just think she's the best. You know, it's so funny you say that, too, because I was thinking, she's also, kids really like Aubrey because she acts like a cat, right? So, like, dogs come and greet you at the door, but cats just kind of chill and wait for you to come to them. and kids really like that. She never, you know, I remember my boys on the set of Parks and she would just like walk by and say something to them like on the way past them and they'd be like, who was that? I'd also imagine that she'd like talk to a kid like an adult.

4:39Yes. You know, like just meet them where they are. Like it's rough out there, right? Totally. Yeah. Yeah. She's really, as the people like to say, she appeals to four quadrants. Yeah. And you guys have worked together. Is Honey Don't, which is the film that you both are in, that you're the star of, congratulations, coming out very soon. It looks so great. And is this the first time you've worked together, the two of you? Yeah, we met on set. I've been such a big fan of hers for such a long time. And I think Parks and Rec was probably my intro to her, which is just like one of the best shows of all time.

5:19And you guys together are so special. But I've I've like felt like I think she has that quality where you feel like, you know, or even when you don't. So, like, I already loved her so much even before meeting her. And I would have been so bummed if she didn't like me.

5:39I'm projecting on this on you, so I don't tell me if I get I'm getting it wrong. But you both to me seem like, you know, in some ways, introverted artists in an extroverted business. Like, do you relate to that? Definitely. Yeah. I mean, it's like, you know, the classic case of, look at me, don't look at me. It's totally. Yeah. Right. Everybody pay attention. Like, what are you looking at? I want to show you something. Stop. What? What? Don't go home. Be alone. So what was it like working together on set? But for those that don't know, you guys are, what is your dynamic in the film? And then what was it like working together?

6:25Dynamic in the film is I play this like suave detective and she plays this like cool cop. And we kind of hit it off right away. And it kind of feels like we've like met our match. Like I usually as a character feel like I'm in the power seat. And when I come across Aubrey's character, that's really challenged. And I think she actually is in the power seat. And on set, it's a really fun set. It's Ethan Coen and Trisha Cook's movie. And they're just great. And like, they're at once, you know, super accomplished and like these like great artists, but really don't take themselves seriously. So it's like a, it's a silly laid back, goofy, fun vibe there.

7:22But, you know, Aubrey, I think, I think in order for somebody to come across, there's like, there's a lot to be so effortless, take some effort, you know, and she's like, she's, she cares, like in the best way. She's thoughtful and considerate and brought so much depth to her character. And it was, you know, just like kind of consistently surprising everyone with just, you know, the thing that she does. I think you bring up a really good point, which is, you know, she started out anyway, especially on Parks and Rec, playing like a very disaffected character. But the secret to that character and Aubrey is that she cares very deeply.

8:16Yeah. And I think people like project on her that she's indifferent. And she's definitely not. No. No. I was wondering if you had a question you thought I should ask Aubrey on this day that you'd be curious to know about or like you want any topic you think we should cover. I don't know why the first thing that came to my mind was the Salem witch trials. Was she was she in them? Is that the question? Probably, you know.

8:51Well, yeah. What was it like being in the Salem witch trials?

8:58Margaret, we love you. I would love to get you in the stude. Anytime. Okay. I'd be lucky. Oh, buddy. And, you know, I know Plaza will be so happy that you did this and surprised and happy that you did it. And also I know that you and many people in her life have been real big supports and a real circle of love during very tough times. So on behalf of her, I'm going to say thank you. And it's so good to talk to you. The easiest to love. Indeed. Thank you for having me. Great to see you, cutie pie. Woo-hoo-hoo! This episode is brought to you by Volkswagen. Nice things shouldn't be reserved for people who use summer as a verb.

9:39They should be for everyone. You, me, the guy at your wedding who thought flannel was black tie appropriate. Enter the 2025 Volkswagen Tiguan. It's elevated, stylish, luxurious, and actually within reach. did I mention massaging front seats and real wood accents? Visit your local VW dealer or vw.com to learn more about the 2025 Volkswagen Tiguan. Aubrey Plaza's here and she has her sunglasses on. I'll take them off if you want. Well, I do because they... I know, but... We'll put them on again. Let me see. I mean, they look very cool. Jackie, what are you doing? That's so creepy. Plossey's here and her sweet dog Frankie is here too.

10:26When you wear the glasses, you do look very Howard Stern. It's because my hair too. Yeah. Right now, it's like...

10:35I mean, it makes you look cool, but as an interviewer, I don't love it. Oh, God. Sorry. Your doggy Frankie is here with you too. Yes. Tell us about Frankie. Okay. Have we started? Yeah, we started. Oh. and just like that Frankie is my dog her name is Francis Fox she's named after Judy Garland that's Judy Garland's real name she's a good dog she got a little sick this morning that's why I brought her I'm not like a bring my dog to work kind of person so much do you ever bring her on set for anything? no But she's really like with you a lot. She is now. Yeah. This is a recent, this year recent kind of thing.

11:26Yeah. She's like, she's like, she's like a therapy dog. Oh, yes. In many ways. And has always been for you, but it's really been. Yeah. She is. She's always been like that. Well, I mean, to just to get it out of the way, people want to see you. I want to see how you are. They love you. I know. They love you and they want to see you. So you've had this terrible, terrible, tragic year. Yeah. You lost your husband. You've been dealing with that. And you've been looking for all different ways in which to feel and find support. And I think I would, on behalf of all the people who feel like they know you and the people who do know you, how are you feeling today?

12:07um i'm i mean right in this very very present moment i feel happy to be with you um i feel overall i i'm here and i'm functioning and i feel you know like i feel really grateful to be moving through the world i think like I'm okay but you know it's like a a daily struggle obviously this is like a really dumb analogy but and it was kind of a joke at a certain point but like I actually mean it did you see that movie The Gorge no okay horror movie it's like a alien movie or something with like Miles teller teller and um but it's like in the movie there there's like a cliff on one side and then there's like a cliff on the other side and then there's like gorge in between and it's like filled with all these like monster people that are trying to get them and like i swear when i watched it i was like that is like feels like what my grief is like where it's like or what grief could be like where it's like at all times there's like a giant like ocean of just awfulness that's like right there and I can like see it and like sometimes I just want to like just dive into it and just like be in it and then and then sometimes I just like look at it and then sometimes I'm like I just try to get away from it but it's always there it's just always there and the monster people are trying to get me like Miles Teller.

13:48Yeah. And Anya Taylor-Joy. Yeah. Who, Anya Taylor-Joy, to me, is the example of, like, the more beautiful you are, the more spaced out your eyes are. Yes. And Rihanna, who, and that's how she says it, guys. What? Rihanna. Yeah. No. Yes. Check out the clips. No. Not saying it ever. Well, Rihanna is so beautiful and her eyes are truly on the side of her head. Yeah. Just like a horse. Yes. That's why horses are so beautiful. Well, I feel, here's how I feel about horses. I feel like horses are fine. You hate them. I don't hate them. I don't hate them. Let's talk about animals. I would love to talk about animals.

14:35No. No? Because I feel, I feel like I, I, I, I think horses are beautiful and they're a little bit scary to me and I'm like, I respect them. but I don't really want to be near them. And that's not how you feel about Rihanna. No, I'd love to truly, like, be in a stall with Rihanna and feed her a sugar cube if she let me. I want to talk to you about many things today. Okay. Okay. But the first person I want to talk to is Little Baby Plaza. No. Why? Okay. No, I don't need you to act like a baby. Oh, okay. I just mean I want to talk. We're going to do role play. We're going to do real intense role play.

15:20I'm going to have a bunch of hats. No. Okay. No, but because I love Little Young Plaza, and I feel like a lot of people don't— I think a lot of people are like Little Young Plaza out there, and they see themselves in you. But can you explain what kind of kid you were? Oh, okay.

15:41I was I mean I think before I would say like before seven I think I was like pretty shy like I was kind of like a quiet like lanky kind of I don't know freakish kind of kid maybe really thin hair like my ponytail was like look like this just like one little strand basically. I would try to have ponytails. Your hair looks really good right now. It's got thicker. You don't have any pieces in? No. Shit. It's gotten really thick. Tina Fey, watch out, bitch. Watch out, bitch. Watch out. I'm coming for you. She's going to brush that hair. Like a real brush. Tina Fey. Nobody's going to beat Tina's hair.

16:26Nobody. Watch me. Sorry, babe. Watch me. My money's on Tina. I've seen that hair. It's incredible. Watch me. I was definitely around a lot of people. Like, hectic kind of, you know, childhood, I think. So, like, I was definitely an observer, but, like, definitely living in my imagination. Like, I could just imagine things all day long. Where did you grow up? Grew up in Delaware, Wilmington, Delaware. Yeah. Ever heard of it? Nope. Never been. Never heard of it. Joe Biden. The land of Joe Biden. Joe Biden. Who we met. Yeah. Who we met. Well, you've met many times. Oh, yeah. But, you know, for people, fast forward to when we were in parks, we got to go when President Biden was in, Vice President Biden, we got to go to a scene with him.

17:14I'll never forget it. And it was pretty exciting. It was amazing. It was amazing. It was super, super fun. And I've told this story before, but Aubrey stole something from his desk. Yeah. I did. I stole. There was, we were getting a tour of his office and of the White House, right? Yeah. And I saw a little like vice president monogrammed notebook piece of paper that said like Aubrey Plaza and then like three facts about me like Wilmington, Delaware, Ursuline Academy. We met. We met. Blah, blah, blah. Because that's what the politicians all do. They get their little. Sure. And then you're like, oh, my God, how did you remember?

17:50You know, and I swiped it. And Mike Scherr was like, you cannot steal. Do you think? And I was like, oh, shut up, Mike. And he was like, we're literally in the White House. And I was like, we are. We're literally in the White House. And you didn't get in trouble. No one ever knew. No one knew. No one knew. I am kind of surprised that there's no, like, alarm system in there. There's nothing in there. It's like a house of cards. It is weird how janky the White House actually is. It's janky as fuck. It is janky as fuck. I didn't see any cameras. And it is like, it's like SNL. Like, you go in there, you're like, this is the White House?

18:25I know. Like, this place sucks. You're like, that pillow is disgusting. It's like a hotel room used for a million years. I know. It is bad. It's weird. But, you know, now it's going to be big and beautiful. It has to be gorgeous now. Okay, so then you're in Delaware. What kind of shows did you do as a little kid? Like, what were your, like, parts that you got to sink into? Baby Plaza Theater was the Wilmington Drama League. I went there. My older cousin was doing the Crucible. and I remember just watching and being like oh my god this is so cool and then I auditioned I think the first thing oh yeah the first thing I got was Hansel and Gretel um you played chorus tree okay tree number four maybe no small trees yeah actually yeah I was um actually um fun fact I got my period uh on stage at the drama league um you used that you just used it yeah I'm going to use this.

19:25I went, I started bleeding and then my cousin took me in the bathroom. I was like, what's happening? And she was like, I'm bleeding. And then I was like, get on out there. The show must go on. And then I did. And you were like, and you felt totally different. You're like, my tea is a woman now. Yeah. Yeah. It was awesome. That's exciting. I was mainly in the chorus a lot. Yeah. I always wanted to be, you know, like Annie or whatever. but the big part that I got that kind of changed things for me was I got the ugly stepsister in Cinderella and I really wanted to be Cinderella like everybody and then they were like ugly stepsister and I was like damn it because I know that's the better part it was the better part and it taught me like I brought down the house with my song and it taught me like comedy is where it's at I was like I'm getting all the laughs I was like Cinderella sucks I bet you have the same memory that I have is like when you get your first laugh that you mean to get, like people laugh at you, but when you get a laugh that you mean to get, it's like becoming a vampire.

20:28Yeah. Like you're like, you're like, I'm fully realized. Yeah. I have all the power. Yeah. I can do anything. It's the best feeling. Yeah. Okay. Then you graduate. You go to NYU. Then I graduated. Then I went to NYU. So do you remember like, like arriving in New York City and what that was like? It was crazy. Yeah. I was like, I mean, I was so ready to go to New York, mainly because of UCB. Which is people listening as a sketch, an improv theater that myself and Matt Besser, Ian Roberts, Matt Walsh started in 90. We moved to the city in 96. So you were arriving when? I came to the city in 2002.

21:11But like growing up, I knew about UCB before. you know I went to New York and like how did you know about it just curious like Neil Casey I mean we Neil is was one of my best friends growing up is still one of my best friends um he was a bit older than me and he was really into comedy he showed me like Mr. Show and Kids in the Hall and like we got really into and obviously Saturday Night Live was like really big for me growing up too so like we just yeah we were like super big comedy nerds and part of the reason I wanted to go to NYU and go to New York is to take classes at UCB. So that was like, I was like ready.

21:47I was like, and you were like studying in, didn't taking classes at the same time you were doing both. Yeah. I started doing it like immediately. What were you majoring in at NYU? I don't think I majored in film, um, like directing and writing more than almost anyone I know love studying, watching and talking about movies. You love movies. I love movies. All I needs movies i need anything else or anyone else but movies um what do you do with your phone when you're watching a movie are you able to fully you are i am i am and i'm not just saying that i think i am i'm also really not good at technology i'm like i'm a real boomer like person when it comes to that although i will say you talk when it comes technology i have a memory that you you've taught me many lessons but I remember one time I was texting on the set of parks to someone who was bothering me or like asking something from me I forget what what the situation was and I was like composing this really long text and you grab my phone and you just type no you sent it really you don't remember no I don't remember and it was um it was very uh illuminating because it was just It's basically like it really underneath it was like, first of all, don't be like beholden to your phone.

23:02Like, yeah, life is happening around you. And also you don't owe anybody any long explanation. Wow. I know. That's so. Remember that? No, I feel like that's something you would do to me. I feel like you taught me how to say no. Well, maybe I taught it and then forgot it. Damn. You did it back to me. Wow. Like like karate kid style. Mm hmm. OK, so then you go to New York. Where do you live when you're in the dorms? I go to New York. My parents dropped me off on 3rd Avenue and 11th Street. Oh, my God. I used to live right around there near Webster Hall. Yeah. I lived in the 3rd North dorms. And then I ended up moving.

23:38I got out of the dorms earlier than you're technically allowed to because there was a mice issue. And so— They have too many mice in the—and they were like, you have to leave? Like, the mice took over? The mice took over to the point where I will never forget I was on the top bunk. And I was being very quiet because I was like reading a book or something and like nobody else was in. You were as quiet as a mouse. I was as quiet as a mouse. And I literally was just like reading for like, I don't know, maybe 20 minutes or something. And all of a sudden there was a Thanksgiving Day parade of mice.

24:15They were like having trumpets. They were like. And they all just started parading back and forth, like selling things. Oh my God. And it was like a flea market. they came out and they were like it was insane like I was like and I was like I couldn't on your floor on the ground like oh lord like in our clothes like in our it was like a messy room too so it was like they were just like like they had like were wearing my clothes they were like running around dancing like they were like those Richard Scary books remember those things where it was like like they were like building they were like in little cars yes it was insane and And I was like screaming.

24:52I was like, this is fucking disgusting. And NYU was like, you got to get out. Yeah. They were like, be quiet and get out. So I got out. And then I moved right down the block to 2nd and 11th. I got in with these like older musical theater girls that like took me in. And then I lived there for a couple of years. And then you studied at UCB. And then a lot of people don't know that you. Well, I mean, I think some people know because you talked about it on SNL. But then you found—you got an internship at S &O. Oh, yes. How did you get that? And what was it? So I faxed my resume. Amazing. Remember that?

25:32That's amazing. Where are you looking? I don't know. At the audience? I'm just looking over here. I'm looking at my fax. I imagined, like, that there were people there. I'm looking—I'm checking to see if I got any other faxes. Hello? Yeah, I faxed my resume to every department. because there was just like a number. There was like a paper on some wall at NYU that had like all the department numbers. It was like 2-1-2-6-6-7. Yes. 2-1-2-6-6-4. Like or 6-6-4 or whatever. It was 6-6-4. Remember 2-1-2? Oh, yeah. I still have a 2-1-2 number. I'm so jealous. I still have a landline. That's nice. Yeah.

26:15But yeah, I faxed my resume to every department. And I didn't get anything. And then on a Friday night on the week of the 2005 season, I got a call from the design department. And they were like, we got your resume. Like, we need someone. Like, can you come interview? And it was Regina DiCicco, if you remember Regina. Sure, of course. And I was like, yeah, I was like, I'm available. It was like Friday at like, I want to say like 4 p.m. or 5 p.m. or something. she's like she's like how about right now and I was like okay and so then I like went up to 30 Rock like immediately saw Ben Affleck sure just there was like I guess he was hosting that episode and it's like I remember how crazy it was just walking in the for the first time because I was just interviewing so I was like I didn't know what was going on but it was a Friday night so I guess they They were blocking or rehearsing.

27:14And they had fired. The design department only ever had one intern. Couldn't cut it. Mainly because he wanted to be in design. And they were like, you. No. Yeah, you can't. No. He was like, so the blueprints of the. And they were like, get the fuck out of here. Literally. They were like, fuck off. And he was like. And then I came in and they were like, do you care about design? And I was like, no. And they were like, can you start now? And I was like, yeah. What is the design part of SNL for people they don't know? Like what does the design do? Because it's a big, it's a very important part of the show.

27:52There's, you have to imagine the sets have to be built somehow. Yeah. And very fast. Yeah. Because basically, as you know, on Tuesday night's the writing night and then Wednesday night is when all the sketches get chosen. Yeah. And so there's really only Wednesday to Saturday and then they have to like figure out all the sets in between. I remember what I had to do was like once the I was there all Wednesday night, like until three in the morning or whatever. And then once the sketches were picked, I would they would like send they would be like go in the filing cat literally in the filing cabinet and find restaurant number 72 or something.

28:30And then I would like sift through and find these like blueprints, I guess, for whatever. And then I would just watch them and they would like draw stuff and that's it. And then the other job I had was to take continuity photos. And that was cool because you guys would be rehearsing and I'd be like – and everyone thought I worked there. I had a camera around whatever and I just was like very quiet and just kind of like taking pictures of the sets, of the plants, of the things. I mean it blows my mind, Plassey, that we were sharing. I mean – You were there. I stalked you. I think now about the people that are crossing our lives right now that are like in our proximity that we don't know yet.

Read the full transcript

29:08Yeah. Like it's really cool that we were in the same physical space. I know. We didn't know each other. It's so crazy. It still blows my mind. And then you were giving tours and— I was giving tours, yeah. And a lot of people know that you just gave—you just made stuff up while you gave tours. I did, yeah. I got fired. I didn't get fired, but I got pretty much encouraged to leave pretty quickly. Yeah. What were some things you would make up? Do you remember? I mean, no, I don't know, like, specific thing. I feel like there was one thing. This is when I was a page. Like, there was one speech I had to give about, like, I guess it was, like, Conan's studio or something.

29:48That studio. And it was, like, very cold. And it was, there was just, like, weird facts where they'd be like, does anyone, you know, know why it's so cold in the studio? And people would be like, why is it so cold? Because of the lights? And I'd be like, no, because in 1956, they had penguins on the show and the penguins needed to be cold so they wouldn't die. And they forgot to turn the heat down after that. So it's been cold since like 1956. And people would be like, well, that's interesting. Okay, then you get your, like, doing comedy, doing shows, and we meet not on SNL, even though we're in the same building, but we meet on the set of Parks and Rec.

30:33And for people that don't know, like, you had a crazy week when you got hired. You got, like, three jobs that same week. What happened that week you were hired on Parks? so I basically I was like trying to get a part in funny people the Judd Apatow movie with Seth Rogan and Adam Sandler and I went through kind of this whole vetting process in New York and then enough where Allison Jones who cast that movie and Parks and Rec was called me and was like all right like you made it to the chemistry read stage so you have to come out to LA and read with Seth and see if you get the part, basically. And so, but I didn't really have an agent or anything.

31:16And I kind of had to like pay my way, you know, to go out there. So it was like a little bit janky, but I got myself out there to do that. And then while I was out in LA for that week to do the funny people thing, Allison was like, how would I send you on some other things? Like, how do you feel about that? And so, yeah. So one of them was she wanted me to go meet Mike Schur and Greg Daniels, who at the time were shooting on The Office. And they were shooting, they were on the set of The Office. So she sent me to the set of The Office. And I didn't even, I guess at that time I didn't realize, like, I didn't think, like, oh, I could, these meetings will get me a job.

31:58I didn't understand. I mean, I think it's one of the things about being young that's kind of nice is you're not really aware what you're actually, like, what's at stake. No. And that's good. Definitely not that. I mean, if it was an audition, obviously, I know, like, all right, I'm going to get the part or not. But like general meetings, I didn't really get the vibe of that. How old were you then? I was 24, 23, 23 maybe. But so then I went to the set of The Office and I was so starstruck. I see in my horse eye BJ Novak and Mindy Kaling walked by and I was like, oh my God. I was like, they're in the show or whatever.

32:33And Mike Schur is like, hello. and he's like at his desk like and I'm like what? and then I just met him for like he describes it he really embellishes this story I think he loves this story he loves it but he's like and then I met the weirdest person later there's no bigger fan of Aubrey Plaza than Mike Scher yeah right he loves it though because I think like I mean it just speaks to honestly the fact that you've always been yourself, confidently yourself, and you don't have a vibe of like, you don't, you are the opposite of a pick me, as the kids would say. Like, you do not have that vibe. And that draws people in.

33:18And I think he was like, who is this person? Yeah. Who seems mad at me? Yeah. I try to give her a job. Yeah. Literally. And why are you wearing jean shorts in a general meeting? Like ripped jean shorts. And you're like, I didn't know what this was. No. And then I got a phone phone call and they were like you're on a tv show i'm like what no but then which one i know what you're like the office yeah i literally probably said that i didn't know what was going on and then they were like um actually you got the part but actually you have to audition to play yourself you don't have to name names but i wonder who else was up to play you i don't think that anyone oh right it was just one person i think they just made me do it like for the network or something i I think I found out later.

34:03I mean, maybe not. I don't know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's probably like, you know. Yeah. It was you, Sharon Stone, and Gina Gershon. Yeah. So you get the part. We're on the set. And then, like, I mean, we could do a whole—obviously, we could do a whole episode about our experiences there. And there are so—like, I mean, I don't—the best thing about our relationship, I feel like, is I don't—like, a lot of, I think, long-lasting relationships is you don't always, like, remember. how you met like I just remember like just I just have this vision of you being next to me on the set of that show and me being like welcome like you know Leslie was supposed to be like welcoming April and April was supposed to be like what am I doing here and Amy was welcoming Aubrey and Aubrey was like what am I doing here truly yeah yeah I mean I I remember when we first met and it i think i told you this story it was um the promos that we shot that's right and which was weird because we hadn't shot the show yet and the rest of the cast hadn't even been cast yet i think at that point it was just like aziz me you yeah maybe another rashida yeah i don't think we had nick yet or i don't think so but they had me and i was there like physically there so they shot this promo of us on a swing set and that's when I met you like officially for the first time and I think I was literally on a swing like a child like and I was like and I was like just don't make any sudden movements um except swinging except swinging and then you which is kind of good because swinging is really good somatically yeah yeah for me like I liked um but then yeah you came over and we were both just swinging like little babies that's how we met on a swing we met on a playground which is kind of nice really nice and it feels like the show was that like it was it felt like a true like playground space it really was like we I mean I loved and love working with you I love playing with you I love acting with you I love you as an actor I love you as a person I love your acting plazzy you know how good I think you are I love playing with you and I feel like our dynamic well like the arc of of um in many ways like April had the biggest growth in the show she goes from truly not wanting to be where she is to like you know ending the show like with some kind of purpose and a love in her life and like some also like a she kind of stands up for what she doesn't want to do which is a big part of your 20s like but um when you started that character when you started her did you have any idea where you thought it would go and did you have any you know did you did you see no yeah no I just no I think I just once I realized like oh what's so fun about this character is that like it's a game of not showing anyone that I really care yes and like once I've locked into that it was real like it felt like there was no limit to like the growth or like what could happen because if you hint that there's something else going on it's like you can kind of play with that and also in different ways with every different character so I feel like maybe on an unconscious level but I felt like oh there's so much to play with even though it feels really subtle and simple yeah that was her secret is she cared but she pretended she didn't and so when it would pop out it was so satisfying yeah it was so funny and good and the ways in which she tried to keep those things hidden were so funny yeah and then I think just the Andy April thing was such an organic like I had no idea that was gonna become a thing until that one episode so let's talk about that so Andy uh played uh played by Chris Pratt um and you um April and Andy had an episode where a bunch of us were off like doing the like a harvest we're at the harvest festival we're at some festival where you guys were we were doing something together yeah or you were like camping or something oh yeah maybe oh yeah we're like cabin episode yeah and so they put you guys in the office and just said like let's see what happens to these two characters when they hang out yeah and basically the chemistry that those characters had was the building block for why they eventually became like the the real romantic love story of the show other than leslie and ann yeah because ann doesn't deserve don't talk about him sorry but what do you remember of that day i have a bit well greg daniels directed the episode which i I will always remember because he was so delighted.

39:03Like he had such a like little kid energy and he was so, he just was like very willing to like, let's just try things. And we had a whole day where we were just playing. It was like, kind of like what you said, like the office, like the bull room or bullpen. Yeah. The bullpen, the bull room, the bullpen like became a playground. And I, I just remember I have an image of like us sitting under the table. We were like under that main table for a while. Like, I don't even know what we were doing down there. But we were under there. And I just remember, I don't know, it just felt, it was so fun. It just felt like, I remember before then there was, I think it was like the finale of maybe the first season.

39:46I don't remember what season. But there was a very subtle moment where we're all in a group. We're in a circle. and um and he's like saying something about his band or he's like something about like i think like this band name is cool or whatever and everyone else is like no and april and i was just like i like it and it was like an improvised thing but i do you remember that where i remember being like and then i remember like knocking on mike schur's like door and being like listen I was like April loves Andy and April thinks Andy's cool because he's so not cool that he's cool do you understand and Mike was like get out of here and I was like you better listen to me wow you did you knocked on his door it was more like just a little conversation that was it was like a it was like a layer to that character because you become his advocate like and that's the part of April that like is like another interesting layer is like again she acts like nothing matters and she's um you know completely disaffected but she's actually very fiercely loyal yeah and very um and like sticks up for people she believes in which I think is a character character trait of you too plazzy like you're very you're a very loyal friend yeah you're a really really protective friend um and you really stick up for people who you love and that side of it was so great because then we got to see her like manage him care about the band see potential for him that he didn't see in himself and he was just like I can't believe how lucky I am and I remember when the writers had you guys get married we were all like what like I know That was insane.

41:32That was, what do you remember of that day shooting it? We, there was a lot of crying. You cried. I mean, I love a wedding. You cried. I remember you like cried in the kitchen and then you were like crying like off camera and I was like, stop. I didn't cry that much. Yes, you did. You like literally cried all day. It was so weird. I was so happy you were in love. You were like crying all day. There was like, I was like. I was not crying all day. I was like, we're not even, the camera, I was like, we're in my trailer. Like, why are you doing this? and you were like how do you feel I'm like oh my god no I didn't I'm ordering a salad for lunch like this is my job I was crying because you were crying so hard and I was worried that we weren't going to get the shot I was crying because I was sad at how much you were crying I don't think so I think that you thought it was real and yeah I assumed it was legally binding yeah but it was so good and the and the vows were so funny yeah and the wedding was so stupid it was so stupid

42:53Thank you. Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremphaya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit Tremfieradio.com.

43:53meningitis vaccinations. Learn more at meningitis.com. Vaccination may not protect all recipients. Sponsored by GSK. This episode is brought to you by eBay Live. First, you're just watching eBay Live. Then a Fendi baguette goes for an absolute steal. A 90s NASCAR jacket comes up and you have to bid. That winning feeling, it's such a rush because you know everyone else wanted it too. Meanwhile, on eBay Live, you don't just watch the action, you're in it. Download the eBay app to stream and shop live. eBay Live, things people love. This episode is brought to you by K18. You know, hair isn't just hair.

44:35It's confidence, identity. So if you're noticing more hair in the shower drain or those first grays, you need K18 Future IQ Biomimetic Hair Longevity Serum. It delivers up to 19 ,000 more hairs, helps prevent premature graze, and improves the scalp barrier to start reversing hair age in three months. K18 is hair science that sees you. Shop Future IQ at Sephora or get 10 % off your first purchase at k18hair.com with code Amy.

45:12Okay. I mean, I guess like when do you watch, have you rewatched Parks and Rec? Nope. What? I'm finding this out. Okay. I wouldn't even know how. Shut up. Okay. Okay. You ask me how. You've never watched the big giant screen that you watch your movies on. How does it work? Go blue, blue, blue. These days, I wouldn't. And go to. Go to. Go to what? Type in where the search is. How? Someone tell me. Peacock. No. Yes. Yes. Go there. Or go to iTunes. I wish I knew how. Or go to, you know. Just pick up your controller and just save parts and rec into it. And it'll come up. Okay. It's probably not the right one.

46:04Go to your DVDs. You love your DVDs. I wish I had one right now. But so you've never rewatched it? No. I don't know what's wrong with you guys. If it comes on in a hotel room, I literally throw something. I throw it. Adam says watching the show makes him sad. Nick has told me he has not rewatched it. Liar. He jerks off to it every night. You know he sits there and like touches himself.

46:35You're so right. He's got it on right now. He's like, Nick, Nick. That's right, Tammy. You're right. He does watch it for Tammy. His real wife, Megan Mullally. They get off on that. They watch it together. You're so right. They watch it together. They're sick. And then they just slap each other in the face. They're disgusting. They're totally so disgusting. Nick, I know you're listening. You're not fooling anybody. I remember like that episode with April and Ron, that very first thing. I love that episode. When we got to play together, I remember like knocking on his door. and being like, I canceled all your meetings today or whatever.

47:09Yes. And it's just the silence, the silences between us. The thing that I love so much about Leslie and April's relationship is that Leslie had a plan for April that, and she kept kind of whispering to April, you know, like 2016, a version of like feminism, like you can do it all. You can do whatever you want. She was like, women belong in the kitchen. that game I love to play the trad wife thing she was always like so good I mean maybe April would be a trad wife we must respect our man and Leslie Knope would be like no April no she'd be like you must bend over for your man I feel like you did you improvise that?

47:53it feels like something you would have improvised two more things about Parks what we had so many fun guest stars come in and like you connected with some of them in interesting ways. Yeah. Who do you remember just like love, like just being like, oh, I just like loving the, because I feel like my job on set was to be like, welcome, you know, and you got to just come up later and be like, what do you think of this? Yeah. You definitely. I'd be like, it's kind of crazy around here. Want to see something insane or whatever. Yeah. Yeah, you were the cool, you were the cool kids. I mean, one of the ones I'll never forget is Patricia Clarkson.

48:33Yes. totally made out with her never made it on on the show still talk about it made out on the set not in the trailers oh sure yeah sure yeah sure although Patty would probably be fine with both that was incredible and April really fell for Tammy one yeah yeah she was Tammy one yeah yeah sure I mean one could argue that Ron's mom was the original Tammy oh right right right played by Paula Pell but yeah oh yeah that was a good one yeah Tammy but she was Tammy one and Malali was Tammy too. Who else did you love? I loved her. Fuck, my brain is so broken. I remember Sam Elliott. I'll throw some people out.

49:10You love Sam Elliott. Sam Elliott always pops up. I love Sam Elliott. You love the actor that played Oren on Parks and Rec. Oh my God, Oren. Remember Oren? I loved Oren. Love Oren. He was so funny and so weird. He was so funny. He was like a vampire boy. Yeah. That was always like lurking in the shadows. Eric Eisenhower. Eric. Played Oren. but Eric wasn't really the vampire boy I think in real life but he was very like method and I really appreciated that like even when we weren't shooting he'd be kind of like did you try the hummus or whatever and I'd be like yes Warren you know whatever who else you also helped us you helped us secure the mayor of Connie you really helped us get Bill Murray on the show Bill Murray.

49:59All you have to say to Bill Murray is, you're playing a cadaver. And he's like, I'm in. Do you remember when? I don't know if you remember this, but do you remember when Chris Bosh was on the show, the basketball player? Chris Bosh. He was a Miami Heat player. Oh, yes. And he was a— Remember we had different basketball, like Roy Hibbert? Yeah, we had Roy Hibbert. Yeah, Chris Bosh, yes. Yes, and he was with like Aziz and was he like— John Ralphio? Yeah, Entertainment 720. Yeah, but like I don't know if you know this story. It was a fairly quick story, but it was so stupid. But I was a really big Chris Bosh fan.

50:39So like I was like, oh my God, like I can't believe he's coming. Like this is insane. I was like, I want to play a prank on him. Do you know this? No. And so he had to go through hair and makeup, but, you know, he I think had very little hair and, you know, whatever. Yeah. Didn't need makeup because he's a guy or whatever. But you know how they always put them through the works anyway. Yeah. So I was like, I'm going to pretend to be the hairstylist. And I think it was Terry maybe was in there. And you know how she had those glasses or whatever. So I was like, Terry, give me your glasses. Or I can't remember, whatever.

51:11And I'm thinking like, this is going to be hilarious because it's going to be me. And he'll be like, ha ha ha, it's you. So I like pretend to be Terry. I'm like at her station. and then he goes through like makeup first and they're like you look good you know a little powder and you're good and then he like went and he was like yeah yeah thanks a lot and then he sat down in my chair and I was like well and I looked at him and I was like what are we gonna do today and I was like doing like a dumb thing and he didn't make any eye contact with me he was just looking down and he was so sweet but he didn't make eye contact he was just like yeah whatever you think oh no and you were like oh And I was like, well, I think that you're looking pretty good, sir.

51:55And he'd be like, yeah, so I'm good. All right. And I'd be like, well, you're not that good. And then I was like, I just kept it going. And someone videotaped it. Oh, my God. And it was so awkward. Didn't recognize me at all. Didn't know who I was. Don't think he ever knew who I was. No, I mean. Not once. Chris Bosh isn't going to be watching the show before he comes in. He didn't know. He's too busy. I was. He thought I was. He thought you were a hair person. And like the PAs are like, we really need him on set. I'm like, well, he's almost done in my department of hair. And then basically it just died.

52:29And he never, you never. Nope. Well, Chris is probably listening. Never not once. Never not once. Did you even work with him on set that day? Never saw him again. Literally never saw him again ever in my life. Oh my God. I mean, people should know you're a big basketball fan. Yeah. I mean, you're a big WNBA fan. Yeah, I love it. you're a big Liberty fan and many other teams. Yeah. What do you like about basketball? What do you like? You're good at basketball. Thank you. Welcome. I grew up playing basketball. I just love the game. My sister and I, we just were a ballin' kind of family. My dad was, like, coaching our teams, and I went to an all-girls high school in Delaware called Ursuline Academy, and we were really known for our basketball team.

53:16Like first, we would, you know, be the best in the state. Elena Deladon went to my school. She's like one of the best WNBA players ever. So I just kind of grew up loving the sport. And then, yeah, my sister Natalie really introduced me to the W. And it was kind of before the kind of Caitlin Clark effect, as they call it. She, well, we, but even before that, before that, we joined a women's basketball league in L.A. and there was a lot of Parks people like Allison Becker a lot of comedians was on one of the teams and there was a whole movement like around that time like 10 years ago in LA where like just women were playing basketball and like really playing and it was so fun and then kind of after that I tore my ACL on the court that's I mean and pretty ballery yeah it's happened twice did it again last year I know it's very cool thank you I know it's the biggest pain in the ass like it's a nightmare to Terry or ACL but like being iced on the court it looks cool yeah yeah well the first time it wasn't so cool because I was actually playing in I was wearing a wig and I was playing in disguise and truly you were pretending to be the hair department I was yeah I was pretending to be Terry yeah on the court okay so we got to talk about your other stuff there's so much stuff that you've done like I you know I don't even I don't even know where to start plaza you're such a good actor I you've done for people that perhaps don't know you have done a million gazillion movies you've been in White Lotus you've done Emily the Criminal one of my favorite performances of yours you've done you've worked with um what's his name you know the most famous um we work with Michael Robert Robert De Niro.

55:11Robert De Niro. You've worked with the other Mike. Bobby De Niro. You've worked with the other guy. Coppola. Sure. You've been in his movies. Yeah. You've been in, like, incredible Black Bear. You've been in, I mean, I should note your IMDb. It's enough. Is that enough? Yeah. It feels like it's not. It just scratched the surface, Plaus. So I guess my question to you is, and it is a genuine question. Hold on. Agatha. Down, down, down the road. Down my witch's road. Road.

55:57I mean, a lot of people think that you were playing yourself in Parks and Rec, but is it true that you were actually playing yourself in Agatha? Of course. Yeah. That was the closest, the most blurred the lines have ever gotten for me. Yeah. when I was holding the dagger in the woods. I mean, that was so exciting to watch. I mean, that part was bananas. It was crazy. And the response to that show, talk about your hag heads. Talk about your parasitic show. I know, my baby hags love that shit. Baby hags, sorry. They're called baby hags, please. Excuse me, baby hags. People, I mean, there's something about you that like is just witch adjacent?

56:39Like you're organically have a witch vibe. As you said, you were called that early on. Like what is it about your fascination? You've written about the Christmas witch. You've played a witch. Christmas witch is your great children's book. And it's a great book, by the way. Thank you. You and Murph. You know, we have a new book coming out that just came out on the shelves right now. Oh, tell us about it. It's called Luna and the Witch. Throw a Halloween party. It's a Halloween party. Yes. What do you love about, what is it about that witch? Your production company is called Evil Hag. What is it about witches and you?

57:14I, you know, it's like I can't pinpoint exactly where that seeped in. But I will say I grew, I think where I grew up has a, there's a witchy vibe in the woods of Delaware, first of all. It's an old state. the first state in fact um and so i think i kind of grew up kind of always i don't know feeling witchy in the woods but also i think that there's a blood a bloodline thing happening you know in my family with the women in my family i think wait say again like i think i feel like I have ancestral like witches in my life. Like for sure. Well, I mean you really – your family feels like a matriarchy.

58:06Like you have sisters. You have really strong women in your family. And it feels like that's been – that feeling has been passed on. Definitely. On both sides too. On both sides. Yeah. On your dad's side too. And I have like Basque blood. And I found out about this years ago when I went to visit. I went to visit like the area where supposedly like some of my family's from. And there's this town called Zugaramerti, which is on the border of France and Spain and northern Spain in the Basque region. And it's apparently where like all thousands of witches would like convene in these caves, which I went to visit.

58:47And like the, you know, we talk about Salem witch trials. That was like 200 witches. What? You love that shit? Boston? Well, that was—it's funny that you bring up the Salem Witch Trials. Why? Because we talked to Margaret Qualley today about you. You did? Yes, who is so nice. I know. I love her. I know, and she loves you. I know. We have a really sweet little connection there. And we got to talk about—and, you know, it's my favorite part of this in many ways is to hear, is to talk well behind someone's back. And she was saying, which, you know, I know firsthand because of the love and support I feel from you and our history together.

59:26But she was talking about how, like, you are a real girl's girl. You are like, you know, you really support women. You love women. You take good care of them. You feel supported and loved by them. And you surround yourself with really strong, interesting women who you learn from and teach to all the time. And but her question was, what were the Salem witch trials like? What? Bitch.

59:57Honestly, they were fun. Alexis. They were fun, Alexis. Alexis, they were fun. They were fun. They were hilarious. Like everyone was freaking out. And I was just like, you guys are like so stupid. But I definitely can see you back in the day being on. I would love it. What do you think that was the best part about playing a witch on Agatha? The best part for me was just like cackling because I had this one scene, like this one part at the end where like, and I don't even know why, but it was I think cackling. There's something about cackling, I swear, that is like really therapeutic. Well, it's probably somatic like you've mentioned.

1:00:38It's like screaming. Yeah. But it's like you think like, why are witches cackling? Where does that come from? I feel like it must be some old-timey way that women were, like, working out their rage. Because I'm not very tapped into that, my rage and whatever. But, like, when I really let loose and am able to, like, cackle or whatever, like, it's—I don't know. It feels good for me. And I really took that and ran with it. And, like, the scene in Agatha where I'm, like, sitting—I'm, like, sitting on top of the house. And, like, I'm on a wire because I'm, like, flying down there. and she's down on the ground going like, you, you know, and like screaming at me.

1:01:17And I was just like, and I was cackling like crazy, but I went really crazy with it. And it felt good. It felt good. It felt really good to just be like, just let loose. Speaking of Margaret Qualley, movie Honey Don't. Honey Don't. You're in it with her. Yeah. And who directed it and how did you, and how did you, tell us about it. um mr ethan cohen directed it um of the cohen brothers um and ethan wrote it with his wife trish trisha cook and um how did i get involved in it i don't know why i mean i find your the way you choose parts really interesting what how do you choose what you're going to do next i mean i think it's just it's a i mean a lot of the things that i do i feel like are somewhat self-generated because I've produced like five movies and, you know, I read scripts and, you know, I've done, I like that approach.

1:02:17You've developed things from the ground. Yeah. Like, I mean, I did that really, that's what I've done a couple of times, but then, you know, as an actor, you also get offers sometimes, you know, but I think people think a lot of times that like actors just like sit there and wait and are sifting through like 10 offers or whatever, but it's never like that it's always kind of different than that but this one I don't know how I choose I think a lot of it's kind of has to do with like what I feel like kind of diving into energetically or like character wise because I tend to really like go there and so I don't there are certain things that I just even if the script's like really good or or if it's like you You got to work with, you know, Glenn Powell or whatever.

1:03:06It's like, I don't. But you got to work with Glenn Powell. I know, but I don't want to. You got to. I can't. You can't. No. He's neighbors with Jack McBrayer. I don't. All right, fine. I'll do it.

1:03:20I'm definitely interested in, like, doing the opposite of what I just did. Yes. Or, like, you know, the honey don't thing to me, honestly, was, like, mind-blowing that a Coen brother wanted to work with me. You know, I was like, oh, my God. Honey, everybody wants to work with you, honey. Tarantino, where the fuck are you? Hello, Tarantino. Sorry, Quentin. Do your earmuffs. If you're listening. Close your earmuffs. Tarantino, I'll do anything. I'll do anything. This is no. Absolutely. Tarantino. Anything you want. Quentin, I am her manager. As her manager, she will not do anything. Ring, ring. And the feet are off the table, babe.

1:03:52Tarantino, it's Aubrey. Guess what? I'll do anything you want, babe. It's extra for the feet, hon. Naked in heels, Tarantino. You're going to get it. You're going to get it. What? Immediate call from Quentin Tarantino. Can't wait. God, I can't wait for whatever is the scary-ass shit he's going to put me through again. Don't care. You think I didn't care before? How about now? Definitely don't care about anything. No. Quentin, no. Okay. But so you— But this brings me— But what do you like? Because you have worked with a lot of different directors. You work—and do you want to direct, right? Yeah.

1:04:29I mean, you have directed already. But you want to do that more? Yeah, I mean, I've never directed a movie. Well, you've directed TV. No, I haven't. You haven't? Well, I directed— Didn't you and Jeff— I directed—yes. Yeah. I directed an episode of a Showtime show called Cinema Toast. Yeah. That Jeff created. Yeah. And it was during the pandemic, and it was a really, really cool show, and I loved my episode. Unfortunately, I don't think you can watch it anymore. I don't think it exists. It just went away. Showtime like literally just erased it. It's kind of weird about some TV. Like we were making jokes about how to find parks, but some TV just is like, it's gone away.

1:05:12It just goes away. It's weird. I mean, I guess when I was growing up, that is what happened with TV. You couldn't watch it again. Yeah, that's true. It just went away. That's true. But now it feels weird that it goes away. Yeah. But yeah, no, I haven't directed. I want to direct a movie, but like I'm... I'm scared. Girl! I know, but you know what it is? it's like I I wanna I know but I it's like I want I'm a little bit like I'm being too precious about it yeah yeah yeah I know yeah you just gotta just do it but I wanna have something to say I have something I wanna I wanna have something to say I wanna shut up I mean I wanna say do you what sorry what sorry I interrupted what do you wanna say I literally don't know what do you wanna say I don't wanna say anything I wanna do a movie where I say nothing how about that it's called Seinfeld the movie okay and so what would be like as we wrap up back to movies what are the movies that like give you what are the movies like what are your comfort movies you know speaking of comfort just a reminder that Frankie's been asleep under your chair the entire time best dog ever Dakota Johnson was on and she brought her dog she thinks she's better than me no sorry no it's not a competition Frankie wins best dog for sure yeah she does okay but comfort movies comfort movies you've got mail love you got mail speaking of Tarantino on his top 10 favorite movies of all time yeah but guess what if he made it what it'd be like you got mail you open the envelope there's a finger in it no he would never oh yeah he would never okay You've Got Mail I love that movie that's like a real comfort movie When Harry Met Sally I think like a lot of like 90s like rom-coms are really comfort movies for me like I grew up like on all those movies like Sleepless in Seattle and I watched two on a plane recently Parenthood and Moonstruck those were like oh my god Moonstruck is Parenthood's so good too love Moonstruck Moonstruck okay and then I ask everybody this Like, and this is maybe, you know, this is like take some more import for you this year probably than other times.

1:07:32But like what do you, what makes you actually laugh? What do you do when you really want to like deeply laugh? Where do you go? Do you watch something? Do you read something? Do you go to friends? Do you like? I mean there's certain, I would say there's just certain people that make me laugh. I don't laugh a lot when I watch things. It's like a question I've asked a lot of people because to me it's like, it's basically like, how do you, how do you stay? Happy? Above the line. Laughing. How do you stay on the cliff and not in the gorge? May I tell you what I've observed that you've been laughing at?

1:08:16I do feel like I feel like the the way in which your friends know you and you know them like the way you like create family and the way that you feel like safe around people and the way that you can like laugh at yourself you have a very good sense of humor about yourself yeah like you're able to get teased really hard and you love to tease yeah I like that I like teasing it I do too. And I think it's a love language. I don't know if it's East Coast. I don't know if it's whatever. But to me, the more comfortable I am with someone, the more I want to tease them and want to be teased by them. Yeah.

1:08:57I would say, yeah, my closest friends, like Bombardo, a group of my women friends that we were in an all-girl improv group, but then we turned into a coven. Legit. We call ourselves Bombardo. Like we do, we have like a text chain and we do like Zooms and we do like trips and those girls make me laugh really, really hard. Also, we've all known each other for so long. It's my oldest, that's the best thing that makes me laugh. It's just funny, all my funny friends. Well, Plazy, we did it. We did. We really did it. Okay. Great job. Thank you for doing this. It means a lot that you came. I got the part.

1:09:38You got the part. You got the part of yourself. Okay. Finally, after all these years. I needed you to audition for the part of you in the podcast, and congratulations. Thank you so much. Thank you, Aubrey Plaza, a.k.a. April Ludgate, my daughter, sister, wife, friend, and we all wanted you to be here, and we're really glad you are. And that was so fun and funny and always a good hang with you. So thank you for coming. And today's Polar Plunge, I just want to talk and just remind people of the beautiful films that Aubrey Plaza and her late husband, Jeff Bain, made together. They include Little Hours, Life After Beth, Spin Me Round.

1:10:24They're all really great, beautiful, funny films that you should check out and check out Jeff Bain's work. He's an incredible writer and director and his work is really special. And it leads me to say that, you know, if someone you know or you yourself is struggling emotionally or thinking about suicide, you can call the National Suicide and Crisis Prevention Lifeline at 988. If you're outside of the U.S., visit Spotify.com slash resources for information and resources. You've been listening to Good Hang. The executive producers for this show are Bill Simmons, Jenna Weiss-Berman, and me, Amy Poehler.

1:11:09The show is produced by The Ringer and Paper Kite. For The Ringer, production by Jack Wilson, Kat Spillane, Kaya McMullen, and Alaya Zanaris. For Paper Kite, production by Sam Green, Joel Lovell, and Jenna Weiss-Berman. Original music by Amy Miles.

1:11:28This episode is brought to you by Visible. Why does it feel like summer ends as soon as it begins? One day the sun is finally shining bright and next thing you know there's football on the TV again It's time to soak up the last dog days of summer and that means staying connected to what you love Visible wireless can help you do just that with visible you get unlimited 5g data and unlimited hotspot Powered by verizon for just 25 a month so you can treat yourself before the summer ends Visible is more than just a wireless plan It's unlimited wireless designed to always keep you connected with no contract to tie you down Switch today at Visible.com.

1:12:04Plans start at$25 a month or get the premium Visible Plus Pro plan and save$10 on your first month with promo code HANG. Terms apply. See Visible.com for plan features and network management details. This episode is brought to you by Allstate. Checking Allstate first could save you hundreds on car insurance. Not checking whether your camera is off before the meeting? Yep, that's how your co-workers find out that your working-from-home setup is more of a working-from-bed situation. Checking first is a good idea. So check Allstate first for an auto quote. It could save you hundreds. You're in good hands with Allstate.

1:12:39Potential savings vary. Subject to terms, conditions, and availability. Allstate North American Insurance Company and affiliates. Northbrook, Illinois.

From the publisher

Aubrey Plaza may or may not have been at the Salem witch trials. Amy hangs with her former 'Parks & Rec' costar and talks about getting run out of her NYU dorm by mice, weirding out Mike Schur, and loving the WNBA.

Host: Amy PoehlerGuests: Margaret Qualley and Aubrey PlazaExecutive Producers: Bill Simmons, Amy Poehler, and Jenna Weiss-BermanFor Paper Kite Productions: Executive producer Jenna Weiss-Berman, coordinator Sam Green, and supervising producer Joel LovellFor The Ringer: Supervising producers Juliet Litman, Sean Fennessey, and Mallory Rubin; video producers Jack Wilson, Belle Roman, and Aleya Zenieris; lighting director Caroline Jannace; audio producer Kaya McMullen; video editor Drew van Steenbergen; and booker Kat SpillaneOriginal Music: Amy Miles

The 2025 Tiguan redesigns expectations.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Good Hang with Amy Poehler

All 66 episodes
Aubrey PlazaGood Hang with Amy Poehler · 1 h 10 min
Listen in VO