Germany's far-right AfD bids for their first taste of power in eastern vote

6 Sep 2026 · 44 min · 19 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Germany’s Saxony-Anhalt state election and the AfD’s bid for power; implications for Germany’s post-war political order and coalition politics.

Guests

Ulrich Siegmund, AfD leader in Saxony-Anhalt; J.S. Tyler, AfD supporter; Jess Parker, BBC Berlin correspondent in Saxony-Anhalt; Markus Ziener, visiting senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund; Lesia Vasylenko, Ukrainian MP (Holos), on US envoys’ Ukraine-Russia talks; Francis Fukuyama, US political philosopher; plus campaign and voter voices.

Key claims

AfD could be first post-war far-right extremist party to hold state-level power; other parties vow not to coalition with AfD, making governance uncertain. AfD policies described as far-right/hard-right: hard-line immigration with “deportation task force” and “remigration,” pro-Russia stance, defunding “anti-German art,” controversial memory-culture views, and LGBT “rainbow flag” bans in schools.

Notable examples

AfD rally rhetoric (“take back the country”); market-square selfie campaigning; 5% threshold for parliament; coalition “firewall” risks.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

The Context of the Election

1:18 to 2:21

Exploring the significance of the AfD in the Saxony-Anhalt election.

“It's coming to you live from the BBC World Service studios in central London.”

Voices from the Rally

2:21 to 4:33

Ulrich Siegmund and local voters share their perspectives on the AfD.

“of the AfD in Saxony-Anhalt, and he spoke at a rally on Saturday.”

Analyzing AfD Policies

4:33 to 6:52

A detailed look at the AfD's policies and their implications.

“And for the AFD, they see it as part of their stepping stone towards bigger, better things.”

Potential Outcomes of the Election

6:52 to 11:40

Discussing possible election outcomes and their implications for Germany.

“They're pro-reopening ties with Putin's Russia.”

AfD's Campaign Strategy

11:40 to 14:00

Insights into how the AfD is campaigning and connecting with voters.

“that, again, there will be a sense from voters that, you know, there's a sort of establishment stitch up here, that they're being disenfranchised?”

J.D. Vance's Controversial Views

14:27 to 14:58

Discussion on J.D. Vance's comments regarding American heritage and citizenship.

“Vance, our vice president, has been pushing this line about heritage Americans.”

US Envoy Visits Ukraine

14:58 to 15:10

Report on the US envoy's visit to Ukraine following Russia's invasion.

“One headline for the BBC newsroom, the top US envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are in Kiev today for their first talks in Ukraine since Russia's full-scale invasion.”

Volcanic Eruption Strands Passengers in Indonesia

15:10 to 16:48

Coverage on the impact of Mount Anak Krakatau's eruption on travel in Indonesia.

“You're with the BBC World Service and live from London, this is News Hour with me, Tim Franks.”

Health Concerns from Volcanic Ash

16:48 to 18:20

Discussion on health risks posed by volcanic ash for residents nearby.

“And any idea from the authorities how long this might carry on for?”

Venice Film Festival Highlights

18:20 to 20:19

Preview of the Venice Film Festival and introduction of a notable film.

“You can let the thoughts go away when they come.”
Show all 19 chapters

Director May Al-Tuhi: Women and War

20:19 to 22:34

Interview with director May Al-Tuhi on her film about women post-WWII.

“Yeah, and so they were actually called horizontal collaborators by some.”

Challenges for Female Directors

22:34 to 23:33

Discussion on the struggles and recognition of female directors in the industry.

“You're one of only two female directors at the Venice Film Festival this year, which I have to say, when I saw that, I was very surprised by.”

Upcoming Segments on NewsHour

23:33 to 24:04

Teaser for future discussions including an interview with Francis Fukuyama.

“And that was May Al-Tughi, director of Women Unknown.”

World Gravedigger Competition

24:44 to 28:00

Report on the annual World Gravedigger Competition in Hungary.

“Get more with BBC Podcasts, wherever you listen.”

Gravedigger Competition Report

28:00 to 28:36

Learn about a unique competition taking place in Hungary.

“And that was Wendy Urquhart reporting on the Gravedigger competition taking place in northern Hungary.”

The End of History Revisited

29:50 to 32:48

Fukuyama discusses his original thesis about liberal democracy and its implications.

“When he came into the NewsHour studio, I asked him what he meant by that.”

Challenges to Liberal Democracy

32:48 to 36:31

Fukuyama reflects on the current threats to liberal democracy and changing perceptions.

“It's also very hard to know, you know, under what circumstance that counter reaction would appear.”

Impact of AI on Democracy

36:31 to 41:18

Fukuyama speculates on how artificial intelligence could affect democratic institutions.

“begin to undermine the argument that the end of history was, it was not about suggesting that, you know, nothing was now going to happen in the world.”

Ukraine's Perspective on U.S. Negotiations

42:00 to 45:30

Gain insights into Ukraine's skepticism about U.S. diplomatic efforts with Russia.

“Lesia Vasylenko is a member of parliament in Ukraine for the opposition Holos party and joins us live from Kiev.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30most to investors, including policy initiatives for retirement savings, taxes and trade, inflation concerns, the Federal Reserve, and how regulatory developments can affect companies, sectors, and even the entire market. Mike and his guests offer their perspective on how policy changes could affect what you do with your portfolio. Download the latest episode and follow at schwab.com slash Washington Wise or wherever you listen.

1:00your business, remember this number, 10 ,000. That's the number of new businesses that join Odoo per month. Join Odoo today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

1:18Hello and welcome to NewsHour. It's coming to you live from the BBC World Service studios in central London. I'm Tim Franks. And we're beginning in Germany, in what may seem like slightly strange territory for a global news programme like ours, because we're talking about a local election and also one taking place in one of Germany's smaller regions, Saxony-Anhalt. And yet, with voting well underway there, the word that keeps on coming up in the reporting of these elections is seismic, because the Alternative für Deutschland party, the AfD, is hoping to secure a majority in the regional parliament, and an outright win would mark the first time a far-right Party has held state-level power in Germany since the Second World War, since the time, in other words, when the Nazis were committing some of the worst crimes in the history of humanity.

2:08The AfD has held a huge lead in the opinion polls going into this election. Whether it's enough to secure power, given the other parties a vow that they won't go into coalition with the AfD, well, that's the key question. Ulrich Siegmund is the leader of the AfD in Saxony-Anhalt, and he spoke at a rally on Saturday. We know that our beautiful fatherland does not have much time left. Every day counts. It will take a long time to rebuild what they have been destroying here for over 20 or 30 years. I'm starting right now, my friends. Let's make history tomorrow. Let's take back the country. Fingers crossed.

2:47What though are those in Saxony Anhalt unpersuaded by the AFD's programme? One will explore in a bit more detail in a moment. This photo was one of those to express concern. I'm very worried and I view the whole situation very critically. I vote for democratic parties. I'm committed to that. But I think that regardless of the results, the mood among people will change. And those who are openly more right populist in their views will then also appear more openly on the streets. And this might also lead to more conflicts among citizens. It is the AFD, though, who've had a huge lead in the opinion polls going into this election.

3:24And J.S. Tyler is one of their supporters.

3:30These elections are very important, not just for Saxony and Holt, but for the whole country, because there must finally be positive changes that benefit the people, rather than working against them, as has been the case for many years now. After all, migration is getting out of hand. We have nothing against foreigners, even if we as AfD voters are branded as Nazis. The BBC's Berlin correspondent Jess Parker is not in Berlin at the moment. She's in Saxony-Anhalt. She's one of those who's used the seismic word. Why? Alternative for Deutschland have been growing in popularity and now they are on the verge, although we've got to be clear, we do not know what's going to happen.

4:13Voting is underway. But they're on the verge potentially of taking power for the first time at a state level. So that in itself is a huge moment for Germany because it's just a very controversial political movement here. It would be the first time that the far right would have held that kind of power in the post-war era. And for the AFD, they see it as part of their stepping stone towards bigger, better things. But for example, Friedrich Mertz, the conservative CDU chancellor, is already in quite a bit of political trouble. he's in the doldrums, poor poll ratings, this could be a further dent in his authority.

4:53So there's quite a lot there in terms of that context as to why this really matters for Germany, even though this is a small state, 2 million people. Much to pick out of what you've just said. One of the things I want to get a bit more detail on is us talking about the AFD as a far right party. I mean, I know that they've come out with a sort of enormous 250 page program of for government in Saxony Anhole. But can you explain to me what you think they're sort of their big ticket items are? What what leads them to be described as a far right or hard right party? Yeah, I mean, look, I think we have to always be clear, all these types of terminology, they are things that are used to summarise a party, and then you get into the detail of the policies that they espouse.

5:45And worth saying, the AFD say they're a conservative libertarian movement. But in terms of their policies for Saxon-Anhalt, and you're right, it's an extensive manifesto. They take a very hard line on immigration, so they talk about setting up a deportation task force. They use the word remigration in their manifesto, which has become an increasingly slippery term, But certainly an interpretation of it that has been written about by people on the far right is the idea of the mass deportation of people with migrant backgrounds or the kind of pressured campaign to make people leave who are of migrant backgrounds in their millions and millions in Europe.

6:27here in Sachsen-Anhalt, where obviously they don't actually set nationwide immigration policy, but they say what they want to do is focus on getting people to leave who are here illegally or whose visas have run out. So people that shouldn't be in Germany anymore and they want to speed that up. So that's what they say they're referring to in this context as remigration. I think party critics suspect that it actually goes much further. So that's one of their policies. They're pro-Russia. They're pro-reopening ties with Putin's Russia. The party talks about wanting to defund what it calls anti-German art.

6:59It wants to create a kind of more patriotic atmosphere in Germany. It describes German memory culture, which is the idea of facing up to the Nazi past as a guilt complex. Now, that's quite a controversial thing to say here in Germany. And they want to do things in schooling like ban the flying of the rainbow flag, the sort of flag associated with the LGBT community. So that's a flavour of some of the policies that they are talking about locally, but also how that feeds into their kind of national perspective as well. When do you think we will know how everything is going to sort itself out, whether they can govern in some way or whether a coalition of smaller parties can be cobbled together to govern in their stead?

7:45Later this evening, when the polls close, we get a projection. There's this big question over whether these smaller parties are going to reach the 5 % threshold. And some of them have been hovering very closely around that mark. And you need to hit 5 % in order to get into Parliament. The more parties that get over their 5 % threshold, the less likely it is that the AFD is going to be able to take a parliamentary majority. We should be getting an idea, unless it's crazy tight this evening, and then possibility one the afd takes an overall majority and that's pretty clear picture or possibility two nobody's got a majority and presumably we'd be looking at a world where other parties are seeing if they can form a coalition but that has the potential to be very messy because if you're excluding the wire the brand the firewall if parties are saying they're not going to go into coalition with the afd how are they going to cobble together a coalition of lots of parties without it being a bit of a political nightmare.

8:43The BBC's Jess Parker in Saxony-Anhalt. So let's look further at how this election, albeit in a fairly small region, could reverberate right across Germany. Markus Ziener is a visiting senior fellow with the think tank the German Marshall Fund. He's in Berlin. How significant does he think this is on a local but also national level? I think we have to put it a little bit in perspective. I mean, Saxony-Anhalt is a state that's very small and the impact actually on governing and governance in Germany on a federal level are limited. I think what really counts here and why it attracts so much attention has simply to do with the fact that it could turn out to be the first state in post-war Germany that has a right-wing extremist party in power.

9:30So I believe that would be a big blow for the chancellor. So it would reverberate on the federal level. But that's something that has to be seen, actually, depending on the outcome of today's election. And just to pick you up on that point, when you say a big blow for the Chancellor, I mean, clearly, you know, whenever the main opposition party picks up votes, secures an election victory, it's a blow for the incumbent. But I mean, Metz himself, the Chancellor, he came into office saying, with me, I will beat back the far right. And he's, I mean, it seems as if the trend is entirely the other way.

10:14Yeah, he was even more blunt in saying and promising to cut the number of supporters of the AFD in half. And what happened was actually just the opposite. I mean, the AFD has increased not only in Saxony Anahalt, but also in general in Germany. So for the chancellor, this is a huge problem from many perspectives. One of them is, okay, how should the CDU, his party, the Conservative Party, how should they act? How should they deal with the AFD? I mean, this has the potential to tear the party apart because there is one part of the CDU that's saying, well, we have to somehow to build an alliance with the AFD.

10:57And then there's another part saying we can never team up with them. And probably tonight, if the election outcome is such that the AfD can only govern with the help of another party, we'll have a very dangerous discussion from Mr. Merz's point of view. And you could also see it. I mean, and, you know, lots of people are suggesting that, I mean, obviously that the AfD has been riding high in the opinion polls and they're likely to be the largest party, but not necessarily secure an outright majority. in which case there could be an option whereby, you know, the other parties try to scrabble together some sort of unwieldy coalition.

11:39But how far do you think that that has inherent dangers, that, again, there will be a sense from voters that, you know, there's a sort of establishment stitch up here, that they're being disenfranchised? Yeah, it depends basically whether the Green Party makes it into the parliament or not. if the Green Party is crossing the 5 % threshold and they have seats in the parliament, it seems very unlikely that the AfD will have an absolute majority of seats in the parliament. But what then? I mean, if the AfD is, and they will clearly be the strongest party, but then basically all the other parties have to, well, form an alliance in one way or the other to govern against the AfD.

12:23Is this going to play in the hands of the AfD in the long run? Because then they could make the argument, well, you see, we are the strongest, but they do everything to prevent us from governing. That's an open question. And secondly, the CDU has clearly stated that they do not want to form a coalition with the far left. But that's probably what's needed in order to prevent the AFD. It sounds as if you're saying this is an election. I mean, clearly, We have no idea how it's going to play out. But how it does play out could have huge implications way beyond this relatively small region. Absolutely.

13:06And it has already quite some implications. I mean, I have been on the ground and looking at how the AfD is campaigning in Jericho, that it's a small town in Saxony Anhalt. And it was really interesting to see how the top candidate, Ulrich Siegmund, is actually doing his campaign. He was talking to basically each and everyone at the market square where I was and where I was watching this and patting people on the back, just asking how they are doing at work, doing selfies for hours actually until the really last person on that market square was able to have a selfie of himself with the potential new prime minister on the smartphone.

13:45So it's a campaign that works very much on the emotional level, while the incumbent Prime Minister Sven Schulze is more of the guy who's talking from the bully pulpit and very rational. And I think that the established parties have not found any way to counter this kind of campaign. Markus Zina speaking to us from Berlin. This is a story we'll be keeping across very closely here on the BBC World Service.

14:15Also coming up on NewsHour, the political philosopher Francis Fukuyama on his concerns about the direction and the strength of American democracy. J.D. Vance, our vice president, has been pushing this line about heritage Americans. If you can trace your ancestors back to at least the Civil War, that you're somehow more American. I think it's terrible. Donald Trump wants to upend the 14th Amendment and birthright citizenship. That affects me personally because my mother was in the United States on a student visa when she met my father at the University of Chicago and had me. And under those rules, I wouldn't be a citizen if those people had their way.

14:58Francis Fukuyama in 15 minutes. One headline for the BBC newsroom, the top US envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are in Kiev today for their first talks in Ukraine since Russia's full-scale invasion. We'll be looking at that a little bit later.

15:15You're with the BBC World Service and live from London, this is News Hour with me, Tim Franks. In Indonesia, more than 150 ,000 passengers have been left stranded after a volcanic eruption forced officials to suspend operations at six airports. The volcano, Mount Anak Krakatau, between Java and Sumatra, began erupting and hurling ash high into the sky on Friday. Lisa Tambunan is the BBC's correspondent in Indonesia and joins me now. Lisa, what is the latest on this? Is the volcano still active? The volcano is still active. It's been active since, as you mentioned earlier, since Friday. And this is impacting flights in the surrounding area.

16:05It is located in the Sunda Strait, which is located in between Sumatra and Java. But it's impacting beyond just its closest vicinity and sending volcanic ash into Jakarta, which is some distance away from the volcano itself. And this has closed down the airport today and impacted more than 700 flights and hundreds and thousands of people left stranded. So the impact is huge. And any idea from the authorities how long this might carry on for? They are giving updates every few hours or so. But as of tonight, there's no signs of reopening the airport until this is now late Sunday in the evening. So it's almost coming toward 24 hours since it was first shot earlier this morning.

17:15And there have been efforts to limit the volcanic ash airborne with disaster response teams planning to conduct cloud seeding operations. This is to trigger rain in an attempt to disperse the airborne ash. But there are some challenges to this due to the dry season with limited clouds to actually be able to induce rainfall. And just in terms of, I mean, you mentioned about the disruption to flights. I mean, for people living close to this volcano, and presumably there are concerns about health effects, just briefly. Yes, there are. With the volcanic ash being sent to the surrounding region, health authorities have advised residents to stay indoors with warnings of respiratory infections as well as risks to skin and eye diseases.

18:13So people are advised to wear masks if they do have to go outside for whatever activities. Lisa Tambunan in Jakarta thank you very much for bringing us the latest

18:29The world's oldest film festival in Venice is now in its 83rd edition it's underway and among films in competition this year our sister programme on the BBC World Service weekend picked out one directed by May el-Touki the Danish-Egyptian director who's one of only two female directors taking part this year in the festival. Her film premieres later today. It's entitled Woman Unknown. You can decide to be scared of it. You can let the thoughts go away when they come. You can decide not to be sad. You can learn to push away sad thoughts. That's the main character, Maria Nanni, talking to the young girl she looks after.

19:13The film is set in the Danish capital Copenhagen in the aftermath of the Second World War. It tells the story of Marie and her secret, the relationship that she had during the war with a German soldier. When Julian Warwicker caught up with May Al-Tuhi, she told him first why she had picked on this complex era of post-war life for her film. There was a lot of saved up anger in the immediate aftermath after Second World War in Europe, many places in Europe. And for Denmark specifically, because we chose a politic of collaboration with the Germans to avoid too many casualties, it's understandable that you would get angry at people collaborating.

19:53At the same time, that was the official politic of the country. So that makes it a messy matter to tell a story about and therefore, for me, more exciting because there's something to debate and talk about. Because people felt, correct me if I'm wrong, that those women, by doing what they did, had effectively gone against their national identity at a time when that mattered so much to people. Yeah, and so they were actually called horizontal collaborators by some. In wartime and in post-war, the female body has always been regarded as part of the kind of national identity, national territory. And that's also what the film is about, basically, the female body as a battleground.

20:38And what that means in a private setting and what that means in a public setting. And sometimes these people, I mean, they were hunted down, weren't they, for what they had done? Yes, and quite violently, they were shamed in the street, humiliated, spat on. You would cut their hair. And then given that time where migration wasn't as common as it is today, people didn't necessarily leave their hometown. So often these women would live in that town that had shamed them and their children would suffer as well. So what we see now is the grandchildren of these women who are starting to, you know, share their stories about their parents who were born out of these relationships.

21:22Which is fascinating. I mean, I was going to take the conversation to the present day and you've gone there before I did. And I wonder what kind of emotions those grandchildren were expressing now that they knew the stories of their grandmothers. I think they look at their grandmothers with a more sympathetic, gracious gaze and with more nuance, which makes sense because my mother is 80, for example, now. So she's born in 46. And so for her, these women were something she heard about, but she would definitely take a stand on the people who spent time with the Germans. I think there is an opportunity now to tell stories about that time where we can maybe be more nuanced and add, you know, a favorable complexity in order to reflect on what went down and also to some extent talk about how can we deal with future conflicts of that sort.

22:22I talked to a historian at some point who had been helping me out, and we talked about the concept that men often pay with their lives during war and women pay with their bodies. I mean, one final question, which is about you and your craft, really. You're one of only two female directors at the Venice Film Festival this year, which I have to say, when I saw that, I was very surprised by. What does that say to you about women at the top of your industry at the moment? I've encountered this many, many times throughout my career, being the only one or maybe one of a few. So it's not a big, big surprise, but I would have hoped that I had more female colleagues in competition.

23:05It is a very structural problem. Even the budgets I work under compared to male colleagues, the talent I can attract, the actors who say yes. And sometimes even the media write about the male director genius that I have never encountered with a woman. So, and not that I think I am one, but just to say that it's so severe, this structural problem, and therefore it's really important that we keep talking about it. And that was May Al-Tughi, director of Women Unknown. It's having its world premiere at the Venice Film Festival later today. She was talking to my colleague, Julian Warica. do stay with us if you can here on news hour we've got much more to come in the next 30 minutes we've got a long interview with a fascinating man one of the world's top public intellectuals francis fukuyama and we'll be hoping also to bring you the latest on steve wickhoff and jared kushner who have made it to kia for their first talks in ukraine since russia's full-scale invasion of four and a half years ago

24:16John Deere is putting in work and putting up highlights. Oh, man, look at those passes. Tillage, planting, harvesting. Three years in, and these pre-owned machines are still at the top of their game. We're talking reliability, performance, and long-term potential. And get this, these veteran machines can pick up the latest precision tech with ease. You know it, and fans ready to add John Deere certified pre-owned equipment and more options to their lineup, can shop at machinefinder.com. Booyah! Get more with BBC Podcasts, wherever you listen. Be the first to listen to your favourite shows, like Evil Genius, Good Bad Billionaire and You're Dead to Me, with a subscription to BBC Podcasts Premium on Apple Podcasts.

24:58You can also enjoy a range of our podcasts ad-free with an Amazon Music subscription.

25:06Welcome back to NewsHour. For a while, apparently, Hungary had a bit of a shortage of gravediggers. And so back in 2016, it launched what it called the World Gravedigger Competition. The event was so popular that it now takes place every year. And this weekend, cemetery workers from all over the globe descended on a town in northern Hungary for the big dig. Wendy Urquhart has this report.

25:36with shovels in hand the 19 teams of two got down to business in the hope of winning the 2026 world grave digging competition and it's no mean feat the earth is so hard in some places that they have to use pickaxes joseph varga from the hungarian cemeteries association says it's Fun for the competitors and the crowds that come to watch, and it also shows the public just how demanding the job actually is. When relatives arrive at a funeral, the grave is already dug. They don't see what actually precedes it. When videos of the competition became more widespread year by year, they saw how hard and stressful it was physically and psychologically, and now they have more respect for the gravediggers.

26:23This contest is also a PR exercise for the trade. There's not enough room for mechanical diggers in some graveyards, so digging by hand is the only other option. And the hope is that this event will shake off some of the taboos surrounding death and persuade young people to join the industry. To make the competition fair, each team pulls a plot number from a pot before the event begins. And just in case you're wondering, winning is not just about digging a hole in record time. There are rules involved. Each grave has to be exactly two metres long, 80 centimetres wide and 1.6 metres deep. And the earth has to be neatly piled at the side too.

Read the full transcript

27:10Laszlo Kiss and Robert Nagy dug their grave in one hour and 21 minutes to win the competition this year, and both said it was really hard work. You can't prepare for this separately because we work every day. There are weeks when there is more digging or less digging, but we have been doing this for years. It's in our make-up.

27:38it's tough the ground is very hard and it's tiring it's very different here at the race because here speed is the main thing whereas when you dig a grave for a funeral you have to keep the exact dimensions and make sure the grave is beautifully carved the authorities don't exactly dig deep when it comes to winnings after all their hard work the two men who came out on top have to share prize money of just$640. But then they do have bragging rights. And that was Wendy Urquhart reporting on the Gravedigger competition taking place in northern Hungary.

28:36This is News Out, coming to you live from the BBC in London with me, Tim Franks. Every so often, someone writes a book which becomes a bestseller, but actually, in truth, not that many people read, or at least read all the way through. And yet its fame goes well beyond being a bestseller. The work becomes, and stays, a reference point in our thinking and the way we talk about things. Francis Fukuyama's first book, published back in 1992, is exactly that. In the aftermath of the Cold War, with the West triumphant, his book was entitled The End of History and the Last Man. His much subsequently misunderstood and ridiculed argument, at least when it comes to the four words that everyone remembers, the end of history, was not that nothing of interest or consequence would now happen, but that the idea that liberal democracy was an unimprovable system of government, that that had been settled, he argued, once and for all.

29:33Well, now the 73-year-old political philosopher, one of the most famous public intellectuals in the world, has published a new book, picking up on the widely ignored second bit of that famous title, the bit about the Last Man. His new book is called In the Realm of the Last Man. When he came into the NewsHour studio, I asked him what he meant by that. The original book really had two parts. So the end of history was about the idea of progress, modernization. Those are the words we use instead of history with a capital H these days. And the question of the end of history was in what direction is it going?

30:11So back then, the Marxists also had a concept of history, and they said the end of history would be communism. That's the ideal state that we're moving towards. And in the late 1980s, with the decline of the Soviet Union, it seemed to me that we were never going to get there and that some form of market economy coupled to liberal democracy would be the final direction in which history was going. However, the last five chapters of that original book published in 1991 was the part about the last man. So the end of history phrase comes from the philosopher Hegel. The last man is an idea of Friedrich Nietzsche, who hated the idea of the end of history because a liberal democracy would flatten everything.

30:56That's the essence of liberalism is that you tolerate different points of view. You don't have a strong sense of national purpose, a single direction everybody is moving in. And Nietzsche said that human beings want something more than that. They don't want to simply be understood to be the equal of every other human being on earth. And if you actually reach the end of history where you have peace and prosperity, people are going to revolt against the possibility of being a last man who's like a cow, you know, cattle just grazing and content with, you know, the status quo. And I said back in the early 90s that democracy may someday fall apart because of that discontent, because people weren't just happy with peace and prosperity.

31:42And I think that actually describes our politics over the last decade where you've had populist parties arising that say that, you know, things have never been worse and we have to upset the whole system. And I'm speaking to you on the day that a hard right party in Germany, which very much is saying that Germany has become this sort of sea of mediocrity and no sense of identity, is, well, it seems likely to come out top in these regional elections that are taking place today. but how far are you saying in that case in your book that essentially I was right, that I predicted that this sort of complacency, this, to some people, mediocrity, would produce not a sense of self-satisfaction but a sense of rage?

32:38Well, I think I did actually make that argument 35 years ago. But people didn't really hear it because they obsessed about the end of history. Yeah, they didn't hear it. It's also very hard to know, you know, under what circumstance that counter reaction would appear. And I think the, you know, there's a couple of things going on. One is just generational change. I think that if you grew up in the period when I was young, you know, for me, the biggest event, political event of my life was the fall of the Soviet Union, you know, the ending of the Berlin Wall. And that signaled, you know, this new era in which liberal democracy would thrive.

33:22But a generation has grown up since that time that didn't experience the horrors of communism, that didn't experience the conflict, you know, the Second World War when nationalism was unchecked and, you know, led to really horrific violence. And so it's kind of easy under those circumstances to think, well, the real problem is not dictatorship. It's the European Union. That's the big dictatorship or, you know, the liberal consensus. This is what a lot of conservatives in the United States say, that it's the liberals today that want us to tolerate everything that are cancelling free speech. And that's the real evil that we have to fight.

34:04And I think they just don't have any historical perspective on what real evil is about. Can I ask you, I want to ask more theoretically about where you think this leaves liberal democracy, but just in a very personal way. If you don't mind me asking you this question, I mean, you are a pillar of the establishment. I mean, you are one of, certainly the U.S. is probably one of the world's most famous public intellectuals. You teach at Stanford. You are also a Japanese-American, and you, your family going back, I mean, your grandfather, I think I'm correct, was interned during the Second World War.

34:45Yeah, his whole family was. Right. So when you hear people these days talking about heritage Americans, about suggesting that the US, as in many parts of the world, needs to think of itself perhaps more in terms of a ethno-nationalist state, how do you feel? Oh, it's horrible. I think J.D. Vance, our vice president, has been pushing this line about heritage Americans somehow. If you can trace your ancestors back to at least the Civil War, that you're somehow more American. You know, I think it's terrible. Donald Trump wants to upend the 14th Amendment and birthright citizenship. That affects me personally because my mother was in the United States on a student visa when she met my father at the University of Chicago and had me.

35:32And under those rules, I wouldn't be a citizen if those people had their way. Now, I think that the big achievement in the United States was at the end of the civil rights movement in the late 1960s, I think we finally achieved a sense of national identity that wasn't based on race or ethnicity. And that you could say, I'm an American because I believe in the Constitution and the rule of law, in the Declaration of Independence, assertion of all men are created equal. And that's what made you an American. But we're going backwards from that right now with ICE and, you know, this very cruel policy towards people that aren't considered, you know, welcome in our society.

36:20So that's, you know, really, I think, the big threat that liberal democracy is under right now. And it's happening in the home of liberal democracy in the United States of America. Does that then, and maybe I'm being too simplistic about this, but does that then begin to undermine the argument that the end of history was, it was not about suggesting that, you know, nothing was now going to happen in the world. But it did imply that the argument in favour of liberal democracy as an unimprovable system of government, that that had been settled. Does the last, I mean, I was going to say the last 30 years, but particularly what's been happening very recently.

37:04Does that cause you to think again about that? Well, I think that the events of the last few years has got to make any advocate of democracy, you know, think twice, because, you know, for example, I really did not think that the American people would vote a second time to put a man who tried to overturn an election back in office. And yet, but they voted also with a plurality of votes, not I mean, it wasn't just an Well, okay. So let me get to the optimistic side of this. I think that the judgment about liberal democracy really is premature to make it because I do think the United States actually has pretty strong institutions.

37:43So if you look at the court system, they have been overturning a lot of Trump's executive orders. The Supreme Court invalidated his birthright citizenship effort. They invalidated his tariffs. And so it's not clear that he's actually going to be successful in his effort to basically push the clock back to the pre-civil rights period. The biggest check I think is yet to come. I think we're going to have a midterm election very soon. All of the indications are that there's going to be a pretty large repudiation of Donald Trump and therefore repudiation of this very, very illiberal authoritarian phenomenon that's cropped up in American politics.

38:30So I would wait until that. We've seen other pushbacks. The Hungarian election in last April, I think, was another sign that this is not an inevitable wave of nationalist populism that's sweeping the whole world. but nonetheless is there any part of you that thinks that maybe i don't know that you know especially as we're talking more and more about how artificial intelligence is going to shape our lives that actually our our construct of what liberal democracy is what it what it what it means what it can achieve how it's organized that all that actually could change quite radically in the next few years?

39:15I have consistently thought that the particular political forms that prevail at any given time reflect the underlying technological horizon. I thought at one point that the computerization of the world, you know, digitalization would actually be good for democracy because basically information is power. And if you make information more broadly available. It would empower ordinary people. And it has done that in many circumstances. But it's also turned into a weapon that can be used. And I think when you get to artificial intelligence, the kinds of changes that are going to happen to both the economy and society are potentially so great that, you know, all bets are off.

40:03And I think there's really a lot of reason to think that our current form of liberal democracy is not going to survive this particular change. For example, I think that democracy basically is based on the idea that the mass of people in a society can have work and that they're going to be paid even if they are not highly educated, but there's still useful things that they can do. That's what a wage means is society is rewarding you. And in a way, it's affirming your dignity that what you do is valuable. And then that's why we're paying you a salary. If these machines start substituting for that kind of labor, it's going to be very devastating for a lot of people.

40:51I know that many people have argued that this is just another wave of automation and that people will adjust and they'll find other kinds of work to do. I hope that's true. I don't think that the results are in yet because this technology seems to be so general and applicable in so many areas that I do think it's going to have, you know, potentially pretty devastating effect on, you know, the nature of democratic society. Francis Fukuyama, the American political philosopher, with his new book just out and that is in the realm of the last man. This is NewsHour. This is NewsHour live from the BBC and it was a couple of hours ago that we got news that two of Donald Trump's closest and highest ranking envoys, Steve Wyckoff and Jared Kushner, had indeed arrived in Kiev for their first visit to Ukraine since Russia's full-scale invasion.

41:50On Saturday they'd had talks with President Putin in Moscow, one of many trips to Russia that they've made. The Kremlin described those three hours of discussions as frank and constructive. Lesia Vasylenko is a member of parliament in Ukraine for the opposition Holos party and joins us live from Kiev. Lesia, what do you make of the visit of Witkof and Kushner? It's a good sign that the conversations are still ongoing. We still view America as our lead partners, as our strategic partners. And it's thanks to the U.S. that we will be able to push back on Russia once the U.S. resumes the necessary aid of air defense and military aid that Ukraine needs to do that.

42:42But apart from that, I have had many questions through this past today about hope and whether The Ukrainians are hopeful that these talks and these visits will lead anywhere. Unfortunately, we have seen too many of such visits. We have heard too many of the reports out of such talks behind closed doors with President Putin, followed by talks with President Zelensky. Unfortunately, they don't lead anywhere. Because we have to be realistic. Talks with Russia are futile. Russia understands strengths. if you're prepared to give Ukraine what it takes to push back on Russia, then we will see results.

43:21Until then, this will be quite a waste of time. Understood. Okay, well, but two things here. I mean, first off, Wyckoff and Kushner are not going to come with a sort of promise of a fresh stock of Patriot anti-missile defence systems. I mean, you know, that those simply don't exist. I mean, the fact that they have come, I think they've been nine times to Moscow since the full-scale invasion. I mean, and this is the first time to Kiev. It does suggest perhaps where American sympathies or the Trump administration sympathies lie, doesn't it? Well, again, it's good that they have come to Kiev. But to believe that these talks or this visit will lead to any kind of results, I'm very skeptical.

44:10We have had many conversations. The only thing that Ukraine needs right now is weapons for our own self-defense. The second thing that we will need is more weapons to push back on Russia's attacks, which are ongoing, and Russia's illegal claims to our territories. That's the only thing that will end this war and be a guarantee for further wars not restarting in the future. We have been the neighbour of Russia for history, for centuries and centuries. And for centuries and centuries, we know exactly that when Russia starts a war, they only end it when they are made to end it. Russia going unpunished means that there will only be more war restarting in the time soon.

44:52And I don't think that Ukraine, the US or EU actually can afford it. Well, in which case, I mean, it sounds like obviously you're not in the room with Witkow and Kushner, But it sounds like you're suggesting that President Zelensky would be right to tell Witkow and Kushner, thanks very much for coming, but there is literally no point to your attempt at third-party negotiations. To be honest, it's not that there's no point to your third-party negotiations. The talks need to be there, but they need to realistically be backed up by some material aid and some material action. Okay. Lesia Vasylenko, thank you very much indeed for joining us live from Kiev.

46:00on Apple Podcasts. You can also enjoy a range of our podcasts ad-free with an Amazon Music subscription.

From the publisher

German voters are heading to the polls in an election in Saxony- Anhalt, which could see the far- right AfD win power at a state level for the first time. The party sees the vote as a potential stepping stone to nationwide success.

Also in the programme: The top US envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, are in Kyiv for their first talks in Ukraine since Russia's full-scale invasion; the political philosopher Francis Fukuyama worries about the future direction of American democracy; and we will hear from May el-Toukhy, one of the only two female directors competing at the Venice Film Festival about her film, premiering tonight.

(Phot0: The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party's lead candidate in Saxony-Anhalt, Ulrich Siegmund (R), and his wife, Julia Siegmund, cast their votes at a polling station in Tangermuende, Germany, 06 September 2026. Credit: EPA)

More from Newshour

All 220 episodes
Germany's far-right AfD bids for their first taste of power in eastern voteNewshour · 44 min
Listen in VO