1. Podcasts
  2. Newshour
  3. Serbia's acting president on post-Vucic future
Newshour

29 Oct 2026 · 47m · 18 chapters

Episode artwork

Serbia's acting president on post-Vucic future

In short

Serbia’s post-Aleksandar Vucic political transition after student-led protests and snap parliamentary elections; debate over rule of law, institutional change, and alleged foreign funding.

Guests

Anna Brnabic (acting president; former head of the National Assembly and prime minister; started as a nonpartisan technocrat, later joined Vucic’s Serbian Progressive Party). Boris Tadic (president 2004–2012; liberal, EU-leaning; opposed Western Kosovo policy).

Key claims

Brnabic says the election result is fair and that the new student-backed movement risks “revolutionary terror,” citing hate speech, mob attacks on media, police non-response, and “revolutionary justice” via plans to dismantle judicial/prosecutorial bodies. She alleges large amounts of money entered Serbia from “all over” (Europe, Moscow, US) without evidence she specifies. Tadic argues the transition will be slow due to constitutional constraints and lack of leadership, warns about repeating “deep state” problems, and is optimistic about democratization and security-force reform.

Notable examples

storming/lynching threats toward media; publishing phone numbers; Transparency International labeling Serbia highly corrupt under Vucic; EU member states opposing Serbia’s EU talks over rule-of-law concerns.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:41

Celebration of Change in Serbia

Overview of the jubilation in Belgrade following Vucic's defeat.

“of jubilation in the centre of the Serbian capital, Belgrade, on Sunday night as students took to the streets, setting off fireworks, celebrating the fall of Aleksandr Vucic, who'd led Serbia for 14 years.”
1:16

Student Movement's Demand for Change

Discussion of the student-led movement's success and its demands for change.

“It won over 50 % of the vote in the snap parliamentary elections there.”
2:24

Interview with Acting President Anna Brnovic

Brnovic discusses the election results and the atmosphere in Serbia post-election.

“She actually started as a nonpartisan technocrat, but joined Vucic's Serbian Progressive Party.”
4:24

Brnovic on Revolutionary Terror and Governance

Discussion on claims of revolutionary terror and governance issues in Serbia.

“But that should be done through the institutions if we are to respect the rule of law and not by an angry mob that is actually storming the media that they dislike in order to humiliate people.”
8:06

Political Perspectives from Boris Tadic

Former president Tadic shares insights on the current political situation and power dynamics.

“But to announce that you will immediately dismantle the high prosecutorial counsel, the high judicial counsel, does not mean that you will have independent judiciary.”
10:12

Challenges Ahead for the New Government

Discussion on the challenges the new student-led government will face in Serbia.

“And right now we are facing a new situation.”
12:28

Serbia's Future and EU Membership

Tadic discusses Serbia's prospects for EU membership and national interests.

“So can you see a clear path ahead that takes you back towards Europe?”
14:00

Headlines and Updates

Key news headlines including drone attacks and train accidents.

“Afghanistan's weather patterns are changing, which means more droughts more frequently.”
14:38

Hello Kitty Controversy

Discussion on Sanrio's reaction to a controversial Japanese TV show.

“The makers of the cartoon character Hello Kitty, the company's called Sanrio, have cut ties with a Japanese TV show.”
18:17

Ceasefire in Kherson

Exploration of life in Kherson following a newly organized ceasefire.

“So that began on Tuesday, that truce, and it's worked.”
Show all 18 chapters
23:25

Rise of Short Films

Insights into the flourishing world of short films and their impact.

“You're listening to the World Service of the BBC.”
27:42

Train Crash in Spain

Details from the scene of a devastating train crash in Spain.

“The train crash in Spain yesterday was so catastrophic that the authorities have still not identified all those people who are missing.”
28:00

Investigation and Recovery Efforts After Train Crash

Learn about the ongoing investigations and recovery efforts following a fatal train crash in Spain.

“Well, the Spanish Prime Minister, Pedro Sanchez, has said today that after the recovery effort, there'll be investigations and then compensation for the families of victims.”
33:00

Opium Production Rise in Afghanistan

Explore the reasons behind the sharp increase in opium production in Afghanistan despite Taliban bans.

“although we do have some indications already.”
40:00

Israeli Elections and Allegations of Interference

Understand the current state of the Israeli elections and the allegations of foreign interference.

“And it's the one thing that everyone keeps talking about.”
42:00

Election Integrity and Allegations of Interference

Discussion on the allegations of foreign interference in the recent election and its political implications.

“anything between 430 ,000 and 480 ,000 people.”
44:30

Comet Theory and the Origins of Life

Exploration of the comet theory regarding the origins of life and its recent challenges.

“BBC's James Landale seems there's more and more cases of elections and then the difficult bit, post-elections.”
46:42

New Theories on Earth's Organic Molecules

Discussion about alternative theories and findings regarding the origins of organic molecules on Earth.

“And what we tried to do throughout our study was to give comets the best possible chance when we were making different model assumptions about what the early Earth looked like.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Thomas Jermaine for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

0:41Ana Brnabic: Hello and welcome to NewsHour from the BBC World Service live from London. This is Owen Bennett-Jones.

0:56We are free!

0:58Ana Brnabic: We are free! of jubilation in the centre of the Serbian capital, Belgrade, on Sunday night as students took to the streets, setting off fireworks, celebrating the fall of Aleksandr Vucic, who'd led Serbia for 14 years. He admitted defeat to a student-led protest movement. It won over 50 % of the vote in the snap parliamentary elections there. A remarkable upset by a movement containing very disparate views, but whose supporters could agree on one thing. They all wanted change. We made the historical result. We have to believe in something. This is the one movement which succeeds to overpower one autocratic regime in a peaceful manner.

1:47Ana Brnabic: Well, that was Ilya Stradinovich, the victorious student-less lead candidate, speaking to NewsHour on Monday. Now, the students argued that the Vucic government was corrupt, that it captured state institutions, and like Viktor Orban in Hungary, had tied state employment and benefits to political loyalty, thereby tightening its grip on power. That's what the Victoria students said. So, what about the defeated? Well, Vucic loyalist Anna Branovic is, for the moment, still the acting president of Serbia. She's previously been the head of the National Assembly and prime minister. That was from 17 to 24.

2:26Ana Brnabic: She actually started as a nonpartisan technocrat, but joined Vucic's Serbian Progressive Party. Well, I've been speaking to the acting president. Does she accept that this was a fair result, that a majority of Serbians wanted change? Without any doubt. It's clear from the election results. I myself, I have to say that I was quite surprised. I did not see it coming. You know, I'm also very happy and very proud that we have accepted the results and that we have congratulated our political opponents. You're being very gracious now in your response to what's happened. I mean, some of your tweets are, I don't know, a bit less gracious.

3:12Ana Brnabic: they promised revolutionary terror and we're seeing revolutionary terror. Absolutely. And I am very, very sorry that we are seeing this in Serbia. I'm very sorry that we are living through this in the past basically 72 hours. What we are seeing is a revolutionary terror that is unprecedented since basically 2000s. And in many ways, I think this revolutionary terror is much worse than what we have witnessed back in back in 2000. So what we are seeing is pressure on people pressure on their families, hate speech, people storming some of the institutions, the media that they dislike trying to lynch people live on air.

3:59The police is not

4:00Ana Brnabic: responding. I think the way they'd see it is they're trying to hold people to account that, Transparency International, as you know, thought that Serbia was one of the most corrupt countries in Europe under the governance of Mr. Vucic. And that there are a lot of people who need to be held to account for what's happened over the last 14 years. And they're angry and they want to see it done. I understand that. I can appreciate that. But that should be done through the institutions if we are to respect the rule of law and not by an angry mob that is actually storming the media that they dislike in order to humiliate people.

4:37When you publish someone's phone numbers the way they have published our phone numbers, calling on people to call us, threaten us, harass us, that's not the rule of law. It is a revolutionary terror.

4:50Ana Brnabic: Let me ask you about something else you've said since the election. This is going to be a government that will be taking its orders directly. You seem to be suggesting that it's been imposed by a foreign power. Which power? Well, let's see. Let's see how the government... Well, you can't go around saying it's been imposed. You can't go around saying it's taking orders from other governments if you don't have any evidence, can you? Well, I have evidence that huge amounts of money were flying into the country to support... From where? From all over the place. All over the place. I mean, I think it's fair for me to ask, is this from Europe?

5:24Ana Brnabic: Is it from Moscow? Is it from the United States? From all over, and literally from all over the place. And the question is, where was the money coming from? What was the purpose of this extraordinary amounts of money? And what for? Why? But you had total control of all the institutions. I mean, if you're making this claim, you must know where this money came from. We do not have total control of the institutions right now, because when the revolution comes, the institutions then by nature try to work to protect themselves. You see, when the angry mob was storming one of the media outlets, the police did not respond.

6:03And at the end of the day, that also kind of proves that we believe in the rule of law, and we tried to form strong institutions that were not governed a dictator that everyone wanted to present Aleksandr Vucic to be.

6:18Ana Brnabic: Can I just put to you how outsiders saw Serbia under Vucic? So the EU had eight member countries opposing the negotiations to get Serbia in line for membership, citing concerns related to the rule of law. I mean, everyone who looked at this from the outside was saying this was an authoritarian government that took control of the media, did all the things that governments like that do, and try to ensure its continued position in power. That's what everyone outside thinks. Aleksandr Vucic was more or less in power for 14 years. During these 14 years, not a single, not a single media outlet was shut down.

6:59He allowed cross-border media open and created a legal space for the media to be established. We had a very, very, very strong media that were constantly, day after day, criticizing Alexander Vucic, dehumanizing and criminalizing Alexander Vucic. And not only that they were not shut down, which I'm also very, very proud of, but Alexander Vucic introduced this practice that we as public officials should not sue the media, Although they were saying that he's a murderer, although they were saying that he organized Sara was Safari, which you know really well, which also the British media said was a complete lie.

7:46Never, ever. The student movement will now shut down, or at least certainly try to shut down, all of the media that they dislike. One of the reasons why I joined the Serbian Progressive Party and the government of Aleksandr Vucic back in 2016 is that when Serbian Progressive Party came into power, they did not dismantle institutions. But to announce that you will immediately dismantle the high prosecutorial counsel, the high judicial counsel, does not mean that you will have independent judiciary. It means quite the contrary, that you will have politically controlled prosecution and judiciary that will do exactly what you tell them to do.

8:31Again, that is not rule of law. That is revolutionary justice. And yes, we will see that in Serbia and we will have to endure. And we will do so and we will fight for strong institutions and for the rule of law.

8:46Ana Brnabic: And that is the acting president of Serbia, Anna Brankovic. Well, we can speak now to a man who was president before Aleksandr Vucic. This is Boris Tadic, who was president from 04 to 12, a liberal, tried to steer Serbia towards the EU, but also objected to the Western policy on Kosovo, thinking it should still be part of Serbia. Is he surprised that the Vucic government has fallen? No, I'm not surprised. I was expecting Vucic to be earlier in that position, but because of problems within the position, which wasn't able to unify it, he was continuing his term. But right now, the game is over. The students' list hasn't yet taken control, has it?

9:28Ana Brnabic: I mean, there are people saying there's a bit of a power vacuum. I mean, it's very early days. But are you worried that they need to move quicker? Yes, especially because of having very bad experience with the so-called deep state when we drove Milosevic. I think the problem is going to be for rules and the law and the constitution we have in Serbia. It takes some time. That is a main problem why they cannot go quicker than today. Well, you say that, but they haven't really got a leader yet. So, I mean, there are things they can do to speed this up. They didn't have a leadership, and that was the only way to avoid targeting by Vucic, secret police and the medias under his control, because he was always blaming his rivals in a brutal way.

10:15And right now we are facing a new situation.

10:18Ana Brnabic: We've just been speaking to the acting president of Serbia, Anna Brnovic, who obviously is loyal to Vucic. She told us that this new government is a revolutionary terror government, that they are breaking down institutions because they don't like them and that the future is frightening in Serbia. What would you say to her? Anna Brnovic is a tool in a votary's hand. This is not a revolutionary time. Totally opposite. Students' list and students' movement is respecting rules. that is a main explanation why they cannot go faster right now. Who has been violating constitution in this country? Previous government and Anna Brnovich on the top of the government.

11:08Ana Brnabic: You're basically saying it's a very complicated political situation that there will be a lot of sort of parliamentary manoeuvres. So the transfer of power is going to be quite difficult. And I think you're sort of acknowledging that there is no leadership to the student list, and that there are disparate views within it. All that to me sounds like this is very problematic to get a stable, unified government that can effectively govern and take over from what's been there for 14 years. I'm quite optimistic in that respect. The people that are on the students list are systematically selected. I truly believe that many of them are very experienced people.

11:44They can run the government, but it takes some time. Let's be patient and let's give them the chance to establish new institutions and to work on democratization of Serbia, freedom of media, and control of security forces, which is very important right now because what Vucic government and Anna Brnovic government has been doing, that was revitalizing the security forces from the Miloša's period. This is one of the crucial moments right now in the recent history of Serbia.

12:17Ana Brnabic: We've got to think about the country's direction. You know, there was a time when you were close to EU membership, something you very much wanted as when you were president. And you're further away from that now. And you're closer to Moscow. So can you see a clear path ahead that takes you back towards Europe? Or is it not that clear? The strategy towards European Union membership is not going to be changed. But we don't know what we can expect from European Union right now. We don't know whether liberal democracy is going to be kept in some European countries that are flirting with the former fascist parties.

12:54Ana Brnabic: If you think that Europe's going nationalist, is Serbia moving in the opposite direction or is Serbia going to remain a very nationalist country? No, Serbia is not a very nationalist country, but Serbia is also a country which is protecting the deep national interest. The Western countries has been violating international law by recognizing Kosovo independence, which brought all of us in a critical moment in Ukraine. And this is why I'm appealing on my friends in Western Europe to be more serious and not to criticize politicians in Serbia that are refusing Kosovo independence from Serbia. The complications of Serbian politics.

13:32Ana Brnabic: That was Boris Tadic, the president there from 2004 to 2012. Coming up, opium production in Afghanistan has risen sharply despite a ban by the Taliban authorities. We'll be asking, why is that happening? For farmers who are really under pressure, it makes absolute sense to grow opium poppy if they can. It brings in much more income than other crops. It does well in a drought and with climate change, Afghanistan's weather patterns are changing, which means more droughts more frequently. More of that later, just now some headlines. The authorities in Ukraine say a Russian drone has killed 13 people at a railway station in the city of Dnipro.

14:16Ana Brnabic: Spain's Prime Minister, Pedro Sanchez, has promised the quickest possible investigation into the causes of a train crash on Wednesday that killed at least 69 people. And as we just heard there, opium production in Afghanistan has risen sharply this year.

14:38Ana Brnabic: You're listening to NewsHour. The makers of the cartoon character Hello Kitty, the company's called Sanrio, have cut ties with a Japanese TV show. The TV show offended China. It's quite complicated this, but the show is called Vivant, and it's a spy thriller, and it depicts Chinese agents torturing a Japanese operative. And China objective because Sanrio, the company behind Hello Kitty, produced merchandise in which Hello Kitty was dressed as a character from the spy show. So in a way, promoting it, promoting the spy show, which China doesn't want. Well, Geoffrey Hall is a researcher and lecturer at Kanda University in Japan.

15:16Ana Brnabic: He does Japanese studies there. So this has been a big reaction from China on this. They're not happy. And Sanrio has cut back its links with this Japanese TV show. Are you surprised how much fuss there is about this? It is a little bit surprising because China usually doesn't go after Japanese companies. But when you consider the fact that this very popular Japanese TV show, which is basically like the Japanese equivalent of James Bond, is showing the Chinese in such a negative light. I guess China can sort of flex its muscles now and demand that the Hello Kitty company kind of move away from this kind of messaging politically.

16:07Ana Brnabic: Yeah, but presumably no one in China is seeing this show, right? Yes, this is a show that almost 97 % of the audience is Japanese. It's a huge hit in Japan. It's the number one drama in Japan this season. So the Chinese state media has used this as an opportunity to, over the last week, really attack Japan over reversing the kind of historical view of, you know, in World War II, China was victimized by Japan and there was torture and there was atrocities. But now this new TV show in Japan is showing China as the bad guy doing similar things to Japanese prisoners. So this is a propaganda opportunity for the Chinese state.

16:58Ana Brnabic: You're saying China can flex its muscles and it sort of works, doesn't it? Because the company making Hello Kitty backed off immediately. Oh, yes. I mean, Hello Kitty, Sanrio, these characters, there's a lot of money to be made in China. There's many fans of these characters in China. So the last thing they want is for China to ban their company's products because that will lose them an enormous amount of money. Because you probably are aware that Mbappé, the footballer, said something disobliging about Chairman Mao, saying he was a dictator. And he had to sort of apologize and back down as well, didn't he?

17:37Yes, you can imagine that Hello Kitty is sort of like a footballer for Japan. She's a footballer who is making money all around the world from fans, and a lot of her fans are in China. And so if her company is associating her with what the Chinese authorities call an anti-Chinese drama that depicts Chinese as just terrible villains who commit atrocities, well, they're going to back off just like Mbappe did because cash is king and this company needs that money.

18:15Ana Brnabic: OK, thank you very much. That was Geoffrey Hall from Kande University in Japan.

18:24Ana Brnabic: Last week, the Office of the First Lady in the US said that she and the Pope had organised a limited ceasefire aimed at getting food and medicine to the Russian-occupied Ukrainian city of Eleshky, and people who wanted to leave could do so. So that began on Tuesday, that truce, and it's worked. And more than that, it seems to have been extended across a wider region, including the city of Kherson. Melania Trump said on X that the ceasefire has expanded beyond Oleski within the Kherson region. Well, Zarina Zabriskie is a journalist in Kherson and she's been there since 2022. So how has the ceasefire changed life there?

19:04Actually, the life is back in the streets of Kherson. Usually, any time after two, you don't see a person. It's a deserted city, especially downtown. which is kind of close to the river. These days are very unusual. We see parents with strollers. We see teenagers in small groups like in any other city in the world. And old ladies sitting on the benches along the boulevard. People are shopping. There are not very many shops left. There are not very many cafes left downtown. but people are celebrating in a way, but in a very poignant way because everybody knows that in two days it will be over.

19:53Ana Brnabic: And can you just tell us, I think you're quite close to Eleski, aren't you? Basically where Melania Trump and the Pope organized this ceasefire in the first place. Have you any news what's happening there? Yes, just yesterday, Owen, we were able to walk to the place from which you can see and film I did an interview with the mayor of Kherson as he's standing and pointing across the river at the high rises that are burned and charred. And you could see that from our side. And I am in conversation with people there and with people on Ukrainian side organizing the evacuation. The situation is very difficult.

20:38People in Oleshke are being disinformed by the Russian authorities who are trying to confuse them or provide the confusing information. So it's very hard to give you a straight answer when the evacuation is actually happening. and it was supposed to be happening just tomorrow. But according to my sources, a group of 29 people were taken from a village close by to Oleski and taken and just basically transported and abandoned in place. There's a lot of chaos going on. I'm also getting the reports that the Russians are cleaning the streets. The corpses are finally being moved from the roads where they were decomposing for months.

21:28And the walls are being painted and everything is being prepared for the journalist, a limited amount of journalist who will be arriving tomorrow to cover evacuation.

21:41Ana Brnabic: Is it clear to you whether those people who are in Eleski will leave for Russia or for Ukraine? Yes and no. From speaking to maybe close to 100 survivors and people who escaped Alashki or still in Alashki, I know that these people are very scared. They live under four years of occupation where anybody could be just killed in the streets or taken to the torture chambers if they show any sympathy to Ukraine. So a meeting, their desire to move back to Ukraine in front of the armed Russian soldiers is basically not an option. Still, we know that there are lists with people who are registered to go back to Ukraine.

22:31So we just have to wait and see how many of them actually will make it back home.

22:37Ana Brnabic: And just one last question to you. I mean, you're reporting in this incredibly difficult city, Kherson. You've been there four years now. I'm just amazed you're able to live there and do it. You don't have to be there. Why are you there? Well, you know, Owen, journalism does matter. Reporting facts matters. We are living during the information warfare battle, and we have an important job. And I'm the only foreign journalist based here, and I consider it my duty to bring this information to you, to your audience. And I'm very grateful for the work that you do because together we can actually bring the truth to the people.

23:22Ana Brnabic: A courageous journalist, Serena Zabrisky, speaking to us there from the city of Kherson. You're listening to the World Service of the BBC.

23:39It is the spookiest time of year, And that's what we're going to be talking about on this week's episode of The Interface. We'll be diving into the 11 ghosts that haunt the AI tools that we use every day and what that might tell us about the future of creativity. And we explore the strange world of algorithmic and spirituality and why some people believe social media is controlled by magic. Join me, Jess Maddox. And me, Thomas Jermaine, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

24:12Ana Brnabic: And welcome back to NewsHour. For many of the world's top directors, from Steven Spielberg to George Lucas, making a short film did play an important role in launching their careers. And at one time, short films were seen like that. They were often seen as little more than a stepping stone for aspiring directors hoping to make the real thing, a full-length feature. But now, as Tom Brook reports, short-form storytelling has become a global creative force in its own right. It's patently clear from the multitude of short film festivals around the world that short film storytelling is flourishing.

24:49Short films have their own ecosystem, their own online audiences, their own festivals and a strong presence at major world film events. At the recent London Film Festival, more than 80 short films were shown and they covered all kinds of subjects, from the first and only astronaut from Afghanistan to make it into space to a woman in New York who wanted to communicate with her dead father by leaving voicemail messages. That well-received eight-minute shot was Mon Taxi, put together by New York-based, Moroccan-born filmmaker Merem Skrohi. The film, perhaps, is making the point that relationships don't necessarily end when a loved one dies.

25:29We see me sharing with Dad kind of like my daily life, and it comes through phone calls that I make for him, which is from a ritual that him and I used to have because I'm born and raised in Morocco and he still lived there. Miriam was overjoyed when her film was accepted by the London Film Festival. Leaving New York and crossing the Atlantic to attend the festival has been a very exciting chapter in her life. She is now mounting an Oscar campaign for her short film.

25:57Ana Brnabic: Busy day. As are the makers of another short, the British film Duronto. It deals with the issue of so-called age gap relationships, in this instance between two men separated in age by many years. It's very mild, isn't it? Short films often deal with subject matter that might be misunderstood or considered controversial, for which it could be difficult to find funding for a full-length feature film. The screenplay for Duranto comes from actor Christopher Sherwood, himself involved in an intergenerational relationship. It might help those who look slightly cynically upon such relationships and help them to see it in a different light and not be so judgmental and not be so quick to jump to what are often the wrong conclusions.

26:38Film festivals are keen to showcase the works of short-form storytellers because often what they offer can be unusual and original. Ben Roberts is the chief executive of the British Film Institute.

26:49Ana Brnabic: They can play around and they can be experimental and people can try and fail a little bit in shorts as well. But it's also a really pure way of articulating your idea or your talent and you allowed a little bit of leeway. Most in the industry would agree that short filmmaking has developed to become more than just a calling card for aspiring directors. It is now, most definitely, a form of cinema in its own right. There we are, cinema for shrinking attention spans. The BBC's Tom Brook reporting on the rise of short film storytelling.

27:42Ana Brnabic: The train crash in Spain yesterday was so catastrophic that the authorities have still not identified all those people who are missing. At least 69 have died. And the fact this was the second major crash on the same stretch of line this year means people are obviously asking why the safety systems are going wrong. Well, the Spanish Prime Minister, Pedro Sanchez, has said today that after the recovery effort, there'll be investigations and then compensation for the families of victims. Let's get to the scene of the crash now. We've got Rajini Vaidyanathan there already. Got there very quickly yesterday.

28:17Ana Brnabic: And what are you seeing there, Rajini?

28:22from where I am standing talking to you now I'm actually looking out and I can see the track in the distance where that collision took place and I can see one of the trains there in my eye line and as I was walking up here to this place, we can't get that close you could see both of the trains one is more red, the other white still on the tracks but you could see where that collision had taken place because some of the carriages of one of the train scattered down the embankment. Now, we got here when it was still dark in the morning and rescue workers and teams had actually been going through the night as they pick through the wreckage.

29:01We've seen police helicopters in the skies and also police drones. Now, as you mentioned there, the focus at the moment for the Civil Guard here, and there are dozens of them I can see right now, and they told us there's some 900 who've been deployed, And their focus really is to secure the scene and find evidence, but also try and secure DNA samples to try and identify the victims. It is a grim task, of course. We know that 69 people, as you mentioned there, have been confirmed dead already. The Civil Guard did say there is a possibility that number could rise. One of the carriages set on fire.

29:43We've seen the twisted, mangled wreckage of some of those trains after the collision as well. We heard from witnesses who said they could hear screams as they saw passengers flying through the train. Well, let's hear a little bit from my conversation with Spain's civil guard. And I spoke to the spokeswoman, Llanos Olivares. Since the accident happened last night, the civil guard has deployed over 900 people from different departments. And the main focus right now is to identify the missing people. And when will you start to be able to release the names of some of the victims? Is the process of identification taking longer than you might expect?

30:33She says that they don't know yet how long it's going to take to identify all the missing people but what they are urging every single person who has relatives, friends, family members missing to go to one of the centres that they have set up in the different regions and to give their DNA to kind of match with the people who are missing right now. I assume you've been closer to the scene. we can see the train in the distance behind us. I wonder if you could just tell us more about what the wreckage is like, how bad the damage was to those trains. When the specialists arrived at the area, the main focus was to save every single person who they were able to bring from the carriages.

31:18And now the main focus is actually to identify from what they have found in the carriages, to identify DNA and bring a name to the people who are missing. Is there a sense that the death toll could therefore be much higher? They don't know yet the data about that, but their main focus is to find the people who are missing right now. And of course, this is the second such accident, second fatal accident on this line in a matter of months. How do you, as the Guardia Civil, feel just more generally about this? It's a really difficult time for the country, isn't it? They understand that before this tragedy, there are lots of feelings surrounding, but what she says is that the Civil Guard is focused on saving lives and bringing a name to the people who are still missing.

32:16Lanos Olivares there from the Civil Guard in Spain here. and Spain is now in three days of national mourning it's a very sombre mood here I was in Urba, Urda I should say which is the small town about five minute drive from here earlier and that is where many of the relatives of those who were on board those trains are gathering a school's been turned into a makeshift gathering place by the Red Cross to support people as they continue to wait to find out whether their relatives were on board that train. So it's a really difficult time. As well as wanting closure, they also want answers, though, of course, because it is unclear what exactly caused this crash, although we do have some indications already.

33:03Now, we did hear from Spain's transport minister on Wednesday who said that it was a combination of a computer failure and human error. So the computer failure stemming from the fact that those high-speed trains were leaving Madrid. They were heading south to Seville on that line when the computer system that signals went down. So six trains were told to stop on the tracks. They were stationary while that was being fixed. And in the meantime, an individual, a human in a control center in Madrid was manually, I suppose, trying to coordinate the movement of those trains. Now, this is where it gets a little complicated because audio has now been released to Spanish media.

33:46of some of the conversations between that individual in the control centre and the drivers of the two trains involved in that collision. Let's listen to a bit of this conversation. It's between the control centre and the driver of the train that was moving and barrelled into the stationary train.

34:19Now, I'll just tell you what we can hear there. So you hear the driver and the controller. The controller is saying you can continue your journey and proceed at normal speed with normal operation. Now, the driver is questioning this because when there's a signal failure of this nature, everyone goes down to restricted speeds. So the driver says, you mean at normal speed? And the controller says yes. And so that train continued on its journey, but also on the track was the other train. It was stationary in another recording released to the Spanish media. You can hear the driver of the stationary train, which was hit.

34:58You can hear her telling the controller, listen, I'm having problems moving. I can't move. There's an issue here. So essentially, while other tribes have moved, trains have moved, she was still stuck. So lots of questions. It's too early to properly speculate, but it really does feel like human error may well have played a part.

35:18Ana Brnabic: Regini, thank you very much for bringing us up to date. The UN says opium production in Afghanistan has risen sharply despite a ban by the Taliban. The UN Office on Drugs and Crimes says four times as much has been grown this year compared to last. And that's, the UN says, the first significant rise since the ban introduced by the Taliban in 2022. Now, the year later, in 23, we made a documentary on this, and Yagita Lamai found the Taliban were clamping down on poppy fields in Afghanistan at that time.

35:53Men who were once fighting for this land now control it. And they're enforcing the diktat of their leader.

36:07This is a Taliban anti-narcotics unit.

36:16Deep in eastern Afghanistan, they stop when they see a field of poppy. While the men raise it, their commander shouts at the family that owns the land.

36:33Ana Brnabic: Well, I've been speaking with Afghan expert Kate Clark. Why is opium production up? I guess there's two factors. One, for farmers who are really under pressure, it makes absolute sense to grow opium poppy if they can. It brings in much more income than other crops. It does well in a drought. And with climate change, Afghanistan's weather patterns are changing, which means more droughts more frequently. There's pressure on land. There's a very high population growth. There's six million Afghans have been returned from Iran and Pakistan in the last three years. The other thing is the stocks of opium have declined.

37:13They've been used up. So the people who did quite well out of the ban were those who had opium stocks because the price shot up. And if you had opium stocks, you could continue to sell them and you could make a large profit. And of course, some of them were richer farmers, but largely the traders. So for them, there's also this desire to get production back up.

37:37Ana Brnabic: Is it clear to you whether the Taliban are going along with this, turning a blind eye to it, just not able to impose their will or what? It's a mixture. So in some places, the ban was imposed very severely. So somewhere like Helmand in the south, which was always the biggest opium producer, that went down to almost zero. this time farmers have been growing it a lot more but they've been concealing it so growing it in walled compounds or staggering the sowings that it if they do get targeted it won't be the whole crop or they're concealing it amongst another crop like wheat in badakhshan which is right in the northeast which was traditionally the second biggest opium producer people there it's been a spark of rebellion, the opium ban, along with the Taliban taking over local mining concessions.

38:32People have been really unhappy about it. It's a very poor province. And farmers have grown opium because they have to for income, but also, I think, because they're not that happy with it. Now, seeing that the Taliban imposed the ban, but there are caveats to that. The big traders have continued to make a lot of money and they typically have good contacts with the regime. If you talk to people in Badakhshan or across the border in Pakistani Balochistan where Afghan farmers have been growing poppy for the last two years, they will tell you that the big traders are absolutely responsible for the opium.

39:11So they're lending money to buy seeds, they're buying the opium ahead of the harvest, so buying it on credit. Or in Balochistan, in Pakistan, they're actually organising the farming generally. It's a mixed mixture.

39:27Ana Brnabic: Got it. But one issue with the Taliban always is, you know, it's very internationally isolated. And so the question arises, does it care about global opinion, you know, or not? And, you know, it can bring in the ban for religious reasons, or it could lift the ban for pragmatic money reasons. But does international pressure come into it as a factor? No, I don't think so. I don't think so. I mean, the Taliban are very reluctant to bow to international pressure. We've seen that with girls' schools, for example. The high schools have been closed since the Taliban came to power. And it's the one thing that everyone keeps talking about.

40:05And it's had absolutely no response whatsoever. And it's the same with opium. But again, I would say, you know, the Taliban are isolated. But on drugs, whoever's trading the opium have excellent international contacts.

40:21Ana Brnabic: Fair point. That was Kate Clark reporting on the drug situation in Afghanistan. And she says the borderlands of Balochistan with Afghanistan in Pakistan.

40:42Ana Brnabic: So let's get to the Israeli elections. The result at the moment is the bloc led by Netanyahu 53, the bloc led by Eisenkopf 48. That's with most votes counted. But there are absentee ballots, mainly military, who are unable to get to a polling station because of their duties. The BBC's James Landale is in Jerusalem. He's been following this moment by moment. So what moment are we at? When are we going to get these absentee ballot results and will they make much difference? Well, we were promised these absentee ballot results around lunchtime. We still haven't got them. Lunchtime is really time.

41:22As ever, these things take a bit of time because these are not just votes. They're votes that are put in two envelopes for security, so they have to verify that it's correct before you take one envelope out and then start actually counting the actual vote that's been cast. So it does take some time, but they're expecting it sometime today. So we're hoping to get at least unofficial confirmation of the result today. And yes, it might change the odd seat here or there, but nobody's at the moment expecting a substantial shift one way or the other because there are an awful lot of votes here. We're talking, they estimated the election authorities, anything between 430 ,000 and 480 ,000 people.

42:06So that's a lot of votes. But at the moment, all sides are hoping it might favour them, but no one's really sure.

42:13Ana Brnabic: Okay. We've also got an issue about the integrity of the election. Now, the president, Isaac Herzog, has said he's spoken with the Central Elections Committee and they are looking into allegations of foreign interference and the president is saying the issue must be thoroughly investigated. What's all this about? There is an allegation made initially by the Likud party, that's the party of Benjamin Netanyahu, the prime minister, alleging that there was some kind of financial interference in the election. The suggestion is that money somehow from Qatar was used to artificially inflate the vote amongst Arab-Israeli parties who have done pretty well in this election.

43:01There was a very large turnout and are currently projected to get 19 seats. Now, there's a lot of confusion about this. There's some uncertainty about how long the intelligence services were aware of this allegation. the allegation was then reported by the intelligence services to the election authorities the election authorities then have to formally write back to the intelligence services asking them to investigate so that's what's happening at the moment there are some reports that the amount of money involved was actually not as large as some people had initially been suggesting anyway, all of this has been seized upon by the political parties to their own ends So Likud and others are alleging that these votes have been stolen, that somehow there has been substantial compromise to the electoral process.

43:57All the opposition parties have hit back firmly, essentially accusing Likud of trying to undermine and question the legitimacy of the Arab votes. and the way that is being interpreted is an attempt by Likud to make it harder in principle for the opposition bloc potentially to cooperate in any way with the Arab parties once the horse trading and the negotiations begin for forming a coalition.

44:27Ana Brnabic: That's very clear. Thanks very much for helping us understand that. BBC's James Landale seems there's more and more cases of elections and then the difficult bit, post-elections.

44:41Ana Brnabic: There's a theory that life on Earth got kick-started by the arrival of comets, the idea being that comets delivered the raw chemical ingredients needed for those chickens and eggs, whichever way around it was, to get started. But theories only last until they're disproven, and Richard Anslow from Cambridge's Institute of Astronomy reckons he might have done that. Before you explain your findings, Richard Anslow, I wonder if you could help us just understand the comet theory, first of all, which you're thinking you might have debunked. But what were people saying about the role comets played? Yeah, good afternoon.

45:16So the idea in this longstanding hypothesis in Origins of Life research was that ice-rich comets formed in the outer regions of the solar system could have delivered these key chemical feedstock molecules to the young Earth. And so although comets are rich in these carbon and nitrogen bearing molecules that we do think were required for the origins of life. What we found was that the majority of these fragile molecules were largely destroyed as these comets impacted the air at speeds of tens of kilometers per second.

45:48Ana Brnabic: Okay, so basically these comets carried things that could have helped life start, but you think they wouldn't have survived impact. But you're not being, didn't you use a sort of qualifier there that mostly or mainly or something like that? Could some have got through? Yes, absolutely. And when we are thinking about these ideas, we need to be careful not to say that anything categorically couldn't have happened. But what was really exciting working on this study was that we were able to pull together lots of recent advances in many different areas of science, including our understanding of comets, the early solar system and recent computer models, telling us about the sorts of chemistry that happens in these first seconds after a comet impacts the Earth.

46:29Ana Brnabic: But it just occurs to me as a total non-scientist that you only need once, really. I mean, life always finds a way, isn't it? I mean, that's the general principle. So if there were even just one comet that provided these materials to the Earth, that could be enough. Yes, that's absolutely right. And what we tried to do throughout our study was to give comets the best possible chance when we were making different model assumptions about what the early Earth looked like. And even in this best case scenario, our results found that on average, we didn't see any of these successful impacts delivering enough of these molecules that we think we need for this chemistry.

47:07So we need a new theory. Have you got one? That's a great question and one that lots of scientists worldwide are investigating as we speak. And so this isn't to be clear. These aren't findings from our study. But it's possible, for example, that these carbon based molecules might have come from carbon rich asteroids. or it's possible instead that they might have been produced on the Earth, potentially involving volcanoes or surface hydrothermal vents.

47:33Ana Brnabic: So just one thought about comets. Why have they got these important molecules and we haven't? So the big difference between the Earth and comets is that comets are these objects that formed very early in solar system history, very far away from the Sun. So these formed at very low temperatures, unlike the Earth, which formed much closer in. And so we have these very different environments and types of chemistry occurring on these comets. OK, well, thank you very much for explaining all that to us. That's Richard Anslow doing really sort of frontline work, as it were, on the nature of comets and what they might have done to life on Earth.

48:10Ana Brnabic: Just before we go, time to tell you that NewsHour is going to be broadcasting live from Harrisburg, Pennsylvania tomorrow. We've got James Kumrasami there. He's been taking the political temperature ahead of next week's midterm elections in the United States. But for now, that's it. Thanks for listening. And from Owen Bennett-Jones here in London, goodbye.

48:55And what that might tell us about the future of creativity. And we explore the strange world of algorithmic and spirituality and why some people believe social media is controlled by magic. Join me, Jess Maddox. And me, Thomas Jermaine, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

After the election in Serbia removed Aleklsandr Vucic from power after 14 years, we speak to the acting president Ana Brnabic about what Serbia's future looks like now.

Serbia's long-standing leader was defeated by a student-led protest movement in snap parliamentary elections.

Also in the programme: How opium production has risen again - not just in Afghanistan, but also in border areas of Pakistan; and an update on the Israeli elections, where there are now investigations into alleged foreign interference in the vote.

(Photo shows Serbia's acting president Ana Brnabic in the parliament in Belgrade, Serbia on 25 October 2022. Credit: Marko Djurica/Reuters)

More from Newshour

All episodes