


How AG1 (Athletic Greens) built trust and demand using early podcast advertising, host-read storytelling, and brand discipline to avoid becoming a commodity in a crowded supplement market.
Pauly Derry, Chief Marketing Officer at AG1; 20+ years brand marketing experience. Previously CMO of Yeti and creative leadership at Uber during its startup-to-IPO transition.
Podcasts provide “time” with trusted hosts, enabling detailed product education (AG1 has 75 ingredients, including pre-probiotics, multivitamins). Authentic host integration improves persuasion versus skippable ads. Brand-building requires clarity on “who we are and who we’re not,” and emotional/financial investment from podcasters. AG1 measures both reach (“occupying the right ears and minds”) and conversions (discount codes), plus brand interest/“energy.”
Podcast placements on Joe Rogan Experience, Tim Ferriss, and Huberman Lab; community-led trust at Yeti; name change from Athletic Greens to AG1 to avoid “greens” commodity framing; comparisons to KFC and Starbucks; AG1’s mechanic-space following; GLP-1s driving gut-health and nutrient-gap relevance.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Learn how AG1 ventured into the podcast marketing space early on.
“It was very early in the world of podcasting.”
Discussing how AG1 uses podcasts to build a trustworthy brand.
“Before he went to AG1, he was the CMO of Yeti, quite another cool brand, and he played a creative leadership role at Uber during its transition from a startup to an IPO.”
Exploration of storytelling in podcast advertising and audience engagement.
“But what we liked about it was, well, you're listening to people you trust, but you get time with them, right?”
Insights on how Yeti and AG1 build trust through community engagement.
“People all of a sudden didn't have the answers and were looking for information, right?”
Discussing challenges in brand identity and the transition from Athletic Greens to AG1.
“Well, it builds up through a couple of things.”
Understanding the balance between brand value and hard numbers in marketing.
“and America's, I do want you to weigh in on this because you seriously are so much closer to the target audience than I am.”
Explore the challenges brands face in representing themselves through various channels.
“It's a tough one to swallow in the health regime.”
Discussing the significance of maintaining brand integrity and selecting the right representatives.
“because it's great when Andrew Huberman shows up because he's got the books open, he's doing the science.”
Learn how authenticity in podcast marketing can strengthen brand relationships.
“I mean, it reminds me a little of like Jason Kelsey and Travis Kelsey.”
Understanding the metrics behind podcast advertising effectiveness and brand engagement.
“Is it measured the way typically advertising dollars are measured?”
Insights on AG1's rebranding strategy and the future of wellness branding.
“It is a brand that means something to you, right?”
Discussing upcoming trends in the wellness industry and AG1's strategic positioning.
“But the discipline of a brand to stay like that is incredible.”
Learn about the importance of product quality in marketing and the growth of wellness trends.
“I always say this, like go work for an amazing product.”
Discover where to find AG1 products and insights into wellness journeys.
“It's been so much fun talking to you, but we are at the end of your time.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Knowledge at Wharton, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:05We took a gamble on podcasts. It was very early in the world of podcasting. But what we liked about it was, well, you're listening to people you trust, but you get time with them. All right. The AG1 products, as demonstrated, even though you did a superb job, Barbara, it's kind of hard to explain, right? It's a daily health drink. Well, it commands a green liquid, and that's not all I can explain. It just kind of looks yucky. Green liquid that looks yucky. Okay, let's start from there. Marketing matters. Marketing is absolutely critical. You can have the greatest product in the world if no one knows about it.
0:43It just doesn't matter. People think out of the box it's going to make you more creative, but sometimes when you're in a constrained situation, that's when a lot of creativity blooms. Barbara, you use Uber Eats, don't you? My husband does. I don't believe in the internet. I didn't know that the internet was faith-based. I'll tell you, you could just buy the car we bought. We have a hybrid. What'd you buy? I don't know exactly.
1:04Paulie Dery: The power of brands, ladies and gentlemen. This is Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network. Hello and welcome. You're listening to Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network. This is our weekly podcast where we analyze the latest in advertising, marketing, customer behavior, new product launches, branding, retailing, everything marketing. I'm Barbara Kahn, the Patty and J.H. Baker Professor of Marketing, and I'm joined by my co-host, Americus Reid, the Whitney M. Young Jr. Professor of Marketing and the brand identity theorist. And today we have a very special guest, Pauly Derry.
1:45He's the chief marketing officer at AG1, which is a global health company focused on foundational nutrition. AG1 is best known for its all-in-one greens powder that combines vitamins, minerals, probiotics, all sorts of weird stuff. Sorry, but cool stuff that America probably knows about into a single drink. And what's also interesting about AG1 is its marketing strategy. It has a very strong presence in podcast advertising. It's been on the Joe Rogan experience, the Tim Ferriss show, the Huberman Lab. And it's this idea of building trust at scale through host-read storytelling. It's a very modern age, modern brand.
2:35And we are so happy to have Paulie Derry. As I said, he's the chief marketing officer at AG1, but he brings over two decades of brand marketing experience to this role. Before he went to AG1, he was the CMO of Yeti, quite another cool brand, and he played a creative leadership role at Uber during its transition from a startup to an IPO. We're going to talk about how you build a premium brand in a very crowded category, how you do it at scale, how you can use podcast marketing to build trust and performance. We're very delighted to have you, Polly. Hello, and welcome to our show. Wow, Barbara, what an intro.
3:19We've got to get AG1 on this podcast immediately. I mean, what a job you did there. That was outstanding. Yeah, she's a pro. We'll get her an affiliate code ASAP. Incredible. And I did mention that you were going to come on the show with a superb accent. I've been working on this Australian accent for quite a while. You're very good for storytelling. Yeah, it's very good, mate. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Awesome. Yeah, I think if I ever lose my accent, I think my wife might leave me. So I've got to keep it. That's all I've got, guys. There's a lot at stake. Those are the things that definitely matter.
3:58So what do you want to talk about first? Do you want to start with AG1 and podcasting? Do you want to talk a little bit about what you did before you got there? What's your preference? Well, yeah, I mean, we're on the podcast train. Maybe I'll try and couple a bit of it all together because I think it is all connected. And a big part of it is how do you build trust as a brand, right? And I think with AG1, what's really interesting is, you know, we took a gamble on podcasts. It was very early in the world of podcasting. But what we liked about it was, well, you're listening to people you trust, but you get time with them, right?
4:41The AG1 products, as demonstrated, even though you did a superb job, Barbara, it's kind of hard to explain, right? It's a daily health drink. Well, it commands a green liquid, and it's not hard to explain. It kind of looks like it. Green liquid. Barbara just gave you everything she's got, Pauly. Yeah. That's great, guys. It's a green liquid that looks yucky. Okay, let's start from there, Barbara. How do you sell a green liquid that looks yucky? We'll work it up. So, yeah, you know, it's got 75 ingredients. It's got pre-probiotics. It's got multivitamins. So it's really this like, you know, more in one kind of way to start your day.
5:17You put the powder in nice cold water and you drink it and you've done. You've done yourself a really good service. But to explain that and anything you put in your body, you need time and you need to build trust. What podcasters gave us was that, right? Time. Time to explain the product in detail. Not only that, everyone we work with has to be an AG1 drinker, right? They have to have been an AG1 drinker. Or if they reach out to us and they haven't tried us, it's like, great, guys. we're going to send you some products and call us back in a couple of months and tell us, you know, how have you found it?
5:59Has it worked? You tell us. But we need them in the journey, right? We need authenticity. We need it. It's super important. Look, and then along came COVID, right? And what happened? People all of a sudden didn't have the answers and were looking for information, right? And they turn to people they trust and primarily via podcasts, right? So it was an interesting moment in time where people were doing the research and really trying to understand what they could take to help them through that process. And thus, I think, was where we had great success. So, yeah, it's been a great story on podcasting.
6:44Again, just to allow to tell the story and build the trust. One thing I think is really interesting about this, I was one of those people who converted to podcasting during COVID, and I'm very loyal. I don't listen to the same to Joe Rogan, but I do listen to my own podcast that I like. And what I think is interesting about what you're saying is that typically when you listen to ads, you skip through them. But when you're listening to a podcast and that host has integrated the story into the podcast and the voice is the same, first of all, it's not as easy to go through it. And second of all, if he or she is a good storyteller, you're halfway through the story.
7:30You don't even want to skip it because they're telling you something that's informational. And so it is very interesting, the collaboration between the right brand and the right podcast host. And it's a very different way of thinking about advertising. Very. And you're spot on. And look, we cast a pretty wide net on who reads our stuff. As long as they're authentic, as long as they love the product, that's great. Talk to your audience about it. Only if you truly believe it, though, right? It's a big world out there and that's where we focus. And let me try and pull the thread back through my history.
8:08You think about a brand like Yeti. Yes. Again, how does that trust build up? Well, it builds up through a couple of things. Yeti did an amazing job early on of getting into the communities. Community marketing is still a huge part of Yeti. And getting in with like fishing guides on the coast of Texas and Florida, right? And but really becoming part of that culture and family, really. And then as the brand grew, as word got out, other communities popped up. And what we did at Yeti was we didn't force it, right? If a community embraced the product, well, then we would embrace them. We would follow the tracks, not try and force them.
8:54And it built up this like same thing. well, you know, this community are using the product and they are actually loving the product. Once that's done, well, then I'm going to go and engage, right, as opposed to inflict it on them. And that's – it kind of kept growing that way at Yeti, right? So that very organic trust through the communities is what we followed and built the brand around. And then we told great stories, right, on top of that. Another way to build trust, right? Telling great stories that aren't product-centric, that aren't trying to sell you things, they're just trying to introduce you into the world that you're in, it's another great way to build trust.
9:35So did you, I mean, the other thing that's interesting to me about AG1, and America's, I do want you to weigh in on this because you seriously are so much closer to the target audience than I am. You changed your name from Athletic Greens to AG1, and you're also talking about this. The Yeti strategy seems somewhat different to me than Athletic Greens or AG1. And I mean, from what you're saying, the way you, you know, bottom up built Yeti. And it seems like this AG1 is not quite the same. Is that right or no? So let me tell you where there are a lot of similarities there, Barbara. Both created a category, right?
10:17And a premium version of the category, right? So you could buy a cooler before Yeti. You certainly couldn't buy one for$400. Yes. You could buy vitamins. You could buy minerals. Yes. Yes. That's fair. That's fair. But at AG1, we put it all together in a really nice tasting green powder. Okay, so what happens after you make this breakthrough, right? Well, everybody comes in, right? Knockoffs appear out of the woodwork. Yes, yes. You know, in the supplement industry, there's a lot of snake oil out there, right? And so what are you trying to stop? You're trying to stop becoming a commodity. And what I mean by that is, look, you could walk into a Dick's Sporting Goods, pull out an insulated cup, hold them side by side and say, right, which one am I getting?
11:12This one's$20 cheaper. Maybe I should just, okay, if you are in that world, it's over. Your brand is over. You have no longevity. You have no love. You have no cult following. You are a race to the bottom. And that's okay. If that's your game, go for it, right? I'm not interested in those brands. I really want to feel something for the brand I'm purchasing or working for. So my real focus with both of these brands is they can't become commodities. Well, what does that mean? It means the customer has to make their mind up because they love it. Before they walk in store, right? Hey, I'm walking in and I know I'm getting a Yeti.
11:54I just don't know which one because I love Yeti, right? Same with AG1. Well, it's a crowded space, but AG1 seem to be the real, you know, they're scientifically backed. They feel like the premium. I like the brand. That's where I'm at. That is the magic, right? And that's where brands have to get. The problem is it is at odds with your CFO a lot of the time, right? Doing the thing. Wait a minute. Hold on. The CFO and the CMO are at odds? Wait, I've never heard this. Well, any aspiring CMO out there, I think the first interview you've got to have with any business is the CFO. And if you don't vibe, it's going to be very, very hard.
12:41I always say, look, you should want to join a brand or a business that wants to do this, right? It wants to be a brand leader. It understands the beauty of brand. It understands the beauty of what you do. It's like when you're with a boyfriend or a girlfriend, right? I'll be the one that changes them. I'll be the one that, no, you won't. They have to change themselves, right? Like it's going to be a miserable, miserable effort. Well, so to that line, why did you change the brand name? Why did you go from Athletic Greens to AG1? and when did that happen? Good question. That was actually because our category, we are not a greens.
13:17We are green by color, right? And if you think about all the knockoffs that started to appear and snake oil, they were saying we're a greens, but there were no pre-probiotics, there were no multivitamins, you know, it wasn't. So they were coming out at, you know, half our price saying we are a greens just like us. And we're like, but we're not. We're more than that. So AG1 was the way actually to say it's a lot of things in one, right? And not lean heavy on the word green. It reminds me a little bit of when Kentucky Fried Chicken changed to KFC. To stop having people rehearse the word fried. It's a tough one to swallow in the health regime.
14:07That's very interesting. Let me ask you this, Pauly, because I want to go back to the point that Barbara made about brand, because I'm hearing the word brand and the difficulty of the CMO to be able to show up with hard numbers, right? Because the CFO loves the hard numbers. They want to see, like, what's this thing worth and what is the brand equity worth? Especially, by the way, in podcast advertising, which is brand new. Yeah. So talk a little bit about that point, because, I mean, as a brand, you have to sort of put something on there so it's not a commodity. And talk us through that, but also remind me a little bit, because you said something that I want to push back on a little bit, Pauly, which is the idea of not push back on, but ask you about the challenge of letting anyone come in and say, hey, let me use AG1 and I will promote.
14:56because that seems risky in some ways because it's great when Andrew Huberman shows up because he's got the books open, he's doing the science. But if you have some bizarre podcasters showing up to some weird extreme part of the internet and they're like, hey, are you going to say no to those guys or what? I mean, there's got to be some non-starters that are out there. Give me a sense of that in terms of how you think about it. Look, you've always got to protect the brand, right? And this is what I think brands have to do out the gate is who are you and who are you not? Because the brands I worry about are the brands that are trying to be for everybody.
15:36And I think you look at a Yeti advertising or any ad Yeti does, you know that's a Yeti ad. Not to say someone at their desk in New York City isn't drinking their coffee out of a Yeti. But they're probably not going to make it to a Yeti ad. And that's okay because Yeti knows who they are and knows who they're not. They're not excluding anyone. They just, when it comes to the brand control, understand who they are. Same at AG1. We know who we are and who we're not, right? We're premium. We're very science-focused. You know, athletes built our business, right, in that they adopted us early. But it is expanded.
16:23It's expanded to a much broader audience. So, yes, you'll always put a filter on, you know, who do you want representing the brand? My point is that if you are really, you know, love the brand and have seen the effects, right, well, then that's a pretty good start for us to have a conversation, right? Yeah, that's true. That makes sense. That's fair. But what I will say, like, we found interesting things, and this is, I think, America's where there is a bit of overlap between the latest two brands I've had, is I don't think a lot of the times also the brand shouldn't be too pushy on where it goes.
17:02It should let the people decide, right? So I'll give you a good example. We actually have a large following in the mechanic space at AG1. Oh, that's interesting. When I joined, I was like, this is strange to me. And, you know, it doesn't show elite athletes. You know, I don't know about this. guys. But what I did discover was these people obsess over what they do. They're professional about what they do. They use their community to get answers. They're very professional in their approach to things and they need the focus, right? And they need to stay on top of it, which AG1 gave them. So who am I to say you're not part of our family, right?
17:46Right. I see. When they take that on. Yeah. I mean, another way to build on America's point, I think going back to this podcast stuff, the podcast people that you are working with have made significant commitments to your brand. I mean, it reminds me a little of like Jason Kelsey and Travis Kelsey. This is one of the podcasts I listen to, New Heights. And they invested in garage beer because it's true to who they are and they're members of their beer. Well, what I understand from doing a little research here is that like Tim Ferriss, who had that podcast, he now invested in your company, believed in it so much.
18:27And Huberman, who, as you said, is a professor at Stanford, a scientist. He's also come on to give medical advice to the company. That's an interesting way to think about the relationship between podcasts and a brand that they believe in it so much. It becomes part of their life and that relationship gets tighter. Would that be something you're aiming for or it just happened? It's a beautiful circle too because, you know, I think about Hugh Jackman, for example, right, who we just did a great campaign with on TV with Hugh, who's amazing and I love him for many reasons, not just because he's Australian, obviously.
19:17Multi-talented. Yeah. Yeah. It's, you know, no one was confusing us on set, unfortunately. Everyone knew who Hugh was. That's good. You know, but Hugh has been with the brand for six years, right? So what a great, to your point, Barbara, I don't have to force or convince or kind of con anyone when I can use people who are absolutely wrapping their arms around our products and vouching for it. Also, imagine you listen to a podcast that was repping a brand for five years and then all of a sudden they take a check for a competitor and they're selling that other brand. How would you be? You'd be like, well, hang on a sec.
20:08What happened here? It just doesn't work that way. You need these people who are emotionally invested, if not financially invested, in what you're doing. That's spot on. I mean, this is kind of where I was going also, and I thought it was where America was going because he always goes to this end on the metrics. It's like, how do you, you know, I said like what's different about podcasting advertising, and I've noticed this again in my own behavior, is it's not like an interruption the way ads are. It's really part of the podcast. It's part of the authenticity. And that's why it's very important, like you said, that it's not fake, because then all of that won't work.
20:51It's got to be something they really believe in. But then how do you measure? Can you measure the conversion rates from podcast advertising? Is it measured the way typically advertising dollars are measured? Absolutely. Absolutely. And that's another reason I really love the medium is because it does a brand job and it does a growth job, right? Like, you know, you may think, well, I listen to this podcast every week. So does everyone else, right? It's the same community, same group of listeners. So why would you keep spending into this? Everyone's heard your ad week after week. Well, I like that.
21:30I like that from the brand. I'm not moving away from someone. We're in a relationship here, right? That's interesting. And I don't want to just, I'm not going to love you and leave you, right? You know, I want that conversation to continually go with all your listeners. But there is a conversion aspect, of course. You know, it's a great channel. So we measure it on both fronts. You know, are we occupying the right ears and minds and are we converting? So, yeah, it's a double-sided medium for sure. People talk about metrics a lot with me. I have a metric. Back to our CFO, who's amazing, by the way.
22:18I will also. He is Australian, so maybe that helps. And I had this metric too at Yeti, but the key KPI for me is energy, right? And people say, well, what the hell is that? Well, energy is the brand of interest to people, right? And so when I turn up to one of our events, are people excited we're there? Are people excited to talk to me? Are other brands calling me during the week saying, hey, man, like, love what you guys are doing. Can we do something together, right? Now that's a marketing metric, kind of hand-waving. That is it. There you go. But they also have discount codes, too, that they can look at and see.
23:03this came from that podcast that's right well we're not stupid americas you know um but uh but but um understood you you know you're right you know because you always say well you've got to prove the financials of it to prove it well okay but what are your favorite brands and what are your favorite ads i guarantee you they're not performance ads right i guarantee you it is a Totally. It is a brand that means something to you, right? And it's a brand that has separated itself from the other commodities in its market. But to my point, it's going to be very hard for you to convince people if they don't want to be convinced of that inside the building.
23:45Let me go back to this change of name. And it's interesting what America said. You're obsessed with this change of name, Barbara. I mean, it's a big thing for you. I like it. You said you changed it because the competitors came in and you didn't want to focus on the green because it was more commodity and that you wanted to be the number one thing, everything all together. Well, the other advantage, which is what America said, but it isn't what you said, is that KFC moved away from their brand because they didn't want to focus on fried. And, you know, Starbucks coffee changed to Starbucks. So they got rid of the limitation on coffee.
24:23That's another advantage you would have going from athletic greens to AG1. And I was wondering if that was part of the motivation at all, because you now can go to, you're not limited to green liquid anymore. You can, if you're building a relationship with an athlete on wellness or nutrition, with a brand name like AG1, you can go to things that are purple. You don't have to be green anymore. Was that part of it at all? I think, you know, being future forward when you make these decisions is always a good plan, right? So for sure, somewhere down the road, it's a lot less limiting, right? You don't have to be so literal with things 100%.
25:10I think it's a great thing to do. You know, we do have a sleep product. We call it AGZ. Oh, that's cute. Which was fun. And it's an amazing, amazing product. But, yeah, look, I think having the flexibility in naming and branding is smart. Like to your Starbucks point, it does open you up to be a brand, not a product, right? And I think that's – So, I love you. I love you. Yeah, so just let me finish on that, Barbara, because one thing I think is incredible about AG1 is for 15 years we sold one thing and one thing only. and you can only get it D2C, right? You can only get it online. And that takes incredible discipline for a brand.
25:59Now we're in Costco and Target and we've got new flavors and all that stuff. But the discipline of a brand to stay like that is incredible. And as we start to evolve, obviously, and competitors came in, we saw a moment to kind of revitalize the brand a little. Well, going along those lines, you know, now that you do have a broader umbrella and you're in the wellness, I think you would define your business as in the wellness business, right? And that is a growth industry beyond belief. I mean, everybody's talking about the growth and wellness. So given that you're there, you're at, what do you see as the future?
26:38I mean, what are the trends? What can you tell us from your inside viewpoint? Well, yeah, well, there's a lot of trends. And one thing, again, I would say the magic of this product is, like, think about GLPs, right? GLP-1s I think is totally changing. I mean, let's just start with this country, right? I think it's changing how people eat. It's changing how people exercise. I think it's changing about how people, what they shop for now, right? I think it's really just impacting the marketplace in such a way that we may have never seen before. well okay what what happens when you get on a glp your your gut is getting messed with well what's ag1 all about it's about gut health right um and and uh what else is ag1 got in it well it's got a ton of nutrients it fills nutrient gaps well what aren't i getting when i'm on glp1s So I'm not eating enough.
27:37Right. Wow. So I think, um, the future is, is, you know, is we still got a lot of road to cover with our product, which, which, but for us as marketers, okay, well now, how do we position? How do we talk? How do we find, you know, how do we interact? How do we stay true? They're all fabulous challenges for us. Thankfully for me, I always say this, like go work for an amazing product. Cause like, I'm not a good enough marketer to work at bad products. You know, you've got to be really good to market a bad product. So, you know, there's lots of opportunities within the sphere of the current product to go after what we're seeing in the wellness space because I actually think we were pretty ahead of the time with the product and kind of everything's catching up.
28:25Especially recognizing the advantage of podcasts and the advantage of this wellness growth, which is like huge. But if you've got some ideas, some product ideas, if you've got product ideas, send them my way. I can't believe it. It's been so much fun talking to you, but we are at the end of your time. Thank you, Polly Derry, CMO at AG1. Thank you so much for joining us today. And so where can our listeners go? I mean, either to these podcasts or where else can they go to find out about your product? You can go to drinkag1.com or you could pop into your local Costco or Target. We will meet you there.
29:00and I hope you begin and enjoy your wonderful wellness journey. Okay. Well, thank you very much. That's all we have time for today, and we'd like to thank our producer, Jacob Grodd, and thank you all for listening today. We'll be back soon. Until then, this has been Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network. I'm Barbara Kahn, here with Americus Reid.
How did AG1 turn podcast advertising into a powerful engine for trust and growth?
Paulie Dery, Chief Marketing Officer at AG1, explains why the company invested early in podcast advertising and built long-term relationships with hosts who genuinely use the product. He discusses how AG1 measures both brand impact and conversions, why authenticity is essential to host-read advertising, and how the company protects its premium positioning.
Dery also shares the strategy behind the transition from Athletic Greens to AG1, lessons from his time at YETI, AG1’s expansion into Costco and Target, and how strong brands avoid becoming commodities.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.