Rule-Breaking Stocks for Your Holiday Shopping List

0:04Some people make holiday shopping lists. We're making a holiday stock list. Today on Motley Fool Money.

0:20Today is Tuesday, December 2nd. Welcome to Motley Fool Money. I'm your host, Emily Flippen, and today I'm joined by Motley Fool analyst Jason Hall and Asit Sharma to talk about favorite rule-breaking stocks for your holiday shopping list. But let's be real. This time of year, We're all surrounded by sales, shipping deadlines, holiday ads. But just because companies are spending doesn't necessarily mean consumers are too. We're going to be discussing some holiday radar stocks here. But first, I want to have to start with what we saw this past week and with Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, as well as some broader commentary around holiday spending as we end out the year.

0:55I don't know if anybody else feels this way, Asit and Jason, but personally, I feel like this holiday shopping season has just been a lot of deal fatigue from shoppers. I see discounts everywhere. the consumer does seem a little bit over it. And it does seem like some of our initial data backs this up. Initial reports are showing retail sales climbing around 4 % on Black Friday this year in comparison to last, but that doesn't account for inflation. If you look at inflation, it's around 3 % right now. So in practice, I kind of think consumers were a little flat this year. Salesforce also collected data that showed average selling prices were up 7 % year-over-year for Black Friday shopping, but order volumes were down 1%.

1:32Jason, I want to start with you. When you hear that, and when you look at the Black Friday and holiday data this year, what stands out to you about the consumer? I think the vibe check and the data line up here for me. We have a bifurcated economy where the haves have a lot and are supporting the big headline numbers, but we also have a large and maybe growing portion of consumers who are having to spend less to make ends meet. Now, there's how I feel as a person, but then there's the investor in me who thinks that the companies that know their customer and know what they are, are the ones that can continue to win.

2:07So you look at companies like Amazon, ticker AMZN, Walmart, ticker WMT, they lead on selection and price. The caveat, of course, that Amazon's playing a different game in groceries than Walmart. Then you look at companies like TJX companies, and that's the ticker, continues to win because They're the smartest buyers of goods that manufacturers and distributors have got to get off of warehouse shelves that they know they can quickly sell for cheap and get good margins. Then you have the Targets and Kohl's of the world, Target ticker TGT and Kohl's KSS. It seems like they're stuck in the middle, likely losing customers on both of those demographic ends while struggling with higher costs, just like everybody else is along the way.

2:50You find the companies that have the go-to-market strategies that continue to work and the excellent operations. And then you continue. Those are the ones that are going to win as investors. Then look at rule breakers like Shopify, MercadoLibre. I think those are excellent examples of incredible retailers. They know themselves. They know their customers. And here's the big thing. They also have really, really favorable long-term tailwinds. Yeah, it sounds like more of that K-shaped economy. That is the new buzzword. It feels like they talk about the economy in the second half of this year. I've heard more about the K-shaped economy and the pressured middle class more this year than any other year in the past.

3:26But it does seem like that is true, right? Big spenders are willing to still spend big. But unfortunately, the middle class is being pushed out for a lot of these retailers. If you aren't positioned to be a discount retailer, it is concerning. And Asit, I know we've talked a lot about how resilient the consumer has been over the last few years. You're pretty good at zooming out. I'm surprised that the resiliency has been what it is, despite the inflation, the tariffs, the challenges that we've seen. But when you look at the holiday season, is there any trends in particular you're watching that would indicate the status of the consumer for you heading into 2026?

4:01Emily, I don't see it a lot differently than Jason. The trends that he mentioned are playing out very easy to spot. Affluent shoppers, they're propping up the overall numbers. And the more strapped of us are still shopping. It's just that I think we are exercising more selectivity. That's what I'm seeing in the marketplace. And sure, buy now, pay later is increasing as a funding source for strapped consumers. When we think about selectivity as a phenomenon, that may be what's driving a K-shaped destiny for retailers. For example, better results from Walmart, symbol WMT, as we said before, that we saw earlier in this season.

4:43They exercise broad-based pricing. They can attract affluent shoppers who are dripping down. And they also keep appealing to those of us who have less to spend. TJX companies, they have the selection and they're really great at getting their inventory from distribution centers into stores on almost a weekly basis. And Shopify, S-H-O-P, Shopify is great at choice. So, if you have less to spend as a consumer, where will you find the place you will spend your dollars? Well, with your specific niche interest. That often comes from a Shopify-based store. Now, speaking of larger trends, when you look out at Cyber Week, I saw the data that you did, Emily, and I also looked at some other data, maybe more online commerce-specific from Adobe Analytics.

5:31That seems to suggest that the mega retailers like Walmart, think of Target, Best Buy, symbol BBY, and Amazon, symbol AMZN, are focused or have been focused this season on moving big-ticket items. They're going straight to those affluent customers. They have deals to bring them in. Put that together with what the higher-end consumers are doing. They're power users of AI tools. Reportedly, they used a lot of AI chatbots this cyber season to find those deals, so the two matched up with each other. And so, we end up with a 7.7 % increase in Cyber Week sales. This online commerce portion, that's about$44 billion, nearly matching last year's increase, which was just over 8%.

6:18I consider myself a little bit of an AI laggard, unfortunately. But even the people like myself, I used AI tools to help me with some holiday shopping over the course of the past weekend. And I expect that, to your point, Asit, A, it's probably driving a lot of the e-commerce expansion, but also just providing a new avenue for consumers who are willing to spend. But to your earlier point, it does seem like consumers have been picky with what they're purchasing in terms of stocking their hypothetical stocking here. But maybe investors should be just as picky with businesses they put on their shopping list, too.

6:52So, up next, we're going to be turning to Jason. He's going to talk to us about the first stock that he's considering and looking at as we head into the end of 2025 and why it could be a winner just beyond the holidays. So stick with us. The Civil War and Reconstruction was a pivotal era in American history. When a war was fought to save the Union and to free the slaves. And when the work to rebuild the nation after that war was over turned into a struggle to guarantee liberty and justice for all Americans. I'm Tracy. And I'm Rich. And we want to invite you to join us as we take an in-depth look at this pivotal era in American history.

7:32Look for the Civil War and Reconstruction wherever you find your podcasts. Welcome back to Motley Fool Money. I'm Emily Flippen here with Jason Hall and Asit Sharma talking about our favorite rule-breaking stocks for your holiday shopping list. We talked about 2025 holiday spending and what it might be telling us about the consumer. But now let's turn that into a concrete stock idea. Jason, what is the stock you're putting on investors' holiday lists this year, and why does it deserve a spot in a portfolio? Emily, what do you say we head down to Mexico for some holiday grocery shopping at BBB Foods?

8:03What do you say? I think that sounds great, Jason. Okay. Let's start with what it is. It's a hard discount grocer in one of the fastest-growing, most dynamic economies in the world. Business model is really simple, and it's proven. Instead of offering a lot of different versions of the same product, like you might see at a Walmart, which, by the way, has a pretty huge presence south of the U.S. border, BBB Foods offers a far more limited selection and also prioritizes private label products when possible. This helps in some really, really important ways. First, it simplifies its inventory management, reducing the number of SKUs that it carries, reducing buyer interactions.

8:41That helps keep operations from the distribution all the way through the store shelf more efficient. Next, it helps in two massively valuable ways inside the stores. By having fewer single product choices, it has more room for more product types. As a result, customers spend less time clogging the aisle trying to choose which dishwashing soap to buy, and more time grabbing more products across more categories. The business model is really, really working. Sales at existing stores are routinely growing in the high teens, even as it opens new stores at a breakneck pace. Companies over the past four quarters has opened 528 new locations, now has over 3 ,100 stores, has a goal to almost 5X that count in coming years.

9:30I like this pick on many levels. I am a fan of the long-term trajectory of the Mexican market, and I like this simpler, consumable selection that you're talking about. I just got back from a trip to India and realized when I was there, yeah, commerce is becoming more and more like the West, but it's still so nice to walk into a store as a consumer and not have a gazillion choices for simple items. I think that's to the favor of the retailer, good economic model. Jason, the only thing that worries me here a little bit is that the balance sheet looks a bit stretched. Working capital is upside down.

10:05Accounts payable is three times the size of inventory, which means they could really be stretching their vendors and their high lease liabilities on the books. I think operating cash flow looks good, but part of this might be on that inventory payables mismatch I just mentioned. They seem to have a lot of CapEx needs as they go forward with that store build-out. Any concerns there that the company might become capital constrained in the future? I don't think so, but I'll say this. That working capital deterioration is one of the things that I have noticed since the company went public a couple of years ago.

10:41But the interesting thing is that, in a way, there's a little bit of a feature going on and less of a bug. It has a negative working capital cycle, which means, in a lot of cases, it's actually selling goods and getting money from its customers before it has to pay its vendors. Now, that's not going to last forever, but because the business is in this phase where two things are happening, its comps are 16%, 17 % comps growth, so it's having to bring a lot more inventory into its existing stores, and it's opening new stores at a 15 % to 16 % rate. It's bringing a ton of inventory into its stores, but it's selling it out of the stores and collecting cash flow before it has to pay those vendors.

11:24So that's why you're seeing that the money that it owes out growing at a faster rate than the inventory that's in. So it's not going to last forever, but in the current high growth, high comp stage, the mismatch you identify, like I said, is really more of a feature, especially when you combine it with a lot of the cash outflows on the balance sheet are tied to assets that it now owns that are tied to its store account growth. It generates a lot of operating cash. That operating cash is largely sufficient to support its growth, especially when you pair that with about$130 million in net cash, a really small debt position, and a pretty decent amount of cash.

12:02It reminds me of a hybrid between Dutch Bros and Sprouts Farmers Markets. Those tickers are BROS and SFM. It's not exactly a fair comparison, but when you guys talk about the balance sheet and the extension there, it reminds me a little bit of what Dutch Bros going through also building out its store count at around that 15 % clip, but also with some of the niche that Sprouts Farmers Market has cultivated in terms of a grocer here in the United States. Now, it's obviously not the same footprint and different competitive positioning, but this is certainly one that I'm really interested in, Jason.

12:34And Asit, I think you have your work cut out for me, at least, to convince me about your idea. But up next, we're going to be talking about your own rule-breaking idea for your holiday stock list, as well as how to put them all together in a long-term portfolio. So stick with us. Welcome back to Motley Fool Money. We're building a holiday stock shopping list of rule-breaking ideas. Jason's already shared his pick, but Asit, I want to turn to you now. What stock are you putting on our holiday list this year and why should we be excited about it today? So, Emily, I am putting a very rule-breakery and, frankly, slightly risky stock on my holiday list for you this year.

13:08Astera Labs is the company, symbol A-L-A-B. Happy Holidays. This is a specialty company in the semiconductor industry that makes components that boost signal speed and data transfer within data center. So think of components in a data center, maybe GPUs and CPUs talking to each other. It makes components that boost signal speed and data transfer within data center. So think of GPUs and CPUs and data center. Estera Labs makes the widgets that speed up the conversation between those components. This is a niche manufacturer. It supplies to NVIDIA, symbol NVDA, AMD, Advanced Micro Devices, also symbol AMD, Intel, symbol INTC, and many cloud hyperscalers that you have heard of.

13:55Now, it's working on a next-generation technology, Emily, called Compute Express Link. And this is sort of exciting because it will allow different parts of a server or a server rack to share memory, to pull memory together, to make all of the processing within that rack go a lot faster. This is going to fuel growth for the next few years. Astera Labs is already profitable. It has an operating margin of around 15%. Revenue is growing at a double-digit clip. What I like about this company is that it's founder-led. The two co-founders own about 9 % of shares, and it scores high in our Rule Breaker database on several fronts.

14:33The proprietary Motley Fool Rule Breaker database, it has a super score of 82, which is pretty good. Now, this is a classic case of a first mover in an important emerging market, so that is the signal interconnect market. And also, you could say it's overvalued, which is another trait of a Rule Breaker. The stock does trade at a premium. It fails the cola test. If you snapped your fingers, would the world miss Estera Labs? I mean, most people have never heard of this company. So, right now, the answer is, yeah, it fails it. No one would miss this business. But could it become more important with this compute express link technology I mentioned?

15:11Yes, companies like NVIDIA are very interested to see that platform developed. I would urge anyone who wants to invest in this to do your homework and maybe dollar cost average in, take a rational position size. My question, Asit, is how much of this is just the picks and shovels play on the continued proliferation and build out for AI infrastructure that's happening now? Is it mostly that or is the cloud broadly and accelerated computing broadly enough to make this a winner if the current AI race doesn't lead to the monetization promised land that we're hoping for? I love this question, Jason, because I think this is a question we need to ask of almost every company that we invest in that is getting a tailwind from all this build-out.

15:55The answer is that Astera's technology is going to be important either way. So, I think there's a place for this company, even if the promised build-out doesn't materialize to the nth degree. We should remember here, and I should have mentioned this earlier, it does have a high concentration of customers. So just a handful of these big hyperscalers and big semiconductor players will make up 70 % plus of revenue in any given quarter. So that may be spread between three or four companies. So for the time being, it's concentrated in this idea. But as the years go on, it's going to become less concentrated.

16:29And also, I think either way, it's still going to be around. The question is, how much we'll be able to get out of this very huge build out in AI scale? I will say, I think the bar was set high. I love a Mexican retailer here, but with a super square of 82, Austin, I think you undersold that in the Rule Breakers database for Astera Labs. It's incredibly high. Certainly a very interesting company. Jason, as we wrap up today's show, I want to pass this question off to you. If our listeners are somebody like me and they like BBB Foods and they also like Astera Labs and they're thinking about how they can add these to their portfolio without just impulse buying stocks the same way they might be impulse buying shopping lists this holiday season.

17:09How should they think about adding these to a portfolio? Well, FOMO is real. And the data does suggest that maybe thinking about FOMO and buying all of the stock you want to own up front is the best thing to do in the aggregate. But we're not aggregates. We're humans in the real world. And we have to find a strategy that we can stick with that will work in our real life. And for me, that generally means that I do start with a small starter position, and I can add to it over time. And you think about these two companies we've talked about, they're younger, newer, very volatile, very exposed to macro things that can make the stocks move a ton.

17:48And they're the kind of businesses that you want to add to over time, I think, generally. BBB Foods, for example, I've bought at much lower prices than today's, and I've bought it at prices that are very similar to the current price. So, So I think what matters more, evaluation is important, but business execution for a company that's trying to 5X its size over the next 10 or 15 years, that business execution is how we're going to profit. So a deliberate process that focuses on adding more money to winning businesses, this probably sounds really rule-breakery, helps me avoid both the FOMO and the trap of the impulse buy.

18:24I'll save the impulse buys, guys, for the junk food at the supermarket checkout out of the aisle. Those are certainly fine impulse buys to have. What I'm hearing is to keep our portfolios a little bit longer-term focus on our holiday shopping lists here. But for our listeners, I hope this gives them a couple of interesting new stock ideas that they might add to their own holiday shopping list as we round out the end of the year. Jason and Asit, thank you both so much for joining today. Thanks, Emily. Thanks a lot, Emily. As always, people on the program may have interest in the stocks they talk about, and The Motley Fool may have formal recommendations for or against, so don't buy or sell stocks based solely on what you hear.

18:56All personal finance content follows the Motley Fool editorial standards and is not approved by advertisers. Advertisements are sponsored content and provided for informational purposes only. To see our full advertising disclosure, please check out our show notes. For Jason Hall, Asit Sharma, and the entire Motley Fool Money team, I'm Emily Flippen. We'll see you tomorrow.