1. Podcasts
  2. Investing Experts
  3. Tech bubble will pop in 2027
Investing Experts

27 Oct 2026 · 37m · 12 chapters

Episode artwork

Tech bubble will pop in 2027

In short

Tech/AI market sell-off and “dip worth buying” debate; why the AI tech bubble pop is expected in 2027 (not immediately), driven more by money/credit than demand.

Guest

Sara Awad, from Tech Contrarians (podcast host/analyst).

Key claims

October sell-off is a “hangover” correction from April–June; earnings are becoming a “test” (good results still sold). Credit risk is rising (lenders seeking more default insurance; higher Treasury yields/inflation). AI labs remain loss-making; enterprise AI is still experimental and monetization uncertain. Bubble timing: 2027, tied to financing running out.

Notable examples

ASML guidance (Q4 sales +22–30%; fiscal 26 EUV targets) and TSM similar “sell good news” pattern; neocloud names (CoreWeave, etc.) down 50%+ from highs; Lumentum/Coherent optics thesis (NPO/CPO) and Lumentum rebound after EMA200 dip; Tesla and Meta CapEx signals (Tesla cut $25B to $20B; Meta held/narrowed CapEx). Micron memory trade critique: DRAM ASP growth moderating; upside driven by non-AI memory shortages, not HBM/AI; PC demand weakness implies memory risk. Upcoming earnings focus: SK Hynix, Seagate vs Western Digital (hammer transition and Toshiba HDD competition), plus CapEx guidance from Microsoft/Google/Amazon; Intel expectations/yields and ARM preference; Apple resilience. Anthropik IPO watch: better positioned than OpenAI; compute leased via third-party clouds.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Market Overview and Sell-Off

Sara discusses the current state of the tech market and recent sell-offs.

“And a lot has happened between then and now.”
2:13

Stock Picking and Market Fundamentals

The conversation shifts to the importance of stock picking and fundamentals in the current market.

“So how would you share what you are liking, what you're disliking these days?”
4:48

Opportunities in Semi-Cap and AI Stocks

Sara shares insights on specific stocks to watch in the semiconductor and AI sectors.

“So, you know, if you think about ASML's print that happened not so long ago, I think they were one of the first people to print after Micron.”
8:00

CapEx Trends and Market Shifts

Discussion on recent trends in capital expenditures and their implications for the market.

“But to us, the bubble pop is going to happen in 2027, not this year, because we're still seeing a market that's biting back.”
14:01

Demand and Cost Dynamics in AI

Discussion on the current state of AI demand and its economic implications.

“rather than necessarily demand actually being impacted.”
16:04

Micron's Market Performance and Future Outlook

Analysis of Micron's financial performance and potential market challenges.

“But what I'm more interested in talking about with you is actually the data points because I think that's what we're going to see kind of confront the market earlier than that big pop conversation.”
22:00

Impact of the PC Market on Memory Prices

Exploring how the struggling PC market is affecting memory pricing and sales.

“because if you think about it, the fact that prices are kind of moderating or price increases are moderating makes a lot of sense against the non-AI backdrop.”
25:15

Upcoming Earnings and Market Predictions

Insights into upcoming earnings reports and what they indicate for the market.

“the end customer is going to go for Apple if they're going to have to cough up that money anyway.”
28:09

Analyzing Cloud Customer Shipment Trends

Learn about the concerns surrounding cloud customer shipments and growth sustainability.

“And so to us, that's concerning because then you look at what drove growth elsewhere.”
29:16

Upcoming Earnings Reports and Their Implications

Explore the anticipated earnings reports from major tech companies and their market impact.

“And so from that perspective, we think, you know, there is a specific headwind that's specific to Western Digital, which is that hammer transition.”
Show all 12 chapters
30:45

Intel's Future and Market Position

Discuss the future of Intel and its position in the market regarding pricing and technology.

“We actually downgraded it into a quarter again.”
32:55

Anthropic IPO Insights

Understand the significance of the Anthropik IPO and its comparison to OpenAI.

“And then the last guy that I would say we're really focusing on is Apple.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Investing Experts, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:10Welcome back to Sara Awad from Tech Contrarians. Always great to have you on Investing Experts. Always great to talk tech. It seems that's all we've been talking about on the podcast, at least for the past month or so. What would you share with investors you're on regularly? How would you update investors right now, how you're looking at the tech market and also how that sector fits into the broader market? So first, it's great to be back. Thanks again for having us. And I think, you know, when we're looking at the market, last time we spoke, if I'm not mistaken, was exactly one month ago. And a lot has happened between then and now.

0:50So I think, you know, looking at the sell-off that we've seen in October, looking at how much, you know, I would say anxiety is growing around the AI build out, both on the hyperscaler front and on the semiconductor front. I think the big question on everyone's mind now is, is this a dip worth buying, right? There's blood in the streets. Is this the time that you go in and you try to buy the dip because we're going to have another rally that follows? We've seen this happen earlier this year. We saw this happen at the end of July with a big sell-off that really paid off for those who bought the dip.

1:19So that's the question I think that's on everyone's mind. And to that, we think that, yes, there are dips that, you know, that we're seeing that happened last week that we're likely to see, you know, continue in terms of downside in the near term that are worth buying. But the difference now is that basically what we're seeing now in terms of the sell-off is more of a hangover kind of correction from that April to June run. And the reason why is because this sell-off is more driven from the money side of things rather than the data points themselves. So this isn't necessarily an earnings-driven sell-off.

1:52So from that perspective, yeah, we think the dip is worth buying, but not on everyone. This isn't the time where it's not Q2. It's not the time when it's going to be easy money for all. I think this is when the market's growing more selective. And I think this is the time that we advise investors to focus most on the fundamentals because those data points are going to carry some stocks out of this better than others. So we've been talking about that as well, how this is a prime stock picking market that you have to know what place in the market you're picking. So how would you share what you are liking, what you're disliking these days?

2:27Yeah. So from that perspective, what we're liking, what we're disliking, we're also making sure that we're very much in tune to the concerns that the market is picking up on. Specifically, when we're looking at the credit risk concerns, when we're looking at, you know, lenders asking for more insurance on potential defaults for this AI build out. I think we have to be in tune to that. It can't be completely ignored. What the market is pricing in is basically red flags that have been around all year, but that have now become more prominent with the U.S. Treasury yields pushing up in the macro backdrop with inflation.

3:00And of course, you have, you know, this this anxiety over Anthropic and OpenAI still losing a lot of money, despite what we might see in the Anthropic S1 in terms of, quote unquote, what they define as operating margin. Right. So if we look about it from that perspective, you know, we take what Broadcom's CEO said, I think it was two weeks ago. Hooktan then he was in a conference in Singapore with Intel CEO. And basically what he said is that right now the AI scene is a lot like a casino. There's a lot of experimentation happening from the enterprise guys. And enterprise is still where the bulk of, you know, money or monetization of AI comes from.

3:36So he's his perspective is that there's a lot of experimentation happening. This is still a money losing game. And a lot of investors don't necessarily understand what they're buying. So when we're looking at the sell-off, you know, it's not a kind of pick up anything kind of thing. We're really thinking about it in terms of sticking to the fundamentals. And that takes me back to what we talked about last month, which is, is earnings going to act as a test or a treat, right? In the theme of Halloween. And what we've seen with ASML, what we've seen with TSM is that despite good results, despite stellar results, really, we're still seeing the market sell good news.

4:13And I think that this is what we saw as well continue through last week. The market is becoming more nitpicky. And that's why I say a hangover from that April-June run, because I think that propped up expectations big time. And I think we're seeing Wall Street really begin to digest where the upside is coming from in terms of this is not just AI's demand is so overwhelming that everyone's going to benefit. it. It's a lot more complicated than that. And there's a lot of, I would say, there's a lot of layers to what's driven this rally. And I think that there's a lot of layers in terms of how this rally is going to unwind.

4:47So that's kind of the perspective that we're thinking about. So, you know, if you think about ASML's print that happened not so long ago, I think they were one of the first people to print after Micron. They had a great quarter, right? They signaled that EUV demand is still going up and they signaled a higher fiscal 26 guide, but still the stock sold off after that. And then we saw a similar dynamic with TSM. So from our perspective, this is the time to look at earnings and not buy necessarily into print, not try to play earnings, but instead try to trade rather than buy and hold these kinds of names, try to trade names on the volatility.

5:25Buying the names of the market is selling even on good news. So from that perspective, we like the semi-cap guys still. We like ASML. I mean, their last print they guided for Q4 sales to increase 22 to 30%. And, you know, they're expecting that their fiscal 26 EUV sales are going to be 65, targeting 85 and 27, and still have this, you know, potential for 110 EUVs in 2028. And so that's what underpins their fiscal 26 sales outlook, which is somewhere between 44 and 45 billion for 36 % year over year growth. And so, and that's, that's against street estimates for 43.1 billion, but the stock still sold off.

6:06So those are the kind of opportunities that we're recommending to investors because these are the guys that still have, you know, they still have a string. They're still tethered to, to, to come back towards the upside, even on, you know, downturns similar to what we saw over the past month. And that's when we'd also recommend, you know, knowing, knowing the story, but not necessarily, you know, knowing the story enough to trade the name, but not necessarily, you know, becoming too attached, buying and holding the stock. A great mentor of mine once put this in a great way. He said, you know, you only date stocks, you never fall in love with them.

6:38And that's something I think about every day. Because for example, when you look at the NeoCloud guys, a lot of these guys have gotten hammered. They're looking at, you know, for CoreWeave, the worst month since last November. And we've seen them shed over 50 % from the highs, you know, CoreWeave, IRIN, Applied, Huts. And this is a group that we've already flagged for investors as higher risk because the business model itself is flawed, right? You have to have this massive upfront CapEx to keep this business model alive. And tech goes, you know, tech becomes obsolete very fast. So you have to continuously have this capital coming in, which really pushes these guys to rely on external, you know, debt markets, etc.

7:16And so, you know, the negatives that the market's pricing in there, I think they're, you know, well-founded, at the same time, the prices of these neoclouds is attractive after that dip. And that's what we saw at the end of last week. And that's how we saw them kind of roar back yesterday and then on days like today as well. So I would say for that kind of group, where the fundamentals do point to an eventual burst or a shakeout, we think about those guys as, you know, trade with caution, because we don't see these guys being meaningfully re-rating higher for the longer term. But we think the market's a bit early in kind of singling this group out, because essentially that credit risk that the market's pricing in through the neoclods, it's much bigger than that neocloud basket.

7:56It's essentially what we think is going to cause the bigger AI pop. But to us, the bubble pop is going to happen in 2027, not this year, because we're still seeing a market that's biting back. And so when we think about it like that, there's opportunity, there's riskier opportunity, but there's also good fundamental names that have this fundamental basis to come back up. And that's also where, for example, last week, we liked the optics names. So Lumentum was one of the names that we triggered an alert on last week when it dipped, it crashed into its EMA 200. And that's worked out really well.

8:30It was one of the top performers yesterday. And part of the thesis that underpins that is that at the end of the day, the industry is moving towards NPO and CPO, near package optics and co-package optics. And that inherently positions Lumentum and Coherent in a good position heading into second half of 2027. So with those guys, we like to buy the dip and then we like to trim it to strengthen, rinse and repeat. So those are kind of the three ways I would say we're thinking about how to handle this kind of volatility. And so, yeah, so that's kind of in terms of trading and playing this market. But I think that what we're getting this Erzny season outside of, you know, opportunity to jump into names with good fundamentals is we're getting a lot of important data points, I would say.

9:13And I think these are the kind of the hints that we need to pinpoint the timing of the bubble come 2027. And what I'm thinking about here when I say that is Tesla's CapEx cut last week that I think too many people kind of brushed over. I'm not sure if you saw anyone talk about that. Basically, this entire cycle, it's only been CapEx going up, right? Everyone's raising CapEx every quarter. We're seeing forecasts for what 26, 27 CapEx is going to look like only increasing. But for the first time last week, we have Tesla cut CapEx from 25 to 20 billion. And Tesla's not this huge player. We're not talking about Meta.

9:49we're not talking about Google, but what it does signal is a shift because this is something that we haven't seen before. And that happened around the same time that we had Meta also basically hold their CapEx. They only narrowed it slightly towards the upside. But basically, Meta held their CapEx on last week's call. And if you run a comparison between Meta's Q325 call and Meta's Q326 call, you'll notice that the commentary is much more vague as far as CapEx goes this time around. And a year ago, the conversation was more about scarcity and needing a lot more, you know, compute supply. This time, it's more about how do we get the most efficient kind of compute supply, a lot more focused on unit economics.

10:32And this confirms our idea, you know, for starters that yes, the industry is going to shift towards more, you know, custom ASIC projects and we're already seeing that underway. But it also confirms this idea that, you know, it's not only about compute, it's not only about the semi-side of this equation. More and more, we need these hyperscalers to deliver on return. And more and more, we're seeing them kind of switch up their positioning, if you will, to be able to achieve that. So even with Meta's Muse, the big focus was, okay, yeah, we want to scale Meta Muse. We think that this can be something very big and we can be able to monetize it.

11:05But the main focus was they need to make sure that everything is running efficiently, not only on, you know, in terms of the capabilities, but also in terms of the compute that's enabling the ability to scale news outside of North America as well. So these are the conversations that are coming out of earnings, and I think they're really important for us to pay attention to because they give us signals on what's to come from 2027. And, you know, the takeaways thus far is that, yeah, ASIC is still very much, you know, we're very much shifting towards ASIC. We still like, you know, Marvell on that front.

11:40And yes, the stock has run up, but we found that continuously, you know, buying the dips on Marvell has paid off very well because the fundamentals still back it. I think, you know, come mid-2027, we got to rethink that because of that shift towards NPO and CPO, because that's essentially going to eliminate the DSPs that Marvell sells and is the world's main supplier of. But for, you know, thinking now until early 2027, that's still a name that we like because of that ASIC shift. and we also like Qualcomm because of that optionality that it can become a very big player in the A6 scene, in the CPU scene because one, it has expertise, it's a legacy player and they have the volume capacity at TSM which has really been a bottleneck for a lot of the players in the industry.

12:25So that's in terms of the takeaways we get there. We still do like NVIDIA in the near term. We don't think it's going to be an uber outperformer to the SOX benchmark but we like it because at the end of the day, they do have this Vera Rubin ramp happening. That's what kind of helped underpin the momentum that we saw. Even with the sell-off, NVIDIA quarter to date is holding up pretty much in line. I think it was down around 7 % or 8 % as of last Friday against the stocks benchmark down about 15%. So we're seeing it hold up, but we're not seeing it be this star-shining outperformer. So come 2027, as that ASIC narrative shifts, I think we shift more away from NVIDIA and we grow more cautious there because the industry is going to have to re-rate NVIDIA on this new reality that, again, it's sharing the market with the ASIC players.

13:10It feels like we've been talking about this for a while, but I don't think we've seen that fully priced in just yet. And then also underpinning this bigger conversation coming out of earnings and also out of the Anthropic S1 is this idea that, you know, what does this shift to more attractive unit economics means for the AI labs? Because these guys also, similar to what, you know, hooked and was saying, are still in very much a money losing kind of game. And they still need a lot of financing or backstops from the likes of Broadcom or the likes of NVIDIA. So when we think about, you know, all of these moving parts, and we think about, you know, Anthropoc is going to be public soon, etc.

13:46I think that there's a big imbalance in the broader industry right now. And that's what we expect the market to have to kind of come to face with in 2027. That's where we see, you know, the big pop happening. And we see that happening more from the money running out, rather than necessarily demand actually being impacted. Because at the end of the day, right now, there's as much demand for AI as all of these guys are saying, right? As Jensen talks about, or Dario, or Sam Altman, or Elon Musk. But what underpins those kinds of statements out of these guys is basically that AI is for the most part free, right?

14:21It goes back again to Huktan's interview, which is really stellar. He really hits on a lot of the points that we've been making this year, which is that at the end of the day, a lot of people are still experimenting. It's not a durable, sustainable kind of demand profile. And a lot of the surveys coming out for enterprises incorporating AI show that there still hasn't been this overwhelming payoff that they felt on their side. So it's all really about the money. I think this is something we, you know, a point that we talked about last time and one that's really worth drilling down again today, which is that it's all about the money.

14:54And now that compute is going up or the cost of AI is going up, it's interesting to think about that against the price not going up that much and what that means for these, you know, U.S. frontier labs, especially given that, you know, in Anthropics S1, they talk about token costs coming down. And then you have the Chinese competition that's also, you know, giving all of these alternatives. And so it becomes, I think, this playing ground where you have, you know, a lot of different themes overlapping, including even political themes with, for example, the DHS trying to ban the use of DeepSeek in different agencies and trying to limit the use of this Chinese kind of AI models within the US.

15:30So we're still watching to see how export restrictions or US government restrictions impact that competition with China. But at the same time, I think that imbalance is very clear. And that's something that we're watching really closely. And so that's on the big picture, when the bubble pops, which is what everyone is wondering, right? They're wondering, is this a big bubble pop or not? We don't think that is. I mean, it was a scary sell-off last week, but I don't think it was anything too much out of the ordinary considering what we saw earlier this year. So yeah, so from that perspective, the bubble pop to us is a 2027 story.

16:04But what I'm more interested in talking about with you is actually the data points because I think that's what we're going to see kind of confront the market earlier than that big pop conversation. And this is where Micron, I think, is center stage. So Micron reported a couple of days after our last conversation. And basically the Micron data points do confirm a slowdown as far as memory, DRAM spot and contract prices go. And I focus here on memory in terms of the data points, because I think a lot of this AI trade, as far as investors are concerned, isn't necessarily attached to that big where the money is coming from, how is this all being financed.

16:41But a lot of the investors today are jumping into buying names on the pullback like Micron, like Western Digital, which I think fundamentals no longer really support. And those guys are the ones that I think that, you know, you focus on the data, you focus on the fundamentals to make sure that you're not getting yourself trapped into a stock that is not going to come back to its golden days of Q2. So, you know, if you don't mind, I'll run through the Micron print just to highlight those discrepancies and why we have such high conviction that, you know, the Micron story has broken. Yeah, definitely.

17:12Definitely. All right, perfect. So basically, Micron reported their Q4, and they reported DRAM sales up 27 % sequentially, driven with 19 % sequential increase in ASP. And if we look at a quarter prior at their Q3 report, DRAM sales were up 67 % sequentially, with a 62 % increase in ASP. So we're already seeing this kind of theme that perhaps DRAM prices have peaked. And then we look at also, you know, the gross margins for the quarter. They reported 87 % gross margins on higher pricing, partially offset by the mix. And they're guiding for a sequential step down to 86.25. And I think a lot of people dismissed that gross margin guide because they were like, oh, this is only 75 basis points decline.

18:01and so they dismissed it because it's 75 basis points not that much we're talking about 86 % gross margins anyway and also management gave this justification that it's because you know incentive compensation that's being capitalized into inventory but I think what a lot of people glossed over is that management told us part of the reason for that decline is also price moderation right not specifically price moderation I should more accurately say price increases moderating And the quarter's results do confirm that, specifically if we look at the sequential growth. To us, that memory kind of story is at a higher risk profile right now.

18:37And what we like to do is we like to go straight into the industry and look at really what's driving that upside. So to us, the upside for Micron has actually not been driven by HBM or AI, but by the shortage that's pushed up the prices or the SPs on non-AI memory much higher. And what confirms this further is the fact that Micron's own share of HVM actually declined from 21 % to 18 % if we look at it between Q1 and Q2. So we know that Micron is not substantially growing that footprint in HVM. We already know that HVM has been sold out for Micron since December quarter, and we already know looking forward it's also sold out.

19:13But for some reason, we still see gross margins expanding, top line pushing much higher against expectations. And that to us is much more driven by the non-AI side of the equation. And so even when you look at, you know, Micron's business units, you know, they have cloud memory, they have core data center, mobile and client, and then automotive embedded. I'm just going to put aside automotive embedded for a minute here because it's not the main focus. It's one of the smaller segments. But if you look at the gross margins on the other three, you'll notice that the mobile and client, which is, you know, completely non-AI for the most part, have had 90 % gross margins this quarter and 87 % gross margins last quarter.

19:52And so that places them as the highest gross margin business unit. They match with the core data center and the cloud memory still has lower margins. So what this tells us is it confirms once again that the upside's not from the AI side of the story, but more from the non-AI. And then I'm going to add one more data point here, just to bore you with all these. But the last data point is basically that Micron's CEO told us in Q2 and then told us again on the Q4 call that their non-HVM gross margins are higher than their HVM gross margins. And they're trying to close that gap. So when we put all of these together, yeah, it looks like potentially memory prices are peaking out.

20:29Now, it's not a guessing game. Micron's very important. So what we did is we dug a bit more and we looked at the guys that sell memory that's non-HVM memory, right? Guys like Nanyatek in Taiwan. And we looked at their monthly sales because they give us monthly sales. And if you look at their stats, they had 49 % increase in July and then a 1.9 % increase in August and a 0.9 % increase in September. So we are seeing somewhat of a deceleration in terms of, you know, similar to what management told us, price increases are moderating. And so we follow the data points, we follow the fundamentals. And so they confirm this idea that, yeah, there is something wrong with the Micron trade.

21:09And since last time we spoke, actually, Micron is down about 16%. And that, you know, last week's sell-off did help, but I think we saw that memory downturn happen shortly after Micron's print. And I think more people are paying attention to the issues with the memory trade of this not being completely an AI story. And, you know, looking at spot prices, last time I think we talked about Q2 spot prices were up 53 % to 58%. And then in Q3, that was down 13 % to 18%. But the newest data point, which we haven't talked about yet, is from TrendForce, and it points to a 13 % to 20 % increase in terms of DRAM prices.

21:46And that's much lower, again, than those Q2 figures. So when you add all of these data points together, we think that there's higher risk on the memory trade. And so this is not a time that we would recommend going into the memory, buying the memory guys on this kind of dip. because if you think about it, the fact that prices are kind of moderating or price increases are moderating makes a lot of sense against the non-AI backdrop. Because, you know, when you look outside of AI, you look at PC, you look at smartphone, and PC in specific has been struggling, right? Most OEMs in the PC market are now seeing that market contracting 15 to 20 % in the second half of the year alone.

22:26And Q3 already, we had a 20 % year over year decline, a 9 % sequential decline. And the last time we saw these kinds of numbers was actually right after the COVID peak. And in the fourth quarter of 2022 and the first quarter of 2023, when PC market crashed 28%. And so when we put all of these together, yeah, PC market is struggling. And a big part of this is because a lot of what happened is higher component costs because of this higher memory costs. So when you look at the five PC suppliers or the top five PC vendors, and you compare their commentary at the start of the year versus our commentary now about PC shipments, there's been a massive shift.

23:07So we ran, basically we compiled the data from the top five biggest guys and we compared their commentary at the start of the year versus now. And Lenovo began the year talking about forecasting double digit growth and is now talking about a 15 % decline. Similar with Dell, they talked about things being flat, and now they're talking about high teens decline. So what I'm saying, I guess, is the PC market crash is going to be felt by everyone, including memory. And I think the PC story is more important for memory than a lot of people give it credit for. And so when we think about it like that, yeah, that confirms our sentiment on memory.

23:43And I think there's also something else to extrapolate from these data points, which is about the supply chain in general and this inflationary kind of phenomenon that we've seen take over the semiconductor supply chain. Because when you look at these guys' earnings and throughout the peer group in general, price increases or anticipation of price increases have done a lot of the heavy lifting to cause customers to pull in or to double order out of fear that there's going to be more price hikes, there's going to be more risk to accessing supply. And so when you look at the numbers, you see that actually a lot of these guys saw units decline and ASP go up.

24:20And Acer and Lenovo actually told us that the higher pricing is what helped offset the weaker unit shipments. So when we put all of this together, it sounds great as long as price increases can continue. But at the end of the day, the downside of price increases, while they look great and they allow these guys to raise guidance and beat expectations and show that upside surprise, they also have the impact of shrinking the TAM. Because today you no longer have cheap PCs or cheap smartphones. The component costs alone have gone up so much that everything now is a higher end product. So a lot of these guys are competing in the same bracket as Apple, for example.

24:59And that's what's underpinned our bullish sentiment on Apple since the beginning of the year, that it's going to be a better position than the bunch during this kind of higher component cost. because when everyone's products is competing against Apple at a higher price point, odds are the end customer is going to go for Apple if they're going to have to cough up that money anyway. I know that that's true for me, at least. In terms of this week's earnings, we have major tech players coming. Anything that you would highlight about if you're focused on those names, what you're focused on about those names, what you would share with investors about those earnings and any points that you're looking at there?

25:36Yeah, definitely. So I think the most exciting one we got coming up we got sk hynix after the bell today and we also have seagate uh and the interesting thing with seagate is that we had basically it's it's it's a close peer western digital report last week and we downgraded western digital after last quarter uh at tech contrarians and the reason for our downgrade then was because you know they're going to have this transition from uh this transition to hammer technology which comes with you know gross margin headswinds as they undergo this transition. And their gross margins were already substantially high, even higher than Seagate's because the SMR technology that Western Digital spearheads actually has higher gross margins than the more advanced hammer technology.

26:23So that was our thinking about Western Digital. And then we had the Toshiba news happen intra-quarter, right? And the Toshiba news is very big. Basically, Toshiba is one of the biggest players in the HDD market, but more of a player that's on the back burner because at the end of the day, between Seagate and Western Digital, they own the majority of the HDD market. And that's really worked in their favor for a couple of reasons, including this idea that, and that was the thesis that underpinned our bullish sentiment on these two guys, which is that they kept unit shipments or unit capacity very tightly controlled.

26:58And instead, they basically expanded capacity through expanding aerial density. So that's where the hammer technology comes in. And that's basically where they use heat-assisted mechanisms to increase the aerial density and essentially create more higher capacity HDDs. And so while that strategy was working really great for them, Toshiba kind of came in and rained on the parade. And the reason why is because Toshiba came out to say, hey, we're actually eyeing 30 % of this market and we're going to start working on this immediately. And so that broke this idea that Seagate and Western Digital can basically keep capacity tightly controlled.

27:41And so from that perspective, that made us more concerned about Western Digital for starters and then after definitely Seagate. So heading into the print now, we're using, you know, we're looking at the data points that came out both from the Toshiba news and from Western Digital's print last week to better understand what's going to happen with Seagate today. And what we saw with Western Digital, if I could run through that real quick, is basically shipments to their cloud customers grew 16%, while total revenue grew 17%. And this is the first time that we see shipments to cloud customers, which usually makes up 88 to 89 % of total sales, grow slower than top line growth.

28:19And so to us, that's concerning because then you look at what drove growth elsewhere. You have client-related HDD sales going up 42 % sequentially and consumer up 17 % sequentially. And so given what we just discussed in terms of what's happening in the non-AI side of the market, these numbers look a bit more unsustainable. And then you look at gross margins that expanded 370 basis points and are guided to expand again to, you know, that was 370 basis points to 58.1%. And now they're guided to expand to 60 to 61%. I think a lot of what we're seeing is pricing is doing the heavy lifting. And now that we have more unit capacity expansion, the pricing is that, you know, that ASP leverage is going to wane.

29:00And that's where we become more concerned both about Western Digital and about Seagate. So that's what we're watching to see with Seagate's print today. And I think that's a big part of why the market kind of sold off Western Digital, despite the results being better than expected. I think they've begun to grow, you know, cautious about this idea that how much more gross margin upside really is there. And so from that perspective, we think, you know, there is a specific headwind that's specific to Western Digital, which is that hammer transition. But that Toshiba headwind really does harm both the same.

29:31And so that's what we're looking at in terms of Seagate today right after the bell. And of course, with SK Hynix, we're watching that memory trend very closely. And then, you know, we're looking to Microsoft, Google, and Amazon reporting in the next two days. And I think the biggest thing on our mind there is CapEx. Because with Meta, we didn't really get a clear direction. I think with Google, with Microsoft, with Amazon, they're going to be forced to have to give the market kind of an answer about where are things heading from here. And so that's what we're watching for mainly. and another thing we're watching for is basically how is you know how is the conversation about anthropic and anthropic going public going to show up with these guys because there's you know there's two sides of these coins where anthropics you know adjusted operating margins don't account for you know the cut the amazon google take but once anthropic is public that's got a shift right because google and amazon are are you know they're writing down those gains they're wall street's it's taking these you know it's jotting those down so how do we think about the discrepancy there now that we have more information about Anthropik and we're very close to this, you know, I would say very important, crucial, one of the most important moments in this AI boom, which is Anthropik, the first of the U.S.

30:40frontier labs to really go public. So that's what we're thinking about. We're also looking at Intel that's going to report on the 29th on Thursday. For Intel, I think it's interesting. The stock has come down quite a bit. We actually downgraded it into a quarter again. And with Intel, they already told us at the beginning of the year that they're going to be raising prices every quarter on their CPUs. So with Intel, the way we look at it is more as an expectations game. If expectations are low enough, the stock tends to do very well into print because of this momentum from higher pricing. But longer term, we're not big fans of Intel because you can only increase prices for so long.

31:17That's for starters. And then the second thing is, at the end of the day, we do like ARM more than we like the x86 players because of where the industry is headed. When we look at fundamentals, when we look at the roadmap, industry shifting more towards custom ASICs, more towards agentic AI. And I think the CPU of choice, this is something I think we discussed a bit more detail last fall, is going to be ARM. And that's because of a couple of different factors, both, you know, ARM's designs already being incorporated into a lot of the hyperscaler projects, plus, you know, ARM having better power consumption metrics against the x86 guys.

31:50So that's what we're looking at in terms of, you know, Intel heading into print. And we're also watching to see what Intel talks about in terms of CapEx. That's what would change our mind about Intel becoming a viable longer-term play. If we see them actually spend CapEx in a way that they actually commit CapEx for the 14A. Because what we've seen from Intel thus far is that they've used the high NA tool from ASML, which is extremely expensive, on their 14, on their 18A node. And they were supposed to use it on the 14A. So if you're going to take a really expensive machine and use it on your 18A, that means to us that you must have some trouble getting your yields up to par.

32:29So we're still watching to see how that kind of story plays out. If we're going to see Intel be able to spend more, commit more spending for 14A, we know from Libutan that they're not going to do that kind of commitment until they've secured an external customer. So a big theme that we're going to be watching for on this call is, what are the CapEx updates? What are the external customer conversations looking like, if any? And that's what would change our mind, I would say, on Intel. And then the last guy that I would say we're really focusing on is Apple. If we got a new CEO, it's going to be very interesting to see how the story behind Apple holds up as far as them being more resilient to this entire downturn.

33:08And I know there was a report out a couple, I mean, earlier this month from Nikkei that suggested that Apple told suppliers to cut production of specific components for its new iPhone 18 Pro and Pro Max by as much as 15%. I think that those to us still aren't a big concern signal because now that we also have a higher price point for these products, I think this is Apple just responding to what we outlined earlier, which is an overall shrinking TAM against these, you know, super high component costs that have been trickling out. Apple, by the way, reports on November 2nd post market. Sarah, like always, this has been a chock full of insight and really good information for investors.

33:52Anything else to add to this conversation? I think that we wrapped up, you know, we touched base on a couple of different guys. I think the biggest thing to watch for now is really in terms of CapEx conversation, where that's kind of headed. And, you know, we're also very excited to see what happens with the Anthropik IPO. Yes. Any sound bites that you would leave investors with vis-a-vis the Anthropik IPO? I think what we're seeing with Anthropik is that, you know, Anthropik is definitely in a better position than OpenAI. And I think that also makes sense considering that they've really gone for their IPO and they haven't held off or delayed, similar to what we've seen from OpenAI.

34:25I do think that, you know, similar to what we discussed last time, they're getting more creative with how they are, you know, in terms of their reporting style, in terms of how they're showing profitability. And the other thing that we're watching is basically how Anthropik leases, you know, their compute versus how OpenAI goes about it. And a lot of what Anthropik does goes through third-party cloud service providers rather than them being committed or owning or developing a specific kind of chip, at least thus far, unlike what we've seen from OpenAI with the Jalapeno and with working with Broadcom.

34:59And I think this is a clever kind of way to, at least for now, protect themselves, considering that there's still not enough visibility in terms of where the market is going and the different forms of compute solutions that we could be looking at down the road. Thank you, Sarah. I very much appreciate this conversation. I imagine our audience does as well. If you would remind our audience where they can find more of your insight and analysis, we'd be happy for you to share that and look forward to the next time. Definitely. I'm looking forward to it already. In terms of where you guys can find us.

35:32So you guys can find us at Tech Contrarians. We have a public site where we like to share our podcast series. We bring on different investors from Seeking Alpha to discuss specific names. And we bring on different industry experts to talk about specific sectors. And where you can find the real in-depth, fundamental, worksheet-heavy work that we do is behind the investing group within Tech Contrarians. We're looking forward to having you guys there. Um, and, and I always like to say this at the end of call, the favorite feature for most people is the one-on-one calls that we do. So we do one-on-one consultations just to talk through the fundamentals because similar to, again, to what Hook Dan said, a lot of people don't know what they're investing in right now.

36:11And that's the best way to protect yourself against the bubble pop, regardless of when it happens.

36:16Sara Awad: Just a reminder, anything you hear on this podcast should not be considered investment advice. This is for entertainment purposes only, and you should seek advice from a licensed professional before investing. If you enjoyed the episode, leave a rating or review on your favorite podcasting app. And we'll see you soon with a new episode.

From the publisher
Sara Awad from Tech Contrarians answers if this is a dip worth buying (0:40) Will tech earnings act as a trick or a treat? (5:00) Tesla's capex cut last week (9:25) Micron (and memory) story has broken (16:20) Intel earnings preview (30:45) Anthropic over OpenAI (34:15)

Show Notes
What Will Micron's Gross Margin Guide Be?

Episode transcripts

For full access to analyst ratings, stock and ETF quant scores, and dividend grades, subscribe to Seeking Alpha Premium at seekingalpha.com/subscriptions

More from Investing Experts

All episodes