In short
NFL Daily’s year-end “All-Pro Teams” discussion, built position-by-position by Ollie Connolly (with Greg Rosenthal). They debate MVP/value vs “best at the position,” and then select first/second teams (plus a third team concept for their show).
Guests
Ollie Connolly (co-host/voter; “Saturday Sickos” on NFL Daily). Greg Rosenthal is the other host. No additional guests appear in the transcript.
Key claims
- QB: Drake May gets the slight edge over Matthew Stafford for value/consistency; Stafford is still elite.
- RB: Bijan Robinson is first-team over Christian McCaffrey; McCaffrey is second; James Cook is a top-tier option.
- WR: Puka Nacua and JSN are first-team; Nico Collins is argued as first-team third WR; Jamar Chase is first-team or second-team depending on voter.
- TE: Trey McBride is consensus first-team; George Kittle is second-team due to impact as a blocker and when healthy.
- OL: Garrett Bowles and Tristan Wirfs lead tackles; Quinn Meinerz is top guard; Aaron Brewer is center.
- EDGE/Defense: First-team edges are Myles Garrett and Micah Parsons (Will Anderson discussed as elite).
Notable examples
- May vs Stafford: QBR/EPA/success-rate/completion% over expected and “what I watched.”
- Bijan: 2,249 yards from scrimmage; ~11 yards per catch as a receiver; explosive + between-tackles improvement.
- CMC: 399 touches; 96 catches, 870 yards, 7 receiving TDs.
- WR: JSN’s growth across levels; Puka’s contested catches/body control; Pickens singled out for “un-guardable” games.
- TE: McBride breaks tight end all-time receptions record; Kittle’s run/pass blocking makes offense “sing.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOConstructing the All-Pro Teams
2:36 to 7:50
Dive into the discussion about selecting All-Pro players for the year.
“And yeah, we didn't want to delay this show any longer with the games on Saturday.”
Running Back Controversies
7:50 to 13:20
Explore the debate over the top running backs of the season.
“So we're confusing our producer, Eric Roberts here, who, yeah, check us out on YouTube and he's putting up the graphics.”
Evaluating CMC's Performance
13:20 to 14:01
Analyze Christian McCaffrey's performance during the season.
Evaluating CMC's Impact This Season
14:01 to 14:39
Discussion on CMC's impressive performance and unique contributions.
Advanced Metrics and Their Limitations
14:40 to 15:36
Analysis of advanced metrics regarding running backs and their effectiveness.
“Just raw numbers, 399 touches right now, which is just crazy.”
Bajan's Role in Offense Dynamics
15:37 to 16:41
Discussion about how Bajan has influenced the team's offensive strategy.
“even if he's not going to go over Bajan.”
Breakdown of Receiver Performances
16:42 to 18:14
Insights on standout performances from Puka and JSN this season.
“it would have been an interesting case because he really had just popped up for four seasons in his whole career, three outrageous, one which was pretty close to outrageous.”
Controversial Catches and Player Development
18:15 to 19:31
Debate over a contested catch and the growth of receivers in the league.
“in his ability to continue to add elements to his game where he is just more explosive uh than ever that he is doing everything in that offense.”
Nico Collins and Jamar Chase: A Comparison
19:32 to 21:13
Discussion contrasting Nico Collins and Jamar Chase's seasons and perceptions.
“And you got to put the two guys we just talked about right there, obviously.”
Selecting the Second Team Wide Receivers
21:14 to 23:11
Debate on who should be included in the second team of wide receivers.
“tell you how constipated their passing game is because they trust absolutely nothing going on with just the general operation of the offense.”
Show all 28 chapters
Rookies and Value in Wide Receiver Roles
23:12 to 25:02
Exploration of how rookies are impacting the wide receiver landscape this season.
“Which is laughable, by the way, because Shuck has been really, really good and is really exciting for the future.”
Amon Ra's Season: Analysis and Context
25:03 to 26:46
Critical look at Amon Ra's performance amidst team dynamics and coaching decisions.
“Loveland and Warren, I guess, has fallen off.”
Tight End Performance Overview
26:47 to 27:58
Discussion on the top tight ends of the season, focusing on Trey McBride.
“All right, let's do a tight end, and then we'll take a break.”
Evaluating Kittle's Season and Impact
28:00 to 29:42
Discussion on George Kittle's performance and his value compared to other tight ends.
“when it's him and McCaffrey and you stick together.”
Transition to Defensive Plays
29:42 to 30:13
Transition to discussing line play, defense, and linebackers.
“And we're going to talk linebackers, which are just Olly Connelly's favorite people on Earth.”
Deep Dive into Offensive Line Players
34:02 to 38:26
In-depth discussion on offensive line players, their performances, and selections.
“Think about what you've learned over the last year.”
Interior Offensive Line Analysis
38:26 to 42:00
Analysis of interior offensive linemen and their contributions to their teams.
“Big news breaking on, what was it, Wednesday here.”
All-Pro Center Discussions
42:00 to 43:14
Exploration of the top centers in the All-Pro selections, focusing on Aaron Brewer.
Edge Rusher Candidates
43:14 to 44:15
Debate over the top edge rushers for the All-Pro team, comparing Myles Garrett, Micah Parsons, and Will Anderson.
“OK, I mean, he was my solid number three.”
Evaluating Edge Performance
44:15 to 46:21
Analysis of edge rushers' impact, including statistics and game performances.
“I just think with Garrett and Parsons, these are the two Hall of Famers at the peak of their powers and everything else is kind of overthinking it.”
Defensive Tackles Overview
46:21 to 48:26
Discussion on the lead candidates for All-Pro defensive tackles, focusing on Jeffrey Simmons and Cam Heyward.
“Even compared to Miles Garrett and Parsons, when he gets there, it's there right of the way.”
Linebackers in Focus
48:26 to 53:10
Comparison of standout linebackers for the All-Pro team, including Devin Lloyd and Zach Bond.
“Whereas down-to-down consistency, maybe you can convince me that other defensive tackles are in the mix there too.”
Secondary Standouts
53:10 to 55:58
Examination of top cornerbacks for the All-Pro team, highlighting Kamari Lassiter's performance.
“I feel like who stood out to me the most this year when he's on the field, it was Devin Lloyd.”
Kamari Lassiter: The All-Pro Cornerback
56:06 to 58:00
Discussion on Kamari Lassiter's standout performance and all-pro status.
“put Kamari Lassiter on the first team you would get on a plane and come after me and so So I guess we got to do it.”
Cornerback Selections for All-Pro Team
58:00 to 1:00:29
Analysis of various cornerbacks considered for the All-Pro team.
“So you mentioned Sertan, who has had great moments this year, had the injury, and it seemed to affect him for a little bit.”
Jalen Petrie's Impact and Team Selection
1:00:29 to 1:02:50
Exploration of Jalen Petrie's influence on the defense and safety positions.
“I don't think Christian Bedford is not a crazy name.”
Safety Discussions and All-Pro Considerations
1:02:50 to 1:04:58
Debate on the best safeties for the All-Pro team and their performances.
“are so profound for a team we know is loaded with talent.”
Finalizing the All-Pro Team and Upcoming Games
1:04:58 to 1:06:36
Wrap-up of the All-Pro team selections and a preview of upcoming games.
“pff site that our all pro team also gets there and i want them to recognize kaimi fairbairn too is my all pro kicker.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. March is here and Uber Eats is delivering deals all month long. Score big savings on all the delicious food you need to fuel your sports fandom. Whether you're ordering in or hosting the whole crew, Uber Eats is serving up deals on wings, burgers, pizza, all from your favorite restaurants, plus snacks from top stores. Perennial powerhouse, underdog, however the madness unfolds, these deals keep it going all month long. Visit the Uber Eats app for all the latest deals and start saving today.
0:58Ollie Connolly:with help from Lowe's, official partner of the NFL. You know how it's never really about where you're going. It's about who you're going with. The right people can turn any drive into a great memory. That's something Toyota really believes. They design vehicles around real life and real people, the ones who make plans happen and bring everyone together. Inside, everything's built with passengers in mind. Comfortable seating, smart layouts, and space that actually works so everyone can relax and enjoy the ride. There's room for the people, room for the stuff, and room for the moments that happen along the way.
1:34Because when people are the destination, your ride is important. Learn more at toyota.com and find the vehicle that fits your people.
1:44Ollie Connolly:Hey guys, it's Aaron Andrews. Breasts get so much attention, but they're still so ignored when it matters most. Everything these days is fighting for your attention. We've got work, family, social media, making it tough to figure out what to prioritize. I got something that should always be at the very top of the list, your breast health. If you're 40 and over, you should be getting screened once a year. And if you're under 40, it's never too soon to visit yourattentionplease.com to learn about breast cancer risk. Trust me, your future self will thank you. It's a tough sport. It's not for everybody.
2:19Ollie Connolly:You gotta be a little sick to love this game and we got some sickos. Welcome to NFL Daily, where we love a year-end best-of list. I'm Greg Rosenthal, here with Ali Connolly. We are the Saturday Sickos, but it's not Saturday. It is a holiday, though. Happy New Year's to everyone. And yeah, we didn't want to delay this show any longer with the games on Saturday. Let's put it out, Ali, and let's talk about our all-pro teams for this year. I'm asking you, in your words, to be my Joe House to my Bill Simmons as I try to construct an end of the year all pro team list before, you know, we're on to coach firings and playoff previews and we forget all about all that stuff.
3:05Ollie Connolly:Sadly, not a drunk house episode. I wish I was. The takes would really be flying if I was able to have a couple of a couple of beers doing the show. No, I do find that sometimes we just get lost in that like day to day shuffle and so much is going to start happening. next week fast. And we are going to do a quick final awards talk. I'll do that with Jordan and Colleen next week. But I did want to go through position by position. I love listening to that as as a podcast listener. And I I love me some year end lists of albums and books and everything. I start diving in. And so I know I would like it as content.
3:43And so you can help me go through position by position. And I'll just bounce some ideas off you and we'll try to come up with our all pro team. And we'll start at quarterback because, you know, we've probably talked about Drake May versus Matthew Stafford enough this week. I haven't really planted my flag of which way I would go. First thing I would ask you, though, do you did you consider, you know, for your team, anyone else other than those two in terms of first and second team?
4:10Ollie Connolly:No, over the read optional, because we are weirdos on the read optional podcast, we do a third team, which always gives me a free out compared to the real true all pro team. So the only other guy I would have in that mix, I think, would be Justin Herbert. I would consider that, but I think there's such a clear distinction between Stafford and May that he wouldn't get into this conversation. Yeah. Ultimately, I'm leaning May, and I don't like to just lean on the numbers, but when I'm struggling to separate them, I think that's a data point that I will use. And just for the listeners out there for what it's worth, using the numbers that I was using on QB Island, in terms of QBR, May's first, EPA per play second, success rate second, first in completion percentage over expected by a lot, first in completion percentage if you care about that too.
5:03PFF had him fourth. Now Stafford's numbers across the board there are all still outstanding. Fourth QBR, fifth EPA, third success. He actually is first in PFF. So the kind of subjective, you know, play by play grading, that's one advantage that he had. He's down at 14th in terms of completion percentage over expected. So maybe not quite as consistently accurate. And all of that makes sense to me. And ultimately, I do it more off of just what I watched and who I think played better. And I just, I think you're splitting hairs. I don't, I don't have like a big, like difference between the two of them.
5:44I I'm giving Drake may the slight edge. And yes, I'm, I grew up a Patriots fans and maybe I'm a little biased, uh, not just cause the numbers ultimately like back up what I'm seeing, but I do think a lot of the things that he's done with the pressure around him and the types of throws that he's making have been just like more consistently excellent and difficult and he maybe doesn't carry as much a load as a veteran quarterback like Matthew Stafford does but it's not that far off and on a play-to-play basis I just give him like the the smallest edge but I it's very small see I think he does carry just as much a load the
6:22Ollie Connolly:complexity of their system is actually shape-shifted more week to week than what the Rams have actually laid down for Stafford. To me, I found this really difficult. I really do put value in the fact they called the most valuable player award for MVP. So I do think about the value side rather than just most outstanding quarterback. And so I do the coward's way out thing of saying, well, I think May is more valuable that you couldn't just drop Stafford on the Patriots and get the same results. You could probably get the Stafford results dropping May onto the Rams, but I'll give Stafford just down to down excellence of the position.
6:53Ollie Connolly:I'll put Stafford as the first team quarterback and May is the second. OK, so Ali is that is that is kind of cheating, though. I mean, so you are one of the three voters or whoever who gave Josh Allen the MVP last year, because essentially the reason that Lamar Jackson won is there were a couple Ali Connellys out there that split the difference. And no, I'm not doing it as a fairness thing, which I think some voters do do. I'm doing it strictly by the definition of the award versus the other award, which is just who was the best at operating this position. I would have picked Lamar Jackson last season, which was the correct pick, the most exhilarating exceptional anyone's ever played the position in human history and yet didn't come away with the award.
7:34Ollie Connolly:I think it's so tight this season that May's value to a team that is just in a worse ecosystem, worse situation is more valuable than what Stafford has done with the Rams. I think you could drop four or five of the guys on that team, get similar levels of production as Stafford has done, But you cannot knock just the consistency he's played with throughout the season for who has just been the best all-round quarterback. So we're confusing our producer, Eric Roberts here, who, yeah, check us out on YouTube and he's putting up the graphics. You know, ultimately, I'm getting the final vote here, Eric.
8:04We're making one team on this show. Ali's got his own show. Check out the read optional. And I do want to hear Ali's picks for a lot of these, but it's more that I'm bouncing off of him. And the fact that he tried to split the baby tells me that either way is fine. I didn't need to be told that anyways. I think you've got to go MVP and all-pro first team the same. And so I'm giving Drake May the little bit of an edge. So Drake May is the official NFL Daily All-Pro, but it's fine either way. We'll talk about that enough, and we'll hit Jordan and Colleen where they go for MVP. Running back was as difficult.
8:42A blood buff. it's crazy that A-Chan and Jonathan Taylor probably can't even get serious consideration. I have a hard time putting A-Chan over Jameer Gibbs if Jameer Gibbs is going to be third in this competition. But my God, A-Chan had an incredible season and has reached levels where he's just a player that's gotten better, I think. Tell me if I'm wrong. I'm like, where have you seen his development? And yet he's not on the top two podium for me, but I do just want to give A-Chain a little bit of love before we move on.
9:18Ollie Connolly:Yeah, between the tackles running, it used to be with him, if you just get him in space, there's a clear runaway. He's clearly one of the most explosive plays in the league. Now he actually does thump between the tackles. He'll square up to people and knock them in the hole. That just gives him more of like a 360 degree ability to attack a defense. Terrifies everyone. You get one little crease and then he's just gone. So yeah, tell me if I'm forgetting anyone. But yeah, Jonathan Taylor, outstanding season, especially in the first half. But to me, it then comes down to Bajon, CMC, and Gibbs. Even though Gibbs might be the guy that I would hand the ball to if I just had to have one run to save my life, like if you need eight yards, even though he might be that guy, I think the way the season ended, obviously he's impacted by what's around him, but the way the season ended and just how stupendous that Bajon and CMC are, he does not make it into the top two teams for me.
10:14Is he your solid third? To me, the toughest decision is going who is one, who is two.
10:18Ollie Connolly:I think it's tighter between McCaffrey and James Cook than it is between McCaffrey and Jamey Gibbs. Ooh, interesting. Okay. And that's a fair point that I didn't even mention the league leader in rushing yards, James Cook, who does everything that is absolutely asked for him. did you ultimately go with cmc or or cook and is that giving away that bajan is is your first team guy i think bajan is the first team guy i ultimately went with mcafree again i'm able to cow it out with the third team on my own show but i this is the tights i think those four you can just throw it up and come down in any order and feel pretty comfortable it's as stacked as i think a position has probably ever been where you just kind of pick in favor to that point cook i love i think he's the most aesthetically pleasing running back to watch um and he gets into this one-off shot I think with Jonathan Taylor where it's just straight running back and you remove some of the receiving side of the game and then it's just Cook versus Taylor and I would just edge it to Cook in that department whereas with McCaffrey and Bijan you bring in all the receiving side of the game which is where McCaffrey has a pretty clear edge well this is where the Joe House comparison really falls apart because he doesn't have some separate podcasts where he's actually going deeper and longer but yeah my official choice I think because I don't think you're going to talk me out of it is going to be Bajon over CMC, just in terms of raw numbers.
11:39Bajon Robinson has 2 ,249 yards from scrimmage. A little under the radar, he is only 174 yards off of second all-time, and he's only, quote-unquote, 254 yards off of Chris Johnson's all-time record which is like okay that's crazy 259 yards four years I mean he got within 15 yards of that last week so it's possible that he could break a great mark and obviously he's getting an extra game to do it you know it's the receiving and we'll get into why CMC is is so incredible but it's probably the the receiving efficiency not that like maybe he's you can talk to me about the route running and the types of things they're asking Bajon to do, but just the efficiency that when Bajon Robinson has touched the ball as a receiver this year, like he's averaging more yards per catch than Brock Bowers and Fannin and Khalil Shakir and Trey McBride.
12:40Like he is getting almost 11 yards per catch on the season on top of, you know, the efficiency that he has running the ball. And you saw it on Monday night, turning all those potential negative games into five, six and seven. So to me, he's kind of checking all those boxes of crazy efficiency along with the crazy explosiveness. And it's also just trusting your eyes that as awesome as CMC is, Bajon has the advantage of youth. And that I think he is in his absolute super duper prime on a snap to snap basis. And that just gives him a little bit of an edge over an epic Christian McCaffrey season.
13:19Ollie Connolly:and I would say degree difficulty both in what's asked of him within the offense as a route runner where he plays as a true receiver flexed outside the formation no one else is doing that all these guys catch stuff from the backfield maybe they wiggle to the slot or something like that he plays all over the formation as a true receiver then the run game he's playing in the most predictable offense in around six years by formation and motion you know exactly where the ball is going it's why he's hit at the line of scrimmage so consistently and yet it doesn't matter he just turns he he always makes one guy miss and if you make one guy miss against him it's going to be a you know everyone's hair's on fire for at least eight nine yards and it could even go to the house so the degree of difficulty and what's asked of him in the passing game coupled with the predictability the run game and everyone knows where he's going to be to me it's just extraordinary what he's done this season yeah we're watching him every week so it really isn't Troy Aikman um talking about him on Monday night during a great performance but it does help you know make me even feel a little better that you know when Troy is like talking about Barry Sanders and he is loathe to go too crazy on the compliments and uh is comparing Bajan to him that I do think he's he's the right choice what was the offense six years ago that was more predictable than Zach Robinson any of the Arthur Smith ones turn around and hand it to Derek Henry he has an answer well you know there was one that Bajan was in a few years ago I guess that's less than six but um Okay, so let's talk about CMC's season.
14:42Just raw numbers, 399 touches right now, which is just crazy. And I thought it would start breaking down maybe by the end of this season, but I think he's actually cutting sharper and looking more explosive right now than he has all season long too. So it hasn't seemed to wear on him at all. And his receiving numbers, he has 96 catches for 870 yards and seven touchdowns just as a receiver. So that's like in the ballpark, depending on how much you value yards per catch or touchdowns. It's like he's basically, production-wise, been around Justin Jefferson as a receiver while still having more than Saquon or Gibbs as a rusher.
15:23It's not like his rushing numbers have been low. Obviously, on a per-rush basis, it's not as crazy. But just the intelligence and the way that you can build essentially the best offense in the league around this one guy is what gets him solidly on the second team for me, even if he's not going to go over Bajan.
15:41Ollie Connolly:Yeah, I agree with you. I mean, it's one where the advanced metrics are oddly unkind to him, and it almost makes no sense to me. Some of the rush yard over expectation. I don't know if the expectation factors in like rotating the offensive line, guys taking massive L's up front. Again, predictability that they have in the run game this season compared to previous years trying to deal with all the constraints and concerns at quarterback and then obviously the O-line. And so I think he's in kind of his own bucket with some of the advanced metrics. And it's a straight eye testing that without him, that would not have been functional for probably 10 weeks this season.
16:11Ollie Connolly:And for at least six of those weeks, seven of those weeks, it was purely, we just got to find a way to get him in a matchup. And that's how we move the ball down the field. And when eyes go to him through motion or movement, we can finally funnel the ball somewhere else in the field to keep us whole for the entire game. So him carrying that kind of loan through Mac Jones to Purdy's return when Purdy was not at his best when he first came back is, it's just as good as it gets. Yeah, and he's over 2 ,000 yards from scrimmage for a third time in his career. And I don't think he was a lock Hall of Famer before this year.
16:40If he had never fully come back from this last injury, which felt on the table, it would have been an interesting case because he really had just popped up for four seasons in his whole career, three outrageous, one which was pretty close to outrageous. But then this one puts it over the top, just carrying a team to me that is this good. And I like what you say about aesthetically pleasing. It's crazy, though, about James Cook, going back to him, because he just looks like Dalvin Cook. I mean, he just had the same— I mean, he looks the exact same as Dalvin Cook to me. I don't know if—I've never seen anything quite like that.
17:14All right, let's go to receiver. Puka and Jackson Smith and Jigba. Sometimes in these exercises, we just skip past the guys who are obvious, and they seem like the two obvious first-teamers. Now they do three guys on the first team, so we will too. but what stands out to you most between these Puka this Puka and JSN season and I'm relieved we don't have to choose between them at wider season it doesn't really matter it's very helpful
17:40Ollie Connolly:JSN just becoming an all-around threat at all three levels quick in breaker the intermediate more timing based stuff and obviously you can just rip it down the field on the deep ball I never thought that would become his game I thought he would max out as kind of a a beat-tier guy slightly overstated because he flashes on red zone every week with the deep shots him being a chain mover as well as the explosive threat guy just did not think we'd see that in his career and so it's to his credit whether it's press coverage zone stuff whatever is demanded of him in the route path he just gets himself wide open and then you can't touch him once he's deep in the stem yeah and puka i mean you could say a lot about this season in the contested catches and in his ability to continue to add elements to his game where he is just more explosive uh than ever that he is doing everything in that offense.
18:30Like he has added something to his game each and every season. But the biggest compliment I would have is I will go to my grave believing he did catch that ball on the sideline. And I know there's a freaking screenshot where the ball is away from his body. But I feel like there is, because we're slowing down everything so much, he caught that thing. Like he caught that thing and you can have control of something. And that's for a split second. Like there was no way he was never not catching that ball because he's freaking Pukunakua. And he did have firm grasp of that. And he does have the toe and just his body control and everything that he does.
19:06I just think receivers and every position is like that. Like the next generation is always better. And for a fifth round pick to, for me to like be taking the position to like new heights is just outrageous from Pukunakua this year.
19:19Ollie Connolly:I mean, this is the same stuff going through all these years now. Same with Tyreek, who obviously followed the draft for different reasons. But year after year, you can just find like Hall of Fame caliber plays seemingly in the full fifth round at this position it's crazy yeah i um think it's harder to find the third pick here so i did a uh social video a few weeks ago or they they clipped one where i had nico collins maybe as my third uh all pro and i love me some nico collins like if i'm just starting the team with a wide receiver it doesn't take long to get to nico collins for me It's Justin Jefferson, it's Chase.
19:56And you got to put the two guys we just talked about right there, obviously. But like, I'm thinking Nico Collins in that category. And he's probably next for me. And at the time, you know, Jamar Chase hadn't put up quite as big numbers. And I didn't notice. But this, I checked it yesterday because I was looking at something else. And suddenly I have about 700 comments telling me I'm the biggest dumbass ever. And it's been viewed by like 130 ,000 people. I didn't even realize of just people thinking this is an outrageous take. I am leaning Jamar Chase now as my first team because I don't want to punish him ultimately for having to not play with Joe Burrow for a chunk of the season.
20:36And he still is Jamar Chase. So I give him a slight edge over Nico, who's going to be on my second team. But I am curious just what you saw out of Nico and how you tried to divide up this third spot on the first team, because they're obviously not the only two candidates here.
20:51Ollie Connolly:are you positive those comments are related to that video i mean no they're just like going why why are you saying what else would they be just be taking general shots at you and you know oh yeah no it was a lot it was a lot of people going back and forth against each other but uh it was a lot of just like nico disrespect that uh that they that's that's asinine absolutely asinine i cannot tell you how constipated their passing game is because they trust absolutely nothing going on with just the general operation of the offense. And so much of his production is tight to the formation, skinny post.
21:23Ollie Connolly:You are going to get your head rocked. That is just the design of the system. You've got to climb over a linebacker. A safety is going to hit you square in the chest. Are you willing to do that? Five, six, seven, eight times a game and hold on to the ball. And there's every now and again, there's a play against Jackson where he can grab it and make something happen after the catch. But for the most part, he's like a catch and impact type player, where it's just big body, go up and get it and make the team look right, even though it's not open by design. So to me, he is when you're listing how who we start a team with, you name Jefferson and Chase, he would clearly be the third guy.
21:53Ollie Connolly:I think there's a compelling argument for him to be on the third guy on this team over Jamar Chase just because of the degree of difficulty. OK, this is what this show is going to be about. Let's let's go through the other potential guys on the second team because we're going to award six guys here. So Puka and JSN are locked in. Chase and Nico, my other first team is probably going to be between the two of them. Who are the other options? We got Amon Ross, St. Brown. We have, you know, we got to mention the Cowboys guys. George Pickens by the numbers is right there. I have a I have a hard time with him maybe this high, but maybe CeeDee Lamb certainly.
22:34Justin Jefferson. I can't I can't ignore him despite just not having the production this year. That's that's probably where my shortlist ends. And where did you think about, like, how are you sorting these guys? Help influence me, because now I might go Nico first team, now that you're making me feel better about it.
22:51Ollie Connolly:I went with Pickens on my first team, because I think he's had the most games this season of all these guys, including Puka, where it's just straight unguardable. There's just five games this season where it's like no one can get near him. He's living in his own space for the entire game. And I can't think of anyone else he's being quite at that level. Some people have better production in individual games, but just full on. We have no one-on-one matchup to deal with this guy. we can't double the guy because we're afraid of cd lamb and he just roasts people for five games so that's where i put picking slightly above everyone else um i think a mom rod numbers wise gets there chase you mentioned i would have uh tet mcmillan in there i think devonta smith has been unbelievable this season he's lost in the shuffle because the the eagles passing game is such a national nightmare for everyone and then there's all the aj brown stuff that we just forget how dominant devonta smith is so that was kind of my shortlist oh i i like that choice and you're sneaky giving a rookie of the year take maybe with T-Mac in terms of what he meant to that offense.
23:47Because suddenly it's Tyler Shuck. Which is laughable, by the way,
23:51Ollie Connolly:because Shuck has been really, really good and is really exciting for the future. It's a full season award. Just deciding this thing, the final three weeks of the season, same with MVP. I know Claiborne is on this island with me, but to strip away 13 weeks to just decide the final few weeks of the season who the offensive rookie of the year is a joke. I'm with you when it comes to Shook, because when we're talking, I know what Patrick is talking about in terms of the MVP award, and that is unfair, but Drake May and Matthew Stafford have been outstanding, like Drake May has been outstanding the whole year.
Read the full transcript
24:23I do think games played matters here. For a quarterback to win an award, for any player to win an award in those nine games, he's got to be one of the greatest of all time, like one of the greatest rookie seasons we've ever seen. He'd have to be like Dan Marino rookie season, but only over nine games or whatever. And Chuck isn't even close to that. Like you could still make the argument if you want, like Jackson Dart versus like Chuck for the season. It's not crazy to me. There's not an obvious choice. I'm leaning McMillan for rookie of the year. We'll talk about that. That is interesting what you say.
24:58You're like, look, Harold Fannin Jr. has like got a top 10 tight end, you know, receiving yards in the history of the game right now. Loveland, like there's a lot of guys. Loveland and Warren, I guess, has fallen off. But I have a hard time with that too. Okay, with your input, I will put George Pickens on my second team. I had him there. He was right on the borderline. But I'm at least going to put him on my second team. I am going Nico Collins on my first team. You made me feel better about it. So I'm going to go Puka, Jackson Smith, and Jigba, and Nico Collins with my first team. And then I'm going Jamar Chase, Amon Ross, St.
25:32Brown, who at this point, I don't think it's fair to even say he's underrated, but he's not just a Lions slot scheme merchant. He is a very unique player, and so he's on the second team, and that's where I put George Pickens, too. So there's our first and second team wide receivers. What did you think about this Amon Ra season, other than kind of ruining the mini Lions dynasty by doing the Trump dance? yes it hasn't been the same since that that at least takes about a first team consideration for
26:08Ollie Connolly:the season imploded from there and then dan campbell a guy i love i know everyone loves but kind of disgraced himself down the stretch this season by turning the lines into this vertical passing attack whilst having no interior offensive line and rotating his centers one that one of the silliest things any coach and this is a coach of one of the sharpest brains in all of football to try and pivot the offense that way which limits what a mom rock and do was just laughable so So Amar in the circumstances, I think we can only really go off the pre-Trump dance portion of the season when the offense was designed differently and was featuring Amar Amar and played to his strengths, and he fried everyone in front of him.
26:40Okay, so we give him his love, and he gets the second team. I like the Devontae Smith shout-out as like a third-team type of guy in this season. All right, let's do a tight end, and then we'll take a break. Trey McBride has the numbers. He broke the all-time receptions record for tight ends. He was the offense statistically. He is far and away the choice. And then I think of what they ask him to do as a complete player, blocker. It seems like it's one of the more obvious consensus first team picks at any position. Do you agree? I agree. I don't think it's all that close. Okay. Then who's your second team?
27:24This is one where I was like, oh, I'm not I don't really know where to go here. You could you could make the case for about five different guys. So who was who was on your short list and where did you go in the end?
27:36Ollie Connolly:Yeah, we've been cleaned out by injuries, I feel, in this category, which makes it really difficult. I ultimately went with George Kitzel, who I know hasn't played as many games as other guys, which kind of, you know, dings some of my other arguments about what you should do with awards over the course of a season. But when he has played, he's just been a tier above everyone, including McBride. He's a significantly better blocker than McBride too. He does make them completely whole in the run past conflict for everyone and makes that offense sing a completely different clip when it's him and McCaffrey and you stick together.
28:02Ollie Connolly:So I just went with Kittle over everyone else. Yeah, because the other guys would be like, I mean, Brenton Strange missed a lot of time. If he had played the whole season, I don't think he would be out of the mix. Darnell Washington would be in the mix, I think, just for second team. If Kittle hadn't played all season, then you get to the rookies. Like, you know, Loveland wouldn't be that crazy of a pick. But ultimately, I think it's all of a stretch. I was like you. I thought Kittle ultimately is so much better than everyone else. It's kind of like I was saying with Tyler Shuck, that like you would have to be so much better than everyone else for your games.
28:42And Kittle did still play 10 games. It's not like he didn't play for much of the season. It's interesting to me you would say that you would have taken him over McBride if he had stayed healthy for the season. It's kind of crazy that we've gotten two vintage, total peak Kittle seasons right now at this stage of his career. Like, guys, I mean, considering how much they've put on him over the years, this is usually when tight ends would start declining. And he really hasn't, at least when he's been on the field.
29:10Ollie Connolly:Yeah, the decline with him is just, is he on the field or not? If he's on the field, he's one of the five, six most valuable offensive players in the league. It's just whether he stays healthy or not. And it's been awesome to see McBride kind of sustain his gains and continue to improve. That's one of the hardest things to do as a pro. And it's what puts you in Canton right now. And it's crazy to think about. But Faye McBride is very young. But this is what Hall of Fame tight end careers look like early in their careers. That's the type of start that McBride has had. Let's take a break. We're going to come back.
29:43We're going to talk line play. We're going to talk defense. And we're going to talk linebackers, which are just Olly Connelly's favorite people on Earth.
30:12or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tremphaya, proper training is required.
30:23Ollie Connolly:Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions and increased risk of infections and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or if you need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremphia today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit TremphiaRadio.com. Lowe's knows Sundays are for football. So tackle your home improvement projects by Saturday and earn your Sunday with great deals on LG and Bosch appliances, select Bounty and Swiffer cleaning products, and more.
31:10Ollie Connolly:Then once your to-do list is done, get ready to kick back, relax, and enjoy the game. Shop in-store or online now and earn your Sunday with help from Lowe's, official partner of the NFL. March is here and Uber Eats is delivering deals all month long. Score big savings on all the delicious food you need to fuel your sports fandom. Whether you're ordering in or hosting the whole crew, Uber Eats is serving up deals on wings, burgers, pizza, all from your favorite restaurants, plus snacks from top stores. Perennial powerhouse, underdog. However the madness unfolds, these deals keep it going all month long.
31:46Visit the Uber Eats app for all the latest deals and start saving today. You know how it's never really about where you're going? It's about who you're going with. Like destination could be totally average, but if the right people are there, it becomes a great memory. Toyota really gets that. Toyota designs vehicles around real life and real people. The ones who bring everyone together and somehow make the drive part of the fun. There's room for all the stuff that comes with togetherness. Luggage, golf clubs, camping gear, plus comfortable seating, smart layouts, and space that lets everyone relax.
32:20And Toyota's lineup makes it easy to find your match. The RAV4 is perfect for everyday adventures. The Grand Highlander brings serious space for up to eight with generous legroom and expansive cargo space. The Highlander also has space for up to eight. It's ready for big moments and spontaneous ones, balancing style and flexibility. And the Sienna is built for everyday life, carpools, road trips, snacks, spills, and it even has a built-in vacuum for when things get a little too messy. Because when people are the destination, your ride is important. Learn more at toyota.com and find the vehicle that fits your people.
32:58Ollie Connolly:Hey, it's Carissa Thompson. and everything these days is fighting for your attention, work, family, social media, and it makes it tough to figure out what should really come first. But here's something that absolutely deserves to be at the top of your list, your breast health. Breast cancer is the second most common cancer and the second leading cause of cancer death among women in the United States. And the rates are still rising. More women under 50 are being diagnosed too. But here's a stat that really hits home. One in two women who qualify for annual breast screening aren't getting them. That's half.
33:31Ollie Connolly:And yet when breast cancer is caught early, the survival rate is over 99%, nearly 100 % for stage one before it spreads. If you're 40 or older, you should be getting screened every year. And if you're under 40, it is never too early to understand your risk. So come on now, pay the girls some attention, head to yourattentionplease.com to learn your breast cancer risk and what screenings you might need. Trust me, your future self will thank you. Brought to you by Novartis. Back on NFL Daily. The new year. Think about what you've learned over the last year. Maybe in a career, Ollie, you've got to know your strengths and your weaknesses.
34:16And I'm sick of pretending I have super hot takes on offensive line at this point. I really do want to dive more into the all 22 and going back over this season when we get to the offseason. But with this blur of the season, and I watch all the games as quickly as I can and stuff, it's like I have general feelings about who's played well on the offensive line. But I'm going to lean on you and your picks because I'm curious. These will be fresh to me. And it is a lot of the same names that you would think at tackle, I think would pop up. Like Trent Williams started off the season poor, but by the end of the season, he just seemed like Trent Williams again.
34:57which is hard to ever leave off. Same thing with Tristan Wirfs after an early start. Like, you know, wasn't healthy, but then he was very much Tristan Wirfs. Garrett Bowles is a guy maybe that stood out to me that had a really good year, but I'm curious where you went for tackle.
35:12Ollie Connolly:I appreciate your humility. You could do the traditional voter thing of just pull up PFF and treat it as gospel and file your ballot, which I think is what most people do. I went with Bowles and Tristan Wirfs as my starting tackles. Well, so then I didn't, who needs you anyways? I nailed it. Oh, wait, so that's over Panay Sewell this year. And why, okay, why would that be? Sewell has had now back-to-back seasons where in pass pro, he just isn't the caliber of play. He leaps off the screen so much in the run game, particularly when they feature him, when he's a puller and a mover in space. He's so clearly at head and shoulders above everyone else in the league as a mover in space.
35:44Ollie Connolly:But he just has so many major Ls in pass pro when it's straight one-on-one. The other guys get caught up when there's some kind of two-on-one conflict. You put two guys over, then they got to figure it out. It becomes more about the protection plan And then just those guys are straight up pass pro players. Soldus has more losses in straight one-on-one pass pro than the other top guys in the league. No, if I actually had a vote, and not that voters are listening to this show, maybe a few. You know, I would, that's, those are the positions, and I would try to do this with all the positions to some degree, but where I would just talk to people inside the teams who have been game planning and preparing and watching and who's giving you the most, like all that sort of stuff versus, yeah, checking PFF.
36:25Or asking people like me.
36:25Ollie Connolly:See, that is difficult, though, because Penny Sewell is when you have to game plan for, whereas I don't think you go in worried about Garrett Bowles. You just can't get past the guy for the entire season. He's gotten, yeah, what has stood out to you about him as he's gotten older in his career? Because he does seem like someone who, his development arc has been really fascinating, but now he's at the point where, yeah, he might be the best pass protector in the entire league. Yeah, and he's not as flashy as the other guys. Trent is obviously more flashier and has more of a size speed combination doing than Garrett Bowles is even at his size.
37:00Ollie Connolly:What he has going for him is he's in the best protection based unit in the entire league. Sean Payton is just the best at devising protection plans. The interior is outstanding, but he gets isolated a lot one on one on his own to one side of the formation. And he's just never wrong. And that is the job ultimately at the end of the day is just stay in front of the blocker. It doesn't have to be as flashy as everyone else when you've got to be aggressive and engage early against someone. He does that stuff when you got to sit back and play more patient football. He can do that, too. So he can just play in a varied number of ways.
37:27Ollie Connolly:And he just doesn't let guys past him, which is ultimately the job. Yeah. He's been that dude, too. When you when you hear from people that are around the Denver Broncos, like he is maybe the biggest leader on that team. He is kind of Mr. Denver Broncos, certainly for the offense. So yes, Garrett Bowles, Denver Broncos, Tristan Wirfs, of course, a left tackle now of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. And he's just someone that I don't think you need to have as great an eye for offensive line play when it comes to him. When I watch Tristan Wirfs, I just think like, oh yeah, that's exactly what you want in a left tackle.
38:06That's kind of teach tape. That's athleticism. It's everything that you want. And I know he just missed week 17 for the Bucs. He missed a couple games early, but ultimately he hasn't missed that much of the season. It sounds like he will be back on Saturday for the Buccaneers for what could be Gene Deckerhoff's final game. But we won't know. Big news breaking on, what was it, Wednesday here. But yeah, what stands out for you for Tristan Wirfs?
38:33Ollie Connolly:Wirfs is just the combination of intellect and size and speed. It just should not be allowed to be in one package. You'd have to take one of those out to make it a fair fight for everyone else. In the run game, everything is on the menu. he can kill people on the backside to have people pull around him he can pull into space himself opens up the screen game for them entirely so he is truly like in that bucket of penny sewell where it's he's a weapon offensive line which is so rare to find a tackle spot because you're so worried about pass pro it's hard to make that guy be a featured weapon he can do that stuff and then he just also doesn't make any errors or mental mistakes in pass pro whereas with sewell you get more of those breakdowns yeah and like it's one thing when they're missing their guards it's another thing like last week you could really see it when they're missing Tristan Wurfs I think that was a big reason why they lost that game against the Dolphins all right who are your choices give me give me the players and the teams for the interior offensive line I'm handing this one over to Ollie Connelly okay we'll start at God we'll go with Joe Tooney from the Bears at God and we'll go with Quinn Minots the God from the Denver Broncos okay so you think that Quinn Miners who I know you have loved his development has kind of kept up his run blocking more than anything as like the definitive run blocker in the NFL right now he is definitely the definitive run blocking NFL just one on head of man-to-man football in the trenches he controls big human beings better than anyone else in the league and I actually think the separation with him to every other line position the season is the biggest gap we have the biggest goal if you can make a case for different right tackles different left tackles he is like streaks ahead I think of every other guard in the league because now he's added so much more balance and fleet footedness in pass pro where he used to not lose the initial phase of the rep but his guys would throw moves at him he would kind of get lost and confused now he just doesn't let anyone buy him for entire stretches and then he is an absolute mauler in the run game he moves the pile individually more than any other player in the league so when you combine those two things together you get the all-around guard that you need not quite the overall skill set as some of maybe the most explosive guards in the league but for what he's asked to do he's doing a complete you know maximum capacity and there's no one else i I see the league doing it quite at that level as consistently week to week.
40:38And you got to give Ryan Poles, or maybe it's Ben Johnson really pulling the strings, but ultimately the Bears executing that trade for Joe Tooney. And you think about all the different reasons why the Chiefs fell apart this year. Trading Joe Tooney and giving Trey Smith all that money, it would have been part of it. I get it in terms of age, but it's interesting to me that you think he ultimately, even though there's a gulf between minors and the rest of the guards deserves that spot as kind of the guy who helped ignite a running game and really a transformation on that offensive line, which really came, especially after the bye week, Joe Tooney getting it done, possibly got to make the speaking of the hall of fame, like him doing it now for another team, I think is going to be a big feather in his cap one day when, when they're talking about him for
41:30Ollie Connolly:canton too yeah and a bit of a mea culpa pick for me i like to do that with these teams when i just get takes wrong to open the season i reward the people for myself being wrong um i i thought that was a a reasonable trade i thought he really backslid last season was kind of getting through on some of the the name brand value looking at how he's played this season i wonder if he was fully healthy at the end there with the chiefs not just when he was forced to play out a tackle which he couldn't play in space like that he just has such a beautiful like old man vet savvy game in pass pro particularly gets away with all kinds of dirty deeds inside to just end the rep as quickly as possible then you mentioned the run game stuff no one is more sound and assignment based than joe tweeting the run game he has a i would say an easier assignment down to down someone like quentin nelson it's so double team based he's getting an awful lot of help but he's just been as clean as anything throughout the season i i love also that you're going so hard in the paint for minors because i don't think his his pff grade is incredible because they knock them uh uh for pass pro and so uh we're planting our flag here all pro first team Quinn Miners by by a lot who's your center uh for the all pro team Aaron Brewer from the Dolphins has to be we we've given him a lot of pop this year he was on our all underrated team and uh I do think that one has sort of caught uh fire on in terms of the cognoscente not necessarily from here but I do think people are recognizing Aaron Brewer, Miami Dolphins.
42:54A lot went wrong for the Miami Dolphins this year, but the development, not just of Aaron Brewer becoming an all-pro type player at center, but the development of Patrick Paul at left tackle was definitely a positive, although I feel like he's had some up and down games lately, but overall he's been good at left tackle. Not an all-pro though. Aaron Brewer is. We got to get to defense. We spent a lot of time on offense. Let's go to edge annually is the deepest position feels unfair that there's only two edge players it's like you almost want to find a spot for everyone else I guess we got to go top down because in the end as deep as it is maybe I'm wrong but I actually didn't have that hard a time with my first team I think it is Myles Garrett and Will Anderson am I crazy oh well you say Will Anderson I think Myles Garrett and Micah Parsons.
43:46I think. OK, I mean, he was my solid number three. And so that was my thing was I figured if Micah had stayed throughout and maybe I'm knocking him too much for the injury that it's it's Garrett and Micah and Will's a nice like kind of third. But because of the injury, I just bumped up Will and moved Micah Parsons down, I guess make the case for why missing how many games is it now for Micah Parsons uh isn't that big of a deal because yeah when he was on the field I think it's pretty clear one and two uh him and Garrett
44:22Ollie Connolly:I think it's perfectly valid to have Will Anderson ahead of him um I would say that they've been comparable production wise there's a slight added benefit of the defense one plays on versus the defense to the place for where Mike was like was the entire engine that made the thing run when he comes off the field you see what that really looks like when Jeff Halfley's left to his own devices without maybe the most dominant pass rusher in all of football. I just think with Garrett and Parsons, these are the two Hall of Famers at the peak of their powers and everything else is kind of overthinking it.
44:49Ollie Connolly:I adore Will Anderson. I love him so much. He is as technically sound as any edge defender we have in all of football. He is a dominant one-on-one pass rusher. He is as good at run defending as any player in the league. So putting him there would be no shame. And if he's played more games, I think it's entirely justified. I just think Parsons and Garrett have been as good as you could ever hope a pass rusher to be. I just put them there. Yeah, and I hate, and I do kind of like putting Parsons in some way on the first team because it pushes back against just some of the light grumbling over the year.
45:22During the season, it was like, was he worth the trade? Or Cowboys fans or even Bears fans trying to say, because the sack production wasn't there early, although it got there in the end anyways, that he somehow wasn't Micah Parsons But in that, he didn't make a massive impact on their run defense, which I think you've seen over the last couple of weeks. So ultimately, he plays 14 games, and Anderson will play 17. It's not that huge a difference. Parsons was a little limited on his snap count early. I don't know. I kind of like rewarding just total greatness. You maybe have convinced me to just go Myles Garrett and Micah Parsons still as a first team because years from now, I'll just want to see that extra all-team, all-pro first team.
46:07Not that my vote actually counts. All right, let's put Micah and Miles Garrett as the first team. And anyone listening will know that I have Will Anderson as a very solid 1B, number three. The hard part, I guess, is going number four. I'll throw out some names. Nick Bonino is certainly in there. One of the things I like about him, which I, I mean, I like a lot of things about him, but his time to pressure just stands out compared to the rest of the league, where that matches what your eyes are, that when he gets the pressures, it's not the same as the other pressures because he's there and the play is just ruined.
46:48Even compared to Miles Garrett and Parsons, when he gets there, it's there right of the way. Aiden Hutchinson, I think, fell off a little bit down the stretch, but still an outstanding season. I think Josh Hines-Allen had a great season and closed very strong. on Daniil Hunter and Byron Young. If you're going to like a third team, are players worth mentioning at least? Is there anyone I'm forgetting there? And where are you leaning for that last spot?
47:15Ollie Connolly:Jared Verse, I would throw in there as well. I think that it came down to me, really difficult to pick between all those guys. It came down between Benito, Josh Heinz, Allen, and Hutchinson, which is again, is a three-man shortlist for one spot. It's just really difficult to pick those guys apart. I would maybe lean Hutchinson, but I think the impulse of Benito is probably, as I think about it, more the right one. He was my, you know, and that was my list. In order, Benito, Hutch, Hines-Allen as the next three. It sucks because this is where I wish there was, and you have a third team so you can give a third team, but I just wish there was an extra spot for edge.
47:52I just feel like they deserve it more than like a second safety or off-ball linebacker.
47:56Ollie Connolly:It is difficult because you want to reward the players who you feel don't get enough publicity for being excellent. Josh Hyans Allen is so unbelievably dominant. And I don't think many people even know who he is at this stage of his career. But it just so happens that Myles Garrett and Mike Barnes are famous because they are just the best at what they do. So what can you think about that? And Benito this year, he's had a couple quieter games in December. But overall, that is where I'm leaning. Even though Hutchinson, first half of the season, would have been on my second team. I'm going Nick Benito.
48:26Also because I'm afraid of him because he tweeted negative things about me. defensive tackle maybe you said guard was the biggest gap from one to two could I could I argue that Jeffrey Simmons the gap at defensive tackle maybe the from one to two maybe not an overall play but just in terms of I feel like he obviously to me has to go on the all pro team and then the other spot I wasn't really sure about is there do you think there is that big of a gap or is Jeffrey Simmons, for all the big play, he sometimes is not a big play merchant, but his great snap, his 20 best snaps are the best 20 snaps of any defensive lineman.
49:07Whereas down-to-down consistency, maybe you can convince me that other defensive tackles are in the mix there too.
49:13Ollie Connolly:No, I still think his down-to-down consistency is outstanding, frankly. His average time to pressure the season is 2.58 seconds. That is by far the biggest gap of any interior defensive lineman. it's almost half a second quicker than everyone else in the league over than christian barmore who plays real snaps um so he it just shows how quick and dominant he is off the ball the other guy i had in the first team who i think is just having one of the most underrated seasons we've had in a long time is cam haywood with the steelers yeah for him to still be doing it at the level he is at this stage of his career playing hundreds of snaps more than the other guys on the list who are 10 12 13 years younger than him is one of the wildest things i've ever seen he is still the fulcrum of the defense without him the entire thing collapses you watch the steals against the Browns and it's just him and Highsmith trying to make up for everyone else losing their mind every the plane being in the wrong spot I think he has been so so dominant and to do it at this stage of his career I think it's pretty close with him and Simmons there may be a slight gap to to the second team so that my I had Simmons kind of by himself and then yeah I had Hayward and it was just a list, but this was the order, rough order.
50:17Hayward, our guy, Kobe Turner on the all underrated team, we could give him even more love, had him in the mix. Leonard Williams is still Leonard Williams and playing well, having a good season. Zach Allen has like the splash production. Give a little love to Jordan Davis and Vita Veya, maybe if you're getting further down. But ultimately, I think we parked our car in the same garage, which is cam hayward i don't know if there's anyone on a long list that you just uh want to give love or if any of those names stood out to you but just the fact they even wrote down jordan davis on a
50:49Ollie Connolly:long list was fun i think on that second team for me it was the two seattle guys i think leonard williams and byron murphy are comfortably the the number two guys think murphy's intelligence is one of the most jarring things i've seen in a young play come into the league at that position when he has all the physical capabilities of someone like a jalen cards the size weight speed phenom that's all in there he's just so far ahead of guys uh where he's at in his career in terms of his development addressing blocks taking on blocks double team single stuff it's just freaky to watch him play at the moment so that could maybe be something where by the end of next season it's like oh this is the guy we were looking for jalen cards to be a down-to-down absolute destroyer it's actually byron murphy but that has happened over the course of the final 10 weeks of the season and leonard williams if you think of his career play playing you know for those two new York teams and he still is getting a little lost in the shuffle in Seattle just because there's so many good players there there's like another world where I just feel like he would have been more recognized consistently throughout his career and will would have a better Canton case in in the end where right now I just knowing how these things go I don't think he's gonna get seriously uh you know considered because he's always like the the fourth best interior defensive line which is an incredible thing to do for 10 straight years and is probably worthy of that and now he's fallen into this spot where you get with like the the march madness tournament where it's like the coach and them boys is like how people describe teams in march madness it's like well mike mcdonald is the guru so the defense is good because mike mcdonald is there and then you rattle off maybe five six players and maybe he's the fourth or fifth player in the list that thing does not roll without Leonard Williams, in my mind.
52:29Ollie Connolly:He would need, I don't know, like a Super Bowl MVP with a strip sack fumble, I think, to actually wind up, you know, getting the case. That is not off the table this season, I guess. But he's unfortunate in the sense that I think that by next season, he won't even be the best interior defensive lineman on his own team, even though he's one of the five best in the league. He's never made All-Pro. That's crazy. I thought he did last year because there was like a little bit of like Leonard Williams defensive player of the year buzz, and he did get 14th place in defense player of the year. So not a lot of buzz, but only a couple of Pro Bowls, like was almost defensive rookie of the year.
53:04Just the guy that, yes, is not created by Mike McDonald because he's been the same guy basically his whole career. Let's go to the linebackers. This is your favorite position. I don't know if it was obvious. I feel like who stood out to me the most this year when he's on the field, it was Devin Lloyd. so I'm not going to knock him for his injured weeks and then I I think it's running back Zach Bond for me do you want to make a case for anyone else on the first team no those two I think are
53:36Ollie Connolly:the correct answers you get more of the splash plays with Devin Lloyd Bourne gives you some splash plays he's the best all-around linebacker in the league when Fred Warren is not healthy and playing so Bourne is the obvious one then I think it's Lloyd but it's a pretty small margin for me to the second team where I had Aziz Alshair who I still think is understated for how good of just a player he is because he's more of like a brand as being like this absolute freakazoid on the field trying to decapitate everyone in his line of sight then my other second team guy was devin bush who we've always the cognoscenti you mentioned talked about carson swestri throughout the season who's had a sensational rookie season i think is the defensive rookie of the year but overlook just how excellent down-to-down devin bush beside him yeah wow what a what a career arc and uh i was afraid i mean he he shows up every week including that he was great in that stealers came last week um i first of all we agree too much i purposely didn't listen to your show just to you know have my own things but i guess that's good that we're agreeing a lot i had i had lloyd and bond and then i had jordan brooks and al shayir jordan brooks to me just he is from that position what i want is someone i see every single week like making a real impact and is consistent so maybe i'm overrating him slightly but i had him in in al shayir and uh that was that That was my second team, but a nice season for Jordan Brooks, too, coming from Seattle and going to Miami.
54:56Ollie Connolly:I think a little bit of inflated production with Jordan Brooks. When the defensive line is getting bench-pressed into your lap, you really do rack up the tackle numbers. It makes people inflate actually how well you play. Devin Bush hasn't been fortunate with that because defensive line is completely dominant. You can't just kind of play sift and find football. So I would have Bush pretty comfortably ahead of Jordan Brooks, but he has had a good season. Yeah, and Jordan, you know, Devin Bush with the Browns, we should point out. I mean, he was basically viewed as a first round bust, has been bouncing around the NFL since then.
55:28So it's cool to see him develop like this. But yeah, Bond. And I feel like I'm forgetting one other person at linebacker, but I don't know who it is.
55:36Ollie Connolly:But you could throw in Demario Davis, who has been unbelievable at this phase of his career. You could throw in Edge Cooper. You could throw in Nate Landman, Divine Diablo. That would be kind of long list. But I think there's a pretty clear separation. Just because of the impact in production with Lloyd, with the pass deflections, all the interceptions obviously he's had game-breaking plays and has been good enough down to down where the other guys have been probably just as good down to down but haven't quite had the game-breaking plays okay we're we're to the secondary and you sent me a video of Kamari Lassiter before we started uh upon the threat of um like physical harm that if I did not put Kamari Lassiter on the first team you would get on a plane and come after me and so So I guess we got to do it.
56:20So, yeah, if you're watching on YouTube, you can put together or watch a video that Ali lovingly put together. And I felt good about putting him on the first team. Let's just start with him before we get to maybe who else would be there. Why is Lasseter your guy?
56:35Ollie Connolly:He just looks everything like an all-pro corner show like in 2025, which is in-out versatility, the tights, the formation, playing on the boundary, all the run defense stuff. He is by far the best perimeter run defender in the league now. And in a league that includes Quinone Mitchell and some really good attack the run type cornerbacks, he's just leaps and bounds ahead of everyone else. Then in coverage, he does every single thing you want to. Textbook technique where it's bump and run, picking guys up on the fly, play more off coverage. And he's doing this in a defense with no bells and whistles.
57:03Ollie Connolly:They are declaring what they're going to run before the snap every single time. He's opposite Derek Stingley. So, you know, he's going to get targeted more. He's like, what, in the top 10 in targets this season. People know they got to go after him. Stingley freelances a whole bunch. Lassiter just placed his assignment and is perfect basically every single snap and you see the impact when he goes off the field with the knee injury against the Chargers the first thing the Chargers do say we got to go hunt the new fish Lassiter's off the field they hit a 60 yard shot right down the field because they know that Lassiter's no longer there just to me he is by technique the best all-around corner in the league this season in part because Pat Zetan has dealt with some health stuff he's not moved quite as fluidly for stretches of the season whereas Lassiter has been able to do that I just think he is as like coaching goes and what do I want a cornerback to look like, both attacking the run game and playing in coverage.
57:47Ollie Connolly:He's had the best all-around season of everyone. I love that, and I love a complete physical corner who also just moves as fluidly as he does. He is an awesome player. So he is part of our first team. So you mentioned Sertan, who has had great moments this year, had the injury, and it seemed to affect him for a little bit. The All-Pro team does give three cornerbacks because they kind of reserve a spot for a slot, which I don't think you have to make it into a slot unless one is obvious. But Cooper DeGene is certainly a good option to put there if you wanted to. You mentioned Quinjan Mitchell.
58:28You mentioned Stingley. I think those are some of the best options there for the first team. I was leaning... I was probably leaning Quinone and Dijin, but I don't know. Where are you looking?
58:48Ollie Connolly:I think Dijin, if you're just having a set nickel spot, you go with Dijin, and that is really tight because then you can bring in Petrie, you can bring in Brian Branch. It gets pretty squirrely. I think I want Petrie on either my second team or he's at safety. It gets a little confusing, yes. Yeah, but I would go with Dijin at nickel. The second cornerback spot, if you're just saying perimeter, outside boundary corner, That is really tight. I went with Stingley. I like the playmaking upside with Stingley. I like rewarding the Texans for having, I think, the best back seven in recent times. They are the best defense in the NFL playing, as I said, head up, straight up.
59:20Ollie Connolly:You know what we're doing in football. Everyone else is running all these confusing systems and schemes, and they say, no, we run exactly what we run. Every other down, you know what's happening, and we lock people down because our corners are so dominant. And so I wanted to put Laster and Stingley on the team together. And some of Stingley's coverage numbers in terms of just, you know, people not throwing at them, and when they do throw at them, they are just absolutely outrageous. I do like making a statement that it's this epic, historic secondary. Caden Bullock isn't that crazy of a guy to think about for a first or second team at safety, but there is a world where we put Stingley on the first team and then we put Petrie at safety and you have three Texans defensive backs on the first team all pro.
1:00:05Are you comfortable with that? because I think Petrie is where I would go as my safety. If that was the case, then taking care of the cornerbacks, I think I'm putting Quinian on the second team. Let's wrap the cornerback discussion because I think that's where I'm ready to go along with you there, that I would put Quinian on the second team. And then there's some other interesting names. DJ Turner is not a crazy name. I don't think Christian Bedford is not a crazy name. Jamel Dean had his moments this year maybe doesn't get across the finish line here I love me some Jordan Lewis like if I'm making a third I don't know if he quite makes the second team here but if we're allowed to reward six cornerbacks basically we'd have the two Texans and Dejean on the first team I think man I guess then you gotta go Sertan and Quinian tell me your thought process going through the second team
1:01:05Ollie Connolly:yeah so Tan has to be on the best corner i've studied since daryl revis and as long as he's alive and healthy he's making my team every single year i just pencil him in there and he's had a good season it's not exactly like he's been surpassed i think this year right of the guys the one that is difficult to leave off if you take it down to three i think is christian bentford then kind of changing midstream and saying we have no pass rush and no way to stop the run the only thing we can do is fire christian bentford into the line of scrimmage as often as possible to fix everything for us and it actually worked for a time people see the first fumble against Joe Burrow and the game against the Bengals where he made a whole bunch of plays but that was just their recipe down the stretch of the season it's like the only thing that can save us is more Benford and so if I see a defensive staff decide to do that with a defensive head coach tells me they believe the guys won the best in the league all right I and I think he was right on the border and so that means the second team for me, I'm not putting Petrie there, at cornerback would be Quinion Mitchell, Christian Benford, and Pat Sertan, which is an outrageous second team at cornerback.
1:02:09And so that's our second team. And then I'm bumping Petrie back to safety because I wasn't sure where else to go at safety other than him and Kyle Hamilton. There's certainly other options like Caden Bullock. Who else stands out are you okay with petrie and hamilton as your safeties i'm okay with all things
1:02:28Ollie Connolly:i would have petrie's the mvp if the you know the league would allow it if it wasn't just a quarterback if i don't have children if i had children i'd have a hard time loving them more than i love jalen petrie i just think he's i mean you're similarly aged you're a young man uh so maybe maybe a brother would make more sense yes um go and look at the on-off splits which is tricky with football compared to the nba or something like that but the on-off splits with jalen petrie are so profound for a team we know is loaded with talent. You just put two corners on the first team all pro. You talked about Bud and Will Anderson on the first team all pro.
1:02:58Ollie Connolly:It is dramatic night and day difference from being historically one of the greatest defenses in the history of the league to really, really good when Jalen Petrie is on the field or off the field in every single facet of the game, run game, pass game, everything. So I think it's difficult to not have Jalen Petrie on there. If you don't put him at nickel, you've got to put him back there at safety. Other people are doing James, I think has been unbelievable this season in a redefined role. has to play more of a blitzer close to the line of scrimmage has answered that bell so he's the other tight one but if you're into a one-off head-to-head I can't book Derwin James ahead of Kyle Hamilton yeah that's I he was the next guy I wrote down Derwin I mean it's really picking nits because he's been incredible there was like a three-week stretch where that defense didn't seem like they knew what they were doing and he was a part of it but the rest of the season he's been like a new I wouldn't even say peak Derwin James because it's like a new Derwin James and an incredible career.
1:03:48He's going to have an interesting case for Canton someday. So if we're doing a second team, he can go there. But let's go Hamilton and Petrie on the first team. And then Quentin Lake was having a great season. Xavier McKinney's still a good player and is in the mix. Antoine Winfield, I think, rebounded this year. Kevin Byard's still making plays at his age. But I feel good about our first second team.
1:04:10Ollie Connolly:The other guy I would throw in there is Telenoa Hufanga, who, again, another Meo Cup one from me, aware. I thought he was completely cooked in San Francisco and had gone from underrated to grossly overrated because he flies around and has the hair. People could just see him on the field and thought he was outstanding. And I just thought his legs had gone by the time they got him to Denver. And Denver hired Jim Lend from Wisconsin this offseason to get more of the safety involved in attacking the line of scrimmage. And he has returned and played at a level, I think, even better than he was in San Francisco.
1:04:38Ollie Connolly:You go and look at some of the run stop numbers, the run stuff numbers. He's just all over the field at all times. And they've changed their entire pass for a structure over a couple of seasons from the all-out crazy wonky blitz stuff to more of a four down rush because they've got nick benito and this season a five-man pass rush because they tagged talanoa hafanga into the thing and he's played at a crazy level so i think him and derwin for me is is pretty tight we need to write these downs etch them in stone i want to get it onto the pff site that our all pro team also gets there and i want them to recognize kaimi fairbairn too is my all pro kicker.
1:05:12I don't know if you went all pro kicker, but I love me some Kayemi. You can go in a few spots. The kicker position has never been better, but I'm going Kayemi-Fairbairn.
1:05:20Ollie Connolly:Why not? And Chimiri DK for all pro returner, getting a rookie to do that. Yeah, it kind of snuck up on me that he set the all purpose record, which is like a weird stat, but because he was, you know, punt returner, kick returner, and also getting it done as a receiver. Yes, he would be the all-pro returner this year. What a sneaky good rookie class by the Titans. They just got to build on that and find a coach other than Mike McCoy. As we got to the end of the season, I was like, what was the point of hiring, I mean, of firing Callahan and Dable so early? Like, yeah, I guess they were worth getting, but there was no point to it.
1:06:05It just got worse.
1:06:06Ollie Connolly:Whenever you can get a head start on interviewing Matt Nagy, It's got to be done. You just got to do it. Like at the time, I wasn't questioning it. And then, and I get it. You just feel like you need to get like some, some satisfaction and make the fans happy. But then the rest of the season was pointless and your quarterbacks probably were worse off for it. But that's, that's another podcast. We did it. We went longer than I expected, but I'm really glad we got our all pro team in. And like I mentioned, we'll, we'll do some awards talk next week, but we got big games to talk about this weekend.
1:06:37and then the playoffs, you're going to be along for the ride. Are you scouting these college football playoff games over there in the UK? I'm excited.
1:06:47Ollie Connolly:I am deep into them. The most loaded linebacker class we've had in a long, long time. On one team, we got two first-rounders. It's very, very exciting. Oh, I'm going to put you on the spot then. Give me like a non-quarterback. Give me a defensive player or two to watch this week specifically that's playing in these college football games that you like. You go to just watch the Ohio State defense. My boy, Matt Patricia, cooking everyone alive in college football. You watch Arvel Reese and Sonny Stiles, the linebackers from Ohio State. Arvel Reese, the most dominant player in the country, should be the second overall pick in the draft.
1:07:22Ollie Connolly:Probably won't be by the time the draft rolls around. Sonny Stiles should be a top 10 pick in the draft. CJ Allen with Georgia, another dominant linebacker. So we are truly rolling about six, seven, eight linebackers deep who should be worthy of first-round consideration in a pretty, I would say, weakish, mediocre top end of the first round this year. All right. Get you an analyst that can do both. We're going to be hitting the draft heavier than ever on NFL Daily this offseason with the help of Ollie Connelly and then on 40s and free agents with Daniel Jeremiah, which will be back weekly pretty soon.
1:07:53Before that, though, we will have our pick show in the speed on Friday. Cynthia and I unfortunately my 12 straight winning week streak came to an end because of the Atlanta freaking Falcons but we're going to get back on the winning side this week so that'll be on Friday before all the games this weekend we will see you then
1:08:22March is here and Uber Eats is delivering deals all month long score big savings on all the delicious food you need to fuel your sports fandom. Whether you're ordering in or hosting the whole crew, Uber Eats is serving up deals on wings, burgers, pizza, all from your favorite restaurants, plus snacks from top stores. Perennial powerhouse, underdog, however the madness unfolds, these deals keep it going all month long. Visit the Uber Eats app for all the latest deals and start saving today. You know how it's never really about where you're going. It's about who you're going with, the right people can turn any drive into a great memory.
1:08:58That's something Toyota really believes. They design vehicles around real life and real people, the ones who make plans happen and bring everyone together. Inside, everything's built with passengers in mind. Comfortable seating, smart layouts, and space that actually works so everyone can relax and enjoy the ride. There's room for the people, room for the stuff, and room for the moments that happen along the way. Because when people are the destination, your ride is important. Learn more at toyota.com and find the vehicle that fits your people.
1:09:31Ollie Connolly:Hey guys, it's Erin Andrews. Everything these days is fighting for your attention. We've got work, family, social media, making it tough to figure out what to prioritize. I got something that should always be at the very top of the list, your breast health. In fact, if you're 40 and over, you should be getting screened once a year. And if you're under 40, it's never too soon to visit yourattentionplease.com to learn about breast cancer risk. Come on now, pay the girls some attention and take the time to find out your breast cancer risk at yourattentionplease.com. Trust me, your future self will thank you.
1:10:07Ollie Connolly:Wasabi is purpose-built to free your business from skyrocketing storage costs and fees. Wasabi is the go-to provider for professional and collegiate sports teams around the world. Check out Wasabi's AI-enabled intelligent media storage, Wasabi Air, to the industry's only cloud storage service with triple protection against cyber criminals. Wasabi, driving innovation in data storage for up to 80 % less than market competition. Try for free at wasabi.com. Wasabi Hot Cloud Storage, proud partner of the iHeart Podcast Network. Lowe's knows Sundays are for football. So tackle your home improvement projects by Saturday and earn your Sunday with great deals on LG and Bosch appliances, select Bounty and Swiffer cleaning products and more.
1:10:51Ollie Connolly:Then once your to-do list is done, get ready to kick back, relax and enjoy the game. Shop in store or online now and earn your Sunday with help from Lowe's, official partner of the NFL. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
From the publisher
Gregg Rosenthal and Ollie Connolly make their selections for the 2025 NFL All-Pro teams starting with the offense and selecting the quarterback (01:30) followed by running back (06:20), wide receiver (14:50), tight end (24:30), and the offensive line (27:40). The show is wrapped up with the defensive side of the ball starting with the selection for EDGE (36:50) followed by defensive tackle (42:05), linebacker (46:45), cornerback (49:30) and safety (55:50).
Note: time codes approximate.
NFL Daily YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/nflpodcasts
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.




