How Much to Charge for Your Membership (The 3 Rs That Make Pricing Easy)

26 Mar 2026 · 7 min · 3 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode explains how to set membership pricing using the “3 Rs”: results (the value members get and the transformation they achieve), replacement (what the membership replaces that members already pay for), and respect (a price that makes both the creator and members prioritize the community). The host claims higher prices lead to better member outcomes and transformation because people pay more attention to what they pay for. She anchors on an average Mighty Networks price of about $48/month (~$500/year). Examples include Happy Horse, Happy Life ($59/month) with $9.99 quick courses; Protrusive Guidance ($16/month) plus $49/month clinical education; The Storage Rubble ($297/month) plus $479 summit ticket; Farina Daly ($49.99/month) plus $199 1:1 consult; Lab (£299/month) plus £699 mastermind; Good Soil HQ ($140/month) plus $499 conference ticket; Flower Boss Academy ($297/month) plus $97 masterclass.

Guests

Gina (a caller/hosted questioner).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Understanding the Three Rs of Membership Pricing

0:45 to 2:51

Learn the three key principles to determine membership pricing: results, replacement, and respect.

“What price motivates both you and your members to prioritize your community?”

Examples of Successful Membership Models

2:51 to 6:40

Explore various successful membership models to inspire your pricing strategy.

“I love this example, the Happy Horse, Happy Life.”

Transforming Membership Into Value

6:40 to 7:03

Understand how to create value through membership that encourages investment from members.

“Certainly that's a little bit of a part of this, but what it's really about is helping people pay attention, helping them get results and transformation that they cannot get on their own.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Gina Bianchini:If you take nothing else away, it is that people pay attention to what they pay for.

0:12Hello, Gina. I'm stuck trying to figure out how much to charge for my community. I want to make it accessible, but I also want to charge a fair price for myself. Vice?

0:23Gina Bianchini:So what should you charge for your membership? Well, I like to use three R's. Number one, results. What is the value of the results that your members are going to generate by being a member of your community? Number two is replacement. What are your members buying today that your membership can replace? And number three is respect. What price motivates both you and your members to prioritize your community? And it turns out, if people pay attention to what they pay for, the higher the price, the better results and transformation your members will get. So results, replacement, and respect. And hopefully all three of those are leading you to something that we've discovered here at Mighty Networks, which is the average monthly price for a membership that gets people results and transformation in their lives, gets people real value from their results, replaces other things that they're spending money on, and is a price that allows both you and your members to prioritize your new membership.

1:37Gina Bianchini:I want you to anchor on this,$48 a month or roughly$500 a year. That is the average price that we see across Mighty Networks. Now, here's the beautiful thing about it. $48 is something that if somebody is able to get that unlock in terms of new revenue or that job promotion, or even the things that you can't necessarily put a figure on like a happy family or more inner peace, this is a price point that is going to deliver results, that's going to replace a number of other things that people are doing, and ultimately give your new membership the respect and attention that it deserves. All right, so now I wanna show you some examples to give you the confidence that there are people all over the world who are creating offers that are at that$48 price point or higher, and in some cases, significantly higher.

2:40Gina Bianchini:You can absolutely do this. And your ideal member, that person who's in a transition, who wants to have their best year ever, they want you to do this too. Let's go ahead and dive in. I love this example, the Happy Horse, Happy Life. It is a membership at$59 a month or$644.99 a year for horse trainers. And it is all around how to train horses for connection, comfort, and choice. They also have done something really interesting, which they have a number of what they call quick courses that they offer on top of that membership. For example, this$9.99 benefits of writing out quick course. And so when you look at a membership, not only do you have the baseline membership, this$59 or$644, but you can also layer on more paid programs on top of it.

3:41Gina Bianchini:Another great example is Protrusive Guidance, which is for kind and geeky dentists motivated to grow in their stressful profession. So this is$16 a month or$140 a year for the baseline membership. And then they also have the ultimate clinical education at$49 a month and$449 a year. Again, you can have different membership tiers and different membership levels. I do wanna recommend that if you are starting from scratch, just start simple with one. You don't have to have multiple tiers. You don't have to have a bronze, silver, and gold level. All of that can get very complex very quickly. And you're much better off starting with something that is a strong foundation of one simple membership and then layering on top of that core membership, that foundational membership as you start to see people get through it or just have great success and want more.

4:39Gina Bianchini:The storage rubble. This is for people intrigued by flipping ordinary garages into extraordinary lives. And their membership is$297 a month with an additional event ticket of$479 for their annual summit. Another great example is Farina Daly. This is a fitness membership for at-home fitness training. And this is$49.99 a month. And then there's also$199 one-on-one consultation. with the founder. So you can take full advantage of different levels and different opportunities within Farina Daily. Another example is the lab for mortgage and real estate professionals. This is a really strong membership with a£299 a month, based obviously in the UK, membership where they also have a 699 pound per year database benchmarking mastermind group as well.

5:43Gina Bianchini:So you can start to see how they are creating their value journey, as I like to call it, from the core membership into premium programs that happen on top of it. Good Soil HQ, it is for business owners and executives looking to launch a new venture in the next year. They have a$140 membership that is$1 ,500 a year, and they have a$499 event ticket for their annual conference. Another great example is the Flower Boss Academy. This is for local floral designers ready to take their business to the next level. So this membership is$297 a month, and they offer one-off programs on top of that, such as a$97 wedding inquiries masterclass.

6:36Gina Bianchini:So as you think about your offer, this is not about asking people for money. Certainly that's a little bit of a part of this, but what it's really about is helping people pay attention, helping them get results and transformation that they cannot get on their own. People pay for progress and what they pay for, they pay attention to. So as you think about your offer, just remember, you've got results, replacement, and you have got respect. I'm Sheena Bianchini. Until next time.

From the publisher

You know that moment where you've built something incredible, your content is ready, your community space is set up, and then you completely freeze when it's time to put a price on it? You're not alone. Most creators either undercharge out of fear or skip pricing altogether, and it's the single fastest way to kill a community before it even gets going.

In this episode, Gina Bianchini breaks down her 3 Rs pricing framework, results, replacement, and respect, and reveals the anchor price point that drives real transformation across thousands of thriving communities. Plus, she walks through real-world examples of creators charging anywhere from $49 to $297 a month and winning.

In this episode, you'll learn:
• The 3 Rs framework that takes the guesswork out of membership pricing
• Why $48 per month is the sweet spot for engagement, retention, and results
• How undercharging actually hurts your members more than it helps them
• Real examples of creators building thriving paid communities at every price point
• How to layer courses, events, and premium programs on top of a core membership
• Why starting with one simple offer beats a complicated multi-tier setup

TIMESTAMPS
(0:00) People pay attention to what they pay for
(0:12) The membership pricing question every creator asks
(0:18) The 3 Rs pricing framework explained
(0:42) Why higher prices lead to better member results
(1:07) The $48 per month anchor price point
(2:00) What makes this number the transformation sweet spot
(2:30) Happy Horse Happy Life membership example
(3:30) Protrusive Guidance tiered pricing breakdown
(4:00) Start simple with one membership level
(4:30) High ticket membership examples
(5:20) The Lab for mortgage and real estate professionals
(6:00) The value journey from core membership to premium
(6:50) Your offer is about results not asking for money

Get Our FREE Community Masterclass

FREE LIVE Intro Event

JOIN the $1-Million Community Challenge

More from People Magic: How to Build a $1M Community

All 90 episodes
How Much to Charge for Your Membership (The 3 Rs That Make Pricing Easy)People Magic: How to Build a $1M Community · 7 min
Listen in VO