1. Podcasts
  2. Part Of The Problem
  3. Coleman Hughes
Part Of The Problem

29 Oct 2026 · 2h 21m · 50 chapters

In short

Long-form discussion between Dave Smith and Coleman Hughes about American politics and culture-war “wokeness,” then a detailed debate over the U.S.-Iran conflict and the justification for regime-change war and later escalation tied to the Strait of Hormuz. They compare the June 2025 “12-day war” (Israeli/U.S. bombing campaign) with a newer, broader war framed as regime change and later shifting aims (missiles/Hezbollah/nuclear limits vs. Hormuz disruption). Key claims include: non-interventionists have a point about overestimating what intervention can achieve; regime-change aims are unlikely to be worth the costs to Americans; and Trump’s administration allegedly misled the public about Iran’s nuclear timeline and intentions.

Guest backgrounds

Coleman Hughes is an author, political commentator, and musician. He runs the podcast “Conversations with Coleman.” He cites Thomas Sowell as a major influence and describes Sowell as a rare thinker admired across ideological camps. (The host also references Coleman’s prior podcast appearance and its timing after Charlie’s death.)

Notable examples

references to Thomas Sowell’s Stanford/Hoover-related conference; comparisons to past “friendly” cross-ideology TV debates (e.g., Tucker Carlson/Rachel Maddow, Ben Shapiro/Tucker); discussion of JCPOA, IAEA inspections, enrichment levels (including 60%); and claims about CIA/Mossad intelligence assessments and past intelligence failures.

Key claims (debated)

whether enriching to 60% implies an imminent nuclear breakout; whether IAEA inspections make “breakout without detection” implausible; and whether military force to prevent nuclear proliferation can be justified under a “just war” framework.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:46

Reflections on Previous Discussions

The hosts reflect on their past conversation and the feedback received from listeners.

“Now that anyway, I'm just saying that's a place to date.”
2:37

Agreeing on Common Ground

The hosts discuss their areas of agreement in American politics and the significance of their dialogues.

“Like I think literally if you're going to talk about politics or write about politics for a living, Thomas Sowell is like required reading.”
5:01

Influence of Thomas Sowell

Coleman discusses Thomas Sowell's impact on political thought and his importance in their discussions.

“And I went and I spoke and I've written a lot of, you know, a lot of essays about soul.”
6:56

The Role of Wokeness and Foreign Policy

The hosts share their views on wokeness, foreign policy, and their implications for society.

“Like his contributions were just like invaluable.”
12:19

Analysis of the Current War

The hosts analyze the current war's objectives and implications, distinguishing it from past conflicts.

“But first, I think it is important to separate the 12-day war from this war.”
14:00

The Complexity of Intervention and War Goals

Exploration of the challenges of achieving war objectives and the implications of military actions.

“since the anti-interventionists since Vietnam have had the point that we overestimate our own ability to accomplish these things.”
17:05

The Ethical Implications of Military Decisions

Discussion on the moral responsibilities of military leadership in light of operational capabilities.

“So in other words, did the Wall Street Journal and I can't remember, man, double check me on this Internet.”
20:29

Lies and Truths in Political Discourse

Debate on the integrity of political statements related to military actions and national threats.

“And this isn't even like, and we can get into all of this in a little bit, but this isn't even like weapons of mass destruction or something.”
23:27

Nuclear Proliferation and International Threats

Analysis of the implications of Iran's nuclear program and the international response to its developments.

“It's also true that there are other nuclear threshold states, Brazil, Japan, South Korea.”
28:00

Debating Iran's Nuclear Ambitions

A discussion on whether Iran's uranium enrichment reflects intentions to develop nuclear weapons.

“abolished their entire civilian nuclear program.”
Show all 50 chapters
29:40

IAEA Inspections and Intelligence Failures

Analyzing the effectiveness of IAEA inspections and the history of intelligence failures regarding nuclear programs.

“guarantee is a little bit too strong of a word, but certainly give you a lot more oversight than you otherwise would have had.”
32:05

IAEA Inspections and Intelligence Failures

Analyzing the effectiveness of IAEA inspections and the history of intelligence failures regarding nuclear programs.

“When was the last time you went to the doctor, you got blood work done, and you felt like you actually got something out of it?”
33:50

Discussion on Nuclear Policy and Military Intervention

Continuing the debate on military intervention if Iran pursues nuclear weapons and the implications of their uranium enrichment.

“That they found that there were some trace particles where the uranium was spun up to like 80 percent or something like that.”
42:02

The Dilemma of Military Action Against Iran

A deep dive into the complexities of using military force to prevent nuclear proliferation in Iran.

“for the Iranians to break out to weapons grade enrichment, develop a deliverable nuclear bomb while under IAEA inspections, they'd have to kick the inspectors out.”
50:08

The Consequences of War and Inaction

Examining the long-term consequences of military interventions and the challenges of dealing with threats.

“It's kind of like wait and see because there might be weapons pointed at Israel from southern Lebanon.”
56:00

Debate on Military Intervention and War

The discussion explores the implications and consequences of military interventions and the discernment needed in deciding which wars to engage in.

“I'm saying that we've launched, this is the seventh of like six regime change operations in the region.”
1:01:48

Analyzing Israeli Involvement in Current Conflicts

Discussion on the complexities of Israeli influence in U.S. foreign policy and the current political landscape regarding conflicts involving Israel.

“Let's talk a little bit about Israel because we've I'm you know, I lose track of time when we're in these things, but we've got an hour.”
1:10:00

MAGA Pitch and Globalism

The discussion highlights the disconnect in the MAGA message and globalist perspectives.

“it's so antithetical to the whole spirit of the MAGA pitch.”
1:10:25

Netanyahu's Influence on Trump

The conversation speculates on Netanyahu's role in influencing Trump’s decisions.

“I mean, I think according to the reporting, it does seem like Netanyahu was instrumental in being one of the people in Donald Trump's ears, one of the major ones, who was kind of going, this will work.”
1:10:58

Military Intelligence and Hubris

Discusses the overoptimism of military intelligence and its historical implications.

“Look, I got my intelligence guy here who also thinks the same thing.”
1:11:36

Predictable Outcomes in War

Analyzes the predictability of outcomes in military engagements based on past failures.

“And if you want to ask me of the years of reading about Warhawks, is hubris a possible explanation for this?”
1:12:09

Israel's Military Predictions

Questions whether Israeli leadership could foresee the consequences of military actions.

“No, I'm not saying this is the one war that couldn't be explained by hubris.”
1:12:38

The Role of the Neocons

Examines the belief that neoconservative perspectives contributed to military decisions.

“But what's actually going on is they can touch the Strait of Hormuz, which then makes it very difficult to inshore cargo ships going through and very difficult to get civilians to go through.”
1:13:16

Security Establishments' Biases

Discusses the dual perspectives within security establishments regarding military efficacy.

“Literally – maybe I've swam in these circles for a little bit too long.”
1:13:49

Warnings Against Military Action

Highlights historical warnings against military actions and their often ignored implications.

“I'm not just saying like, hey, this is what Dave Smith, this is what I read in Ron Paul or Murray Rothbard's book, or this is what Scott Horton believes.”
1:14:32

Understanding Military Bias

Explores the inherent biases that lead to miscalculations in military planning.

“We're disagreeing about degree though because to me it's never surprising when you have military guys that overestimate the ability of their own army.”
1:14:58

Speculating Military Motivations

Debates the speculative nature of motivations behind military decisions and the influence of intelligence.

“them from the second half of the obvious examples.”
1:15:38

Persuasion vs. Manipulation

Distinguishes between persuasion and manipulation in political contexts.

1:16:32

Trump's Awareness of Israeli Intentions

Discusses Trump's knowledge of Israeli intentions and decisions regarding Iran.

“you're lobbying me to have a certain guest on my show, Dave, you should really have this guy on, and I end up having him on my show, we could sit here kind of debating forever, like, did you persuade me?”
1:17:52

Iran Negotiations and Israeli Strategy

Examines the implications of Israeli strategies on Iranian negotiations.

“debatable how you want to look at it persuaded donald trump to adopt the zero zero enrichment Is it debatable based on the evidence?”
1:18:39

Evidence of Manipulation

Questions the existence of evidence suggesting manipulation by Netanyahu.

“That's not – I think – The problem with these stories is they only work if everyone else involved is like a low IQ idiot.”
1:19:24

Evaluating Speculative Claims

Dissects speculative claims regarding Israeli intentions and their influence on Trump.

“I mean, so I'm basing, it's not equally speculative.”
1:20:14

Foreign Influence and American Politics

Discusses the implications of foreign influence on American political decisions.

“And this was when I read the – you wrote an article after your conversation with Glenn Greenwald kind of reflecting on your conversations with me and him.”
1:21:19

Comparing Foreign Influences

Compares perceptions of different foreign influences on American politics, particularly Israel and Saudi Arabia.

“She was born in 46, I believe, before the state of Israel was created.”
1:24:01

Debating Influence and Manipulation

The hosts discuss perceptions of foreign influence on Trump, comparing it to allegations about Russia.

1:25:15

The Nature of Presidential Decisions

Exploration of how presidents respond to pressures and influence from various donors and factions.

“He didn't say he moved the Capitol for them.”
1:26:37

Cultural Dialogues and Arguments

A discussion on cultural narratives regarding feminism and societal norms in relation to political arguments.

“Okay, but even leaving aside the distinction between whether there's pressure put on him or manipulation or something they just want and they'll just give him money for that.”
1:28:47

Evidence of Israeli Influence

Examination of the alleged influence of Israel on U.S. politics and specific historical examples to refute this.

“You see people from the State Department saying, openly saying, America is the greatest country in the world.”
1:31:43

Data and Influence in Politics

A critical look at how data is interpreted in the context of political lobbying and influence.

“If you look only at those cases and exclude all the other data points, you're like, man, we're always just doing whatever Israel wants.”
1:35:01

The Complexity of Lobby Influence

Discussion on the complexities of understanding lobbying power and its impact on political decisions.

“I kind of broke up my train of thought here.”
1:38:00

Debating Influence and Accountability

Exploring how lobbying and political donations correlate with influence.

“If – this is kind of how we – what we were debating about Benjamin Netanyahu testifying ahead of the authorization of military force.”
1:40:06

Examining U.S. Support for Israel

Discussing the rationale behind America's support for Israel post-Cold War.

“I'm also not dismissing it as like, no, it's very, very weird.”
1:42:45

The Power of Lobbying Perspective

Understanding the relative power of different lobbying groups in the U.S.

“spent like a tiny fraction in the 2000s lobbying Congress compared to, say, the smoking lobby.”
1:45:29

Defining Lobbying and Personal Opinions

Debating the definition of lobbying and personal advocacy in politics.

“I mean, you're – again, I think what we've come to is that it's impossible to exactly quantify how much influence these things have.”
1:51:43

Comparing Foreign Lobby Groups

Contrasting the Israel lobby with other foreign advocacy groups.

“And I'm not saying Jews didn't, Israelis didn't get slaughtered on October 7th.”
1:52:00

The Complexities of Loyalty and Lobbying

Exploring the nuances of political loyalty and foreign influence in the U.S.

“lobbying for big steel or big pharma or the dentist lobby.”
2:06:43

Midterm Elections and Woke Culture

A discussion on the impact of midterm elections and cultural shifts related to 'woke' ideologies.

“I wonder, like, you know, we're going into a moment here in the midterm elections coming up.”
2:13:12

New York City's Political Landscape

Exploring the changes in New York City under recent leadership and the implications of socialist policies.

“I wouldn't necessarily want to always be weighing foreign policy against moment to moment popularity.”
2:20:01

Reflections on the Conversation

The hosts reflect on their discussion, emphasizing the value of open-minded dialogue.

2:20:24

The Importance of Good Faith Debate

They discuss the necessity of having good faith debates to understand diverse perspectives.

“I think they only get the most extreme version of that perspective, and that's what social media does.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Part Of The Problem, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:08Coleman Hughes. How are you, sir? How are you, man? Thank you so much for coming in.

0:12Coleman Hughes: Yeah, my pleasure. You came on my podcast. I feel it's only fair to repay the favor. That's right. Well, Coleman's podcast, by the way, if anyone is unfamiliar, is Conversations with Coleman. Coleman's also an author, political commentator, musician. You do a lot of stuff. and as you were referring I did your podcasts I think it was like right a year ago I think so I believe it was in October it was right after Charlie got killed I remember it was like a few weeks after that so I think that would have been in October or was it after the it was right after he got killed a few weeks I think like a few weeks after he got killed I remember down to the point because we were talking about whether it was going to be a live show or remote and it was like my whole team was going through Like we have a new security protocol for half.

0:58You know what I mean? Like it was like right at a hot time. Now that anyway, I'm just saying that's a place to date.

1:04Coleman Hughes: I think it's, it might be, it's within my top three most listened episodes of all time. Wow. And I've had people come up to me on the street or people recognize me and say, you know, I loved your episode with Dave Smith. And some of those people thought, thought like I agreed with me. Some of those people agreed with you. And then some of them said, you actually both made a lot of good points. So if that feedback is any indication, I think it means hopefully we did something good and rare for the discourse in our line of work. Yeah, that actually – like, man, and I want to say this without being like too self-congratulatory or self-important or something like that.

1:40But that means a lot to me. I've had a very similar reaction. Yeah, it was one of the biggest shows I did in 2025 for sure, and I did a lot of big shows that year. It also – I said this on Trigonometry. I did that show a few days ago. and um i think constantine just did your show as well right so i was talking to those guys and i did say because i had you guys both kind of in the same week and of 2025 both those shows to me were like ones that stood out of like two of my favorite shows that i did of the year where it was i don't know it was just you i mean you started the very beginning of our podcast for anyone i encourage people to go listen to that one if if you're starting with part two do part one and part to um but you started it by going look i've seen a lot of guys debate you who like you're talking about issues and they're kind of going at you i'm not doing that we're doing issues we're gonna like really get into this and i just really appreciated the spirit of that and i think that um and that'll be i'll do my best to return the favor here you know today of course also as you kind of uh got it there there is just something to someone it seems like today it's a little bit of a weird thing like if you you know there's these old clips back in i don't know i want to say like back in like 2012 or something like that of like tucker matter tucker carlson and rachel maddow you know arguing friend in a friendly manner on msnbc a few years later that was kind of like unthinkable that they would even be in the same room same with ben shapiro and tucker carlson like a few years ago you could have seen them kind of being friendly now it's like and while tensions are up so high i do tend to think again i don't want to put too much importance on me and you having a conversation but i do think for like someone broadly speaking in your camp and someone broadly speaking in my camp to be able to say hey let's do a long-form thing let's go through these issues let's you know at least try to press your perspective up against mine and see where the chips fall it does it does seem to me that like like someone definitely should be doing that and there's not too many uh i don't think besides me and you who are going to do this right yeah yeah i totally agree with that um all right also i do feel a little bit compelled to say maybe before we get into there's so much stuff to get into but before we get into it i do feel a little bit compelled to say in a weird way there are also um lots of areas that we really profoundly agree on yeah that probably won't be the focus of today's show but i feel like that's worth mentioning up

4:06Coleman Hughes: top when i hear you talking about american politics from a libertarian perspective i'm i'm usually there with you like 75 of the time yeah well i know that i've seen some of your stuff you've done a lot maybe about as much as anyone of say like popular young um political commentators to uh spread the work of thomas soul who is one of my greatest influences i think it's like a generational genius who is, like I can't overstate it. Like I think literally if you're going to talk about politics or write about politics for a living, Thomas Sowell is like required reading. You shouldn't even be, this is my non-libertarian view.

4:46You should not be allowed in the room.

4:48Coleman Hughes: I devoured him in college. That sounded weird, pause. I devoured his writing in college and he actually, there was a Thomas Sowell conference, one in his honor at Stanford at the Hoover Institution, like about a year ago. And I went and I spoke and I've written a lot of, you know, a lot of essays about soul. And they intentionally did the concert, like right where he lives. And he is such a recluse that he didn't even come. Like he's, Condoleezza Rice was there to honor him. Clarence Thomas, who is his friend, Victor Davis Hanson, who is his close friend. They were all there to honor him. and he just wasn't bothered to show me like okay maybe he had a health issue or something but he is old he's pretty old these days he's very old these days but he's also so famously reclusive yeah that i just you know this guy never comes out he's the number one question i've gotten on my podcast the past six years when are you getting so long i've tried i've i've reached out through friends that have gone on camping trips with him and he doesn't respond he's just a one of one but i think he had to be that level of stubborn in order to argue the way he was arguing back in the 1970s yeah because people have come around to his argument he's become famous in our circles but in the 1970s it was like him and basically him i mean there's milton friedman of course but there was like but he also was a cultural he went into the cultural stuff in a different way than milton friedman ever did you know so like yeah i mean economically i guess there was Friedman there and obviously Walter Williams did a lot of great work too.

6:24But you're right. I mean, it was a very small group, a very small group. And it is crazy, at least with say like, say center right to right wing, like the right half of America. Someone like, even as you say it, like you and Victor Davis Hanson and whoever, like I'm sure Barry Weiss and lots of people like this would probably speak of Thomas Sowell with absolutely nothing but admiration. And also, if I brought him up in a circle of Tom Woods and Ron Paul and Pat Buchanan, every single one of them would go, yeah, that Thomas Sowell, man, he's brilliant. Like his contributions were just like invaluable.

7:03And so anyway, I do think that says something. Very few people kind of could be regarded in both those camps as like great thinkers and great men. The other thing is, of course, I think probably at least in the beginning part of your career, what you've been most famous for is kind of somebody standing up against the woke insanity of our time, which again is something I just completely agree with. And I think is – I do – I said this to Constantine the other day too. There is – no matter how much we disagree on issues of war and peace and issues of foreign influence and we'll get into all these things.

7:37and I do find these topics to be so important but there is, I guess it is to me, for me personally I guess it's like there's like foreign policy but there's also like say wokeness and COVID where anybody who's like was really good on either of those issues, I do at least to some degree view as like a brother in arms who was fighting the good fight I have young children to me this is not a game this is like whether my kids are going to be growing up in an insane society and I'm somewhat grateful to all the people who stood up against that. So anyway, I do want to say on those issues, I think we actually probably have a lot of overlap in a different world where Israel got along with their neighbors more or something like that and we weren't involved in these wars.

8:21Maybe it would be like me and you are on the same camp fighting against other kooks who maybe we will be in a few years now as they're coming back into power.

8:29Coleman Hughes: Yeah, no, I agree with you about the woke stuff and maybe we could do another podcast about that. It's your show, your topic, so I'm happy to talk about whatever. We could talk about that a bit. In fact, I did want to a bit talk about it because, of course, we got midterms coming up next week. And so with the forecast being that a lot of the Wokes are going to come back into power or Woke 2.0 or maybe some version of whatever. So maybe we will spend some time on that. But let's start with the Iran war because we talked a year ago and one of the things we spoke a bunch about was the 12-day war.

9:02which of course I should say the June 2025 12-day war at this point, just so everybody is clear on when I say the 12-day war I'm talking about, the very short, less than two-week bombing campaign between the Israelis and the Americans last June.

9:17Coleman Hughes: Since then, there's been another war and we're still involved in this war. So I briefly kind of give my overview of it and then I'm curious your thoughts on this because there's been a whole other war. And when we were on the show last time, I did say at one point that I forget my exact words, but I did say like this baby might be at halftime. Yes. Something along those lines. We might be at halftime here, which, again, I said might be. It's not that it was a foregone conclusion. Seems like that was that was correct. So in this new war now, this is a bit different. This has been this was from the very beginning launched as a regime change war.

9:54Donald Trump announced on the opening of the war that that's the goal here. The regime is going. And he also demanded total surrender. And then said – he did tell the people – he didn't exactly just say people rise up. He said take shelter for the night, but the government is going to be in the hands of the people soon. There were other clear war aims like getting rid of the missile program, their support for Hezbollah, ending that. Ending the nuclear program at all. That was the original zero enrichment standard. The nuclear dust, as Donald Trump likes to call it, which I do not think is actually a scientific term.

10:24but referring to the enriched uranium, the gas and the metal that's left over there. And then – did I miss a major war aim there? Anyway, those war aims, none of them have been achieved. A new problem now has come up, which is the Strait of Hormuz. Of course, in the week of the Memorandum of Understanding, the Trump administration – and this is a little – it's been so schizophrenic that I – but I want to just make the point. In the week of the Memorandum of Understanding, they walked away from all of the war goals, all of the original negotiating hard lines. You know, Donald Trump for a week was, everyone gets to enrich some uranium.

11:02I mean, come on, what are we going to say? They can't have a civilian nuclear program? Missiles. We got Saudi Arabia's got missiles. They got to have some missiles. The first line of the Memorandum of Understanding, or the second line, included Lebanon, meaning we've walked away from they're not going to support Hezbollah. As Marco Rubio has said over and over again, now the war is all about the Strait of Hormuz, which wasn't a problem before the war. All the original aims have been abandoned. This new aim is now what we're struggling to achieve. This is not the 12-day war. It probably already has a price tag in the hundreds of billions of dollars.

11:33Kind of hard to calculate, but we could get into that. Americans have died. Iranian children have died. So I guess, listen, I want to give you all the time in the world and all the room to answer and give your thoughts on this. But from my perspective, I'm curious what your thoughts on this war are, whether you can defend this one in a way that you could defend the 12-day war. And I'm curious if maybe – because clearly from my perspective, there would at least be something here to say the non-interventionists had a point. The people arguing against going down this path really did have a point because what a disaster.

12:04And against the will of the people and it's obviously clearly having disastrous effects on the administration. So what are your thoughts?

12:13Coleman Hughes: Sure. So I think I fully agree with you. The non-interventionists have a point and I'll tell you exactly what point I think they have. And I've always thought this. But first, I think it is important to separate the 12-day war from this war. I think they're separate not only in their objectives, they're separate in their causes, too. because when you said we were at halftime, you might be tempted to give yourself credit for a good prediction. And I get that. But at the same time, had Iran's economy not collapsed in December and runaway inflation and all these things that we didn't really control, probably the first domino doesn't fall on this regime change war, right?

12:51Coleman Hughes: So not all of that was predictable from the POV of the 12-day war. This regime change war, I've always felt while it does, you know, if we could buy a weaker Iran for no American lives and a very cheap price, it would be in our interest. So in that sense, it's directionally in our interests. But will the American people tolerate a war simply to weaken a regime that wants to ultimately destroy us? My view on that was the answer is no, the American people won't see that trade as worth the price. Even if the pro is in the direction of our interests, the cons are too big. Now, if we could get regime change in Iran, and get a friendlier regime, let's say a regime that was at minimum, not chanting death to America and not wanting our destruction as a matter of their ideology, that would be worth paying some price for.

13:47Coleman Hughes: I don't know exactly what price, but it would be worth, that would be worth military intervention for. As it stands right now, and this is the point that the interventionists, I think, you know, I think the interventionists since the anti-interventionists since Vietnam have had the point that we overestimate our own ability to accomplish these things. And the ability to accomplish it must be part of any analysis, right? So if we could have accomplished Vietnam like South Korea, then maybe it would have been worth it, but we didn't. And we went on and on and on much longer than we knew we were likely to fail.

14:28Coleman Hughes: So you can separate the goal from your likelihood of actually achieving the goal. The goal might be worthy, but if you're very unlikely to achieve it or delusional about your chances of achieving it, that's the legitimate critique that the anti-interventionists almost always have, at least in the past 60 years or so. So does that make sense? Yeah. Well, OK. So I agree. And I think I kind of almost said this when I brought up. Like I wasn't trying to overbrag of bringing up halftime because I said maybe we're at halftime. And then I did preface by saying not that it was like written in stone that we had to be at halftime.

15:02And in fact, as I, which I think maybe is just in the spirit of being charitable, I admitted this to Coleman, too. In a sense. Excuse me. I'm sorry. I admitted this to Constantine, too. You're Coleman. Sorry about that. I didn't know that. That, look, essentially the big warning about the 12-day war from people like me, the point that we were making, which I guess now has been demonstrated, although every analyst knew this was true, was just that Iran has these options. Iran could do this. they've done now. They could have done that after the 12-day war. They essentially, in a way, Trump called their bluff and it turned out they were bluffing.

15:41They were not going to do something big. In fact, at least the old Ayatollah was going to call ahead, give you a warning strike, give Trump the off-ramp, right? So the concern was that risk. Essentially, from my conception, not saying you'd agree with this, but you played Russian roulette and won. It didn't go off. So, So yeah, you could have gotten away and stopped there. So I'll certainly agree with that. And it could have, look, whatever you find, whatever damage was done to the nuclear facilities, whatever was benefited from the 12-day war, yes, I guess they could have gotten away and stopped there.

16:15However, it's a little bit more complicated than that because, you know, once you empower a president to do this thing once, they are more likely to do it a second time. And of course, all of the people involved, as we were arguing last time, you know, for our partner in this war, the Israelis, Their goal here wasn't just to degrade the nuclear capabilities of the country. Their goal always was some type of regime collapse. And so that's also sticky. But I want to get into all of this. But there's a couple of things you said there that I just want to touch on. So look, there's something about – it's an important point to make and to separate the two things out.

16:49What you said, the aim of a war versus the logistical reality of whether you can pull this war off. But you'd have to admit that after being separated, those things must be re, you know, fused back together. Because if you have no capability of achieving something and you put your boys in harm's way in the attempt to like there is something immoral about that. So in other words, did the Wall Street Journal and I can't remember, man, double check me on this Internet. It might have been the day before the war was launched, but it was certainly the week of the war being launched. They had reported top Pentagon officials telling Donald Trump that our interceptors are dangerously low for this mission.

17:32You know what I'm saying? So while I get your point of separating the two, there's also an area where you go, this is like criminally negligent to have not known this or to be on the record saying no one could have foreseen the Strait of Hormuz being closed or something like that. I would also add that in this war, very clearly, and I don't really think you're going to deny this, although please tell me if I'm wrong. Trump is clearly lying to the American people. This is fundamentally – and it is a whopper greater than anything Bush or Obama ever told to get into war. The current lie is that Iran was two weeks away from a deliverable nuclear weapon and they were going to destroy the world.

18:17It started with Israel. Then it went to L.A. and San Francisco. By the way, he got a raw deal where people were saying he was telling them to nuke L.A. That's not what he was saying. He was saying they would have already nuked L.A. He was just telling the biggest lie in the 21st century to get us into a war, keep us in a war. He wasn't inviting the nuclear attack. I don't think it was the biggest lie. Okay, well, just from my perspective.

18:39Coleman Hughes: I think it was an exaggeration. Because whether they were two weeks away or not, and I'll grant that they, let's just say they definitely were not two weeks away. So that's a lie. Okay, so then it's a lie. There's no reason to enrich uranium to 60 % other than to get a bomb. I don't think that's true. Yeah, it's definitely true. You could enrich it. You can enrich it to negotiate back down. Okay, but what's the threat you're using in the negotiation? That you could potentially break out. Yes. What's the potential? The potential is the bomb, right? So in a negotiation, if I have a knife of whatever, a foot away from your neck, you say, well, he hasn't moved his arm yet.

19:17Coleman Hughes: He hasn't actually shown me he wants to cut me. Well, what's the threat of having the knife out? Having 60 % enriched uranium is the equivalent of pulling a knife out of your pocket, right? And this is the point I tried to make on the podcast last time, which is literally in the entire history of nuclear proliferation, there are zero examples of countries enriching that many kilograms of uranium to 60, and then stopping and not getting a bomb. There are zero examples of it, right? So reading Iran's overall goal of getting a nuclear bomb as a commitment, whether it happens in two weeks or two years, or five years, that is accurate.

19:56Coleman Hughes: Now saying we have intelligence that says they're sprinting now, that's a lie. Right. But he's saying the second part, that's a lie. Yeah, and I'm with you on that. So once you know that you have a regime that wants to destroy America, they would like to destroy America, right? If you're saying we shouldn't use military force to prevent that nuclear goal, then you're essentially saying we should never use the military to prevent any possible regime from getting a nuke. okay is that your let me follow me uh yes i follow but i completely disagree so there's so much here so i'm really glad okay two different things let's just separate them we got all the time in the world so let's do both of them um not all the time in the world me and you could talk for 12 hours but we have time um okay so first things first you're not objecting to it again even if you want to say it's an exaggeration i mean well yeah that's another euphemism for a lie the claim he's making is that he's also adding in that they killed a hundred thousand protesters at this point.

20:56He is blatantly lying. None of this is true. And this isn't even like, and we can get into all of this in a little bit, but this isn't even like weapons of mass destruction or something. It's not even like they had a group that formed this consensus amongst the foreign policy establishment. Nobody believes this. Nobody's pumping out this lies. Nobody, like it's just Donald Trump saying it. So my point anyway, just being, look, that even you are conceding this is a lie to support this war you kind of have to support a commander-in-chief who's lying us into it and so i don't know i don't see how you can kind of get away from that there's there's no intelligent person who's going to defend the war which you're not like you're certainly an intelligent person you're not really defending the war but nobody

21:40Coleman Hughes: can really say this isn't a lie the 12-day war for sure right right okay this one let's let's get into the nuclear program stuff. Hold on. Okay, sorry, do that, but then let's do the nuclear stuff. If you're going to get no disagreement with me on Trump is a liar, Trump lies, but to understand Iran's general intention of getting a nuclear weapon, that is a major load-bearing fact in all of our decisions toward that country. Again, to belabor this analogy, it would be a lie if I said this person is going to stab me in the next two seconds. Let's say that's a lie. But they have pulled out a knife.

22:20Coleman Hughes: They've pulled out a knife and they're giving me that look and they say, one of these days, I'm going to kill you. Okay, so it is a lie in that scenario to say that they're swinging at me right now, right? But it isn't a lie to understand this as an adversary that wants to destroy you, that you should use force and pay a cost to prevent from getting the ultimate weapon. Okay, so to be clear, I also disagree with this second part. Let's do that. But what Trump's saying is a lie. That's just not true and nobody can say it is. So he was not saying, I want the Iranians to nuke LA. No, I'm not saying he was saying that.

22:54I'm saying what popular liberal commentators pretended he was saying is not what he was saying. But he was lying the country into war, which is still pretty bad. Not quite as bad as inviting your own city to be nuked. Okay, let's go to the nuclear program now. You said this in the first time we were together. I don't know that I had the best response for it. But again, a lot of this, I've thought about some of these arguments, and I come back to with most of the stuff we disagree on. Either I think maybe we're talking past each other, or maybe, I don't know, maybe I just fundamentally disagree.

23:25When you say no one else has ever gone up to 60 % and not developed a nuclear weapon, that is a correct factual statement. It's also true that there are other nuclear threshold states, Brazil, Japan, South Korea. So there are the nuclear thresholds, but you're right. Nobody's enriched up to -

23:45Coleman Hughes: What is nuclear threshold state? What does that refer to? Meaning that they have a nuclear program. Oh, sure. A civil. They've developed that. They've demonstrated they can master the fuel cycle. And they enrich up to 5%. They're enriching uranium. They're compliant with the non-proliferation treaty. But they don't have a weapons program, right? And look, there is part of this. And when I say nuclear threshold state - They don't enrich to 60%. Correct. Correct. Correct. But so the reason that term is used is because, no, for, listen, Japan, yes, they might, this is a, they have a energy program, but they are also absolutely letting it be known, hey, we have mastered the fuel cycle.

24:21Now, they're not enriching up to 60%, but anyway, so you make the correct statement that they've enriched up to 60 % where no one else has done that until breaking out for a bomb. But it seems like you almost finish, you leave it there. What is the implied actual argument there? So, yes, they went up to a level no one else. I'm saying that doesn't prove anything.

24:39Coleman Hughes: Is that they've announced their long-term intention to get a nuclear bomb. No, they haven't. They've said they're not going to get a nuclear bomb. No, no, no. What I'm saying, you could say whatever you want. Okay. To enrich is to announce effectively, de facto, to announce your intention to get a nuclear bomb. I don't agree with that. Now, let me ask you a question. What other purpose is 60 % enrich uranium for? Again, like I said, to negotiate it away. It's either to threaten it. Negotiation only works if at some level you either are willing to go through with a threat or you want everyone to think you're willing to go through the threat.

25:15Yeah. Or you could be bluffing. Right.

25:17Coleman Hughes: Yeah. Okay. So you're saying you just know that they're bluffing. No. What I'm saying is this. Well, let me ask you a question just to your whole worldview. Sure. Why didn't they go up to 90? Why didn't they break out to weapons grade? Why did they stay at 60? If you have a long-term goal to get a nuke, when you do it, it matters a great deal. Okay. It might not make sense to swing the knife right now. It might make more sense to bide my time and swing it at a time my opponent is weaker. But it doesn't matter. Or maybe. Look, okay. So just for people to know this, right? So if anybody doesn't have this information, right?

25:50So just keep the timeline in your mind here. Donald Trump tears up the JCPOA. I shouldn't say people say tears up. He exits the JCPOA in 2018. Okay? the there's still IEA inspections going on this whole time up till 2025. It's not till 2021 after the Israeli attack on Natansk that the Iranians start breaking out and enriching. So just just to be clear for everyone here it's 2018 to 20. It's three years they sit without going up to 60 percent.

26:23Coleman Hughes: The Trump Biden switch was at that time too which may have been part of their calculus. Yes quite possibly but it's three years. Right at that time. Sure. It's three years. Yeah, quite possibly. It's three years before they start enriching up to 60%. And that's in 2021. It's then four more years that they sit at 60%. So now they're also negotiating this entire time. They're negotiating. And in fact, there's been reporting on a bunch of different offers that were made. I think probably the best one, Trita Parsi had a great article on this, but I think the best one was at Geneva, which would have been even after the 12-day war.

27:01OK, but before this war where they essentially got the deal that was made was offered was back to three point whatever enriched uranium for, you know, what you need for just the civilian energy program, not even the medical stuff down to three point whatever percent enriched uranium and diluting the rest of their stockpile is what the Iranians had officially offered. And the American demand was zero enrichment. And this is what set this whole thing off. but i'm saying you're sitting here and saying that they went up to 60 therefore it can be concluded by the laws of logic that they were going to go up to 90 and i'm saying no they had

27:39Coleman Hughes: every other example of nuclear development ever no but it's not really there's not really other examples of i mean i don't know you are right there's 20 nuclear countries but there's one that went up to 60 but there's they were once in a deal that kept them down to three point whatever they offered to get back into a deal that keeps them down to three point whatever the one thing they wouldn't agree to was what the Israelis insisted, which was the poison pill that they abolished their entire civilian nuclear program. We all knew that wasn't going to be accepted. And I don't know. I just don't see exactly what your claim is that because they went up to 60, therefore, what is that proof of?

28:13Coleman Hughes: If someone whips out a knife and they're threatening you, they might also have other goals. They might also want your money. But if you're playing with all the marbles and every other time you've seen this situation, it indicates a desire to get a nuke, then it is in the american interest to prevent them getting that nuke it is very much in our interest right that's my argument well so i agree that it's look by the way we would probably totally disagree on what we should do in order to achieve this but i agree it's in the american interest i think it's in the human interest probably you never know exactly how things are going to work out but probably it's in the human interest for around to not get a nuclear weapon.

28:51But again, we're sitting in a situation where, again, this is the intelligence since 2007, and the CIA didn't just find this, but they put out the report that the Iranians have abandoned nuclear ambitions. They're not trying to get a nuclear weapon. The Mossad even conceded that they agreed with that at the time.

29:09Coleman Hughes: The year of - After we discovered their nuclear program in 2003 and engaged them on it. Sure, sure, fine, fine. They were not disclosing that to us. But just if we could do this one first, we can get into that too. But just this one first. Yes, they went up to 60%. But from all indications, they were willing to come back to the table and negotiate. And instead, we insisted on this ridiculous demand that I got to say seems like was only stuck in there by people who wanted this to fall apart and wanted the war. That they don't have a nuclear program at all. If you wanted to avoid them having a nuclear weapon, then why wouldn't you want IAEA inspections that could guarantee they were going to be back down at 3.7?

29:48guarantee is a little bit too strong of a word, but certainly give you a lot more oversight than you otherwise would have had. I don't get the argument that because they went up to 60, therefore it's inevitable that like everyone else, they're going nuclear. Again, like I said, if they wanted to, they could have already done it.

30:02Coleman Hughes: I know, but no, here's the thing. If you have a goal, like I said, it doesn't mean you're going to go for it right now, right? There's all sorts of reasons why you might want to wait for a different American president. You might want to wait for the geostrategic balance of the world to shift a little bit more in your favor. You might want to, as North Korea did, you might want to wait till you have basically a kill switch, a bunch of missiles pointed at Seoul that can't be defended so that you know you have insurance in the case of a breakout, right? So there's all sorts of reasons why you could have a goal, but not execute it right now.

30:40Coleman Hughes: Now, when it comes to IAEA inspections and this kind of thing, my argument would be that the history of the CIA and MI6 being almost totally surprised by the nuclear programs of other countries, their history of failure on this point is pretty bad. That's a good point. Yes, that's a fair point. They thought the Soviet Union was five years behind where it was. they thought china was behind where it was in the 1960s they didn't learn about south africa's nukes for 14 years until south africa just came forward and said hey cia we've had seven fully like operational nukes i'm sorry i just have a smile on your face that it's not i'm agreeing with actually what you're saying at this point it's just so funny that because all everyone knows about the cia is them starting illegal wars and killing people and all these horrible things but just so you guys know they're also really really bad at intelligence i'm sorry keep going Okay, well, it's all relative.

31:35Coleman Hughes: I guess. No, but you're right. You're right. No, they didn't see the collapse of the Soviet Union coming. I mean, yeah, there's a lot they missed. So isn't the logical deduction from this, at least one potential deduction, that waiting until Iran makes the decision is not a rational policy if you agree we should prevent them getting a nuke? Because when they make the decision, there is far less than 100 % guarantee that our intelligence will even know about it. All right, guys. let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, which is Superpower. Let me ask you a question. When was the last time you went to the doctor, you got blood work done, and you felt like you actually got something out of it?

32:11Coleman Hughes: Did you get real answers, or did you feel like you were just very quickly treated, moved along, and no one really examined your health? If you're tired of that and you want to take your understanding of your own health to the next level, you got to check out Superpower. Superpower sends a licensed therapist to your home, or you can visit a nearby Lab. It's one simple blood draw with over 100 biomarkers, which is way more than what you typically get. And then they have their app, which gives you detailed information on your heart, liver, thyroid, hormones, metabolism, vitamin and mineral levels, even environmental toxins.

32:45So from disease prevention to treating that annoying brain fog or simply optimizing your gym game, Superpower is the most comprehensive and advanced system out there. They're going to give you suggestions on what supplements to take, how much sleep you need, what diet you should focus on, all these things that are specifically designed to you and your body, nutritional guideline, lifestyle and behavioral adjustments. You can even get your true biological age, which you can track over time. And then the really cool thing is that each test builds on the previous one. So you put the results into the app, you get more information about where you've come and how the recommendations that you've implemented are working.

33:22This really is the next level of taking care of your health. Go check them out. This is your blueprint activated with superpower. And not only did superpower reduce their price down to just$199, but for a limited time, our listeners can get an additional$20 off with the promo code problem. Just head to superpower.com and use the promo code problem at checkout for$20 off your membership. All right,

33:48Coleman Hughes: let's get back into the show. Well, the thing about the reason why it's a real apples to orange comparison here is that we didn't have international inspectors at the nuclear facilities in any of these countries that you're talking about so we weren't having real updates like me and you can sit here and be like they're at 60 enriched uranium because i can read an iaea report where they just inspected all of the labs know exactly where they are if around i said they were out of compliance over and over and over again throughout the late 20 what are you talking about okay i'm sorry finish your sentence before i said like i the iaea has censored iran in the past like five six years several different times yeah yeah but it's always again but then these guys are fucking with us essentially yeah but have you actually like read the conclusions of the reports because i have and they're like yes there are there have been issues with it there was one particularly right this is a big one that the hawks love to bring up right there was the one in um and again double check me on this because i want to say it was 21 it might have been in 22 But there was one where they came and they had found that – you might have read about that.

34:51In fact, you probably have heard this. That they found that there were some trace particles where the uranium was spun up to like 80 percent or something like that. And then they had this whole thing where they're like, look, the Iranians gave us this reason. We're saying this. They're very hard on them. They come back the next month, have this intense round of inspections, and then release this whole new report. And they go, look, the Iranians are claiming that this was unintentional and spun out here, and that is very plausible.

35:14Coleman Hughes: But then I'm sure after that there was another censure by them by the IAEA, right? I don't believe so. I believe that was the last one. I could be wrong about that, though. I believe – double check. I think it was 22. Is that what I'm saying? No, there was one after that. Was there – okay. I'm pretty sure. The bottom line, dude, is that the conclusion always of all of this was that Iran has not made the political decision to start developing a nuclear weapon. That's exactly what Tulsi Gabbard said in her threat annual assessment. a couple months before the 25, June 12. You bring this up a lot, but you don't mention what Tulsi Gabbard said in the next two sentences, which is that the taboo on getting a nuke in Iran is gone and they have enriched so much uranium, it's unprecedented for a non-nuclear country.

36:02Coleman Hughes: That's what she said in the sentence after. But that doesn't imply anything. But that doesn't imply what you think it implies. Okay, what do you mean by that? All she's saying is that they've enriched up to 60%. That's what that means. Yes, they've enriched higher than other people have. That's unprecedented for a country. Yes, other non-nuclear armed states have not enriched this higher. That's like saying people who don't want to stab you, they almost never bring out a knife and wave it around. But these guys are bringing out a knife and waving it around. Well, not really. They haven't made the political decision to stab you yet, to run at you.

36:38Coleman Hughes: They haven't made the decision to run at you yet. How long are you willing to wait, especially given that your intelligence agencies have a horrible track record of seeing the moment where they try to run forward? Okay, but just – okay, there's a few things in here, Coleman, that I just – first of all, the example of pulling out a knife and having a civilian nuclear program are just apples to oranges. One is aggression and the other one isn't. And if you talk about pulling out a knife – 60 % isn't a civilian nuclear program. That's a weapons nuclear program. No, it's not. Yes, it is. It's on the way there.

37:04Can you make a nuclear weapon out of 60 % in this stadium? I think actually technically maybe you can, but no one's ever done there.

37:08Coleman Hughes: across that threshold to go to 90. Everyone – But in order – okay. But what are we – The only people who have ever gone that far are the ones that get weapons. Again, you're just making the statement over and over. I agree with it. It's a factually correct statement. But there's an implication that there's an argument attached to that. Yes. What is the argument attached to that? The argument attached to that is when they – if you're trying to model the world, you're trying to predict the world, right? Mm-hmm. You think like a Bayesian or whatever. Okay. You see someone behaving a certain way. You say, okay, when other people have behaved this way, what has that signaled about their intentions?

37:42Coleman Hughes: Well, in every single case, when someone enriches to 60%, they're going to get a bomb. So you follow me. This is not crazy. No, but you're taking one simple data point and drawing this broad conclusion out of that. Like you're leaving out the fact that if you want to use your analogy, the guy pulling out the knife is also screaming, I'll put the knife away if you just stop fucking with me. If you just stop threatening me, I will put this knife away. I've put it away before. By the way, you murdered the guy who's touching my right shoulder and the guy who's touching my left shoulder, and you've been threatening to murder me for a lot of years.

38:17You know, you're omitting a lot of things here. The bottom line here, Coleman, is that the intelligence said they haven't made the political decision to get a nuclear weapon yet. If they wanted to break out to 90 % weapons-grade uranium and start the process of building a bomb, they'd have to either, at the time of this, before the 12-day war, they would have had to either kick the inspectors out or do it with them still there, where the IAEA would have announced it to the world. We had more than enough time, if they had decided to break out, to have that information. I don't agree with this. It has been consensus amongst every single U.S.

38:51president of my lifetime, including Barack Obama, the one who got into the JCPOA. And in fact, this was his big selling point that he would yell to the Israel lobby and all the hawks who hated him while he was doing it. He said, if Iran ever broke out, I will go to war with Iran to stop them from getting a nuclear weapon. Iran always kind of knew that if they did that, we'd be here now. They were coming to the table to make a deal. If you really don't want a nuclear Iran, you didn't have to sneak attack them in the middle of negotiations. I don't see why. I don't know. I guess maybe we're talking past each other again.

39:26Coleman Hughes: No, I don't think we're talking past each other. I think I understand what you're saying. Is there anything Iran could do short of – so like if you can see that when they make the political decision hypothetically to go for a nuke. Yes. There's far less than 100 % chance that we will know about it or that MI6 will know about it because we've missed half of those in history. But under the framework of the JCPOA with IAEA inspections, you think they could go to weapons grade without anyone knowing? I don't see how that's possible. I've never heard anyone make that argument. Perhaps it's true. If they screw with the inspectors.

40:07Again, I'll say this. Is there any behavior? Despite the best critiques of Douglas Murray against me, I do admit when I'm not an expert. And maybe that is the case. I've read about this relentlessly. I've never heard one expert even insinuate that it would be possible for them to break out to weapons grade, develop deliverable nuclear weapons while under IAEA inspections without them knowing about it.

40:31Coleman Hughes: I think the crux of our disagreement is that. But is that the claim you're making? No, not necessarily. Not necessarily. But the crux of our disagreement is that for you, you would have to see something more. You don't consider enriching to 60 % solid evidence of a goal to acquire a nuclear weapon. Just to be clear, that's not happening in a vacuum. It's with all these other factors. But if you could become convinced that, you know what, the Iranians, they're going for a bomb. It might not be today. It might not be tomorrow. But their strategy, their geostrategic strategy includes a strong actual goal to get a bomb.

41:11Coleman Hughes: And they might deceive us. To get this, they might. They're going to pull out all the stops to do it as cleverly as possible, but I'm pretty convinced they're going to get a bomb. If you became convinced of that, then you would feel that military intervention targeted to the nuclear program was justified. No, I am not saying that. You wouldn't, even in that case. I'm not saying that at all. Oh, wow. No, I don't think them developing a nuclear weapon would be. But let me just be very clear here, okay? um it's i i would not support that war uh i would not call i wouldn't think the people are as full as shit i guess who are supporting it because they at least have a case because in your hypothetical they are working toward a nuclear bomb like and you've become convinced of this and i've become okay but again i just really do want to harp on the point because i think it's a very important one to make i am operating under the assumption i think i'm right about this that it is impossible for the Iranians to break out to weapons grade enrichment, develop a deliverable nuclear bomb while under IAEA inspections, they'd have to kick the inspectors out.

42:19And so we would have this big warning, this big indication that they've stopped complying. So that does make a really big difference toward this hypothetical. But in this hypothetical, no. I don't think, again, if we may have had some bad intelligence on this and you're right about the bad intelligence, but it's not as if we didn't know that Mao Zedong was attempting to get nuclear weapons. Yeah, but we didn't know when. No, no, right, right. No, I'm agreeing with that. When is a crucial question.

42:47Coleman Hughes: Sure, sure. But I'm just saying like Mao Zedong, Joseph Stalin, Kim Jong-il. It was under ill. Yes, Kim Jong-il. I mean, like amongst the worst madmen in history have developed nuclear weapons and had them. I don't think that's good. I'm against that. I'm for doing whatever you can do short of a war to stop that. I'm for doing a lot of things to stop that. Let me walk that back. But no, I don't think you launch a war of aggression, a war of choice over that. That is not in line with my conception of a just war. We might have a semantic disagreement here because I'm not necessarily saying launch a war.

43:22Coleman Hughes: I'm saying use military force to prevent it, like blowing up a nuclear facility, assassinating a top scientist, something like that. We would consider that an act of war if anyone did it to us, and I consider that an act of war. Okay, so you're against the use of military force to prevent Iran getting a new period. Yes, correct. Oh, okay. I misunderstood some things you said earlier in this conversation. I'm arguing they weren't there. I'm arguing that's not the scenario anyway. But if you're asking me if that was – I'm asking the hypothetical. If you're asking me the hypothetical, no, I still wouldn't be for a war in that.

43:54If you haven't been attacked, it's not a just war.

43:56Coleman Hughes: and that you know there's somebody so we shouldn't when you're the only country in the history of the world we shouldn't use our military in any capacity to enforce nuclear non-proliferation in particular among the countries that have declared themselves to be enemies of us i think that just let them all get nukes it's not a matter of just let them all get nukes and in fact i think the use of american force has done much more to incentivize nuclear proliferation than it's done to limit it. But no, I think, Coleman, for the only country who's ever used nuclear weapons in a war in partnership with a country who secretly has nuclear weapons and is not a member of the Non-Proliferation Treaty to go around the world attacking, launching wars of aggression against people for, again, not on the path to, but in your hypothetical, on the path to getting nuclear weapons, no, I just don't endorse anything about that system as being right.

44:51Coleman Hughes: If the people in charge of America agreed with you, they would try to get some kind of Iran deal. But they would understand that they're completely toothless if Iran decides, I'm out of the deal. I'm going to get a nuke. Because Dave Smith is president. He's against, which wouldn't be bad on every issue. But Dave Smith is president. We'd turn around some things. He's said that we're never going to use military force to prevent anyone getting a nuke. We're not launching wars of aggression. so we're just going to pull out of this and maybe not you know if i'm if i do uh find myself uh president of the united states of america that would be your probably wouldn't i probably wouldn't advertise uh that exactly the way you've said i feel a little bit more comfortable saying it out loud okay i don't know that it would be wise to advertise it that way that's interesting why wouldn't it be wise though why wouldn't it be it wouldn't be wise because you want them to think you might use military force right well i listen again you're right well why wouldn't it be wise Well, because in that situation, perhaps I would.

45:49I don't know. We're in a weird hypothetical territory now. Can we get back to the real world of Iran? The war we launched over them not getting nuclear weapons?

45:57Coleman Hughes: We can, but I'm trying to understand your position. I don't think that— Would you or wouldn't you authorize force if you really believe they were about to get a bomb? I've been very clear about—no, I'm being kind of tongue-in-cheek about how I wouldn't, as president, advertise, you can do whatever you want and I won't use force. I don't think that—I think— But it's interesting that you wouldn't. Well, hold on. Let me just – it's not – Dave, you realize it's interesting because you're admitting that it behooves us to be perceived as willing to use force. No, I'm not. I'm saying in some scenario it hypothetically could.

46:29No, America has been using a whole lot of force over the last 25 years, Coleman, as I'm sure you're quite aware. And I don't think we've done anything to solve these problems. But look, I would – again, we could spend some more time on why I don't think it's theoretically justified to launch wars of aggression over a country developing a weapon that we have. But I just want to stick here a little bit more to the real world stuff that we're arguing of over the – say the 12-day war, the nuclear program and all these thoughts.

46:54Coleman Hughes: I want to move on because I got a bunch more topics that I want to head. Do you not – I guess – I don't know. You have the 12-day war. there's this threat with whatever, however you perceive them going up to 60%. Maybe let me ask you a question like this. If it were the case, let's say we could have gotten back into a JCPOA style deal, right? Let's say that, which by a whole lot of reporting, that is the case, that this was offered. And what was insisted on by the Americans was 0 % enrichment. And I'm sure you've read a bunch about this. This is, again, not really disputed. This is Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, New York Times.

47:33This is literally what the negotiations right before the 12-day war and right before this current war were about. If it is the case, okay, as I think is a fairly strong argument that there is, but if it is the case that like Iran would have gotten into a JCPOA deal, let's say it's not even your favorite JCPOA deal. Let's even say there were some sunset provisions that you think were a little bit too weak or whatever, but they were willing to dilute the enriched uranium, they were willing to bring it down to like 3.35 % or whatever it is for nuclear power needs.

48:08Coleman Hughes: If you could have gotten that, right, and that was on the table, and instead we've chosen multiple wars or whatever we're in the situation we're in, wouldn't you acknowledge that it would be highly preferable to be in a deal like that? You take off your big concern off the table. Yes, I can't prove against the counterfactual that they will ever in the future try to break out, but you brought down what you claim the immediate threat is. And, you know, I don't know, you didn't have to kill little girls for it. So there's, there's, there's death on both sides of the equation here. My answer to you is that it's a difficult call.

48:44Coleman Hughes: And it's a difficult call because allowing Iran to get into that deal, and let's assume in the hypothetical, like they comply with the deal, right? They comply with the inspections, um, as they mostly did, uh, during, during, uh, the Obama deal. And it frees up billions and billions and billions of dollars with which they then pour into their terror proxies. Um, so it was right after that deal that Hezbollah balloons, its amount of missiles, stored in homes and villages and pointed at Israel, you would have to weigh the threat of Iran's nuclear weapon against the threat of giving it a ton of money to pour into its terror proxies all over the Middle East and destabilize other countries and pursue its regional ambitions.

49:39Coleman Hughes: And it's not obvious to me what the right choice is there because they're both destabilizing and neither one of them is really like pro-stability and peace fully. They both have a cost. I don't mean to listen. I mean this. You follow me, right? I follow your point, but like you don't think looking at this war right now versus say we lived through the JCPOA with Obama, however you felt about it, according to all reports, they were complying until Donald Trump got out of it. You don't think like that situation in Iran was enormously preferable to this situation in Iran. It's kind of like wait and see because there might be weapons pointed at Israel from southern Lebanon.

50:18Coleman Hughes: Well, this – okay, but the wrinkle in this is that this goes back to North Korea. The North Korean example, the reason that Bush couldn't do shit or kind of wisely, I guess, chose not to do shit about North Korea developing a bomb is that they had so many missiles pointed at Seoul that they could have rained – They could have killed tens of thousands of people in Seoul in a day. Right. So the missiles create a shield by which you can develop nuclear weapons. That's right. That's right. So if Iran is allowed just tons of free cash to develop those kinds of shields, it's not an obvious choice to me which one is preferable.

51:01Coleman Hughes: Because you might just be playing into a long-term plan that's going to end like North Korea. and at any given moment in the plan, a deal seems preferable because there's no war right now. And then bam, before you know it, it's too late. The frog boiling in water, the North Korean example, it's not hypothetical. Like it happened in North Korea. But even in the North Korean example, they developed the nukes, but it's not like, I don't know, it's not a war broke out or something like that. I mean, they're continuing to oppress their own people as they were before they had nuclear weapons. But like, I don't know.

51:30There's, it seems to me like a pretty overwhelming onus when you have a disaster like a war where literally already thousands of people, school kids are dying, Americans are dying, hundreds of billions of dollars, the global economy being disrupted, to just say, oh, we could get back in a deal like we had before, but that might lead to these other negative problems. I don't know. It just seems to me like the overwhelming onus if you want to take this type of intervention is on you to demonstrate it with something more than that. Also, it's just, that sounds like more of Israel's problem than our problem, to be completely honest.

52:05Coleman Hughes: Sure. I think these decisions are complicated because the consequences of inaction don't show up and they don't show up for years and years and years and then they show up all at once. And then you say, well, shit, why didn't we do something 20 years ago when the problem was much less threatening? I mean, that's the strange and sad irony about foreign policy is that if you deal with a problem when it's not a threat, everyone says, well, what the hell are you doing overreacting to this tiny threat? But if you wait for it to become a huge threat, then suddenly the cost of action is so high that anti-war folks are going to have a point with the consequences of your choice to act.

52:51Coleman Hughes: It's going to be a huge war. And the enemy is now so strong that they can impose huge humanitarian costs on various countries if you try to. So this is, I would caution against, like, it seems like in your mind this is like an easy decision. and in my mind it's not an easy decision. I agree with that analysis. I think it's an easy decision. I think it's the dumbest foreign policy decision in American history. Do you follow my point about the consequences of inaction? I follow. It shows up all at once and it just happens. I get it. Again, it's painting a hypothetical. I think that, if it makes sense, there's much more of a danger in my mind in using this vague hypothetical of like, Yeah, but in other words, it's very neoconservative logic.

53:36I mean, I don't mean that just as an insult. I mean, like, literally, this is what they wrote in the project for a new American century, was that what you got to do, you know, the famous line is put a small country up against the wall and beat the crap out of them every few years just to let everybody else know we mean business. Like, they would openly say, we got to fight a war against the country we know poses no threat to us with a wink and a nod. Yeah, I would not say that. No, no, no, I'm not saying you say that. But with a wink and a nod, because they'll always say that the country poses a threat to us when it's time to fight the war because in theory they could get much bigger and then they could like i follow the point i think it's a recipe for um permanent war to to think that well because anytime anyone paints a picture of how threatening this next country is then we have a recipe to start a war and then also what ends up happening is it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as every as all the war hawks start threatening this country more and more they become more and more belligerent.

54:30And then that's more and more proof that look, we do need to go take these guys out. So no, I think it's a much more, um, I think there's a reason why after like all of these wars are going disastrously so much more often than they're not. Um, and I think that to launch another regime change war in the middle East after seven in a war have been catastrophes and to pretend that you couldn't see the consequence of this when everybody Coleman, You've been in the world talking about these issues for so long. You didn't see the consequence. Everyone's been talking about the consequences of this war for 25 years.

55:06Everybody knew that this was a possibility that could happen. Yeah, he launched the dumbest war and he lied. And he lied his way.

55:13Coleman Hughes: The consequences of which war? Iran? Iran. Okay, okay. So you said for 25 years. I'm saying that I'm referencing the fact that immediately after 9-11, Iran was put on the axis of evil. And that the conversation about this war has been happening this whole time. So honestly, I don't – man, I really, really don't want this to come off the wrong way because I really do – I like you and respect you, honestly. I think that – I do follow what you're saying. I think you're unbelievably good at making these arguments. It does almost seem to me like it's like you're working from your conclusion to defend this.

55:50Like that's the best argument we can come up with. But the reality of the situation here is that – Why do you say that? Because, look, I just mean this, right? And I don't mean in a sense, I'm not saying that you're being bad faith. I'm saying that we've launched, this is the seventh of like six regime change operations in the region. Every last one of them has been a catastrophe. Hundreds of thousands of people dead, trillions of dollars wasted against the will of the entire American public or most of the American public. He just launched this war. It's also turned into another disaster. And he's lying us into it.

56:24You're not even disagreeing with me with all of this. But yet you won't just connect it to the obvious conclusion here, which is that, yeah, this is kind of an easy decision. We should not have done this. Obviously, we've put ourselves in a terrible position. And even by your own stated intentions here, Iran is more likely to break out from nuclear with a more radical government. and they're being transformed into, I think, a legitimate global power with their control of the strait. So let me say this.

56:52Coleman Hughes: I think part of the disconnect between you and me is that I think more about the good results which have come, which have been secured through military force in the past in certain cases, and also the results of inaction. And I think people in the anti-war camp don't think enough about that because there's a seen and unseen phenomenon where what you see - Yeah, well, you see the costs of, we all see the costs of war, as we should, and we see it more and more in the age of first television with Vietnam, and now social media. But we don't really see or grok the consequences of inaction, right? So first of all, if you want to talk about the great moral victories of humanity that have been achieved through war, many are wars of choice, by the way.

57:46Coleman Hughes: The existence of America secured through the American Revolution, very bloody war. The end of the enslavement of sailors by the Barbary pirates, war of choice. End of slavery in the Confederacy secured through a war. The existence of the country of South Korea secured through a war of choice. The end of civil war in Liberia secured through a war of choice. and so there the reason i can't just be anti-war like okay i see a war i'm immediately against it is because i understand that great oh i didn't even mention the end of nazism and imperial japanese rule over asia right did you not mention world war ii i guess i just i guess i just counted that i don't think before you mentioned it but it's like a rather big data point so but great moral victories, which have had enormously good consequences for the human race, have been secured through the willingness to use military force in the right situations.

58:46Coleman Hughes: And the key is discernment. I wish our leaders were much more discerning. And this is where I agree with you. Our leaders have shown consistent, poor, very far from perfect discernment in terms of which wars are worth fighting and which wars are not, which wars are winnable and which wars are not. But the anti-war position implies that really the smartest thing for a person to do is to just, if you see a war, you're just against it. I think that's the wrong orientation, as far as I'm concerned, towards the use of force. And that's a big part of the disagreement between us. Okay, I think that is a big part of the disagreement.

59:25I think it's a misrepresentation to say certainly that my position – maybe it is the position of some – but certainly not my position is that if you see a war, you're against it. And in fact, like the example you gave of the American Revolution I think is a pretty easy war to support and not necessarily supporting the decision of – I mean who knows? I don't know. There was a lot of conspiracy. At the time, a lot of people were against it. Oh, sure, sure.

59:49Coleman Hughes: Their arguments weren't crazy. That is very Trump-y. A lot of people say it's not good. okay let's just pay a little bit more taxes well look i mean look there's no i'm not even saying there's a debate there's always a debate to um whether you should just pay a little bit more taxes or fight a war to not pay those taxes and i mean really i think the only moral conclusion from that is that it ought to be the decision of those people who are willing to risk their lives whether they want to fight for that or not much like in the same case of any invading army it's like yeah you could cede your country but i think when when you have an invading army and you're repelling and invading army.

1:00:23It's a much more clean cut moral dynamic than obviously when you're, you know, attacking a country. All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show. Brand new sponsor who we're thrilled to have on board, which is Ghostbed. Ghostbed is engineered to help reduce the reasons sleep gets interrupted. It's designed to relieve pressure, help regulate temperature and support your body. It has cooling technology, get this, built into every mattress and it's made in the USA, which doesn't that make us all feel better? They just sent me a ghost bed mattress and I put it in my guest room of my house.

1:00:58It is a delight. Let me tell you, I'm trying to start fights with my wife so I can get kicked into the guest room to sleep on this thing. She's not taking the bait so far. She's really difficult to start it. But anyway, the ghost bed is great. That's the point. Ghostbed.com slash problem. And they are offering our audience an extra 10 % off. This is their lowest price of the season. With Ghostbed's 101 night sleep trial, you can try it at home because the real test of a mattress is how you feel in the morning. So if you are out there, if you're waking up sore or tired or just feeling like you're not getting the most out of your mattress, check out Ghostbed.

1:01:35They are offering you an extra 10 % off when you go to ghostbed.com slash problem and use the promo code problem. Ghostbed.com slash

1:01:43Coleman Hughes: Problem promo code problem for 10 % off. All right. Let's get back into the show. Let's OK. Let's talk a little bit about Israel because we've I'm you know, I lose track of time when we're in these things, but we've got an hour. We haven't talked that much about Israel and that is almost an hour. And that would be against the laws of podcasting. That's right. If we didn't talk about that. So what let me ask you what when it comes to like kind of the Israeli involvement in all of this. And, look, man, obviously this is like one of the major topics of politics over the last three plus years. The kind of, you know, I don't even know exactly how to describe it.

1:02:26You know, there are probably a lot of different terms that would be correct. Like people will say, I think a lot of people in your circles talk about the rise of anti-Semitism. A lot of people in my circle probably talk about the collapsing support of the state of Israel. but there's no question that this the political awareness of this topic has exploded over the last few years that's come with a lot of negatives I think a lot of positives too but it seems like you have a real like you have a real gripe with the narrative that like Israel is dragging America into war that these are wars on behalf of Israel this is something that you've kind of kind of you know been pushing back a lot when your debates with me with glenn greenwald and in other uh shows that you've done sure so with the war here i'm kind of wondering exactly what your position is because this one is a little bit unique like particularly the 12 day and this current war that we're in that this isn't really like you know we can go back through iraq and do all that in a little bit but like this isn't like oh the neoconservatives formed you know kind of took over these apparatuses and had these think tanks and formed this consensus over this information.

1:03:37And this is a war we're launching with Israel. This is a war that Benjamin Netanyahu and Donald Trump are launching together. According to the New York Times, Benjamin Netanyahu is really the one who kind of pushed him over the edge toward it. Of course, there's those statements of Marco Rubio. We can get into all of that about, because I don't actually think that's right. And I think some on my side are jumping on that in the wrong way. But I guess I'm kind of asking, what is your thought here? Because it's like the Israeli influence and involvement here is undeniable. So like, what is your position on that angle?

1:04:10Coleman Hughes: If I gave you the movie of how I think it went down, broadly, it starts with Donald Trump hating Iran for many, many decades, being old enough to remember the hostage crisis, hostage crisis, for starters. It continues with Donald Trump's probably strong and potentially accurate belief that the Iranians tried to kill him as if we believe the New York grand jury which found that Asif Merchant was an Iranian agent. To be clear, you're not talking about Butler though. Just to be clear because everyone thinks you're talking about Butler if you say that. It's not Butler. I just want to make that clear because it's one of these things where whenever anyone talks about it, people assume.

1:04:53But by the way, I'm sorry. Please don't lose your train of thought there. I apologize for interrupting. It's not clear.

1:04:59Coleman Hughes: I think I should make that Trump is aware of that distinction. I've heard Trump say a few things where it seems like he might actually have been convinced that it was the butler one. Anyway, I'm not sure if that's true, but I think it was worth pointing out. Please continue. So the movie, it starts with him hating Iran for all the reasons you would expect an American from the 70s and 80s, formative years. for the same reason he still still thinks like cats is like a still talks about cats the musical like that's where he is that's his era he thinks they tried to kill him he may be right about that um he is famously vindictive and then netanyahu everyone from netanyahu to to mbs is who it's in their interest obviously to have an iran war they say you know we encourage you we're we have your back.

1:05:47Coleman Hughes: We think now is a good time. Trump decides for his own reasons, okay, given everything I'm seeing, this seems like a great chance to strike down a regime, which I hate for both personal and I guess his own political, not in the bad sense of the word, reasons, right? That the existence of this regime is not in the American interest. You can go through the list of how many times they've plotted terror attacks in America and Europe and all over the world. So let's get rid of these guys. That's the basic picture that I think happened. Now, if you zoom in on, you do what the anti-Israel people do and just don't play the whole movie, but play the part where Trump's talking to Netanyahu.

1:06:33Coleman Hughes: And like, you also don't play the part where he had the same conversation with MBS and half the other, you know, Sunni monarchs that hate Iran and view Iran as an existential threat to them. You say, oh, Netanyahu manipulated him into it. No, I'm sorry. This is nonsense. Unless I see actual direct evidence of Trump being blackmailed, I will continue to model Donald Trump the way I have been modeling him since he came on the political scene in 2015, which is this motherfucker is so shameless, you couldn't even blackmail him if you wanted to. First of all, because he would just say, yeah, release the tape of me peeing on the blah, blah, blah.

1:07:09Coleman Hughes: I'm the greatest pedophile that's ever been. Yeah, I can shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and you motherfuckers would still vote for me. He can't be blackmailed. He's famous. He has the highest – I'm going to say this. If it's wrong, somebody just – I assume he has the highest churn rate in the history of any White House because he fires everyone who says something he doesn't want to hear. He must. I don't know. I've seen that stat out, but he must have the highest turnover rate. If he were annoyed by some quote unquote Israel lobby person talking his ear off about how he had to go to war in Iran and he didn't like it, he would say, get the fuck out of my office.

1:07:45Coleman Hughes: What do you like? This is annoying to me. Right. So my conclusion from the evidence is that Trump thought the Iran war, the regime change war was a good idea. He thought the moment was right. He thought he had strong allies at his back that were not only aligned with the overall goal, but also at this moment, with this being the correct moment. And so he pulled the trigger with Israel, with Israel as an ally. But there's no manipulation in my story. There's no this. There's no puppeteering. There's no whatever. it's and i totally get why americans are like fuck trump this motherfucker chose to increase my gas prices for a year for a war with an with that's unlikely to succeed i'll say lower than 50 chance of succeeding 25 chance of succeeding totally makes sense to me why you'd say you know what i'm voting for the other party uh i'm voting for the party that's going to bring down my gas prices i'd never have a i'd never have an issue with a person that had that view.

1:08:51Coleman Hughes: But then to say, okay, to go the further step and say, ah, Netanyahu manipulated him into it. I mean, I just don't see this as a fair reading of the evidence at all. And it's such a classic, reflexive, knee-jerk thing to do with Israel. I don't know why people do it. It makes, it frankly makes people who do that just look like they have a kind of delusional, like out to get Israel, Israeli puppeteering the world kind of a view. Okay, man, there's a lot there. And I find that really interesting. You know, I got to say, I don't know that we're that far apart on the substance of this. By the way, as you say that, I also just can't completely outside the realm of how either of us feel about this, just purely putting our political analyst hats on.

1:09:37I can't believe that this is actually Donald Trump's fourth quarter pitch going into the midterms. Like I'm not exaggerating. His pitch is what you just said. Yeah, I made this decision that made your bills more expensive, but they're going to come way down soon. And you're just like, however you feel about the war, just looking at politics, you go, man, that is death. He's a weird guy. That is a terrible sales pitch. But also as weird a guy as he is, it's so antithetical to the whole spirit of the MAGA pitch. That was at the very beginning, that was like, it's not about the world. It's about you.

1:10:10And no one cares about you. Hey, Rust Belt, you've been suffering. And these globalists only care about like whatever. But anyway, back to the substance of what you just said is very interesting. I do kind of agree with you that I think I think essentially really to me in my reading of this here, I think it's to say like, you know, Donald that that Netanyahu manipulated Donald Trump or tricked Donald Trump or something like that. I mean, I think according to the reporting, it does seem like Netanyahu was instrumental in being one of the people in Donald Trump's ears, one of the major ones, who was kind of going, this will work.

1:10:54If we do this, this will work. We could do Venezuela all over again. You're going to get a big success out of this. We'll top them. They won't have time. Look, I got my intelligence guy here who also thinks the same thing. Now, Coleman, this is a bit of speculation, if I want to be completely fair here, but this is a bit of speculation on my part. It's very hard for me to believe that Netanyahu and the head of Mossad actually thought there was a very high likelihood that they would be able to decapitate this regime. It is possible I'm wrong about that and that it was like kind of wishful thinking on their part or bad intelligence.

1:11:25Isn't it just classic?

1:11:26Coleman Hughes: Isn't there no more common mistake than for military intelligence to be too optimistic? It is certainly – like I was saying, I'm saying it's possible and it certainly is not against the laws of logic. And if you want to ask me of the years of reading about Warhawks, is hubris a possible explanation for this? More than possible. It's almost default. I don't know if I – in this particular situation, I have a very tough time imagining that the people who specialize in this could not have foreseen at least the likelihood of this incredibly predictable result coming out of it. So I guess there is – I do think it's – Why is this the one war that couldn't be explained by hubris?

1:12:09No, I'm not saying this is the one war that couldn't be explained by hubris. What I'm saying is that after us living through the regime changes in Iraq, in Libya, in Afghanistan, in Yemen, in Somalia, in knowing the dynamics with Iran, you would have for anybody to not know that going into this war, there is a high likelihood that you will not get a regime change without a ground force, something that has probably never been achieved before in military history. There is a high likelihood that they will be able to, if not, the popular term is close the Strait of Hormuz. But what's actually going on is they can touch the Strait of Hormuz, which then makes it very difficult to inshore cargo ships going through and very difficult to get civilians to go through.

1:12:50And that they could touch our bases, which we have all throughout the region. Like all of these things were so incredibly predictable. This is now, again, it is true that I think a lot of neocons really believed Iraq would be a cakewalk. And it wasn't. It turned into an eight-year brutal civil war where over a million people died. But I really have a tough time believing that the Israelis couldn't see this coming. Why? All that – because it's so predictable by every single person who's talked about this for the last 25 years. Literally – maybe I've swam in these circles for a little bit too long.

1:13:19But everyone who's opposed this war –

1:13:20Coleman Hughes: You're thinking like Dave Smith. I mean you're thinking like Dave Smith, the anti-war libertarian who is always super in touch with and assuming that military adventures are going to be a failure. The way that security establishments tend to think is generally to overestimate their own abilities. That's why – I'm not disagreeing with that generally. I'm talking about a very specific – Why wouldn't Netanyahu think that way? Because, I mean, after living – Or at least the security – I mean, I guess just after living through all of these obvious examples to not at least have indexed a proportional chance that it could go the way – Again, just to be – Hold on.

1:13:57Coleman Hughes: Let me just make this point. I'm not just saying like, hey, this is what Dave Smith, this is what I read in Ron Paul or Murray Rothbard's book, or this is what Scott Horton believes. I'm talking about like this is what the Pentagon warned George W. Bush about. This is what, as I mentioned earlier, the Wall Street Journal had reported just a couple days before this war that top military Pentagon officials were warning Trump about. This is not – like I'm saying I find it hard to believe, as of course we've had confirmed from Joe Kent, that obviously there were people who were like saying like, yo, this is a real threat to do this.

1:14:31But regardless, to your point, I really was trying almost to agree with you more than disagree with you on this specific point. But please continue.

1:14:37Coleman Hughes: We're disagreeing about degree though because to me it's never surprising when you have military guys that overestimate the ability of their own army. It's almost a systematic bias that security states tend to have. The fact that you say there are so many obvious examples, well, what does that imply? To me, that implies that the first half of the obvious examples weren't enough to warn them from the second half of the obvious examples. So why would this be the time that suddenly they all wised up and were super conservative and risk averse? And this is not the nature of security establishments is that there's always a contingent that is generally overestimating their abilities.

1:15:19Coleman Hughes: And there's usually another contingent that's like warning. Right. And the truth is none of them know. They're all making like various levels of educated guesses and there's inherent uncertainty. So when you see a leak in the Wall Street Journal saying there is this Pentagon guy that was warning again. Well, there's always someone warning against it. and there's always someone warning for it yeah but we give people who get the warnings correct and who are basing their opinions in reality anyone who has a high batting average across the board should be respected more sure okay okay okay these predictions are inherently difficult who predicted did anyone like predict that weakening hezbollah would topple would like topple the assad regime i didn't i certainly didn't did you predict that no yeah so it's like these things are unpredictable sometimes they go one way sometimes they go totally okay again i don't i don't disagree with that statement but i just don't think that contradicts what i was saying but uh more let's drill down a little bit more here so like but still on your point i don't think that what if you want to frame it as like donald trump was tricked or manipulated i mean in a in a sense these are things that we're almost psychoanalyzing people when we do this we're guessing to like what you know like obviously if you have somebody whatever if you're lobbying me to have a certain guest on my show, Dave, you should really have this guy on, and I end up having him on my show, we could sit here kind of debating forever, like, did you persuade me?

1:16:46Coleman Hughes: Persuasion and tricking are two different things. Everyone knows what they are. Okay, fair enough, fair enough. But I'm saying even without the variable of the distinction between persuasion and trick, like even between trick implying something dishonest, where persuasion just being like, you made a case why I should have this guy on and I agreed with you. How much of that was me deciding that I agreed with the case you were making, how much of that was your persuasion over me is a difficult thing to quantify in any scenario. I give, I just, I guess Donald Trump gets no excuse. He should know all of this stuff.

1:17:17He's more than well aware of what the, who the Israelis are and what their intentions are here. Like, I just don't think, um, I think there's something that serves to excuse what Donald Trump's done away by framing it as he was purely manipulated into this where i think that's what i was saying i think we probably agree on that what i do think there is evidence of and this is what joe kent specifically uh alleged and this is really the only thing that joe kent alleged that like he knows from his work at least that i that i found to be a bombshell is that it was netanyahu who persuaded i wouldn't say tricked well debatable how you want to look at it persuaded donald trump to adopt the zero zero enrichment Is it debatable based on the evidence?

1:18:01Coleman Hughes: Is there evidence of a trick? Or is that just an assumption? No, the evidence, I'm going to try to say this in the most careful way. I think it is reasonable, given the evidence that we have, to speculate about what that might have been. We don't know for sure either way. I think it's reasonable to point out that it was very easy – look, like in the same way I was saying, it was very easy to know how this war would go. It was very easy to know that the Iranians would not agree to 0 % enrichment and a complete abolishing of all of their civilian nuclear program. Did Israel stick that in there so it's the poison pill so that we end up blowing up negotiations?

1:18:37I think they wanted negotiations blown up. That's not – I think –

1:18:40Coleman Hughes: The problem with these stories is they only work if everyone else involved is like a low IQ idiot. it. No, I don't think that's true. And I don't think I think you're speculating just as much when you presume that the intentions of all of these people are noble. No, no, I'm speculating based on the evidence that exists. There's no until there's evidence of a trick. In other words, until there's someone said, you know, I was in the room, and I saw Netanyahu. I heard Netanyahu confer with the head of IDF intelligence. And they said, you know, this Iran war, it's probably the regime change is not going to work.

1:19:09Coleman Hughes: But we're going to tell Donald Trump, it's going to work. and we know it's basically impossible, but we're going to tell him, we're going to beef him up and we're going to pump him up because we think the result will be in our interests. Right? That would be evidence. Like leaks, people leak things all the time, right? Do we have a leak like that? I mean, so I'm basing, it's not equally speculative. Mine is based on the evidence that actually exists. Yeah, but I'm not - Yours is based on an assumption that there could be a trick somewhere. No, no, no, no. It's not based on an assumption. I'm literally saying that I find it very hard to believe that the Israelis would have been convinced with high likelihood that this plan, this very unlikely plan will work.

1:19:49Now, you could say that is speculation. But if you're saying, no, I believe they were convinced it would work, you're also speculating on what their motivations were. All we know is that they told Donald Trump that it would work. That's all we know. Anyone speculating on their motivations is equally speculating, you or me.

1:20:06Coleman Hughes: Oh, I see what you mean. So you're just saying they could have been lying and we don't know. Right. We don't know. And it does seem like it lines up with a lot of their interests. Let me ask you that because this is I think maybe gets more to the heart of the issue. And this was when I read the – you wrote an article after your conversation with Glenn Greenwald kind of reflecting on your conversations with me and him. And I think that they're – OK, so at one point you kind of say as you did just a few moments ago. You kind of go, well, look, why are people doing this? Like why are people speculating that Netanyahu tricked Donald Trump, that the Israelis are pulling the string here or something like that?

1:20:46And when you're going, look, the evidence here really is that like, yeah, Benjamin Netanyahu is one of the players here. He's conducting this war with Trump. But there's also the Saudis. There's also the other Gulf states. There's also Donald Trump's feelings about this situation. And you're saying it's kind of unfair to frame it this way. And it's like people are kind of kooky to be framing it as this. But it just – OK. But it seems like there's a lot that's omitted there that I just – and particularly because you're you. You're kind of the rational atheist. Like let's lower the temperature here and like examine this guy.

1:21:22Look, when you see something like – on the broader question of like the Israel lobby or Israeli influence over America, when you have – like if we didn't have this and I set this as the standard, it would be kind of – like the president of the United States of America openly says that his biggest donor, the Israeli woman, technically I think Palestinian. She was born in 46, I believe, before the state of Israel was created. But the woman born over there, he openly says that her number one issue is Israel, that that's all she cares about, that she comes to see him all the time over Israel, and he pretty much gives her whatever he wants.

1:22:01Her late husband, who is also the biggest donor in Republican politics, has openly stated that his greatest regret in life was that he didn't wear the IDF uniform. He wore the American military uniform. And his greatest accomplishment in life is that his son wears the IDF uniform. The president of the United States is openly saying this. Now, Coleman, I know we sit on different sides of these camps and on different things. But like, brother, you got to admit, that's kind of a smoking gun, man.

1:22:32Coleman Hughes: A smoking gun that Trump is making decisions that they want him to? No, a smoking gun that there is an intolerable situation going on here. where an influence from a foreign... Dude, the fact that the biggest donors to this guy, their loyalty is a foreign nation. If you go back... You don't see a problem with that? What you're saying right now is that Trump is making decisions on that basis. No, no, no, no. I'm not saying that. I'm not saying that. If donors can have whatever beliefs they want, I care if the president is being influenced and making his decisions for a foreign country. So you're saying...

1:23:04Coleman Hughes: Hold on, hold on. So when you go back to Trump 1, everyone goes, Jesus Christ, this Trump guy, I can't stop talking about how much he loves Putin. And maybe we think Putin has something on him. And we spent years in this country trying to explain the genuinely like sometimes hard to explain for an American, given that Russia's like our historical enemy, like the things that he would say. Right. And now you have, you know, everyone who's who's pro-Ukraine is obviously like super upset at Trump over his break with Zelensky, the things he says about Zelensky. and for years we had this discourse about how Putin must be manipulating him.

1:23:40Coleman Hughes: And I just thought this was totally ridiculous. Me too. And you thought this was ridiculous. And I know we see eye to eye on that. Yep. And so for me, I'm just applying the same way I think to Trump and Netanyahu. Obviously, Netanyahu is not some master whisperer that's manipulating him. You can disagree with Trump's support of Israel. That's no problem with that disagreement. But the idea that he is somehow being manipulated by his donors after winning the second time he doesn't need his donor he has lots of other donors too you know like so that's the biggest one though okay but he has he has lots of donors i've never seen anyone allege that the other donors who have other interests are manipulating him the the saudis can come out in a new york times article where the headline is like head of saudi arabia tells trump to bomb iran and everyone just snooze nothing to see there but oh maybe netanyahu is in his ear it's like it's literally a headline in the saudis and nobody thinks the saudis are to blame right nobody thinks the saudis are manipulating him it's only israel so for me what's really weird is that like why does someone like you who can so clearly see through this type of bs argument on every other front suddenly give it like you're like by no means the the most extreme version of this argument but you give it more credence than you would in any other situation well let me say this i um i was and people can go back and check my track record on this that all the podcasts are still up i was man like russiagate was my number one issue for years on this show and i mean it was just every day like that was what we did on the show just tearing apart because it was dude it was such an extraordinary claim being made by the entire halls of power against the sitting president of the united states like it's like if your claim is true this is the biggest story in american history your claim is that a hostile foreign power overthrew our democracy and installed their agent you know like this and it was so clearly bullshit going if man if they had had what they have on israeli influence on america that would have been quite a different story if donald trump had been out there going dude my biggest donors donate to me just because they love russia and i give them everything they want they come every day asking for it and i move the capital for them and i support them doing this and That is an apples to oranges, completely different story.

1:25:59Coleman Hughes: He didn't say he moved the Capitol for them. He literally said that. He said he moved the Capitol for who? I think it was for Sheldon that he said that. Or he said that he kept demanding it every single day. I mean, dude, it is crazy. Look, I'll say this, okay? Look, if you go back in the memoirs of Trump making that decision, he has all kinds of people in his ear. But this goes to my earlier point. telling if you're a president people say hey do this you don't have to do it and trump and trump uniquely almost uniquely to a degree that like is exceptional given his extremely strange personality is the type where if he really doesn't want to do it he tells people to fuck off and fires them i guess look so it's always a little evidence of people who care about israel like jewish americans who care about Israel and are around Trump, the evidence of them wanting something and saying they want it is not equal to evidence that Trump is being manipulated.

1:26:55Okay, but even leaving aside the distinction between whether there's pressure put on him or manipulation or something they just want and they'll just give him money for that. This is, I remember, honestly, and this is almost why, man, when you say like, you can see through all this other stuff, why do you see it like this on this one, right? I remember I had this argument. you would totally be on my side of this argument but i remember getting this argument with this feminist uh girl it's like 15 years ago i really liked her she's a nice girl her politics were just awful but we were getting this argument at a comedy club uh not far from here is this old club called eastville new york it's right down the block there and it's like the front of it is a full window so we're just looking onto the onto the street of the east village on a summer night and we're at the bar having this argument and she's trying to convince me that we live in a rape culture and i'm literally just like pointing out the window while girls with their asses hanging out are walking by us on the street and i'm going like you know but that you know now i don't know now then i said i remember her i said we live in a slut culture you know we're at a comedy club being funny or whatever and then we started out and immediately when i said we live in a slut culture she goes how do you even prove that what does it even mean to be in a slut culture what's And I go, yeah, exactly.

1:28:08That's my point about all your things. Like, what does it mean we live in a rape culture? So like when you're having these conversations, Coleman, I don't know what to say. It's so overwhelming, man. This is why I don't like dismiss this, whereas I did dismiss Russiagate. Almost everyone, and I honestly understand why an atheist like you can't see this. Almost everyone in power, dude, has like this religious type devotion to a foreign nation. It is weird, man. And I honestly, almost just like when I'm pointing to the feminists, like, look at the ass outside. How are you going to tell me we live in a rape culture when you can see that there?

1:28:45You see so much of our political class kissing their wall and crying. You see people from the State Department saying, openly saying, America is the greatest country in the world. Well, except Israel. Of course, we love Israel. You have Huckabee and Cruz talking about how God gave all of this land to Israel. And as I just mentioned, forget whether it had any influence on Trump at all for a second. Miriam Adelson is the number one donor to Republican politics. And he says his greatest regret in life is that he wore our country's uniform rather than another's. Like you don't see something outrageous here.

1:29:20Coleman Hughes: Nothing at all. This is. It's exactly what the Russiagate people said is the evidence is overwhelming. He met. He took a meeting with him. And, you know, they said. But meeting is bullshit. Your number one donor is not bullshit. Hold on. Hold on. So at the end of the day, you have to look at the evidence on this issue. In my view, I gave this example last time. There's tons of examples like this. One is that there are so many examples from the past 30 years where Israel wanted X and America was just like, no. And something that was like really in Israel's interests. It was like relatively easy for America to provide.

1:29:59Coleman Hughes: And we just said no. For example, not recognizing Israel's sovereignty over the Golan Heights for decades and decades and decades. It would have taken any single president one flick of a pen. The Israel lobby definitely wanted them to. And president after president after president after president just said no. Moving the embassy to Jerusalem. Every single president since Bill Clinton just said no every six months. No every six months. again, really symbolically important to the Israelis. American presidents have no problem resisting it until Trump decides he wants to do it, right? And again, I maintain that that was his decision.

1:30:42Coleman Hughes: He was not bought and paid for in any sense, right? That's just not a good model of Trump's mind or personality. And so another example I gave on our podcast last time is a story from Condoleezza Rice where Bush is about to give a big speech in 2002 and he's about to like endorse theoretically the idea of a Palestinian state and the Israelis are freaking out about this they're like hold on hold on hold on and they call Condoleezza Rice and they say okay fine fine fine if he's going to give the speech if we can't you know if you're not going to you know kill the speech just add one word to it instead of saying Palestine say new Palestine that's all we're asking and condoleezza rice goes what are you talking about no i'm telling you the speech is like fuck off like click and he gives the speech the way the way it was written it wasn't even a thought in her mind to like bend to this supposedly massive pressure and yet we're supposed to believe that the the lobby that couldn't even change one word of a bush speech that like basically no american would have noticed the difference uh somehow can get us into all of these wars and can manipulate the president on all sorts of other uh decisions they asked bush to bomb the syrian nuclear reactor in 2007 and dick cheney even wanted to do it for his own reasons and bush was like no um so if you include all the data ran in 2007 and you said no many many such cases but the point is if you look at only the cases where u.s president has decided okay, this thing that Israel wants, I think I also want.

1:32:20Coleman Hughes: If you look only at those cases and exclude all the other data points, you're like, man, we're always just doing whatever Israel wants. But you're literally excluding all of the data points that would refute. In fact, I would argue you guys aren't, you're supposed to falsify a thesis, right? Like in science, you're supposed to be like, okay, I think this thing might be true. Let me look for all the data that falsifies it. I would argue that none of the Israel lobby people have ever done that like a scientist. Look for the data that might falsify your thesis before you come to a conclusion, because there are some deep underlying assumptions there that are motivating this line of argument, not an unbiased look at the data.

1:32:56I think that you're I think you might be guilty here of strawmanning what the thesis is and then thinking that you're disproving that. And I think you did this in your article about me and Glenn, too, where you lay out the all powerful Israel lobby. But like that was never the claim to begin with. The claim wasn't they always get their way. For example, right, if somebody were to say, you were to broadly look at my life and say, my wife has a huge influence on me, that would undeniably be a correct statement. She has more influence on me than any human, well, my mother, whatever. Very quickly, very quickly.

1:33:29Coleman Hughes: You just said the people who run this country have a religious devotion to Israel. Hold on one second. Let me just do one thing. Equivalent to? Yes, let me. I'll explain that. I'm happy to explain that further. I mean, literally, I'm talking about half of them who say God gave all of this land to Benjamin. But I'm not strawmanning your argument then. What I'm referring to with that is that people go and cry at their wall. They say God gave them this land. They say those who bless Israel are blessed. This is a religious devotion to something. Let me just get back to the point I'm making. If I were to say to you, my wife has enormous influence over me.

1:34:02And then you were to point out examples of where my wife asked me to do something and I didn't do it. As simple as your wife asked you to send a letter one day and you just didn't send that. Therefore, we can kind of conclude that she doesn't have this enormous influence over you. This is bad methodology, Coleman. This is fallacious thinking. It does not prove the fact that you don't always get your way or that there might be one time when I didn't listen to my wife doesn't prove anything. And that's not a scientific examination of how much influence an organization or a broad loosely. Hold on.

1:34:33Hold on. Let me just finish this point. and then I promise I'll give you all the time in the world to respond. Even the examples you chose – That's a really bad analogy, Dave. Well, hold on one second. You can make this point at the end, but I don't think it is a bad analogy. The fact that somebody could have enormous influence over somebody else and there still could be examples where that influence wasn't, I don't know, taken or used or wasn't effective. There is – excuse me. I'm sorry. I kind of broke up my train of thought here. Okay. the idea here I'm sorry, here, you can go ahead it'll come back to me, you can jump in, sorry

1:35:07Coleman Hughes: if my fiance asked me, hey, go get me a cup of water like literally today my fiance is sick, she woke up with like a throat thing she said, hey, can you go downstairs, get me a cup of tea? of course, baby you know why? obviously I would do that obviously I would do that because it's something that is in her interest it's like, doesn't cost me very much has there ever been a small request that you've said no to from your wife though could i find example could i find an example of something where like she was like hey can i get a glass of water and for whatever reason you were like making a joke about it or something i don't why would i say i can't do it right now well maybe there's a reason i i don't know why would there be a reason i couldn't get her a glass of water if she's like you're running out the door you have to go to work yeah i don't know something is coming up there could be some other reason you wouldn't conclude from one by the way let me just finish the examples you used were examples where the Israel lobby ultimately got their way and it was acknowledged by the president.

1:36:07No, but now it was - This is tennis without the net. Hold on, no.

1:36:08Coleman Hughes: If they're asking for it for 30 years and then one president does it, you throw out the data of the 30 years of the - I'm not throwing out any data. The lack of influence. Coleman, what do you think my claim is? Ultimately choosing to do it is evidence of the influence. This is heads I win, tails you lose. No, it's not. No, no, no, no, no, it's not. If an organization lobbies for something for decades and gets their way, then I don't know. You don't conclude from that that they have no influence. And I don't think you'd conclude from that that, I don't know, it's proof of they're not. It's like, yeah, for 30 years they were working toward this and then they achieved it.

1:36:39I'm just pointing out that the examples you used were examples where they got the policy they wanted and the president who gave it to them credited the Israel lobby for getting them.

1:36:48Coleman Hughes: There were several examples you're ignoring. Well, I'm not ignoring them. It's fine. Syrian nuclear reactor. The point I'm making, I'm just pointing out that you happen to choose these even in your examples. The point I'm making is having some examples that go against this doesn't prove anything. We're saying this is a lobby that has a lot of influence. Nobody's saying they're all controlling or they always get their way. Okay. So the problem with this thesis is that it treats any example of the United States and Israel pursuing a common objective as evidence of the lobby, quote, getting its way, right?

1:37:21Coleman Hughes: So is it possible in your worldview? Could you admit that it's possible that a United States president does something because he or she thinks it's in the United States' interest and it also happens to be something that Israel wants? Sure, of course. Okay, so then how do you – if that's possible, then not every data point of the lobby got this is evidence of the lobby's influence. Right. That's absolutely true. I think the error that you're making here, right, is that just because you can't quantify that doesn't mean we assume it's zero. I think this is the error. I don't assume it's zero. I mean all lobbies have some power.

1:37:59Yeah, but that's not – I think you're kind of missing my point. If – this is kind of how we – what we were debating about Benjamin Netanyahu testifying ahead of the authorization of military force. You know, if Coca-Cola, let's say, put a billboard in Times Square and they pay$10 million for a big billboard that says Coca-Cola on it, and then Coca-Cola is doing a ton of business. Look, it's hard for us to exactly quantify how much business that$10 million billboard produced for Coca-Cola. We do, we can, in a Misesian kind of sense, we can deduce from the action, reasonably speaking, from the performative action, we could deduce that Coca-Cola felt that this was going to be worth more than$10 million in revenue.

1:38:47Like that's their expectation going into it because logically we could say they wouldn't be, they're not in the business of charity. They wouldn't be paying this unless they thought this was worth some amount of value. It's going to be kind of impossible for us to quantify how many people bought a Coke off of that billboard. And probably no one will tell you, I bought a Coca-Cola today because there's a big billboard up in Times Square. We do not conclude from that that therefore that billboard was completely ineffective and had nothing to do with anyone buying a Coke. When you look around and you see that the biggest donor only cares about Israel.

1:39:18So much of the political class is devoted to Israel that there's all this influence. And then you notice Israel's the number one recipient of foreign aid. Israel has an unconditional relationship with America, unlike other relationships. The more reasonable conclusion in this thing, I think I'm being perfectly scientific here. It's just we don't have a way to quantify this exactly. The more reasonable conclusion of the Koch billboard is that, yeah, it is probably driving some business. That's why they're doing this. The more reasonable conclusion – I'll finish in two seconds. The more reasonable conclusion of the Adelsons giving hundreds of millions of dollars to Trump, Netanyahu coming over here and meeting with him seven times to push him toward the decision of invading.

1:39:57The more reasonable position is that they're doing this for a reason. They're not investing all their money and time, and they certainly at least perceive it's going to move the needle. That's not me saying the Jews control all of society. These are different claims. I'm also not dismissing it as like, no, it's very, very weird. And I would argue intolerable that so many people in power are loyal to a foreign country.

1:40:17Coleman Hughes: When you say they're loyal to a foreign country i mean they're not loyal to a foreign country like who what do you call saying a man so let me say this so even john meersheimer the father of the israel lobby if you read his book the father of the book by the way not the actual lobby for people not familiar obviously um to you even even he says like until the 90s he saw no no contradiction between supporting israel and there's no mystery to explain because Israel was perceived by the U.S. security state as a Cold War ally. And so we spent a whole bunch of money helping them, you know, helping them build their military, selling them weapons as we did.

1:41:02Coleman Hughes: Yeah. Very in line with Cold War foreign policy. So Mearsheimer's whole question is like, okay, why have we still supported them after the Cold War? And then he has his own thesis, which is what you're saying. But I think another thing you have to a very plausible alternative to that is that all of Israel's enemies are loudly talking about how they want to wipe America off the map ultimately. And that sort of probably gets under the skin of the US security state. And we say there's one country over here that not only do they not have a problem with us, they, you know, they're a flawed, they're a flawed liberal democracy, like America has been throughout pretty much its entire history and arguably still today.

1:41:47Coleman Hughes: And then it's surrounded by jihadists who literally write in all of their manifestos, once Israel gone, we're going for America and the world needs to be ruled by this literalist reading of Islam that would make the American experiment vanish off the map. Now, obviously, that's not going to happen. But when all of Israel's enemies are loudly saying this, obviously, that influences a certain sense in the US security establishment. Well, you know, this country seems to be more or less aligned with our interests. And so, obviously, it makes sense to do things that are aligned with that country as in conflict with its enemies.

1:42:26Coleman Hughes: And you don't need a special mysterious explanation of a lobby to explain that. obviously the lobby believes it's buying something when it pays for money. I think you also have to keep the actual power of lobbying in general relative to the rest of the democratic political process in proportion. Like the Israel lobby has spent far less money lobbying Congress, spent like a tiny fraction in the 2000s lobbying Congress compared to, say, the smoking lobby. And the smoking lobby, which outspent... How are you measuring? Where do you get those numbers from? Because I've heard you say this before. OpenSecrets.org.

1:43:00But what are they measuring as the Israel lobby and how do you measure that budget exactly?

1:43:04Coleman Hughes: There's dollars spent lobbying Congress. Coming directly from AIPAC or from other organizations? Not just AIPAC. AIPAC, J Street, all of them. Okay, but again, if you're measuring... But hold on, let me finish my point. Sure, go ahead. They spent like one hundredth of what the tobacco lobby spent in that decade, right? The decade with all the wars, Afghanistan, Iraq, all the wars that are supposedly influenced by the Israel lobby. And even the tobacco lobby didn't get what they want. They didn't get, you know, that was the decade when like smoke, like all of America became smoke-free. Thank God.

1:43:40Coleman Hughes: Now we're just fat. Yeah. And we do Zins. Alps, people. The point I'm making simply is that you have to keep the power of lobbying in general in perspective. When people donate a bunch of money to a lobby, I think for them it feels like donating to a charity of a cause they care about and they hope that it does influence the world. Obviously they do or else they wouldn't be spending that money. But that is not the same as claiming that the lobby has a huge effect on the whole political democratic political process itself. All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, which is Cove Pure.

1:44:18Great company with a great product. If Flint, Michigan taught this country anything, it's that the government's word on your water is worth exactly nothing. And Flint wasn't a one-off. The problem is all over the place. That's why I switched to CovePure to purify my water. There are still millions of lead service lines actively carrying water to American homes. Many were installed before your parents were born. Well, if you're concerned about that at all, or anything else in your water pretty much, CovePure removes it. It's certified to eliminate up to 99.9 % of contaminants, but also PFAS, fluoride, and pharmaceuticals.

1:44:53And setup could not be simpler. No plumbers or drilling. You just put it on your counter, fill it up, and plug it in. Your city tested the water and said it was fine. Well, so did Flint's. Cove Pure is what you put between that track record and your family's water. Go check them out. Go to covepure.com slash problem right now. And because you're a listener of the show, you can get$250 off for a limited time. That's covepure.com slash problem, C-O-V-E-P-U-R-E dot com slash problem for$250 off, but only for a limited time.

1:45:28Coleman Hughes: All right, let's get back into the show. Well, I don't know. I mean, you're – again, I think what we've come to is that it's impossible to exactly quantify how much influence these things have. Again, the reason I'm asking these numbers is because I really do think the devil is going to be in the details here of how exactly you're defining the Israel lobby and what you're talking about here. Because the way John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt are defining it, I mean, you're telling me you might look at how much they've lobbied Congress. I have a problem with their definition though. Well, okay, let me say – Their definition is super overly – I think this is important.

1:46:01Coleman Hughes: Hold on. No, go ahead. I think this is important. I read their book, and the way that they defined the Israel lobby, I would be a part of the Israel lobby. But like, why? Perhaps. I'm not—I'm literally an American. Working at the free press. I'm actually like a heritage American that— It's the free press thing probably is what would get you there. Why, though? Well, do you not think Barry Weiss kind of is pretty pro-Israel? I mean— Yeah, but why does that make you a part of the lobby? Here's the thing. American citizens have their opinions on all sorts of things around the world I have super strong opinions like you and I have this in common super strong anti-communist opinions oh yeah if god forbid like war breaks out between South Korea and North Korea I know what side I'm on like period I would have a really strong feeling in that case for one side of a conflict I would not be part of the freaking South Korea lobby and fuck you if you said so I'm an American citizen listen, I can have the right to my own opinions and I can feel strongly about foreign conflicts because of which side I think is better for the world.

1:47:05Coleman Hughes: That doesn't make me part of the lobby. I could even join a magazine who shares that perspective and write about it. And again, fuck you if you tell me I'm a lobbyist unless I am taking money from someone. So it's a totally circular definition of the lobby that writes out of existence any American that felt strongly about the issue without being paid for. And it's really annoying to talk about the issue with all of this, So$7 ,000,$7 ,000, I'm sorry. I see a flawed liberal democracy in the Middle East surrounded by jihadists of the same ideology that did 9-11. I know which side I'm on as an American.

1:47:39Coleman Hughes: Okay, that's it. Okay, look. No lobby. The ones who did 9-11 are actually their friends or whatever. They're not the enemies. Would you agree it's an analytical problem with Mearsheimer that he defines the lobby as any American that feels strongly about the issue? Okay, so let me, first of all, I really understand the point you're making. I think it's very reasonable. And I want to directly answer this. But by the way, me and you really should start the South Korea lobby. No one's in on that yet, dude. That's our next project. No one saw us becoming best friends and starting a lobby together, okay?

1:48:09No one had that on their bingo card. Let me say this. I remember I mentioned this when I debated Alan Dershowitz. But I do think this story kind of illustrates it for me. It's a direct answer, I promise, to what you're saying. So there was this episode of Pierce Morgan. And John Mearsheimer's on. this is one of the things say whatever you will about pierce morgan um it is man it's such a product of capitalism and i say that as with as the highest possible compliment yes it is true people say it's the jerry springer of whatever but it really is i don't know how you're giving people what they want but here's the crazy thing is that then there'll be weird moments like in between all of the craziness then all of a sudden there's just like benny morris debating like so you're like wait a minute he just he just set up like a really kind of amazing that one kind of flopped but there have been some other ones that were really good so anyway so he has this one show so it's it's john meersheimer and then alan dershowitz but they're not on together pierce is interviewing meersheimer and then he's interviewing dershowitz afterward so before as pierce often does before he switches over to the interview with dershowitz now he asks meersheimer a question about dershowitz he goes you know it just came out that epstein and dershowitz i think had been emailing trying to like discredit the Israel lobby.

1:49:19So that was the topic I guess they asked. And then, you know, Mearsheimer just dismisses him in exactly the way you're saying. He goes, well, he's a part of the Israel lobby. So like, of course, that's going to be his opinion is he's not going to like the book, the Israel lobby, blah, blah, blah. So then Alan Dershowitz comes on and he goes, hey, kind of what you said, right? He goes, excuse me, like I'm an American. I'm not a lobbyist. I'm not working for any lobby. And it's totally unfair to just say, oh, you're a member of the Israel lobby. Like I'm an American citizen. and I have the right to have whatever opinions I have about whatever issues.

1:49:47And I will say, as he said that, as you just said that, my initial reaction was, yeah, he's got a fair point. That is a really fair point, man. Because what the fuck? Like, I'm allowed to have the opinion I have. And no one does it on the other side.

1:50:00Coleman Hughes: No one says Zoran Mamdani, you're part of the Palestine lobby. And if they did - Everyone does it on the other side. By the way, they sound part of the Palestine lobby. They call him an Islamist who's pro-Hamas. Okay, that's different. It's still kind of similar. No, that's a different accusation. And I have a different problem with it. Okay, but I got to finish this story because the big punchline is coming up next. Go ahead. This is my defense of the why it is a useful term, the Israel lobby. So the next episode of Pierce Morgan that Alan Dershowitz is on, and this is – people can check the timestamps.

1:50:26And I'm not exaggerating at all, man. Go roll the clip. It's like maybe a month, two months later, Alan Dershowitz comes on to announce that Alan Dershowitz is leaving the Democratic Party because they've gone anti-Israel. and even though he agrees with them on all the other issues and he's still a democrat and if there was an option to be a domestic democrat and a foreign policy republican he would but there's no option and his priority is israel and so he's going to go down with the pro now i'm just saying coleman it is you are making a reasonable point you are making a point just because you

1:50:59Coleman Hughes: work at the free press if someone switched parties because of palestine would you say that that makes them part of a foreign lobby no but let me what point well let me just let me try to maybe i can kind of explain it here it's like there is and there isn't this with palestine which is why it's not an apples to apples comparison as i was telling you man there is it's not like it's throughout the didn't a whole bunch of michigan voters literally like vote not present in a primary because of palestine oh yeah no i'm not saying that an issue can't affect why someone you know has an opinion but what you have here is a situation it's also a little bit different when like, you know, I don't know, Palestinians are getting slaughtered and that's kind of the beef there.

1:51:43And I'm not saying Jews didn't, Israelis didn't get slaughtered on October 7th. But anyway, whatever, let me just finish the point here I'm making. When you have so many people within the powerful class who literally in their own words are like devoted to this foreign nation, this is different than a lobbying group that's lobbying for big steel or big pharma or the dentist lobby. And by the way, fuck all those guys too. But it is different when the issue is a foreign nation. And you have all of these – when you have someone whose number one issue is a foreign nation, this does end up serving as kind of like a fifth column where you've got a bunch of people here.

1:52:21Coleman Hughes: If a Ukrainian-American's number one issue were Ukraine, would you call them part of the Ukraine lobby? If they were just like a Ukrainian butcher who makes his money in Ukraine village in New York, and he's like, you know what? Trump lost me. I was a Republican. Trump lost me on Ukraine. I'm a Democrat now. Would you say he's part of the Ukrainian lobby? I would not use the term the Ukrainian lobby. I would say that if he has – because it's not a thing that – there's a reason why it's a useful term with Israel. The reason why it's a useful term is because lobby means money paying for things in politics.

1:52:53Coleman Hughes: It's meaningless outside of that. Because people have strong feelings about politics and they're allowed to. It could be religious. It could be foreign policy. It could be your philosophy. It doesn't matter. You're allowed to have strong feelings. The importance of the word lobbying is that it signals the influence of money on our politics. Otherwise, the word lobby is meaningless. Okay, I get your point. So then if you think Israel first or something like that is a better term, we need to have a term. for people who, and by the way, to your point about - It is a better term. It's a fairer term.

1:53:22Okay, fine, fine. But fine, fair enough. But then that's what, right, okay. Then I guess I wouldn't particularly argue with that. But I will say that if there is a Ukrainian whose loyalty or number one priority was Ukraine, I don't think they should be around influence or power. They have a right, I guess, supposed to vote the way that they want to vote. But like, no, I do think that is, in the same way that Kennedy had to make his big speech about his loyalty not being to the Vatican and it being to the United States of America. I mean, Coleman, again, I know you never exactly addressed this, but again, Sheldon Adelson,

1:53:57Coleman Hughes: this is what I mean. Loyalty is smuggling something in here that doesn't need to be in here. The word loyalty, I'm not sure exactly what you mean by it, but if a Ukrainian American, a second gen Ukrainian American citizen were to come to me and say, you know, honestly, my big issue in life is Ukraine. And this is the issue I switch parties for. I'm a single issue voter, as many people are. And this is my issue. I would say, okay, I would, I would have questions, I would be like, you know, what I would, I would ask them, like, okay, do you think American interests and Ukrainian interests are always aligned?

1:54:29Coleman Hughes: Or do you think, like, what's your overall philosophy? I'd have questions, I think it's an interesting perspective. But they would tell me a story of who they are and what their values are. And I would never in a million years think to accuse them of not being loyal to this country, because they think, in their political worldview, we ought to stand strongly for Ukraine against Russia. It's a total, it could, in certain cases, obviously, it comes from a religious belief. If you're an evangelical Christian, as an American, you might be super strongly attached to Israel as a result of your religion.

1:55:01Coleman Hughes: That doesn't make you a part of any lobby. That makes you a human being with a worldview that stems from whatever premises it stems from. Right. Okay. No, I see your point. When Sheldon Adelson says, there's an old man reflecting on his life at this point, that his greatest regret in life was that he wore the U.S. military uniform and not the IDF uniform, and his greatest joy in life is that his son doesn't wear the U.S. military uniform, but he does wear the IDF uniform. Can I define that as loyalty to a foreign country? Is that a reasonable description of that? Loyalty to a foreign country would be like he's spying on us for them?

1:55:37I mean, isn't that in effect what he's doing

1:55:40Coleman Hughes: if that's his outlook on the world working for them. I mean, it's weird. I don't like it. All right. At least you grant me that. I was thinking I'd get a little bit more on this. I've been all a bridge. Coleman, it's an intolerable, insane dynamic that, of course, everybody's going to be against. It would be disloyalty if America was at war with Israel. And he said, you know what? I'd rather fight with them. No, it would be treason. It would be treason if we were at war with Israel. Yeah, but treason and loyalty are tightly connected. Yes, sure, sure. They're actually the same concept. treason is the legal definition of loyalty hold on can i give you an example can i give you an example of the other hold on hold on okay no no one is the legal proof of the legal version there's lots of ways you can be disloyal treason is a specific way if you had a guy from finland who said i really want to go like i'm a dual citizen or whatever and join the finnish army because they're threatened by russia i'd be like okay but he didn't want to join the american army i'd be like okay we're not at war with finland if he chose america over finland then i'd be like get the fuck out of this country what the fuck is wrong with you okay i get your point but i do feel like we're seeing the naked ass in the window and we're arguing over whether there's rape culture the guy said he would rather wear a foreign uniform than this one that is disloyalty to your country it's not treason but like come on man i think we can be reasonable and by the way that this is not my number one concern but it is my number seven concern or whatever i am a jewish person who doesn't like the rise of people not liking Jews.

1:57:04And I just don't even, even from like, I, and maybe this would, maybe this would be something that Noam at the Comedy Cellar podcast, or you guys would agree like to there. Cause there are some reasonable takes on this topic, but like, even from your perspective, wouldn't you go, man, that's going to lead to a lot of people like really being suspicious about this whole thing. I mean, I can understand where you don't like jumping on conspiracy theories, but like you could also recognize like man that's going to be fertile ground yeah that kind of a comment

1:57:34Coleman Hughes: of course it's a totally fertile ground but what i would say is like i i the idea of fighting like going to fight a war in another country is not necessarily a bad thing oh i'd agree with that theoretically george orwell left the uk to go fight the spanish civil war is like because he because in his mind the same enemies of the spanish civil war were going to be the uk's enemies and it's like i don't have a problem with that it's a very problem if our if our countries are beefing like militarily and you choose the other side that's what you would mean by disloyalty i know but the comment and i promise you you can go be precise with these things i know but coleman but we are being precise here he didn't say uh look it is something say there's some country being invaded and you went to go join the army to repel the invasion you could certainly but that could be a very noble thing to go do but it's a very different thing to make the statement i'm gonna go join these people because i believe in this fight or i even really care about these people to go like it's a my shame is that i wore the american military yeah that's crazy and i wish that is i'm taking your word if he said shame that's that's crazy it's the first time you're saying that natalie could you just do me a favor just because i don't want can you just pull up uh um sheldon adelson um idf uniform and then because i don't want to actually misrepresent what he said here.

1:58:52But I do think, now obviously I would say, and I'm sure this one I don't think you're going to give me any pushback on at all, is my guess, but you tell me whether I'm right or not. You see someone like Mike Huckabee who literally will say, and I could not believe he actually said this out loud to Tucker Carlson, also kind of a shocking international incident because it has been, I believe even with Trump, but it's been the official US policy for both of our entire lifetimes, mine a little longer than yours, that like, you know, we're against the settlements on the West Bank. We're broadly in favor of a two-state solution.

1:59:22Like we're not like – like we're not Likud party members officially in the US government. And we shouldn't be. Right.

1:59:28Coleman Hughes: Thank you. I agree. Absolutely. But Mike Huckabee just went out and just said like, no, no, no, no. This is a religious issue to him that he believes. First of all, I found it shocking because – here, give us one second on that thing. Let me just wrap this up. I found it shocking because like it seems to me on this side of the enlightenment and modern politics, even someone – when people are clearly motivated by religion politically, a pro-lifer let's say is a good example of that, right? Like even a pro-lifer typically, you would kind of be taken aback if you saw a podcast where there was a debate and the pro-lifer came on it and he went, God says so.

2:00:09Coleman Hughes: I would be taken aback? Well, I just mean you'd be surprised that someone – I know a lot of people like that. No, no, no. I'm sorry. Let me be clear about what I'm saying. You wouldn't be surprised for someone to have that view. You'd be surprised if that's what Stephen Crowder brought to a debate. You'd be like, oh, shoot, dude. I thought you were going to argue. Because typically even someone like Stephen Crowder would argue, we can detect a fetal heartbeat at six weeks. We can detect this. They'll make some type of secular scientific argument even though they may be informed by a religious one.

2:00:37because kind of the rules of a secular society are, well, I can't assume you have the same religious views as me. So if I make an argument that this is what God wants, you could just say, well, I don't believe in your God or whatever. But my point is, wouldn't you agree that anybody making decisions based on what they believe God gave someone should be nowhere near positions of power or public policy?

2:00:58Coleman Hughes: Yeah, I mean, I'm an atheist. Like I would, if someone's pitch was like, here's my policy platform and it comes from my holy book, whether that's the Bible or the Quran, that person's not going to get my vote. Yeah. Absolutely not. And I'm sure you would object to the – which is not like all of it. And again, maybe difficult to quantify the percentage. But like there is certainly a lot of religion tied up with support for Israel. As you alluded to earlier, evangelical beliefs about end times. um uh obviously jewish beliefs about god giving all of judea and samaria to them and i'm sure we're in common ground like rejecting that that it's totally it's totally ridiculous to claim some supernatural property right 100 okay there's no i don't i think there's probably no god it might be nice if there were but i don't think there is one and i don't think anyone knows about it and also all of israel's enemies are steeped in the language of god and Oh, 100%.

2:01:59Coleman Hughes: And their own version of it. And part of the problem with all of the religious beliefs is that it's very difficult to negotiate with them. Because a secular belief could admit of trade-offs and, okay, can I give you half of what you want and you give me half of what I want? But if it's religious, if it's a mandate, if it's a sacred mandate from God, then it can't be compromised upon. And so different, it becomes just difficult to live with competing religions claiming the same thing. No, I agree. And to be clear, I do believe in God. I'm not an atheist. But I think you can believe in God and still hold all of these points to be true with just a little bit of humility of going like, okay, but this is a realm that involves faith.

2:02:41We don't know for sure and for certain. And to your point, it is, I don't know, man, when someone – And this is true on both sides of that conflict, obviously. But when someone does have the view that like – which I know – I'm sure you saw there was this video going super viral of this like pretty young Israeli girl talking about how all of them should be moved out of Gaza and all this. And again, there's people who say these things on all sides. I never want to like go after – I always try to keep my criticism to like those in power or those who are corrupt. I'm not trying to go after just like regular people.

2:03:16but like you said it is very difficult when people if you really do have a view that like God gave us this land and all these people are just like it's his will that we get them all out of the way then yeah what are you going to be slowed down by little you know matters of like the particulars

2:03:32Coleman Hughes: you can give me half of God's will I'll settle for half of God's will just so we don't have conflict or just so there's not more suffering yeah it does make it difficult and then I would also argue and I'd be curious your kind of thoughts on this but I think And there's, you know, the line of like where religion begins and where it ends is a little bit murky. You know, you claim something like the Nazis were atheists, but like, I don't know, dude, it's pretty religious to me. If you really look at it, you had your own God and your own blasphemy and your own everything. It's just kind of a state religion.

2:04:04Same with like kind of the woke kids. Like it really is kind of a religion. You know what I mean? And there is a problem. And I almost think this is, from my perspective, removed from whether or not you believe in God. It's just like when your arguments aren't derived at from any logical foundation, shit, how the fuck do you? You know what I mean? When it's purely just like this is my religious view, it's much more challenging to argue people out of it.

2:04:28Coleman Hughes: Religious beliefs, including those about the afterlife, can be particularly problematic because if you really believe you're supposed to die for some reason, then, again, it makes you really difficult to live in society with in a secular democracy. That's part of the problem with jihadists. you know yeah yeah no oh listen i agree like dogma is the problem and there's dogma there's there's there's secular dogma there's religious dogma and they're each dangerous like to different degrees based on what those actual dogmas are yeah yeah well okay yeah i agree with that um i wonder because there's there's you know i don't know if we're gonna have time to get to all the things i wanted to man because it is funny too with me and you like last time it is like you i remember thinking we did 90 minutes i know me too i literally left that like going which a very interesting thing for another time but the way that doing podcast locking messes with your perception of time is is a very interesting thing all right guys let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show which is quince i love this company very happy that they're they're on board i've bought a bunch of articles of clothing from them and i love all the stuff that i've gotten it's very much my style they've got great stuff kind of casual yet formal the type of stuff that you could wear out to you know do it on a date with the wife but you could also wear to work They have staples like 100 % Mongolian cashmere sweaters, and they're starting at just$60.

2:05:48Real leather jackets without the crazy price tag. You can refresh your whole wardrobe. It's stuff that's kind of understated. You can wear anywhere. It looks good, and they're genuinely reasonable prices, which is something that you do not hear in the year of our Lord, 2026. Quinn saves you a ton of money because they partner directly with ethical factories. They skip the middleman so you can get top-tier stuff at half the price you would pay with other brands. Keep it classic and cool this fall with long-lasting staples from Quince. Go to quince.com slash P-O-T-P, and you will get free shipping on all of your orders plus 365-day returns.

2:06:26Again, I highly recommend this company. Really quality stuff at very affordable prices. is q-u-i-n-c-e.com slash p-o-t-p, quince.com slash p-o-t-p for free shipping on your orders and 365-day returns. All right, let's get back into the show. I wonder, like, you know, we're going into a moment here in the midterm elections coming up. Obviously, there's an election in Israel that just happened, which I don't know that we even have any results on. Exactly what's... Yeah, I think we'll clear results. Right. Next week, I think it's going to be

2:07:00Coleman Hughes: a good night for the democrats what's your feeling probably i don't know anything more than the predictors and the poly market does you know do you think i wonder this from your perspective because like i said we're both um there's something i've been thinking a lot about particularly and i don't know i'm not as familiar with your you on like covid stuff but i know where you were on on the wokeism stuff and it seems to me um there was a big okay so there was this kind of you know if We're talking about woke insanity. I don't know how to describe it other than like a mass cultural psychosis, you know, where just really crazy ideas took over that are, you know, it spoke to so many different failures throughout academia that any of the stuff wasn't checked.

2:07:43You know, like that some college professor didn't just win a debate against a critical theorist and shut this shit down 30 years ago is crazy. But it's this big thing that kind of swept the culture. it's kind of now looking at it in hindsight it's kind of amazing to even see where the culture was like in 2016 2017 we it does seem like there was to some degree it was culturally defeated or at least rolled back perhaps um it's the issues like trans and kids and stuff like this does not seem to be being pushed as much in the forefront i think there was a real effort that i think the

2:08:15Coleman Hughes: podcast to stand people are somewhat a part of who stood up against this crazy shit yeah and now i do really see a really direct correlation to like donald trump launching this war kind of ruining his moment over this and handing power back to the democrats now do you think because and i want your like i'm curious your thoughts on all of this but particularly it seems to me that given your whole worldview even our whole disagreements you wouldn't necessarily have to disagree with me at all that like you're not really defending this second war after the 12-day war it's clearly very unpopular and clearly hurting them in the midterms.

2:08:50Do you think the cost of this to some degree has been like, we're going to give these Democrats power again and see what woke 2.0 is or any thoughts on any of that?

2:08:58Coleman Hughes: Yes, I think very simply, if you make a choice that increases gas prices for months and months and months, that is probably the reason why you're going down in the polls. It's not that complicated. It's usually the pump and the pocketbook. That's what screwed over Biden, I think, in a lot of ways. When the inflation starts, people start losing their minds. And you talk about that a lot on your podcast, but it's not necessarily what the elites talk about all the time, but it is what the typical person cares about. If I thought regime change was likely to succeed, I'd have a very different attitude.

2:09:34Coleman Hughes: I think it's unlikely to succeed. So again, likelihood of success is like, that's a big thing for me. Sure, sure. So in other words, if it was – sorry, correct me if I'm wrong, but to restate what you're saying. If we were going to – like if there was a reasonable chance that – I don't know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Fanciful. But like – fanciful. Sorry, Marco Rubio's word. But if a – like if a better regime, something, you know, dramatically – a dramatic improvement were to come to Iran that led more stability in the region, led to less tensions between southern Lebanon and Israel, is it just like a better thing?

2:10:09not just for Israel's interest, but for America's interest. If the price of that were handing the country back over to woke Democrats, like I'm wondering, like even for you, that must be like a major calculation of like, geez, what are they going to do with that power? How good is this new regime going to be? You know what I'm saying? Like I don't think it's unreasonable to have a calculation in your mind, but man, that's a tough one.

2:10:30Coleman Hughes: When you say handing the country back to woke Democrats, I feel you're putting a little topspin on that. Sure. Some political power. A lot of power of the purse strings and subpoena power and impeachment power. A lot of power back to them. Two years of Republican White House and a Democratic Congress, which basically means not that much is going to happen by way of legislation, which from a libertarian perspective is not necessarily a bad thing when the government just can't do much. It's hard when the government's this big. It's kind of hard, you know. But, yeah, I get your point. But I think, obviously, if there were a chance of success, I think it could be so important for the Middle East, for the world, that it would probably be worth that price.

2:11:13Coleman Hughes: I just don't think there's a high chance of success at this point. So then would the conclusion be it wasn't worth it? Yeah, in retrospect. But like I said, my view on foreign policy is that most things are not obvious. I think that's a difference between us. You tend to have a really clear, like, this was obvious, this was not. And sometimes that's true. But a lot of times things aren't obvious. Like, you know, I took the example of the Assad regime falling. Like, very few people saw that coming. Well, it's not always obvious what's going to come. I mean, that I think is for sure. But I wonder if you have, you know, because this is, I don't know, at least my perspective on this.

2:11:50And maybe this is somewhat biased by my perspective. But I wonder if you agree with this at all. That, look, man, I think, obviously you think I'm getting a lot of things wrong. That I don't, you know, and I think I'm getting them right. We have disagreements here. But overwhelmingly it's like, look, man, like, support for this is just really, really low. I mean, support for Israel has cratered, support for Trump has cratered, and support for this war in Iran has always been really low. And whereas it does seem amongst at least the majority, so many of these arguments were won, you know, like the argument against woke insanity, the arguments against COVID tyranny, like these became popular issues.

2:12:34And I wonder if I'm sure I'd imagine from your position, you see people like Momdani in these guys and you're not a big fan of this direction that we're going in and don't you think kind of like in this battle against those guys this is kind of really hurt the side who's against

2:12:51Coleman Hughes: them yeah right now right at this moment it has it it has hurt um but sorry i was gonna what was your question uh do you think that the you know like given that this war hasn't worked out and It's a low likelihood that like in hindsight is essentially what we've done is we've given the woke new life and we're going to see what that means. I wouldn't necessarily want to always be weighing foreign policy against moment to moment popularity. But yeah, in this moment, the trade was a bad one for Republican electoral prospects. And I didn't vote for Trump. I sat out the last election because I felt both options were subpar.

2:13:35Coleman Hughes: But, look, I don't base my views on what's popular. I base my views on what I think is right. And I think you do too, because you're a Ron Paul supporter, and he's never won a popularity context. And so, you know, the fact that Israel is unpopular, I can tell you a story about why, and you can tell me a story about why, and maybe we'll mostly agree, maybe not. but ultimately I'm okay being in the minority in my opinion whatever that is I mean the difference with wokeness is that it was never actually popular none of the woke ideas were actually ever beyond maybe 15 or 20 percent popular but the elites made it seem that way and were able to successfully intimidate and quiet through the threat of cancellation the rest of the country And so that the back of that broke when people started just one by one from the inside out to to quote a title of a book.

2:14:36Coleman Hughes: I like, you know, people got the courage to speak out and then the whole back of the thing breaks. Right. Yeah. What has happened with Trump, I think, is actually a sincere dip in popularity because the prices are high, I think. And he hasn't won the war. Yeah. And it's looking like less and less likely as with each passing day that he's going to be able to achieve this objective. And the thing about war is that if you pay all the costs up front, but all the wins, all the moral wins, the financial wins, if they're there, they all come only with 100 percent victory. So that's the situation. Yeah.

2:15:15No, listen, I don't completely disagree with that analysis. All right. Before we get out of here, this will be a final question, and then we can wrap this up. I'm curious. I like asking people who live in New York this. I lived in New York my entire life up until 2020, but I've been gone now for six years. What is your impression of how the city's changed since Mamdani's been here?

2:15:39Coleman Hughes: And that could be culturally or policy-wise. I've lived in New York City since 2014. it's amazing to me that it's been 12 years uh when when i got to the city i for me i'm a two issue voter as a new york as a new yorker my issues are cost of living and crime or you know the polite euphemism for it which is public safety right those are those are the things that actually affect me as a new york i honestly don't give a single fuck what the mayor of new york thinks about foreign policy one way or the other. I thought it was brilliant when Mamdani on the campaign trail was like, all the other mayors were like, oh, I'm going to visit Israel.

2:16:20Coleman Hughes: And he was like, dude, I'm going to visit Brooklyn. What an own goal. It was brilliant. And also that Cuomo went at him with that attack was just like, yeah. But then he made an idiot of himself by being like, I'm going to arrest Netanyahu as the mayor. Like, the mayor? Fuck. Sounds good when you say it. Sounds good when you say it. But obviously it was a lie that he didn't care about the issue, but it was brilliant. And he should maybe genuinely go with that. They all, all local politicians should, in my view. But my issues are cost of living and public safety. And those issues were good and getting better between 2014 and like 2020.

2:16:59Coleman Hughes: 2020 and 21, they got incredibly, just much worse. I was, you know, I was like trying to buy pepper spray and like all this shit, like scary situation. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, no, the city really fell to pieces, man. It was zombie town. And I stayed in New York during all of COVID, the entire time. And with Adams, it began to get better. By 2023 and 2024, it was better not only in terms of crime statistics, but also in terms of how the subway feels. Right, right. And my understanding now is it's continued to get a little better under Mamdani. Assaults are up, but murders and all that stuff is down. my worry with Mamdani was because he was associated with defund the police anti-police policies and politics and because he's okay a democratic socialist with probably marxist sympathies to put it mildly yeah that he would have a bias towards not letting capitalists build not letting landlords profit and building a bunch of public housing and believing that the government can solve the affordability problem, doubling down on rent control and all the other policies that have proven disastrous and destructive in so many cities around the world.

2:18:16Coleman Hughes: And I would talk to my friends about this and they would say, well, look, I'm 30 years old. They'd be like, yeah, I'm 30 years old. I can't afford a house. I have affordability problems. Why don't we try something new? Like Mamdani is preaching something new. And I wanted to grab them by the collar and say, socialism is not new. It's 170 years old. almost it's been tried for there's like data on socialist policies going back a hundred years in european cities there's so much data control the only conclusion is that empiricism i guess doesn't matter because there's so much data if there was ever an experiment we would run like you couldn't imagine we have an east and west germany a north and south korea we have like the best case studies yeah yeah and so um that was my worry is that crime would go up yeah but he kept he kept um tish as police uh commissioner it seems like he moderated a lot and so to be honest i haven't seen any thing seriously worth worrying about yet and i'm like a big fan of not being alarmist just because he doesn't have my politics doesn't mean he can't be a good mayor yeah yeah no i look i agree i think that's a good attitude and also sometimes you can't really be a complete communist from the mayor's office anyway so yeah totally there's like i think he's compromised which I like.

2:19:28Coleman Hughes: There you go. Look, I'll just say this, dude, and I really mean this very sincerely. When you do things like this, particularly in the landscape that we're in right now, I even found this the other day when I did Constantine's show. Me and him were texting the other day joking about this. But dude, man, it's like his audience hates me so much, man. And my audience hates him so much. Our audiences hate each other. And look, man, maybe there's some room for that. People are supposed to get angry sometimes and be mad at each other. whenever you do something like this we do it then you put it out there then everyone gets to have their opinion on it you know and whatever it is people can have their opinion on what the first conversation we had was what this conversation was i just want to say like from my perspective very sincerely i just really enjoyed both of them i really appreciate you for doing both of them i think again without being too self-congratulatory i think there's value in us like kind of having this and continuing this and i hope we can do it again in the future right back at you man i you You know, I don't expect to persuade your audience of my point of view, but I commend you for at least hearing me out with an open mind and your listeners for hearing me out with an open mind because it's a perspective.

2:20:37Coleman Hughes: I think they only get the most extreme version of that perspective, and that's what social media does. So to have a good faith debate and conversation, I think it is important. Maybe we're flattering ourselves, but it is important, I think. Yeah, I'd like to think so, too. then there's something narrator goes it wasn't important it wasn't important the whole world's going to show you Colm Hughes thank you so much brother thank you guys everyone for listening have a good one peace

From the publisher

Dave Smith brings you the latest in politics! On this episode of Part Of The Problem, Dave is joined by Coleman Hughes! They discuss the upcoming midterms, Israel's influence on Trump, the motivations of the Iran war, and more.


Support Our Sponsors:

Superpower - Head to Superpower.com and use code PROBLEM at checkout for $20 off your membership. Unlock your new health intelligence. 100+ biomarkers. Every year. Detect early signs of 1,000+ conditions. #superpowerpod


Quince - Get free shipping on your Quince order and 365-day returns at

https://www.quince.com/POTP


CovePure - Head to http://www.covepure.com/problem for $250 off your CovePure water purifier.


Ghost Bed - https://www.ghostbed.com/problem and use the promo code PROBLEM


Part Of The Problem is available for early pre-release at https://partoftheproblem.com as well as an exclusive episode on Thursday!


PORCH TOUR DATES HERE:

https://www.porchtour.com



Find Run Your Mouth here:

YouTube - http://youtube.com/@RunYourMouth

iTunes - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-your-mouth-podcast/id1211469807

Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/4ka50RAKTxFTxbtyPP8AHm


Follow the show on social media:

X:

http://x.com/ComicDaveSmith

http://x.com/RobbieTheFire


Instagram:

http://instagram.com/theproblemdavesmith

http://instagram.com/robbiethefire


#libertarian

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from Part Of The Problem

All episodes