1. Podcasts
  2. Newshour
  3. 03/11/2026 21:06 GMT
Newshour

3 Nov 2026 · 47m · 21 chapters

In short

The episode is a BBC NewsHour roundup covering multiple stories. Main topics: US midterm elections (whether Democrats can win control of Congress from Donald Trump), European flight bomb threats (security assessment and credibility thresholds), Netherlands euthanasia law and a family’s assisted-dying case (timing, dementia eligibility, doctor ethics), India’s gold rush around Diwali (who profits vs margins and import duties), Israel coalition talks after a general election (whether opposition will cooperate with Arab-majority parties; Trump’s claim about ending US arms subsidies), and UK-led particle physics evidence for a rare “zeptoverse” decay (Dr Harry Cliff; implications for dark matter/Big Bang mysteries). Guests/backgrounds: Tom Bateman (BBC correspondent, Ohio); Netta Tolfik (BBC correspondent, Michigan); Samira Hussain (BBC correspondent, Iowa); James Kamarasamy (BBC NewsHour anchor, Washington); Will Geddes (security CEO, International Corporate Protection); Dr Rosmarine van Bruchem (geriatrician/ethicist, Erasmus MC); Helen Lewis (Atlantic staff writer); Anshul Pfeffer (Economist Israel correspondent); Sam Fenwick (Business Daily reporter); Itaba Zam (filmmaker); Isra (subject of documentary). Notable examples/claims: Trump approval 40% in NBC poll; Michigan candidate Abdul El-Sayed could be first Muslim US senator; bomb threats likely connected but unknown objective; euthanasia requires voluntary request and mental capacity; gold import duty raised to 15%; Israel opposition faces coalition constraints over Hamas labeling and Israel as a Jewish state; zeptometer-scale decay could reveal new particles.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:36

Exploring the Agnelli Family Legacy

Discussion on the significance of Fiat and the Agnelli family in Italy.

“The real-life dramas of one of Italy's most prominent dynasties, Fiat's Agnelli family.”
2:08

Midterm Elections Overview

Analysis of the upcoming midterm elections in the US and their implications.

“It's a verdict on the people who've been in power and a verdict on the people who want to take over.”
4:00

Voter Sentiments and Engagement

Interviews with voters expressing their hopes and concerns for the elections.

“I've just been following Trump the whole time.”
6:10

Election Day Insights from Ohio

Correspondent reports from polling stations in Ohio highlighting voter turnout.

“Over its northern border in Michigan, that's where Netta Tolfik is.”
8:01

Michigan's Election Climate

Update on voter enthusiasm and key issues in Michigan's elections.

“I'm at a polling station in Des Moines, Iowa, and this is a state that has been reliably Republican for many years.”
9:24

Iowa's Political Landscape

Report on polling in Iowa and the dominant issues influencing voters.

“Let's bring this all together now with NewsHouse.”
12:10

Election Stakes and Predictions

Discussion on what the elections mean for the future of the US and Trump.

“If no candidate gets more than 50 percent, they have a second round of counting of votes, looking at the second preferences.”
15:09

Bomb Threats in Europe

Discussion on a series of bomb threats affecting flights across Europe.

“This is the BBC and you're listening to NewsHour live from London.”
19:00

Euthanasia in the Netherlands

Exploration of euthanasia practices and a poignant story of a couple in the Netherlands.

“Last year in the Netherlands, nearly 10 ,500 people died from euthanasia.”
23:58

The Business of Gold in India

Insight into the gold market in India ahead of Diwali, including costs and societal views.

“Listen on bbc.com, the BBC app, or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.”
Show all 21 chapters
27:42

Political Developments in Israel

Analysis of the aftermath of Israel's general election and potential coalition scenarios.

“Just a reminder of some news that broke shortly before we came on air, and that is that Spain's transport minister has resigned nearly a week after a terrible rail accident that killed 69 people.”
28:20

Post-Election Coalition Challenges

Discussion on the complexities of forming a coalition government in Israel post-election, particularly regarding Arab party cooperation.

“Today, for the first time since that election, the parties in the main opposition bloc met.”
30:34

U.S. Military Subsidies and Politics

Anshul Pfeffer discusses Donald Trump's surprising comments on U.S. military subsidies to Israel and its implications.

“despite the Arab-Israeli politicians having condemned the massacre of October 7, they haven't been prepared to call Hamas a terror organisation.”
32:44

Media Ethics and Press Freedom

Helen Lewis examines the ethical implications of a media injunction related to mental health and the rights of complainants in journalism.

“relationship are certainly no longer guaranteed.”
36:54

Exploring the Zeptoverse in Particle Physics

Dr. Harry Cliff explains the recent findings in particle physics and the quest to understand dark matter and the universe's structure.

“One of the first rules of journalism is not to read out press releases, but I'm afraid I can't resist the opening paragraph from Cambridge University today.”
40:44

Documentary on Syrian Refugee Journey

Rebecca Kesby introduces a documentary about a Syrian family's journey from Aleppo to Germany, highlighting their struggles and resilience.

“So for example, one of the other big mysteries in physics is that this standard model predicts that the universe should not exist.”
42:00

The Journey of Filming Refugees

Learn about the challenges and experiences of filming refugees over a decade.

“And we went to make a film about people crossing and doing the journey.”
43:06

Isra's Perspective on Filming

Isra shares her excitement and experiences during the filming process.

“Because the woman from my family, all of them take hijab and she didn't do it.”
44:24

Challenges of Documenting a Refugee's Life

Itab discusses the emotional and physical challenges faced while making the film.

“That was a very hard time for me and my family.”
46:10

Reflections on Identity and Change

Isra reflects on how her identity has evolved after years of displacement.

“Isra, when you finally saw the film and yourself, you know, growing up over the 10 years, because you're married now, your husband's actually listening into this interview.”
47:11

Empathy Through Storytelling

The filmmakers discuss the importance of empathy in understanding refugee experiences.

“What does looking at the story in this form, in a film, with a character like Isra, a real person and a real family, what does that do to the understanding for Europeans of this story?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30all in one place, so you can invest your way. Visit schwab.com to learn more. The real-life dramas of one of Italy's most prominent dynasties, Fiat's Agnelli family. Fiat was so important in Italy's economy. Italy was Fiat and Fiat was Italy. Inheritance Fiat from the BBC World Service. It's about money. Power, the succession story. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

1:27the almost impossibly tiny world, we're talking billionths of trillions of a metre, which has brought physicists to the brink of the zeptoverse. This is a journey that began 130 years ago with the discovery of the electron, and since then we've been zooming in and zooming in and zooming in on matter. We've discovered the nucleus inside that, protons and neutrons inside that, quarks, and then most recently the Higgs boson. And every time we've gone to zoom in further to shorter distances, we've discovered new particles. So in a very broad sense, what we're looking for are new basic ingredients of our universe.

2:01It is a cracking quest, and you can hear from the scientists leading it in about 40 minutes. All elections turn on the same things. It's a verdict on the people who've been in power and a verdict on the people who want to take over. So 10 years after he was first elected president, today's midterm elections in the United States, elections to the US Congress as well as to the state legislatures and governorships, they're a chance to pass judgment on Donald Trump, the man who has dominated US politics with a generational force. The vote's also going to test whether the much-tarnished Democratic brand is being bought once again by voters, or at least enough voters to see the Democrats wrest control of the House of Representatives and maybe even the Senate from the Republicans, and maybe begin to constrain and hold to account the White House.

2:52There is a lot riding on this for the country and, you could argue, the world. Cue the thumpy music. Election day in America. Millions of people will head to the polls to vote in the midterm races that will determine control of Congress. Donald Trump's approval rating in our final pre-election NBC News poll stands at 40%, 60 % of voters saying they disapprove of the president's performance. Alaska is highlighted. Texas is highlighted. Kansas, Iowa, Michigan. Those are just some of the states that we are watching very closely. And there is plenty of talk, and not just in overheated TV studios, about intense interest across the country, about the early signs of a high voter turnout, about the American people being particularly engaged in these midterms, as we've been hearing from this tiny sample of the millions queuing to cast their ballots.

3:44If you're watching American politics around the world, which I know a lot of people are, it feels like we're on the precipice. And I know that people say that a lot, but it really does feel like that now, that if we do not use our voice with our vote to try to put some changes in place, it feels like we're going to be too far gone. I've just been following Trump the whole time. I really think he's doing an awesome job. We need to get the Senate and the House, because if not, then they're going to, you know, it's just going to be crazy. I vote a straight Democrat right now. You know, we've got the Republicans.

4:17They're pretty much, you know, kind of kind of running things. And the results are not good. The results are definitely not good. So if you want to make a change, get down here, exercise your right to vote. My hopes for tonight is that Ohio does the right thing for the future and doesn't vote on emotion. and that here in UA we require our leaders to write issues well and not just ask us to vote, to spend a little more money. Well, in a moment we'll get the big picture with our man in Washington, D.C. But first we ask some of our BBC correspondents dotted around some of the key races to give us a flavour of the contests where they are.

4:59First, Tom Bateman. Well, I'm standing outside an elementary school in Columbus, Ohio. It's been really busy here. This is a suburb, like many in this state, that will help to decide which way Ohio goes. A state that has been Republican-read pretty much for the entire Trump era, but the Democrats are feeling they can break into that, that they can take a US Senate seat perhaps, and the governorship of this state. It will be a bellwether for what happens across the country today. Interesting that J.D. Vance, the vice president, was here last night in the state he is from. and was urging, rallying the Republican vote out.

5:38They know that is their weakness, is about issues around turnout in this campaign. And actually, most places we've been, we've seen high numbers of people, Democrat-leaning areas in the city itself, and this morning we were at Rumpoling Station. I spoke to one woman who came out, she had just voted. The moment I spoke to her, she was in tears about what she felt was the state of the country under the Trump administration. and again we've seen that sort of intensity around the way people are feeling in Democratic-led areas and the reasons they're trying to get out to vote today. We could have projections for the state pretty early on actually, potentially even before midnight, and that I think will give us a real sense of how these Republican states are going and whether or not the Democrats have done enough to try and flip them.

6:24Tom Bateman in Ohio. Over its northern border in Michigan, that's where Netta Tolfik is. We're in one of the college campuses in Detroit. where polls have just opened and people are trickling in. And there is a lot of enthusiasm here. Voters have been telling us that they, for the last two years, have been unhappy with the war on Iran, the price of groceries, the price of gas. And there is a lot of enthusiasm for the Democratic candidate, Abdul El-Sayed, here in Michigan. He is a populist left-wing candidate who defeated the more centrist candidate in the primary. And Mike Rogers, the Republican nominee, has been attacking him as radical.

7:08President Trump has even resorted to anti-Muslim rhetoric, calling him a jihadist. And El-Sayed originally kind of struggled in these Detroit suburbs with black voters who largely supported his opponent in the primary. But what we're seeing here today is a real rallying around El Sayed in the black community. And we're seeing that because they are typically loyal Democratic voters. And their anger with President Trump is very evident. They want to come out and register their anger. This has been one of the most expensive midterm elections in the country's history. and, of course, at stake is nothing less than the direction of the country for at least the next two years.

7:56Nedda Tolfik in Michigan and head a bit further west, but still in the Midwest heartland of America. That's where Samira Hussain is. I'm at a polling station in Des Moines, Iowa, and this is a state that has been reliably Republican for many years. But Democrats are making a push to flip this state from red to blue. During the day here, we have seen a steady stream of voters coming in to cast their ballot. It's raining, it's pouring outside, and that hasn't dampened the spirits of people that are coming in to make their voices heard. There have been two distinct issues that have come up time and time again.

8:39First, of course, is the economy, and many have cited the high cost of petrol and the high diesel costs. Remember, Iowa is a state that has a lot of farmers and high prices for diesel are particularly hitting the American farmers quite hard. The other issue that has come up again and again has to do with the tone of politics these days, that things have become so divisive that people aren't able to even speak to each other about basic issues, that it becomes so intolerable. And that polarisation is something that many voters here have cited and they really want to see changed. Samira Hussain in Iowa.

9:24Let's bring this all together now with NewsHouse. James Kamarasamy, who's anchoring our special election programming, which starts in just under two hours here on the BBC World Service. What does he think's at stake? I think, as you laid out in the introduction, Tim, this is about President Trump, this generational force, as you put it, in American politics and whether he can keep control of power, the levers of power, because if the Democrats do take one or both, and that is a possibility, houses of Congress in Washington, it does give him headaches. Now, he's already talked about using his veto power.

9:59But if the Democrats do get power, it will make the last two years of his second term more difficult for him. He will almost certainly see the Democrats try to take control of certain policies. They have the power of the person in the House of Representatives. They also have the power to start investigations, and they've made it pretty clear they're going to be trying to do that for, if not him personally, then certainly members of his administration. So, you know, while he does have the power still, while he is ruled by executive order in many cases and will continue to do so, it will just become a lot tougher for him to escape some of those pressures in Congress itself.

10:40As you've been hinting, Jamie, the opinion polls are suggesting there will be perhaps significant gains to the Democrats. How much caution should we treat these opinion polls with? It's worth being cautious. Traditionally, in the Trump era, they have underestimated the Trump vote. Now, he is not on the ballot, despite what he has been going around telling his supporters over the last couple of weeks, saying, imagine I'm on the ballot. he's not on the ballot and that traditionally has has not been as good for the republican party as when he has been um so we do have to be cautious but at the same time pollsters and we've heard from so many of them over the last few days and weeks here are saying look we are aware of this precedent so we have adjusted our polling and and you have to say it will be in some of the some of the races it will be an almighty upset if democrats do not win i think the house there is a sense given the history of midterm elections, when the party in power almost always loses seats in the House, it's going to be very much likely a democratic gain.

11:46The Senate, though, is trickier. If you look again in the last couple of cycles, even when overall perhaps voters have wanted to send a message to the White House, actually the last couple of cycles the party in power has gained in the Senate. So bear that in mind when you look at these results as they come in, And bear in mind that they might not come in immediately. As you said, I'll be presenting our special programme here. But in some cases, Maine, Alaska, two of the key states in power. If no candidate gets more than 50 percent, they have a second round of counting of votes, looking at the second preferences.

12:21And that can take a week, maybe two weeks. And in terms of the lessons for the Democrats themselves, given the range of opinions in the parties, I mean, how important is it going to be to look at that? Yeah, I think it is important. I mean, we heard from Neda in Michigan. I mean, that race is a very important one to look at. It is very particular, the Abdul El-Sayed race, given the amount of money that's gone into that. But, you know, he is a progressive candidate. He's on the left of the party. He would be the first Muslim in the US Senate if he wins. You know, can someone like that win in a traditional blue collar state like Michigan?

13:00It's not. People have compared it to New York. It's not New York. Michigan is a swing state. And for both parties, I think the point to make is after these midterm elections, they will be looking at what kind of leader they have, what kind of candidate they have going into the 2028 election. So, you know, if the Democrats win big, for example, in Michigan, maybe they'll think, well, we need a more progressive candidate. For the Republicans, of course, their choice is what comes after Donald Trump. And, you know, the next two years he will still be in power. He will still be very much the leader of the party, but the party will be looking beyond him.

13:36And I think we'll get some very interesting indications, depending on how some of these results go, about what that might look like, what that battle within the party might look like. As we've said, special coverage here on the BBC World Service. It starts at 23 hours GMT through the night. Then our colleagues at Newsday pick up the coverage. And I will be back with you all on NewsHour tomorrow. Wednesday, I believe it is. I'm losing track of the day. It's Wednesday on NewsHour, the early edition. And that was James Kamarasamy speaking from Washington, D.C. Coming up on this edition of NewsHour, the endearing value of gold to many Indian families.

14:15Indians love gold. It is in our DNA. Even you can't afford anything, but you must have gold. Gold for any family is not just gold. It is our sustainability, our rainy day saving. Ahead of the Diwali Festival, we have a special report on the business of buying and selling the precious metal. That's in just about 10 minutes. Our main headline, as we've been hearing, voting is in full swing across the US in the midterm elections, which will determine whether Democrats can break Donald Trump's grip on Congress. And Spain's transport minister has resigned over the train crash that killed 69 people last week.

15:09This is the BBC and you're listening to NewsHour live from London. There's been a series of bomb threats targeting flights across Europe today. Ten flights have been affected. No explosives have been found but the disruption has been extensive. One Ryanair flight from Dublin was escorted by Italian Air Force jets on its journey into Rome. A plane from Manchester in northern England made an emergency landing in the Spanish city of Murusia following a reported threat. It's still not clear whether these events are connected or who may have been behind them. Will Geddes is a security specialist who's CEO of International Corporate Protection.

15:46This makes me think of the hoax threats that were made across hundreds of schools in Serbia, Hungary and the UK back on the 19th of October. The scenario with these particular airlines, the question that goes immediately to my mind is they are all very different airlines and they were all departing from different embarkation points and going to different destinations. So there was no commonality other than they were airlines. Does that then make you think that it's likely that these threats were connected or are unlikely to be connected? I think ultimately they are connected. As to why these particular airlines were issued with these threats, now that's the big question.

16:34And what we will often do in our world will be to reverse engineer as to why it would have happened, why those airlines, what was their objective in terms of were there any demands. And although we're unlikely to know any specifics about how the threats were issued, ultimately down to the airlines themselves, what assessment processes they had to be able to determine the credibility of these threats. You know, one doesn't want to give any potential bad actors any clues who might be listening. But in terms of establishing credibility, I assume there is a certain threat threshold for airlines and for those who are in charge of air traffic safety.

17:17Can you give me some insight into where those are set? They will look at how the threat was received, i.e. how was it communicated? Was it in person? Was it through an intelligence agency that alerted them to a potential plot that could have potentially sort of been in the making? The second thing will be the content of that threat. It will be a case of, is there any more context, any more content, if you like, and meet to that particular message? And also, is there a group or an individual that is claiming responsibility or is it anonymous? Look at this in the context of all the other disruption that we've seen in recent weeks and months when we think about the drones flying over airports, think about the hacking of power grids, for example, in Poland, supermarkets in Europe having their fridges and freezers tampered with.

18:13Do you think this sort of disruption of maybe probing weaknesses and responses of people trying to get in between the connecting tissues of daily life, is this something that you think is likely to be all part of that? In this instance, this isn't necessarily the actions of a hostile state actor. And you have to look at the particular mechanics of what was the ultimate objective of causing that disruption, whether it be a refrigerator's temperature units being turned up to thaw out food, or whether it be bomb threats against schools, or whether it be bomb threats against airlines, for that matter.

18:53And that was the security specialist, Will Gerriss.

19:00Last year in the Netherlands, nearly 10 ,500 people died from euthanasia. An assisted death is only legal if a request is voluntary and a person's suffering, psychological or physical, is assessed by doctors as unbearable, with no prospect of improvement. Of those who died last year, 120 of them chose duo-euthanasia. That is, they received a lethal injection at the same time as a loved one. In 2024, Linda Presley met a couple who decided this was the way they wanted to end their lives. Jan was 70 and in continual physical pain. His wife, Els, was 71 and had been diagnosed with dementia. But even in the Netherlands, a nation with one of the most liberal right-to-die laws in the world, allowing the assisted death of people living with dementia is still contentious.

19:49Sometimes this is about timing. A person who has dementia and requests euthanasia must be assessed by doctors as still having the mental capacity to decide for themselves that they want to die. If that is at all in doubt, they're unlikely to be accepted. Linda's returned to the Netherlands and met Jan and Els's only son, Bas. It was three days before they died by lethal injection that Jan and Els recorded an interview with me in their camper van in the north of the Netherlands. My life is completed. I don't want no pain anymore. Yeah, there is no other solution for this. Else qualified for euthanasia because she was assessed by doctors as suffering unbearably due to her fear of how her Alzheimer's would progress.

20:41Jan was eligible because of his ongoing chronic pain. Their son Bas recently listened again to his parents in that edition of Assignment on the BBC World Service. Hearing them on the documentary, it was so surprising again how convinced they were of their decisions. Imagine you're sitting there and three days later you're going to a place where you will die. They sound so relaxed. That was my impression too. but at the same time it seemed to me this adventurous couple could have easily continued living as they were and I asked them about that in 2024. Is there at all a feeling that you might be doing this just too early?

21:27I don't know I don't know I don't know. What do you say else? No no no no I cannot see it. Perhaps we die too early it could be but I have lived my life. Right and how do you feel about it Elsie? That is with that one right? I cannot I cannot go beyond that. When Els talked about not going beyond that she means her Alzheimer's getting worse so she'd be deemed incapable of making decisions for herself especially about deciding she wanted to die. In the Netherlands it's very rare for doctors to approve euthanasia for people with advanced dementia. At her clinic in the Erasmus Medical Centre in Rotterdam, Dr Rosmarine van Bruchem, a geriatrician and ethicist, spends a lot of time talking to her dementia patients about the timing of their euthanasia requests.

22:21Now it's too soon, but maybe next month is too late. So how do I decide at what point I need to start this process to see if I meet the criteria, to see if I can get euthanasia. And if I wait too long, might I have missed the window? So there is a debate and kind of a fear that people will apply for euthanasia sooner than they actually want to. And we don't want people to request euthanasia too soon. It should be, and it should remain, the ultimate solution because life is no longer worth living and there are no other options to better that life. Bas has been reflecting on the experience of losing both his parents in the same moment.

23:09It's been an arduous journey of grief for him. Now, nearly two and a half years on, does he think Jan and Els went too soon? I think they could have stretched it for another year, for sure. But the whole thing is that, I mean, for my dad, he was sitting there already for what I mean, he was in this situation for 10, 15 years. So he could have stretched it probably for another few years. For my mum, looking at the progression of dementia, probably she could have extended for another year, I think so. But then I think waiting for another year, then she got into trouble not being capable to make the decisions.

23:46And if that had been the case, Els may not have qualified for euthanasia at all. And that was Linda Presley reporting from the Netherlands. You're listening to NewsHour.

24:27power the succession story. Listen on bbc.com, the BBC app, or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

24:42Welcome back to News Ad. This coming Friday is Danteras, the most fortuitous day of the year for Hindus to buy gold, and Diwali follows Hardenet's heels on Sunday. The precious metal, though, is now worth about double what it was four years ago. So who's making money and who's missing out on the gold rush? Sam Fenwick has been following the money for Business Daily.

25:07This is Renu Sharma in her office in Delhi, asking her staff to bring out some of the gold jewellery that she sells. It is 22 carat and this is all 22 carat gold that people buy. This one weighs 190 grams and it costs nearly 3 million rupees. That's more than 30 ,000 US dollars. India love gold. It is in our DNA. Even you can't afford anything, but you must have gold. Gold for any family is not just gold. It is our sustainability, our rainy day saving. But India mines almost none of its own gold. So nearly every gram starts in a mine abroad. And right now, it's very good business. In the spring, it cost the average miner about$1 ,900 to produce an ounce of gold, against a selling price of about£4 ,500.

26:06John Reid of the World Gold Council, the industry body funded by miners, says that miners don't get to set the price gold sells for. Mining companies are by and large price takers. They sell whatever they produce, whether it's coal, whether it's iron or whether it's gold, at the prevailing market price. So the gold price has gone up dramatically and that's allowed gold mines on average to have really high margins. When gold reaches India, the government takes a cut. In May, it more than doubled the duty on imported gold from 6 % to 15 % as the rupee fell. Whoever brings the gold in pays it, and it ends up in the price of every gram.

26:51Back in Delhi, Renu adds a making charge, 15 % on a handmade necklace and about a 3 % sales tax. But she says very little of it stays with her. Because the main cost here is the cost of my gold. Out of 15%, I would have given 13 % to the labour. So my saving is 2%. I'm working on very thin margin. If a family ever sells, they get back only the value of the gold, not the making charge or the sales tax. On Renu's necklace, that's nearly$5 ,000 gone. Gold is now more than a quarter below its January peak and the miners are still doing well. The family at the end of the chain pays last and has no guarantee its gold will hold its value.

27:42And that was Sam Fennec reporting. Just a reminder of some news that broke shortly before we came on air, and that is that Spain's transport minister has resigned nearly a week after a terrible rail accident that killed 69 people. Oscar Puente had been under mounting pressure to step down in the wake of the country's second major rail tragedy in less than a year.

28:13You're with NewsHour, live from the BBC. I'm Tim Franks. It was a week ago that Israel held its general election, and we appear still to be a long way from knowing who will form the next government. Today, for the first time since that election, the parties in the main opposition bloc met. One big question for them, would they try to cooperate with Arab-majority parties who won a record 19 seats? You might think that surely the opposition's number one priority would be to ensure that Bini Minnetanyahu, not be allowed to return as Prime Minister, and for the most right-wing coalition in Israel's history not to return to power?

28:47And if so, why not cooperate with the Arab majority parties? A question for Anshul Pfeffer, Israel correspondent for The Economist. The problem is that to form a majority coalition, you're going to need at least five or six of the 11 parties which have been elected to the Knesset. And every party has different conditions of who it's prepared to sit with in a coalition, What are the conditions for doing so? And some of the Jewish opposition parties are categorically against sitting with the Arab parties because of various positions that they have regarding Israel's Jewish identity and regarding the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict.

29:26And the same goes for those two Arab parties. There are different approaches among them. Ra 'am, the conservative or moderate Islamist party, wants to be part of a coalition, whereas the joint list does not want to be part of a coalition because it doesn't want to take joint responsibility for various government decisions. But it does want to be a safety net or a confidence and supply junior partner. And then there are other parties who are potential partners. There are orthodox parties which have been ruled out by some of the opposition parties. but some of them are more open to dealing with them.

29:58And then there's the biggest question, perhaps will they sit in a unity government with Netanyahu despite having promised to replace him? So you have a series of election promises made by different parties and in order for there to be a government in Israel, someone will have to break some of his election promises. Anshul, I know we're talking about several different Jewish-Israeli parties here that may have slightly different flavours of objections, but can you go into a bit more detail about what specifically their issue is about bringing predominantly Arab parties into a putative governing coalition?

30:34There are the more immediate reasons that, despite the Arab-Israeli politicians having condemned the massacre of October 7, they haven't been prepared to call Hamas a terror organisation. There's a deeper concern over the more fundamental ideologies of some of the Arab parties, which are against seeing Israel as a Jewish state. And there's also the concern that having those parties in a coalition or having a coalition reliant on those parties may limit the room for decision-making in future issues such as another war with Hamas in Gaza. Anshul, can I just ask you about something else that has sort of rather caught us by a little bit of surprise?

31:13Donald Trump appeared on Fox & Friends on American Breakfast TV earlier today and said that the nearly$4 billion subsidy that America offers Israel to buy US weapons, that that's going to end by the end of this year. What do you make of the announcement? The issue itself has been in the air for a long time. Nathanael told us as The Economist in January that he's planning to taper off that$3.8 billion annual subsidy in 10 years. And I've known for a while, talking to sources, that this is an issue that the Americans and Israelis also realize that at some point are going to come to an end. But I think the timing of all days on the day of the midterm election is surprising.

31:56The fact that Trump is saying that it's going to end at the end of this year is surprising because it was expected to be something more gradual than that. So, I mean, we're still trying to make out what exactly Trump means and what the deal is. He claims that Netanyahu knew about it. But from what I understand, not everybody in the Israeli security establishment which knew that this was something which was going to end so soon. Does this mean that America will still sell the same arms, just Israel will have to pay more? Does it mean there will be more strings attached to how Israel uses those arms or whether they use them in the West Bank or Gaza, etc.?

32:29And then there's going to be a question of, will America also start blocking certain arms systems for sale to Israel? We'll have to see who's going to be controlling Congress and the Senate over the next years and then who the next president is going to be. But many things that were taken as a given in the Israel-U.S. relationship are certainly no longer guaranteed.

33:13Thank you. Allegations involving large numbers of girls and young women has said that were his name to come out, he would be highly likely to kill himself. Helen Lewis is a staff writer at The Atlantic magazine who believes that such an injunction could make a dangerous precedent. Why? If you say that a subjective assessment of mental health is a reason in order for stories about someone not to be published, that has obvious repercussions and the ability to be misused. And in this case, I would say that the two media organisations that involve, which we can now say are ITN and The Guardian, did approach the celebrity with a very extensive right of reply.

33:53So that's one of the things that's very key, not just to a libel defence, but also ethically. The person should have a full ability to see what all the accusations are against them, to be able to provide contrary evidence and to be able to have their denial in full on the record. That stuff is all really important. The other thing that is interesting is to consider whether or not there may be mitigations. litigations. And this is something that the judgment does talk about, you know, what mitigations could you possibly have in place, such as a publication date that is fixed, right, so that somebody will know that that's, you know, they won't have to wake up every morning wondering if today's going to be the day that the article comes out.

34:25And I think that those are things that a media organisation might think about being a not unreasonable request to answer. What I do think is unreasonable is the idea that you should never be able to have these allegations litigated in public. And what about a date of publication or broadcast which allows, for example, for there to be the chance of the subject of this story who's, you know, said I may kill myself to have medical treatment to see if the risk could be mitigated that way. In other words, to delay publication or broadcast. Right. But I would say that these, you know, these allegations have been in process now for quite a while.

35:01And we do know from the court filing that the media organisations have spoken to more than 100 people for this investigation. So these are very long and thorough investigations. So I think that is all part of how it will be judged in the court of public opinion. And as you say, it is an incredibly tricky situation. We are now much more attuned to people's mental health. And no media organisation wants to think that they've contributed to someone's mental health crisis or suicide. What I would say is that there are other people involved in this case. There are three complainants who are anonymised in here.

35:32Those people also have a right to be heard and a right to life and a right to speak. And that's what makes this very difficult. It's not just about one person's mental health. There are multiple people's mental health involved in being weighed up in this case. Britain, England anyway, because English law is separate, is often seen as a sort of an interesting place where these issues are thrashed out. How do you see the balance of press freedom at the moment in this country? It's very odd for me because I work across America and the UK. In America, you can't even really libel a public figure unless it's done maliciously, unless you know what you're saying is wrong in advance.

36:07So America, you know, and some other parts of the world do have very different free speech standards from Europe. I can see both sides of that. You know, the American discourse can be very helpful to minority people with minority opinions sometimes. It can also be extremely brutal. You know, I covered the Cornell alleged rape case and everybody involved in that really has had their private details published all over the internet. The glare of publicity can be really brutal. So I don't think that this is kind of easily cut and dried in the sense that there is obviously one shiningly right path.

36:39It is, and I think the judgment makes very clear, it is about weighing up the right to publish versus someone's right to life, right to privacy, all these other kind of things. But ultimately, what worries me is, is it just this case? What happens when the next person comes along or the next person comes along? And that was Helen Lewis from The Atlantic magazine. One of the first rules of journalism is not to read out press releases, but I'm afraid I can't resist the opening paragraph from Cambridge University today. After a search lasting more than four decades, a UK-led team of physicists have found evidence for the rarest decay of a subatomic beauty particle ever seen.

37:17The results could open the door to a strange new world known as the Zeptoverse, where particles that could help explain mysteries like dark matter and how matter came into existence during the Big Bang may be hiding. I mean, what's not to like about that? Anyway, the physicist who led the analysis team working on this at the Large Hadron Collider near Geneva is Dr Harry Cliff. What were they looking for? Particle physics as a subject is all about understanding the most basic building blocks of the universe. And this is a journey that began 130 years ago with the discovery of the electron. And since then, we've been zooming in and zooming in and zooming in on matter.

37:53And we've discovered the nucleus inside that, protons and neutrons inside that, quarks, and then most recently, the Higgs boson. And every time we've gone to sort of zoom in further to shorter distances, we've discovered new particles. So in a very broad sense, what we're looking for are new basic ingredients of our universe. And we think these new particles must exist to explain mysteries like dark matter, which makes up the vast majority of the stuff in the universe. But we have no idea what it is made of fundamentally. And this particular breakthrough is we found this way, essentially, by measuring a very, very rare process to get information about what might exist at distances of about a zeptometer.

38:31So this is what we call the zeptoverse or distances 100 billion times smaller than an atom. And we think it's in this very, very tiny world that these new particles that could explain these big mysteries might be hiding. So this breakthrough really tells us for the first time or one of the first times about what you would find in the zepto world. and hopefully in the future it will lead to a major discovery of something new that will help us solve these big mysteries. It is amazing, obviously, the scale at which you are working, but also was this a process that you were actively looking for? It was posited and now you've found evidence for it or was it just a surprising by-product that you looked at and thought, what could this be?

39:09No, this is something we knew should exist. We have this theory that describes the make-up of our universe called the Standard Model of particle physics and it predicts this process should occur, but it should occur incredibly infrequently. So you essentially need 10 billion beauty particles to be made before you see just one of these decays. So it's almost impossible. And the reason it's impossible basically is that the fundamental forces that we know about in physics can't really make this decay happen. And the reason this is such an important process and why people were looking for it is they knew that it would be very, very sensitive to the existence of new particles.

39:43So new particles essentially can, through quantum mechanical magic, change how often this decay would happen. And so what we're trying to do is to see if this decay happens at exactly the right rate that our standard theory predicts. But what we hope to see, actually, is that it's happening at a different rate, one that isn't predicted by our theory. And that would tell us about the existence of new particles in this septoverse. Right, and potentially also give us an insight into this strange world of dark matter and dark energy. Yeah, indeed. I mean, we're in this extraordinary position. that we have.

40:11This standard model that we have is amazingly successful. It describes basically every experiment we've ever done, but it's spectacularly incomplete. We know from astronomy that 95 % of what's out there in the universe is invisible. It's made of these two things called dark energy and dark matter. And these are just words for basically to cover our ignorance. We have no idea what these things are actually made of. And so what we hope is that this sort of measurement in the future, if we can collect more of these decays, we'll get more precise and we'll be able to hopefully probe into this Zeptoverse and find those new particles that can explain dark matter.

40:43I mean, it's not just dark matter. There are other things we might learn. So for example, one of the other big mysteries in physics is that this standard model predicts that the universe should not exist. Everything should have been annihilated by antimatter during the very first moments of the Big Bang. And again, to explain that, the fact that we're here, we believe there must be new particles to find and this could help us unravel that mystery. Dr Harry Cliff, absolutely fascinating, knocking on the door of the Zeptoverse. You're listening to NewsHour. This is NewsHour from the BBC. One in a Million is a new documentary filmed over ten years following a Syrian family who fled fighting in Aleppo in 2015 and eventually travelled through the Balkans to Germany to seek refuge.

41:24The filmmakers Itaba Zam and Jack McInnes followed through that arduous journey and then the challenges of building a new life in the totally new culture of Germany, before years later returning to Syria after the fall of the Assad regime. The story particularly focuses on the eldest of four children, Isra. She was just 11 years old when she met the filmmaker Itab Azam, who was also born in Syria. Newshouse Rebecca Kesby has been speaking to both of them. Itab first described the film in that initial crucial meeting with Isra. We went to Turkey in 2015 to what was called the refugee crisis in Europe.

42:02Everyone was talking about it. We were hearing a lot in the news. And we went to make a film about people crossing and doing the journey. We did that journey many times with other families and other refugees. But we kept going back to Turkey because we thought we haven't got the story that we really wanted. and one day I was we were just standing in this square called Basmani Square in Izmir where like it's really a busy square with people selling life vests and you know the swimming rings and all sorts of stuff and it's where people do deals refugees and smugglers and out of all these miserable faces the face of this amazing woman appeared in front of us when she was a child back then.

42:46She was smiling and she started talking to us very curious about the camera and what we were doing and all of that and that's how all started and we talked to her father and they were like really, they wanted to tell their own story and they wanted us to be with them in the journey and that's how it all started. And the face you mentioned is sitting right alongside you. Isra, welcome to NewsHour. Do you remember that moment? What was your memory of that moment? so hello everyone and my first one when I saw Itab I was so excited to meet her because I think I heard how she speak Arabic and she was like different not like the woman from my family and I was so excited to meet her and to know more from her and I think to learn also from her In what way was she different?

43:41Because the woman from my family, all of them take hijab and she didn't do it. And I was 11, so I don't really understand what's different. I was just very, very excited. Yeah. And so you did this filming over the course of 10 years. And as you say, Isra, you were only 11. So, I mean, these are really important years in anybody's life. And then to be filmed during those years in quite a traumatic situation with your family fleeing a war and having to try to live in a new country. What was it like? That was not easy. That was a very hard time for me and my family. but and then in my opinion I found that was very important for all the world to see how we can change us how we can live with other people because we are different we are looking different we are thinking different like the other people but we can live together so yeah it's very important for me.

44:51And Itab, in terms of making the film, that's a big commitment, isn't it? 10 years. Were there any challenges for you in covering this story for that long? Yeah, I mean, it's crazy, really. So, so many things happened in the 10 years. And we were really young when we started and enthusiastic. We didn't have a child. When we decided that we want to cover the story and like be there with them every step of the way. We gave up our flat in London because, and so we were on the road for a long time, you know, sleeping in the street, taking long journeys in the mud. And so it was physically really difficult.

45:32Emotionally, it was really difficult. And you are Syrian yourself, of course. I am Syrian, yes. And lots of my friends were doing the journey and lots of people I knew were doing the journey. But after the journey we were in Germany, we have to do other jobs because we didn't have money for three and a half years. So we were doing full time jobs alongside this film. So it's also a burden. And then we had a child and Israel had children and the whole dynamic changing. And like Israel changed, we changed and we have to maintain the trust between us and them the whole time for 10 years. Isra, when you finally saw the film and yourself, you know, growing up over the 10 years, because you're married now, your husband's actually listening into this interview.

46:21That's kind of a very, that's a long way away from being that 11 year old child. How did you feel looking back over those years? This is really crazy to see your half life on TV or in the cinema. And you have made a trip back to Aleppo since the Assad regime. fell a couple of years ago. What was that like? So I was very happy. And at the same time, I feel I am different. So it's not like before when I was child in Syria, it's everything has changed. And I feel I was more German in Syria. It's I mean, the issue of refugees and And migrants in Europe is constantly being spoken about in politics.

47:08It's a real issue all over the continent. What does looking at the story in this form, in a film, with a character like Isra, a real person and a real family, what does that do to the understanding for Europeans of this story? I mean, we are really hoping for more empathy and understanding. That's what we hope for. But like many people that we talked to after watching the film, like people take from it different things. You know, some people told us like, oh, I saw my I have more empathy for my parents. Like, you know, like the parents sacrificed. And but also like the story of Israel and her family in Germany is not unique.

47:55Syrian refugees are going through these issues and problems. and that is the reality of families arriving in Europe. We want to show the reality of refugee families' displacement and what they go through because not every migrant is a hero or not every migrant is a villain. And Itab, very briefly, it was a good choice then, wasn't it, when you first spied Isra on the road there to make her the subject of your film? 100 % like we fell in love with her from the first moment and we're still in love with her. Thank you. You heard it up. Azam and Isra both talking to NewsHour's Rebecca Kesby. Don't forget, we've got special coverage of the midterms anchored by our very own James Kamarasamy coming from Washington, D.C.

48:46in just one hour's time. He's going to be pulling a late night and a long night in Washington, D.C., but he'll be staying faithfully with the story. And, of course, you can keep up to date with all the results and the analysis as it comes in here on the BBC World Service and across BBC News websites and TV as well.

From the publisher

Interviews, news and analysis of the day’s global events.

More from Newshour

All episodes