

The episode is about a Microsoft global outage and its ripple effects. Microsoft reported progress fixing disruptions affecting Microsoft 365 services in 70+ countries, including Outlook email/calendars, Teams, online meetings, and Copilot. Key impacts included email downtime for organizations and individuals, with health services, government departments, businesses, and a GP practice in Cornwall relying on Microsoft products. Microsoft said recovery may be intermittent as restoration continues; evidence of improvement included email returning and fewer outage reports on tracking sites, though recovery took about 24 hours and some fixes reportedly failed before working.
Chris Vallance (BBC senior technology reporter) interviews; Paul Armstrong (founder of UK tech advisory TBD Group) discusses likely causes like overload/snowball effects; Dr. Tim Frank (Cornwall GP practice) describes real-world disruption.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion of the widespread impact of Microsoft's outage on various sectors.
“As I mentioned, just as we were coming on air, Microsoft put out statements saying that some users may still experience intermittent access as recovery continues.”
Insight into how governments are adapting to communication challenges due to the outage.
“Dr Tim Frank runs a primary care public medical practice in Cornwall, a GP surgery as it's known, in southwest England.”
Personal account of a healthcare professional navigating the disruptions caused by the outage.
“Well, we are starting to see email coming back, as you mentioned here, and I think other people that we've been speaking to are seeing email, which seems to be the key thing affected returning.”
Technology reporter discusses the current status and recovery efforts from Microsoft.
“that sits at the heart of, you know, thousands and millions of people working life and, you know, is used by all sorts of critical systems as your sequence at the start highlighted.”
Discussion with a technology expert about potential causes of the outage and system resilience.
“Paul Armstrong is the founder of the UK-based TBD Group.”
The need for organizations to prepare for technology failures and the costs involved.
“So, again, sort of learning as they go and sort of giving extra technological advice is sort of one thing they're always going to be looking for, really.”
Wrap-up of the discussion about Microsoft's outage and its broader implications.
“and Amazon's sales department to call some people.”
Learn about Pakistan's rapid shift to solar energy and its implications.
“The Turkish hosts of this year's UN Climate Summit, COP31, say they want one of the big points of focus to be a new goal for electrification, to speed the move away from fossil fuels.”
Discover the phenomenon of strong gravitational lenses and recent findings.
“Astronomers call it one of the universe's most remarkable spectacles, light bending and mind bending in equal measure.”
Understand the EU's involvement and position in the ongoing Ukraine conflict.
“What were Lyons doing in York in the third century?”
Examine the fallout from NVIDIA's CEO resignation and its implications.
“It's live from the BBC World Service with me, Tim Franks.”
Explore the political dynamics surrounding NVIDIA's leadership changes and implications.
“and is covering the political fallout of the NVIDIA story.”
Discuss the concept of key person risk and its implications for NVIDIA's future.
“as a particularly extreme example of something called key person risk, loading responsibility and power onto one single person without an obvious fallback.”
Learn about the dire medical conditions in Gaza due to ongoing military strikes.
“For more than a year, hospitals in Gaza have told the BBC that just since yesterday, 14 people have been killed by the IDF.”
Examine the significance of Pope Leo's visit to Peru against a backdrop of past human rights abuses.
“This is NewsHour from the BBC with me, Tim Franks.”
Learn about the deep connections and challenges faced by Pope Leo during his early years in Peru.
“So they were difficult and dark times at the 11-year period that I was living with him in Trujillo.”
Explore the historical significance of the Fan Bay Plotting Room in WWII and its recent opening to the public.
“More than 50 years after it was buried and lost, a landmark of wartime technical know-how has been unearthed and today for the first time it's been open to the public.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:07Hello and welcome to NewsHour. It's coming to you live from the BBC World Service studios in central London. I'm Tim Franks and as we come on air, Microsoft says that it is making progress trying to sort out an outage that has affected its services around the world. Outlook, think of email and calendars, Teams, the online meeting app, and the artificial intelligence software co-pilot have all been affected around the world in more than 70 countries. Health services, government departments, businesses, and of course, individual users have been among those experiencing disruption. As I mentioned, just as we were coming on air, Microsoft put out statements saying that some users may still experience intermittent access as recovery continues.
0:59But just here in the BBC, our emails appear to be back up and running, but they have been down for much of the last 24 hours. According to Microsoft's own figures, more than 430 million people across the globe use Microsoft 365 apps. In Japan, Minoru Kahara is the Chief Cabinet Secretary. The government's IT infrastructure, GSS, is still experiencing certain issues when communicating with other ministries. Prime Minister Takeichi instructed three things to all ministries at 10am following Microsoft's outage. To secure alternative communication tools, such as telephones, and let others know. to support those who are facing application deadlines and make sure they don't face any disadvantages and to capture the impact of the outage and report accordingly.
1:55Australia's Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said he was in close contact with Microsoft about the problems his country was experiencing. In terms of the impact so far, the impact that they are dealing with very much is very much on email systems. The relationship that we have with Microsoft is an important one. There is good security work that is done with Microsoft as a business. And when it came to the formal cyber agreements, which I've signed on behalf of Australia, the first of those was with Microsoft. That agreement has in fact been activated today to make sure that we get appropriate prioritisation of Australian interests in this.
2:36Let's talk about one individual user. Dr Tim Frank runs a primary care public medical practice in Cornwall, a GP surgery as it's known, in southwest England. He told the BBC that he was already trying to organise workarounds. All the local nursing homes, the intensive community support services that keep people out of hospital and communications with the hospital when we admit patients rely upon Microsoft products. There have been no emails overnight or again this morning. This is going to be very disruptive today, and Fridays are always a heavily laden day due to the upcoming weekend. However, since the radio reports, we are already distributing alternative communication numbers throughout our teams, so hopefully no patients will suffer.
3:28Let's get the latest now with our senior technology reporter, Chris Valance. Chris, as I mentioned at the start of the programme, Microsoft says they're making progress. What's the evidence? Well, we are starting to see email coming back, as you mentioned here, and I think other people that we've been speaking to are seeing email, which seems to be the key thing affected returning. I have to say on the status page from Microsoft, this is where they document what's going on, they do suggest that there are sort of variations regionally in how that recovery is going. But I mean, if I look at Down Detector, which sort of tracks outages, admittedly it probably has a bias towards perhaps English-speaking users.
4:15It's showing the number of people reporting issues falling consistently this afternoon. So, you know, I think we are on the mend, but let's not jinx it, because we've seen with these outages that, you know, suddenly things can go wrong or take longer to fix than anticipated. Well, you say take longer to fix than anticipated. I mean, it has been, correct me if I'm wrong, the best part of 24 hours. It feels like, for one of these sorts of things, it feels like it's been very slow. Indeed, and I think that's something people are drawing a lot of attention to. I mean, you know, when did it start? The first reports were sort of around about six o 'clock.
4:58And here we are, what are we, 20 hours later? And, you know, it's just being, we're now getting, things are getting better. We're on the road to recovery. You know, that is a very long time for such a critical piece of business software that sits at the heart of, you know, thousands and millions of people working life and, you know, is used by all sorts of critical systems as your sequence at the start highlighted. Yeah. I mean, it was interesting. Obviously, Microsoft, you know, are not giving us a running conjure on absolutely everything they've been doing. But from what I have been seeing, it did seem to be interesting that Microsoft was saying, you know, some of the, I don't know quite what technical terms they use, but essentially some of the fixes, some of the patches we try to use haven't really worked.
5:50So it felt as if they were scrambling a little bit. Yes, I mean, you can see them again through these these status updates, they were giving a sort of a bit of a running commentary on what they were trying to do to fix it in quite technical language. So I'm going to caveat this with, you know, I'm not a networking engineer or a server engineer. So, you know, I'm interpreting this. But I mean, they were trying things like so, for example, they say one of the problems was that these servers, these are the big computers, you know, warehouses, data centers all around the world, that run things like your email.
6:27They're saying that some of these were declaring themselves unwell, if you like. They were not functioning properly and were sort of effectively turning themselves off. And then that was sending traffic to other computers, which were then suddenly swamped. So it's a little bit like trying to, you know, sort of adapt to, say, the closure of a motorway. You know, other roads then get jammed up. And then you've got this constant problem of everybody wanting to use the system. And the minute you sort of start something up again, immediately all the traffic, all the data requests come to that thing and it falls over.
7:03So I think that's part of the story. I mean, we don't have a clear, plain English post-mortem yet. We may get that in the coming hours and days. Chris Vallance, our senior technology reporter, thank you very much. Paul Armstrong is the founder of the UK-based TBD Group. It's an independent technology advisory firm. Paul, thanks for your time here on NewsHour. I realise I'm asking you to sort of guess, probably without all the information in front of you, but what is your best guess as to what has gone wrong here? I think you could have sort of hit the nail on the head a minute ago with an overload.
7:45That's probably what happened, where remaining systems essentially receive more demand that they can handle and they try and pass it off and it creates more issues and that sort of thing. Equally, it could be something to do with power or cooling failure. There's lots of things that can cause these areas. In the past, an update's been released, and it's caused systems to sort of go down and things like that. It can also be physical damage, a rat gnawing through a wire and stuff like that. These are these systems that are still physically on the ground, even though they're called the cloud, and they can have lots of problems.
8:18But because of Microsoft's size and other companies, when they have issues of this magnitude, they go very big, very wrong, very quickly. Yeah, well, as we have seen. But I thought, I mean, if it is, and, you know, lots of people are talking about this snowball effect in terms of the sort of the power that is needed and the demands that are needed as one bit goes down and then another bit gets overloaded. I thought that these systems were supposed to have automatic load balancing, but can they just be overwhelmed? That's the key. You know, every system has a limit to what it can take. So it passes on to another one, passes on to another.
9:00That is a finite answer to sort of have. You can only build in so much backup to these things. I think those limits may need to be improved. If it is that issue, obviously, we are guessing at this sort of stage, it's more likely to sort of be this with the way that they're bringing it back up. But yeah, these are systems that, you know, a lot of people, they've never dealt with the scale before. So that's one thing to sort of keep in mind. So, again, sort of learning as they go and sort of giving extra technological advice is sort of one thing they're always going to be looking for, really. Yeah.
9:27I mean, I suppose there are obviously questions as to what conclusions and what improvements Microsoft can draw from this and what greater resilience perhaps they can build in. What about for the rest of us? I mean, it's tremendously difficult, isn't it, to sort of tell organizations or tell companies that they need to plan for failure? They need to be able to diversify, have other options. I mean, it would be incredibly expensive to be able to have something that you can just turn to immediately. Yeah, and costly for people as well. So, you know, having a backup for something that shouldn't fail, you know, that's key.
10:06But the sort of measure of resilience is how much essential work you can sort of continue while those repairs sort of happen, number one. But then also moving forward, making sure that, God forbid, it happens again. I mean, it's going to happen again. It happens a lot all the time. but with different people, not just Microsoft. But it's intriguing to sort of see how a company can be resilient. For example, a lot of people got caught off the hop and they didn't have really ways to sort of communicate with their people. And they went back to the old school social medias and people were making fun of them with pigeon remarks and that sort of stuff.
10:32But it's important for companies and organisations to have sort of independent backups and make sure you've got things like important numbers and emails and that written down and you've got the ways of getting that out, like a telephone tree, which is to a lot of people like, what's a telephone tree, you know? So it's figuring out, making sure that people have these sort of understanding and methods for when these things do happen to make sure that it's easy for people to sort of keep as business as usual as possible. Are you reassured by the indications that this does not appear to have been a malicious attack?
11:00Yes, I think that's a good thing for everyone to know that it's not a malicious attack, you know, and that sort of thing. I think you have a duty of care if you suspect that to say it immediately. So that is good. the argument for a lot of conspiracy theories and how information travels on the internet at the moment, I think that's important to get that out straight away, so I think that's a good thing I think increasingly bad actors and things like that are everywhere there's been a lot of the news this week about spies and what not, I think it's important for people to sort of understand that not everything is always bad actors and things like that sometimes just the technology does fail But I suppose one of the things people may have to be just careful about is as systems begin to reset, I presume it's going to be prime territory for people phishing attacks, that sort of thing.
11:45You know, people sending emails suggesting you need to click on this in order to reset your password. You know, people should be particularly vigilant about that in the wake of this. Yes, I think particularly vigilant is never not be vigilant for phishing attacks. They're unfortunately getting more and smarter every day. So yeah, always being aware of those sort of areas. Expect intermittent issues for the next sort of 24 to 48 hours, I would imagine. And also just, you know, everything with a pinch of salt and make sure that you're looking at where emails come from and, yeah, keeping aware of all of those things.
12:13And just in terms, I mean, Microsoft is so omnipresent. I mean, you presumably aren't drawing the conclusion that somehow Microsoft's dominance of the sector is going to be under threat in any way from this. I definitely think it doesn't help them. It's certainly not a good PR story to ever do it. They have sort of put out everything that they should do in the right sort of time and manner and that sort of stuff. But again, I think a lot of IT departments have new options these days. Amazon, Google, others and that sort of stuff. But Microsoft, as you say, are still very dominant, but they are not the only player in there.
12:41That may cause some heads to turn and certainly an opportunity for Google's sales department and Amazon's sales department to call some people. Paul Armstrong, thank you very much for joining us here on NewsHour, founder of the UK-based TBD Group independent technology advisory firm. We've got a live page up on this on our still-functioning website, bbc.com forward slash news. Coming up on the programme is the fallout from the resignation of the NVIDIA boss Jensen Huang continues to reverberate. We'll look at the tricky business of corporate succession planning. It's almost certain that someone else is going to come in and look at some of what they've inherited and think, I'm not sure I want all that risk in my name.
13:21And so there's going to be some reckoning whether someone else comes in and has the same audacity as the leather-jacketed predecessor. More on succession planning. and key risk, a key person risk rather. That's coming up in 15 minutes. Our main headline, it's what we've been talking about. Microsoft says it's making progress in fixing an internet services failure that's caused disruption for millions of people around the world.
13:56You're with NewsHour, live from the BBC, I'm Tim Franks. The Turkish hosts of this year's UN Climate Summit, COP31, say they want one of the big points of focus to be a new goal for electrification, to speed the move away from fossil fuels. One country that has seen a rapid increase in solar is Pakistan. In the space of a few years, around a quarter of its electricity is now produced by solar. But as panels spread across the country's rooftops, the country's government is trying to stop the exodus from the national grid from sending it into a total demise. So what lessons can the world learn from Pakistan?
14:35Islamabad correspondent Caroline Davis reports.
14:43From industrialists to tiny villages, solar panels are everywhere in Pakistan. As-salamu alaykum. This is my room. Faisal lives in rural Punjab. He got married a few months ago. His wife's dowry stowed carefully in one room, gifts from her family for their future. So you have all the silverware up here, and the bed new as well? Four ornate wooden charpais, fans, sofas, and one particularly special item, stored for safekeeping under the bed.
15:23And this is your new solar panel? Amazing. How many watts is this?
15:32Even in small weddings here, people used to give motorbikes or other household items. Now they give a solar panel and an air cooler. It has become almost a must. One panel can power a fan, but for now, the rest of his electricity is from the grid. Three families live here. The water motor runs, the washing machine runs, the iron runs. When there is that kind of heavy load, the bill is higher too. When a bill of 15 or 18 ,000 rupees comes, we can't afford it. I want solar panels over every room of the house so everything runs on solar. I'll do this in a month or two. Pakistan's solar transformation in the last few years has been unprecedented.
16:16And none of it was planned. When electricity prices became too high and solar panels started dropping in cost, people made the switch. But it's not only households. Large-scale industries have increased their solar panels too, including Koh-Noor textile mills in Islamabad. This factory produces material that's shipped around the world. It's been buying solar panels for years and is planning more, along with industrial-sized batteries to store excess solar energy for when the sun goes down, which means they'll be even less dependent on the grid. Tawfiq Saeed Saigal is the company's CEO. We can say that the state must do everything, but the state, unfortunately, today doesn't have the resources.
16:58So we can't really say that we blame everything on the state. So we need to do some of the things ourselves. Pakistan is heavily dependent on imported fuel. Solar can help ease that. But fewer consumers on the national grid means the cost goes up for those still on it. That can encourage more to leave, which raises prices again, risking sending the national grid into a death spiral and creating a two-tier system of solar haves and have-nots. The cost is already being felt. Just the past two years, the exodus from the grid has cost the rest of the consumers more than US$500 million a year. Awais Ahmed Lagari is Pakistan's energy minister.
17:40This is going very rapidly. Is there a fear that this could run away from you? No fear at all. We've already incorporated that growth. Are you trying to slow it down a bit to make sure it doesn't go any further? We can't slow it down. It's not under control. The only thing that will slow it down is a more efficient pricing mechanism on the grid. And that's what we are focusing on. We are wanting to compete with this technology. The government says the exodus from the grid is slowing. The threat is not over. Analysts say Pakistan is at a crossroads. It can be a lesson to others on the pitfalls that can befall a fast energy transition or a guiding light in how to make solar power a success.
18:27And that was Caroline Davis reporting for us from Pakistan. Astronomers call it one of the universe's most remarkable spectacles, light bending and mind bending in equal measure. It's known as strong gravitational lenses and up to now it had been thought to be very rare, or at least the phenomenon only had been rarely detected. But now a team has discovered an order of magnitude more of them. Natalie Lyons is a PhD student astronomer at the University of Portsmouth and the co-leader of the team. Natalie, welcome to NewsHour. I obviously was speaking with great authority about strong gravitational lenses.
19:07Haven't got a clue. What is it and what are they and what does it look like? Yeah, so gravitational lensing is the distortion and magnification of images of galaxies. It's actually a consequence of Einstein's theory of general relativity, which tells us that massive objects such as galaxies and also galaxy clusters bend the fabric of space-time, and that in turn bends the light from anything behind them. When this effect becomes so extreme, this light can actually take multiple routes through the universe, meaning that we actually see multiple images of the same background galaxy and it's often warped into arcs and rings and this is strong gravitational lensing.
19:47However because you need multiple galaxies to line up really really perfectly it's really really rare which is why very few have been found up until now. Well you say quite and I love some of your description I mean bending the fabric of space-time but so you it's very rare that you see this sort of this alignment that allows you to see these multiple images, and yet you have detected, what, 15 ,000 of them? Yeah. So tell me how. So what is actually really crucial for finding strong lenses is the quality of the data that you search in. This is because this strong lensing effect is actually so small on the sky that most of them can't really be seen through Earth's blurring atmosphere.
20:35And while we've had previous space telescopes, such as Hubble, these space telescopes have only covered tiny, tiny areas of the sky. Whereas Euclid is a space telescope that was launched in 2023 that is on a mission to survey a third of the whole sky with this sharp space-based imaging and to build a 3D map of the cosmos. And this also makes it really the perfect instrument for finding things that are both small and rare, like these strong gravitational lenses. And I was reading that you have surveyed, I mean, you've picked out these phenomena, this strong gravitational lensing from 900 million galaxies.
21:14I mean, that sort of makes my teeth fall out just thinking about that. But I mean, it is remarkable. Tell me how you do that. Yeah, yeah, you're absolutely right. It's really huge quantities of data. In fact, in total, it was about 1.7 million gigabytes that we had to search through. So this was great because it meant that there were going to be loads of strong lenses hiding in this data. but it also meant that searching for them was extremely challenging. It was actually only possible thanks to a combination of machine learning and also citizen science. So around 7 ,000 people at home volunteered their time to help search through this Euclid imaging, and we wouldn't have been able to find them without the help of these people.
21:55And yet this allowed us to find 15 ,000 strong lenses, which is more than astronomers had found in the entire history of the field up until now. It's just remarkable. I introduce you as a PhD student. I mean, what's going on? Am I going to be calling you Professor Lyons tomorrow? Yes, no, I am a PhD student. But I'm very fortunate that I've got to work with a load of amazing collaborators, not just here at the University of Portsmouth, but worldwide. The Euclid Consortium has over 2 ,000 scientists over a dozen countries. So it's really a huge team effort. OK, well, you're very modest about it, but it sounds like an absolutely amazing research that you've been a co-leader of.
22:37So many, many congratulations. And Natalie Lyons, thank you for joining us here on News App.
22:50In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were Lyons doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glennie, and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world. It's one of the first times, really, that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers. If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure. In our time, listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Another cup of tea.
23:26Welcome back to NewsHour. One potentially significant shift in the latest efforts to bring peace to Ukraine is the emphasis on the involvement of Europe. The US appears keen. European nations are certainly keen. Kaya Callas is the EU's top diplomat. It's high representative for foreign affairs and security policy to give her full title. And she's in Dublin for a meeting of EU leaders and has been taking time to speak to my news colleague, James Menendez. What does she think of Europe getting its own seat at the negotiating table? Well, I think after the almost two years of talks between U.S., Russia, they have now realized that Europe is a big player here because we are the ones who have been supporting Ukraine and we are the ones who have put sanctions in place and we have the frozen assets.
24:16So clearly, without us, any agreement that is there cannot be implemented. Because let us be very clear, there is one aggressor and one victim. How do we make sure that this aggressor does not attack again? Russia's position, and this is coming from President Putin's representative at the talks, I mean, he put it quite bluntly. He said Europe needs to decide whether it wants war with Russia or peace. What do you make of that? Well, we have always wanted peace with Russia. If you think about before this war started, Europe was living in peace with Russia, was doing a lot of trade with Russia, all these countries, but it still didn't satisfy Russia, and they needed more territory.
24:58We had the security architecture in place. We did not have a war. Russia started this war, and we want to make sure that they don't start any new wars, because if you look at the history, last 100 years, Russia has attacked at least 11 countries, some as many as three or four times. And none of these countries has ever attacked Russia. Is the EU ready to present a united front, though? I mean, it doesn't seem at the moment, for example, that the EU can agree even who might represent the bloc. If the other leaders said, look, actually, Kaya Kalas, we think it should be you. You take that up, would you?
25:34Well, I'm the high representative for European security and foreign policy. So European security is my mandate, what the leaders were giving me in 2024. So of course, I'm ready to do that job, because that is the job that I was given in 2024 by the leaders of European Union, and then afterwards also by the European Parliament. Okay, so that's a yes. Because there has been some suggestion that they don't want to choose you because you're seen as too hawkish against Russia. Let's imagine a scenario where you are around that table. Are you prepared to make compromises if it means peace in Ukraine?
26:15Well, I'm representing 27 EU member states. I have the meetings with the EU foreign ministers every single month. I get my mandate to negotiate from the EU member states. I'm not representing myself. I'm representing European Union. That is also putting the frames to my work. Yes, of course, I'm very strongly opinionated. That's very true. But But that's why I was chosen to be the high representative for European foreign and security policy. And that was exactly the reason. And that was Kaya Callas, the EU's top tip, talking to James Menendez. You're with NewsHour. It's live from the BBC World Service with me, Tim Franks.
27:01The US tech giant NVIDIA, indeed much of the US tech sector, is hoping that the resignation of Jensen Huang at pretty much precisely this time yesterday will, before long, calm the turmoil around one of the world's most highly valued companies. Huang's fall from rock star CEO and AI industry leader came after newspaper revelations about his alleged extramarital affairs, one with an NVIDIA employee, one with a woman suspected of being a Chinese spy. But the prospect of a rapid and neat ending to all this looks distant. Several congressional committees have summoned Jensen Huang for questioning.
27:38The Senate Banking Committee has requested that not just the former NVIDIA boss, but also the U.S. Commerce Secretary, Howard Lutnick, appear before its members. Recent reports raise serious concerns about our national security and the protection of sensitive U.S. technology, wrote the committee's Republican chairman, Senator Tim Scott. Daniel Lippman is the White House and Washington reporter for Politico and is covering the political fallout of the NVIDIA story. So Lutnik is seen as very pro-tech, pro-AI, someone who Jensen Huang was very close to in the administration. And the Commerce Department has been at the forefront of kind of opposing export controls on chips, which was a big NVIDIA priority.
28:24They wanted to keep selling their chips to China, make sure that Southeast Asian countries that had potential chip smuggling from those countries to China, that they kind of got a pass as well. And so he's received a lot of blowback from the White House, from inside the administration and Republicans and Democrats on Capitol Hill because of that. Is there a feeling that there may well be stuff on the record here with Lutnick that the Commerce Secretary that he's actually said in terms, I think, for example, that this company Megaspeed, which is the one that the woman who is alleged to have been a Chinese spy, she was involved in and she was the one who had the affair with Jensen Huang, that he may well have said, look, we need to tread lightly with this company.
29:14Well, the U.S. government was warned a year ago that there were some issues, that there was this likely affair. The New York Times even wrote a story around the same time in 2025 about this unusual company. and President Trump and Lutnik really did not do much. And so a lot of people in the administration are unhappy that Lutnik was seen as just, hey, let's just keep the AI boom rolling. I think there was reporting about a confrontation in the Oval Office in the White House a couple of days ago with Scott Bessent, the Treasury Secretary with Lutnik, where they want to now do these export controls and Lutnik is still kind of resisting.
29:59And so that's led people in the White House to be asking tough questions about whether Trump should fire him. But Trump has known Lutnick for a long time, and so it's unlikely he may get rid of him just at this point. Yeah, I mean, it's fascinating because it's also about the dynamics within the administration. And as you say, although Howard Lutnick is seen as being an old friend of the president, And I mean, Mr. Lutnick himself has made real enemies. I mean, the battle to become Treasury Secretary supposedly between him and Scott Besson, I mean, it sounded absolutely bruising that there may well be people within the administration who wouldn't be so unhappy were he to be the fool guy.
30:44We're going to see how this plays out in terms of Capitol Hill hearings. But Lutnick is this very brash guy. Trump likes this type of dealmaker. And so he may want to keep him on the inside and rather not have him on the outside, potentially criticizing him down the road if he doesn't get a graceful exit. And so you're seeing much more infighting in the White House and administration. And also Republicans are not afraid of Trump on Capitol Hill after the historic losses last week. Daniel Littman in Washington. NVIDIA does have a new boss, at least an interim boss. She's Colette Kress, previously the long-serving chief financial officer.
31:23But lots of people have been talking about the dethroning of Jensen Huang, such a dominant figure in the company and sector, as a particularly extreme example of something called key person risk, loading responsibility and power onto one single person without an obvious fallback. Bruce Daisley is a writer on workplace culture and a former vice president of Twitter. What's his view? We witnessed this. We witness the importance of lining up succession in multiple areas of life. We witness it maybe if our football team loses the manager and we think, well, why did they not anticipate this? Or we witness it politically.
31:59You know, sometimes confidently, there's a very comfortable building up a series of people around them. Whereas leaders whose power seems to be leveraged, like Putin, seems to be leveraged on their preeminence are reluctant to do it. And in this regard, Jensen Huang has really behaved like a Trump, like a Putin, trying to ensure that he was very much seen as a genius with many helpers rather than the steward of a group of intelligent equals. And it sort of poses enormous problems. Huang very famously had 50 direct reports. And that might seem, it seems a lot of people to deal with, but it's also a way to ensure that he had no obvious successor.
32:42Now, one of the things that you might say in the defense of that, it was a very flat culture. You didn't have managers reporting into managers, reporting into managers. And that was certainly the way that it was sold as a benign, progressive way to overcome bureaucracy. But what it does do is it puts us in the situation now where this company that maybe some listeners have missed the fact that this is the biggest company in the world. And it's sort of it's found its way to this situation now where it's got no obvious leader. And the whole of the AI ecology largely depends on NVIDIA. So it's this remarkable situation we've unexpectedly found ourselves in.
33:21Yeah. I mean, I suppose one counter argument to what you're saying is that had he appointed an obvious deputy or an obvious successor, then as with political careers, you have the possibility of being seen as less powerful. and that can have more consequences than just to one's own ego because it can mean that maybe people take you a little bit less seriously. But also this, I mean, apparently absurd number of direct reports that he had, these dozens of direct reports, it could mean that equally the person who has stepped up, I mean, albeit in an interim role, she's only had to step up one rung, as it were.
34:07Yeah, that's right. Although, you know, she was one of 49 other people doing similar roles. So as a result, she might now find herself in the position of having to earn respect, having to earn her power from 49 other people who thought it could have been me. Look, it's an anachronistic model of leadership. The notion that leaders are the special one. They are set apart from the rest of us. And certainly it's left his company in a quite tricky position. one of the things that you might presume is that there's a lot of audacity and bombast that's gone into the nvidia business in the last couple of years they've taken some sort of quite high stakes risks quite often when you've got this explosive exponential growth trying to work out whether you're going to grow 100 or 200 next year well the margin of error is pretty vast when it comes to a multi-trillion dollar company and so as a result of that it's almost certain that someone else is going to come in and look at some of what they've inherited and think, I'm not sure I want all that risk in my name.
35:12And so it's going to be this. The reason why the markets, I think, have reacted so badly is that I suspect there's going to be some reckoning whether someone else comes in and has the same audacity as the leather-jacketed predecessor. And that was Bruce Daisley. We talk a lot less about Gaza these days, but the conditions there for the more than two million Palestinians crammed into a beleaguered strip of the enclave remain miserable, especially now as winter is closing in, but also with continuing strikes by the Israeli military, despite the ceasefire that's supposed to have been in effect. For more than a year, hospitals in Gaza have told the BBC that just since yesterday, 14 people have been killed by the IDF.
35:54Overnight on Wednesday, six people are reported to have died and about 30 were injured in an Israeli airstrike on Nasser hospital in the south of the Gaza Strip. Among those confirmed to have died in the strike was the surgeon Dr. Rizik Abu-Shaira. Dr. Feroz Sidwa is a trauma surgeon from the US who's worked in Gaza. And indeed, he knew and worked alongside Dr. Rizik. And Dr. Sidwa joins us from New York. Thank you very much for your time. Tell me what Dr. Rizik was like. yeah dr isek was a wonderful guy we um in in surgery there are surgeons who like surgery like me i i enjoy surgery i enjoy being in the operating room obviously but then there are there's a smaller subset that just love surgery i mean they just cannot get enough of it and that's that was dr is a key this man just loved being in the operating room he loved caring for surgical patients he just he would actually like run ahead on rounds to get charts pull down dressings he just he was an incredibly enthusiastic man.
36:56And even after, you know, 20 years of experience, he's still, he really just lit up anytime there was an operation to do. He was a wonderful colleague to have. And I, you know, the, the, it's, it's very bizarre. You know, I'm in a documentary film and he and I are actually on the, on the poster of it together. And so now knowing that he's been killed while at work waiting to do an operation, you know, the only solace I can take from it is that he probably died happy because he was about to go into the operating room. You worked in Nassau Hospital. The Israeli military said of this particular strike that it was targeting a particular commander of a Hamas brigade and that there were other fighters hiding inside the hospital.
37:43When you were there, I mean, I presume it's incredibly difficult because you're not stopping everybody who you see in a corridor and asking, you know, what their affiliations might be. But I mean, did you get any sense that there may have been, I'm sure against the medical staff's wishes, but that there may have been armed people or militants in the hospital? There's nothing even remotely approaching a militarization of a hospital by the Palestinians anywhere in the Gaza Strip. This is a common, the Israelis say this all the time. I was almost killed at Nazar Medical Complex on March 23rd. I was on my way down to a 16-year-old boy's room that I'd operated on five days later when the Israeli military fired a drone-fired missile directly into it, killing him.
38:25Now, they said that they were doing that because the other guy in the room, whose name was Ismail Barhum, he was the prime minister of Gaza. Well, okay, let's just turn the antagonists around for a second. Benjamin Netanyahu had his prostate removed in December of 2024 in a hospital in Jerusalem, and by every account, he militarized the hospital. He ran war cabinet meetings there. He ordered strikes on Gaza from there. Does that mean Hamas can bomb the hospital when Nip Nihau was there. That's insane. It's so completely and utterly crazy that I don't, I'm sorry, I know you can tell it's making me angry, but I do not have words for the fact that anybody even takes this seriously anymore.
39:01It's outrageous. And in terms of Nasa Hospital and its importance to those in the south of the Gaza Strip, I mean, can you just put that in some context for us? Yeah. So, you know, three of the surgeons there were badly injured and one was killed and two others were badly injured. One seems very likely to die, Dr. Mohamed. And the operating rooms are not functional anymore because the strike hit the fourth floor ICU and operating theater and also the second floor men's surgical ward, from what I understand. So there are basically no longer serious surgical services available in the Gaza Strip at any of the hospitals.
39:40The hospital system in Gaza, the BBC has covered this pretty well has just been ripped to shreds. Nothing like this has ever been done to a hospital system before. Dr. Perez, I'm afraid we'll have to leave it there, but thank you so much for joining us. This is NewsHour from the BBC with me, Tim Franks. The Pope may be the head of the Catholic Church worldwide, but pontiffs have always had a special connection with some countries more than others. And in the case of Pope Leo, his current visit to Peru is a cause of particular delight, probably for him, but definitely for many Peruvians, because Robert Prevost, as he was before he became Pope Leo XIV, spent nearly a decade as a bishop in Peru before leaving in 2023.
40:22Father John Lydon is a fellow Augustinian priest and served in Peru at the same time as Pope Leo. He's now director of a leadership institute at Villanova University in Pennsylvania in the US, joins us now. Father Lydon, thank you very much for your time. um pope leo born in the u.s but he does call peru his homeland doesn't he yes definitely um he actually most of his pastoral ministry was actually in peru he did very little in the united states after his training and his degrees he went to peru on two occasions he was there first of all from 1985 to 99, and then went back as bishop into Chaclayo the second time down.
41:10And when he was there, I mean, these were really dark days for Peru. And I mean, they were under the leadership of Alberto Fujimori when terrible human rights abuses were were committed. And it must be a visit for him that is freighted with particular weight, given that, you know, Fujimori's daughter Keiko is now the sort of the president and greeting him in country. Yes, certainly. The late 1980s and 90s were very difficult years in Peru. As you said, we had the, first of all, terrorism is signing pass in Dero Luminoso, and there's another group also, MRTA. And then the repression of the Alberto Fujimori government when he dissolved the Congress and took all the power and the human rights abuses that resulted from that.
42:10So they were difficult and dark times at the 11-year period that I was living with him in Trujillo. this was before he was bishop in Chiclayo of course so these were the early days yes the early days when we first were there together can I ask given how you obviously knew him at such a formative time how do you think he's doing? oh I think he's doing great You know, the Proven people have a lot of what they call cariño, love for him, in part because he accompanied them. In those years, the 90s, our superiors in the United States asked us to come up with an exit plan to leave Peru because it was just like collapsing the country with the terrorism and the government abuses.
43:09and he and all of us, the Augustinians, we responded and said, we didn't think we should do that. We should accompany the people in their time of the cross. So the very fact of accompanying them during those times and not leaving the country, I think it was just indicative of that tie to the Peruvian people that he felt. And they felt that from him. So way back, even in those years of the 90s, he forged this strong relationship just by being with them during those difficult times. Wonderful to hear. Well, Father John Lydon, thank you very much indeed for sharing those memories of your time in Peru with Pope Leo and also the importance of his visit right now.
43:58More than 50 years after it was buried and lost, a landmark of wartime technical know-how has been unearthed and today for the first time it's been open to the public. The Fan Bay Plotting Room, an underground bunker in the White Cliffs of Dover on the southeast coast of England, played a key part in the defence of the English Channel against the possibility of invasion by Nazi forces. But long before its secret role was made public, all signs of it had been removed. David Sillito has been to take a look. Dover had a nickname in the Second World War, Hellfire Corner. German guns try to achieve what Nazi bombers fail to do.
44:38From the French coast, high-velocity guns bombard our shipping. There were no bluebirds over the White Clefs, just huge guns. And directing them, a place so secret its existence was classified until the 1980s. And for decades, this underground command point was lost. The old military sites had been deemed to be an eyesore and had been buried. More than 50 years on, the site is now owned by the National Trust and it's been doing some detective work. And even this road was under earth then, we're crossing over. Everything up here was buried, yes. Gentlemen, just to introduce yourself, you are? I'm Gordon Wise, I'm a volunteer.
45:17And I'm John Barker and I'm the project lead. So Gordon, we're standing on top of the White Cliffs of Dover here, aren't we? This has been 15 years in the making and this was the needle in a haystack I think we need to go into the ground guys, don't we? We're walking in now There's a metal hatch across there That is the main entrance If you can open the hatch door, that'd be great Right, come it on
45:48From a vantage point, the Prime Minister takes a keen interest in new military preparations We shall defend our island, whatever the crust may be. Right, so you are now at the base of the main shaft. This was the original entrance, and there would have been steel rungs into the wall here, and that was how the soldiers would have come down. The first thing that strikes are these very heavy iron doors that takes me to the one larger room. This, underneath the rivets, the rust and the remnants, was the beating heart of the Battle of the Channel, the plotting room. Line-up at 150 degrees, 8 ,000 yards.
46:41Travel correction balance dials, coincidence. What is plotting? The plotting is taking all the inputs, things like your wind speed, direction, your humidity and coordinates of the target and putting them all into a computer. There was a computer down here. There was a computer here. We're talking about 1941, 1942. You're talking 41. 41. There's a computer. It is an electromechanical computer that is capable of providing a firing solution. Prepare for action. They are firing out at sea. They're firing to seaward. This is Churchill's orders to close the Dover Strait to enemy shipping. Now, here inside the cliffs, you can watch what was going on in this top-secret bunker with its 1940s computer.
47:35And that was David Sillito in the bunker, the fan bay plotting room, out in Dover. That's it from this news hour from all of us here. Thanks for listening.
Microsoft says it's made progress fixing its services after an outage caused major problems across the world. Why is it taking so long to fix and what lessons can be learnt?
Also in the programme: does the Nvidia debacle teach us lessons about the importance of planning for a corporate succession?; remembering Dr Rizq abu Shaira, killed in an Israeli airstrike on Gaza's only remaining major hospital; and why the Pope's trip to Peru is so special.