40s and Free Agents: The AFC North's 5 Impact Additions and Rookies

15 Aug 2025 · 35 min · 16 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The AFC North’s five biggest veteran/free-agent impacts and five biggest rookie impacts, plus “wild card” players for the division.

Guests

Greg Rosenthal (host) and Daniel Jeremiah (NFL analyst; former NFL scout/coach, longtime draft evaluator).

Key claims

  • Ravens: Malachi Starks is a “Raven-type” leader with Ed Reed-like football intelligence; scheme fit for moving Kyle Hamilton closer to the ball. Jair Alexander is the key secondary addition if healthy.
  • Bengals: Demetrius Knight (older rookie linebacker) should start and pair with Logan Wilson to help a defense that was “atrocious” last year; concern is limited coverage ability.
  • Steelers: Aaron Rodgers at age 42 is the “big bet” for a highly productive season; Steelers’ defense should be better. Rookie Jack Sawyer fits a rugged Steelers identity; Jalen Ramsey’s versatility (nickel and safety) should create matchup advantages.
  • Browns: Kenny Pickett’s role is uncertain behind Joe Flacco; Browns’ long-term QB may be in next year’s draft.

Notable examples

  • Starks compared to Ed Reed; Knight praised for competitiveness (blocks after interceptions).
  • Sawyer’s playoff sack/forced fumble/scoop-score; Ramsey used in multiple defensive roles.
  • Steelers’ heavy 13-personnel usage; DK Metcalf expected to be used on slants/shorter shots.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Greg and Daniel Discuss AFC North

0:42 to 1:56

Hosts introduce themselves and start discussing the AFC North division.

“So tackle your home improvement projects by Saturday and earn your Sunday with great deals on LG and Bosch appliances.”

Malachi Starks: Ravens' First Round Pick

1:56 to 3:20

Discussion on Ravens' first-round pick Malachi Starks and his fit with the team.

“I'm Greg Rosenthal with my friend Daniel Jeremiah in the Chris Wesseling Podcast Studio talking a little AFC North today.”

Comparison of Starks and Ed Reed

3:20 to 5:15

Analyses similarities between Malachi Starks and Ed Reed's personalities and skills.

“Starks first round pick for the Ravens out of Georgia.”

Ravens' Offseason and Key Additions

5:15 to 8:00

Overview of the Ravens' offseason activities and key player additions.

“And it was, if the offense was on the field, you almost would go to the bathroom because it was, the defense was so fun to watch and not just like fun to watch defense.”

Demetrius Knight: Bengals' Second-Round Pick

8:00 to 9:50

Discussion on Bengals' second-round pick Demetrius Knight and his potential impact.

“I mean, they've got a bunch of receivers.”

Bengals' Defensive Needs and Challenges

9:50 to 11:17

Talk about the Bengals' defensive challenges and the importance of Knight's role.

“Let me give you one random scout thing on him.”

Aaron Rodgers and Steelers' Quarterback Situation

11:17 to 14:00

Examination of the Steelers' quarterback situation with Aaron Rodgers and its implications.

“And in the words of Dave Damaschek, don't, don't blame me.”

Analyzing Jack Sawyer's Fit with the Steelers

14:01 to 20:39

Discussion on Jack Sawyer's playing style and his potential impact with the Steelers.

“I talked about Malachi Starks as guys I thought were kind of built to be Baltimore Ravens.”

Analyzing Jack Sawyer's Fit with the Steelers

22:34 to 22:45

Discussion on Jack Sawyer's playing style and his potential impact with the Steelers.

“Klarna balance account required to be eligible for cashback points.”

DK Metcalf and His Role in the Offense

22:45 to 23:45

Analysis of DK Metcalf's potential impact in the new offense alongside Aaron Rodgers.

“Limitations, terms, and conditions apply.”
Show all 16 chapters

DK Metcalf and His Role in the Offense

23:48 to 28:00

Analysis of DK Metcalf's potential impact in the new offense alongside Aaron Rodgers.

“Back on 40s and free agents talking about the biggest pickups in the AFC North.”

Analyzing Draft Missteps

28:00 to 31:10

Discussion on the unexpected falls of DK Metcalf and A.J. Brown in the draft.

“By the way, going back to DK, he was 228 pounds coming out.”

Browns Quarterback Situation

31:10 to 35:58

Examining the dynamics of the Browns' quarterback roster and potential trades.

“So I haven't been impressed with his film.”

Bengals Offseason Overview

35:58 to 40:00

Reviewing the Bengals' offseason moves and current roster strengths and weaknesses.

“projecting out as the season goes along and keeping up with it week to week.”

Bengals Offseason Overview

40:26 to 40:56

Reviewing the Bengals' offseason moves and current roster strengths and weaknesses.

“AI can make a fake ticket offer look legit or a sportsbook text sound official.”

Bengals Offseason Overview

40:59 to 42:29

Reviewing the Bengals' offseason moves and current roster strengths and weaknesses.

“Some people use ChatGPT to answer questions.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. Scams don't always look like scams anymore. AI can make a fake ticket offer look legit or a sportsbook text sound official. And once an identity thief gets your personal information, they can start using your name like it belongs to them. And then what? LifeLock helps detect potential identity threats and suspicious activity. And if identity theft happens, LifeLock's restoration specialist can help restore your identity. guaranteed because only LifeLock truly protects your name and identity. Get LifeLock at LifeLock.com and use promo code FOOTBALL for up to 30 % off your first year.

0:39That's LifeLock.com, code FOOTBALL. Lowe's knows Sundays are for football. So tackle your home improvement projects by Saturday and earn your Sunday with great deals on LG and Bosch appliances. Select Ego, DeWalt, Phil Treat products and more. Then once your to-do list is done, get ready to kick back, relax, and enjoy the game. Shop in-store or online now and earn your Sunday with help from Lowe's, official partner of the NFL. Want to know you're on the best path to the right car? Start at CarMax, where every car is CarMax certified and backed by a 10-day money-back guarantee at a price that's up front from the start.

1:17Visit CarMax.com for details. Want to drive? CarMax.

1:55We are back on 40s and Free Agents. I'm Greg Rosenthal with my friend Daniel Jeremiah in the Chris Wesseling Podcast Studio talking a little AFC North today. The black and blue division. The division that one day, two decades ago, employed you with the Baltimore Ravens. Do you pay attention to them more now because you once worked for them? I also work for the Cleveland Browns, who happen to be in the same division. Good point. But, I mean, at least my co-host really does homework. I focus on the positive, you know. Hey, we had a 10-6 year. One year, 10-6. The next year, 4-12. Average it out. That actually is a feather in your cap that you...

2:35There aren't many 10-win seasons in the Cleveland Browns over the last 30 years. You literally were there and authored the best season of the Browns in the last two decades. And I started after the draft, which is the draft they took to Joe Thomas. and after free agency. So I literally had nothing to do with that 10 and 6 win team. Nobody would remember that. Yes, we're talking AFC North. And on my side of things, and if you're just joining us each episode, we go through the five biggest impacts in free agency, veteran additions, and the five biggest impacts in terms of rookies. And I got to say, there wasn't as many free agents outside of the Steelers.

3:12So I'm going to let you start in this division because I know there are a lot of good rookies. Okay, we'll get to some Steelers stuff here. but let's start with some of these other teams and let's start with Malachi Starks first round pick for the Ravens out of Georgia. There are guys that just feel like Ravens and having worked there, that's, you know, I was there when the whole play like a Raven thing started and that's a real deal. They know what their players look like and Malachi Starks. Now I'm not talking about it as a player. Now I'm going to talk about the, the person, the makeup, the character is very similar to the Ed Reed makeup and character.

3:41He is incredibly smart. He's the leader of the defense. He, he galvanizes guys, gets guys to go with him to watch tape all that stuff elite off the charts then you add into that the versatility is someone who can play the nickel who can play high i know in the run-up to the draft there was a you know there's a desire on the ravens uh side of things to be able to allow kyle hamilton to be closer to the ball so in order to do that you've got to get someone who can play in the middle of the field and that's exactly what malachi starks can do um so i think it's a great fit from a personality type uh for what they love as a player you know intelligence wise all those things.

4:16And then I think scheme wise, it's also a great fit. Is he similar personality wise to Ed Reed? Because I don't know Ed Reed well or at all. I have interviewed him once, but I've seen him in a lot of interviews. And I don't know if I've ever met another or seen another human I would say is similar to Ed Reed's personality type. He seems like a one-on-one. Well, I would say, yeah, from like a cigar hat beard combination that there's that version of Ed Reed. The way his mind goes too, but maybe football-wise. I'm talking football. Incredible football intelligence and awareness and smarts. And then it's more like the kind of magnetism that he has that can kind of control things.

4:57So that's what Ed did. Ed probably, and I don't know if Stark's like that, but Ed more verbal, like a little more demonstrative. And obviously with the success Ed had came the confidence and kind of the swagger that came along with it. I think you'll see Stark's. I know you like to keep things moving but you were there at the time I always thought did Ed Reed like did he get to be who he was because Ray Lewis like to me they were such a perfect marriage of like leadership types like those two guys together what was that like well first of all keep in mind we had Jamal Lewis as a 2000 yard rusher that year you had unbelievable offensive line you had Todd Heap you had some players on offense like real legit Pro Bowl players.

5:43And it was, if the offense was on the field, you almost would go to the bathroom because it was, the defense was so fun to watch and not just like fun to watch defense. Like we might have a better chance of scoring with Ed than maybe we would on offense because he was so prolific at taking the ball away. I wanted to look this up because while you're talking about him, this is getting off track here. But Ed Reed, you talked about, did the Ravens make him or he make the Ravens? Go back in college. I mean, his 2000, so his junior year, he had eight interceptions. His senior year, he had nine. He's always been that guy.

6:19Right. I guess I was thinking even less, yeah, just how incredible. When was the last time you saw a college kid with 17 picks in two years? They were just like a relationship that just seems like a perfect, like if they were like a couple that they balance each other out, like a podcast duo. They just balanced each other out. Well, they had the thing about them is they were both probably the two smartest football players I've ever been around. Okay, I don't know if Jair Alexander would be in that category, but if we're talking Ravens secondary, he is one of the non-stealers on my list, so I'm going to talk about it there.

6:49If you look at the Ravens offseason, they're really running it back. Had a good draft, did not add almost anything in free agency. They picked up DeAndre Hopkins on a flyer. He's going to be like a fourth. You know, I like that. Jair Alexander is the guy that they bring in every year, whether it was Ozzie Newsom back in your day or Eric DaCosta, where at the end of the season, you're like, wait, when did they get him? They got him in June, July. And how much are they paying him? Oh, they're only paying him$4 million. Meanwhile, it's the divisional round, and he's out there covering T. Higgins at a high level.

7:25And you're thinking, how did they get away with this again? That's obviously hoping that he can stay healthy. But for them, to me, he was the key addition for a secondary that has a chance to be really good around Kyle Hamilton. And they've done such a good job, as you mentioned, with these veteran type players. Think about Calais Campbell. I think about going back to the receiver position where it was Derek Mason one year, A 'Kwon Bolden another year. Like they've always kind of just found these veterans. And then I think, look, we'll see what they get. Justin Houston was one that played very well for them.

7:53They will go down that road. I mean, shoot, Deion Sanders at one point in time was one. So, I mean, they've always been able to get something out of veteran guys. And, you know, we'll see. Hopkins will be interesting too. I mean, they've got a bunch of receivers. We'll see what that looks like. When Jair Alexander plays, he matters. It's just about staying on the field. He's really never been on the field and not had a high-level play. And to me, it's just an intriguing pair there with Nate Wiggins going into his second year and Marlon Humphrey, a guy who's made a lot of Pro Bowls. So a fun secondary there.

8:20All right, give me another. All right, I'm going to go to Cincinnati. I'm going to go to the Bengals, and I'm going to go to their second-round pick, not their first-round pick. I'm going to go to Demetrius Knight, linebacker out of South Carolina. Again, middle of the field. We've talked about Ray Lewis a minute ago. You want somebody in there that's intelligent, that's smart, that can kind of be the control person for a defense. He can do that. He's not necessarily going to have to do all that right away in terms of all the responsibilities, but he is going to imagine he's going to start. He's going to play a lot and a chance to be an impactful player for a defense that was atrocious last year.

8:53So you bring a new defensive coordinator. We'll see what they can do with Al Golden, how different that looks than what they've been previously. But when you look linebacker wise, putting him and Logan Wilson together, two really, really smart guys. Fun tandem. And I think Demetrius Knight would be high on the list of rookies that their team needs to work. Yeah. Because he is starting. So I follow Paul Daner. He works for the athletics. I don't want to pretend I'm getting this information myself. And he says Knight has stepped in there. It's like a joke almost how mature he is. and he is an older rookie, but that everyone around him already is starting to look to him as a leader.

9:35And some of his veteran teammates jokingly like call him future captain and that he's really looked good on and off the field. They were happy with how he's been in training camp. And so he's someone, it's just got to work, I think, because I think he's going to be out there almost every snap. Let me give you one random scout thing on him. So one of the things in scouting I've always loved and I had an older scout that gave me this advice when I was young. He said, you want to talk about the competitiveness of a player. There's a couple of things you can look at. Number one, watch how they compete on a point after.

10:03Like that's a play where it's basically give up play. You can see the kick and you watch guys who rush hard on that. Usually shows you a little something. The other thing he said was watch teammates on interceptions, whether that's an offensive teammate trying to effort to make a tackle or whether that's a defensive teammate efforting to make a block. There's a game. There's a pick six in a South Carolina. I don't remember who it was against, but he has two knockdown, two pancakes blocks after a teammate picks off a ball. and I was like, okay, this guy's ultra, ultra competitive and that matches with the leadership that you're hearing about there in Cincinnati.

10:35It's a tough position though. That just worries me because everything... He's got the nerve center next to him. I think Logan Wilson can kind of be the nerve center initially and he can just play ball. The one thing, he's not great in coverage. That's the only concern I have. Yeah, I mean, who is? We did a show last week on NFL Daily with my friend Ollie Connelly. He's like, how many linebackers are excelling? and like everyone is targeting these guys. I mean, there are some, but it is the exception. I see one day on Henley can cover. That's one that it's the exception, not the rule. There's like six to eight guys.

11:06And that's why the conventional wisdom has been those linebackers take, you know, two, three years. So they're really at their best, but he's going to have to play right away. I don't have a Bengal in my top five. And in the words of Dave Damaschek, don't, don't blame me. I didn't do this to you. You did this to you. You just, you just don't have a lot of options. So let's go, Let's go to one of my Steelers. I mean, it's Aaron Rodgers. This is the bet. This is the big bet. That a guy for the second time in NFL history is going to have a highly productive season at the quarterback position at the age of 42.

11:42It's only happened with one player. And that man was Tom Brady. Now he did it another three years. So it's possible. It's another all-time great. And the reality is you had no other options because you didn't want to pay Justin Fields as much as the Jets. They tried on Sam Darnold and came up short. Yeah, that's what I mean. Very weird, too, because it's like they're treating quarterback like another position. They tried on Stafford. I have information on that. It just wasn't going to happen. They tried on Justin Fields. I think they gave him an offer that would have been a raise for him, but it wasn't as big as the one that the Jets gave.

12:15And, yeah, they tried a little on Darnold, too. And I don't think the tape was great last year. I don't know if you, like, broke it down, but to me the arm's still there and the mind is obviously there but the willingness to maybe stay in there and hold the ball and that just wasn't there for me at least so so let me just show on the other side of that because i agree there's not there's some things that are missing but if we just went numbers wise if with this stealer's defense that they have which i'm going to get into some pieces here in a second they've added and what they already possess if ryan rogers throws for almost 4 ,000 yards, completes 63 % of his passes, goes 28 and 11.

12:53I think they're going to win a lot of games just with that, what he was last year, which nowhere near what Aaron Rodgers has been. But even just last year's version that he was with the Jets with this Steelers defense, they're going to win double digit games. Probably. They made the playoffs with Russell Wilson and Justin Fields last year. That's what I'm saying. That's better than what they got last year. I don't think he was better than the combination of Russell Wilson and Justin Fields last year. And if he was, it was marginal because those numbers speak well for him. If you look at the success rate and the EPA per play, it's a lot of seven-yard gains on third and 11 and him just being very safe.

13:31And ultimately, a lot of those advanced metrics, he was more around 23rd, 24th among starters, which is about how he felt he played. Maybe that's a little bit of an upgrade, but this is the bet. He's got a chance. They have the pieces certainly on defense to get it done. So that's, again, that leads to my point, which is this defense is going to be better. I am DeMetrius Knight running down the field. There you go. There you go. Helping you out. Good teammate. This defense is going to be really good. And I'm going to go to the defensive side of the ball, and I'm going to go to the third round pick in Jack Sawyer.

14:01I talked about Malachi Starks as guys I thought were kind of built to be Baltimore Ravens. Jack Sawyer is out of the old school Pittsburgh Steelers playbook. He is a 265 pound edge setter, physical presence, kind of a no nonsense guy. He played big in the big moments. You think about that, that playoff game where he has the huge sack of Texas, right? He has the, the sack, forced fumble, scoop and score. Like he's, he's been big in big moments. He was kind of their leader. He's the one who lost his mind when he's getting planted the flag at Ohio State. Like he just, that's a stealer type. That's a pride, you know, like there's, there's guys that just kind of fit with what they do.

14:39And I think that was a theme. I don't think I know that was a theme of theirs, that they wanted to get back, have an edge. And Aaron's a little bit of that, right? Aaron Rodgers. Is he? He has an edge. He has an edge to him. He's not the nice. Like you would say, if we're going to go nice meter, I would put Justin Fields and Russell Wilson on another stratosphere in terms of how they would be viewed as like nice guy versus an edgy guy. You do hear reports of him absolutely staring down Roman Wilson when he's not running the right routes in training camp. That's your point. And then we add to that, okay, defensive line-wise, Derek Harmon in the first round, who's a big dude, physical presence.

15:16YA Black, who's, gosh, what, 330, 340 out of Iowa. They get him in the fifth round. You add Sawyer in there. Jalen Ramsey, who is a junkyard dog. I'm sure you're going to get to him in a second. But overall, you can see even DK Metcalf looks like a bully. You're just thinking of my picks. They have gone with a theme in the offseason, which was we're going to be the rugged, edgy Pittsburgh Steelers. And I think Jack Sawyer, getting back to where I started on this whole rant, is part of that process. It's been a great rant. And I love being able to talk to you about these draft picks because Jack Sawyer is a guy, and I wonder how much you pay attention to this, that I feel like the NFL draftniks out there, the internet dudes, for lack of a better word, without maybe the exact same platform, but very knowledgeable in their own right, doing a lot of work on the draft.

16:08I feel like they were out on Jack Sawyer. I feel like he was not a draft-nick guy. And ultimately, I guess the NFL kind of agreed. What pick? Agreed, because he ended up going in the fourth round. So maybe he's just a victim of, you know... He was the 123rd pick. Yeah, he's a well-known guy who fell a little bit in the draft. He was my 70th player. So you did like him. He is at a position. How would you answer? Because this is supposed to be most of the biggest impact. He is at a position. I would argue is as good as literally any position group at any position in the entire NFL. You have TJ Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Nick Herbig, who's been really good for them too.

16:45Yeah, it's a great foursome. I think they roll those guys through. And I think to me, it's going to be fascinating to see how him and Highsmith could pair up there. Because I think on some of those early downs, if you want Jack Sawyer to get out there on first, second down, let him get out there and make an impact against the run for sure. So that leads to my Jalen Ramsey pick, because I hope you're right. I hope they do rotate a little bit more. T.J. Watt never left the field last year. He never even left his side of the field. He just lining up the same side like a thousand snaps. And I'd like to see the guys moving around a little more, maybe use some of your depth a little more.

17:19And that is one thing I think Jalen Ramsey is going to allow you to do just an instinctive. athletic, versatile guy who in camp, you know, he's going to be their nickel. Everyone wants their own Cooper de Jeanne type of player. Well, how about the guy who was, you know, winning a Super Bowl, doing it for the Rams a few years ago? But it has interested me, I think for the first time in his career, they say when they're out there, just four defensive backs on the field, he's playing safety for them, which is new. And I do think Jalen Ramsey has one great year left in him. It just, he's one of those players.

17:54He reminds me a little bit of T.O. Every time T.O. showed up at a new spot, he would be a first ballot Hall of Famer for that first year there. Jalen Ramsey, I don't think his teammates love him. Everyone views him as a leader. So that's a difference. But his first season in new places has gone amazingly. And then for whatever reason, after a few years, it's like that team is ready to move on. I think Jalen Ramsey is ready to have that type of season. That was a rant. I think that is a good rant. Jalen Ramsey likes a challenge, and I think they have challenged him. They've challenged him by using him in all these different spots.

18:25And it's going to be matchup based. There's going to be games where he is going to live in the slot. And that's going to be where he's going to be a presence, not only in coverage, but someone who can force the run. You can blitz him. And there's going to be other games where he's literally going to be playing as the high safety and just kind of playing on top of that Christmas tree, as my buddy Bucky Brooks likes to say, where he can just kind of, you know, roam over the top and free him up, let his instincts play. But everything that I've got out of there has been off the charts in terms of the competitiveness that he's brought to practice.

18:52he's engaged and he's enjoying the challenge of, of the roles they're giving him. What a cool room there with Darius Slay, who I know he's not going to be the hall of fame or anything, but it's like one of my just favorite players and personalities over the last decade. And then you have Joey Porter, like Chuck Clark too. I mean, like they've got Elliot who played, I mean, if you look at it to Sean Elliot, there's some people in the league that would say, if you looked at him and make a Fitzpatrick last year and say who, who played better, they would lean towards Elliot. I think if you looked at the people in the Steelers organization, they would say Deshaun Elliott.

19:22People love them some Deshaun Elliott. That's a really interesting point about Bucky and the Christmas tree because if he's going to do that, Minka was extra. I think that could be an upgrade for them. Let's try to upgrade on our first few picks after this break. Do even better.

19:44Every player in the league has a scouting report. Strengths, weaknesses, history, tendencies, Everything an opponent wants to know. But what if somebody built a scouting report on you? Data brokers collect your personal stats, your name, address, phone number, family details, and other private information. Then they package it up and legally sell it to anyone willing to pay, sometimes just for pennies. And then what? The person buying your information may not be looking to draft you. They may be looking to scam you, steal your identity, and start using your name like it belongs to them. That's where LifeLock comes in.

20:17LifeLock's automatic data broker removal tool helps you find exposed personal information and remove it from those data brokers. If you fall victim to identity theft, LifeLock's restoration specialist will block and tackle for you, which means they'll handle your case from start to finish and restore your identity guaranteed. Because only LifeLock truly protects your name and your identity. So go get LifeLock at LifeLock.com and use promo code football for up to 30 % off your first year. That's lifelock.com code football. Again, lifelock.com code football. ChatGPT can do more than answer questions.

20:53It can help you get real work done. ChatGPT work is built for bigger projects with multiple steps. You bring the goal along with the information it needs, like briefs, notes, files, feedback, calendars, data sets, or project plans. Then ChatGPT can help turn all of that into something useful, An analysis, a tracker, a deck outline, a prototype, or a workflow you can keep shaping. It can also use approved apps, connected tools, files, and browser contexts to help move the work forward. And you stay in control. You give direction, review drafts, approve actions, redirect the work, and choose the final output.

21:33So you spend less time sorting through busy work and more time making progress on the work that matters. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode. Available on Plus and Pro plans. This is Becca and Tanya from Scrubbing In with Becca Tilly and Tanya Rad. Becca, can I ask you a question? How do I convince myself I need something before I buy it? Oh, so we're doing that today. Well, I'll be shopping online and suddenly I'm like, well, technically this counts as self-care. You're definitely not alone there. That's why Klarna stands out.

22:13It's about smarter tools that help you feel more confident with your money. Klarna brings payments, cashback, and money management together in one place with flexible ways to pay. It helps you make smarter money moves without the stress. That's the goal, right? Having tools that make your money work with you. Download the Klarna app today or visit Klarna.com to learn more. California resident loans made or arranged pursuant to a California finance law license. It's NMLS number 1353190. Klarna balance account required to be eligible for cashback points. Limitations, terms, and conditions apply.

22:47Amazon Health AI presents Painful Thoughts. Why did I search the internet for answers to my cold sore problem? Now I'm stuck down a rabbit hole filled with images of alarmingly graphic sores in various stages of ooze. I can clear my search history, but I can never unsee that. Don't go down the rabbit hole. Amazon Health AI gets you the right care fast. Health care just got less painful. Discover a spectacular island destination with crystal blue seas, endless sunshine, and the cool Bahamian breeze. Bahamar, located in Nassau, Bahamas, offers your choice of three luxury hotels, Over 45 fine dining and nightlife venues, John Batiste's all-new Jazz Club, the Caribbean's most luxurious casino, and one-of-a-kind experiences for the entire family.

Read the full transcript

23:39Like our 15-acre tropical water park, wildlife sanctuary, world-class golf course, and so much more. Visit Bahamar.com today.

23:51Back on 40s and free agents talking about the biggest pickups in the AFC North. and if there's Browns fans out there, Bengals fans, like, why didn't, you know, talk about us more? Well, little Browns coming, but the Steelers changed who they were this offseason. Suddenly they became the team that gave us a lot to talk about and they became an offseason team. And so I guess I'll go with DK. You mentioned it. Yeah. Earlier. So let's just talk DK. How do you think he fits with Aaron Rogers and this offense? Because it's a pretty, pretty big drop off, at least that wide receiver from one to two, what is that mix in an Arthur Smith, Aaron Rodgers, DK Metcalf offense?

24:33It's just, if you had told me that three years ago, like that is kind of a mind blowing combination of names that will be working together. Which is exactly why I'm going to give you the reason of, I have no idea what it's going to look like or how it's going to work. But I do know, you know, DK is going to be able to get vertical. And Aaron, to me, this offense is going to be a heavy, you know, 12 personnel team. I think you'll see them. John O. Smith, they love. So he's going to be out there on the field a lot. He didn't make your list there, I don't think. He did not. Maybe an oversight on your part.

25:04I mean, how many Steelers can I put in? I went with the big names. There's a lot of new pieces here. But with Friermuth and John O. Smith, I think they're in a lot of 12 personnel. I think they really want to run the ball. I also think you could see some 13 personnel, even when you've got a freaking monster human being. I've got a number for you on that. You know who ran the most 13 personnel of any team in the NFL last year? Who's that? Pittsburgh Steelers. There you go. I think it was over 10%. That's crazy. It's a third tackle. He's amazing. He's enormous. He might be the best tight end on this team overall.

25:33I think he has a real ceiling to do something. I'll go one better. Okay. I think he's the best tackle on our team. That's interesting. And I like, and I like, and I really like Fatanu, the right tackle, and we'll see what Broderick Jones can be. But just in terms of talent, he's got the frame to do it. If you're going to, if you want to earmark this for three years down the road, and we're talking about Jason Peters 2.0. It's this dude. Well, that gets to what I was saying and I wouldn't have the scouting chops. You know, I'm trying. I put my work in, but I wouldn't have the scouting chops to be that strong on his offensive line play and his blocking, but everyone I trust says something similar.

26:11And yet, when he gets out in the open field and you see his hands like... He can run. How many other players are like that in the league? No, he's a unicorn. But I mean, that's to me, this goes back to your DK point of what this offense is going to look like. Think about if you're in 13 personnel with the tight ends, and then now, okay, we want to be a heavy team. We're going to run the ball, run the ball, run the ball, and now we get DK out there, and you get some one-on-ones and take your shots. Well, they said in training camp, when the reporters were watching, they got in 0-4 personnel. I don't even know what to call that one snap.

26:42They had John New in the backfield and three other tight ends. I'm not sure who the third tight end, Connor Hayward, I believe, was the other tight end. So they're just going wild here. It's a long way of talking about DK. and his route tree. I did want to mention that all the reports out of camp, like they're living on his slant. So maybe it's keep them on the move. Yeah. A little more yards after catch, maybe a little more, little less go balls. That's the thing I was frustrated watching Aaron Rogers. I think Garrett Wilson got a little frustrated with Aaron Rogers, maybe not as willing to take as many shots down the field.

27:16So it's going to be the shorter shots. Can I pull up? Cause I, this is why I love doing this show. Cause then I just go into my notes. because I like seeing if these guys change a lot from when they were coming out to what they are now. So I'm just going to pull up some DK Metcalf notes. He reminded me of Demarius Thomas. He can fight through press, burst, wall off on slants. Nice one-handed catch versus Bama. He's not great working back to the quarterback, not great getting in and out, keep him on the move. That's still true. That's who he is. I mean, he's gotten better, more well-rounded as an NFL player.

27:51The Demarius Thomas comp is a really good one. You think of the most famous Demarius Thomas play of all time. You didn't actually see as much of that with Seattle. So I would look forward to it. By the way, going back to DK, he was 228 pounds coming out. He ran 4-3-3. That's when he ran the 4-day. I see he looks like he's in a Batman suit. It's one of those drafts that I do think if it had happened five years later, receivers were just falling a little more than, or maybe I'm wrong, But it seems completely bizarre that the DK Metcalf, Aaron, AJ Brown picture of them flexing as college teammates, that those two gentlemen with like those freaks, how did they fall to the late second round?

28:36Both of them. All right. Now I have to open it back up. So that was 19. So DK Metcalf was my 21st player. He was the 64th pick. W. Another W for DJ. Let's go A.J. Brown. A.J. Brown was my 36th player, was the 51st pick. Both of those guys. What were we doing at the NFL back then? I don't know. They weren't listening to you. I don't know. So you go back through this database. I always do this just to show how this whole thing works. Hey, great job. You had A.J. Brown, 36th. Just one spot behind Jerry Tillery. I mean, they're the same guy. Same career. I did have him one spot over in to kill Harry, though.

29:18Give me that one. Good job. Thank you. that was a mistake that Bill Belichick made. And who knows? If he had drafted A.J. Brown, like instead of Nikhil Harry, just that one pick different. Maybe he's still there. Maybe he's there. Maybe Jordan Hudson is running the personnel department. I'm just going to, because we've done so much to those, and I know people that are probably fans of these other teams. Okay. Just glossing over it, but I did have Caleb Johnson down as one of my guys. Third round pick, running back, foot in the ground, go. Like that's what he is. he's kind of just he's a no-nonsense north-south he's big he's fast I don't think there's a ton of wiggle there for me but there's he's gonna fit there they're gonna try and maul people create a crease and let him see if he hits some home runs they haven't had that he's the Nadja Harris role with a little more explosiveness and they're not gonna ask him to be on the field every down for fantasy owners like Jalen Warren is gonna have a role they like what they see out of Kenneth Gainwell who's a good player no no no they love what they've seen out of Kenneth Gainwell that's on the fantasy football list on the side Kenneth Gainwell and they look if he they feel like in that building what you saw you know with him behind Saquon Barkley like just what if we just give him a little bit more he was excellent there and they've they've love Kenneth Gainwell well I will never forget a Super Bowl performance by an awesome Eagles offense at the highest of levels against a Steve Spagnuolo defense going up and down the field they didn't win the game but the offense did their job I'm like, who's the running back that was on the field that they trusted the most?

30:49It's Kenneth Gainwell in the biggest of spots. All right. I'll throw up. What do you got left? I got Kenny Pickett. Kenny Pickett is my last guy. That's funny because I've got, can I just, my last one, I couldn't pick, so I've been paired him up. Dylan Gabriel and Chidvers-San. So we can just have this whole discussion. Let's talk about the Browns quarterbacks. Kenny Pickett, to me, was a missed opportunity. So I haven't been impressed with his film. I don't love the idea that two teams, including the Steelers, have essentially given him away. Steelers, in hindsight, got a pretty good value for him from the Eagles in that trade.

31:24The Eagles just got a fifth round pick back in that trade in DTR. Why didn't they get more aggressive in going after trying to upgrade the position? Joe Flacco makes sense there. He knows the system. It's good to have a veteran in the room. It was cheap. It makes sense. but Kenny Pickett was the guy that they've gone into camp with and said, we kind of hope he wins this job. We want to develop them. He has a chance for the future. Weird bet with one of the most expensive rosters in the league. I know they're a rebuilding team. Maybe it'll work. Maybe it won't, but I think he's going to have a big impact because if he doesn't work, I think it just is a big swing and a miss.

32:02It's a question that I've been asked probably more than any other in training camp during training camp. And as we're recording this, we have not seen the preseason yet. So this, you know, we've already had a Browns game. We haven't seen that when we're talking here. So I want to get that out there. But I don't know where he fits. I've been asked this. How does this quarterback thing shake out? And I've said, okay, well, Joe Flacco feels like the week one starter. Like they're comfortable with him. They know who he is. Like he's on the team as that guy. And then it feels like you're not going to get rid of a third or fifth round pick.

32:31You know, the fifth round pick being Shudor Sanders because the talent that was, you know, warranted a higher selection that. So you're not going to give up on the two young guys. You don't really know what you have there. so then it just leaves me with Kenny Pickett. I'm like, are they going to roster four guys? I don't think so. And then is it, are they just looking around the league to see, you know, is there an injury? And then does that provide an opportunity to trade him? But then they've talked him up so much. So part of me is like, well, they talked him up because they really like him.

32:54And the other part of me is like, oh, it's just a pump and dump. They're talking him up so they can create value for him to go somewhere else. It feels like they went into the draft knowing they wanted to have a younger option. They had that younger option with Kenny Pickett. And they're like, hey, if something works out, maybe, you know, Maybe we could draft one as well. So then they love Dylan Gabriel. He's there. Then they took him in the third round. And then Shadur, after they'd pass on him a million times, eventually we can't pass on him anymore. And they just kind of find themselves in this weird position with these four quarterbacks.

33:22And Gabriel struggled in training camp by all accounts. Shadur Sanders has had more impressive moments where he looks like bigger potential. But he's a developmental quarterback. He's a fifth-round pick. But again, he was so much higher rated on my, just selfishly looking at it the way I saw both these guys come into the process I went on part of my take before the draft and they said give us a Brock Purdy type quarterback a quarterback who could go in the sixth or seventh round and he ends up being a starter down the line like who's your guy and I'm like Dylan Gabriel well that doesn't work when he goes in the third round so that that was kind of where I thought maybe it's Sanders is your Brock pretty like guy because honestly they the strengths are not that different between Shadur if he's going to work at the pro level and a Brock Purdy type.

34:07Yeah. No, he's in that family. I've kind of said that archetype, right, of quarterback. Joe Burrow is at the very top of that mountain. And then like Brock Purdy kind of factors in there below him in that level. Shadour Sanders is in that line of style of quarterbacks. Now people can say it's the Kirkland brand or whatever you want to, however you want to use that. But that's how he's going to win is going to be playing that brand of football. So when I go back and look at Shadour, he was my 20th overall player. And then when you go out and look at, where is he here? Oh my gosh. Dylan Gabriel was 148.

34:46That's a pretty big difference. And the reporters that have been there at the Browns would say your ranking sounds right. Shudder looks like a nice, interesting young player who has some potential and Gabriel's just not ready for it quite yet. So, but do they keep four or do they not keep four? It's fascinating. I don't think they will keep four. I do think Andrew Barry should take, you know, more grief for the roster that he's built. You know, the craziest thing when we do these discussions on them is that they have Deshaun Watson on the roster. Just kind of, you know. That's the original sin.

35:25But the reality is, like, they're in year five of this group. and the rest of the roster has its share of issues too. And so I think just going into this season, and by the way, if it's a pump and dump, I mean, what are you dumping it for at this point? Yeah. Well, it depends on who gets hurt and how desperate people are. It's a penny stock. I don't think it's happening. The other thing though is that, again, is you just look at how it's projected right now. I'll give, should I? Tankathon. Tankathon's a great website. If you love the draft, you want to keep up with like how the draft order is projecting out as the season goes along and keeping up with it week to week.

36:02They do a great job of it, but they project before the season. Next year's draft, the Browns have the second overall pick and the ninth overall pick, which would be from Jacksonville. So their quarterback discussion, as elongated as it is right now, their long-term quarterback is more than likely in next year's draft class. That is a fair point. We did it. We talked about the Browns quarterback. We get to do our bonus. It is time for our wild cards. I always forget how you name that. Wild card. bonus baby has I wonder if you had Shader Sanders by the way higher than Kenny Pickett when he was coming out I bet you did yeah a little bit higher but similar but higher my wild card is Tyler Loop wow for the Baltimore Ravens look they had such a long run with Tucker and everybody knows what you know transpired away from the football field and then his play had tailed off over the last couple years but on a nice run that they had there it was when they got to the freaking 40-yard line, it was three points.

37:00I mean, this guy's got a huge leg. So we'll see. Loop's done. You saw in the preseason game of the night, I think he missed one. He had a miss. You could see the leg strength. Would Justin Tucker have missed that? This year he would have, or last year at least. Prime Tucker didn't miss anything. So I think that's fair. We're talking about this division. We talked a lot about the Pittsburgh Steelers, the Cincinnati Bengals with Joe Burrow and that offense are going to be in the mix. There's going to be games for them that come down to Tyler Loop. I feel bad for not talking any Bengals, so I'll just throw out Noah Fant.

37:31Why not? That's my wild card. Okay. Because it's more as a reminder that they just didn't add a lot this offseason. Of course you're happy that you give Chase and Higgins all that money, but they've been there. That's not a reason to think you're going to get better. Have a couple draft picks that they can get excited about. You mentioned Demetrius Knight. They have the first round pick, Shamar Stewart. But ultimately, they kind of ran back the same defense that wasn't very good last year. And then on offense, I think they could have gotten better on the offensive line than they really did. They don't have a lot of depth, especially at tackle.

38:08There's questions at guard as well. The one move they made in the middle of training camp was bringing in Noah Fant, another tight end. And so just building strength on strength. I don't mind that. I like that move. I think he can fill a role kind of with Mike Gesicki as the slot guy and Fant's there. and they just have a plethora of weapons. But to me, it was a reminder, like the Bengals, they didn't give you a lot of reasons to feel like this is a better team other than you change your defensive coordinator. Yeah, I mean, they're going to need these young rookies to play well. Demetrius Knight, Shamar Stewart, going to have to play big roles for him.

38:40And, you know, offensively, the tight end position, it's funny that you mentioned that. Tanner McLaughlin was like one of my sleepers. I loved him coming out of Arizona. He was older player. So he ended up dropping to the sixth round. I thought he was worth like a third round pick. But now that I look, I'm looking at their roster. He's buried because Drew Sample plays for them. Drew Sample plays. You have Fant now. Eck, who they like. Sorry, Eric Alge, the kid who he had been hurt coming out too. And the other night, Tanner Hudson caught two touchdowns. One at the beginning of the game and one at the end of the game, which that's a lot of football to be playing week one in the preseason for Tanner Hudson.

39:13But they obviously like him. So he is 100 % buried on that depth chart. Yeah. Well, if I wanted to spin something positive to, you know, who was out there starting for them with Joe Burrow and the ones and had some nice plays by all counts. Rookie guard Dylan Fairchild. So that's another rookie man. They like Dylan Fairchild. They're really counting on rookies. See, I felt bad because I'm rooting for the Bengals. I want the Wesleyan brothers to be happy. That's fair. They're ruining them out there. They just, I mean, I do think it's interesting they're playing the offensive guys here in the preseason after their slow starts the last few years.

39:44It's one of these offseason narratives that I've gotten sick of like since January, Zach Taylor has been talking about, we got to start faster. We got to start faster. We're going to do it. Like we'll see. Maybe playing in the preseason can, can change everything. We're ready to go. Like we don't need to warm up. These forties and free agents have been flying. We will be back next week with the AFC South and the NFC South. I know you will miss me until then, DJ. Hey, leave us a rating and review. Why not? Good job by DJ. Leave us a rating. Leave us a review. Tell your friends. We'll see you next time.

40:25Scams don't always look like scams anymore. AI can make a fake ticket offer look legit or a sportsbook text sound official. And once an identity thief gets your personal information, they can start using your name like it belongs to them. And then what? LifeLock helps detect potential identity threats and suspicious activity. And if identity theft happens, LifeLock's restoration specialist can help restore your identity, guaranteed, because only LifeLock truly protects your name and identity. Get LifeLock at LifeLock.com and use promo code FOOTBALL for up to 30 % off your first year. That's LifeLock.com, code FOOTBALL.

41:03Some people use ChatGPT to answer questions. Others use it to get real work done. With ChatGPT work, you bring the goal, plus real inputs like briefs, notes, files, feedback, data, and project plans. It can help turn them into an analysis, tracker deck outline prototype or workflow you can review and keep shaping you stay in control giving direction and choosing the final output put chat gpt to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects get started at chat gpt.com by selecting work mode available on plus and pro plans there are exciting things happening at your local cvs shop new extra big deals with extra care every two weeks.

41:42No coupon needed. Plus, get access to exclusive sale prices, personalized deals, and more as a member. Extra Care is the way to save at CVS. Join for free, online, or in-store and start saving. Visit your local CVS store or cvs.com slash extra big deals for this week's deals. Wait, I came in for two things. How is this$47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here. Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25. Plus, as a new checking customer, you can earn$100 when you open an account and make qualifying Zelle or debit transactions.

42:23Oh, that's actually really simple. Safe Balance Banking. One less thing to figure out. Learn more at bfa.com slash earn100. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC. Grainger knows when you're a procurement manager for an office park, You're not managing one building. You're managing all of them. And to stay ahead, you need to see through walls and around corners. Lights about to fail, filters ready to clog, HVAC on its last leg. If you wait until something breaks, you're already behind. Count on Grainger for quality products, easy reordering, and 24-7 support. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by.

43:00Grainger, for the ones who get it done. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human

From the publisher

Gregg Rosenthal and Daniel Jeremiah give you their five biggest impact additions and rookies for the AFC North. Find out why Gregg and DJ think players like Malaki Starks, Jaire Alexander, Shedeur Sanders, Aaron Rodgers, Jalen Ramsey and more will have a major impact for their teams next season. 

NFL Daily YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/nflpodcasts

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

All 390 episodes
40s and Free Agents: The AFC North's 5 Impact Additions and RookiesNFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal · 35 min
Listen in VO