Super Bowl ads, Bad Bunny, and the business of cultural risk, with Autodesk’s Dara Treseder

0:00As a founder, you're constantly wearing multiple hats, usually at the same time. but the most successful leaders have learned to hand a few of those hats off to the right people. That's where Upwork shines. It's a one-stop shop to find trusted freelance talent across IT, web dev, design, and admin support. And it's built to be simple. Register for free, connect with freelancers who match your style and pace, and hire them with industry low fees. Upwork makes the whole process easier, more affordable, and way less stressful. If your business is ready for that next level, Upwork has the talent to help you get there.

0:39Visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free. That's U-P-W-O-R-K dot com. Upwork dot com. On Masters of Scale, we talk a lot about inflection points, those moments when a technology stops being optional and starts being fundamental. AI presents one of those moments, and behind every breakthrough, whether it's medical research or education or even cinematic visual effects, there's infrastructure most people never see. As the essential cloud for AI, CoreWeave is building that foundation. It provides a purpose-built AI cloud designed specifically for pioneers at leading AI labs and enterprises ready to power the biggest ideas and the boldest ambitions.

1:29Ready for anything. Ready for AI. To learn more about how CoreWeave powers the world's best AI, go to coreweave.com slash ready for anything. Many of the ads were just so forgettable. And I think that some brands could have sat it out. They should have looked and said, hey, do I have something simple I want to say that I can really cut through? Is this sincere to who we are in this moment? And am I actually making a statement about something? Now, if you weren't ticking all those boxes this year, I don't think this was the year for you to have done a Super Bowl ad. The best ad of the night was Bad Bunny for Bad Bunny.

2:16That's Dara Treceder, Chief Marketing Officer of Autodesk, back on the show to break down this year's Super Bowl ads, what worked, what didn't, what we can all learn from the high-cost high-wire act, from anthropic shot at OpenAI to Lady Gaga's homage to Mr. Rogers to Duncan's nostalgia-fueled celeb fest. We also dig into the Bad Bunny halftime show and what it means for the NFL and Apple, and Dara shares her view of Black History Month and opens up about her personal experience as a Black woman in America. It's timely, uplifting, and instructive, so let's get to it. I'm Bob Safian, and this is Rapid Response.

3:00I'm Bob Safian. I'm here with Dara Treseder, the CMO of Autodesk. Dara, great to have you back on Rapid Response. You ready for our annual post-Super Bowl dish? I'm excited. I've been looking forward to this. So I have to say that the on-field game wasn't much of a contest, kind of a blowout, but plenty of trick plays and Hail Marys in the ad battle. The cost for a 30-second ad this year was somewhere between$8 and$10 million to place. You talk about Romy, return on marketing and investment, what's worthwhile, what breaks through. Just quick off the bat, any big winners or losers that jumped out at you?

3:40There were some big winners. I think Anthropic was a big winner this year. Rocket and Pepsi was a big winner this year. So we can go into details, but off the bat, I would say those were some of the big winners this year. I mean, I've been scanning all the best and worst lists online, and there's like roughly zero consensus. I would say we are the authority, Bob. You know? But I know you use this lens of like memorable, relevant, and ownable, right? And so is that why you're particularly picking those three that you mentioned? So, you know, we have been using ownable, relevant, and memorable for the past few years now.

4:29And this year, we are adding a new layer. Given the context of where we are at, I think we have to add the lens of simplicity. So was it simple enough? Because there's so much chaos happening in the world. I think it had to also be sincere. There is so much insincerity and inauthenticity in today's context. And the last thing I would say is it had to be statement making. To win this year, you had to be making a statement of a sort. So like I saw a lot of mentions in the other lists of like the Duncan ad, the Goodwill Duncan spot fronted by Ben Affleck. Does it fit on all of the layers that you're looking at?

5:14So I thought that that ad was sincere. You saw a lot of insincere use of celebrity. The only winners this year from a celebrity standpoint were the celebrities who got paid, okay? A lot of brands used celebrities in ways that they really did not need to do that. over$250 million were spent on celebrity placements for these Super Bowl ads. That's a quarter of a billion dollars. And the ROI was really not there. In fact, 60 % of the Super Bowl ads this year used celebrities. And many did not use them intentionally or use them well. I think Goodwill Duncan was where celebrity use made sense. We all know one thing is true about Ben Affleck.

6:00He does like a Jennifer and he does like Dunkin' Donuts. And like some of the more artsy highbrow ads like Emma Stone for Squarespace or Adrian Brody's like TurboTax, you know, sort of purposely overacting. That was effective or sort of modest? I think it was modest. I don't think it quite cut through as well. Well, I would say that I will give the Squarespace one was simple. Get a domain name using Squarespace. Many people might have thought about Squarespace to design their website, but not necessarily like, I'm not even ready to design it, but have I gotten my domain name yet? That if emmastone.com is unavailable, girl, what you sitting on?

6:47Go get your domain name right now. Like that cut through. I even had my kids say, mommy, should I get my domain name? I was like, wow, this is cutting through all generations right now. You know, we've got an eight-year-old wanting to figure out if he needs to get his domain name or not. He better. He better. Otherwise, someone else is going to get it. In some ways, like one of the simplest ads to me that sort of cut through was the Levi's ad, which just focused on his rear end. Right? It worked. It worked. My son was like, are we looking at butts? What's going on here? But you know what? It showed that, look, every human body is original.

7:21And, you know, whoever you are, we've got genes for you. So much about marketing is about pursuing attention, particularly in the Super Bowl. But it's like this interesting time because brands are also wary about sparking controversy. You know, like, how do you get attention and stay under the radar at the same time a little bit? and you mentioned this, one of the biggest risks I thought was the rocket Lady Gaga ad using won't you be my neighbor from Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood. To me, it was kind of treading a line with all of the ice controversy and neighbors, activists handing out towels in front of the stadium.

8:03That's one of the ones you said stood out to you. That was an incredible, incredible ad. I thought everything about that was brilliant. From the insight, the insight was rooted in the business strategy, right? They have that line, own the dream. And then the execution was really well done. First of all, let's talk about good use of celebrity. They used Lady Gaga to rerecord Will You Be My Neighbor, the Mr. Rogers All. That was beautiful. Even before the ad came out, all over social media from Maria Shriver, like people were sharing just the song, right? The song itself, the Lady Gaga execution of that song was amazing.

8:46And then you have the added cultural context of Lady Gaga being kind of a big winner in the Grammys this year. And then Lady Gaga also happened to be in the halftime show. So you had this, the musical choice for the ad was so spot on. I thought that there was a lot of love for that ad because given everything going on in our context right now, that ad was one of the few ads, if not the only ad, that made a statement in our cultural context that was tonally appropriate. And it did it without passing judgment. And I love that because it was an invitation to all of us to say, hey, how can I be a better neighbor?

9:28And that's a call that all of us can identify with from a cultural standpoint. And of course, there's a business standpoint of as you're looking to find your next home, come and use, you know, Redfin or Rocket, right? There was that underlying premise. We love when culture and brand magic is sitting on the bedrock foundation of a solid business strategy. Another one of the ads that you mentioned was the Pepsi ad, which was a risk of a different kind, this polar bear ad that sort of adopted Coke's mascot to use against them, right? It was bold. The return of rivalry. We love that. The return of rivalry.

10:11You know, I thought that was a brilliant ad and the internet loved the ad. And I think part of what made it work so well was it was a little self-deprecating. And it's okay to say you like Pepsi better, right? That sort of self-deprecating, you know, layer, I think worked really nicely. Also, the fact that they were able to co-opt the polar bear, that worked incredibly well. And Taika Waititi, who doesn't love a good Taika Waititi? And I obviously have to give a shout out to our Autodesk customer, Framestore, who, you know, used our design and make platform to bring that world to life. But I did think even the art was well done.

10:51It was tastefully well done. And it did hark back to Pepsi's own legacy of, you know, the take the Pepsi challenge from way back, right? Exactly. Sort of always been their fighter persona in the marketplace. They've always had that fighter persona. I thought they personified that. And they did it really, they made a statement. Making a statement doesn't have to be a statement about the cultural environment. It could be a statement about your truth. But on a platform as big as the Super Bowl, it was sad to me that a lot of brands said nothing. One of the things I loved about Pepsi is they said something.

11:32They said something about who they are as a brand. They said something about the competition. They might not have made a cultural statement, but they made a category statement. The other ad that you mentioned and was also a bold shot was Anthropik's jab at OpenAI. Definitely came in hard with their clawed spots. Did they win even before the Super Bowl ad ran because people were talking about it? Before the Super Bowl ad ran, they were talking about, I mean, there are very few times my husband sends me a text about an ad, okay? It grabbed a lot of people. The ads were incredibly well done. When you also think about the 360 strategy of, hey, we are going to maximize conversation and ROI, they absolutely did that.

12:19When you take a shot at another company and the CEO and the CMO of that company start to comment, you know you've won. Because you struck a nerve. Now, I think that the proof will be in the pudding. Because now if they start to bring ads to their platform, the internet will not forgive. Yes, it's a strategic business decision to play that up. It's not just a tagline. You got to live with it. You got to live with that. You absolutely have to live with that. I mean, there were a lot of AI-related ads. Something like one in four of the ads I was tracking were AI. One of my producers really liked OpenAI's ad for Codex.

13:04Another one hated the GenSpark ad, the one with Matthew Broderick, for being tone deaf about people's fear of AI. Like, all of these ads around AI, is it like it was a couple years ago where suddenly every ad seemed like it was from a crypto company? Like, is this a bubble? Like, what does all that mean? I think the big picture was AI is here to stay. That was the big picture. The ads were not as spot on or bullseye as they could have been. So there wasn't a single AI ad that I would say other than the Anthropic ad that we talked about, right? It almost felt like Anthropic was over here and everybody else was over here.

13:46So there was a huge gap. So the AI winner was Anthropic and everybody else was sort of either meh or even in the kind of loser category. But in general, the AI ads were sort of, they were overdone this year. I would say the overarching theme this year was disappointment. I think a lot of the ads were not that great. There were a few standout ads and we've talked about them. And I think a few honorable mentions and we've talked about a few of them as well. But the majority of the ads were sort of a little meh. It's like, you know, when your agency comes to you and suggests Bowen Yang, Jon Hamm, and Scarlett Johansson in a spot, your question should be, why?

14:28And if it's not clear, maybe don't do that. So, you know, there's a lot. They were just trying to reach every demographic. It doesn't work. When you try to speak to everyone, you speak to no one. When you try to speak to everyone, you speak to no one. The YouTube ad about things being meh, I thought it was kind of a meh ad too. I was like, yeah, you've defined yourself perfectly. It was a meh ad. There was just a lot of meh. And I think this is one of the things that I worry about with our industry. I worry that in the age of more, the lack of focus on being excellent at the fundamentals leads to a lot of mediocrity, right?

15:15I've talked about how AI raises the floor, but it's human ingenuity that's going to raise the ceiling. And I thought that a lot of ads were playing at the floor. There was just a lot of mediocrity. Many of the ads were just so forgettable. And I think that some brands could have sat it out. They should have looked and said, hey, do I have something simple I want to say that I can really cut through? Is this sincere to who we are in this moment? And am I actually making a statement about something? Now, if you weren't ticking all those boxes this year, I don't think this was the year for you to have done a Super Bowl ad.

15:53Dara isn't shy with her critiques. So what did she think of the Bad Bunny halftime show? Was it good for the NFL and for Apple? And how is she personally trying to show up with simplicity and a statement as a leader right now? We'll talk about that more after the break. Stay with us.

16:15This is Mike Nicholas, Capital One business customer and co-founder of Ansett Uncles, a plant-based restaurant and community space in Brooklyn, New York. And he's telling us how they started a product line. We already had a space in the community. The food was an extension of our lifestyle and our values. So we know we wanted to create something that was an offshoot to that. Our pepper sauce. That's my grandmother's recipe. That's like a liquid gold, right? If someone wants to approach us and ask us what do we do, we provide flavor. Growing a product line is no small investment, but Mike and his wife and co-founder Nicole were able to manage with the help of their Capital One business card.

16:54Working with Capital One business, we're able to leverage our limits and utilize those points, making sure we can continue the scale at the speed that we need it to go. To learn more, go to CapitalOne.com slash business cards.

17:11Before the break, Autodesk's Dara Treseder took us through the highs and lows of this year's Super Bowl ads. Now we talk about the Bad Bunny halftime show, what it says about the NFL and Apple, and what it means to live in the purple. Plus, assessing the brand of Black History Month, AI and layoffs, and the power of joy. Let's jump back in. In many ways, the biggest statement of the Super Bowl was the halftime show. You know, Bad Bunny singing in Spanish, you know, at the Super Bowl party that I was at, like some folks loved it. Some honestly were put off. I don't understand what he's saying. What was the larger impact, do you think?

17:51The best ad of the day, of the night, was Bad Bunny for Bad Bunny. Like I thought he did an incredible job. And, you know, at my Super Bowl party, I was up, I was dancing. I had a great time. Now, you know, there were also people at my Super Bowl that were like, you know, they were not up, they were not dancing. And I think that was kind of reflective. I think your Super Bowl party and my Super Bowl party were like reflective of what's going on in the world today. The people who didn't want Bad Bunny there, there was nothing he could have done to have pleased them. So to have tried to please them would have been a failure.

18:29I thought he was a tremendous success because he spoke to the people who he needed to speak to. And he did it in a way that was incredibly authentic to them. I mean, from a real-life couple getting married to, like, Lady Gaga performing to just the joy. The overwhelming thing was joy and unity. He said, God bless America, and he said it in English. So everybody could understand that. He had the football that said, together, we are America. But the America he referred to then wasn't just the United States of America, right? He referred to all of the countries in the Americas, which, again, turned some people off.

19:10I mean, there's risk in that. I thought, you know, I thought what he was saying, and this might be my own little interpretation, but I thought he was talking about all of these people come to America and then they are American. And that very much resonated with me as an immigrant. I'll go a step further and say I thought it was a win for Apple. I thought it was a win for NFL because they are trying to be global. These are global brands that have global, and guess what, who is global? Bad Bunny is global. A lot of people all over the world love Bad Bunny. The NFL is trying to go global. You saw that they were even showing the watch parties, right?

19:48Here's people watching the NFL in London and they're trying to be more global as an institution. So to take a very established and loved global superstar, who, by the way, again, was the winner from the Grammys. And they didn't know that when they chose him, but they stuck with him through the controversy. So I think that also builds goodwill because they would never have won by ditching and by opining with a spine. I think they have actually gained more followers and loyalists than if they pulled away. And guess what? Those other people, they still tuned in and they still watch the game anyway.

20:23And the fact that, you know, President Trump called out Bad Bunny before, after that, you know, Turning Point, Charlie Kirk's organization puts on an alternate halftime show fronted by Kid Rock. Did you watch that? Did you? Did you leave the halftime show? No, I did not. I did not watch that. But it got a lot of attention. And I guess I guess the question it raises for me is like the Super Bowl is one of the few shared experiences these days, you know, across the United States, across the world. And yet you could say that that in some ways having Bad Bunny sort of undercut that a little bit, you know, instead of connecting us.

21:03I disagree. I disagree. I think that Bad Bunny united us. There are things that he could have chosen to say or chosen to do that would have been divisive. Instead, he says, God bless America in English. He has a football that says, together we are America. And so I actually thought that he brought healing, he brought hope, and he brought unity. You encourage us all to opine with the spine and to, you know, not try to be everything for everyone. But at the same time, like there's so much risk of being called out as being partisan in the United States. And like, you know, how do we live in the purple?

21:50You know, not in the red or in the blue, but in the purple. Is that question running in your head all the time? What is honestly running in my head a lot of the time is, are we saying the things we need to say to the people we need to say them to in a sincere way? And I think sometimes that might be a statement that is red. It might be a statement that is blue. It might be a statement that is purple. I think that that's actually not the problem. the problem that we are facing or seeing is moral decay. And it's saying, hey, I might be making whatever statement I'm going to make, but I'm going to make it in a way that is really awful and rude or racist or hateful.

22:44And I think that what I love about what Bad Bunny did is he showed us, you can be you and you can make the statements you want to make, but you can do it in a way that is full of integrity and in a way that is not hateful. And I think if more Americans, whether you are red, whether you are blue or whether you are purple, if more Americans did that, I think we would be living in a less polarized society and in a more joyful society. I noticed that last week you posted a picture on LinkedIn of you with your family, with your kids, your husband, even the dog. And the heading was Happy Black History Month.

23:23Your husband's not black. You were born in Nigeria. And you wrote, our kids have been asking a lot of questions lately. So much feels heavy right now. And you talk about courage and justice and dignity. What prompted you to share that publicly? This is the hundred years of celebrating what we know today as Black History Month. It's the hundredth celebration. And, you know, some people have chosen not to recognize or celebrate this Black History Month at all. Beyond that, some people have chosen to roll back some of the progress that Black people have made over the last hundred years, or they are trying to roll it back and they're criticizing it.

24:09There is a rise in anti-Blackness and an anti-Black sentiment, right? Racism is at an all-time high in modern history. So now I'm going back the last 20, 30 years. And so, you know, as a Black woman, as a Black leader in today's world, I felt it was important for me to acknowledge what is going on and to share a message that I hope is a message of hope, is a message of encouragement, and is helping people be seen. There are historic levels of unemployment for Black people, especially Black women. It doesn't get a lot of coverage, but it is the fact. And not a lot of Black people and Black women feel like they can say something, right?

25:00Because there is also a lot of fear, fear of retribution, fear of judgment. And do I feel fear? Absolutely. Bob, I feel fear. I feel afraid. I have not felt this scared in a very, very long time. The last time I felt this scared was when I was in Nigeria and there was a coup. And we lived on the military rule. That is the last time I felt the levels of fear and anxiety that I feel right now. So I feel fear. And I still think it is important to say something. Because I'm thinking if I who have, and I have some privilege, right? I went to great schools. I have some financial security. So if I feel afraid and say nothing, what about the millions of Black Americans who might feel this fear as well, but maybe don't feel like they're in a position to say something or even in a position that anyone might even listen?

25:56And so to me, it's important to say something because that is critical for not only acknowledging the moment, but rallying each and every one of us to do whatever we can do in our own sphere of influence to be a light, to help to push things forward, to keep progress moving. because, you know, when Black people in America are treated fairly, are treated well, are treated with dignity, it is good for all Americans. And I think we have a duty to the next generation coming after us to make sure that we leave this world a better place than how we found it. This fear, does it make you, I don't want to say less proud, but like, how does it make you feel about being an American or what it means to be an American?

26:49Does it mean something different? I mean, I'm sure you're still rooting for Team USA at the Olympics. I'm always rooting for Team USA. You know, I will always be proud to be an American. You know, you might know my husband is a Marine. So we are a military family. I love this country so much. I will always love this country. And it is the love that I have for this country that inspires me to say, hey, let's look here. How can we continue to be our best selves? It is the love that I have for this country that compels me to call out injustice when I see this. It is from a place of love, from a place of saying this is a country that I deeply believe in.

27:31You know, Nigeria was my country of birth. America is my country of choice. This is where I chose to come to. This is a country I chose to become a citizen of intentionally. I love this country and I always will. And I also think it's important for me to say when I feel like we could be better, hey, here's where I think we could be better. I'm more than just say, do something about it. You know, professionally at Autodesk, you are supporting Team USA. You're the official design and make platform for Team USA in the Olympics. What does that mean? The designing and making of the games, of the different venues, of the stadiums, of the equipment, a lot of that is designed and made with our Autodesk software by our amazing customers all around the world.