1. Podcasts
  2. Here & Now Anytime
  3. Inside Tennessee's botched execution
Here & Now Anytime

1 Oct 2026 · 18m · 6 chapters

Episode artwork

Inside Tennessee's botched execution

In short

The episode covers two investigations: (1) Tennessee’s botched execution of Krista Pike, including why it was allowed to proceed and what went wrong; (2) Cornell University’s handling of an alleged gang rape involving “Jane Doe,” including how documents and reporting may have affected prosecution.

Guests and backgrounds

Catherine Sweeney, reporter for member station WPLN in Nashville, witnessed Pike’s execution attempt. Sharon Otterman, higher-education reporter for The New York Times, helped break the Cornell documents story. (Other segment: Tammy Patrick, Chief Programs Officer at the Election Center/National Association of Election Officials, on election security.)

Key claims

Pike was given two sedative injections but survived; retained medical experts say she likely has brain damage. The Supreme Court allowed the execution to proceed because courts focus on technical Eighth Amendment issues, not whether concerns like PTSD and health conditions make execution humane. Cornell police omitted “rape” language from an initial summary, potentially limiting what prosecutors saw and contributing to non-prosecution.

Notable examples

Pike’s execution attempt took hours; IV access was established late; sedative was run twice while she was still breathing and talking. Cornell: a quote (“100 percent confidence I was raped”) appeared in later interviews but not in the six-page summary; texts show confusion and later apologies/denial from accused men.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:35

The Botched Execution of Krista Pike

Explore the details surrounding the failed execution of Krista Pike in Tennessee.

“It's Thursday, October 1st, and this is Here and Now, Anytime from NPR and WBUR Boston.”
3:00

Witness Accounts and Reactions

Hear from witnesses about the execution attempt and reactions from lawmakers.

“Well, she would have been the first woman executed in the state in more than 200 years.”
6:00

Legal and Ethical Concerns

Discuss the legal and ethical implications of the execution attempt.

“said, hey, if you guys keep messing up these executions, you're handing ammunition to people who hate the death penalty.”
9:00

Jane Doe's Case and Sexual Assault Reporting

Investigate the issues surrounding sexual assault reporting at Cornell.

“I was struck that in her interview with campus police that happened three weeks after the party, She said, quote, I can say with 100 percent confidence I was raped.”
14:12

Election Preparations and Other News

The host previews other news stories at hereandnow.org and introduces Tammy Patrick of the Election Center to discuss how elections are run with just over a month until election day.

“Some other news we're following today at hereandnow.org.”
14:16

Election Security Insights with Tammy Patrick

Tammy Patrick discusses election security, the role of federal agents, and voter turnout dynamics.

“election day, we wanted to talk to someone who knows how to actually run an election.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Here & Now Anytime, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Sharon Otterman: WBUR Podcasts, Boston. A group of state lawmakers said, hey, if you guys keep messing up these executions, you're handing ammunition to people who hate the death penalty.

0:18Sharon Otterman: A botched execution in Tennessee has shocked even supporters of the death penalty.

0:35Sharon Otterman: It's Thursday, October 1st, and this is Here and Now, Anytime from NPR and WBUR Boston. I'm Chris Bentley. A little later on the show, inside Cornell's investigation into the alleged sexual assault of Jane Doe, according to new documents from the university.

0:53Catherine Sweeney: Over those three weeks, she comes to terms with the fact that she lost control and that things happened to her body that she did not want to happen.

1:01Sharon Otterman: But first, Tennessee Governor Bill Lee has paused executions for the rest of the year after the state tried and failed to kill Krista Pike. Pike was sentenced to death in 1996 for murder when she was 20 years old. 30 years later, the Supreme Court stepped in to allow the state to put her to death. She was given two injections of what were supposed to be lethal doses. of a sedative. But she survived. She was taken to a nearby hospital, and a medical expert retained by Pike's legal team says she likely has brain damage. Catherine Sweeney witnessed the execution attempt last night. She's a reporter with member station WPLN in Nashville.

1:45Sharon Otterman: She told Indira Lakshmanan that she's covered executions before, but none like this. We got to the prison at 8.30 in the morning, all of a sudden, a circuit court issued a stay, which we didn't even realize there was a challenge before a circuit court. The Supreme Court had already said that it should move forward. So long story short, we sat at the prison for about 10 hours. So by the time that we did get into the death chamber, it was after seven o 'clock. And it took a really long time for them to establish IV access. Because there's a curtain over the window that whole time, we don't know what went wrong.

2:23Sharon Otterman: They pushed this enormous amount of sedative that is designed to kill somebody by a pretty broad margin. They ended up running it twice and she was still alive. She was talking at points where she should have been appearing comatose. She was lifting her head up and looking around. They left us in the witness bay room listening to her ragged snoring breathing for over half an hour and, you know, in the dark for a lot of it. And then with the lights on and We didn't know when they were going to let us out or if they were going to try to resuscitate her or what was going to happen and nobody would answer our questions.

3:00Catherine Sweeney: All right. Well, she would have been the first woman executed in the state in more than 200 years. There were several attempts to block her execution. Her advocates said she had endured severe physical and sexual abuse since she was a toddler and suffered from untreated mental illness and PTSD. So explain briefly why did the governor and the U.S. Supreme Court allow this execution to go forward?

3:24Sharon Otterman: That's a great question. There was a slew of hearings about that exact issue in August, and they spent hours and hours discussing the effects of her PTSD from a lifetime of sexual trauma. They also talked about some of her physical health conditions. essentially with hearings like this, they're not really assessing whether that seems like a reasonable concern. They are assessing whether it seems on a technicality like an Eighth Amendment constitutional right violation. So remind us what the Eighth Amendment is. Yeah, it bans cruel and unusual punishment. But there have been hundreds of lethal injection lawsuits and it's gotten to be so granular.

4:10Sharon Otterman: what counts as a rights violation.

4:13Catherine Sweeney: Well, Krista Pike's lawyers, when they were fighting the execution, warned that it might not even work for her because she has small veins and other medical conditions. What do we know about her condition and why the injections failed to kill her and how she's doing now?

4:30Sharon Otterman: It's really complicated to know what went wrong. She did have a platelet disorder that could have made all of this more difficult. She had small veins. A lot of doctors here say basically only unethical doctors would sign up to be involved in this. Only unethical healthcare workers would because every ethics code says they're not supposed to participate in executions. And so all we know is it was catastrophically wrong. It was an enormous dose of a sedative and she was still breathing. But we don't know much about her condition now either. They're being very secretive about it. We do know that she is still alive, but that's about it.

5:07Catherine Sweeney: So as you referenced, the American Medical Association bars its own members from participating in executions, which might leave these injections to workers who don't know how to oversee them. There was a case earlier this year where Tennessee tried and failed to lethally inject another inmate. What do we know about how these failures might be changing public opinion about the death penalty or about lethal injection?

5:34Sharon Otterman: I think there's a lot of confusion about how popular the death penalty is in Tennessee. Some polling by Vanderbilt University here found that people are pretty split on it. It's about 50-50. And then when you throw in some of these complications, it's even lower than that. after the earlier failed execution you mentioned of Tony Carruthers, a group of state lawmakers said, hey, if you guys keep messing up these executions, you're handing ammunition to people who hate the death penalty. So even people who love the death penalty say we can't be having these kind of violent mistakes happening. It's not good for anyone.

6:16Catherine Sweeney: That's Catherine Sweeney. She's a reporter with member station WPLN in Nashville, who witnessed the attempted execution last night of Krista Pike. Catherine, thank you so much for joining us. Thanks.

6:32Sharon Otterman: Coming up next, what former Cornell student Jane Doe said to campus investigators that was apparently never relayed to the district attorney and why the system for reporting sexual assaults on campus is rarely straightforward. Indira has that after the break.

7:04Catherine Sweeney: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. Now to an update from Cornell University, where New York prosecutors have reopened a criminal investigation that is raising questions about sexual assault on college campuses and how universities handle such reports. And a warning to listeners, this conversation will include discussion of rape. The New York Times has obtained more than 1 ,000 pages from Cornell's internal investigation related to an alleged gang rape at a fraternity house two years ago. Text, emails, and interviews reveal crucial details of what happened in the three weeks between a party at the Chi-Fi fraternity and a report made to campus police.

7:48Catherine Sweeney: A female student who's being referred to as Jane Doe alleged that she was drugged and raped by seven members of the frat. Sharon Otterman is one of the reporters who broke this story for The Times, and she joins us now. Sharon, welcome. Thank you so much. So the documents you reviewed paint a picture of a woman who seems to be processing over these three weeks what has happened to her. She's just 20 years old. She's only a sophomore. She has just joined a sorority. Tell us about your takeaway from these documents overall. I think the documents provide us with this crucial window to see how a potential victim of sexual assault will process this information in real time.

8:34Catherine Sweeney: When she first talks to her roommates, she doesn't use words like rape. But she's also very sort of defensive and being strange. weird, you know, from their point of view about how she's describing it. So they know that something more went on. And I think over those three weeks, she comes to terms with the fact that she lost control and that things happened to her body that she did not want to happen. I was struck that in her interview with campus police that happened three weeks after the party, She said, quote, I can say with 100 percent confidence I was raped. And yet the original six page summary report that was filed at the time by Cornell campus police did not include that quote, didn't even use the word rape.

9:23Catherine Sweeney: What is the reason for that? And could that be why the district attorney at the time did not move forward with a criminal case? If you read police reports, they're not gripping narratives. And this police officer decided to omit anything that he did not think was a sort of who, what, where, when, why statement of fact. But in doing so, he left out crucial context about why a woman in this situation would take a drug or why she would not verbally stand up and say no. These are the kinds of consent-based moments that most modern women have experienced. And they know how difficult in these situations this can be.

10:16Catherine Sweeney: The DA never gets to see the full breath of what she actually says to the police investigator because he receives a very abbreviated report that is just a recitation and kind of like a flattening of some of the descriptions that she gives of the moments that disturbed her the most. And so that might not fully explain why he decided not to prosecute because there are very high bars to proving rape in New York State. But it definitely seems to make it more understandable why he might not have. I want to talk about the text messages you reviewed between the alleged victim, her friends and the men involved.

10:58Catherine Sweeney: The texts show a lot of confusion, even for the alleged victim herself, about what happened at the party. But then some of the young men involved apologized to her by text after the event. Talk about that. I think after the party, the men got together and realized like, oh, wow, that got out of hand. And everybody went into kind of damage control mode. Some of her texts, she later says, are her trying to get information about what happened that night from them to try to fill in some of the gaps of her memory. So she did have kind of a strategic goal in some of the communications with the men. And the men, I think, had a strategic goal in apologizing to her and trying to say, hey, let's not worry about this.

11:47Catherine Sweeney: Let's let bygones be bygones. How did the university's interviews with six of the seven accused men square with the text between Jane Doe and these men that you reviewed? I mean, none of the men admit doing anything beyond the drug use. Some do say that they engaged in consensual sex. One of the men actually accuses her of being the aggressor and sort of counter claims against her. There's sort of a diversity of responses from them, but you could put them all in the category of denial. I'm wondering what universities can do better because, you know, this is a young woman who was only 20 years old.

12:33Catherine Sweeney: She was confused by what happened. She went and saw a medical doctor, and the report seems to indicate that the doctor kind of dismissed her concerns and said, maybe you should go get therapy. So how can universities and the authorities there be doing better? There is enormous room for improvement. I know universities have tried training, but it's really a culture shift. And there's been a lot of research done on how do we improve these sorts of cultural situations to make this completely unacceptable. And so this is a work in progress that not just Cornell, but all universities are working on.

13:15Catherine Sweeney: Sharon Otterman covers higher education for The New York Times. She was part of the team that broke the story about the 1 ,000 pages of internal documents related to this investigation. Sharon, thank you so much. Thank you.

13:36Catherine Sweeney: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Progressive Insurance. The Mighty Dollar. Once upon a time, it had a whole menu named after it. Now, no more. But$1 a day lets you add Progressive renter's insurance to your auto insurance. Definitely something your younger self would roll their eyes at, but your current adulting self appreciates. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company, affiliates, and other insurers. Average premium cost based on Progressive home data from 2025. Product and prices may vary by state.

14:12Sharon Otterman: Some other news we're following today at hereandnow.org. With just over a month until election day, we wanted to talk to someone who knows how to actually run an election. Tammy Patrick is Chief Programs Officer at the Election Center, also known as the National Association of Election Officials. She served on President Obama's Commission on Election Administration. Despite the Trump administration suing states for their voter rolls and attempting to restrict mail-in voting. She told Robin Young the election is secure.

14:43Catherine Sweeney: Before every federal election for the last couple of decades that I've been doing this work, there has been a posture of increased observation, increased, you know, either the political parties or others who are going to be at the polls in droves. And that usually doesn't play out in quite that way. So in this moment, I'm not sure if we're really going to see that manifest because it's been postulated numerous times before and has not come to fruition. But in this moment, we are seeing changes in the way the federal government has been involving itself in elections. And it's really important for listeners to realize that our elections are run by professionals at the state and local level.

15:28Catherine Sweeney: Right. It has been that way for, you know, since the beginning of our of our country. Well, there is fear of outside interference. And generals have told members of Congress, like Michigan Senator Alyssa Slotkin, that there are no plans for troops to be deployed at polling places. But Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen says immigration agents will be there if there are specific threats that is vague to some state officials. Have we been here before where we're talking about troops or federal agents at polls? We have not. The most important piece here for listeners and voters to realize is that it's really easy to say things.

16:10Catherine Sweeney: It's more difficult to actually make them come to pass. And what I mean by that is that if you say, I'm going to rig an election, I'm going to hack voting equipment, it's very easy to say that and to spread that message. It's much harder to do all of these things. And it's much harder to do all these things everywhere. So even if it's the case that we have observers and we always have federal observers and party observers at the polls in every election, but the federal observers are usually, you know, a few of them across the country. It's not going to be the case that this is something that every voter is going to encounter if they choose to vote in person.

16:53Catherine Sweeney: Well, what about the effect of saying things? You know, just just the saying, as President Trump has done, well, there's fraud with ballots. Does that have an impact on the vote? It remains to be seen if it will have an impact because what we know from some research is that when there are policies and practices that are put in place that are seemingly obstacles to voters, it actually increases turnout because voters realize that voting is their superpower. And it's important for them to not let someone take it away easily or lightly or to be dissuaded.

17:29Sharon Otterman: There is more to that conversation about the election and voting, including what poll monitors can do and cannot do when they're observing elections. You can listen to that at hereandnow.org.

17:44Sharon Otterman: Here and Now Anytime comes from NPR and WBUR. Today's stories were produced by Jessica Carissa, James Mastromarino, and Lynn Menningon. Our editors were Todd Muntz, Micaela Rodriguez, and Michael Scotto. Technical direction from Caleb Green and Andre Peralta. Our theme music is by Mike Moschetto, Max Liebman, and me, Chris Bentley. Our digital producers are Alison Hagen and Grace Griffin. And here at Now's executive producer is Helen Price. Thanks for listening. We'll be back with you tomorrow.

18:29Catherine Sweeney: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

From the publisher
Death row inmate Christa Pike survived two injections intended to kill her. Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee has now paused the state's remaining executions pending an independent review. We get an eyewitness account of the botched execution from WPLN's Catherine Sweeney. 

And, newly obtained documents by The New York Times reveal the timeline between the alleged assault and when Jane Doe filed a report with Cornell University campus police. Times reporter Sharon Otterman explains what the documents show.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

More from Here & Now Anytime

All episodes