Rapid Response: Crypto’s new chapter, w/Crypto Council for Innovation’s Sheila Warren

0:00Scaling a business in the US can feel like a maze. Each state has its own payroll, benefits, and compliance rules, pulling your focus away from growth, which is why founders use Deal. Deal is the professional employer organization, or PEO, that gives you a dedicated HR expert, plus Fortune 500-level benefits for your team. The National Association of PEOs says businesses can grow twice as fast if they use one. So, if you're scaling, make it simple with Deal. Go to deel.com. slash MOS and get up to three months free. If you're in private capital, you understand that your next great deal starts with who you know.

0:41That's why over 3 ,000 firms trust Affinity, the CRM platform purpose-built for private capital. Affinity's relationship intelligence reveals your team's strongest paths to founders, investors, and decision makers using insights It's hidden in emails, calendars, and meetings. With powerful AI tools like Affinity NoteTaker and Deal Assist, you'll spend less time managing data and more time closing the right deals. Learn more at affinity.co slash marketplace. 20 % of Americans across all demographics hold crypto. It's a wild number, one in five. It's something to take seriously and not to be afraid of.

1:27but also to be aware of because it's not just something relegated to like some randos on the internet, you know, or sophisticated investors who are tracking the price of tokens every single day. It's more relevant to everyday people than most people understand.

1:49That's Sheila Warren, CEO of the Crypto Council for Innovation, a global alliance supporting the technology. I wanted to talk to Sheila to understand the state of crypto today as prices rebound after scandals at FTX and elsewhere. Sheila takes us inside the crypto industry's big gathering last week in Austin, and she shares lessons from a new comprehensive crypto bill passed 10 days ago by the U.S. House of Representatives. She also reveals how crypto is impacting the presidential election and why you may already be using crypto tools in your business and personal life in ways that you don't realize.

2:27For anyone skeptical about crypto culture and Bitcoin hype, Sheila is here to show you what you might be overlooking. This is Rapid Response.

2:42I'm Bob Safian, and I'm here with Sheila Warren, CEO of the Crypto Council for Innovation. Sheila, thanks for being here with us today. Thanks for having me, Bob. It's good to be here. I understand that you just got back from the Consensus Conference in Austin, which is coined a big crypto conference each year. How was it? Any memorable moments for you? Oh, my goodness. This year, they had a bunch of different members of Congress that came down. They had RFK Jr. speaking, who's come out as kind of a crypto guy. Lots of discussions about Foreign President Trump, about President Biden. in. So I'd say it was a more policy and politics oriented conference than usual.

3:23The other thing I'll note on technical side was lots more discussion of decentralized AI. You know, people in crypto, even now, it's become a little bit more mainstream for sure over the last five or so years and definitely in the last year and a half. But it's still it's a place of people who believe there is a culty element to it. Definitely. So sometimes you see some funny things for sure. People often misunderstand and conflate like crypto and blockchain and Web3. Can you try to quickly sort of explain those terms, explain the differences and what you mean when you say crypto? Yeah. So blockchain is a technology.

3:59It is an underlying technical architecture. It is essentially a way of creating a decentralized and distributed system for tracking the exchange of value from a place to a place. And that's a blockchain is a technical term. Web3 is an ecosystem. It is about everything from culture to governance to the applications built on top of a blockchain. There are different what's called layers that go into that. So if you think about Web2, it's kind of like we're all using apps and giving our data away all the time, et cetera. It's kind of the traditional web experience. Web3 is a different experience where at the heart of the experience is user-owned information.

4:37User-controlled, user-owned data, user-owned, user-controlled value, money, whatever it is. Okay, so that is a lot of different elements. It's the broadest of the terms. So, and if I understand that, like blockchain is a real technology that is used now. Web3 is an idea that is coming into being, but may not be fully implemented everywhere yet. I think that's fair. It's a transition. Web3, we're transitioning into a Web3 world, as a lot of us say. And that is happening faster when it comes to the money side of things, the current side of things, and slower when it comes to the data side of things, but that's catching up.

5:12So crypto is a tool. I think of it as a tool. Usually when you refer to crypto, you're talking about a token that is a marker of a thing. And what you can do with a blockchain is track the movement of the thing from place to place. And crypto is the thing you could say that is moving. So the last time I had a guest on this show to talk about crypto, it was a couple of years ago and it was in the midst of a crash. Like the mood was not good. Prices were down, FTX and others dominating headlines, right? This year, it feels like all of that has shifted. I imagine that must have been part of what you were feeling at ConsenSys.

5:49Why is that? Is there something specific that has changed or is this just sort of the nature of the cycles that tend to go around with crypto? I think it's both. So first of all, I'll say I didn't find the mood at ConsenSys to be as euphoric as I think people on the outside of the industry might imagine. I think that's just because so many of us have been through these cycles before. So it's the enthusiasm for this kind of rising bull market is a bit more tempered than it's been in the past. There's been some maturity, I think, there. But I think it's different this time because we're finally seeing some movement in the United States in terms of what seems to be a bipartisan and real understanding that this technology is, A, it's not going anywhere.

6:32It is very sticky. It's around. So everyone has to figure out what they're going to do about it or with it or whatnot, right? And that there is a desire to make the United States competitive when it comes to the innovators and builders in this space. Whereas I'd say two years ago, particularly in the wake of like the FTX, you know, all those kinds of things, I think there was this sense that, oh, man, like we're really going to see the United States from its regulatory and legislative perspective push this technology offshore as much as it possibly can. And that was very demoralizing for people not to understate the impact of the FTX fraud.

7:09Nevertheless, that was one small group, right? Didn't represent an entire industry to say the least. So I think we have kind of, I wouldn't say we've exited fully the sort of FTX era, if you will. But I find for me, no one's really talking about that anymore. Sam is in jail. Ryan is apparently going to jail. I think people feel like consequences were issued. And the industry has grown so much and proven, even in the wake of that big collapse of a really massive exchange, to be very sticky and persistent. And so the idea that one company could kind of like topple the industry was never true. And I think that that messaging is very different than it was two years ago.

7:47You mentioned sort of the position that the U.S. has in crypto relative to other places. That was one of the panels you spoke on was about sort of other locales that are further along. Yeah, all of them. I mean, yes, pretty much. Yeah. You know, you can't count out the United States, right? The United States decides that it wants to invest in a technology, meaning make it a friendlier environment within which to build on that technology. You're going to see it skyrocket. But nevertheless, it has not been a particularly friendly or easy environment for builders in Web3 more broadly, certainly in crypto.

8:27And I do think you've seen offshoring of developers, folks moving to other places that do have more established rules. So everything from everywhere from the EU to the UK, United Arab Emirates, Singapore, Bermuda, like all big, small jurisdictions. And the United States, we're still kind of like, well, really, what's going on here? Who's in charge? Who has authority? Who's in charge? Who are my regulators? You know, so, yeah, it's it's it's you can see why it would be challenging to try to build something really innovative and novel in that environment. Just before consensus, the U.S. House passed a crypto-related bill, which I think is referred to as FIT21, about the regulatory environment around crypto.

9:10It was bipartisan, so there were 71 Democrats who voted for it, I think. Not much bipartisan is happening these days. I know you worked on this bill. Can you explain what the bill is and sort of how it came to be? It sounds like it's an attempt to resolve some of this uncertainty that you're talking about. That's right. So this bill really tries to lay out a path forward to say, not necessarily to settle the question of whether any individual token is a security or commodity, but to say, here are kind of the options, right? And it gives the CFTC a clear role in the regulation of digital assets, which is the generic term we use for all these assets, NFTs, you know, tokens, etc.

9:52I should give some context here. So the CFTC, SEC, you kind of debate, if you will, who goes where, has been something that precedes crypto. But in an area as novel as digital assets, it's not entirely clear what the rules should be in terms of who goes where. So it attempts to clarify some of that. There's a lot of other stuff in there that I won't bore your listeners with. But suffice it to say, it's been in the making for two years. And in fact, the original version of this bill was set to kind of move through and get to the floor even potentially when the whole FTX thing blew up, actually.

10:29So that put a big, big, put some reins there and didn't really go forward until right now. Now, I should note also, I want to be very clear, FIT 21, as it's called, is not law. It passed the House. It now, of course, goes to the Senate. Oftentimes, when you have a bill like this, the Senate will have what's called a companion bill. So in parallel, they're working on the exact same issues. They have their version of it. In parallel, usually it makes it through their committees, through the floor, and then you kind of have a negotiation between the Senate and the House. We don't have a companion bill, okay?

11:00So what's starting now is a lot of work in the Senate side to pull together essentially a companion bill to put the Senate's position on the table on these issues. So there's a lot more to do here before this actually becomes law. But the signaling from the House that they have alignment on this in a bipartisan way, I cannot overstate. It is massive. It is an absolutely massive accomplishment. It demonstrates tremendous progress. And as you also noted, Bob, in this Congress, doing anything in a bipartisan way is extremely unusual. So here we are. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you said two years of work on this, you know, that may not be that long for a bill.

11:41For you, it's a lot of time, though, right? I think you just never know until you know. And the other thing happening in parallel here is the industry getting very fatigued by the Democratic Party. And in some cases, like I think Senator Warren pretty overtly starting her anti-crypto army, like we're really trying to attack this technology. There's no party platform on this. There are individual actors that have strong views. Most folks don't have any view on this technology. They don't even know what it is. They're on Judiciary Committee. They're worrying about getting judges nominated. They're not thinking about cryptocurrency.

12:11They don't care. So you don't know until the moment of a vote, like how are they going to turn out? Again, it is just a massive statement on the part of the House anyway, but on the part of both parties to say, you know, we believe that America should remain at the forefront of technological innovation, which is a stance that some folks were doubting was the case. And I do think that has a lot to do with just this kind of sense, I think, in the United States of like, what are we doing here? There are things about the technology that are problematic, fraud, whatever. Let's address those, but not vilify an entire technology or industry because of certain things that we actually are tasked with addressing because that's the job of Congress, right?

12:53So I think it marks a significant shift in politics, not just in the approach to technology. But, you know, I'm an optimist, so I guess we'll see what happens when we get into election season. Legislators, they're not technologists. And, you know, if they have trouble understanding what social media is, like blockchain and crypto is much more complicated. And I think it's just hard sometimes for them to really understand what it is they're working on. Yeah. And I think what's interesting about that, Bob, is, you know, I don't know that most people understand how the Internet works. And you don't need to understand how the internet works necessarily to say, that seems like a thing I probably want to keep an eye on and have in this country.

13:29The reason I took this job in part was because I got so tired of policymakers all over the world telling me like, God, if folks come in here, I don't know what they're talking about. A lot of folks like in the Senate, it was their kids. It was a couple of their kids who were saying, hey, mom, who's a senator, this stuff is really interesting. I'm like mining Bitcoin in the basement, FYI. And they're like, what the hell? And they came from that kind of personal connection because they were like, well, if my kid is doing this, I probably should pay attention to it as a parent. But also, my kid is not an idiot, so there must be something there.

14:00So you have to kind of have that approach of like what's going to make this interesting? How do you get somebody curious about it? And then why the trajectory of influence of this technology is going to be quite profound, even though the more it becomes mainstream, the more invisible it will be, ironically. Right? And I think that has been a winning argument, clearly, for 71 Democrats and most Republicans. So here we are. You mentioned the political environment and how it has shifted around relative to crypto. You know, Donald Trump seemingly swapped his position, now vocally supporting crypto versus at some point seeming like he's attacking it.

14:36The Biden White House seems maybe to have softened some of its language. You wrote an op-ed for Fortune recently in which you identified yourself as a Democrat and then kind of exhorted the party not to let itself be defined as anti-crypto. Why did you write this? Justin Slaughter and I wrote about how we consider ourselves old school progressives. The new progressive movement is very different, but we're kind of like, you know, 80s, 90s progressives, if you will, right? And we actually feel that the crypto Web3 ethos is inherently very progressive. What's trying to accomplish, right? Distribution of power, decentralization, user-controlled information.

15:17Like, all of those things are very progressive. We made that case that the loudest voices of the Democratic Party are very overtly anti-crypto, right? We were saying, what are you doing? Like, why would you do that? The reality is that the more the Republicans become vociferously in favor of this technology, the more you look out of touch or you look like you're hostile to something that is actually like a movement that is growing and growing and growing. I mean, I should note, right, Bob, that 20 percent of Americans, and this is of likely voters across all demographics, hold crypto. Not a lot of crypto, but a little bit of crypto.

15:51Whether they're registered Democrats, Republicans, or independents, it's 20 % across all of them. That's exactly right. Old, young, black, white, rural, urban, like 20 % across all demographics hold crypto to some degree. And that is, it's a wild number. One in five. One in five is pretty wild, right? So when you think about that, you're like, are you sure it's not your constituents? So it really comes down to, do you want to be seen as a party that is taking a stance, a political stance on a technology, period? Or do you actually want to be a party that is attempting to comprehend and wrestle with the reality that this thing is not going away?

16:33And it actually is beneficial to people in your districts and your constituents who are engaging with it, whether you know it or not. Sheila's raising an interesting point here about what it takes to not just seem modern, but be modern as a political party, as a country, and for many of our listeners as a business. If one in five Americans are engaged in crypto and the numbers are growing, that's a trend we should all take seriously. Of course, there are concerns about crypto, too, that it might be used by bad actors, that it can be distorted into a get-rich-quick Ponzi scheme. We'll dig into those topics and more after the break.

17:12Stay with us.

17:20Real leaders don't back down when the stakes are high. They innovate, they push forward, and then they take the stage at the Masters of Scale Summit. Join us in San Francisco, October 7th to 9th, to hear from the CEO of the New York Times, scientists using cutting-edge technology to find cures, the leader of crypto powerhouse Coinbase, a retired four-star general, and many, many more. Apply now at mastersofscale.com slash apply25. That's mastersofscale.com slash apply25. If you're ready to take your startup from idea to impact, then AWS is your launchpad. From data storage to machine learning to secure app hosting, AWS gives you the tech, trusted by the world's fastest scaling startups.

18:10And here's the best part. Join AWS Activate today and you could score up to$100 ,000 in AWS credits tailored to your stage and network. Go to aws.amazon.com slash activate and start building. Expanding your business in the US can feel like a maze. Every state has its own payroll, benefits, and compliance rules, which can pull your focus away from growth. That's why founders use Deal. Deal is the professional employer organization, or PEO, that gives you a dedicated HR expert plus Fortune 500 level benefits for your team. The National Association of PEOs says businesses can grow twice as fast if they use one.

18:53So if you're scaling, make it simple with Deal. Go to deel.com slash M-O-S and get up to three months free. Before the break, CEO of the Crypto Council for Innovation, Sheila Warren, updated us on the state of crypto today and the intersection with politics. Now we dig into what most people misunderstand about crypto, the threat of nefarious actors, and how Web3 could be an antidote to things like the Scarlett Johansson open AI dispute. Let's dive back in. You joined the Crypto Council two years ago. You came over from the World Economic Forum. How did you get involved in crypto in the first place?

19:37I was general counsel at a social enterprise called TechSoup. And I actually got into blockchain from the data side of things. We were noticing that there was just hacking attempts coming. And I had dinner with a friend of mine who said, well, you know, rather than creating this honeypot centralized database, have you thought about putting data on a blockchain? And I said, what the heck is the blockchain? So I read the Bitcoin white paper. Ethereum had launched recently. IPFS had launched recently. And I got very, very interested and compelled by the idea that you could create distributed, decentralized systems of data storage that would not have this sort of centralized place where a hacker could go and grab a lot of valuable data.

20:14We were doing ourselves no favors with the way that we were holding data online. The cloud was good and bad, right? Lots of cons of the cloud, right? And how could we do better with that? And that's something we're now seeing begin to emerge. It's interesting that you're drawn to crypto really as a way to sort of safeguard things. And yet a lot of people's worries about crypto and blockchain is that it's going to be used for nefarious purposes, whether that's criminal enterprise or individuals being taken advantage of by something they don't understand. And how do you think about those two sides of it?

20:50And how do you respond to those concerns that people have about a technology that can be used for less than honest purposes? Yeah, I do. I think those are real concerns. I understand them. I think I can tell you on behalf of the industry, nobody in this industry is building things so that bad actors can use them for nefarious purposes to hurt people. I mean, that is not an intention. That being said, I think what I would say to that is blockchain is one of the most, it's a traceable technology. And so the reality is that if you're a criminal and you are using crypto, you're an idiot, okay, because it is extremely traceable.

21:27And in fact, if you talk to people at FinCEN, at DOJ, at the FBI, they're like, yeah, like we can literally see when something moves from a wallet to another wallet. We can track the movement of the money. We know exactly where it is, where it's going. And so the reality is, yes, that you can use anything for nefarious purposes. Cash. Cash remains the number one private secret way for criminals to do business is pallets of cash. At the end of the day, it's really hard to trace cash. It is very easy to trace cryptocurrency on a blockchain. It is shockingly easy, in fact. It's interesting, right?

22:03It's more anonymous in some ways, but also more transparent all at the same time. No question about it. In terms of like the scams and whatnot, that's horrible, right? The same way someone will go onto Facebook and create a fake profile and catfish someone and steal their bank account information, people are doing the same thing using crypto. But the problem there isn't the form factor, I would argue. It's not that crypto makes that easier, right? It's that those are terrible people and they're using a different method for doing something they've been doing for a long time. And I will also say and credit a lot of the exchanges and people in the industry who've done a lot of education about how do you fight scams?

22:41What do you do if this happens? How do you notify people? How do you prevent this from happening? If you open a wallet at any of the major exchanges, you're going to see a pretty significant work stream that's educating you about how to keep that information secure and safe. So what do people and businesses most misunderstand about crypto? For a lot of people, they just think of it as like, what's the price of Bitcoin? that, you know, you're hearing someone talk about on CNBC. What should they be paying attention to? The investment side is not what I focus on. It doesn't really help that you have like a crypto ticker now, you know, and all the financial programs have like a segment on crypto.

23:17So the overemphasis on the value of the token and whatnot is, I just find it very distracting. And I genuinely find the price of the asset at any given moment, the least interesting thing about the technology and about crypto. Like, great. I know for people that are just looking to make money, that is the most important thing, but I'm in this for very different reasons. And what I think is being missed is, again, we are talking about restructuring the architecture of the entire internet, right? Underlying these systems is an invisible layer right now. We're talking to each other over the internet, right?

23:50Someone has access and light a sight to that. It is not you or me. We have the ability to influence any of that. Our information goes into this void. We don't know where it goes. all those things we take for granted as being part and parcel, the cost of doing business, if you will, the cost of being online. It doesn't have to be that way. There is a different way of creating a much more user-centric internet that is focused more on the individual. And for me, again, the big play is data. And we're starting to see this really emerge in the conversation more than it has. I've been waiting for this for almost 10 years, this conversation, right?