


Post-midterms election analysis with Jonah Goldberg, focusing on Trump’s evasions, the plausibility of election-fraud claims, and competing “autopsy” narratives—especially J.D. Vance’s theory that the Iran war (and Israel’s influence) cost Republicans.
Jonah Goldberg is a conservative commentator and frequent CNN guest.
The election was “incontestable,” making sweeping fraud claims unlikely to succeed in court or with major media. Trump’s fraud narrative is framed as backpedaling after a “rebuke.” Vance’s “Vance guard” argument is criticized as inconsistent and anti-Semitic in substance—blaming Israel for U.S. decisions while ignoring similar right-wing acceptance of other interventions (e.g., Venezuela). Voters mainly shifted via turnout and independence breaking against Trump, not a large 2024-to-2026 switch.
60 Minutes interview with Trump; Roger Stone’s North Korea fake-ballot claim; Trump’s “Venezuela model” approach applied to Iran; Vance’s autopsy tweet omitting “corruption” despite Fox polling showing corruption as crucial.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the aftermath of midterms and Trump's recent interview.
“There's really nobody I would rather talk to about the aftermath.”
Exploration of narratives surrounding election outcomes and the responses from various political factions.
“And maybe it's merely because of what a trouncing it was that really you just can't lie about it.”
Speculation on the potential traction of Trump's claims of election fraud.
“Do you think there's any chance he's going to get traction with claims of election fraud?”
Analysis of Trump's support base and their motivations amidst the election results.
“So I think Trump may, as the West Wing becomes a reenactment of a downfall video, he may lean into it more and more, but I just don't think it'll have much purchase where it would matter.”
Discussion on the impact of the Iran war on Republican election losses and ideological inconsistencies.
“For instance, if the war is the reason why Republicans lost, I mean, if J.D.”
Explore the complexities of U.S. foreign policy decisions and their impact on elections, particularly in relation to Iran and Israel.
“They celebrated the whole take the oil initiative in Venezuela and all of the lying and illegal, you know, pretext that went into that.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Making Sense with Sam Harris, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Sam Harris: You're listening to Making Sense with Sam Harris. This is the free version of the podcast, so you'll only hear the first part of today's conversation. If you want the full episode and every episode, you can subscribe at samharris.org. There are no ads on this show. It runs entirely on subscriber support. If you enjoy what we're doing here and find it valuable, please consider subscribing today. I'm here with Jonah Goldberg. Jonah, it's great to see you again. And it's great to be back. Thanks for having me. So I can only imagine that you have done 12 podcasts and been on CNN 15 times post midterms, but I've yet to talk about it.
0:40Sam Harris: So if you're not too sick of the sound of your own voice, I want you to be my oracle here. There's really nobody I would rather talk to about the aftermath. But before we jump into the election postmortem proper, did you see the 60 Minutes interview with Trump last night? I did. I thought it was great. Yeah, I thought Ross did a great job. I don't know what I was expecting going in, but I felt that his, I mean, Trump is successfully evasive in ways that are still fairly supernatural, but Ross cut in with rational questions again and again and again. I thought it was really, I have nothing but respect for how he handled his side of that interview.
1:18Yeah, I do think it's a bit of a triumph for, I mean, Ross is a friend and I was nervous for him because a lot of people have been steamrolled by Trump. Oh yeah. And I'd say it's probably the, with the exception of Jonathan Swan, who did a really fantastic interview with him a while back, I would say it's, it's the best one I can remember. and I want to give a little shout out to print people. Because there is something about TV broadcasters that I don't want to cast dispersions to colleagues at any of the networks or any of that kind. But like there is something about Ross's way of doing things from being a print guy, I think, that lends itself really well to this about, you know, and recognizing that Trump wants to do the weave, right?
2:03And go on as normal talking points. and Ross went in just very prepared as is his want. So I thought it was good. There were some people who were complaining about the interruptions, but I think the interruptions were vitally necessary.
2:14Sam Harris: Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. Because otherwise it was just going to be the same bullshit like meandering, nursing home patient, wandering her off into the snow kind of stuff. And I thought there were some answers I would have loved to hear a more fulsome answer, but I think Ross's instinct was that Trump was looking for all sorts of exit ramps to evade. Yeah. And so he had to intervene. And I thought it was great. Yeah, I thought he managed to do it without being adversarial in a way that Trump would have had a bad reaction to. I really thought it was a very impressive high wire act on death's part. And I don't know if there's anything in the interview that you want to reflect on.
2:53Sam Harris: I mean, the first thing I was going to say about the election is that the most gratifying thing from my point of view is that we have proven to ourselves that we can hold an election that is really incontestable. And maybe it's merely because of what a trouncing it was that really you just can't lie about it. But I've noticed that since the interview last night, Trump has begun to lie about it and claim election fraud. But in the interview, he simply admitted that the Republicans lost for a variety of reasons. Yeah. I mean, I saw those, you know, him backpedaling on the stolen election stuff, which, you know, we don't have to spend a lot of time on.
3:32We'll talk about whatever you want, but like it is so flatly preposterous that, you know, there's these Trump accounts. They're talking about these voter shifts in Texas and how this is impossible. Oh, it's not impossible because it actually happened. But second of all, it's what's impossible is the idea. This is something I've had these arguments for so long. These people who want to claim that like ballots were faked and all of these kinds of things. One of the great features of our system is how local our elections are. And you can go into an election in your neighborhood and the ballot will be different than one five minutes further up the road because you have a different dog catcher on ballot, you have a different superintendent for schools, you have a different, you know, local, you know, commission for this, that, or the other thing on it.
4:21And the idea that you could go to Kinko's and get these doctored ballots at literally tens of thousands of different locations without anybody noticing, you know, is just so preposterous when you think about it. I remember Roger Stone, who I think is, you know, a carbuncle, but he had this great thing where he said, I know for a fact after the 2020 election that North Korea has shipped fake ballots that they unloaded in Maine and then - Imagine the graphic design on those ballots. Yeah. Yeah. Because the North Koreans really have a granular understanding of who ran for dog catcher in Peoria. It's just all so stupid.
5:01But it's not as surprising as I thought it would be that he would eventually backslide into this because I think it's now dawning on him how total the rebuke of him was. And that's one of the problems we've got with, you know, we're in this weird moment where it starts a few days before an election and it continues for about three weeks after an election where partisan factions of all sorts want to put their stamp on the official narrative about why so-and-so won or so-and-so lost and that kind of thing. And it's not just Democrats want to say it was this and Republicans want to say it was that, it's that the DSA wants to say it was their very progressive agenda and the normie moderate Dems want to say no, it's like we returned to sanity and that's why we won these red states, which I think there's a lot of truth to that.
5:51Vance wants, which we'll get to I'm sure, Vance wants to say it was all about the Iran war and nothing else. And the reason why everyone's scrambling so much so fast right now is because pretty soon the narrative congeals and then there'll still be, people who dispute it and have their counter narratives, but the conventional wisdom becomes kind of locked in in terms of how reporters talk about it, how the parties mount a, either for the Republicans, a comeback operation, or how Democrats determine where the Overton window is for what they can get done. And everybody kind of recognizes this and everybody wants to sort of, while the Clay is still malleable, wants to get their thumbprints in it.
6:39And that's what we're seeing right now on just all across Washington.
6:42Sam Harris: Do you think there's any chance he's going to get traction with claims of election fraud? Not really. In part because he's a lame duck and the various factions who are looking to 2028, they might do it as a lot of Republicans did, as lip service to, you know, MAGA populists and that kind of thing, but it'll get laughed out at courts, you know? I mean, look, there might be legitimate legal stuff in Alaska and Mississippi because the recount stuff is narrow and hard, but this idea that there was sweeping voter fraud, it can't go anywhere in courts and it'll further brand the Republican party as this extension of sort of Trump's narcissism and conspiracy stuff.
7:29And I just think there are too many Republicans who realize there's no percentage for them in that now. And also, you know, there's a lot of reporting and from some people I've talked to as well, is that, you know, Rupert Murdoch has zero desire to go back down the Dominion lawsuit path. And they kind of think Trump is a increasingly spent force and passed his sell-by date. So the idea that it'll get traction in, I can't speak for OAN or Newsbacks and those places, but the idea that it'll get major traction from Fox is unlikely. And without that, you know, I just don't know how far it could go, even if there was some superficial false, but superficially plausible rationale behind it.
8:09So I think Trump may, as the West Wing becomes a reenactment of a downfall video, he may lean into it more and more, but I just don't think it'll have much purchase where it would matter.
8:22Sam Harris: Well, what percentage of Americans do you think fall into the just irretrievable MAGA bitter ender camp? I mean, do you have a sense of the people for whom there's literally nothing Trump could do or that could be said about him or that could happen as a result of his policies that would pry them loose from the cult? i mean obviously when we're talking about large numbers individual people are different and you know but as a as a block i think it's the lion's share of what's left of his positive favorability rating right i mean i think the so that's what it was at 30 35 it's in the low 30s depending on the poll that you're looking at that kind of thing and i if i had to guess it's you know it's probably 28%, 26%.
9:11And I don't think all of those people, I don't think it's fair to say all those people are the cultists. Some of them are just so polarized and anti and defensive about their choices, right? And anti-left, anti-democrat, anti-mainstream media, anti-establishment and all that kind of stuff that they won't countenance the idea of saying they dislike Trump to a pollster or something like that, but they're still out there for sure. There's just a half-life to it, I think.
9:44Sam Harris: So obviously these election results were in some sense overdetermined. Everyone can find their favorite reason why the Republicans lost so many seats, but I do worry that some of the reasons why they lost were bad ones, or at least suggest something dysfunctional in the future about our politics. For instance, if the war is the reason why Republicans lost, I mean, if J.D. Vance is right there, if it's the war plus Israel's manipulation of the president into the war, so the scheming Jews behind the war, that is depressing on at least two counts. I mean, obviously the conspiracy theory and the anti-Semitism that you just need only add water to to get a whole worldview that's diabolical, that's a problem.
10:30Sam Harris: But in my view, the Iran war, which we can talk about or not, is one of the only things that, in addition to closing the border, that is rational that Trump attempted to do. Now, he's done it with a level of incompetence that is astonishing even for him, right? So it's been a disaster in its waging. But the people who are against the war are not against Trump's ineptitude. They're against the war in principle, right? No new foreign wars. I mean, they're isolationists. They want us to retreat. We shouldn't be the world's cop. This war was always going to be wrong no matter how we waged it. And I think that's a scary lesson to draw if that is the reason why.
11:14Sam Harris: If in fact, the right war, no matter how you wage it, is going to raise gas prices for a period. We're proving ourselves to be a nation that can't stomach that. I don't know if I feel free to react to that, but I - So yeah, if you give me a second on this one, because I think you're absolutely right, but I think you're offering, I don't want to shock you, too rosy a scenario. I'm rarely convicted of that, so I would love to hear that. So the argument that Vance put out in his really disingenuous autopsy tweet, you know, that 617 word thing, the logic of it and the logic of what people are now calling the Vance guard, you know, the people who rallied to his Praetorians who rallied to his defense and everything.
11:56The argument they want to make is that people voted on an ideological basis against the Iran war, that the original sin was doing it at all. Now, I'm very much a critic of how Trump did it. I think announcing in the middle of the night, wearing a baseball hat with no preparation, no sell, no going to Congress, none of that stuff was incredibly inept. No allies. I would argue, no allies. Yeah. And without just utterly dismissing through his power of positive thinking, the idea that they would close the Strait of Hormuz, something that is in every single war game and textbook going back 40 years.
12:34Yeah. About what Iran would do if attacked. And, and in part, we know that they would do it because they've done it before. Um, and, and they said they'd do it. And, and so like, it was like, he just, I don't think it'll happen. So the argument that they want to make is that it's forever wars that are the problem, right? And I'm against forever wars, but I'm looking, I've been looking for a couple of days now to find someone who's making that's the robust argument, the Vancean argument that it wasn't gas prices per se. It was the initial decision to go to war that drove all of this, who didn't also full-throatedly endorse the Venezuelan operation.
13:15Right? So they're not against imperial adventures and regime change or any of these kinds of things. They're against doing it because in their mind, they think if you do it in the Middle East, it's for the benefit of Israel. and maybe because these bagel-snarfing warmongers in Israel pulled his strings and made him do it. And that, I think, is in many ways objectively an anti-Semitic argument. Not necessarily everybody who makes it is full of Jew hatred, though some are, but that it says that it singles out Israel as a part of our foreign policy as different from any other place. These people didn't mind Trump threatening to use force to take Greenland.
13:56These people didn't mind Trump, you know, trying to bully Canada into becoming a state. They celebrated the whole take the oil initiative in Venezuela and all of the lying and illegal, you know, pretext that went into that. But when they, when Trump goes into Iran, suddenly they become these principled isolationists. They get, they forget all of their Don Roe doctrine bullshit and everything else that they said, and they embrace this sort of veneer of ideological and intellectual consistency, but they only apply it when it comes to things that they think fit this narrative of Israel running our elections or running our government and that kind of thing.
14:36And so I don't credit them for that argument, right? Because it's not a consistently held argument. And part of my problem is you'll hear people argue, including my friend Michael Brendan Doherty at National Review, that it is unfair to say the American people were voting against higher gas prices and not against this Middle Eastern war because the whole point, and I think this is an intellectually serviceable argument, the serious people, like Michael, would argue, well, the unintended consequences, the blowback of going to war in the Middle East has to be part of the equation and you can't separate the consequences from the initial bad decision.
15:17Okay. Well then how do you reconcile the fact that Donald Trump has been quite explicit that his intent was to replicate the Venezuela model? He called it the Venezuela model. He wanted to do Venezuela with Iran. And these people who warn about blowback and unintended consequences and all that kind of stuff cannot countenance the fact that one of the unintended consequences of the, you know, arguable success, I have some problems calling it, I think it's a little premature to call Venezuela a success, but as a military operation, it clearly was that one of the unintended consequences of that was that Donald Trump would take away from it the lesson that wars are easy.
15:59And no one criticized him or Hegseth or any of these people when he did Venezuela. So Trump said, well, I did it once. I can do it again. And it turns out that Iran is a very different country than Venezuela and all the other things that we know about, you know, the, the difficulty of doing it apply. But the simple fact is, is that at the end of the day, there's no data that whatever Vance's alleged great pollsters and all this kind of stuff that he says he consulted in that thing, no, you know, Omicron 5 ,000 supercomputers spit out the results that he claims were spit out about how it was, you know, four issues would bring back all of these wayward Trump voters.
16:38And it's Iran, put America first, whatever that he thinks that means. affordability and economics and recalibrate with Israel. It's really just two things, right? Because the Iran and the Israel thing are basically two sides of the same coin in his mind. And recall, Trump had argued, not Trump, Vance had argued that the memorandum of understanding fell apart because of a foreign interference operation by the Israelis in America. When in fact, and they actually kind of leaked that in this weird TikTok that they did in the New York Times about the lead up to the midterms where they blamed it on hawks like Ted Cruz and other supporters of the war, they insinuated in this sort of as told to by Vance version of events that their pressure caused the war to reignite, which is just a lie.
17:28The war reignited because the Iranians didn't observe the rules of the MOU and started hostilities again because it was a dumb MOU to begin with that Vance claims brought peace in our time and it didn't. And so I just think, And also, the last thing on the Vance thing, he says at the beginning of it that the issue about why they lost was because former Trump voters, it's not that the 2024 MAGA voters didn't show up in 2026 in his telling. It's that too many of them voted for the Democrats. There's very little data to support that. Maybe 7 % of Trump voters from 2024, according to the Fox exits, according to the Nork stuff, according to a bunch of different sources, say only about 7 % of the Trump 2024 voters switched to vote for Democrats in this election.
18:19The real source of the Democrats' win last week was massive Democratic turnout. A lot of people who didn't vote, who stayed home and didn't vote for Harris really turned out. And independence broke in ungodly numbers against Trump. And meanwhile, if you look at the exit polls, basically 80%, 77 % say that our relationship with Israel is about right or should be stronger. And Vance's argument, which I think is just a really dumb argument, is that the Republican party needs to recalibrate everything to win back this alleged 7 % of voters while insulting the nearly 80 % of voters who disagree with them about Israel.
19:04Now, I don't think, just to be last point, voters in America almost never vote on foreign policy. Right. The idea that many people, whether they like Israel or dislike Israel, voted that that was their main motivation, or even the Iran war as a matter of foreign policy debates, that that was what was driving them is just nonsense. I'm sure there were some, and I'm sure a lot of them were Democrats to begin with who would never vote for Trump. But the simple fact is, is that the consequences of the war, high gas prices combined with high tariffs, right? And the Vance people are putting out these charts all over the place to show that Trump's favorability declines starting with the, with the Iran war.
19:44And they, they take the chart and they, they basically airbrush out that if you just move the timeline back, it, his decline actually starts with the liberation day tariffs. and it's accelerated by the Iran war and then it's accelerated by the high prices caused by the inept and incompetent conduct of the Iran war.
20:03Sam Harris: Jonah, doesn't a lot of the polling suggest that corruption was also high on the list of people's concerns? Huge. And let us say, so the Vance autopsy does not mention the word corruption at all. And Vance, let no one forget, is the Trump administration's official anti-corruption czar. I missed that somehow. He fired all the inspectors general, but he put Vance in charge of routing out corruption in the government. And that was because what they meant by that was looking at corruption in Minnesota and the Somali stuff and all that, which I think there is a lot of corruption there, but he doesn't care about, he doesn't talk about the corruption.
20:43His biggest mentor is Don Jr., who, you know, had a Russian oligarch pay for his wedding, you know, and it is all in on the crypto stuff. And so the Fox poll says, and again, it's a Fox poll, right? Which should have some credibility in Megaland says 50, I think it's 55 % said it was a crucial issue in why they voted. And an additional 35%, it gets to 90 % said it was either a major or crucial issue for why they voted. And they just, he just airbrushes that out too. I mean, and so that's, this is what I'm getting at about the conventional wisdom formation stuff. It's so important because if we come out of this with the Republican party, taking away this idea that defenestrating Israel, turning our back also on Ukraine, because that's embedded in a lot of this stuff is the reason for the lost election.
21:38Then you're committing the Republican party to that path going forward. And, um, there's just an enormous number of the sort of new right MAGA intellectual types who are pushing extremely hard on that narrative. And they're memory holding the fact that Kevin Roberts of the Heritage Foundation and lots of other people celebrated the war when it started. And now they just want to say, oh, it's just those perfidious neocons who did this. And there are no neocons in this administration. And so it's an attempt at myth-making for the benefit of Vance and the sort of Tucker Carlson wing of the right.
22:15Sam Harris: Well, it seems that both parties are drawing the lesson that the U.S. needs a reset with Israel, right? I mean, like the Democrats and the, and the Republicans have drawn this lesson and don't, I mean, how do you, how do you map that onto the poll you just cited? What was it? 80 % of Americans think 80 % of Republicans, 80 % of Republicans. Okay. So it's, it's gotta be quite different among Democrats. I would imagine. Yeah. I don't know what the numbers of Democrats, but I'm sure it's different. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So it's, I mean, And if even if the Republicans are poised, well, maybe maybe maybe these vapors will dissipate and the Republicans will not be making these noises about Israel as we go into the 2028 campaign.
22:54Sam Harris: It'll just be the Democrats. Let's talk about both the Republicans and the Democrats here and the lessons they can plausibly draw. Let's start with the Republicans. What are these results due to J.D. Vance's prospects in 2028? Is he one of the main casualties of this, do you think? he's definitely a loser in this. He's not, there's no way you can talk about him being a winner, except in one scenario, which is that if Republicans concluded that no Republican can win in 2028, then it's, you know, was it the Napoleon line? I found a crown in the gutter and I put it on, you know, like it'll be, it'll be his for the taking because no one else wants it.
23:35Sam Harris: So, uh, drill down on that a little bit. So, because it's kind of counterintuitive, you think that it may look, 2028 may look so inauspicious for Republicans given this sweep that Rubio and, um, anyone else who - DeSantis, Cruz, you know, all that. Yeah. Well, I mean, we'll talk about DeSantis in a second, I guess, because he's, he is in a different orbit, but if it just looks like pure doom for whoever that Republican candidate will be, then J.D. Vance might just fine that he's just got an open lane to the coronation. Yeah. And again, I don't think that's likely. I'm just saying it's, it's not a scenario you can entirely rule out.
24:14I mean, it certainly, everyone I know follows this stuff, thinks Cruz is definitely running. Chris Christie is making noises that he's going to run. DeSantis certainly seems like he's going to run.
24:25Sam Harris: Well, DeSantis can plausibly say that he wasn't part of any of this debacle and he's always kept a critical distance conveniently on certainly this incarnation of MAGA in the second term. So he's squeaky clean as a candidate, isn't he? Yeah, it's a little ironic. He and Vance seem to have very similar, not exact theories of the case, that they both seem to think that the GOP has been permanently MAGA-fied and that what people want is competent MAGA, right? They want fewer mean tweets, less stuff, less corruption. You know, for Vance, his theory seems to be he's the vessel for Trumpism with twice the bigotry and half the charm, right?
25:18And he thinks he can just sort of fake that by being obnoxious and pugilistic, that's what people liked in Trump, so they'll like it in him too. And he'll double down on the tariff stuff and the anti-forever war interpretation of what MAGA was. But MAGA wasn't that. MAGA, at the end of the day, was a cult of personality about Trump himself. And the idea, I'm pretty sure I said this last time I was on here or the time before, in 2016, something the pundits, including me, we all got wrong. It was a cliche to say it. It's a cliche for pundits generally is to say, oh, he's not Donald Trump's not immune to the laws of political gravity and he'll come down eventually.
26:04And we said it throughout the primaries after one weird gap, attacking Gold Star moms, attacking John McCain. Right. It's like this won't last. He can't sustain this. And what we all missed was that he is immune to the laws of political gravity, or at least was because he is a subject of the laws of entertainment gravity.
26:22Sam Harris: Members can hear the full conversation by subscribing at SamHarris.org. Subscribers get a private RSS feed you can use with your favorite podcast player. What bothers me in some ways more about the anti-Semitism on the right is that, well, first of all, I spent my entire life, you know, as a conservative trying to defend conservatism. J.D. Vance will not condemn Tucker. He won't really condemn people who are hurling racist slurs at his own wife. That is very depressing to me. You
Sam Harris speaks with Jonah Goldberg about the aftermath of the midterm elections. They discuss Trump's 60 Minutes interview, Trump's claims of election fraud, JD Vance's autopsy of the Republican defeat, corruption and the pardon power, the prospects for impeachment, Stephen Miller, the 2028 field, the Democrats and the far left, trolling and the collapse of norms, the tech oligarchs, and other topics.
If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to gain access to all full-length episodes at samharris.org/subscribe.