1. Podcasts
  2. Newshour
  3. Israelis mark three years since 7 October attacks
Newshour

7 Oct 2026 · 47m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

Israelis mark three years since 7 October attacks

In short

The episode is a BBC World Service NewsHour roundup anchored by a report marking three years since the 7 October 2023 Hamas-led attacks on Israel. It reviews the death toll (1,145 killed; 251 hostages) and the Gaza war’s impact (over 70,000 dead, per the Hamas-run health ministry), then focuses on Israeli memorials and an election debate over security failures and accountability.

Key claims

Benjamin Netanyahu denies responsibility and rejects a state inquiry; critics argue there was a catastrophic intelligence/operational failure and political leadership failures, including warnings ignored and attention diverted during the judicial overhaul.

Notable examples

a border surveillance unit warning for months (15 killed, including Ronnie Eshel); a widow describing a husband’s final message; the “Sleepy Bibi” video game.

Guests

Chuck Freilich (former Israeli deputy national security advisor; academic in Washington); Maria Ressa (Nobel Peace Prize winner, Rappler founder).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:44

The October 7 Attacks: A Tragic Anniversary

Discussion on the significance of the October 7 attacks on Israel.

“Hello, welcome to NewsHour from the BBC World Service.”
1:41

Memorial Services and Ongoing Questions

Exploration of memorial services and the questions surrounding security failures.

“Our Middle East correspondent Lucy Williamson reports.”
2:49

Government Response and Political Accountability

Analysis of the Israeli government's response and political implications.

“In Bar Goldstein's brother and niece were killed that day and four other relatives taken hostage.”
4:19

Public Sentiment and Legacy of October 7

Examination of public sentiment and the legacy of the attacks on Israeli politics.

“You ask me what would have happened if they had working me up?”
6:15

Expert Insights on Leadership Responsibility

Expert analysis on Netanyahu's leadership and responsibility regarding the attacks.

“At a memorial ceremony this year, the father of one of those killed on October 7th accused him of not protecting his son or the others killed that day.”
7:40

Chuck Freilich on Security and Political Challenges

Interview with Professor Chuck Freilich discussing security and political dynamics.

“The Prime Minister's strongest card is arguably his domestic image as hardline guarantor of Israel's security.”
14:01

Remembering Eva Marie Saint: A Hollywood Legend

Explore the life and career of Eva Marie Saint, her impactful roles, and her legacy in film.

“And then he was frowning and I was trying to figure out why he's frowning.”
18:51

Current Situation in Ukraine: Escalating Attacks

Get insights into the recent surge of Russian attacks on Ukraine and its impact on citizens.

“Across Ukraine, at least 20 people have been killed in the last 24 hours alone.”
22:58

Housing Crisis in Spain: The Case of Marie Carmen Abascal

Understand the implications of Marie Carmen Abascal's eviction and her role in the housing crisis movement.

“there's an online version of the programme available twice a day.”
28:00

Legal Challenges in a High-Profile Case

Learn about the ongoing legal case involving allegations of rape at Cornell University and its societal implications.

“It led to the fraternity being shut down and two of its members being expelled.”
Show all 14 chapters
35:03

WHO Guidelines on Childhood Obesity

Discover the latest WHO recommendations on addressing childhood obesity and their implications for treatment.

“Now, the World Health Organization has warned against using surgery and weight loss drugs to tackle rising obesity rates in children.”
39:56

Maria Ressa on Democracy and Authoritarianism

Hear Maria Ressa's insights on the threats to democracy and the role of technology in spreading misinformation.

“Now, an overwhelming tendency among those of us who've periodically despaired at various aspects of the state of the world is to bury our heads in the sand and hope bad things go away.”
42:03

Digital Authoritarianism and Its Impact

A discussion on the rise of digital authoritarianism and the manipulation of media by tech leaders.

“If you can't tell the difference between fact and fiction, they're cascading failures.”
44:48

The Role of Citizens in a Tech-Dominated World

Exploring how citizens can combat feelings of helplessness amid powerful governments and tech companies.

“For many, many years, big tech wanted us to look at this as a content moderation problem.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. An observatory in space. This is the real deal. This is going to revolutionise astronomy. Capable of capturing light from the dawn of the universe. It could be real exciting for the astronomical community, I guess, and for the whole world to see what Hubble really can do. From the BBC World Service, 13 Minutes Trouble with Hubble. The story of the Hubble Space Telescape. Listen now on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

0:44Hello, welcome to NewsHour from the BBC World Service. I'm Paul Henley. We're coming to you live from London. Three years ago today, Israel suffered the deadliest attack in its history. Hamas-led militants crossed the border from Gaza and killed 1 ,145 people. They took 251 hostages. It will forever be a significant moment in the history of the Middle East. Israel's military response in the Gaza Strip has since left more than 70 ,000 people dead, according to the Hamas-run health ministry there. It also caused many in Israel to ask serious questions about their security and what had gone wrong to let Hamas mount such a large-scale attack.

1:29Today in Israel, memorial services have been taking place against the backdrop of an election campaign, where accountability for the security failures of October 7 has become an important issue. Our Middle East correspondent Lucy Williamson reports.

1:47At 6.29, they lowered the flag and opened old wounds. People began arriving at the armory here in Kepha 'aza just as the sky began to lighten. This building, the armory, is where seven members of the kibbutz's civil defence unit were attacked and killed by Hamas gunmen after they broke through the border fence early on the morning of the 7th of October.

2:21Shahar Hindi, the widow of the unit's deputy commander, described the moment her husband stopped answering his phone.

2:31At 7.21, he gave me the best leaving present he could, she told the crowd. A message saying he loved me. The pain of Israel's security failures is still fresh here. but three years on there are questions about who else should pay the price. In Bar Goldstein's brother and niece were killed that day and four other relatives taken hostage. I need my country to take responsibility for what happened. No one investigated the roots of this disaster, what brought us to it and what happened after it. October 7th didn't start nor end on October 7th. It's a long process of abandonment. Early on the morning of the 7th of October, Hamas-led gunmen broke through this border fence.

3:23Within minutes, they were inside Israeli communities. Three years on from Israel's worst security failure, there's been no state inquiry into how it happened. Senior military and security figures have resigned or been fired, but Israel's prime minister is still in place and is running for re-election as the man who can keep Israel safe. Israel's prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has consistently denied responsibility for the attacks, rejecting reports that he was warned about Hamas plans, including in a phone call from the UAE president 10 days before. Instead, he told Israeli television it was the fault of his own security chiefs for not waking him early enough.

4:14God forbid we wake up the prime minister and he says, wake up the entire IDF immediately, scramble the air force. You ask me what would have happened if they had working me up? This would not have happened. An Israeli surveillance unit at the Gaza border had been warning for months about Hamas activity. 15 of the unit were killed in the attacks, among them Ronnie Eshel. She loved music. She loved Taylor Swift and Harry Styles. A week before, she told her uncle, Elad Levy, about her concerns. She told me it's very, very hot. It's very, very hot. Like, it's very active. There are always stuff on the fence.

4:54She actually showed me a couple of videos where, you know, Hamas is cutting the fence, coming to Israel and coming out, doing explosions and she said there are no troops.

5:07Netanyahu has refused calls for a state commission of inquiry, saying the country's judiciary would be biased against him. Protesters have asked Israel's highest court to force his hand.

5:24Why do you think the Prime Minister has not done a state commission of inquiry? He's scared. He's scared for people asking questions, that people will be able to find all the documents that what happened in this day, what happened seven days before, that he got information. The people warned him from Egypt, from Saudi Arabia, whatever, and they refused to listen to them. Amir Ahana, a senior member of Netanyahu's Likud party, said in a social media video it was preposterous and absurd to suggest that Netanyahu could have known about the attack when the Hamas leader behind it, Yahya Sinwa, had only told a handful of people.

6:10For years, Netanyahu's policy was to contain rather than confront Hamas. At a memorial ceremony this year, the father of one of those killed on October 7th accused him of not protecting his son or the others killed that day. Shame, he told him. Disgrace. Netanyahu's denial of personal responsibility has become an election issue. A video game called Sleepy Bibi, released by his main opponent, asks players to help the prime minister dodge warnings of an attack and make it safely to bed.

6:49Recent polls suggest this month's election will be close and that the 7th of October attacks are central to many voters' decisions. Defense analyst Yakov Katz says the legacy of the attacks has two sides. When you look at October 7th, and this has to be said, it's a coin with two sides. There are the failures, but there's the other side, which is the Netanyahu argument. And that is, I have re-engineered the Middle East. I have made Israel a safer place today, more than it was before October 7. The shadow of these attacks hangs over this election, dividing Israel once again along political lines.

7:28For Benjamin Netanyahu's supporters, he's still the man who will keep Israel safe. Critics say his political survival puts Israel at risk. Lucy Williamson. So in those Israeli elections due at the end of this month, The Prime Minister's strongest card is arguably his domestic image as hardline guarantor of Israel's security. It's an image Benjamin Netanyahu has curated carefully, especially in his response to October 7th. But as recently as the end of last month, Mr Netanyahu was saying he'd filed libel suits against a number of media outlets and journalists over reports that he's said to have received from the UAE and from Egypt three years ago warning of Hamas' plans.

8:12Chuck Freilich said at the time of the attacks that the blame would ultimately lie with the Prime Minister. He's a former Israeli deputy national security advisor, now an academic and associate fellow at the Middle East Institute in Washington, D.C. I asked Professor Freilich if he still saw Mr Netanyahu as responsible today. Well, absolutely. I mean, he is the leader of the country, so he does bear responsibility, overall responsibility for whatever happens. Obviously, and this is the argument that he's made, he doesn't know everything that's happening all the time. That's understandable. And it's up to the security people to brief him in time.

8:51So he claims that he wasn't woken up that night. That's, to my way of thinking, not much of a defense. Yes, there was an immediate and catastrophic intelligence and operational failure, but it was partly the result of two things for which he does bear responsibility. One is sort of imposing on the defense establishment his preconception that Hamas had basically been tamed, was being forced to focus domestically, and had no intention of attacking Israel. And the other point was that it was at the height of what the prime minister called the judicial overhaul. I call it a judicial wrecking ball, which threatened and still threatens Israel's basic character as a democracy, the entire judicial system.

9:35And there was a truly remarkable situation at the time, given Israel's history, whereas the intelligence community and the defense establishment were really focused on keeping themselves together because this overhaul was ripping Israeli society apart. And they took their eye off the ball, off what they're really supposed to deal with, obviously the intelligence picture. The situation was so extreme that the Mossad, for example, gave their employees special permission to participate in the counter demonstrations because they were simply afraid that the organization would come apart if they didn't.

10:09And it's a contravention of civil service rules. But here they made an exception. Since then, however, the chiefs of the army, military intelligence and Israel's internal security counterintelligence service have all accepted failures to do with October the 7th. Isn't there a scenario in which the buck stops with them and doesn't extend to the prime minister? Well, if it had really been the fact that they didn't wake him in time, then I would accept that. But I think the other two examples that I gave simply negate that form of argument. He is the prime minister. He set the policy, the policy which was also to try and keep Hamas in power, weakened, but keep them in power as an alternative to the Palestinian Authority.

10:56And that would also create a situation in which as long as Hamas was in power, international and especially American pressure on Israel to go ahead on the Palestinian issue would be lower because how can you work with Hamas? He was the prime minister and he wasn't a prime minister who has just been elected. He had been in office for 15 years, give or take. And specifically, what about these reported warnings from the UAE and from Egypt, the warnings that Mr. Netanyahu is threatening to sue over, sue journalists over? How significant is that? To be fair to him, they weren't pinpointed warnings.

11:34They were general warnings. It wasn't that on a certain day something's going to happen or a certain week. It was beware, Hamas is planning something. Now, when that kind of warning comes from a foreign leader, it is something that should be taken seriously. But at the same time, there are warnings all the time. You can't prepare or no, you have to prepare, but you can't be ready for every single one of these things. So I'm saying that's the part of the equation where, to be fair to him, it was OK. On the other hand, again, the leader of the UAE called a couple of times, the head of Egyptian intelligence came to Israel a couple of times.

12:15Again, this was part of the arrogance and the dismissing anything that didn't fit with the preconception that he had in his mind. So primarily, do you see this as a failure of political leadership rather than an intelligence failure? No, I think it's both. It was a catastrophic intelligence failure on the order of the 1973 war, the Yom Kippur War, Pearl Harbor, other cases of strategic surprises. But again, he is the prime minister and I don't think that he can escape public accountability, public responsibility for what happened here. Israeli government policy since October the 7th, three years ago, has been quite clear.

12:58It's been to eliminate, to defeat Hamas. Is Israel any safer now after the Gaza war, in your opinion? Well, I think much safer than it was. And it's on a number of fronts. It's not just Hamas and Gaza, it's Hezbollah and Lebanon. And it's, well, the war with Iran, I believe, ended in strategic failure, but it did postpone the threat of somewhat, not a great deal, but somewhat. That was Professor Chuck Freilich in Washington, D.C. This is the World Service and NewsHour. Coming up, we hear from the Nobel Peace Prize winner Maria Ressa on the threats to democracy in the Philippines and her meeting with Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg.

13:45What I did in 2017, we were in California and I invited him to come to the Philippines because I didn't think he understood how powerful Facebook was. And I said, you know, Mark, 97 % of Filipinos on the Internet are on Facebook. Facebook is our Internet. there's tremendous power for it to do good. And then he was frowning and I was trying to figure out why he's frowning. And then he asked me a question that really made me think. He said, Maria, where are the other 3 %? More in about half an hour. A headline for now for five former traders in the city of London who were sentenced to prison in one of the biggest scandals of the 2008 financial crisis have had their convictions overturned.

14:33Eva Marie Saint, one of the last surviving stars of old Hollywood, has died at the age of 102. Jack Phillips, Western Sales Manager for King Bee Electronics. No, you're not. You're Roger Thornhill of Madison Avenue, and you're wanted for murder on every front page in America. And don't be so modest. Whoops. Don't worry. I won't say a word. How come? I told you. It's a nice face. Is that the only reason? It's going to be a long night. True. And I don't particularly like the book I've started. That was Eva Marie Saint flirting with Cary Grant in the Hitchcock film North by Northwest in 1959. She'd already won an Oscar for her debut film On the Waterfront when she was 30.

15:26She continued to act well into her 90s. Isabel Stevens is managing editor of Sight & Sound magazine, published by the British Film Institute. I asked her if she agreed that that dialogue between Eva Marie Saint and Cary Grant had been quite risque for its time. Yes, it was. And she referred to the role she played in North by Northwest as the sexy spy lady. And, you know, she really is quite magnificent in the film. She's very much the femme fatale with a steely stare. She never loses eye contact with Cary Grant's character. And in fact, Hitchcock had she said specifically to her, always look directly into Cary Grant's eyes at all time.

16:09She was fully like a cat playing with her prey. She was a huge character. She had presence. She was a wisecracker, not a Bond girl type. No, she was very funny in this film. You know, she wasn't the sort of damsel in distress. She, you know, she's sort of, you know, very much in control and sort of the mysterious woman, while Cary Grant's character is all sort of flipping out and trying to work out what's going on. You know, she's telling him what to do and to come to her carriage later that night. So, yeah, it was an unusual role for a woman of that time, I think. How much independence as an actress was she able to exert?

16:50She was a contracted actress in the old Hollywood studio system and that changed mid-career, didn't it? Yes. And I mean, she's a very interesting case because I think she could have been a sort of superstar. You know, she certainly looked the part, but she very specifically did not said to her agent, I don't want to be a superstar. And she turned down a lot of roles because she wanted to have a normal family life, too. She was trained as a method actor, which, I mean, today we often think of method actors as being men, whether that's, you know, Daniel Day-Lewis or Marlon Brando, who she starred against in On the Waterfront.

17:27But, you know, she came up through that process and, you know, she was always very serious about acting. That was what she really liked doing. She liked being in playing with other people. She didn't really want to, I think, be the isolated star whose build at the top. She really liked acting alongside other people. She protected her private life. Did she have a successful private life? Oh, yes. She had a family and that family was very important to her. When she starred in Otto Preminger's Exodus, she stipulated that her two children had to come with her and her husband. Her husband was a TV director.

18:02So I think it was sort of a slightly easier for her to stay acting for longer than many other women of her time perhaps did. And she did take a lot of TV roles. And what roles did she take on later in her career? It was a very long career. Yes, it was very long. I mean, she was in lots of things. She would be on panel television shows, sort of comedy shows. She starred in Frasier. She was also in one of the Superman movies when she was in her 80s. So she had a very, very varied career. And I think she was often, she was very funny as we saw in the North by Northwest clip. And I think that lots of the roles that she had in TV, I think, allowed her to explore that a little bit more.

18:42Isabel Stevens there of Sight & Sound magazine.

18:50Now, Russia appears to be escalating the number of attacks it's subjecting Ukraine to at the moment. Across Ukraine, at least 20 people have been killed in the last 24 hours alone. In the capital, Kiev, Russian drone attacks have been concentrated on the bridges across the Dnipro River, which are used by half a million people every day who commute to work. Those bridges were recently hit for four consecutive days. Dan Johnson is our correspondent in Kiev and he sent us this. Russian attacks have been intensifying throughout the summer to the point where the air raids here in Kyiv are almost constant some days, on the busiest 19 in the space of 24 hours.

19:31That is disturbing life here, day and night. It's causing chaos, and the attacks have been focused recently on infrastructure, particularly the bridges that connect the two sides of this city, which are vital for keeping traffic flowing. It means there is more armament, obvious, out on the streets. The soldiers are wearing heavier gear, and it's not unusual now to see machine guns positioned at strategic locations around the city. There's a nip in the air, the leaves are starting to fall, so how are people feeling about the impending winter? Kristal is actually visiting Kiev from Southampton to see her relatives.

20:09We were actually on the bridge when it got the hole in it. When it got hit? In that morning, we were still on the other side of Kiev when it got hit, and then we were like the first bus that passed next to it after it got hit. Do you think the city could be cut off, could be divided if those bridges keep getting attacked? Yes, and that is the scary thing, I'd say. Even for my mom's family, because they also work on this side, but we live on the other. So that is the frightening bit, we'd say, getting cut off from the main source of income and so on. Some of those who don't have the choice to leave this city are more nervous.

20:44Tatiana is expecting a baby. I think we need more help from our partners so that they can give us at least some assistance. Our people are doing everything to protect us and they need at least some help to be able to shoot down all the missiles and drones and everything else. And the rest people will do themselves. We are strong. We will do everything. There is still plenty of resolve amongst people here. Dennis works in a restaurant.

21:14As for the future, I don't even know what to say. I want to live and I want all of this to end as soon as possible. For now, I honestly can't believe it. I just live one day at a time. I can't plan anything for the future. I can't even plan for the next week. Of course I hope for the best, but I don't see any signs this will change soon.

21:37Many are considering what the best move is for the forthcoming months. I met Daniel, a 26-year-old ballet dancer who was pushing his baby daughter Estelle in a pram. She's just two months old. It's so hard. I've been living in Kiev now and we try to prepare for winter because we know this winter will be so hard. What is the hardest thing right now? Every night when you heard alarm or when you go to work and saw drones or some missiles Yes, and it's so terrible when you, every time you're nervous about your family, about your friend, about yourself in the end. Are you thinking you'll stay for the winter?

22:30Yeah, I think yes, but my wife with my baby, I want to try to go to other country in this winter. It's so hard because you want to see how your baby grows up. So, yeah, it's a hard decision, but I think it's safe and more important. That report was from the BBC's Dan Johnson in the Ukrainian capital. Don't forget if you want to listen to NewsHour but miss the live broadcast, there's an online version of the programme available twice a day. You need to search for BBC NewsHour podcast and you can subscribe to the feed if you want to get it on a regular basis. I'm Paul Henley with NewsHour from the BBC World Service.

23:37from the dawn of the universe. It could be real exciting for the astronomical community, I guess, and for the whole world to see what Hubble really can do. From the BBC World Service, 13 Minutes, Trouble with Hubble. The story of the Hubble Space Telescape. Listen now on bbc.com, the BBC app, or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

24:04Welcome back to News Hour. Marie Carmen Abascal, an 87-year-old woman who was evicted from her home in Madrid and became a symbol of campaigns for improved housing, is died in hospital in the Spanish capital. She was forcibly removed on a stretcher from the apartment where she'd lived for more than 70 years on the 23rd of September and was admitted to hospital following the eviction, which sparked protests across Spain. Our correspondent Guy Hedgco gave me more. Well, Mary Kanmin Abascal had been in hospital ever since her eviction. She'd reportedly been suffering from exhaustion, understandably, given the circumstances for eviction and the fact that there were protests outside her home, people protesting against the eviction.

24:51There was a massive backlash and she became the focus of a protest movement almost overnight. And I think it was a lot of pressure for her. And so she went straight into hospital and had been there ever since. We don't know the exact cause of her death. The Tenants Union, which is the organization which has been leading protests over the last couple of weeks, just said that she had passed away. We do know that she had been told by the company that evicted her that she could, in fact, return because of the backlash against that company and others. but the tenets union said obviously that deal, that agreement had come sadly too late for her.

25:39Given that her case and the housing crisis had put a spotlight on it, Spain was a major cause of a snap election that has just been called by the Prime Minister, what kind of effect could her death have? Well, already we're seeing protests out in the streets of Madrid, demonstrations, people remembering her, and she remains the symbol of this protest movement very much. You could see her picture and her name, for example, in Puerto del Sol in central Madrid, where hundreds of people have been camping out in tents as a protest over the last couple of weeks. So I think this is obviously going to perhaps give more impetus to the protest movement.

26:25You mentioned there the fact that she essentially had triggered a general election because the Prime Minister, Pedro Sanchez, presented emergency measures to Congress to try and tackle the housing crisis. But following her case, they were blocked. That caused him to call the election. We've also heard today that a general strike has been called for next month, focusing specifically on the housing crisis. And I think you can say that all of this can be traced back to the case of Marie Carmen Abascal. Has there been any comment from the Prime Minister? As far as I know, we haven't had any comment from him so far, but he has been following her case very closely, and when she was evicted, he was following it very closely, as were many politicians.

27:12Our reporter in Madrid there, Guy Hedgecoe.

27:31Now, an alleged gang rape at Cornell University in New York State in 2024 continues to divide American public opinion and make global headlines. The elite US college yesterday appointed a former high-profile prosecutor to assess its own handling of the incident, in which a female student claims she was pressured into taking drugs and raped by seven members of a male fraternity. Her account of what happened at the time failed to initiate a criminal investigation. It led to the fraternity being shut down and two of its members being expelled. Others, alleged to have been involved in the attack, were told to write essays as a punishment.

28:11Well, the woman making the accusations is unnamed. She's been referred to as Jane Doe throughout this process. We're joined now by her lawyer, Thomas Jufra. Thomas, welcome to the programme. How is the woman you're representing? What does she make of the headlines her case is making? Well, unfortunately, things have taken a very dark turn. Recently, there have been threats on her life, threats on her family's life. I just this afternoon had one of these cowards call me at my office and make threats on my life. And it's really surprising to me, But unfortunately, there are some commentators, a very small minority, were whipping up this sentiment.

28:55And now it's getting dangerous. And now I'm very concerned. Before it was a court case. It was a case that involved, you know, trying to improve our society, improve safety of women. And now it's getting to a point where people have been whipped up by a certain irresponsible podcasters and the like to where now it's getting dangerous. I mean, I, within the last 15 minutes, had a call with somebody who's threatened my life. And I've been on this planet 59 years. That hasn't happened to me before. President Trump chose to comment on the case, didn't he? What do you make of his intervention? Well, I think the problem is that this is not a political question.

29:35I mean, my client's from a deep red state where she's from. In 50 years, they haven't elected a dog catcher who's a Democrat. I think what he said has made this a political issue, but I've said this before. Democrats' daughters are getting raped. Republicans' daughters are getting raped. It has nothing to do with politics. It has to do with how women are treated in our colleges in this country. It should not be partisan. It's been made partisan by people who want to divide this country, and now they've made it dangerous. And I hope they're happy with what they've done. Yeah. Cornell University have hired a former U.S.

30:16attorney general to review their response to these accusations. How do you respond to that? Well, I think it's a good first step. I think she's an excellent investigator. I think she'll get to the bottom of all of the failures that have gradually been uncovered in the last week. I think she'll she'll be able to deal with how they failed to handle the police investigation, how they failed to disclose materials. Look, I think there was a cover up. I've said this on the record. You had a woman who said I was raped 100 percent. Doesn't make it into a police report, despite this being in a transcript.

30:52Woman who says I was hit, violence was used against me, doesn't make it into a police report. And then the fact is, all this information that's coming out has been leaked by people in the Cornell police. I think they were unhappy with how it was approached. I think they are unhappy with the higher ups. And that's why all this information is coming to light. Because for me, as an attorney, I don't get investigation materials. And that's why it's coming out. Because there are certain people, I believe, in the Cornell police, because somebody's releasing it, because this is all investigation material, is unhappy.

31:22They think there was a cover up and they're standing up to their bosses in a subtle way saying, hey look we think this should have been prosecuted and you guys hit it because there's no reason for any of that information to not be in the police report why was it sanitized that's the question i have the law on consent in new york is complicated isn't it especially where alcohol is concerned and the woman you're representing said she gave initial consent to sex with one person possibly two i understand am i right to say that it's down to the accuser to prove that she was too intoxicated to give consent?

31:59Well, the problem is this. There was an investigation, a Title IX investigation, where there were testimony from witnesses about her level of intoxication. When she left her sorority house, she had already been clearly, clearly intoxicated. She shouldn't have left that sorority house. She was served alcohol at some local bars. There's small players in this whole thing. And then she goes to the frat house. By all objective means everybody who testified who's not aligned with the plaintiff not aligned with the defendant says she was intoxicated she had no ability to consent from the minute she walked into the door of that frat house to anything but most of the burden of proof potentially falls on her correct well the burden of proof falls on her and i'm not a criminal lawyer but yeah the burden of proof is on her is on the state to prove that they took advantage of an intoxicated woman when forced her to do drugs and took advantage of her.

32:56I mean, look, this is not something that happens every day. A 20-year-old woman who's in an Ivy League school, I mean, she was a student there. She was a smart woman. And she's in a room with seven guys, and some of them raped her. And I'm saying all of them did. I want to be very clear on that. And yeah, I think it's a pretty ugly story. And I'm sure you know the group chat, which was sent out while this was going on to 57 members of this fraternity, inviting them to participate in the abuse. And that's the smoking gun that actually was left out of the police report. And that establishes a crime.

33:31Post the accusations, the woman was in charge with at least one of her accusers. Two of the accused are still at Cornell, I understand. Have you been in contact with them? Well, our process servers sure have, and that's a crazy thing, right? I mean, in the UK, if somebody participated in something so low, do you think they'd still be permitted to remain in the university, or would they have had to go somewhere else? I mean, frankly, the fact that these guys are going to walk out of that school with an Ivy League degree, with all the benefits that come along with it. And my client, who worked hard to get into Cornell, now has not even gone to college since February after the attacks.

34:12She's not going to get any benefits, but these guys all get to have it. And isn't that fair? What stage is this case at? What happens next? Well, it's very early days. I mean, I certainly never expected to be talking to you about a case that I'm handling here in New York City. It's early days. It struck a chord with people in this country. And, you know, civil lawsuits can take up to five years to get wrapped up. So it's very early days. Thank you very much for coming on the program. That's the lawyer, Thomas Juffra, representing the woman known as Jane Doe in that case of alleged rape at Cornell University in the US.

35:03Now, the World Health Organization has warned against using surgery and weight loss drugs to tackle rising obesity rates in children. The organisation says children and adolescents should focus on healthy eating, physical activity and behaviour change. Most anti-obesity drugs are only licensed for children over a certain age, but some doctors prescribe them anyway for younger ones, and the drug companies are involved in testing on young patients. Professor Aaron Kelly is a paediatrician and co-founder of the Centre for Paediatric Obesity at the University of Minnesota Medical School in the US.

35:38He gave me his reaction to the report. Well, overall, I think there's a lot to like about this WHO guideline. I think they did a good job of summarizing what childhood obesity is and what it isn't. They talk about it as being a chronic and relapsing and serious disease, which is supported by the evidence. They talk about how children and adolescents are often stigmatized, bullied, and ostracized for their obesity. and they also talk about, importantly, that kids are at higher risk if they have obesity for mental health problems like depression and anxiety. Do you think parents treat it as a disease?

36:16Well, that's a good question. I think that we have a lot of work to do to get the evidence out there to not only parents and the lay public, but also to health care providers. To be honest with you, there are many health care providers that I think underestimate overestimate the severity of the disease of obesity and they overestimate the ability of people to be able to have control over their body weight. And a lot of this is controlled biologically. And what about the warning not to use surgery and new weight loss drugs to tackle obesity in children? Does that make sense to you? Well, in their report, they talked about how kids up to nine years old should probably not be going to medications right away, except in extreme circumstances.

37:00And to be honest, there are very few medications that are approved for that age range for less than 12 years old. The only medication that is approved that I know of is approved in the EMA in Europe, and that is lorreglutide, which is a GLP-1 receptor agonist for kids 6 to 12. But if we talk about the recommendation for 12 to 18-year-olds or 12 to 19-year-olds, my understanding of the report is that they are recommending that there be a requirement of health behaviour and lifestyle treatment, lifestyle counselling essentially, to have produced unsatisfactory results before a team could be considered for treatment with pharmacotherapy or medications or even bariatric surgery.

37:44Lifestyle counselling seems like a luxury that is not afforded to many of the children who are overweight who come from difficult, are from poor backgrounds. Right. If we look at the evidence of how the outcomes of health behavior and lifestyle treatment, lifestyle counseling on average, and there's a lot of variability, it's not, this doesn't apply to everyone, but for most children and adolescents who engage in lifestyle treatment alone, the reductions in body fat and body weight and body mass index are clinically insignificant. So it's not really that the patients themselves fail the treatments.

38:24It's that the treatment fails them. This speaks to the strong biological forces that are at play in combination with us living in an obesity-promoting or obesogenic environment. And that's where advanced therapies like medicines can be very, very helpful. The general consensus seems to be that in the future, many more adults will be taking Manjaro and Wegovi injections or pills. Is it inevitable that more and more children will be too, do you think, realistically? I think so. The evidence is showing us, and we need to generate more. But the evidence that we have right now in the clinical trials for adolescents, and now we're starting to generate them for younger children, ages 6 to 12, is that if medically indicated, these obesity medications can be highly effective and safe.

39:11We do need to do more work in understanding the long-term effects of the medications, both good, bad. We need to look at side effects. However, children and adolescents or adolescents specifically who are medically indicated to receive this therapy and receive it tend to respond very, very well in terms of reducing BMI, body fat, improving their cardiometabolic risk factors. And what I mean by that, reductions in blood pressure, reductions in blood cholesterol, improvements in quality of life. So these can be real game changers and improving the quality of life in these young people. That was Professor Aaron Kelly, paediatrician, co-founder of the Centre for Paediatric Obesity at the University of Minnesota Medical School in the US.

39:54You're listening to the BBC World Service and this is our twice daily roundup of global news and events. It's News Hour.

40:23I'm Paul Henley with NewsHour. Now, an overwhelming tendency among those of us who've periodically despaired at various aspects of the state of the world is to bury our heads in the sand and hope bad things go away. It is easy to feel helpless when an accepted order of things that many of us grew up with seems to be fraying at the seams, be it through the rise of mighty's right politics or perhaps technological change. Well, one woman who defies that tendency is the Nobel Peace Prize winner Maria Ressa. She has more experience than most of standing up to authoritarianism. The founder of the news website Rappler in the Philippines took on the violent excesses and the corruption of the president Rodrigo Duterte.

41:09She is still working while he's in a prison cell in The Hague, awaiting trial at the International Criminal Court, accused of crimes against humanity for his self-declared war on drugs in which an estimated 30 ,000 people were killed. Maria Ressa has a book out next week called The Fight Back, A Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators. She came into this programme studio and she spoke to my colleague James Menendez. He asked her how she characterised the threat to democracy and freedom around the world and how serious she thought that threat was. Critical, existential. And you've heard that word existential from the tech bros, the CEOs of the tech companies, the top six that literally control our lives.

41:57Because the design of social media spreads lies faster than facts. As early as 2018, MIT said lies spread six times faster. If you can't tell the difference between fact and fiction, they're cascading failures. Without facts, you can't have truth. Without truth, you can't have trust. Without these three, we don't have a shared reality. We can't begin to solve any existential problems like climate change and health. And we can't have journalism. We can't have democracy. We're at this point already. And you can look at from 2016 until today, the most recent VDEM report told us that 74 % of the world is now under authoritarian rule.

42:40We're literally electing illiberal leaders democratically. So in terms of democracy, we're there. We're at the cliff. And so when you use the word in the title to your book, Standing Up to Dictators, those dictators are not just autocrats around the world. You're talking about digital authoritarianism as well. So just expand on that for us. The two dictators in my life. Dictator one is Rodrigo Duterte. He became president of the Philippines in May 2016 with the help of Facebook, right, with tech. But the second dictator is Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook, because by 2017, and I told Mark this, I said, you know, you told him direct.

43:24Did you tell him he was a dictator? No, because I was going to ask you if the lawyers been in touch. No, no, no. But I have told him what I did in 2017. We were in California and I invited him to come to the Philippines because I didn't think he understood how powerful Facebook was. And I said, you know, Mark, 97 % of Filipinos on the internet are on Facebook. Facebook is our internet. There's tremendous power for it to do good. And then he was frowning, and I was trying to figure out why he's frowning. And then he asked me a question that really made me think. He said, Maria, where are the other 3 %?

44:00And so look at my two dictators, right? The reason I say Facebook, because it was on Facebook where these bottom-up attacks, an average of 90 hate messages per hour. That's where I was attacked. It was also tearing apart my reputation that this is my 40th year as a journalist. So it was tearing apart my reputation for others. But it also laid the groundwork. In 2017, they started trending hashtag arrest Maria Ressa. two years later we had about 27 investigations in rappler and me and then my criminal charges started coming you know in 2019 i just kept a workflow for posting bail 11 criminal charges in a little over a year presumably though i mean first of all mark zuckerberg would if he were here would deny strongly that he were a dictator but presumably he would also say look he cannot be personally responsible for the way that an autocrat or an autocratic regime uses his platform to do whatever they want to do, whatever they see fit, right?

45:08For many, many years, big tech wanted us to look at this as a content moderation problem. It isn't a content problem. It's a safety by design problem. There's your contention, though, that the tech leaders, there is no accountability? Absolutely no systems in place to hold them accountable. And starting with social media, this is insidiously manipulative. We look at it as fun, but it isn't. Can I just put this counter-argument to you? Sure. Which is that we've seen in recent months a whole swathe of so-called Gen Z protests around the world. Young people who have harnessed the social media that you're talking about for their end.

45:48So is this not a two-sided coin? It's a Faustian deal. corruption of democracy, and we've mapped this in starting in the Philippines in 2016, most recently in the United States. In the UK, we've looked at Brexit, right? There's a three phase funnel where narrative warfare, right? So this is information operations, but multiplied without the safeguards that were even there in 2018 and 2019. Because by 2024, we began removing all of this, as in the tech companies, right? We went and looked at the data from the first 100 days of Trump 2.0. And the report that we came out with based on the data is Trump 2.0, narrative warfare and the breakdown of reality.

46:32Even faster, he issued 143 executive orders in his first 100 days. And each one of those executive orders actually had a real world impact. So we journalists wrote about USAID breaking down, but we did not pick them up, each one of those executive orders, as content triggers in the virtual world that created that cycle I just laid out. The picture you paint is quite a grim one at the beginning, but actually the point of the book is to try and stop people feeling too helpless and hopeless. So as citizens, given the power of certain governments over our life and the power of information technology and the power of these huge amounts of money that some of the tech companies have.

47:21How do we not feel hopeless? What does the average citizen do then? I wrote the book because I was tired of learned helplessness. Everyone says the news is horrible. I'm not going to watch the news. People watch the news, right, and act. What do we have to do? It is to retain our humanity. Nobel Peace Prize laureate Maria Ressa on her book The Fight Back, A Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators. It's out next week. That was NewsHour for a late Wednesday evening, UK time. Good to have had you with us. Thanks for listening. Bye-bye for now.

48:25An observatory in space. This is the real deal. This is going to revolutionize astronomy. Capable of capturing light from the dawn of the universe. It could be real exciting for the astronomical community, I guess, and for the whole world to see what Hubble really can do. From the BBC World Service, 13 Minutes, Trouble with Hubble. The story of the Hubble Space Telescope. Listen now on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

From the publisher

People across Israel and around the world have been marking the third anniversary of the October the seventh attacks -- which saw Hamas- led fighters kill around twelve- hundred people. Hamas officials say Israel's subsequent offensive in Gaza has killed more than seventy- five- thousand people.

Also in the programme: The World Health Organisation has warned against using surgery and weight loss drugs to tackle the rising obesity rates in children; commuters in Kyiv talk about living under the daily threat of attack, as Russian strikes intensify; and we look back the nine-decade career of Hollywood star, Eva Marie Saint.

(Photo credit: Getty Images)

More from Newshour

All episodes