Was It A Genocide?

30 Sep 2026 · 1 h 8 min · 20 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Whether Israel’s war in Gaza amounts to genocide, argued through satellite imagery, legal definitions, and rebuttals to pro-Israel claims.

Guests

Robbie “Fire Bernstein” (co-host/comedian). No other guest is clearly identified in the transcript; the episode references outside commentators/clips (e.g., Bill Maher, Ben Shapiro, Mark Levin, Scott Horton) but they are not guests in-studio.

Guest background

Robbie is a comedian/performer who discusses touring (porch shows, Texas shows, Salt Lake City, Las Vegas) and appears as the episode’s co-host.

Key claims

  • Google Earth satellite updates show extreme destruction across Gaza; journalists’ exclusion is cited as making aerial views especially important.
  • The destruction is argued to be morally and legally hard to justify; “genocide” is defended as meeting the legal threshold “intent to destroy…in whole or in part.”
  • Vaccine/aid arguments against genocide are called straw men; aid entering doesn’t negate genocidal intent.
  • Israel is portrayed as having made choices after Oct 7 (security failures, blockade, statements about “relocation”/ethnic cleansing).

Notable examples

  • Figures cited: ~330 structures destroyed; ~80% of structures destroyed/damaged (as referenced).
  • Smotrich’s “no grain of wheat” blockade claim.
  • Bill Maher clip “Genocide or Not” and the “vaccinated population” argument.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Upcoming Shows and Events

0:45 to 2:09

Hosts discuss their upcoming comedy shows and events.

“I've already done it in most of the towns I'm going to do it in.”

Impact of Recent Gaza Images

2:09 to 3:55

Hosts react to recent satellite images of Gaza's destruction.

“but I did think that we kind of got to start here with this, topic that has really, I got to say, rattled me a bit more than I expected to.”

Discussion on Justifications for War

3:55 to 6:15

Exploration of moral justifications for the destruction in Gaza.

“On some human level, the way our brain works, that is like a dimension change where you're now into the human dimension.”

War and Innocence in Conflict

6:15 to 8:18

Hosts debate the morality of involving innocent lives in warfare.

“Like essentially speaking, you know, Gaza has been destroyed, essentially.”

Israel's Choices Post-October 7th

8:18 to 13:44

Analysis of Israel's military actions following the October 7th incident.

“for something like this, like just looking at the picture.”

The Shifting Perspective on Controversial Issues

15:02 to 17:46

Explore the evolving opinions on controversial topics as new information emerges.

“Well, I think as we get more and more information, there's going to be more and more people with that exact perspective.”

Debate on Genocide Terminology

17:46 to 19:16

Discuss the implications and definitions surrounding the term genocide.

“We were in the minority, the clear minority on this position, you know, personally for many, many years.”

Analyzing Israel's Actions in Gaza

19:16 to 24:16

Examine the actions taken by Israel and the resulting humanitarian crisis.

“comments on this, as I was looking back at the great stuff you were saying about COVID in April of 2020.”

Understanding the Legal Definition of Genocide

24:16 to 28:00

Gain insights into the legal definitions and debates surrounding genocide.

“And just to be clear, Rob, like, again, objectively speaking, I'm not even saying here this definitively is or isn't a genocide there.”

The Debate on Genocide

28:00 to 36:50

Explore the complexities surrounding the term genocide in the context of Israel's actions.

“You know, and so look, what am I admitting there, Rob?”
Show all 20 chapters

The Debate on Genocide

36:54 to 38:18

Explore the complexities surrounding the term genocide in the context of Israel's actions.

“If you're looking to level up your kitchen game or your grill game, you got to check out HexCloud.”

Challenging the Morality of War

38:19 to 42:00

Delve into arguments about morality and strategy in the ongoing conflict.

“But like, when you actually look at the definition and you look at all the stuff that they're doing, you go, ah, there's a very strong argument.”

Analyzing the Claims of Genocide

42:00 to 48:32

The discussion focuses on the implications of terminology in the context of the Israel-Palestine conflict, specifically around the word 'genocide'.

“But so I guess maybe it is like worth pointing out that.”

Transition to Political Commentary

48:32 to 48:46

The hosts transition to discussing political clips featuring Ben Shapiro and Mark Levin.

Evaluating Political Perspectives on Iran

48:46 to 56:01

The hosts critique Ben Shapiro and Mark Levin's views on Iran and the implications for the Republican Party.

“Yeah, so I would start it right from that.”

Critique of Political Decisions

56:01 to 56:35

Discussion on the perceived failures of political leaders and the consequences of their decisions.

“I know I've been saying this now for a year and a half, but it's just become more and more obvious the whole time.”

Skepticism Towards Military Strategies

56:35 to 58:49

Exploration of military options and skepticism surrounding their effectiveness in the current political climate.

“Let's hear the Cargillin pitch and the gas prices pitch.”

Gas Prices and Economic Policies

58:49 to 1:01:49

Discussion about gas prices and the economic implications of current policies, including reference to prediction markets.

“There's always a very simple way to win, and somehow only Ben Shapiro knows it, and nobody will take his sound advice on the simple solution.”

Gas Prices and Economic Policies

1:02:07 to 1:02:19

Discussion about gas prices and the economic implications of current policies, including reference to prediction markets.

“If you want to go check out that site, you can keep yourself busy there for hours.”

Election Predictions and Consequences

1:02:20 to 1:07:06

Analysis of upcoming elections and their implications for political parties and policies.

“I'm sorry, I should say on the Democrats taking the House and the Senate.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:06Oh, hello. What's up? What's up, everybody? Welcome to a brand new episode of Part of the Problem. All right. We were having some trouble, but the internet gods looked down on us. How are you, Robbie the Fire Bernstein? I'm doing well. I'm between porches, temporarily displaced, but I'm having fun. What about you? I don't like that it looks I can't tell whether you're outside or not I am currently outside but luckily some fans hooked me up with a sweatshirt because I didn't bring any winter gear so I'm good Rob we can find you a hotel I'm sure we're doing okay I'm on my buddy's porch we're going to barbecue in a bit we went for a hike real casual heterosexual not my lover friend relationship Rob you don't have to start justifying things to me rob you're living good you're barbecuing you're on i don't care what it goes on in between that all right uh well listen man there's a lot of depressing news in the world so yeah me and you got to uh we got to get out there and tell some jokes where are you where are you telling jokes next uh so i got a whole bunch first is um in salt lake city before you get out there for the weekend so uh come hang out for porch store it's the only chance to see my fbi entrapment scheme presentation and then uh next week uh i've got a bunch of texas shows texas a &m then a big one in Austin where I'm going to make Scott Horton sit through my entire presentation and then fact check me.

1:25Tell me all the stuff I got wrong. I'm looking forward to that. I'll definitely have a bunch. Well, good. I've already done it in most of the towns I'm going to do it in. That's okay, but I can correct it before I film it. Doing Childerberg on Saturday. Got to be my sixth time doing that. Find even more dates at porchdoor.com. All right. Hell yeah. Of course, then this weekend we will both be together as we're meant to be, but as I'm only truly happy. We will be out in Salt Lake city at the wise guys there. And then at the wise guys in Las Vegas this weekend, comic Dave Smith.com for, for, for tickets.

2:07All right. So gosh, I got a bunch of stuff on my mind, but I did think that we kind of got to start here with this, topic that has really, I got to say, rattled me a bit more than I expected to. It really did have an effect on me, but it was the latest images out of Gaza that were, well, okay, so these were, they're Google, what is it called? It's Google Earth, I believe it's called. So Google Earth, they take the pictures of the satellites, and I don't know, I've played around with it before. I'm sure you have, Rob, where you can zoom in and kind of see any point on the globe. and I guess they periodically update them.

2:50And so they kind of just updated this portion of the globe. But this happens to contain this area of Gaza that has been destroyed where journalists haven't been let in. And so these are some of the, you know, best images that we get. Now, of course, Rob, like, as you know, it's not like, this is, I guess, what was a little bit, maybe it was, it's not as if this is so much worse than anything we've seen. We've kind of seen aerial drone footage. we've seen that this is what Gaza looks like. I don't know though, there was something particular about some of these images. I don't know if I'm saying like I encourage people to go look through them or not, it's kind of dark and morbid, but there was something kind of profound where you'd see just like, geez, like how much this whole place has been destroyed.

3:34It really was, I don't know, it was something. And I'll tell you, while there's been this whole thing about like Israel won't let the journalists in, this was the first thing I said on Piers Morgan the other day about it, you start to look at some of these images, it's like, I can understand why they want these to be aerial and not on the ground images, man, because doesn't that change everything? It really is. On some human level, the way our brain works, that is like a dimension change where you're now into the human dimension. If it was a video game and you switched from the aerial Google view into the person view, you'd be like, oh, I'm playing the game now.

4:12I'm a character. And there's anyway, so I would just say that. Any thoughts? Well, I think the fact that the images were first updated this week, you know, sheds new light on the situation, calls into focus that journalists have not been allowed in. And then on top of all that, I mean, when you just see the sheer level of destruction, which at the time I said, hey, you can't drop a leaflet on some guy's house and then just blow it up. That's not a justification. But when you see the totality of how much has been destroyed in the area uh it just really showcases what they did was so undefensible and for all the people out there trying to say that uh um you know that these were all just military targets i think even since the ceasefire they've destroyed 10 more infrastructure and so i think when you kind of see the total numbers now that they've accepted gaza health ministry death numbers and you see just the sheer destruction of what's taken place i mean anyone that's uh still arguing that what they did is justified is just criminally insane well let's i mean oh by the way i apologize i was thank you natalie good producing i was coming out of the wrong microphone before sorry glad we fixed that early um so i would i would almost start like this rob like let's do it like this rob with here first of all natalie can you just pull up i think we have one let's see if this like translates well but just to see one of the images for anybody who's watching who doesn't kind of know what we're talking about and i'm not showing you anything like brutal or graphic with little kids but yeah if you could put like this is the type of stuff we're talking about and this is rob this represents like you guys can go dig through them if you want to but just look at that and know that represents all of gaza the second picture literally the second picture looks like an excavation site of ancient ruins yes yes that's right so all right you can take that down a little bit just to like kind of give people a bit and and okay so like when you look at something like that and you look at the, you know, that some of the numbers have come out, Rob, or whatever the estimates are, there's like 330 structures have been destroyed and like 80 something percent of all the structures in Gaza have either been destroyed or damaged or whatever.

6:19Like essentially speaking, you know, Gaza has been destroyed, essentially. Okay. So when you look at that, like, let's start here, let's start backward almost in a fair way. A pure thought experiment, Rob. What could justify that? Like, isn't that like a fair thing to start with? Like, what could ever justify you doing that to a city, destroying the entire thing? Rob Markman Well, because you missed a phone call and a warning about what was about to happen and you funded the exact military division to keep him in power, make sure he didn't have a peace partner and then your whole area that you're responsible for gets real upset at you and you go, man, I really got to go look tough right now.

7:07I just feel like, Rob, if I was taking a test and I saw the question was what could possibly justify that and it was multiple choice and what you just gave was one of the answers, I'd go, well, that can't be right. That can't be the right answer, right? It can't. I mean, I've read my Thomas Aquinas just war theory. That can't be why it's okay to destroy entire cities. No, I mean, like, honestly, and I try to do this, and I'm not even trying to do this from, like, the strictest, like, Rothbardian, it is always wrong to kill an innocent person no matter what. Although, like, look, that is, I do think, you know, the correct view, right, that perhaps there could be some situation you could come up with where the only answer was to kill an innocent person.

7:53But there's still something wrong in doing that, Like that innocent person still gets killed. That's still horrible in some sense. But to me, Rob, and I don't know, I mean, I'm not, you know, again, a lot of great philosophers have tackled the question of war. I'm not claiming to be one. I've read a few of them. I would say that essentially the only way I think you could come up with a justification for something like this, like just looking at the picture. And I do think that there are some cases where there's a picture like that, that like, oh, my god, this is, you're already in very difficult to justify territory.

8:28You destroyed an entire people's place. Okay. If the only way for that to not happen to you was to do that to someone else, perhaps I could see getting to a point where I don't know that you could call it justified exactly but you could go dude we were in this horrible situation where you know like literally they were going to do this to us or we were going to do this to them and there was and it's and obviously the onus would be on you to like really prove that that there was just absolutely no other option right like i literally not commenting on israel gaza just commenting on doing that to anyone.

9:16That's the best I could come up with. Okay. Just like purely an abstract is like, if you said, you know, like, no, it's never right to, it's never okay to kill an innocent person. But if I can absolutely, you know, if I really absolutely know that a missile is coming from this one building, that's going to take out my entire building. And the only option I possibly have is a missile that takes out their entire building. And like, there is no other option then like it like maybe you could find a justification i don't i don't think there's any other scenario where you where you can't i don't think anything short of that in other words like like if that's not good in other words rob and i know this is kind of fucked up to make these type of decisions or something like that but we do kind of in some way go look even after 9-11 nobody thought it was okay or very few no sane person thought it would be okay to like just nuke every single Muslim country in the world.

10:14Just go, you know what? They killed some of our people. We're killing all of their fucking people. Like even, we never even thought we could nuke Afghanistan. You know, like nobody really ever thought that was in the, like, to do that, to destroy an entire people, an entire, you know, whatever you want to call Gaza nation, you know, collection of cities or whatever. Like because one of your civilians was going to die or a few of your civilians, like no one would accept that. No one would accept like for a minor terrorist problem, we have to do this. The only thing that you could accept is like something to that level of extermination was going to happen to you.

10:51And so you had to do it before it could happen. Does it like where I'm going make sense with this, Rob? I think this is like very basic moral like philosophy, right? Yeah. Well, Afghanistan, we couldn't do because we had to preserve the opium trade. Well, that's true. And make sure that their, you know, child rapists were and general culture culture was preserved. Rob, we don't defend the military industrial complex too much on this show. But have you ever tried to microwave your heroin before? Have you not going to work? Right. Right. But so but so the reason why and of course, this is kind of why in every scenario, the Israeli defenders have to try to make it seem like that's what's happening here, dude.

11:36right? Like, yeah, it's a hostage situation where, oh my God, we're going to die unless we do this. But the problem is that this is on the level of like two weeks to flatten the curve. Like, or, or, or I'm sorry, I should say this is on the level of a, I was going to, I meant to say, um, a round was two weeks away from getting the nuke and, and delivering it. It's just like, no one believes that no one believes you. No one believes you. No one believes you. Like, It's like literally, dude, you got the people on the payroll and the tiniest sliver of people who are still propagandized by this bullshit.

12:10But the fact is that October 7th, the reason why there is so much speculation about whether October 7th was an inside job, at the very least, everyone would have to admit this, is because it was such an enormous security failure. You know, they didn't have men on the exact place where you would think they needed men between the wall that guarded them and Hamas. They had like eight hour, 13 hour response times to some of these events. The fact is just, Rob, that Israel's been living with Gaza next door since Israel existed. They've had Palestinians next door since Israel existed for 100 percent of the history of Israel.

12:53They've, you know, they've been at war the whole time, but they've both existed, you know, and the idea they've existed with Hamas there since the 1980s. The idea that they couldn't have just like cracked down that this fortress of the world was going to suffer even another October 7th. The next day is ridiculous. No, they weren't. They could have defended against that. And it's just, Rob, there is just no plausible way I see that anyone could possibly get to, like, Israel had to do this. Like, and when I say had to, in some sense of, like, something on this level would have happened to them if they didn't.

13:33They just didn't have to. It was a choice. It was a choice to do this as a response to October 7th. And this was their choice, to destroy all of Gaza. All right, guys. let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, a brand new sponsor who I'm very excited to have on board. And that is ghost bed. They just sent me my ghost bed. I just got it. And I set it up. I'm very excited to, uh, to test it out. There is nothing more important than getting good sleep at night. And it's one of the things that people don't think about when they really should a huge portion of your life is spent sleeping.

14:04So you really want to pay attention to what you're sleeping on. And that's why you got to check out the ghost bed. It's engineered to help reduce the reasons that your sleep gets interrupted. Ghost bed is designed to relieve pressure help regulate temperature and support your body it has cooling technology built into every mattress and it's made in the usa with ghost beds 101 night sleep trial you can try it at home because the real test of a mattress is how you feel in the morning if you're waking up sore or tired before the day even starts check out ghost bed they're offering part of the problem listeners an extra 10 off their lowest prices of the season so go check them out at ghostbed.com slash problem and use the promo code problem for an extra 10 % off of their lowest prices of the season.

14:49That's ghostbed.com, G-H-O-S-T-B-E-D.com slash problem, promo code problem for an extra 10 % off. All right, let's get back into the show. What can I say, right? Well, I think as we get more and more information, there's going to be more and more people with that exact perspective. and the few people that were trying to defend it will have less little goofy talking points to cling on to of, hey, there was raw military targets, the civilian ratio was appropriate, there was nothing else we could do, we had to show force. Whatever you've heard over the last couple of years, no one's going to be saying it.

15:31Well, I tend to think you're right, you know, Rob, I saw, I know, listen, man, I know I pat both of us on the back a little bit too much for this, but i do you know i i'm i do kind of say it for a reason but i saw um i saw someone posted the did i mention this to you already but i saw someone posted a clip of us in covid doing a covid episode it was a clip of us in april of 2020 um and um captain america that uh are great uh or what's it not captain america captain and kappa or whatever our guy i'm sorry i'm bad with stuff um but he uh he posted it but it was like us talking about the lockdowns in the absolute height of the very beginning of the lockdown it was april 2020 and like dude it was just i'm just i was really goddamn proud of all the shit we were saying man like and you rob you add some like literally like we both made a bunch of great points that you're like yo that aged so well like We were so right about all this shit.

16:33And at the time, it's like, I know I've used this example before, right? But like, okay, so there's that time. I'm literally at the time, Rob, I'm in my mother-in-law's house at this time. I mean, I had an apartment in New York City, but I didn't feel comfortable keeping my family there when the shelves were getting dry and riots I thought were about to pop off, which did end up popping off. And so I took them out and brought them to the burbs to my folks' house. So like recording upstairs there. Now, cut to a few years later, I'm debating Chris Cuomo in front of a few million people, and everybody agrees with me, and I'm making really good money, and everything's good.

17:10And don't get me wrong, that Cuomo debate was a lot more fun than just being right about stuff when it really mattered at its most important point down. But I think, Rob, if we're going to be in this at all, then the only real value we bring is if we're getting something right when it's really controversial and really unpopular to be right. Because it's a lot easier. You can find a lot of people who will be right when it's the popular thing to be. But throughout this whole thing, man, which is hard to imagine, dude, this started as America was a pro-Israel country. We were in the minority, the clear minority on this position, you know, personally for many, many years.

17:53Um, and I mean, dude, I don't know, man. It's one of the big advantages of just being able to see this shit clearly and get it right. Is that, yeah, this will age better, man. There's Howard, there's dude, it's, it's really crazy, Rob simultaneously. And we'll get into this a little bit, but simultaneously as the, the, uh, Israel lobby is out there arguing that only buffoons call this genocide. That is literally what they're out there arguing constantly, that you that this is just so goofy and ridiculous. They're all types of clips from Ben Shapiro. We got one from Bill Maher. Maybe we'll play that in a little bit.

18:36All types of clips arguing this isn't a genocide. And not just that it's not a genocide, but you must be a fool to think it's a genocide. And then by the way, oh, here are the pictures. What did we do? Oh yeah, we destroyed the entire fucking place. I mean, when you destroy the entire place, one of the oldest, most continuously inhabited, like ancient, you know, areas of the world, man, I don't know, dude. It just, look, even if you want to argue, that's not genocide, which we could get into that a little bit, actually. Rob, I remember your first comment or one of your very first comments on this, as I was looking back at the great stuff you were saying about COVID in April of 2020.

19:24And I remember you said this in October of 2023. And it was right like maybe a week after Israel, their initial response to October 7th. And so October 7th had happened, think about the optics there, everyone's feeling bad about the poor people who got slaughtered on October 7th. Israel's immediate response was to turn off the power and water and electricity to, or sorry, I repeat myself, to the entire Gaza Strip. I remember it was a few days after that where you just went, essentially all that had been signaled was that this war will be against the entire civilian population of Gaza, and you just went they'll never get away with this dude you know and like i'm just saying you you were just like in this pr game there's no way they're gonna win this they're not gonna be able to defend it and literally rob from that point to now depending on the poll you look at israel has cratered something like 50 to 70 percent in approval so anyway i say all that to say you got a couple right buddy i'll take it it's nice to be right that's all you get in this game well i mean look i just i do think it's just important to um it's important not you know just for the sake of like kind of like you know um pointing out the track record or something like that but it's like look there's a reason why there's a reason why we were able to see those things right and it's the same reason why kind of you know in different ways why we're also able to do it with this um did i want it was there a clip i wanted to play before the Bill Maher one, or does that actually feel like maybe that is the best one to go into off of this?

21:05Because look, maybe even Bill Maher put out this segment, he titled it Genocide or Not. Shockingly, Rob, there's no representative from the genocide side. And so I kind of thought, like, why don't we, I mean, we could respond to that. Like, is this a genocide? And I don't think, well, certainly I have called it a genocide several times. I've never really exactly been of the position, Rob, that like, no, like I want to argue about the semantics. Like this is genocide, not horrific war crimes, not horrific war crimes plus ethnic cleansing, but genocide. And in fact, Rob, as you know, and I guess people who paid attention to it know, I did not call what Israel is doing to Gaza intentionally.

22:00I did not call it a genocide. I went out of my way to not call it a genocide for, let's see, it was up till it was in March of 25 when I first started calling it a genocide. So it was in March of 2025. So, October 23 to March of 2005, so like a year and a half of a war against the entire civilian population, just bringing hell on earth to two plus million people, including like a million kids. And then after all of that, like, you know, half of this destruction, you know, whatever it was, Rob, it wasn't like 330 ,000 homes destroyed at the time, but it was like 120 ,000 or something. So like after all of that, then Smotrich, the like number two or number three post of the Israeli government who is basically Goebbels, he announced that not one grain of wheat would get into the entire Gaza Strip.

23:06And for three months, it didn't. He just put them on a starvation blockade after all of that. And at that point, Rob, what was I to say to all of the other anti-Israel people next to me calling it a genocide while I was sitting here saying, I don't want to use the word. I just went, yeah, fuck it. I don't know, dude. I mean, I called what the Saudis did to Yemen a genocide for all those years because I think it was. It was a war of genocide. They were bombing wheat silos, dude. Wheat silos. What is that? Okay, so like hundreds of thousands of people die because you're conducting a war. I consider that a war of genocide, right?

23:42But when I was calling Yemen a genocide, it wasn't like, it was more like, okay, this is the, this is like the strongest possible language you can use that's still accurate to condemn this end. But when it was Israel, obviously you call what the Jewish state is doing a genocide. You're playing on the Holocaust. There's all this other thing. It becomes this whole debate about semantics. I was like, I'm just going to stay away from all this and go. But at this point, all this time later, like the argument for it being a genocide is just stronger, objectively stronger than it's ever been. And now these guys are coming out acting as if it's laughable.

24:19And just to be clear, Rob, like, again, objectively speaking, I'm not even saying here this definitively is or isn't a genocide there. I will say there is room for debate on the subject. I will say these guys are absolutely wrong objectively to dismiss it as if this is a ridiculous idea. And it's because they don't want to be honest about it. They don't want to be honest about what the term means. It's that simple. Yeah, I personally am of the view that I condemned what Israel did. And it's absolutely atrocious as to whether or not it falls into the category of genocide. I'll leave it to the academics.

24:55Yeah, which is fine. I'm like literally, and I'm fine literally almost with what I just said. I'm fine with Lee, like within the question of that, me and you could say, hey, this is a question for like scholars, you know, genocide scholars, which there are. And the biggest organization of them came out and called this a genocide. But you know, okay, so they've kind of had this debate and decided. But the point I just want to make is that these Israel lobby hacks are absolutely wrong to dismiss this claim. They're in no position to do so. Yes, I think the ones that say that it's morally atrocious that anyone would even consider that it is it's already enough in the realm of academia for serious consideration or even coming on that side that without having looked at the definition of genocide or whether or not this reaches it because uh like i said that's just a little bit more academic than could you just me just going natalie just just to be good could you just pull up the legal definition of genocide just google the legal definition of genocide We'll just pull that up because they'll quote it right from the international law.

25:54Because I just want to like say this. I'm not like, again, I'm not like getting into, I don't want to spend the rest of the time debating whether or not this meets this claim. I just want to say to be clear, it's because this is the quote, right? It's specific acts committed with intent to destroy in whole or in part a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. Okay. So just to be clear here, right? This, like go through this again. specific acts with the intent okay so it has to be acts you have to be doing things to people and it has to be intentional that's a part of genocide too like what your intent is to do it um and then um it has to be trying to wipe out in whole or in part a specific group now palestinians clearly meet a specific group there's no question about that i guess i guess I guess the problem that this conversation somewhat runs into, and like I said, I really haven't dug in, but that or in part probably means that this meets the technical definition.

26:57And what you're running up against is that most people in their heads, they think that when you're saying genocide, you're thinking of in whole and that in part would not meet that definition, which I think is exactly right. Yeah, that's exactly right. And I think it's really important because let's actually like get to the bottom of this and like stop talking past each other here. Right. So like because this is I think this is really important. So just for example, because I think this gets to exactly what you're saying. I've heard many, as I'm sure others have, too. I've heard many Zionists refer to October 7th as a genocide.

27:35Now, I'm not saying that's the standard talking point and perhaps they're being a little bit hyperbolic, but hey, Rob, let's be completely fair here.

27:45By that definition, it is debatable. Like, and I'm going to sit here and say, dude, if let's say they grabbed some of those terrorists who committed October 7th, let's say they snatched some of them up, you know, right after killing a bunch of people, they grabbed them and they were being charged. and like okay obviously i'm not saying they'd be charged under the international you know court or whatever but like let's just say they were and like they go you know what we're gonna ratchet up the charges to genocide you you were there to destroy a group of people in whole or in part with intent i mean look i would say at that point you go like this does seem to kind of be abusing the spirit of what we all consider genocide to to mean um but and cry me a river i I mean, technically, yeah, by the letter of the law right there, that guy is kind of guilty of that.

28:34I don't know. You know, and so look, what am I admitting there, Rob? That obviously there is some and this is why I avoided using the term genocide for so long. In fact, I said this once on I think it was the first time I was on breaking points. I got into this, but I went. The thing is that even though what Israel is doing probably meets the legal definition of genocide, which is part of the reason why, you know, they were able to get the International Court of Justice, you know, to at least say that it was plausible. While that's true, most people's conception of genocide is more like, oh, you're killing every single member.

29:14Like, like Israel just went in there and put every, you know, like went in there and just literally went over here to kill every single member there. And we're going to do absolutely everything we can with all of our power to kill every single member. the now while that is something that comes to people's mind in a genocide the the problem um that the people making that argument have is that it's a legal term and that's not what it means so again we're in this point where you're like it's kind of like okay so let's just say what it is rather than you know debate over whether or not we have this term but also just making the point that obviously it is debatable whether or not this term applies to it We can get into this a little more.

29:55Let's jump to the Bill Maher clip, because I think this will kind of, you know, make it a little bit more clear. Let's just get it on the table here. Genocide or not? Absolutely not. Look, if it's a genocide, it would have been the first genocide where Israel vaccinated, where the country committing the genocide vaccinated the population, where they sent them two million tons. Okay, so pause it there. Pause it for a second. So already, Rob, hear what you say, right? This is what they'll go to already, right? Look, dude, they sent vaccines in. Now, leaving aside the part that like, I don't know, Rob, so many people are skeptical of vaccines post-COVID.

30:36It just already almost becomes a self-defeating argument where as soon as you go, they couldn't. They sent them all these vaccines. You feel like a huge percentage of people are going like, oh, did they? Wow, how generous. But even leaving that aside, The problem these guys have is that what they are saying is they're going, look, dude, if the intent was to kill every single member of every single Gazan, then they wouldn't be sending in any medical devices or any food aid or any anything. You know, you hear these people say it all the time. In fact, he's going to say it in a second. Right. So they're just building up to this point that they wouldn't do any of this if they could.

31:15But there's two major problems with this, Rob. Number one is just that that's not what genocide means. There is no, look, Rob, the term genocide also, so you know, is like as old as the legal definition. I think the term was coined in like the 1940s. It was enshrined into law shortly after being called a term. And the term doesn't sit like in that legal definition, Rob, there's nothing there that says, but if you give them vaccines, it's fine. If any food at all got in, it's fine. If you blockaded food for three months, but then let a little bit in and then cut a little bit back and then, then it's not a genocide.

Read the full transcript

31:55None of that. It's just, it doesn't. And the fact that if you're sitting here going, yeah, but even if you want to argue, this demonstrates that they're not trying to kill every single person there because they're at least trying to get some food or some medical aid into them. the genocide claim doesn't revolve around wanting to kill every single member of them. Like the legal statute says that wanting to kill part of them, 100 ,000 or so of them, and then destroy their entire habitat intentionally to destroy the people so that they can't live, that rises to the level. So they don't have to meet this other claim.

32:35It is a straw man. You're coming in with a bar that isn't the bar that they have to meet. Hey, right. Maybe not a straw man, but a false argument of some sort. The Nazis gave Jews potato skin soup and materials to get rid of lice. There were right. Well, look, it does not. Again, also, it doesn't prove the fact that some Jews got food during the Second World War doesn't prove that Hitler wasn't trying to kill all of the Jews. And the fact that some aid got into Gaza doesn't prove that they weren't trying to kill all of the Gazans. But the other idea, sorry, go ahead. It also just really doesn't prove as to the rate at which there might be choosing to do it as being socially acceptable with plausible deniability.

33:19That is number two. Yeah, I was literally setting out one and that's two. Is that because you're exactly right, Rob, because the idea. Well, here, let's play the rest of the clip and then Rob can make it. I think he's going to add the same exact thing of food. um israel could commit a genocide of yeah in a week probably they haven't done that because they have no intent to do it okay suppose here because that's the other thing they always go to there rob right is that this is the other big thing and this is again i just say to the pro israel people this is why your argument is dying this is why no one is rallying like this is why you're persuading no one because that argument is just total bullshit dude it is such fucking bullshit.

34:02It is so ridiculous to just go like, look, dude, like in the same way that let's just say, um, you're, you're physically. Okay. So Rob's Rob exercises regularly. He's fairly strong guy. Let's say you, uh, you walk into a convenience store or something like that. And there's a little old lady who's behind the desk and I go to you and, and let's say you were trying to like, steel, you know, you're, you're, uh, you're, you're trying to, um, what do they call it? Shoplift something. And I were to say to you, well, dude, look, you have, you know, Rob starts shoplifting a bunch of stuff. I go, he's trying to take the whole fucking store.

34:41Someone else goes, no, he's not dude. He's bigger and stronger than that lady. He could just go up and strong arm her and take everything if he wanted to. Okay. Well, like actually, yeah, but then maybe she calls the cops, you know, like maybe there was a security camera. Maybe there's something else. No, actually The fact that you're bigger and stronger in that immediate moment does not mean you can get away with anything. Like, dude, do you think, think about what has happened to the popularity of Israel since October 7th? What do you think would have happened if they had done the scenario you mentioned?

35:12If they had just said, instead of, let's say, they go, that's how we're going to conduct our genocide. We're going to conduct it by just executing every single person. We're going to, in a week, murder 2 million people, not the 100 ,000. We're going to kill all of them. What would happen, Rob? Israel had been destroyed. Absolutely destroyed. Even at that point, even America could, even nobody could defend them at that point, dude. They would have absolutely, like, so actually, Rob, no, it's not so clear that they could have done it like that. It's actually pretty damn clear if you actually run the scenario out that doing it that way would have gotten them absolutely destroyed.

35:48And doing it this way is going to get them all of Gaza, the West Bank, most of the parts of Lebanon that they want, more parts of Syria and the war in Iran that they wanted. So why would they do it that way instead of this way? So you know what I'm saying? Like, even if your intent was to exterminate every last one of the Palestinians, it would make more sense to do it this way than to do it that way. So this argument just flat out fails. Yes, Israel has nukes. And I'm not even sure someone ask a scientist about, you know, I mean, you're talking about right next door. I don't know which way the winds are blowing that day, if it actually is an option for Israel to nuke Gaza, but they do have, let's just say the winds are blowing toward Egypt and it's not a problem.

36:28You think they could have just dropped a nuke on them and that wouldn't have like, if this brought them down 70 points in approval, that would have brought them down 100 % of everyone. So no, that wasn't an option. This is complete bullshit. And it doesn't, it doesn't relieve you of the genocide charge. Hitler could have killed all the Jews day one. Does that prove he didn't want to? All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show. Longtime sponsor of the show, HexCloud, which is an unbelievable company. They have amazing products. If you're looking to level up your kitchen game or your grill game, you got to check out HexCloud.

37:04I have a bunch of their pieces. I got the grill set and I have a bunch of their stuff in my kitchen. Two pans and a pot made by them. All great stuff. This is like if you really want to upgrade your kitchen gear and get the last pair of knives and pots and pans that you're ever going to need to get, check out Hexclad. Their six-piece set is the perfect starter bundle for any kitchen. It includes three of their most popular pans with matching lids, giving you everything you need to handle daily cooking with ease. Their 12-piece set is the ultimate all-in-one cookware upgrade with three versatile pans, two sauce pans, and a family size stock pot, each with its own lid.

37:39You'll have every tool you need to cook for a crowd or master any recipe. They are metal utensil safe, dishwasher safe, and oven safe up to 500 degrees. And their patented laser etched hexagon steel ridges boost your searing power. They are the best pans you will ever own. Definitely, I highly recommend this company. Check them out. Give the upgrade that every kitchen deserves. And you can take 10 % off at hexclad.com slash problem. Cook like a pro get 10 off at hexclad.com slash problem that's h-e-x-c-l-a-d.com slash problem all right let's get back into the show so yeah they got a problem with this one which is uh they're trying to say well they could have had an immediate genocide but i guess the reason why they didn't want the immediate genocide is because they wanted to pretend like they're the most moral army they wanted to tell you about civilian to combatant ratios they wanted to tell you about how we drop leaflets and we're the only army that does that when we uh then flatten somebody's homes we're only targeting so and they're even out in the media right now trying to tell you hey how dare you even call it this so clearly in engaging in these activities they did not want to do it in the most transparent violent and immediate way well but that's why it's because that's why when you start to actually look at what the, and again, obviously look, dude, there is a degree of being provocative when you, when people were using the genocide label, especially at the very beginning.

39:11But like, when you actually look at the definition and you look at all the stuff that they're doing, you go, ah, there's a very strong argument. And that, I mean, that really is kind of the essence of the point here. Um, all right, let's, let's keep playing a little bit. what matters when it comes to genocide. So I agree with Netanyahu and you. It really is the biggest lie of the 21st century. And I'm telling you, right now, the single biggest. Oh, dude, I was so sure it was weapons of mass destruction. You're saying, oh, dude, you're saying that the absolute destruction of Gaza being called a genocide, that's the big lie.

39:51But the made up nuclear program that led to a war of aggression that got a million people killed and cost trillions of dollars? That wasn't the big lie? I'm sorry, there was this two weeks to slow the spread lie that kept Americans on house arrest for years? What are you talking about? You can't get COVID or transmitted if you get this experimental vaccine, which might hurt you, by the way. This is the lie. This is at best, Rob, at best, Rob, this is a slight exaggeration. They're in their in their strongest argument. Genocide is a slight exaggeration. That's the realm of argument that we're in here, because look, dude, I mean, again, we'll play through this before we just get into like what they actually did.

40:46But so, yeah, let's keep playing. On the 2028 Democratic debate stage, raise your hands. Raise your hands if you think Israel committed a genocide. Well, it's not just a question on the debate stage. There was Representative Haley Stevens. She's from Michigan. This week was followed to her car. This goes on all the time. I showed a tape of it, but some other, the guy, Brad Weiner, who's Scott Weiner is running for Nancy Pelosi's seat. And a crowd gets around him and say it, say it. You have to say the word. This woman surrounded her and just say it. And she said, see you at the gallows. Is what, yeah?

41:28No, I was just gonna say, the interesting thing is that there were all these other litmus tests that existed in 2020. And you see politicians, Pete Buttigieg took out, he had his pronouns on his social media account. He got rid of them. So there's actually an effort to get away from what AOC has called woke one. But the new litmus test is Gaza and genocide. That's replaced a lot of these old litmus tests. Yeah. So, I mean, I don't know how the point about litmus test does anything to prove whether it's a genocide or not. But so I guess maybe it is like worth pointing out that. OK, so I think this like this, Rob.

42:09And tell me if you think this is fair. Like, let's just for a second leave out the word genocide. OK. Like. If the if we're trying to be as charitable as we can to say the Bill Maher and that one guest who it's a little bit challenging to be charitable to them because they're such incredibly smug people. um but like if you wanted to say hey dude well i'll put it like this rob look it is like when you see those pictures if you're not following you know what's been going on in the war it might you could be shocked that so few people have died right like i mean if i were to tell you that like 2.1 million people lived in gaza and then showed you gaza you might think to yourself like oh my God, did 2.1 million people die?

43:01Are there 1.8 million people buried under there? And that's not right. That's not what happened. And so if they want to make the claim that no, Israel didn't just do that with all the people in there, that is true. So okay. If they want to say that when you use the word genocide, that's what you're invoking in people's mind and that isn't actually what happened, then okay, that is a legitimate point I suppose to make. So to be clear, what that's not what Israel did. What Hamas says that there's 70 ,000 people underneath all that, essentially, like that's the all that rubble that you see, they say there's 70 ,000 people underneath all that.

43:45There's the Israel, the Israeli supporters and the Israeli government spent the entire first two years of the war. I mean, if you saw any debate and there were more debates on this topic than anything else through that time. If you saw any debate through that time, every single time the pro-Israel guy said, those are Hamas numbers. You're getting those numbers from the Gaza health ministry, which is controlled by Hamas. Okay. At the end of this entire war, the official government, the official stance of the government of Israel is that they've accepted the Hamas figures. The Hamas figures are correct.

44:18Most estimates put it a bit higher, a bit north of 100 ,000. But so essentially what Israel did was immediately after October 7th, They cut off all the power. They cut off all the electricity. Why do we keep doing this? They cut off all the electricity. They cut off the water. They shut down Gaza. They immediately started bombarding it. They made all types of blatant statements openly about what was going to be done, Rob. I mean, from the very top all the way down through the civilian leadership and military leadership, all types of comments about Amalek and relocation to this day, the number two and three posts in the Israeli government openly talk about how they're going to ethnically cleanse the place.

44:57This is just openly discussed. Benjamin Netanyahu has himself said that they're going to occupy the vast majority of Gaza going forward. They're taking over this area. So they immediately start bombing the crap out of the place. Now, in the bombardments of all this stuff, you see tons of people are getting killed. But what they would do is they would send out these leaflets, Rob, Rob, like you said, like not all the time. They bomb some places and not send out leaflets. Sometimes they would just take out a building because it was a terrorist they wanted. Didn't matter if there were a bunch of innocent people there.

45:27They would just kill them. But a lot of other times they would force the civilians out. You know, we would read about this all the time, Rob, as it was happening. They'd force them out this way. They'd force them out that way. Sometimes they'd get killed in the process and they'd be starved. I mean, they're still living in like at this day. They're living in like horrific refugee conditions. These people just have it. Absolutely. And then while Israel had the civilian population out, they made the decision to destroy the whole thing. Everything, everything, dude, like every. And, you know, like I don't even know what to say.

46:03I was talking on the phone with Horton about all of this the other day, but it's like everything because Gaza didn't have a government. Like, technically speaking, they were always ruled by Israel. But I mean almost like government buildings in the sense, Rob, of just think about, this is Gaza. This is a place that millions of people have lived for hundreds of years. I mean, now most of the people who live there have lived there since the creation of the state of Israel, since the creation of the state of Israel, because they were crammed in there. They're mostly refugees who were kicked out of Israel.

46:30But so every building that has every official record of every property deed and genealogy pool, every nursery, every playground, every single hospital, every single schoolyard, every single school, every single business, all of it destroyed forever. your entire lives, your history, your family, your mosques, your culture, all of it destroyed forever. And we are planning on taking it after that. And we're not sure what we're going to do with the rest of the people there, but it looks like we're probably going to try to kick them out. That's what they did. Okay. So call that whatever the fuck you want to call that, but I'm sorry by the legal definition, the people arguing it's a genocide got a damn strong case.

47:24And the people laughing about it has nothing to be laughing about. It literally does remind me, supposedly, I got to reread this, Rob. I don't know if I'm remembering this right, but I remember watching, I read a book about this and then I watched a documentary about the Nuremberg Trials. And I guess there was one point where all the Germans are laughing about how they're going to be charged for fucking the Holocaust or whatever it was, genocide, I think was one of the charges. and then they like started playing the films of the death camps and like it wiped the smile off their faces and they were like yeah we're going down you know and like i don't know dude it kind of seems like that too like it seems to me that like if this was like a court of law like this little gimmick that bill maher's doing but then once you actually explain the story it's like yeah dude the people making the accusation of genocide aren't saying they went in there and killed all two million people of that like we know that but this is what they did do and jesus fucking christ rob it's pretty rough uh that was an epic rant i got nothing to add to it um all right you want to move over to uh we should do uh at least touch on a couple of these ben shapiro mark levin clips dude how can you not how can you not rob you tell me which one is the one we should start with now To be clear, I only saw one of these, and you said there were a couple other that were good.

48:49So what do you think? I would just start it right from the beginning, which I think I marked it at the 114 timestamp, where they are claiming that the conservatives should be doing just fine in this upcoming election because only 4 % of the population actually cares about the Iran situation. Oh, wonderful. Yeah, so I would start it right from that. All right, let's jump in. Two friends of the show. with the American people. So whatever happens in the midterms, it doesn't appear that Iran's going to drive anything one way or another. What's your take on this? I think that's exactly right. Obviously, there is a contingent who would love to see President Trump do poorly in the midterms who want Republicans to lose.

49:31Some of these people are openly saying they want Republicans to lose, by the way. Some of them are openly standing in favor of the pro-terrorism candidate in Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed. So there are some people who are attempting to destroy the Republican Party from within in the hopes that they will then be able to sort of take over whatever remains of the Republican Party. I don't think that it's going to work. You know, when you look at the Iran issue, there's one thing that Americans hate more than anything else when it comes to foreign policy, and it is not foreign conflict. It is losing. It is losing.

49:59And the reality is that the president has done yeoman's work in reopening the Strait of Hormuz and putting the United States in a position to really finish off the Iranian regime without having to put some stuff around. Okay, go ahead. I guess we started a couple seconds late there, but off the top of my head, 4 % was definitely in the number, and Mark Levin's claim is that only 4 % of the population actually cares about the Iran war. Now, just as a theoretical, let's just go that that's theoretically true. I'm going to say that that number is totally bullshit, but how much do you think that number changes if you have the question, how concerned are you because of rising prices as a result of the iran war or how concerned are you that uh that donald trump did not uh follow through on america first agenda because he got distracted by a foreign war and so if you're just going to ask people how do you care for fighting a war in iran and would you like to see us win it i don't know maybe you get polling that's some that's close to that i'm going to say that it's totally not true but the idea that prices are not the absolute biggest issue right now and that iran's not driving that and that that's not the chief complaint amongst your average american citizen that we got dragged into another quagmire when we were promised no new wars and it's affecting pricing i mean it's just it's certifiably not true well yeah i mean look dude they're just so it's such it's such cope man it's just like and that yeah and then why is it so then why is it that you guys are about to get destroyed well then what is so look you also here's the thing what I'm, it's not, look, dude, people obviously, look, my, think about how much I care about all these issues.

51:36My number one priority in life is that my kids are taken care of. After that, it's that my wife is, is okay. You know what I'm saying? Like I have more. And if I'm like, um, if I was in a, luckily I'm doing quite well, but like if I was in a situation where I'm really struggling to get by, then obviously like my healthcare costs and the cost to feed my family and the cost to house my family, that's going to be my, my number one priority. No. So obviously people who aren't as obsessed with this stuff as us. Why would what's going on in Iran be as big a priority to them as the things that they need?

52:06Americans are putting groceries on the credit card right now. Obviously, that's the number one priority. Also, their country has been completely demographically changed against their will. That's a big priority right now. Obviously, Iran isn't the priority right now. But that is the entirety of our point, idiot. That's not a point for you. That's a point in our column. If you launched a war of choice against Iran, then you better damn well hope that the polling shows that that's the number one priority of your constituency. Are you retarded? Come on, like, I'm sorry, Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro are not particularly bright men.

52:43They're not. They're not impressive thinkers, but they're not this dumb, Rob. Everyone would know that. Yes, the whole point is your voting base doesn't give a shit about Iran. And yet you launched this huge effort. You put your whole political thing on it. You're running on it now. And, you know, I guess in addition to that, I would say, well, what was the thing that Ben Shapiro said that made me laugh? They're just holding out that there's a victory right around the corner. We just have to bomb. Oh, right, right, right, right. And Donald Trump is too stupid to do it. The accomplishment was that he did God's work when he opened the Strait of Hormuz.

53:17I never thought I'd live in a world with the open straight of Hormuz, Rob. I never thought I would see such an accomplishment. You can't brag about an accomplishment when you caused the problem. Like what? Come on, come on. This is low. Anyone with a 100 IQ can debunk any of this shit. How about this one, Rob? They just think about how like genuinely what a like, how low resolution, low IQ, you, the argument here would be to go, these people want the Republicans to lose. The people criticizing Trump want the Republicans to lose. The overwhelming majority of the people you're referring to right now, whoever is in these people's minds, it usually seems to be like Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson and Nick Fuentes and me and Megyn Kelly or whoever else it is.

54:09It's almost all of those people supported Trump, but they didn't want Republicans to lose just recently. And like, you can say, oh, they want Republicans to lose, but well, look, how about this, Rob? Okay. Just, uh, off the top of my head, cause I'm old. I can go back in history a little bit. Now, this is what's cool about being old, Rob. I can remember 20 years ago, like no problem. So 20 years ago, 2006, there were midterm elections. Okay. The Republicans got destroyed in the midterm elections and lost both chambers of Congress. The Democrats stormed back, and I think they lost both chambers.

54:45They definitely lost the House. Nancy Pelosi comes in as the Speaker of the House. And the Republicans tried to rally around George W. Bush. And in 2008, they ran John McCain, the same exact George W. Bush foreign policy guy. And they got slaughtered by Barack Obama and led to eight years of, of democratic, uh, control who right now would say it wouldn't have been better for the Republicans to just reject George W. Bush in 2006. Like, yeah, dude, we're not trying to rally on him. We're not running McCain next time. We're going to run someone who was against the war in Iraq. Yeah. You could have saved yourself the Obama eight years.

55:24You didn't have to go through the worst crushing defeat ever. You didn't have to We go through the embarrassment of the John Boehner years and all those awful guys, Mitt Romney and the rest. So like, no, obviously it would. Okay, so why would it have been better to bail on George W. Bush? What was the problem with rallying around George W. Bush? Everyone hates his fucking guts. Everyone in the country fucking hated him. And why? Because he launched, he lied us into stupid wars that we lost. That is exactly what's going on right now, Rob. And it is crazy that these people don't see it. I know I've been saying this now for a year and a half, but it's just become more and more obvious the whole time.

56:07And it was clear as day to see, just like the COVID shit, just like opposing the genocide, just like all of it. It was clear as day to see. He's going fucking down. This is George W. Bush. So anyone telling you like, yo, we got to wipe our hands, that it's so low IQ to go, oh, so you want us to lose. It's like, no, I'm saying like, it's like supporting that we will go, we will burn, we will crash and burn in 28 unless we find something else other than this is the point. Anything else you want to go back to that? No, no, no. Let's hear the Cargillin pitch and the gas prices pitch. Oh God. Oh Lord.

56:41The United States in a position to really finish off the Iranian regime without having to put boots on the ground in Iran. The president has to within his capacity to essentially finish the Iranian economy. with a single bombing sortie over Clark Island or South Pars. The biggest thing, I think, that is the obstacle right now to just completing that victory is just a matter of decision-making. Does the president actually believe that a deal is on the table or does he not? I'm very skeptical. Let's pause it for a second, Rob, because isn't it convenient, Rob, that every time someone's defending this war, and it's unbelievable, dude.

57:14I saw I saw Will Chamberlain, the guy who guaranteed or said he'd be shocked if the Iranians lasted another month back in April, back in April. Oh, yeah. He just said he just said, we're winning the war. It's looking better than ever. You know, and they always rub. They always have this and they say it with a lot of confidence. They go, listen, man, there is this military option. Let me tell you about if we went in here and then we came in like that and then we fucking kicked your ass, fucked him up like here. We could just do that and win this whole thing. We could just do that. That option's right there.

57:48That's what I said we'd do. And that's why you support the war, because you know I got this option where we could just win the whole thing, destroy the whole economy in this one option. Oh, and why isn't Trump doing that? Huh? It's decision-making. He's waiting. Yeah, yeah, yeah. He's been sitting here for six months waiting. There's this obvious option to win the war, but he's just not doing it. And by the way, hey, guys, when none of this comes true, when he doesn't do any of this, you know, Ben Shapiro will just move the goalposts and move on to something else. But literally what they are requiring you to believe, they're backing this up with nothing other than an assertion that this can be done and not telling you what the costs or how many people are going to get killed or what it could, what, you know, like the possible bad outcomes of this could be.

58:30It could be done. Isn't this doesn't this just not pass the smell test? Then why the fuck have they not done this yet? It seems like the option there is because it doesn't exist. There is no plan. Sorry, I call bullshit. Back it up with something. You're muted. There's always a very simple way to win, and somehow only Ben Shapiro knows it, and nobody will take his sound advice on the simple solution. If what Ben Shapiro's saying is true, am I getting this wrong? What Ben Shapiro's saying is true. shouldn't he be as outraged at the trump administration as we are maybe more oh yeah because he's just leaving a simple solution on the table that could solve all the problems like dude get rid of these jokers in the pentagon and put ben shapiro in there dude just fucking bomb car guy it's literally like dude it's i mean i don't know if i remember once uh buddy of mine this dude named uh greg uh black dude from brooklyn loved greg haven't seen him in years.

59:36Great guy though. 05.: Not a very black dude from Brooklyn name. 05.: Yeah, no, it's what it really threw you for a loop. Yeah. It was like a kind of hood black guy. But so he was over at my old apartment that I used to have in Brooklyn and Louis Jay Gomez was there. We were like 25 years old or something like that. And we were over at my apartment. We were watching UFC. Me and Louis had just gotten into UFC and we were watching old UFC. It was a hoist Gracie fight. And my black friend, Greg goes, uh man if that motherfucker came up on me I just elbow that motherfucker and hit him like this and then I just told him for 15 minutes what a child he sounded like right now and I go do you know what hoist gracey would do to you if he grabbed a hold of you you think you you think you just look at it like you it's like I go you sound like a seven-year-old boy right now going I'd come in and go like that's what Ben Shapiro's doing here if it were me I'd go down to Carg Island and I'd just be like I'd kick him right in the face like yeah okay Ben I guess that's your claim that you should really be furious at the trump administration if they would just put you in the pentagon we'd have won this war already and we'd go dominate the midterms and now we're about to give them over to these crazy socialists who hate israel all because they won't do this one simple thing that you could do he should he should be calling for his impeachment his uh his next dumbass pitch which uh we can play him it will catch a little bit of it but he says for those that are concerned with gas prices if we don't end this now uh it's only going to be a problem moving forward.

1:00:57And that's also not true because you could just walk away, let them charge a toll, and that would be the end of higher gas prices. Yeah. Oh, OK. Right. Right. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. It's just all so it's like just genuinely childish. All right. Here, let's let's let's keep on. I'll deal on the table. But as you say, the American people are significantly less interested in any foreign policy issue than they are with how things are going here in the United States. And if the economic numbers continue to boom in the stock market, if they continue to do well in the unemployment numbers, if the wages increase to keep up with the inflation and inflation drops, then Republicans will do fine in the midterms and the rest of the presidency will be a success.

1:01:39It really is almost that simple. Pause it. Pause it right here. OK, so it really is that simple. All we got to do is lower prices. It's really that simple. All we got to do is have this war go good and lower prices. What are the, what are the, well, let's check, CalShay, our sponsor there. What are the Calci odds right now on the Republicans? I'm sorry, I should say on the Democrats taking the House and the Senate. I should say that the episode is sponsored by Calci. Also, we have a link, which is calci.com slash r slash Dave Smith. If you want to go check out that site, you can keep yourself busy there for hours.

1:02:14They can the prediction markets for everything. So go check that out. It is very interesting. OK, let's get back into it. What are the Calci odds right now on the Republicans? I'm sorry, I should say on the Democrats taking the House and the Senate. I think it's like 60 percent or maybe I think I think it's higher in the House. And I think it's something I think it's around 60. And that's going to be my guess is going to be 70 in the House and 60 in the Senate. I'm not sure, though. I haven't I haven't checked this recently. Those Calci markets move. You got to check them. I don't know where the money's going.

1:02:47But I got to say, well, look, dude, and as with all polls and with all markets and things like that, although markets are a little bit different because people are actually putting their money into it. It's not these things aren't crystal balls that you're looking into the future. But it's like it is interesting to see where people's money are right now in these prediction markets. And yeah, I already will tell you it's not looking good. So, yeah, let me know if you if you have those back up. I don't know anything else on any of this Rob I mean it's like what what does that mean again like there was that old clip if you remember I always loved bringing it up when Thomas Massey pointed out that the math didn't add up on the amount of electric vehicles they wanted and how much juice was in the power grid to get the power to the electric vehicles and that and it was uh what's his name the gay dude um Buttigieg was up there and he goes uh um you know he's got this this new, you know, he's going to implement that all these cars have to be, you know, carbon neutral by, you know, this date.

1:03:50And he goes, but we don't have the power grid to have enough electricity. And he goes, that's why we need to reinvent the power grid. And you go, oh, so you have nothing. So then you have nothing. You don't have a thing. That is what that means. That is you have zero. You get zero out of a hundred for that. And like for Ben Shapiro to just go, look, all we need to do is make the war work good, win, and then bring prices down and then we'll win the midterms. This is delusional. I'm sorry. What is it? 91.5 Dems, eight Republicans. I don't know what that. Hold on. Let's see. Wait now. Hold on. Which party will win the U.S.

1:04:27House? And what is it? Democratic Party? 91%. Oh, wow. Jesus. They were way higher than I thought. Okay. 91 % they're at for the House. And where are we at for the Senate?

1:04:40wow 91 is where the money is right now i mean take that's for what it's worth hey and it's criticizing the war can i uh wait can we change our guess for the senate now now i want to go higher that i didn't realize that was quite as high as it was um 70 maybe i don't know geez the house isn't going to be that high um i'm inside the senate isn't going to be that high 62 okay so 91 and 62 in other words utter catastrophe rob utter catastrophe if you care about the trump coalition at all it is just impossible to overstate what an utter catastrophe calamity disaster this is house is on fire the defcon 80 this is the worst situation you could imagine, dude.

1:05:31And here, look, Rob, like, why? Because the Democrats are about to come back in, dude. And that's it. That's it. This is Trump's second term. That's it. This is the rest of it. Democratic control of Congress. And what does that mean? Oh, I mean, his entire domestic agenda is fucked. And what was it again, Rob? Remind me what Ben Shapiro just said Trump voters care about. Oh, yeah. Everything they care about is fucked over the war. Now, they could sit here and pretend all day long that it's not over the war. But I don't know, man, like saying, you know, if I literally their argument comes down to I've I've put all my chips in on policy A and their argument is people don't care about policy A.

1:06:23So you can't say that policy A is the reason why this is a disaster. I mean, it's it's so dumb. It's like, I don't know if there was a pollutant in the air and you and I were criticizing the pollutant and the administration allowed for more of the pollutant. And then the pollutant killed all of the fields and there was no grass, grain or food to eat. And then you said, well, people don't care about the pollutant. Whereas and everyone's upset about that. There's no food to eat. This is the natural consequence of the war was that there was inflation and prices went up. And so firstly, I don't think the 4 % is even true.

1:06:53But if you're looking at it as being a price issue and pretending people don't care about the war, you're just one step removed from the policy that caused the price increase. Yep. Yep. That's exactly right. All right. I guess we got to we got to leave it there. Guys, come out and see Rob. Go see him run the FBI special out in Salt Lake. Dude, that's going to be a lot of fun. Porchdoor.com, ComicDaveSmith.com. Come see both of us out in Salt Lake City and in Las Vegas. We're looking forward to that. And yeah, catch you guys tomorrow, regular time tomorrow. Catch you then. Peace.

From the publisher

Dave Smith brings you the latest in politics! On this episode of Part Of The Problem, Dave and Robbie "the Fire" Bernstein discuss the newly released Google Earth images of the destruction in Gaza, Bill Maher discussing with experts why it's "not" a genocide, Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro discussing why Iran isn't an important issue to most Americans, and more.


Support Our Sponsors:

Hexclad - Find your forever cookware @hexclad and get 10% off at https://hexclad.com/PROBLEM! #hexcladpartner


Kalshi - https://kalshi.com/r/DaveSmith


Ghost Bed - https://www.ghostbed.com/problem and use the promo code PROBLEM


Part Of The Problem is available for early pre-release at https://partoftheproblem.com as well as an exclusive episode on Thursday!


PORCH TOUR DATES HERE:

https://www.eventbrite.com/cc/porch-tour-2026-4836968



Find Run Your Mouth here:

YouTube - http://youtube.com/@RunYourMouth

iTunes - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-your-mouth-podcast/id1211469807

Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/4ka50RAKTxFTxbtyPP8AHm


Follow the show on social media:

X:

http://x.com/ComicDaveSmith

http://x.com/RobbieTheFire


Instagram:

http://instagram.com/theproblemdavesmith

http://instagram.com/robbiethefire


#libertarian



See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from Part Of The Problem

All 65 episodes
Was It A Genocide?Part Of The Problem · 1 h 8 min
Listen in VO