

21 Nov 2026 · 8m · 5 chapters

How brand strategy and consumer advertising should balance moving people with building brand meaning, using Bold Bean’s “bold bean” approach as an example; also argues the biggest risk in ads is “no one cares,” so judging should focus on whether people engage, steal/share, or want to buy—not just whether messaging checks boxes.
The transcript doesn’t name specific people. It includes speakers discussing Bold Bean and “Co x Uncommon,” plus references to “marketing directors” and “d” (someone involved in mock-up feedback).
Great campaigns fuse brand story with cultural resonance; bold experiments are “two-way door” decisions; ads should be judged by real-world reactions (photos, requests, purchases).
Mock-ups that initially got “oof” feedback; comparison to Tesco’s generic playbook; Jeff Bezos “one-way vs two-way door” decision-making; merch/content should be desirable without huge logos.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the challenge of harmonizing brand movement with consumer engagement.
Discussing the importance of taking bold marketing decisions and the potential rewards.
“Like consumers embrace it, but the brand fuels it.”
Analyzing the risks in advertising and the need for lasting consumer impact.
“But he basically says most of the stuff we fret about is we think it's one-way door decision-making and actually most of the time it's a two-way decision.”
The necessity of designing engaging content and merchandise that resonate with consumers.
“Is this going to do what, you know, where's, you know, all these kind of questions.”
Proposing new criteria for evaluating marketing ideas beyond traditional metrics.
“Like we don't want to create a bag that has a huge logo on it and is just delivering the brand can't huge logo.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On HUNGRY., what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00I think in the world of brand strategy, our job is to kind of like wrestle I think with actually some of the stuff that sits behind that which is you do absolutely need to move people but you also need to move the brand and actually finding a way that these two things can sit in harmony is a challenge you can do one very easily but to do both is the really hard thing and I think we're now like both of them have their own kind of criticism if you just move people but it's not connected to the brand the brand just can't feel superficial and we're like great you've sponsored a festival but like why that brand yeah what the hell like and similarly the brand can kind of obsess over what it wants to tell people but if it doesn't find a way to make it culturally resonant then it's not going to move anywhere and so the thing that makes brand strategy really interesting is the job to try and find the halfway point between these two and find something that works really really powerfully and not as a concession but finds that interaction between the two that is really going to move people like i think the thing that's kind of phenomenal about bold bean is that the kind of obsessive story sits on both sides, right?
1:00Like consumers embrace it, but the brand fuels it. Like it's not a challenge to kind of stitch those two things together. They work better together than they would individually. But it is still, as you say, like that dangerous thing. Like I did send like these mock-ups to a few really experienced and brilliant marketing directors. And they were like, oof, this is... it's oof that's there's so many so much in that when it wasn't like hell yeah i love it and that really that is where the danger lies because there you know is that you know people have the first bean in the jar is you know they always you know all of these kind of different things came in which makes it scary but that also is probably where the opportunity is as well is that there's a reason why like there is yes people don't do this the whole time yeah that's how does that sort of feedback affect you with your course so how i try and i'm an optimist so for example what i said to d was like when we were kind of pranging to be honest like is are we just like oh you know so much money we're a small brand all of that um is actually this is our opportunity if it goes the way that i hope and believe it is gonna go it's incredible for us we can always go back to the generic marketing playbook available at tesco we can always go back to that and that's in the option for the future but you can't really retrospectively you know do something like this be bold if you've sold out already people are like oh well now you're trying a bit hard it's like this is the only time we can do it so let's give it a go and see where it takes us because you heard of like jeff bezos's one uh one on two-way door decision making so one one-way door would be doing the old it's basically one way do is you walk through a door there's no coming back two-way door is is you basically can walk in and come back and he says both most of us i mean He's a clever fucker, right?
3:06He did Amazon wrong. But he basically says most of the stuff we fret about is we think it's one-way door decision-making and actually most of the time it's a two-way decision. So like... I never thought I'd be like, yeah. Yeah, but I think to your point, but if it was a one-way door, one-way door, you would have gone... If you go through that and do the old school way, it's very hard to claw that back. But as you say, you can go and do this way. Oh, fuck, it doesn't work. We'll just do the bait way. Do you know what I mean? the um yeah that's see it's almost there's there's there's there's the anxiety around it can be diminished when you know you can go back yeah but i yeah i also think that it's we don't we can yeah i don't know what i'm saying it's funny thing happens when you're like consuming advertising that you get very sensible all of a sudden and there is absolutely a time you like someone in that room has to represent the business challenge and and some of the realities of it when you say consumer advertising as like a strategist or as no just with people creating it who are signing it off who are you know paying for it you know there is a need to kind of go is this going to do the objective are we going to be able to deliver it or is it going to be work on all the spaces that we need to there is a need to have like quite a rational hat on but we sometimes see the hat on so long that we consume in such an abstract way that actually the biggest risk for the advertising is that no one notices it it can fills completely wallpaper although sealed for a second and completely ignore it or not have a feeling not have a feeling but it has no residual impact on someone a second after they've seen it because you know we're going to look at a small window in the calendar right in the totality of someone's year in the totality of someone's life it's a very small moment so actually the biggest risk that that we need to be aware of is no one caring no one being moved people forgetting it um and so but you know it's hard to kind of appraise, people like don't allow themselves to appraise stuff through that lens.
5:02You can be really grown at weight. Is this going to do what, you know, where's, you know, all these kind of questions. But if you just like look around for a minute, go for a walk on the street, like name one ad that you can kind of remember on the walk you did around this block, you know, you'll see 30 advertisements and most of them are just over labored, you know, and I think marketing is downstream of consumer culture. I think consumers could tell you the cliches of today's adverts, what they're sick of seeing, what makes them, what they've just seen a hundred times, you know, What's tired?
5:29It's like all car adverts. They all look the same. They're all the same. It's like just driving through some Vista. It's the same people. It's just like, ooh. Same people, same default. It's just, you know, I think consumers know exactly what they're kind of tired of and what switches off. That is not making it into the rooms that are making these decisions, and we sometimes over-engineer and get nervous. But actually, the biggest risk we need to be talking about is like, why the hell would anyone care about that? You know, the benchmark for a great, you know, poster shouldn't be, did it say all the things that we wanted to in workshop?
6:01It's like, will anyone take their phone out and take a photo of that? Is anyone going to write to the brand and say, can I have a copy of that? I want to put it on my wall. Like, that's the benchmark you should be getting. Like, there's no other rooms like bands, you know, to go back to that. When they're coming up with their poster, they're not sitting around kind of going, is it doing all this stuff? They're like, this is cool. Will people steal it? Will people pay 15 bucks for it at the end of the concert? I love that because I think that actually how you've just spoken about that is how we try to think about both content and even things like merch.
6:29Like we don't want to create a bag that has a huge logo on it and is just delivering the brand can't huge logo. We want a bag that people actually want. And it's the same thing with content. We don't want content that is we just put money behind it and it says everything we want to say. We want content that they find naturally engaging. So they're engaged with it. And I suppose this campaign is a way of just engaging them on something and a feeling that they feels natural to engage with rather than, oh, I'm just being sold to, right? Yeah. And I think across the board, you know, from big brands to small brands, we need like a new criteria and vocabulary around the ideas that we're judging.
7:06Because we have this very marketing science point of view, which, by the way, is super important, but it's kind of known. It only gets you halfway there. You know, there are boxes to tick. But once they tick, you haven't created something great yet. actually what's great is like who's looking at their work and saying are people going to steal this are people going to could we um sell this as a poster you know like that should be the standard that we're aiming for we're in people's lives all the time like how do we move the bar on from just is this an ad that says everything that we need to that people actually care about yes yes people we're trying to make hungry into the most valuable food and drink business podcast on planet earth but I really need your help.
7:45I want to make this podcast so valuable for you to help you grow your business faster, stronger, better, have way more fun. We've got a super short customer feedback, sorry, consumer survey, audience survey thing on Google Forms. There's a link at the top of the show notes. If you could fill that out, it would be so helpful. We make this podcast way better for you. Yes, yes, people. So the hungry reading list is here, right? If you listen to the podcast regularly, you know I love reading. I think books are the most beautiful thing in the world. As Stephen King said, they're teleportable magic or something like that.
8:18These books are whittled down my gargantuan bookshelf into 46 absolute 30 bangers. The link is in the show notes to get the list, whatever. And it'll also make you a subscriber to our weekly newsletter, which I think is sick. So, yeah, get your fucking books, buddy.
📙Download HUNGRY Big Banging Reading list here
🧾 HUNGRY survey would be so grateful if you may please fill out
♨️Still bloody HUNGRY? Course ya are. Each week I spend 15 hours writing my newsletter. It’ll take you 5 mins to read. Full of wisdom from the biggest names in food and drink. Subscribe here - https://hungryfeast.beehiiv.com/🍲
==============================================
🤝 Let's Connect!
►Let’s link-up here (https://www.linkedin.com/in/daniel-pope/)
►Stalk me here (https://www.instagram.com/_hungry.pod/)
This episode was edited by: G.Thomas Craig (https://www.linkedin.com/in/gthomascraig/)
📙Download HUNGRY Big Banging Reading list here
🧾 HUNGRY survey would be so grateful if you may please fill out





