

Episode topic: Global stock-market sell-off tied to “AI bubble” worries, especially opposition to data-centre expansion; includes interviews on data-centre environmental impacts, a Paraguay digital-bank collapse and protests, a Siberian archaeology study suggesting ancient cannabis use, a US TV copyright case (ER vs The Pit), Kenya’s sentencing of a doomsday cult leader, and a segment on space weather risks.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Introduction to the News Hour episode and preview of topics.
“What were lines doing in York in the third century?”
Discussion on the current state of the tech sector and AI investments.
“I'm James Menendez and a little later we'll be heading to Kenya where a cult leader has been sentenced to 200 years in prison for killing more than 190 people, all but one of them children.”
Analysis of stock market fluctuations related to tech sector concerns.
“Well, in a moment, we'll discuss what that means.”
Exploration of how midterm elections influence tech regulation debates.
“When Sherrod Brown won his Senate seat in Ohio from the Republicans, he had this message for his supporters.”
Overview of protests against data centers and their environmental impact.
“in about 15 European countries calling for a halt to major AI projects.”
Discussion on the sustainability and community impact of data centers.
“We do, of course, have some data centers, as Rich says, which are powered better or are more responsible about their water use.”
Report on political turmoil and protests in Paraguay.
“Global Action Plan you're listening to News Hour from the BBC World Service This is James Menendez with news are live from the BBC.”
Understand the connections between President Pena and the collapse of Bueno Bank.
“What is the president's connection to this bank and why has it gone under?”
Explore the discovery of cannabis evidence in an ancient Scythian tomb.
“Lawrence Blair joining us live there from Asuncion.”
Examine the legal issues surrounding the medical drama 'The Pit' and 'ER'.
“Now, TV medical dramas, there are lots of them.”
Discussion on the sentencing of Paul McKenzie for cult-related murders.
“Many of their remains were found in a remote forest close to the Kenyan coast.”
Reactions from families affected by the cult's actions and the implications of the sentencing.
“So 200 years in prison, as you say, he'll spend the rest of his life in prison.”
A victim's father shares his emotional response to the sentence and loss of his family.
“The BBC's Thomas Mukwana joining us live from Nairobi.”
Analysis of the political implications of recent midterm elections for the Democratic Party.
“this week, where it's becoming clear that the size of the swing to the Democrats in the midterm elections is so great that the party's chances of winning the next presidential election in 2028 have been hugely enhanced.”
Discussion on the potential impact of solar storms and space weather on technology.
“But I have the sense that Americans are really desperate to stop fighting.”
Learn how solar events can disrupt technology and infrastructure on Earth.
“And sometimes their effects can reach Earth.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals or appetite for investing. Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were lines doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glenny and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world. It's one of the first times really that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers. If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of infrastructure. In our time, listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:05Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea.
1:13Hello and welcome to News Hour from the BBC World Service. We're coming to you live from London. I'm James Menendez and a little later we'll be heading to Kenya where a cult leader has been sentenced to 200 years in prison for killing more than 190 people, all but one of them children. More on that in about 30 minutes. But we are going to begin with what looks to many like the early days of the AI bubble, if not yet popping, then certainly starting to deflate. For several months now, there have been worries that the US economy, and by extension Wall Street, is far too dependent on the vast tech sector for growth, firms such as Apple, NVIDIA and Meta, and on the AI giants such as Anthropic and OpenAI, who are about to go public.
1:55and their eye-wateringly large investments in the infrastructure needed for the technology, the data centres that power things like ChatGPT and Claude. Opposition to those was central to the campaigns of many of the Democrats who swept to victory in this week's midterm elections. Well, in a moment, we'll discuss what that means. But first, let's talk to our international business correspondent, Theo Leggett, about how this is playing out on the world's stock markets. Theo, good to see you. We're waiting for the New York Stock Exchange to open. But what's been the picture elsewhere today? Well, as you know, we had big falls on the US stock markets yesterday and on Thursday, and that was motivated by falls in tech stocks.
2:36The Nasdaq composite was down 5.5%. That index is largely made up of the titans of the tech industry. You're talking Microsoft, NVIDIA, Meta, people like that. And we saw something similar happening on the main Asian exchanges. So in Japan, shares were down about 6%. In Korea as well, and the Nikkei 225 and the Kospi, they're indices that are heavily tech-weighted as well. In Europe, things have been a bit more muted. We've seen falls in London, in Paris, and in Frankfurt of around 2%. And that's largely because the European indexes are less reliant on tech stocks. So this does seem to be in a sell-off that was largely prompted by what we saw in the midterm elections, where the Democrats took control of both houses of Congress.
3:24And there has been extensive campaigning by leading Democrats, such as James Tellerico in Texas and the like, casting scepticism on the growth of AI and data centres and suggesting that it might be more tightly regulated in future. Investors too, I mean, even before the midterms, were they starting to get spooked by the sort of levels of investment that AI companies need in order to expand and whether that was sustainable. Absolutely. Company valuations are based on what people think those companies will do in future, how much money they're going to make or whether the valuation of the company itself will increase.
4:01And over the past four years, since the launch of ChatGPT in late 2022, really, we've seen a huge wave of investment in AI and the infrastructure associated with AI. So chip making, infrastructure connections, data centres, all of that kind of thing. And that's seen tech company valuations go sky high. The amount of investment expected to have been made this year alone is going to be about a trillion dollars, according to Goldman Sachs. That's a worldwide figure, but it's a huge amount of money. But at the same time, concerns have been growing. You've had leading AI researchers coming out and saying they're worried about the safety of all of this.
4:37You know, there have even been suggestions that it could be an existential threat to humanity. Whether you believe that or not, it's sort of making people think again a little bit about AI. there have been concerns about increasing regulation and then there's been the simple worry that there might be a bubble forming that these colossal valuations couldn't be justified by prospective earnings so all of this has been mounting up and it's not just the falls we saw in New York on Thursday for example the Nasdaq is down about 12 % on the month as a whole but you have to say it's still higher than it was at the beginning of the year because the amount of money that's been poured into tech previously.
5:16So there are growing concerns about whether things were getting too frothy. The issue now is what kind of a turnaround we're seeing, whether it's just a bit of froth coming off share prices, a revaluing of risk, or whether it's the start of something more emphatic, which might see, you know, some companies potentially go out of business, others entrench their positions, and where the industry goes from here. Theo, thank you very much indeed. Our international business correspondent, Theo Leggett there. Well, as I mentioned, and Theo mentioned too, data centres and their billionaire owners were a factor in several key races in the US midterm elections on Tuesday, races that tipped both the House and the Senate in the Democrats' favour.
5:56When Sherrod Brown won his Senate seat in Ohio from the Republicans, he had this message for his supporters. I do not work for data centres.
6:08I do not work for Wall Street. I work for you. I work for Ohio. And on Thursday, in an interview with CNN, the Democratic governor-elect of Texas, Gina Hinojosa, said there needed to be tighter controls on those data centers. Right now, what has happened is data centers have moved into mostly rural communities, and there are no rules and laws to protect Texans, and Texans are being taken advantage of. So the difference is we will have laws to protect Texans, and we need to stop what we are doing with data centres until we have those protections. And in the Netherlands today, about 100 protesters broke into a Microsoft data centre construction site in Amsterdam in a protest against that facility.
6:53One of the protesters, Sam van der Beek, told journalists why they were there. So this is here a data centre by Microsoft that's being built. This data centre is going to use a lot of water, electricity and land, which we just don't have to spare in Amsterdam. and these data centres are destroying our world. It's becoming uninhabitable because of all the resources they consume. That's why we're here to go. Well, the Amsterdam demo is one of several protests taking place in about 15 European countries calling for a halt to major AI projects. Oliver Hayes is head of campaigns and policy at the NGO Global Action Plan, which is coordinating those protests.
7:30And I'm also joined by Rich Kenny, who's managing director of Interact DC, a data centre sustainability and performance consultancy that works across the world. Oliver and Richard, good to have you both with us on NewsHour. And Oliver Hayes, just picking up from that clip we heard from one of the protests, talking about data centres destroying our world. Just expand on that for us a bit more. Yeah, good afternoon. I mean, communities across the UK and Europe are taking action this weekend to protest the rapid expansion of data centres and their impact on local communities and public infrastructure, on land, on water and energy use, housing, jobs, cost of living, and the far-reaching impacts of AI, including on surveillance and militarisation.
8:14So there are a range of reasons why people are very concerned about the completely unchecked expansion of data centres. And it's mirroring what we've seen in the US, and we're seeing it in communities throughout the UK and throughout, as you say, those 15 European countries. So I think this is an issue which is only going to continue to grow because data centres are being given a blank check by governments and the big tech are having a red carpet rolled out for them in place of where there should be regulation. Let me just bring in Rich Kenny. Are data centres inherently bad or is it just the way they're being currently constructed?
8:59I think it's silly to say they're inherently bad. I don't think anything's necessarily bad or good in abstract. It's how they're built, how they're used, the size, where they're sited. I think there's a lot of factors that make a good data centre, from a capability point of view, a terrible planning decision, depending on where it lands. Because most of the benefit of data centres is national, but a lot of the pain is felt locally. And that local pain can be significant or it can be very small. And that's a lot of that's around planning and impact and foresight. So not inherently bad, but can be a bad decision for a certain locality, definitely.
9:33Are there good data centres and what do they look like? And do they use less, for example, less water? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, the technology that goes into a data centre should be entirely determined by the place where it sits. So a data centre built in the UK should not be the same as one built in Virginia, should not be the same as one built in Santiago in Chile. because the technology determines how it impacts its local community and the constraints. And that's water, that's power, that's community impact, that's noise, it's pollution. All of these things play a role in how something's built.
10:05But a very well-built data center has a much lower impact across all of those channels. But they do have to be built well. And we see a lot of bad actors in the sector who are taking advantage of the data center gold rush to cause a lot of problems for communities that they didn't need to create. whereas there's tons of good builders out there who are building good highly efficient and appropriate data centers but there are and you have to be super clear there are very very few but very prominent bad actors who are causing irreparable harm to communities and even the data center community itself would say that's a significant problem yeah let me just bring in oliver hayes on that i mean what do you make of that i mean if for example a data center could run exclusively on on renewables uh use a lot less water use a lot less energy uh would that be okay Well, I think that hits the point exactly on the head, because there is no cumulative assessment of data centers impact here.
11:00We do, of course, have some data centers, as Rich says, which are powered better or are more responsible about their water use. But actually, the examples are pretty few and far between. And there is no overarching framework and there is no transparency. Data centres are not obliged to say where their power is coming from or how much power they're using. And they're not obliged to say how much water they're using, where it's coming from, how they're disposing of it safely into the environment. And it's really that overarching assessment that we are so sorely lacking. And that's the main reason that we and communities up and down the country and across Europe are calling for a moratorium on data centres.
11:39there are very basic questions that are not being asked or answered about how these are going to be consistent with our climate goals, how we're not going to have local air pollution as a result of the gas power, which is increasingly how data centres are choosing to power themselves. But in an ideal world, if you had that transparency and it was a data centre that was, for example, climate neutral, I mean, net zero in terms of its carbon use, that would be OK. you're not saying you don't want to see any data centres at all, are you? No, nobody's saying that they don't want to see any data centres at all.
12:14I mean, everybody recognises that we live in a world where we're going to need some digital infrastructure. We already do have some digital infrastructure. But let's just take the UK for an example. We have about two gigawatts of data centres at the moment in the UK, and we're the second biggest market behind America. But what the industry is asking for in terms of connections to the electricity grid is, according to Ofgem, at least 80 gigawatts of connections. Now, to give that some context, last winter, the peak electricity use for the entire country was 45 gigawatts. So this is an eye-watering increase and a completely unacceptable increase in demand.
12:55And there is no overarching framework. Let me just get, we've only got about a minute left. Let me get a final word from Rich Kenny. I mean, has the horse bolted in terms of the construction or can things be turned round for data centres and to make them more popular. Yeah, it's not bolted at all. I think now's the crucial stage. And I agree a lot with what Oliver's saying, to be honest. But it hasn't bolted. We're at the time now where this is the time to provide transparency, to provide community benefit, to provide a true accounting for the benefit versus the cost in the UK data centre scene.
13:25And this is the time now. It's not bolted at all. We've got a real opportunity to get this done right. And it needs a little bit of oversight, a little bit of regulation, and a lot of community engagement and a lot of support for communities because it needs to be about permission to deploy data centers in local communities not about iEnergy users just getting put in bad places this is now a time where communities need to have their say but also feel the benefit of data centers on a UK level thank you very much to both of you that was Rich Kenny of Interact DC and Oliver Hayes of the NGO Global Action Plan you're listening to News Hour from the BBC World Service
14:08This is James Menendez with news are live from the BBC. Let's head to South America now, in a country that doesn't often make it into the headlines, Paraguay, where the president, Santiago Pena, is fighting for his political life.
14:27Protesters there in the capital, Asunción, chanting, Santiago, you are trash. He has been blamed for the collapse of a digital bank that's left huge numbers of people unable to access their savings. He has submitted his resignation to lawmakers, but some of them want to pursue his impeachment. This protester agrees. I believe Santiago Pena's resignation should never be accepted. It's a complete act of cowardice for which there was no quorum in the impeachment session. As far as I'm concerned, the criminal case must continue. The impeachment process must go ahead because a thief like that cannot go unpunished.
15:07He disappointed us. He robbed working people. And the people are the ones who make the government. Well, let's speak to Lawrence Blair, who's a freelance journalist in Asunción. Lawrence, very good to have you with us here on NewsHour. What is the president's connection to this bank and why has it gone under? Hi there. Yeah, well, the connections between Santiago Pena and Bueno Bank really go back quite a few years now. Notably, when Peña became president, he appointed a former director of Bueno Bank to be the governor of the central bank. Soon afterwards, a series of favorable decisions were made by that regulator to give Bueno a banking license, and it massively expanded in the following years.
15:49At the same time, Santiago Peña also held shares in a company called Bueno Holding, which is part of the broader business group which owns Bueno. And on his watch, the bank's and the broader group's share of government business has risen dramatically. It's also come to hold about$850 million in public deposits, including about 10 % of the state pension pot. And so what's happened to it? It's overextended itself and it's now insolvent? Effectively, yes. I mean, effectively, the investigations are ongoing at the moment. There are criminal cases that have been opened by the public prosecutor's office and the central bank itself is investigating.
16:34What seems to have happened is that Wenner allegedly, reportedly was lending money to companies that were part of its own business group. We're talking loans totaling$150 million to pretty tiny companies which were owned by its own employees and its own managers. So effectively, we're dealing with what's called related party transactions. And that kind of operation is risky on two fronts, not only because it causes potential risks to the balance sheet of the company, but also because it can breach those kind of rules that govern what sort of business deals you can do. Yeah. So what's going to happen to people's money?
17:13Is the mood where you are getting ugly?
17:19I'm just across from Congress now. There's a line of riot police that are preventing protesters from reaching Congress itself. There's a lot of desperation. There's a lot of anger. Last night, there were minor disturbances between police and protesters. So in terms of whether the money will come back, people are starting to receive a certain amount of their savings. people's deposits with the bank are guaranteed by a by a state insurance fund to the tune of about 38 000 so smaller savers should get their money back but larger depositors major companies probably possibly won't and i think that could have a broader knock-on effect for the economy as a whole yeah because just briefly i mean the economy in paraguay have been booming hadn't it that's right last year paraguay was the fastest growing non-oil economy in latin america you know it expanded by about 6.6 uh the the gdp of the of the economy so so a massive wave of investment paraguay had kind of become in recent years under the peña administration this this almost kind of uh gem in south america you know there's this narrative that this was a fast-growing economy that had shaken off a history of corruption and repression and was really a place that was kind of open for business.
18:40And I think at the same time, Paraguay became a very strong ally of the Trump administration. It's always been very pro-US, but even more so in recent years. And I think that kind of positive, buzzy kind of spin about Paraguay's position as this kind of emerging giant, as President Pena is so fond of saying, I think that's taken a bit of a beating in the past few days. Lawrence, thank you very much indeed. Lawrence Blair joining us live there from Asuncion. Now, were the Scythians, nomadic people that roamed the vast grasslands of northern Asia more than two and a half thousand years ago, also fond of smoking cannabis?
19:17Quite possibly, yes, is the conclusion of a new paper in the journal Scientific American. Researchers have been analysing the contents of a Scythian tomb in southern Siberia for several years. Now they found what they say is evidence that those buried inside had somehow ingested the drug. Dr. Gino Kaspari is the lead author. He's been telling me more. We excavated a tomb since 2017 in southern Siberia, a monumental burial mound of about 140 metres in diameter. When we approached the central burials, there were several individuals there, and we found these tiny little black dots throughout the burial, and these turned out to be seeds of cannabis.
19:57And then just a few hours later, we found preserved human hair, which is incredibly rare. And so, of course, we knew what to do next because it's only so many times as an archaeologist that you get to drug test a person that's been dead for almost 3000 years. We did find active compounds, cannabinoids that stem from cannabis. When you consume cannabis, part of these active compounds get built into your tissue. We can't tell whether that was through inhalation or through ingestion, but we know it's there in human soft tissue. And Gina, how certain are you of the evidence? And I only ask this because there have been some who've cast doubt on the hair evidence saying that it's scientifically weak.
20:42This is the University Medical Center in Freiburg in Germany, and that there wasn't enough evidence. Was it pretty clear cut to you? It was pretty clear cut to us because the thing is, like it's either in or on the hair even if it's on the hair that means that the cannabis compounds were at some point airborne which means somebody has actually burnt it that indicates still psychoactive use because the burning was very likely intentional. I guess the obvious question given what we know about Siberia now and I imagine it wasn't that different when this burial mound was formed. I mean, how did it get there?
21:18It's a cold place. Based on the size of the seeds, it doesn't seem to have been cultivated. It seems to have been a wild form that naturally had elevated levels of THC. Even today, we actually have serious amounts of cannabis growing not too far away from this tomb. So the cannabis lives in the area even today. Given the connection to a tomb, a burial site, I mean, what might it have been used for? Given that it was found in a burial context, of course, some of the interpretation goes towards the sort of ritual embedding of this. We do have also potentially a sinister way of speculating about this because we have a lot of horse sacrifices and human sacrifices.
22:03Preparing your humans for sacrifice, it might be beneficial if they're somewhat sedated before something bad happens to them. We can't really prove that, but that is some speculation based on the archaeological context that we find. And who are the people buried at this site? I mean, tell us a bit more about them and where they come from. So we're in the first millennium BC, almost 3 ,000 years ago. People in the area live largely nomadically. They're pastoralists. Animals are extremely important for them. Horses, first and foremost, are the main assets. This is a very, very interesting site. That was Dr.
22:41Gino Kaspari, lead author of that research. He's an archaeologist at the Max Planck Institute of Geoanthropology based in Germany. You're listening to News Air. Do stay with us. We've got lots more coming up in the second half of the programme.
23:09It often starts with a question. What were Lyons doing in York in the third century? Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? Then we searched for answers. It's one of the first times, really, that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers. If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure. As I was doing the research for the programme, my jaw just dropped further and further down. In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Watch the discussions unfold and explore over a thousand conversations in our archive. I'm Misha Glennie, and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world.
23:50In Our Time. Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Coffee? Love a cup of tea. I'll have tea too. Tea for me, please. Thank you very much.
24:07You're listening to News Hour. Now, TV medical dramas, there are lots of them. Can you tell the difference between them? As you can see, our house is always packed and our department is mostly clogged up with borders. Those are admitted patients waiting for a room upstairs, sometimes for days. That's from the Emmy award-winning show The Pit, currently on HBO Max. The main character, Dr. Rabinovich, is played by the actor Noah Wiley. Wiley also had a key role in another hugely successful medical drama, ER, which ran until 2009, playing Dr. Carter. Here he is being given his induction into the ER in 1994.
24:44Do you know how to start an IV? Actually, no. I thought you were third year. I am, but all I've done is dermatology and psychiatry. The well-dressed specialties. Well, a court in the US ruled yesterday that the pit and ER are similar enough for a lawsuit to progress against the pit's producers. The widow of the writer Michael Crichton, who created ER, has argued that the pit is effectively a reboot of her husband's series made without proper permission or credit. My colleague Jane Hill has been talking to Dominic Patton, editor of Hollywood's Deadline.com, about the case. ER, which was created by Michael Crichton, who, of course, many people know for writing Jurassic Park.
25:22It was a look at an ER, literally, in Chicago. It launched the career of George Clooney, as well as Noah Wiley and many, many others. It really revolutionized the notion of medical dramas, but it also had a continuing life that maintained well into the streaming era. So how come there is now a court case? There were a lot of talks about maybe finding some way to bring ER back. And they reached out to the estate of Michael Creighton, which is now run by his widow. Those negotiations broke down. And from what we understand at Deadline, it was mainly over money. Not long after that, the notion of the pit emerged with Noah Wiley as an ER doctor in Pittsburgh in this particular case.
26:06But before the show even debuted, the widow Crichton sued for breach of contract. And she basically said is, you just took the show that you wanted to make, calling it ER as a limited series, and you called it the pit. And this is just a ripoff. Initially, she wanted an injunction against the debut of the pit, which she did not get. But there are some real issues here of what are known as derivative. Now, what had happened, Warner Brothers, John Wells, Noah Wiley and others tried to get the case thrown out last year. A L.A. Superior Court judge said no, not throwing it out. In fact, I think there's a real case here.
26:39This week, a appeals court trio said, we agree and this is going to trial. But I mean, there's a lot of variations on a theme, aren't they? And you're going to put this before a jury. and if you're going to set a drama in a hospital, there are going to be some similarities. Well, yes, and I mean, this is part of the argument that the lawyers for Warner Brothers and the producers made to the appeal court in September. They said, look, we are not stealing anything. But the reality is, with anything, there's a paper trail. There is also some things which, while not legally binding, will have an impression on a jury.
27:16Noah Wiley being the star of ER and being the star of this. Having said that, you can't just say, well, because it's this, it has to be derivative of that. But what's interesting is it's the derivative nature that the Crichton estate are particularly centring on. And that is something that's very, very hard to prove. Dominic Patton of Deadline.com. You're listening to NewsHour live from the BBC in London. I'm James Menendez. Let's turn to Kenya now, where the leaders of a now notorious doomsday cult has been sentenced to 200 years in prison for ordering his followers to starve themselves to death in order to meet Jesus.
27:53Paul McKenzie and more than two dozen of his associates were convicted last month of killing 191 people. All but one of them were children. Many of their remains were found in a remote forest close to the Kenyan coast. Well, during sentencing today, Judge Diana Mochachi said it was clear that McKenzie had planned the murders. He had already purchased 4 ,860 acres of land in Shakahola where he subsequently settled his followers. The sooner had the followers settled at Shakahola, then he changed the narrative claiming that Jesus was not coming and that all his followers must fast to death to go to Jesus.
28:30The decree led to mass death. Let's speak to the BBC's Thomas Mukwana who joins us from the Kenyan capital Nairobi. Thomas, good to talk to you. What's the reaction been to the sentence? Because I think some people have been calling for the death penalty in this case, haven't they? Yeah, some people have been calling for the death penalty, particularly the prosecution here in Kenya. But that's not something that the Kenyan court said it could do because no one has been executed in the country since 1987. And the death penalty was considered unconstitutional by a court in 2017. So the next best thing in this case, according to most people, was life imprisonment.
29:09And Pastor Paul McKenzie is 53 years old. A 200-year sentence is effectively a life imprisonment sentence. So a lot of families have, I remember speaking to a man called Stephen Whitty who lost six of his children in the cult. And he told me that there isn't a thing, there isn't a sentence, even if McKenzie was hanged, that wouldn't bring back all his children. So his only wish was that Paul McKenzie is kept in prison and he never sees the community again because he believes he's a danger to community. And the judge seemed to agree. Yes. And we're going to hear a bit more from him and what happened to his family in a minute.
29:47So 200 years in prison, as you say, he'll spend the rest of his life in prison. But there are other cases still pending against McKenzie, aren't there? Yeah. Yeah. These 190 murders were of children and just one adult. He's still facing manslaughter charges in a different court here in Kenya. And he's also facing terrorism charges because the prosecution is arguing that his doctrine was terrorism. And it's hard to disagree with that. And at the same time, he's also facing crimes against children, which is a massive crime here in the country. But it's also important to say that people locally here in Kenya have been calling for accountability because prior to the conviction and his arrest in 2023, after all these bodies were discovered, But Pastor Paul McKenzie had been arrested but then let out in the community.
30:32And at that time, he'd been arrested for a different charge of running an education facility without a license. So over the next few weeks, there should be, and many people are already starting to ask, important questions of the government. Yeah, and questions too about why it took the police so long to uncover what was happening within this cult. Yes, yes. Stephen Moody, who we spoke to at that time, also said that he went to the police officers to try and get answers. At that time, his wife had run off with all his kids into the forest and his wife had just given him cryptic messages and no explanation about what's happening there.
31:14And he went to try and get police involved, but the police weren't getting involved at that time. And there were also reports of what Paul McKenzie was running in the facility. But by the time everyone was finding out about this at a national level, the crimes had just become too much. And yeah, the rest, everyone knows, 400 bodies found in a few months of digging. So yeah, accountability is going to be at the centre of this, just so this doesn't happen again. Thomas, thank you very much indeed. The BBC's Thomas Mukwana joining us live from Nairobi. Well, shortly before we came on the air, we did also manage to get through to Stephen Whitty, who lost his wife and six children.
31:53He had seven, six of his seven children to the cult. They did starve to death. He spoke to us through a translator and gave us more of his reaction to the sentence today.
32:09The sentencing today, I'm 10 % happy, satisfied about today's sentencing because at least he will be in jail and that means he will not come back to kill other people. But I'm not happy still, 90%, I'm not still happy because I lost all my six children. I've lost all my family. So at the moment, I am still traumatized. the sentencing that cannot help me in any way to move on at least to heal my life because at my age at the age of 48 I feel like losing my family my family was the biggest part of my life and the fact that they are no longer here with me is something that I can never move on about that.
33:15And again, out of the six children I lost in Shakahola, only one was identified through DNA. The others, the rest are still in the mob. So moving on at the moment is not something that is enriched for me. My children used to be very good kids. They used to be jovial, playful. I remember I used to be very fond of my daughter, Adirian. She used to run to me whenever I came home from work. Up to today, it still pains me because looking back, I still have their memories. with me. And to my wife, my wife Joanne used to be very obedient at the beginning before joining the culture in the Colmarcade. When she became a member of the UQAL, her behaviour changed and she became very disobedient.
34:25Sometimes when the kids were sick, she refused to take them to the hospital. That was Steve Mwiti speaking to us through a translator with his reaction to today's sentencing of Paul McKenzie.
34:48Let's talk a bit now about those momentous events in the US this week, where it's becoming clear that the size of the swing to the Democrats in the midterm elections is so great that the party's chances of winning the next presidential election in 2028 have been hugely enhanced. The BBC's Justin Webb is in Washington, has been talking to a man at the very top of democratic politics. He's Jim Messina. It started the next morning. The next morning, candidate, potential candidates for president were calling up donors to say, will you be with me? Did anyone call you? I've already talked to over two dozen people thinking about running for president.
35:26Two dozen? Yeah, over two dozen. And these are serious people? Yeah, yeah. And a bunch of people are going to kick the tires. You know, there's an old adage in Washington that everyone who's elected wakes up in the morning and looks in the mirror and sees the future president. And so they think through it. And, you know, and at least on my side of the aisle, people think, well, if Donald Trump can be president of the United States, I certainly can be president of the United States. But do they also think I could be president of the United States? Because the chance of a Democrat becoming president of the United States has been hugely increased by what's just happened.
35:56Yes, because the swing, all the swing presidential battleground states now have a Democratic governor, which is incredibly predictive of how they vote in the next election and very helpful to the overall theory of how you run a presidential campaign as someone who's run one. I also think that, you know, President Trump's numbers are very unlikely to get better. And so the party will be running against Trump, even though he's not on the ballot. However, it's likely that he'll play a very big role in selecting the Republican candidate, which would be good for the Democrats, because they will be able to say, if you enjoy Donald Trump, you can vote for whoever it is, Bob, Bob the Republican.
36:40and so there's a lot of people who are thinking to themselves this is as clear of a shot as i'm going to get at the presidency and then presidents of both parties trump bush obama clinton etc have put most of the people who ran against them in their primaries into their cabinet you remember trump and rubio went at it for months and now rubio's secretary of state um hillary clinton became secretary of state after she and barack obama had the longest primary contest in the history of the American world. So there's no reason not to run. Correct. Correct. And some of these people have said, Jim, what do you think?
37:16I'm like, I don't think you can win. But I think you could be a great member of the cabinet. And some of them care deeply about issues that they want to advance in a presidential. So is it issues that now the party has to have a debate about? Or when it comes to a presidential candidate? Is it something else? It's both. The country wants to know, especially after Trump, that you have a plan. That you, you know, when I was running President Obama's campaign, every month at 2 o 'clock in the morning, annoyingly, Bill Clinton would call me up and say in his great southern drawl, all presidential elections are always an economic referendum on the future.
37:54And we just won an election in the midterms that probably had more to do with Donald Trump than it did us. And when you look at what voters think about the Democratic Party, the two words they most use are weak and woke. And they're going to want to see a plan. You didn't need this plan as much, although I thought the leaders did good to have good ideas in a midterm election. You will need that in a presidential election. And so these candidates are going to need to lay out a very clear vision. And is that an economic populist vision? I don't think so. I think it is a plan that makes people's lives better.
38:31It's really specific. Like you guys have these great manifestos. I remember when I went to work in British politics, I was like, what's this? And they're like, we publish everything we're going to do. And I was like, why would you do that? And they're like, because people want to know. And, you know, I think in this election we're going to have to do some version of that. People are going to say, hey, make my life better. Tell me how you're going to make my life better. because Americans have become deeply cynical about American politics. Is there also an aspect of being the anti-Trump, though, that American politics goes through these periods where one thing is in fashion, one vibe, and then something completely different?
39:11In other words, when you're looking for a candidate, where does that mean that the Democrats have to pitch it or the individual has to pitch themselves? Yeah, it's interesting. I think that if you look at presidencies, that's something Obama taught me, over the past 40 years, each president's kind of been a reaction to the previous president. And I think the country is going to want, in my opinion, someone who can pull them together. We've been divided enough, and they're going to want someone to be a little less day-to-day. It is interesting that the last two leaders of the United Kingdom have been kind of moderate, boring technocrats.
39:50Maybe we're going to follow you. You guys did Brexit, we did Donald Trump right after, right? Maybe we're going to follow you to a normal person who can just run the government. Maybe we won't. Maybe we'll go, you know, pick our version of Donald Trump again. But I have the sense that Americans are really desperate to stop fighting. Democratic Party, grandee, Jim Messina talking there to the BBC's Justin Webb. You're listening to NewsHour from the BBC World Service.
40:36A reminder of our top story today on NewsHour. Tech shows across the world have plummeted over concerns about a slowdown in AI development in the US as opposition grows to big data centres. Oliver Hayes from the NGO Global Action Plan told NewsHour he believes that responsible and environmentally sustainable data centres are a rare thing. We do of course have some data centres which are powered better or are more responsible about their water use but actually the examples are pretty few and far between and there is no overarching framework and there is no transparency. Also this hour the leader of a doomsday Carlton Kenney has been sentenced to 200 years in prison after being found guilty of murdering 191 people.
41:21And a military commander in Ukraine says Russia used the Eleshki ceasefire last week to advance 20 kilometres closer to Ukrainian positions.
41:37This is James Hernandez with NewsHour live from the BBC. We're so dependent on technology for so much of modern life that a lot has been made of the risks of a major cyber attack that could cause catastrophic disruption to our communications with all the knock-on effects that entails. But what if that disruption were to be caused not by humans, but by the thing that most of the time sustains life, the sun? Things like solar storms and solar flares are all part of what's known as space weather, and they happen all the time. And sometimes their effects can reach Earth. And because of that, scientists are working to find ways to predict when they might occur.
42:13Dr Monica Lorenza is an expert on space weather at Italy's National Institute for Astrophysics in Rome. So what can happen here on planet Earth when these disruptions happen? All these phenomena can affect our technological infrastructures. For instance, satellites are particularly vulnerable. Even instruments or bones can be affected. But it's not only about satellites in space. We also have problems on communication and navigation systems. they can interfere with the radio signals and also GPS can have reduced accuracy. Is it possible that if you had a huge amount of energy, a particular solar event, that that could knock out the working of satellites?
42:56I mean, is that a possibility? Yeah, it's a possibility. We know from, let's say, historical records and also geophysical evidence that in the past we had many events that were much, much stronger than what we have recorded so far in the space era. How do we prepare then? Because we obviously can't control what the sun does, can we? Yes, of course. No, no, not for sure. We cannot control the sun at all. But we can monitor heat and we can develop the forecasting models for such events, for such energetic events from the sun. I suppose the key question is, do you get a warning if something big on the sun is going to happen that might affect the Earth?
43:36I mean, how much time do you have? It depends on the kind of the events that we have on the sun. So for instance, if we have solar flares that are basically just light enhancement, abrupt enhancement in the radiation, so the light from the sun, then we have basically eight minutes. Otherwise, we have the CMEs, so the coronal max ejections that are moving much slower. So we have, let's say, a few days before they arrive to the Earth. And in that case, we can have an advanced warning time. It's not very much time though, is it? So people need to be ready when they get the signal. When you say this has happened or it is happening, people need to act quite quickly.
44:16Yeah, exactly. Yes. So there should be like protocols so that countermeasure can be applied really fast. Countermeasures like, for example, what? Doing things to, what? Turning off certain functions on satellites to protect them? Yeah, exactly. For instance, satellite operators can activate some protective modes or like switch off temporarily the sensitive instruments. Also, power grids on Earth can be severely affected. So even power grids operators can take such precautionary measurement to protect the equipment. For instance, planes or generally aviation services can adapt their operation to minimize such disruption.
44:56For instance, planes can go lower when energetic particles are arriving. Does this keep you up at night? Do you worry that there will be some major event that causes real problems? Well, not in that catastrophic event. It would be mainly from the economy point of view. For instance, a flare like the so-called Carrington event in 1859 would occur now. Our economy would be really, really affected. that was space weather expert dr monica lorenza and that brings us to the end of this edition of news air from me and the rest of the team here in london thanks so much for listening till the next time bye
Technology shares across the world have plummeted over concerns of a slowdown in AI development in the US. Newshour debates the rights and wrongs of data centres.
Also in the programme: Paraguay's banking scandal; and the harmful effects of space weather.
(Picture: People walk past an electronic board displaying Japan's Nikkei 225 index trading in Tokyo, Japan, 06 November 2026. Credit: EPA)