In short
Review of Netflix’s Last Samurai Standing, framed as “Shogun meets Squid Game meets Race Across the World,” plus discussion of Netflix commissioning dates, look/feel, pacing, and violence “samurai fatigue.”
Guests
No specific guests are interviewed in this episode; it’s a podcast discussion between the hosts (Kay and Boyd are named; James is also referenced).
Key claims
The show’s premise is samurai forced into a deadly contest to reach Tokyo, with tokens around the neck used as “points” (kill to steal tokens). Netflix says it was mooted before Squid Game, but reviewers question timeline consistency (development 2022 vs Squid Game airing 2021). The first episode is spectacular and beautifully shot, with Junichi Okada as star/action choreographer.
Notable examples
VIPs betting and gunmen behind gun ports (Squid Game parallels); a battle sequence that feels like a one-shot; a cholera outbreak subplot; the show’s violence and varied archetypal fighters (including a character with dreadlocks) and an episode titled “Mortal Kombat.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOOverview of Last Samurai Standing
0:46 to 2:30
Discussion on the Last Samurai Standing and its unique premise.
“and I'm not the only one, because it's an incredibly glaring comparison.”
Cultural Comparisons and Themes
2:31 to 4:19
Exploration of similarities with Squid Game and cultural themes in the show.
“Well, first of all, this was, as you said, it is a quiet week, so it's fair enough that we're doing it.”
Production Quality and Storytelling
4:20 to 6:10
Analysis of the show's production value and storytelling techniques.
“it starts out in absolutely spectacular style there's this amazing battle sequence and it kind of feels like a one shot is it a one shot?”
Character Development and Fatigue
6:11 to 8:00
Discussion on character depth and action fatigue experienced while watching.
“It just has an intrinsically more epic story.”
Narrative Style and Engagement
8:01 to 9:10
Reflection on the narrative style and engaging elements of the series.
“And there was a point where I was like, shall I just forward it for a few?”
Final Thoughts on Last Samurai Standing
9:11 to 12:43
Conclusion on the overall impression of Last Samurai Standing.
“and I don't know if I'll watch any more.”
Post Bag Introduction
14:01 to 15:11
The hosts introduce the post bag segment and describe its format.
“Ladies and gentlemen, it's Miss Kay versus the post bag.”
Listener Feedback on Pilot Plus
15:12 to 15:59
Discussion about listener Andrew's feedback regarding the podcast format.
“Okay, just so you know, his eyes are basically telling a different story.”
Documentary Discussion
16:00 to 17:20
A listener raises a concern about the lack of documentaries covered in the podcast.
“I strongly suspect this is due to the authoritarian control James has over what you review and is famously, ha ha ha, a version of things, even barely touching on reality.”
Debate on Documentary Coverage
17:21 to 20:01
The hosts debate the podcast's focus on scripted shows over documentaries.
“Well, that's a film, so we wouldn't cover that.”
Show all 24 chapters
In Defense of the OA
20:02 to 24:17
Discussion about whether listeners should watch the series 'The OA' despite its incomplete story.
“I mean, we generally assume everything is his fault, and then every now and then there will be something...”
Listener Emails and Game Recommendations
24:18 to 28:00
The hosts discuss a listener's recommendation for a superhero game and its narrative style.
“So, yes, resoundingly, you should watch the OA.”
Chocolate Debate and Listener Emails
28:00 to 29:20
Discussion on chocolate preferences sparked by a listener's email.
“But I've sent myself a reminder to get hold of a copy of the game for consideration for our Games of the Year list.”
National Treasures and Celebrity Status
29:20 to 30:20
Exploration of who qualifies as a national treasure in the UK.
“Oh, boy, it'd be like a little, you know the little rabbit with a bell around its neck?”
Defining 'Deliberately Paced' Shows
30:20 to 32:40
Analysis of pacing in television shows including 'Pluribus' and 'Better Call Saul'.
“I watched a bit of Tracer, so you can see why his stock has risen.”
The Committee of National Treasures
32:40 to 34:20
Humorous discussion on the informal committee defining national treasures.
“When they're on the round table, they keep going, I'm voting for you, for yourself, Brian, or whatever.”
Listener Thoughts on Pluribus
34:20 to 36:50
Listener feedback on the pacing of 'Pluribus' and its comparison to other shows.
“Now for a message from Holly about Pluribus, and specifically the pacing.”
British Procedurals and Their Impact
36:50 to 42:00
Discussion on various British procedural dramas and their storytelling styles.
“Also, thank you for the traitors chat and the D &D updates from James.”
Exploring British Procedurals
42:00 to 44:50
A discussion on the merits of various British procedural dramas.
“When Cracker is, I mean, I guess it's in blocks, isn't it?”
Game Show Creators in TV
44:50 to 47:10
Discussion on writers and directors transitioning from game shows to serial television.
“After some fact-checking on this, I can confirm it's true.”
The Spoiler Dilemma
47:10 to 49:40
An exploration of what constitutes a spoiler in television reviews.
“as I asked about it a number of years ago, although he kind of roasted me for it.”
Viewer Reactions to The Morning Show
49:40 to 52:36
Listener feedback and discussion about the current season of The Morning Show.
“Do you think I should start each episode by saying spoiler, but Boydy spoilers something in this episode?”
Partridge-isms and Podcast Naming
52:36 to 55:48
A humorous exchange about podcast naming conventions and comparisons to Alan Partridge.
“I still maintain this is a lesser series of The Morning Show, but as we said when we reviewed it, a lesser series of The Morning Show is still very watchable.”
Discussing Screeners for Black Doves
56:00 to 56:30
They discuss the idea of early screeners for the series Black Doves.
“Okay, that is it for this week's Pilot Plus.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:07Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters. And this week, we are gathered to address an oversight. Not ours, if I'm honest with you. I'd say a Netflix oversight. So, a show dropped several weeks ago called Last Samurai Standing on Netflix. And it was one of those shows, much like the original, when they dropped Squid Game originally, they didn't really talk about it much beforehand. You know, it just kind of appeared and people discovered it through the algorithm. But it quickly became a bit of a phenomenon. Lots of people talking about it online. And I was like, what is this thing?
0:36So, and this has nothing to do with the fact this is an incredibly slow week and there's nothing else on. we were like, well, you know, let's go back and let's review Last Samurai Standing on Netflix. Now, this is a show that I would describe, and I'm not the only one, because it's an incredibly glaring comparison. If you took Shogun and Squid Game and put them in a blender, you would basically come up with this show. So this stars Junichi Okada, Yumiya Fujisaki, and Kaya Kiyohara. And it is essentially a load, it's set in the, oh, let me get my ears right, it's the Meiji period in Japan. which is the late 19th century.
1:13And to give you some concepts, there's a period of time where the samurai class was essentially being sort of pushed to the margins. It's a phase-out. Right, yeah, they were being phased out. They were being constructively dismissed. So essentially, they were banned from carrying swords. They were no longer receiving stipends or financial assistance. So the samurai class was seen as anachronistic and Japan was modernizing, so they didn't want samurais around. So enter essentially the Squid Game, where they offer a huge catch prize. There's almost like the piggy bank from Squid Game, except it's a big earthenware urn thing full of gold coins.
1:43And they invite, I think it's 292 samurai into this arena. And the idea is that they're going to play a game. And if they agree to play the game, they have to play the game. They cannot quit the game. And the essentially game is, you're going to go through various checkpoints to get to Tokyo, and you must fight to the death along the way. It's basically my idea of a better race across the world. So, because you have to have a certain amount of points at each checkpoint, and that's caused by these wooden tokens you have around your neck. So you essentially have to kill people and take their tokens.
2:13And that's, broadly speaking, the setup of this. And the main character here, who is played by Junichi Okada, he is an old sort of former samurai, a war veteran with crippling PTSD, and doesn't like to unsheathe his sword. But yeah, so, Boydie, that's, broadly speaking, the setup for this. What did you think? Well, first of all, this was, as you said, it is a quiet week, so it's fair enough that we're doing it. But I don't think it's that glaring an omission. Because, I mean, you were saying everyone's talking about it online. It has been a lot of buzz. Maybe in your world. Well, maybe. In James' universe.
2:45But, first of all, it's not in the top ten, we should say, of the UK. So the algorithm doesn't like it. I mean, you know, it's not... Maybe it will grow. I mean, I looked online, and you're right, there's a lot of, you know, people... Basically, the reason it's causing so much discussion is because of your description. Yeah, because it's Shogun meets Squid Game. So extraordinarily, particularly the Squid Game element of it. So, so heavy. It's insane how similar it is, because you've also got bigwigs kind of watching and betting on them. Oh, yeah, like the VIPs. Like the VIPs, yeah. And the host, again, has a real...
3:16And also, and this may not be true, but I was curious, I turned on the dub at one point, and I would swear Blinded is the same people doing... Maybe they do all the Netflix stuff, I have no idea. But I recognise the voices doing the dub from Squid Game. Yeah, I mean, it may be the case, yeah. So it is really weird. And Netflix, I was also doing the research, and Netflix are very keen to point out this was commissioned, or at least mooted, as a show before Squid Game came along. Yeah, but did you see the dates, they said? Yes, I did see the dates, yes. So one reviewer pointed out, an American reviewer pointed out, that actually, unless it's a misprint, the dates don't tally with what they're saying.
3:57No, because I think, oh, this was in development in 2022. Yeah, well, Squid Game aired the year before. Yeah, so it's a real mystery. and also did anything like this really happen? No I mean there's vague attempts by some people somewhere to say something might have happened but no I don't think it did I don't think it did either so it's fascinating from that point of view as for the show itself it starts out in absolutely spectacular style there's this amazing battle sequence and it kind of feels like a one shot is it a one shot? Halfway through I was thinking is this one shot? Do you know what?
4:30I didn't notice It's beautifully shot Beautifully shot your main guy here Junichi Okada he's the action choreographer and the star so he's very much in the thick of it very much like what's his Jackie Chan Jackie Chan was like full on kind of directing being starring and doing all the choreography etc so he's the new Jackie Chan for sure so that sequence is astonishing and it's like incredible mass slaughter beheading then there's these like bombs that arrive at the end of the thing I'm like what are these where did they come from and it's incredibly effective and then it settles down to show you his backstory with his very sick daughter and wife.
5:09And there's a lot... There's a cholera outbreak, isn't there? There's a cholera epidemic going on. Falls on the heartstrings. Just to add to the sense of fun. But it's what you're saying. It's basically the setup of Squid Game. Is it people in financial hardship and desperation are forced into this dangerous game? Yeah. So I think the main reason why it's so interesting as a project is because of the mad connections to Squid Game. but I think once it's settled down and starts doing what Squid Game had to do which is introduce you to a cast of characters who are all going to end up taking part in this game it becomes slightly less interesting and the characters at least to start with I've only watched the first episode are fairly one dimensional but you can't really blame them You don't have to watch the second one because the first one ends on a cliffhanger I couldn't stop Oh yeah, I know It's more of a timing issue Fair enough It does end on and it's bookended by the beginning and the ending are both really kind of exciting and intense and the big old battle royale in the middle yeah I mean there's a lot going on and it is really well handled did you see there was another thing this week there's been a lot of Netflix news stories and stuff going on Stranger Things arrives by the way hopefully we'll be reviewing that if we all get up early enough in the morning but yeah about how all Netflix shows look the same now you know this went back years ago there was this claim that all Netflix shows look the same and have the same kind of colour palette but I was watching the thing that struck me about this show this doesn't look like every other Netflix show at all and it has its own look and feel I don't even know if that and I was reading this a recent article delineating all these Netflix shows that supposedly are the same which I don't think they do I'm really going I don't think that's true anyway you should do a counter article if I had the time pull your finger out maybe yeah I might do a counter sentence just to point out we've done it you said it now exactly it's out there the person who wrote the article should listen to what I'm saying but this but this felt like a show in and of itself which had its own unique style and approach and it is it is spectacular I mean it looks it looks really expensive you know that's the other thing it's not like a it doesn't feel like a kind of you know rip off of those shows we mentioned it feels like it's got the production values of Shogun I mean not quite as no I don't think completely the same right well I think it doesn't need to have quite Shogun has this epic historical depiction of the people the different rivals people in charge of the country.
7:32It just has an intrinsically more epic story. I think this is a slightly smaller scale. I mean, the battle sequences and all of that are a big scale. But it's a personal journey, isn't it? It's Lone Wolf and Carb is what this is. That's what I'm trying to say. Yeah, exactly. But, you know, within its production, it's still pretty impressive. I think it looks the part. It looks like it's had money thrown at it. And it's pretty decent, yeah. But I didn't feel, unlike you, I didn't feel I had to carry on watching it but I will hopefully catch up and yeah it's an interesting phenomenon I'd like to hear more about just how just how when it was commissioned because that's the interesting thing okay so I think anyone who likes Shogun will love this if you love being immersed in that world and I did love Shogun so I did enjoy watching this I don't think the quality is I mean I can see that there is money on the screen but I don't it doesn't compare to me to Shogun which I think is in a league of its own but yeah this is what I'm describing as soapy squid gun right and I think if you like lean into that of this like this blend of these two shows and the fact that it's because I think some of the acting like particularly by our main guy some of it it's there is a soapy quality to it you know these lingering glances and like and in terms of the fighting and everything I actually got samurai fatigue I'd say three quarters the way through because it's only like it's a blitz It's this blizzard of like sword fighting, head decapitations, etc.
9:01And there was a point where I was like, shall I just forward it for a few? Because it was interminable at one point. But I think it's really enjoyable. I don't think it's, you know, up there with Shogun, and I don't know if I'll watch any more. But if you love that world, you're going to, yeah, lap it up. Yeah, I think there is an issue that you are slightly numbed to, because there's so much violence going on intrinsically within the storyline. There has to be. yeah you get a bit immune to it and a bit it all kind of yeah i think that is a danger and it was shogun if i remember rightly didn't really have that much action going on it was about kind of exploring the characters developing the characters introducing them just introducing us to this quite complicated world um whereas this is just going hell for leather isn't it most of the time um thrusting you into the into the violence and mayhem i did enjoy the checkpoint the mention of the checkpoints because i did think yeah this is race across the world but oh yeah it's race Race Across the World as well.
9:56It is, exactly. Yeah, that's the other thing it is. It's Shogun meets the... What's it called? Squid Game meets Race Across the World, which, of course, you would know about, James. I did. I referenced Race Across the World when I introduced it. Oh, did you? Yeah. See, I'm not the only one who doesn't listen. No, he didn't. Don't get smug. We both know that there's one winner of that. I was more monitoring your pronunciation of the star names. I see. I see. That's fair. I don't actually think this really has much, if any, DNA in common with Shogun, other than the fact that it's set in this kind of feudal Japanese time period.
10:26Or post-feudal, I guess, at this point. But it's kind of like, because it begins with the Bochian War, and that I think you could definitely get fatigue from, because he's running through the battlefield just like, and you're seeing this sort of central character in his prime. He's the manslayer. He's this extraordinary samurai, and he just carves a path through this battlefield. And then kind of showing that samurai have essentially become an anachronism, then they sort of bombard them with artillery. It's like, you know, all the swords you like, but we've got mortars. And then you see him afterwards, you know, flash forward a few years later, after the war, he's horribly PTSD'd from all of his ordeals, but also desperate.
11:04So I think, you know, to your point, Kay, I think if you like that sort of like Japanese period, you know, sword, samurai, all that kind of, you know, Shambara stuff, then absolutely it delivers on that. It's quite, I think, computer game inspired. I mean, the last episode, I think, is literally called Mortal Kombat. but there's an element of that in that and I get why they've done it so you have these 292 samurai spoiler not that many by the end of the first episode quite a few get killed but there are very distinct like there's a big grizzly one with dreadlocks and there's another one with a robe and there's like a woman with her weapons and so there are I would say very visually distinctive archetypes amongst the fighters and that for me feels quite gamey but actually I understand why they've done it because you need some visual distinction because otherwise you're right, you get samurai fatigue, it's just people hitting each other with swords.
11:53I actually like that they've got a variety of different weapons and characters, like a huge guy with this great big fat scimitar thing. And it's, you know, I thought the fighting stuff was brilliantly choreographed. I thought it was really, really entertaining. Oh, yeah. I don't think he's only disputing that. It's just more the amount of it. But you also have that squid game aspect where you've got men with guns hiding behind gun ports. Just picking them off. Picking them off when they break the rules. It's so squid game. But that honestly just made it incredibly compelling to me because it is, for me, it's like, it's Squid Game, but it's on the road and it's like in this kind of, and he, we should say, when I mentioned Lone Wolf and Carbis, because there's a young woman there who's clearly out of her depth and she's there to kind of save her mother and he takes her under his wing to try and protect her.
12:34And so he ends up with her and she is, to be fair, certainly early on, a bit of a liability. But yeah, I thought it was really well put together. I blazed through the second episode. I'm really enjoying it. I think it's six episodes long. It's quite short. Do you not feel the music cheapened it somewhat? I didn't. No, I didn't have an issue with the music. No, I thought the whole thing was great. I don't recommend listening to the dub. I did it for about five minutes and then immediately turned it off again. The subtitles, obviously, not on a par with Shoguns. But, you know, I dealt with it. They were quite big, though, weren't they?
13:04Oh, they were big. They just weren't quite as good. Not big enough for this. No, that's right. No, for a while. This connoisseur. I think on the length, I think Six seems right. I'm trying to work out how they're going to stretch it to that far. And continue it. Yeah. But it's, yeah, I think this is one of those really nice discoveries on Netflix. You're like, oh, this is great. Didn't know what it is. It's here. So I do, I recommend people watch it. I think it's a load of fun. Last Samurai Standing on the Netflix. Now. Okay, brilliant. Shall we have the post bag? I was just thinking a spin-off show for us would be the last Pilot TV pod standing.
13:41Last podcast standing. for our Christmas party. Wow. Well, But you've often said that we should go on Race Across the World, so perhaps this is a more interesting spin on it. Yeah. We all just have wooden dog tags. Yeah. And by the end of the party, see who's... See who's got them all. Yeah. God. Anyway, it's something to think about. Ask two for standing. Yeah. Right. Are we going to do post? Yes. Let's do the post bag. Ladies and gentlemen, it's Miss Kay versus the post bag.
14:22Because the sort of like the post bag potluck work quite well, I'm going to go for it again, James. Okay. This is a... The triage system emerges triumphant. Well, for this week. Right, so we are going to start with a message from Andrew who says, Hi guys, I seem to remember James asking for us to give feedback on what we thought about Pilot and Pilot Plus. What was the outcome? I suggested that the three of you should recommend a programme each week, so less of a benevolent dictatorship in operation. Imagine the variety of shows we could hear about. Thanks, Andrew. Well, obviously, I got a team of people to sort through all of the data and separate it into separate spreadsheets, which I then spent many hours poring over, distilling all of your feedback into the show itself.
15:10Oh, good shame. And that is largely what's happened and is continuing to happen. Is it really? Yeah, it's an ongoing process. Okay, just so you know, his eyes are basically telling a different story. Okay, fine, he forgot about it. No, I did not forget. I did not forget. And to be fair, I have gone through a number of... Well, the reason why the kind of spoiler specials got broken out of this episode into their own separate entities is partly for that reason, because that was an overwhelming request from people. Okay. But yes, no, I appreciated all of the feedback. It was great. Okay, well, there's your answer, Andrew.
15:41we can take that you took one bit of advice from the questionnaires and the rest of it is now languishing no I'm sure you are filtering it and slowly yes yes that is that is exactly what is happening that's what we're saying yeah I'm actually happy because I was terrified about the results I don't know about you so the fact that you know yeah it was really I was just scared to share it with Kay that's really what it was I mean I'm a very sensitive son the one who don't slurp tea in the middle of oh he's going to do it he's literally he's slurping tea look at him I love it he can't be contained he just has to do what he wants to do I'm sorry just needs must sometimes always stay hydrated Boydo right so now this one comes from Marek who says oh James you like this a subject heading of a bone to pick with James oh god great so that's a good start they love the potluck nature of the pace back yeah I really enjoy it it seems heavily skewed in a certain direction I wonder why that is no usually I filter this stuff out right okay so he says I've been listening to your fab podcast since it started and while it's an essential part of my week and has helped me wade through the overwhelming amount of TV and choose what to watch, I've recently noticed one glaring omission, documentaries.
16:47I strongly suspect this is due to the authoritarian control James has over what you review and is famously, ha ha ha, a version of things, even barely touching on reality. There are a wealth of fantastic documentaries on streaming services that are just as compelling and dramatic as scripted shows, but there are also a huge amount to choose from and it would be great if you could help your listeners wade through these too. I just watched The Perfect Neighbor on Netflix, which was fantastic. What are some of your favorite documentaries? And James, they don't all have to be scary and depressing and hard to watch.
17:18The latest Eddie Murphy documentary was really funny and interesting. Well, that's a film, so we wouldn't cover that. Being Eddie, which is, yes, quite correct. It's very good. If you're into Eddie Murphy, it's great. But no, so we've covered documentaries in the past, though generally speaking only when there hasn't been a relevant scripted show. We would have covered the Beatles anthology, because last week was very slow, except we didn't get screened, so we literally couldn't. And it was heavily embargoed. And it was heavily embargoed. I think you maybe overestimate my amount of authoritarian control over this podcast.
17:50I don't think it's true about the documentaries. I don't think that he's underestimated it, but I would say... I don't know the demis. But, oh my God. I wish I had more control over this podcast. Absolutely not. But anyways, no, he hasn't put his foot down about documentaries, to be fair. No, I have not banned them. Oh yeah, I think our emphasis from the start, the whole nub of the Pilot TV podcast was cinematic television. That was the whole kind of start of it, of the brand, if I can use that word, wasn't it? And obviously documentaries can be cinematic and often are, and they're often in their way as creative, etc., as scripted shows.
18:32But I think unashamedly our emphasis is always going to be on transcripted stuff just because that's how it all started really so and i guess um you know everyone every now and then did we do the the uh the beetle the last beetles documentary i'm trying to remember which was so interestingly i watched that yeah and i can't think why else i would have done my memories we did because yeah i remember watching yeah exactly i mean i would watch it anyway because i'm i love the beetles but um that i think we did that and we i think back in the day Making a Murderer didn't we do that because that was such a phenomenon I don't think we did Making a Murderer but we've done a few we've done a few true crime was there a staircase staircase maybe yeah we've done a few of those true crime that really hit home and became phenomena and I think we would again but and I love you know do you know what we probably should have done recently in a good example is the Martin Scorsese series Mr Scorsese Mr Scorsese which is which I loved and is a you know it's kind of inherently cinematic because half of it is clips of his work, you know, etc.
19:35Did you mention it? I did mention it. I totally mentioned it. Kay would have vetoed it because it involves films. Yeah, maybe. No, if it's a TV show, I would have. Yeah, no. But something like that, I think we probably should have done looking back on it. But I can't remember what else was on that week, etc., etc. But in general, we admit, it is for good or ill, documentaries are lower on our list of priorities. Yes, but it's not on James. That's just a... No, no, that's definitely... I mean, that's not James. Many other things are my fault. Yeah, everything is his fault. We should emphasise that.
20:01Oh, yeah, he carries the burden for everything else. I mean, we generally assume everything is his fault, and then every now and then there will be something... But on this particular occasion. We're nothing if not fair. Thank you. I'm innocent. But it's like saying one more thing. We don't do... There's other genres of TV we don't really do. Animation, Boyd, lest we forget. No, we have done animation. We have done animation. Similarly, when it's a phenomenon, we have done animation. Oh, really? I advocated for Arcane. I loved Arcane. Yeah, exactly. And I watched that, as I recall, based on essentially listeners telling me that I needed to watch it.
20:29and I did a Bojack Horseman yes you did in fact we did watch that I did not enjoy it no there you go because we did we did a few when we I don't know if it was an off spin off spin an off spin one of those off spins I don't know if it was a funny or dire thing but we went through a period of watching like we did a Rick and Morty we did a few different things on Pilot Plus I think because people got so annoyed with both you and me because was Beth a fact so Beth was our animation correspondent oh okay so she used to champion animated stuff It has been a lack. So it is, in many ways, your form. Listen, when I signed up, you knew that I didn't like animation.
21:06But okay, let's move on to now, James, who says... Is this me? Is this me writing in for right of reply? James Heal, who says, My pilot crew, Boyd briefly mentioned Death by Lightning a couple of weeks back. I'm only two episodes down, but so far it's been fantastic. And it's all largely down to Matthew McFadden. He really brings that Tom succession energy to the role. in a way the show feels like someone typed in Broadwalk Empire does the West Wing but with some succession dark humour to create this show and it really works it's going to be high up there alongside the Chair Company and Pluribus in my end of year list we're really being treated to some great TV this autumn kind regards James yeah Chair Company another show that we weren't able to cover on the podcast I think Boyd did you mentioned it I mentioned the big erect penis shot last week oh yes you did we've not had any complaints about that that I've seen which is good what about the erect penis no about the spoilers about Yes,
22:03I second all those things. And Matthew McFadden is brilliant in that show. I think he'll get Emmy nominations and everything. Heard it here first. Okay, actually, I'm going to skip forward to some spoiler stuff because you mentioned spoilers. And the subject of this is Boyd versus the Spoiler Police. Excellent. Oh, God. Come for Boyd. You've already had your pound of flesh from me. Right. so this is from Alison who says hello lovely pilot team in the case of Boyd versus the spoiler please just now Alison I just want you to know because I've skim read this so I know where it's going right but Boyd doesn't and crucially at one point his arms were crossed in a very like telling way yeah the people versus Boyd Hilton as we should call this may I direct the jury's attention to the title of the episode of Pluribus for which Boyd is accused of giving spoilers which is grenade yes Okay, that's really funny.
22:58As basically, all boys said was, I love the bit with the grenade. I rest my case, Your Honour. Thank you. Yes, Alison, well done. Oh, what a hero. Always a bit exonerated. Yes. This was disappointing. I know. Do you know what? Because I had skim read it. I led you down the garden path, James. You did. But anyway, she goes on and says, I just wanted to say thanks for a fantastic pod that has allowed me to catch great new shows like Pluribus and also older shows that get a mention as being favourites of one or more of the team. this allowed me to discover some absolute delights such as the leftovers which i had missed at the time and brassic where i had the great pleasure of binging season one six prior to the finale of season seven which i'd love a spoiler tastic discussion of i have questions regarding older favorite shows would the team still advise watching the oa which i've not seen despite the fact that the planned story arc was cut short or will it just be too upsetting keep up the good work five star, no notes.
23:51I think you absolutely can, because A, I think the first season of the OA could stand alone, to an extent. And the second one, even that also, it doesn't stand alone in that it ends on a kind of big cliffhanger, but not... It's weird, it's hard to explain without spoiling it, which I'm not going to do, but I would argue, wouldn't you agree, Bordy, that the ending of the OA... It is a cliffhanger because it's tantalising, but the broad events of season two do get wrapped up. It's just, there's a thing on the end, there's a coda that will blow your mind and it's just so exciting what they would have done after that, which we'll never get to see First of all we might get to see because still in answer to any question about it, they say well Jason Isaacs, on this very podcast we interviewed him before, the White Lotus was like, no we're still talking about how to carry on, so I mean I live in hope that one day it will be, I can't quite come to terms with the idea that it won't be because the ending is such a extraordinary thing of season two that it will be insane for us to never find out what the fuck is going on.
24:54So, yes, resoundingly, you should watch the OA. Yes. As should everyone else. Okay, Alison. And thanks on Boyd's behalf for the defence, right? Very much so. Grenade, here we come. Now for a message from Bent who says, taking a risk here because I know that Boyd doesn't play games, Kay doesn't play games, nor has much interest in superhero stories. And James brushed over this last week on the phone. what this is going to be about. But you should really give Dispatch a try. Is this what you thought? Yeah. Okay, he says, yes, it's a game, but think interactive narrative with some mini-games. It's the best superhero story in years across any medium.
25:31The writing is exceptional with A-list performances from Aaron Paul, Geoffrey Wright, and Laura Bailey, brackets Abby from The Last of Us. Come on, James. I'm attaching a 9 out of 10 review to win you over. You're genuinely missing out on something special. Loyal paying listener from Norway who will bring you all real chocolate in capsules at the next Pilot TV or Empire Live show. Best regards, Bent. The next Empire Live show is I think on the 9th of January. So best book your ticket. Okay. Episode 700, I think. Wow. I don't remember. What an achievement. Yeah, don't even. But this, with this patch, yes, I have heard that it's fabulous.
26:05The issue I have, I don't enjoy that type of game. Those kind of interactive narrative games, the telltale type story. Nick, the assemblyman of the Empire Parish, loves those things. But I'm always a bit like, I could just watch this on YouTube and it would be much the same because you don't really, there's not a lot of interaction. You're really just watching it play out. Now, Dispatch started life, it was going to be a TV show before it became a games, which I think, and a lot of that DNA is still in it. So I'm interested in it, but I like games that have proper gameplay. So, just to give you some perspective on this, so The Expanse released a Telltale game, which was an Expanse narrative game where you kind of interact with it, but really it's just an interactive story.
26:44What does Telltale game mean? Telltale, no, Telltale is a company. and they make a lot of these games. The first game of theirs that I genuinely love, which is the very first Walking Dead game they did, which I thought was really powerful, and I thought that was great. But then every game of theirs I played afterwards, these are all very much the same. Like, Clementine will remember this. And I got a bit bored of it. Nick loves them, as I say. I just don't really. It's a type of storytelling I've never really been able to get on board with. I'm like, give me something I can just watch or give me something I can play, but I don't like this kind of hinterland between them.
27:17That said, all of that said, I will do my absolute best to give it a go because we're going to be doing the Games of the Year list on the website. Talking about Unsung Heroes. So I will maybe see if we can have a look at it for that. What is this Dispatch game about? Superheroes, essentially. I think it's a dispatch centre for superheroes, is my understanding. But I know it's had great reviews. It's supposed to be fabulous. Do you know what? Not least from Bent. Right. I'm going to assume it's Ben T. But I don't know. Oh, Ben T. Oh, my God. Oh, Lord. Well, Ben. Ben T. Well. I'm going to send myself a reminder now.
27:47Is that a Norwegian name? I don't know. I'm so embarrassed. I don't know, but I'm going to... Benti, I'm so sorry that I've just been calling you Benter. Hey, I don't... It might be Benter. It might be. Benter is a name. Nicholas Bender was an Arsenal player. Oh, really? It could be just his nickname. Yeah, all names turn back to Arsenal. But I've sent myself a reminder to get hold of a copy of the game for consideration for our Games of the Year list. Oh, very good. See, your emails matter. Yeah, there we go. You've moved the needle. Wow. Right, now for a message from Michael. And the subject heading is, in defence of lint.
28:19Yes. Dear James. Love it. Here we go. I agree with you on quite a number of things. Foundation and reality chase, for example. And I love dairy milk chocolate as much as any other chocoholic worth their sugar. Well done. But to rank it above lint, which is arguably the greatest chocolate in the world, is just absurd. Does he just like the little rabbits? Hang your head in shame, he says. Hi, Kay and Boyd. Just for the record, you three can bang on about chocolate or long promised cakes or New York hotel rooms or missed trains or even TV shows as much as you like. I'm just happy to hear the three of you chatting twice a week.
Read the full transcript
28:54Oh, you might be my favourite. Who's this? Michael, Michael Shirley. Thank you. What a great email. And he says, you can even spoil twists, etc. I don't care. I do wish people... I'll same to you, Boydie. Well, it's fine. I do wish people would stop being so precious about it. Yes. I left you a five-star rating on my podcast app, Pocket Cast. But did you write a poem? That's the question. But as far as I can tell, I can't leave a comment, so consider this my review. Cheerio, Michael. Bars of lint all round. Yeah. Oh, boy, it'd be like a little, you know the little rabbit with a bell around its neck?
29:24You'd get one of those, not a bar. Do you know what the most egregious point about the whole story, other than obviously he went on this whole thing about the lint thing and thing, was the fact that I bought these chocolates. Yeah. Not a single word of thank you came out of his mouth as he guzzled them and complained about them. I thanked Darren. They were Darren's chocolates. Yeah, I mean, I suppose that's true. Fair enough. All right. Well, at least as long as someone was saying, I don't mind. As I've said before, that's what happens when you live in a fascist regime. It's just part of the hard thing.
29:52Yeah. So, yeah, lint. We should get our next live podcast sponsored by lint. Do you think that's what they meant in The Dark Knight? When they say there was nothing in his pockets but knives and lint, they actually meant lint chocolate. And the joker is a massive fan. Yeah, get lint sponsorship and then a fondue situation. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Great. Dairy milk, not having it. It's so basic. It's true. Right. Paul's got in touch to say, not convinced, re-Alan Carr. I watched a bit of Tracer, so you can see why his stock has risen. Oh, sorry. How can you watch a bit of Tracer? Sorry to interrupt.
30:29No, that's all right. I just realised I didn't read the subject heading, which would give context. It says National Treasure slash Treasures. Right. So he's not convinced, because if he's won, then Graham Norton would be brilliant, Ed Terrier Wogan on Eurovision. The term is so over slash misused, see unique, exclusive, myself, etc. Yeah, I hate the myself one. Oh, yeah. Yeah, that people are now talking about a true national treasure. So who does that leave us with? Judi Dench, Stephen Fry, and question mark. I agree. Like, I actually don't think... Alan isn't a national treasure to me, but he just...
31:03No, I mean, I love him. I don't know if he's like, you consider him a national treasure in the same league as, say, Judi Dench, for example, but he is like a brilliant entertainer. I think he's the definition of a national treasure. They're all different. Obviously, he's not a dame yet. Could be if he wanted to. So, yeah, the national treasure thing is that he's been... Beloved. Beloved for years for those in the know who followed his career, as we have, Kay and me. And he's done a lot with Heat over the years. Absolute bloody legend. And giving me awards, obviously, a high point for him, career-wise.
31:41Completely. Then he did, so I think he was much loved anyway. Yes. And on the verge of national treasure status anyway. And then he did the traitors and won and burst into tears when he won. And all the emotions came out. And he's handled it brilliantly and talked about it brilliantly. And that's what elevates him to national treasure status. I think he's a different kind of national treasure to David Judy. She's the only one we keep thinking of. other names are available. Also, hello, David Attenborough. David Attenborough, for sure. But I think he's definitely a national treasure. Okay, so what we're saying is...
32:16And there's something about his fundamental kind of decency, he's a big word, but he's such a delight, I think, all around. On screen and off, crucial. Yeah, on screen and off. He's totally the same off screen, exactly. So yeah, I think it's partly that. It's slightly intangible, but I think he absolutely, 100 % is a national treasure. But I agree it's overused, by the way. I totally agree with that. And the yourself thing is brilliant. Oh, myself. When they're on the round table. But both. When they're on the round table, they keep going, I'm voting for you, for yourself, Brian, or whatever. It's like, oh, stop saying yourself.
32:47No, it's my fault. I voted for you. Carry on. I don't know what you're referring to. So, it's particularly egregious in traitors, but it seems to be a young people's thing. I'm going to sound like an old twat yet again. I was like myself and Boyd. Yeah, it's saying, people refer to themselves as myself, rather than just me. and when they're talking about someone else, they're going, hello, James, yourself. How are you doing? What? How are you yourself doing? I vote for yourself, James. I voted for yourself, yes. Particularly in the round table, you know on the traders, they go around nominating who they want to tuck out of the show.
33:22And the younger guys, and women sometimes, often end up weirdly saying, I voted for yourself, rather than I voted for you. I don't hear yourself as much as myself, and myself's the one that makes me want to vote. Oh, I hear yourself more. Oh, really? It was particularly the guy who, Harry, I think it was. He's used it all the time, constantly on traitors. And it's weird. Yeah, let's park that, the usage of myself. So, Paul, what we're hearing is basically that Boyd's on the Committee of National Treasures. And if you have any further complaints, do come to him. God, if only I was. I should be.
33:51But what is the Committee for National Treasures? It's you, just decided, I think. With a massive blackboard set upon your TV. It's like the honours list, but I've created it. Yes, Boyd's honours. Instead of the key. Would we get an honour? No. You might. I definitely wouldn't get one. No, neither. Eventually. Look at his face. That is not a man who wants to give me an honour. Look, he scrunched his face up. He's so judgy. Stop being so judgy, Boyd. Right, we're taking the ability to give honours away from now. That didn't last long, did it? No. It's been withdrawn. Yeah, you're dishonoured now, so get in the corner.
34:21Right, okay. Now for a message from Holly about Pluribus, and specifically the pacing. Hi, Gunas and Sir Duluth. now that I've found out what gooners means in saying yeah that's just what we should say it's it's Sir John DeLuther's triumphant second adventure are you talking about yourself in the third person again well it's not technically me he's my level two paladin but yeah we're doing our our Empire D &D session again tonight it's very exciting oh are you in the office oh you've had one already oh no that's hilarious it's brilliant are you gonna like is it cosplay as well do you dress it up no okay fine it's gonna be a lot of gooners Sorry.
35:00There may or may not be gooning. I wouldn't think there will be. None of that. Joe Barton, if Joe's listening, our friend of the pod, who delighted in the fact, he DM'd me about the fact that how gunners are known as gooners, and he's thrilled at the new usage of that word. Well, no, he posited that it in fact is not a new usage at all. And I think he said that it's always meant absolute twats. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. All I would say is, and I've withheld saying anything until this very moment but 4-1 4-1 to the Arsenal first of all as a hat trick Joe must be reeling must be absolutely reeling as we speak listen I think he'll get over it when he's at his glamorous Amadeus screening I don't think he'll ever get over it really?
35:43yeah which I think are you going to? a bit of live admin here? yeah I'm not sure if I have obviously mainly because I need to watch it anyway before that screening you know to write about it yes okay right anyway moving on to Holly's email about Pluribus. She says, I'm very much enjoying Pluribus in part because it's so, to borrow a euphemism, deliberately paced. I was wondering about how you all define the difference between deliberate and just too slow. I appreciate it's subjective and also maybe just difficult to pin down. But the specific thing that got me questioning it was the fact that James seems to be loving Pluribus, brackets understandably, but he's also in the past echoed the opinion that Best Call Saul in its early seasons is maybe a tad too slow.
36:25Personally, I love those early seasons of Best Call Saul just as much as the latter ones, if not more so. And while I'll happily tune in to see Carol going supermarket shopping and watching Golden Girls episodes, I don't think it's necessarily more gripping than, say, Jimmy doing Elder Law. Anyway, thanks all for your hard work. The interview with Vince and co was great. Pre-emptive, I know, but can we expect a pluribus spoiler special at some point? I'd also be fascinated to know what Kay made of it because a sci-fi goes is pretty grounded. Also, thank you for the traitors chat and the D &D updates from James.
36:55I'm here for both. come on you Spurs Holly oh dear we've gone horribly wrong there to which Boyd responds 4-1 4-1 yeah exactly exactly no it's a good point it is deliberately paced it is yeah but I think sorry it's mainly aimed at James no no you go well what I would say is that it's so gripping because the idea the central idea is so fascinating it has so many implications that sometimes I think if a show is absolutely riveting every single moment that's on your screen, then it's not, I don't think you can call it slow-paced. I think it's deliberate. That's what deliberately paced is, the phrase is for, in my mind.
37:36It's like describing the phenomenon where scenes play out, take quite a long time to play out, maybe, and you're trying to work out what's going on. That's the thing that he does. He did a lot. In fact, I read an article taking the piss slightly out of our friend who created Better Call Saul. Vince Gilligan, thank you. sorry I forgot his name your best friend yeah my best friend more James' best friend he did have his arm around me as the photos attest James exactly but I read an article saying this out of him for loving opening episodes with a thing that you don't understand what's going on I love it and slowly you put two together and that happens a lot as I say slowly but the fact that it's it's not playing out in an action packed you know fast edited style doesn't mean it's not absolutely gripping and it is so that's I think that's the key to it.
38:26Whereas I think Better Call Saul, I do agree, was a bit too slow for me sometimes because I'm not sure, it didn't feel necessarily like it was telling us stuff that really needed us to be told in such a slow way, if you see what I mean. Whereas this, because the concept of this is so unique. Yeah. It feels different. Yeah, it drives the narrative, I think, even if like the sort of day-to-day stuff going on on screen is quite pedestrian. But Better Call Saul, I think, is different because Better Call Saul, I think, differs from both of the other two in two ways. I think, first of all, I think it takes a while to warm to Jimmy McGill.
39:04He's not instantly likable. Now, Walter White, the whole point of Walter White is he's very likable at the beginning. He becomes less so as he goes along. I think Jimmy is quite hard to like early on. But also, you know where his story's going, ultimately. You know where, because it's essentially a prequel. I mean, yes, it will continue and it will do other things. Broadly speaking, you know what his arc is going to be. And so because it takes so long to get there, there's, I think, an element of impatience to it. You're like, I know where this is going. I want it to get there. So I think maybe that makes it feel slower than it otherwise would do.
39:37Yes, exactly. Whereas I have no idea where this is going. In fact, there were flash forwards, weren't there, in Bedical Saw in the beginning of each episode that showed you. Where you see him working in the Cinnabon. Yeah. So Bedical Saw, which is genius. But again, I do maintain that first season of Bedical Saw, I did find a slog and then I grew to love it the first season of Breaking Bad I didn't find it a slog but I was I struggled a bit with the pace at times but I think also I mainly kind of had to get onto the wavelength of Gilligan's particular type of storytelling and I think I'm much now I'm much more at ease with it now which is probably part of it as well just to say to Holly I will be watching it because I went to visit a friend at the weekend at Eastbourne and she is obsessed with it my friend Sal In fact, so much so that her husband and I watched Strictly and she watched it for a bit and then took herself off to watch an episode.
40:29Good choice. She must have been bored by Strictly. Well, she wanted to be... She is bored. She doesn't like Strictly, but she didn't want to be left out of us watching it. And then towards the end, she was like, I might just go and watch an episode of Pluribus. I was like, go on. I've heard good things, so I will watch it. I'll be interested to hear what you think. I don't think the sci-fi aspect of it will necessarily put you off. No. I like the concept. When you described it, I was like, oh, okay, that sounds interesting. Yeah. So, okay, Mike Reid got in touch. That one. Yes. Who got in touch to say, question not for James, what is the best British procedural?
41:03For me, Murder City always stood out from the noughties. Oh, you're not going to punt for Law and Order UK? Did either of you watch that? No. With Jamie Bamber? Was it good? It was like Law and Order, but it was in the UK. It was much the same thing. I quite liked it. Chris Chibnall, because Chibnall wrote that. Chibbers. He's a showrunner of Law & Order. I thought it was decent, actually. I'm not a Law & Order fan because obviously I don't like those kind of episodic procedures, but I don't know, something about it being grounded in the UK, I quite enjoyed that. Is Cracker a procedural? I mean, it kind of is, yeah.
41:31It's the way it generally works out. It was kind of like, was it two or three episode arcs they did generally? And it would be a case and then it would be another case. So yeah, to a certain extent. And the procedure was very much like Fitz would profile someone while being an abusive superior alcoholic and then he would get them in an interrogation room and grind them to an intellectual pulp. It was great. You love Cracker, don't you? I do, it's fantastic. Line of juicy. I mean, it's procedural to an extent, but it's not episodic in that way. It's heavily serialised. Yeah, it's not story a week.
41:59That's what we were talking about. Oh, okay. When Cracker is, I mean, I guess it's in blocks, isn't it? Story of three weeks. Yeah, basically. And I think Prime Suspect was... Prime Suspect Crapper was Crapper. Wow, Freudian slip there. That's the sequel coming up, which goes down different routes. No, Crapper, I think you're referring to is the show Fits, which was the American remake of Cracker, which was dreadful. True. Cracker and Prime Suspect, I think, I believe were multiple episodes, maybe two or three or four episodes, but one story across a number. So you'd get like, each series would have maybe like two or three and there'd be blocks.
42:35Yeah. Prime Suspect, by the way, is just as good as Cracker in my opinion. I mean, it's not, but it's very good. Because this correspondent was asking, what our favourite procedure, I think referring to a case a week. Yes. Yeah. Okay. And British ones. Evil was a good procedural. I didn't watch it at all. Oh, yeah, that was American. Yeah, that's true. Of course, you were talking, yeah, British ones. Damn it. Let's bring it back to the bill. I'm not even sure. I don't think the bill was procedural. It was a soap. Yeah, it was a police soap, really. Yeah. And that's heavily serialized. That wasn't an episodic one.
43:08They used to have cases per week. I think there were multiple cases, but they were, I mean, it was all tied into the ongoing. It had June Carver. I like the brown load. Burnside. I think we're talking mores here. Yeah, that's a good shot. That's proper British procedural. Vera, another... Do you know what I lied? DCI Banks. DCI Banks was great. Yeah. I watched all of that. Yeah. Isn't Shetland one story across a series though? When it first started out... Oh, it's not now? Oh, wait a minute. You're obsessed with Shetland so you should be the one who knows. I think it's one story across the whole series.
43:40It was, but when it first began I believe it was a case per episode. Oh, you might be right. Touching Evil. was another one that I enjoyed back in the day. That was quite grim, wasn't it? Yeah, it was quite grim. But I seem to recall that that was episodic. Because if you're talking about... So Cracker and Prime Subject... Prime Subject. Cracker and Prime Subject. You know there was a Prime Cracker for Colin Relief? Comic Relief. Yes, I do. What is that? I love it. Colin Relief. Colin Relief. That's the new charity where we support all the Collins in our lives, starting with the dog from Collins from Accounts.
44:14Yeah. isn't the dog from from Spaced also called Colin is it it's a good name for dogs it is a good name for dogs I like I like you know human names for dogs yes but yeah I'm not sure that Prime Suspect or Cracker quite qualify otherwise those would be the correct answer for it Cracker's really made me laugh what about Foil's War do you remember Foil's War I do remember Foil's War you're really going back in the old place that wasn't bad yeah I'm trying to think because Luther's serialised that's not episodic so we can't have that yeah I'm I'm yeah I'm maybe sticking with touching evil. That's quite a few answers.
44:47Yeah. Case board of this question, let's move on. I'm not. Fair enough to be fair. Fair enough to be fair. No, I love watching you Google it. We all do. Right, okay. Now for a message from Michael Flynn, who says, I recently saw an interview with Edgar Wright where they dropped a random fact, which is that Stephen Knight of Peaky Blinders fame co-created Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? After some fact-checking on this, I can confirm it's true. I love the way they didn't trust him, that he's lied. I mean, Edgar Wright lying about who wants to be a millionaire again. With this revelation, what other writers or directors have crossed the aisle from game shows, sorry James, to serial television?
45:24Hope you can tour sometime like the Empire podcast has done in the past. All the best, Michael. It's a tough one. That's a very specific question. I mean, Richard Osmond, but he hasn't gone on to serialize TV, has he? Well, I mean, unless you count, you know, Thursday Murder Club books and then the film, which is on... Yeah, but it's a film. It is a film, yes. You know how I'm a purist. I know you are a purist, that's true. I'll tell you I'll give you an example I happen to know Russell T. Davis yes friend of the pod invented blockbusters no he worked on he worked on the TV game show Cluedo back in the day was it ITV?
45:59they turned Cluedo it was on ITV yeah into a game show and they'd have like the mystery and they'd have like I think celebrities like playing the part but then Russell in the library with a sonic screwdriver yeah exactly and of course he went on to make quite good I think he might mention on the live show you know yeah I think he might have done yeah that's a great fact he worked on loads of weird shows in his early days well he worked on Why Don't You I remember that that was his first job that was his first job which is genius but he worked on loads of mostly for Granada I think at the time and yeah Cluedo it was a game show was one he worked on yeah the Stephen Knight thing is wild though I remember when I first found out I was like really?
46:35and Jasper Carrick his company produced it the whole Who Wants to Be a Millionaire story is absolutely fascinating there was a documentary there was a drama about it, wasn't there? They dramatised that to some extent in the three-part ITV series about the Colonel. Yeah, that was about the cheating scandal. They did a bit about the creation of the show as well. Was Osman a co-creator? No. Is he connected to Millionaire? I thought he was. I don't think so. Oh, okay. No. Right, now for a message from Mr. Jeff Hovinger. What a great surname. Who says, Hello, big fan of the show and will always feel partially responsible for James coming around to Taskmaster.
47:10as I asked about it a number of years ago, although he kind of roasted me for it. James, does that sound right? Sounds about right. I mean, to be fair, it's not like I've become a massive Taskmaster fan, but I did watch an episode and enjoyed it. No, but exactly. And I did Taskmaster Live. You opened your mind by a millimeter. Yeah, I did Taskmaster Live. Oh, yeah, with the Empire team. Well, me, Chris and Nick, yeah, last year. Fun. On my birthday, as I recall. Oh, yeah, I actually do remember that. I use my listening ears. Anyway, so Jeff continues and goes, Anywho, I have a new question for you all.
47:39I notice you often will bring up a spoiler for a TV show, but add that it's not a spoiler because it happens in the first X amount of the first episode, 5, 10, 20 minutes, etc. What would you say is the cutoff time in an episode that makes something not a spoiler? I would argue if it's any information that will come as a surprise to the audience, even in the first few minutes, then it's a spoiler. Love to hear your thoughts. Thanks and enjoy the upcoming holiday. It's a difficult question because I would say there are certain shows where something that happens at the very beginning would be a spoiler because I guess you have to think about would knowing about this going in significantly impact your enjoyment of the series?
48:14But also, with the caveat that we do have to review it, and to review it, we're probably going to have to talk about it to some extent. Like, a lot of people who reviewed Pluribus, for example, did not talk about the central premise because they were asked not to when they did it because they did it quite far in advance. And I'm like, I don't know how easy it is to talk about that show unless you at least tangentially touch on the central premise because otherwise you're just like, yeah, it's got Ray Seahorn in it, it's a show. Like, what else are you going to say? Like, it's kind of mad. So sometimes we do have to talk about things that we don't want to necessarily talk about.
48:47But then other times, like for example, the whole setup of the show Paradise, we deliberately didn't mention what the twist was because to know that going in, even though it happens in the first episode of a multi-part show, would significantly impact your enjoyment of the show because it's a big rug pull, it's a great event. You don't want to know that. But then when people talk about Silo, for example, there's a, shall we say, a significant cast change in the first episode of Silo. But to a certain extent, you almost have to address that because it sets up a show that isn't the show that Silo is.
49:17So you kind of need to get into it. Look, reviewing's complicated. It's difficult. Oh, my God. Don't you... I honestly... Kate stopped listening five minutes ago. Well, not because I don't listen to you, because you know I always listen to you. It's very polite. But it's more that, like, just this spoiler chat. You know, it's just endless, isn't it? No, but I do understand it. I understand it as well, but it's so hard sometimes reviewing shows. Like, obviously, I get the spoilers that Boyd drops are outrageous, right? Egregious, yeah. Do you think I should start each episode by saying spoiler, but Boydy spoilers something in this episode?
49:51Just before you introduce him, just introduce him as the spoiler. But anyway, yeah, but in Boyd's defense, right? Like, I believe, was it Alison? It's Trixie. It is Trixie sometimes. It is Trixie. not just tricky it's Trixie yeah Trixie in answer to the to the question if a thing happens at the end of the first episode which I think it did in the example you gave wasn't it that's a spoiler right at the end I wouldn't yeah we definitely wouldn't spoil that the difference with Pluribuses it's kind of it's right at the start the whole kind of first episode is explaining the premise when it was first announced right Apple TV we're not going to we're not going to explain what the fuck this show is and they gave up.
50:34They had to give up. Because no one would have watched it. Yeah, no one would have watched it. And, you know, you have to, it's just, it's not so, the way it's done, it could have left its twist to the end of the episode, if you like. I think then you kind of stay clear of it. But if something is kind of unfolding within literally the very first scene and the premise is being made clear very early on, then I think we're within our rights to express that, if you see what I mean. But if there's a big twist at the end of the opening episode, then that's different I think we wouldn't spoil that there you go okay right two last messages this one is from Joe who says oh Joanne sorry I've got if you're familiar who says dear most revered pilot hosts Joe already like you a lot just wanted to national treasures even yeah just wanted to agree Death by Lightning is a cracking addition to Netflix and thank you Boyd for suggesting it see thank you it's a motion rollercoaster for you this week yeah always However, I put off watching The Morning Show partly because of your somewhat lukewarm reviews for the current season.
51:39Is this actually from Steph? No. The rants about Corey Ellison being irritating and stranded in LA only apply to early episodes. It's from me, James. Oh, you know I love Corey. And ultimately, he was the key to the resolution of the whole season's central plotline. Is that a spoiler? Not without details. Fine. I'm very much looking forward to season five now, but might listen to your review after I watch it. still an avid fan and the banter between you all never fails to bright my day don't forget to remind listeners they can oh Jo this is why she this is an excellent email okay she points out something that we as the co-hosts have forgotten okay what's that don't forget to remind listeners they can buy a subscription as a Christmas gift thus swelling the coffers for Boyd's next New York extravaganza Kay's next retreat and James' next White Lotus experience yeah if any of us got any of the money but yes yes that would be great but yes you totally should buy Pilot Plus as a gift and I said yes of course I'll be getting another year subscription for my lovely daughter keep up the good work Jo now actually here's a new thing element of the post bag if you're going to buy a subscription for a friend or a loved one get in touch I'm going to give you a shout out they don't listen to it because they don't listen to Plus so it's fine they're not going to have their Christmas presents spoiled but we would like to honour those people who are buying them as gifts because that's a kind thing to do what are you doing?
52:58I'm doing a subscription shout out anyone who's buying one as a gift Remind me what the question was I've lost the thread Just basically saying you were a dickhead about the morning show she almost didn't watch Oh yeah yeah Corey Steph literally upbraided me about this this morning when I came in because she thinks it's wonderful and she thinks he in particular is the best thing in it I love Corey I said this I did when he was when he should have been in it but I will agree with her to a point that his role while utterly extraneous early on becomes more organic as it goes along Oh I'm glad to hear it Yeah, I was happier with it towards the end.
53:33I still maintain this is a lesser series of The Morning Show, but as we said when we reviewed it, a lesser series of The Morning Show is still very watchable. Indeed. Indeed. So, yes, apologies for them being dismissive of The Morning Show. I also got put off a bit, and I haven't continued, but I will. And, yeah, everyone should just buy subscriptions as gifts, shouldn't they? Yeah, they should. Right. The last message comes from Ian, and the subject heading is, the greatest partridge-ism of all time. Oh, wow. Why do I sense this is going to be about me? Well, hi pilot peeps. While James quite rightly gets compared to Alan Partridge on a regular basis, I'd argue that he isn't the worst culprit on the pod.
54:16Wow. On last Monday's episode, or Monday the 17th of November, if you're behind with the postbag, in the marathon versus moonwalk debate, Boyd came out with the classic, I think walking is harder than running a marathon and Gabby Logan agrees with me. That trumps anything James or indeed anyone has ever said. That is brilliant. That's true. That is peak partridge. That is a great accidental partridge. Thank you. Thank you so much for getting in touch, Ian. That is the postbag letter of the week. That's fabulous. On the Empire podcast, Chris has started naming the episodes not after the guests but after like something someone has said that would 100 % have been the title of that episode.
55:05Marathon running with Sue Cook. Yeah. Would be. Yeah. Wait a minute. So Chris has started naming episodes as well as we stopped naming episodes. So we've always named them after the shows we review because I take a very utilitarian view on titling. We stopped numbering them. That's the thing we've got. We've stopped numbering them. Chris has also stopped numbering Empire but the Empire used to always be named after the guests but presumably because there are approximately 28 guests now on every episode there just isn't room so he's now just started naming them after like a funny thing but that's hard for search oh no I suppose you'll still come up if you wanted to search the person because you know some people just want to know no I agree and people I think have maybe brought that but look it's fine I think most podcasts do that particular thing yeah Arsenal one I'd name after something that people said yeah which is you know which is a fun thing to do footballistically Arsenal Joe Joe if you want to take this oh god here we go I'm so sorry Joe can you get subscriptions for that Boyd yeah oh gotcha of course come on you two are very slack John I'm just going to put this out there but if you really want to stick it to Boyd like when when the second series of Black Doves is available if you were to just provide screeners to me and Kay like really really early like really months before it airs and then we could like drop little teases to Boydy about the fact that he hasn't seen it also may I say neither of you to think that the showrunner and creator of a show has power over Netflix do you not think JB has that power I believe he does I think Boyd should be further punished for assuming he didn't have that power I agree.
56:26Okay, we'll see. Okay, that is it for this week's Pilot Plus. Thank you very much for listening and thank you for subscribing and, as I'm sure you're going to, for ordering a special gift subscription to the people you love the most and also for the people you hate the most because, you know, it serves a dual purpose. That's a really good point, actually. We'll be back in your ears on Monday when we will be reviewing Stranger Things, the final season, or rather the first chunk of the final season. Spartacus the house of is it Asher or Usher? I don't know one of the two I've forgotten it's Asher or Usher anyway it's a Spartacus and the war between the land and the sea bring it on bring it on indeed so it's a big goodbye from Kay and from Boyd and from myself oh god pilot out
From the publisher
On this week’s show, we take a look at something that dropped on Netflix without any fanfare whatsoever a few weeks ago. Specifically, Last Samurai Standing, which is essentially Shōgun meets Squid Game. Plus the postbag turns feral as Kay fully embraces the madness of James’ triage system.
Want your messages read out as part of The Postbag? Email us at pilottv@empiremagazine.com




