1. Podcasts
  2. Pilot TV+
  3. Animation Education
Pilot TV+

12 Oct 2026 · 1h 1m · 22 chapters

In short

The episode “Animation Education” is a follow-up where animation consultant John McEwan-Whyte assigns “homework” to the hosts to broaden their views of animation beyond mainstream drawn cartoons. They discuss how different animation styles (stop-motion, stylized 2D, rotoscoped action, adult sci-fi animation) can deliver emotional weight, serious themes, and high craft.

Guests

John McEwan-Whyte, an animation consultant (“animation guru”). The hosts are Boyd, Steph, and James (no other guest named).

Key claims

  • Animation requires controlling every pixel, so craft choices (texture, color, motion) can be more deliberate than live action.
  • Animation is often dismissed as a “genre,” causing under-recognition of adult and experimental animated work.
  • Modern tech/AI may shift animation labor toward pre/post and design roles rather than eliminating jobs.

Notable examples (homework picks)

  • Steph: Hushabye Lullaby (BBC iPlayer), praised for fuzzy-felt-like textures and star/rocket magic.
  • Boyd: Electric City (Tom Hanks co-created; 2012), praised for noir/sci-fi beauty and an early domestic abuse scene.
  • James: Primal (Genndy Tartakovsky), praised for minimalist visuals paired with brutal grief and no-dialogue storytelling.
  • Extra credit: Captain Laserhawk: A Blood Dragon Remix (hated), Cyberpunk: Edgerunners (loved), Scavenger’s Reign (too slow/unclear), Blue Eye Samurai (loved for fluid action and grounded drama).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Discussing Animation Homework Assignments

Hosts reflect on their homework assignments related to animation education.

“like I did at school when you have to present your work to the class and teacher is kind of looking at you judgmentally with a certain amount of expectation and you're giving that energy John at the moment really?”
3:02

Steph's Assignment: Hushabye Lullaby

Steph discusses her animated assignment, Hushabye Lullaby, and its beauty.

“and obviously I do actually watch a lot of animation.”
7:03

Boyd's Assignment: Electric City

Boyd shares his experience watching Electric City, an animated web series.

10:14

James's Double Assignments: Primal and More

James discusses his assigned animations, focusing on Primal and its impact.

“of this animated show starting was some animated domestic abuse which occurs in the, yes, expression on Steph's face is horrific, horrified, quite rightly.”
14:00

Exploring 'Primal': A Blend of Grief and Animation

Discover the emotional depth and surprising darkness in the animated series 'Primal'.

“The first, of course, was Primal, which is a Genndy Tartakovsky animation.”
16:44

Diving into 'Captain Laserhawk': An Animated Disappointment

A critical review of 'Captain Laserhawk', highlighting its flaws and disappointments.

“very minimal dialogue in the second season but yeah Genndy Tartakovsky's primal or primal tales of savagery as it is known somewhere and they're not fucking kidding.”
22:33

Cyberpunk Edgerunners: A Compelling Animation Experience

An overview of 'Cyberpunk Edgerunners', emphasizing its emotional storytelling and visuals.

“I was about to say that I think you would What's the music like?”
24:44

Scavenger's Reign: Art vs. Entertainment

A discussion on 'Scavenger's Reign' and its artistic approach to storytelling in animation.

“But I think what we did was we gave you a gateway.”
28:00

Scavenger's Reign: Art or Entertainment?

Exploration of the artistic depth versus accessibility of animated shows.

“It feels like I've skipped too many rungs on my animation journey to seize onto this.”
30:30

Finding the Right Animation Fit

Discussion on personal animation preferences and discovering enjoyable series.

“The Good Dinosaur is a prequel to Primal.”
Show all 22 chapters
31:34

In-Depth on Blue Eye Samurai

Analyzing the animation style, narrative, and character depth of Blue Eye Samurai.

“I'm going to use a weird analogy, which may fall a little bit flat on you, John, because you're young.”
36:05

The Mainstreaming of Animation

Discussion about the growing popularity of animation and its cultural impact.

“And this is called, I think it's called genre spectacle.”
40:05

Animation News and Updates

Latest announcements in the animation industry including new shows and projects.

“James Dwyer has announced a Pilot TV podcast every week dedicated to animation.”
42:05

The Rise of Animated Series

Discussion on the increasing number of animated series and their potential for success.

43:58

Animation Technology and Industry Evolution

Exploration of how technology impacts animation production and reduces costs.

“And they'll invest in like, you know, Coco Melon the movie.”
45:56

Listener Insights on Animation

Reading and discussing listener recommendations and insights regarding animation.

“so kind of the middle that's after pre and before post, all that's going to happen is they're all going to shift to pre and post.”
48:25

Critiques and Recommendations in Animation

Listeners share their critiques and suggestions for animated content.

“or the hilarious hijinks of those bunnies in Watership Down.”
51:44

Dungeons & Dragons and Animation

Discussion on Dungeons & Dragons and its crossover into animated series.

56:00

Exploring Dungeons & Dragons Characters

Learn about character creation and chaos in Dungeons & Dragons.

“and their characters are characters in the show.”
56:58

Animation Recommendations from Listeners

Hear various listener recommendations for animated shows.

57:50

In-Depth Review of Animated Series

Discover insights into popular animated series like 'Castlevania' and 'The Great North'.

“The Great North is family first cosy show that has become one of my comfort watches.”
59:40

Closing Thoughts on Animation Education

Reflect on the lessons learned about animation and future discussions.

“Well, you know, my favourite thing is Nick Hoffman being Nick Hoffman.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Pilot TV+, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:08Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters. And this week we are rejoining John, our animation consultant, for a follow-up to our animation education segment, which we did on the main show. John, how are you? John McEwan-Whyte, animation guru, as you are. I'm very good and I was really happy to see you guys in your faces and really happy about your commitment to making every pilot episode feature an animated series to review. Thank you James for you. I feel very strongly like I did at school when you have to present your work to the class and teacher is kind of looking at you judgmentally with a certain amount of expectation and you're giving that energy John at the moment really?

0:57that's like authority I don't have a lot of authority you've managed to make us all watch cartoons I'm saying that's quite something Boyd emailed me yesterday by the way urgently asking what it was that he needed to watch just to dob him in This is a fascinating insight into your school history, Boyd. You emailed your homework rather than, I mean, you could have just listened back to the podcast and listened to the bit where he actually...

1:23John McEwan-Whyte: Wait a minute, Steph, yes, it would be much more professional to trawl back through the myriad episodes of the podcast, work out when the hell we had John on anyway, and then rather than just email him and say, what the fuck am I supposed to be watching? Which he did answer, and I fulfilled. I fulfilled myself. I'm going to forgive you for lashing out because you've obviously had a hard time with the animation. So your lash out is going to... I'm filing it, but for now... Okay, but look, we did have our section on animation, at which point you tried to educate... Tried being the operative word.

1:54Tried to educate us in the ways of animation. For those of you who don't know, and I don't understand how anyone would not know since they subscribed to Pilot Plus, we have a patchy trap record when it comes to appreciating animation. Boyd and I in particular. Steph, on the other hand, likes Mysterious Cities of Golden Bluey, which apparently makes her an anime expert. But, you know, that's fine. That's okay. But what you did, John, which I thought was a smart thing to do, you set us all specific tasks. You set us all homework. You set us all things to watch, which were bespoke tailored, I imagine, or possibly pulled out of your arse.

2:22I'm not sure. To our specific sensibilities. So I feel like to kick off this conversation, we should probably begin with showing our homework. Now, Steph, you are very much the keno who does her homework. the second it is set, hand up, front of the class, you are that person. Can you tell us what your particular one was? And John, perhaps you could remind us why you chose that for Steph. Mine was Hushabye Lullaby on iPlayer, BBC iPlayer. And I have to say, I watched it, yes, exactly as you said, straight away after I was told to. So I had to re-watch it yesterday to remind myself of it because it was glorious.

3:04and obviously I do actually watch a lot of animation. So for me, this was just a dip into a beautiful world. But John, you can say why you thought it would be a good idea. I thought it would be a good idea because you're the best of all stuff in that you actually appreciate animation instead of consistently being rude and disrespectful. Not to me, to society. And so I thought I'd give you a lighted little one, less duration, but also I wanted to give you a hug in animated form, which was Hushabai Lullaby, sound and visual. It's like everything that kids' animation should be, but also in itself, like a bit of an art form, like you're witnessing something beautiful being created that people really care about.

3:48Do you know, so let me tell you, it's exactly what you said. It's so beautiful. So they're only three minutes long. And what the feeling I got, I don't remember, I don't know where you guys were when you first saw Monsters, Inc. But when I first saw Monsters, Inc., do you remember there's that very – and I remember at the time it being a really huge big deal because there'd been some kind of big advancement in the way that they animated fur. And Sully – and it was a bit like – do you remember the ballroom scene from Beauty and the Beast when that was a huge thing? and it was I don't know if it's like photorealism or whatever but the way that the fur moved on Sully and if you don't know he's the big blue monster um was incredible and it was like oh it was so captivating you couldn't take your eyes off it and when I watched Hush by Lullaby I thought my god I firstly again I don't know if any of you ever played with fuzzy felts you'll be not old enough john did you yeah right so the way that this animation is done is it's as if um the animated is like a couple of like a green creature like a green like a green um parent creature and a green child creature and everything is kind of puffy and animated it looks like it's been sewn together with fuzzy felt but what really struck me is how how the textures were so incredible and when they're when they needed there's an episode early on where they're animating stars oh it's so magical the way they do that because I thought how are they going to get this movement in to this because obviously things move around because they're in a rocket and they're and someone's singing and it's and it really is a beautiful it's just a beautiful lullaby someone's singing and taking you through the sheep and it's just a lovely way to fall asleep as I did fall asleep to it last night so i was really struck by how it felt very different like i think we talked before like i had watched a lot of patchwork pals which is a great animation on um iplayer but for me this one had a feeling of if do you remember button moon if button moon was like super like super animated now and everything it had all the technology that's what i thought it I felt like it would be like like this so I thought it was absolutely magical and beautiful and yes that's what it reminded me of so it was perfectly correct for me you're you're a plus for Steph for turning in her homework by the way and like the whole thing with animation is like when you're when you're pointing a camera at something you can't control every pixel of the frame but with animation you have to control every single bit of what's in that frame so it means you have to be so particular and you have to make a choice for everything and I think it just goes to show just how kind of how far art can be when you bring in a whole other kind of uh tool to to create it and i think like the texture you wouldn't look at humans that are on live action and be like oh their skin looks very nice i mean maybe some people do uh but with with kind of hush it by lullaby it's very much just about every choice that they've made to do with texture to do with color to do saturation to do with the environment is all aimed towards making you feel warm and comfortable inside and it's just it's just a perfect example of why animation can just take something and make it kind of 10 steps better yeah it's so magical it's just i think the thing is is that a lot of people when you say animation they just kind of think of drawn animation and they never really think of stop motion animation and all that kind of stuff maybe maybe they think of you know shawn the sheep and all that kind of stuff but they don't really think like the the breadth is just astronomical and it's and and when you're looking at something you're thinking well how is this animation and how have they done that it's it's so unbelievably impressive to someone like me who cares about animation probably not someone like james who couldn't give a shit about animation or could you james well you'll find out but not just yet because boydy i want to hear from you what was your task that you literally watched at the 11th hour last night uh and what did you think of that and also john why did you choose this for boyd well yeah

8:00John McEwan-Whyte: it's electric city which is a um a web series is that what we're calling it that came out originally in 2012 kind of co-created by tom hanks um in fact it's called tom hanks's electric city on the uh title card and um one of the most extraordinary things about it is this whole thing it's like 20 episodes it's like turned into a 90 minute film um so to speak won awards i've never heard of it i don't know about james and steph but i've never heard of this thing no i hadn't electric city um before i pronounce on it though john why did you why the hell did you choose this for me well i mean the fact that you're saying you never heard it is a perfect example of how kind of under-recognized animation is get like this was something that Tom Hanks voice loads of big names and as he said it looks beautiful it's a good story and yet no one's like heard of it at all because for some reason animation has this thing that just understandably people just discount and it's something that is in the animation world it's really trying to break through and some of those i find it strange that when the simpsons came out everyone watched simpsons and everyone watched like family guy and american dyad and it never really crossed over into any other genre like even you don't really see that much animated sitcoms are as successful as those nowadays and it's because animation is really seen as a different genre not as just kind of a different lens to tell stories through so yeah and I chose it because it's classy and legendary and a little bit sci-fi we should tell Steph it's post-apocalyptic I'm out sorry having said that though this is one of those post-apocalyptic worlds where there's loads and loads of survivors still in fact there's little towns cities and neighbourhoods that are still thriving.

10:02John McEwan-Whyte: Okay, so are they hunting, are they starting again? It's a start again. Well, they've started again. They've started again and they've pretty much you know, they've achieved quite a lot seemingly. What I wasn't expecting, I have to say, is within minutes of this animated show starting was some animated domestic abuse which occurs in the, yes, expression on Steph's face is horrific, horrified, quite rightly. Oh my god. James needs the warning anyway because this is one of his triggers that he can't I'd be interested to know whether you could bring yourself to watch this with animated domestic abuse but it is quite shocking I have to say and almost more shocking than it would be if it was acted out by actors because it's something you wouldn't expect and something I wasn't expecting at all so that was interesting and I think that kind of the show set its still out saying this is an adult quite edgy piece of work because it's not for children, it's not The Simpsons and this is definitely a different genre to all those shows you mentioned this is not an animated sitcom this is quite a serious kind of, you know, it's kind of a mixture of noir and melodrama and it does look beautiful by the way it's got that kind of spider-verse kind of as a non-animation expert it's got a similar kind of beauty to it the visuals um and the it's it's kind of stylized and it looks great and i i really i thought it was fascinating i it didn't it didn't entice me to carry on watching it beyond you know the first few episodes when it started the 20 minute episodes it didn't entice me to go and watching it desperately after that but i was certainly intrigued and fascinated and i absolutely kind of claim it for its beauty and it's daring and it's quite bold and different, I would say that.

11:57John McEwan-Whyte: And Tom Hanks' voice is the make-out and his voice is fantastic. And so that kind of helps as well. Yeah, I think kind of opening with that domestic abuse scene, it's interesting, like, you wouldn't say, oh, it was weird, we watched something in black and white and there was a domestic abuse scene. Like, just because it's in animation, as you say, it's, like, jarring, but I think this is why animation education is really important because we need to kind of be re-educated in that there's this whole world of stories that we're missing out on because it's a bit weird that it's cartoons. But for so many reasons, like, as you say, the choice that they made to make that animation made that scene stand out to you a little bit more.

12:39I think, yeah, I think the kind of world that they paint is very unique. And you've seen so many dystopian worlds, but as soon as you see it animated, then it has a very distinct quality. I think that was something that I feel Tom Hanks is very ahead of his time on. And I think it was a shame that it came out kind of 10 or 13 years ago, because if that came out kind of on Netflix now-ish, it probably would have got a lot more coverage. Yeah, that's true. That's for sure.

13:11John McEwan-Whyte: Yeah, if this arrived suddenly now on a big streaming service with Tom Hanks behind it, it would be very noteworthy. Yeah, but somehow it's past mainstream TV people like me. both past this budget. Have you heard of it, James? No. No, I had not. It's interesting, isn't it? Yeah. You get a B plus because you're not continuing to watch it. Thanks. Penalised for lack of dedication to your studies. Yeah. To be fair, I have just received the email saying that all the rest of the episodes of The Diplomat are available for me to watch. So, you know, it's... I mean, some of us have seen them, Boyd. So, you know, things are looking up.

13:51God, you two are insufferable. Okay, right. Now, I don't know whether I should feel victimised by this, but I was given two assignments. You were given two very short things. They were very short. The first, of course, was Primal, which is a Genndy Tartakovsky animation. And obviously this scratches the back of my lizard brain that doesn't like things that are factually inaccurate, but obviously it blends prehistoric eras together in an egregious way by putting uh homo sapiens and and tyrannosaurus rexes together but you know we're gonna we're gonna slide over that so this uh this sees the main character who is a who's a caveman called spear it's a catchy name uh and he ends up coming into the orbit of fang who is a kind of tyrannosaur it certainly looks like a tyrannosaurus rex certainly a cousin of one of those anyway but what surprised me about this was a couple of things so first and foremost this genuinely scared the shit out of me there is a bit early on where there is a jump scare that genuinely had me flying out of my chair and it's just something comes out of the water but i guess i just maybe it was just i was disarmed by the fact that it was animation but i wasn't expecting that and that made me that made me watch the rest of the episode more warily i think than i had done previously um and i guess what what really struck me about this first episode is because spear's family is killed including his children and then fang the tyrannosaurus her children are also killed it is really fucking dark like really dark and quite upsetting as well and then fang and spear essentially become friends and together they decide to sort of you know wander around the cenozoic era trying to survive and dealing with dinosaurs and monsters and things like that united in grief well exactly but it really is that it's so upsetting oh but in both cases because it's just it's a really brutal way of bringing these characters together and because of the art style again maybe it's my own preconception because it is an animation you don't expect that level of just weight to hit you um so i was quite disarmed by this and i was actually very impressed with it again i'm probably like people who love animation is rolling their eyes at how basic i'm being because of course animation does this all the time and i'm sure it does i'm saying from my perspective it was just it just it surprised me it caught it caught me by surprise that it had so much emotional weight to it and that it was so dark and so kind of grief infused so actually i didn't i mean i didn't carry on and watch the whole thing of this there are a couple of seasons with this i think in fact there are three as i recall uh because i did look into it a little bit uh and there's no dialogue whatsoever in the show no speaking of any kind just grunts and growls and shouts and screams and misery though apparently there is some dialogue very minimal dialogue in the second season but yeah Genndy Tartakovsky's primal or primal tales of savagery as it is known somewhere and they're not fucking kidding.

16:52So James do you think that you just were so surprised with the depth of emotion that you felt because you just always feel like animation can never reach that kind of level with you No, no because I mean look I've seen up, do you know what I mean I am aware that animation can be emotionally powerful. I think there's a disconnect. Wow. Steph, I've seen up. I've seen up. I have witnessed animation. Thanks. But what I'm saying is up reduces everyone to a quivering mass of tears. That's what it does. That's all it does. It's like the Terminator, but with grief. But I guess this is disarmament because the animation style, no, let me rephrase because I get in trouble for that.

17:35The art style of this is quite basic. It's quite simplistic. it's a minimalist art style uh and i wasn't really sure what it was going to be so i guess i just assumed it would be i would i guess i assumed it would be as basic in its emotional content as it was visually and i was surprised at the disconnect between the aesthetic and the content if that makes sense yeah i get i totally get what you mean i think sometimes the the basic nature of the art style whatever is actually makes you appreciate more what's on screen like less is more type thing i think again that exacting nature everything is chosen for a reason to be represented i think you're so right in saying the weight of it and it's it's it's really weird like you really wouldn't see something that has a dinosaur team up with a homo sapien in live action that you couldn't that would just look ridiculous except i want it yeah i know right it would actually be very good but it just wouldn't work in anything other than animation and so already you've got like a cool idea and a cool world but then on top of that you actually it's a it's a story about loss it's a story about grief it's a story about like i feel when i was watching it it was still felt relevant to me today because like family and life and the people you love you got to appreciate them so much you you know everything isn't here forever and yeah these Oh my god, you're like the best person ever.

19:01So true. And you've got these two incredibly lonely people that kind of dislike each other, but find each other and find joy again and find happiness and find faith in continuing living, find a reason to continue living. And yet I'm talking about a big grunting homo sapien and a Tyrannosaurus rex. Like, it's just so cool to tell a story in such a different way, you know? Effective, then. And I'm saying that was a win. I definitely approve of that one. Good. You gave me another task. Yeah. And it was Captain Laserhawk, colon, a Blood Dragon remix, which is a Netflix animated series based on the myriad video game properties from Ubisoft.

19:53And I would say, what does it lean most into? It leans most into kind of the Far Cry 3 Blood Dragon DLC, which I have actually played, which is kind of weird cyberpunk-y, futuristic, neon-soaked, 80s throwback romp thing. But, you know, you've got Assassin's Creed in here, you've got Rayman, like, you name it, if Ubisoft have done it, it's in here. Now, I hated this with the fire of a thousand burning suns. I thought it was smug, I thought it was irritating, I thought it was nonsensical, I thought the acting was disastrous. it had the worst examples of what i call animation voice where humans don't fucking talk like that and i just wanted to punch every frame of every second of the show um and also it doesn't not help by the fact that ubisoft is a deeply smug gaming company to begin with uh and all the games are very much the same um so i got yeah i got i was really cross with this one like i fundamentally hated it like you're very and what's the matter honestly you need to calm down it's an alternate history kind of i was going to say it's like sci-fi futuristic but it's actually set in 1992 but it's like an alternate history 1992 and it's like a dystopian technocracy and they're incorporated again it leans heavily into that kind of um traditional cyberpunk stuff which originates from the 80s right so this is this is an 80s view of the future if that makes sense so it's it is a sci-fi but it's a sci-fi as if it was created in the 80s so it looks forward to the 90s as this sort of cyber punky type extravaganza um and then there's a story but honestly you won't care because it's nonsense and i don't like it it's it's very right so fair play okay um it's very throws everything in and just tries everything the writer i can't remember the name of the writer he's done a bunch of live action stuff and it's very marmite in that most people hate marmite but some people don't mind if that's okay i love marmite really oh my god i will eat it out the jar like me too listen i'll have a teaspoon of marmite oh delicious is that not how you get yeast infections that depends on where you put it john okay yeah yes Okay I think It was I was really trying to play the game And that's video games The video games You know Yeah And I So I probably should have stopped at Primal Yeah Because now you're almost like There's a bitter taste in your mouth Because of this show

22:28John McEwan-Whyte: Yeah that was a tactical error on your part I think I would have liked Primal by the way Oh yeah I was about to say that I think you would What's the music like? It's dramatic It's a lot of drums Yeah It's very percussive Yeah now look uh as we said like blood dragon was a disaster but it was uh it was a cyberpunk thing and as someone who grew up reading the shadow run rpg spinoff novels as a teenager i do have a soft spot for that kind of cyberpunk oeuvre so i decided swap that i am to do a little bit of extra credit homework oh my god james yes so i decided that i would watch i'd go back to the source and i would just watch cyberpunk edge runners which is the spin-off of the cyberpunk 2077 game by cd project red which is a really good game which i have finished and the dlcs too um and this is fucking great like this is really really good in fact there's a second season of this it's an anthology show i think so it's totally separate to the first season but it's coming i want to say either this month or next month it's it's imminent um and this is everything the blood dragon isn't in the it's really compelling the visuals are very very striking there's so much emotional heart to this So it's about this kid and he's being bullied.

23:42And then eventually he ends up sort of going into the underworld of sort of edge runners and getting cybernetic implants. Because the interesting thing about this future is it's like if you do not have implants, you are kind of almost like disabled. Like it's like you're at a disadvantage to everyone else because everyone is implanted in one way or another. And it's this person trying to find themselves within this sort of like weird and wonderful cyberpunk universe. I think it really captures the feeling of the games. and the sort of real violence of the game. So this is brutally violent. In a way, that actually quite surprised me, but it's quite shocking.

24:16But I really like this. I thought the story was compelling. I thought the visuals were great. And for me, with animation, visuals are often a bit of a barrier. So yeah, I very much enjoyed Cyberpunk. This is what you should have picked instead of the other one. Okay, back off, my friend John, okay? For one.

24:34John McEwan-Whyte: Classic James. Yeah. Finding his own thing to do. This is your choice. I think there's nothing wrong with that. No, John, stop protecting him. He's an absolute monster. We have to stop. I mean, that's fair. So you've seen Cyberpunk, right? I haven't seen Cyberpunk. Ah. I know, right? Excuse me. But I think what we did was we gave you a gateway. John, if I could set you some homework to open your eyes to animation, I might suggest Cyberpunk, Edgerunners. I'm going to watch that now, for sure. It's because I haven't played the game. okay fair enough yeah i don't think that would be a barrier because i i don't think i mean certainly i had a familiarity with it and i enjoyed it because there was a familiarity and i enjoyed that world but you know and these kind of crazy kind of chrome head there's a psycho at the beginning killing all these police officers and it's quite i mean it is so full-on from a violence point of view but it's very in keeping with the tenor of of that story whether it be in the games or the rpg or the novels or whatnot um but look i didn't stop there i didn't stop there Do you know what?

25:37I'm going. I'm leaving. I'm leaving. Unbelievable. Because not only now have you not just watched the two things you want to watch, watch something else and watch something else. Obviously, you're speaking about it in the most eloquent way, like incredibly knowledgeable. And I just don't like you anymore. And that is entirely fair. Okay? Now you understand what it's like being at school with me. Right. So I decided to watch, based on the recommendation I've had from many listeners, and because I am a massive sci-fi head, it was suggested that i might like to give scavenger's reign a try oh yeah right so this is a very very well regarded science fiction animated show it's got some great voice talent there will be masaku's in it alias shawkats in it um i watched this i have no idea what is going on like yeah no idea what is going on he has a slightly minimalist very i would say mature art style to it and it has what i think is actually really impressive it weirdly addresses one of my key points with animation there is no quote-unquote animation voice in this at all everyone speaks as if they are acting a live action role and honestly it weirded me out a bit it's what i've asked for but it actually i noticed how strange it felt to have people not putting on kind of animated performances be careful what you wish for james the verisimilitude like seemed it seemed slightly unsettling but then the actual storyline is so fucking surreal so it's basically it's the survivors of this ship the demeter 227 it's stranded on this alien planet which has got weird animals and plants and dangers and they're like inflating things and they're suffocating and they put squid on their face as a mask and i was just like i don't know what's happening i don't know who you are i don't know what this is about and you don't seem in a hurry to tell me.

27:29Although I will say, the people who recommended this to me pretty much said, someone said on, I think it was on the subreddit, saying, oh, James needs to watch Scavenger's Reign, and someone else just went, lols, the vision of him just jumping into Scavenger's Reign and expecting to understand it. So I'm assuming it's not just that I'm an idiot. I watched Scavenger's Reign, and I didn't get to the end of the first series. It's, I feel like it's very sophisticated, probably too sophisticated for me. Like, I'm, i think it's not bluey it's not bluey that's probably my level of sophistication probably sometimes a bit too much um but i think with scavenger's reign it's kind of like we're creating art we're not creating entertainment which is probably a terrible thing to say but i kind of like the animation that is a bit more accessible that i can kind of share with everyone it's not hugely accessible yeah it's very arty it's very and it's i think they got really obsessed with building a whole world that we would not it's like a more realistic different planet the floor and the fauna are like not something you would imagine as you say the the inflating thing the thing they were in the the face it's very different it's very patient uh it takes its time and i just it took too much time for me it's it's hardcore i feel like it's one this is like imagine that we're doing this and we're at school i feel like i've gone straight from like year three and someone gave me a book aimed at like year 13.

28:59Do you know what? It feels like I've skipped too many rungs on my animation journey to seize onto this. This feels like hardcore extra credit degree level stuff. It's like, what's that film with, is it Chinatown? The one with, what's his name? Jack Nicholson. That's really classy. Okay. But if someone's like, what's your favorite movie? You want to say that. And you probably say that to try and be cool. But really it's probably just Avengers Endgame or something like that. It's the Citizen Kane thing. It's like, everyone goes, yeah, I love Citizen Kane. Like, do you? Do you really?

29:33John McEwan-Whyte: Tell me about it. That's true. That is true for James. But let me just point out, Chinatown is a masterpiece. Chinatown is a masterpiece. It is. You know when people go on about how Woody Allen is their favourite director and you're like, you've never watched a Woody Allen film, have you? You go around, you say he's your favourite director. Unless you're Boyd. Unless you're Boyd. That example, I don't think many people are volunteering their love for Woody Allen. Boyd has to say it very quietly. I was being very specific about Boyd there, by the way. Yeah, no, I think Scavenger's Reign is like a bit too cool for school.

30:04And I'm like, I don't really want to spend my time watching that because it's a little bit. It's probably beautiful. It's probably well written. It's very slow. As I said, it's very patient. It probably unravels a beautiful story. But I'm like, I'd rather watch a Tyrannosaurus Rex and a caveman become friends. That is fair. I really want you to watch The Good Dinosaur, which is a dinosaur. and a human becoming friends because that is beautiful and that has emotional depth, James. The Good Dinosaur, I don't know if you know this, Steph, The Good Dinosaur is a prequel to Primal. Shut up. Yeah. It is.

30:37It's nuts. You wouldn't expect it. That is nuts. Watch Good Dinosaur and then watch Primal. Oh, that's wild. Just, you know, The Good Dinosaur is not great. So sorry. What? So sorry. It's fine. The Good Dinosaur is amazing. Oh my God. you're going to try and tell me the land before time is terrible now oh no the time is okay you make no sense ducky is my hero

31:06anyway now john look yeah i didn't stop there either so my god i decided i decided that based on your recommendation uh and because i loved uh i loved arcane and you thought that i should i should i should i should tee this up as probably the closest thing i could get to arcane which was maybe an unrealistic goal for animation to go back to blue eye samurai which i had sort of like watched bits of at the very beginning but not really sort of uh you know pressed on with and this i think was my level i think when i found this i was like this this is the sweet spot we've gone we're in the goldilocks zone here we've had maybe too hot in in scavengers rain maybe primal might be a little bit too cold and then the lack of sort of narrative maybe wasn't it blue eye samurai though hits the sweet spot because a lot of the characters do not put on quote-unquote animation voice or at least if they do it's very very mild yes the comedy sidekick guy is the lone exception and he is over the top and i i have yet to be able to tolerate him like he's quite sweet and nice and i get that but i but he's he's too over the top and unrealistic and he takes me out of it but him aside everyone else is largely i would say playing it sort of dramatically rather than enhanced which i quite like and it has an earthy kind of grounded quality to it the animation is beautifully like it's buttery smooth it's so silky it's absolutely stunning it's not arcane level but it is it is quite exceptional and actually one of my big barriers as you know is is is i find sort of janky visuals pull me out the story i thought the visuals in this were were genuinely stunning and the amount of emotion that they managed to convey on the characters faces is is quite extraordinary and also it's in this incredible story of of this sort of mixed race essentially female samurai and how she's on a rip-roaring rampage of revenge to kill these sort of i think it's four or five uh westerners in edo period japan when there are no westerners allowed there one of them is her father and she wants to kill him and she is a little bit handy with the old sword um the action sequences in this are extraordinary there's a bit in the first episode where she has a fight with a bunch of guys in the dojo and it uses slow motion it uses the fact that But it has this incredibly silky animation stuff.

33:18Do you know what? I'm going to use a weird analogy, which may fall a little bit flat on you, John, because you're young. But there was a game that came out in the, I want to say 90s, might have been the 80s, let's say 90s, called Prince of Persia. The very first Prince of Persia. Oh, everyone knows Prince of Persia. Yeah, Prince of Persia. Jake Gyllenhaal. Yes, indeed. But the game, and other games like it, like Another World, used incredibly fluid, detailed animation. when we were so used to seeing sort of pixel animation in games where it was like you know like mario where he's got three frames as he moves whereas the prince of purge has maybe 50 frames when he takes a step and this felt like that to me like every single second there's no jankiness there's no jumping the animation is so fluid and it works so well for these sort of woosha sequences especially when she's playing with people like she's dodging she's sort of slipping past them she's pushing them over and it's like you're watching animation you're also watching like the best martial arts sequence you've ever seen is it a bit like ray and the last dragon but more advanced it's more adult and and more focused on like less myth and fantasy even though there's a little bit tied into but it's kind of realistic and towards the culture of japan at that time okay um it's uh so interestingly right uh the director jane woo i think is her name um She came on from the Marvel Cinematica Universe as one of their stunt directors.

34:44And she came in and she basically reinvented rotoscoping, but made it more expensive. And that's why the fight scenes are so interesting. They have so much weight to them. They look like ballet. It's beautiful. The actors aren't animation actors. So that's, I think, why you avoid that animation voice. I think there's a really, really clear, just as well written from beginning to end. It's like drive from the start to the end. You know that show that's deaf, like the Catherine Zeta-Jones one about the Kill Jackie, right? I feel like if Kill Jackie was good and said in Ido period, that's what it would be.

35:20I see your face there. You're upsetting me by comparing this show to Kill Jackie. So in Kill Jackie, you're like, oh, you find out who the baddies are at the end. You're like, you've got clear different flavors in Blue Eye Samurai of villains. You know, you've got the riders on the horses. you've got the lighter ones you've got um the way they fight is different and at the core of it is a really interesting story that jives you from beginning to end but it's relevant to this main character's culture this main character's identity it's explaining one kind of core that the whole story is built about which is kind of belonging and where she comes from you know who the main villain is you know who voices the main villain uh i i have a i have you're not allowed to look it up well i i do know that george takai is in the show so i'm assuming it's no george takai is just a side character the main villain's voiced by kenneth branna oh is he yeah right okay fine because like randall parker's in this masioka's in this it's got loads of like great people in this yeah and it's branna yeah it's really really good and season two is coming out very very soon it's probably one of my favorite animated shows ever made it's this it's a genre that netflix They have like four genres that they refer to behind the scenes.

36:37And this is called, I think it's called genre spectacle. So it's basically like they see that less as a TV show and more as a film in eight parts. But we'll have different series and stuff like that. It's beautiful. And honestly, Netflix is one of the only people that can spend this amount of money on an animated show. And it's also, it's educating you about a time and a culture the way Shogun did. That is otherworldly. and relevant today because of their inward-facing nature, but also understandably fear of... Yeah, it's beautiful. You've done very well, James. I think you'd like it, Steph. I think I would like it.

37:19Do you know what, James? I am so... I hate myself. I'm so impressed with you. But do you know what would really, really top it off? If you told me now that you'd watched one episode of Bluey, I've been asking you for about three months. I'm so sorry. I did all that extra credit I didn't even spare five minutes to watch one episode of Bluey and you could have watched a mini-sode I could have done I should have done I do feel quite remiss that I didn't also tack that on I feel like I should definitely have done that it will make you cry though it will I'm going to give you an episode of Bluey that I really want you to watch James okay and then he can be our first guest on our animation podcast when we do so yeah so John and I are going to do an animation special when the Bluey movie comes out exclusive yeah we'll go to a screening we'll get Bluey movie and then we'll do like a whole thing about Bluey and how amazing it is.

38:04Okay, brilliant. Do you think if we speak about Bluey enough, they'll send us stuff that we can give to our kids? 100%. And also I think we need to get Patrick Bramall back. I was about to say, they sent us Bluey's uncle. I mean, that's something. Yeah, rad. That is good. Yeah, and we will get him back on and see who else we can get on from Bluey. Bluey, Bluey, Bluey, Bluey, Bluey. Yes. That'll pick up. Yeah, definitely. Well, I think you've done very well. You get an A+. Plus, maybe. Oh, God. Sickening. I think we may have established a slight problem Is that my elitism is so much That I can only watch animations that cost an ungodly Amount of money That seems to be where my tastes lie But you know look how much Game of Thrones costs I mean I guess that's very different I think Blue Eye Samurai Kind of broke into the mainstream a little bit more The more mainstream stuff we can get You know Blue Eye Samurai Isn't that far off Most prestige TV shows and yeah it's I think we're slowly getting to a world where animation is becoming more common to watch which again I think is weird because everyone used to watch Simpsons but that's for some reason in the category all of its own I think we still haven't had that breakout hit that is kind of basically I test it on my wife in that if I show her like the trailer and she says yes, then I think that's our breakout hit because usually it takes a lot to convince her to watch it.

39:35It's just what most large audiences want to watch. We've got to find the Mrs. Brown's voice of animation. Oh, we really don't. No, we do. It's really, really, totally important. We need to find the Game of Thrones of animation. I think Bluey is the closest we've got because now adults do watch Bluey. With their kids. No sometimes adults watch it on their own

40:00John McEwan-Whyte: Louis is a phenomenon Louis has become a phenomenon It has become a phenomenon And you know why Louis was successful I think because they treated kids Like humans They didn't treat them like little tiny things I think they treated them with respect Well I'm very impressed Very impressed By everyone And did Kay watch her stuff?

40:28I think it's safe to say no. I'm going to ask her. I'll ask her to report back. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I've got animation news, James. Oh, you do? Hit me with it. Okay. So, first of all, the big news. James Dwyer has announced a Pilot TV podcast every week dedicated to animation. Oh, wow. Fantastic. Which is really interesting. I hadn't heard that. No, Boyd, the new Doctor Who animated show has been announced. it is for kids but it does look pretty cool it's called Doctor Who TARDIS crew

41:03John McEwan-Whyte: does it look pretty cool? oh boy you're not really a true fan it's like you're not a true fan of Woody Allen as well I love the way you keep I wasn't expecting Woody Allen and Mrs Brown's boys to be the representatives yeah but none of that image they put out of that show has caused quite a lot of controversy shall we say in the Doctor Who community yeah it looks because it looks i'm sure it's not but it looks a bit it looks a bit ai people are saying it looks it doesn't look ai everything looks ai i know i'm not saying that's accurate or fair but i can tell i feel it definitely isn't blues you like very much care about their animation they're the people that made it yeah um the other thing i'd probably say is marvel animation are doing a bunch of stuff so they had marvel zombies and they've got two new uh three more two-part specials uh one called marvel zombies winter soldier which is meant to be coming out halloween 2027 marvel zombies fist of conchu which is halloween 2028 and marvel zombies the last guardian for halloween 2029 obviously marvel zombies has done very well for the marvel cinematic universe and animation kind of world because they're fancy and they cost money but they obviously care enough that they've literally announced one for the next three years X-Men 97 is getting a third season and they also said something about the friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man season 2 is coming out on January 13th I think that's all that matters really Can I ask you a question John have you ever watched Descendants?

42:36The one with George Pugh? No no no Because that's really interesting in that Descendants they had three Descendants of the original films and then now they've got they have two more then they had rise of red and they've had the latest one which is a queen of hearts one uh which is a wonderland one but they did yeah rita or is in the early ones are really good but the reason i mention it is because what i think they did was really interesting with descendants because then they had an offshoot which was um an animation which was uh descendants wicked world and then they also did a stop motion animation oh which was really amazing and i wanted to know if you'd seen that but if you haven't then you should watch it because they did it was kind of a halloween in the wicked woods uh stop motion animation i thought god that's really interesting to show this kind of in three different ways they're not the same story but they're the same characters um and yeah it's great i'm now just trying to get points over james yeah you're now a plus plus stranger things did it was stranger things 85 yes people are starting to realize that if you make an animated show the big name cast that everyone knows that's really expensive to get in the same room don't have to be in the same room anymore exactly record it virtually yeah things 85 i don't think did that well but it's really cool i i rate it but i think you're going to see a lot more animated spin-offs i'm surprised there isn't a game of thrones animated thing announced that is really true that's so true yeah i'm sure there will be a game of thrones animated spin-off even lord the rings had that animated charge of the roherium and whatever it was called which i it wasn't great but i i quite liked um but yeah i think over the next few years especially with kind of basically if you use ai in the right way that isn't just to paint pictures which is absolute crap but i think what people are seeing especially in the animation industry it's is it's just making productions more affordable and with animation it's always just like anything it's so difficult to raise funds so if you're able to raise 50 of a project with the technology that's out nowadays you might still be able to make it and still pay like everyone the right amount and stuff like that um and i think i think like i can get into it but there's definitely i think i mentioned it last time when it comes to technology that's here it's like you can use the technology to make the colors brighter as opposed to drawing the picture and i think that that's bringing costs down which is going to mean more people with very good ideas don't have to you know either wait 10 years to raise the money for it or have you know or it just doesn't get made you know it's like um it's like k-pop demon hunters that was 10 years in the making yeah wasn't it and look at the massive global success that was but that was an idea from 10 years ago that everyone thinks that just came out of nowhere but it didn't it was a film that um sony sold to netflix because they didn't believe in it yeah because at the end of the day animation still like everything you have to raise money for it and there's still a lot of people that look at stuff and be like, no, that won't be successful.

45:35And they'll invest in like, you know, Coco Melon the movie. Yeah. Or, so I think slowly technology's changing. I feel it's a very positive time to be in animation. I think even the people that are worried about kind of losing out on the jobs and stuff like that, I think all that's going to happen is all those people that are worried about losing the jobs in principal animation, so kind of the middle that's after pre and before post, all that's going to happen is they're all going to shift to pre and post. It's going to be, we're going to have a lot more character designers. We're going to have a lot more environmental designers, a lot more storyboard artists.

46:10Storyboards are kind of every scene. I was speaking to my friend who also runs an animation studio. And I think in the next few years, what you're going to see is storyboards. The images are actually drawn for every second because you can spend more money on that front. And things are going to look beautiful. And yeah, I think I'm excited about the future of animation. And I think what you guys are doing is a service to the world of animation. And I think it will only grow and hopefully break a bit more into the mainstream. Well, we had a few people who wrote in when we announced this with suggestions for things.

46:47So I'm going to read out a few of the listener questions about this and things that people have recommended. So Ellen here has recommended Hedgehog in the Fog by Yuri Norstein. and it's about a hedgehog that gets lost in the fog and by all accounts it is absolutely delightful and lovely and life-affirming and wonderful and it strikes me Steph as something that you would very much enjoy it is available on YouTube Ellen says I honestly don't know what you're going to think of it but it's an important piece in the history of animation so worth seeing for educational purposes even if it doesn't melt your hearts to the same extent it does mine if you really hate it Brackets James please don't talk about it on the podcast my heart couldn't take it.

47:27Oh, don't worry. I'm going to watch it and I definitely won't hate it. I can tell by the title. John, is that one you know? Hedgehog in the Fog? I haven't heard that. A hedgehog in the fog sounds like a beautiful image in my head. It does. It sounds like what you would call a lovely work of art. This one comes from Paul. Paul says, I myself work in the UK animation industry. I can't tell you how many times while listening to the podcast on my walk to work I've been stopped in the street by people asking me why I'm crying. I have to explain to them that pilot TV has just been disparaging my entire career choice and james has yet again described a highly sophisticated piece of animation art as a cartoon luckily i predominantly work in children's animation okay yes cartoons so i don't ever need to worry about you reviewing any of the shows i work on but please do think of us as we toil away at our desks obsessing over the precise location of every pixel in a frame while wondering if ai is going to replace us i will be very interested to hear what animation recommendations the other listeners will suggest for your viewing pleasure, perhaps the box set of Bod, or the hilarious hijinks of those bunnies in Watership Down.

48:30AI won't replace you, Paul. You matter. Too much. Oh, it won't, yeah. And here comes Bod. Yes, I have seen Bod. So, other recommendations. Martin suggested series 3-7 of The Clone Wars, Star Wars The Clone Wars. Not the Genndy Tartakovsky one uh but the dave filoni one obviously because it's serious three to seven he says series one to two are very skippable so there we go but apparently the rest is gold so that's an option uh let's see what we have here now this is a very long one jim says love the show as always uh sorry this message is so long this is not an extensive list for your animation education but a few thoughts are added here too the way you talk about animation feels very similar to the one inch barrier which is why it can be frustrating to hear you talk about it the criticisms often have little to do with the story quality or character arcs but just the inability to get past the format and the more fantastical elements animation allows while the instant dismissal of something you haven't watched is frustrating i do understand the reluctance anything can happen in animation and they often break their own rules of reality and have heightened over dramatic voices to compensate for the lack of detail and facial expressions to attract younger audiences or to make something more visually spectacular even in more grounded shows people would change color when angry or float in the air when mad and apparently major injuries or emotional moments are often quickly forgotten to serve the next joke this leaves a sense of frivolity and inconstancy which can be hard to engage with or take seriously as a form of storytelling like a video game musical or theater show it often requires a different set of expectations and suspending your disbelief differently to a film or tv show which typically strive to create something that seems real there are many fantastic series which i don't think will overcome this so i won't add in the classics like Batman the animated series the lewd humour of Archer the satire of South Park or the fun dialogue of Futurama Amon has tried already a lot of eastern animation series are also quite extreme and lack any relatable characters or subtlety so I don't think much of that will win you over either my suggestions are the following and we begin with yes Steph Bluey which is undoubtedly fantastic will often catch you off guard when it explores more heartfelt topics while this suggestion may sound like a joke I suggest watching this first as if anything can soften your cynical hearts to animation it will be bluey there we go blue eye samurai is also on the list i think again because i liked arcane this seems like an obvious next start and i'm very pleased to say that that was a hit most things by genji tartakovsky obviously we've just had one in primal but jim goes on to say staying on the samurai theme samurai jack is a classic that's a good one to look at uh genji's clone war series which we mentioned earlier which i have referred to on this podcast or indeed the empire podcast as the blur blur but the lesser of the better and he recommends primal as well so john i feel like you and he are on the same wavelength which is good um daria he says appealing to james's grunge days this shares many similarities to king of the hill and bojack horseman and exploring it's often heavy and depressing topics while disguised as something more comedic the misery chick season one episode 13 and boxing daria season five episode 13 are great sad episodes there are many more light-hearted and satirical ones to pick from but i need to balance out the bluey uh there we go so some suggest that have you seen daria do we know what this is daria i do you watch daria yeah it is a classic um yeah that is great do you have you drew have you watched you must have watched giant jack john have you watched that oh it's a it's a netflix kids animation but it's also incredibly heartfelt and it is really really it's about this it's about a huge um dustbin van and it's and it's and it's really and the animation in that is incredibly beautiful please watch that i watched that for sure that looks beautiful it is really nice who was the name of that person that just gave that big that was jim jim said everything i could have said like 10 times better i feel you could just replace the whole podcast with just that yeah and i think i think james you actually did you did what he asked you to do james you you oversaw the one inch barrier what should we call this the i don't know what sort of barrier is it it's the it's the brushstroke barrier perhaps yeah the brushstroke barrier um the uh i think yeah you did that in self you you you you watch different genres you found what you like you didn't see it as something to stop you and stephanie you're already doing this for years you're you're you know when like you have one kid that's always good and the other kid that's bad right does something good so you really have to reward the kid that did something good and then the kid that's always good is always like well what's the point in being good yeah exactly now i'm gonna hit out yeah yeah she's lashing out at us for anyone who doesn't know and i'm sure they do the one inch barrier this was something that bong june ho i think uh coined and he's talking about subtitles subtitles are the one inch barrier that people struggle to access subtitle content because they don't like to read yes i've told you this before what i call uh reading shows i can't i don't like watching shows i have to read yeah it's very difficult books yes it's hard but i'm like this i i i because obviously younger viewers now you know let's be honest kind of millennials but gen z and below always have subtitles on on their tv shows and i cannot watch anything with subtitles on because it just ruins it for me but did i i've told you this i'm sure i've told you this before on the bbc iplayer everything defaults on the children's channel to have subtitles because they believe that it helps children to learn to read yeah i agree that's good we watch stuff for subtitles yeah yeah i think it's good it takes me out of it again it's a barrier to entry if it's in another language it's absolutely fine i've got no problem with it.

54:03But if it's in English, fuck off with the subtitles. Oh, it's good of you. It's a good of you if it's in another language, just so you can understand it. Thank you. You're fantastic. Alright, couple more we can run through here. So, what have we got? So, Cameron has suggested in addition to his Robot Chicken, Bob's Burgers, and indeed, the number one, Cameron says, is Looney Tunes. There are not enough words to describe the importance of this show and the constant relevance and influence it still has, and it still makes me laugh out loud 50 years later. Bob's Burgers is funny. Bob's Burgers is funny.

54:31Bob's Burgers is good. Looney Tunes is good. Did anyone watch Coyote vs. Acme? Yeah, I watched it the other day. That's good. It was very good. I think, yeah, Looney Tunes is very good. I mean, obviously nothing compares to Space Jam 2. I was just about to say about Space Jam, actually. No, Space Jam 2. Space Jam 2, of course. Why not Space Jam? Do you not think Space Jam? Space Jam 2 is terrible, terrible. Space Jam 1 is a piece of art. That's what I was going to say. Space Jam 1 was just revolutionary. Oh, my gosh. It was amazing. It was so good. I remember always drinking my flasks and telling myself that it's miracle juice and that would get me ready for I don't know.

55:08There you go honey. Ross sent in a very very cogent argument for all things Genndy Tartakovsky which we've kind of covered so thank you for that Ross. Venus from Wisconsin said I recommend giving the legend of Vox Machina and the Mighty Nein a try. Both on Prime both brilliant. Sorry sorry hold on a minute. Venus from Wisconsin what a name amazing I mean I hope she just introduces herself like that yeah do you think Venus is such a cool name would you call someone Venny if they were called Venus no V just call them V V like the character from Cyberpunk see it's all full circle Venus hi Venus this is actually a very good suggestion because The Legend of Vox Machina is of course critical role isn't it this is the this is the D &D group and this was their adventures when they did their D &D stories, they've now turned it into an animated series and their characters are characters in the show.

56:02And it's very good. Right. And as I've heard, and because I've now sort of taken my first steps into the world of D &D via the Empire D &D group, this is actually something that I'm genuinely interested in. So I actually, The Legend of Vox Machina is on my sofa list. Tell everyone your name. James in that Dungeons & Dragons. Sir John de Luthor. And he is a paladin. A slightly chaotic, overly violent paladin. Because he once spoke to the creator of Luthor and you told him that luther is mixed with something i told someone remembers this stuff i told him that i thought i said to him i don't know if you play dnd i said but i think luther is chaotic good and you went oh my god he's a chaotic good paladin and obviously paladins and dnd are always like lawful they can be lawful evil but they lawful good generally and so my paladin in dnd is chaotic good and he is the most chaotic character you could possibly imagine and he's extremely violent slightly psychotic and a bit homicidal oh my god the geek siren is so deafening it's just yeah out there is it we hope you've enjoyed uh james on animation for the last hour and a half wow fine boy he's bored so we're gonna have to wrap this up soon a few other suggestions i'm just gonna run through the people sending castlevania was one that came up archer is another one that has been suggested quite a few times cool animation that yeah so i have heard the apothecary diaries was sent in here by sarah i've never heard of that no now they're right i'll have to look into that pantheon have you watched in your dreams on netflix what's that one it's where the kids it's where the kids get like it literally goes into their dreams and they're in their bed and then it's really good that sounds a bit like freddy kruger no it's beautiful oh the film yeah the film oh yeah oh that's cool alright I'm gonna end the post bag here with a message from Neil who has recommendations for each of us following on from the animation education I have a few more recommendations for the team James Castlevania on Netflix it is the most James show ever after finishing the Empire of the Vampire books I craved more bloodsuckers and I thought I'd give this show a go and my god it is fantastic vampires are actually scary again with a nuanced take on dracula and game of thrones style political machinations behind the scenes also a ridiculously talented voice cast with baltar himself james callis richard armitage jessica brown finley theo james bosh titus welliver and the late great lance reddick best of all it didn't get cancelled and you have 32 episodes over four seasons that tell a complete story from start to finish boid and also james pantheon on netflix this is proper hard sci-fi and existential angst in an adult animated show that doesn't use animation for fart jokes and swearing but the closest live action example i can find is something like devs there's ghosts in the machine evil corporations all that good stuff only two seasons before it was cancelled thanks to amc cutting costs but it still works as a complete two-season arc again fabulous voice cast with katie chang paul dano scoop mcnery william hurt and rosemary dewitt for Steph The Great North on Disney Plus from the makers of Bob's Burgers comes this delightful cosy family sitcom set in Alaska headlined by Nick Offerman basically playing Nick Offerman as he raises his four kids in Alaska it's charming and heartwarming with occasional songs and yes the Alanis Morissette does appear as a spirit in the sky who talks to daughter Judy other voice actors of note are Jenny Slate so not for Boyd Will Forte Jane Lynch and Chelsea Peretti where most adult animated sitcoms seem to push good taste.

59:35The Great North is family first cosy show that has become one of my comfort watches. Oh my God. Well, you know, my favourite thing is Nick Hoffman being Nick Hoffman. So, yes, I will be watching that. That sounds perfect for me. Thank you very much. Great North is really good. It didn't do well. It like is really good, but it didn't do well audience wise. I don't know how long it's going to last. You know why? Because of people like James. Yeah, people like James. I'm really, really lashing out at you, James, because I'm so jealous about how well you've done. Not anymore. Because yeah, well, yeah.

1:00:02that person was also much better recommendation than I did you should definitely just get the post back instead of me stop doing yourself down don't do that I appreciate you

1:00:11John McEwan-Whyte: I mean you made a mistake giving James A plus but apart from that it's been fun I gave him an A plus plus point don't do me down don't do me dirty but okay that is it for our sort of rejoinder I guess our response to animation education and I think we've all learned a great deal but we have more to learn there will be more of this in future John you will return to continue to educate us in the animated arts and to get us past the brush stroke barrier that we've all been struggling with but for everyone enjoyed it do continue to subscribe to Pilot Plus please because you know we need the money and we will speak to you soon Pilot's out

From the publisher

It’s been a few weeks since our animation consultant John McEwan-Whyte came on the show and set everyone homework to try and crack our way into the wonderful medium of animated television. Well, we’re happy to report that the homework is now complete and we’re delighted to bring you Animation Education Part 2! John returns to shepherd us thorough the animated wilderness, assessing our various responses to the animations in question and fielding some of your suggestions as well.

More from Pilot TV+

All episodes