


Lanterns Season 1 spoiler special discussion of HBO Max’s Lanterns (8 episodes), focusing on character arcs, fear/grief themes, the mystery of the Manhunter, and the season finale’s major deaths and consequences.
Chris Hewitt (host). Amon Warman (co-host; DCU/TV critic). James Dyer (co-host; DC/James Gunn/DCU commentator). They discuss performances and storytelling choices rather than production details.
The show is “exactly what the DCU needed,” praised for zigs when viewers expect zags, grounded human drama over spectacle, and strong character work. Hal Jordan’s death is framed as bold and emotionally earned; recharging the ring “deletes” Hal’s hologram backup. John Stewart’s arc is about overcoming abusive conditioning and embracing fear as strength.
Hal’s early “raging bellend” portrayal; John’s parents’ abusive parenting; Zoe revealed as Manhunter; Kerry Kane shooting Hal after hologram appears; gravesite conversation about Mogo; John’s detailed constructs (digger/watch/bird) and the ring’s limited charge.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The hosts humorously discuss the Green Lantern ring and its significance.
“And welcome to the latest in our series of Spoiler Special Podcasts.”
The hosts share their initial thoughts on the Lanterns series and its potential.
“But let's talk about general stuff before we get into this.”
Amon discusses the unique elements of the show and its character arcs.
“And because it's at times inventing things from whole cloth, like we haven't really got a Jon Stewart origin like this before until this show.”
James shares his views on the show's risks and character dynamics.
“that character might have shown up given what John was doing and given what happened to Hal.”
The hosts discuss the choice to kill off Hal Jordan and its implications.
“But for me, I thought it really, really worked as a mystery that sustained much of the season.”
Exploration of a significant emotional scene and character relationships.
Discussion about characters facing consequences for their actions.
“And I like that, you know, consequences we talk about all the time, but I think that really works and everything that we get with Kelly MacDonald and Carl Chandler, the cast of that, it's just brilliant, by the way.”
Analysis of Hal and John's character arcs and growth throughout the series.
“So when he charges it and takes the oath, essentially, it's like factory default.”
Discussion on Sinestro's motivations and potential story implications.
“John and Sinestro and the hologram, and he says, I can bring you back.”
Exploration of the intricate relationships between characters in the show.
“I love the fact that Hal is, as I said to Carl Chandler, introducing him to the term a raging bellend when you meet him.”
Reflection on the show's grounded storytelling versus traditional superhero tropes.
“You don't want Hal to have the ring because you don't want that version of Hal to win, to triumph.”
In-depth discussion on the powers and limitations of the Green Lantern ring.
“I mean, they go off-world a little bit, but not a lot.”
Analysis of John Stewart's character journey and unique origin story.
“it's a good question who charges the lantern?”
The hosts share humorous reactions and insights as they dive into character dynamics.
“yeah but it's not the heart though is it it's the balls in that point so I don't know ain't nothing better than eating up another man's grill oh I don't This is so upsetting.”
Discussion on John's journey, origin story, and the unique narrative choices in the series.
“I liked that it was an origin story that didn't have any dead parents to deal with so many superheroes.”
Exploring the portrayal of John's parents and the expectations placed on him.
“But John Stewart's been around since the 70s so he doesn't have an origin in that way?”
Analysis of John's relationship with his family and the nuances of reconciliation.
“We've gotten some stuff with him in the military before in the cartoon.”
Future possibilities for the series and discussion on its structural choices.
“I mean, how is he going to, like he says to Guy Gardner, he says to Guy Gardner, he says, you know, you take the stars, I'll take the dirt.”
Discussion about character revelations and the structural shifts in storytelling.
“I think it's been really well conceived and really well put together.”
Exploring the motivations behind characters' actions and the concept of misdirected anger.
“I think it's interesting because what it does is it pushes the focus towards the end of the show on who killed Hal Jordan.”
Examination of the significance of the Green Lantern ring and character abilities.
“So you can understand why they have a certain amount of misdirected anger.”
Learn how Jon Stewart's character grapples with fear and grief in the show.
“And they've changed their policy after Sinestro killed all of them.”
Discover the portrayal of the Manhunters and how they differ from comics.
“be that once because they still have the portal right?”
Examine the contrast between the new series and the previous Green Lantern film.
“Yeah, I mean clearly you're very technologically capable but I would have liked to have seen a bit more of the Killing Machine.”
Discuss the significance of character cameos and fan service in the show.
“Carol Ferris is The Blake Lively character.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Pilot TV+, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:17Chris Hewitt: Yeah, I should have thought of an Empire version of this. In blackest day, in brightest day, in blackest pod, no evil shall escape my board. it's tough it's tough to rhyme things with pod guys would you like my one? no but okay in brightest day in blackest night no exclusive shall escape empire's sight if you read that that's not true yeah I mean that's fundamentally you're off to a bad start let those who worship AI's might beware our power empire's might No, you said you rhymed might with might Yeah, I couldn't do that Empire's light Is that our power, to rhyme the same word with itself? I think that might be We don't really have a light, so it kind of fizzled out It was good poetry, though, Amon Thank you And what rhymes with poetry, James Dyer?
1:13Chris Hewitt: Noetry Precisely
1:18Chris Hewitt: Oh, dear Well, listen, you get a gold star Thank you But you don't get a lantern and a ring Not yet Damn I've got loads of them. I've got a forge out the back. I actually do have a lantern ring. Do you? Yeah, true story. Why are you not wearing it right now? I was sent it by Warner Brothers when the film came out. In 2011? And it came from the States. Like, is it a special gift? It came from the States. And I had to pay about£70 in import duties. And I didn't know what it was. It was like the worst lucky tip ever. So it's a 70 pound green lantern ring. That probably... Hang on, when you say...
1:58Chris Hewitt: Okay. Welcome, by the way. Hello. Hello, Pod. I'm Chris Hewitt. And welcome to the latest in our series of Spoiler Special Podcasts. And this one is dedicated to Lanterns, which has just finished its run on HBO Max. And I'm joined by Amon Warman. Hello. And James Dyer. Hello. And I was going to ask them both if they were afraid. But now I'm afraid of what James is about to say. So describe this thing. Is it like a proper size, like a full-sized lantern? For the amount I had to pay for it, you would hope that it had actual emeralds in it or something. But no, it's just exactly what you think, a cheap cracker type ring, but with the lantern symbol on it.
2:34And you are a cheap cracker. Indeed, I am. Did it imbue you with the power of the Lantern Corps? It imbued me with the power of that particular movie, if that helps. So not a lot of power. Make of that what you will.
2:48Chris Hewitt: Amon Mormon is also here, as I've already said. Amon, is it time to rehabilitate Martin Campbell's 2011 masterpiece Green Lantern? No. No? Absolutely not. I find that most movies, given enough time passing, their reputation gets rehabilitated whether you want it to or not. And is no one rehabilitating Green Lantern? There's got to be something good about Green Lantern. No. No? It's not going to happen for Green Lantern. Not helped, I think, by the fact that Ryan Reynolds, seemingly, every chance he gets, bashes that movie himself. so yeah it's not going to happen not with that one not with that one alright well we tried we tried Martin we tried but anyway we're not here to re-litigate Martin Campbell's Green Lantern genuinely terrible movie we are here instead to litigate to discuss Lanterns which is the show created of course by Chris Mundy and Damon Lindelof and Tom King and saw Hal Jordan played by Cal Chandler and Jon Stewart, not that one, played by Aaron Pierre, team up, or not, kind of, over eight episodes to sort of do something in Rushville.
4:00Chris Hewitt: But hey, it's a supporter podcast. We could talk about it. But let's talk about general stuff before we get into this. Not general stuff, general stuff. We have less than an hour. So I think, Amon, that's maybe one question for you. Less than an hour until the ring loses charge. Oh my gosh. Well, if we go off the charge that John had, he charged it 5 % at the end of, I believe it was episode 6, and it was still going in episode 8. Now, my iPhone, if it gets down to 2%, lasts maybe a minute, maybe two. But my word, the hologram was still banging away. Not literally. Although, maybe, who knows? Spoilers for the final episode of Landon's.
4:48Chris Hewitt: I mean, he's probably capable of doing that, right? The hologram? He is corporeal. He is corporeal. He's fully functional, versed in multiple techniques. Yeah. Do you think he has the... Anyway, let's not get into it. Amon, what did you think of this show overall? I really liked it. And it was exactly what the DCU needed, I think, after Supergirl came and went and bombed and everything happened with that. But yeah, I just thought it was really interesting. This show zigs when you think it's going to zag. And it did that quite frequently over the course of its eight episode run. Like you think this is the moment where John finally ascends and becomes a Green Lantern.
5:33It's like, oh no, he's going to leave the Lantern and live with the Guardian and go off and do another thing. You think this is the moment where how Jordan finally starts becoming a really good mentor to Jon. It's like, oh no, he just almost killed him by crashing the car into a tree for like the second time. You think even going into the final episode, I think because we've been conditioned by so much other superhero stuff that we've gotten that this is going to be a time where we're finally going to see some cool ring slinging from Jon. It's like, no, it's a very muted episode in many ways.
6:06Chris Hewitt: We've just checked the budget and we can't afford any ring slinging there's that as well but also it reminded me a little bit of the season finale to the first season of loki where it's just people talking um about stuff but it's really really compelling thanks to the incredible performances so i thought this was really really great and a really good example of taking the comics and doing something new with them there's actually a lupe fiasco line from a track called superstar and which is quite famous is did you improve on the design? Did you do something new? I feel like this did. And because it's at times inventing things from whole cloth, like we haven't really got a Jon Stewart origin like this before until this show.
6:52It can really do stuff that surprises you all the way through the season. I got a couple of niggles with the show and I'm sure we're going to get to that. But by and large, I thought this was a triumph.
7:03Chris Hewitt: A triumph. James Dyer, do you concur with Amon's assessment of lanterns yes it's fantastic I really really like this sorry hang on a second I think James' microphone is working I've made no bones about the fact that I think James Gunn's DCU is a shit show from top to bottom but this is genuinely fantastic and it did a lot to redeem what he's doing in my eyes and partly it's because it's something different it's something that you maybe didn't expect you know the true detective analogy has obviously been used quite a lot but it has a lot of that in it and it's about these two characters and their dynamic and you know everything else plays second fiddle to that and I interviewed them both together which was a delight and what I particularly enjoy is that the relationship that they have in the show is 100 % identical to the relationship they have in real life where they are just so Cal Chandler drove absolutely yeah and it's funny like Aaron Pierre burned him alive at the end of the interview really unexpected they both burned alive in the course of this season It's absolutely wild.
8:05They're just like ragging on each other for being too young or too old. Do you need a nap? That kind of stuff. It's genuinely a lot of fun. And I thought they were great together. But they're so good on screen as well.
8:17Chris Hewitt: That's surprising. I didn't know you liked this show. Really? Yeah, I genuinely thought you were going to come in all guns blazing. G-U-N, not G-U-N-N. And I now have to ask, Amon, is this a construct? Are you projecting James? Is he part of your subconscious? Is James O 'Graham? Yeah, that's me. James O 'Graham, oh my word. That's really, really interesting, because I think, I agree, I really, really like this. I have some quibbles as well. I think there are some things that the show didn't quite show us. I think there are some omissions. I think, you know, where was Laura Linney for the last couple of episodes?
8:51Chris Hewitt: You'd think that, you know, that character might have shown up given what John was doing and given what happened to Hal. But I thought it was really, really bold. Took a lot of risks with, I think, Hal Jordan right off the bat, Batman. And I really, really liked it. I think I'm not as dyed in the wool about the DCU being a top-to-bottom shit show as you are. I speak the truth. What can I tell you? I think this is the best thing since James Gunn took over the DC studios. Yes, agreed. Because I'm counting things that have James Gunn's fingerprints all over them, like the Suicide Squad and the first season of Peacemaker, which was brilliant.
9:30Chris Hewitt: the second season of Peacemaker was not, sadly. But this is really, really great. And, you know, apart from obviously it has Guy Gardner in there and as I mentioned Superman at one point, it is completely separate, I would say, to what's going on in Metropolis because, you know, the 2026 parts obviously are after Superman takes place. So I thought it was really, really interesting. It took a lot of risks. Should we talk about one of those risks? Go for it. Right off the bat. So I've got to stop saying that. This is my new conchu. Right off the bat, man, one of the big risks is Hal Jordan. Killing Hal Jordan.
10:07Chris Hewitt: I had a theory that Hal was going to be brought back to life using the Manhunter's regenerative shit technology. And that they were somehow going to find a way of taking the hologram and making the hologram properly flesh. And then obviously as the show goes on, you begin to realize, oh, they're not doing that. so that actually means that and you know and listen I have absolutely no I'm under no illusions I do not believe that Hal Jordan as played by Kyle Chandler is going to stay dead for long I think he'll come back at some point because it's a characterization and a performance that's so good you just want to see more of this guy in the DCU and also this is a sub point but I was watching him and he's an amazing amazing actor Kyle Chandler he's been great in a lot of stuff for a long time but he's not a big star and he should absolutely be a big star and we were doing recently an Indiana Jones ranking.
11:04Chris Hewitt: And we were talking about, oh, who could possibly play Indiana Jones these days? There's nobody. There's nobody who could play Indiana Jones who has that same level of, you know, kind of magismo, but they undercut it with a little bit of, you know, knowingness. And they're good looking, but they're grizzled and they've had, you know, it's not the year's, honey, it's the mileage. I'm watching this show and they're going, fuck me, it's Kyle Chandler. It's absolutely Kyle Chandler. He is terrific. And they have killed Hal Jordan. now you know I'm not as steeped in DC comics as you are but this is a bit like having a Batman show and killing Bruce Wayne in the first season it's kind of like that how Jordan is the well not the original Green Lantern as Alan Scott right yes but he is Lee Green Lantern for a lot of people and so to bring this character into the into the the TV show and then kill him and not bring him back that was pretty damn bold I think very bold how are people reacting to that by the way There was a lot of chatter that there are some people who are quite annoyed about this being the direction they went in.
12:04But for me, I thought it really, really worked as a mystery that sustained much of the season. I think they could have pulled the trigger on certain reveals, maybe an episode. Oh, pulled the trigger.
12:16Chris Hewitt: Good. They did. That's why he died. Maybe an episode or so sooner, because I think by a certain point, it was fairly obvious who the Manhunter was. Were you surprised they didn't bring Hal back or retcon that in some way or find a way out for Hal? No, I wasn't surprised. It felt kind of like halfway through, like he was dead dead and then he wasn't coming back. And also, you know, they have to work backwards, given what has already happened in the DCU, because Guy Gardner before this show was established as the Green Line to the Earth so why isn't Hal Jordan the Green Line to the Earth so to give that mystery and to make it I thought it was a very interesting bold storytelling that really worked for me yeah Jimbo I remember texting you or maybe it was a conversation we had before I'd seen anything of the show and I was just like Hal Jordan's not making it out this one is he because Kyle Chandler's name is conspicuous by his absence in the casting for Man of Tomorrow which has everybody in it except of course him and you just gave me an enigmatic smile.
13:19You didn't know at that point that they weren't going to bring him back but what's your take on that? Do you know what? It's interesting. I wasn't sure where this was going to go. I didn't realize that what they were going to do is not just not what you said which is resurrect him but do the complete opposite of that whereby they've also deleted the hologram. And I thought because I saw this ultimately as an ongoing concern as being like a buddy dynamic but one of them is a hologram. and I thought oh that's what it'll be so we're not going to get we're not going to get Hal and Jon Stewart but we're going to get Jon Stewart and the hologram and that's going to be the pairing and then in this it is essentially laid out what actually happens I do not know but it's laid out that Hal is now gone and you have that very emotional parting I love you scene which is fantastic and on the one hand part of me is just like if we get more seasons of this I need those two together because they're dynamite on screen but on the other hand that scene works so well and it's such a great send off I would almost be gutted if they undid that by bringing him back.
14:15So I'm really, really torn on it now. I think Hal is dead dead. And I like that, you know, consequences we talk about all the time, but I think that really works and everything that we get with Kelly MacDonald and Carl Chandler, the cast of that, it's just brilliant, by the way.
14:30Chris Hewitt: Well, how do you feel about Kerry not facing any consequences for essentially killing a Green Lantern? I buy John's line, final line, to somehow it's not what I think Hal would have wanted. and given that you know the final line to how to Kerry is I love you like you know and look how she repays him yeah I was gonna say can we talk about that a second like we've all lost our temper and been annoyed with someone in a conversation but she goes from 0 to 100 very quickly and then puts a bullet in his face that's harsh I'm saying that's harsh it's gonna be hard to walk her back and counsel yeah I think they're a bit beyond couples counseling Kerry why did you feel so angry to Howard you shot him in the face and where do you think your relationship can go from here I think I think the hologram has a chance to come back we don't know I mean in the show they say like charging the ring means you delete the hologram given the success of the show given the success of that pairing and what they can do given that it's a lantern made by Sinestro given that there's yellow streaks in the lantern we haven't really gotten down the yellow lantern core route yet maybe there's a way that Hal can come back as like a different maybe corrupted version of a hologram that whispers bad things in John's ear I don't know but I feel like that has a chance of happening more than Hal coming back in any way I have a question why does recharging the ring get rid of the hologram I don't think it's recharging the ring necessarily I think it's the fact that John is about to take possession of the ring and that deletes the backup copy of Hal which Hal made because that ring was Hal's So when he charges it and takes the oath, essentially, it's like factory default.
16:16Essentially, yeah. Return to factory settings, goodbye hologram. Okay, that makes sense.
16:21Chris Hewitt: He needs to take it to a genius bar. He does. A greenier spa. What about, I mean, I want to talk about so much for this show. I want to talk about the treatment of Hal and the depiction of Hal in the first four or five episodes. So it's kind of the Hal who's a bit over it and a bit past it and is obviously trying desperately and is afraid and is trying desperately to cling on to the ring. And I want to talk about John and his journey as well because I think the show does really, really great things in terms of leaving us with the best version of Hal and the best version of John, which is, you know, because John, the first four episodes is, you know, my God, what's that Philip Larkin line?
17:03Chris Hewitt: They really fuck you up, your mom and dad. They don't mean to, but they do. But they do. and my God, that kid has had a number done on him by his parents, and it's only when he finally faces up to the fact, or the knowledge that, you know what, I don't need the ring, I don't want the ring, it wasn't worth it, this kind of also wasn't really my choice. It's only in the 10 years between those two events that Jon Stewart begins to emerge as an actual live human being to get him to the point where at the end he can take the ring for himself and do what he wants to do. I think that's a really, really fascinating thing.
17:40Chris Hewitt: Before we get into those, real quick, Sinestro. So Sinestro says, he says, there's a little moment when they're having the conversation, John and Sinestro and the hologram, and he says, I can bring you back. If you charge the ring, I can bring you back. Now, is there a little tease there? I believe there's something to do with the Black Lantern Corps, which are kind of zombies. there might be something in that or is Sinestro just bullshitting to try and is he just saying what he wants so he can get off that rock? That is a very intriguing question and gosh there are so many different colours when it comes to the lantern corner I keep forgetting More than the rainbow Yeah I have no because I don't read DC Comics as you know so I had no baggage going into this I didn't care that Hal Jordan died because I have no attachment to Hal Jordan and I sometimes think that helped my enjoyment of it because I didn't have to get over any of that stuff that the baggage naturally brings.
18:42Like, if you're really invested in the world and the mythology and how it plays out in the comics, you maybe are going to kind of, there's going to be some friction there between maybe what you want to happen and what actually is happening. But I think it was actually useful to me to go in not really knowing anything about those characters and kind of accepting them for who they were on screen because I think one of the reasons why this show works so well is the character work in it is absolutely superlative. And I think, you know, I love the fact that Hal is, as I said to Carl Chandler, introducing him to the term a raging bellend when you meet him.
19:09And I love that. Like, he's old, he's over it, he's a bit jaded, but he's also massively insecure and a bit butt-sore that this guy's coming in and he's basically going to replace him. So you've got all of that going on. And then, in the meantime, you've got Stuart, who is essentially a kid who's been abused and brainwashed his entire life with this one goal. I mean, there's tiger parenting and then there's whatever the fuck that is. And that's an extraordinary bit of character work. And then to bring those two together in that sort of slightly chalk and cheese dynamic. It's the heart of this whole series, and I think it works so well.
19:40Chris Hewitt: It's terrific. It gets you to that point. I think it's the end of episode four. It might be the end of episode five, where the Manhunter has been revealed, and much of my shock when Zoe, whose truck was blown up, turned out to be the Manhunter just a few minutes later. But they have that fight, don't they, Hal and John? and I think the show's triumph is in that moment you don't want either of them to have the ring genuinely you don't want either of them to have the ring because you would think that naturally I think Hal is incredibly charismatic and he's very very funny and he's got this devil may care attitude and he's incredibly watchable but he is also a bit of a car crash of a human being and John is he's also damaged goods but he presents it in a very very different way and you don't want him to have the ring because in a way would justify everything that has happened to him to get him to this point.
20:35Chris Hewitt: You don't want Hal to have the ring because you don't want that version of Hal to win, to triumph. And it's really, really complex storytelling, I think, in that moment. It really, really is. I feel like Hal, John, and Noah have all been conditioned in a way by their parents. and much of the show is about can you overcome your conditioning? Or programming, which is an interesting word that they use quite a lot in the finale, isn't it? About listening to your programming and breaking your programming. Yeah, and that fascinated me. The conversation in the car between John and Noah in the finale is brilliant.
21:16And M.P.A., I feel like he gets less stoic as the season goes on and his performance gets better as the season goes on. The more he loosens up, I think he's just great. And there's a couple of really humorous moments. The funniest moment in this entire season for me is that gravesite conversation between Halogram and John. They're talking about Hal's funeral. And John is like, I was with Mogo. I was standing right here beside us. Like, Mogo's a planet. If you know your DC lore, you need to go to... And obviously, Hal points that out. And that was hilarious to me. So yeah, I've got the initial point.
21:52I was making but
21:52Chris Hewitt: no that's fine it's alright it doesn't matter yeah I was I was going to ask about about John and his progression as a character I think it's really really interesting but the show itself before we do that I keep saying that before we do that and we won't have time to do it but we will the show is called Lanterns Jimbo and I knew that again again going into it did you as someone who's not steeped in DC lore did you know the thing that there can only really be one Green Lantern at a time because I thought oh they're going to find a way at some point we're going to see Hal Jordan and Jon Stewart and maybe Guy Gardner as well we're going to see all three Green Lanterns together wielding their rings doing really really cool shit and the show doesn't really have the interest I was going to say not the budget but that's kind of you're absolutely right doesn't have the interest and I think that was a really smart move because you know you could easily I mean you couldn't because it is a part of it but I think the for want of a better word sort of super-powered, supernaturally stuff takes very much a backseat to the human drama, to the murder, to the character development, to kind of the talk of, you know, destiny and conditioning and expectation and birthright and all of these things.
23:04And, you know, look, I love a super-powered show. You know, I love explosions. I love powers being unleashed. I love the fact that this was so grounded and quite literally down to earth. I mean, they go off-world a little bit, but not a lot. And I think, again, it's a brilliant show because not only does that work dramatically, but it also doesn't alienate people who maybe wouldn't be on board with a superhero show. Weirdly, I think Lindelof did something very similar with Watchmen as well, which is a really grounded sort of earthy show, which has much broader appeal than I think maybe a more, shall we say, comic-centric show would do.
23:36The spectacle is really limited to episode five, which is fun, but the whole conceit of the season is that they treat the lantern ring as kind of like a service weapon. You don't draw it unless you absolutely have to, because, as Hal says, when you draw it, that's the ballgame because it is the most powerful weapon in the universe. Is it though? Not to get into a DC off with you because you'll win that, but I never really got the impression that it was like an Infinity Gauntlet, right? So, yeah, I can make a bird and this will be a big green snot shield that will stop bullets. But he didn't feel like he could snap half the universe away or anything like that.
24:10I mean, if we're comparing the Lantern Ring to the Infinity Gauntlet, then the Infinity Gauntlet is going to win. but in this universe yes the Green Lantern ring more useful than a cricket bat is what you're saying
24:21Chris Hewitt: I get it we could make a thousand cricket bats with it and green cricket bats yeah be very very fetching indeed yeah it is it is a very very powerful weapon and it's it's maybe this is something we'll get into in Man of Tomorrow or James Gunn we'll get into in Man of Tomorrow you know the idea that Green Lantern or our Green Lantern is seen to be as powerful potentially as Superman which is which is really really interesting You don't really get a sense of that here. No, you really don't. But there's that moment in Guns Superman where Guy Gardner goes toe-to-toe with Superman and you can just see him going, all right, bring it on.
24:57Chris Hewitt: I don't know how, and maybe you can help in this one, I don't know how Guy Gardner would fight someone who can move faster than he can see. Superman could punch Guy Gardner's face off quicker than Guy Gardner could lift his fist to power the ring to stop Superman punching his face off. You know what I mean? that just doesn't it seems like an unfair fight to me but yeah since the ring has roughly the same battery life as your average Apple watch and all he has to do is really just hang around for a while and then he'll be fine the Manhunter's tactic is just to wait him out yeah you don't have a child with you oh you're fucked mate who charges the lantern?
25:32it's a good question who charges the lantern? who watches the watchman? I think it's plugged in yeah there's a lantern there's a massive lantern battery in Oa which is always charged which charges all the rings across the universe.
25:46Chris Hewitt: That's very convenient. Almost as convenient to say as Noah the Manhunter breaking Sinestro out of prison off-screen just so Sinestro can off-screen create a handy lantern and ring in a forge that we have not previously seen in any episode. I thought that bit was a little bit spotty. I have a question. When he's charging the ring, what's he charging it with? Presumably it's not electricity. Because I always thought it was like a magic ring. But are we saying it's a piece of tech? Therefore, it needs like power to run. I don't know exactly what is in the lantern battery that is charging it. But you have to say the oath with it.
26:27Chris Hewitt: What is he, an expert on DC? So it's like having your passcode on your phone. If you don't say the oath, it won't charge properly. Basically, yes. But you can make up your own oath and it'll work fine. Okay, got it, got it. By richest jobs. By wealthiest cook. No, it's not working. Damn it. By USB.
26:48Chris Hewitt: All right, John Stewart. Mon, what did you think of his journey in the show over the course of the eight episodes before finally, of course, becoming a Green Lantern of sorts, but we suspect with a hint of fear. You have that thread running through the show, don't you? The idea of fear is something to actually be embraced. Fear is the mind killer, Chris. Fear is the mind killer. It is the little death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will... Anyway, go on. Speaking of little death, we see John has sex with Zoe a couple of times, right? Yeah. He does. He gets his manhunter out.
27:22Chris Hewitt: Yeah. Again, that was something that didn't quite work for me. It was one of the few notes that rang false over the first few episodes. You know, the idea that she's clearly picking him out. She's manhunting. But he doesn't... Manhunter-splaining. He doesn't seem like that sort of guy. is a very impetuous thing for him to do to suddenly have sex with someone and then to later on have sex with her again even though he knows that she's the wife of well he knows that she's the manhunter at that point right but yeah anyway anyway just a little thing but what do you think of the heart ones yeah but it's not the heart though is it it's the balls in that point so I don't know ain't nothing better than eating up another man's grill oh I don't This is so upsetting.
28:12Can we please make it stop?
28:13Chris Hewitt: That sounds so wrong coming from you. What? No. I'm just quoting the line. I know, but don't do it. If you say anything about him fingering the ring, I just don't even want to fucking hear it. So just keep that shit to yourself. You're the innocent one. You and Ben are the innocent ones of this podcast. We can't corrupt you with our filth. Come on, man. It is much too late for that. Oh, dear Lord. But John's journey. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Forgot about that. I thought it was really, really great. Really, really, really bold. I liked that it was an origin story that didn't have any dead parents to deal with so many superheroes.
28:52Have that, including how. But, yeah, John, they go another way. And I think episode three, I said it in my review, I think it's absolutely fantastic. Everything they do, diving into the racial themes inherent in this story, I think was just so compelling and so interesting. And the performances by J.R. Fonz Nicholson and Jasmine Seppis-Jones as John's parents, I think they're fantastic. I really like Jasmine Seppis-Jones especially. In this entire season, whenever she pops up, those conversations that she has with John are so interesting and loving. And she obviously... has a lot of expectations for what she wants John to become but at a certain point she allows him to chart his own path and I think that's partly why John ends up where he eventually does in the end that 10-year distance we were talking about was crucial to his development so yeah I thought it was brilliantly done and the fact that we haven't really had that many comics dealing with that to go off of made Tom King and Damon Lindelof and Chris Mundy be able to tell the story in a really fresh interesting dynamic way.
30:08Chris Hewitt: But John Stewart's been around since the 70s so he doesn't have an origin in that way? Doesn't really have an origin story. Obviously he's still the Green Lantern that I grew up with and I think many people who were pumped for this show had seen the Justice League animated series like me which was to me the greatest super animated series of all time. You've never mentioned him. No, I mean, he has an origin story, I guess, because he left The Daily Show when Trevor Noah took over, and then, of course, he came back. So we know a lot about his past. It's just not spelled out in the story. And they don't mention The Daily Show here.
30:39Chris Hewitt: Why is that? Very strange. Seems like a key moment in his life. A question to ask in the spoiler special interview, I'm sure. Yeah, maybe read it in one of your little comics. Maybe it'll be in there. Who knows? We've gotten some stuff with him in the military before in the cartoon. and in comments before, but never really spelled out the way that this show does, which is really interesting. And there are a lot of cool, bold choices that can cast the parents in a certain type of light, which James has already sort of mentioned. And there's definitely some stuff there. Oh, they're dreadful. They're absolutely dreadful.
31:19Look, you know, I'm not saying that I've read every book on parenting, but I'm saying if there is ever a point when you are shooting apples off your child's head with a gun, you're doing something wrong.
31:28Chris Hewitt: Yeah. Or when you bring your child to the worst part of town. Make your way home. And I know that John has had that conversation, obviously, with Kerry and the bleachers in the final episode where he says, you know, I can understand now that my mom, or mom, as he says, was holding her breath the entire time and it was like an incredible sacrifice. If anything had happened to me, her world would have been over. And I can see that you're holding your breath in the same way because your son is potentially an unstoppable killing machine. but I still don't know that even with that sort of newfound empathy that I 100 % bought the reconciliation at the end of the show where he goes back home and everyone's there and they're all having a big, big, big old hug.
32:13I don't think hug equals reconciliation.
32:16Chris Hewitt: It's a step along the road, surely, but these are people he's called Bernadette and I'm not sure what he has his dad down, probably John Senior in his phone. He won't even call them mum and dad. One of the things that excites me about potential season two of this show is what the dynamic between Jon and his family is now that he is the, I guess, unofficial Green Knight on the Earth. Another thing that excites me is what the Guardians will say to Jon telling them how it's going to be, which I think is going to be met with something. But yeah, I wouldn't say they're fully reconciled by a long shot.
32:51It was just a nice button to end the series.
32:54Chris Hewitt: How's that going to work, though? I mean, how is he going to, like he says to Guy Gardner, he says to Guy Gardner, he says, you know, you take the stars, I'll take the dirt. But how is he going to enforce that? Like Guy is off a metropolis. He's got the Justice Society they work with. He's not going to give up Earth anytime soon, right? Justice Gang? Justice Gang, sorry. That's a great name. That's right, yes. Such a good name, I forgot it. But clearly they're going to be called the Justice League at some point. But how is he going to enforce that? Like, they're going to be in two different places.
33:23Chris Hewitt: can't you have two Green Lanterns at the same time? It's not like there's a law against it. So if there had been two rings we could have had Hal and Jon ringing up, so to speak, at the same time. But, you know, I think it's good to have two Green Lanterns on Earth. I don't know. Couldn't have. But again, maybe the Guardians will change their minds. I don't know. I'm very intrigued to see what they will make of Jon laying down the law. But we shall see. I mean, one thing we should say that I really love about this show is that it has captured the fandom. I think the week-to-week theorizing, it was all over my timeline.
34:04It reminded me of when WandaVision first dropped and how people were discussing it. Lanterns did that for the DCU, and I don't think they really had that with any of their shows or films to this point. It was really, everyone was discussing it all the time, At least it was on my feed, which was really, really cool to see. Did you see any of this, James? No, I actually didn't. That did not appear in my feed at all. But it doesn't surprise me. Again, I think the quality for this speaks volumes. It really does feel like a really prestige TV show. I think it's been really well conceived and really well put together.
34:39And it works week to week as a kind of mystery as well and a character piece. Yeah, I mean, people can be denigrating of superhero stuff or not. But I put this up against any kind of dramatic TV show. I'm not saying it's the best thing on TV by any stretch, but it's a really solid example of one of the best shows of this year.
34:55Chris Hewitt: Let's talk about some other stuff before we wrap this bad boy up. Let's talk about some of the other characters. So the show is structurally quite interesting. So, you know, the first five episodes are dedicated mostly to what happens in 2016 in Rushville and to trying to figure out who the Manhunter is. Was that a surprise to you, by the way, when the identity of the Manhunter was revealed? I mean, I correctly guessed it. Oh, you're talking about Zoe? That one was a surprise. One that I probably should have seen coming. But yes, I was surprised by that. The Noah one, I guessed. But the structural thing you're talking about was interesting in a way because they would end episodes on major reveals and then not return to it until an episode after.
35:45I know that they were listening to interviews. switching things up, the order of things constantly. I think episode five was meant to be episode seven at one point and they kept switching it back and forth. But ultimately, I think they ended up with a good structure.
36:01Chris Hewitt: I think it's interesting because what it does is it pushes the focus towards the end of the show on who killed Hal Jordan. Yeah. Which I think is a more interesting and affecting story than who is the Manhunter. Even though the Manhunter thing has a lot of interesting stuff wrapped up in it. The idea of this town of Rushville is so indebted to the Manhunter that they are they basically blame Hal and John on everything going wrong even though it is Zoe's choice as much as anyone's to start that sort of all that war she's the one who's using the satellites to blow up half the town and it was interesting to me that Hal takes the blame he takes the fall for that figuratively and literally in that he was culpable to a degree not to a degree the person they should be angry with is the person who blew up half their fucking town.
36:51Chris Hewitt: Fair. Not the person who was trying to stop it. But if Hal and John just left the town, there would have been... But that violates their oath. I think it's like they're very invested in the Manhunter. The Manhunter is kind of the source. Like they will protect the Manhunter at all costs because they believe the Manhunter protects them. And so that's their person. So they blame everything on the outsiders who've essentially come in and upended the Applecart and disrupted their way of living. So you can understand why they have a certain amount of misdirected anger. But yes, logically from the outside, it doesn't make sense.
37:25But you can see why they go there, I think, from a motivational point of view.
37:28Chris Hewitt: Yeah, you can see it, but it doesn't quite sit well with me. But another thing that happens with the decision to switch, well, I don't know whether it's a decision or whether it just was a natural thing, but the focus on who killed Hal in the last three episodes. But one of the things about that is that we get this wonderful moment where the hologram appears behind Kerry Kane, played, of course, by Kelly MacDonald. And she has this amazing reaction to him, which, of course, you know, I felt at the time was because she looks like she's killed him. And obviously the hologram feels that as well. She killed me.
38:02Chris Hewitt: She killed me. The way she reacted is an amazing, amazing piece of acting. but one of the problems with leaving all of that stuff to the end is that we as viewers are mourning a relationship we didn't get to see and so it's only at the beginning of episode 8, the final episode that we really begin to see Hal and Carrie connect there's been little bits of flirtation in the previous episode but we don't get to see them really establish that relationship so when she's mourning it in episode 7 it's like well I don't know that I have the feeling the depth of feeling that I should have as a viewer or I should be emulating your sense of loss here and obviously I am because I'm sad about how but I'm not really feeling it for this relationship I thought that was an interesting thing structurally to do that I didn't really bump on it but I know what you mean you don't get the kind of establishing beats of that relationship so it feels quite abstract as we're watching it and you're right you don't have the kind of emotional connection to it by the end of the last episode you really do like you feel it but I think you needed it before the revelation that she shot him you had to have that otherwise you'd have just been like Alan Partridge gif shrug like alright whatever but actually by that point you've kind of earned the emotional impact of that scene it just yeah it definitely comes later than you would imagine they were prioritizing the mystery over any sort of special layering of that relationship before we see what happens and I think it worked did you see Kerry killing Hal did you predict that I mean for me it could have been only one of two people really properly it was either her or Noah when Halogram said it I was like yeah I think that's I think that's what's happened here but yeah it was interesting that conversation obviously where Noah takes the credit for it and John sees through him and goes Noah this guy is actually he's a good kid even though he is potentially the next Hitler.
40:04Chris Hewitt: Yeah. I like the the Brightburn aspect of this that is quite fun. Nature versus nature. Right. Like what is he going to become and is he going to become a problem? But I like the you know the fact that that Stuart accepts that but is willing to give him the benefit of the doubt while also saying I'm going to be keeping an eye on him. So like you know if he does step up I am going to come here and let's be honest probably get killed because I was just thinking about this like you know we talk about the ring as being this ultimate powerful device but actually like when they're trying to get into the compound, they're doing all kind of like subterfuge shit, like creating a digger to dig it.
40:37Just, if it's that powerful, just stroll in there and, you know, No, but they can't,
40:42Chris Hewitt: because they can't be found. So, they can't be seen. Otherwise, it'll trigger everything. Hence the subterfuge. Yeah. Yeah. But it's pretty cool. I think it was the coolest use of the ring in the show, because mostly it was bubbles. You have to scale back these things. And I think, you know, for the plot to have jeopardy, for the plot to have stakes, if you're going to have a god-like MacGuffin, you have to scale that the power of it. Even if it's just like, oh, you know, it's only on 5 % charge. That's actually a great thing, because then that ration, it's like it's a spawn thing, isn't it? You've got loads of unlimited power, but you actually don't have unlimited power because you literally don't have unlimited power, and it will run out of charge.
41:18Yeah. Yeah. But I like the fact that one of the things that makes John distinct from his other lanterns is how detailed his constructs are. You can see that with the construction of the digger. You can see that with the construction of the watch in his interview scene. And also, he is powerful enough to not even need the ring to make constructs like he does with the bird, which is another interesting detail. Yeah, what's going on there? I feel like that's all part and parcel of the fact that this man has been conditioned and trained his entire life to do this thing. In a very unhealthy and abusive way.
42:00but weirdly he is the most qualified to be the lantern by far because that's all he's ever been trained to be and so he has this mental fortitude and he has the ability and the clarity of thought to do all the things that a lantern needs to do he just ultimately doesn't have the will to do it because of how he was made yeah
42:21Chris Hewitt: whereas Hal of course just kind of had the ring given to him yes he obviously passed the test I mean is it as simple as just the ring the ring what kind of scans your personality before it goes, are you afraid? And then, off it goes. Yeah. Yeah. And they've changed their policy after Sinestro killed all of them. It's like, are you afraid? Also, are you a massive psycho? We should probably have asked that first. But the Guardians kind of are as well, right? That's very heavily implied that they created the Manhunters themselves and then have eradicated their creations and aren't exactly on the up and up themselves.
42:59Chris Hewitt: I mean, they're literally encouraging Jon Stewart to replace Hal Jordan by any means necessary really it's all a bit sort of like office politics isn't it all that stuff yeah what do you think of Laura Linney showing up as a character whose name I can't remember of insert guardian name here Leanna Leanna yeah no I thought she was great I love the dynamic between her and Jon again I keep saying episode 3 is just so so good the non Lilia storytelling is I think just really really well done the way that it's bookended with John sort of falling through the black portal I thought when I saw how that episode ended to bring it back I was like oh that's so smart that's so genius so yeah I thought she was great I didn't expect to see more of her in this show going forward beyond just I think it's episode 3 and episode 5 that she shows up but again maybe that's something They're saving for season two, because it's grossed.
44:01Chris Hewitt: Yeah, it'd be really fascinating to see how they react to the fact that Jon's basically going rogue, and will that lantern be infected with fear, and will that turn him evil at some point, maybe? Or at least can maybe conflict him morally? No, see, I actually think, because this show, like the theme of this show, Beyond Grief, and I think grief is a big part of it, because you've got, you know, grief for parental figures, grief for a life that, you know, was taken from them, you know, there are lots of sort of layers to that, but fear is the theme, the sort of vocal, emotional sort of, I guess, center point of the show and what fear means to different people for how its obsolescence, you know, is being replaced, you know.
44:38For Jon Stewart, it's very different and there's that very pointed line where he says like, you know, he's like, I'm a black man in rural Nebraska so obviously their ideas of what fear is is very different but I think at the end what we're supposed to take away from it is like suppressing fear and not having, like fear is a valuable thing, it's what keeps people alive, it's a survival trait. What's the line, you know, show me something without fear and I'll show you like an endangered species or an extinct species. I saw you on an extinction. Exactly. And that's 100 % true. And I think what he realizes at the end, it's like being a lantern is not about being without fear.
45:08It's about using that fear and harnessing it. And I think actually, rather than it sort of having a negative connotation, I think it's definitely sort of framed as a strength here. Do not be afraid to be afraid.
45:18Chris Hewitt: Yes. That's not something that really flies that much in the Green Lantern comics, right, Amon? Because you have Sinestro, he breaks away and he forms a Sinestro core and they're powered by yellow lanterns and fear, but they're baddies, right? So is there a sense that Jon might get corrupted by that? Potentially. I mean, given how he came into possession of that lantern and who made it and the yellow streaks on that lantern, I would not be surprised if they go that route in season two and beyond. I don't think this is the last we have heard from Sinestro at all. Now, having said that, wouldn't the smart thing to do with Sinestro be that once because they still have the portal right?
46:00Chris Hewitt: We need to talk about the portal. That will get them back to that planet I'm not sure what planet that is. They leave him there. Yes. Now that's what's he going to fucking eat in this desolate dead world? Yeah he's like I've got to be some castaway it's like there's not a lot of coconuts here mate I think you're in trouble. Yeah. I feel well Chris Mundy I think has given an interview in the wake of this episode dropping about how Sinestro was able to stay alive in the first place on the planet. And apparently Noah gave him some supplies when he broke him out of... I love stuff that happens off camera.
46:38Chris Hewitt: Yeah. So I imagine that John, being the decent man he is, will give Sinestro some supplies as he keeps him locked up in that. Or maybe take him back to whatever prison the Guardians had him in initially. I think the smart thing to do for John maybe to take him back to prison. He doesn't seem to have done that. Yes, he seems to have just left him there. But I'm sure he's back. And also Ulrich Thompson is fabulous. Yes. I would like to see more of him. He is excellent as Kai Proctor in my beloved Banshee. So yes, I'm a fan. I would have liked to have seen, like I said, that jailbreak. And I would also like to have seen more of a sense of what a formidable threat the Manhunter is.
47:20Chris Hewitt: Because we keep being told throughout the thing that this thing is incredibly, incredibly deadly. And didn't really get that sense? I get that desire, but I think they get a wave with it because I guess the biggest scene when it comes to how formidable Manhunters are is when John has been kidnapped by whatever alien race is after the Manhunter. And they have this gun that sort of imparts the memories of the Dead Planet. Now, in another show with a bigger budget, I'm sure we then go to the actual flashback and we see everything. We say this as if there's like a low-budget thing where they were eating dust at Caps or a mummy.
48:04But in this show, it's just MMPR and his reactions to the gun. And for me, all the hurt, the torment, everything he's feeling, you can see across his face. So I think they get away with showing the formidableness of the Manhunters in that moment especially.
48:24Chris Hewitt: Yeah, I mean clearly you're very technologically capable but I would have liked to have seen a bit more of the Killing Machine. We get a little sense of Zoe as Killing Machine when she saves Kelly MacDonald from those two dickheads from Gotham who were clearly sent out by Bruce Wayne. Hey, stop. Okay now. He would never. But I don't know, I just needed to see a bit more of her as Killing Machine rather than her hiding behind her entire town and its formidable arsenal and the satellites as well. Oh, by the way, I love that sequence where they go to the abattoir and the cow gets lasered. And I said to my wife, that's why John's vegan.
48:58Chris Hewitt: Two seconds before John went, that's why I'm vegan. So it's good. We were simpatico. We bonded as one showing me for just two seconds, but it was nice. But yeah, I would have liked to have seen more of her. When they say Manhunter, we don't mean that, because I thought they were building up for maybe Martian Manhunter, but that's something different. I had a question. is that a different thing? What, Martian Manhunter? Yeah, because my assumption from this and not knowing anything about it was like the Manhunter's presumably a thing from the comics, right? Yes. I just assumed that in the comics they were called Martian Manhunters but that's a goofy name and they changed it.
49:33Okay. No, Martian Manhunter is a completely different thing. He's an alien from Mars who can shapeshift and read minds and yeah, he's awesome. And what are Manhunters in the comics? In the comics, Manhunters are robots built by the Guardians. So they have this line which they repeat, no man escapes the Manhunter. and well they're a bit on the nose aren't they this is Kenobi all over again in blackest day in brightest night
50:00Chris Hewitt: wait that's wrong no no man shall escape my hunt because I am a massive anyway let's what were you saying I'm on oh gosh so yes in the comics and in the cartoons they are these kind of red clad machines who who are very deadly and have these energy batons and all the rest of it. They obviously are going in a very different route with this show. But I like what they do with it. It's interesting. Did this show do anything for you? All you guys have done is rag on it for the last hour. Did this show do anything for you that was better than Martin Campbell did with the Green Lantern movie? I know it's a high bar, but was there anything that you thought, oh yeah, they've nailed that in a way that Martin Campbell did not in that masterpiece?
50:51Chris Hewitt: everything? Wow. Okay. There were some things that I don't think it did quite well. Like the whole, in the 2026 storyline, the whole extortion plot line. Oh, that was, yeah, that was dumb. That was silly. That didn't quite work for me. So, no, it can't get everything right. She was a kid with a watch, right, in episode five. Yeah, but that, I think, was about guilt, wasn't it? It was about reckoning with the past, and it was taking accountability for your actions. So it was a nice character beat at the end that he gives the bag of money. But she didn't deserve it. No, she didn't. But then, I don't think it was about her, I think it was about him.
51:28I think that was an act of atonement. There's one more thing I'd like to mention. That's one of the best moments of the show. But Hal's funeral speech is brilliant. Very funny. I hope I mattered really. It hit hard.
51:42Chris Hewitt: Oh, yeah, yeah. Of course you go, you go for the emotion. I was just thinking about the jokes. Because there were some good gags in there. Mr. Mr. Mrs. President or the first lady first man. Yeah, he thinks he's going to the assembled superhero. He thinks that everybody is going to come. It's just an ex-girlfriend and an ex-partner. But cool that we got Carol Ferris sort of on the show. Wish we saw more of her on the show. She's in the comics. Carol Ferris is The Blake Lively character. Ah, I see. That's what I'm meaning to know. I was going to say she is the MJ to house Peter but sure that works well yeah I don't that felt very fanservice-y to me a little bit of fanservice not a bad thing sometimes what did you think of Earl?
52:33Chris Hewitt: oh Earl I wanted to talk about Earl yes yes yes feed me Seymour yes loved Earl Little Shop of Horrors coming out in 4K UHD later on in the month very very exciting yeah Earl was cool I do have questions about how Earl survived the house fire yeah but that's fine did Earl survive the house fire of course he did because oh yeah good point we've seen him since yeah yeah good point he seems to be totally fine well we can assume that Noah is a plant lover and therefore you know repotted Earl when they hummed plant hunter yes no plant shall escape my hunt yeah I also like that we see multiple instances that John does not need the Ving to handle himself in the fight.
53:18Chris Hewitt: Yes. Kicks the shit out of those five guys. He does. One, two, three. I can kick the shit out of five guys at lunchtime. That doesn't mean I know him. Yeah, that was good. I also really, really liked the bit in, I've got to wrap it up. I really, really liked the bit where Hal, John, has been waiting for months to kill this dude and then Hal just swings in and Green Lanterns the shit out of it. It's very, very funny. I hope that they focus on those two guys going forward in season two. if there is to be a season two. But if you're listening to this, James Gunn, and I know you are, then do please bring back Hal Jordan and Kyle Chandler.
53:53Chris Hewitt: And make a mid-deanna-jones while you're at it. On that note, that is it for our Lantern Supporter special. Goodbye to Amon, and thank you. Peace. Thank you to James. Goodbye, Chris. And it's goodbye for me. I'm off to recharge my iPhone. Oh, no, it's fucked. You didn't say the oath. Yes, yes. I didn't read the tears to seize. That's my problem. Thanks for listening. See you next time. Bye-bye. You
Now that the first season of Lanterns, the HBO Max show that throws not one but two Green Lanterns, Kyle Chandler's Hal Jordan and Aaron Pierre's John Stewart, into a deadly investigation in a small Nebraskan town, has come to an end, it's time for the Empire Podcast to swear an oath to have a big old chat about what might just be one of the best TV shows of the year. Join Chris Hewitt, James Dyer, and Amon Warmann as they try to talk about their favourite moments from the eight episodes before they run out of charge. Enjoy.