Rapid Response: From Taylor Swift to the Emmys, lessons in celebrity, with The Ankler’s Janice Min

0:00Scaling a business in the US can feel like a maze. Each state has its own payroll, benefits, and compliance rules, pulling your focus away from growth, which is why founders use Deal. Deal is the professional employer organization, or PEO, that gives you a dedicated HR expert, plus Fortune 500-level benefits for your team. The National Association of PEOs says businesses can grow twice as fast if they use one. So, if you're scaling, make it simple with Deal. Go to deel.com. slash MOS and get up to three months free. If you're in private capital, you understand that your next great deal starts with who you know.

0:41That's why over 3 ,000 firms trust Affinity, the CRM platform purpose-built for private capital. Affinity's relationship intelligence reveals your team's strongest paths to founders, investors, and decision makers using insights It's hidden in emails, calendars, and meetings. With powerful AI tools like Affinity NoteTaker and Deal Assist, you'll spend less time managing data and more time closing the right deals. Learn more at affinity.co slash marketplace. How many stars can withstand a message from Trump on Truth Social, like saying, I hate Taylor Swift, capital letters, exclamation points. It's like very few stars can psychically handle that or would feel that their business could handle that.

1:31I think the risks are being made clear, you know, whether you're a CEO or whether you're a star.

1:43That's Janice Min, co-founder and CEO of The Ankler, the insider business media covering Hollywood and celebrity. Janice and I caught up the morning after the Emmy Awards to talk about what TV's biggest night revealed about the entertainment business. And we also talked about Taylor Swift's endorsement of Kamala Harris and how the shifting pressure on celebrities to take political positions echoes the pressure on CEOs. Along the way, we touched down Disney's evolving strategy, the decline in HBO's brand, and why stars like Patrick Mahomes and Caitlin Clark may be hesitant to follow in Taylor's political footsteps.

2:22Plus, Janice explores the vagaries of what makes something a hit, whether that's a politician like Harris or an Emmy-winning darling like Netflix's Baby Reindeer. It's fun and revealing, so let's get to it. I'm Bob Safian, and this is Rapid Response.

2:45I'm Bob Safian. I'm here with Janice Min of The Ankler. Janice, thanks for coming back to Rapid Response. Thanks for having me again. We're recording on Monday. Last night were the Emmys, TV's biggest awards. It was kind of an unusual night in a bunch of ways, not the least because the last Emmys were just eight months ago. Like everyone remembers that, right? Nobody remembers that, but it is that, remember, we were coming off the strikes, so they couldn't have the Emmys last year. And so in this world of franchises and sequels and universes, we got a whole Emmys universe this year of not one, but two ceremonies.

3:28We had a different host than earlier this year, right? Instead of Anthony Anderson, we had the father and son team of Eugene Levy and Dan Levy. Bob, the fact that you knew that it was Anthony Anderson, you alone in America remembers that fact. Though I think your producer looked it up for you and gave it to you. There's no way you remembered that. Guilty. Guilty there. Not to give Anthony a hard time, but, you know, they're not the most exciting shows. They're more exciting to talk about than they are to watch. Well, the Emmys are notoriously long and boring. and it's been this staple on broadcast television.

4:07And for your audience who isn't aware, it rotates on the broadcast network. So ABC, CBS, Fox, NBC, every single year. This is not one of these shows that has a bidding war like the Oscars to get it on air to broadcast. And it's very important to the people who work in TV. And everyone knows Hollywood loves to award itself, but the show's long, it's bloated, it's boring. And as a reflection of these streaming times we live in, you have an audience watching television who watching the show, if they indeed tuned in, you know, lots of over 65 year olds tuning into their broadcast channel to watch it live to see a bunch of shows they probably haven't seen get awarded.

4:46And that's kind of the story of television in 2024. And I will remind you, I'm sure you remember this, the moment in 2023 when Bob Iger was at Sun Valley and made the comment, television is not core to Disney's business. And there were the Emmy Awards on ABC last night owned by Disney. So there you go. With him there in the audience, right? Smiling away. Yes. Yes. Everyone still loves a red carpet no matter what and being on television. So there you go. Is there a way that you like evaluate the night? I mean, Shogun made history with a slate of wins. The bear got a lot of love. And then you have these sort of sleepers in hacks and baby reindeer, which I will confess I have not seen either of, like win a bunch of awards.

5:35I'm watching the wrong things. No, you are the representative of the American viewer, right? Like, I mean, what's a mass show? If they could award NFL broadcasts, that would be something that maybe would please the crowd. And so what's the takeaway? So the take, I mean, I think from a business perspective, it's a little bit about the shifting tides of who's doing well in television right now. And no matter how sort of meaningless and empty and they'll all tell you awards don't matter, blah, blah, blah. They all care about the awards. And part of it is just the bragging rights and the narcissism of Hollywood, of course.

6:15But a bigger part of it is you want to prove that you are a home for the best creators in town. And if you can't attract the best people in town, then you aren't going to have the most swings at bat. So let's just talk about FX for a second. So FX, which made Shogun, Shogun was this enormous swing. It was 10 years in development. By the way, no one would spend 10 minutes in development on a show today. So 10 years in development, largely Japanese language, unknown to Americans cast. And it was the dedication of the creative executive in charge of FX, John Landgraf. The Bear, which did not take home the prize, the big prize that it was in contention for of best comedy.

7:00And, you know, remind me how many times you laughed during The Bear, like zero. And they made the unusual move of submitting as a comedy and they lost to Hacks. And so there's some applause in town today. Like, you can't trick our categories. You weren't a comedy. And, you know, but the thing that I think is important for listeners to think about is that you're not going to see shows like this for several years now. And that's because the industry in the last two years has changed to the point where this idea of prestige television right now is like a dirty word. Like, ew, like we're not going to make these big swings and spend all this money to make your precious show.

7:39Like, no, we need either like crazy huge swings on known IP or we're going to do cheap shows that cost that we can just churn out and still get eyeballs. And when Richard Gad of Baby Reindeer gets up there in one of his multiple acceptance speeches and points up that Hollywood does need to invest in existing IP to succeed, that's what he's poking or trying to spur change with? Yeah, this is not dissimilar to, if you recall at the Oscars, when Cord Jefferson, the writer of American fiction, got up and made a speech and said, instead of doing, I'm going to mangle this a little bit, but instead of doing, you know, one 50 million project, do 10,$5 million projects and Hollywood will be the better for it.

8:26Granted, he's saying this is the person whose project was financed by Amazon MGM. So take that as you will. Um, so I think there's something parallel to what Richard Gadd was communicating also. But it doesn't sound like you think this is really going to change anytime soon. Do winning Emmys like this really change the business? We're in too fearful of a time for it to change the business right now. And I will note, I will note that Baby Reindeer took Netflix by surprise. So that's a little bit like the audience telling them what worked. And they were not prepared to do an Emmys campaign for Baby Reindeer.

9:04This was not something they were going to prioritize. And they pulled it together at the last minute once they saw the reception it received. It is ironic, though, right, that a TV awards show about TV is the worst TV of all the award shows. Like, shouldn't the TV people know how to make better TV? Listen, it's like this is like going to the dental supply convention in Las Vegas and they're doing their trade award show. Like to pretend it's for anyone who is not in the industry is would be a mistake. I mean, it's it is literally meant to service the however many people can fit in the theater. Those people in the theater to make them feel good, to fluff the executives.

9:48Are Emmy after parties like as the same as Oscar after parties? So it's not the same thing. It is not the same thing. I think most notably this year, there was an HBO after party. And so in the days of old, like let's remember when Richard Plepler was running HBO and they would be these splashy, unbelievably extravagant affairs. That was the hot ticket. People would be clamoring to get in and every star would show up. And HBO is, you know, inhaling Oscars faster than they could digest them. And this year, it was a very small affair. They refused access to a ton of journalists. And I'm sure you might have seen some people might have been following some of the headlines around HBO, around the Emmys.

10:33in this crazy twist of how TV works today, HBO is going to become basically basic cable for charter subscribers. And so this very premium channel that people used to pay$15 a month for on their cable bill is becoming free to a wide swath of cable, of the cable audience, which is, I think a lot of people are horrified. It's a dilution of the HBO brand. But HBO, its dilution began when Discovery and Warner Brothers merged. And the big show coming. Yeah, it's confusing. Like, what's HBO? What's Max? Who knows? And the thing with HBO, the big show they have coming out is The Penguin, which is a spinoff of, like, the DC universe of superheroes, which makes a lot of people throw up, even though I think it's supposed to be good.

11:24But, you know, that's a far cry from The White Lotus or Sopranos. It's leveraging IP. Again, leveraging IP. But so sorry, just to hammer that point home, in terms of Emmy nominations, HBO used to be the big daddy. Like they would get all the Emmy nominations. And this year, I think it ranked FX, Netflix, then, you know, HBO, maybe a distant third. Richard Plepler's HBO, they wanted to kill Netflix every single day. And if they killed them once a day, it wasn't enough. And so that sort of fierce competition ended. And if you're following this game at all, David Zasloff even went so far recently to start selling HBO programming and Warner Brothers programming back to Netflix, which felt like the game had been won by Netflix in the end.

12:11Yeah, which, in point of fact, as we've talked about before, is true. They are winning. Well, correct. It's not perception. It's fact. Janice doesn't mince her words, which is both refreshing and necessary when it comes to the entertainment business. Personally, I'm dismayed if the age of prestige television, as she calls it, is coming to an end. But maybe I'm just a snob. These projects have to be sustainable. And that means building a vibrant, paying audience as in any other business. Next up, Janice and I go into new territory, courtesy of Taylor Swift. Stay with us.

12:54Real leaders don't back down when the stakes are high. They innovate, they push forward, and then they take the stage at the Masters of Scale Summit. Join us in San Francisco, October 7th to 9th, to hear from the CEO of the New York Times, scientists using cutting-edge technology to find cures, the leader of crypto powerhouse Coinbase, a retired four-star general, and many, many more. Apply now at mastersofscale.com slash apply25. That's mastersofscale.com slash apply25. If you're ready to take your startup from idea to impact, then AWS is your launchpad. From data storage to machine learning to secure app hosting, AWS gives you the tech trusted by the world's fastest scaling startups.

13:43And here's the best part. Join AWS Activate today and you could score up to$100 ,000 in AWS credits tailored to your stage and network. Go to aws.amazon.com slash activate and start building. Expanding your business in the U.S. can feel like a maze. Every state has its own payroll, benefits, and compliance rules, which can pull your focus away from growth. That's why founders use Deal. Deal is the professional employer organization, or PEO, that gives you a dedicated HR expert plus Fortune 500-level benefits for your team. The National Association of PEOs says businesses can grow twice as fast if they use one.

14:27So if you're scaling, make it simple with Deal. Go to deel.com slash mos and get up to three months free. Before the break, the Ankler's Janice Min took us inside the lessons from this year's TV Emmy Awards. Now we talk about Taylor Swift, her foray into politics and the pressure to endorse a presidential candidate for celebrities and for business leaders. Let's jump back in.

14:59Gotta talk about Taylor Swift and her endorsement of Kamala Harris, which sort of set off a media frenzy and then Trump posts in all caps, I hate Taylor Swift. Can you describe Taylor's first endorsement post and your reaction to it? Well, for starters, to think that that was spontaneously done after the debate that she spontaneously wrote out that Instagram post is, you know, comical. And I also don't believe for a second that it wasn't coordinated with the Harris campaign, but whatever, maybe I'm wrong. But she talked about that she watched the debate, her decision was made. She was distressed by the fake AI endorsement that had come out where someone had created her endorsing Donald Trump and Donald Trump had posted it on Truth Social.

15:47And then, of course, her ultimate trolling signature on the whole Instagram post was signed from a childless cat lady. She also didn't post it on X, notably, I have to presume, given the Elon Musk environment that has been created. And as your listeners know, Elon Musk has endorsed Trump. So if you thought Kamala Harris won that debate, it made it very extra that night, I guess I would say. You've covered the celebrity world through a bunch of election cycles. Is the way celebrities act in politics different this time around? I mean, I'm thinking about how so many business leaders have pulled back.

16:27They seem to be like afraid of alienating the marketplace. It's definitely quieter, I think. And, you know, we did an interview at the Ankler with Mike Murphy, the Republican political strategist who is a never-Trumper, who has talked about how celebrities have gotten smarter. They've wisened up. And at the Democratic National Convention, this was also a theme. We had sent one of our reporters there. And it was about, like, you don't say stupid things. Like, you're like, don't do, if some of your listeners might remember when Obama was running for president and Scarlett Johansson was saying things like, oh, he's my boyfriend.

17:03I mean, like, no, you don't, you don't, don't say things like that. You know, Mike Murphy had said to us that politicians endlessly have had to listen to celebrities try to tell them how to do, you know, nuclear arms deployment or their thoughts about high level policy issues. And that kind of has, I feel like dissipated to some degree too. And if you recall when Hillary Clinton was running for president. It was like the Emmys. It was a little bit tedious. Like, here are my famous friends. Here's another and another and another and another. And it just felt like, and if you, and when she was running against - Well, it didn't really, it didn't really work, right?

17:42I mean, it didn't work. So, so like, does, does Taylor Swift work? Is it, is it different because of who she is? Yes. I mean, Taylor Swift is, is one of a kind. And I'm sure, you know, that if you believe that reporting that young women are becoming more left and a lot of it around the abortion issue, if you could just pour kerosene on a group of voters to get them to take action, that was it. And I think there's also this cynicism among younger people about politics, like neither side can get anything done. I don't like them. I'm going to sit this out. And just if you know, if you can get people to, you know, fly to Amsterdam and save all their money to go see Taylor Swift in concert, imagine how much easier it might be to get them to go vote or even register to vote is the first step.

18:32I mean, the other fuel that I've been looking at and noticing, I mean, the late night TV hosts, I mean, Jimmy Camel has been like brutal towards Trump, totally savaging him. Stephen Colbert has been like a little bit more subtle in his digs, although only kind of slightly so. And then Jimmy Fallon has tried to kind of steer clear of the whole thing. Is that like a reflection of corporate ownership at ABC versus CBS versus NBC, or maybe a reaction to Fox's Gutfeld show? Like, I don't know. I suspect that somewhere that these conversations are happening all the time, there's a, whatever the number is, is it 40 million people who love Trump and are immovable, Right.

19:15That you like what? Why would you leave off half 50, 48 percent of the population? And and also knowing that these these viewers, your kids are not watching late night television. They're not even watching the clips of late night television anymore. So who who's watching these shows? Like it's largely older white Americans. and I have to imagine that there are some advertisers who over the past, let's say, eight years have said they don't want to be part of this political conversation. It's caustic, it's exhausting. I mean, I have to even note, you know, so we're taping today, Monday, September 16th.

19:52Yesterday, there was a second assassination attempt on Donald Trump. Like, no one even texted me about it. You know, the first one, nine weeks before, people, like, I had a thousand text chains going. So I think there's a fatigue among the populace of politics and talking about politics. And I mean, there's part of the reason Kamala Harris has caught on because she's new, she's fresh. But I think the exhaustion and also with Trump, it's been the same political joke for eight years. I mean, it doesn't the story really doesn't change. And you saw Kamala Harris able to exploit those things incredibly well on the debate stage because she's been training for this for eight years.

20:31She knows all his tics. Like the crowd size joke is still going. There's an impression that like Hollywood in the celebrity world is sort of more Democratic, more anti-Trump. Does the media underestimate celebrity support for Republicans, for Trump? Or is it really like that much of a one horse town? I think it's a one horse town with a very quiet hidden pony. People really do fear they will get blacklisted for being overtly supportive of Donald Trump. That contingent absolutely exists here. I mean, Donald Trump comes to Los Angeles and has fundraisers. So it's I think that the powers that be in Hollywood, the most powerful people in Hollywood, whether it's Dana Walden at Disney or Ted Sarandos at Netflix, the Democrats are in power, I guess I would say.

21:24And so you wouldn't, you wouldn't, I mean, people can't get jobs or work in Hollywood right now for largely, unless you're at the very, very top and no one's going to put that at risk. I think Holly was very sensitive about issues around racism. I mean, I think anyone in Hollywood looking at this stuff going on with, you know, the supposed dog and cat eating in Springfield, Ohio. It's like you it would be very hard to sell your public support of a candidate like that when you are overseeing an HR department that has invested 10 years in this idea of, you know, safe workplaces and all of that. And so I just I think there's just no incentive to come out and publicly support Trump.

22:06Obviously, you see who he gets as his supporters like Kid rock, Scott Baio, you know, Dana White, that he gets, you know, wrestlers and certain musicians and certain sort of on the fringe people. And he's able to sort of build his own celebrity coalition out of that, Jon Voight. But by and large, these are not people who are the bread and butter A-list of Hollywood. Yeah. You also see celebrities who kind of refuse to say who their support. I mean, I'm thinking of the hubbub around Patrick Mahomes, the chief's quarterback, you know, like his wife, I guess maybe made some posts that people said sounded like she supported Trump and then he's declining.

22:48And, you know, people are saying, oh, he doesn't want to cross his wife. And I'm just thinking he doesn't want to cross his sponsors at State Farm, right? I mean, is that isn't what it's about? I mean, NFL, right? Already Taylor Swift and Travis Kelsey had become subjects of like crazy conspiracies and QAnon and all this nutty stuff in the last NFL season. So I'm very curious to see what, if there's blowback or how it blows back on him. I mean, NFL is very broad, very, it's in all States. It doesn't care if, you know, it's blue or red and it's, it's very red meat. And there's always been that strange conflation of NFL and patriotism that, uh, and you know, until really until Kamala Harris took the stage.

23:31Like, patriotism has been owned by the Republicans, you know, factually or not factually, but they've made it their message. And Kamala Harris has sort of, with some skill, managed to flip that message. And so we'll see how that plays out. Are you hearing anything about the corporate world demanding neutrality from spokespeople more than they use? I mean, I'm thinking about, too, like, Caitlin Clark liked Taylor Swift's endorsement, but then declined to say anything about her position. I just keep thinking, is that all about, you know, the corporate world or are they really just wanting to stay private?

24:07Both. I mean, I think that the incentives to come out of and state your political position are so small now. What do you gain? Are you so impassioned you have to say something? Fine. That's fine. But I think the risks are being made clear to both, you know, whether you're a CEO or whether you're a star. And I think there are very few people who are willing to take that risk these days. How many stars can withstand a message from Trump on truth social, like saying, I hate Taylor Swift, capital letters, exclamation points. Like very few stars can psychically handle that or would feel that their business could handle that.

24:47And, you know, being a star is like being an elected official in your own right. Like you're trying to stay in office as long as possible. And I have to presume for a lot of them taking a political stance doesn't help that. So as, you know, the political coverage intensifies as we move close to the election, we've asked ourselves on this show, like, how much do we lean into that obsession in our coverage, you know, versus kind of counter-programming going the other way. And I'm curious if there's like a playbook that works for media companies, because leaning in can help ratings, at least in some ways.

25:28But then sometimes, you know, there are things you have to do hyperbolically to maximize that attention. I always feel like fish where the fish are. People are obsessed with it. And I think that in the way that in 2015, when Trump was running for president, politics became the new entertainment. I would say this summer, you know, when you have, you know, George Clooney and Brad Pitt's movie on Apple TV being taken out of theaters and sent direct to streaming, like, we have a new star system this summer and to lean into it. And it just speaks to the point that you can't fabricate stardom in the way that it was maddening for some people to see Trump capture the imagination in 2015, 2016, that you're seeing that with Kamala Harris, too.

26:14That's something you can't fabricate. And I think the problem that we were seeing with Biden is that he did not have star power. He didn't have star power in 1976, and he did not have star power in 2024. for. Well, we weren't sure that Kamala Harris had star power, you know, certainly four years ago, but she does now. I mean, there's something she's done or they've done right. It's so crazy. I think some of it is like, how do you meet the moment? Right. So I'll use some Hollywood analogies here since I'm your Hollywood person today. So like, let's talk about like the actor Glenn Powell, who was like a sort of a solid working actor.

26:54You didn't know his name. and then suddenly he became the biggest thing in the world in his 30s. And that's very unusual. And so that's someone just hitting for some reason at a certain time. Well, this is the thing that makes people in LA also lose their minds, right? Like you see these people become famous and you're like, but why? What? How did that happen? I would say the same goes for television shows, for movies. Like why that and not this? And it's one of the last unexplainable things in a world that's trying to game the system with algorithms and recommendations. And to have an intangible left in the world is sort of fun and like sort of crazy making.