1. Podcasts
  2. Here & Now Anytime
  3. Why Utah is taking on Kalshi
Here & Now Anytime

21 Oct 2026 · 18m · 6 chapters

Episode artwork

Why Utah is taking on Kalshi

In short

The episode has two segments. First, it covers Brad Lander, a New York City congressional candidate, who was detained by Israeli forces while joining Protect the Harvest, a group of Jewish peace activists harvesting olives with Palestinian farmers in the West Bank. Lander claims the harvest was on private Palestinian land, posed no safety risk, and that Israeli forces used “uncoordinated harvest” as a pretext; he says this is state-sanctioned prevention of Palestinians harvesting and living on their land. He cites settler violence and examples like a demolished home and displaced family, plus prior detentions/attacks on U.S. figures. Lander argues the Trump administration backs Netanyahu and that Gaza’s civilian deaths are unjustifiable.

Second, Utah Attorney General Derek Brown discusses Utah’s lawsuit against Kalshi (and mentions Polymarket). Brown says Utah’s constitution bans gambling, that Utah can enforce anti-gambling laws despite CFTC regulation claims, and that Kalshi’s prediction markets (e.g., political outcomes, sports futures) are effectively gambling. He cites about 33,000 verified Utah accounts and alleges Kalshi made $60 million in fees in Utah. He says the goal is compliance and recovering money, not targeting individuals, while warning about addiction among young men.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:50

Brad Lander's Arrest and Human Rights Issues

Brad Lander discusses his arrest while advocating for Palestinian rights and highlights ongoing violence and displacement issues.

“Today on the show, Utah's Attorney General joins us to talk about his state's lawsuit against the betting app Kalshi.”
7:20

Transition to Utah's Attorney General

Indira introduces Utah's Attorney General to discuss the state's lawsuit against Kalshi.

7:53

Utah's Legal Challenge Against Kalshi

Utah Attorney General Derek Brown explains the lawsuit against Kalshi, the legality of prediction markets, and concerns about gambling.

“Utah's attorney general filed a lawsuit yesterday against Calci, one of the country's most popular prediction market companies, alongside Polymarket.”
14:01

Response from Kalshi

The hosts mention reaching out to Kalshi for comment but not receiving a response.

14:50

Story on Russia's Release of American

Discussion about the release of a 74-year-old American detained by Russia.

“In the NPR app, it's a bell notification icon.”
15:18

Analysis of Trump's Policy on Ukraine

Analysis of President Trump's approach to the Ukraine conflict and its implications.

“government deny that and say he moved to Ukraine to be with his partner.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Here & Now Anytime, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This message comes from Wallace Annenberg Genspace, a national model for reimagining aging by creating opportunities for purpose and connection. Learn more at AnnenbergGenspace.org. WBUR Podcasts, Boston. We were with the farmers whose land it is. There's no obligation to coordinate with the Israeli military. we were posing no safety risk. We were literally just harvesting olives. Israeli troops detained dozens of Americans in the West Bank, including rabbis and a candidate for Congress.

0:47It's Wednesday, October 21st, and this is Here and Now, Anytime from NPR and WBUR. I'm Chris Bentley.

0:57Today on the show, Utah's Attorney General joins us to talk about his state's lawsuit against the betting app Kalshi. But first, a leading congressional candidate from New York is speaking out after he was detained by the Israeli military in the occupied West Bank today. Brad Lander was with Rabbis for Human Rights and other Jewish peace activists harvesting olives alongside Palestinian farmers who say they've not been able to reach their olive groves because of attacks from Israeli settlers and soldiers. Lander told Indira Lakshmanon about his arrest. So I'm here with an effort called Protect the Harvest.

1:33Dozens of American and international volunteers, a bunch of rabbis. We went to an olive grove in between a Palestinian village and an Israeli settlement. It hasn't been harvested in three years out of fear of the farmers that they'll be attacked. So they were delighted to have about 60 of us harvesting. But after about two – and we got there just at their invitation. It's their land, no checkpoint. But after a couple hours, the IDF, Israeli soldiers and police showed up and detained us, put us in a bus, took us to an IDF station, prevented us from harvesting. I've been released, but the others are still detained.

2:13So the Israeli defense forces posted on social media that this was a, quote, uncoordinated harvest that they say posed a security risk to a nearby Israeli community. The Israeli forces say some 100 so-called coordinated harvests have taken place safely without incident. What do you say to that? Oh, it's just lies. We pose no risk to anyone. We were on private Palestinian land. We were with the farmers whose land it is. There's no obligation to coordinate with the Israeli military. And in fact, when they made it seem like we were too near the settlement, we moved down a tier and harvested some trees even further away.

2:55There was absolutely zero risk. This was the IDF making it impossible for these poor Palestinian farmers to harvest their olive trees. And I do think Americans should be clear on this. This is a state-sanctioned effort to prevent them from harvesting their fields, from living in their homes, from driving on their roads. When we say state-sanctioned ethnic cleansing, it's not just settler violence. It's the IDF's effort to prevent Palestinians from living their lives. Well, let's put this in larger perspective. There's been a sharp escalation in reports of violence by Israeli settlers in Palestinian areas of late.

3:33Israeli settlers detained U.S. Congressman Ro Khanna of California back in July. An American photographer working for The Washington Post was attacked by settlers and seriously wounded several days ago. International diplomats have been attacked. So what have you seen on the ground and what are you hearing about? We saw a home that it was demolished yesterday morning and a family displaced to a refugee camp. They had been trying the whole town to get a zoning plan so they could have permits, but they won't be given a zoning plan. And then their homes are demolished. It is a coordinated and state-sanctioned effort to push Palestinians off their land.

4:10So what we've observed is the Netanyahu government in Israel backing settlements on Palestinian land. a steep increase in the number of those settlements. Where does the Trump administration stand on what's happening? And what sort of pressure have you and other local officials been able to exert? Sadly, the Trump administration is backing the Netanyahu government's ethnic cleansing of the West Bank. You saw Trump endorse Netanyahu this week. Americans don't want their tax dollars to pay for Netanyahu's wars. That's part of why I'm here. It's part of why I have more than 100 Democratic members of Congress voted against sending more military aid to Israel while it violates international law and Palestinian human rights.

4:59Well, let me ask you, Israel and Gaza are an issue in the upcoming midterm elections. We're seeing it in certain races even more than others. Democrats as a party have been under scrutiny for where they stand on Israel. In the last election, we saw some Jewish voters switch over from traditionally supporting Democrats to supporting Donald Trump because of his staunch backing of Israel. You're running for Congress. What is your position and what is the message that you think the American public needs to hear about U.S. support for Israel, but specifically for this Israeli government led by Benjamin Netanyahu?

5:43I'm a proud American Jew. I believe in the vision of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state, care about it. But I hate what is taking place, you know, as an American Jew. And yes, American politics are changing and being reset. There was rightly so much sympathy for Israel after the horrible Hamas attacks after October 7th. But that does not justify killing 70 ,000 Palestinians in Gaza, mostly women and children. You know, Americans are saying so loud and clear, and that is part of why I'm here this week. You are leading most of the polls for your upcoming race for Congress. What are you hearing from voters in your own district in New York City where there is a large Jewish population for sure and Israel is definitely an issue on the ballot?

6:37People feel fear and understandably so. Anti-Semitism is on the rise amidst war and fascism. But also so many of the Jews in my district don't want their tax dollars or their names being used for violence and displacement of Palestinians. So it is possible to walk the path of saying, I care deeply about the safety of the Jewish people and I care deeply about Palestinian human rights. Brad Lander is a candidate for U.S. Congress from New York City. He was detained today by the Israeli military while accompanying a group of Jewish peace activists who were harvesting olives on Palestinian land in the occupied West Bank.

7:19Brad Lander, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you.

7:37Coming up next, Indira speaks with Utah's Republican Attorney General, who is one of a growing number of state officials criticizing the federal government for letting so-called prediction markets handle bets without being regulated like other forms of gambling. That's in just a minute.

8:21even the weather, violate that ban. Utah's attorney general filed a lawsuit yesterday against Calci, one of the country's most popular prediction market companies, alongside Polymarket. It's the latest effort to rein in an industry that has exploded in popularity in recent years. Attorney General Derek Brown of Utah, a Republican, joins us now. Attorney General Brown, welcome. Thank you, Indira. I appreciate you having me on. So gambling is illegal under Utah's constitution. Calci says it's not a gambling company, that it's regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. So explain to us why the lawsuit.

8:59Well, first of all, as you mentioned, Utah is actually one of only two states in the country where gambling is illegal under the state constitution. Literally, Utah and Hawaii are the only two states where that is the case. and a number of years, well, probably six or seven months ago, the company Calci actually sued the state of Utah trying to get an answer to this question of are they in fact regulated by the Commodities Future Trading Commission? Really, the question is, are we as a state empowered to enforce our anti-gambling laws? And that went to federal court and we won. As a state, the case was tossed out, and effectively that answer was decided that no, Utah has the ability to make that decision.

9:49So ultimately, that's what this lawsuit is about, is states like Utah making a decision that this is the kind of activity that is prohibited. And the reality is, in our system of government, other states make different choices, and that's perfectly fine. But here, we've made a different choice in the state of Utah. And that's why I feel very strongly about the issue. All right. Well, let me ask you a question from the point of view of your own citizens in Utah. Your lawsuit says nearly 33 ,000 people in Utah have verified Calci accounts. These prediction markets are hugely popular. People bet on real life questions.

10:27Will the brewers win the World Series? Who will win the midterms? During this year's Super Bowl, Calci said it had a billion dollars in trading volume. So why not follow the will of the consumer, including tens of thousands of people in Utah who want these products? Well, ultimately, because it's against the law. I mean, fundamentally, that's what this comes down to. In fact, you mentioned the Super Bowl. You know, the morning of the Super Bowl, I was sitting next to my son, who is a college student, and he got an ad from Calci on social media. And it basically, you know, even though you can't bet on the Super Bowl here in terms of sports betting, his ad basically said you can trade on a future football outcome.

11:10Well, you know, that seems like a distinction without a difference. And, you know, instead of, you know, trying to figure out is that is there really a difference? In the end, that's that's ultimately, you know, it comes down to the fact that in the state of Utah, that behavior is illegal. Now, if the law changes at some point in the future, you know, then that's a whole different story. But the reality is for 130 years, that kind of activity has been illegal. All right. So let me ask you, if there are 33 ,000 people in Utah with verified CalSHI accounts, will the state go after them, too, for engaging in illegal activity?

11:48Right now, this is primarily about the civil action against the companies that are creating these, you know, the opportunities to do the gambling. My real concern are the individuals, and we're hearing from a lot of them now. In particular, after this filing yesterday, we're hearing from a number of people who have lost money. And the reality is gambling is a problem. I mean, there's a reason, I think, in the past that we have confined gambling to areas like Nevada, to casinos in the middle of the desert. Now, there's no friction. It's in your pocket. It's on your iPhone. It is, it's there all the time.

12:30And we're seeing the number of predominantly, for whatever reason, predominantly males, younger males are engaging in this and are just, and are really struggling. I've talked to, you know, university presidents. I've talked to ecclesiastical leaders. I mean, I can't tell you how many parents will say to me, yeah, I've got a son who's 21 and he and all of his friends are, you know, they're addicted to sports. gambling. They're addicted to it. And the problem is, is what they've done is they've incorporated the language or hijacked the language of investing instead of gambling or waging, you know, putting wagers or bets.

13:10They're basically saying, well, we've got positions or contracts or that kind of thing. Let me ask you. So you say in the lawsuit that Calci has made$60 million in fees off of people in your state. This goes to your point about sports betting. Utah's not the only state to pursue legal action. Some 20 states have. Arizona even filed criminal charges. What's your goal here, to shut these companies down? The goal is to make sure that they follow the law. And then the goal of this lawsuit is to basically identify how much money have they made by breaking the law in our state and have that returned.

13:51And in the end, mostly I just want, I want them to follow the law and I want to help those who are - Thank you so much to Utah Attorney General Derek Brown. We reached out to Calci for comment, but did not hear back before airtime.

14:21Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

14:50In Apple Podcasts, it's a plus sign. In the NPR app, it's a bell notification icon. I just got back from Iowa and heard some interesting things from people there, so click that follow button now so you don't miss that. At hereandnow.org, we've also got a story today about Russia releasing a 74-year-old American it seized four years ago in Ukraine. Russia accused Stephen Hubbard of fighting for Ukraine. His family and the U.S. government deny that and say he moved to Ukraine to be with his partner. President Trump claims that Hubbard's release is not connected to the president's recent decision to lift sanctions on Russian diesel.

15:31But NPR's Charles Maines told us there is a broader context to consider. Well, there are different ways to look at it. I think one version is that President Trump is letting domestic interest dictate his attitudes towards with the war in Ukraine. So the fact that polling numbers show that Republican candidates are struggling at the polls with gas, rising gas prices, a major factor has him looking for scapegoats. And one version of this is that he's basically looked at Ukraine as a way to explain away why gas prices are high. He says that Ukraine strikes on Russian energy sales or energy facilities is what's driving the price of gas up at the pump in the U.S.

16:11and elsewhere. although economists would say it's primarily due to Trump's war in Iran. But that's one version. But the other one here is that all throughout, since Trump has come back for his second term in office, he's been pursuing this peace deal in Ukraine. He's tried various mechanisms to get there. You can agree with him or not. But along the way, I think there's been this assumption that instead of they've tried sort of pushing Russia into a deal, they tried pressuring Ukraine. It seems the latest attempt or sort of tactic here to try and sweeten the pot for Russia, to try and keep them in the peace process.

16:44And it was interesting today, as we saw after this meeting between Witkoff and President Putin in St. Petersburg, the Russians, a Kremlin aide later issued a statement saying that the Russians were willing to, you know, essentially resuscitate trilateral talks between the U.S. and Ukraine starting in November. So in some ways, they could make the case that this is working, that they are keeping the Russians on board. although you could take a cynical view and say this is Russia sort of making Trump look good in a moment when he needs it. You can find that whole conversation with NPR's Charles Maines and a lot more at hereandnow.org.

17:21That's it for the show today, though. Here and Now Anytime comes from NPR and WBUR Boston. Today's stories were produced by Lynn Managon and Kalyani Saxena, who, I'm not going to lie, I'm a little devastated to say is leaving here and now. You've heard Kalyani host this podcast many times and report on everything from government surveillance of internet data to romantic novels. She did expand my little genre world of sci-fi as well. So I don't need to tell you how skilled she is as a journalist and a broadcaster, but I can tell you what a delight she's been to work with. We will miss her dearly.

18:01Kalyani, thanks for everything. Good luck in your future endeavors. Today's editors were Todd Munt, Peter O'Dowd, and Michael Scotto. Technical direction from Caleb Green and James Trout. Our theme music is by Mike Moschetto, Max Liebman, and me, Chris Bentley. Our digital producers are Allison Hagen and Grace Griffin, and here and now's executive producer is Alan Price. Thanks for listening. We'll be back with you tomorrow.

From the publisher
Utah is suing Kalshi, the prediction market company, accusing the platform of gambling, which is illegal in the state. Utah's Attorney General Derek Brown tells us about the lawsuit. 

Then, New York Democratic congressional candidate Brad Lander was briefly detained by Israeli defense forces Wednesday morning while picking olives in a pro-Palestinian protest in the West Bank. Lander joins us.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

More from Here & Now Anytime

All episodes