1. Podcasts
  2. Pilot TV+
  3. Celebrity Traitors Spoiler Special
Pilot TV+

2 Nov 2026 · 49m · 27 chapters

Episode artwork

Celebrity Traitors Spoiler Special

In short

A spoiler-heavy discussion of Celebrity Traitors (series 2) focused on whether the finale lived up to expectations, standout “traitor” moments, and why the season felt different from the first celebrity series.

Guests

Boyd Hilton (host). Steph Sealand (co-host; says she became obsessed quickly after starting the show). John McKeon White (animation correspondent; says the spoiler special idea was to react immediately like other podcasts, but they let it “steep”).

Key claims

Series 2 felt more immersive and “taxing” than series 1; it had more twists and banishment moments. Richard E. Grant’s early “I’m a traitor” set the tone. James Acaster’s refusal to be a traitor (and later confession in the round table) is framed as a major ripple and a mismatch with the game’s lying premise. Claudia Winkleman is praised as elevating tension.

Notable examples

Richard E. Grant’s first-episode reveal; James Acaster’s round-table bombshell; “killing in plain sight” with the three traitors; finale voting twist (Kenny not voting); Leanne Pinnock jumping out of a plane while pregnant; Bash convincing Romesh to change course; helicopter moment for Bash/Romesh.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:46

Reflections on Podcast Culture

Discussion on the current podcast landscape and viewer reactions to Traitors.

“And I was like, oh, I can literally never listen to this podcast because I don't know what you're talking about.”
2:30

Initial Impressions of Celebrity Traitors

Hosts share their feelings about the current season and its comparison to the previous one.

4:42

Character Analysis and Key Moments

In-depth discussion on standout contestants and pivotal moments in the show.

“Who was in the end with him when he revealed he was a traitor?”
7:13

James Acaster's Impact on the Game

Exploration of James Acaster's unique position and impact during the season.

“Grant point because I think what the Richard E.”
9:47

Female Contestants and Representation

Hosts discuss the contributions and performances of female contestants in the series.

“And that was almost like so, almost as mind-blowing for me as a drummer, because it kind of, it blows apart the kind of whole, the whole creation of the show, if you like.”
12:19

Audience Reactions and Critiques

Discussion on audience reactions to various contestants and critiques of gameplay.

14:00

Analyzing James Acaster's Game Play

Discussion about James Acaster's approach to the game and his emotional struggles.

15:06

Lying in Games vs. Real Life

Exploration of the difference between lying in the game versus in real life.

16:06

Game Mechanics and Player Reactions

Discussion on how players react to game mechanics and the importance of understanding the rules.

“Okay, you touch someone, they join you in trying to chase people and touch other people, okay?”
18:11

Twists and Turns in the Finale

Analysis of the unexpected moments and twists in the finale of the show.

“And in fact, the finale was full of twists and turns.”
Show all 27 chapters
19:32

Celebrity Performances and Reactions

Insights into various celebrity performances and their reactions throughout the series.

“And then you get to the twist of Kenny not voting, you know, voting out.”
21:20

Competitive Spirit and Celebrity Dynamics

Discussion on the competitive nature of the game and its effects on the celebrities involved.

“And I think if there was sports people in the cast, I think they would have been like, guys, it's a game.”
23:26

Behind the Scenes and Emotional Moments

Exploration of behind-the-scenes dynamics and emotional moments from the show.

25:38

Viewer Engagement and Mission Highlights

Discussion on viewer engagement with missions and the highlights of various challenges.

“David Baddiel was saying he's fast forwards through the missions.”
27:30

Mythology of the Traitors Game

Discussion on the inconsistent mythology of the game and its implications.

28:00

The Mythology of Traitors

Exploring the inconsistent lore and design choices of the show.

29:32

The Joy of Buffet Food

Discussing the enjoyment of watching contestants eat buffet-style meals.

“I just love seeing what they're going to put on their plate.”
30:39

Celebrity Banishment and Hotel Life

Speculating on the experiences of banished contestants post-elimination.

31:35

The Cast and Their Dynamics

Analyzing the interactions and personalities of key cast members.

“That Bash and Rom had had a dinner together before it was revealed that they'd won?”
35:09

Game Strategies and Key Moments

Examining crucial strategies and surprising moments in the game.

“I remember at the time people were saying, oh, it's too easy for them to carry out that task.”
38:48

The Rising Stars

Predicting which contestants will gain fame post-show.

“Again, another moment that people were really not acknowledging was brilliant TV.”
41:00

Final Thoughts on Contestants

Reflecting on standout contestants and their performances.

“I think it'll boost Love Island, I have to say.”
42:00

Joanne McNally and Uncloaked Insights

Discussion on Joanne McNally's performance and highlights from the show Uncloaked.

“I don't think I did I feel like you're not going to have an affair with Hannah Fry I think it's okay Don't worry I met folks here once Remember?”
42:35

Strategies and Observations in Traitors

Insights on strategies players could use in the game Traitors, including breakfast routines.

“and she said, we were building a life together.”
43:31

Friendships and Moments in the Castle

Exploration of friendships formed in the castle and memorable moments among contestants.

44:26

Speculations for Next Season's Cast

Discussion on potential celebrities for the next season of Traitors, including wishes and rumors.

“Leanne basically she made up the big you know they had the thing they said it was going to be called they were going to be called Big Mix and she sent her a record and she made an album cover for it.”
46:00

Fan Dream Cast for Traitors

A fun conversation about which celebrities the hosts would love to see on the show.

A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Pilot TV+, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:08John McEwan-Whyte: So, this is our Traitors Chat. I'm Boyd Hilton. Steph Sealand's here with us. I'm here. Having flown back from her holiday, Friday, just in time to watch the finale. Yeah, flown back from my living room to my kitchen. Flown back from your kitchen to the room and back again. and we're joined by the man the legend our animation correspondent yeah john john mckeon white thanks give him his full name yeah animator extraordinaire and fan of the traitors who's actually whose idea this spoiler special uh was other podcasts you know do it live straight after the show went out you know and give their immediate reaction we've let it we've let it kind of steep like a nice cup of tea we've given ourselves the whole weekend to think about the ramifications of the finale you can't rush into this you'll think about it and think about it we have had but also can I just say other podcasts which I don't actually listen to I don't listen to the other podcasts but I caught a clip of a moment from this podcast and someone on the podcast said the thing about this season of traitors is there haven't been any water cooler moments.

1:26And I was like, oh, I can literally never listen to this podcast because I don't know what you're talking about.

1:31John McEwan-Whyte: Yeah, I think I know the one you mean, yeah. People have gone nuts, like, in their negativity. It's a bit weird. It is a bit weird. It is a bit weird, isn't it? But also, on the flip side, you've had people congregating in pubs to watch the final of this as if it was the World Cup. so it's like there's no gray areas did you did you see the last season because my wife and i we must have we had to catch up but in the last season i think they did it again bbc had their own rolling news channel yeah just for the lead up yeah yeah yeah it was the strangest thing i've ever seen so let's just overall to start with what are your feelings about this is it did it live up the first celebrity series was such a phenomenon wasn't it I think that people were surprised by just the level of celebrity they booked you know Celia Imri breaking wind and there was so many in quotes iconic moments of it that it's hard to live up to that in series 2 what do you think Steph do you think it did live up to what's your thinking about the series as a whole the difference being right okay with me in this is that I if you remember oh yeah you watched series one no no not only if i never watched didn't watch series one i've never watched traitors ever i've never watched any of the series right okay so i am literally a total traitors virgin but i promised that i was going to watch this series of celebrity traitors and in the back of my eyes thinking everyone's so obsessed with it like what is it about it and i think we said on the podcast i was like i mean i must have been it must have been three minutes in when i text boyd and k and i said i am obsessed with this show and it hooked me immediately and then i i just i've absolutely loved it now i'm not a massive i'm not a reality tv massive reality tv um it's it's not really my bag i'd rather watch i'd rather watch something else but this captured your mic just moving it closer sorry i mean sorry he'd be going mad He'd be going mad He'd literally Yeah anyway Say that again Steph I think is what we have to do So this This just captured It absolutely It drew me in Yes I was completely invested From like From day one I love everyone In it I was like Oh my god This is just such It felt so immersive Like in my living room Being like I can't stop Watching this show And I was thinking about it When it wasn't on And talking about it I became a true Traitors Like Like absolute obsessive and then people kept saying to me oh my god if you love this you need to go back and watch series one of celebrity traders and then one of my lovely insta pilots richard was like listen if you love this you need to go and watch the real like the actual proper traders because it's unreal um but yeah i'm so in so whilst i don't have anything to compare it to all i can say is this has been one of my most enjoyable tv experiences this year i've thoroughly enjoyed it i think boyd i'm just going to say i think we called it from the beginning we said romesh was going to win did we oh i think we did i think we both said we thought romesh was going to win yeah and he was just an absolute joy like all of them though so my my overarching view is before we get into the ditty gritty what a fucking show claudia's just deserves all the applaud that she gets and more she is an absolute sensation and everyone in it was brilliant and it was just so nice to have some like amazing feel-good brilliant television uh with without that level of toxicity and even when they did feel that like toxicity it was game playing so it doesn't matter what's interesting is there's a couple of interesting things there for me one is that i think if you are new to it this and you haven't and you're constantly banging on about comparing it to the first celebrity tracer series right which had alan carr and the winning moment it had it had a lot of those moments it's a different it was a very different kind of series this one oh was it was he a traitor yeah yeah and he won and he won and he was a traitor and he flew under the radar to use the lingo of the show you know flew under the radar he would say the things that were borderline you know like kind of mistakes and borderline almost admitting that he was a traitor but managed always with his charm and and the fact that people loved him so much okay he got away with it and eventually won.

5:56So who was in the final with him? Who was in the end with him when he revealed he was a traitor?

6:01John McEwan-Whyte: Alan Carr and... David Dodd-Isoga, I think, was he? Joe Marler. Joe Marler and Nick Muhammad. And yeah, I think you were right. But he got kicked out first. But what I'm saying is, I think for traitors obsessives like me and I think John and the general fans of the show, a lot of people were comparing it to the first one expecting the same kind of stuff to happen again and the whole point is this game very different things happen during the game and what were people expecting? People were expecting suddenly Romesh to go to do a fart joke in honour of Celia Inry It's weird that everyone keeps bringing up the Celia Inry It was an incredible moment It was funny But for me, this show this series had an even more incredible moment which is richard e grant in that first episode yeah saying he was a traitor and not and not say oh i'm only joking as he said on uncloaked on friday he said that he everyone's told him they should have just said i didn't mean i was a joke which he didn't do it made it even worse but that moment has sent such ripples through the whole of the second series and then you had the james acaster element it's interesting stuff you said that it's all a game it's all fun well i mean i have to say right now james acaster's absence from the post finale kind of um you know press media run and press coverage and just going to uncloked etc is notable i think he had a genuinely tough time didn't he i think i think the thing is and um if you follow my drama she had said yesterday look had i known before that hannah and james acaster that never wanted to be traitors at all i would never she would never have recruited james acaster okay yeah and i think what it has shown is like james acaster is an absolutely delightful lovely man okay but what it has shown is that this show is is incredible and it's so much more immersive and it's so much more taxing on these celebrities than we really when then we see we see a tiny snippet of it okay we see an edited snippet he you could tell he was struggling you could tell he's genuinely not a dishonest person and he found it it went against his true nature and i think that was really i think obviously in some it clearly it was harmful to him um and it but he always admitted that and he said time and time and time again throughout it i'm not you know i don't never want it to be i'm trying my best i never wanted to be i never wanted to be so you can i just go back to your hugh grant i think the other hugh grant you got richard e grant That would be amazing.

8:44John McEwan-Whyte: I want to go back to the Richard E. Grant point because I think what the Richard E. Grant I'm a Traitor thing did which was incredible for the whole series, right? Is it set a tone because he said that and he said it so blatantly, not only did it gel that group together saying, oh my god, like they were like oh, because they were all like oh, definitely Richard's done it. Then it made it so hard for them to see that anybody else was in any way deceitful because he'd set the tone for it being overt. Like, people are so excited that they just would say, or it would be so easy, and then they never thought, they didn't look, you know, and you see with the whole pumpkin, the whole pumpkin thing that they did, and they picked out the three traitors as the most trusted people, which was unreal.

9:34John McEwan-Whyte: That was hilarious, yeah. But anyway, sorry, Boyd, carry on. Well, I was going to come to John, obviously, for your general impressions. And just to think about James Acaster as well, because there was the second big bombshell moment that had similar ripples was him in the round table just telling everyone it was a trait if it didn't want to be one. And that was almost like so, almost as mind-blowing for me as a drummer, because it kind of, it blows apart the kind of whole, the whole creation of the show, if you like. it makes it feel like the reality has suddenly entered the room you know when he just suddenly tells everyone exactly what's going on in his head i think because so i think that actually relates back to why i think like personally i preferred this season to last season which is supposedly insane i didn't really realize that that was a controversial subject or a controversial view to have but see one of my absolute favorite things with traitors right and similar to you steph i was a little bit late in the game we only started watching it during my wife's maternity leave and then we just watched it all and it was awesome because you became obsessed yeah right we became obsessed very quickly that i feel that the peak traitors moment the moment you get like the best feeling ever is when they banish someone and they're in front of everyone and they say i'm a traitor like i i feel like that is why you watch traitors oh so you felt like you were denied a little bit and because seeing season one i don't think you actually did get that point am i right like was it not that the traitors made it all the way from the beginning to the end was it not something crazy like they either only got one traitor or they never got a traitor um oh god you're testing my remember i think they've got traitors yeah i honestly think they got no more than one definitely uh maybe i can't remember but you got so then this is where we're the traitors experts so season one i was like well i missed that out and so i thought season one was good but i just love like them getting a traitor and then them recruiting and then you seeing someone that is a faithful and then they have to be a traitor and all that kind of stuff so i love that so in this season there was a lot more of that and like the whole season it's being about the james so yes you're right i felt a bit robbed by james acaster when he did that and i felt like everyone in the room was maybe a bit robbed he is clearly a lovely guy and he's clearly didn't want to do this and i feel a lot for him and i feel it got very much in his kind of head and stuff like that but like i wish and probably the producers wouldn't be able to say this to him but i wish at one point they were like you know when he was brought into the crypt with amol yeah yeah they had to choose he could have just been like i don't want to be a traitor so if that means i get murdered then just murder me and like it's annoying that he's out on the first day but it's kind of the game you're signing up for i feel like there was probably an out for him but i yeah i think i think this series yeah was so full was it was such like it was such an amazing display of like nice guys you know like i saw this great headline from one of our publications uh grazia and they literally it literally said yeah sometimes nice guys finish first and for me that was just absolutely the keynote of this series that the all these men in here were amazing and not only all the men were like really amazing lovely lovely people genuinely nice guys the women were fucking awesome leanne pinnock jumped out of a plane when she was three months pregnant she was phenomenal three months she was three months pregnant the pregnancy has been a real that's been a revelation yeah it was phenomenal she was amazing i think she's absolutely incredible she's an amazing woman did she know she was pregnant did she get pregnant in the house no no she did not um miranda it was wonderful to see miranda's journey like sharon was i loved like sharon was able to like show her image i just thought it brought the best but i absolutely am obsessed like people are rich marriage arm has proved incredibly divisive for people in this right what and i heard someone say yes i don't know why i heard someone say which is so weird to me in the office right in the office i heard somebody said in the office it's annoying them that my drama they want my drama out and she's just getting loads of air time because she was pretty and i was like she's not getting loads of air time she's getting so much she's a traitor yeah there is nobody who has played that woman was unreal she played that game so well but to um just to on the james like i said one last thing about it yeah i think a lot of people were angry with him and myself included i mean angry you know you were you were angry hold on yeah i was annoyed by that though annoyed by my anger yeah because he's so sweet he's just a fabulous guy i didn't play the game i i found i was annoyed not angry is is too strong word i was as annoyed as you can get by a reality tv show um even this the rolls royce of the of the genre but i felt like you can't go into this show assuming you're not going to be a traitor right that's not how it works yeah and he's an intelligent you know people say he's on the spectrum is on the autism spectrum and I think he's talked about that in a vaguely ambiguous way during one of his shows I think it's not even even that's not as clear-cut anyway he's talking about mental health issues and all of that and he clearly had a tough time so I'm not having a go at him I want to make that absolutely clear yeah you know I'm sensitive to to to who he is and everything but I think if you stand back from it a minute when to join this show and assume you're not gonna be the thing you really really don't want to be yeah it's either one or the other you know you're either a traitor or you know or a faithful and so for me for him to be so unprepared for that possibility and be a slightly kind of if you like um i'm trying not to use the word pompous or slightly i don't know kind of let's claim almost a lying within the game the difference between lying within a game like this and lying genuinely to people you know etc it's so different in reality right it's that he couldn't draw the distinction between taking part in the game which involves lying inherently and real life yeah where you don't obviously he doesn't he doesn't want to lie it's morally completely opposite it's not there's no morality once you're playing a game to lying or not lying it's just the way it's just the rules you know i'm trying to say

15:57John McEwan-Whyte: that surely he should realize that and i think i think maybe he did realize that and in the end the whole thing just got too much for him and that's why I just think I just think until you're in it you just don't know I think he was so he was so loud about not wanting to be a traitor I just think yeah look of course he's incredibly you can tell he's an incredibly sensitive soul okay he's an utter delight right I know there are absolutely rafts of people who love James Acaster and he's been their absolute favourite in this series he always and he didn't want to lie and he i don't he knew he was he obviously did have an awareness he didn't get the distinction did he in his mind he couldn't right about what i'm saying john as you chip in is is he should have realized the difference and what you know what it's you know what it's like right and you know when you're playing tag and tag in the playground uh we have to bring ourselves back many years okay i don't know what that is take and tag take and tag you know when you like what how do you not know you know when you touch someone something different in england yeah when you touch someone on the shoulder and then they're oh it she called it yes yes yeah right it is do you have a thing called den as well or like All these things, what are you talking about?

17:23This is like a lesson in Scottish. Okay, you touch someone, they join you in trying to chase people and touch other people, okay? Consensual. And then, if you don't, if you want to be safe, you go to like the safe place. Oh, homie. Go to homie. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, you go to homie. I feel what James Acaster did was the equivalent of playing a game of It. And you know when you had those kids that sometimes was like, oh, actually, these steps are homie these steps are yeah he made up his own yeah yeah yeah yeah you're kind of in the game for everyone like or if you're playing monopoly and someone steals the money you're like you can everyone steal the money it slightly ruins the game yeah exactly we're just yeah we don't you know he's as i said he seems to be a lovely guy but i'm like no one wants to be a dishbag but you're also playing a game and if you're being a faithful you're also going to have to lie to someone you think is a traitor because you're probably going to tell them so there's no you know it's like my my like uh sister-in-law her sister said they weren't ever gonna lie to their kids and i meant does that mean that when you're when your kids ask if santa claus is real when they're two years old santa claus is real by the way everybody that's listening yeah and if if you don't want to explore this take a moment and just walk away for a second but if that mean when your two-year-old kids ask if santa is real you just say no like you have to lie you have to yeah Exactly.

18:49John McEwan-Whyte: That's part of my point. So getting over James then, in terms of back to the show itself, the other thing I think that I found brilliant about it, and I couldn't believe people didn't acknowledge this, is that there were amazing twists and turns. Oh, my God. So many. Genuinely. And in fact, the finale was full of twists and turns. Yeah. Remember that people forget, like, an episode before the finale. They were all in. Well, we all assumed that the Tracers were going to win. Three most trusted people. Yeah, from the three most trusted people. Exactly. That iconic moment, you know, to overuse that phrase, but it was.

19:25John McEwan-Whyte: It was. And that chat they had was brilliant, by the way. That's kind of impromptu Claudia Winkleman chat. Yeah, which the producers would have loved that as well. It was so lovely. It was another turret tower. And then you get to the twist of Kenny not voting, you know, voting out. Oh, when he voted for Maya. Right, and her face. Oh, my God. Maya's face. And then from her to say, good luck, everyone, you're going to need it. Yeah. All of this stuff was brilliant. It was. Brilliant TV. And what are the standards of TV you're using whereby you just ignore these incredible twists and turns? As you say, you forget, as you already mentioned, Steph, the first episode, you have Richard E.

20:00Grant. Yeah. For the first time ever being like, yeah, I'm a traitor. Of course I'm a traitor. Yeah. Let's not forget we have Geri Hall. I mean, Geri Hall was so crazy. Yeah, yeah. She was the most acting like a traitor, non-traitor ever. It was like, Jerry, you're just making everyone think you're a traitor, even though you weren't. But let, oh my God, we have to take a moment to talk about James Blunt. My God, James Blunt. James Blunt, the whole time when he was pleading that he was not a traitor, it was like he was trying to get out of like gangsters murdering him or something. Like every time it was like there was a drug bust gone wrong.

20:42He was like, I didn't do it. No, no. Oh my God, I've never seen someone.

20:45John McEwan-Whyte: Well, Ramesh in the finale. In the finale. Oh. For all of that, and the fact that, yeah, his reaction to Ramesh, just even daring to doubt him. Just like a faithful would do. Yes. And the fact that, because he clearly thought Ramesh and Bash were faithfuls, yet he still was like, well, if you're going to do that to me, Ramesh, then the game is, and that's not very fair, James Blunt. Oh, there were outbursts like that all the way through. There was, yeah. That's why I think the whole format is so clever, because it, no matter how, you know even ron was like i have moments where he was annoyed you know i would you know with james a bit and i i think leanne voted for him right didn't i think i think the reason one of the reasons why because i don't really want to get into this because we can't really read it and it's pointless speaking about that but you know everyone said there was more drama behind the scenes that everyone realized but i think honestly i might just be an idiot i just thought it was fine and but supposedly though but i think one of the reasons why that may be in the case was because there was no sports people in the cast.

21:45John McEwan-Whyte: And I think if there was sports people in the cast, I think they would have been like, guys, it's a game. That's a really good point. And I think if you think about what James Acaster said and kind of did, imagine he sat down with Joe Marler. You really need to watch the first season, by the way, Steph. Okay. And Joe Marler was really good. He just kind of just saw it as a game. And I think as soon as he left, he still gave hugs but still took the piss but they could take the emotion out of it on some degree yeah i think you really need to realize also little things like there was something that there's often points as well when you have to realize it's not just a game but also you are kind of raising money for charity like yeah you know it's what's interesting is i think i you i think you expect the celebrities because they are in quotes just raising money for charity not themselves obviously as opposed to the civilians you know civilians are competing for a life changing sum of money and the celebrities obviously aren't but still for me like they get as immersed in the gameplay as the as the civilians and that again the finale showed that again like they all got a little bit annoyed with each other yeah because the tension is huge and they're not going i think they've completely banished to use a yeah to use a you know indicative word um banish the thoughts that they're oh they're just playing for their chances and obviously the church is really important to themselves but um do you think the house is haunted and kind of it affects people in strange ways i think it's so no i don't know i don't either i just i just think it becomes you know the thing is is that with any kind of game it's like anything when you really sit down and play yeah you're like i'm gonna win this i don't care about beating in these nine-year-olds like i'm gonna you know if you have a competitive spirit which let's be honest people go in let's play with four nine-year-olds just saying i'm just saying if they if it's not a word it's not a word okay anyway sorry right i digress right the thing is it's like you don't right if you're gonna say you're gonna you yes if they say do you want to be on celebrity yeah you've got to love the game yeah to understand the game and i think like to go back to that's why people are annoyed with james encaster yeah yeah but the other thing is you get i mean if you think as a viewer how how involved you become in it with it because you're sitting there going oh my god please get that other one oh my god please wait if you're playing that game we're like god it just must just be so crazy how much you want to win yeah and then also i think claudia is so brilliant at like ramping up that tension and you know ramping up the drama and making them so excited about getting you know gay i mean one thing that i would say is the person i would have loved to see all the way through to the end is ross kemp oh yeah i really would have loved to see he went out in a shit way but then he probably would have made sure that he was in the helicopter hanging off the helicopter and i don't know someone like maybe like bash wouldn't have got that incredible experience oh my god that was very moving wasn't it that was he i literally messaged boy yesterday and said when we do this i'm going to cry because do you know what right when bash jumps out of that helicopter and then what he says afterwards about it was like if somebody had told that little gay boy at school that i'd be jumping out of here and i was in floods of tears because i was like oh my god you're such an amazing person and how awful that you would have felt like that but i really want to jump out of that helicopter I really want to know.

25:15John McEwan-Whyte: There's lots of things people talk about, as you said, people alluded to the what's going on behind the scenes and they were clearly James had a tough time and you know, you don't want to see, by the way, people are going, oh, they edited out certain key moments. I mean, if someone's having a tough time to the point of where they're, you know, breaking down a bit, you don't want to milk that for reality. I think it's quite right that they didn't show certain people going too far. For sure. yeah but um what i want to know is when they when they told when when you know bastion etc they're told by the way we're gonna have you dangling out of a helicopter they must like give them forewarning right they must go they must do they can't just they need to know whether he can swim they must they must have been told he was gonna try yeah i mean imagine i don't know imagine if he'd miranda you know something like yeah what would they have done then i'm asking you were three months pregnant exactly well indeed she was yeah so though i really want to see yeah wanted to know more about how that worked but what do we think about a lot of people say they fast forward through the missions I didn't interview David Baddiel the other day I interviewed David Baddiel on Friday about his new show and he was like he's obsessed with the traitors and by the way wouldn't it be brilliant if they had Baddiel and Skinner on it oh my god if they had David and Skinner it would be amazing he would do it anyway I met Frank Skinner once oh oh did you I gave him a flyer for a play I did you can cut this out Darren this is boring but he was very nice there's no point in cutting it out No, we're going to cut it out.

26:37John McEwan-Whyte: You met him. It's fine. Anyway, what was I saying? Oh, yeah. What was I saying? Fast forwards through the missions. Fast forwards through the missions. Yes. David Baddiel was saying he's fast forwards through the missions. But I think, and I am compromised. I am in the pocket of big traitors because I host the launches of it and I interviewed Claudia at the launches and blah, blah, blah. Why don't you ever invite me to anything, Boyd? Fuck's sake. Why don't you ever invite me to anything? You're just busy. What can I do? You're always claiming you're busy. Do you know what? We're going to take this off air because that's just annoying.

27:06Anyway. Like, go on.

27:06John McEwan-Whyte: But I am connected in that way, too. Yeah. But I still think that there's a magic to it that is, you know, it's almost inherent and built into the formula, into the format. And that was it. And the missions, that was the point I'm making, the missions were, by and large, even better than usual. Were they? Because they were amazing. I think, what do you reckon, John? I just think some of them were more grotesque and Halloween-y and scary even before the missions are fun i think if you fast forward them you're just losing out on traitors time so yeah are you a true traitors fan so much stuff happens in the mission so so many little quips happen in this so many little allegiances change like if they're gonna get the shields and stuff why would you fast forward from that because that point to de-stress as well you need to have a bit of a laugh right yeah to see them all but i would i would like to say one thing and i've had this problem with the traitors for a long time about okay what is the lore of traitors what is the mythology of traitors because right now it's all over the place because sometimes you have like oh here's a hidden cabin in the woods and then suddenly you have like a robot that speaks only riddles and then you have like a pharaoh they need one strict mythology and more right that that like the traitor's house is built porn there's no lower here okay i think it's important i mean it doesn't bother me um no it doesn't bother me i think it only bothers you i think it only bothers you too i can mix it up as a comparison john i've got messaged by kirstie allsop right of okay of location location classic yeah classic she she she's actually she's not it's not even a dm it's there on twitter you can see on twitter she's she's she's she is annoyed by the um interior design of the castle she thinks it looks shit basically get in there babes yeah that would be a great special if kirsty and phil okay did an interior special on the traitor's castle would be incredible they should do that as a christmas special but the interior the interior decoration doesn't have anything to do with the fact that in this world people are murdered and banished like what does the cloaks what power does the clothes come from i just think that someone should just write like an encyclopedia of how it's led up to this moment and this house that's not a bad idea i volunteer myself to write that book oh you'd be great can we take a moment to talk about the food okay because i'm telling you now the food watching them eat yeah it was giving me untold joy watching watching people eat buffet style food is one of the greatest joys of my life.

29:51John McEwan-Whyte: It's very humanising, isn't it? I wasn't expecting that detail. I just love seeing what they're going to put on their plate. They don't show enough of it as well. Do you know what? They don't show enough of it. I think you don't want to see too much, do you? I want a top-down picture of everyone's plate. Their first plate. I'm actually a vegan, for example, so that's quite tough for him. Oh, he was very big on the peppers, though. They'd have a lot of stuff like that. like so i would like what i want them to do is for every meal i want them to have taken an aerial photo yeah yeah the buffet area so i can see what they got to choose from yeah and then i want a before and after like this is what it was and this is because it's very clear see i think because they say it's breakfast and then you like almost miss lunch i'm sure that breakfast happens at midday yeah yeah yeah yeah dinner it's a like we have four or five or something like that yeah I also wanted to jump in that helicopters they need to yeah yeah that's right here's a question for you and by the way I've got notes on each not notes on each episode but I think we should go through who got murdered or by shot okay well here's a question for you right here's a question right okay you're talking to a writer here okay right after um after a celebrity gets banished or murdered where do they go and this isn't the mythology question oh okay they go back to their hotel do they all share a hotel together like is actually more fun to get banished or murdered on day four because then you have no pressure playing the game and you just get to hang out with a bunch of celebrities for like a week i mean they all go to the same hotel but they're very monitored very closely so they can't even They mustn't hang out.

31:31John McEwan-Whyte: No, they mustn't hang out. That's one of the big rules. Even after they leave? Yeah. So one of the things... Well. See? One of the things was that... Wasn't there... Wasn't there... That Bash and Rom had had a dinner together before it was revealed that they'd won? But I'm talking about when they're in Scotland. Since the filming. You get kicked out on day four. You get kicked out on day four. You can't stop them socialising after it's been filmed. Yeah. No, no, but I'm talking about during the... This is very relevant. like would it be it would be quite fun if you were just ross kemp you get kicked out and then you go to the swimming pool and you're just hanging out with richard e grant the next week without the pressure they just go home oh 100 they definitely need to stay there because richard e grant is not hanging out with these people richard e grant is a busy man john i'll tell you another thing i also met richard e grant one oh in fc uk in aberdeen and he was very nice I don't want to outdo you well he phoned me when I worked at Empire actually why?

32:29tell me he was bringing out a film and he wanted our editor to put a review in and it was a brilliant film so it was fine while we're talking about all these people, the overall cast

32:41John McEwan-Whyte: again I've seen people saying that not as good as a series one I think I would almost prefer to hang out with this lot to some extent, not completely I mean, Alan Carr and Jonathan Ross, I know. Jonathan Ross forgot about Jonathan Ross. Jonathan Ross was the one. He was the evicted traitor. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That was the one traitor that was evicted. I think you're right. Until the final. Yeah, until the final. Yeah. I think you're right. In fact, I know you're right because I checked on Wikipedia. Yeah. But these guys, hanging out with these guys via this format on television. It's a good hang.

33:11John McEwan-Whyte: It's a good hang, right? And again, people have been, I think, needlessly critical of them. You mentioned Jerry Hall. You mentioned Ross Kemp. Yeah. Miranda, brilliant for her. I mean, she was in a bad way. She was. I really love her. I read a whole book about how old she was. Yeah. Michael Sheen, I thought, well, you know, I can't underestimate Michael Sheen. Yeah. Because the kind of daddy of the round table. Oh, my God, I can't believe we haven't even spoken about Michael Sheen. Yeah. He was the king of the table. Yeah. It was unreal. Oh, my God. When they were talking about getting the king, Michael Sheen was an unbelievable player.

33:41John McEwan-Whyte: And I'm surprised you. He was full Game of Thrones. Brilliant. He was brilliant. And I'm surprised you, Steph, haven't mentioned, surely, the one you fancy most, who you would King Kenny. Yeah. Oh, my God. he is so you don't even get started king kenny is absolutely oh my god he was so funny he was just absolutely brilliant oh god i loved him so much i was sorry john i'm just gonna say he was so lovely yeah i wonder if because he was friends with the other brilliant traitor yeah he was a brilliant but i'm also a brilliant faithful like you forget that he was a brilliant faithful as well yeah he was also that choice that turn from one to the other he managed he was the most into the gameplay if we talk about people who were prepared bella was into the game as well yeah he was the most he was the most prepared to go either way and he's not any less morally you know we don't judge him no because that's my point listen he was having the time of his life a boxer yeah yeah and right when if you're a boxer you know that you have to go and even when you're sparking you have to punch someone and the next time you have to be friends with them yeah i guess your point about having a sportsman he was the closest you got to a sportsman and he was the one that anyway and of course the other thing i meant i wanted to mention was the um the killing in plain sight right that yeah yeah the three traitors were all there for that had ripples throughout the rest of the series right yeah that's how that is how you know we ended up in this in this position really of the fact that my my drama and kinkani couldn't both really feasibly win this thing yeah yeah and it all goes back to that doesn't it that scene where they're all there in that room yeah I remember at the time people were saying, oh, it's too easy for them to carry out that task.

35:16John McEwan-Whyte: I was like, easy? Oh, I didn't think they were going to do it. I didn't think they were going to be able to do it. I thought it was kind of... They were going to run out of time. But not only that, it had such impact. A task like that had such impact on the rest of the series. Yeah, the only thing that I think was a little bit of a flaw with that task was it was too kind of by chance. Sometimes you want the killing in plain sight to be a little bit more... The person you actually want them to murder. Yeah, a little bit. Or at least try to. because they just waited for two people to come to the room.

35:43It was funny and it was good because I think that's why Ross Kemp, I reckon, would have made it all the way to the end because he was quite funny. He was quite like, it was like James Blunt making it all the way to the end. He was quite strong with his opinions and mission, but usually wrong. So it was... They were all usually wrong.

36:02John McEwan-Whyte: They were all wrong about everything. Here's a question though. So there's two things. Michael, Sheen and Ramesh, right? do you think those two maybe more specifically ramesh ramesh just played an absolute blinder of a game in that he kind of had thoughts about who it was the whole time and then because michael sheen as well he kept saying i'm just playing it low i'm just not saying anything i think michael sheen was the absolute key to cracking it for them when he had that conversation and he said if i die tonight remember what i've said and he was the one who said he thought that that it was going to be those those those three yeah he really he was like we've been looking the wrong way what actually what about actually yeah he was he really did figure it out but i think the thing about romish right okay is he that man could not be more lovable and more brilliant if you it's it's like he just he just everything about him is so nice he's hilariously funny yeah and he just and also like if you listen to um all the other contestants afterwards they've all talked about actually how Romesh was the one who was like emotionally holding people together behind the scenes.

37:10And you could see that. He was the one darling out the big hugs. He was the one comforting everybody. He's such a stable force.

37:16John McEwan-Whyte: He lived up to that reality TV maxim, which is he was just himself. Yes. And he was, in his case, himself is, knowing him as I do, my third major name drop of the Yeah, he is the best. He's a friend of he has been, you know, we've interviewed him many times. Yeah. Just the way it is. anyway yeah no no it's true it's true because he's such a likable guy he's just so you know what he is he's the most classic good teacher you know when you have a good teacher yeah and they actually care you can you you they probably seize the day he's he's robin williams he's robin williams he's like the one that you know when people get older and they become famous and they go oh i had this one teacher yeah he's that guy yeah you could see he was like that with bash a little bit yeah you can see that friendship between the two that the fact they did have dinner together in central london yeah as they're revealed i did i said about four or five episodes ago it was going to be bashing rom because i felt that rom on radio 2 lately has had a lot of giddiness about him oh now is this just wise after the event you're saying you could somehow sense from the tone of his voice that something you know he was yeah stephan and i did say apparently We did say, we did say earlier, we said, can I just say, of course, the harsh reality is, much as we love him, and brilliant though it is, really, he didn't, he kind of didn't get anything right.

38:41John McEwan-Whyte: He didn't, like everyone in there, absolutely nothing right. In the end, Bash was the key. Bash, that little moment where Bash convinced him, when they went off to the back of the room. Yeah, that was brilliant. Again, another moment that people were really not acknowledging was brilliant TV. Right. They'd go off and have a whisper, and Bash somehow convinces Rob to forget about James Blunt, It's fine. And changed the course of the whole game. Speaking of nice men finish, what was it? First. Finish first, right. Okay. What a perfect example of a good guy in Ramesh in actually listening and being convinced by someone that's younger.

39:16Absolutely. That man has no ego. He has no ego.

39:20John McEwan-Whyte: Yeah. If you're talking of clout, right, you've got Ramesh Ranganathan, one of the most loved TV presenters. And by the way, you know, very busy TV presenter. Yeah. And you've got Bash who's basically been in Heartstopper And he's not really known outside that particularly Young Ned Stark There you go But the fact that Rom took what he was saying on board That was fantastic It says a lot for him I think it reflects so well on him and so well on Bash James Bond's reaction didn't help James Bond was so furious James Bond did a classic toddler reaction James Bond just loves the helicopters he was just thinking about when he did that explanation of why he he was like I'm fortunate enough to have a pilot license and my dad has it and I've been in a lot of and I just thought these peasants that didn't go wrong I thought I'd let him have a go who do you think is going to be we'll wind up in a minute because I've got work to do do you see that I'm sorry he didn't even say hi to me when he joined this call didn't he?

40:20John McEwan-Whyte: no apologies it's fine yeah who is going to be the biggest star like in terms of like making them you know make their start even bigger yeah do you think that i just think he has he when he cries and says i think this is the best day of my life and you could see how much it meant to him and he has endeared himself to a nation because he was just he's obvious because he played the game he put himself out there and all but also he was incredibly lovable and just the fact that he fucking Fell out of that helicopter And swam in that Freezing cold water Like just There's so many Bash moments But also Kenny That make it special Oh Kenny That's obvious Kenny is He will have Millions of pounds Worth of offers By now Yeah To do this To present stuff To be in stuff To Because I think This is just one rung On the ladder of upwards For Maya Jama Like I don't think She doesn't need it She's cooked She's a winner anyway Do you know what I mean She's like She's just going to get a few more offers.

41:20Like, she, everybody.

41:21John McEwan-Whyte: I think it'll boost Love Island, I have to say. I think, you know, people love her so much. Because you also, I'm just looking at my notes that we're not going to go through. But we forgot, like, we haven't even mentioned that. if you want to film, do you record your own podcast with your notes. I do, We haven't even mentioned. Episode by episode, John's breakdown. Yeah, literally. Quietly, I won't even record myself. I'll just go after this. We'll know it exists, though. We haven't mentioned Joe Lysett. Like, Joe Lysett. Even Hannah Fry was alright I think those two Even Hannah Fry was alright I'm not actually allowed to speak too much about it Because my wife is I have a physics degree So when I used to listen to her podcast My wife was convinced I fancied her Supposedly I said I fancied her I don't think I did I feel like you're not going to have an affair with Hannah Fry I think it's okay Don't worry I met folks here once Remember?

42:09John McEwan-Whyte: Oh yeah That's it, Joanne McNally Oh my god I can't believe you haven't talked about Joanne McNally Alright Joanne McNally, my God. That's why I brought her up now. But for me, Joanne McNally, I'm going to say something controversial here. It's not really. I think her performance on Uncloaked was even more entertaining. When she was reviewing the traitors. Yes. She knocked over the mic. Oh my God. That was so good. When she said, when they said, when she found out Maya Jama, and she said, we were building a life together. I could not stop laughing. Yeah. I think, though, I thought it was a bit rubbish of her to even mention that a girl was putting on makeup that Leanne was putting on I'm like come on when you've got nothing to go on when you've got nothing to go on that is kind of a clue you know what you should go on if either of you ever go on the trailers and this is for anyone that's listening one thing that they haven't realised yet which is just insane why don't you just write down the last people that come into the room every single day at breakfast because either because the way that is shown on tv you have to have a cliffhanger so it's always going to be one of the last people are going to be one that we're about to be murdered or a traitor that has been mentioned yeah people there's two things to mention is that which is a valid point and interesting and the fact that why why not keep in traitors people you really think of traitors there's no in the early days there's almost no point oh yeah yeah like a like you're playing pool and you put the ball in the pocket someone else is going to replace yeah when richard e grant was there i was like wouldn't it be interesting if someone said okay we clearly know he's a traitor so why don't we just keep him in absolutely and why don't we keep him until the end yeah but obviously i don't know that's not part of the game you got a part a big part of the traders which is kind of coming back james a caster i have one question by the way boy before you cut call this okay but i'm all it just ending it they're not going to come the one thing that comes back to James Acaster is now it's completely gone because you're you calling the podcast is going to I'm going to make a point about the fact that I think that this was a great example of friendships in the castle and I think it was and actually I found that really beautiful I thought that was a really lovely friendship did you see that Miranda sent Leanne basically she made up the big you know they had the thing they said it was going to be called they were going to be called Big Mix and she sent her a record and she made an album cover for it.

44:36Oh, that's cute. And that's so Miranda. That's cute. Isn't it? She's lovely.

44:40John McEwan-Whyte: Again, another classic moment. It was a classic moment. Which was then used by some to think. And they couldn't stop talking about what it was. Oh my gosh, yeah. Definitely a bit. She was just making someone happy. I know, and the thing is, Miranda was sad. But that's the thing for me. She was having to defend like female friendships. No, no, no, we just, she was feeling sad. I was just trying to make her feel better. It was hilarious. It was so. and also and i shout out sharon i think the only scottish person on the show was great i felt i think she had a bit of a rough time she did she was a bit sad at the end i think she i think also i reckon with actors as well they're so emotionally charged yeah you saw with the other scottish guy in the last season stephanie to watch it but like the i think sharon got quite hurt if someone accused me of being a traitor i would be so hard time yeah yeah and so but um it's the power of the format it's incredible yeah yeah can i ask my question now boy before we go of course yeah you remembered what it was yeah well no the other thing was all i was going to say earlier was james acas you got to play the game but now it doesn't make sense because i forgot about it we can just but my question is okay who would you want to see in the next season oh i mean well you mentioned hugh grant i think there are rumors that they they approached you grant i think there are rumors that who's the guy who's in all the Marvel films whose name I've forgotten Jeremy Benner Albert Downey Jr.

46:00John McEwan-Whyte: No British you know posh British Tom Hiddleston Tom Hiddleston I thought you were talking about Paul Bettany No Tom Hiddleston I think Tom Hiddleston got quite close to being in it I think one of the producers talked about how a A-list actor was very nearly in it and in my opinion it's him I may be wrong I'm not sure if Hugh Grant having seen Richard E. Grant I think he probably wouldn't do it yeah go on do you know who I would absolutely love and you're going to go this will never happen in a million years but I would absolutely love to see Adele in that episode I would die to see I think she would be amazing I think she would be so good I would like to see Adele I would like to see James Corden I would like to see he won't do it I'd like to see Ruth Jones might do it Ruth Jones would be amazing if you catch her in a Rob Brydon Oh yeah yeah yeah And I've already said Bedin and Skinner Bedin and Skinner and or Rob Brydon and Steve Coogan Would be incredible I think Steve Coogan would take it too seriously I don't know About that I don't know He wouldn't do it I don't think he'd do it And David Mitchell would also be good I think As the puzzler of Ludwig Obviously he's back in role Imagine The new twist is everyone plays the role That they've previously played Imagine if Victoria Beckham Was in the Traitors' Council She wouldn't have She wouldn't But can you imagine It would be so amazing It would be incredible And what about Someone that plays for Arsenal Like David Beckham He plays for Arsenal Doesn't he Oh good God You're just testing me now Yeah Oh good God A footballer A good ex-footballer Would be good Beckham Ian Wright Ian Wright Ian Wright's And I'm a celebrity though So I think My beloved Gary Neville Oh my God can you imagine if gary neville would be so good oh actually jill scott would be great as well but she's done i'm a celeb too ken kenny dug kenny the leash doug yeah i mean he's he's he's still alive he's but he is still alive he's very old i think he's got it isn't he he's scottish well done anyway it's been a joy uh for us to be able to talk about everything um john and stephan the listeners and i hope it's been some kind of joy to listen in as well you know we should have got your questions and we didn't do any of that anyway that's about it for this uh special um spoiler special discussion of the traitor celebrity traitors i'm falling apart james is here to end our conversation we did this whole thing yeah with james's say so and he's a busy man and he's illness and he's struggling but he did record this thing thanks bye

48:48you

From the publisher

Boyd and Steph break all the rules and take advantage of the fact that James is off sick with flu to stage a guerrilla Celebrity Traitors spoiler special, enlisting our Animation Correspondent John McEwan-Whyte into their nefarious plan. It's absolute anarchy, the inmates are running the asylum etc. All we can do is apologise for all of this. Normal service will resume as soon as James is feeling better.

More from Pilot TV+

All episodes