

The episode “Financial Advisors Versus the Internet” is a debate-style reaction to internet personal-finance advice, arguing for a “financial order of operations” and fee-only, holistic planning rather than paying for simple index-fund handholding. Guests discuss long-term investing vs trading, using index funds/passive investing, and tax strategy—especially Roth vs traditional 401(k) based on future tax brackets and Roth conversions. They critique “creative” tax schemes and warn against skipping employer match, Roth/HSA funding, or brokerage steps. Notable examples include a “Costco hot dog” affordability math breakdown, “house hacking” with low down payments, and a case for switching Roth 401(k) to traditional 401(k) for high earners to exploit tax arbitrage.
Brian (host, Money Guy team) and Bo (former financial advisor/portfolio manager; Money Guy team).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the comparative experiences of owning stocks versus luxury items.
“Owning a stock is boring unless it goes up in value.”
Exploring the financial advantages of treating trips as business expenses.
“Me and my wife, we don't go on vacations.”
The importance of discipline and strategic planning in wealth building.
“There's discipline, living on less than you make.”
Discussion on the drawbacks of 401k and the benefits of real estate investing.
“Can you imagine you're on your business trip with your family and your wife wants to post some beautiful pictures?”
Analyzing the affordability of everyday items and financial decisions.
“But it's not something that you do at the cost of the other things that you are doing.”
Arguments against the standard practice of charging 1% by financial advisors.
“The Costco hot dog with a 20 ounce soda costs about$1.50 before taxes and fees.”
Situations when seeking a financial advisor makes sense.
“I'm Tyler, a former financial advisor and portfolio manager.”
Situations when seeking a financial advisor makes sense.
“If they can't do it, then you're barking up the wrong tree.”
Discussion on practical approaches to achieving financial independence.
“This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
Discussion on practical approaches to achieving financial independence.
“So yes, it's small contributions, small impact on your daily life, but huge results for your future self.”
Discover how paying off a mortgage early can lead to financial independence and a better work-life balance.
“No, we actually paid off our mortgage 8 years ago.”
Learn the importance of prioritizing financial decisions and avoiding becoming a debt crusader.
“But I will say money is nothing more than a tool that allows you to accomplish the goals that you have in life.”
Explore the nuances of 401(k) contributions and the impact of tax brackets on retirement planning.
“pay off the mortgage before they're funding their Roth IRA, before they're maximizing their employer 401k and even setting up a brokerage account so they can do coast fire and live life on their terms.”
Understand how a fee-only financial planner can optimize your financial future.
“And you do that until your income hits that tipping point where the current year tax benefit is so valuable that you don't want to walk away from.”
Learn about the importance of personal finance and how to make informed financial decisions.
“And that's really the job of what a fee-only financial planner does, is they not only look at what you've got going on today, your current triage situation of your financial life.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Money Guy Show, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Brian Preston: This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more.
0:38Brian Preston: Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Welcome back to another React. What I've been told by the team is we're going to be reacting to us versus the internet. Brent, I am so excited to go toe-to-toe with what the internet has for us today. Let's check it out. Owning a stock is boring unless it goes up in value. Like, think about my Marcielago.
1:14Brian Preston: I paid$2.75 for that car. The doors go up. It's worth$800 ,000 now. It's a manual V12. I get to drive it. I get to take it to car shows. I get to meet people. You own a stock, like, ho-hum. If that car was still worth$275, I've still had a great experience. Yeah, what about the maintenance? What about the insurance? I don't care if my stock goes up or down today. In all reality, when I go invest in a company, when I go buy shares in a stock or a mutual fund, I really don't care what happens to the value today, tomorrow, the next day, because it's a long-term holding. I don't need to show it off to my friends.
1:47Brian Preston: I don't need to ride in it. I know a lot of people who have lost their shirt buying and selling and trading cars, often not the same with a side market. Exotic cars, that's a hobby. It's a cool hobby. What's the retail on one of those? More than you can afford, pal. By the end of the day, I want my money, my army of dollar bills to work harder than I do with my brain, my back, and my hands. The easiest way to do that, just buy the market through an index fund, let it be passive. Me and my wife, we don't go on vacations. We only go on business trips. I can't write off a vacation. So why would I go on one?
2:19Brian Preston: It makes no financial sense for me as a self-employed business owner to be taking vacations when I can justify every single traveling trip to be a business trip. If I think creatively ahead of time, I come up with a plan and I create an itinerary. This isn't rocket science. If you go somewhere where you're conducting business, you can make it a business write off for you. I refuse to go on vacations when I know strategically how to leverage the tax code to take business trips every time I travel with my family. And you should, too. We have three ingredients to wealth. There's discipline, living on less than you make.
2:49There is that turns into the margin or the money that gets invested and then you give enough time. His content is so entertaining to me coming from a tax background and I want to give him credit. He has step number one, which is the discipline. This gentleman has the discipline that he doesn't tell us solely he's going on vacation, not to go visit the mouse or the wizard down in Florida. He's on a business trip.
3:12Brian Preston: Yeah, here's what I think is so interesting about Carlton. And it makes me nervous because I do think a lot of what's so compelling about what he says is that there are glimmers of truth or there are shades of truth in all the things that he says. He said that you have to be really, really creative. In my experience, when it comes to the tax code, I don't want to be super creative. There is black, there is white, and I try to live outside of the gray because it's not worth the inherent risk of doing it the wrong way. So I would be cautious of taking that advice and applying it car block. Can you imagine you're on your business trip with your family and your wife wants to post some beautiful pictures?
3:53Whoa, whoa, whoa. Nope. We got a gig going here. No posting pictures of the mouse in the castle. This is a business trip. Don't post that. We can't post that. This is a business trip deductible. Do not put all of your money in your 401k. Instead, do this. 401ks are great if you just want to set it and forget it, take the safe route. But if you want to actually make real money on your investments, there's plenty of other avenues to pursue. One of the options, and this is the one that I use, is cash out your 401k, use those funds as a down payment on a multi-unit property that
4:27Brian Preston: you can house hack by living in one unit and renting out the others. That way, you're not just letting your money sit in an account that's earning a low rate. You're getting cash flow, you're getting tax benefits, you're getting appreciation, and you're getting leverage options. It always frustrates me when these internet experts act like all these things are mutually exclusive. If you want to do this, you can't do this. You got to go cannibalize this to do that. I don't know if it's true. We love investing in real estate. We love house hacking. We love house hacking. It's great. But it's not something that you do at the cost of the other things that you are doing.
4:58Brian Preston: And there's a hierarchy. Some people would even call it an order of operations by which you should follow when it comes to making these financial decisions. But he just said, you know what? Scrap that and jump right to the end of the plan. I think that's bad advice. You can do and. That's right. You know what? You can house hack with a 3 % down payment because it's your first house and you live in a portion of it. So if you buy a duplex, quadplex or whatever, do the whole house hacking thing. But you don't have to go raid your 401k that has the free money that your employer's dumping in there.
5:29Make smart decisions. There is a better way to do money.
5:32Brian Preston: Here's how much you need to be making to comfortably afford the Costco hot dog with a 20 ounce soda. The Costco hot dog with a 20 ounce soda costs about$1.50 before taxes and fees. A standard down payment is around 20%, which means that you should roughly put around 30 cents down. And after taking the final price of the Costco hot dog with a 20 ounce drink, adding the 20 % down, finance at 8 % for a total of 60 months, you're left with a total monthly payment of roughly 2 cents a month. So for only 2 cents a month, you could technically have a Costco hot dog with a 20 ounce drink. But if you were to multiply this by 10%, you'll find your monthly gross income.
6:02Brian Preston: Then multiply this by 12 to find your annual gross income. You roughly should be making around$2.04 a year to be able to very comfortably afford this Costco hot dog with a 20-ounce drink. You know, this is super funny, but a lot of people, I think they do approach their consumption decisions this way. Oh, I don't know if I want to spend this much on that thing. But if I broke it down and I just paid for it over 19 months or over 36 months or over 60 months, man, it becomes a lot more affordable and a lot more palatable. Just because you can afford the monthly payment does not mean that you can afford that thing.
6:31We should all just take a moment and pause on the$1.50 Costco hot dog. Because what a genius business concept this is. Is because without a doubt, it's a loss leader. I think they've published, they lose money on these transactions. Look, I know hot dogs are horrible for my heart. But they taste so good. And these guys at Costco in a diabolical plant have put something that tastes so good, but is so bad for me, but at such a cost. I mean, you're kidding me? I get a drink and this huge foot long hot dog that's all beef and delicious. It gives me, I basically shake every time I go to Costco to like, Brian, don't buy, don't buy, don't buy.
7:17Brian Preston: Here's why paying 1 % to a financial advisor makes no sense. I'm Tyler, a former financial advisor and portfolio manager. Former. And I used to charge 1%, and it made no sense. Number one, if you retire with a million bucks, and you want to follow the 4 % withdrawal rule, you take home 30k, your advisor takes home 10k every year. Number two, over 30 years, that 1 % could cost you between 25 and 30 % of your total returns. And number three, the worst part, most advisors invest you in the exact same index fund that you could buy yourself in under three minutes. That's not advice. That's an expensive subscription for handholding.
7:48Brian Preston: Very, very expensive handholding. Two things really, really quickly. if all you're doing is paying an advisor to go out there and buy index funds, we agree. Don't do that. That's why he's a former financial advisor. Don't go pay an advisor to just buy index funds for you. If that's what you're doing, you're not getting your money's worth. But if you have a holistic financial advisor, looking at all the different areas of your financial life, even though they do use index funds, what should be happening is even if they are charging you 1%, even if they are charging you some fee, the value that they add to your financial life should be greater than the fee that they charge.
8:22Brian Preston: Of course, if you're in a situation where all that's happening is 1 % is getting leached off of your net worth of offer your portfolio off of your wellbeing every year, that's not a favorable trade-off. This is no different than buying toilet paper at Costco. Speaking of Costco, the bigger you show up with in bulk purchases, the cheaper it all gets. I mean, so it's such a math crime because they run this 1 % and they'll get it to where you'll have, instead of having, you know, if you have 12 million in assets, they're still taking 1 % off of$12 million. No, this is not the way it works. It gets cheaper and cheaper and cheaper, the bigger you get.
8:59But look, I get it. It's easy to do a math crime and then make yourself feel better and then go sell some other product. Cause it's back to at the end of the day, who's putting the interest of their clients first, or is it the person that's legally just selling you something and suitability or has some product or does life insurance Ask yourself these questions. That's why I always say go to moneyguy.com slash resources. We have eight questions you ought to ask your financial advisor. If they can't do it, then you're barking up the wrong tree. Bo, I'm willing to bet there's someone watching or listening who's wondering if they should work with a financial advisor.
9:35Brian Preston: Brian, if I were going to say an answer to that person of when it makes sense, there are really three times that we think it makes sense to reach out to an advisor. The first is when complexity finds you. What I mean by this is that your financial life has gotten more and more complicated. Now you realize you simply don't know what you don't know. The second is when you don't have the time or even the desire to be the CFO of your financial life. Important stuff is falling on the back burner and you just don't have enough time to put in the effort it takes to do what you need to do. And the third is when the gravity of your decisions are bigger than you feel comfortable navigating alone.
10:12Brian Preston: Because of your success,$100 decisions start turning into$100 ,000 decisions. And one tax decision or one bad investment move can literally be a six-figure mistake. Look, this is likely the first time you're navigating wealth at this level. But we do this all the time. And having somebody on your team who's done this a thousand times can help you do this more efficiently and give you incredible peace of mind because we can help you uncover your blind spots. Yeah, if any of this sounds like you, just head over to aboutwealth.com or click the link below. We'd love to connect and see if we're a good fit for you.
10:49Brian Preston: Roth IRA. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18+. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications, and more.
11:29Brian Preston: Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Oof, great account, but the contribution limits are tiny. Three. Traditional 401k. Four. Hear me out here. A lot of us build wealth here, but every dollar is taxable on the way out. Cash value life insurance. Easy five, and I hope you give me some good ones next. HSA. Two. Triple tax advantage when you use it for retirement health care.
12:03Brian Preston: Taxable brokerage. Definitely number one if you're looking to retire early. James, I don't disagree with you a ton. I do have a little bit out of, I look HSA beating out Roth. I'm okay with, but I think I got to move those into the one and two spot taxable brokers. Number three, because most people, when they start out in their financial journey, we don't want to start a taxable brokerage account. We want to start with the Roth IRA, with the HSA doing$50 a month, a hundred dollars a month. Get those accounts growing because tax-free growth is so, so, so, so valuable. I agree. Cash value life insurance should be at the end.
12:34Brian Preston: What was his number four? His Roth IRA. Oh, traditional 401k. Yeah. But But if you're getting free money, I argue that one's got to be a little bit higher up. So I love the way that you have the first four and the first four. We can throw the fifth one away. What the heck are you doing? But I think I would have rearranged it a little bit because I think if people start with a tax brokerage account, they're missing a lot of opportunity in the front end, whether it be through employer matching in that traditional 401k or through building tax-free dollars in your Roth and HSA. You're Roth IRA. Most of you, hopefully you're discovering this content in either your 20s or 30s.
13:10And yes, you're going to be capped out at putting around seven grand a year in this thing. But the thing is that seven grand, depending upon what your wealth multiplier is, go to moneyguy.com slash resources, look at what your wealth multiplier. And for a 30 year old, that's 23 times. So yes, it's small contributions, small impact on your daily life, but huge results for your future self. Do not sleep on the free money from your employer. Don't sleep on that you can load up your Roth 401k, your Roth IRA, and your health savings account. It's almost like there's something that can tell you an instruction manual, tell you what to do with your next dollar to live your best life.
13:47And it's called the financial order of operations. Just like math has an order of operations, so do your finances. And we've perfected it.
13:54Brian Preston: Hey, man, nice house. Hey, if you don't mind my asking, what's your mortgage rate? Oh, we don't have one. Oh, are you renting? No, we actually paid off our mortgage 8 years ago. Really? In your 30s? Why? Well, we wanted to lower our cost of living so we didn't need to work as much. After front-loading our investments until we hit coast fire and paying off our mortgage early, my wife and I now work two part-time jobs instead of two full-time jobs. This allows us to have more time for our marriage, more time to spend with our kids, and more time to take care of our health. Huh. I never thought of it like that.
14:32Brian Preston: When life costs less, you don't need to work as much. Exactly. All right. So we consider Andy a friend. I'm not going to say anything bad here. I'm not going to go against him. But I will say money is nothing more than a tool that allows you to accomplish the goals that you have in life. And for he and his wife, one of their goals was financial independence, retire early and being debt free. And so they prioritize the financial decisions they make based upon those goals. where I sit in my position, I think if you have a super low interest mortgage in the two, three, 4 % range, for a young person in their 30s, it's really hard to justify paying off that mortgage early when those dollars could potentially work harder for you elsewhere and give you the ability to be debt-free on a tighter timeline.
15:15Brian Preston: But Andy's done great. I'm not gonna fault him. His plan worked for him, even though I would argue perhaps it's mathematically suboptimal, but behaviorally, it was perfect for him. Andy's been on our show. We've been on Andy's show. I have additional context here, and that's that Andy followed the food. He didn't pay off his mortgage until he was already in step eight of the financial order of operations, meaning he was already loading up and saving well beyond 25 % in his Roth IRAs, his 401ks. He wanted to be debt-free that much sooner. I just want to make sure people who watch this content don't become debt crusaders where they pay off the mortgage before they're funding their Roth IRA, before they're maximizing their employer 401k and even setting up a brokerage account so they can do coast fire and live life on their terms.
16:07Andy also was a hyper accumulator of saving. They had a very good income. They made really good decisions and they just prioritized that they did want to be debt free that much sooner so they could live life on their terms and own their time.
16:20Brian Preston: My financial advisor is advising me to switch from contributing to the company's Roth 401k to a traditional 401k due to basically my income level and the amount of tax savings that I would receive now. Wow. Okay. He sounds like somebody died. You need to get a new financial advisor that can actually do math. That was kind of my guess, but I didn't know if there was any specific circumstance where that was beneficial. High income. Yeah. So what are you, what are you, how old are you? I'm 40. Okay. And how much are you going to be putting into the 401k? I'll basically be maxing it out. Okay. So you're going to put in how much in dollars?
17:07Brian Preston: About 24 ,000. Okay. We'll call it$2 ,000 a month. Okay. If I put that in the retirement calculator, that says that you're going to have at 65, 3.1 million. Okay. I started zero. I'm sure she already has assets. And for 25 years, you put in$24 ,000. And I'll have to add up what that is. You want to do that for me? Say 25 years times$24 ,000. And everything above your contribution is taxable. What was the number? $600 ,000. Okay,$600 ,000. So he's telling you to save taxes on$600 ,000 of the$3.1 million. but for doing that you get to pay taxes on two and a half million lovely that's you go okay you go here's the thing when your tax rate is between 25 and 30 percent you know if you add your state and federal we think that that's kind of the the gray zone where you take into account what your age is and other things but once you're 30 percent or greater especially if you're somebody who thinks you're going to leave the workforce anytime between 55 to 75, which is a huge window, by the way, because that's the window right before required minimum distributions.
18:27What if you could leave the workforce? Let's say like myself, if I'm paying 40 % to taxes, but then I could retire at say 60 years of age, I have 15 years before the government mandates me to take the money out. Now I don't have all this earned income that's driving my tax rates way up. I could go from 40 % to potentially 15, 22%. I could manipulate the, or 12%. You know, we deal with this 12 or 24 % on the marginal rates where we see clients, they drop from the highest, the 37 % marginal rates all the way down to 12%. And they start doing Roth conversions. They legally get to manipulate the tax code.
19:09That's good planning because that spread between the 37 and the 12, you got the compounding growth while you were in those peak earning years paying the highest possible tax rates. And then you got to convert it at a much lower tax rate.
19:24Brian Preston: I just think about for this lady, she's 40 years old. She's in a higher tax bracket. Let's assume that she pays 32 % marginal on the federal. We don't know her state. If she puts that$24 ,500 into the pre-tax side of a 401k, it's going to save her$7 ,800 in income taxes. That's enough money where she could go fund, she makes too much money, so she can't do a Roth IRA, but she's going to do a backdoor Roth IRA. So not only is she saving the 24-5, she's also building tax-free dollars via some sort of like backdoor Roth at$7 ,800. You can think about that tax savings in this year as like a 30 % imputed rate of return.
20:01Brian Preston: She can do that every single year. And just like you said, when she moves into a lower tax rate environment in retirement, she'll be able to convert those dollars to Roth at much lower rates. This is the arbitrage here. I can either turn dollars into Roth today at a 30 % tax bracket, or I can turn dollars into Roth tomorrow at a 12 % tax bracket. It's a favorable trade-off. That current year tax benefit is so, so, so valuable. It is difficult to walk away from. That's why we do say for most people, you start with Roth 401k contributions, And you do that until your income hits that tipping point where the current year tax benefit is so valuable that you don't want to walk away from.
20:41Yeah, it pains me because Dave does such a good job of getting people out of debt. But this is one of those things where I think you have to just say there's a better way to do money. And Dave, I would caution him. He's thinking about all the benefits of the Roth, but not thinking about the tax arbitrage. Because, look, we live in a progressive tax situation. The higher, more money you make, the more taxes you pay. You have to take into account the full context of somebody's financial life. If they're in the peak earning years with peak taxpaying years, you have to ask yourself, is there going to be a period in the future where maybe they're leaving the workforce at 50 years of age, 55 years of age, where you can now optimize the tax planning for the long term?
21:26And that's really the job of what a fee-only financial planner does, is they not only look at what you've got going on today, your current triage situation of your financial life. They look at your future life and say, how do we bring these things together? So you own your time, you live your best life today and tomorrow.
21:44Brian Preston: Look, there's tons of financial content out there on the internet. And a lot of it is really, really good. A lot of people we looked at today are fantastic financial commentators. But when it comes to what you should do with your financial life. Now you should make your financial decisions. Personal finance is personal. That's why we've come up with things like the financial order of operations to help you decide exactly what you should be doing so that you can live your great, big, beautiful tomorrow. Guys, this was a blast. I don't know. I felt like it was us more of nibbling on the edges, helping the internet know how to do life just a little bit better.
22:19There is a better way to do money. As we already shared with you. Go to moneyguy.com slash resources. Load up on the free stuff. We want you to live your best life. Get there that much faster because one day that success will create complication. We'll be waiting right there with the front porch light on. I'm your host, Brian, joined by Mr. Bo Money Guy team out.
23:09Brian Preston: We'll see you next time. most desirable menu has returned to Sweetgreen, featuring Fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
Is viral financial advice helping you build wealth—or leading you toward costly money mistakes? Financial advisors Brian and Bo react to internet money gurus and break down the truth about 401(k) investing, Roth vs. traditional retirement accounts, financial advisor fees, real estate investing, tax deductions, and paying off your mortgage early. Should you cash out your 401(k) to buy rental property? Is paying a financial advisor 1% worth it? And when does a traditional 401(k) make more sense than a Roth? Discover how smart investing, tax planning, and the Financial Order of Operations can help you make better decisions for financial independence.
Jump start your journey with our FREE financial resources
Reach your goals faster with our products
Take the relationship to the next level: become a client
Subscribe on YouTube for early access and go beyond the podcast
Connect with us on social media for more content
Bring confidence to your wealth building with simplified strategies from The Money Guy. Learn how to apply financial tactics that go beyond common sense and help you reach your money goals faster. Make your assets do the heavy lifting so you can quit worrying and start living a more fulfilled life.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices