

13 Nov 2026 · 1h 29m · 32 chapters

The episode argues that investors must distinguish cyclical weakness from structural decline, using Australia’s David Jones store closures and administration as the main case study. It also briefly discusses how a high-profile Jensen Huang scandal could affect Nvidia as a strategic AI supplier.
Scott Phillips (host; The Motley Fool Money). Andrew Page (guest; runs Australia’s online investment club Straw Man; discusses AI enthusiasm and investing perspectives).
David Jones’ collapse is framed as structural retail economics plus contract/counterparty dynamics, not simply government policy. Administration is described as a “half-pregnant purgatory” that can tear up long leases and reduce counterparty risk, aiming to maximize value for lenders/creditors. Retail margins are thin, so small permanent sales losses can make stores unprofitable; the “skill” is separating temporary downturns from one-way structural decline. Job losses and short-term discounting may boost reported sales while damaging the brand.
David Jones closing 19 stores after Christmas (7 more under review), layoffs of ~3,000 staff; comparison to other department-store failures; counterparty/lease example with Westfield; Nvidia’s Jensen Huang affair/alleged China-spy claims and potential shareholder impact; WiseTech CEO removal/reinstatement as an analogy.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the rapid advancements in AI and its broader implications.
“I think I've got, it's been called AI psychosis for the condition of just people like me, just like giddy with excitement with this stuff and only looking at the positives, which I'm very hyper aware of that.”
Analysis of David Jones' plan to close stores and implications for the brand.
“And the pace of change is incredible, which is very, very cool.”
Exploration of lease agreements and management issues affecting David Jones.
“But essentially, DJ's has 38 stores currently.”
Insights on the administration process and the concept of counterparty risk.
“They've got a chance now, and this is the benefit of the administration, to effectively – I mean, it sounds like it's – I mean, it is kind of a bit.”
Discussion on the inherent risks of business and the importance of allowing second chances.
“But it's sort of a record of intent in a lot of cases there too.”
Examining the rational behavior of retailers and consumers in the face of failures.
“It's like, so we're going to keep doing this, but we don't have to give you that.”
Discussion on the future of David Jones and the implications of brand repositioning.
“So it's just a question of finding the right point after that.”
Discusses the struggles of David Jones, including layoffs and brand challenges.
“You know, it is very much just that story of, well, what else do you, you know, what else do you expect given the challenges that face it?”
Explores potential future job cuts and the viability of shopping centers.
“but I just feel as though, get used to it.”
Examines the profitability of retail stores and the impact of online shopping.
“Because we haven't used the phrase, the word omni-channel much in recent.”
Discusses the value of retail space and how market dynamics may shift in the future.
“But you're reminding me of a company where they made some hard decisions closing a bunch of stuff.”
Learn how to differentiate between cyclical downturns and structural problems in retail.
“There is a point where it's kind of like actually no one's interested at these rents.”
Explore how external factors and poor management are often misattributed to government policies.
“I just worry, and this is just me, you know, navel-gazing.”
Understand the impact of economic cycles on the survival of businesses.
“bad businesses do go broke when there's cyclical downturns because they just don't have the wherewithal to make it.”
Discuss the implications of personal controversies involving NVIDIA's CEO on the company's future.
“Hey, let's – speaking of interesting, have you been following the NVIDIA palaver in the US with Jensen Huang and – Well, I woke up to it yesterday, our time, and it was like, oh, God, what now type thing.”
Exploring the realities of corporate espionage and the levels at which it occurs.
“Yeah, and I think that's, you know, and there's, yeah, those companies have been found guilty of spying on each other and going through each other's garbage.”
Discussing the forward P/E ratio of NVIDIA and its implications for investors.
“But that's already been a big bone of contention between the US and China with, you know, you're ripping off all our technology.”
Analyzing stock market behaviors and the psychology of buying during price drops.
“And there is something to be said for, So, and again, I haven't done the work, but just from a procedural perspective for an investor, this is why it's so valuable to have done work on a company previously.”
Examining the implications of leadership decisions within tech firms like NVIDIA.
“The Economist is running an article titled Jensen Huang Must Resign.”
Discussing the conflict between ethical considerations and investment strategies.
“And they are churning out chips and selling for four times the price.”
Highlighting the necessity of compromise and acceptance of imperfections in investments.
“Now, I'm very aware it could be a NextDC type situation, not the more recent issues they're having, but I was wrong on NextDC for years because I kind of went, this is a glorified REIT.”
Learn about the importance of acknowledging both negative and positive aspects in investment decisions.
“Like you must, they say politics is the art of compromise.”
Explore the significance of viewing investments from a portfolio perspective rather than focusing solely on individual stocks.
“You just go right, let's not, let's go into it.”
Discuss the implications of major companies outsourcing jobs and its effects on the workforce.
“Man, let's finish off quickly with some news this week and I'll give away the lead.”
Analyze the ongoing debate about outsourcing versus insourcing and its impact on corporate efficiency.
“The ABS put out some data this week, I think it was, that in July and August, I think were the months, there were more than 100 ,000 Australians retrenched from their jobs.”
Exploring the implications of efficiency and service delivery in public services.
“Well, the answer is, well, if they manage to get the same service delivery for a lower price, then it's a good move.”
Discussion on the growing presence of AI across various industries and its implications.
“With the exception, I will say two things.”
Debating the effectiveness and challenges of regulating AI technologies in Australia.
“And so it's like making homosexuality or swearing, like banning it.”
Discussion on the implications of a potential Bitcoin ban and its global effects.
“I mean, the obvious example is a Bitcoin ban as well.”
Exploration of the differences between structural and cyclical market risks and their implications for investors.
“I don't mind saying to a member, this could go wrong, and it goes wrong.”
How to adjust investment strategies in response to changing market conditions and regulations.
“the great thing about this sort of game is that you don't.”
Concluding remarks and a look ahead to future discussions on the podcast.
“But just to when the news drops to have gone, yes, I have considered this.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Motley Fool Money, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:03Listener. Welcome to Motley Fool Money. the podcast is not about to outsource jobs to India, at least not this week. I'm Scott Phillips from The Motley Fool. He is Andrew Page. He's the man who put the straw in straw man, the man in straw man, the raw in straw man, the all man in straw man, and at that point I have to start giving up. The nah. The nah. The nah. I like it. Mate, straw man, of course, is Australia's premier online investment club as well. It should be, given the time and energy you've put into it. How are you, mate? I'm good. Yeah, really good. Just, you know, every day is AI Christmas.
0:42You wake up and there's a new gift from the AI overlords. And yeah, I'm just, I'm in a delirium. I think I've got, it's been called AI psychosis for the condition of just people like me, just like giddy with excitement with this stuff and only looking at the positives, which I'm very hyper aware of that. particular bias. And yes, there are two sides to that particular coin. But yeah, it's just things are moving so fast. I cringe a little bit in just even mentioning it because it feels like we're just coming back to this well again and again and again. But every time you kind of think, yep, it's done, something else sort of comes out and you go, whoa, okay.
1:30And it's got implications for personal life, for business life, for the economy at large, for investing. It just touches everything. And my head's spinning, man. And I'm loving it. It is really cool. Yeah. And you and I generally start off air chats with this week in AI. What did you do this week? I did this. I did this. And there was so much stuff around. There was so much going on. And the pace of change is incredible, which is very, very cool. um let's uh we'll be back to that i'm sure at some point let's let's start though speaking of ai this is there anything more anti-ai than physical department stores it's just different uh yes extremes on the same continuum on one hand you've got ai on the other hand you've got dj is still trying to pretend it's 1952 uh and we talked about last week so we're not gonna do a whole heap on it this week other than we got some extra information i think there's a couple of angles mate it's worth kind of just drawing out a little bit more than what we talked about last week.
2:27So most people would have caught on to the news by now. We're recording this on Thursday morning and again, because these things move quick, I'll just say that because whatever changes between now and then, we'll see. But essentially, DJ's has 38 stores currently. That's after closing five already recently. They are now going to shut out another 19 of those 38 after Christmas and apparently seven more are under review. And this is a little bit of chutzpah, a little bit of, I don't know how to describe it really from the The DJ's manager said, well, this is always the plan all along. It's like, well, you guys signed stupidly long leases and you went broke because you couldn't execute that plan.
3:04And to be fair, it's not current management's fault. The previous manager signed them up for multi, multi, multi-year leases, in some cases 10 to 15-year leases. And DJ's was like, well, we want to shut these stores anyway. And again, it's hard when we talk about companies because it's not the same people. So it's easy to say, well, David Jones said, but realistically, it's like a footy team, right? The footy team in 10 years is still wearing the same jerseys, but they're not really the same team they were a decade ago. But, yeah, they're saying this is the plan all along, closing 19 stores, another seven, as I say, under review, leaving them with 12.
3:34I would take pretty short odds on those seven actually being closed unless something dramatic happens between now and Christmastime. If they're marginal, they're marginal, right? And here's the other thing. They've got a chance now, and this is the benefit of the administration, to effectively – I mean, it sounds like it's – I mean, it is kind of a bit. It's an interesting question as to where the obligations should lay because there are counterparties here, right? But effectively, what administration does is it lets you walk away from every binding legal agreement you previously had as an entity.
4:02It's like, yeah, sorry, Westfield, we have a 15-year lease, but no, you're not giving them the money we're going. And again, that's what bankruptcy allows. And on one level, it makes fair your reason. And it's also just welcome to counterparty risk. It is just an unavoidable reality of any kind of business or just interpersonal agreement. Yeah, yeah. You know, hey, do you want to do this? Yeah, let's shake on it. Now we can formalise that with ceremony and forms and legalities, but that's what it is. They are, I like to keep saying, it's just two different types of upright ape making an agreement and it's not written into the stone of, you know, a stone tablet, you know, that is watched upon by God Almighty.
4:46It's, yeah, and it's sort of like it is a good reminder for the counterparties as much as it is for shareholders in DJs, right? It's just sort of like this is why anything that's long dated must be, and particularly once it gets added to a balance sheet, there's something more tangible when it gets written there, that it feels like, oh, here it is as a record of truth. But it's sort of a record of intent in a lot of cases there too. And again, not to be too down or even conspiratorial on it. It is just the nature of things. Things on balance sheets get rewritten all the time. contracts get torn up all of the time.
5:25How much money has been lost on the ASX just in our time for companies that just said, oh, listen, we had this big deal and it just fell through? And it's a good – I'm kind of repeating it, flogging it a bit much for my own sake because I have made more investments than I care to admit on what management have sort of said, hey, we're doing this and this is going to happen and we've signed this. And you go, oh, it's all happening. And it's like, well, things change, right? And you always need that little allowance for that kind of possibility, particularly when it's, you know, a very concentrated part of the business and a big one.
6:03It can like, oh, the client concentration is such that one sort of misstep can really unwind things extraordinarily quickly. So, yeah, Westfield, I'm sorry. You're going to have to cop one here. Yeah, I guess I'm just reflecting on the administration as a process. Not so much that the contract was null and void, but there's this halfway house between being in business and then being able to sort of continue on. The idea of administration itself is not – it wasn't like, so we can't pay the bills, the whole thing's over. We're shutting the whole thing down. It's like, so we're going to keep doing this, but we don't have to give you that.
6:42And I mean, it's not either good nor bad. It is what it is. It's just interesting, I think, in that context of what the administration, it's like this half-pregnant purgatory kind of choose-your-own metaphor. That kind of sits in between of like, well, maybe we come back out, maybe we don't. And I've had so many conversations with people saying, oh, could DJs survive? It's like, well, it depends if you're in by DJs, which sounds like a stupid thing to say, and I'm not trying to be pedantic, but it's like, well, could there be stores branded with the Houndstooth logo in 2027? Yeah. Is it going to be DJs?
7:11I mean, for the consumer, probably not a lot of difference unless they change model meaningfully. But DJ as the company is effectively gone. There'll be some new entity that kind of takes ownership and control. The brand is clearly worth something. Right, well, not as much as it used to be. Not as much. Don't misunderstand me. I'm not saying there's not zero, I guess is what I'm saying. No, you're right. I'm not being smart. I'd buy it for a dollar, right? Oh, so here's the thing. There's a price, I mean, I guess a dollar. If it's a limited liability dollar, then absolutely I would too. Yeah, just give me the brand to trade under.
7:45I'm sure I could milk that. I'm sure I'd get a positive return on investment, even if it was$2 that was made out of it. And that's the calculus, really. It's like this is what's going to come in. I'm putting in, what will I get out? At a dollar, it's a no-brainer. At$10 billion, it's like probably not. So it's just a question of finding the right point after that. And we kind of talked a little bit very early on in the podcast about some of the kind of corporate structures and the way that we organize business in the country and in the West in general. but to your point about you'd buy it for a dollar my first thought was well there'll be a lot of debt or go broke have lots of losses the idea of a limited liability company which you would you wouldn't buy as Andrew Page you'd buy it as you know Andrew Page buying David Jones Limited and and that entity is where the and this is this is the this is the by the way back to the counterparty risk uh you know DJ shareholders are not going to get any money back but no one gets to come after them for any more money than they're put into the business already the entity is ring-fenced And so to your point, would I personally buy DJs for a dollar if I had to deal with any liabilities or losses that it may incur from here?
8:48Not a chance in the world. No, no. If I could deal with limited liability, which is just, I set up this$2 shelf company, buy it as SP DJ Co, and then if it goes broke, I've lost my dollar, but nothing more than that. But yeah, and that's your point. I think this is where the administrators are hoping to make a sale because they're saying, well, hang on, there is a brand, to your point, there probably are some profitable stores or stores that could be profitable, a whole lot that won't be, which is exactly what they're closing. And yeah, that's exactly what they're hoping, that someone will come and buy this thing and say, I'll put in my$2 or whatever the auction price ends up being or the negotiated price ends up being.
9:22So they can keep this going. And as long as there is more money to be made than not, then yeah, you're right, mate. It's entirely rational for any buyer with limited liability to pay an amount of money if they think they can get a return on that money. Now, it doesn't matter how much, if you're paying$10 or$100 or$1 ,000, at some point you say, well, I don't think I can make any money out of this. So$1 is worth a gamble. $1 ,000 is worth a gamble. Would I pay$1 ,000 for DJs? Not a chance, personally, because that's my$1 ,000 gone. If I can't make it work, do I think DJs is going to return something for a$1 ,000 bet?
9:54Personally, I mean, some listeners may. You may. I don't know. I wouldn't pay$1 ,000 for DJs because I don't think there's a positive expected value. I'm not prepared to gamble a seven-figure sum that I might be wrong. At$1 ,000, of course. At$100, sure. Oh, a thousand bucks, yeah, I'd do that too. But at some point you say, again, we talk about probabilities all the time on this podcast. That's what investing is all about. And yeah, I would absolutely at that point say maybe this is not the right, you know, way, place, time, whatever it is to make that work. Just because that's kind of the nature of the beast.
10:24Yeah, yeah. I do think it is important structure to have an administration process. It's a bit like sort of bankruptcy proceedings in the US or whatever. It is something that you really don't want it to be punitive. And the whole point of it is to give the company the best possible chance to trade its way out of its problems. And if that's not possible, then to make creditors and everyone sort of whole. So it's sort of, why is that important? It's not that we're trying, I think you can read it incorrectly. I've heard other people sort of comment it on this way. It feels like, oh, you're allowed to sort of claim this condition.
11:05It allows you to sort of, as we said before, tear up some of your contracts and change things around. You stuffed up, you should be gone. And I get that. But it's sort of like we're really trying to do here is mitigate further damage. You're trying to actually, yeah, reduce the harm. But even on a broader level, I mean, you don't want, let's go back even one more step. most is the stat that everyone knows, whatever it is, 90 % of businesses fail in the first year. You know, a very large percentage fail within 10 years, almost all of them. And it's kind of like, well, that is the nature of business.
11:40It's very experimental. You don't know, you can intuit what you think the market will want and you can reasonably plan for how you're going to deliver that. But even super smart, super fortunate, super lucky people are going to make all kinds of mistakes along the way because it's just really, really, really, really hard. But when that happens, the last thing you want to do is make it so incredibly painful that you will never, ever try again. Like you want, you want entrepreneurs and people with capital to have as many shots and goal as possible, not to get a get out of jail free card, not to be made whole when they make terrible decisions, but not to make the process so arduous and difficult that if you like, and again, statistically, you're not going to go well in the, in the first, um, uh, first instance.
12:25But if that is the case, well, we'll give you another chance here because ultimately it is creating value and jobs, taxes, and all of those kinds of good things. So as a process, a secondary point to what you're making, I think it's important that we have this. And I think it is important that we make it as not trying to shield people from consequence. In fact, you know me, I'm the opposite of that. I think consequence is super important to keep things going pretty well. But not to make it so punitive as to, you know, A, to make even trying an extremely risky proposition and to make trying, going back to the well again after an initial failure, you know, you have to be mad to do that.
13:05I think is a mistake. Yeah. And there's a long list of, you know, what's fascinating, we talked a little bit about this last week, so I won't do too much more, but there's a list in the Australian this week, Australian newspaper about, website, about the number of department stores that have gone broke overseas. And the surprise really shouldn't be that David Jones had gone broke. The surprise is really that it survived this long. You know, the department stores that have gone broke as long as it was 2000. There was an absolute huge number from 2018, 19, 20. Not just, by the way, obviously COVID related, but just around that time, there's a heap that were listed in the Oz.
13:40I can certainly bring it up quickly. But basically, the kind of the idea of, you know, DJs and Meijer, both being able to kind of make it this far, is honestly, that's the surprise. Not that it's finally gone to the wall. It's a really different story. And I think that's, we shouldn't be at all, a slave is slightly surprised. You know, it is very much just that story of, well, what else do you, you know, what else do you expect given the challenges that face it? And then, as we say, working out what then happened with the organisation, with the stores, with the staff. I mean, the bad news for the staff, 3 ,000 people probably roughly laid off as a result of the closures after Christmas.
14:20By the way, retailers are very rational, right? Sorry, retailers, consumers are very rational. Apparently, it starts booming at the moment because DJ's cutting or the administrator's cutting costs, trying to clear as much stock as possible and recognise as much value for their creditors, which is their job. And so it's very much a case of, you know, it'll look like if and when you see it reported, when the numbers come out, oh, DJ's having a great month. Things are good. Yeah, it's like, well, yeah, if you want to be a discount department store. But here's the other challenge. What damage do they do in the meantime to the brand?
14:48What is the DJ's brand? If you're cutting everything to sell a whole lot of stock and then someone wants to buy it and reposition it as a high-end retailer again, that's an interesting kind of challenge to undertake. So, yeah. And it might boost sales but not do much for profit too. Exactly, exactly. And again, think about the administrator's job, right? They are literally now appointed on behalf of the lenders to maximise any possible value they can get from this thing, including, hopefully, keeping it alive long enough to make a sale because if they can, the lenders might get some money back.
15:18So this is, you know, we're talking about, you know, what's in the interest of shareholders, what's in the interest of long-term investors versus other things. The administrator's got a very, very, very clear job. They are not there in the slightest to maximize long-term value. They are there to try and get as much cash out of this thing for the lenders. And that's a very short-term story. That is, you know, they'll shut it down if they can't because they'll stop losing money if they can actually turn a profit and keep it going enough to make a sale, they'll make a judgment call as to how long they want to keep it going before they have to close it.
15:48Barbecues galore went through that. I think they kind of left the shell going for a couple of months while they tried to find a buyer and then eventually just said, it's not going to come to anything. We're shutting this thing down. And that may still be David Jones' future. I don't know. I mean, in theory, anyone who's paying any price to buy this thing is worth selling it to. So I suspect if there are genuinely interested parties, and they can't say they don't know about the challenges of department stores, I guess that's kind of what's happening right I don't know what else we could or should expect the um I don't know what we could should expect the the the business to do the administrators probably make a sale I guess I it's going to be a question of you say mate of how much is someone prepared to bid or offer now we say a dollar you pay a dollar I pay a dollar if you're a corporate entity you're not going to do that because you don't want all the hassle if you don't think you you can actually turn a buck.
16:37So you're going to say, well, I've got a return expectation. I'm not going to buy 19 department stores and try and run them for$4 ,000 a year profit. You would, I would, but they're like, it's just not worth our while. We want to believe there is a long-term story here. Anyone who buys it probably wants to list it again at some point to get their money back. So just because it might be worth a dollar doesn't mean anyone will pay a dollar for it necessarily. But that's going to be the interesting conversation of, you know, will someone pay enough to make it worth their while, make it worth the administrator's while and the lender's while?
17:09Otherwise, this one goes the way out of the dodo. And to your point, there's another 19 stores that, your counterparty risk color, we're here again. The landlords then have to wear some of that cost. Yeah, man. Yeah, it's sad. It really is. I don't mean to be too gloob about it at all. You know, so there's one thing to sort of opine from an economic macro standpoint. A lot of people are going to lose their jobs. It's an individual tragedy and, you know, my heart goes out for them. I said to you off air, I just feel as though, not to pivot into this topic, but I just feel as though, get used to it.
17:45There's going to be a lot of job cuts coming down the pipeline, I feel. Yeah, interesting times. Yeah. We might touched on this a little bit last week, but I'll make a statement that I don't expect you to disagree with. But I would be really worried if I own shares in a large shopping centre, real estate investment trust, listed property trust right now. I don't know they can. We talked about last week, but maybe it becomes housing or something else at some point. The land has value. The buildings have value. But value isn't the same as the current value or the current expected value. I don't actually even mean just because of DJs.
18:24I'm on record, mate, as saying I think this is not the last time we talk about retail store closures. I think – and we talked again, I think it was last week. We've certainly done in the past. about how marginal every individual store is for every retailer. You know, you don't have to lose 50 % of your sales before you go broke in retail. You lose 5 % or 10 % of your sales. I would suspect, mate, I'm going to make up a stupid number. I'm going to say half of all retail stores, if they lost 10 % of their sales permanently, would be unprofitable. Is that an unreasonable statement to make? Yeah, 100%.
18:52Oh, it might maybe even less for a lot. Like it's, yeah, very thin margins. And, you know, it doesn't take a high fixed cost in a lot of cases and thin margin. It's actually a wonderful combination when things are going well, because you really get that operational leverage sort of kicking in where like 10 % sales can do 20 % profit growth and sort of hard to do the maths verbally. But, you know, but yeah, that's a double-edged sword and that can very much work against you. So, yep, it's, yeah, man, I don't know. I generally, I learned the hard way of being very cautious towards retail. And then as a general, before all of this kind of stuff, right?
19:39And then every now and again, I get drawn back in by these, what seem ostensibly like obscenely low multiples. You go, yeah, it's got all the troubles, but look how cheap it is. It's like Warren Buffett sort of wondering about airline stocks. He's like, I know I shouldn't, but, you know.
19:58but there's not only those normal challenges that you talk about where you're not you're a bad quarter or two away from sort of like copying some losses but there's also this massive disruption that's coming down the pipe as well so gosh I wish them well I don't think I don't think physical retail is dead by the way I don't let's not get hyperbolic and silly about this that there there is something uh social if anything else this like the actual act of foraging and and shopping and being around other people i think it will be fine but i just think it's going into some pretty stiff headwinds and in ways that are difficult to sort of imagine and yeah it's just like i need some really low multiples and then i probably i could probably admitting on air like in another year's time it's like well like if it was like a p of three Like, how could I go wrong?
20:45And I was like, well, this is how. Do you have any retailers yourself? Yeah, retail shares. So Amazon and Kogan, I own. Of course, yeah, yeah. I own shares and retail. Amazon's a bit different though. Correct. And this is where it matters, right? Because we haven't used the phrase, the word omni-channel much in recent. It was bricks and mortar, it was clicks and mortar. And it should be both. It's omni-channel, all the channels. and so but that's and you're right about you're right about Amazon obviously pure online but yeah I actually I really like I like consumer facing companies with their brands or retailers where I think the businesses themselves have some sort of future so I own ARB which is not exactly a retailer but is you know has retail stores I could see that I own Shares and Domino's Harvey Norman yeah and then Treasury which is again consumer focused so yeah And it's kind of a – for me, mate, it's really a question of can they make the transition or are they making the transition?
21:48Is it working? And I think – remember Mosaic brands way back in there, Katie's and whatever? They went broke effectively after COVID because they had no online presence to speak of it. And I think they probably had taken the gamble that their clientele didn't want to buy online, which is fine until, you know, everything got shut down. They had no online presence. But even that, I think, was nice. We've laughed about Jerry Harvey once saying, you know, people never buy stuff online. you have a sofa's and beds online, now everyone's buying sofa's and beds online. That for me is the deal breaker right there.
22:14As an attitudinal position, it's kind of like, I just can't touch this thing. And I've said before, I think JB Hi-Fi will have fewer stores in 20 years' time than it does today. Maybe, frankly, probably a lot sooner. But for those reasons we just talked about with store economics, at some point, if JB's, what, 20 % of their sales online, 30%, 40%, 50%, I don't know where that tops out. But at some point, the person who would have gone to the local JB store buys it online. And at that point, the store owners go, turns out we can't make that marginal group of stores. They pay their way now, so of course we'll keep them.
22:48And obviously, I think we've seen this before as well. Premier Investment, Solomon Liu, billionaire rag trader, the man for whom the sobriquet was named.
22:59He's done this forever. He's closed stores very proactively where he didn't like the rentals being charged based on the return the store would get. And so he had done, and he's still in Maya, funnily enough, just competing in the loop, but Just Jeans, JJ's. He still owns Smigel and Peter Alexander, a couple of other brands in that retail group as well. But they, yeah, he would just close stores and move them. It's not making sense, they will move it. And most retail organisations want more stores. No one wants to put a press release out without no one. The usual suspects say, we're shrinking our store network.
23:31I mean, imagine what happens at the share price when a JB Hi-Fi or a Harvey Norman, again, which I own, or someone else says, We're shrinking the store network. It's not profitable. We're going to fewer stores. The market would lose its mind. Growth is over. It's so dumb. It's so dumb, mate. Right? Right. I won't name it. It's too small and liquid. But you're reminding me of a company where they made some hard decisions closing a bunch of stuff. And revenue fell because there was just less stores. But profit rose. Because you're getting rid of all the loss-making stores, right? Like it's obvious when you think about it.
24:00And it's just like you're so right that it's unusual. But it shouldn't be. It's just rational. It's like we don't need to get overly emotive or emotional about any of this kind of stuff. It's just as an allocator of capital, I want to be putting my capital where it's getting a positive return. If it's not getting a positive rate of return or even an adequate one above what a risk free rate might be, I should sell that. It's unarguable. I don't know how anyone else arrives at any other different position other than perhaps it's like it's temporary and we can trade our way out of it. But it's just, yes.
24:35And it's sort of, Munger talks a lot about that idea of just like not doing anything that special, just doing the obvious thing that everyone else refuses to do. And I think that's a big part of Solilu's success. It's just sort of, I don't know, it feels like I'm downplaying what is savvy here. But when you unpack it and you say it out loud, it's just like, yeah, just not pursuing, not continuing with uneconomic or marginal stores. It's not the ground-shaking epiphany you might otherwise think it would be. And yet they don't do it. And I think this is, so yeah, I, we'll have more people in the country.
25:13We'll spend more money. What kept DJs afloat was that, I spoke to another podcast, actually the Bonafide podcast with Luke Boner, who used to be on Triple M Overnights, and with Shane Oliver, only literally this morning, about 7.30 this morning before we came and did this one. And Shane was saying, only to give him credit for his number. He said, and I don't remember how long ago it was, but departments were something like 8 % of retail, Australian retail, X years ago, now they're at 5%. And that's the other thing. Departments didn't go to zero. It just becomes unprofitable. And things become unprofitable, as we said before, way before people actually stop spending there altogether.
25:47together it's just a question of does that can the model itself survive and that's where you know again at a total retail level i don't know how big online retail gets the share of total retail i suspect over two-thirds would be my my my outlandish guess but at that point yes the economy would be yes there'll be more people yes retail sales will go up but what really killed djs at the end wasn't even that sales were falling massively they might have been relatively flat i think for a while it's just the cost kept creeping up and the sales didn't grow and so You had this really, you know, the vice got tighter and tighter because you've got to be able to at least grow your sales at the rate of cost growth just to stand still.
26:23And so at a store level for some of these other guys, I'm not even saying, JV Hi5 may never have a store that sells less than it does today. But they saw my shutter at some point if that sales growth at a store level isn't enough to keep up with the cost growth at a store level. I don't mean that even in a current inflation environment. 4.3%, yes, it's very high. If it was two, if it was three, two and a half, one and a half, at some point you just simply have a case of sales going elsewhere not growing as quickly at a store level cost cost go up why because wages go up and electricity goes up and insurance goes up and rates go up and rent goes up and all those things frankly the interesting thing will be where that where the um pain falls between the retailers and the shopping centers i think that's the fascinating one right because they're just talking about rent rising it may well be that in light of this there are some retailers that can negotiate actually lower rent oh hell yeah moving forward because they're so desperate to keep them.
27:15And so you end up, maybe I'm wrong about JB Hi-Fi because the loser ends up being the landlord, not the retailer. And maybe that's how this plays out. But the reality is the value of a retail space, I don't just with the property, but the combination of the value itself, whether it's the rent, the ownership, the whatever, that I think is the key difference. I think for so long the landlord was the better play because there was always, there was a supply demand imbalance, so to speak. There was just less supply of good quality retail, you know, within a nice air conditioned shopping center kind of space relative to the number of retailers that would like to be in that space.
27:55And whenever that imbalance exists, you can charge a good rate for it. But you're right. Theoretically, it's very obvious. There is a point where it's kind of like actually no one's interested at these rents. And that's what prices will adjust. as they always do in relation to that. And it is something that might not manifest until, you know, it's like gradually then suddenly kind of thing. It's like, no, there's always someone. Oh, DJ's gone. That's cool. We've still got 10 other people out the door here. But then when that goes, it's sort of like what else do you have except the ability to lower rents?
28:31Because it becomes a choice of, well, I mean, anything's better than zero. An empty store is not paying you a cent, right? And it's a liability. So it's sort of like, yeah, it's just a, it's a thing we always talk about when we talk about retail is like the skill ultimately, I think if I could distill it down is, is, is the ability to distinguish cyclicality from, from structural issues. And yes, yes. And you have to, because it is just such a cyclical industry. So when you see a few quarters of, you know, pretty meh results, it's like that actually happens for the best retailers that have got the brightest futures.
29:08because the economy's in a recession, everyone's in a funk. It's got nothing really to do with the long-term earnings capacity of the business. And then there are businesses that are just like on their way to irrelevance, but they both present the same kind of patterns and numbers, you know, in that point in time. So it's kind of like, that's why I said it's all, that is the skill, right, if you could sort of tease the two apart. I just worry, and this is just me, you know, navel-gazing. I've got no particularly great crystal ball, but it feels as though it feels like there's very much a structural tinge to what's going on here rather than just like, ah, some management to drop the ball and the rest of it.
29:52And beyond even just DJs, like brick and mortar retail. And not necessarily – markets love to sort of go from one thing to the next and, you know, this quarter it's this. This has been playing out for like a decade or well over a decade, in fact. but it is that potentially that there's a hole in the hull of the boat. It's not a big one necessarily, but water's coming in, you know, and you've really got to double check your numbers, cross your T's, dot your I's to wade into this space and have a pretty firm view of things because the difference, I guess, back to the point, with cyclicality, like by definition, you'll come out the other side and things will be great again.
30:30With structural decline, it's like it's a one-way kind of train. So it'll be interesting. It'll be super interesting. It's worth saying too, you know what really got up my nose was the usual suspects, right? So DJ's goes broken. I got this phalanx of bloody tweets. Oh, bloody elbows. Government destroyed another retailer. Couldn't survive. I survived 188 years. Couldn't survive a Labor government. And it's just such complete and total nonsense, right? Like I got my issues with the government. We've talked about those a lot. And we've talked a lot about having a team, right? I don't have a team.
31:00I like just stop. but yeah the whole oh Labor's fault and by the way would David's survive another year or two if inflation had been a bit lower maybe yeah I mean timing possibly sure but when it's like you know was the policy of the current government that caused it no of course it wasn't this is a as I said the only surprises that survive this long frankly let alone you know in some degree of health it was sold a couple of times over the last couple of decades but yeah it's just the idea that somehow this is government related to your point cyclical versus structural yes bad businesses do go broke when there's cyclical downturns because they just don't have the wherewithal to make it.
31:35So yes, the final nail on the coffin is almost always an economic downturn because when things are going really well, even bad businesses survive because there's so much money being thrown around. You can run a business badly and kind of go, you still want my stuff? Okay, okay, sure. It's like, yes, pay for it and I'll charge you a higher price for it because you're feeling pretty good and the world's happy and everything's good. And yeah, when people start to say, maybe I might ration my spending, of course then they say, oh, the extra money I was spending at DJs, I'm not going to do that anymore.
32:00So, yes, it's almost always the final nail in the coffin is almost also never the cause. Yeah. Interesting. Very interesting. Tis, tis. Hey, let's – speaking of interesting, have you been following the NVIDIA palaver in the US with Jensen Huang and – Well, I woke up to it yesterday, our time, and it was like, oh, God, what now type thing. And, I mean, you can see – the headlines write themselves. Not only is it one or, I was going to say, the or one of the most important businesses on the planet. One of the most valuable. It's got, so it's got that dimension to it. It's got the geopolitical dimension to it.
32:42It's got the salacious sort of affair dimension to it. It's got the spy and the espionage dimension. It's like, it is perfect. And then you kind of, as an investor, you're going, oh my God, what, okay, what's the so what here? And a genuine question, and not a leading question, I kind of got to the point, I was like, I don't get all the, I get it from a, what's the word I'm looking for? A tabloid kind of standpoint? Yeah, exactly. I don't get it from a, what does it mean for NVIDIA? Genuine question. I mean, if you were to play devil's advocate, how would you answer that? Well, so here's, just to flesh it out a little bit more.
33:21So Jess is doing married, which makes a nice cyber pro. it's an affair, it's always good press. Potentially, allegedly, the woman has been linked with the allegations of being a Chinese spy. So there's a national security issue. Now again, allegations from here to daybreak, so just be a little bit careful. World's most, one of the world's most valuable companies, the company that is literally powering... Valuable and strategically important too. It needs to be added. Powering most of the internet, the AR revolution, right? Most of the chips being used are Nvidia chips. This guy's built, he's a co-founder, built the company for decades.
34:01So you're kind of thrilled. I mean, it's a great soap opera story. It's a great tabloid story. I've made the joke before, mate, that we all pretend we read the AFR for the editorials and we all really just click on the, you know, Andrew Forrest. I buy the Playboy for the articles, my friend. It's purely for the articles. It's exactly what it is. And so, you know, that's the, so it's all, it's all, it's all pretty tense. We all pretend we're responsible, serious people and we click on the Britney Spears stories and the SMH or the, you know, I tweet regularly about the SMH. It's got a private school story every second day.
34:28Why? Whatever gets clicks. And people say, oh, yeah, journalism, this, and they're not wrong. But it's like they're just very rational business people, right? They could write some really long 15 ,000-word investigative journalist piece on something we've never heard of. Or they could just have a photo of some sandstone private school and say X thousand dollars spent on insert product here or trip here at Sydney private school, and they know the clicks should be through the absolute roof. So, I mean, that's what they do. But yeah, so what is interesting, mate, the so what is we don't know, I suppose, at this point.
34:59I mean, it's possible that the lady is involved with the Chinese government in some sort of nefarious way. It's possible that in the affair she was able to access or was privy to information that otherwise might be considered commercially sensitive, maybe even sensitive from a strategic perspective. What conversations did Jensen Huang have with US government, given the strategic importance, as you say, mate? I don't know these things. And so there were, frankly, allegations, claims, speculation on social media, for example, that he may well have actually broken some laws. So the so what may well be in one version of the future.
35:41Now, by the way, Donald Trump's been out and defended Jensen Huang and said, oh, he's a good guy. Whatever weight that carries. Of all the people to sort of like give you a character on that account, you know. Please don't, please don't, Donald, please don't. Moral bastion. Except that we know that Trump is effectively influencing the DOJ because it's a government instrumentality. And so realistically, you know, if he has been alleged to have at least been worthy of investigation, will the DOJ investigate him? I don't know. Will they investigate the circumstances? I don't know. So the so what could, I mean, if you're an Nvidia shareholder, this is a$5 trillion company.
36:18And there's no apparent, there's no heir apparent, seemingly inside the company. So if you own the shares, if you think about the role of NVIDIA in the technological arms race that's going on now around AI, not only between the companies we know and use, the SpaceX's, the Anthropics, the open AIs, but the Chinese ones as well, others around the rest of the world. There is a lot of pieces moving here, and I wouldn't be at all surprised if, despite Trump's personal preferences, whether the government would actually run a cover for Jensen Huang just because they need this to work for their purposes.
36:53and you know it's the old line if you owe the banker you know ten thousand dollars you're in trouble if you owe him ten million dollars they're in trouble um you know it may well be that quang is more more valuable to the u.s government than not and at that point and again because the rule of law doesn't always follow um from top to bottom in the u.s when when executive power is involved i wouldn't be at all surprised if again it may be he's completely innocent maybe there's nothing going maybe she's not even trying to spy um there is there is a chance too that people you know we we there's a little bit of kind of blatant casual racism in some of this stuff She's a Chinese lady.
37:23She's had ties with the Chinese government before. Oh, maybe she's a spy. Maybe she is, but maybe she's not. And so it's really impossible to know, mate. But in a worst case scenario, Huang is taken away from the company. And we have to find out, if you're a shareholder, you have to find out as a shareholder, what's left? Who runs the business? What does it do? How important is he to the company? We've had the same things with it, not the same allegations, to be really, really clear. Richard White at WiseTech in Australia. Effectively, he was kind of booted out. And then the major shareholders went, No, I'll have him back, thank you.
37:53And we get rid of the directors that booted him out. Why? Because they decided he was worth more to the company there than not. Despite the bad news, despite the bad press, despite whatever may or may not have happened. So, yeah, there's lots of moving parts. You've got to separate two things too, don't you? It's sort of, it can be seen as abhorrent behavior. I want to justify it for a second, right? But it's also, what's the job there? I mean, Jensen, I mean, he built an incredible business. He went in directions that were seen as crazy at the time and just created immense value and built a literal platform for all of this other value to be created on top.
38:32It's sort of like, do you want to tut-tut some unsavory personal behavior at the expense of taking away such a wonderful capital allocation? Not to justify their actions or condone their actions. Like, I just think we all have trouble keeping two things in our heads at once. Someone could be an absolute piece of work, you know, but also very vitally important at the role that they do. And I suspect you make the case, you lay out what happened with WiseTech. Look, it depends on what the exact details of the story are and how they evolved. But I would suspect the market would see it as a negative if Jensen was gone.
39:12You'd have to, right? And from the outside, you're forced to speculate. So it's entirely possible this thing could be run by a ham sandwich. Or it's entirely possible that without Jensen Huang, it's worth a quarter of its value. And the reality is probably somewhere in between. The other thing that I, with the spy and the espionage kind of stuff, just to be, let's just be adults here for a second. Like, was anyone thinking prior to today that there wasn't, even if it was just not statecraft, but, or not statecraft, I'm not, you know, state-based espionage, just corporate espionage. Like, do you not think that there's people with ties back to Google that are on the inside or, you know, that there's a million hackers on the outside trying to get into this?
39:53Or that when a chip comes out, that that isn't going straight to a lab for reverse engineering. And, you know, like this has been the story of business forever is trying to steal corporate secrets. And whenever there is a geopolitical strategic dimension to it, there have absolutely been three-letter agencies in there getting what they can. Knowledge is power. It's a hackneyed term. I get it. And again, I'm not saying, don't worry about it. It's all good. This happens all the time. Let's just acknowledge the fact that one of the most valuable company on the planet with such strategic significance, there's probably about 400 different spies infiltrating Like right from like the janitor right up to, you know, someone working in the CFO's office.
40:42I just, I think it's not that you can say, oh, it's definitely happening, but I think there's a lot of things where you just assume that it is for no other reason than just to make sure that you're aware of what ramifications that there are. And it's just sort of like Jensen's infidelity is sort of like, you know it's like i was like oh prior to today i just thought that this was locked down tight and there was just these magic black boxes that they shipped and that no other engineer or computer scientists in the planet had any clue as to what they were doing and i i i don't know and i i i would i would and that's why to me it was a little bit of so what so i i i agree with your with your your take on it that that is what the market is obviously thinking is jensen gone What are the other sort of competitive strategic ramifications?
41:34I just would have thought that, really, no one was factoring this in as an already inevitable kind of situation. Or am I being too conspiratorial to think that that goes on? I mean, it obviously goes on. Espionage and counterespionage is as old as nation states, right? Half the people who work at Pepsi are being paid by Coke, right, and vice versa. I'm sure there's some truth to that. Yeah, and I think that's, you know, and there's, yeah, those companies have been found guilty of spying on each other and going through each other's garbage. Oh, that's a story as old as time. But so it's both. I think it's both obviously going to happen, but also I think it's reasonable to say if and when it does happen or if you can find a case of happening, you should stop it happening.
42:18So there's both of those things happening at the same time. But you're right, this is not all of a sudden the only possible area where there might be an issue. I think it's notable that it may well be at the CEO level. It's not just someone in the coffee room or, you know, looking through shredded memos from a branch office. It's kind of like, you know, you're in the bedroom quite literally, allegedly, with the CEO overhearing phone calls and whatever else is going on. So there's different levels of it, but you're right. It's not – we shouldn't pretend to say it's never happened before. Oh, my goodness.
42:46You know, do companies really do this? Do the governments really do this? Yes, all the time they do. And people leave one time to go to the other. Well, as you know, I'm sure when any of these execs travel, the security team is doing a sweep of bugs in any room and stuff that they go into. And, you know, I read a bunch of Frederick Forsyth books back in the day. I don't have books. This was back before the tech was that good. Like, what are the bugs that you aren't finding? And, you know, it's just I just take it as read when it comes to frontier technology that there are all kinds of flies on the wall that are there.
43:23And you're right, absolutely, we do something about it, but I just, it's not something, well, I just, maybe it's a nice reminder, not that people dismissed it but just didn't think about it, but it's a good reminder to think that this stuff kind of is just a reality of the situation. And even without that kind of stuff, even without sort of illegality that is there, things do just get released and copied and, you know, It's really just sort of legal protections that try to sort of protect against that stuff. But that's already been a big bone of contention between the US and China with, you know, you're ripping off all our technology.
43:59It's like, hey, there's a piece of paper here that says you can't do that. Is there now? Okay. We won't do it. Hey, you're still doing it. No, we're not. Oh, yes, we are. Okay, we'll stop doing it. Just take it as read, right? And so I actually, I made the point, and this floored me a little bit. And again, I'm not trying to make the case here for any particular stock. But the forward PE of NVIDIA is 13. That's a one and a three for a company that's growing at the rate it's got. Now, zero is at 50. And I just quietly, or not so quietly because I'm on a podcast. I mean, I regard that in most SaaS businesses as just the walking dead at this point in time.
44:43Like they just borrowed time. I will fight they're in for the fight of their life let's put that out there and I don't think even that that hot a take my point is even in spite of that it's trading at a multiple that you know is full can I use that that adjective a fool uh and then and then you've got this one with all kinds despite whatever secrets may have been leaked with like just such incredibly deep integrations amongst this rapidly expanding industry on a PE that's lower than Harvey Norman. Now, it's a forward PE. It's a forward PE. So it's based on a forecast of earnings and maybe those earnings don't materialise.
45:25But even on a trailing basis, it's in the 20s. It's just, it's interesting is all I'm saying. And there is something to be said for, So, and again, I haven't done the work, but just from a procedural perspective for an investor, this is why it's so valuable to have done work on a company previously. We've spoken before, you can spend a lot of time researching a company and get to the end and go, I don't know if I had the conviction or I don't think it's cheap enough or anything, and I walk away. And it feels like time is wasted having all this work. I didn't even end up buying it. But it's like, these are the kind of opportunities that when you do have a, potentially I should say, when you do have a form, a well-formed view of the business, you can very quickly contextualize new events as it comes.
46:19So like, while most of the world is trying in real time to figure out, what does this mean? What does this mean? These are great questions. If you've actually know the business rather well, you go, well, actually, what does it mean? Does this change this, this, this, and this? I don't know. I certainly don't see it as existential. And I'm looking at a stock that was, you know, what is it? US dollars,$240 a few months ago. And now it's$170. You know, it's sort of like, it's a big change. And it's, what's my point? My point is, I guess, are you not entertained, dear investor? Is this not what you are here for?
46:57the the the the you whenever i go to the shops i want to buy something that's on sale and when market is the only place where things get cheaper and people are less likely to buy and things get more expensive and you're more likely to buy it doesn't happen for socks and undies or tvs or ipads but it happens with stocks yeah and and again it feels like i'm very sort of like unsubly sort of like it's a bargain you should buy nvidia i'm not and i'm not doing it myself actually tell a lie I bought some on straw man with play money. I don't, I don't have any in, in real life, but you know, it's, it is, it is the kind of thing that I think at the very least should cause you to sharpen your pencils because if you were, and how many people have been sitting on the sidelines for this for forever going, Oh man, I wish, I wish, I wish.
47:43I was like, well, I missed it. I missed it. Yeah. Yeah. Here are the chance. Let's not, let's not forget. You can go back to 2024. It went from 140, $40 ,000, almost$150 ,000 to under$100 ,000 had a 30 % drop over the course of about six months. And imagine if you had the chance to buy, even after all of this, you're still in the, you know, it's sort of like, fortune favours the bold when it comes to investing. Not the foolhardy, not the arrogant, not the wishful thinking, but, you know. Misery favours the bold too if you get it wrong. Yeah, it's got to be a boldness that is supported by rationality and reason and good judgment.
48:21But you must have that, though. You must have that. And, yeah, I think it's interesting. So a couple of things in the video, I think this is where it's really – we've talked about this a little bit about Richard White and others, but actually where you were speaking about it, an email just popped up on my screen. The Economist is running an article titled Jensen Huang Must Resign. And I think – because there's the what's in it for investors. Sorry, for the government and strategic and other things. There is a genuine question about, you know, what does it say about the judgment of a leader in that context?
48:53Don't know. Again, no allegations from me. Don't know. But to what, you know, don't worry about the government thing. Well, he may worry about this criminal. What's his kind of... Let's say some of the stuff, some of the tech, some of the ideas, some of the plans, some of the whatever IP that NVIDIA is working on does make its way through someone nefarious to another party, in this case it may be the Chinese government, but, you know, in that circumstance, how much damage has he potentially done to NVIDIA? And I'm not saying he had done any at all. Maybe it's none. Maybe it's not none, right? And there is something about that idea of in some world where that fall is maybe justified, in which case, you know, how much damage do you need to do?
49:37Now, we say all the time, and I've said regularly, I'm not open and shut on this one. I don't believe in public executions or, you know, Buck having to stop heads must roll. It's just vengeance crap from our deep evolutionary past. The question is just simply, is he the right guy to keep leaving the company from here? Because what's gone is gone. And the only question is, who do you want? If you're an Nvidia shareholder, who are you entrusting your money to? Now, if you don't like this, you say, he's shown bad judgment. He's possibly hurt the business. He might go to jail. He might be charged.
50:05He might be distracted. That's all bad. Unquestionably, those things are possible. On the other hand, you say, I've got the Nvidia shares. No, I sell them, of course, but I've got Nvidia shares. Do I think him being there is worth more than him not being there? And that's the Richard White conversation. So as an investor, again, to your point, mate, about thinking about the probabilities, thinking about the pricing, about what you're buying, if Jason Huang was to leave, is that good or bad? And you can make a very clear and definitive case for either outcome. And here's the other thing, and we've said this before at Richard White, and again, we're going over all ground a little bit.
50:36but think about what matters to you as an investor versus your moral ethical uh i'm not saying i'm saying your moral ethics at the door necessarily i'm just saying if your reaction is he's done a bad thing he should pay okay that's fine as an investor who you want running the company and and they can those two things can be the same at the same time you can say he's a bad person he's done a bad thing all the all the bits and pieces that's all bad um and he's also still the best person to run the company now if that feels like cognitive dissonance then that's what you got to work through because they can both be true at the same time and this is where it's really important and you can have an ethical view you can have a legal view and again if he's broken laws and he should be prosecuted he's found guilty you should you know go to jail if that's what if that's what comes of it but in the meantime as an investor your job is simply to probabilistically allocate capital and so do i want to invest in a jensen huang run nvidia before during and after these investigations or do i not do i want him there or do i not and i don't i don't know the guy well enough i will say in your valuation mate i it looks cheap the the thing i keep coming back to is their gross margins are 75 yeah they are they are making i won't say replicable chips because nvidia has its own ip and so it's not like no one sells anything for four times what it costs to make right software companies do but they don't actually really make a thing they just release some code that's why their margins are so high these guys have incredibly expensive equipment I assume it's billions of dollars worth of gear, but I could be wrong.
52:04And they are churning out chips and selling for four times the price. Now, why? Firstly, the IP is better than anyone else's because people want the Nvidia chips rather than other ones and that may or may not be true forever. There is a shortage. They're selling absolutely every chip they can possibly make right now. So you get to charge those prices. So maybe that goes on forever. But in a world, and I don't know, we say this is not your line, but I'll go with it. In a world where, let's say in a year's time, there's a chip out there which is a third of the price but only half as good. you're going to buy it yeah if there's if there's someone who catches up they're 90 is good and 90 and 80 of the price you're going to buy it um maybe they're better maybe the next generation of chips from someone else about the llm race right the next chip might from intel or from amd might be even better again and then if it is like no one wants to buy your video chips and i'm just buying those ones i'm not saying that'll happen either i just i think i only to put the counterpoint man the reason i haven't bought in video shares despite the price fall to your to or point before, I haven't done it in play money or real money, is I just don't know.
52:58Now, I'm very aware it could be a NextDC type situation, not the more recent issues they're having, but I was wrong on NextDC for years because I kind of went, this is a glorified REIT. We talked about REITs before. It's a glorified warehouse and trading on stupid multiples on some future. Now, I was wrong, either in air quotes or not, for years because demand continued to outstrip supply. And for NVIDIA, given the growth of AI, I wouldn't bet against that. I mean, if everyone's buying as many chips as they can get, presumably if you increase the number of chips, more people are going to keep buying them until you hit some sort of market saturation.
53:31And there's no shortage of new data centers being created. They're all going to need new chips. And at some point, the old data centers are going to replace theirs. And so I'm far from sure this is not dirt cheap. But I also wouldn't be surprised if there's not a world where the shares are trading at half the price in X years' time. And that's still fair value because margins normalized, stabilized, demand stabilized, competitors caught up? Again, I don't know. But that's why I haven't personally bought in media yet. Well, exactly. And that's exactly the thing to work out, you know. This is always the way.
54:05Regardless of what the details are, it's like a stock that has a big fall, something has happened that is not good. You know, the market's not that dumb. Like it's not. It's a little too, what's the word for it? you know, smug when people are the market, everything it does is silly until after I buy and then it's perfectly rational, you know, or it's just, it's, it's all to get a bargain. You've got to have a few hairs on it, right? It's just, you don't get a company that is flying on every front with, which is just got the wonderful brand and public license to operate. And just everyone thinks it's fantastic and it's cheap.
54:47Those, Those things just don't exist, you know. And so you need to have a adult kind of viewpoint towards these things. I know, we both know investors, dude, who are just so morally high and mighty that, you know, there is nothing that meets their bar of, what's the word for it? Like, you know, that they consider all the team good for the world and what the business is doing. And if they do, it's only because you don't know the business well enough because the business is full of human beings and human beings are very, very flawed creatures, as we all kind of are. You know, it's you need to. It always feels like I'm rationalizing and justifying bad corporate or individual behavior, and I'm not.
55:36I'm just trying to make out the point that as an investor, perfect is very much the enemy of the good. And I shall only invest in companies that have no negative characteristics whatsoever. It's like, okay, fine. I don't fade the idea, except that it's just like you will probably have a portfolio of one or two stocks. And it's not practical. Like you must, they say politics is the art of compromise. I would say investing is the art of compromise too. It's like every single stock, every investment, full stop that I own, I can point to things that aren't perfect and I don't like about it. And if I can't, and then I'm just kidding, it's only because I haven't found them yet, right?
56:19So you need to have these kind of, these two things in your head at once where it's like acknowledging things that are objectively negative and not great, but while still making the calculus that, Well, actually, on balance, when everything is considered, there is still a case to own. Yeah, that's right. And I wish it wasn't that way. I wish it wasn't that way, but it just is. It just is, right? You need to have a different view to the market. And so your point about the hares thing is largely that the market is not stupid. Now, you can find a business that will grow faster than the market, so it doesn't always have to have hares.
56:58It can just be, well, I guess the hair would be overvaluation or perceived overvaluation using traditional valuation metrics. You know, Amazon was stupidly expensive 100 times earnings in 1995. Guess what? You know, I own shares as everyone knows. You know, so that's the hair on that one. You know, or it could be a turnaround that's not going to turn. It can be cyclical or structural problems with the markets overweighting things. Often it's just short-term versus long-term in my experience. It's the, you know, why do I own some of those retailers? I bought a decent number of the most of them when there were short-term troubles because I kind of went, the market's saying the next six months are going to be tough.
57:30You're talking about cyclical versus structural again. I was like, yeah, it's going to be tough, sure. And the market's saying it's going to be tough in the next six months, therefore I'm out. And I'm like, well, I think it's going to be tough in the next six months, but in five years' time I'm going to be glad I paid this price. That won't always be right. Sometimes they will be structural rather than cyclical. Sometimes it'll be both. You can have a cyclical decline, cyclical moves inside a structural decline or even a structural decline, just a structural reset, if you like, just a change to behaviour.
57:58That's been DJs. AMP, another great example, right? There are businesses that have had better and worse years but are structurally either growing or declining because that's just the nature of the beast. As we started by saying, we kind of end up back in the same place, which is the job for the NVIDIA potential investor, actual investor, is to look at that and go, what do we think? What does that look like? And the other thing too, mate, we talk about this a bit too, but the portfolio level stuff is worth doing as well because you don't need to. In fact, I would argue you shouldn't allow other people to do things differently.
58:29I'm not looking for lots. I'm not – well, if I could, I would. If I could fill my portfolio with all 90 % probability companies, of course I would. I'm not stupid. Why would you not? But we're playing a – we're professional gamblers. This is going to sound weird, but we're working with you. Bet on horse races. They bet on almost every horse in the race. Yeah. Why? Because they're trying to play the probabilities. The favorite's got a two-in-one chance of winning. The second favorite's got a three-in-one chance. So you're – okay, I'll size my bets accordingly. They're not trying to pick the winner of any race.
58:57They're trying to make a 10 % return on every race, right, which is a really different thing. They know - You're exploiting mispricings. You're trying to find mispricings and then exploit them. That's exactly what you're doing. In their world, they know the vast bulk of their bets will lose. By definition, if you bet on every horse in an eight-horse race and you're trying to pick a winner, you're going to be wrong seven out of eight times, but you put that money down because overall you expect it to all work. Now, I'm not saying as an investor in shares you go for one out of eight. I mean, you can if you want.
59:22That's what VCs do, venture capital firms. but the idea is not even so much to say I am so sure about NVIDIA, I'm going to buy it but rather if I've applied my process well across my entire portfolio on average I think I will beat the market knowing that I'll be dead wrong on some that some will be mediocre and some hopefully be very good and that's all open question I don't know the answer to that we can't know the answer to that in advance but it's worth thinking about the sort of investor you are as well as the way you pick your individual companies because the portfolio context really matters.
59:54Oh, I'll go further. I 100 % agree. And I'll go even further. If you look back over time and, you know, you don't have at least a 30 % failure rate on your stock picks, you're not taking enough risk. There is a world of difference between individual stock, the risk associated with individual stocks and portfolio risk. Entirely different, you know. Here's the other thing. If you have, let's say you do find enough stocks that you have 90 % confidence sort of in and that will, you know, more often than not make money and not lose money. You somehow build that portfolio. I reckon that, again, because the world, the life investing is a game of compromise and trade-offs.
1:00:41The trade-off in that particular approach is that you'll get very ordinary returns. even though you're right most of the time because the things that are that low risk and so obviously so are priced in in a manner that just kind of removes the upside potential but the the king makers are the stocks that no one understands no one understand as understood amazon 20 years ago that's why it was a screaming bargain right no one understood nvidia you know about 10 years ago and And that's why it's done so well over time. But again, these misunderstandings aren't entirely naive and wrong. And a lot of the time, the market in that general consensus view is going to be right.
1:01:24But you're looking for that. I want the 10 bagger. I want a few of them. And I don't really give a stuff if six or seven out of 10 go to zero. What am I trying to do here? I'm trying to. I've got a pool of capital and I'm trying to grow that pool of capital at an adequate rate of term overall. Now, it really doesn't matter too much how that is achieved, but I'm here to sort of tell you the counterintuitive part of it is that in order to get, whenever you look at any investor of any particular style really, and you sort of say, wow, how did they deliver such strong outperformance over time? It's usually because there was a handful of just absolute rocket ships into that portfolio that they bought on a very strong variant perception to the rest of the market that was just so spectacularly good for such a long period of time.
1:02:12It made the other positions irrelevant, you know, and it's sort of like you stay in the super comfy, cozy part of the market. And it's like, again, I'm not saying you won't do okay, but it's kind of like, yeah, just buy the ETF and just make your life a lot easier. You guarantee the average rather than trying to engineer the average, which is effectively what you're trying to do by avoiding quote unquote risk, individual risk, like lean into the, I can't, it's a religion for me, I've structured my entire portfolio around this thing, you know, and every now and again, it makes give me crap about, I remember when you said that this was a great stock, it's like, yeah, but you know, it's kind of, I was wrong, yeah.
1:02:54Yeah, but that's the point, like it's like, it could have been, and there was a parallel universe where it was and it didn't turn out this way. But what about this one over here? Oh, you got lucky. It's like, well, but as an investor, you're trying to make your own luck. What I'm saying is you'll never get that luck if all you're doing is staying within the 100 % certain kind of things where there's just, there's no sort of, there is no contra view that leads to a wildly different outcome. So it's kind of messed with your head, all of this stuff. And in doing that you are knowingly walking into things that will more often than not, not work out.
1:03:30So that's why I sort of say, you know, God, I am rubbing my hands in a certain degree, looking at NVIDIA going, wow, it just seems really cheap. And it's like, if I was to actually allocate real capital to it and it didn't go out, I wouldn't lose any sleep. It's like, actually that happens more often than mostly what happens. But if it is one of those opportunities, it's sort of like, well, I have to walk headlong into these kind of scenarios, knowing what the possibilities are, knowing what the odds are, but framing that risk and those odds from a portfolio level and not from an individual stock level.
1:04:05You just go right, let's not, let's go into it. That's been my whole argument. That's a very fresh conversation I had with a mate the other day with Bitcoin. It's like, dude, it's not asymetric. Just put two bloody percent in. I don't understand. Like I gave you a half baked pitch on a stock and said it, you know, it's got odds to sort of be 10 times higher or it could be cut in half. You'd probably buy it without thinking about it. But this thing you wouldn't. My point is it's sort of like this is why you can do things at an individual level. Hey, should I put all my money in Nvidia or all into Bitcoin or whatever it happens to be?
1:04:38It's like, no, probably don't do that. But don't confuse. I'm sorry, I'm laboring. I'm flogging a dead horse. Don't confuse the risk of the individual position with the risk of the stock, of the portfolio is what I'm saying. Yep. Nicely done. Motley Fool Money. For more, subscribe to the free newsletter at fool.com.au forward slash listener. Man, let's finish off quickly with some news this week and I'll give away the lead. You said before we chatted that there'll be much more of this. and that was news that Qantas is sacking 850 workers and moving their jobs to I think India via a deal with Accenture the CAP the consulting group can I say mate my first thought was how can there be more than 850 people at Qantas head office anyway how can you just cut that many jobs until people left the head office and maybe that's just my naivety I don't know how many people you need to run an airline at head office level but I wouldn't have thought it was that many so yeah 850 jobs largely technology going to Accenture I don't know if they're publicly listed but they've done deals with Qantas, NAB, Coles, Woolies, and it is all happening.
1:05:47What's interesting, I don't think we know the breakdown yet for Qantas, but I'm pretty sure Woolies or Coles, maybe both, are outsourcing things like marketing operations and other things to Accenture. So this is not just the usual person coding a computer. Again, AI is part of this conversation, obviously. But it raises some interesting questions, mate. So there's a question about what it means for Australian jobs, and that's probably what a lot of listeners care about most, I suspect. That's kind of the first layer, first level question. Second one for me is I wonder about, well, obviously then there's, you know, what does it mean for individual companies?
1:06:23What does it mean when this happens? But also the jobs aren't being lost overall. The work is still being done. And so a couple of things there. What does it mean for average wages here versus overseas? What does it mean when you are trusting, frankly, what starts to become business critical-ish assets to a consulting company. It's one thing to say, you know, can you run the database? It's like, yeah, I can do that. And if it fell over, you'd take it back and it'd be fine. When you're saying we're going to outsource marketing in HR, I mean, we already know companies are using consultants and they're, you know, the specialists in third-party distribution.
1:06:57Very few companies run their own distribution centres anymore. They're all outsourced to someone else. But the core competencies of these businesses start to become questions. Accenture becomes the expert in all these things. and you wonder kind of what Qantas or Coles or Willys are left with. Yes, it's running the stores. Yes, it's putting planes in the air. But there's questions about, you know, what does core competency look like? What do you need? What do you retain? What is the business? Is it just the brand? And, you know, and effectively that's the value. Everything else is just outsourced and cobbled together.
1:07:24In AI world, it's also hard not to think about that, that same context of what AI can do for you versus the skills you need. But, yeah, I don't know if you have a thought, mate. I guess my overarching thought was I'm not surprised that you've already made the point, so I'll give you the credit for it. But, you know, I think we all think it's the beginning of much more to come. I suspect - Undeniable at this point. There's nothing - There shouldn't be anything controversial about this statement at this point. So, 2027 is going to be a year of job losses, I suspect. I bear it a little bit. The ABS put out some data this week, I think it was, that in July and August, I think were the months, there were more than 100 ,000 Australians retrenched from their jobs.
1:08:00Now, not just AI again, not just all these things, but just that number is notable because their business is making changes. Again, cyclical structure we talked about, that might be the theme of the podcast. There is a lot going on. I'll just hand the floor to you. Yeah, well, I mean, I always sort of chuckle a little bit when, you know, particularly politicians jump up and down and talk about productivity and then get upset when there's less of a workforce. It's like that kind of is what productivity getting better means, is that I can do more with less. So, yes. And, again, not to make light of it, again, we need to separate the individual tragedy from the broader macro kind of picture here.
1:08:39And there are, even before AI, there was a pendulum that always swang, swing from, swanged. Swanged a good word. Swanged, there you go. It swanged between outsourcing and insourcing. And, like, oh, we'd be so much more efficient if we did it this way And then a few years later, they change their mind. And then a few years later, they go back again. And actually, there's no intrinsic reason as to why one would be better than the other. I mean, it actually makes a great deal of sense to outsource things if there is a counterparty that is trustworthy and better at it and can do it in a more cost-effective way.
1:09:18Most companies do that with – back in the day when we started, most companies had a server room. It's where the IT teams, it's like the IT crowd, if anyone knows that. You sat in the basement, you put them there, and they ran the servers, and it was all in the building. I'm like, who does that? Who does that anymore? Actually, I'll tell you who does that. There was a buzz when you walk past the thing. I wrote about it recently. I got 37 signals, and David Hanson, DHH, the Ruby on Rails guy, I've mentioned him a bit. I'm a little bit quietly obsessed with him at the moment.
1:09:50But they brought the cloud in-house, and they end up saving about$3 million or something annually in doing it. Yeah. Okay. Fascinating. But my point is that this has always and forever happened. And so is it good or bad? Well, the answer is, well, if they manage to get the same service delivery for a lower price, then it's a good move. I mean, it's improving efficiency and productivity in a perfectly fair market, free market kind of scenario that almost cheaper prices for all of us. So it's sort of, I'm not intrinsically opposed to any one particular approach. My hope would be that whatever management is doing, they've found a way to do what needs to be done.
1:10:35There's a critical service that needs to be provided. And if you are telling me that you can do that just as effectively or more effectively for the same price or lower, then please do it. Absolutely do it. You should do it. Will that be the case? I don't know. Again, there's plenty of times where they've all been outsourced and it's like an absolute disaster. Not a private enterprise thing either. I mean, like the libs back in, well, not that long ago, cut a bunch of work from the public service, but they ended up just eventually having a full-time roster of consultants. Consultants, yeah. It's kind of like, is this really any different?
1:11:10Like it's sort of, but again, I'm not, you know, it's not an ideological perspective there. It's like if they were able to do that and taxpayers got the same kind of service delivery for lovers. We should want that as taxpayers. I want good roads and healthcare and defence and all of the things that government provides. And I want you to do it with as little taxes as possible. Thank you very much. So I think, yeah, that's what I think of all of that. Is AI a part of it? 100 % it is. And maybe not to a dominant degree, but it's coming. It's just, there are some things where you can look into the future and like, well, maybe this happens.
1:11:48and you can sort of, as you say, you think more probabilistic about it. I'm putting the odds of this at 99%. And only from a firsthand experience. I'm sick of people telling me what this tech can do, which just denies my lived experience of it. It's sort of like we can all read blog posts and newspaper articles and come to a perspective on what we think, what we reckon, based on our interpretation of it. But when you do something yourself and it's like, oh. Oh, you just, like it's something about experiencing the visceral, you know, just firsthand interaction with something and going, yeah, this is touching virtually every industry and every part of every industry.
1:12:30And it's coming like a freight train down the track. So, yep, a lot more jobs. Again, I'm not celebrating it. I'm not saying it's a good thing or whatever, but it's just as adults, I think we need to sort of acknowledge the reality of this happening. So I don't know. I'm sounding very sure of myself, and I am very sure of myself, but I always invite a bit of pushback if you think I'm being a little bit, maybe a bit too hyperbolic there. I don't think. Well, there are two groups of people, those who have used AI and those who have used AI, and they're not most of the same people, right? So if you ask.
1:13:04If you haven't used it, your opinion is precisely zero to me. Honestly, it's. Yeah, you used it once or you used it badly and didn't get the result you wanted. and it's, I said to you last week, I think when we spoke, I love that I get annoyed with AI at the moment. And I love it in the sense that it makes me laugh because I go, it can do all this stuff and I don't know it, it can't do a little bit more, you know. It's like I built a plane and it can't yet break the sound barrier. It's like, what is my issue? You know, like I want to go faster. Sure, I'm going to go faster eventually, but like you're flying a plane, you know.
1:13:31And that's my experience with AI. And I think people have used it once or had someone talk about it. Or frankly, here's the other thing, and let's be real, you and I are tech heads and we love our gadgets. and there are people who just don't like the idea of AI for all the reasons, right? They don't want less human interaction. They don't want less human involvement. Maybe they're artists. And I get it. And this is kind of what we said before about NVIDIA. You can have a view on what you wish was true. You can have an ethical and moral view as well. You just have to keep that alongside the simple question of what can AI do?
1:14:01Is it beneficial? Is it going to be useful? Will it be disruptive? They are very different questions to should it be or would I wish it wasn't? And that's where you made the point. We're not celebrating it. It's just the losses, the downsides of it. But the reality is, in my experience and yours, you can do amazing amounts of things. I was asked this morning at work about one of the websites, The Economic Picture, and I went, oh, actually, I've done this. Yeah, I've done this. I've got six. There are six different URLs that I have published content to, right? Now, that's, I mean, none of them is making money.
1:14:29They're all costing me money and whatever. The point is I know what it can do. I've seen it work. You've seen it work for Straw Man. We've seen a little bit of The Fool for a whole lot of different things. It works beautifully. We are saving money. We have fewer team members, unfortunately, than we used to have, and the work and the quality is not dropped because we're using AI to do it. We're literally, you know, to your point, mate, it's like denying the lived experience, you know. You can't do that. I am. I'll let you do it now. Watch me. No, you can't. Oh, don't do that. Careful. It gets it wrong.
1:14:55It's like, well, not for this. And also, yeah, my pushback there is always to us. Like the bar is not perfection here. Yes, correct. You know, humans make mistakes all the time. Yes, yes. Is it better than the average human? Does it have to, it's sort of like, again, I had a chat with someone the other day and they were sort of saying, oh, it's still not as good as the best human. It's like, you, do you, you're saying to me that when I'm going to open up my local cafe, I need Henry Ford and Einstein manning the barista, you know, being the barista here, or it's just not like, no, 99.999 % of jobs just require just average competency, average kind of intelligence.
1:15:35We're there. It's solved. It is done. on, you know, on, on that kind of regard. And for you to point to this one error that happened, you know, in, in, as part of all of this other stuff that was just sort of like, would have taken a team of genius level experts, 10 years working around the clock to come up with. And you're, and you're like, this is not real because of that. Your benchmark, your benchmark is, is totally inappropriate. Different world. If like humans were just like Einstein level humans, we're just falling out of the trees and happy to work for three cents an hour. It's like, okay, you've got a good point.
1:16:09But the average person is an Einstein and they don't work for three cents an hour. And I've got these problems I need solved. And like any rational human, I'm going to look around for the most straightforward, painless way to solve those problems for me. It's just, again, it doesn't deny the tragedy, doesn't deny the structural challenge of it all, but that is at the coalface of it, that is the calculus that is being made. And it's coming, man. It is undeniable. With the exception, I will say two things. One is we are currently being subsidised by VCs, that these things are already at a loss and we're benefiting from it.
1:16:51So there may well be a world in which the use of AI is restricted to higher value tasks because what I'm paying 50 bucks a month for is going to cost 400 bucks a month when I'm actually going to pay their own way. And I go, I want to pay 50, I want to pay 400 for that particular expertise or that particular skill or that particular piece of work. Or I might, by the way. So depending on what it is and what we're doing with it. Well, again, you say that, but like how much hours do you get from a human? $400. Exactly. Exactly. So there'll be points at which the decision is, I'm not going to have incremental value and there may be plateauing in the ability of AI.
1:17:28It may just simply plateau at a certain capability until it jumps up again. So I'm not disagreeing, man. I'm just, I'm making, I'm painting the, why might you be wrong or why that may not happen as quickly as you think or want or hope. And I would suggest probably those sorts of reasons. That'd be why I would probably, go on. Yeah, I know you're a hundred percent right. My thoughts on that are, I mean, I'm also very, I'm humble enough to know I don't know, But you do have to have a position and hopefully just be fluid enough in that position that when the facts change that you can alter it. But the lay of the land at this stage strikes me as something where you've got a few sort of first movers with some advantage, but a lot of what are called fast followers that are there.
1:18:15And I look at some of the, I use DeepSeek a lot for one of my local harnesses. And I can run that thing all day, you know, and it might cost a buck, you know. And it's like, is it as good as Fable 5.2? No. No, Fable 5.2 is like, oh, my God, that just dropped this week. And oh, my God. Yeah. But it's, you know, that local, that open source, open weight model probably will be as good as 5.2 in six months' time. and the other and then there is so many different you go into open router for example where you see all the you can sort of get api access to all the different models out there literally thousands of them and and if it was something like um the the comparison i usually use is is uranium enrichment you look at nuclear technology that is a that is an area where only the biggest and best resourced players can operate.
1:19:13You have to be a state, nation state, or just, you know, a Dr. Evil type enterprise to even think about doing that. Restrictions and regulations sort of aside. If you've got a mid-level desktop computer and a bit of IT smarts, you're in the AI game, right? There's labs that are just propping up everywhere, you know? And it's sort of like, Why is that good? It's good that it means that there should be enough of a supply out there that there's no concentrated group of players that will be able to sort of exercise significant price power is my base case assumption at this point in time. I think Anthropic and OpenIR, I think they've worked that out themselves.
1:20:01I think that's why they're very desperate to sort of release what they can now, get the IPOs done now before the commodified nature of it reveals through. And in the meantime, hold back a few of the more exciting things so that we can monetize them more directly. I think that's the play at this point in time. There's an investing dimension to all of that from a humanitarian sort of dimension to, I think that's a good, it's a good thing for us in the sense that it should be a technology that's fairly well democratized. You know, there'll be some kid in Calcutta with a smartphone that can interact with this as well.
1:20:37Like that is a wonderful thing. Like that is taking away the access to only the rich and powerful. And sure, will the rich have the ability to buy more tokens? And yes, will they be able to lean more into the more capable of frontier type model? Absolutely. I'm not going to pretend for a second that it's a level playing field. Hopefully it loses the baseline. It's far more level. It's far more level just by the nature of the tech than any. other things that have come before, which mitigates, I think, the very real risk that you're talking about. We'll see. It's not my best case either. I'm just making the part.
1:21:14There are, you know, like everything, we haven't got flying cars, but we've got, you know, the God in our pockets. Technology evolves in weird ways for different reasons and different feedback loops happen and make things faster and slower than you expect. I'm just painting the, you know, if it doesn't happen, why wouldn't it? They're about the best ones I can come up with there's a chance of regulation um at government level there's things that could happen possibly can we speak about that the latest thought bubble from the government regulating it all i mean this is uh what do we shouldn't i shouldn't get going at this stage of the podcast but it's just sort of like again it's not to deny the challenge i mean it's a very significant challenge i can't stress it enough right but there's also like what are you going to do about it what are you going to do about it australia you you tiny little net on the like we are so small in the grand scheme of things we're bringing absolutely nothing to the table and like australia could disappear and nothing changes in terms of the pace of this technology and what's going forward and it's it's absolutely going to revolutionize the world and we're and we're just we're we're we're locking it down and and walking away from it it's just like the strategic misstep peer is just unbelievable sorry mate you when you talked about when you said regulated oh my god you're right but but my point to that is as well is that they you can't i'm running an open source model right now on my machine i've got a quen 3.5 right and it's just like okay it's not a very good but it's on my machine you can regulate it all you like it's ones and zeros on my hard drive bro what are you gonna do you don't even know i've gone now i've outed myself but everyone does a million people like 10 million 100 million people around the world do it's out there it's on repos that are completely publicly accessible, you can download it at the click of a button.
1:22:58And so it's like making homosexuality or swearing, like banning it. It's like as if it changes anything, you know? It's like maybe it makes it a little bit more difficult and it increases the risks, but it's just, it's, sorry, I didn't mean to hijack your point. I know you sort of said it as a throwaway line, but it is kind of an understandable but absolutely pointless response to my way of thinking. Yeah, but also it could be done in a way that means that any responsible, reputable corporate, for example, couldn't use it. So not to cross too many lines over here, but owning gold was made illegal in the US for years.
1:23:36And did people still own it? Yes. Was there still a black market for it? Yes. But did it significantly impact its use? Yes. If you said to Australians, you may not use AI, right? Would you use your computer? Of course, you wouldn't. You're law-abiding. Neither would I. I'm law-abiding. But other people might, and that's okay. But you couldn't be any significant operation with more than one person in it without running risk of, you know, being out-of-the-end or prosecuted for using something. Oh, it definitely makes it harder. I mean, the obvious example is a Bitcoin ban as well. It's like, how'd that work out?
1:24:05So it's sort of, you're right. And it's not to make light of it, but it was sort of like the game theoretical dimension to it is, is it just sort of like, well, maybe Australia does that, but Taiwan doesn't, or I don't know, big random country, right? And it's a little like, there is, it doesn't mitigate any of the worry that you're concerned about. And it just puts you at a massive disadvantage, you know. It's the Japanese fighting with swords when gunpowder comes along. It's all that all over again. Just don't show you they won't try it. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. They are trying it. Yeah, right.
1:24:39Exactly. They're doing it. Yeah. Idiots. That's all I can say. Just idiots. It's just. Mic drop. It's just, it's first order, knee jerk, understandable until you pick at it for more than five seconds and you just go, that's a complete nonsense. It's pointless, it will achieve nothing and it will hurt us. And yeah, they might do it anyway. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. I agree with you for the record. I'm not disagreeing with you. It's just more that, you know, I think, you're talking about, you know, I know in the bear case, and I think that's just, it's just worth holding out the, So, yeah, without recommendations that work, I will always say, I don't mind saying to a member, this could go wrong, and it goes wrong.
1:25:24I don't like losing money from our members, but it's like, hey, this could be cyclical, let's go back to it. This could be structural rather than cyclical. It's like, okay, it turns out it was, okay, got it wrong. It's the one where I kind of go, where something goes wrong, and the member says, didn't you know this could happen? Or why were you at least aware of that possibility? You were blindsided as opposed to a calculated risk. So, it's just making enough space for that. I recommend stocks that I think are going to be market beaters on average because that's what I do, knowing that some won't.
1:25:50And hopefully I'm more often than not wrong for the right reasons in the sense that I said, hey, here's the upside, here's the downside risk. The downside risk has come to pass. Okay, that sucks. It's the one where it's like, oh, I didn't see that coming. Or I had all this good news and didn't share with you where it could be wrong. Even though I'm really comfortable and confident with the company. Berkshire Hathaway, right? Maybe Warren Buffett's a massive fraud. Is he? No. Almost certainly not. But is there a chance? Yeah, in some version of the world he dies and it turns out the whole thing was a Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme, right?
1:26:17Now, very likely, no. Like, infinitesimally small odds, yes, if you've got enough zeros to string them together around the world a couple of times, maybe you get there. But, you know, it's just more holding out that, you know, if it's not his way, it won't be. I think it's a useful conversation. Oh, yeah. Yep. Yep, definitely. You just, yeah. I mean, that's the other thing. the great thing about this sort of game is that you don't. I think people too often just assume that you've got to make a decision now and then you've got to live with it. It's like, well, you have to live with it while you're holding it, but you can change your mind.
1:26:54Like you should be changing your mind. It's like here's my base case. I've got to make a – it's binary at some point. Do I buy or do I not buy? Like that is an absolute binary decision. But as things unfold and be aware what could go wrong, maybe this happens, maybe they ban it. What happens if, oh, maybe this, maybe that. And, you know, you think it all through. And then you watch and then you see which way the wind is blowing. Oh, I thought that regulation was just something no one would be that stupid to do it in that heavy ham-fisted way. Sure, they wouldn't do that. Meanwhile, the Australian government hold my beer, you know.
1:27:28Okay, I didn't consider that a pot, but I can react to it. Yes. Much better. Not trying to get ahead of any sort of share price movement per se, But just to when the news drops to have gone, yes, I have considered this. I know what the implications of this are or are likely to be. It fundamentally changes my investment thesis. I either formulate a new thesis or I move away from this position. That's fine. You can absolutely, you should do that. Like what else are you going to do? But yeah, just to wait and feel like, back to an earlier point, I only do stuff that I'm 100 % certain of and this is the only thing that happens.
1:28:09It's just like, well, that's got its own consequences as well. Very true. I reckon that probably draws... Sorry, go on. I just lost my point along mid-ramble there. I'm sure I was heading towards a target at some point. I'm sure you got there. That's important. Let's wrap this one up, mate. Let's come back on Sunday and go from our own ravings to our own ravings about your questions. How about that? We'll do that on Sunday. Will you come back? Hell yeah. All right. Until then, have a great weekend and full on. Cheers. The Motley Fool and people appearing in this program may have positions in the companies mentioned.
1:28:45General advice only. Please speak to your financial professional to understand how it may pertain to your situation. Subscribe to the free newsletter at fool.com.au forward slash listener. The Motley Fool operates under Financial Services Licence 400691.
– DJs slims down… enough?
– Nvidia boss faces allegations
– Qantas cuts jobs… and won’t be the last
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.