PLUS Gomorrah: The Origins 

29 Jul 2026 · 53 min · 17 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Review of Gomorrah: The Origins (Gomorrah Le Origine), a Sky Atlantic prequel to Roberto Saviano’s real-life–inspired Gomorrah crime saga about Naples’ gangster culture. The hosts discuss its authenticity, pacing, tone, and standout set pieces, especially a major party episode (episode four).

Key claims

The show is beautifully shot with a dreamlike, romanticized feel that still implies violence (less graphic early on, more later). It’s deliberately paced but builds mounting tension; characters are sympathetic because they’re driven by love, ambition, and survival rather than pure brutality.

Notable examples

1977 disco dance-off opening; Pietro’s loss of innocence; Pietro’s love interest Emma (a talented singer/musician); a pivotal episode-four party where everyone knows they’re walking into a trap; director’s visual influence likened to Once Upon a Time in America.

Guests

Kay Ribeiro (co-host; foreign-language drama fan). Main host: Boyd Hilton (no guest).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Celebrating 400 Episodes

0:46 to 2:39

Discussion about the upcoming 400th episode and changes to the hosting.

“including Pilot Plus, of which this is that, than by getting rid of James entirely and making sure he can't impinge upon our enjoyment of this historic moment.”

Introducing Gomorrah: The Origins

2:40 to 4:05

Overview of the show Gomorrah: The Origins and its significance.

“which was based on a real-life nonfiction book, which detailed the rise and rise of the gangster culture in Napoli, Italy.”

Themes and Character Exploration

4:06 to 5:48

Discussion of the characters and themes within Gomorrah: The Origins.

“I think, you know, as you say, Boyd, I'm a massive fan of foreign dramas, as the correspondent of Pilot Podcast, having reviewed maybe three shows.”

Kay's Impressions and Comparisons

5:49 to 9:05

Kay shares her thoughts on the show's cinematography and pacing.

“of petty crime and um they're working for this sort of like very charming young local gangster called Angelo, who is running an illegal gambling den.”

Character Development and Plot Points

9:06 to 11:25

Exploration of key plot points and character arcs in the first episode.

“probably is far worse but um all i'd say is wait till episode four yeah i really oh no okay so yeah And, you know, as I said, it's got a romantic feel anyway, just in the way it's shot.”

Production Quality and Influences

11:26 to 14:00

Discussion on the production quality and influences from classic films.

“Both there was a film and there was a TV show, etc.”

Exploring Themes of Youth and Choices in 'Gomorrah: The Origins'

14:00 to 21:30

Discussion about the characters' youthful choices and the inherent challenges they face in 'Gomorrah: The Origins'.

“Because of course, Saturday Night Fever came a year later in 1978.”

Overview of 'Gomorrah: The Origins' Availability

21:30 to 21:55

Information on how to watch 'Gomorrah: The Origins' and its critical acclaim.

“Kay, pleased to know, on Sky Atlantic and now, formerly known as Now TV.”

Listener Feedback and Discussion on Casting Young Characters

21:55 to 28:00

Engagement with listener comments about casting younger versions of characters and discussing memorable examples.

“Our first message is from Amar, who says, Hi gang, I guess the Yellowstone brand is one I'm going to have to put up with rather than live up to, smiley face.”

Late Discoveries in TV Shows

28:00 to 30:00

Discussing their experiences of discovering popular TV shows long after their release.

“Which series did you come to years after everyone else only to end up loving to bits?”
Show all 17 chapters

Debating Android: A Personal Review

30:00 to 32:00

Engaging in a lively debate about the merits and flaws of the show Android.

“I said you'd find it hard to answer because you just watched everything instantly.”

Grievances and Recommendations

32:00 to 39:50

Sharing listener grievances and discussing recommendations for new shows.

“Two people have got in touch, so I'm saying that in my head is hundreds.”

Character Depth vs. Tropes

42:00 to 43:40

A discussion on the overuse of trauma and illness in character development.

“because their wife slash husband slash sibling slash parent slash friend slash cat slash dog died.”

Detective Tropes in TV Shows

43:40 to 46:00

Exploring the clichés of detective characters, particularly regarding their traumas.

“like by the way the dark i'm i think it's excellent on itv the serial killer thriller or the disney plus serial killer thriller which we reviewed um it in pilot on out on monday I knew you were going to ask that.”

Examples of Unique Detectives

46:00 to 48:20

Highlighting unique female detectives who avoid common tropes and clichés.

“She's a brilliant example, exactly, of how it should be done.”

Reactions to Series Continuation

48:20 to 50:40

Discussing the evolution of the show 'The Crow Girl' and reactions to its later series.

“It was making it a bit ridiculous and I thought it had a good, you know, there was a good story at the core of it.”

Upcoming Films and Guest Announcements

50:40 to 52:36

Previewing upcoming films and announcing Ricky Gervais as a special guest.

“I mean, all of them are brilliant, but I just don't know how she was able to pull off the director-actor multiple hats there.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:08Hello and welcome to Pilot Plus. I'm Boyd Hilton. And to celebrate the imminent 400th episode of Pilot TV Podcast, although when you look at the podcast list on Apple Podcasts, it says that we're way off beyond 400 episodes. So I don't really know how that's worked out. Yeah. Oh, that little voice you heard there, the little spoiler. I was building up to that, to the excitement. But, you know, hold your horses, second voice, because I haven't got there yet. So we're approaching officially our 400th episode, which will be next week. But in the build-up to that, especially to celebrate, what better way of commemorating the 400th episode of the Pilot TV podcast, including Pilot Plus, of which this is that, than by getting rid of James entirely and making sure he can't impinge upon our enjoyment of this historic moment.

1:02So we've got rid of him for two weeks. For two weeks, you're not going to hear any of James droning on about friends, about the expanse, all of foundation, all of that nonsense. And instead, you've got me hosting the show for the next couple of the weeks. and the joyous surprise, which has already been ruined because you've heard her voice already. I'm joined by my esteemed co-host, the grand return of Kay Ribeiro. Welcome, Kay. Thank you, Boydo. Sorry, I know I ruined that. It's just when I hear your voice and you're talking, I just want to answer. So yeah, I got ahead of myself. Excellent. Too excited.

1:42Don't get too excited. No, get even more excited. Today, we're reviewing Gamora The Origins, which is, I know Kay's a huge fan of subtitled foreign language dramas. So I especially came up with this for us to review. Its official title, of course, is Gomorrah Le Origine in the Italian. So we'll be looking at that. It's the sequel. It's the prequel series, really, to the Gomorrah, epic Gomorrah show, which went on for about five series and dozens and dozens of episodes of an absolute phenomenon in Italy. and, frankly, around the world, Kay. So we'll be reviewing that and we'll be opening the postbag.

2:24Kay will be opening the postbag, as is her won't. Yes, it's like my cheek. We'll be answering some of your questions. Gamora of the Origins, though, is first up. It is the prequel, as I said, to the hugely successful and popular and excellent Italian crime saga, which was based on a real-life nonfiction book, which detailed the rise and rise of the gangster culture in Napoli, Italy. And it was absolutely astonishing, just in terms of the kind of authenticity of the whole thing. It was written by a guy called Roberto Saviano, who kind of explored all of the worlds of this extreme, violent and powerful gang lord and gang family.

3:13So are these real characters based on real people? they are basically loose-dumor people obviously he couldn't he couldn't base them too closely doesn't want to get shot otherwise he's going to get killed yeah but he is still with us thankfully because I think he's been very careful in how he depicts these things it's a pretty no holds barred approach to this whole world it's going to it's on Sky Atlantic and now and Kay as a fan of foreign language stuff as I mentioned what did you think? do you know what I'm just going straight in I really, really like this. So I hadn't watched any of the previous series.

3:51So I was coming new to it. And I thought, you know, when you do that, you sometimes think, oh, God, is it going to be completely confusing to me? Because I'm not invested in these characters. But actually, if you think about it, it's the perfect place to start, because as you say, it's the prequel. And I just loved everything about it. I think, you know, as you say, Boyd, I'm a massive fan of foreign dramas, as the correspondent of Pilot Podcast, having reviewed maybe three shows. and um and this one i would say is top of my list i just i love that it's so it's the way i think it's so beautifully shot first of all that's the thing that struck me first is just how wonderfully it's shot it instantly makes me want to live there um and there's just such a sort of dreamlike quality to it you know it's so dreamy dreamy and romantic and it romance i mean it romanticises the violence and the crime, of course, but you find yourself wanting, you feel immersed in it.

4:45You find yourself probably wanting to live there, if you're me. Wait a minute, wait a minute. Amid all the violence and gang culture, and back in 1977. You probably transplanted back to 1977 where it's set. If I had full body armour and I stayed out of the fiery line, I don't know, do you know what I mean? it had that romantic quality to it just you know it is of course and it's very impoverished and yeah okay so maybe i wouldn't but i i wouldn't mind having a short stay there and hanging out with pietro so from i mean i had to read up about it before i began because i wanted to have some knowledge of it and is that how i'm saying his name right is it pietro i believe so yeah pietro well they often were calling calling piet or p or whatever i'll call him p for ease of my try and pronounce it so it starts in 1977 and um p is a 16 year old boy having fun with his friends you know i think the aspect of you know when i was saying i wanted to live there it's like they're just having fun dancing in the cafe having a good time um but they're also involved in a little bit of petty crime and um they're working for this sort of like very charming young local gangster called Angelo, who is running an illegal gambling den.

6:03And they're doing some very small, low-key tasks for him and jobs. But it's clear that P wants to be part of Angelo's world. And I'd say the themes of the show really are love and ambition. And it's clear that P plus Angelo himself, who I find quite charming. And that's the thing with these characters. I think it's easy to... You fancy Angelo. No. I mean, listen, is he a good looking man? Yes, he is. But I mean, I felt sympathy for him in a way because they're all locked in this situation through wanting to provide for their families and friends, right? To have a better life. So, you know, sometimes when you watch crime dramas, they're like so unsympathetic because they've become so hardened and they're so brutal and violent.

6:48Whereas you can see this guy is conflicted and he works for a big crime boss called Don Antonio, who's in charge of the second Liano. Just random Italian words, throw them in, yeah. He's in charge of this. I presume it's an area void. I don't know. It's an area, yeah. And P basically gets involved with this local gang, as I said, but he helps Angelo out because something goes awry within the gambling den and P provides valuable information to identify who has caused Angelo a major headache. and what's really interesting is like when you're when you're watching it you just see the exact moment that Pietro lose you know loses his innocence and and the corruption sets in it's really like in a way it's heartbreaking because it's this boy who ultimately is quite small fry just loves hanging out with his friends dancing he does do these criminal things but they're quite you know they're not serious but yeah but you know and obviously if anyone who watches the series the main series knows where this is leading to so yeah I really love the way it's shot I really like the characters and I also enjoyed and I don't usually enjoy this with shows because I want to be entertained constantly and you know that's that thing of wanting it to be propulsive I like how it takes its time it really does take its time deliberately paced but in a good way I think it's so measured you know how everything it takes its time sweet time and particularly when it gets to the really, as the tension ratchets up, right?

8:22It's so agonising in a way. Like even the creak of a leather jacket at one point, I was like, oh my God, what's happening? Yeah. How many episodes did you watch? I've only watched one, but I'm going to continue. Okay, like you said, but okay. Well, we've got a lot of shows this week, Boyd. But the last thing I want to mention about it, of why I really, really liked it, other than all the reasons listed, is the fact that the violence isn't graphic. right so there's in this first episode so far i warn you that in fact it does get graphic as it goes on oh really yeah okay fine i thought i thought it was doing a like a novel thing where you're not going to see as much violence because in this first episode particularly at least you don't see a lot it's implied which is very effective because obviously what you're imagining probably is far worse but um all i'd say is wait till episode four yeah i really oh no okay so yeah And, you know, as I said, it's got a romantic feel anyway, just in the way it's shot.

9:21But also we see the moment that the fateful encounter of P with Emma. Yes. So for anyone who watches. Emma is his love interest. Yeah. His love interest who becomes his wife. Yeah. Yeah. She's an outstanding singer. Oh, is she? Yes. It turns out. She was holding an instrument, actually. So, yeah. Makes sense. She's a musician and singer. And yeah, she's very kind of talented. You were taken by her musical talents. I was. Yeah. there's a scene again so i've watched four episodes and there's a scene in episode four where she she drags him not drags him but she says follow me because he kind of you know doesn't i wouldn't say he doesn't take his talent seriously but he does not fully aware so she takes him to a rehearsal for a performance she's about to do and it's brilliant because he's just like stunned watching her singing this song yeah so she's she's a key character i had a question actually which you'll be able to answer so in the first episode there is a uh prison scene and i wondered because i haven't got knowledge of the characters i wondered is that one is that a rival crime boss who's gonna um i think it's more of a politician who um is is going to try to is is possibly corrupt but also is going to try to kind of um work for the neighborhood against the crime families.

10:40Yeah, so yeah, I'm pretty sure that's his role. As I said, I watched, yeah, I mean, it's absolutely brilliant, is the bottom line. I'm really, to be honest, let's be honest, let's draw the veil. What's the phrase? Let's show what's beneath the veil. Let's show what's beneath the veil. Beneath the veil is the fact that - Let's get under that curtain. Is that at the moment, pretty much every major new show that arrives is heavily embargoed until the day it comes out. I mean, part of the reason we do Plus is because we can cover stuff that was embargoed that we can get to. But this week, it's all embargoed.

11:20So, you know, I didn't have hardly any choice of what to cover. And I was like, hold on, Gamora of the Origins, Gamora of the Origine is starting. And I was a huge Gamora fan. Both there was a film and there was a TV show, etc. And the film and TV show didn't have that much to do with each other. But I was expecting this to be good, so having watched most of the original Gamora series. But I don't think I was expecting it to be quite this spectacular. Oh, really? Yeah, because as you say, the visuals in this are even more grandiose than they were in Gamora. Gamora was all about kind of like the brutalism of the architecture in the kind of, you know, 90s, 80s, 90s, et cetera.

12:05Whereas in this earlier phase, it's still, that's yet to come. And it is, you're right, the kind of the landscape, the cityscape and the settings and the way it's shot and the lighting. It's very much, I have to say, slightly pompously influenced by the classic film Once Upon a Time in America. To the extent that, and I'm not going to say whether that's one of my favourite films of all time, but it's definitely a contender. We've got some correspondence about this. Oh, excellent. Oh, I didn't know that. Excellent. Anyway, it's definitely one of the greatest films of all time. One of your favourite films.

12:39It's generally considered to be hugely Robert De Niro, Sergio Leone. And why I think it's deliberate is because the colour scheme in that film is very much like kind of browns, dark, kind of like vivid browns and kind of gold almost. And it's all shot in a kind of golden hue. And this very much looks like Once Upon a Time in America. and it even has a little bit of a flute on the soundtrack, which is the signature Ennio Morricone theme tune of Once Upon a Time A Record. It's this incredible, beautiful kind of, I think it's a flute kind of woodwind. Woodwind instrument. Instrument. Anyway, it's definitely deliberate.

13:21So it's not piccolo? It might be a piccolo. It may well be. I don't know my little wind and struts, I admit. So it's got that look. It's definitely, definitely deliberately got that look. And in fact, I looked up, I think, oh, this is very Once Upon a Time America. And then I read an interview with the director who was like, yeah, absolutely. He was, you know, using that as a starting point. But then it starts with this scene, as you say, with him and his gang, Pietro, P-A-P, whatever the fuck it's called, doing this kind of like dance. Luca Lombrano. Thank you. The actor, yes. They do this like dance-off, this disco dance-off, because it's 1977 and disco was arriving.

13:58And so it's really interesting the way it seizes upon that as the cultural phenomenon. Because of course, Saturday Night Fever came a year later in 1978. But I think that they have classic disco songs as needle drops throughout. And that opening scene where you're watching this gang of kids outdoing each other. It's so joyful. Yeah, it's brilliant. But that's what's so clever about it. It's then so powerful when he gets drawn in, almost not against his will, but as you say, in the deliberate pacing issue, there are a lot of close-ups of his faces and the faces of these kids as they begin to realise what they're getting themselves into.

14:40Yeah, particularly him, especially as he gets deeper and deeper into it. Right, exactly. I don't think it's against his will at all. I think it's a real conscious decision of his because he wants to sort of... You know, he wants to emulate Angelo. He wants that life. 100 % you're right. But I think there's moments where, particularly as it goes on, and there are moments where people are saying to him, no, no, no, don't get involved in this thing. And I'm pointing out, there's two options in life, in these kids' lives. Leave it alone. Don't get involved. Just have a good time with your disco dancing.

15:18Have a lovely time with your disco dancing. watching, watch your girlfriend singing, etc. She gets drawn in, by the way, into a really powerful kind of abuse storyline. Oh, really? Yeah, it's really interesting. What I'm trying to say is that it looks at the – basically, for someone like him, he wants to make a name for himself and his friends, one of them wants to be a footballer. One of them's just like, you know, we want to go into this magical restaurant where one of the early crimes is committed. and they look, I want to go one day when I'm an adult, I want to have, what's the line? Just like all the food in the world until we explode.

15:54It's good at emphasising just how young they are. Yeah, yeah. You know, and innocent. Absolutely. Then by the time you get to this, this big, the whole thing is set up to, there's a kind of gang rivalry between these French dudes, these French gangsters and his friends, Pietro's friends, older friends. and the French guys invite them all to this party, this big party where they're going to kind of like thrash out, you know, what's going on. And everyone knows. It's so clever because as it builds up to this party, which takes place in episode four, all the characters know that they're heading into a trap.

16:31You know, like they're all like, we can't not go because that would be humiliating. They've got to go and deal with the obvious threat of these French guys who feel that they've been robbed by the Italian mafia guys. And it builds up. And episode four, honestly, is one of the best single episodes. Oh, wow. Part of the reason I carried on watching because I read online somewhere, said, you know, you've got to get to episode four because it's so the party scene. And it's such a brilliant set piece. It's literally as good as... You know, The Godfather, Once Upon a Time in America, as I've mentioned, Scarface, these classic gangster crime movies.

17:11It's up there with that. it's so brilliantly handled it's so brilliantly done do you know what some people don't like it when you do that but I love it when you tell me to continue to look you know to make sure I see it you did that in fact for do you remember Smoke with Taron Egerton you said you have to get to episode 2 because it's going to go it's going to go crazy yes bonkers and so alright well I was going to continue watching anyway because yeah I think it's fab but definitely get to episode 4 yeah I think it's absolutely phenomenal yeah it's even even better than I expected I think in some ways it's even better than the original Grimora.

17:43And I think it does take its time. You're right, the pace is deliberately paced, but there's so much tension. There's always, as you say, there's always a lot of tension involved. You know, even Emma gets involved with stuff that is, you know, yeah, that she shouldn't get involved with, but she doesn't have much say in the matter, to be fair. Everyone's just trying to survive, aren't they? That's the thing. Exactly. And it's all like, you know, it's pride and reputation. Because in this first episode, you know Angelo has to make decisions that ideally he probably wouldn't have to but you know his hands are tied either his hands are tied or another person's are and you'd rather think the other person there's a lot of tying of hands yeah it's not bondage just to be clear steady steady I think it's too early in the morning for that no I was thinking about that apart from you so all in all yeah I was absolutely blown away by it I have to say I was so pleased genuinely you probably wouldn't have even looked at it or reviewed it.

18:41I wouldn't have watched it. So once again, this is why the podcast is brilliant. It's introducing us. Let's blow our own trumpet. Let's do some trumpet blowing. Yeah. Well, we're into the woodwind. Exactly. Well, that's brass actually, isn't it? Sorry. Very good. But thankfully, to be brutally honest, we only did it because there wasn't much else we could do in this episode of Pilot Plus, apart from the postcard coming up. But what a brilliant thing to have in the end, because it is so good, honestly. Fans of Gamora, go on. I never say this, but thank God for embargoes then. I thought you were going to say thank God for me.

19:15Well, I wanted to ask you now, given what we've said about that, would you have liked to have lived? No, absolutely not. You're mad. It is violent. As soon as you started saying that with all the criminality, I was like, oh, I know. It's just the director makes it look so beautiful. Yeah, but he doesn't flinch. The violence issue, yeah, It all kicks off again in episode four. The violence will more than make up for the lack of it. Well, that's fine. If it's beautifully shot, then it's fine. Totally beautifully shot, yeah. But would I, I mean, of course, you forget I was alive in 1977. I was around, not in Naples, not in Laplace.

19:57I was alive in Ilford, Essex, which I tell you, Kay. Very similar? Not too far. Not too far from the mean streets of Napoli. are the Mean Streets of Gants Hill. I'd like to think that you were somewhere in a cafe doing your own disco dance-off with your friends. But I can confirm that the whole disco thing was absolutely massive. Really? It was just such a predominant thing in the culture. Yeah, all the, you know, because it went from kind of punk. I mean, I'm sure you're fascinated by this history lesson in popular music. It went from punk in 76, 77, 78, and then at the same time, which was kind of a reaction to the rise of disco, Donna Summer, et cetera, et cetera.

20:40And then Saturday Night Fever came along, as I said, 1978, and changed the whole world. And that became the biggest album of all time. I didn't have flares, no. But I just remember the music. I just remember everyone. You had to have a copy of Saturday Night Fever, the album. Literally every single person in the world had a copy of that album. And still to this day, it's a brilliant thing. Anyway, I've been completely sidetracked. But the music and everything, the authenticity, what that sort of touches upon in Gomorrah, the origins, Gomorrah, the origine, is astonishing. Yeah, exactly. Well, very good.

21:17So it's, and the clothes and the music and all of that, you know, are so phenomenally, feel phenomenally accurate, don't they, historically? Yeah, 100%. True. So Gomorrah, the origins is available now, Kay, pleased to know, on Sky Atlantic and now, formerly known as Now TV. Now we just call it Now. People think we're making your outfits wrong, but it's called Now. And it's all there now. And I strongly recommend it. Six episodes. Get on it. Oh, very exciting. And now I believe it's time to open the post bag. Ladies and gentlemen, it's Miss Kay versus the post bag.

22:11Yes, okay, right. Our first message is from Amar, who says, Hi gang, I guess the Yellowstone brand is one I'm going to have to put up with rather than live up to, smiley face. But one of the things the show does is cast really good young versions of the characters. Josh Lucas as a young John Dusson is great, but the best is Forrest Smith, who plays a young Lloyd. and fun fact he's the son of Forry J. Smith who plays current day Lloyd the question is who are the most memorable castings of characters younger selves? For me the stand up is always the young Dolores Langdingham in the West Wing played by Chex Google Kirsten Nelson she seems to capture the character brilliantly I look forward to your top best Rip Wheeler moments.

22:54Well you said that you had an answer to this question this question involves some research on my part Boyd James sent us the questions in advance and if you've chosen not to do your homework no I'll go first while you hastily google because um yeah well one one of mine was a google answer I was I was googling to just refresh my memory um so this answer didn't instantly come up in my mind but when I saw it on the list I was like oh my god yeah of course Viola now is it Pretz John Pretz John as the young Queen Elizabeth in The Crown later played by Claire Foyd do you remember She looked like the absolute double ganger of her.

23:32So that was a great bit of casting. Who is it you're saying again? Viola Prette, Prette John? P-R-E-T-T-E John. You look at me with a confuzzled face, but I'm just reading the words on... Yeah, you've cunningly seized upon the crown, which of course is the ultimate song, isn't it, of a show that had people, the same characters, the same real life characters, ageing through each series. But I had never heard of this person. Claire Foy played the queen in episode. Yes, and then the younger version. Oh, okay. While you look up images, let me give – because I have got two more answers to this, Boyd.

24:10You'll be shocked to hear because you know I only like to give one. The other one is – so did you – I think you reviewed the Legally Blonde prequel. Yes, we did, yes. So I think Lexi Maintree as Elle Wood, I think she was well cast as that because I think she had the charisma of Reese with Spoon and a similar vibe and look. I think she was the thing that held that together. So I thought she was great. And then my last answer, because James is not here, so I feel I can get away with it, is connected to EastEnders. But I have to say, Daniel Delaney, who plays the young Phil Mitchell in, they occasionally do these flashback episodes for really poignant moments, sometimes standalone episodes.

24:54this guy is incredible anyone who's ever watched the show and who knows what Phil Mitchell is like Daniel Delaney basically is him he looks like him and his performance, all his mannerisms is he having an aneurysm? oh my god all his aneurysm, mannerisms all his mannerisms are so spot on it's like watching just a young Phil with Grant so I'll have to give him credit for that and those Boyd are my three answers very good answers I can't better them to be honest I was just looking up Viola Prétijon I guarantee you if you said to people in like a pub quiz who played who's the first version of Queen Elizabeth in The Crown hardly anyone would remember that Viola Prétijon played Queen Elizabeth yeah because they'll remember Clef Boyd but I know yeah yeah that's what I'm saying I think that's being a bit harsh on Viola she was very good I just, I guess it's because we've had all the series of it.

25:58You know, how many series? Six series in the end. And she probably didn't have as much screen time, obviously, as Claire Boyd, you know, later did. So she's more stamped in our memories. But don't you think she looks really like a double ganger? Now you've come to remind me, yeah. She was very good. Yeah, looked very much like it. Off the top of my head, I can't come up with any other examples. That's fine. Listen, as always, I'm just here to carry the load. Yeah. Right. Maybe you'll have an answer for this one. Oh, actually, I don't think you are, but I'm just going to ask you anyway. Okay, so this is from - Can you deliberately put questions that take you to my research?

26:36No, no, no. No, for this one, I don't think you'll have an answer because you're very good at what you do, your job. Steady. Yeah, I know. An unlikely compliment. Get used to it. Very unlikely, yeah. By the way, this is cool. Talking of EastEnders, we should have mentioned, this is a dot-netthor. We have people who realise this by now. Yes. We refer to them as Dot and Ethel when it's just two of us. Droning on. Carry on. I'm Ethel in this equation and you are Dot. Fine. So this is from Givion. I think I've said his name right. And he says, Hello, pilot pretties. I arrived home yesterday after a glorious two-week holiday in Spain, devoted almost entirely to crime fiction and sunbathing.

27:15Before boarding my flight back to breezy Iceland, I decided to finally download the first season of Jack Ryan, a series that has been sitting on my sofa list for ages. This sounds like James with his sofa list. Determined not to raw dog the flight home, I pressed play on episode one. I'm a huge fan of Tom Clancy since the late 90s, and my favourite Ryanverse novel is The Cardinal of the Kremlin, which tragically has never been adapted for screen. Well, listen, you never know, it might be. Is it called The Cardinal of the Kremlin? Okay, Karen. I absolutely devoured the first two episodes on the flight and now fully expect to binge the rest over the summer.

27:52The strange thing is that I'm almost eight years late to the party given when the series first aired. So my question is, have you ever been fashionably late to a TV show that should have been completely up your street? Which series did you come to years after everyone else only to end up loving to bits? Keep up the excellent work. The podcast is the perfect companion for my painfully early Monday and Thursday gym sessions. Best wishes. Well, of course, you are a very good person to ask this question, really, aren't you? Because let's face it, you have a history. Listen, Kay has a history of getting into TV shows, sometimes decades after they've been on.

28:27Yeah, so I've teed you up for it. Go on, you can give me a little bit of a slagging because it is your regular response to this. And it is true. So go on. Was it the West Wing? Yeah, it was the West Wing. Yeah. I one day came into work and was like, oh, my God, Boyd, the West Wing is amazing and he actually stopped what he was doing he put his head in his hands his desk, started rubbing his eyes and then started laughing because he was like how will you only come to this a decade later or whatever it was yes I have to say and I feel no shame around this no shame not that you're trying to make me feel shame but in the past I have felt embarrassed because obviously you know with what we do and stuff Although CV is only one part of what I do.

29:13But yeah, I often will come to stuff later, not a decade later. That was an extreme example, but a bit later than everyone else. And I actually don't care because I'm seeing it as everyone else is like the royal tasters, right, for me, to sample it and see. I mean, that very much sums up your regal approach to life. Queen K, Diva. Boyd's my royal sampler, right? so I get him to watch everything and then if he gets into something then I might consider it. So yeah. That's good to know. I have that power over you. So I'm coming late so as not to waste my time and then I really get into something and then I am that annoying person who will then talk to him about the thing that he watched however long ago.

30:00But so there are many things. West Wing being a great example. What about you? Is there anything, Royda? I said you'd find it hard to answer because you just watched everything instantly. I do watch most things instantly. I mean, you could go back in history. I don't think I watched The Wire as soon as it arrived. In fact, I'm trying to remember how and where it arrived on British TV. I failed to watch it, not first time around, but certainly for a while. And then halfway through season one of The Wire, all the critics were so enamoured with it, enamoured of it, enamoured by it, they were enamoured that I thought oh I've got to check out The Wire because I saw it as, I didn't really engage with what it really was, The Wire it's like a gangster drama you know like Gamora and I was like it takes someone to tell you this is not just a normal saga, this is something special and explain how special it is and it's the characters because, you know, it was the show that brought Idris Elba to fame and fortune, quite rightly, because he's so brilliant in it.

Read the full transcript

31:12All these British actors, by the way, playing, you know, characters from Brooklyn or the Bronx or whatever. So, yeah, that's the one that sticks in my head, actually. I was a bit late to the party with The Wire, I think, I'm pretty sure. Not years, but quite late. But you're right, because it's my job, and it has been for 27 years, Kay, to watch all this stuff for heat, you know, let alone Pilot TV when Pilot TV came along. I generally have to watch stuff that went as soon as it starts and then, you know, often I'll be wrong about it, as in, you know, the recent example of Widow's Bay. Oh, well, Boydo, actually, at that juncture, I've got a bit of a bone to pick with you.

31:55Yeah, Segway. If you finish talking about that. I have finished droning on incoherently about the show that I was slow to get on board with. Now, I have a bone to pick for you. Two people have got in touch, so I'm saying that in my head is hundreds. To say, I need to talk to all of you guys, but I said I'm going to just actually hone in on you about, and listeners, he is biting his nails. Good. Good sign that he's a little bit nervous. I mean, I don't know why you need to, go on, yeah. I'm always biting my nails. What I'm going to be cajoling you about. You've always got me on edge. Yeah, good.

32:28Where I'd like to keep you. Android. Yeah. Boyd. Okay. All right. Yeah. I know what you're going to say. I know what you're going to say. I'm shook, as the kids would say. Yeah. Now, before I begin this, I have to say, and this is, James is not here, but he'd like me to point out, I hosted the screening of Android, right? So I'm in Linda's pocket. That is the truth of it. You're in the pocket, big Android. However, anyone who knows me, first of all, knows I love comedy. I love Diane Morgan. I think she's so incredibly talented as an actor and a writer. I've loved all the stuff she's done before.

33:06And I love that she's joined up with Sarah Kendall in creating this and Sarah obviously stars in it as well. And I just don't understand what you didn't like about this because I think it's, I mean, I'm not saying it's uproariously hilarious, but it is funny and amusing and sweet and it's like heartwarming. I was surprised about how moving it was. I think obviously Sue Johnson, legend, she's great. and the dynamics between Linda and Su Su Su. Fantastic. Kevin from Motherland. You know, Paul Reddy. Why did you not like it? First of all, it wasn't just me. No, but I'm targeting you. Clearly. But I'm just putting context as if I'm the sole outlier.

33:52Right, question. How many episodes did you watch? Two. I totally, I like it. Don't get me wrong. She's brilliant. Diane Morgan is absolutely brilliant in everything she does. She's very funny as the robot. I just think, for me, I think it took too long in episode one to get to the point where she arrived as the robot. Right, okay. And I thought it was – I don't mind, you know, a melancholy, you know, kind of move. I thought it was trying to be moving too quickly. I thought it hadn't quite earned the right to be – this is a fan, it's very pompous, but this is my genuine thought. It hadn't quite got to the point where it was going to be moving and emotional.

34:36It moved too fast to that point for me, and I wanted more of the comedy of Diane Morgan's performance, which is hilarious, to arrive earlier on in six episodes. That was my quite specific criticism of it, and I just think she should have arrived earlier because it was getting a bit – it was getting too sad for my liking. but you know you say that and then you look at afterlife yeah but from memory no no no no no afterlife is sets up a situation being said from the off but it's it instantly dives within minutes into the how the characters being funny and you know that is true he doesn't weigh around yeah thanks that's a good good comparison thanks for bringing it up yeah in fact that you can you can have you can you can establish the situation this is just personal taste.

35:25I'm not saying it's not really good. I can see, my feeling about it is I admire it, what it's doing, and I love the fact it's addressing old age and loneliness, and it's also at the same time got a very funny performance by Diane Morgan in it as the robot, completely. But it's not, I feel merit as well to Amanda Land and those shows, it hasn't grabbed hold of me to the extent where I felt I had to carry on watching and watching the whole thing whereas you know Amanda Land did that and um Afterlife did that and a lot of those really you know the great comedies of our time you I really want I can't wait to develop the rest of them I just have not got that feeling with this show yet and I watched the second episode partly to um I wanted to write full full Diane Morgan led episodes with that character and it's still and I don't quite think it's got enough funny bit moments for me, scene upon scene.

36:25Yeah. But see, I disagree with that. I do take your points about the first episode. It feels slightly thin. It feels like it hasn't quite got enough people in it, enough characters in it. Do you know what I mean? I'm being hypercritical. No, I disagree with this because I think as soon as Linda is bedded in to the you know to the the household that dynamic between sue and linda provides a lot of comedy and the fact that actually sue's very resistant to having linda there and it's actually quite rude and horrible at times you know abrasive because she doesn't want to feel like she's a burden and that she needs it and then actually as that goes on it becomes funnier and funnier especially when they get involved in like certain things like getting locked out of the shop and you see the warmth in the relationship start to build and a friendship and that's like then you've got all the I can't remember what his character's called the son, Michael, and his wife who's cheated on him, and then all the stuff with the BJJ instructor.

37:26That is really funny. That comes into it as well. And then the Sue character, the widow, has all her motley crew of friends around her. So I think there's plenty of characters, and I think there are actually plenty of moments. But I think you need to open your heart to it, Boyd, and I think you need to continue watching. Will you give Okay For the people The hundreds of people Who got in touch with me Will you commit Considering they're Very short episodes Will you commit To finishing They're not very short They're half an hour Okay well Considering that you Watch movie 24-7 Will you watch some more I will watch more yeah I guess I'm thinking Of Diane Morgan So She's always had Brilliantly funny Flat out funny Laughter machine Types of shows You know All of All of her Stuff stuff has so far in her career has been brilliantly funny from word go from the first minute to the last and there's always been jokes and jokes and jokes funny scenes funny scenes funny scenes so there's a relentlessness to her i think so all the stuff she's done so far from filomena kunk to um what was the amanda lands origin show um motherland motherland thank you um whereas this doesn't feel that way that's my that's what i'm saying it just doesn't feel like it and i've seen people on social media going oh this is the greatest creation in the history of comedy you know about I think the characters are great like I think her as Linda is a fantastic creation but I do take your point this is not like gag per second it is it is sparse of gags I suppose like over you know it is funny still and there are gags in it it's just not as relentless as say Philomena Cunk which is one big gag Yeah, I mean, it's unfair for me to compare it in many ways.

39:15I get it. Thanks for acknowledging that, Boyd. I appreciate it. But I can only be honest. I'm gutted. I want to love it. I absolutely want to. And I really hope the time Morgan is listening because, you know, I think she's brilliant. I just haven't got that feeling about the show yet that I desperately need to carry on watching. Sorry. It's my honest reaction. I feel bad. But you've committed to watching more. I like this diversion from the mail back into a personal attack. Sorry. Well, because it was on my list of grievances that I need to address with you. And I just thought, let's just get it off my chest now.

39:45Yeah, good. Okay. It's almost a little bonus episode there. Yeah. Sorry. It could be a new slot, the grievances. Okay. Right. Now onto a message from Steve Cram. Still not that one, he says. Hi, team. With Kay back for a bit, I thought it was a good time for a recommendation. While waiting for a new series of Colin from Accounts. Oh, my God. I have to talk about that. That's me saying that, not Steve. He said there's a new Australian dog-based comedy called Dog Park. It's more of the dreaded, in inverted commas, comedy drama than Colin from Accounts, more gently amusing. That means Boyd's out.

40:22With a very few funny moments. The first season is only six episodes of 30 minutes each, so it's an easy binge. No idea where you'll be able to access it in the UK, but have a look if it turns up there. And if you do like it, also check out the programme created by one of its stars, Celia Pequola, called Rosehaven from a few years ago. Cheers, Steve. Have you heard of the swan ball? I haven't heard of it, but if it's a comedy set in a dog park revolving around dogs, then count me in. I mean, that's inherently a great idea. Yeah, fantastic. Can you keep an eye on, remember it, now try and commit that to memory, dog park.

41:01So have your radar. I'll try to remember, yes. And then as soon as you send out an alert, send off a flare, set up a flair dog park TV series it's an Australian dramatic comedy TV series released on February of this year so it's not it's quite recent it focuses on Roland played by Leon Ford who is in the grip of a midlife crisis and joins a group of dog owners in the local park sounds right up my street yeah sounds very much like up all our streets Colin adjacent yeah hey how did you take that news by the way I know I'm derailing us again What news? Last series. I mean, it has to be last series, yeah.

41:41Yeah. It has to be. Yeah. I agree, but it's still sad. Yeah. I thought the video they did was hilarious. Time for a couple more. I think we've got time for a couple more, don't we? Right. This message is from Simon, who says, Hi all. Question for the pod. I would like to hear everyone's thoughts on detective show tropes that are overused. For me, it's a substance abusing maverick detective because their wife slash husband slash sibling slash parent slash friend slash cat slash dog died. Very overused. A recent show you reviewed, I believe, The Detective had piles or something. Surely writers can give a character depth without resorting to trauma, addiction or illness.

42:16Love the pod. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts. Kind regards, Simon. I was trying to remember what show that was, The Detective with Piles. I remember it. It was because he applied it in the cubicle of the service station before he went to intercept a terrorist plot. and he was about to, he was then put on gardening leave. Do you remember? Yes. I wasn't on the pod, I don't think, but I watched it. Okay, full transparency. We had to pause and Google it because Boyd and I couldn't remember. Our communal brain fog was too much, but we both had it on the tip of our tongues. It's The Betrayal and it starred Sean Evans as John Hughes, who was a veteran MI5 operative, and he did have piles.

43:00But I have to tell you, Simon, I liked that detail. I thought it was very funny. and, yeah, just an everyday complaint. Well, for some people, not me. He's a hasten dad. Hey, don't pile shame anyone. No, I'm not pile shaming you. Steady. I support you. I'll go to boots for you boys. Fucking hell. Thanks. No, this is actually an example. Him having piles in the show, hemorrhoids, was actually an example of, because they hadn't fully been, they hadn't fully been, you know, diagnosed and all of that. And that was an example of showing his normality, really. so my my the tropes the detective tropes that annoy me are and i was i i saw a show the other day in fact in fact almost every show whether it's um uh the dark which was on which i really like by the way the dark i'm i think it's excellent on itv the serial killer thriller or the disney plus serial killer thriller which we reviewed um it in pilot on out on monday I knew you were going to ask that.

44:01Furious. It's called Furious. And we didn't like that. God, one of your most used words. Yeah, I know. Incredible. And yet the show failed to have up to the title. And in both cases, the detectives had issues from their past, traumas from their past. And that is such a trope. That's such a kind of cliche now, that every detective in every show has to have some trauma they're getting over, whether it's an old case where they were inadvertently responsible for someone dying or they hadn't solved the case. There's always that they haven't solved the case and they've ruined people's lives. They're getting over the trauma of something.

44:36Or they've had a trauma in their past that then fuels them on their quest for justice. Yeah, yeah. And obviously, it's quite, on one level, if you do it well, it can be quite realistic because obviously being a detective is a thing where you come up against a lot of bad stuff happening and you have to fight through the trauma. Yeah, and it also can send a lot, people turning to the bottom because of it. But for me, it's an absolute joy when there's a new detective drama series and within the first five minutes there isn't a flashback to something that happened in the detective's past that's going to haunt them to this day.

45:11It's a real uplifting moment. I agree. Wait, did you list the dark as an example of that? No. Well, the dark she has got. Have you watched the dark? Well, I watched the film. In fact, so I jotted down a couple of answers for this in terms of I think I completely agree with the correspondent about the fact that there are so many tropes. On the one hand, I am tired of them, particularly when they involve a flashback and you're like, oh, here we go. But then I also can see that sometimes it is part of life. Most people have small T, big T traumas in that job and it can either be as a result of the job or a motivating factor to do the job.

45:52So sometimes, as you say, if done well, it's not an issue for me. But I've noticed, actually, there are quite a few female detectives that aren't tropey like that and are really enjoyable. So, for example, Karen Peary. I don't think she's particularly fun. And that's refreshing. She's a brilliant example, exactly, of how it should be done. They do a brilliant job with Karen Peary, from the novels to the adaptations, of avoiding those cliches. Yeah, absolutely. absolutely but the doc i really the doc isn't quite i don't think of that level but but it's but and the lead detective does have issues oh so i listed her as an example because i'd only watched the first episode i know they there was a slight hint or something but it didn't seem major so detective inspector yeah um monica kennedy i listed her as an example of actually she's just a woman doing her job and there is something there but oh okay is there more there's more there is more not too much having said that I'm being slight and not too much Laura Donnelly play it it's not too much it doesn't derail it like it would in some shows well my last example was so DCI Jeanette Kilburn played by Eve Miles in The Crow Girl now I've got so first series of The Crow Girl do you remember it we reviewed so I thought she was fantastic I mean I love Eve Miles and I thought she was fantastic in this role and I love Jeanette because she seems so grounded and was just like a real like you know she was just juggling this domestic situation with her husband and kids like mostly the drama at home was involved around getting breakfast everyone having breakfast and then going to work um and she was refreshing in contrast to sophie um was it sophie or sophia craven katherine kelly's character basically who was quite heightened although having said all that like and i did feel like jeanette kilburn was an example of a not tropey detective.

47:48I just have to quickly say, did you watch series two? Have you watched any of it? Yes, yes, we reviewed it on the Stray Podcast. Okay, I watched the first episode. It has just gone crazy. Oh, completely. No, I wrote a poem about it. Total shit. I think, you know, it was always a lot. Yes, the most bonkers show of the year. It always had a hint of bonkers the first series, right? Oh, no, it's gone completely over the years. But they've just like, I was annoyed. I was going to, I needed to tell, I meant to text James because I know he loved series one. I was like, what have they done to it? Yeah, we all found it very entertaining though.

48:18Oh, really? I was annoyed because I just thought... Don't get annoyed. It was making it a bit ridiculous and I thought it had a good, you know, there was a good story at the core of it. I think it was always ridiculous, right? I mean, if you watch to the end of the first series, I mean, come on, the twist is absolutely preposterous. The twist is crazy, but then he just like... Just embrace the madness. Embrace the madness, Kay, is my voice. I thought it was a bit too cookie bogged, but maybe I'll continue. Anyways. Right, and our last question comes from Gary, two R's. he says having listened to the pod for many years now i've narrowed it down to approximately a thousand movies but if we could come up in the top 10 it would be great i get it it's not a film podcast but getting this list down on record is a holy grail moment for a lot of us now boy i've sprung that upon you but i think it's true i'm with gary to yours like at some point you do need to nail your colours to the mast.

49:10Listen, with the cat away, with our leader James having ousted him, as we have from this week of podcasts, listeners, we're recording four podcasts, so you might go, anyway. I feel it is time to finally nail down my list of favourite movies, so I'll be delighted to do so in the next pod. Okay, so next plus. I could do it in the main. Oh yeah, alright, okay. so the main podcast Boyd we're going to do it oh my god it can be like a little drum roll moment I'll practice my tapping yeah that'll be amazing I'll go through my top 50 favourites of all time no I'm joking 10 top 10 because this is your problem you get a bit too loosey goosey with the parameters I just quickly before we wrap up and I know I'm breaking the rules that I used to try and enforce so just to be a massive hypocrite while James is not here I went to the cinema at the weekend and watched The Invite.

50:08Yeah, I went for my yearly trip, film image, to the cinema. You didn't miss the screening? You didn't go to the wrong cinema? No, I know. Oh, incredible. Look at me, all grown up. Very good. And I absolutely bloody loved it. Oh, it's brilliant, yeah. It's my film of the year so far, yeah. Is it? It's so good. You know what it is, Kay? Go on. It's better. Yeah. It's better than The Odyssey. Wow. And that was going to be one that I saw this week, maybe. Well, put three hours aside for that. but you don't need to put three hours aside for the invite because it's mastered the art of gravity. Olivia Wilde.

50:43I mean, all of them are brilliant, but I just don't know how she was able to pull off the director-actor multiple hats there. And also, just before I finish on the film front, because this is illegal territory, now, have you seen Spa Weekend as a preview? Because the trailer came up, and it looks like it should for me, but it also doesn't look funny enough. It's got a fish in an echo. Yeah, I think it's a no for me. I would steer clear. I would, yeah. Heavy. I mean, I don't like to judge a film without seeing it, but, you know. But you have. Yeah. All right. I'm done. Okay. Are we closing the mailbox?

51:21Mailbag even? Yeah, I'm tying it up. That's me figuratively and metaphorically tying it up. Excellent. So that is a Pilot Plus for this week. Don't forget to watch Gamora The Origins on Sky Atlantic or now. That's all there now for you to enjoy all six episodes. And next week on the Pilot TV podcast, we have got very special guest, okay? Ricky Gervais will be on. Oh, my God. I'm excited. Talking about his new animated show, Alley Cats, which we can't review yet until the following episode because of embargoes. But we have got Ricky talking about that in full. And what we will be reviewing is a thing called Possession on Sky Atlantic with Gugu Bartha Raw, I believe.

52:07Benidorm is Murder on 5. Yes, John Hanna in Benidorm is Murder. You think it's a thin week? Yes, it is a thin week. And Lioness on the Paramount Plus, season three of Lioness. I don't know if you've watched any of that already, Kay. We'll find out. That's all to come in the next episode of the Pilot TV Podcast. Thanks for listening. Pilot out. Ow, Ow, Ow, Ow

From the publisher

James is away so the mice will play. That means in this case a ‘Dot & Ethel’ special with  Boyd and Kay co-hosting and reviewing the new Italian crime epic Gomorrah: The Origins on Sky Atlantic/NOW, specially chosen by Boyd because Kay is a foreign-language TV drama enthusiast. But how will she respond to this prequel to an ultra-violent mobster classic? We also crack open the postbag and remind ourselves of who played the young Elizabeth in The Crown, and get diverted by a disagreement over Ann Droid. 

More from Pilot TV+

All 149 episodes
PLUS Gomorrah: The Origins Pilot TV+ · 53 min
Listen in VO