

The episode marks three years since Hamas’s 7 October 2023 attacks on Israel, focusing on memorials and ongoing trauma in Israel, the continuing war and humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and Israel’s internal political divisions over security failures and the conduct of the war. It also includes other NewsHour segments: South Africa’s gender-based violence prevention efforts, Maria Ressa on digital authoritarianism, and lighter culture/science items (Nobel chemistry and an alleged earlier “talkie”).
Professor Tamar Herman (Israeli Democracy Institute) analyzes Israeli public opinion and political divides; Akram al-Satari (freelance journalist in Gaza City) reports on life in Gaza’s “Green Zone”; Dalit Aharon and Achi (Neroz kibbutz survivors) and Emi Palmer (rebuilding project director) discuss rebuilding and trauma-informed design; Christian Parkinson (BBC reporter in Johannesburg) covers men’s anti-violence meetings; Maria Ressa (Rappler founder, Nobel Peace Prize laureate) discusses her book on standing up to dictators.
near Oz houses marked by red/black stickers; trauma-informed re-planning; Israelis split on whether warnings existed; most Israelis back the war’s approach; Gaza has “no ceasefire” in practice with minimal government/policing and dire humanitarian access (water, tents, food trucks).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion of memorial services and the impact of the October 7 attacks in Israel.
“I'm James Menendez and we're heading first to Israel.”
A report from Near Oz detailing survivors' experiences and the devastation in their community.
“Near Oz, one of the community's hardest hit on the 7th of October 2023.”
Insight into how the October 7 attacks have affected social and political divisions in Israel.
“but deep divisions persist in the wake of October the 7th and from even before those devastating attacks, as I've been finding out from Professor Tamar Herman of the Israeli Democracy Institute.”
Discussion about the current situation in Gaza, focusing on humanitarian issues and violence.
“What about the conduct of the war, the huge levels of death and destruction that we've seen in Gaza?”
Teaser for an upcoming discussion on the history of early sound films and their impact.
“You're listening to NewsHour from the BBC World Service.”
Get the latest updates on global events, including airstrikes and health warnings.
“We'll be talking about that in a few minutes.”
Explore the significance of molecular handedness in chemistry and its implications for pharmaceuticals.
“I'm very glad you're here to help us through this.”
Discover the debate surrounding the first spoken words in a film and the Scottish film that predated The Jazz Singer.
“Well, those are, in theory, the first words ever to be spoken in a film delivered by Al Jolson and the jazz singer.”
Examine grassroots efforts to combat gender-based violence in South Africa.
“It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing.”
Exploration of fostering a better future through positive role models.
“by being the good role models to them, so that when they grow, they become a better nation out there.”
Maria Ressa discusses the existential threats to democracy worldwide.
“The founder of the news website Rappler in the Philippines took on the violent excesses and corruption of President Rodrigo Duterte and survived.”
Ressa elaborates on the role of digital platforms in authoritarianism.
“And you can look at from 2016 until today, the most recent VDEM report told us that 74 % of the world is now under authoritarian rule.”
Discussion on the lack of accountability among tech leaders.
“What I did in 2017, we were in California and I invited him to come to the Philippines because I didn't think he understood how powerful Facebook was.”
Ressa emphasizes the importance of action for hope amidst adversity.
“Can I just put this counter argument to you?”
Coverage of Lionel Messi's last match and its significance.
“The journalist and Nobel laureate Maria Ressa on her book, The Fight Backer Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators.”
Report on the recent Russian airstrikes affecting civilians in Ukraine.
“This is James Menendez with NewsHour live from the BBC.”
Explore the daily realities of people living amidst ongoing attacks in Kiev.
“on the busiest 19 in the space of 24 hours.”
Learn about the botched execution case of Krista Pike and legal implications.
“bbc's dan johnson last week the u.s state of tennessee attempted to kill by lethal injection a prisoner on death row.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing. This is the story of an Islamic boarding school in Indonesia with a dark secret. Of the school's head teacher. This was someone I respected above anyone else. And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence. If this is leaked to the media, I'll be destroyed. This is World of Secrets, catching my teacher. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
0:44Hello and welcome to NewsHour from the BBC World Service. We're coming to you live from London. I'm James Menendez and we're heading first to Israel.
1:02The sound from one memorial service earlier this morning at a kibbutz close to the border with Gaza where people gathered to remember those who died on this day three years ago. A murderous rampage led by the Palestinian militant group Hamas in which almost 1 ,200 people were killed, two-thirds of them civilians. A further 251 people were taken back to Gaza as hostages. Only 168 survived. the last survivors, were returned this time last year as part of a US-brokered ceasefire agreement following two years of war in Gaza. Well, we'll be hearing from there a little later. But first, this report from our Middle East correspondent Yolan Nell, who's been to Near Oz, one of the community's hardest hit on the 7th of October 2023.
1:54Time stands still in this burnt-out house in Near Oz, where a couple and their three young children were murdered by Hamas fighters in their bomb shelter. Dalit Aharon, hiding in her own safe room in another part of the kibbutz, got a message from Tamar Simantov. She wrote, they shoot us. And after that, she wrote, with a lot of mistake, we are very injured. From what we understand, after they touched the house, the children were dying from suffocation. So all the family was killed. Dilit is showing me around with her husband, Achi. Do you support some of the houses being left like this so people can understand what happened?
2:37Everybody needs to see and to know what happened. You should see the destruction, pure hatred that happened here. In the deserted communal dining room, birds have made nests in the ceiling. Dilit points out the coloured stickers on the rows of residents' post boxes. On October 7, we were 400 people. One of four was either murdered or kidnapped. The red stickers are the one that murdered and the black stickers is the one that kidnapped. Some of them were kidnapped and then murdered there. Among those killed in Gaza were Cherie Bibas and her two ginger-haired sons, the youngest a baby. They were seen in a video surrounded by Palestinian gunmen.
3:28This is the hardest house for me because Shiri was a very, very good friend of mine. She was like a sister. The pain is too much for some survivors now making new lives elsewhere. But Dalit, whose parents were founders of the kibbutz, is determined to return when it's fully rebuilt in two years' time. Welcome back for memory of Shiriz and for all the people that didn't have the chance to live here and for memory of my parents and to continue our roots. Dozens of burnt-out homes have already been torn down. Just the bomb shelters made of reinforced concrete still need to be removed. A few former hostages are back living in Neroz in smart, newly built villas.
4:19Emi Palmer is director of the rebuilding project. We started an entire re-planning of the kibbutz. It's trauma-informed design. It tries to help you feel at home and yet feel that the place has changed enough so you're not triggered by every step that you take. There are still unanswered questions about security next to war-torn Gaza and political accountability for the huge security failures is a big issue in Israel's upcoming general election. But as Aki talks up a surfboard at a beach in southern Israel, he and Delete are focusing on their own healing. This is the first 7th of October anniversary since all the hostages were returned, dead and alive.
5:04Until the hostages came back, it was the only thing on our mind. And now it's our recovery or some kind of recovery as much as we can. Ahi was taught to surf by an Israeli therapy organisation. Today, Dalit cheers him on from the beach. The couple still face huge struggles, but say they're trying to ride out the waves of their trauma. The BBC's Middle East correspondent Yolan now reporting there from the kibbutz near Oz. Well, it is a day for coming together in Israel, but deep divisions persist in the wake of October the 7th and from even before those devastating attacks, as I've been finding out from Professor Tamar Herman of the Israeli Democracy Institute.
5:53We are all post-traumatic after October 7th, and this in a way brings us together. However, it is divided because the conclusions are very different from people on the centre-left, and on the right. So even on this Memorial Day, the third university for October 7th is perceived differently by different people. It is not united, for example, like on Memorial Day for the Holocaust, where people are not divided. Just thinking about the events of October the 7th, and I guess the days leading up to it, I mean, how do those two camps that you describe, How do they divide over the issue of whether the attacks might have been prevented and this crucial issue of whether there was information that might have led the security forces to take different actions on that day?
6:50Let me remind you that in the eight months before October 7th, we had experienced a huge wave of protest against the government regarding what one side calls judicial reform and the other side referred to it as the judicial overhaul. So the people who were protesting against Netanyahu before October 7th, of course, accept or take as a very libeled information that he got some pre-warnings and that he didn't act accordingly because his perception was that he would appease Hamas with the Qatari money. Netanyahu's supporters would claim that the security agencies, the IDF and Shabak, did not warn him.
7:46And this is exactly where the two sides diverge. Yeah, and of course, I mean, he has denied having any warning about the attacks. What about the conduct of the war, the huge levels of death and destruction that we've seen in Gaza? Are Israelis broadly supportive of the way that the war was fought? I'm returning to my initial point. On the very left side, there are Israelis who, starting about March 2024, demanding that the IDF way of conduct of the war should be changed, not necessarily halted or stopped, but to prevent collateral damage. mainly of Gazan civilians. I have to say, however, that the large majority of Israelis are not of this opinion.
8:44They think that the war should be fought as if Hamas is still there and is using the civilians as a human, you know, shield. So there is not much empathy amongst Israeli Jews to the destruction that happened in Gaza. They are not very critical of what happened and what is still happening. Professor Tamar Herman. Well, the attacks of October 7th triggered a ferocious response from Israel that's laid waste to Gaza and in three years killed an estimated 74 ,000 Palestinians, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry. And the fighting continues despite the ceasefire. The enclave is divided into an area controlled by Israeli forces in the so-called Green Zone, where the entirety of Gaza's population now lives.
9:38Well, shortly before we came on the air, I spoke to Akram al-Satari, a freelance journalist based in Gaza City. The Palestinians in Gaza have seen no ceasefire. There was a recent attack around one hour and a half ago that claimed the life of one Palestinian, 60 years old Gazan. There were similar strikes throughout every single day in Gaza Strip. Yesterday, there was another incident claiming the life of another Gazan. So the situation is still extremely volatile, and Gazans believe that there is no actual ceasefire and that the war is continuous. Akram, can I ask you this? In the green area where most Gazans are living, I mean, who is in charge there?
10:17Is it Hamas? Living in the green area, I can tell you that there is minimum government presence. There is minimum Hamas presence. So there is a relatively large scale chaos in the green area. No police or policing, no government or government activities. And families are forming groups to preserve the order. Some also organizations, including the Egyptian committee, are forming some groups for the sake of helping the population and also maintaining order in the areas. But there are incidents where people are exposed to the even death because of the chaos resulting from the continuous targeting of the government of the government offices and Hamas offices as well.
10:57I mean, under the peace plan and a national committee for the administration of Gaza was was meant to be set up. I mean, that was mandated by the UN to administer Gaza. I mean, is that has that been formed? Does that exist at the moment? Unfortunately, this has not been the case. And there were some statements that were made by the Board of Peace about imminent visit to the Gaza Strip. But technically, this has not been substantiated by thus far. So the situation is complicated. And people are hoping that the Board of Peace and the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza would come and start organizing the police force, start organizing the humanitarian affair, and start to orchestrate the humanitarian response.
11:44Well, let me ask you about the humanitarian situation. I mean, what are things like at the moment? The humanitarian situation in Gaza is extremely dire. When it comes to access to everything that has to do with a normal life for humans, they start their day by trying to get the water. They start their days by trying to collect the wooden pieces for the sake of starting fire to kick their food. They are receiving the food through the food trucks that are entering in Gaza in the form of humanitarian assistance and commercial quantities at a very minimum level. And they have been in need to rebuild their homes, but they are not able to access anything that will help them rebuild their homes.
12:24minimum number of tents entering the Gaza Strip, minimum number of non-food items entering the Gaza Strip, and minimum number of food trucks are entering the Gaza Strip, which makes the life in Gaza an extremely challenging life. Do people still worry that they are going to be moved away from Gaza, that they won't be able to stay long term in Gaza? Yeah, people were haunted by the idea that IDF and Israel are planning to uproot them, as they say, from the land of Gaza. And I think this issue is reviving every time. There are statements made by the Israeli defence minister and Israeli prime minister.
13:07Some people are willing to leave Gaza and some other people say they would stay in their land and they want to live a human life that they are entitled to as a human in Gaza, not elsewhere. And that was freelance journalist Akram Al-Satari speaking to me a little earlier from Gaza City. You're listening to NewsHour from the BBC World Service.
13:41Coming up later. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. You ain't heard nothing yet. Wait a minute, I tell you. You ain't heard nothing. You want to hear T-T-T-T-T-T-T-T-T? All right. Hold on. Hold on. The famous Al Jolson line that heralded the end of silent cinema. But was the jazz singer really the first talkie or was it an obscure film from Scotland? We'll be talking about that in a few minutes. Our main headlines from the newsroom this hour, though. Russian airstrikes across Ukraine have killed at least 20 people. We'll have more from Kiev a little later in the programme. As we've been hearing, Israel's marking three years since the attacks of October 7th.
14:20And the World Health Organisation has warned against the use of surgery and weight loss drugs to tackle rising cases of obesity in children.
14:41This is James Menendez with News Out Live from the BBC. It is Wednesday of Nobel week, which means today is the prize for chemistry, which this year is awarded jointly to the French scientists Henri Kagan and Kenzo Soei from Japan. I'm not going to even try to explain their achievements. So with me in the studio is friend of the programme and more importantly, Professor of Inorganic Chemistry, Andrea Sella of University College London. I'm very glad you're here to help us through this. Afternoon, James. What have they been awarded this Nobel for? Well, they've been awarded this prize for something really quite subtle but incredibly fundamental.
15:16And I have to say, the intellectual challenge that lies behind this is really, really profound. And one of the really interesting things about the chemical world is that an awful lot of it has handedness. So if you think about it, I've actually brought my little cycle in. I've got a pair of gloves. And you know that you've got to put your left hand into your left glove or the right hand in the right glove. And that turns out to be incredibly important because most molecules will have two forms. But the biological world only has one. And so if you give somebody a drug, its action depends on whether it's the left hand form or the right hand form.
15:59And if you get that wrong, you can end up with disasters like thalidomide, which was a morning sickness drug given in the late 50s and early 60s for morning sickness in women, which then caused disastrous malformation in the children who were born. So these are very similar, but not identical. Mirror images, but not identical. Mirror images, but not the same. So I've brought two molecular models. And you can see that the connections between the atoms, if you thought about the order and you described it on the telephone, the order, the connectivity is the same. But what's on the left on one side is on the right on the other.
16:36A little bit like cars in Britain that have the steering wheel on the right and all the controls are that way. And if you go to France, then what you find is that the steering wheel is on the left and the controls are reversed. So the real question is, how can we make molecules of only one kind? And this has been a real challenge for chemistry for a very long time. Now, in the 19th century, Louis Pasteur, one of the fathers of the origin of life, of vaccination, one of the great 19th century minds, He first noticed this under the microscope in crystals, and he used tweezers to pick up the different shapes.
17:16I mean, my God, that's incredibly tedious. Physically picking them up. Physically separating them like that. Well, we've come a long way, and now there are chemical mechanisms, right? There are chemical methods we can use, which essentially use a chemical robot, a catalyst. Of course, biology uses enzymes. But these are little robots. And what they're able to do is they're able to generate only one of the two forms. And if that were just the beginning, okay, so you need a chemical robot which is like the left hand, right, to do the job. What these guys have found is something unbelievably subtle, is that you don't need something which has very much handedness to begin with.
18:01You only add a smidge of something which is handed. And then the chemical reaction becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. What it does is it amplifies. And so it starts making a bit of the left hand. And then guess what? It makes more of the left hand. And the more left hand it makes, the less right it does. And the whole thing generates almost purely the left hand molecule. Now, this is very, very important for pharmaceuticals, pharmaceuticals for the pharmaceutical industry, because it means that you have a much simpler way of manufacturing, of creating the molecules that you need to deliver to treat certain drugs.
18:43But there's something much more fundamental. And, you know, when we think about fundamentals, we always think about, you know, oh, the origins of the universe and what is time. What about the origin of life? Why is life all with molecules of one kind and not the other? Where did that emerge from? And what this work shows, what it really starts to hint at, is the possibility that exactly these kinds of, they call them autocatalytic, these amplifying processes, which start very small and maybe by accident, but then build up, that's where it comes from. It's kind of amazing. And it's really deep.
19:24It's extraordinary. I'm almost left speechless, Andrea. Thank you very much indeed. Andrea Sella there.
19:34Now, let's have another listen to this. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. You ain't heard nothing yet. Wait a minute, I tell you. You ain't heard nothing. You want to hear all right. Hold on. Well, those are, in theory, the first words ever to be spoken in a film delivered by Al Jolson and the jazz singer. That was in 1927. It ushered in the age of the talkie. But are they? Well, one researcher believes that Jolson may not have got there first. Instead, it was an actor in an obscure Scottish film screened in Edinburgh almost exactly 100 years ago. Till the bells ring, billed as a super talking picture of Victorian and Scottish life, appeared in cinemas a full year before The Jazz Singer.
20:17While Mark David Jacobs made the discovery, we asked him for his job title. He said, film nerds. We'll stick with that, Mark. Very good to have you with us here on the programme. I mean, this sounds like a huge discovery. How did you find it out? Yeah, well, lovely to be joining you from Glasgow, the very home of Graham Moffat, the writer-director of this film. And yeah, I made the discovery because, I mean, effectively, it is about being a film nerd. I think that I came across it because part of that for me is about sort of looking at the bits and pieces that, you know, other people, you know, other researchers don't touch.
20:50And I was just going through the catalogue of British films from the early sound era, which is very much my favourite part. I moved to the UK because I fell in love with British cinema and I wanted to really immerse myself in it. And I came across this title that had a Scottish connection. I was living in Scotland at the time, so that was always of interest to me. And the more and more I delved into this, the more and more it appeared that there was this kind of film hiding in plain sight that was made seven years earlier than it was supposedly made. And that if everything about this film was true, then it had indeed beaten Al Jolson and Warner Brothers and Hollywood and the rest of the world, indeed, to the punch by a full year.
21:29Screening, as you say, in this cinema in Edinburgh, in the shadow of Edinburgh Castle, a hundred years ago. How did they manage to do it? Because it was a full sound feature film, as I understand it, wasn't it? Well, exactly. And, you know, that's what we talk about. You know, 99 % of the time when we talk about, you know, I went to see a film last week or have you seen any good films lately? What we're talking about is a feature length film, narrative film with sound. And this is the first time that's ever made or shown by anyone in the world. And they did it because, weirdly, you know, there were companies making films of sound, but they were all sort of novelty shorts or in some cases, you know, filmed lectures, things like that, which people, I mean, it's almost impossible to think that at the time, no one was sort of waiting with bated breath for people to introduce sound to silent cinema, which had obviously been around since the end of the 19th century.
22:18People saw it as this kind of niche that would exist on its own and not take over from what they knew as cinema, which was silent and theater, which already existed. And why would we just recreate that on film, which is more expensive than having a live thing in front of you? And so Graham Moffat, this playwright who had been obsessed with creating sound, in fact, since he'd written about it in a sci-fi novel that he wrote in 1893, where he predicted them as cinephonographs, clearly had this bee in his bonnet about doing it. And by 1926, he's a world famous playwright. He'd written a play called Bunty Pulls the Strings that had a thousand performances between the West End and on Broadway.
22:50way and he has the ability to effectively hire a sound studio that's making these short films and say i want to put on this play of mine which is in the scots language which is extremely important in terms of the history of scottish culture as well and he and he films the entire thing with his own company and indeed his dog mark can you can we've literally got 10 seconds can you just tell us then what is likely to be the first spoken words on film that just just give us that line the breakthrough line of this film according to the enborough evening dispatch is what would the kirk of scotland do without peppermints a line that will hopefully live in history what will the church of the church of scotland do without peppermints fantastic stuff uh time against us but thank you mark david jacobs on the discovery of that scottish film the first talkie uh well before well a year before at the jazz singer in 1927 O-O-O-O 'Reilly Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on.
23:49Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. O-O-O 'Reilly Auto Parts It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing. This is the story of an Islamic boarding school in Indonesia with a dark secret. Of the school's head teacher. This was someone I respected above anyone else. And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence. If this is leaked to the media, I'll be destroyed.
24:34This is World of Secrets, catching my teacher. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
24:53You're listening to News Hour. The killing of a number of women near Johannesburg has reignited anger over South Africa's long-running crisis of gender-based violence. In a televised address last week, the country's president, Cyril Ramaphosa, promised new measures to protect women. But campaigners say government action alone will not solve the problem. In one Johannesburg community, men have been encouraged to confront violence and their own behaviour. The BBC's Christian Parkinson went along to one of their meetings to find out more.
25:27Men, they shout. We are men. I'm at an all-male gathering outside a tavern in an area known as Organic Market. It's an informal settlement to the north of Johannesburg, a maze of corrugated metal shacks and narrow unpaved roads. But we can sit down with a man and talk and resolve the problem with a man before it happens. Some of the men are sipping on bottles of beer, and in the middle of the group is Itumeleng Stephen Tamaga, known locally as Bras Steve. Stop gender, violence, violence. As I'm sure you picked up the subject today is gender-based violence and femicide, something that many around here are familiar with.
26:06Did you used to hit women before? Yes, I did. And I remember myself grabbing her, slapping her. Yeah, I was so aggressive. That's Homotsua Matejka, a local man who's attending today's meeting. And as in, like, seeing what's happening around the world, I feel much more pain. I feel like I have contributed to what's happening. It's been a tough time in South Africa. The issue of femicide and violence against women has dominated the headlines and sparked outrage after a string of brutal murders in the east of Johannesburg. Recent government measures aimed at curbing violence against women here are seen by many as too little too late.
26:46The politicians, they love to talk, but we are the guys that love to make action. Craig Wilkinson is the founder of Father A Nation, a non-profit that focuses on using positive male role models to help end violence against women and try to fix broken neighbourhoods. I have absolutely no doubt that we need to focus on prevention. The thing that will change it is raising boys to be good men, is raising the standard of what masculinity is. So I'm utterly convinced that this kind of programme, focusing on prevention, that is what this country needs. I'm now walking around the area. There's a group of people in the local salon doing their hair.
27:22Amongst them is Providence Maseko. We're afraid to talk to anyone because we do not know who to trust anymore. We do not know because you might be the serial killer. We do not know, right? And Providence isn't the only one who's scared. Doing her washing in a large metal bucket nearby is Linky Masele. She was beaten up by a minibus taxi driver last year. We feel afraid. We feel scared. We are not safe. I'm a man. I'm a force. Back at the tavern today's men's meeting is wrapping up. I don't need any... Homoto is impressed with what he's heard. My message is to other men, stop lying, be protectors of your community by protecting your children, by being the good role models to them, so that when they grow, they become a better nation out there.
28:07That report by the BBC's Christian Parkinson, reporting from Johannesburg in South Africa.
28:23This is the BBC World Service in London. You're listening to NewsHour. I'm James Menendez. Now, how many of us at one time or another in the past few years have thrown up our hands at the state of the world and resolved to bury our heads in the sand and hope it all goes away? Quite a few, I imagine. It is easy to feel helpless, even hopeless, when the world that many of us grew up in is fraying at the seams, either because of the rise of might-is-right politics or the march of technological change. But is there a way to overcome those feelings? Well, one woman who has more experience than most of standing up to authoritarianism in the face of persistent threats to her life and freedom is the Nobel Peace laureate Maria Ressa.
29:05The founder of the news website Rappler in the Philippines took on the violent excesses and corruption of President Rodrigo Duterte and survived. She is still working while he is in a prison cell in The Hague awaiting trial at the International Criminal Court, accused of crimes against humanity for his self-declared war on drugs. And she has a new book out next week. It's called The Fight Back, A Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators. She came into the NewsHour studio a little earlier today, and I asked her, first of all, how does she characterise the threat to democracy and freedom around the world?
29:42Critical. Existential. And you've heard that word existential from the tech bros. The CEOs of the tech companies, the top six that literally control our lives. Because the design of social media spreads lies faster than facts. As early as 2018, MIT said lies spread six times faster. If you can't tell the difference between fact and fiction, there are cascading failures. Without facts, you can't have truth. Without truth, you can't have trust. Without these three, we don't have a shared reality. we can't begin to solve any existential problems like climate change and health. And we can't have journalism.
30:24We can't have democracy. We're at this point already. And you can look at from 2016 until today, the most recent VDEM report told us that 74 % of the world is now under authoritarian rule. We're literally electing illiberal leaders democratically. So in terms of democracy, we're there. We're at the cliff. And so when you use the word in the title to your book, Standing Up to Dictators, those dictators are not just autocrats around the world. You're talking about digital authoritarianism as well. So just expand on that for us. Look, the two dictators in my life, and I speak first from experience, but then after that, backed by data, right?
31:09So dictator one is Rodrigo Duterte. He became president of the Philippines in May 2016 with the help of Facebook, right, with tech. But the second dictator, and I would argue probably more powerful, is Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook. Because by 2017, and I told Mark this, I said, you know. You told him directly. Did you tell him he was a dictator? No. Because I was going to ask you, have the lawyers been in touch over that description? No, no, no. But I have told him. What I did in 2017, we were in California and I invited him to come to the Philippines because I didn't think he understood how powerful Facebook was.
31:48And I said, you know, Mark, 97 % of Filipinos on the internet are on Facebook. Facebook is our internet. There's tremendous power for it to do good. And then he was frowning and I was trying to figure out why he's frowning. And then he asked me a question that really made me think. He said, Maria, where are the other 3 %? And so look at my two dictators, right? The reason I say Facebook, because it was on Facebook where these bottom-up attacks, an average of 90 hate messages per hour. That's where I was attacked. It was also tearing apart my reputation that this is my 40th year as a journalist.
32:29So it was tearing apart my reputation for others. But it also laid the groundwork. In 2017, they started trending hashtag arrest Maria Ressa. Two years later, we had about 27 investigations in Rappler and me, and then my criminal charges started coming. You know, in 2019, I just kept a workflow for posting bail, 11 criminal charges in a little over a year. Presumably, though, I mean, first of all, Mark Zuckerberg, if he were here, would deny strongly that he were a dictator. But presumably, he would also say, look, he cannot be personally responsible for the way that an autocrat or an autocratic regime uses his platform to do whatever they want to do, whatever they see fit, right?
33:16For many, many years, big tech wanted us to look at this as a content moderation problem. It isn't a content problem. It's a safety by design problem. So is your contention, though, that the tech leaders, there is no accountability? Absolutely no systems in place to hold them accountable. And starting with social media, this is insidiously manipulative. And we look at it as fun. Can I just put this counter argument to you? Sure. Which is that we've seen in recent months a whole swathe of so-called Gen Z protests around the world, young people who have harnessed the social media that you're talking about for their end.
33:57So is this not a two-sided coin? It's a Faustian deal. Corruption of democracy, and we've mapped this in starting in the Philippines in 2016, most recently in the United States. In the UK, we've looked at Brexit, right? There's a three-phase funnel where narrative warfare, So this is information operations but multiplied without the safeguards that were even there in 2018 and 2019 because by 2024, we began removing all of this as in the tech companies. We went and looked at the data from the first 100 days of Trump 2.0. And the report that we came out with based on the data is Trump 2.0, narrative warfare and the breakdown of reality.
34:42Even faster. He issued 143 executive orders in his first 100 days. And each one of those executive orders actually had a real world impact. So we journalists wrote about USAID breaking down, but we did not pick them up. Each one of those executive orders as content triggers in the virtual world that created that cycle I just laid out. The picture you paint, you know, is quite a grim one at the beginning. But actually, the point of the book is to try and stop people feeling too helpless and hopeless. So as citizens, given the power of certain governments over our life and the power of information technology and the power of these huge amounts of money that some of the tech companies have, how do we not feel hopeless?
35:35What does the average citizen do then? I wrote the book because I was tired of learned helplessness. right everyone says the news is horrible i'm not going to watch the news people watch the news right and act what do we have to do it is to retain our humanity well let me let me put it like this i mean as someone who has had so many sustained threats to to your life and freedom and so on and yet you know you're here now saying we you know we cannot be defeated we still have to act what do you say to someone who says look this is too big for me i can't do anything about it i I mean, how do you maintain optimism?
36:13Oh, my God. Hope comes from action. The window to act is closing. It isn't closed yet. But if the pattern continues, don't be scared by the tech CEOs saying the killer bots are coming. It isn't just that. It's us. go back to who we are, the strength of who we are, which is trust, person to person. The journalist and Nobel laureate Maria Ressa on her book, The Fight Backer Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators.
36:57Now, it's the end of an era for arguably the greatest footballer that ever lived. Lionel Messi's played his final international match for Argentina, and he scored a penalty in front of a packed stadium in Buenos Aires on Tuesday. In fact, he set up two other goals for his team to beat Benin 3-0. Not that Benin seemed to mind, their players just seemed delighted to be part of a moment of history. Fernando Rodriguez travelled from Mexico to watch the game. Messi has left a legacy of determination and unity, especially for the people of Argentina. He leaves behind a sense of community and shows that great things are always possible.
37:37Well, let's talk to the football journalist, Marcela Mora y Araujo, who joins us on the line. Marcela, very good to have you with us here on the programme. Was this match a fitting end to his incredible story, do you think? Well, you know, the sort of cynics like myself were thinking no beforehand. Like, you know, it's a small rival. There's been issues with finding opponents for all these international fixtures. The FA is seemingly rather shambolic. The tickets were stupid expensive. But then Messi played his magic and turned it into the most incredibly emotional and lovely event ever. So, yes, it was.
38:24I mean, I don't know if the sending off was up to Messi's standards or if anything Messi touches just becomes sort of out of this world and, you know, something incredible. But it was really, really special. It's good that he actually scored the penalty. It would have been a bit of a letdown if he missed, wouldn't it? Well, I think part of what made it a better evening than many expected was that Benin were actually quite good. I mean, there were sort of rather politically incorrect jokes beforehand saying, where is Benin and who are they? But they actually played well and gave it their all and fascinated, as they clearly were, to play with Messi.
39:04They gifted him a sort of statue of female warriors. It was all rather great. But there was a point where it looked like Argentina might not win or even score at all. And I do think it's rather fitting that he gave a pass to Otamendi, who's also leaving the national team after, you know, 15, 20 years or whatever, forever. Then gave a pass to Nico Pass, who is the new number 10 and the guy that we have as a sort of heir to Messi. Not that he's that good, but, you know, who will replace him on the pitch, the young newcomer. And then scored from a penalty and didn't miss because Messi has famously missed enormous amounts of penalties throughout his career.
39:47But so it was just perfect. Yeah. I mean, playing for Argentina for him, I mean, it's everything, isn't it? Yes. I think for many years, it was actually his father's main desire that Messi be Argentinian. It was really important to him. And Messi, of course, went to play for Barcelona when he was very young. And so he could have been signed up by Spain at one point. But his father sort of engineered with the then manager of Argentina, Marcelo Bielsa, a very sort of improvised friendly against Paraguay to make sure that Messi had played for Argentina and was therefore sort of tied to Argentina forever.
40:30Rules now have changed. So you could play a youth game for a country and then end up representing another one. But back then you couldn't. And for many years, Argentina and Messi didn't have that sort of profound emotional bond that Jorge Messi was seeking. And I think a lot of parents of children who were born or brought up far from their homeland feel it's a very deep desire. And it was rather moving yesterday also to see Messi sort of instilling that love to his own children, who, of course, have lived abroad all their lives, but were visibly moved and amazed by the national anthem and the sort of patriotic firework.
41:10Marcela, thank you very much indeed. Great to have you on. And that was the football journalist Marcela Mora y Araujo there on Lionel Messi's final game for Argentina last night. This is NewsHour. This is James Menendez with NewsHour live from the BBC. Russian airstrikes on Ukraine today have killed 22 people and damaged several buildings, including a block of flats. They're part of an intensifying campaign of attacks on civilian infrastructure as Russia tries to gain the upper hand in the war. Part of that campaign is also a series of strikes on the bridges in Ukraine's capital, Kiev. The city straddles the Dnipro River and half a million people rely on these crossing points for their daily commute.
41:53Over the weekend, they were hit by Russian drones on four consecutive days. From Kiev, Dan Johnson reports. Russian attacks have been intensifying throughout the summer to the point where the air raids here in Kiev are almost constant some days. on the busiest 19 in the space of 24 hours. That is disturbing life here, day and night. It's causing chaos, and the attacks have been focused recently on infrastructure, particularly the bridges that connect the two sides of this city, which are vital for keeping traffic flowing. It means there is more armament obvious out on the streets. The soldiers are wearing heavier gear, and it's not unusual now to see machine guns positioned at strategic locations around the city.
42:39There's a nip in the air, the leaves are starting to fall. So how are people feeling about the impending winter? Kristal is actually visiting Kiev from Southampton to see her relatives. We were actually on the bridge when it got the hole in it. When it got hit? In that morning, we were still on the other side of Kiev when it got hit. And then we were the first bus that passed next to it after it got hit. Do you think the city could be cut off, could be divided if those bridges keep getting attacked? Yes, and that is the scary thing, I'd say. Even for my mum's family, because they also work on this side, but we live on the other.
43:15So that is the frightening bit, we'd say. Getting cut off from the main source of income and so on. Some of those who don't have the choice to leave this city are more nervous. Tatiana is expecting a baby. I think we need more help from our partners, so that they can give us at least some assistance. Our people are doing everything to protect us and they need at least some help to be able to shoot down all the missiles and drones and everything else. And the rest people will do themselves. We are strong. We will do everything. There is still plenty of resolve amongst people here. Dennis works in a restaurant.
43:56As for the future, I don't even know what to say. I want to live and I want all of this to end as soon as possible. For now, I honestly can't believe it. I just live one day at a time. I can't plan anything for the future. I can't even plan for the next week. Of course I hope for the best, but I don't see any signs this will change soon.
44:18Many are considering what the best move is for the forthcoming months. I met Daniel, a 26-year-old ballet dancer, who was pushing his baby daughter Estelle in a pram. She's just two months old. It's so hard. I live in Kiev now and we try to prepare for winter because we know this winter will be so hard. What is the hardest thing right now? Every night when you hear an alarm or when you go to work and saw drones or some missiles. and it's so terrible when you, every time you're nervous about your family, about your friend, about yourself in the end. Are you thinking you'll stay for the winter? Yeah, I think yes, but my wife with my baby, I want to try to go to other country in this winter.
45:20it's so hard because you want to see how your baby grow up so yeah it's so hard decision but i think it's safe it's more and more important yeah ukrainians in kiev speaking there to the bbc's dan johnson last week the u.s state of tennessee attempted to kill by lethal injection a prisoner on death row. She's Krista Pike, but they failed twice. And now her lawyers are reporting that Krista is conscious and speaking. Our chief North America correspondent is Gary O'Donoghue and joins us on the line now. Gary, good to have you with us. Are we any closer to understanding what went wrong? What happened?
46:06No, we're not. And that's one of the things the lawyers for Krista Pike are going to court for in what, about two hours time to try and get more information to try and preserve any information, any details, including syringes and things like that and results from any tests that they think they're not getting proper access to. They also want some independent access for testing, which the state is resisting. They also want to get proper access to her physically, which at the moment is slightly unclear, but it doesn't seem they're getting direct access to her, even though she's now awake and speaking.
46:44So there are lots of unanswered questions. But it's unprecedented, someone get two doses of this pentobarbital and survive. And you have that extraordinary picture, as we saw last week of them, trying to kill her one moment and then trying to save her life the next. Yeah, it is an extraordinary turn of events. I mean, the fact that it's unprecedented, presumably means, well, that there's no legal precedent for this situation. I mean, And presumably her lawyer is going to be asking for clemency now for her. Well, they've been asking for a commutation of her sentence to life. That's what they've been asking for all along because they believe that she wasn't represented properly at the time when she was 18 years old.
47:23And the account that would be taken nowadays of her childhood traumas and being raped as a child, etc., that that would have been a different decision now. You know, it's worth pointing out that her crime was a horrific one. She murdered and tortured a 19-year-old, Colleen Schlemmer, in the woods with a couple of accomplices. It was macabre and horrible and one of the most notorious crimes. And Colleen Schlemmer's mother was present at the botched execution last week. So there's no denial about her guilt and the nature of her crime. The question here is whether or not cruel and unusual punishment can be used by the state, which is, you know, constitutional protection.
48:06You know, you can kill people in the United States. You can execute people. And 27 states have that on their books. You just can't do it in a cruel and unusual way. And that is part of the argument that the Pike lawyers are making. Just briefly, though, I mean, the state of Tennessee, are they still arguing that potentially another executioner should go ahead, given the major crime? There's a moratorium for the rest of the year. There was due to be another one in December. But don't forget, they failed to carry out one in May, couldn't find a vein. So there's a moratorium and an independent inquiry into what happened last week.
48:40Gary, thank you very much indeed. That was our chief North America correspondent, Gary O'Donoghue, joining us live from Washington, D.C. That brings us pretty much to the end of this edition of News Out. Don't forget, as ever, you can get all the latest on our top stories on our website, bbc.com forward slash news. However, from me and the rest of the team, thanks so much for being with us today. I will be back at the same time tomorrow. until then take care bye bye
49:23it felt like everything i believed in was suddenly collapsing This is the story of an Islamic boarding school in Indonesia with a dark secret. Of the school's head teacher. This was someone I respected above anyone else. And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence. If this is leaked to the media, I'll be destroyed. This is World of Secrets, catching my teacher. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app, or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
People across Israel and around the world have been marking the third anniversary of the October 7th attacks which saw Hamas-led fighters kill almost 1200 people and take 251 hostages. Israel responded by launching a military offensive in Gaza that Hamas officials say has killed more than 75,000 Palestinians. We'll get reflections on the anniversary from Israel and Gaza.
Also on the programme: Argentinian footballer Lionel Messi scores in his final game for his country; why a film enthusiast believes cinema's first 'talkie' was made in Scotland; and we speak to the Nobel Peace Prize laureate Maria Ressa on her new book which is part autobiography, part manifesto.
(Photo: Israeli family members visit a memorial site for victims of the Nova music festival on the third anniversary of the 7 October attack. Credit: Atef Safadi/EPA/Shuttershock)