

10 Nov 2026 · 47m · 20 chapters

This NewsHour episode mixes international war reporting with politics, culture, science, and literature.
High-level US-led peace talks in Abu Dhabi between Ukraine and Russia, with ongoing fighting in Ukraine’s “fortress belt” around Slovyansk; skepticism about whether talks can succeed without concessions from Moscow. It also covers: allegations in the UK against TV figure David Walliams; research on chimpanzee vocal learning; an interview about the Booker Prize winner M. John Harrison; and separate US/UK political and legal stories (a US soldier arrested for alleged Russian spying; impeachment proceedings against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth; Novaya Gazeta’s closure in Russia).
John Herbst (former US ambassador to Ukraine; Atlantic Council). Sarah Dytam (Times journalist; book Toxic Women). Dr Catherine Crockford (Institute of Cognitive Sciences, Lyon; PNAS study). Mark Kankian (retired Marine colonel; CSIS). Steve Rosenberg (BBC Russia editor). M. John Harrison (Booker Prize winner).
Putin won’t accept concessions; Trump’s team may pressure Ukraine too much. Slovyansk civilians face dwindling numbers and drone attacks; Peaky Blinders drone unit claims 1,000+ drones destroyed. Walliams allegations involve grooming of girls as young as 15; concerns about industry “sin of omission.” Chimp “raspberry” sounds are learned socially when adults model contexts (e.g., grooming). Harrison’s novel uses beachcombers and an alien invasion aftermath to satirize post-2008 economic rage.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the latest developments in Ukraine peace talks in Abu Dhabi.
“For the US team leading the latest efforts to end the war in Ukraine, one modest obstacle appears to have been cleared.”
Describing the ongoing conflict and the significance of Slovyansk in Ukraine.
“that his military has so far failed to seize.”
Jonathan Beale reports from Slovyansk, detailing daily life amidst the war.
“This is now one of the most dangerous roads in Ukraine, the road to Slovyansk, to Ukraine's fortress belt, its last line of defence.”
Analysis on the prospects of peace talks and the motivations behind current strategies.
“And that was Jonathan Beale reporting from Slovyansk in eastern Ukraine.”
M. John Harrison shares insights on writing patiently and avoiding shortcuts.
“Readers know when you've shortchanged them with a quick solution.”
Discussion on serious allegations against David Walliams and his response.
“This is NewsHour live from the BBC with me, Tim Franks.”
Sarah Dytam analyzes the implications of recent allegations against Walliams and Brand.
“He'd also asked the High Court in London to block the publication of the investigation, saying that were the allegations made public, it was highly likely he would kill himself.”
Discussion on how the entertainment industry is addressing allegations and its culture.
“I wonder whether you think there is any evidence that the culture has moved on.”
Dr. Catherine Crockford discusses chimpanzees learning communication from adults.
“Sarah Dytam, Times journalist and author of the book Toxic Women, Fame and the Noughties.”
Exploration of the study focusing on how young chimps learn to use sounds.
“We mentioned that raspberry sound and I think you very kindly sent us some of the sound that you recorded, which we'll play now and then I'll ask you a question.”
Discussion on similarities between chimpanzee and human communication development.
“And I was going to say in a rather sort of human centred way that it was, you know, it makes these chimpanzees sound very human like.”
Profile on Geri Cormack, the youngest lighthouse keeper in the UK.
“The first one she takes us to sits on the edge of dark cliffs with waves crashing below.”
A US Army soldier is arrested in the UK on espionage charges.
“Our UK Home Affairs correspondent Daniel Sanford has the story.”
Analysis of the political implications of impeachment articles against Defense Secretary Hegseth.
“Hegseth was in typically pugnacious form.”
The story of Novaya Gazeta's closure and the impact on independent journalism in Russia.
“And of course, that was the president's decision.”
Celebrating M. John Harrison's win of the Booker Prize at age 81 for his latest novel.
“And that was Steve Rosenberg there as the Novaya Gazeta closed down for the last time in Moscow.”
Learn about the author's creative process and inspirations for their writing.
“a process of spiritual tourism and gentrification pursued by advanced civilizations from a mooted ninth planet wonderful voice uh katherine hunter reading an excerpt of that book um as is the tradition.”
The author emphasizes the need for patience when developing a novel.
“I think, you know, the whole idea of putting something in a drawer and walking away from it is to do with patience.”
Discussing the complexities and categorizations in literary genres, especially science fiction.
“Well, I think that's true, but also I think that there is a problem with categories.”
The author shares their astonishment at winning the prestigious award.
“Well, going back to the methodology, I've got the bits and pieces.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Newshour, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day, but what policy changes should investors be watching? Washington Wise is an original podcast from Charles Schwab that unpacks the stories making news in Washington right now and how they may affect your finances and portfolio. Listen at schwab.com slash Washington Wise. That's schwab.com slash Washington Wise.
0:57Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts or find us on YouTube.
1:09Hello and welcome to NewsHour. It's coming to you live from the BBC World Service studios in central London. I'm Tim Frax. For the US team leading the latest efforts to end the war in Ukraine, one modest obstacle appears to have been cleared. The news that a second day of talks will take place in Abu Dhabi tomorrow, Wednesday, involving high-level Ukrainian and Russian teams, along with the US negotiators Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff. Fundamental differences remain. Vladimir Putin still insists that Ukraine must give up the remainder of the Donbass region in eastern Ukraine that his military has so far failed to seize.
1:48Ukraine insists that is not going to happen, calling that remaining territory its fortress belt, in effect protecting the rest of the country. The area includes the city of Slovyansk, which used to be home to more than 200 ,000 people. Just 20 ,000 civilians are thought to remain, and the number is ever-dwindling. As our defence correspondent Jonathan Beale reports, I should warn you that Jonathan's report contains some air raid alerts. This is now one of the most dangerous roads in Ukraine, the road to Slovyansk, to Ukraine's fortress belt, its last line of defence. We're going to meet a unit calling themselves Peaky Blinders.
2:31John Herbst: My name is Tatyana, but military name, Nita. Tatyana, who's just turned 21, and a colleague, Yasha, who's armed with a shotgun, are going to escort us into the city. If I told you, run, run, OK? I've got you. We're just walking down this main street in Slovyansk. Pretty much every building you look at has been hit by something. This looks like something bigger than a drone. It looks like a bomb. Just a pile of rubble on the pavement. And Tatjana is telling us to hurry up. Yeah? Come, OK.
3:15Tetyana shows us a video taken on her phone just a few days ago. The sound of several drones buzzing overhead, met by a volley of small arms fire. A look of outright fear etched on her young face. Today it's good weather, meaning it's bad for drones. Rain and cloudy. these air raid sirens are pretty constant and you can see why just over the road day some of the vehicles that have just been damaged in the last week clearly by small fpv first person view drones that's how close we are to the russian forces and our escorts are keeping a ear and eye out for the dangers
4:14There's an air raid siren, so they just said we should get into this building here.
4:21Ten minutes in here, OK? Ten minutes in here, OK. Don't worry.
4:32And yet out on the street, there's evidence of people still clinging on to life here, looking for supplies and just surviving. Stressful. We meet Inga, who's lived here all her life.
4:48John Herbst: Honestly, I don't even know what to say. I simply have nowhere to go and I don't have the money to leave or support myself afterwards. And then there is the fear of the unknown. You don't know how you're going to live or support yourself in the future. So we're just going to go in and get some coffee. As you can hear, it's the generators. It's keeping this business going. This is one of two coffee shops still operating in Slovyansk.
5:16It's where 63-year-old Irina works.
5:22John Herbst: I'm forced to walk around crying. How can they do this? I will not leave Slovyansk. This is my home.
5:34The Peaky Blinders, a specialist drone unit, has spent the last eight months here. Their main task, to destroy Russian drones. They've taken down more than 1 ,000. Their frontline positions are too dangerous to visit. Instead, we watched them testing a new drone just outside the city. It's kind of hard to without goggles. But even that proves risky. Dron! He just heard a drone. He just didn't tell to spread. Sounds like he's gone. I hope so.
6:15An abandoned building's their refuge, where they return for hot food and arrest from the fighting.
6:27Every night their commander, Oleksandr, says a prayer. Thanks for their survival. They eat to the calming sound of classical music. It helps gran out the noise of explosions nearby. Oleksandr holds out little hope for the latest round of US-led peace talks. I really want this war to end. I want to live to see its end. And I want to start living a peaceful life again in my free country. The country we are fighting for and for which we have already paid a very high price. Do I believe these negotiations will succeed? No, I don't really believe they will.
7:13The next morning, we're not the only ones making an exit. About a dozen civilians wait in a bunker to be escorted out of the city. On average, 60 people are leaving every day.
7:30Outside, another heavy blast of gunfire signals drones are flying nearby. Alina Sharko, herself a resident of Slavyansk, coordinates the evacuations. Everyone is thinking of leaving, she tells me. I'm thinking about it too.
7:53There are tears as the latest evacuees leave. They know they may never come back. The lifeblood of Slovyansk, its people, is ebbing away. And that was Jonathan Beale reporting from Slovyansk in eastern Ukraine. Donald Trump, not for the first time, has confidently predicted a peace deal with these latest talks. A big, beautiful agreement, he said last week, adding everyone's going to be thrilled. His negotiators today have not been quite so effusive. They're still upbeat, though. This was Jared Kushner as the talks got underway. Overall, I'd say that we're seeing positive signs from both sides.
8:33John Herbst: They want to see an end to this horrible war. I think nothing would make President Trump happier. This war has gone on for a long time. It's had a huge human cost. And obviously, we have a lot of respect for the Ukrainians, the way that they've fought very, very bravely and very strongly to defend their country. And on that point, Jarrah Kushner's point, Vladimir Zelensky this evening has been quoted by the Reuters and AFP news agencies as saying that I am very happy about recent messages from the U.S. side. John Herbst is a former US ambassador to Ukraine. He's currently senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center.
9:13Is he holding out for much from these peace talks? No, because Putin doesn't want peace. He wants to persuade President Trump. He's willing to negotiate peace, but he's not willing to make any concessions. Ushakov, his national security advisor, said that. And Lavrov, the foreign minister, said that. And is that, do you think, because he feels, I mean, quite apart from, And, you know, whether he wants or does confidently expect his maximalist positions eventually to succeed, do you think that he's also just seeing the damage that he is wreaking on Ukraine over the winter as possibly his sort of best gambit yet?
9:52I think his subordinates are afraid to tell him how difficult things are for Russian soldiers on the battlefield. So he has a rosy sense of Russia's chances of winning on the battlefield. And he's also counting on weak leadership in the West to eventually stop supporting Ukraine. That's why if you want to get peace to this war, this war of aggression, you have to put pressure on Moscow for pursuing war. The signals out of the White House at the moment, I mean, they're certainly saying that they want there to be a deal. Of course, everybody wants there to be a deal, but there is expectation of a deal.
10:28Do you think that there is any chance in that case that there may be a slight change of approach from President Trump, less pressure on Ukraine, more pressure on Russia? I don't doubt that Trump and his team would call off Kushner want peace. It's just that they don't understand that Putin's aim is to take control of a great deal more of Ukraine. Not just the Western Dunbar, the Fortress Belt region that they've been unable to take militarily. and that he's not going to accept a ceasefire now. His aim is hopefully that Trump will distance himself from Ukraine. What we've seen over the past month where we gave concessions to Russia and put pressure on Ukraine is exactly what Putin hopes to see more of.
11:15So their tactics are wrong. They have to put the pressure on the aggressor, which is what Trump said he would do when he came into office. But we have not seen too much of that since the sanctions he put down on Ross Neth and Luke Oyl in October of last year. Given your disapproval of the current administration's tactics then with regard to the war and given what you view as the unlikelihood of President Putin really wanting peace, is there something constructive that the Ukrainians, I don't know, maybe even the Europeans as well can do to try and build the outlines of a deal which maybe could give Putin more incentive somehow to declare peace?
12:03Because as you say, it is a ruinous war for Russia as well. And somehow give cover, but also give the sufficient security guarantees for Ukraine? American leadership dealing with Russian aggression in Ukraine over the last 12 years has not been strong. Perhaps the best leadership was Trump's first term. So I'm an equal opportunity critic of poor policymaking. But, you know, Obama was talking about an off ramp for Ukraine. Biden was talking about an off ramp for Ukraine. Merkel was talking about an off ramp, excuse me, for Russia, for Putin. Putin didn't want an off ramp. He wants Ukraine. Not necessarily the entire country, but most of it.
12:40And he wants to have it firmly under his control. That's the problem. Yeah. I mean, if things go badly, as far as you are concerned, your reading of things are concerned, if the US continues to put more pressure on Ukraine and perhaps give more of a free pass to Moscow, I mean, how far do you think that the Europeans can step into the gap? I'm not predicting that this will continue. Trump got some pushback, including from his own party members in Congress over the past few weeks, which is why he and Elon Musk were trading charges as to who is responsible for the irresponsible policy of preventing Ukraine from receiving Starlink's information, right, on Russian ballistic missile attacks.
13:24So they have to be careful because it's not a good look to be coddling the Kremlin, coddling the aggressive. So, and we know we saw Trump put serious pressure on the Kremlin a year ago with those sanctions on Rosneft and Luke Doyle. It's just this instinct is to, you know, give flowers to Putin and bric-a-bracs to Zelensky, which is exactly the wrong tactic. And that was the former ambassador to Ukraine for the United States, John Herbst. He was speaking to me from Vilnius, the capital of Lithuania. This is News Air.
14:06And coming up on this edition of the programme, the 81-year-old winner of one of the most coveted awards in English literature. The Booker Prize gives NewsHour listeners his advice on how to write a good novel. Be patient. I think if you force it, if you look for a quick solution, people can tell. People know. Readers know when you've shortchanged them with a quick solution. So be patient and be ready to shift your ideas about what the book actually is. wise advice from m john harrison the uh oldest uh ever winner of the booker prize um you'll hear more from him in about 30 minutes our main headline from the bbc newsroom this hour a senior u.s soldier has been arrested in britain over allegations of espionage involving russia we'll get an update from our correspondent in about 15 minutes
15:06This is NewsHour live from the BBC with me, Tim Franks. The British actor, TV celebrity and children's author David Walliams has today been accused of preying on girls as young as 15. In a joint investigation by ITV News and The Guardian newspaper, Multiple women alleged that Walliams used his fame and status to target them for sexual gratification when they were teenagers and young women. The actor denies the allegations. He'd also asked the High Court in London to block the publication of the investigation, saying that were the allegations made public, it was highly likely he would kill himself.
15:45That injunction was refused last week, and the deadline for the lawyers of his to appeal passed yesterday. Sarah Dytam is a journalist with The Times newspaper. She's written about the story. Yesterday we heard about the sentencing of Russell Brand on charges of rape and sexual assault. Whereas with Walliams, these are accusations of grooming. But what might this week tell us about male celebrity culture?
16:13John Herbst: You're absolutely right to differentiate the two cases. These are allegations and Walliams. certainly denies the most serious allegations and denies that he was exploitative or abusive in any of these relationships. Nonetheless, I think the reason people are putting them together is we're talking about two really big stars of British TV. I think Walliams didn't achieve the same international currency that Brand did, but to a UK audience, he's really one of the biggest figures of TV over the last couple of decades. So he broke through as a comedian, had a massive hit with the sketch show Little Britain, went on to be a very beloved judge on the talent show Britain's Got Talent, and also had this secondary career as one of the best-selling, in fact in many years, the best-selling children's author in the country.
17:14John Herbst: But at the same time, behind the scenes, there are these allegations that he was using his celebrity and using the access that his celebrity afforded to groom very young fans. And that also his professional conduct in the TV studio while making Britain's Got Talent and his publisher HarperCollins was really not appropriate. You're absolutely right to differentiate what's being alleged about Walliams to what we know of Russell Brand and the crimes of which he has been convicted. but one of the aspects that appear to be shared here is that at the time the rumours were going around it was one of those sort of open secrets that at least there was talk about this and it feels as if there was just a bit of a sin of omission as far as those who were invested in whatever way in these two men's careers.
18:15John Herbst: One of the significant allegations in the Walliams case is that producers and publishers were aware of his conduct to a certain extent and the informal practices were developed to kind of manage them or to work around them so that female staff were not exposed to behaviour that was inappropriate. That is really concerning if true. All that you're saying is, I mean completely correctly, is in the past tense And, you know, when we're talking about these allegations against Walliams, when we're talking about the crimes of which Russell Brand was convicted, they date back, I mean, getting on for 20 years ago.
19:00I wonder whether you think there is any evidence that the culture has moved on. This idea that you can treat women either in your routines or actually in real life in this way is at all acceptable.
19:17John Herbst: I think there has been a considerable tightening up of practices. But at the same time, you know, the entertainment industry is no longer focused on legacy broadcasters. It does also take in social media platforms. And the relationship between stars and fans on those is much more vulnerable to exploitation. and the oversight of those platforms for what happens, you know, for example, in private messages, is it's not clear what responsibilities platforms have when it comes to the behaviour of the people who are stars on those platforms. Sarah Dytam, Times journalist and author of the book Toxic Women, Fame and the Noughties.
20:02Chimpanzees are among our closest relatives. And according to new research, just like us, the young learn to communicate by copying adults. In other words, some of their highly distinctive voices are not innate. Dr Catherine Crockford is research director at the Institute of Cognitive Sciences in Lyon in France and was the senior author of this study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
20:25John Herbst: So the main finding is that there is a particular sound, these unvoiced sounds that chimpanzees make. So it's not their whole repertoire, it's just this one part that we've looked at, one of which is a raspberry sound. These sounds we found are actually meaningless, but they can take on shared use or function that is passed on from older to younger individuals. Our closest living relatives, the primates, are considered to have very fixed, innate vocalisations. What we have recently shown is that there may be more flexibility, there is more flexibility in chimpanzee vocal repertoires than people have traditionally thought.
21:05We mentioned that raspberry sound and I think you very kindly sent us some of the sound that you recorded, which we'll play now and then I'll ask you a question.
21:21And you recorded this where?
21:24John Herbst: We did the study in two different sites. That particular one was taken in a sanctuary in Sierra Leone. The other field site was in Ivory Coast, the Thai chimpanzee project. So these are wild chimpanzees who live in a largely primary rainforest. Antoine Vallée, who's the first author of the paper, went out to both sites to observe the chimpanzees and record the vocalisations while they were behaving. Okay, so you were able to draw comparisons between these different communities of chimpanzees. Can you explain to me what the differences in sounds were, or the usage of those sounds were, that you were able to denote?
22:06John Herbst: What we realised is that the chimpanzees who grew up in the peer-raised groups without a role model, their use of these vocalisations is very chaotic. It is not shared, it is not stable. They can use it in any context that they like. Whereas those groups that have a role model, whether they are in the wild, their usage is stable and it is shared. In Thai, for example, they use this vocalisation in grooming contexts. I saw one write-up of your study in a newspaper article about it. But you can think about this in terms of English kids or kids who speak English growing up to use the word dog, French kids, Xi 'an, German kids, Hund.
22:51And it's just, it all means the same thing. And it's not, they're not making the sound of the dog, but they're all using very different words from a very early age that denote dog.
23:01John Herbst: I think that's a reasonable analogy to make that the chimpanzees who grow up in groups with an adult role model from the age of two or three, when they first start producing these sounds, they're using it already in the adult context. And this is just so different from the groups where there is no adult role model, where they use this all over the place, you know, grooming, playing, aggression, resting. It's very interesting hearing all this. And I was going to say in a rather sort of human centred way that it was, you know, it makes these chimpanzees sound very human like. But maybe actually we should consider ourselves to be rather chimp like, rather primate like in the way in which we we build our language.
23:41John Herbst: Exactly. I mean, I think we do have a tendency to reduce animals to simple beings. And I think the more research we do, the more we find that there is fascinating complexity. And in fact, you know, maybe what chimpanzees are doing is a little bit more like people than we thought. The primatologist Catherine Crockford on the narrowing gap between chimps and us.
24:12Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to the Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube. welcome back to news hour most of us do everything we can to avoid going out in bad weather but for some braving the appalling conditions is not just in a day's work it's all the more important when it's filthy outside and that's the case of jerry cormac who at 28 is the uk's youngest retained lighthouse keeper our scotland correspondent lorna gordon has been to caithness to meet her
25:05John Herbst: Geri Cormack has an unusual job which takes her to the northernmost edge of the British mainland She's part of a tradition going back centuries and is currently the youngest lighthouse keeper in the country It's one of those jobs that doesn't really exist anymore You're part of such a small group continuing on this legacy that is spanning back hundreds of years Her job is to look after three lighthouses in Caithness. The first one she takes us to sits on the edge of dark cliffs with waves crashing below. So I look after Noss Head, which is this one here. It was built in 1849. It was one of the Stevenson lighthouses.
25:46John Herbst: And there are 76 steps from the bottom all the way up to the top. Among her tasks here, routine checks to ensure the light stays on. So I have a big checklist that I send off to headquarters in Edinburgh. I tell them if there's been any damage. I also maintain the station, so I clean it. A lot of letter picking, a lot of window cleaning. If they get too dirty or messed it up, it can reduce the range of the light by several miles. It must be the most qualified window cleaner in the country. This is the start of the Pentland Firth here, which is one of the most dangerous stretches of water in the world.
26:24John Herbst: Along the coast, the next of her charges. Smaller in stature, but its role just as important, and a family connection here. So this is Duncan's Behead, and this is close to John O 'Groats. I grew up just down the hill from here, and my great-grandad was one of the labourers who helped build the lighthouse back in 1924. It's still got its original optic, which spins there, so you get the lovely sweeping flash coming down the hill. Is this kind of magical as a child looking out onto a lighthouse? There was, and there's something a bit comforting in it as well. The third lighthouse Gerry Cormack looks after is Dunnett Head at the most northerly point on the British mainland.
27:08John Herbst: Conditions here and right along this exposed Cateness coastline can be brutal. It gets pretty wild. This is tame today. This is just a light breeze. We had hailstones in June. The wind whittles by, you sometimes can't get the doors open. So it's great to watch from up in the warmth. For Geri, this is still her dream job. I love it. You're in such a fantastic place. You've got views like this. It's history that's still relevant. It's still doing the same job it did 200 years later. Time and technology has moved on. Lighthouses are now fully automated. but they remain as important as ever in keeping sailors safe in what can be dangerous waters.
27:59And that was Lorna Gordon reporting from northern Scotland.
28:10This is the BBC World Service and live from London, you're listening to NewsHour. I'm Tim Franks. A senior US Army soldier has been arrested in Britain on suspicion of spying for Russia as part of a counter-terrorism operation involving the US military and the FBI. Our UK Home Affairs correspondent Daniel Sanford has the story. He's a 41-year-old man described by his own forces as a senior soldier and he was based at Imjin Barracks in Gloucestershire in West England. Now, Imjin Barracks is the headquarters of NATO's Allied Rapid Reaction Corps. So this is the bit of NATO which is supposed to respond quickly to crises as part of NATO's operations within Europe.
28:56So it's a very significant strategic part of NATO's operations. It used to be based in Germany, but now based in Western England. And I understand that he was based there at Imjin Barracks. This was an investigation which involved counter-terrorism policing UK, who investigate hostile state activity in the UK, but also involved US military intelligence, MI5, the British Security Service. And the allegations are under sections one and section three of the National Security Act here in the UK. Section 1 of the National Security Act is essentially disclosing sensitive information, espionage, and Section 3 is working for a foreign intelligence service.
29:39So that all adds up to a senior American soldier, aged 41, based at NATO's Allied Rapid Reaction Corps in the UK, accused of spying for Russia. And that was our UK O-Affaires correspondent, Daniel Sanford, with the story. Pete Hegseth, the US Secretary of Defence, doesn't give many news conferences, despite having one of the most senior jobs in government, and despite his position leading a military that has been, since the start of this year, embroiled in a conflict in the Middle East. Today, though, for the first time in six months, Mr Hegseth invited journalists into the Pentagon in order to take aim at those members of the House of Representatives who would try to have him impeached, in other words, to declare that he's unfit for public office and sent him for trial in the Senate, Mr.
30:25Hegseth was in typically pugnacious form. Let's be clear about what this resolution actually does. It tells our enemies, Iran, the cartels, every adversary watching that the United States will actually punish its own warriors and its own civilian leadership for successfully executing lawful military operations. It tells them that a single rogue legislator loaded with personal animus for the president can attempt to veto national security decisions made by the duly elected commander in chief. Well, that single rogue legislator, the defense secretary was lambasting as Thomas Massey. He's actually a fellow Republican, albeit a noted dissident when it comes to the Trump administration.
31:11Mark Kankian is a retired Marine colonel, now a senior advisor at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. in Washington, D.C. What does he make of these articles of impeachment currently being read out on the floor of the House of Representatives against Secretary Hegseth? In terms of the articles of impeachment, most of them are pretty weak in the sense that they reflect policy differences, not crimes. The one exceptions may be the extrajudicial killings of alleged drug traffickers. But he has to keep in mind that impeachment is a political process dressed up as a judicial process.
31:56In other words, whatever the Congress decides constitutes a high crime, that's what it is. And they can impeach an official regardless of what the law might hold. Right. Actually, that's a very good point that it is a political process. This isn't a court of law. I mean, you mentioned the extra judicial killings, there is a maybe a connected article of impeachment where Massey says that Pete Hexeth sidestepped laws to prevent civilian deaths. And in particular, I mean, he ties this to the terrible events on the opening day of that of the war with Iran, where, at least according to Iranian officials, I think about 175 people, Most of them kids were killed when that school was struck.
32:44And I mean, Hegseth himself has said things like, you know, there will be no stupid rules of engagement. We're about maximum lethality, not tepid legality. I mean, could Hegseth have maybe given a few hostages to Fortune here? Well, this example is really not a very good one for two reasons. The first is that the targets were selected by Central Command. Exit didn't have any involvement in that selection, and the error was on Central Command. They did not update the target list after the employment of that building changed. And if you were going to impeach somebody, you should certainly fire the head of Central Command under whose direction these were carried out and whose staff selected the targets.
33:40That would be Admiral Cooper. And also in Desert Storm, there was a similar incident. The United States hit a bunker in Baghdad. It was called the Alfredo's Bunker. 450 people were killed because we had very bad intelligence, but there was no impeachment talk from that. So that was a bad policy error. And of course, the war in Iran has been very unpopular. But whether it constitutes impeachable offense, you know, I think that's a stretch. I hear what you're saying. And I suppose the other way of looking at it, I mean, you talked about Admiral Cooper, but also that Pete Hexeth is not the most senior civilian.
34:21I mean, he's not the president of the United States, well, who's not just a civilian. He's also the commander in chief. So, you know, these decisions about whether to go to war and how the war should be prosecuted, I presume, ultimately end up with President Trump. Well, they do. And one of the articles of impeachment is that he conducted an illegal war against Iran. And of course, that was the president's decision. But as I say, there's a stand in. And just in terms of the job he has done, the type of defence secretary he's been, we've seen others, other defence secretaries have been rather more bipartisan.
34:56I mean, Pete Exeth is a very particular type, isn't he? He's had a mixed record as secretary. You know, he's had some real successes. The seizure of Maduro was done with great expertise. Recruiting has been way up on his watch. And he's bought a lot of money into the department, which is very important for funding their programs. On the other hand, we've got Iran, the war going on. He's purged a variety of senior officers with no real explanation. and really because of what appears to be personal dislikes. And that was the retired Marine Colonel Mark Kankian now with the CSIS. Now, if you were listening to NewsHour last week, you may have heard my interview with Sergei Sokolov, the editor-in-chief of Novaya Gazeta.
35:47For decades, it was Russia's most prominent independent news outlet. One of the key words there is, that was, because yesterday, as Sergei had told me, was the day his paper completely shut down. They had, he said, been strangled, suffocated by the python that is the Russian state. They're the latest victim of a crackdown on critical voices in the country. Our Russia editor, Steve Rosenberg, was there to witness the final demise of one of the country's most famous newspapers. I'm standing outside an office block in Moscow, which for the last 30 years has been the home of Russia's leading independent newspaper, Novigazeta, a paper which gained a reputation for fearless reporting about corruption, about human rights abuses, about abuse of power in Russia.
36:36But this is the newspaper's final day. It's closing down. Novigazeta has had its funding blocked and it's being evicted from the building. It accuses the authorities of killing it off. Inside, the last cardboard boxes are being sealed up and wheeled away. The paper's final editorial meeting begins.
37:06Since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, independent Russian voices critical of the war and of the Kremlin have come under huge pressure. Norvega Zeta had already lost its license. Its website had been blocked. It was designated a foreign agent. Yet it had survived until now. The paper's co-founder, journalist and Nobel laureate Dmitry Muratov, tells me that the wave of repression in Russia has caught up with his newspaper.
37:40When I hear people say repressions in Russia are limited, Dmitry Muratov says, first of all, it isn't true. And second, repression is not knowing if there'll be a knock at your door at six in the morning. We now live expecting that knock at the door.
38:04Well, I've wandered into a side office now. This is where the investigative journalist Anna Politkovskaya had worked. She was the special correspondent for Norvega Zieta, who was murdered 20 years ago this year. She was shot dead in the stairwell of her apartment block. This office had been turned into a museum in her memory, with her desk and her computer and her books. But now everything has been packed away and removed.
38:38Some of the journalists have found a guitar and are keeping their spirits up with a song. Others sit in empty offices in quiet contemplation. I get chatting to Anastasia, a photographer. She says that in the six years she's worked here, she's learnt a lot from her colleagues.
38:57John Herbst: I grew up with these people. They taught me everything I know about journalism, everything I know about being human. With the closure of your newspaper, What has Russia lost? I would say Russia lost hope, but just for a few years maybe. But it's not the end. History always goes on circle, and I think it's just not the best part of this circle. But I truly believe that we're going to work again. Maybe it's not going to be the same newspaper. Of course not. It will be a slightly different one. It will be a beautiful, young newspaper, and I believe that it will be a different country, a different newspaper, but still with high standards of journalism.
39:50As for the Kremlin, well, it thinks this is all a fuss about nothing.
39:59President Putin's spokesman Dmitry Peskov denied that the age of independent Russian media was over. Some media get replaced by other media, he claimed. It's just normal rotation.
40:17But as the staff of Novaya Gazeta leave the building, evicted from their office, and pose for one final photograph, this feels like anything but a normal rotation. What was the flagship of investigative journalism in Russia is now falling silent and can no longer hold the authorities to account.
40:43And that was Steve Rosenberg there as the Novaya Gazeta closed down for the last time in Moscow. You're listening to NewsHour from the BBC.
41:05This is NewsHour, live from the BBC with me, Tim Franks. The Booker Prize is one of the most coveted awards in English literature. It's been running since 1969. And on Monday night, an author who's been writing since the prize was formed won it for the first time at the age of 81. He became, indeed, its oldest recipient. The science fiction writer M. John Harrison won for his dystopian satirical novel The End of Everything, which tells the tale of a beachcomber and his aunt, and an alien species, the I Getty. Here's the actor Catherine Hunter reading a passage from the book.
41:41John Herbst: What were the I Getty and where did they come from? They had seemed at first like neither a thing nor a picture of a thing. They seemed to be extruded from a space that wasn't quite in the world. Various simple beliefs surrounded the invasion, competing authorities associated the i getty with dark matter or with the banking crisis of the late 2000s while others believed it to be less an invasion than a re-enchantment of the world a process of spiritual tourism and gentrification pursued by advanced civilizations from a mooted ninth planet wonderful voice uh katherine hunter reading an excerpt of that book um as is the tradition.
42:25The morning after the celebrations, the night before, M. John Harrison, still clutching his bronze Booker Prize statuette, joined Newshows' Regine Vaidyanathan. When we read, as it were, a normal book, a normal piece of fiction, we tend to know more than the characters. That enables us to feel quite superior to the characters. So I thought, what if we loaded some of the same confusion that the characters feel onto the reader, see what happens. So it's a story about two people, one of whom earns his living as a breachcomber, selling off artefacts that he finds in the sea, and his aunt, who is an earlier migrant to the coast from London, as an artist who's part of the arts gentrification of that sort of coast.
43:12And I thought, well, let's let them move slowly along until they meet one another again. What's revealed steadily by this whole process is that when the Aygetti arrived, if they arrived, and how they arrived and who they are, we don't know. They brought with them biological machines, but that when they'd finished their invasion, if it was an invasion, they just did what we would do in the circumstances and dumped them in the sea. And this is what is being harvested by the beachcombers.
43:45John Herbst: You were inspired to write this after the 2008 financial crisis. What was it about that period of time, that period of history, that made you want to write this dystopian, satirical novel? It was simple rage, really, at an economic collapse which seemed not inevitable. I wanted to write something that would be ironic. You often find disaster stories are basically views of the world in which they were written and the present time in which they were written. They're a good place to do satire. But I couldn't get it to work. I got some of the characters. I got the setting in the city of London and I got some scenes, but I couldn't make them coalesce into anything that I could actually start working on.
44:34So I put the whole lot in a drawer. But two years later, I thought, well, nothing's happening with this. I'll make it into short stories. Wrote a short version. And by the time I'd finished that, all the rage that I'd felt originally had come back. And also it had given me the structure for the book.
44:54John Herbst: You mentioned geography there because the English coast and the seaside plays a big part in this book as well. Yeah, yeah. I've always wanted to write a seaside novel. For various reasons, I spent quite a bit of time on the Kent coast and around there. The only reason I hadn't written a seaside novel was that whenever I went to the seaside, it was to climb rock. I was a rock climber for most of my existence. But there was something about the Kent coast. It's a very eerie sort of place. And I thought this would be perfect. I wanted to pick up on what you said about putting a book in a drawer and then coming back to it?
45:31John Herbst: Because there'll be many people listening who want to take inspiration from your story. You've been writing since the 60s. You've won the biggest prize in writing after decades of writing many books, more than a dozen and short stories, as you mentioned. What is it about keeping going in writing that you can tell our listeners is the most important thing to bear in mind? Be patient. I think, you know, the whole idea of putting something in a drawer and walking away from it is to do with patience. If you force it, you will disappoint yourself. If you look for a quick solution, people can tell. Your editor will tell you that that's not true, but it is true.
46:12People know, readers know when you've shortchanged them with a quick solution. So be patient and be ready to shift your ideas about what the book actually is. And a period away from it is just perfect for that. Indeed.
46:28John Herbst: I want to also ask you about the genre that you write, science fiction, because this is a really big moment for science fiction writers as well. Do you think sometimes that genre has not been taken as seriously as it should be? Well, I think that's true, but also I think that there is a problem with categories. There is a problem with categorization itself. And while I would always use imagery from various types of generic fiction, not just SF, but fantasy or horror, I wouldn't consider myself to be a writer of those things, mainly because the product of science fiction is science fiction, Whereas my product is about the world and about people.
47:10And I use science fiction to demonstrate that. But certainly I would, if I needed to, I can reach out into horror. I can reach out into fantasy. This novel is a complex weave of four different genres.
47:24John Herbst: Yeah, I mean, I was taken by one of the quotes from the chair of the judges, Mary Beard. She said, it's a book that turns you upside down and raises a wry smile. and surprisingly, given the subject matter, leaves you with a twinge of optimism. Is that what you want the reader to walk away feeling? I didn't intend to, to start with. I intended to write a much grimmer book. You may find that odd. About two-thirds of the way through, I began to feel considerable sympathy with some of the characters and I thought, well, let's do something for them, which is not perhaps entirely hopeful, but is a bit more elevated.
48:01John Herbst: How do you feel having won this, having written for so many decades? Astonished. I mean, delighted, but astonished. To me, to be shortlisted was the best I could hope for. And that in itself would have been a cause for celebration. To win, that's astonishing. That really is. It will change my publishing career completely. It's a bit sad that it's so late, that it's come on when I'm 81. But it's great. It's just great. Have you got another novel coming up? Well, going back to the methodology, I've got the bits and pieces. In a drawer. Yeah, of something that might be something. Yeah, in a drawer.
48:44It might only be short stories, but it might coalesce as a novel. I'm John Harrison, a wonderful winner of the Booker Prize. He was speaking to Regine Vaidyanathan. That's it from this edition from me, Tim Franks, and the team here in London. Thanks for listening.
49:29The Haunted Library Haunted Library, wherever you get your podcasts. Or find us on YouTube.
President Zelensky has described talks in Abu Dhabi between Ukraine, Russia and the US as "constructive and quite substantive". Former US Ambassador to Ukraine John Herbst assesses the prospects for peace on Newshour.
Also in the programme: impeachment proceedings commence against Pete Hegseth; and how chimpanzees learn language.
(Picture: Jared Kushner, US President Donald Trump's son-in-law and United Arab Emirates' Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan attend the UAE-hosted trilateral talks between the United States, Russian and Ukrainian delegations, in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Credit: Reuters)