1. Podcasts
  2. NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal
  3. Top 20 NFL Running Backs
NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

23 Jun 2025 · 40m · 16 chapters

Episode artwork

Top 20 NFL Running Backs

In short

NFL Daily hosts Greg Rosenthal and Nick Shook draft the top 20 running backs for the upcoming season (not based on last year alone; includes receiving, blocking, and “fit”/availability). They also discuss brief NFL offseason news during the “dead zone.”

Guests (hosts)

Greg Rosenthal (NFL Daily host) and Nick Shook (NFL Daily host). No other guests appear in the transcript.

Key claims

Saquon Barkley is the top pick for 2025 due to improved “success rate” and big-play/short-yardage balance (496 yards over expected in the second half). Bijan Robinson is the most complete and most consistent (league-leading success rate). Derrick Henry remains a high-end bell cow despite Baltimore’s spread usage. Jameer Gibbs is versatile and physical; Josh Jacobs is a trusted workhorse; Kyren Williams is a high-snap, consistent Rams engine. Christian McCaffrey is valued but availability concerns drop him.

Notable examples

Henry pistol production (49 for 492); Kyren Williams’ snap impact; Alvin Kamara’s three-down route/target usage; Bucky Irving’s single-high matchup dominance; James Cook’s receiving versatility; David Montgomery’s under-center success.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:54

NFL Offseason and Running Back Importance

Discussion about the NFL offseason and why running backs matter.

“I don't know if I believe you, but I definitely believe you that we're in the dead zone.”
3:46

News Updates and Retirements

Updates on players returning for training camp and retirements.

“We're going to draft the best 20 running backs in the league back and forth, who we would want to be our running back in our backfield this year.”
4:33

Drafting the Best Running Backs

Discussion on the criteria for selecting top running backs for the upcoming season.

“Mosley, a really good player who just couldn't get medically cleared to play another year.”
5:26

Top Picks: Saquon Barkley

In-depth analysis of Saquon Barkley as the first overall pick.

“Interestingly, he was one of the few people that completely opted out of the COVID season.”
7:59

Analyzing Bajon Robinson's Impact

Discussion on Bajon Robinson’s performance and potential.

“he's at the top of my board absolutely he had 496 yards over expected according to next gen stats in the second half of last season.”
10:15

Evaluating Derek Henry and Jameer Gibbs

Comparative analysis of Derek Henry and Jameer Gibbs.

“He has improved steadily in each one of his seasons.”
14:00

Ranking Running Backs: Insights and Evaluations

Explore the evaluations and rankings of NFL running backs, focusing on their performance metrics and potential.

“You want to talk about different running backs with higher success rate.”
28:59

Drafting Running Back #13: Alvin Kamara

Analysis of Alvin Kamara's performance and value as a running back.

“Number 13 overall in the running back draft.”
30:13

Drafting Running Back #14: Bucky Irving

Discussion on Bucky Irving's statistics and potential for success.

“Well, you're just doing this to annoy me.”
32:41

Drafting Running Back #15: Joe Mixon

Exploration of Joe Mixon's career and impact in Houston's offense.

“The highest rate of forced missed tackles in the entire league.”
Show all 16 chapters
34:56

Drafting Running Back #16: Omari and Hampton

Evaluating Omari and Hampton's skills and potential in the NFL.

“Yeah, the only question is really if he can keep not just on the field, but when when he comes out at the beginning of the season and he's fully healthy, he looks one way.”
36:12

Drafting Running Back #17: Tony Pollard

Analysis of Tony Pollard's performance and his situation in Tennessee.

“And this kind of goes back to what I was saying about rooms is I really love the Chargers room.”
38:55

Drafting Running Back #18: David Montgomery

Discussion on David Montgomery's play style and impact on the field.

“That's a guy who I watched in multiple instances last year, just win the war of attrition, the ground and pound.”
40:44

Final Thoughts on Running Backs

Concluding remarks on the running back position and draft strategies.

“I'm just going to throw to give people some love.”
42:02

Assessing Running Back Potential

The hosts discuss the potential of various NFL running backs for the upcoming season.

“I know Ramondre was too, but ultimately, man, that guy, it would be great to see him behind a good offensive line and I think can be a really dynamic playmaker has the highest ceiling.”
44:13

Offseason Thoughts and Injury Talk

Hosts share offseason thoughts, injury impacts, and personal anecdotes.

“And don't celebrate the Cavs suddenly being the favorites in the Eastern Conference next year, just because Halliburton and Tatum are injured going into next year.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Nick Shook: This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. How do you turn 16 games, injury reports, team notes, betting lines, and matchup trends into one clear weekend preview? Chat GPT work can help. Give it the goal, plus real inputs like notes, files, data, and project plans. It can help turn them into an analysis, tracker, deck outline, or workflow you can keep shaping. You stay in control, reviewing the work, and choosing the final result. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting Work Mode. Available on Plus and Pro Plans. Nationwide is so much more than a great insurance company.

0:42Nick Shook: They're one of America's largest financial services companies. Just like I'm so much more than quarterback Peyton Manning. I'm also Peyton Manning. Insurance and financial services together? It's a masterpiece. Peyton Manning does it again. For your insurance and financial needs, Nationwide is on your side. Nationwide Investment Services Corporation, Ember FINRA, Columbus, Ohio. Now more than ever, football teams are embracing advanced analytics. Nothing's more popular right now than coming up with a fancy new stat that helps teams get an edge on game day. And this season, Bet365 is embracing a fancy concept of its own.

1:23Bet$10, get$150. Here's how it works. When new users sign up with Bet365 and place their first$10 bet, they'll get$150 in bonus bets. Fine, maybe it's not that advanced, but an offer this good doesn't have to be. Bet365, where winning is everything. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET. Must be 21 plus and present in a state where Bet365 operates. Please gamble responsibly. Restrictions and terms and conditions apply. Void where prohibited. Download the app today. Lowe's knows Sundays are for football. So tackle your home improvement projects by Saturday and earn your Sunday with great deals on LG and Bosch appliances.

2:08Select Ego, DeWalt, Phil Treat products, and more. Then once your to-do list is done, get ready to kick back, relax, and enjoy the game. Shop in-store or online now and earn your Sunday with help from Lowe's, official partner of the NFL.

2:27Welcome to NFL Daily, where running backs have always mattered to us. I'm Greg Rosenthal, and I'm here with Nick Shook, where you are taping this show, Nick. June 23rd, it is officially the dead zone of the NFL season. Spoiler alert, football's not back for the next couple weeks, and yet we're going to be cranking out some fun NFL Daily content. No one I'd rather do it with than you, Nick.

2:51Nick Shook: You know, judging by your tone and the way that you made that claim about running backs, I don't know if I believe you, but I definitely believe you that we're in the dead zone. Surprisingly, we are operating in a world now in which the NFL dominates, I'd say, about 50 weeks out of the year. So to have two off, not bad. Good job. People will still want to come up with it. It is a weird thing. Yeah, for people who aren't as familiar, this is the one time a year not only a lot of media goes away and we'll get into our schedule coming up in the next few weeks, But the teams are just literally out of the building until at least after July 4th.

3:26So even though we're getting closer to training camp, when NFL Daily is truly back to daily again, it is the one time a year, even though we're close, that teams are off. And yet, Nick, running backs have always mattered to me. I don't know why you're coming at me. I mean, it's like the coolest, the most fun position to watch. And so we're going to talk about them today. We're going to draft the best 20 running backs in the league back and forth, who we would want to be our running back in our backfield this year. Kind of a snapshot of where the position is at. And it's better than it's been in a long time.

4:01You know, since we last taped a show that was kind of taped that day, it was Patrick and Omar. Great job by them. They did the Jair Alexander news. Not a lot of news has popped up since. Some updates injury-wise, Anthony Richardson fully expected to be back for training camp. I personally thought it was interesting that the Chiefs confirmed their first-round pick, Josh Simmons, fully ready for training camp, including contact. That's interesting. And then C.J. Mosley, the longtime Jets and Ravens linebacker, retired. So happy trails to C.J. Mosley, a really good player who just couldn't get medically cleared to play another year.

4:36but a hall of very good guy five second team all pros like a very steady captain type and that's about it that's all you need for the news for the last like three or four days yeah if you think

4:47Nick Shook: about mosley's career i prefer you think about his career with the ravens instead of the jets because he went to the jets as a high price free agent they obviously had their struggles he did make a pro bowl and a second team all pro in 2022 but again yeah he had some health issues in his last season and just felt like he never quite lived up to the contract. And yet he was a very good football player over the course of his career, especially if you think about his Ravens years where he was at his best. You know, I think he gave the Jets leadership that year he had where he got the second team all pro.

5:18He was outstanding. One of the guys that everyone said that played around him second in defensive rookie of the year back in 2014. 14. Interestingly, he was one of the few people that completely opted out of the COVID season. If you remember, he didn't play at all that season, but was a really good player for the Ravens. And yes, had some nice years for the Jets. So happy trails to him. Let's get to the draft. I will give you the first overall pick. Again, the parameters, who we want playing running back this year. It is not a lifetime achievement award. It is not even just who was the best last year.

5:54who is our type of guy it's not fantasy numbers because we're taking everything into account receiving blocking whatever you want who are the very best right now looking forward you have the

6:05Nick Shook: first pick it's gonna be chalk and and really what i found in this exercise was that i like rooms more than running backs individually like i'm a big fan of certain rooms in the league and we're not drafting rooms so i'm gonna go with the guy who's on the cover of madden 26 i'm going with Saquon Barkley. It's as simple as that. There's no argument. I think there could be an argument. It would be just that he's coming off this incredible season. And maybe we knock him for that, that the history of running backs, or can you do it like two years in a row? And that this year is some of the other top five guys, like a slightly more consistent player on a snap to snap basis.

6:47You could have said that, Nick, in Saquon's career before this last one. The thing that changed in Philadelphia was, for instance, his success rate in New York was always a little hit or miss, was kind of low. Big plays, but a lot of negative plays. And that was partly because of the offensive line. But this last season, he was hitting the 6, the 7, the 8-yard gains in addition to the 80-yard gains.

7:09Nick Shook: Yeah, and he was a player that was three down back and was a home run hitter and a closer, which we hadn't seen from him except for in early in his career before you know he encountered those injury struggles that he ran into in his final years with the jets and and i think more than anything yes we like to see a guy rush for 2 000 yards it's fun to watch that it's cool to be like i remember where i was when saquon broke 2 000 yards i remember that season but what really i thought was most special to me beyond the super bowl victory was the fact that he was able to overcome all the doubt all the naysayers all the well saquon might never be what we thought he was going to be because of all these injuries no he just went out and rushed for 2 000 yards and was an awesome running back can i do i think he's going to do it again i don't know it's it's really hard it's basically almost impossible to do it two years in a row so i'm going to say no but also if he's the player he was last year which i think he is i'm and i'm picking him just for this year he's at the top of my board absolutely he had 496 yards over expected according to next gen stats in the second half of last season.

8:09That number, Nick, would have been more than any running back in an entire full season since 2018 when they started keeping track. So just in the second half, he was getting more extra yards than any runner in a full season since 2018, except for one guy who did it over the course of last season. We'll get to him in a minute. But yeah, he's the man. He would have been my number one pick. It gets interesting here. I think the next three backs in my mind could go in any order, but I'm taking Bajon Robinson. It's my team. It's who I want. Last year, it kind of snuck up on me that he had 1 ,887 yards from scrimmage and 15 touchdowns.

8:48And one thing that I love about him is he gets more than what's blocked. Since he entered the league, he has 15 more missed tackles forced than anyone else. So that's over a three-year span. Derek Henry's actually second in that. So that shows that that's been a skill set since day one, But what gets me about him is just how complete he is. Obviously, he's good as a pass catcher. But I mentioned success rate hasn't been as consistent for Saquon. As great as Saquon was, and I'm sure we'll get to Derrick Henry sooner than later, the league leader in success rate last year, and you can measure it in different ways, different companies measure it differently.

9:24But essentially, it's getting a certain amount of yardage or a first down on plays, like over four yards on first down. The leader in success rate was Bajon Robinson last year. So he was extremely consistent in addition to giving you all the eye-popping plays that you expect from him.

9:40Nick Shook: Yeah, you know, when I think about the Falcons, I think about the players that are actually quite talented that maybe don't get the exposure league-wide that they should. And he's one of them because people don't necessarily pay attention to the Falcons all the time. They did early in the season last year because they got off the hot start, but then they fell apart down the end. And it feels like they're in the shadows there. Players like Bijan are always in the shadows there. Kyle Pitts was the subject of that before, and now he's going into a pivotal year, of course. So I just want them to succeed as a team so that then he is elevated, B.

10:09Nick Shook: John Robinson, to a larger stage so that the rest of the football world can appreciate him properly because those numbers that you just listed absolutely do not lie. Right. He has improved steadily in each one of his seasons. I think we expect running backs to come into the league and just blow the doors off. And rookies are eligible, by the way, Nick. I don't know if I mentioned that to you. and they're eligible in fancy drafts too. Okay. Okay. They're, they're eligible. He has gotten just a little bit better. He came in already, I think better than people realize like a top 10 type of back. And he's gotten just a little savvier, a little better in each one of the seasons.

10:42All right. Give me who you have. Number three.

10:45Nick Shook: My number three is going to be Derek Henry. And this was a pick that I may not have made even a year ago because I thought, look, this guy, a lot of the tread has been worn off those tires. He's gotten a high volume of carries over the course of his career. He's been the rushing leader multiple times. He is the model of being a superhuman running back who will throw defenders through the air if you try to encounter him and take him on with an arm tackle. But what he did last year within Baltimore's offense told me that he still had plenty of gas left in that tank. Do I think that he's necessarily going to flirt with a career year this year?

11:17Nick Shook: No, because they spread the ball around so much, but that's what makes him so effective. So I know we're talking about just running backs on their team and not necessarily taking into account all the circumstances around him. But you can't evaluate him without considering the fact that he plays with Lamar Jackson, that he plays behind an offensive line that got a lot better than most people would expect last year, and an offense that's balanced enough to throw to Rashad Bateman and Zay Flowers so that they can't just load the box against Derrick Henry, which helps him succeed as much as he did last year.

11:42Nick Shook: I believe in him for at least one more year as a guy who's going to hit home runs, who's going to run guys over. He's going to go over 1 ,000 yards, and he's going to be a bell cow back for this team. So that's why I take him with my second pick. It's crazy. if you look at the numbers, they were almost identical to his best season. You know, when everyone remembers he ran for 2 ,100 yards from scrimmage, ran for over 2 ,000 in that COVID season where he was offensive player of the year. And that's what you think of as his peak. And yet last season was actually right there. In a lot of ways, he was better because he took 50 less carries to get there.

12:18So he led success rate. I mean, in terms of he led an EPA per play or total EPA. He actually ended up having more rushing yards over expected than Saquon Barkley last season. By almost any measure, it was one of the best rushing seasons of all time. I saw another interesting stat. You know, NextGen does a lot of work for us that, you know, out of the pistol, when they ran the pistol, he had the best like running back season out of the pistol of any running back ever. 49 for 492 yards. Like he was 10 yards per carry out of the pistol. So he somehow is getting better as he gets older. I think that's a strong pick for number three.

12:54But I would have disagreed. I actually would have had him fourth. I would have taken Jameer Gibbs fourth or third. And so I'll take him fourth now. And again, I'm just thinking I am projecting a little bit forward. And I'm thinking about what I would want on my team. And to me, he's just so versatile. He led the NFL in terms of yards per carry between the tackles. And that's the thing I think people don't really understand with Gibbs. Obviously you have the home run ability that Saquon and Derek Henry have, you know, Gibbs had the highest explosive rate, explosive play rate in the league in terms of plus 10 plays, but he's very physical.

13:31Like he can run inside, he can run over people. And to me, he's just hitting his prime. So I'm going Jameer Gibbs next. Yeah.

13:38Nick Shook: He was up there on my list too. And I actually went back and forth with my choice here because this is where I think it gets a little interesting because it skews toward preference. and I like a guy who I can trust to make defenders miss, to break tackles, to be very hard to bring down, and to also make a difference out of the backfield as a pass catcher. I like Bellcows. I like Josh Jacobs. That's where I'm taking him here. And this might be a little high from what most people would expect, but you look at success rate. You want to talk about different running backs with higher success rate. His actually was lower than it was outside of the top 10, really out of the top 15 when it comes to next-gen stats.

14:12Nick Shook: And yet when I think about a per-down back, if circumstances are right the play is schemed up properly he's going to make a play he's going to get those extra yards he's going to be a guy that I can look down my roster and say I would give him the ball 25 times a game and feel perfectly fine about it because I know he's a workhorse so that's why I would take him yeah bigger bigger workload certainly than Gibbs although for instance Gibbs 250 carry so less but 50 catches so he gives you that receiving game jay jacobs does that too he's made people miss in terms of missed tackles since the day he entered the league no he would have been either either next or or two away on my list he does have a little bit of an every other year thing but he's kind of earned that spot almost reminds me of a little of uh a mod mon green back in the day for the the packers in terms of a guy who's like never the best, but man, it's really awesome to have a guy that you can give the ball to 300 times and you'll know is like a top seven or eight back and you don't have to worry about him.

15:13I think that's the part of Josh Jacobs's career that he's in now. I am going to take a rookie now. I'm going to Ashton Gentry. I love a lot of other running backs in the league and I know you might think this is high. This is sixth overall, but I just thought like, would I rather have Ashton Gentry or let's say Christian McCaffrey, who's going to come up at some point, or whoever else is coming up next. I am confident enough in Gentry. I'm going sixth overall. It's not a position where players have to ease their way into the league. Often they peak rather early. Even great all-time backs are great right away, like in Adrian Peterson, like LaDainian and Tomlinson.

15:53So the contact balance, the consistency I think he's going to bring, I'm believing in Gentry. I don't need to see anything.

16:00Nick Shook: No. And you know what? This is a rare case in which I would agree with a high evaluation of a rookie coming into the league. Usually I'm, I'm very anti, like don't put, especially when it comes to fancy, don't put a lot of stock on a guy who hasn't played a down in the NFL yet because you're just, you're, you're playing blind essentially. But if somebody was buying stock in teams this year, you are buying all the stock in the Raiders. So I'm not at all surprised that you're taking Ashton Gentry here. And, and what you just said makes a whole lot of sense because what you see on tape translates to the pro game.

16:29Nick Shook: It's just a matter of how fast can he hit the ground running? Can they scheme it up well for him? Because you don't want to put him behind an offensive line that's not good and he has to try to be a superhero just to gain a few yards. But if it's in a vacuum, yes, I totally agree with you. Well, part of the reason I did it, Mick, and I'm curious how you would answer with your next pick. I thought, like, what would NFL teams rather have for 2025? Even if it is somehow in a weird universe where they could only take him for one year, Would they rather have Ashton Gentry or would they rather have the guy they already have who's coming up on our list?

17:00I bet almost all of them would take Ashton Gentry. I really do. But maybe I'm wrong and maybe we're all wrong about our evaluations. Who do you got?

17:06Nick Shook: No, actually, I agree with you on that, too. My next pick is this is where I get a little uncertain, a little nervous because I have a hard time putting stock in running backs who can't stay on the field. But I'm going with it anyway. And I'm going with Christian McCaffrey, who never got rolling last year because of injury. And his season ended prematurely. and it was basically just a wash or a waste of a season for him. But I believe in the talent, and I believe that he would still have one healthy season in him if we're only playing for one season. And there are few players who are as dynamic and as explosive as he is when he's fully healthy.

17:37Nick Shook: So at this point, I'm getting him with this value. Christian McCaffrey, I'm taking it. Yeah, at first I had him high on this list. And as I kept doing, I kept moving him down and down. And I realized he's only been healthy, Nick, three out of the last seven years. So maybe there's be four. Yeah, that's not enough to me. It's just not enough. He did the two straight in San Francisco, but then when you have a completely missed season, essentially last year, then it reminds you of all the other ones that happened before that with Carolina. And to me, that's part of the position, unlike any other, where availability is really a trait.

18:18It's really a skill. it's why I feel fine taking a guy like Kyron Williams eighth because I want to have some love for the consistent player uh fifth and success rate in his two seasons he's 1 ,350 yards from scrimmage 1 ,490 yards from scrimmage he played the most snaps last season this shocked me of any running back in the league no doesn't that surprise you you think of them like bringing in some other backs, but he's there blocking. He's there as a terrific receiver. He's there to pick up five when you block three, he's just consistent. And to me, he is a guy I am just trusting to be out on the field.

18:56So it's a rare position where I'm not just going for ceiling. I actually would rather have him than McCaffrey because I'd rather just have a guy that I know is going to be there, even though I know at their peaks, obviously McCaffrey is a better player.

19:07Nick Shook: Yeah, that and, you know, Kyron Williams value to the Rams is even more noticeable. It's obvious painfully so when he's not on the field because they are so much worse as a running team without him than they are with him on the field. He is a special type of player and a guy that a lot of people didn't see coming and kind of forget about until he's back in the field and makes a big play. And then they're just constantly reminded of how good he is and they have to accept that he's, you know, an excellent running back. So I agree with you on that. And I'm not surprised by the total snap count because it's visible.

19:34Nick Shook: Basically if he's available and he's playing a lot, the Rams are going to win games and if they win games, they'll make the playoffs. And that's basically how last season went. So that all tracks. I'm going to go, I'm overdrafting here and this is because I believe that the Bills are treating this man wrong and it's James Cook it's James Cook because I again work horseback and a guy who if you actually get him in the right scheme and run it with him with intent you're not in the Ken Dorsey offense you're more in the Joe Brady offense and you're handing it to him you know many times a game and you're letting him get going he can be a big time difference maker and we spent all this time paying attention to Josh Allen and everybody else and rightfully so, but he's a big part of that offense that I think isn't getting the love he deserves from that organization as he goes into a contract year.

20:19Nick Shook: And frankly, I would pay him and keep him and put him in the right situation and ride him as a bell cow. So that's why I take him this high. Yeah, I love it. I had him a few spots lower, but I don't think it's crazy to go James Cook that high. You look at the last couple of years, very similar in terms of yards from 15, 1660 two years ago, then 1216 last year, but out of the 18 touchdowns. And he's my type of back that he's just an excellent receiver, a versatile receiver. You want him on the field, even though they have a great third, third down back. So they don't need to like lean into it. Cook can, can do absolutely everything.

20:58So I'm fine with that. I'm struggling with my next pick. If it was actually my team that this next group is all very close. I'd cook a little lower, but I'm just going to give James Conner some love here to wrap out. Yes. His first 2000 yard rushing seasons were the last two, but he did get over 1500 yards from scrimmage last year. And he's really improved as a receiver. He's very high in terms of forcing missed tackles. And he would rank really high in a stat that doesn't exist that Adrian Peterson, I think, would be the all time leader in these of players that I've watched, which is running hard per snap.

21:36Joe Mixon is going to be high in this one. I'm sure he'll come up later. The effort on every single run is outstanding. He's getting better as he gets older. And so there's a couple of flashier options out there, but I'm going James Conner, number 10.

21:52Nick Shook: I like that pick because much like Kyron Williams at the Rams, you could basically predict the Cardinals' outcomes last year, whether he had a good game or not. If he was near 100 yards on the ground, they probably won the game. if he was bottled up they probably lost and and he was so important to them in that regard and is such a hard runner i totally agree i'm a big fan of his and every time he had a big game i i enjoyed it very much i am gonna take a guy who statistically uh resonates with those who like to scroll down spreadsheets but those who like availability a little on the sideline here because that's where he spent a lot of his time over the last few years and it's jonathan taylor from the Colts.

22:30Nick Shook: He finished last year with 1 ,431 rushing yards and 11 touchdowns. And yet here he is going 11th in our draft. It was quiet because of the Colts and their dysfunction at quarterback and his checkered injury pass that he hasn't been a reliable player. But when he's there and he's healthy and sometimes it's more in spurts than consistent, it still looks really amazing. So to get him here at 11th, I'm going to take that all day. I love it. It's exactly where I had him, but there's a reason if James Cook is kind of my type, I think Jonathan Taylor is not, not that big plays aren't incredibly valuable, but it's why I'm not going to knock Kyron Williams too much.

23:12If, if you're 25 to 30 yard run would have been 60 if it was Jonathan Taylor for a touchdown, like that is a big edge for Taylor, but the consistency on always looking for home runs, grinding out the four or five, six yard runs. And then more importantly, the receiving this, he has an old school, like box score, uh, only 136 yards as a receiver, just kind of a zero in that department. Um, not that he like can't catch the ball though. He has some pretty high profile drops, but they also just don't trust them as a blocker and to really understand the full thing. So I think that's, that's why he is a great runner.

23:51That's, but that's also why he, he went 11th. All right. I'm going to go Aaron Jones, number 12, just a guy I love. And I had this feeling that he kind of faded at the end of last year. And then I like by the end, he actually had over 1500 yards from scrimmage. He was not great in the red zone. He's not a true, just give the ball to him. And he's like your main guy. Like, but how many guys we already have gone through? How many of those are there really? Not, not that many. He actually hasn't lost his speed at all. He is the sixth fastest player according to next gen stats on a like per snap basis in terms of just the miles per hour that he is running.

24:33So the speed is still there and I'm going Aaron Jones, number 12. We're going to take a quick break and we'll be back and wrap up the rest of the running back draft. They're back.

24:52How do you turn 16 games, injury reports, team notes, betting lines, and matchup trends into one clear weekend preview? ChatGPT work can help. Give it the goal, plus real inputs like notes, files, data, and project plans. It can help turn them into an analysis, tracker, deck outline, or workflow you can keep shaping. You stay in control, reviewing the work, and choosing the final result. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode, available on plus and pro plans. Now more than ever, football teams are embracing advanced analytics.

25:31Nothing's more popular right now than coming up with a fancy new stat that helps teams get an edge on game day. And this season, Bet365 is embracing a fancy concept of its own. Bet$10, get$150. Here's how it works. When new users sign up with Bet365 and place their first$10 bet, they'll get$150 in bonus bets. Fine, maybe it's not that advanced, but an offer this good doesn't have to be. Bet365, where winning is everything. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET. Must be 21 plus and present in a state where Bet365 operates. Please gamble responsibly. Restrictions and terms and conditions apply.

26:13Void where prohibited. Download the app today.

26:16Nick Shook: Nationwide is so much more than a great insurance company. They're one of America's largest financial services companies, just like I'm so much more than quarterback Peyton Manning. I'm also Peyton Manning. Insurance and financial services together, It's a masterpiece. Peyton Manning does it again. For your insurance and financial needs, Nationwide is on your side. Nationwide Investment Services Corporation, Amber Finra, Columbus, Ohio. Lowe's knows Sundays are for football. So tackle your home improvement projects by Saturday and earn your Sunday with great deals on LG and Bosch appliances, select Ego, DeWalt, Filtree products, and more.

27:00Nick Shook: Then once your to-do list is done, get ready to kick back, relax, and enjoy the game. Shop in-store or online now and earn your Sunday with help from Lowe's, official partner of the NFL. For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters. Tremphaya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tremphaya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tremphaya, proper training is required. Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis.

27:51Nick Shook: Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremphaya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit TremphayaRadio.com. Back on NFL almost daily. Yeah, you probably noticed this time of year we're taking a little bit of a step back. But this week we have regular shows throughout the week. We've got our crew with Jordan Rodrigue and Colleen Wolfe for our next show.

28:35We'll have a Friday show as well. And then we've been working on a really exciting project that's going to start going up next week. And so everyone be on the lookout for that. Also, thank you to everyone who's listened to me lately and been writing reviews on iTunes and Spotify, giving us five star reviews. It really helps us out. Subscribe on YouTube. We appreciate you all. All right. Number 13 overall in the running back draft. Nick, this is your most important pick.

29:05Nick Shook: Oh, this is my most important pick. Wow. Because it came back after the break. Got to keep the listener engaged. OK, cool. Well, listener. Pull up a chair because we're going to pick a guy that I think Greg overlooked. a guy that's been one of Greg's favorites over the course of this man's career. It's Alvin Kamara from the New Orleans Saints, a running back who fits exactly what Greg looks for on a three-down basis. Let's just look at his numbers from last year. Yes, he finished with 950 rushing yards and six touchdowns he played in 14 games, but he added another 543 through the air with a couple of touchdown catches.

29:35Nick Shook: Greg, I think back to a couple of years ago when the Saints' offense was just dreadful, which we could say for most of the last three years. And it was a game in Seattle in which their defense won. I think the final score might have been 10 to six. And it felt like the entire Saints offense with Jameis Winston at quarterback was just drop back. Let Alvin Kamara run a choice route and just throw it wherever he decides to go. And that's how we're going to move the ball in that game. And that's the type of running back he can be. I don't know if he's the home run hitter. In fact, I don't think he's the home run hitter that he used to be.

30:01Nick Shook: But he's still an every down guy that presents a threat that when he's healthy is still one of your top weapons on the field. So to let him come down to 13, I'm just going to scoop him up here and right off into the sunset all happy. Well, you're just doing this to annoy me. I told you during the break that I forgot someone and we should make this a sponsored segment. Every single one of these drafts, there is someone I was like, oh, wait, I meant to take him way earlier. And I said that during the break. I didn't say who it was. And you guessed it. It was. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's the benefit of knowing you for a decade.

30:33I want to apologize to that man. So this is why you got to listen to the pod and not just look at the rankings that we're going to put out on social. We should still do it because I had Camara ranked eighth. And it's not that I forgot him. Like I got my sheet. I printed it out like an old man. We've got a printer here. And I for some reason I spaced looking past. I had him eighth. I had him ahead of McCaffrey and Connor and even Taylor. It kind of snuck up that he proved what I had believed for the last handful of years, which is that if they could just block for him, he really hadn't declined as much as the numbers showed, that I thought he still had juice, that I thought he's very intelligent.

31:13Reminds me a lot of Frank Gore in terms of his intelligence in the passing game. And then, yeah, you mentioned it last year. I mean, he went for 1 ,493 yards from scrimmage. He had the highest target rate by far of running backs in the league. actually had one of the highest target rates of any player. I think it was top five, including wide receivers. So if he's on the field, what that means is they're throwing him the ball, like 68 catches for 540 yards. And you're like, okay, he's just catching a bunch of dump offs. No, he's running a lot of different routes. And yes, he doesn't have the long speed.

31:45He just doesn't. You're absolutely right. Top five, Nick, according to NextGenStats, in speed crossing the line of scrimmage. So that's that initial burst. And when you watch him, I see that too. And yeah, he's those long plays that maybe he hit earlier in his career. Like that's not quite as there, but he can, he can crease you if you can block. And so I think he's going to have a good year. I really regret that. I let him, if I could trade, I would trade him up higher, but I'm not allowed to.

32:15Nick Shook: Well, the only trade I'm accepting is Ashton Gentry for Alvin Kamara. So I don't think that's an offer. That's too rich. I would give you Kyron at the eighth pick. I don't even know what that means since we're not actually playing fantasy here. I will go my next pick. That broke my heart. I'm just such a space cadet. Maybe we can put a little note with the top 20 rankings that we put out that Greg just forgot and apologizes. Bucky Irving. Oh, yeah. I love this pick. The highest rate of forced missed tackles in the entire league. Over five yards per carry on inside runs and outside runs. there were there were some number numbers and this is you know in large part due to the great bucks offensive line but when teams played single high safety and bucky irving was on the field like he averaged a preposterously high uh yards per carry just like you literally could not play single high against bucky irving you took that extra guy from not in the box like he is gonna to have some space he is gonna make you miss and the numbers like the the advanced numbers and and the raw numbers would actually tell you he was already like a top eight to ten back I'm not ready to go there but I'm happy to put him this high yeah ninth and success rate right behind Saquon Barclay by just a 0.1 percent difference a player who finished with 186 rushing yards over expected and a guy who I think is just scratching the surface one of my favorite guys out of the combine in his class, went to Tampa.

33:47Nick Shook: They needed a running back. He took Rashad White's job, rightfully so. He's on the path to success. I love that pick. Now, you've kind of wiped out a little bit of what was remaining of my board, but we're going to go to a guy that I think, look, yeah, he had a couple of ankle injuries last year. Yes, one was caused, if not both, by hip drop tackles, but we're going with Joe Mixon in Houston because I think Joe Mixon was kind of not treated poorly, but undervalued a little bit by Cincinnati. They let go of him for a seventh round pick. They were going to cut him. He ends up going to Houston. He has a really good start, gets hurt, misses some time, comes back, has a nice little, you know, period of games before he gets hurt again.

34:29Nick Shook: If he was healthy over the course of the season, he'd be an unquestioned weapon in that offense more than he is. And the idea of him with the Texans, with CJ Stroud, with everybody that they have a receiver, and then adding in whatever is left of Nick Chubb, I feel good about him going into the season. Now, it might be one of his last productive seasons of his career, considering how long he's been in the NFL. But he's just a guy that I like. He runs hard. He can hit the home run. He can make plays. He's just one of my favorite running backs to watch. So that's why I'm going to take him here. Yeah, the only question is really if he can keep not just on the field, but when when he comes out at the beginning of the season and he's fully healthy, he looks one way.

35:08Or sometimes if he has a week or two off and then it's coming back like he looks one way and then you see it fade just a little bit if he loses some of the burst, some of the physicality. But he's averaged over 1 ,350 yards from scrimmage over the last four years. So extremely consistent. This is right where I had him in the draft as well. I'm going back to another rookie here for 16 because when it comes down to it, I am confident enough in Omari and Hampton. He is one of my favorite running back evaluations over the last handful of years. I think he is complete, like a great blocker I think he's going to matter in the passing game.

35:44He can be a big playmaker. I think he, in a perfect world, he's a, he's a little bit bigger and a little more complete of a Jonathan Taylor type of player. Probably not going to make you miss as much as a lot of the running backs ahead of him, but, but that's okay when you have the juice. And I think that the third down availability that he's going to have. So I would take him over the rest of the veterans on the list. I feel good about the UNC back at 60.

36:11Nick Shook: Yeah, I like that pick too. And this kind of goes back to what I was saying about rooms is I really love the Chargers room. The balance between Najee Harris and Omari and Hampton is really exciting for me, especially with their identity as a team that wants to be physical, that wants to win on the ground. They have two different backs that can do a lot of different things. They can balance them well together and make quite a tandem. I think it's going to be very beneficial for them going into 2025. Next up on my list, we're going to go Devon Achan. And I'm going there because of the big play capability, because he is a guy you always have to account for on the field because of that home run speed that he has.

36:45Nick Shook: I don't see him as an every down back, but I do see him as the best option that they have in that backfield who could grow into something more if the rest of their offense could get back on track because they certainly weren't last year. I like his raw potential, the untapped potential that we've yet to see and what we've already seen from him with the big plays. I mean, a ridiculously efficient rookie season. Last year was kind of the opposite where it felt like he left yards on the field. Not great blocking, certainly, but he was hunting big plays. He's a guy who won't look good in terms of yards over expected.

37:17I think he was under because he was trying to make things happen. I'm not going to say it's a reach, but I had him more like around 25. But I think it's more styles. It depends what you're looking for. The runners at this spot, it's kind of like pick your favorite. I do think one back has been underrated in our draft more than any other. And, you know, I've taken other guys over him. So that's on me, too. And that's Tony Pollard. Like, what does Tony Pollard need to do to get a little more respect? He's actually been consistent in terms of production, despite, you know, you think of him at the end of Dallas getting hurt.

37:54But that was at the end of a season over 1300 yards from scrimmage in three straight. He was sixth last season in terms of yards after contact. so he's a guy who actually makes plays on his own. I thought last season was about as good as he's ever run, but really no one noticed because it was in Tennessee, and so he was someone, if you were still sticking around with your game pass condensed or whatever, deep into week 13, 14, it was like, man, Pollard is the guy I think that they wanted him to be when they brought him to Tennessee. The guy that Dallas almost never let him be, like a real 1A type of guy, complete guy, really nothing I could say was wrong with Pollard.

38:39Maybe not like the number one guy you would pick to like get two yards when it's fourth and goal and like run through tackles, but not a zero in that respect either. And so I really like him here at AT. I'm glad he got on the list at least. Yeah, I agree with that too.

38:53Nick Shook: And I think that he unfortunately is a representation of the mismanagement of the running back position on the part of the Dallas Cowboys over the last two to three years because they had a chance to make him their guy and stick with him and they let him walk and he walked to Tennessee where he obviously didn't have he wasn't in a good scenario because their quarterback situation was in flux and you know they're still a rebuilding team but the talent is undeniable there I mean everything that you just said I totally agree with and that if he's in the right situation if they get better as an offense you know with Cam Ward being there and they've shored up the offensive line again I think we can see great things from him because he's got the juice for sure he's making seven million dollars a year too nick like i know he's cheap like it doesn't why did you not keep him dallas what are you doing there is a level of veteran running back that becomes available in free agency that the second contracts are very much worth it because then you the titans don't have to worry about that position and that is not a lot to pay no your last pick shook this is it last make sure you get whoever you want on this list needs to be back we're throwing it back i'm gonna take the other half of the lions tandem i'm going david Montgomery.

39:55Nick Shook: That's a guy who I watched in multiple instances last year, just win the war of attrition, the ground and pound. I'm bigger and stronger. I'm going to run harder than you. And I'm going to close this game right now by running between the tackles and doing what my coaches want. I want a guy like that on my team. I don't care if he doesn't bring everything to the table in every area that you get from other running backs. That's a guy that I want in my depth chart and the capability, like you just said, to get fourth and two, two yards. I'm giving it to David Montgomery. I can trust him. He's a gritty type of old school running back.

40:25Nick Shook: I love him. He's on my he's my last pick. He was first in the NFL last year in success rate on under center runs. So it's exactly what you say. How did the NFL used to be played like under center? He's he's going to get you four to five yards. He was absolutely my next pick, too. We've reached 20. And now it's like, who do I want to make sure is on this list? Because a lot of them aren't my types. Some options. I'm just going to throw to give people some love. We didn't pick Travion Henderson, and I'm not going to, but just wanted to send him some love. Pacheco's coming off a bad season, so he's not going to get drafted.

41:01Chuba Harbord really improved, but I think doesn't quite have the juice to make this list. I like what I saw out of Tyrone Tracy. I think Chase Brown is an ascending player, but ultimately this last spot comes down to three players for me, either Brees Hall, ken walker or ramondre stevenson now those the next three on my list okay now in my heart ramondre is is more my type of guy he's coming off a season where he fumbled he was not good he's not coming off of a good season neither neither is breeze hall and yet like ramondre is to me the the most complete of these guys and like the guy that would be my style, but I'm so, you know, anxiety ridden about being called just a Patriots homer.

41:49I will take Ken Walker, who I had written down next, who it is fun to have a runner who can run one way, look like he's going to get tackled for five yard loss and run for 40 the other way. And he was hit behind the line of scrimmage so often and was playing in such a bad situation. I know Ramondre was too, but ultimately, man, that guy, it would be great to see him behind a good offensive line and I think can be a really dynamic playmaker has the highest ceiling. I'm torn. If it was actually my team, maybe I would take Ramondre. I think he's got a bounce back season coming up and is a really good NFL player, but I will go Kenneth Walker for just the, the highlight reel plays.

42:29Nick Shook: Yeah. I don't, I don't hate this pick at all for everything that you just stated. I'm on board with that. I, I am curious though, because it was such a forgettable season for Brees Hall. Where does he, cause we don't know what the jets are going to be. They They have a new identity, new quarterback, new everything else. But like, do you see a bounce back year for him that reminds us of the guy he was? Because you want to talk about home run hitters. He was a home run hitter a couple of years ago. And that's maybe that's more my style. I don't know. I'm kind of bouncing between the two. But do you think that that is within him going into 2025 and maybe even 2026, even though we're not considering that year in this draft?

43:02Absolutely. This is a confirming my prior situation. There is something about running backs of. You know it when you see it. and I like instincts. I like the feel of making people miss in a small area, in a hole. The vision, I think Ramondre is very good at that, even though he's not going to be a big playmaker. He's more like the Frank Gore type of mold. Brees Hall, I've never wrapped my arms around too because to me, he doesn't feel as talented as he is. He doesn't feel as instinctive as a back as some of these other guys, just like a truly great, natural, just runner. But he's an athlete and And he could make this ranking look very disrespectful with a big season.

43:45It could. Yeah, he could.

43:46Nick Shook: He could. And you know what? We can eat that crow. That's fine. That's how this thing works. Yeah. And I don't know if the Jets are like totally in on him. He was like dangled a little bit. So I think they'll spread it around. But it is a position where opportunity makes all the difference in the world. So who knows? Like maybe an R.J. Harvey or Quincyn Junkins. I'm trying to think of some other players that didn't come up. The Caleb Johnson, Travis Etienne. maybe he'll bounce back like any of those players could bounce on this list for next year we will put it out and we will see who we get made fun of the most uh shook it's gonna be a it's gonna be a minute until um we have you back on an nfl daily so enjoy uh the time off and um you know i don't know what what you're doing this offseason well i mean that's that's all good because yesterday i narrowly avoided getting a sunburn on the top of my head so maybe by the time i come back, I'll be looking like a tomato.

44:37Nick Shook: You don't know. It could be possible. And don't celebrate the Cavs suddenly being the favorites in the Eastern Conference next year, just because Halliburton and Tatum are injured going into next year. Nobody celebrates injuries, but the Cavs had their own injuries in the Eastern Conference semifinals that they had to deal with, too. We'll see. We'll see how it goes. It's a long way away. We got a lot of football before that. I watched that Game 7 on a flight back to LA and it broke my heart even though I'm not a Patriots fan. We will be back in your feed on Wednesday morning. Yes, Colleen Wolfe, myself, and Jordan Rodriguez.

45:14And yeah, I can't lie. This is the part of the season. Football's not back, but we're going to make you want to listen anyways.

45:27Nick Shook: This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.

From the publisher

Gregg Rosenthal is joined by Nick Shook to draft the top-20 running backs in the NFL. Find out who comes in at number one (03:20), and where players like Bijan Robinson (06:10), Derrick Henry (08:20), Ashton Jeanty (12:50), Kyren Williams (16:00), Alvin Kamara (22:29), Joe Mixon (28:05), David Montgomery (33:55), and more land on the list. 

Note: time codes approximate. 

NFL Daily YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/nflpodcasts

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

All episodes