


Pilot Plus discusses Netflix’s limited series Below (created/written by Jesse McKeown), starring Josh Hartnett as a Newfoundland ice-fisherman whose childhood sighting of something in the sea returns decades later during “coming home” year. The island’s economy centers on harvesting pure ice for vodka; the show blends monster-movie suspense with Jaws-like set pieces, eerie isolation, and horror moments (including an especially gnarly opening/episode-1 finale). Guests/hosts also debate multiverse storytelling (The OA vs Marvel), soap opera value, and Celebrity Traitors.
No external guests appear; the “guests” are the podcast hosts (James Boyd, Steph, Boyd, plus mentions of Alex/Danay/Phil/others as correspondents).
Below is propulsive, bingeable, visually distinct (not “typical Netflix”), and heavily influenced by Jaws (including specific shot/setups). Not a comedy, but with levity.
resettlement house stuck at sea; boy sees something in water; “get out of the water” beach moment; Snook’s Arm welcome shot; dolly zoom; ice-vodka money system.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion of Below's premise, including resettlement and family dynamics.
“And what we're actually seeing is we're seeing what is called a resettlement.”
Insights into characters and the unfolding mystery in Below.
“It's like Canadian Irish is what I would describe it as.”
Discussion on the potential monster aspect of Below and its influences.
“The tagline to the whole show is something's in the water.”
Analysis of the show's visual style and its resemblance to Jaws.
“Meet Close Encounters of the Third Kind in certain bits.”
Final reflections on the series, including themes of isolation and character portrayals.
“And I was thinking, yeah, 18, that's heavy, hefty.”
Discussing themes of isolation in a science fiction context.
“I have to say, the one issue I had with it is I thought when you found out that he had three children.”
A debate on the nature and implications of multiverses in storytelling.
“But what I will say in a continuation of John's post is that Tom also wrote in to talk about the multiverse.”
Discussion on the significance of soap operas in British TV culture.
“John, in another branch of the multiverse, maybe we're the same person.”
Discussion on the term 'soapy' in the context of TV shows like Downton Abbey.
“But I try not to use it too much, but Soapy as a way of describing a show that is trying not to be a soap opera, if you like.”
Analyzing the new season of Celebrity Traitors and sharing personal opinions.
The hosts discuss the quality and reception of reality shows like The Traitors.
“I urge you to carry on because just for Richard E.”
Listeners' feedback and hosts' thoughts on the Scrubs reboot and its critiques.
“And I think the thing is, again, when we're talking about pejoratives, I think when we say reality TV, we use that as a pejorative.”
Discussing their disappointment with the pilot episode and past experiences with Scrubs.
“hold our hands i hold my hands up and say i didn't enjoy the pilot the first episode at all and I didn't wash anymore.”
Speculating on future episodes and the uncertain review schedule for upcoming shows.
Excitedly announcing upcoming guest Russell T. Davis and discussing his memoir.
“podcast is we're going to have a guest in the studio with us aren't we boydy yes oh sorry that's very loud I shouted yes that was a big yes sorry you surprised me with that with that exciting news yes Russell T.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Pilot TV+, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:07Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters. And today we are going down below. Not in a weird sex way, but in a Netflix way, because Josh Hartnett's limited series Below, written and created by Jesse McKeown, is landing on the Netflix. And it stars Hartnett as a man in Newfoundland dealing with something that lives below the waves. A man who sells ice for a living, which I didn't actually know was a thing. Steph, why don't you tell us about life under the sea? Okay, so Josh Hartnett, so it opens on a gigantic house being transported across the water. As you do. As you do.
0:49And what we're actually seeing is we're seeing what is called a resettlement. So in what I'm calling Newfoundland, right, people would resettle from one island to another because it was too expensive for the government to resource small islands. Okay. So when there was only a few people in there, they were like, no, let's just get them where there's more people and then it's less money. And we'd have to like send a load of resources there. So let's just resettle everyone. And people got paid to be resettled. Okay. That's the setup. The setup is people in this part of the world get resettled. However, aboard this tiny boat, which is pulling this gigantic house, a mother, two children and a dad, and the person who's in charge of the resettling.
1:36I know this sounds like a lengthy setup, but it's very important. Okay, so - Tell us more about the settling, Stan. So then, what happens is there's, it gets stuck. The house gets stuck and it's like, what is going on? What's going on? So the dad asks you to, when it's not scary and there's not scary music at all, you go and investigate. So he then goes aboard the house only to never return. This is not a spoiler because this happens in literally the opening scene. And then the young boy aboard the boat sees something in the water, but he's not entirely sure what he sees, but he definitely sees something.
2:16And then we fast forward 40 years later, 40 years later, we meet that little boy again. He is now turned into Josh Hartnett. And Josh Hartnett is living on the island where he was resettled with his family. And he now has a family of his own. And the setup is, it is coming home year. What that means is all the people who have fleed the island to go and start a new life are coming back and his children are coming back. And there we begin the journey to find out if something strange is happening, no spoilers, on this island. And if that is to do with something that he saw in the water. The other very important thing to know is the people on this island are all fishermen.
2:56So they make all of their money from fishing, but mostly fishing for ice. So there's a certain type of vodka which uses this specific ice. And if you could get a big, massive chunk of this pure ice that's come into the island, then you can get money. And that is how Josh Hartnett, the Penny family, that's how they make their money. And that is the setup. Thanks, Steph. you're welcome I don't this is a really I'm just going to say this now this is a really hard one obviously I've done a lengthy set up this is a really hard one to not talk about without spoiling any of it and the reason I know that it's really hard not to spoil it is because this is a six part miniseries Netflix six part miniseries and boys I've boxed it off I've watched the whole bloody I've watched the whole bloody bloody thing right now to no one's great surprise really are you not surprised by that no you love watching these whole things i mean it's very it's very um good it's a good thing i am telling you now there was another show which will go into the main pod which i watched and it and it had an incredibly huge impact on me and i do you know what i needed i needed something a little bit horrorish a little bit otherworldly and a possible with a possible monster in it and this ticked my box a possible monster a possible monster in it a possible sea creature in it or cephalopod cephalopod anyway a stephalopod is what we've got on this podcast oh nice um i watched the first one now i'm going to encourage you all to put aside any initial fears you have about josh hartnett's accent in this and everybody else's accent okay because can we clarify what that accent is it's It's kind of, it sounds a little bit, it's a Newfoundland accent and it's a little bit kind of Irish-y.
4:48It is. It's like Canadian Irish is what I would describe it as. So, yes. So, once you get past that, because sometimes it does take a little while to get past it, then you have got to bed in, lean into everything strange that happens. And then I'm telling you now, this is full throttle entertainment. For me, I watched three on Saturday and three on Sunday, and I thoroughly enjoyed every single one of them. What I would say is in the first episode, it takes a little bit of time to get going. So I would say in kind of the last third, the third act, you're like, okay, this is going. And then it ends on one of the greatest scenes ever of people being found at sea, I would say, in terms of things that have happened to them at sea and then what you see when the light shines on them.
5:36Again, not giving it away, not giving it away. But yeah, I was fully in. Charlie Heaton from Stranger Things. If you like anything, kind of a little bit, is it a little bit, you're like, is this sci-fi? Is this monsterish? Is this, what is this? Trust me, you're going to find out and you are going to love it. And I'd be really surprised if people don't just binge the hell out of this because I did. I couldn't stop watching it because it was so propulsive. I was like, I need to find out what happens. I need to find out what that thing is. I need to find out if it's really a thing or if it's in people's minds.
6:05I need to find out this mystery, that mystery. It's so brilliantly signposted all the way through of like, you need to get to the next bit to see this. You need to get the next bit to see this. And I did. The characters are all kooky. They're as kooky as their accents are. If you're from Newfoundland, Canadian, Irish, and you have that accent, it is a great accent. Don't think I'm not casting a special for the accent, but just take a little bit of time. And Newfoundland listeners will be furious. But yeah, I absolutely loved it. I loved every single second of it. And when it got to the end, I was also very happy.
6:40What did you two think? I think it's really funny how in this world where James is trying to impose non-spoiler issues, you can't even say that it's a monster. The tagline to the whole show is something's in the water. What's that coming over the hill? Yeah, but you don't know what it is in the water. I'm not about to tell you. Well, it's a thing, isn't it? This whole thing is a monster movie. It's a six hour... To be fair, it starts with a monster. The first episode ends with a monster. We won't say what the monster is, but there is something in the water. There is something in the water. It's funny.
7:13I'm amazed you didn't mention Widow's Peak because the setting is literally... Well, I would have mentioned Widow's Bay. Widow's Bay. You can mention Widow's Peak as well if you want, but Widow's Bay would be more pertinent. Well, I was going to say, actually, it's very, to me, it's kind of a mix of Widow's Bay meets George... George meets... George. George Jaws. George Jaws. George Jaws. George Jaws. Meet Close Encounters of the Third Kind in certain bits. Oh. Yeah, there's a bit. There's a bit. You haven't got to that bit. Is there a UFO in it? You haven't got to the bit. I've only watched two episodes.
7:45Yes, exactly. It's very heavily early episodes of Widow's Bay. The setting, this island kind of, if you like. But it's not funny at all. No. Well, I was just about to say, minus the comedy, There is a little bit of levity in terms of sometimes Charlie Heaton's character. Yeah. He's kooky. But it's not a comedy, unlike Widow's Bay, which was an out-and-out comedy horror. This is like horror with little inflections. But it's very indebted to Jaws. And in fact, it's so indebted to Jaws, I had to look up the kind of birth of this show, if you like. And to be fair, the creator completely credits Jaws.
8:25He says it's basically the setup of the whole show is Newfoundland, Jaws in Newfoundland, with a mysterious beastie in the water. And there are certain shots, there's a shot where the camera pans across the welcome to whatever the island is called. Snook's Arm. Snook's Arm, which is literally taken from Jaws. Oh, no, there's an actual scene. Have you seen the scene? Sorry, you didn't talk about it. Yeah, there's an actual scene indeed as well, I guess, aboard the boat. But that's fine because Jaws is literally one of the greatest films of all time. One of my favourite films of all time. But the colour palette is also very Jaws.
8:59It looks very Jaws-y. The direction, there's that thing that Seamus Bielke did with Roy Scheider on the beach. What's it called, James, that thing with the camera pulling in and out? Oh, yeah, that shot where they go in and out, in on his face and then out on his side. What's it called? Dolly Zoom. Dolly Zoom. They do a Dolly Zoom. Anyway, there is no finer filmmaker or film to be influenced by, so that's all fine. and I think Joshana is really good the accent is takes some getting used to but that's fair enough funnily enough Joshana right in my mind there was a period in like not so long ago maybe five six years ago where he wasn't getting that much work and now it feels like he's had a full renaissance with he was in Oppenheimer and he was in Black Mirror he was in a brilliant episode and he's also in Verity that was out last week Verity exactly the film Verity and he did a Q &A with me at the BFI not so long ago, and he was wearing a delightful cardigan, I have to say, and he was very friendly.
9:57So it feels like a renaissance for him, but this is like the big out-and-out lead role in this whole thing. He drives the whole show, doesn't he, with the characters who play his sons, et cetera. But I think he does really well. I think he's really good in it, kind of believable as this, you know, masculine fishing man who's fishing for ice, this weird ice stuff that they put in the vodka that turns out not to be that healthy. Anyway, all in all, I did enjoy it. I didn't feel – I'm interested that you went through the whole thing in classic Seth style for shows you like. I watched the first two, and I'm kind of in a medium, like, yeah, I'll carry on watching it, but it's not feeling completely important that I watch it all now.
10:39I didn't have that kind of obsessive desire to watch it instantly, because I've got a lot of other stuff to watch, partly. When we're talking about Jaws, we're talking about literally – and again, I don't mind this at all – ripping the ripping scenes from Jaws there is an actual scene okay James you cut this out if this is a spoiler but there's an actual scene where Josh Hartnett's character goes to a beach and literally weaves between the crowds and says get out of the water get out of the water get and it's like it's like oh I am actually just just watching Jaws but like I said I love Jaws and I I think for me what really it sounds ridiculous but the color palette the color palette really kept me watching this so i was like oh i i loved that so much it really like drew me in they used the they used the setting really well in the sea and god they really did and didn't jesse say that like didn't he say that he wanted that he thought that this would be such a great place to set this kind of horror which also which also belies the theory the the oft expressed theory that netflix insists on a certain visual um palette for its its shows because this doesn't look like a normal netflix show to me um it looks more like an apple tv show i would say in fact and jaws um so it looks really good yeah i i'm enjoying it it's not like i don't think it's quite peak it's not widow's bay peak oh it's not widow's bay no widow's peak bay but what then again what is um so yeah i'm enjoying it i would say i think you just said this jose i think you know what it is it's a it's like a six part just monster film and and if you're just in it for kind of like a not as extreme as kind of Godzilla but if you're in it for sort of that kind of like there's a monster what's going to happen are they going to defeat it you know those kinds of like scenes of like people gathering stuff and getting it in their van and going to see and stuff like all that kind of stuff then like it's it's pure entertainment it's pure entertainment um but and that's what kept me watching it did you notice did you notice the official Netflix certificate for this is 18?
12:41And I was thinking, yeah, 18, that's heavy, hefty. Because for some stuff to get 18 in cinemas, it has to be pretty full on in this day and age. Does it get gnarly, Steph? It does. But all the way through, I'm thinking, oh, it's not that bad. And then you get to the finale of actually episode one, and that does get quite gnarly. That's what I mean. That end of that episode is amazing. And there are some bits in it that are like, oh, I can't watch that. um so yeah i can see why i can see why it's an 18 but yeah even down to yeah i can't give that away sorry i was going to say something there's elements literally ripped from jaws and ripped from um you haven't got because you're not into you're not further on than two episodes but there's literally people ripped from it i'm not going to say anymore i'm not going to say anymore uh well it borrows from jaws but i would argue if i'm going to be if i'm going to equal your nerdiness, Steph.
13:31I would say it borrows from Beast, which is another Peter Benchley book. So I think there's a lot of that in there as well. I think one of the reasons why this works, and you have touched upon this, so it's not a fucking revelation, but the setting is so distinctive. This idea of this sort of very isolated place where they've come to and they may be leaving. Is it a transition place? Is it a destination? It's a place that's sort of like drowning in entropy where the fishing industry has kind of evaporated. Industry no longer exists. jobs aren't really there it's in a state of decay and despair and it almost feels slightly detached from the world we live in like it feels almost like an alien place like imagine this is a science fiction show and actually you could totally carry that as a weird frontier colony on another planet and i think that sense of geographic and cultural isolation really feeds into this really well the other thing that makes us feel like a sci-fi is josh hartnett is 48 years old what is he drinking what is his skincare regime i want to know because it's insane because It's like, you know, Charlie Heaton goes, hey, Dad, I'm like, I'm sorry, what?
14:32I have to say, the one issue I had with it is I thought when you found out that he had three children. Yeah, who all look in their late 20s and 30s. I did think this just seems inconceivable, but it's mostly because Josh Hartnett, he obviously is conceivable for a 48-year-old to have three children, but it's mostly because Josh Hartnett looks, he literally looks like he's walked off Pearl Harbor and onto this set. So he looks incredible. He's maddening and a full head of hair as well. I did look this up. I looked up because I had the same thing. I think Josh's character would have to be 16 when he became a father.
15:06You can totally believe, not to throw shade at Newfoundland, but you can totally imagine that that was the case given that character and his background in his arc. Yes, but also that becomes kind of part of it. The fact is that they live in these kind of, not incestuous, but very kind of like close quarters and people do marry people off the island. Not incestuous. I'm glad you threw that in there, just so we know, Steph. In that way, in no incestions. I like to be clear. I'm just saying, you know, it is kind of, you know, they live in these close quarters. These are very kind of closed communities in lots of ways.
15:37They live in closed communities. They live in closed quarters, and so they would naturally end up having sex with their relatives. Yeah, absolutely. Totally, Steph. That makes an absolute sense. I'm just saying. I really hope the Newfoundland branch of the listenership isn't what you'd say. I said not incest. I said not incest. The more you say not, the worse it gets. All I'm hearing is incest, incest. Anyway, let's move on. I'm enjoying this. I'm enjoying it more because it is a limited six-part series. Weirdly, that is the reason why I will probably watch the rest of this. Whereas if it was an eight-part ongoing concern, I would have tapped out by now.
16:11How many have you watched? I've just watched the first one. I am so surprised you didn't watch it because it very much taps into the kind of things that you and I really love. It's like a mystery with a monster and it's got a sci-fi element. I was like, I am full in on this. and you're gonna by the end of it i think you're gonna love it we should do a spoiler special because i'd be really interested to see what you think of the ending and also how this progresses because there's i mean there's some incredible one-liners like we're saying ripped from classic films in this and just even that that's a whole discussion right there because if you're if you're a cinephor like we all are you're like oh my god oh my god i can't believe they said that exact word i can't believe they've done that exact shot it's yeah it's it's brilliant i i love it i think people will really like this because it's yeah it's a lot of fun i brilliant is perhaps not a word that i would use but i think it's good i think it's quality i think there's there's fun stuff here um and i want to see how it ends so it's only six parts as the only person who's watched every single episode i'm gonna say brilliant so thumbs up to the cephalopod from the stephalopod yes indeed okay and that is available now on the netflix boydy yes it is available as we speak in below then on the netflix okay let us move on to this week's postbag
17:39okay i've got a few things to go through here uh now i am not going to continue my ongoing feud with john about what is or is not a multiverse although he has responded and bless him he said lots of very nice things but it's quite a long message uh and his point just to kind of summarize is the distinction between timelines and the multiverse which is a fair point it's a fair point to make i don't disagree with it although i think that things do get conflated quite a lot and obviously the whole point of the multiverse is that every timeline is a separate universe uh but yeah i i totally get what you're saying john i've obviously just been trolling you so do not feel that i am disregarding you by not reading out your your email but it's more just to safeguard people's sanity at this point from this ongoing conversation I'm putting it in the same basket as all conversation about the most recent brackets terrible series of Reacher.
18:29But what I will say in a continuation of John's post is that Tom also wrote in to talk about the multiverse. And again, quite a long email echoing a lot of the stuff that John said. But I want to pull out a particular paragraph for you, Boydie, specifically towards the end here. And he says, I was particularly surprised, aghast, nay appalled, to hear Boyd coming for multiverses. Since what is the magnificent OA if not a multiverse story? Spoilers for an almost 10-year-old show, but if Brit Marling's character can avoid certain death by just hopping to another universe, should, quote Boyd, as smug as possible, please, James, why should I care?
19:10The sincere answer, of course, is that the writers, directors, and actors did an excellent job of making us care about the characters as they ideally should in any show or film multiverse or otherwise oh my god i never even thought about that boyd what have you got to say boyd first of all it's it's different because it's a whole the whole of the oa is about what is what is happening and it being a multiversal story that is an explanation of what is happening but it's it's the whole it's the whole kind of you know it's like saying The premise is it's a multiverse. You're right. Yeah, but also the fact that it is that is one of the – I mean, it is a spoiler.
19:47You know, it's like – you don't go into it going, oh, we're going to – this is – where we're going to extricate ourselves from this bit of story is to build in multiverses, which we can have guest appearances from five different actors playing the same role or five different – do you know what I mean? It's not like that. It's not using it as a device. It is the show. It is the crux of the show. Or is it? You know, is this a multiverse? Is this what's happening? And so that is why it's different, if you can get my meaning. But I take on board, I'm not against multiverse stories entirely forever in all cases.
20:17I'm not against in Marvel either. I just personally, I felt that the multiverse, the use of multiverses as an idea and a concept in the Marvel Cinematic Universe became stale for me quite quickly and made me care less about the individual characters for the reasons I've mentioned. But the OA is just a completely different thing. I get it. it's using a similar concept multiverse but it's different i wonder whether the criticism there is is kind of as you say it's not really about multiverses is it it's kind of about storytelling isn't it and i feel like definitely with the marvel movies the storytelling has become a bit wobbly and i think part of that is the multiverse stuff hasn't landed in the way they maybe hoped it would um and i think it always comes back to me with there is a natural i think human aversion to any story that leans on a deus ex machina kind of like solution to a plot problem and it feels like multiverses are all too often used as exactly that a kind of crutch for slightly lazy storytelling or a way of resetting things or a way of taking away consequences or and ultimately leasing your investment in a story and characters so i think maybe multiverses aren't the problem it's just bad storytelling that's the issue yeah i mean i don't think you could levy that against the oa because that is an absolutely incredibly crafted piece of storytelling.
21:36One of the greatest TV shows of the 21st century, according to the New York Times. Well, I would agree with that. And I think, I get what you mean, Boyd. It's not quite the same, is it, as it's a simple, yeah. It's like the ending of the LA, season two, one of the great endings of all time, as I bag on about regularly, is much more audacious and surprising and shocking and kind of extraordinary than the way the Marvel Cinematic Universe uses its version of multiverses. So that's, you know, I rest my case with that. You know, it's just, what they're doing is different and weird and mysterious. It's more of an intricate, yeah.
22:09It's not just saying, oh, in this alternative universe, the same characters are doing this thing slightly different, but they're still, you know, and allow us to do storytelling that is a little bit kind of cheating, if you like, cheating the viewers to which version of the characters they should care more about as in the original. But yeah, the OA is heavily invested in that kind of idea. And it's different. Agreed. You came for the OA and unfortunately... Well, I think they came. We've all agreed. We've come together. And to prove that we've come together, I'm going to go back to my multiversal adversary, my Kang, if you will, John, who in his email about the multiverse, he did mention you, Steph.
22:50And I want to go specifically to that paragraph and read that out. He says, Recently, in the patriarch's cancelling of female-led shows, and incidentally, I'm a middle-aged Scottish heterosexual man. I loved Ride or Die and it should not have been cancelled. There we go, Steph. Incidentally, Steph, you should check out DIRR, D-I-R-R-A-H from Detroit. I have never seen so many funny, kick-ass women in a crime drama who have the profane vocabulary of merchant semen. And it has Morris Chestnut. It's brilliant and you will love it. Oh, I will. That does sound like I love it. Okay, thank you very much for that recommendation.
23:21Thank you, John. John, in another branch of the multiverse, maybe we're the same person. Who knows? Let me leave that nightmare fuel with you there. We have a message here from Alex. And Alex's headline is, enough is enough. Dear James Boyd and Steph, I'm sending this email under a pseudonym for reasons that will become obvious. Oh, no. I'm a huge fan of the pod, and I feel like I'm going to ask for the impossible in this email, because let's face it, James and Boyd are renowned TV snobs, particularly James. Let's be real. Don't you roll me in. Oh, thanks. It's too late. But lately, I've caught so many offhand sneering comments about soaps on the show, and I'm writing to say, enough is enough.
24:03You might think that you're above them, and I'm pretty sure James said he has never seen more than five minutes of EastEnders in his entire life, but you can't escape the fact that they've always been a huge part of British TV culture. They're the training ground for some of the best TV talent on and off screen. Sally Wainwright started on Corrie, and there are too many actors to mention who started their careers on soaps in this country. How do we expect to keep nourishing British talent if we don't give props to these shows? You'll spend 30 minutes lavishing praise on The Pit, but you'd sneer at a homegrown casualty, which right now is the best it's ever been, and many of their episodes, such as the COVID special they did, could absolutely rival The Pit if you didn't look down on them.
24:38And I should know, I watch them both. if Russell T. Davis can appreciate what Coronation Street brings to the TV landscape then why can't you I do have skin in the game I'm a young script writer and I write for one of them it's always been my dream to write for TV and they gave me a shot everyone who works on these shows puts in a gruelling amount of effort to make sure there are sometimes five episodes a week every week of the year so no it's not prestige telly and I'm not saying you have to praise or enjoy these shows but please stop using them the next time you need a lazy shorthand for shit TV I live in hope yours soapily Alex Alex I'd just like to officially apologise on Boyd and James' behalf because they're both massive arseholes to be fair to Boyd more my behalf than Boyd I can't remember when I said something disparaging about the soaps I think it's mostly James to be fair we all of us well maybe not Steph but me and you Boyd we both do tend to use the term soapy to describe a certain amount of melodrama you do I try not to I may have done but I try not to and can I just say sorry Steph before you go on that I actually wanted to us to review Casualty, the anniversary specials that went out recently.
25:46I'm going to say something now, which really made me so happy because as I mentioned, I watched every single episode of the show that we are recommending to you below. This is not a spoiler, James, so do not cut this out. There is a scene in below, right, where some And people are sitting around and they put the television on and they are watching Coronation Street. And it is wondrous. The Coronation Street theme comes on and it's great. Just saying. So not only does James not appreciate soaps, people in the upper echelons that are making these concerts do appreciate soaps, which somehow makes James even more wrong.
26:25I mean, it does. James, how do you respond? To be fair, Sarah Phelps has taken me to task for this vocally on this very podcast and been right. and I'm sure Russell has done and probably will do again when we have him on the next episode. And you are, of course, right. There are great people working at soaps both in front of the camera and behind the camera and they do what they do very well. Not all soaps are created equal. I think it's fairly safe to say. There is a reason why, you know, Days of Our Lives and Its Ilk in America are mocked quite roundly. And I don't think I know enough about soaps to say it's because American soaps are terrible because I don't watch American soaps so I don't really feel qualified to comment.
27:00Hold on a minute. They're mocked. You say that about telenovelas, but the thing is, is that you think about the massive audience that watches these kinds of shows, and I feel pretty sure you must have watched Neighbours when you were young. Oh, I watched Neighbours religiously when I was a kid. I even watched El Dorado for a bit as well. What else did I used to watch? I used to watch Dallas. I used to watch Dynasty. Are those soap operas? I guess they're not really, are they? Yes, they are. I would say they're 100 % soap operas. They were referred to as soap operas. Okay, I watched the Colbys, the spin-off back then.
27:29What else did I watch? And EastEnders I watched for a very short period of time, so I probably only watched 10 episodes of EastEnders when I was at university. You've basically, we watched Yellowstone like all six seasons and that is soap essentially. That's a Montana soap. It has a lot of that in there, doesn't it? Yeah, it absolutely does. I think, yeah, and you've got to think, without soap, we wouldn't have Michelle Keegan. If you haven't watched The Blame, you should watch it. Saran Jones. Think about all these other incredible actors that have come out of these soaps. I would go as far as, I think you're right, I agree with all of that.
28:02But I try not to use it too much, but Soapy as a way of describing a show that is trying not to be a soap opera, if you like. I think it is valid as a shorthand way of talking about how many storylines a show has, how many characters, what kind of melodrama goes on. Do you know what I mean? So, for example, Downton Abbey. I think one of the reasons why Downton Abbey became such a success is because it is actually soapy. I think it's intentionally so. There's 22 characters or whatever in the first episode and eight different storylines, and that is soapy. So it's British and so - Yeah, yeah, completely.
28:41Absolutely. So it's not even necessarily being used as a pejorative. It's a descriptor of the kind of thing you get sometimes in prestige dramas, so to speak, as in self-proclaimed prestige dramas, that actually end up being melodramatic and soapy. So I would just, yeah, I would just defend that. Yeah, I agree. I think James is using it as a pejorative though. Like, absolutely. That's not an unfair accusation. But then I am a horrible TV snob. It may not be my best personality trait, but it definitely is there. You know what, right? Okay, you are a TV snob, but also you do enjoy things that you maybe wouldn't admit to enjoying.
29:16I mean, I - Yeah, Downton Abbey was pure guilty pleasure for me. Like, I loved every second of it. When we establish James' grotesque hypocrisy, many times there's no consistency at all you know that yeah that's true yeah the comedy hater who loves friends it just doesn't make any sense it's just painful what can I tell you I'm a conundrum you really are I can take multitudes an enigma wrapped in a riddle that's it that's it well yes Alex I apologise for that and next time I rag on soaps which I invariably will do at some point can I just apologise now in advance and get maybe like a free pass that would be great but I'll do my best don't give him a free pass Alex I will tell him off every single time now but also alex best of luck i hope that one day like you know that you'll be writing like the next series of something that i'm absolutely obsessed with like let's say you write the expanse reboot and you come back and then feel free to come on this podcast and tell me what a massive bell end i am and a huge hypocrite he could be the next um russell t davis you know he could be but let's be honest it's not it's not the same as an expanse reboot i saw alex can you let us know what you write for i kind of want to know can you i don't know why i mean i'm not i'm not having a go but i don't know why he feels he has to be anonymous i think it's fine because he's defended his okay alex whatever your name is he or she boydy yeah it could be she yeah yeah don't be sexist boydy sorry yeah alex yeah ladies the patriarchy message here from danay and this comes for boydy this is for boydy that's how we know uh please please don't do a reverse ferret on the box it's a load of bollocks and i will lose faith if you do keep up the triff work danay you'll be pleased to know i accidentally watched a little bit of the box on i think i was waiting for the football to start and um it was terrible still terrible yeah now as you know i do not approve of any kind of traitor's conversation on this podcast and i'm already bracing myself for whatever it is you're going to bang on about on the regular pod brace yourself for the main pod because boyd and i've got a lot to talk about we have an important message here from phil and phil says dear pod long-time listener normally when delivering flowers around the streets of the ancient roman city of colchester steph always gives off plenty of buddhika energy and has proven herself to be a formidable addition to the team i initially really missed cave her gentle but firm nature when dealing with james but i've very much warmed up to steph and her love of all things dog i have fired myself including hugo boss the delivery pug a lean mean hunting machine forever on the lookout for biscuits anyway while driving past colchester castle i was forced to consider my opinion on the first episode of the new season of Celebrity Traitors.
31:51I never previously watched this show, despite the height, but decided a rare whole family watch was due. Anyway, I'm completely with James on this. What a complete load of used toilet paper. This would have been enough to send the Romans back to Rome if they were still here. The overuse of dramatic music was excruciating and reminded me of an early episode of The X Factor. How can the BBC have created a show so like Saturday Night ITV is beyond me. I really don't get the massive hype and I couldn't believe the positive reviews. What am I missing? Needless to say, I will not be watching anymore and will stick to the Sheridan universe and will re-watch episode seven of season three of Lioness, which was just incredible.
32:27And a certain scene with a helicopter literally had me whooping with joy. Yes, agree. Steph, you must watch. Anyway, I'm completely done with traitors and shall not be returning. The only positive was that it featured no animals, so the dogs didn't go crazy at the TV. We can't watch anything featuring dogs, so have not caught up with colin yet please enjoy some dog pictures of my crazy pack and has included pictures of the pug which lives up to all possible expectations and a small whitish dog with shaggy hair who's doing excellent eye roll uh oh and the pug again and the other send them all to me i need them all i need i will send you all pictures of the pugs right there we go celebrity creators okay phil right i'm so there's so many things that i need to unwrap here okay firstly don't worry k has not gone anywhere in fact i think she's coming back in like a couple of weeks because it's half term so she's not going anywhere we're still very much in a job share secondly right I you love dogs and I love dogs so obviously with friends but however I too had not watched Celebrity Traitors or any Traitors okay and I said I'm gonna watch this I'm gonna watch this and I'm telling you now I think I was nine minutes in to Celebrity Traitors and I text the group and I thought oh I probably I wish I didn't text, I was texting this group because James is on it, to say that I was completely obsessed with it already.
33:43I urge you to carry on because just for Richard E. Grant alone, you must carry on. It's a duty to carry on to find out what happens. It's brilliant. It's like, I don't know what there is to not like about it. It's so fantastic watching these people squirm and, oh God, I loved it. everything about it. And also, Claudia is at her absolute best. She's having a whale of a time. The tasks are brilliant. Everyone in this series is great. Like, given, I haven't watched it before, so I don't know. But as a dog-loving first-time watcher of Celebrity Traitors like you, you need to come with me on this journey.
34:25Get back. And it is a great family watch. Yes, everybody else in my house left, and I was watching it on my own by the last half an hour. But still, I just, I don't get why you don't love it. Please come back, give it one more try, and then if you don't like it, I'll just let you go. I'll let you go. But please do. Boyd, please defend traitors. Oh, I mean, you've done a very good job defending it. Look, it's not for everyone. I think, what's the name of the correspondent? It's Phil. Phil and the Five. Five Dogs. That's a lot of dogs. Five Dogs, Phil. Philly Five Dogs. That's his mafia name. Philly Five Dogs.
34:57I mean, you have to concentrate a little bit on it. So maybe the Five Dogs interrupted his viewing. Pleasure. I don't know. I think to compare it to Saturday night ITV is not fair, particularly because it's actually got a kind of look and feel of its own. It is cheesily, it's deliberately cheesily over the top in terms of the music and the way it's shot. It's very Halloween-y. It's no coincidence that it's shown in the build-up to Halloween. It's traditionally got that kind of autumnal, use of coffins all the time, et cetera, and the missions are very much based in Halloween-y type settings. So I don't know what Saturday Night TV show you're talking about that has that kind of look and feel to it.
35:40But it's just the nature of the gameplay and the cast of it that are so delightfully exciting to watch. But, you know, it sounds to me like you take it against it. That's fine. You haven't literally taken it against it. It is not fine. No, not if it shows for everyone. Come on, Phil. But we're doing it together. Come on, Phil. Come on, back you come, babe. Come on, we're watching this together. And can I just make the point? The other thing - 8.9 million viewers. I think they can do without Phil's. No, no, I want Phil. I want Phil and his five dogs. The other thing that I really love about it, and maybe this is because I just, like, I'm obsessed with other people's human experience, but, like, I love the fact that all the celebrities on it are so happy to be on the show and genuinely love the show that just absorbing their excitement and happiness from being on the show gives me joy.
36:24Yeah, except James Acaster, who's in a state of torment, shall we say. I think he didn't realise quite how distressing it would be. anyway he is being brilliant this has turned into a trailer yes well you've turned into a traitor's trailer slash spoiler special yeah it's your own fault if you're gonna mention it that's what's gonna happen yeah god i wish i hadn't brought it up the only thing i would say and much as i hate to alienate in an ally in phil um i don't think i ever said and i actually don't think the traitors is bad television i actually think it's kind of like it's like it's like it's the peak tv it's the prestige tv of reality tv like it's extremely high quality it's extremely well put together and were i someone who likes reality tv i'm sure i would love it and even as someone who actively would like to fire all reality tv into the sun i probably would watch the traitors if i happened to be like sitting down with someone who was obsessed with it like i probably would watch it with i'm never going to watch it on my own but like and i'm not going to watch it for this podcast i'm going to come around to your house and i'm going to watch it with you because Bella Ramsey is brilliant.
37:30And I think the thing is, again, when we're talking about pejoratives, I think when we say reality TV, we use that as a pejorative. And actually, this is a celebrity game show, really. And it's fabulous. Yeah, yeah. It's a celebrity game show because it's celebrity traitors, but it's still a celebrity version of reality TV. Oh, yeah, yeah, it is. Unashamed. Yes, it is. Yes, you're right. Absolutely. Let's all go around to James' place. A sort of precinct game. And we'll watch it. Okay. you get some you get some of the fancy snacks from M &S and we'll come around and watch it with you and then we'll finally put this to rest if I have to watch it you're bringing the snacks okay fine right okay we have just time for one maybe two more but we'll see how the timing goes a very quick correction from Henning in Oslo just a quick message said that I interpreted the ice line from Lioness that James talked about on the latest plus completely the opposite of how James did when I watched the episode.
38:30In my view, Lioness is in many ways competence porn, where the operators are considered the best of the best. Ice, on the other hand, is currently viewed as horribly mismanaged and or downright evil by all but the MAGA crowd in the US, and there have been many news reports about how you can become an ICE agent with almost no training at all. So I saw it as them blaming ICE, shifting the blame to someone who would, of course, fuck up big time, and the line to me read more like, those incompetent fools already have it rough and now we're just adding fuel to the fire so to speak from henning in oslo um yes and that is quite possibly how it was meant i must admit the way i interpreted it i was quite surprised because to me even though you could read a lot of that stuff into taylor sheldon stuff even though he's not overtly political it that felt to me far more of a political statement than he would make in one of his shows and he's a much more subtle writer than that so i suspect you are you are right but i think when i said it i was i think i might have said at the time that i'm not sure that's how it was intended that's just how i heard it i was a bit floored by that um but anyway that's my uh that's my because steph wouldn't know because steph has still not watched lioness no no i haven't because i've been watching mirror of kingstown which you promised to watch with me so when i come around i'm gonna do you know what i'm gonna do i'm going to pack my bags i'm gonna move into your house for like two weeks and in those two weeks we're gonna do dtsst louis uh mayor of kingstown all uh five seasons four four seasons because fifth season's coming out possibly band of brothers uh but bob would you bob that's only eight episodes that's fine and then what other what else do i want to oh yeah and then just for fun we're going to top it off with an episode of america's sweethearts dallas cowboys cheerleaders yeah we're really not uh by the way while you mentioned band of brothers stephen connolly wrote in to say that uh he sent in a message last year and this is true 23rd of july 2025 to say that he had seen phil barrentini in band of brothers so he accused you of stealing his fact so there you go maybe I got it from him yeah it's possible I wouldn't deny it alright last question before we have to go and this comes from Ben and Ben says hi gang I listened to and very much enjoyed this week's podcast until the final few minutes that is when I heard all three of you dismiss the Scrubs reboot as quote unquote not good and express surprise and derision at its renewal I really think you should be clear about which show you watched and didn't like, because listeners could quite easily think you were referring to the Scrubs reboot that captured much of the original magic that left me with a big smile on my face at the end of each episode.
40:53You know, the show that has a 90 % critic rating and a 92 % audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The show that has a 73 critic score and an 8.3 user score on Metacritic. The show that was, in fact, a shining example of how well revivals can work. As I say, you'd probably better issue a clarification or people might think you were condemning that show as, quote unquote, not good. as president bartlett once said just stand there in your wrongness and be wrong and get used to it oh the email that was dripping with sarcasm i don't know i took all that at face value um i think we were talking about that and once again i would say that yes none of us liked it at the time um and i believe i watched should i watch two of the episodes but you're not because two people have got in contact with me and said that i should go back to the scrubs reboot and that was actually all right and it was actually good but i don't know i've been back to a couple of reboots recently and they haven't been as good they haven't been as good as people keep telling me they are it's it's no fraser reboot let's be honest four stars uh but uh but i didn't i didn't love it it has to be said it did not do it for me no i i didn't watch i think we should probably hold our hands i hold my hands up and say i didn't enjoy the pilot the first episode at all and I didn't wash anymore.
42:09So I'm completely judging on its failure to, and I really liked Scrubs originally back in the day. So I feel the first episode was not good enough and that's my critique and I have not proceeded with it for that reason. I think the thing as well is we've come off the back of Scrubbia, what we call Scrubbia. Do you remember that when they did that weird other season? Do you remember? At the end of Scrubs. Yes, the final season of Scrubs that we don't ever talk about. Yeah, so I think it feels like, oh, if that didn't work, then maybe this will work. So maybe, yeah, I don't know. Maybe I should go back to it because somebody else has messaged me to say that it's really good.
42:45But it didn't feel to me like it had captured the magic. And I think we knew at that time it wasn't going to have the caretaker in it. And we were like, why would it not have the caretaker? And obviously, John C. McGinley wasn't in it, but then he went and did Rooster, which is absolutely phenomenal. James, have you finished? Yes. Have you finished it? Have you finished it? No, following up, Steph, that didn't even make the sofa list. okay sorry have you just watched one of them then okay fine i rest my case i rest my case yeah it was i was gonna steph but you know it's a bit soapy so i just kind of didn't you know i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm kidding i'm kidding uh yes right that is it for this week's postbag we hope you have at the very least tolerated it i've still not got on top of my kind of triage system i need a better system than what i currently do which is just the first things that jump out and we get read out but i will find a system and the rest assured when i do i will tell people uh now we'll be back on monday when we will be reviewing do you know what i'm not entirely sure what we're gonna be reviewing so we're going to be reviewing i think the party i think we're going to be reviewing treasure island we may be reviewing time or we may be reviewing vision quest well that's not strictly true we're definitely reviewing time no we may be reviewing time if we don't get vision quest i think this is all going to be moots because i don't think we are going to get vision quest yes and this is what i was going to say this may all be moving we may absolutely be doing time in the literal and metaphorical sense uh because vision quest while it will not be embargoed i don't think they're going to give us episodes to watch in advance of us recording the podcast so we might have to kick that down the road a little bit we will cover in one uh way or another but all of that is academic because the main draw of the next podcast is we're going to have a guest in the studio with us aren't we boydy yes oh sorry that's very loud I shouted yes that was a big yes sorry you surprised me with that with that exciting news yes Russell T.
44:38Davis will be joining us to talk about his outstanding new memoir yes really good content slightly badly written but other than that you know steady oh my god don't even joke a life in television it was he we we co I co-wrote it yes can I say that written with I think the official the official line Russell T. Davis written with me so yes but it's a TV delight for anyone interested in television god that was a terrible plug wasn't it well done Boydie you are quite the hype man yeah yeah yeah James I'm gonna out Thursday the 8th of October 2026 there you go plug the book James I'm gonna hop to M &S then I'm gonna jump in my car I will bring two weeks worth of clothes and we will snuggle down to a big watch yeah okay this is already more upsetting than i can possibly tell you but in the meantime we'll see you on monday pilot out
We’re heading beneath the waves on this week’s Plus as Josh Hartnett’s northerly Newfoundland town is set upon by a beast from fathoms deep in Below on Netflix. Plus the postbag sees us taken to task by the writer of a popular soap opera, The Traitors read to filth, and Boydy forced to make a (semi) climbdown on behalf of The OA.
Want your messages read out as part of The Postbag? Email us at [email protected]