

This episode is a BBC NewsHour live broadcast plus other segments. Main topic: early exit-poll results from Israel’s general election and what they imply for coalition-building. It discusses projected seat counts (Likud/Netanyahu bloc around 50–52 seats; opposition bloc around 53–54; Arab-Israeli parties projected around 17–18 seats), record Arab turnout, and why excluding Arab parties makes a majority hard.
Netanyahu may declare victory but likely cannot form a government; the Israeli president (Herzog) will consult parties and may favor Gadi Eisenkot; far-right parties may fail to pass the threshold; absentee/military votes (~600,000) could affect final results.
Netanyahu’s campaign rhetoric about Arabs; Likud supporter reaction (“Bibi, King of Israel”); discussion of coalition arithmetic in the 120-seat Knesset.
Joe Floto (BBC Middle East Bureau chief); Dor Halap (Likud central committee member); Rula Hardal (Shalom Hartman Institute research fellow); Lazar Berman (Times of Israel reporter); Nuka Tanopalski (journalist/commentator); Avigdor Lieberman (comment via statement). Other segments include Sam Fenwick (Bank of Japan rates in Japan), Kerry Allen (Kylian Mbappé in China), Oliver Stunkel (Brazil politics), and Regine Vadinathan (Russia-Ukraine ceasefire near Oleschki).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion of the exit polls from the Israeli election and initial results.
“Gadi Eizenkot will succeed to build a government.”
Exploration of the difficulties faced in forming a coalition after the election.
“So currently it's 53 or 52 votes to 50 for Benjamin Netanyahu's bloc.”
Analysis of Benjamin Netanyahu's potential to remain Prime Minister despite challenges.
“And the arithmetic doesn't work if you exclude the Arab parties.”
Discussion of Likud's strategy and the public's perception of Netanyahu's leadership.
“of what the exit polls tonight suggest he's going to get.”
Debate over Netanyahu's record on security and the implications for his leadership.
“and when we speak about security and the way that we handle things which are the most important to us about Iran, about how to treat the international issues.”
Continuation of updates and discussions on the Israeli election results.
“Much more to come here on NewsHour on the Israeli election.”
Discussion with Rula Hardal on the implications of exit polls in the Israeli elections.
“Let's get some more reaction to what the early indications from the exit polls in the Israeli general election point towards.”
Reports and reactions to the Israeli election results and potential government formation.
“She's also the Palestinian co-director of a joint Palestinian-Israeli political organisation called A Land for All, Two States, One Homeland.”
Learn about the implications of Netanyahu's coalition collapse and the political landscape in Israel.
“Nuka Tanopalski is an Israeli based journalist and commentator.”
Explore the political ramifications of Flavio Bolsonaro's potential move to the US.
“No, Gatónal Palski will be back in Israel before the end of the programme.”
Discuss the humanitarian situation in Oleschke amidst a ceasefire and its effects on residents.
“Oliver, just very briefly, if you would, how far do you think these money laundering allegations may have influenced voters in the second round of the election?”
Understand the fallout from Kylian Mbappé's comments and their impact on his image in China.
“We'll be back with the Israeli general election before the end of the programme.”
Explore the fallout from Mbappé's comments and their implications in China.
“Mbappé has crossed a red line and Mbappé knows the taste of humiliation but does not understand respect.”
Understand the dynamics of the recent Israeli elections and Likud's challenges.
“Let's return to our top story this hour.”
Analyze the role of absentee ballots in influencing the election results.
“So we're talking about 600 ,000 absentee votes in a universe of 7.3 voters in the election.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:10Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts or find us on YouTube.
0:41Hello and welcome to NewsHour. It's coming to you live from the BBC World Service studios in central London. I'm Tim Frax and we have one major story. It's not our only story tonight, but it is tonight London time. and Jerusalem time, but it is a major story, and that is the Israeli general election. The polls closed just over an hour ago. The exit polls came in swiftly from the major broadcasters in Israel, and this is how they sounded on Israel's Channel 12.
1:26Gadi Eizenkot will succeed to build a government. The Likud, the biggest flag in the world, and it comes to the responsibility. Well, the news from Channel 12, and it was not entirely reflected elsewhere, but more or less, that the Likud party led by Benjamin Netanyahu, the long-slepping prime minister, in Channel 12's exit poll anyway, had 24 out of the 120 seats in the Knesset, the Israeli parliament. Yashar, the main opposition party led by Gadi Isencott, 22 seats. These exit polls need to be treated with enormous caution, especially at this time. And given the perils of building a coalition in Israel, I got the latest from our Middle East Bureau chief, Joe Floteau.
2:13They don't tally up completely. But the main two that we're trusting tonight, Channel 12 and Can News, the state broadcaster, They both have Gaddy Isencott, the challenger, have his bloc narrowly ahead of the governing coalition. Not by much. So currently it's 53 or 52 votes to 50 for Benjamin Netanyahu's bloc. Another headline is that Benjamin Netanyahu has managed, it seems, if these are proved to be true, to have the largest party in the Knesset. and it also seems that the Arab parties, the parties that represent the Arab citizens of Israel, have emerged with a record number of seats and that would chime with what we've been hearing all day, that the Arab population of Israel, which ordinarily doesn't vote in huge numbers, has decided that this election is too important and they've come out in a massive show of electoral force.
3:09And yet, although you would imagine that those Arab parties would be forthright in their denunciation of Benjamin Netanyahu and the most right-wing coalition in Israel's history, it doesn't then follow that they can team up with the opposition change bloc. Because presumably if they did, well, I mean, take 53 plus 17. I realise these are notional figures. But then you've got potentially a block of 70, which is easily over the majority in the Knesset. But tell me about why that doesn't necessarily follow. So this has been a tricky issue during the run up to this election because most of the Jewish parties in opposition to Netanyahu who have ruled out a formal coalition with the Arab parties, even though they represent 20 % of the population, because of the electoral sensitivities of that, because the public opinion in the Jewish side of Israel didn't really want it.
4:10And it's been a stick with which Benjamin Netanyahu has relentlessly beat the opposition throughout the campaign, and today in a flurry of social media posts, many of which not only bordered on racists, but were flat out bigoted. was set to scare the Israeli Jewish population into voting because he said the Arabs were coming to topple his government. And because of that constraint, then we've got a mathematical problem here. The 120-seat Knesset requires 60-61 seats to get a majority. And the arithmetic doesn't work if you exclude the Arab parties. Now, people have said lots of things in Israeli election campaigns and then do a complete 180.
4:58And this may be something that they have to do. The other option, of course, is that in order to get rid of Benjamin Netanyahu, everyone holds their nose, votes in a minority government, which traditionally in Israel hasn't been a very stable configuration, and then they go for another election, but with another politician, probably Gaddy Isinkot, as prime minister. But we're all getting ahead of ourselves now. the results don't start coming out till midnight and there's a huge chunk of absentee votes the military, almost 600 ,000 or estimated around 600 ,000 votes probably about 10 % of the total haven't been counted yet they won't start counting those till tomorrow and those results won't be through until Thursday and that is a young demographic that's been fighting for three years and many of them if the opinion polls are to be believed skew much more right wing than Gadi Eisenhower.
5:55In the meantime, Joe, I mean, you've been following Israeli politics for many, many years. It sounds just in conclusion as if you're saying this has been a bit of a wounding night for Benjamin Netanyahu so far. But, I mean, presumably from your big experience, you'd say he's such an experienced politician, such a whiz at doing politics, one shouldn't discount the possibility that he might continue to be Prime Minister. Look, I fully expect him this evening to declare victory. Most of the opinion polls for the last month have not put his party above Gaddy Eisenkopf. In fact, they've had him four or five seats shy of what the exit polls tonight suggest he's going to get.
6:43And because he's the biggest party, he will feel a moral right to be invited to form a new coalition. But that's not how the rules work here. The president of Israel, who's largely ceremonial, this is where he comes into his own, he has full discretion to consult with all the party leaders, to sit down and make a judgment call as to who has the best chance of forming a government that can win a vote. Not even a full majority, but can win a vote in the Knesset. And given that for Benjamin Netanyahu, teaming up or relying on Arab votes or abstentions is not going to happen, then that choice for the president may well go to Gaddy Eisencock.
7:26But that process doesn't even start until next week and can play out for the next two months. The BBC Middle East Bureau Chief Joe Floto. Let's get some reaction from Likud shortly after exit polls closed. I spoke to Dor Halap, a member of Likud's central committee. First of all, this is for sure a failure of the party itself. As far as it looks from the first data that arrived to me, that the results will not be so dramatic. It will be that Likud will be the biggest party, as you just said, and our big media channels are saying. But the thing is that the people do believe in the leadership of Netanyahu, but they don't believe in the Likud's party.
8:23And specifically, they don't believe on the specific coalition that we had in the last four years. That means that in the international arena and when we speak about security and the way that we handle things which are the most important to us about Iran, about how to treat the international issues. People do trust Netanyahu, but they don't trust most of the civil issues that have been led by this coalition. It's slightly hard to say with such confidence, isn't it, that people do trust Netanyahu, even on what is supposed to be traditionally his strong territory, security, dealing with Iran and so forth.
9:11I mean, I haven't got the precise figures in front of me, but I think it was 20 % of the electorate, or even less than 20 % of the electorate, voted for Likud, and a huge number of people, I mean, you must be aware of this, are absolutely furious with him on the security issue because they say it was his security, his lapse over security that preceded the October 7th massacres. So when you look in the data, okay, last time Likud had 32 seats, but in percentage Likud was more towards the area of 28 to 29 seats, but a very left-wing party didn't pass the threshold. So most of the votes went to the Likud last time, okay, four years ago.
9:58So between 29 seats to 25 seats, as we see now, it's not such a big... But yeah, the whole coalition have been dropping from 61 to around 50 or 51. But there was more a substantive point that I'm not sure how many Israelis would share your view that he is still Mr. Security. I mean, put aside all the other issues that they have with him. So why did they give 25 seats to Likud? You know what I'm asking? So there is no any other explanation for that because, and you can also see that Likud's campaign was mainly about those issues and almost didn't speak at all about the civil issues. In the perspective of most of the Israeli citizens, let's say Yoav Kish, the minister of education, he was terrible.
10:47That's why no one spoke about education in Likud's campaign. OK, well, let's talk about one of the things that Mr Netanyahu is very keen to talk about a lot, and he has been talking about just recently, and that is Iran. Let's look at his record on that. I mean, in June last year, as I'm sure you're aware, he announced behind a lectern in the prime minister's office, we have achieved a historic victory that will abide for generations on Iran's purported nuclear threat. I believe we spoke, me and you here spoke on this platform also. Yeah. So so which then begs the question as to why he felt the need to go back to war in February this year with the United States and why indeed he has been pressing publicly for a resumption of the war, because he says the only thing that can deliver Israeli security now is is not just destroying Iran's nuclear capabilities and its ballistic missiles.
11:47He says there has to be, we have to deliver regime change. So he hasn't delivered on one of his central promises that he announced last year. I totally agree. I agree with you. And I believe that the, look, Netanyahu during the war has spoken highly about the full victory. OK, and also about Iran. He spoke like the way you have just explained. And that in the way of the citizens, how they look on the situation. has definitely brought a high bar of standards for what, but then reality hits our face, which was not that simple. We saw that even though we had an amazing first round against Iran, it was not enough for changing the regime.
12:34Even though we were striking them, we were hitting them, we were controlling all the area of Iran and still was not enough. And maybe the conclusion, Doris, that the iron fist, I mean, you can keep on smashing the Palestinians, smashing your near neighbors, smashing Iran. It doesn't bring Israel security, ultimately. I definitely disagree with that. I just believe that we should finish the job. And Netanyahu has failed in the way that he is explaining his way to the Israeli people. And he was setting the bar, the standards way too high. And then reality was not that easy for us. You know, we were facing a very tough reality here.
13:17And we're still facing that. But the people of Israel, they say, you promised this, you promised that. And where is that? But the reality is not that simple. And that was Dor Halap, a member of Likud's Central Committee. Much more to come here on NewsHour on the Israeli election.
13:37But we'll be looking at some other stories as well, including the fact that two Chinese firms have cut commercial ties with the French footballer Kylian Mbappé after he appeared to mock the former Chinese leader Mao Zedong. as I've been hearing from our China media analyst Kerry Allen. You see him on the side of buses and on billboards so it will be really quite a shock to the Chinese public that suddenly they're opening newspapers and turning on the TV and seeing that he said something that, quote, harms the Chinese people, hurts the Chinese people. That interview with Kerry Allen coming up in the second half of our programme.
14:16Our main headline this hour, we've been hearing exit polls in Israel's general election. show that the opposition bloc has a slight edge, but not enough seats, the main Israeli broadcasters reckon, to form a government on their own.
14:39This is NewsHour, live from the BBC. Let's get some more reaction to what the early indications from the exit polls in the Israeli general election point towards. And Rula Hardal is a research fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem. She's a Palestinian political scientist. What does she make of the exit polls, which suggest, among other things, that the parties representing the Arab-Israeli citizenship of Israel, they have about 20 % of the population, that they've done extraordinarily well? Well, first of all, these are the results that we are now, all of us seeing and watching, will give us quite good indication about the end results of this election.
15:34And in this, there are many things to say carefully. First of all, the powerful position and electoral size of the Palestinian parties inside Israel. The second is the weakness or the new weakness of the very far-right parties like Utsma Yehudit and Tzionud of Bitzalels Motrach and Ben-Wir. Jewish power and religious Zionism, yeah. Exactly. This is very important. And the last thing, I do believe that according to these results and carefully, I'm saying that this election has weakened Netanyahu and his bloc and his coalition definitely. And I don't see good chances for him to rebuild his coalition.
16:39I do see much more chances for Yashar party headed by Gadia Eisenkot. And what do you think? I mean, clearly, if these exit polls do come into fruition, are what the end result is? So, you know, the Arab-Israeli parties getting 17, maybe even 18 seats. That will obviously suggest that there's been very high turnout from Palestinian citizens of Israel. What do you think has driven them to the polls? What do you think they are hoping for from this election? Well, first of all, they were driven by their silencing, by their fears, by their existential fear, I would say. from this government and its policies.
17:31I mean, Netanyahu's government over the last four years. Second, it's voting against the Israeli democracy and it's a kind of opposing the Israeli democracy. What do you mean by that, voting against Israeli democracy? Yeah, I mean that they don't believe that the Israeli political system is democratic the way it's democratic for the Jewish citizens. In what way, though? Can you explain? Legally and also politically. If you see the whole political discourse, or if you follow the whole political discourse prior to the elections in the last couple of months, it was mainly about excluding them and taking off any legitimacy of their role as equal citizens, of being equal citizens in the election.
18:35And forgive me that time is relatively short, but just on that, briefly, do you think that there is a chance now that actually the opposition bloc, led by Gadi Eisenkot, it may actually show flexibility and say we are willing to cooperate with these Arab-Israeli parties? First of all, they have to, according to these results. And we were saying also that before, knowing the results. These are facts. The second thing, yes, I do believe that the chances of the Arab list, led by Mansour Abbas to be part of a coalition, are now higher than any day before. And we know about not public conversations between Eisenkot and Mansour Abbas.
19:27But even if they are going to be in the opposition, they are going also to protect a weak government led by Eisenkot. And that was Rula Hardal, research fellow at the God Center at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem. She's also the Palestinian co-director of a joint Palestinian-Israeli political organisation called A Land for All, Two States, One Homeland. Well, as is important to say and just, well, to repeat, really, Israel's exit polls do have a fairly checkered history when it comes to their accuracy, particularly when the races are seen to be tight. What we do know for certain is that turnout was extraordinarily high, not far short of 80 % of eligible voters casting their ballots, according to Israel's Central Election Committee.
20:24Well, a lot of eyes are on Likud election headquarters in Jerusalem. It'll probably be a little while before the big politicians turn up there to try and get ahead of the story. But Lazar Berman is there for the Times of Israel. He's normally their diplomatic reporter. What's his initial take on the exit polls? I think the big story here, first of all, as you were talking about, the turnout from the Arab-Israeli parties, again, a lot of this is reacting to some of the policies, a lot of the statements from this government, especially to Marbengvir. What he's done is actually driven up the Arab participation in elections to record numbers.
21:06So that's number one. Number two, these small parties, there was a reservist party and a party by Ofer Winter, which Netanyahu himself has been attacking, even though it's a right wing party, didn't come close to the threshold. And that will take away votes that could have gone to the government as well. So what we have here, I think, is what many feared, that the big party is Likud, the bigger bloc is the opposition bloc. And it's not clear how we make a government out of this. And do you think that turns ultimately on how far they are going to be willing among themselves to countenance some sort of cooperation with the parties that represent Palestinian Israeli citizens?
21:51That is only an option for the opposition bloc, of course. Yeah, indeed. Right. So it could be that they'll be willing to go into a minority government with regular support, and then that will allow everyone to say that they've kept their promises. We know that President Herzog is going to have a very big impact now because he's going to do whatever he can to make sure we're not going to another round of elections. And I just want to get, you know, kind of think of a wild scenario here that maybe President Trump, who has no qualms about interfering, might invite people, might invite the party leaders all to the White House and say, listen, I have two years left.
22:24I have a lot I want to do. Figure it out amongst yourselves quickly and let's get to business. And what about the other, well, one of the many other options that people are talking about, which is that lots of people are suggesting there could be a resumption, full scale resumption of the war against Iran that Mr. Netanyahu obviously stays on as acting prime minister until a new coalition is formed. And during that time, because it's wartime, he announces that there should be a national unity government. I mean, do you think that can fly? That could happen. Ultimately, the decision to go to war on Iran, we've seen, sits in the White House.
22:59You know, if Trump decides because the midterms are over, he wants to go back, and there is a very big chance of that happening, then it could happen. If he says, no, I think it won't happen. Netanyahu has the authority to declare war or to order military operations. And it could be a way for everybody to say that we have to do something different and go back on some of our promises. Ladies and gentlemen, Times of Israel, diplomatic reporter at Likud election headquarters in Jerusalem. One of my BBC colleagues at the Likud HQ has just said that Likud supporters are chanting Bibi, King of Israel.
23:35So they clearly retain hope.
24:01Welcome back to News Am. More on Israel and the general election coming up shortly. But at the end of this week, the Bank of Japan will decide whether to raise interest rates again. They're currently at their highest level for more than 30 years, which is good news for savers, but obviously comes at a cost to some, as the BBC's Sam Fennec reports. Bathroom. This is Noriko Sakai's flat in Sapporo in the north of Japan. She bought it two years ago with a mortgage fixed at 0.8 % and that deal runs out in March. I can either go variable or I can do another fixed rate, like fixed three years, five years, 10 years, but which is going to be higher than the variable.
24:48Four percent would be a bit tough, I think, monthly. I might have to sort of start thinking about doing, you know, side work. Using her bank's published rates, we worked out that payments will rise from about a thousand US dollars a month to somewhere between 1150 and 1320, depending on the deal she picks. When the Bank of Japan put rates up by a quarter of a point in September, the country's three biggest banks passed all of it on to borrowers. Savers got a tenth of a point, and not until November. Sajiro Takeshita spent 14 years as an executive director at one of those banks, Mizuho. If we see the interest rate rise, you see the shares of the banks advancing very strongly, if not exploding in many cases.
25:40Sayori Shirai sat on the Bank of Japan's policy board for five years. So banks were suffering from low profitability, but now this interest rate rising cycle, the banks are increasing their margins. So banks are very profitable right now. Japanese households keep almost half of their savings and investments as cash in the bank. That's more than 7 trillion US dollars. Sejiro Takeshita says very few people think of it as an investment. I don't think that they see it as an investment vehicle. They consider that as almost like your cash box almost, I think. That's the notion that many people have.
26:21Most of the Japanese public don't really see the interest rate rise as part of their investment, but more like they're a very big, strong piggy bank. In that sense, I think banks are lucky because they won't get accusations about possibly making a lot of too much money when the rate starts to rise. In a Bank of Japan survey this month, 58 % of people said their living conditions have got worse over the past year. Asuka Kowabara, who moved her own savings out of Japan, doesn't expect them to make too much noise about it. The difference between Europe and Japan is that Japanese people do not protest.
26:56people will just suffer quietly. If rates go up again at the end of this week, the bank's record so far suggests borrowers will feel it first. Sam Fenwick reporting from Hokkaido in northern Japan. To hear more about what Japan's rate rises might mean for savers and borrowers, you can listen to Business Daily at bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts.
27:31This is NewsHour live from the BBC World Service with me, Tim Frax. We're going to head back to the Israeli general elections. I can see that Avigdor Lieberman, the leader of the right-wing Israel Betenu party, I say right-wing, but he's part of the opposition bloc. He's just making a statement. He's a first party leader to react to what the exit polls have suggested. And those exit polls do suggest that the opposition bloc may have a slight lead over the one led by the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. Nuka Tanopalski is an Israeli based journalist and commentator. What does she think is the headline?
28:15Well, I think the headline has to be a collapse of Netanyahu's coalition. He entered Election Day today with 68 out of 120 Knesset seats, and he's ending the day with a projected 50 seats. That's a loss of 18 if these exit polls numbers hold, as you said. The other thing I think we have to add to that is, according to these projections, Netanyahu simply has no way to form a government. So that implies the end of his rule, even if the results look initially at first glance a bit mixed, because the opposition bloc without the Arab majority parties appears not much greater than Netanyahu's, hovering at around 53 or 54 seats.
29:09But I think that's a mistake. The Arab majority parties have won an estimated 18 seats. They're absolute kingmakers. And I would be surprised if the opposition bloc does not find some way to try to form a government, even if it's a minority government, with the backing of these parties. Yeah. But I mean, again, I mean, without wanting to get too lost in the weeds and we have to be very cautious about these projections from the exit polls. I mean, within the opposition bloc, even if some of the parties decide that, you know, they're happy to cooperate with these Arab majority parties, there are some in this opposition bloc who have absolutely cast iron, ruled it out and say that it would go against everything that they stand for.
30:00And so it's not necessarily that easy for the opposition bloc to get to the point where it would have a majority in the Knesset. It's not easy. It's, of course, legal for a minority government to be formed. But it is possibly potentially a challenge. We should say the smaller of these two Arab majority parties has as its number two very much a Jewish man who was number two in the Israeli version of MI5, of the Shin Bet in Israel. He's a very well-known law and order type, Faldioff, Segalovic. And it shows, I think, that the wager made by the head of this party, Mansour Abbas, a very shrewd politician, has paid off.
30:54And if even just this one party that cannot really be called an Arab party, it's an Arab majority party. If they join, you would see Gadi Eisenkot again if projections hold with 60 or 61 Knesset seats. Of course, looking forward, the danger, as you said, is that one of his coalition partners could peel off, that it would be an unstable government. But for now, the clearest result we're seeing is that Netanyahu has no way to form a new government. No, Gatónal Palski will be back in Israel before the end of the programme. We've got an intriguing story out of Brazil. Well, actually, now it's been taken on by the US State Department, which says it will issue visas to Brazil's defeated hard-right presidential candidate Flavio Bolsonaro and his family so they can come to the US.
31:50This follows reports that Mr Bolsonaro had left Brazil despite a court order banning him from doing so. Before we got this news from the State Department, I spoke to Oliver Stunkel, Associate Professor at the School of International Studies at Fundação Getúlio Vargas in Sao Paulo. What did he think of these reports? Well, it seems increasingly likely that, in fact, Senator Flavio Bolsonaro is about to arrive in the United States. There have been discussions about that after he lost the elections on Sunday. 24 hours ago, a pre-court justice asked Flavio Bolsonaro to turn in his passports because he's facing money laundering investigations.
32:36Flavio Bolsonaro expressed the fear that these could lead to his imprisonment. His father is also in prison for having attempted a coup after losing the election four years ago. and his brother Eduardo Bolsonaro is already in the United States after having been convicted of seeking to mobilize the US government to interfere in Brazil's domestic affairs. So that has been a big discussion, not entirely surprising. However, Flavio Bolsonaro initially after the election said he would like to lead the opposition. So if he in fact has left Brazil, that would also have significant political impacts for the right in Brazil.
33:16Yeah, well, I mean, one wonders, and I understand that, you know, I need to carpet this with caveats that we've yet to have any confirmation that he is en route to the United States. But one wonders how that news might be received, I mean, by both wings in Brazil. I mean, presumably the authorities would be dismayed if they say that he's got questions to answer about money laundering investigations. But as far as the large section, large minority of the population who voted for him, I mean, I guess it would be a disappointment to them, wouldn't it? Absolutely. And he has promised several times that irrespective of the result, he would lead the opposition.
34:05After all, he's also been part of an effort for legislative elections where he's been really successful. So his party represents the biggest bloc in the Senate and Congress. And even having lost the presidential election, the right is actually quite influential to shape Brazilian politics for years to come and potentially run again in the future. So that is certainly for his supporters a disappointment. And there's a lack of clarity of who would lead the opposition now that Lula is set to start his fourth term as president. But again, it's not entirely surprising given that Jair Bolsonaro four years ago also spent time in the United States in the midst of the coup attempts.
34:58But all this will obviously also have a potentially negative impact on US relations, Brazil's relations to the United States, which are already quite rocky. And now there's yet another key politician, in addition to Flavio's brother, Eduardo, now the defeated presidential candidate, Flavio Bolsonaro. Oliver, just very briefly, if you would, how far do you think these money laundering allegations may have influenced voters in the second round of the election? Well, there's a lot of cynicism in Brazil about the political system, about the political elite. Both sides accuse each other of being corrupt.
35:36But in fact, the amount, the frequency of revelations about potential crimes committed by Flavio Bolsonaro are likely, yes, to have had some impact and may partially explain how Lula was able to turn things around before the runoff. Oliver Stunkel, Associate Professor at the School of International Relations at Fundusau, Jatulia Vargas. We've got news of a respite, a very partial respite in the Russia-Ukraine war. It's a ceasefire covering Oleschke. That's a town under Russian occupation in the south of Ukraine. And it's been a place, even by the harsh standards of this long war, a place of utter terror and desolation.
36:17About 6 ,000 people are thought still to be trapped in Oleschke and its environs. trapped without food, water and electricity. Many residents have told the BBC they've resorted to cooking garden weeds to survive. New South's Regine Vadinathan has been speaking to Sehi, who's in the city of Kherson. That's still under Ukrainian control, but it's just across the Dnipro River from Oleski. For the last several hours, we do not hear explosions. So I can prove that ceasefire is from both sides. So the skies are quiet and clear today? Yes, yes. There are some drones, but they do not attack. They're just looking.
36:59Have you been able to speak to anyone in Oleski this morning? Actually, right now I do not have connections to people who are over there right now. And just tell us a little bit about Oleski. They have a huge problem over there. No food, no medical treatment for people, no electricity, no water supply, no heating. And it looks like a total catastrophe, you know. People cannot live like people, you know, like humans. That's very bad. We had a chain of events. Initially, Russians exploded the Kochovsky power plant in Kochovka. and part of the Oleski was flooded with water. Yeah, so Oleski suffered twice in a way because what you were describing there was the destruction of the Kakovka Dam?
37:51Yes, exactly, yeah, Kakovka Dam and power plant used to be over there. Are you hopeful then that this ceasefire will allow much needed aid and humanitarian assistance into Oleski? We hope that it will be because nobody can guarantee the future of the people who stayed there. And tell us about how your son and daughter-in-law were able to leave Oleschke when they did. That was last year, wasn't it? They travelled through Russia to Western border and now they're located in Bulgaria. And are you hopeful that other people will be able to leave in the way that they did? Yes. The problem is that the people who remained over there are mostly of old age and it's difficult for them to travel or to move somewhere, someplace.
38:38So I hope that they will have the opportunity to escape that place. How do you feel about this local ceasefire? Yeah, that looks like a miracle, actually, because for several years they're shelling her son from Oleski. So it looks like a miracle right now that we do have total silence. So it's something unusual. And it was announced that this truce was actually brokered by the American First Lady Melania Trump, wasn't it? What was your reaction to that? I personally am very grateful to Melania Trump. It's great help and real help. Such assistance is very, very welcomed. Does this give you any sort of hope that there might be a wider, longer term ceasefire in Ukraine?
39:30I do not sure about that. And mostly, I do not trust Russians first. We all hope for that. You live in Halson. It's across the river from Eleshki. It's now in Ukrainian control, but it was under Russian control before. What was that like? That's the most horrible time I've ever had in my life. I cannot express my feelings in a couple of words. We also did have a lack of food. We'd had problems with medical treatment. Even my younger son was taken by a Russian secret service and spent several days investigating him. And they put the gun towards his head and he was threatened to death. Thanks to God, they released him from that place.
40:19So he asked that we not use his family name, but he was in the city of Kherson speaking to Rajini Vajinathan. This is News Air.
40:32This is News Hour from the BBC. We'll be back with the Israeli general election before the end of the programme. But just to step away for a moment, because Kylian Mbappé, he may be one of the world's most talented, most famous footballers, but he's just tripped himself up very publicly. This is what the French striker had to say when he appeared on a podcast called The Bridge and was asked the innocuous question about which meme involving him makes him laugh the most. the one that makes me laugh the most when people put my face on a video of this guy i think he's a chinese dictator i use this a lot with my friends he thought it was just a light-hearted comment about a meme that superimposes his face on what appears to be an image of the founding leader of communist china mao zedong the joke is that mbappe has often been portrayed as a dictator because of the control he exerts not just on the pitch but within the clubs he plays for.
41:28It was a joke that fell very flat in China, as I've been hearing from the BBC's China media analyst Kerry Allen. It's been such a major story. Today the official broadcaster in China CCTV has said that it's no longer going to show Real Madrid matches with Kylian Mbappe in, they're not going to show adverts that he features in. Lots of Chinese companies that he had cooperation deals with have severed their ties, they've said they're no longer going to work with him and a lot of the social media hashtags that I've seen on platforms like Sina Weibo, which would be the equivalent of a platform like X or Facebook, they've been using hashtags like Mbappé has crossed a red line and Mbappé knows the taste of humiliation but does not understand respect.
42:11Right, so I mean the fact that he has now apologised for what he described as ill-judged comments doesn't sound as if that has particularly quenched the flames. No, there have been stories like this in the past where it does take a while for China to really accept the apology. I think it will be positively received that he did apologize so quickly. But I remember a very similar story back in 2019, where the basketball team, the Houston Rockets, their coach, Daryl Morey, he posted a pro-democracy slogan for Hong Kong that was anti-communist party on the social media site x and what happened was that again cctv the official broadcaster said we're no longer going to show any nba games featuring the houston rockets lots of sportswear brands they they suspended cooperation with the basketball team and it went on for months so with this story it could go all the way up to la liga the spanish football league when i've been looking at pictures on this today you see them on the side of buses and on billboards so it will be really quite a shock to the Chinese public that suddenly they're opening newspapers and turning on the TV and seeing that he said something that, quote, harms the Chinese people, hurts the Chinese people.
43:25It also, I suppose, just underlines the extraordinarily central position that Mao Zedong still occupies in China, or at least, I guess, in official China. I mean, he's been dead for 50 years. And this is a historical understatement. I mean, he had a mixed record when it came to governing the Chinese people. I mean, millions upon millions died during his decades in power. But nonetheless, he is seen as still seen as untouchable. Absolutely. I mean, you can still go to many cities in China and see huge Mao Zedong statues. He's highly revered. He's seen as the father of the Chinese Communist Party.
44:08But one thing about China is that it has a very tightly controlled media environment that is highly saturated by government outlets. So it's very difficult to see anything negative about the Communist Party. And that was Kerry Allen, our China media analyst. Let's return to our top story this hour. Today's general election in Israel, the polls closed just under two hours ago and there were exit polls pretty much immediately. Exit polls to be treated with caution in Israel, especially in what appears to be a fairly tight outcome. Tight because it does suggest that the main opposition bloc has a small edge over the governing bloc that is led by the current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
44:57Israeli-Arab parties are deemed to have done well. Also, Uga Boshega is at the Likud watch party for us in Jerusalem. What's his sense of how Likud is going to play this now? I think, you know, the exit polls, as you've just said, have put Likud on top. So it is likely, I think, that the prime minister will try to paint this as a victory. Although, as you just said, it's the opposition that seems to have emerged as the largest group, short of a majority, but the largest group in the upcoming Knesset. So no clear winner. You know, these numbers suggest no clear path here for the formation of a government.
45:43And I think this is going to put a lot of pressure on the Israeli president. So we obviously need to wait the official results. The president, after the results are confirmed, will be consulting parties to invite the leader he believes has the best chance of forming a government. So what is likely to follow here is weeks, talks and negotiations for a coalition to be formed. And I think we should expect, you know, the prime minister, despite the results of the night, to be trying to be the man to be asked by the president to form the next Israeli coalition. There's been a bit of talk about how far the absentee ballots could swing this or influence just, you know, where the final results come.
46:30Now, absentee ballots, I think then normally it's normally something like only as much as eight or 10 percent of of the of the votes. But these are these are ballots that are delivered particularly by members of the military. How far is there a feeling that that could be important in a tight election? Yeah, I think we need to wait the results, the numbers to see, you know, to confirm the exit poll. So we're talking about 600 ,000 absentee votes in a universe of 7.3 voters in the election. And let's not forget, you know, there's been massive turnouts. And according to the numbers, you know, we were on track to have, you know, record turnout.
47:20out. So it could be that they could have some kind of influence in the final numbers once those confirmations come through. And that was Hugo Boshega at Lekud headquarters in Jerusalem. That's it from this edition of News Ave. We'll of course be keeping across the story here on News Ave and the additions to come here on the BBC World Service and we've got a live page up on our website bbc.com forward slash news. It is difficult to read too much into these exit polls, but let's just try and put this in a little bit of context. In the 2022 Knesset election, Benjamin Netanyahu ended up with a governing coalition of 64 MKs out of the 120.
48:09It looks from this, if the election exit polls are correct, that actually he now controls only about 50 members of the Knesset. 70 members of the Knesset have vowed to get him out of power. That's it from this edition of NewsHour from all of us here. Thanks for listening.
48:36Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.
Interviews, news and analysis of the day’s global events.