Susan Yara on How She Sold Naturium To e.l.f For $355 Million, Her FTC Investigation, and Building Through Backlash

4 Jun 2025 · 58 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: Hot Smart Rich - Episode with Susan Yara

Episode Overview In this episode of Hot Smart Rich, host Maggie Sellers interviews Susan Yara, founder of the skincare brand Naturium, who discusses her journey of selling the company to e.l.f. for $355 million, her experiences with public backlash, an FTC investigation, and personal challenges including divorce. The episode is characterized by its candid and tactical conversation, with Susan sharing insights into both her entrepreneurial and personal life.

---

Key Themes & Discussions

  1. Controversy and Backlash
  2. Transparency is Key: Susan emphasizes that backlash can arise from a lack of clarity rather than controversy itself. Her openness about her journey and the backlash she faced regarding her undisclosed involvement with Naturium helped rebuild trust with her audience.
  3. FTC Investigation: Susan was investigated by the FTC due to numerous complaints, which she navigated while managing her brand and personal life. The investigation lasted nearly two years but concluded without any wrongdoing on her part.
  1. Personal Transformation
  2. Navigating Divorce: While scaling Naturium, Susan struggled with her divorce and the challenges of single motherhood. She reflects on how personal hardship shaped her leadership style and identity.
  3. Authenticity and Ambition: Susan discusses redefining her relationship with ambition and authenticity, especially during difficult times, and how it influenced her approach to both life and business.
  1. Building a Successful Brand
  2. Masstige Skincare Movement: Naturium is highlighted as a leader in the "masstige" skincare category, blending mass-market accessibility with high-quality products. Susan's journey illustrates how creator-founded brands can succeed and impact the beauty industry.
  3. Retail Strategy: Susan shares insights on the importance of retail partnerships, particularly with Target, as a strategy for credibility and scaling the brand.
  1. Lessons for Founders and Creators
  2. Focus on Margins: Susan stresses the importance of profitability and contribution margin over vanity metrics like social media likes.
  3. Partnerships and Trust: Her collaboration with co-founder Ben Bennett is described as crucial to navigating the brand's growth and challenges, highlighting the importance of mutual trust in business partnerships.
  4. Building in Public: The discussion revolves around the importance of being honest and transparent while building a brand in the public eye, especially in the age of social media.

---

Key Takeaways

  • Controversy Doesn't Cancel You: It's a lack of clarity and transparency that can damage trust.
  • You Can Build While Breaking Down: Susan's experience shows personal challenges can lead to growth in leadership.
  • Retail Still Matters: Physical retail presence can enhance brand credibility and drive awareness.
  • Quiet Founders Can Lead Loud Growth: Embracing operational strengths rather than seeking the spotlight can differentiate a brand.
  • Partnerships Over Perfection: Strong, trust-based partnerships can help navigate business challenges effectively.
  • Prioritize Margins: Profitability from day one is essential for sustainable business growth.

---

Conclusion Susan Yara’s journey, from navigating public scrutiny to achieving significant financial success with Naturium, serves as an inspirational case study for aspiring entrepreneurs. Her insights into authenticity, transparency, and strategic partnerships provide valuable lessons for anyone in the business landscape today, especially in the creator economy.

---

For more resources, follow Maggie Sellers and Susan Yara on their respective social media platforms to stay connected with their latest projects and insights.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:13İng 2020

0:30The Jack Welch Management Institute at Strayer University helps you go from I know the way to I've arrived with our top 10 ranked online MBA. Gain skills you can learn today and apply tomorrow. Get ready to go from make it happen to made it happen and keep striving. Visit Strayer.edu slash Jack Welch MBA to learn more. Strayer University is certified to operate in Virginia by Shev and as many campuses, including at 2121 15th Street North in Arlington, Virginia.

1:03In case you missed it, you're allowed to be hot, smart, and rich. So let's get into it.

1:13Susan Yara, are you ready to get hot, smart, rich? Yeah, yeah. I feel like I'm already, you know, embodying it. Yeah. You're also the first guest that I've done wearing shoes. How does that feel for you? Oh, well, that should we take our shoes off? Should we get comfy? Should we take our shoes off? Okay, are we getting comfy? that you said that because I'm such like a comfy vibes person, but this is so much more cozy. Okay. I love this. So this is not the first time that we've met. I know. Well, I guess in person, in real life, IRL. Do you want to explain how we met the first time? I used to have a talent agency called glow lab, glow lab collective.

1:50And, um, one of my talent, you had reached out to one of my talent to get her a deal where she would essentially be an ambassador slash, uh, investor in a company you're working with. So you and I went back and forth negotiating and it fell through, unfortunately. All for the best, but yes. Yeah, all for the best. Probably for you guys too. And since then, I no longer have that talent agency. I was going to ask. Okay, so you don't do that at all anymore. I do consult and I do work with any of the talent that I brought over to the digital department, which is the agency that now has that roster.

2:27Okay. I do work with them a little bit. I consult with them. And then, you know, obviously the talent that I brought over, I love and I adore them. So I still work with them too. It's so funny too, because I actually didn't, I was never a YouTube girly growing up. Like it was just never my thing. I was like playing sports and just doing other stuff. And so when we first got connected, I just was like, wow, mad respect. This woman's like an incredible manager because that's the role that like I thought that you were in. Little did I know that you had this like huge audience yourself. You had been building this like white space in makeup for so long.

2:58So one of the things that I've always been so fascinated about you with is like you're so equally as good on the camera and behind the camera. Do you find it hard to like switch what hat you're wearing? You know, I think that people, I don't, obviously we can't assume that everybody who is a content creator is a good business person, right? We've all met people who are creative and maybe they don't have that business mind. but I actually think to be a successful content creator, especially on a platform like YouTube where you have to do long form content, you have to really plan things out, almost like you're creating a TV show.

3:30I think you have to be very business minded. So I feel like I've always had a very big business mind. It's something that I got from my mom. She was always starting little businesses here and there when I was little and I was always helping her. I used to be the manager of her video store, RIP to video stores. Oh my God. And I learned just a lot about business and how to manage people. And then eventually I went into media, became a journalist. I was an on-camera news reporter in New York City, hated it. And then I went into publications and I started working at Forbes magazine. And they were just starting this whole world of the digital era.

4:07Like it seemed like something strange and new. And it's funny to say it like that because nowadays everything is digital. But back then it was all about print magazines. and so they hired me on to help start their video network and to be an online reporter and that eventually led to me doing this at different publications and then eventually I was like you know I could do this myself I could go on to YouTube I could start a network that's essentially for women with content that women want especially women in their 20s 30s and 40s where we're getting really well produced content around cosmetic procedures because believe it or not people wouldn't even admit that they did Botox 10 years ago I know it's crazy to think how, how, just how open people are about Botox these days.

4:49But just a few years ago, you couldn't get anybody. It's interesting. Like people are so open about certain things, but I think you're actually the first person that I'm going to talk to you. That's open about like, honestly, every single thing in their life. Like I actually want to figure out like, is there things that are off limits for you? But even your podcast is called like my life online. Would you say you're chronically online? First of all, Oh, I'm chronically online. I feel like the people I get along with the most know what I'm referring to when I like quote something from TikTok or I refer to something that was in a video.

5:20It's just, it's what I do and I'm always online. What do you think the biggest pros are of always being online and what are the biggest cons? I think the biggest pros are obviously you're in tune with what's happening on a day-to-day basis in pop culture with social media. If you run a social media business in any aspect of it, you have to know what's happening and it's changing rapidly every single day especially the algorithm the way that the social media networks work the way that things are trending obviously the cons are that you're not as present right and it takes up a lot of your time and sometimes you can just get stuck in a rabbit hole that's not serving you at all do you feel like sometimes when you're around people that don't want to live their life like chronically online or being present that it's hard for you to like relate to them in a certain way um yes and no I think first off I'm a zennial meaning oh what is that so I'm I'm I'm an elder millennial and elder millennials basically are the people who grew up with a little bit of like the old school we didn't have social media while we were in college we barely had cell phones we barely started texting in our early 20s um so like everything with that era was new so like we we spent our childhood and our teen years living old school okay like off the grid and then we transitioned into the digital the digital era in college okay so it gives us a different perspective and I think that because of it I I know how to just shut off too because I have kids as well and they're young they require a lot of attention I try to really turn off and spend weekends with them evenings with them and not really be so online and um and I think that because of that mentality I can be around other people who aren't chronically online okay so like when you think about what you want to share and what you don't want to share have there ever been parts of your life where you're like this is off limits yeah it's honestly it's my children yeah that's actually one of the things I was actually like doing serious diligence on because you do talk about a lot which we're going to get into today but like you do post with your kids but like so rarely where it's like you know that they're there do you ever get mom shamed because you don't post with your kids that like you're not with your kids enough in the beginning not mom shamed for not being with my kids.

7:31I think people realize that I'm a present mom. And I think that's because in the past, when I was first pregnant with my son, I really did actually start posting. I started a whole personal channel outside of mixed makeup. And I made that a focus because I found that I wasn't getting a lot of just straightforward information. I was in my journalist brain. I just wanted somebody to give me a top 10 list of what I should be buying for my baby. What should I take to the hospital? What should I, you know, just anything that I needed to know, I wanted it to be researched and have actual information behind it, not just somebody saying like, I got this today and I liked it.

8:08And this is a haul for my kid stuff. I really wanted to, to have some information and real reviews behind stuff. So I started posting about becoming a mom. And I think I connected with a whole new audience when that happened. And then they, they were with me through a big portion of it. I actually recorded a weekly show where I posted being pregnant with my daughter. And then that was the end of it. But that's so necessary because like as someone who wants to be pregnant, like I'm terrified of it. I literally have been talking to my partner about like maybe we should do surrogates. Like I don't know if I can handle that.

8:40Like I have so many problems. So I think this is where like it's a blessing and a curse because even with me calling off my engagement, like part of the Hot Smart Rich brand is about like embracing your full self and like doing everything in your power to just like have a life that you're so proud of sometimes that's business sometimes it's finance sometimes it is relationships and it's so funny where it's a double-edged sword where it's like when you're so brave to be able to share that part of your life so many people will take that and be like she's using this as like clickbait or to build a business like how do you think about your life in terms of like okay this is like what I'm living for me and this is what like is actually helping people and can be turned into a business and monetized um well for okay so i either that's a multi multi-pronged question there um when i'm thinking about what i can and can't post i think it's easy with when it comes to my kids there came a moment where i started realizing that my son would eventually um get a little bit older yeah his parents his kids his friends the parents of those friends and stuff they have access to social media it just felt strange there was some time in lockdown where social media seemed to change the vibe totally the vibe completely changed it felt less friendly it felt a little less um I don't even know how to explain it because I'd been online for so long at that point that this felt like a very big 180 in the in the way that being online felt and it didn't feel safe to me to put my children online and it felt like suddenly this wasn't their decision and so I just completely stopped doing that um now my son doesn't want to be online at all he just whenever I even try to record him he's like absolutely not you know how old is he he's eight see that's so smart that he even knows that though because so many kids I feel like are so interested in it like I look at Alex Earl's siblings and I'm like oh these kids want to be like chronically online already so young that it's interesting that your son is already like no I actually don't want to be like that do you know why that is um well he's very aware I think of social media because he's had an iPad for a while um and he thinks it's cool like he I have this picture of him where he he discovered I had them packed up my YouTube plaques where you know it shows that I hit a hundred thousand subscribers and I've got two of those because I have two channels and then I hit a million subscribers and I got a gold plaque for that and he found them and he was like it clicked for him he was like oh my god this is what my mom does and he he took he actually took a picture with my with my YouTube plaques being he was just like really proud of that so I think I think kids are very aware of social media yeah maybe not the repercussions and how long it how permanent it is right?

11:11But, um, but I think they're aware of it for sure. So when you were saying that things changed during COVID from being online, how many years were you online before that happened? Um, with my own personal, with my YouTube channel, mixed makeup, I had probably been online for about seven, eight years at that point, but I had been online for publications and media companies for since 2004. So a long time. I've been online for a very, very long time. Not as my own, like as a, as a media personality, basically. So was this the time when you said that you didn't feel safe, that you were canceled online?

11:48Yeah. Yeah. Can we talk about that? You know, I wouldn't even call it a cancel. Okay. Let's talk about this. When I think about people getting canceled to me at the time, it felt very intense, right? Like it felt like, Oh my God, I've been squeaky clean online for years and I've never done anything wrong. I can't believe this is happening. And then, um, you know, when you look at people who get canceled for things that are just awful. Yeah. And then you look at my situation. Wait, so for anyone that's listening that doesn't know what happened, can you explain what happened? So when I, while we were in lockdown, because of everything that was happening with the pandemic and COVID, the contract manufacturer I was working with at the time for a completely different brand basically sent me an email and shut it all down.

12:29They were like, they were based in Korea and they were just like, you, we, we, unfortunately because of this virus that's going around can't take on any new clients so we're sorry all the stuff that we've worked on the last few months we're gonna have to put a hold on this and it really occurred to me that I needed I needed to find somebody else to help me with this business and so I found my old business partner and at the time he had just started Noturium and and as we got deeper into the lockdown we were both kind of like you know why would we work on two separate brands this is a weird time at that point in in lockdown nobody had really we didn't really know that there was going to be this boom with e-com yeah right everybody just assumed like everything's going down like you could actually get a house at a really good deal at that point it was crazy people were like stocking up on toilet paper like it was a wild time so he was like you know notorium's a new brand it's a baby brand you've already helped to shape it with your point of view the way that you've you know like talked about it with your viewers and everything and the way you've been even convinced me to switch things up because he had started as a clean brand and I was like this isn't a clean brand this is a science brand this is a science-backed brand clinically tested results like this is what you need to be focusing on with this and um and so we were like you know what if there were ever a time to just last minute join forces let's do it yeah because we had no idea what was gonna happen what was gonna happen right so we joined up but at that point I didn't talk I stopped talking about the brand online.

13:58Okay. Because now this is like, how many times do you post it about the brand before? Maybe like three times. Okay. I know. Yeah, I know. But, um, but still three times. And, uh, and I wasn't the owner at that point. I didn't even know I was going to become the owner. Right. And then, um, you know, it, this conversation started happening. I stopped talking about it. There's like a true gap. I remember saying there was this, uh, I want to say it was a beauty independent article where they like put, like put a graph of like how many times I talked about the brand before I announced my, my ownership of the brand.

14:29And you can see there's this three times I talk about the brand and then there's this gap, like two months where I go silent about the brand online. And then I announced that I'm the owner. And, um, and I'm like, does, does anyone at all think about like what might've been happening at that point? It was that I'm in negotiations with my, my business partner, like to try to become an owner. It's a brand that's already started. He's already put money into it. Now we got to negotiate how this works out for me to come on as a co-owner. And even at that, we didn't expect to really talk about the, for me to talk about the brand because it was just a, it was a strange time, right?

15:03I wanted to get my hands on the brand, really turn it into a brand that I had put all of my influence into and then announce it when it felt like a really good time to do that. And you know, who knew when that was going to be, but I had signed the paperwork in early June and then there was a reporter from, I'm actually going to call it out from into the gloss and uh she's no longer there i don't think everyone said she was like the nicest person there were all these like like people online who had i can't remember what it was um my business partner had posted something that alluded to who the owners of the brand were okay and uh and he i hadn't signed my paperwork yet and he even gave me like a hard time he teased me he's like you better sign that paperwork because i'm posting this you know to like people are asking who are the owners and and he's like i'm gonna post something kind of ambiguous and you better sign it like he's teasing me yeah yeah and um so he put something like the two owners are Asian for him Asian Hispanic for me and then his like few uh employees that were working for him at the time and I saw that post go up on social media I didn't even have access to the social media at that point because I was not an owner yet and I said to him you know what's funny there aren't that many Asian Hispanic people in the skincare industry I wonder if anyone's gonna notice that and he's like oh that's so niche like no no one's gonna know people are creeps online like they connect dots that you would be like how did you know that yeah and in hours a reddit post goes up and it's like conspiracy theories susan yara is the owner of naturium and she's been talking about this brand and not disclosing that she's the owner and we were like wow and so i here's where i'm like the person that that probably messed up in the in the way that i handled it and that is i'm a very um i'm a very stubborn person it made me mad when's birthday?

16:50Um, a Leo I'm August. Okay. I'm all fixed signs, by the way. My big three are like all fixed signs. Okay. I'm a Leo. I'm a Scorpio moon and I'm a rising. Yeah. You're so stubborn. So unbelievably stubborn. So instead of just being like, Oh, you guys like long story short, here's what happened. Just clearing this up. Instead. I was like, Oh, I'm going to egg them on. Oh, you like fed into the drama. Oh my God. That is like the complete opposite for me. I'm so like whenever I feel like I've done something wrong I immediately just get like panicked like I need to solve the problem but you were like I'm gonna like feed into this yeah I was like this is so rude of them like how dare they like try to try to accuse me of something that I've never that I haven't done but in reality I should have again this is this is social media had changed right everybody's kind of upset we're in lockdown there's a lot of injustices that are being you know put in the in the forefront yeah and and I really should have read the room a little bit better I really should have um but I didn't and and so I just decided you know what I'm just gonna and you know I was talking to my business partner he's like you worked so hard for this moment like don't let don't let this become a thing that that brings you down instead why don't you just announce it announce you're the owner we'll handle like we'll do some interviews and stuff and you'll get to tell the story of how you and I met how we became business partners and it'll all be fine because this is how social media used to be and how things online was it fine absolutely not no so it was like a disaster as soon as you what so how did you announce it did you have like a pr plan or you just went on live and you were like people i loved seeing people saying like she really like her pr agency really steered her wrong her like you know like all these things i'm like what do you guys we're all in lockdown i'm not even in person with anybody i'm sitting on my sofa with a six-month-old baby on my boob like i don't even we're not we're like just all watching and feeling the same way that everyone else is feeling.

18:43We're in this lockdown. Anyway, so we're ignoring it, ignoring it. And then this one girl who was just the most upset, like she was like the leader of the pack with this whole like cancel Susan situation. She went around to the media and she started saying, I've got this theory that Susan, that this like woman who's on YouTube has been pitching this brand to all of her viewers and not disclosing that she's the owner. And someone from Into the Gloss went ahead and bit. They were like, oh, we'll look into this. so fast forward to June and uh and and by the way I'm hearing about this I like like friends are calling you being like there's a story going around their own Facebook group that where it was like all about canceling me so I had like friends in that group that were like watching what they were posting and stuff it was really strange but how do you as like someone that has a six-month-old baby like feeding off of your body literally like handle the pressure of knowing that there is a group going around to cancel you and like take away your livelihood well in your mind you're like I haven't done anything wrong so like like if I truly did something wrong and meant to like hurt people yeah to people whatever then maybe I'd be like really nervous yeah but in some ways I was I was not seeing it from their perspective right I was seeing it from my perspective and I was like what's going on here yeah right like this feels wild and I'm not I haven't even done anything in my opinion I I was thinking in my head like I haven't even like done anything really really bad like these people were like a pitchfork being like we need to go and destroy her life where you're like wait why though yeah so then okay so you basically have to launch your brand with all of this negative cloud over you there's reporters but okay so so uh let me take it back to the reporter so this one reporter goes to the pr company yeah that we're working with as a brand right and she says she's worked with them plenty of times she's a beauty reporter and she says, hey, I want to do this roundup on serums and I want to include one from Notarium.

20:38And I can't find who the owners are online. It seems very strange. And so the first person she reaches out to on the team doesn't respond back because they know it's like a weird, sensitive issue. I only signed the paperwork like a week before. And then she emails again. She's like, hey, just following up on this question, she emails another person on the team. And that person writes back, oh, the owner is Susan Yara, but it's embargoed information. she doesn't get any more context from there doesn't know that I just signed my paperwork a week before nothing and again I'm in the background kind of like like egging people on whatever they want to think this let them you know that kind of thing so she goes back to these people and she's like you guys were right like confirmed she is the owner she doesn't even write a story she just goes back to the Facebook group and like the leader of the screenshots of it wow so there was no article on into the gloss that was like okay no she just on her own was like but I like to think about the time of our lives at that moment and everybody was like on edge everyone was on edge and everyone was trying to do the right thing so I like to think that a lot of these people thought they were doing the right thing right there's probably a lot of people in that Facebook community that weren't like pitchforks we want to like cancel Susan Yara so many people probably were like open to being suede right so how do you start rebuilding trust with your community to now put Naturium in like this amazing light that I grew into yeah well actually I can and finally say this, you're gonna get some scoop here.

22:03So I didn't get a chance to actually talk about what happened for the longest time because the FTC called me. And they were like, we've never received this many complaints about an influencer ever. In like the history of the FTC, they were like, we are gonna have to do an investigation into this. You had an investigation from the FTC. I had an investigation. Wait, please talk about this. Because I literally just talked about this on a podcast episode about Revolve and like these three influencers that were named in this case. Yeah. What happened? So they basically, it's very intrusive. They make you hand over every form of communication with anybody that might be even closely, like slightly involved with the brand.

22:43And so they, and they, you have to give all this information, prove that I just signed my paperwork. I hadn't been like purposely trying to lie to people and not. Deceit people. It's like, you have to prove all this stuff. the thing is you would think it'd be very straightforward but it's the government right you had a lawsuit versus the government essentially yeah and uh and the and again like I wasn't that worried because I knew I hadn't done anything wrong right besides being a jerk right besides being like a person who decided to be stubborn and egg everybody on instead of just being forthright right um and uh but the problem is they were like if I was like well I gotta discuss this online like I'm a YouTuber I'm an influencer my community is going to expect me to address to them what happened and they're like if you talk about it then we have to open up everything to the public and I was like oh no no thank you like they've got my text messages and I'm talking text messages you can't erase anything like you have to give them everything so your most personal like if you're telling your friends like oh like about a BJ that is going to the FTC everything they're reading everything.

23:50Like it's, it's, it doesn't matter if it's like mixed into these conversations about your business as well. Like any conversation, you cannot pull any of it out. So you have to send it all over for a period of time that they asked for. So how long did this investigation go on for? It took almost two years. And then it's closed now. Yeah. They were like, sure enough, they send an email to our attorney and they're like, oh yeah. Like basically they were like, there's nothing to see here we're moving on you know like thank you that was it but I had to wait for two years to get that answer and then at that point it just felt like all right why even yeah like I'm like is it hard for you to talk about now where it like it's so irrelevant to your life but it's like it's still a big part of the story um it's not hard to talk about there was a moment it definitely changed the way I felt about being online.

24:38Okay. And it changed how, you know, like what I wanted to start, what I wanted to talk about. I feel like I used to be so completely open online and you could find anything about me. And if people asked me things, I would share everything. And it kind of closed me off because I felt like people who I had opened up to and really given my time to, a lot of these people were in my own private Facebook group for mixed makeup. And in there, I was always accessible, right like if they had questions about products we would make jokes we would have fun it was a really fun community and it just really put a damper on it and I think it did that unfortunately for a lot of my community too where we all felt like this fun community and then it felt less fun right you know have you been able to still do stuff with that community and like just in a different way um I think that I've had I'll say actually overall um this was a small group of people that were upset with me like the 80 20 rule like maybe even less than 20 right like I I would say that if anything, what it really showed me, I, there were like two or three days there where I just closed off, cried for days.

25:41Right. Like where I was like, Oh my God, my, my career is over everything I've worked for, everything I've built. My team was so sad. Cause they'd been there building it with me, you know? And even they had been like, you should just tell everybody what happened. Like just tell everybody the story. And I'm like, you're like, I can't though, because also because of the FTC. Wow. So what has made you decide to start talking about your divorce um people start noticing I wasn't wearing a ring okay that happened to me too so they noticed they noticed that real quick yeah um and uh and I just felt like eventually if I start dating or if they don't see me with my kids or because it's surprising how many people know you in person right also after you've been online for so long I don't have this massive massive following but because I think I've been online for so long people will recognize me or will have watched some of my videos or bought some of my products or something.

26:30And so they'll have questions. Right. And so I just felt like this was a really important detail because everyone knew me as a married woman. So if they saw me like out on a date or something, can you imagine people are like, I mean, shoot, I know how Reddit works. Like, like, oh, we saw Susan like cheating on her husband or something. So I was like, I'm just going to shut this down as soon as possible. I've learned from my lessons of like keeping things to myself that are really important to put out there. So I just went ahead and announced it and just kept it at that. How did it feel? Um, very, very final.

27:01Um, but good. You know, I, I, I think divorce, especially I was with my husband for 15 years. We were married for 13 years. So a very long time. Yeah. And, um, and I think what people don't realize is as a woman, I think that we take a long time to grieve that relationship before we even make that final decision. We probably have tried to fix it or have talks or do whatever, even with ourselves, right? Like what could I do to make this work? Before you finally get to that point where you're like, I am so done. So I think when I announced it, it felt very final to me and there was almost like a relief.

27:37So you started Naturium in 2021, 2020. So you were still married when you guys started it. And I guess like you have achieved truly like the hot, smart, rich lifestyle. Like you sold your business within three years of building it for$355 million. Has anybody else ever done that? Um, K-18 built theirs in about three years. Okay. All around the same time, actually. So as you have stepped into like this hot, smart, rich financial freedom power, did that change the dynamic of your relationship and your role in your marriage? I would say it probably played a factor, but before that I was already doing really well as a content creator.

28:16Okay. So I was already the breadwinner. Okay. Um, and, uh, and it was already in that direction. Right. Going in that direction. I think it's so interesting because money sometimes actually makes things so much more complicated and sometimes it makes it easier. What do you think like now that you have sold your business, like your relationship with money is like as it stands today? Yeah. Um, I mean, obviously it's, it's easier. Things are easier, right? When you have money, you're not as stressed out about, you know, like little things. Like if my kids get sick, I know I can handle it. I have a lot of privilege now, right?

28:49Like I get to spend a lot of time working on myself. I get to go to the gym and work out with a trainer all the time. Get a spray tan that looks amazing a week later. Like what is the secret? I get my spray tan whenever I want. I get lymphatic drainage every month. You know, I get to do a lot of these things where I'm focusing on myself. I feel like I'm on a big wellness journey and it's partially because I get to focus on myself now, right? And I have the money to do that. I was able to retire my parents that was a big dream of mine right get my mom a new car do all these things get them to you know just live a peaceful life because they were part of the rat race too right they were doing the constant day-to-day nine-to-five job where they barely I feel like they barely made ends meet and they were still doing this into their 60s you know so it felt really good to be able to help them and to be able to tell my nieces and my nephew that they're good.

29:38They want to go to school wherever they want to go, get good grades. I've got them. Do you feel like though, that now that you have achieved financial success, like people's relationship with you has changed because you have money. Like, are you constantly like picking up the bill when you're going out for dinner with girlfriends? And like, that's something I see when I'm around certain people in my life. It's like, they're just expected to do things versus it being like a treat for people or like you wanting to do it because it's out of the kindness of your heart. um I've always had this abundance mentality even when I was broke where I was like I'm good with paying for everybody I'm not gonna like I'm not gonna sit around thinking oh I only had I don't drink right like okay you don't forever barely have like a drink maybe a drink and I'll babysit that drink at dinner or something it's really just to be like make everybody else comfortable around me that they're not like oh god she's not drinking you know yeah um so I barely drink and uh and, you know, when I go out to dinner with people and they are drinking, right, or like, like couples and they're both drinking and I'm here like one Prosecco and, you know, like, and like one plate of food, whereas everyone's like getting a bunch of stuff and everything.

30:44I've never been the person to be like, um, excuse me, I only, I only owe$40. You guys owe 500 each, but I only owe 40. Like, I've always been of the mentality that like, if someone needs something, help them. If somebody, if you're like, you know, you're going to go do something, but you can't take someone with you because someone can't come with you because they can't afford the ticket to the concert buy the ticket for them if you can do it because it's going to be so much more fun if we're doing this together and you figure it out anyway and I've always felt that way like if I spend if I'm spending money and I'm at this point where I need a certain amount of money I'm gonna personally figure out how to get that money yeah right and it just kind of pushes me to keep getting it you have a true rich person mindset which is like you're not thinking and this is something I learned recently is like rich people think about how can I make more money and then make my money work for me whereas poor people or poor-minded people think like I need to save the money and like control the money and have it so tight to my chest what are the things that you're doing to make your money work for you now that you've achieved this financial success I do want to take a step back I grew up really poor yeah dirt poor okay and I and I do think that there is a little bit of this mentality right yeah you are trying to figure out how to just survive, right?

31:55And there's a cycle that I don't think people really consider if they didn't grow up poor, if they're not poor. You're in a cycle where everything seems to go against you, right? You don't have enough money to make rent this month, but now your child just got sick, so you're going to have to take them to the emergency room. There's extra fees around that. Your car suddenly breaks down. So now you have to pay for, you know, because you don't have a brand new car. You have a little hoopty ride, right? Like you're trying to just get around with that car. And that car gets you to work too by the way um so now your car breaks or you got a flat tire you need to replace the tire that's gonna be another 250 300 and then you park it you know like trying to figure out something and then you suddenly get a parking ticket in los angeles that can cost you 200 right and you're sitting here thinking how in a matter of a week did i just like get go in debt for like a thousand extra dollars and i can't even pay my rent yet yeah you know and it turns into this really crazy cycle where I feel like you cannot get ahead when you are poor.

32:53Yeah. And that just continues to happen every single time that every day of your life as a poor person. So of course they're thinking I need to hold on whenever I totally they don't come into chunks of money. They owe money. Yeah. You know and and life is how did you pull yourself out of that though coming from that family background? I truly believe that it's a mentality that you're born with. Right. Like I really, really think that success and, and, and knowing that you're going to go do something big, you're just that person. I have always, always thought that I, I always knew that if I worked really hard, I focused and I, and I knew what I wanted to achieve, that I was going to achieve it.

33:31And I always thought that even as a poor little girl, like I, you know, I, I'd be in rooms where I probably didn't even belong. And I, I'd be like first to speak up, you know, like, you're not getting me to shut up. Yeah. I'm going to like, let you know what I'm thinking. And I've just always been that person. Do you think that that is what, like when you look at your kids and now that they have a mom who has achieved this, like, do you think that they are going to have that same hustle, that same grind for themselves? I hope so. You know, this is my Roman empire. You know this, right? Like I, I think about this on a very regular basis.

34:03How do I raise children that are not brats first off, right? Because they do have access to anything that they basically want, anything they need, right? Whereas I used to have to watch my parents struggle through things. Their first languages weren't English either, right? My dad spoke Spanish, my mom spoke Korean. So as a five-year-old, as soon as I learned how to read and write, I was translating things for them. I was writing letters for them when they needed to send a letter to work or to the school. I was watching them really have to struggle through things, right? And it obviously created something in me that made me want to succeed to be able to take care of this.

34:39and not be in that situation like them, right? My kids don't see that. And I actually, there was this moment, I remember it was a couple years ago, my ex-husband was watching ESPN and this athlete, they had just like won something, let's say it was like, I don't think it was like Super Bowl, but it was a big moment for this athlete and he's being interviewed and he's talking about how his mom was a single mom and she worked so hard, she worked three jobs to be able to get him through everything and be there and support him. And I said, you know, it's crazy to me, you know like obviously like amazing for that guy and his mom that he's gotten where he is because of her help but my kids didn't see my struggle right they didn't see my growth and they didn't see how hard I had to work to get where I am um and uh and so they're not going to experience that gratitude right you know so I keep thinking about how do we how do we do this like how do we make it so that they can feel that gratitude feel that get have a little bit of grit yeah right and I truly don't have the answer for it.

Read the full transcript

35:37Well, it's so funny. I don't, not that I'm giving parental advice since I don't have children, but actually my boyfriend and I were talking with this yesterday at F1 because we were lucky to go enough in the JP Morgan box. And you know, it's like their top whatever clients world in the North America. And there was these two girls that were beautiful wearing these gorgeous dresses. There may be like 16 and 18. And he looks at me and he's like, with our kids, they will never be going to events like this ever because like that gets in their head that like, that's the norm where it's like, that is such a privilege and such like an opportunity to be able to do.

36:08But when your 16 year old woman is like child is dressing up, wearing the most beautiful forward dress and going to these events, you just think that that's normal. And it's like, that's so far from normal that I feel like just as little things like that, because I know some of like the richest people's children who have grinded it out and built a name for themselves. I don't know if you've watched Phoebe Gates, but she just built the burnouts and she's building Fia and you know, Alex Cooper asked her, like, how have you remained so normal with like your parents and she acknowledges her privilege and is like but I'm still gonna make a name for myself and I think that there is a way to do it it's just like incredibly difficult to figure out like what is the right steps of that right well so some of the things that I have been doing with my kids especially with my son because he's at an age he's eight years old where he now wants to buy things right he asks can we have this can I buy this lego can we go to target tomorrow yeah that kind of thing right and I talked to him a lot about how mommy is working right they see me travel a lot right work and they get upset that I have to leave so I always point out to them I'm leaving to work yeah and why do you why do I work right and then I try to teach them the value of money because I used to say these things all the time too we're never going to take them to F1 guess who's been to F1 twice now your son my son yeah yeah like not wearing a dress from forward yeah you know like he's gone to F1 yeah he's gone to some really amazing things places he's he's he's traveled the world at this point because why would we keep them from doing that if we have the ability to do it it's about teaching them though that this is a privilege that you know this took hard work right it took money um there are things that you have to do and by the way have you seen that quote from ben affleck where i think it was ben affleck he was like his son wanted these like thousand dollar sneakers or something and uh and he was like absolutely not why would you need thousand dollar sneakers and his son was like well we've got the money he goes i've got the money you don't have the money you're broke yeah you know and so i think talking to your kids about how they can make money yeah I say to my son all the time let's discuss ways that you can earn some money if you want there was this like robot he saw you know in Selfridges see this is my son right like he's at Selfridges in London during the holidays right and he's like oh there's this robot that it's like a transformer robot that costs almost two thousand dollars and he's like oh I want that I'm like well this is almost two thousand dollars right how are you going to earn the money for this and so he I haven't bought it for him yet he's gonna to earn that money.

38:29And then he can, he can get that, that robot if he wants it. I love that. Okay. You talk a lot about building with hard work. Can we just talk about how you built Naturium and sold it within three years for$355 million? Well, first off, I tell everybody it wasn't in three years. My YouTube channel has, is 11 years old at this point. So I really feel like I built the, the groundwork for Naturium with my YouTube channel by focusing on skincare education, being you know up front with people about cosmetic treatments and having experts on to talk about these things and I feel like people really got to understand skincare and really trust in my opinion about skincare so I think by the time Notarium launched even with the drama that was happening in the background I'm telling you there were so many more people that were so excited yeah about the announcement of this brand um that you know I think that it just it had already it was people were waiting for it yes what do you think the biggest double standard is that you faced as a creator founded brand um I think the assumption is that because you're a creator you don't you can't be a business person right and um there's no doubt that I had so much help from my business partner he's a genius he's an icon in the beauty industry people don't realize that I you should probably try to get Ben Bennett on your podcast because he is the definition of hot, smart, and rich.

39:52Okay, I love it. Had he sold a brand before he had sold this one with you? Not a specific brand. He had an incubator before that called Hatch Beauty that he sold his part in. Okay. And then he learned a lot of lessons from that. And one of those lessons was he should build brands for himself and sell those. Yeah. And it was genius. And this is the first one that he sold through his incubation house? Exactly. Okay. And why did you guys decide to go with Elf? They were the best fit. Okay. We, you know, people don't realize this. when you are trying to sell your company or even when you're trying to get a big investment, you almost go through like a dating series.

40:25Yeah. And it takes months and months and months. You know this because you've been on that side of getting investments and deals. But the, you know, when we start going through the process, I actually, I tell this story to a lot of people. I had told my ex-business partner like a year before we even sold, I was like, Elf is going to be the company that buys us. I don't know why, I just knew it. Like I just, I could see where they were going I felt like their principles and the way that they treat their employees and the way that they view things, they don't really even consider themselves a beauty company.

40:57They just see themselves as this publicly traded company, and they're trying to do things better. Right. They actually have more women on their board than any other publicly traded company. They really try to help their employees. They give them equity in the company. Wow. Well, stock in the company. Yeah, equity. And, you know, like they just really take that into account and they try to make this a big family as much as they can as a company that's growing bigger and bigger. And I felt like they really understood what we were trying to do with excessively priced products. All of our products for Natarium, the big thing for me was how can a person be consistent with their skincare routine if they can't afford their monthly routine?

41:35Wow, it's so amazing to hear that because just like after this interview, understanding where you came from, it's like you didn't just be like i want to build a la mer like for people that you didn't grow up it's like it's built for like the person that was in your life from a childhood it's like the brand yes was around for three years before it sold but like to your point 11 years before that but it actually the roots of it sounds like it started from when you were in your childhood my childhood and i'll tell you i um this is a story i shared a lot in the beginning of noturium when i first became um like a beauty editor i was at forbes magazine i was really covering just lifestyle in general but beauty was a part of that beat and I started receiving all the really expensive luxury products in PR and I started taking some of that home to my mom because I was so excited about it I'm like mom you have to try this cream it's worth hundreds of dollars this serum and then I would come back a few months later and it would all be sitting on top of her dresser unused and when I would ask her why aren't you using these products I didn't even pay for them why wouldn't you use them and she's like you told me they're expensive and I don't want to waste them and I think to this day people do think this way when it comes to luxury products right even with purses if you think about like there are people who are like I only take this bag out because when it's like a special occasion or something right it's like why aren't you using that bag it's actually me with candles so like when someone buys me a really nice like dipty candle or um what's the one that someone just bought me this morning um loeve and I'm like I will never use this because I don't want to waste and it's so crazy or like when am I going to be able to afford another the weve candle i just have to keep this one on my drawer it's like so true yeah this is exactly how people think but when it comes to skincare in order to see in order to see results with your skincare you have to use those products at as many days a week as you can usually it's it's really you're going to see results if you use it every single night or every single morning right whatever it is that that product requires you to use it at whatever consistency right and you have to use it for at least six weeks before you see a beginning of a change right you have to see you have to really consistently use it you'll start to see changes and then three months later if you consistently use it that's when you'll really see what was supposed to happen but most people when they spend too much money on their products they won't do that what's the average price point of naturium on average like 24 yeah it's amazing and it's all that like target ulta online anywhere else amazon um globally we're in space and k in the uk uh boots in the uk yeah shoppers drug mart in canada love um we're also in australia online um where else and italy actually okay that's amazing you keep saying x business partner are you and ben no longer business partners no because uh he when we sold the company he took a step out so he's totally out of the business now out of the business he was an investor he was my my mentor my biggest champion and he's got way more businesses to still work on and so what has your role adapted or evolved to now that you've been acquired?

44:29So my role is as the founder, I still work on innovation. That's a really big part, helping to figure out what products we should be creating next, how to market them and talk about them. Education, I do a lot of the marketing side when it comes to appearances and really working with consumers and influencers on getting them excited about the brand. So I'd say that's my primary role right now. What is it like working in such a large conglomerate as Elf, like managing all of your other responsibilities, like creating content and like your YouTube channel and now a podcast and like being an amazing mom.

45:00Elf is amazing to work with. Okay. If there is ever a company to sell your brand to, it would be Elf. It really is the best. They didn't lock me into this crazy contract where I like can't do anything else the rest of my life. And you know, like I'm gonna have to stay with them for years and years and years. They made it really straightforward and put a lot of trust into me. And they, I mean, part of, they knew that being a content creator is a big part of what I do and benefits the brand, right? Totally. And so, um, so they were like, keep going, just, just keep going, keep doing what you do.

45:33And we'll be happy with that. Do you have a specific period of time? Like, are you like to talk? What if you haven't earned out? Um, I, I can, I can walk out anytime now. I can give a 30 day notice that I'm telling you they're great. They're great. But you just love building this brand. Like that's what I think so many founders listening to this don't think about. And even creators, they think like, how can I start a brand to sell it and then like go and do something else but I think people can spot authenticity and it's like so evident when you're building something for an exit and then your plan is to exit out of that whereas like you like would you want to be doing anything else other than building I cannot imagine not being part of an attorney it's and I actually I had said this to a lot of the people that we were talking to when we were trying to sell the company first off we sold the company because in some ways you kind of have to right you get so big we were growing so rapidly I tell people this all the time one of the hardest things of being a startup brand is finding cash.

46:24Yeah. Right. Like trying to keep it going. It's amazing that we're so in demand, but then you have to have the money to be able to continue with that growth or you get stuck or, and it might cause you to have to shut down. So you, you, you're in this constant cycle doing this. So to sell it to a big company like that, it takes a lot of the pressure off. And then I get to focus on the things that I do the best when it comes to the brand. Right. And that is the marketing, the innovation. in that three-year period where you were like okay we're growing like insane so many founders listening to this like have a business they have something in their hands and they're like I can't move product like what do you think you would tell that person that's listening that's like I don't have these crazy budgets what can you be doing that's going to move product I think everyone should be on social media and we were just talking about another guest that you yeah that you want to have on or that she's coming on tomorrow yeah um you know i i think people underestimate that you can get on social media and start new and these days because of the way the algorithm works you don't have to having a big following doesn't even seem to matter anymore no it's really about how do you connect with audience and how do you get into the algorithm and the for you page and if you can do that and figure out how to connect you can sell your products did you guys start selling on tiktok shop well you know what it we had it was like It's so strange to me.

47:43We had a big issue getting all of our products onto the platform. And so we only recently got onto TikTok shop. So we were late to the game when it came to that. But also it's amazing, like for people that are listening that don't know how it works, like an acquirer really wants to be able to like open up different distribution channels and make sure that you're not everywhere and that's where you're at. So it's like, it's actually an amazing opportunity for you guys to be able to like go into TikTok shop now. And that's actually, so Ben used to call it, leave a little meat on the bones for the buyer, right?

48:09Like you can't, because we had the opportunity to open up more distribution, be bigger globally. Again, it would have costed us more money. We would have been working harder and maybe not smarter, right? But you also are keeping in the back of your mind, well, what would a big company come in and do if you're doing all of it yourself, right? So you do have to actually give them an opportunity where they can do it and do it better, right? Where they're excited also to help you grow. That's crazy. okay so now that you're like okay I have Natrium it has its home I have all the budgets in the world I'm like a free single woman like what is next for you free single woman um like I said I'm on this wellness journey um I've been really learning how to co-parent it's it's not as easy as people think um it's harder on the kids I think so do you guys have that I've heard a lot of people doing this where when they divorce they actually get like a family home where the mom and dad actually rotate in and the kids stay the same I have a friend who did that um she's actually a beauty brand founder divya i don't even know that she she started uh she was co-founder of wander beauty oh love they just sold right yeah yeah they did yeah um she has the best eye patches actually this is the eye patch that hayley bieber uses and i swear to god when i wear them incredible yeah and she she says that that's like her hero her hero product um anyway but she did that when she got a divorce she and her ex-husband kept one home and they just rotated i i think that would take a lot of coordination I think that I don't know I think you have to have a different kind of relationship with your ex also to be able to do that my ex and I are in a decent place I wouldn't say that we're in this place where we want to be besties right and so she had a situation where she was like she's besties with her ex do you think that with dating new people that there's like once they hear about you being online and like you talking with things is there like a oh my gosh I don't want that to be me I have yet to experience that okay every first off um like I I I kind of started with apps right okay I was like screw it why not you know what apps Raya like no I didn't actually do Raya I did hinge and I actually even checked out field wait how have I never not heard of fields field is like a hookup app it was like really wild I just was curious I'm like this is interesting um and you realize like you don't have to put much about you like as a woman you don't really have to try I don't think you have to try very hard I agree Yeah, and so you just like go put yourself out there.

50:33And I think my mentality was I wasn't necessarily looking for a new couple. A forever? Yeah. Are you looking for a forever now? I don't know. I think I'm more open-minded to whatever happens happens. Do you think that you'll get married again? I don't know. I don't know. Marriage is hard. Marriage is hard. I'm not going to say no, but it would have to be the right person. It would have to feel so good in my gut and in my bones to just be like, you know what? Yeah. I'm going to marry this person. Okay. Because otherwise, I don't know why you get married, honestly. I know. I'm like about like, it's so crazy because for me, I, I, I still want to be married.

51:09And I think I've like found the person that it's like worth it for, but I know it's not going to be all easy, right? Like there's so much that is the work and you always hear that. But I do think that if you do find someone, and this is like what I keep coming back to is like that you want to be a witness to your life, not necessarily like the rules of marriage, but just like someone that you want there and you feel like you can work through the really hard things with them, like that is what makes it worth it. Yeah. Will you get a prenup when you get married? Yeah. Did you have a prenup? Nope.

51:38That makes it hard. We'll just leave it at that. Okay. Okay. Let's do some rapid fire to finish up. Okay. Okay. Who would you switch beauty closets with? Eczema isn't always obvious, but it's real. And so is the relief from EBCLIS. After an initial dosing phase, about 4 in 10 people taking EBCLIS achieved itch relief and clear or almost clear skin at 16 weeks. And most of those people maintain skin that's still more clear at one year with monthly dosing. EBCLIS, LibriKizumab, LBKZ, a 250 milligram per two milliliter injection, is a prescription medicine used to treat adults and children 12 years of age and older who weigh at least 88 pounds or 40 kilograms with moderate to severe eczema.

52:17Also called atopic dermatitis that is not well controlled with prescription therapies used on the skin or topicals or who cannot use topical therapies. EPCLIS can be used with or without topical corticosteroids. Don't use if you're allergic to EPCLIS. Allergic reactions can occur that can be severe. Eye problems can occur. Tell your doctor if you have new or worsening eye problems. You should not receive a live vaccine when treated with EPCLIS. Before starting EPCLIS, tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. Searching for real relief? Ask your doctor about EPCLIS and visit ePCLIS.lily.com or call 1-800-LILY-RX or 1-800-545-5979.

52:48Tuesday on NBC. Jimmy Fallon and Bozema St. John host the highly anticipated new competition show. I hired 10 creatives from all walks of life. They will be battling it out to see who can impress the world's biggest brands. This is a huge opportunity. This is the battle for the next big idea. This is not play play. We're spending millions of dollars. I'm so excited to embark on this adventure with all of you. Make the best idea win! On brand with Jimmy Fallon. Series premiere Tuesday on NBC. see beauty closets with oh I have a pretty good one who would I I know this is a hard one it would have to be a makeup girl because like are you more a skincare girly I'm a skincare girly so I have mostly skincare but I spend my money on makeup and hair care and all that stuff so it'd be somebody like that probably like Michaela or somebody who has like access to all of it yeah hers must be insane.

53:45She probably gets access to every product she wants. Okay. I was going to ask this one later, but it's a good one based on what we just said. What is the best and most favorite beauty brand of yours that isn't yours? Ooh, let's see. That isn't mine. There's more like, I see products come out from brands that I'm like, genius. I wish I would have done that genius. I thought, I wish I would have started that. Um, let's see. Uh, you know, I really love all the little indie brands. I feel like indie brands are really changing, especially the skincare industry and the way that we think about products.

54:21So I'd say it's, it's probably some of these like indie brands. I wish I would have been part of them. Not necessarily been the person that started them, but maybe been part of it. Are you investing now? I am investing. Yeah. Okay. What's like the type of company that gets you excited? It's really hard to get me excited. I've found, um, don't you believe that like when you have so much experience and you know how hard it is, you just become like this is never going to work this is literally like it you become your naivety goes away and it's so much harder to get behind things yeah I you know what I find is actually the hardest is when people just want to pick my brain I just want to pick your brain and then and it's not that I I listen I'll give people my brain like they want to pick my brain take me out to some coffee and ask me some questions and inevitably I almost always think their idea has flaws big flaws and and I hate having to tell them that but I'm going to tell them that if I want to pick my brain.

55:12Have you made an investment since you sold your company? I've made a couple. Okay. Yeah. And what was like different? Cause I think so many people are listening to this are going to be like, I'm that person that like, if I email Susan, like I have that idea. Like what was it about those, the thread, the through line with those people that was like, I'm going to invest in their company. I think it's that first off, there's got to be a certain amount of passion from the founder or founders, right? Where you just believe that they're gonna they're gonna do this no matter what nothing will stop them i really believe like what they call now online like having delulu being delulu um i i don't think it's being delulu i think it's that they just i told you this from the beginning i just always knew what i put my mind to i was gonna achieve it yeah right i didn't know how quickly or whatever but i always knew that i would put my mind to it i would work hard and i would achieve whatever i set my goals to and you know when you meet those kinds of people yeah so I think that that's number the first thing yeah and sometimes when I meet those kinds of people I don't need to hear anything else you're just like okay I'm gonna wire it to you um but obviously to be smart yeah I have people behind me to be hot smart rich yeah you have people that also watch out for you yeah um you know I'll run it by like my financial advisors my portfolio manager um and we'll discuss what we think should and shouldn't be done.

56:33Okay. And, and yeah, so I think that like, once we look at their financials, their deck, everything and see that they've got a really solid idea and the personality to really have the stamina. Yeah. Cause that's, that's the big one. Yeah. So I think then that, that can sell me, but I really like, if you guys are like, Oh God, we've got an investor here. Trust me. I'm very, very picky. I actually feel like the next era for you is going to be a shark tank judge really i really see that for you like i think you have the personality obviously for being on camera but you also have the chops like you actually know what it's gonna take so i actually am putting this into the world i am manifesting slash predicting that susan yara will be a shark on shark tank miami or la a miami oh i love miami what about the humidity susan it doesn't matter it's only for a certain period of time it's like three months out of the year you love it i love miami people think that i moved to miami because i was like selling my company you guys my company was so big that I didn't get saved by the taxes yeah like it it's like we paid like United States taxes yeah I think people are like oh she just moved there for tax benefits and whatever okay fine I get like some slight ones I moved here because I love Miami I love the way that the the way the culture feels here I my dream was to find a mom group where we were supporting each other and do you have that oh my god I have that here the moms are amazing I feel like I could call them if I really need them for anything.

57:57Our kids hang out on the weekends. There's good schools here? It's great schools here. There are bad schools too, but there are great schools here too. I feel like it's just a little bit more down to earth here. And I say that knowing that it's very vapid here too, but it's different. Who is your favorite comfort creator? Who do you just search in your search bar when you're like, I need to feel good right now? Valeria is one for me actually. I love Valeria. Her content always makes me laugh. I think it's, I really just let, I really let the For You page do its job. Really? I do. You don't have a comfort creator.

58:31I have two. Yeah. Paige Lorenz, love watching her vlogs, and Valeria. Yeah. I think those two are really good ones. But yeah, I think I let the For You page do its job. And I have so many friends. I feel like I open up my phone and I already have everything sent to me, so. I love it. Okay, this one fed perfectly into this. IG, TikTok, or YouTube. You can only go on one for the rest of your life. YouTube really yeah okay because I feel like but is that for creating or consuming okay for consuming TikTok okay yeah but you have a huge Instagram profile like do you love Instagram I love Instagram I love so I feel like Instagram is where I have a community just like YouTube right but especially on Instagram where I want to like reach them quickly and directly um like I always know if I put a piece of content on TikTok who knows what's going to happen there but if I I posted on IG.

59:21You know. I just know I'm going to get comments from the same people. All these things are going to, it's going to be the people that I know. Yeah. So I don't know. I think as a content creator, I like to be on Instagram. I like to be on YouTube because I feel like YouTube is where you get to really be creative. Yeah. But TikTok, personally, for just consumption. Okay, last one. Favorite designer brand? Ooh, I'm going to see. I would say Loewe, but they just lost their creative director. I know. So, um, so I don't know if that's going to be the truth. I probably think that like if ever, if I ever really want a bag and I want to splurge it's Bottega.

1:00:01Yeah, I agree. I agree. Yeah. The HSR community was so excited that you were coming on. You are the first founder that has had an exit in our podcast spot. I'm so honored, Susan, that you did this. Thank you. You're even better in person than you are online. Thank you. And that's saying a lot because you're pretty dope online and I love watching your videos. Thank you so much. Where can people find you? I'm at Susan Yorov. Basically everywhere in my YouTube channel is Mixed Makeup. Thank you so much for coming on. Thank you. Bye guys.

1:00:40And Doug. Limu and I always tell you to customize your car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. But now we want you to feel it. Cue the emu music, Lemu. Save yourself money today. Increase your wealth, customize and save we say. That may have been too much feeling. Only pay for what you need at LibertyMutual.com. Liberty, Liberty, Liberty, Liberty. Savings vary underwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and affiliates excludes Massachusetts. Last lap alert. The Daily Tech Showcase roars into Richmond Raceway. October 14th. And the biggest names in tech are in the driver's seat.

1:01:18Apple, AWS, Meta. It's the main event for education, government, healthcare, manufacturing, and enterprise leaders. Ready to hit the gas on innovation. Time's running out. Claim one of the last few spots at daily.com slash VA25 before the checkered flag waves.

From the publisher

What happens when the internet turns on you, your marriage falls apart behind the scenes—and you still scale Naturium (your startup) into a $355M acquisition from e.l.f.? Susan Yara is telling her side of the story.


In this episode of Hot Smart Rich, Maggie sits down with Susan Yara, the founder of Naturium, for one of the most honest and tactical conversations we’ve had on the show. Known for her credibility and candor in the beauty space, Susan opens up about the backlash over her undisclosed involvement in Naturium, being cleared by the FTC, and scaling a brand that became a case study in profitability, performance, and modern brand-building.


But this isn’t just a founder story—it’s a personal one. Susan shares what it was like navigating a divorce while in the public eye, raising two kids as a single mom, and redefining her relationship with identity, ambition, and authenticity. From moments that nearly broke her to the business strategies that built her, this episode is a blueprint for long-game thinking in beauty and beyond.


Naturium became one of the first creator-founded skincare brands to exit at scale—paving the way for brands like Rhode by Hailey Bieber to follow. As a pioneer in the masstige skincare category, Susan didn’t just ride the wave—she helped define it. Her story proves that credibility, community, and clarity still win in the age of algorithms and outrage.


For anyone building in public, recovering from criticism, or wondering if you can be both honest and successful—this one’s for you.


⸻


Key Takeaways

  • Controversy doesn’t cancel you—lack of clarity does. Susan opens up about the Naturium backlash, her FTC clearance, and how transparency helped rebuild trust with her audience and consumers.
  • You can build while breaking down. She reflects on navigating a divorce during the brand’s biggest growth phase—and how personal transformation shaped her leadership.
  • Masstige is the new frontier. Naturium’s success helped define the mid-tier, high-efficacy skincare category, making room for other creator brands like Rhode to follow.
  • Retail still matters. Scaling with Target wasn’t just a channel strategy—it was a credibility builder. Susan breaks down how shelf space drove awareness and repeat sales.
  • Quiet founders can lead loud growth. Susan never sought the CEO spotlight. But leaning into her strength as an operator—not just an influencer—helped Naturium stand out in a crowded space.
  • Partnerships over Perfection. She unpacks her working relationship with Ben Bennett and how mutual trust helped them navigate mistakes, milestones, and media storms.
  • Margins over vibes. Susan made Naturium profitable from day one—and explains why obsessing over contribution margin (not Instagram likes) is what scaled the business.


⸻


Use ⁠Opus Clip⁠ to turn long videos into shorts.


⸻


⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

If you like what you hear, rate, review, and subscribe to Hot Smart Rich, the podcast supporting women who own their worth — in business, wealth, and life.


⁠⁠⁠Subscribe on YouTube⁠⁠⁠


⸻


💌

Own your worth — and build the life you want. Subscribe to the Hot Smart Rich newsletter, the no-BS guide to startup life, consumer brands, and becoming your hottest, smartest, richest self, written by Maggie Sellers. Join 250,000+ women building wealth, confidence, and community on their own terms.


⁠⁠⁠Subscribe here⁠⁠⁠


⸻


Follow Maggie here:

Instagram: ⁠⁠⁠@maggiesellers ⁠⁠⁠⁠

TikTok: ⁠⁠⁠@maggiesellers_ ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

LinkedIn: ⁠⁠⁠Maggie Sellers⁠⁠⁠ ⁠

⁠⁠⁠ShopMy⁠⁠⁠

⁠⁠⁠Amazon Storefront⁠⁠⁠


⸻


Follow Susan here:

Instagram: ⁠⁠⁠@susanyara⁠⁠

TikTok: ⁠@susanyara⁠

LinkedIn: ⁠⁠Susan Yara⁠

YouTube: ⁠@Mixedmakeup⁠ ⁠@SusanYara⁠


⸻


More from Hot Smart Rich:

⁠⁠⁠The Hot Smart Rich Money Mindset⁠⁠⁠

⁠⁠⁠Merch⁠⁠⁠


⸻


This episode is produced by HSR Media, a division of Creative MES LLC, with support from Coldea Productions and Vandana Ravi.

More from Hot Smart Rich with Maggie Sellers Reum

All 94 episodes
Susan Yara on How She Sold Naturium To e.l.f For $355 Million, Her FTC Investigation, and Building Through BacklashHot Smart Rich with Maggie Sellers Reum · 58 min
Listen in VO