

18 Nov 2026 · 1h 8m · 23 chapters

How to improve retention and product roadmaps so customers place a second order (and keep buying), especially for non-consumable “durables” brands. The panel contrasts acquisition vs return-customer revenue, discusses cohorting by first purchase product category, and explains how frequent product launches, distribution channels, and “getting the product in hand” drive repeat purchases.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the importance of treating customers well for both consumable and non-consumable brands.
“uh consumables right i don't think any of us sell any consumables i guess i'm playing i wish people would eat my pajamas.”
Analyzing different types of brands and how they approach customer retention.
“because the supplement companies, I mean, that's just like a different, that's its own vertical.”
Insights into various retention rates and strategies among different brands.
“because I think you do have the more interesting business and that like your products tend to be like, I buy lots of bags.”
Exploring the balance between acquiring new customers and retaining existing ones.
“But, um, but yeah, we like Curtis, we, we obsess over it.”
Examining typical buying journeys of customers and how brands can cater to them.
“You know, we have a pretty good cadence of sort of smaller new products.”
Discussion on the importance of unique products and limited editions in driving customer engagement.
“months, I think we might only get like 15 to 25 % lift on that value in the same year.”
The complexities of balancing product offerings and customer demands in retail.
“And I definitely think we both have the benefit of being able to use frequent launches to give a customer a reason to come back.”
Learn about the complexities of product development and the importance of innovation.
“So then you have unicorn web days where we sell 15 ,000 unicorns, but everybody can do it.”
Understand various strategies to enhance customer retention and brand loyalty.
“You said you've been working on the bakeware for years.”
Learn about the importance of customer experience and word-of-mouth in product strategy.
“And again, I was just like optimizing for like when did the financials look best?”
Understand how embracing mistakes can lead to success in business.
“I can see how that would have closed me with an upsell.”
Explore the different strategies for launching new products effectively.
“everybody told me, look, I made a little journal in a garage.”
Learn how to leverage customer cohorts for maximizing lifetime value.
“and Curtis, maybe I'll go with you first, is do you make product that you think this is a great acquisition product?”
Discuss the challenges of identifying products that drive repeat purchases.
“Recently, in the last year, we noticed that with certain products that were lower priced, lower AOV, lower priced products, that we could run acquisition funnels on them.”
Discover how analyzing product categories can lead to better customer acquisition strategies.
“This comes back to the initial question that Matt asked me that I didn't answer right away.”
Exploration of customer acquisition strategies and their long-term value.
“is probably an underplayed thing in most companies.”
Discussion on the importance of product focus and customer retention strategies.
“Because like, okay, so like use Katie's example.”
Analyzing the relationship between product offerings and customer retention.
“You have to obsess over all of it because a little tiny bit, we're chasing down a retention problem right now.”
Explore how product issues can lead to retention problems.
“like, Curtis, when you're like, hey, I'm somewhere in the middle, you know, that's a tweet.”
Discuss why focusing on product is crucial for retention success.
“he's not, or maybe, maybe they need a new purse or a new style, right?”
Learn strategies for reacquiring customers after they've dropped off.
“I didn't think when I made a leather journal in my garage, we were going to find a$100 billion TAM of women's handbags.”
Delve into the importance of segmenting customers for effective marketing.
“oh, once you have them, you've got them forever.”
Understand the significance of clearly defining customer types for marketing.
“but like tell us just how you guys think about this.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Operators, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Matt Bertulli: Okay, welcome back to the Operator's Pod. Today is all things retention. This is for all of you brands out there who do not have the luxury of tricking people into subscribing things that they don't want. So for the non-consumable people, this is the retention episode. Also, if you are in the consumables, you should listen to this because this is all about how you treat your customers really well. I've got Jason, Katie, and Curtis with me. You're going to want to stick around to the end of this one because Curtis is going to drop some heat on how to think about reacquiring customers. I know this is a hot topic right now in all things.
0:30Matt Bertulli: is meta but stick around and listen to curtis if you are new to this show or if you are just listening to us and you do not subscribe on spotify on youtube please go hit the button subscribe and follow us on whatever channel you're consuming this on it's really good for our egos and we need the love let's get into it i was excited for this because um none of us sell uh consumables right i don't think any of us sell any consumables i guess i'm playing i wish people would eat my pajamas.
0:59Katy Mimari: It would make my job a lot easier.
1:00Matt Bertulli: That would be way better if they ate. Yeah. And Curtis, I'm sure, would wish that people ate his bags. I think we're tensioned. It's like, it's the hottest topic on social right now. Because like all these supplement brands basically like trick people into subscribing. I saw somebody post on this the other day. You're laughing, but it's true. It's like, I have an 85 % subscription taker. And I'm like, you're lying to them. That's why it's 85%. So this is going to be fun because you're all basically like Durables brands. I'm Durables. And we still have to think about lifetime value. We still have to think about retention.
1:40Matt Bertulli: And I thought it would be fun to just have like a conversation about like retention for regular people is what we should call this show. So we're not lying. We just, we make things that people want to buy more of. Yeah, I mean, it's retention for like real brands, not the real D2C companies too, because the supplement companies, I mean, that's just like a different, that's its own vertical. And Katie is different than us in the sense that Katie's apparel, right? I think the three of us are closer together, even though I would argue Portland. Portland Leather is probably closer to us, but still there's, I think there's a bit of a, like you can have a lot of different bags, right?
2:20It's like fashion. That's what's awesome. You know, it's fashion, but like we're not fashion.
2:24Matt Bertulli: You know, we're function. Yeah, I think that's it. It's like fashion and function. Pila is definitely more fashion, but we still, I mean, guys, like I think I've said this before, probably not to you guys, but I think our average customer comes back once every two years or two and a half years. It's like we're sort of married to the phone cycle. So it takes a lot. Now, we have like 5%, 10%, 15 % of customers that treat it like fashion, so they'll buy like 12 cases. You know, like they're just constantly rotating them out. It's very design-driven. But the vast majority of people are like, no, this is a utility.
2:58Matt Bertulli: I'm just going to buy it. It has functioned to me, and I'm never going to buy another one. So maybe a good place to start would be, like, Curtis, let's just start with you because I think you do have the more interesting business and that like your products tend to be like, I buy lots of bags. Cause I think we can contrast that with Katie. People buy many things from you, but for different reasons. So like Curtis, how, how maybe just frame up, like do you put a lot of time into retention? Is it just something you do with product? Like it's the whole game and we're really lucky. Now, a couple of things.
3:32Number one, it's okay to make fun of people in Miami that all they sell is beauty and supplements, right? You go to a dinner table of these direct to consumer people and you know exactly what all 20 of them sell. And they do that because they want to get that lifetime value, that recurring revenue. We kind of lucked out. Here's a post I read this morning. A woman was talking on our insider group about how she bought this bag and she was able to get this rare blue color of a bag. And she's like, I own 116 of their bags, but I have none in this color of blue. I'm sorry,$116? $116. Our average bank costs$120.
4:16We had a woman come to one of our events and say, I'm your biggest customer. And we're like, really? She's like, yeah, I spent$110 ,000 on your bags. And we looked her up and she wasn't in the top 10. So, I mean, they keep coming back. So we have to create a focus, right? This game is in two sides. And we're lucky this way. The first side is how do you get a new customer at a profit, right? We buy new customers at a profit. Number two is what is your return customer orders? What is your return customer rate? And I knew you were going to do this, so I looked it up. So I had actual real numbers here this morning.
4:55And this year, 58 % of our revenue is return customers. Yesterday, it was 63%. In the last month, it was 58%.
5:06Matt Bertulli: Can we all just take a minute and recognize how old Curtis is, picking up a piece of paper to know his retention numbers?
5:13Katy Mimari: He faxed it to me just to brag.
5:17Matt Bertulli: I love that. I probably have, I have paper notes over here too, so Curtis, I'm with you. Katie, how does that compare to what you guys see at Caden Lane? Like what percentage of revenue on a given day is a repeat versus like you're acquiring net new?
5:34Katy Mimari: So ours is 55%. which oh wow so similar yeah and honestly i think it's even higher we have a high amount of gift givers that purchase from us and so a gift giver is coming for one-time purchase but they're buying for somebody else that is technically right like a repeat purchase like they're giving it to a mom that's coming back so there's not a whole lot of ways for us to track that we really watch it with just our direct traffic. But, um, but yeah, we like Curtis, we, we obsess over it. Um, and mine's kind of cool, Matt, because like the kids, so ours is it's apparel, like Jason said. So it is a bit of like seasonality and then buying new things like Curtis's.
6:15Katy Mimari: I also have the advantage of my customer sizing up. So every year, right. So I think, yeah, but same thing. I mean, we, we obsess over retention. Yeah.
6:28Matt Bertulli: And Jason, I'm going to suspect you're much closer to Pila. So what, with HexCloud, what percentage of revenue, I guess you can only really talk about D2C, but what percentage of revenue is a returning customer? At any point in time, it's around 20%, I would say. Wow. That's a rough number. And, you know, I look at it in terms of the overall cohort LTV, and our best cohorts get to 50 % up off of AOV. Those are our best cohorts. Okay, so day one AOV, it increases 50 % over time.
7:03Katy Mimari: Jason, I'll trade you your AOV for my return customer rate. Yeah, and actually, don't quote me on the return customer rate. I'll have to double-check that because I really focus more on the AOV to LTV aspect of it. And it changes over time, too, because, you know, we we have obviously, you know, we have our hero acquisition products. And then we're always, you know, we're dropping a lot of new products over more so than we did years back. You know, we have a pretty good cadence of sort of smaller new products. And when we launch the ratio changes and then it flips back. So I'll have to I'll have to do a look back over time and see where we're at these days.
7:40Matt Bertulli: You're bringing up interesting point, Jason. Like years ago, I started to look at like cohorts for Pila. um i stopped doing that largely because i wasn't making any decisions around the cohorts like so i went back to this just like straight up what percentage of my revenue is coming in from returning and i think on pila uh we're about a good a good place to be is like 62 to 67 percent of revenue on any given day is from a new customer like um and if it's not if it was lower than that I could tell you that our business was going to slow down growth just because like our repeat rates are like the time to the second purchase is just so long.
8:22Matt Bertulli: So we kind of like you, Jason, like we sort of always need to be in like hunt mode and go get more, go get newer. Um, and man, we have tried to like, we have tried to get sort of like every cohort to buy more. So I think if I haven't looked at it recently, but I think if you were to look at like day one AOV to 12 months, I think we might only get like 15 to 25 % lift on that value in the same year. Everybody knows I love Northbeam. Been a Northbeam customer from the beginning, from literally the minute I got to Hexclad. Now there's something new that Northbeam has launched that we are super excited about.
9:06Northbean Apex lets you optimize your ad delivery on Meta against your cross-channel Northbean data. For a brand like Hexclad, that's huge. It means that Meta can target our customers more accurately and more efficiently than it can do on its own. Across ad platforms and purchases, all it takes is a few buttons in Northbean. It's so easy to set up. It's a no-brainer. Friends of the show, like Kitsch, are finding double-digit improvements in their meta ROAS using Apex. Northbeam is always ahead of the game. This is no different. If you want to beat your competition, go book a demo and tell them that the operators sent you.
9:45So like Curtis, I'm with you.
9:48Matt Bertulli: I have to acquire a customer profitably. Like I have to. Oh, you have to. And the juxtaposition here is it used to be, if you've been in business for a long time like I have, It's always the fight between customer service and marketing, right? Marketing is like, my job is to sell and customer service. Like, you can't say that. Our customers are pissed off. Like, there's always a difference there. Our fight in our company is between new customers and return customers. Because you have to focus so much energy on that. We have new SKUs coming out every Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday, okay?
10:24Those are new colors, new products, new launches, new everything. And we need that to keep that returning customer revenue up while the marketing who just says, hey, give me the same bag and the same color, never run out of that. I need these ad sets. I need these hero products. And it really is a fight for these lines behind me. It's like, no, no, no, no, no. I want more of these hero products. I just, nothing but this is to get me. We have, we'll get about 880 ,000 new customers this year, right? That's kind of the number we're on track to hit. Okay. We need the exact bags for those people. But the ecosystem of return customers is much deeper.
11:07It's more colors. It's more bags, more variety of it's more unicorns. It's more unique. And it's a pain in the ass. So you have to balance this stuff to get where we're at.
11:15Matt Bertulli: I would have actually and Katie, I'm curious to hear how this changes for you, but I would have ventured Curtis with PLG that new and weird would acquire new customers. And what you're what I'm hearing is that like, no, There's like bread and butter, like shapes, colors, like this is where we acquire. And then new and weird is where we get returned. Katie, is it the same at Caden Lane? Like, or is it new prints, new patterns, new and weird gets you new customers?
11:42Katy Mimari: Yeah, I think it's both, right? Like we, we track down our retention even based on product type. Like we really look at what is the customer's first purchase and then what are they most likely to buy next? So like the journey of it. Um, but same with Curtis. I mean, we do two launches a week. If you look at a retention rate, just on like when we launched Christmas pajamas, it'll skyrocket into the 80 % because that's a great way for customers to come back. But we also look at certain launches as a way to acquire new customers. But like what Curtis is saying, there's like your BAU products, right?
12:18Katy Mimari: That, you know, like I know every new mom's goodbye, something pink for a girl and something blue for a boy, But her second purchase may be a different color or a different print. And I definitely think we both have the benefit of being able to use frequent launches to give a customer a reason to come back. Like we roadmap out our entire purchasing behavior of our customer. And then we purposely will put in flows mimicking it. So like, what does she buy when she's pregnant? And then what does she buy? What does a three month old need? What does a six month old need? What is a nine month old need?
12:52Katy Mimari: So we're really strategically planning the purchasing calendar of our customers.
12:59Matt Bertulli: That's actually really smart to look at what would be a typical buying journey of a customer. And then do I have product at every stage of that journey in the categories I want to be in? Curtis, do you guys do something similar to that? Or is it straight up like we just know that there's collectors? The buying behavior is like I collect. It's a balance between the collector and what is easy for us to do, right? Because it's more complicated than that. We have unicorns at the store. Let me explain what a unicorn is. A unicorn is we buy a little amount, like 1 ,000 square foot of a leather, rather than 500 ,000 square foot of that, right?
13:39And we make it in different bags and we send it to the stores, right? People will line up on Wednesdays and Saturdays, 100 people deep to get into the store to have a chance to get one of those rare bags. They're a pain in the s*** to make. I would much rather make one brown bag and make 500 ,000 of it on this line, but it creates the excitement. So then you have unicorn web days where we sell 15 ,000 unicorns, but everybody can do it. And we tell them they're more rare. You're going to get this. it's balancing what makes it real how can the manufacturing make that efficiently at the right time put in the skews ship it to your 3pl get it ready do the marketing have people buy it compared to just mass making the main bags that everybody does it's not easy everybody like we're talking to people who are listening to this like we think oh just do this do the return customers and do this.
14:38Katie's had to live this thing for a decade in the minds of these people figuring this out. That's how she got to the flow. It's how do we get the next one? And what is the real cost of trying to make these specialty things? Sometimes you, Katie, you've done it. I'm sure Jason's done this. Matt, I'm sure you've done it. You said, this is a great idea. We'll make this batch of it. You're like, oh, those are just sitting there. That's a loss. It took us design time, skew time, all this stuff. And now we got to get rid of this product. Curtis, you're right.
15:08Katy Mimari: Like, it's how we think about even product expansion. Like, how do we make sure that we're there when she thinks of our customers, you know, primarily female, when she needs something else, we're thinking about her buying behavior. And when we know she's going to need something else, how do we fill it? I mean, Jason, I feel like HexCloud's doing it with like your salt and pepper shakers and your like all of these accessories, right? Well, we've been trying to broaden it out because the kitchen is a perfect place. There's so much in the kitchen. We want to own the kitchen. We should be able to own the kitchen at some point.
15:44That's our strategy. It's like, what can we do that's innovative and differentiated and sell it to you in the kitchen? Our pepper mill was a differentiator. Even our knives, it's hard to innovate on knives, right? They've been around for millennia. But we made our knives super nice and we used Japanese Damascus steel. And we just did our bakeware. And our bakeware is really special because it's really the only coated bakeware that really, really works. Most bakeware doesn't have a coating. and some other cookware companies, they've done bakeware with ceramic coating and it just doesn't work well.
16:23It doesn't heat correctly. The ceramic coating gets too hot. It burns the bottom of your cookies. So if you go to some of the other D2C brands, their bakeware all sucks and took us three years to do it, like millions of cookies. You know, like we finally, we almost killed the project. We almost weren't going to do it. I mean, seriously, we just weren't going to do it if it wasn't good enough. And our bakeware, it's actually heavy. It's actually a lot. Like when you pick up our sheet, our baking sheet, you're like, oh, it's kind of heavy. you know you may not like that but that's why it works great i love talking to a marketing sales dude he's like you know what the real world is other people suck and our product is this and this and this and this and that's the only way to look at it but i'll tell you that phrase we want
17:03Katy Mimari: to own the kitchen i think it's where brand is important jason like what what hex clad's got is that if i'm cooking on hex clad and my knives are dull you want me to think like i need new knives and I'm going to go to HexCloud to see if you sell knives, right? Like, or you're going to try to map out like, you know, your customer's purchasing journey. Danny always talks about like when he was a kid, his dad, if they needed to buy electronics, they just bought Sony, right? Because they knew Sony back then was going to be great. And that's the way we look at it at HexCloud. We just want to be Sony in the kitchen.
17:41You just know, oh, I need something for my, it's like back in the day when you went to buy tools, right? You bought Stanley or Craftsman. That's it. You didn't buy any other brand. I'm going to buy the Stanley or the Craftsman tools because I know they're the best.
17:52Katy Mimari: I think that's so smart. And for people like just starting off brands right now, don't pigeonhole yourself into one product and obsess over it because I learned the hard way early on. Like I just thought, oh my God, this one product is just going to crush it. And I I didn't consider what she was going to buy next. So I was literally prepping my customer to hand her off to my competition. And it's an expensive lesson to learn. You don't think about it at the beginning, right? Over the past six months, I have spent literally tens of billions of tokens. And one of the things I've worked on the most has been building an analytics foundation for our business.
18:33And you know what all of that has taught me? is that unless you have someone that is a psychopathic nerd that's willing to go in the weeds for months and think really deeply about every aspect of APIs and structure for your analytics, that you should be going and buying from a provider who's doing it for you. What I like to say is that just because I can make a burrito doesn't mean I'm going to stop eating at Chipotle, and neither should you. You should be buying from someone who every day is putting in the work and gathering the context of how to do this with excellence like Sarah's Analytics.
19:05Stop building custom pipelines and start making better business decisions. Head to Sarah's Analytics dot com today to start your free trial.
19:15Matt Bertulli: I want to go back to Jason. You said you've been working on the bakeware for years. How long? Just I'm curious. People are going to be curious. Probably two and a half years to get it right. Yeah. But we knew we needed, you know, we really wanted to do it. It sometimes bothers me when I see some of the other D2C cookware brands, like just their ability to launch stuff so fast. It's like, why are we so bad at this? But the reality is we're just really obsessive about the product. We really are. Yeah. And I think that, but that's, that's, again, that's how you become the Sony of cookware, right?
19:51Matt Bertulli: It's like you, is that level of obsession and detail. Do you guys, Jason, I got a question for you though. Your approach to product development, is it always that you have to find a way to make the product different than other places? Like, is that, is it always like we need to make it more functionally beneficial to the customer and that's why it takes so long? It's like you're actually chasing some level of innovation? That's absolutely our mantra internally. Like, I can't think of a single thing that we've launched that isn't like in some way differentiated. Like even our aprons, which is aprons are not a great business, but they're made out of this fabric called RPET.
20:28It's like 32 recycled plastic bottles. Those are our aprons, right? So it's got to have a differentiated story. And otherwise, we're just not going to do it. And Curtis, I feel like you have a different approach. I'm going to say what I hate about Jason right now. Those bastards, they own the hexagon, right? I mean, literally, they own that shape. It's in their freaking name, right? So they're like, that's the stability. Oh, look, we put this hexagon pattern on there. You know who it is. Now you differentiate yourself and you say you're better. Damn, that's good. That, I mean, literally, hey, we all luck out a little bit, right?
21:09We really do in this business. Maybe not Katie. She just works her ass off all the time. But I lucked out. I didn't expect a TAM this big. And they said, hex clad, that's really good. No, we're going to own the hexagon. People are going to be in the kitchen. And if it has that pattern on it, they're going to now think, oh, it's a great company. And now that they own quality, anything else they put in there, son of a bitch, that's good, Jason. Like you've got a road in front of you. That's amazing. Okay. Now you had a question. I'm sorry, Matt.
21:38Matt Bertulli: Yeah, Curtis, I want to, so like Katie's talked about like this, the buyer journey, Jason, you want to own the kitchen. Curtis, what's your version of those two things with your product then? Like, cause this is, this is basically how retention works. You have to have like, we're going to get retention by being blah. Like, what's the PLG version of that? If you watch the operators now, I think on the marketing side, occasionally there's going to be this jerk named McCoy Merkley on there. He's my CMO and he's a cocky son of a... And I always end up quoting him, right? I like to be the smart one, but he said, our best marketing is getting our product in people's hands.
22:22and i'm like oh that's really good like we know that when they get the leather and they're like wait it smells like leather it looks like leather it feels i've worn it for a couple months it's better than it was that's really the thing that we have so our thing is let's get new customers and we set a number like last year we were going to get 550 000 this year we're going to get 880 thousand, right? We'll know what we're going to do next year, probably about 1.2 to 1.25 million new customers. Once you have that path of here's how we get those new customers, then you say, how do we continue to feed this beast of return customers all of these styles and colors and newness and fun and interest that they want to do?
23:08So that's the entire path. We did the heavy lifting in the first five years. We got the right product that we found out that people liked. Same thing with Hexclad. They got the right product that people like. It's the same thing with yours. Hey, it's the right pelicase. Hey, it's the right kids. My kids love these pajamas. Everybody, that's the first part. Those first five years of your company, everybody. Get the right product that people love and keep making it better. Once you got that, then the rest of this you can build.
23:37Matt Bertulli: Go ahead, Katie.
23:38Katy Mimari: Curtis makes a good point. Well, McCoy made a really good point. Curtis stole it.
23:44Matt Bertulli: I was going to say, Katie, Does it pain you to say that Curtis makes a good point?
23:47Katy Mimari: Yeah, it pains me. I'm like, as soon as Curtis takes a breath, I'm going to come in. So the point was, is that getting it in your hands. And I think that it's important to say that like retention just isn't about like having another product to sell them. It's also how you reach them. And you can't just depend on email and SMS. You know, what Curtis McCoy did by opening up stores probably increased their retention rate alone. I mean, maybe not, Curtis, but I think people walking by your store, it brings you to top of mind. They may not have needed another color of their leather bag, but there is something about them seeing it or going and seeing it in Nordstrom or going and seeing it in another retailer like with Hexclad.
24:36Katy Mimari: If I own one pan and then I go to Costco and I see their baking goods like that, you know, having other channels is a great way to increase your retention. I think Target's going to be a huge retention play for us. So so when you say getting in your hand, Curtis, like you're talking about their first order that they're receiving and then they're more likely to come back and buy. Or do you not think your brick and mortar was a play for retention? I didn't think it was at first, but we luck out. Okay. Hey, everybody that's watching this pod, we've all lucked out like more than you can frickin' imagine.
25:09Like we really have. Curtis, I love that you say that. Let me just double click on it because this is the second time you did it. I totally agree. I've been saying this forever. The harder you work, the luckier you get. But we got lucky, but we also put ourselves in a position to be lucky. And we also took advantage of the luck, right? We also executed on the luck and not everyone does that. So give us a little credit. It's not all luck. There's a lot of skill. I try to be humble every now and then. It's rare, but you're going to catch up on it. Guys, we set up the stores. Our statistics on our stores are now, we have 19 stores.
25:45We'll have 55 by the end of 2028. And we have found out that someone who's first purchased in a store, actually their next purchase comes more quickly and their LTG is higher than online.
26:00Matt Bertulli: I mean, Curtis, we heard that from Sunil at ShopLC, right? Is that his stat was, it blew my freaking mind.
26:09Katy Mimari: LTV was like three times higher, Matt. No, it wasn't even that.
26:12Matt Bertulli: It was like, it was actually, it was like orders of magnitude higher. So, Curtis, their view, their data, because they have like, they run shopping television, they've got DTC, they've got all these different channels. channels and what they found was that a customer who buys in all the channels is worth like 25 times or like many many orders of magnitude more than a customer who just bought in a single channel so I'm actually not surprised to hear you say that with your stores and I do think that I think Katie you are right that being in more places of capture like more distribution channels so like you build the brand you build brand equity and you have to have places for that that brand equity to turn into cash right those are points of sale i think having more points of sale as you take product out like adding bakeware for hex clad absolutely is what spins that damn flywheel like it all it all makes sense to me and how each of you has like actually done this you know what pila we uh a number that would always terrify me is if in any given month the percentage of orders coming in so post-purchase survey it's not perfect but if post-purchase survey data showed that our percentage of orders in a month, if 35 % or less was not from word of mouth, I started to panic.
27:30Matt Bertulli: Like I actually got like, I'm like, oh, we screwed something up. Or we were trying to go too fast on paid. Like we were just, we were pushing hard in the wrong direction. Cause like that was another one of those numbers that like were, were most profitable if we're at least 35 % of our orders are coming from a person who heard about them from a friend.
27:50Katy Mimari: When you looked at that number and you saw it lower, what was the number one thing that drove that?
27:54Matt Bertulli: It was probably because we were pushing too hard on paid acquisition. So I was like overpaying for customers somewhere else. And again, I was just like optimizing for like when did the financials look best? And it was always when we had this like guaranteed, like the whole put the product in the customer's hand. You know, we don't have great LTV in the core case category, but we have amazing word of mouth. so as long as we don't like try to outrun the word of mouth the business is really good and that was like so we put a weird amount of effort into every touch point leading up to the person getting the product like right down to like you got the package uh and when i say effort most of that effort was just in like reinforcing the reasons that the person bought in the first place.
28:42Matt Bertulli: So like all of the on brand, you're buying a mission, like you're a good human. We would just sort of hammer that through. And my, our theory with that was that if I can't win on a person buying a lot more, I am going to win on giving them the stories that they can hand over to somebody else and convince somebody else to buy.
29:02Katy Mimari: But shouldn't we be obsessing just as much over what else can we sell to our customers. We're spending so much money.
29:11Matt Bertulli: Yeah, no, we screwed that part up. We did not launch enough product fast enough. They're now doing it. They're following in Ridge's footsteps and they're adding more product categories. PostScript 2.0 is the AI retention platform built for Shopify brands. And AI is the product, not the feature. Unified profiles. Every subscriber is one person across SMS, email, and orders so the AI works from the full picture, not a fragment. One-to-one experiences. Instead of messaging to a segment, each customer gets their own message, timing, and offer. Infinity testing that never stops. Copy timing offers sends all running continuously and compounding so every send is better than the last.
29:55The point isn't automation for its own sake. It's incremental revenue you weren't getting before. Go to postscript.io for retention that runs itself. I just got hit with one of these. I can see how that would have closed me with an upsell. It was like hitting me with an upsell. Like, I absolutely knew I didn't want this upsell, but I could totally see how this would close people. It was insane. I think that we miss, uh, the concept to people who are watching these podcasts, who are like, wow, they said this, so if I do this, I'm gonna be successful. the main thing is being unafraid to mess up like you're going to mess up you have to taking action means you're going to mess up that means you learn something mess up again and again and again and the the reason that a bunch of weirdos like me and and everybody else are successful in this is because since we were young we were people who were unafraid to like push forward it's there have been studies that show that people who are very, very good at school and very, very smart at certain things, they don't like to do things that they're going to mess up.
31:08They don't want to take a test. They're not going to get an A in, right? Does that make sense? So they're like, hey, do you want to start a business and do this? I don't know. Is it a guaranteed success? Well, no. Well, I don't want to do it. And you've got to be a little bit crazy and say, okay, yeah, everyone thinks this is wrong. I'm going to do it. Everybody said this was a stupid idea. everybody told me, look, I made a little journal in a garage. I said the first day I'm going to make a$100 million company. And they're like, this is the stupidest thing you've ever said. And I said, you, I will show you.
31:41And then I made every mistake in the business. We've all done that.
31:46Katy Mimari: I agree. I think also, Curtis, as marketers and operators, if our daily job doesn't feel like whack-a-mole, we're not trying enough things, right?
31:56Matt Bertulli: This is true. This is true. That's our personality there, Katie. Let's just be honest on that. I think you're both right. Like the, when I'm hearing like you guys talk about launching new products and at the pace that you both do it, because you were both like weekly drop people, Pila's also weekly drop people. Like it's just, it's a huge contrast to how Hexclad does things. But the pace at which you do that, like you are just throwing it against the wall. Like there is some thought that goes into it. But it is also like, I don't know. I can't tell you how many times my team came to me on Pila sudden was like hey we're gonna do this collection and here's the designs and I'm like that's so stupid like why are we like why are you spending time on this and then it'll turn out to be like our best seller you know like uh I think two years ago they're like we're gonna put little fruits on a case and I'm like why like that what like why are we wasting designers times it's like number one selling design for like 12 months and it made no friggin sense and I'm like okay well I guess they just have to try stuff.
32:54Matt Bertulli: What I want to know from each of you, and Curtis, maybe I'll go with you first, is do you make product that you think this is a great acquisition product? And when I say great acquisition, I mean it's going to lead to more customers later, right? It's not cheapest to acquire, but it gets me the best quality customer. Yes and no. that's a little more on spend after we do it. So we have what are called superheroes. Superheroes are like, these are the four bags you just, you know, a good product, you know, it's going to make you$1.5 million in revenue. So, okay, it's actually called a slow runner for us.
33:38A good, a superhero will sell 500 ,000 bags, right? So there's the difference on that. We know which ones have the best chance in next year. We have four that are pegged. They have the best chance to be a hero product. So before we do it, we have to make a lot more of those and have them ready because you can't, even as us, we can't make them fast enough. We're going to have videos ready. We're going to have them ready for affiliates going to TikTok. We're going to have them on Amazon. We're going to have them in the store for a launch. We're going to have them on the e-com. And then we're going to build them up and we're going to hit them with ad sets right out of the gate.
34:14Now, for us, they have certain things inside of them. that bag is not the most expensive one. It has to have a certain price level so people are more able to click that right off the thing. Our number one leather bags that are our heroes sell for 99 bucks. And if you make them 120, they're not a hero because you can't capture that meta Instagram,
34:38Matt Bertulli: TikTok traffic as well. I want to push on this because Katie, and then Jason, I want to get your take on this too. Katie, you said that you guys actually look at LTV by the first product category that a person buys.
34:51Katy Mimari: Right.
34:52Matt Bertulli: Right. And now obviously you have like this natural, hey, if I get them at newborn, maybe I keep them longer. But then are there are there actually products where you're like, no, like these are our best LTV product categories and they actually don't make a lot of sense on paper. But this is a kind of customer or a buying behavior that I get where if I can get them to buy this first, then they will buy more later. Oh, yeah.
35:18Katy Mimari: Yeah. I mean, I would say we have over actively over 20 or 30 customer cohorts that we track their buying behavior based off of their first purchase. And we advertise on meta to them accordingly. So and then we also have products that we know they're just going to buy one time. Right. And that no matter what, until they come back in the like, we've got to try to sell them on a product that's going to lead to another. yeah I think there's a lot of uh opportunity in really studying what products drive next products
35:52Matt Bertulli: Jason like hex clad like do you guys because I remember years ago we were talking about this on the show dude where one of the challenges was like you got such a high AOV high margin product in the cookware that you're like what the hell do I sell them next uh that's like meaningful to the business right do you have you looked now at all the products that hex cloud has is there a product category when you acquire a customer to that product category that that's your best ltv cohort of a customer you know we struggled for a long time with the the issue of having like a high aov hero product that we put spend behind to acquire customers and for the long for many years we believed that was the only way to acquire customers because we had to have that high AOV so that we can support a CAC that's good enough to perform well and succeed.
36:50Recently, in the last year, we noticed that with certain products that were lower priced, lower AOV, lower priced products, that we could run acquisition funnels on them. and the order value wound up being pretty good. So that was really helpful. But in terms of just, you know, is there a product that gets people coming back to buy something else? I really don't know. It's a good question. I'm going to go check on that. I'm not sure.
37:25Matt Bertulli: I think what Katie does is worthwhile for you to look into because maybe it'll surprise you. It might be that like when people buy the pepper mill.
37:33Katy Mimari: I'm going to tell Jason how to do his job. Can I do that? Yeah, I love this. My goal is to work less, okay? I want to just work less. I work too much. So please help me out. You, Jason, you are missing a massive opportunity and creating product that you don't need to think about what the CAC is for it. You should be literally designing product that doesn't have a$300 AOV. It's just product. You have this ginormous customer base that is very easy to access through email, SMS, whatever. I mean, those are the two easiest ones. Right. And if you just show them like, you know, I don't know. I love HexCloud.
38:14Katy Mimari: I would I would buy really great dish towels if you had like high design ones, like things that are impulse buy that you don't need to acquire customers with. But what if I just come back every six months and I spend$60 with you? Add that up. And you didn't just increase the cost of your customer acquisition with me because all you did was send me an email or an SMS and you had a reason to do it. And you don't have to go in big. Like, you don't have to go in big. I feel like you can test this so easy. We keep saying it on this show. Straight percentage off is lazy. The best holiday offers don't just add orders.
38:52they grow the order. That's why operators run AfterSell at Ridge, Hexclad, Pila, Trevi, and more. Cart rewards, one-click post-purchase upsells, and subscription upgrades grow every order without blanket discounts. The numbers. Hexclad adds about$5 per transaction, and Pila drove $80 ,000 in six months from traffic they'd already paid for. Rocked Thanks turns the thank you page into pure profit. With earn and save, Aftersell matches those earnings on your bill and you keep the payout so the whole platform can run at zero per month. Check them out at aftersell.com slash operators. This comes back to the initial question that Matt asked me that I didn't answer right away.
39:38We have all these new products. He said, hey, are there some that work better, you know, and then you realize you can spend more money on it? Yes. So what we found out is, first of all, a wallet, just a wallet selling to somebody is the same LTV as a bag, as most bags, right? So it doesn't matter what they buy first, they're going to buy. But there are two, our mystery box and our mini crossbody. We've had the mini crossbody for six years. It costs a little bit more to get people to buy it. It's been around so it doesn't have the hype on it. But the LTV on that particular bag is way higher. So every time someone says, hey, we need to be lowering that, we're like, screw that, make more colors, put more money, because the LTV is going to pay that off.
40:24The biggest one is our mystery box. And this idea of why it works came to me from this beauty supply DTC seller. He said, if they sell them one thing for their face, it's like this chance. if they sell them a bundle of like five products, if they buy one and they don't like it, they'll never come back. If they buy a bundle of five and they like two of them, they'll realize it's a good brand and come back. So we sell them this mystery box that has six to eight items in it. That's our largest LTV.
40:56Matt Bertulli: I think this is an underplayed thing, guys. And Jason, I keep thinking of, I don't know why I keep coming back to your Peppermill thing because it's such an interesting, it's a cool product. Like it's a very good product, right? And like, I wonder if you looked at like people who bought just that as the first purchase, what is the lifetime value? What is that cohort of customer? And if you were to, it's like, okay, well then how do I get more of those? Maybe that customer is like, oh, 85 % of them come back and buy the cookware afterwards.
41:24Katy Mimari: But he might not be first purchase profitable on that.
41:27Matt Bertulli: But that's what I mean. Like if you don't look at the first purchase and as a, so like everybody thinks of cohorts and consumer as when they bought. So like most brands look at cohorts by month, by week, by day. And like, how do they age? Right now we're recording this. It's like a month before Black Friday. Guaranteed all the content online is going to be about like, how profitable are your Black Friday cohorts? It's like, okay, but by product, what Katie is doing in her business, by product category, first purchase, which one leads to best quality customers is probably an underplayed thing in most companies.
42:04Katy Mimari: Matt, you know that our lowest LTV customer is acquired during Black Friday?
42:09Matt Bertulli: That doesn't shock me at all.
42:11Katy Mimari: Yeah. But how many brands out there, like, their entire year is, like, planned around, like, Q4, and then maybe the quality of the customer you're acquiring right there isn't as profitable long-term or as valuable as one that you're acquiring? I don't know. I just, it's so many ways to look at it. Like what you're saying, like I, why would you not have different product categories where you're obsessing over the value, the long-term value of that customer? Or is it just a volume play?
42:40Matt Bertulli: I think if you're a hex clad and you take the amount of care and thoughtfulness that they put into their product, right? To me, it's like, if you're going to put that amount of effort into to making a badass product. Because Katie, you're right. Like every Hexclad product is great. Like Jason, hats off to you guys, like you and Danny and the team. Like they're all awesome. So to me then it's like, okay, well, which one is the best at like getting them, somebody through the door to my brand? Because I know they're all awesome. You know, like if I want to own the kitchen, it's like maybe I just need them to buy some knives first.
43:13Katy Mimari: Jason, have you ever looked at like, is your customer the one that buys like the big, like five piece package? 12 piece set. Okay, 12-piece set, Jesus Christ. Whatever your big package is, is that customer more valuable because their first purchase was larger? Or do you actually, like, a customer comes in and first buys, like, I don't know, a frying pan and, like, slowly kind of collects and builds up her HexCloud collection? Does she have more dedication to HexCloud because she's coming back? I don't know. Do you track those separately? Well, here's the crazy thing about our business. Like, these are all amazing questions and things that I want to go do and understand.
43:56Katy Mimari: But Jason doesn't know the answer to that. No, no, no. Well, here's why. But here's why. I have an excuse. Here's why. We sold so many 12-piece sets, okay, in the last five years that everything else was in the noise. There's only so much you can focus on, okay? We literally just, that's our hero product. That's our acquisition. When you think about it, it's just the dynamic of cooking, right? We gave you all the essentials and we got you to spend$699 on it. So our laser-like focus has been and still very much is on selling you that and then just layering in retention after. Dropping new products and trying to keep selling you new products.
44:40But the idea of, okay, using something else as an acquisition product and seeing whether that's more valuable, it was just very, very clear that the 12-piece set acquisition product model, and if you didn't buy that, and you bought a six-piece set for$3.99, those were the two. We're very fortunate. Talk about the lock and the structure. There's a lot of things that suck about being a cookware company. People only buy it once. It's a high product. It's hard to sell in a retail store because it's a 20-pound, 40-pound box. There are a lot of things that suck. But one of the things that's great is that when you hook someone, they're probably going to make a big purchase.
45:20Matt Bertulli: Yeah, I totally get why you guys did that, Jason. I really do. I also get how the LTV math now on somebody who bought a$699 product is kind of weird math. Because like, okay, so like use Katie's example. They come back now and they spend 60 bucks. It's like, whoop-de-doo. You know, like, thanks for the$4 more. You know, so it's and because it's such a high AOV first purchase, your volume of customers, sheer quantity is going to be lower than like, let's say, Curtis or Katie, where their first purchase price might be sub$100. Right. So like you, if you're if somebody's listening to this.
46:01Katy Mimari: What you just I just did. I got my calculator out. Your pink calculator, by the way. Look, I don't understand. Hold on.
46:10Matt Bertulli: I can't believe you have a calculator when you're on like a supercomputer.
46:14Katy Mimari: Shut up and listen for a second. Why would Jason, you guys are like, I'm going to acquire a bazillion new customers this year. Both of y 'all. Why would you not want to sell them another$60? Like, do the math.
46:29Matt Bertulli: No, no, no. I'm just saying I understand the focus challenge that Jason's talking about. No, I just figured this out. When Jason was talking, he said something that just like hit in my head. He's got this big company. He's like, you can't focus on everything. Katie and I, we are very much alike that we have a superpower and we try to focus on everything. She runs every little aspect of her company like crazy. Guess what? I do the same thing. Jason's like, oh, really? Well, I got this big million dollar company here and here's what I do here. And we're scrambling like, how can we get more out of that?
47:04So he's right in a way and we're right in a way that, hey, I'm looking at every aspect. I always say I have 1 ,500 employees, 38 divisions. I know every one of those divisions. I walk into a meeting in every single one of those and I try to fix everything. Now, maybe someday I'll join the big white club where I'll actually step away and not do that. And then I'm like, remember when I I tried to focus on everything. That sure was stupid. But right now, I'm like, pull every lever I possibly can. HexCloud is over half a billion a year in revenue now, and I don't think we could have gotten there without Fulfill.
47:42Coming in as CFO in 2020, one of the first things I did was figure out how to get our hands around ops, inventory management, demand planning, distribution. I did not feel confident in NetSuite, so we decided to onboard Fulfill. Not only did it replace our spreadsheets with one system that tracks everything down to the zip code, but it scaled with us as we grew from two fulfillment centers to close to 10 and expanded into Canada, Mexico, Japan, Australia, all over Europe, and China. On top of that, Fulfill's MCP has been monumental. It gives us a 360-degree view across every 3PL so we can spot slowdowns and fix problems before they hit our customers.
48:22Big dogs like Grunz, Comfort, Cuts, Ridge, and Hexclad use Fulfill as their ERP. Go check them out at Fulfill.io and tell them that Jason from the operators and more importantly, Hexclad sent you.
48:38Katy Mimari: Matt, I want to add something to what Curtis said because I think it's important for people listening too because they're not in Jason's, right? You have to obsess over all of it because a little tiny bit, we're chasing down a retention problem right now. and trying to figure out, because our return customer rate is there and it's not dipped at all, but the volume of it has. And that's a new customer acquisition problem, right? Like filling the funnel and making sure you still have the volume of people coming back. At scale, little things really do add up. And I think Curtis has a point. You have to obsess over every single little thing.
49:14Katy Mimari: When I got my calculator out and I did the math, it was$48 million that Jason would have added just by selling the customers he's going to acquire this year a$60 thing. Like, you know, little things.
49:26Matt Bertulli: Maybe, maybe. And like, can I push back? This is what I want to push back on. The math in, so in a business, when you have a$500 to$1 ,000 upfront first purchase value, like Katie, you have made this point before. When you look at the quantity of customers that you acquire on Black Friday compared compared to hex clad quantity of customers, you acquire a load more of them. So if you do the math on it, when you get six or$700 out of a customer on day one, and let's say like, let's just shrink the numbers down and you get a thousand customers. Okay. All thousand aren't going to go spend an extra 60 bucks.
50:08Matt Bertulli: 60 of them might. And when you look at the dollar amounts, these are actually like in Jason's defense, when he says, we focused on the main thing because the main thing was so big and so lucrative, right? The dollar amounts to go get distracted by something else, those little things actually in HexCloud's case, I would argue, Katie and Curtis, they don't fucking matter. They didn't for a long time because putting an extra 40 bucks into that customer is a waste of time if he could put his effort into acquiring more people at the$700. That's my defense of the HexCloud focus. Jason? Well, you're absolutely right, but also in my defense of like we're calling Jason lazy here for the last five minutes, okay?
50:52You know, I obsessed over Hexnit for five years straight, okay? I started working at Hexnit in June of 2020, and I unpacked Box. I packed Boxes and unloaded containers during COVID when our warehouse staff was down, okay? So I did everything at the company. But at some point that doesn't scale guys. And we are a company. I'm trying to scale our business. Curtis is a machine and he's in founder mode and he's completely obsessed with doing that. Katie, you are the same. You two are like really impressive people. Like you both are so similar in the sense that you guys have so much energy. It's like insane.
51:28Katy Mimari: Well, we're half your age, Jason. Yeah, right. Exactly. Yeah. So I have the metabolic age of a 41-year-old, just so you know. All right? But no, Matt, you're right. It's like we try to stay big picture. We talk about big picture and little picture. But things change and things evolve. And I can see our business now and a lot of the things that you guys are talking about between looking at the LTV of his customer who bought a certain product and also just getting more small hits. We're doing all that. I mean, certainly if you look at our product catalog, it has expanded, you know, tremendously.
52:08And like our aprons are not a high priced product, but it's just like in our space, it's like, you know, the buying pattern of stuff for your kitchen, we don't have the velocity that. No, that Caden Lane has.
52:25Matt Bertulli: It's a slow, it's a slow turnover room in the home. Whereas like, if you look at a closet, that's a high turnover room.
52:33Katy Mimari: But I immediately think about like, what if he unlocks an entire huge customer segment of gift givers like during their wedding and they're adding wedding registry items?
52:42Matt Bertulli: But I think they already do that. I think that if you were to look at his repeat rates, I bet you a lot of people, like they buy it for themselves. And then the buying behavior that drives people back to Hexclad to buy more product before he expanded categories, I would venture to say it's likely gift givers. It is. Yeah, very giftable product. We have a lot of gifts. I mean, you know, I know people, they bought themselves a set and they bought five family members a set. Like we, you know, we heard that all the time. So I think that like that, the lifetime value of a customer, you have to sort of break it up into behavior, which Katie, I think is like what you and Curtis are describing in your business is that you just have different behaviors.
53:17Matt Bertulli: And then what Jason has is a different buying behavior that they have to lean into. I'm in the middle, Matt. I've got to tell you, I've actually, I celebrate what we do because it works, okay? Does that mean that if I had said, we're going to do half the bags, make sure they're in stock, go into more things and do a more simple type of a marketing thing, that might not have worked better? It is possible. I thought about it. But I know that this works. And I'm like, would I really want to cut the new SKUs down? Would I really want to stop that? It's so much energy. People love what's successful.
53:52Well, it's not saying if I didn't cut this down, made it more efficient, changed my cost of goods, increased my channels, I couldn't be more successful. I think about that from time to time. I really do think about, can I simplify the whole thing just down a little bit and it actually grows faster because of it?
54:11Katy Mimari: Your ads can scale overnight. Your support can't. Every BFCM orders jump, backlogs grow, and replies slow, even with temps. A first-time buyer waiting two days for reply might never come back. Imagine support that keeps up. It answers like your best agent in your brand's voice 24-7 for less per ticket than an offshore agent. That's Rich Panel 2.0. They move your data, they set up AI, and they train your team. You're up and running in two weeks. Ridge, Mudwater, Lomi, and Pila Case, they all use them. So does Plateful, Rosabella, and my brand, Caden Lane. They guarantee AI solves 50 % of your tickets in 30 days or your money back.
54:51Katy Mimari: Handle BFCM without another hiring scramble and book a demo at richpanel.com backslash demo. You know what?
55:00Matt Bertulli: Listen, we all ask it, right? Like I think that the grass is greener sort of thinking of like, and as an entrepreneur, you're always wondering like, is there characteristics of my business or Jason's or Katie's that I could take and apply to mine? The reality is though, and the reason I love, by the way, I love doing podcast and long form content like this is that the reality is that in business, there's so many ways to win that you need to look at the nuance of things. Like everybody's company here is like on paper can look very similar, but the nuance is what matters. This is why I hate Twitter and Twitter advice.
55:38Matt Bertulli: And I'm like, I'm sorry, like three or four or 500 characters of advice is not good. It's not. It's like, and it only works, like goes viral, only works because you make a polarizing statement. Like the only way to sell is like that's that type of content is not helpful. And I think that this type of content is actually helpful because you get into the nuance of like what makes a business work. like, Curtis, when you're like, hey, I'm somewhere in the middle, you know, that's a tweet. It really is. It's like, could be this, could be that. It depends. Like, it's a piece of content to put out.
56:18Katy Mimari: Matt, we think of it as like, to us, I think about like, write down the moment that your customer is going to need you next. And if you can't think of that moment, like, if you can't think of when will my customer or need me next. My gut is, is you don't have a retention problem. You have a product problem because you should be solving that with product. But what Curtis is saying is that his retention, he's not, or maybe, maybe they need a new purse or a new style, right? And he's solving that with these frequent launches. But I just think so much of retention can be solved with product. I mean, like in durables, unless I know everybody's like the nuance.
57:04Matt Bertulli: Yes, we're not all in durables. Katie, I don't think your product is considered durable. But in like non like naturally consumable product categories, I would say what you just said is a good broad rule. Like it's more likely to be true than not that retention is going to come from product, not some email sequence, some SMS thing. Like, and again, this is just my gripe, like being somebody who studies this, the space of consumer in the way I do, I can't tell you how often I just want to scream at the internet. It's like, you are not increasing retention with another email tactic. You're not, not in a meaningful way, you know, like fix the buying journey up front, fix your product or add product, that is going to meaningfully move the needle on retention.
57:52Matt Bertulli: It is not the Clavio flow and what order you put the email in. Like, it's really not. Like, you are tripping over dollars and picking up pennies, people. Products are hard. And that's why when you get into something that you can get a long lifetime value, you put so much attention and energy into it because i'm sure katie and i both live in that like it went one day when when i follow the hex clad pattern and as the founder and owner and everybody of this and i'm living abroad and working one hour a day by video call and everything like that like hey when i get to that then maybe i won't focus on as many things but i'll still be focused on what is the product.
58:38How are we getting out? What's new? What's fresh? What are the people excited about? And how I do that? Because, you know, I've mentioned luck several times. I didn't think when I made a leather journal in my garage, we were going to find a$100 billion TAM of women's handbags. That was not the goal. But once we got into it, I said, how can we differentiate ourselves? How can we make this work? And I work my ass off. I'll have four to five hours of meetings today on product numbers, exactly what we're making in design, when is it delivered next year for the marketing team to be successful.
59:14Matt Bertulli: You know, it's funny, Jason. You're like, I just listen to people tell me I don't work very hard for five minutes. And what's funny to me is like, I could call you so many names, but lazy is not one of them. I can't. I know. It's amazing.
59:26Katy Mimari: It was Curtis calling you lazy, not me, Jason. I was dying. No, I wrote it on my piece of paper. Remember that. Curtis is just flexing, like sitting there in front of his factory while people bring him coffees.
59:40Matt Bertulli: No, no, the real flex is that you're sitting at your frigging loft in downtown LA doing a podcast because you're like, yeah, I'll go to work in a little bit. I don't, I don't. That is a good look, Jason. I know that's just like a spare room in the enormous place that you're at there, but that looks really good. That's a great background. Can I ask you guys, like I got one more question on retention. I think we can wrap. How do you all think about reacquiring customers? and the cost of reacquiring customers. Because like we just, you know, email SMS, it makes it sound like, oh, once you have them, you've got them forever.
1:00:11Matt Bertulli: But we all know that that's not true, right? Like, and we can't really try as we will. We have a hard time allocating media dollars to like net new customer only. You know, we're going to reacquire. So can maybe Curtis, like talk to me about like if 58 % of your customers are returning, how do you think about the dollars that you're deploying and reacquiring them? I have zero to do with this, but like a cross episode, I'm going to talk about the marketing operators podcast. You need to go on there and listen to McCoy Merkley. I had nothing to do with this because I see it the same way. They're a new customer or they're a returning customer, and you can only be a new customer once.
1:00:50McCoy would disagree with you, Curtis. But he found out six months ago by testing people who for a year had not bought anything by a new marketing campaign just for those you could reacquire at pennies and get them back on track with what they wanted to do. So that's like a third thing that we did. I didn't think about it. I had nothing to do with that. But once he told me, I'm like, hmm, yes, of course, that's the right way to do. Let's put more money and time and energy into doing that. literally kills for us right now. Something we've only really focused on, added up, spent the money, made plans for in the last six months.
1:01:29Matt Bertulli: Katie, what about you? How do you guys think about reacquisition? Because this is part of our tension.
1:01:35Katy Mimari: Yeah, and it's why we obsess over the customer journey. So after two years is really where we, about 18 months is where we see the big drop-off. And then we'll take those customers and put them into a segment and remarket to them. We see the exact same thing Curtis is talking about. They're actually cheaper to acquire as a new customer and they start the journey all over again. Now, it could be because they had a second child for us, right? So maybe they really become a new customer again. But I think that if you're not revisiting customers that have gone stagnant, right, like that you haven't heard from and they're not opening emails or not clicking on your SMS, try creating like an audience of them and remarketing to them.
1:02:18Katy Mimari: I bet you acquire them cheaper the second time around.
1:02:21Matt Bertulli: I mean, Jason, with your repeat rates looking a lot like Pila's, like we spend a lot of time trying to make sure we don't spend money on targeting past customers because we're just trying to push a boulder up the hill with behavior. I'm like, I'm not going to convince the majority of people to buy a second phone case this year. It's like, I really don't want to spend money there. Is it similar at HexGlad where you're like, we're deploying dollars? I mean, at your scale, you have a really hard time figuring out where those dollars go, but like tell us just how you guys think about this. Yeah, look, I think about it, you know, you're constantly acquiring the same customer, you know, like that when you're there.
1:02:58Yeah, they bought a 12 piece set a year and a half ago, and you're still trying to get them to acquire. So retention, you know, my paid ads are just part of retention. You know, it's all it's all one concerted strategy to get people to keep coming back. And I don't think it's a and we just keep dropping new products. I don't think it's particularly scientific in the sense that that we have a strategy to say, okay, this person hasn't purchased in two years, and let's go get them back. It just happens by continuing to drop new products for the kitchen that we think someone is going to need.
1:03:35Katy Mimari: If you really just look at even your meta account, and you're doing exclusions to try to keep it being a top of funnel for first customer, you are going to exclude those customers. And I think that's the big unlock Curtis and McCoy are talking about, is you've got to think of them. Most people will go in with heavy exclusions on meta and most people are spending high dollars on meta. Don't count those people out. I think you need to have an end point. It shouldn't be all time.
1:04:01Matt Bertulli: Well, I think also like the way I think of it is every brand in every category should have a really clear definition of what new means and what returning means, right? It's like at Pila, we would consider, we had two news. We had new all time and I had new in the last 12 months. Right? Like they haven't bought from us in a while. And I was okay spending a certain amount of money on reacquiring like an older than 12 months customer. I didn't want, I wanted to spend the least amount on somebody in like the first 12 months on like a returning. And then I was okay reacquiring past that. But I would definitely guide everybody listening, everybody watching.
1:04:44Matt Bertulli: You have to figure out what new means to you. Because the default in software is new means new all time. And that may not be how you want to deploy marketing dollars and marketing effort. It's different by category. That's a great point. And I don't know the answer of what's going on in our meta accounts. I just know that I have one of the best paid media teams on the planet. And if they're not making the right decisions, I'll probably kill them. But it is a really good point. I think that, I would say for us, my default would be like, you wanna make sure that you minimize excluding existing customers.
1:05:25Because you know, maybe you could exclude a bought in the last year, maybe, right? But after that, why would you wanna do that?
1:05:33Katy Mimari: I don't know, but I wanna shout out, Jason, if you go back to your media team and they're like, we're excluding all time, I get a shout out. I just texted them that question.
1:05:44Matt Bertulli: find out. All right. I think we can wrap it. This was a great conversation. This was awesome. I actually had a lot of fun today. This was a good one. Everybody came in a little hot, you know, feeling a little spicy.
1:05:55Katy Mimari: It's because Curtis talks so much to us and I got to stand up for us, you know?
1:06:00Matt Bertulli: Oh, that's it, Katie? Is it like you're altruistic and you're trying to defend poor old Jason and I from Curtis? No, Katie is so funny because, by the way, I thought Curtis was pretty tame today.
1:06:12Katy Mimari: It's his black shirt. I don't know what it is, but like... It's based on what color he's wearing. Just don't go to happy hour with Katie, okay? Just remember that there's a rule. Don't go to happy hour with Katie. Or what? You're going to have the best time. Or you're going to have the best time ever. And her compadre. Those two are like, this is insane. Oh my God. All right, that's the pod.
1:06:39Are we off or are we still recording right now? No, it's recording right now, but we'll edit. All right, so just like a sound bite, and of course, if you want to drop, that's fine. Seriously, whoever is doing the thumbnails of my face, they're gonna be fired if it's not fit. It's like in every picture, Matt looks so professional. You know, Matt's always got like his pen in his hand and doing his thing. And there's all these pictures of like me making weird faces. Like what is going on? I demand that this is in the pod. I demand right now that this is the best part of the pod. I do control, I do have access to the bank account and I will make some moves, okay?
1:07:20This will be a post-credit scene. It'll run the, Matt will say that's the pod, the logo will run, and then we'll cut right into, I'll be on screen too. When these pictures are ridiculous, and what is going, it's literally only me. Pull up, Aaron, all of the old pictures. I mean, they make Sean Frank look like a GQ model. Listen, you had some good poppin' smiles today, and I already dropped it on our designer, Paul. Shout out, Paul. I already dropped it on him. We got you. Paul, you're, I'm taking you to cast, Paul. Make Matt look bad, Paul.
1:07:49Katy Mimari: What? Not us. No, no, there's the,
1:07:51Matt Bertulli: have you guys not seen these Instagram TikTok videos? Like, it was a meme thing for a while. It's like, you've got that friend who's always photogenic, where, like, they show up, like, you know, taking a picture of the guy's girlfriend, and she's making a ridiculous face, and it just always turns out perfect. Jason's the opposite.
1:08:06Katy Mimari: Oh, God.
1:08:06Matt Bertulli: It's like, even if he's sitting there smiling, it's like somehow it's like him all mangled on screen. Thank you, Matt. I got you. I got you. And you laughed a few times this time. That's gonna pay dividends.
“You don’t have a retention problem, you have a product problem.”
What should a brand launch next when its customer has no reason to reorder?
Matt Bertulli (Founder, Pela Case & Lomi), Jason Panzer (President, HexClad), Katy Mimari (CEO, Caden Lane) and Curtis Matsko (CEO, Portland Leather Goods) split on how to keep customers buying when the product lasts for years. Their fixes range wide, and email flows barely make the list.
PLG drops new SKUs four days a week and earns 58% of revenue from returning customers. HexClad built its business on a $699 set most people buy once. Katy prices a $60 add-on at $48M, and Matt calls it a distraction. The math picks a side, and it depends on what the first order is worth.
Powered By
Northbeam
Saras Analytics
Postscript
Aftersell
https://9ops.co/aftersell-operators
Fulfil
Richpanel
Operators Portal
https://portal.9operators.com/dashboard
Operators Newsletter