PLUS Lord Of The Flies

5 Feb 2026 · 1 h · 27 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The BBC TV adaptation Lord of the Flies (Jack Thorne, based on William Golding’s 1954 novel) and how it dramatizes the collapse of civilization among prepubescent boys stranded on a desert island.

Guest backgrounds

This episode is hosted by James Boyd and Steph (no external guests). They discuss their own school reading experience and attend a BFI screening; Steph also references photographer Martin Schoeder’s face-close-up style.

Key claims

Golding wrote the novel as a counterpoint to “Coral Island” colonial propaganda, showing that “civilization” is a thin layer. Thorne’s adaptation removes supernatural elements (publisher cut ghosts/demons) and keeps the story grounded. The series is told from different boys’ points of view (episode-by-episode), highlighting betrayal, unreliability, and psychological change. It’s praised as powerful, shocking, and not “soft” despite being about children.

Notable examples

Piggy’s POV and early betrayal by “the hero”; close-up transitions using Martin Schoeder-like shots; filming in Malaysia; score credited to Hans Zimmer (and Christopher Tapia de Vere).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Boydy's Late Night Adventures

0:45 to 1:55

Discussion about Boyd's late-night recording from Santa Monica.

“And that's we have to be out of the door at 8.15am, which means I have to have breakfast before that about 7am.”

The Presentation and Sleep Deprivation

1:55 to 4:17

Boyd discusses upcoming presentation and his lack of sleep.

“This book, I think it's fairly safe to say is the bane of GCSE English students everywhere because I'm fairly certain it's been on the national curriculum for about the past 40 years if not longer.”

Introduction to Lord of the Flies

4:17 to 5:12

Hosts introduce the topic: the new adaptation of Lord of the Flies.

GCSE English and Personal Experiences

5:12 to 6:35

Hosts share their experiences studying Lord of the Flies in school.

“well, certainly not in the beginning of the show, and to the best of my knowledge, it's not explored in the films either.”

William Golding's Intentions

6:35 to 8:25

Discussion on Golding's motivations for writing Lord of the Flies.

“What did you think of Jack Thorne's adaptation?”

Adaptation Insights and Screening Experience

8:25 to 10:47

Detailed thoughts on the adaptation and the screening experience with young actors.

“It was filmed in, you know, Alpington or wherever it was.”

Themes and Directorial Choices

10:47 to 13:15

Exploring themes and innovative directorial choices in the adaptation.

“Because you're just on that point about those close-ups, do you know the photographer Martin Scholar?”

Score and Cinematic Feel of the Show

13:15 to 14:01

Discussion on the score by Hans Zimmer and its impact on the series.

“It's all there in Jack Thorne's adaptation.”

Cinematic Elements of Lord of the Flies

14:01 to 15:30

Discussing the powerful visuals and score of the adaptation.

“It's such a beautiful kind of descent into madness that happened with these boys.”

Character Depth in Adaptation

15:31 to 17:34

Exploring Jack's character complexities and background in the story.

“And yeah, I couldn't agree with you more.”
Show all 27 chapters

Themes of Society and Civilization

17:35 to 19:36

Analyzing the themes of civilization and societal constructs in the narrative.

Challenges of Filming

19:37 to 21:11

Insights into the logistics and challenges of filming in remote locations.

“Did you say, Boyd, is it Jack Thorne who has a teenage son or is it Mark Munden?”

The Score and Its Creators

21:12 to 21:40

Discussion about the music score and its contributors in the adaptation.

“Massive jolly, but you wouldn't know anything about that, Boydie.”

Release Information for Lord of the Flies

21:41 to 22:15

Providing details about when and where to watch the adaptation.

“Lord of the Flies then, which airs on the BBC, Boydie, BBC One, I'm saying.”

Listener Feedback on British Police Shows

22:30 to 28:00

Discussing differing perceptions of police portrayals in British vs. American media.

“But like round here, you can get a delivery robot.”

Exploring the Rise of Short-Form Content

28:00 to 31:30

Learn about the impact and future of short-form content in the media landscape.

“the real shorts app slash daily motion yeah i've heard of them that they were talked about on that other podcast that I often refer to.”

The Longevity of TV Characters

31:30 to 37:10

Discover insights on iconic TV characters and their cultural impact.

“Before the turn of the millennium, I think she may hold the record outside of soaps.”

Viewer Engagement During Exercise

37:10 to 40:00

Discuss strategies for watching TV while exercising, and the rules involved.

“Yeah, you definitely can't exercise and read a show at the same time.”

Marketing Challenges for New Shows

40:00 to 42:01

Understand the difficulties in marketing unique TV shows and the implications for viewership.

“but I'm really intrigued to see where it goes.”

Challenges in Marketing Shows

42:01 to 43:22

Exploring the difficulties faced in marketing certain shows and films effectively.

Listener Feedback on 'Shrinking'

43:22 to 45:26

A listener expresses thoughts on the challenges of reviewing shows with multiple seasons.

“Someone in the office came up to me when I'd said about this whole thing, when I went on the Reddit, and I said, oh, people are being mean to me.”

Discussion on Character Relationships in 'Shrinking'

45:26 to 48:41

Delving into the importance of character relationships for understanding shows like 'Shrinking'.

“In my defence about this week and Cross, there was nothing else.”

Video Games in Narrative Storytelling

48:41 to 51:42

A listener's critique on the podcast's treatment of video games versus other media.

“Long shot, I know, but if it means less traitor's talk, I would take it.”

The Limits of Media Consumption

51:42 to 53:24

Discussion on balancing interests in different media like TV, film, and gaming.

“Did you play video games when you were younger?”

Opinions on Show-Specific Podcasts

53:24 to 56:00

Evaluating the impact and quality of podcasts focused on specific shows.

“Right, last question before I will let Boyd go to bed.”

Favorite Podcasts and Their Unique Formats

56:00 to 58:04

Explore various podcast formats and discuss which ones resonate most.

“The West Wing Weekly was obviously my favourite one.”

Upcoming Podcast Plans and Studio Arrangements

58:04 to 59:10

Learn about the next episodes and the challenges of recording in a small studio.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:07Boyd Hilton:Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters and a special international edition of Pilot Plus, specifically because Boyd is coming to us live from his intergalactic jolly to Santa Monica. How is the Santa Monica sun, Boydy? Well, it's dark at the moment because it's one in the morning. It's five past nine in the morning. Oh, I see. Right. And you're not at the beach. I'm not at the beach, no. That would be madness. Boydy did you go to sleep and then get up for this record No Oh you've just stayed up I've stayed up because if you go to sleep That way madness lies Because you're just going to wake up groggy Or you're going to miss the alarm But yeah I've battled through Steph Because I'm that kind of hero Oh honey you're so good I try and stay up till 10 Like when I go to LA I don't normally do a 1am But then you don't really need sleep being as you are a vampire Well, it'd be nice to have a couple of hours because the thing is we've got this big presentation tomorrow, which is the reason I'm here.

1:04And that's we have to be out of the door at 8.15am, which means I have to have breakfast before that about 7am. So it's all, you know, but I can't complain, because I am on a massive freebie to LA, courtesy of the Apple people. You're going to get what, like four hours sleep, if that? That's a line for Boydie. I think five. I think I can do a solid five, yeah. Four and a half five. It'll all be fine. You're so good for doing this. You're such a good boy. Should we power through, Boidy?

1:34Boyd Hilton:Once we do this, should we just record the regular podcast and then should we maybe just do the Night Manager Spoiler Special straight after that and just do like a four-hour back? But pull an all-nighter. Just all-night podcast. Let's do it. Be kind. Be nice. No. Boyd gets no niceness for his jolly. Should we press on with this? Look at notes. Please, God. Podcast. So we're here to discuss a TV show, as is our plan. and it's going to be Lord of the Flies which is the new BBC adaptation of the 1954 William Golding novel of the same name written by Jack Thorne who, you know, had some free time in between doing 15 ,000 other shows this year and it follows a group of prepuessent boys who crash land on a desert island and go full feral.

2:14Boyd Hilton:This book, I think it's fairly safe to say is the bane of GCSE English students everywhere because I'm fairly certain it's been on the national curriculum for about the past 40 years if not longer. Did both of you study this at school? yes i did and i but i also did a midsummer night's dream so i think i was kind of it was i didn't do loads of it but i definitely did i definitely did it but i didn't do it as much as that this is you don't need that information i did it what sorry my what was the reference to a midsummer night's dream i did a midsummer night's dream so you did like lord of the flies and a midsummer night's dream and then you went and did one of them yeah what were you doing for Because I did English, because I did like English literature.

2:54But most of us did like four or five books.

2:56Boyd Hilton:Yeah, exactly. Did you only do two? At least you did two things. No, because you did English language and English language. English language. What do you sissy? It clearly worked. English language and English literature, didn't you? You know, I'm going to sound slightly younger than you, so I think it changed a bit. Well, clearly. You only had to read two books. Hold on a minute. Oh my God, I've remembered what else I did. I did Z for Zachariah, which I hated, which is why I don't really like dystopian things. Oh, wow. This has turned into an impromptu therapy session. We're getting to the root of your TV trauma.

3:27Boyd Hilton:Yeah. I absolutely studied it and really, really loved it. And among many other books and plays that I read when I was doing English literature in school. You know, like when you do a GCSE, you only do a couple of books for your GCSE? No, no, no. Totally. way more than that what kind of gps are you doing where did you go to school yeah i got i got an a star so i'm not surprised you only had two books yeah oh my god uh i do think about this yeah i did henry the fourth part one i did the general prologue to the canterbury tales i can't remember now which books were a level which books for gcse so i can't uh i can't tell you which one i did the wife of barth f4 but yeah anyway we've got sidetracked again we are talking about lord of the flies which was it turns out and i know this because i may have looked it up on wikipedia but william golding wrote this as a kind of counterpoint to the coral island which was like a british colonial propaganda thing about how it's all in the blood and upper class people will do fine and we're all terribly civilized and so his idea was you send a bunch of let's be honest quite posh prepubescent boys and he was showing that put in a completely societyless boundaryless lawless environment they will go full feral and start killing each other regardless of whether they are a british or b posh uh and that's essentially the moral of this particular story um the one thing that's always troubled me about this so from my original reading of the book uh i think there've been at least two films i've seen both of them uh and now this series i've never understood how there is a plane crash with a bunch of boys on it and yet none of them apart from the choir seem to have met each other before I'm like, what kind of school do you go to that you don't know the names of any of the other pupils?

5:11Boyd Hilton:However, it turns out the backstory to this, which is not explored, well, certainly not in the beginning of the show, and to the best of my knowledge, it's not explored in the films either. Because obviously it was written in 1954. It's a wartime evacuation thing. So they are evacuees. So they're all of a similar age, but they genuinely don't know each other because they're all from different schools. And you can tell it in this show because they're all wearing slightly different uniforms. They're wearing different colored shirts. but there is a there is a um a group of them that know each other yeah so the choir in particular yeah jack's choir are obviously all from there's apparently a choir randomly being evacuated yeah which is completely wild here's another thing i found out the book originally started with them they're actually it's not a world war ii evacuation it was supposed to be fleeing some sort of world war iii nuclear war is what they're what they're fleeing um but also there was a supernatural aspect to it now there is a there's a kind of the boys imagine this beast on the island uh in the actual novel as it published but there was a weird supernatural thing with a demon and all sorts of stuff which his publisher was like yeah william mate no bill bill bill yeah let's lose that shall we steph's not going to read this if it's gone kay is definitely not going to read this if it's got ghosts and goblins in it so let's keep it quite basic let's scale it back take out the supernatural uh and he got quite fed up with the whole thing and washed his hands at the novel i think by the end but it all it all uh it all turned out well i think but crucially did the...

6:30Boyd Hilton:Well done, William Golding. Well done, William Golding. Well done, William Golding. You continue to torment GCSE students in perpetuity. What did you think of Jack Thorne's adaptation? Well, I went to the screening of this at the BFI. Was it on an island? It was not on an island. It was in the cinema. Did you all go feral at the BFI? Well, here's the thing. I mentioned this on a previous episode, but I'll just, in case people didn't listen, I can't remember I can't remember whether it was on Plus or regular pod. But anyway, there were about 25 kids in this show. Yes, I remember. And I think there's about like seven, eight, nine main speaking roles, and then the rest are kind of mostly non-speaking roles.

7:15But nevertheless, 25 people had to be corralled by the absolutely heroic producers and people, casting directors, et cetera, and the director, Mark Munden. and all of them were at the screening clearly and there except various families and siblings and stuff and it was pandemonium. It was so funny. I've never seen anything like it, a screening like it with a young cast of a show all gathered to see the thing and they were, they just, you know, they're just not following the rules of normal screenings of shows, etc. So there was all shouting and screaming. It was delightful, but they were very dramatic.

7:52Yeah, it was about to say. It wasn't really a reach for them. Yeah, as to your question, did they go fair? Not as bad as they do in the actual story in the show. But I think this is a brilliant, absolutely brilliant adaptation. And, of course, it's Jack Thorne. And he was saying, he did the Q &A. He took part in the Q &A with Mark Munder, the director. And he was saying how they made this at roughly the same time as Adolescence. And he actually went from one set to the other. This was filmed in Malaysia. And Adolescence was not filmed in Malaysia. It was filmed in, you know, Alpington or wherever it was.

8:30And, yeah, he went from one set to the other, and he was kind of like not overseeing because there are other people who were showrunners, et cetera, or the director. He definitely was heavily involved in both, and he kind of almost wrote them at the same time as well. So they're both very intense stories about adolescent boys. And I think it is a subject, you know, he was, without wanting to sound glib, he absolutely was like, yeah, I am, you know, I think he's got a son. who's reaching, you know, early teens. So it's a particular worry or interest to him. And he's really, and you can tell how, just how passionate he is about, you know, we mustn't let kids, particularly boys, go wrong and pick the wrong path when they're this age.

9:14It's a crucial age. And I found it, I remember, obviously the book is quite distressing. It's full on. You know, it's a very visceral book. And I think he's captured that tone. Mark Munden the director and him the writer Jack Thorne the writer it's incredibly powerful and quite shocking when bad things happen shall we say it's not soft soaked in any way this is not a kids show it's a show about kids you know quite rightly it's on 9 o 'clock BBC 1 and I think I was kind of watching it thinking you know what there was quite young kids in it you know like 8, 9, 10 years I was sitting there thinking what do they think of this obviously for them who were in it it was more of like an adventure to be in a big thing like this but oh my god it's really it's really harsh stuff happens and like and the full-on disintegration of civilization is brilliantly dramatized and their little touches which under the director brought to it which i think worked brilliantly so he does this thing whereby he just has big close-ups of the kids faces um kind of intercut with the action at various moments at various and and at first you're like why is he doing that but then you're like because i think these huge close-ups of these boys, when they're just standing there looking into the camera, you're kind of wondering what's going to happen to them.

10:33And it just really worked. I thought it was such an ingenious thing to do because you're thinking about what is the face of that innocence of them, if you like, just staring to camera before the pandemonium that ensues later. Yes, Steph, you've got your finger up. Because you're just on that point about those close-ups, do you know the photographer Martin Scholar? Very incredibly famous photographer and what he does and if you look up Martin Scholar you'll go oh him. He almost exclusively does these shots which are the close-ups of people's face. So he's done Obama, he's done every famous person and I so loved that about this adaptation that he, I'm not saying he's stolen that technique, I'm just saying he utilized that technique of just the full face close up.

11:24And it was beautiful. And you're thinking, oh, God, this, like, exactly as you said, this beautiful innocence completely lit so wonderfully, like a photograph. And if you look up Martin Schoeder, you'll see it's, sorry, I didn't want to interrupt you, but just to that point, that's exactly what that is. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. He said, by the way, he said he kind of, he knew he should take these shots of the boys looking into the camera, but he himself didn't really know why he did it when he first decided to do it. And then it turned out it was key because they're actually used as transition points as well as the story developed.

12:02Anyway, that's one directorial innovation. I think as far as the scripts are concerned, Jack Thorne's absolutely brilliant innovation is each of the four episodes is told from the different point of view of a different one of the boys, the characters. So the first one is from Piggy's point of view. Famously, the young guy is called Piggy by the bullies at his school, and he's betrayed early on in this first episode by... By the quote-unquote hero. Exactly, by the quote-unquote hero who initially says he won't tell the other boys that he's called Piggy, but then of course does. And it's full of those horrible moments of betrayal.

12:44It's heart-rending. It really is heartbreaking. So that decision to tell each episode from a different point of view is, again, works so well. I've only seen the first two, but it's really clever. And it's just – because the book is fairly linear, as far as I can remember. But just to kind of show things from different points of view and to kind of create this – and to underline the unreliability of these kids and to show what different personalities they go through and what's happening to their brains at this stage. It's all there in Jack Thorne's adaptation. So I think it's – it's one of those shows where you watch it And you think they've set out to capture a absolute all-time classic book, and they could not have done a better job.

13:33I don't see how this could be improved upon in terms of what they're trying to do and what they're trying to convey as to the original themes and ideas of the novel. And I think it's just extraordinary, yeah. Yeah, I mean, I could not agree more. I think what makes this also such an exceptional adaptation is the score that really underpins the whole narrative of this with incredible accuracy. And obviously it's Hans Zimmer. It's such a beautiful kind of descent into madness that happened with these boys. I found as well that the silence in between the narrative was really powerful. And obviously, juxtaposing this incredibly beautiful island with these grubby little gits running around, you know, going mad, it is such a perfect, it really reminded me, it felt incredibly, it felt it has a very cinematic feel to it.

14:36The score has a big screen feel to it. Oh, the score's brilliant. It's unbelievable, the score. It's incredibly beautiful. And it felt to me like, it reminded me of Dunkirk the way it was shot it had that kind of Christopher Nolan feel to it I don't know about you guys yeah I really enjoyed those intimate shots those close-up intimate shots even I really enjoyed the intimate shots of just nature in it um I think anybody if they're still doing Lord of Flies now this is such this is such a delight this is a delightful way to access this text. It's amazing. But yeah, I just, the desecration of youth and innocence on this lush, beautiful island is just, it's magnificent.

15:18This is really, it feels big screen to me. It really did. I felt like when I was watching, I was like, God, I'd love to have watched this at the BFR. I'd love to have watched this on a bigger screen because it felt like it had that kind of spectacle. And yeah, I couldn't agree with you more. I thought it was an incredible

15:37Boyd Hilton:adaptation yeah it looked brilliant on the big screen yeah i like the fact that he hasn't felt the need to update it for modern times the most recent film which i think was in the 90s did um instead it's it's pretty much it kind of still feels like it could easily have been the 1950s you don't really know because a they're wearing school uniform and b it's a desert island so there's no real way of dating it except for the fact that they've managed to maintain the kind of the speech patterns from the book which obviously are very 1950s and also that very very sort of like posh post-war almost rp speaking you know demeanor that they all have which actually i think is kind of integral you'd have to retool a lot of the book to kind of adapt it for shall we say modern pre-adolescent sensibilities like i like the fact that they feel slightly out of time as well as out of place i also think and it's been so long since i've read the book um so i cannot remember how much of this is in there but even from the first episode of this he takes pains to reveal jack in a way that again it may be in the book as well but but showing you why he is the way he is like he's not a you know a black and white villain like the stuff about his father though he's clearly lying about who his father is his relationship with his father is obviously problematic like again it feels like in the same way as adolescence like this isn't some you know born villain he is someone who is the product of his upbringing and neglect and i think that comes across quite early on in this story that jack is quite damaged and he lashes out and there's a scene with a pig and with piggy with piggy and a pig uh where jack hesitates to kill a pig and then he turns and essentially gaslights piggy and saying it was his fault and he's desperate need to save and you can almost see like the shadow of his disapproving father looming over him as he does it and it's actually heartbreaking he's so desperate to be something while constantly feeling that he's not enough and so that's why he's constantly trying to dominate and this power struggle that emerges between him and ralph for the boys it has a lot to do with that and i really like that they don't paint him as just oh he's a problem child like no there's there's sort of there's an underlying sort of psychological uh background going which i thought was was good but yeah it's i mean it's beautifully shot it's very cinematic and that book is very very powerful weirdly it kind of it froze into to my mind into really sort of like how much yellow jackets has kind of gone off the boil do you know i mean because obviously that that tackles a very similar subject matter um and one of the things that kind of interested me looking at this again i didn't really think about it when i read the book when i was a teenager but it's not just a study of you know human nature and you know anti-colonialism to a certain extent and uh it's also a study of masculinity and emerging masculinity because these are prepubescent boys struggling for dominance in an all-male environment and i thought actually weirdly having now sort of like seen that and kind of appreciated it more uh now that i'm slightly older now going back to yellow jack and seeing what they've tried to do with an all-female group or a largely female group is actually quite interesting as well but see i think i think it's not just yellow just i think there's so many films that have been influenced by it i mean i think the whole you know you know the hunger games is influenced by it um the uh battle royale the the legendary um film they're all i don't i think without this i don't think you have any of those it's such an influential um not like such an incredibly smart idea to to kind of show society and psychology and everything through the eyes of these kids that i think it's had massive impact culturally and i think i agree well squid game as well all of that kind of stuff it's the idea that we live bound by a very flimsy set of rules and social constructs and if someone suddenly decides to not adhere to that contract they're a criminal they're a terrorist they're whatever they want to be but if those rules are suddenly withdrawn everything falls apart and people basically turn into animals because it's it's a very thin layer that kind of layer of civilization those rules that we all kind of mutually agree to live by.

19:35Boyd Hilton:They're very, very thin. And I find it fascinating, that kind of exploration. But yes, it's great. Did you say, Boyd, is it Jack Thorne who has a teenage son or is it Mark Munden? He does. See, that to me, I love that detail. I didn't realise that. That makes that, it seems all the more special to me that he's doing that. That's really interesting. Wow. Okay. He said lots of interesting stuff. It was a really good Q &A, actually. They're brilliant at talking about it. The producer was in it as well. They're really interesting talking about the whole, can you think about the whole, the logistics of this, by the way, that's the other thing.

20:10You've got to, as I say, you've got to corral 25 kids of varying ages, some of them really quite young. They will have to be looked after by their various, you know, help. I mean, their families were there most as well, but you know, it still have to be, they have to be taken to this genuinely remote part of Malaysia. They have to wheel in all the equipment, you know, all the cameras, everything. It was a massive, massive operation. They pulled it off, yeah. Yeah, and they probably all just wanted to fucking make sandcastles. Do you know what I mean? It looked amazing. Oh, they had a brilliant time, by the way.

20:41That was quite interesting as well. It's Malaysia, isn't it? Yeah, they turned it into like a kind of, you know, a special trip, like a special, you know, treat for them all rather than – and they kept it very light between the heaviness of the actual takes, which I thought was interesting. So, you know, they made sure they weren't distressed by the whole thing, if you like. How long did it take for them? do you know how long they filmed for? Quite a long, considering it's only four episodes, I think it was quite a long time, like a few months, yeah, I think, from what they said. A few months on a Malaysian island.

21:12Boyd Hilton:Yeah. How traumatic. Massive jolly, but you wouldn't know anything about that, Boydie. No. Yes. We should mention, obviously, from a score point of view, it's actually unclear, because Hans Zimmer is credited, but Christopher Tapia de Vere is also credited, who did the brilliant score to Utopia. Yeah. But he did oversee it. Yeah. I think he particularly worked on the theme tune, which is great. Hans Zimmer. Yes, he did. And I think they co-created, co-worked on the soundtrack in general. Wow. Lord of the Flies then, which airs on the BBC, Boydie, BBC One, I'm saying. When? Sundays. Sunday, the first one would have just started after we, I think.

21:53Yeah, it starts, when does this come out? Well prepared then,

21:57Boyd Hilton:that's good. To be fair, it is like 1.30 in the morning for Boydie. Yeah, exactly. I think it is on this Sunday. Okay, it might be on this Sunday. We're not really sure, but turn it on to see what happens. Yeah, I'm pretty sure you'll find it. Is it drop at once? Is it all on the iPlayer? Sorry, I don't know why I'm asking you questions. You're in LA. I genuinely don't know whether it drops at once. That's what I'm saying. Steph, he doesn't even know when it's on. Why are you arguing these things? Yeah, exactly. Exactly, yeah. Okay, now it's time for the post bag.

22:40Boyd Hilton:okay now i should i should qualify this by saying that you notice that i've actually been much more on top of the triage system i've been looking at stuff in advance and i've been getting this week is an exception i've not had a chance to pre-triage the post bag unfortunately uh because it's been a very i was up till very late last night doing homework uh for a course that begins in half an hour so i didn't get a chance so i'm doing a machine learning and ai course for work it's unclear why for sure machine learning yeah we did neural networks last night it's basically this course which began as foundation of ai has jumped up to machine learning and data science and neural networks overnight and the difficulty has magnified and i thought i'll do the homework last night and i went on and it said the homework will take you approximately five hours i was like fire and it literally took all evening oh my god at the end of this are you going to be like a robot possibly yeah i'm aiming to i'm aiming to be like a cyborg by the end of it that's you know in la among other it's like being in a future city and being in la because they have delivery robots walking around the city so i was walking up sunset boulevard today and honestly this little robot thing was approaching me with a with a and it's a delivery robot and yeah you get those here like the delivery robots from Tesco's yeah the little square little and you see them sometimes going along the street and you can get you know Doritos or whatever you want I promise you guys Luton they have them everywhere they all sit outside they have little robots and they drive along the street and they come to your door and drop off your stuff that is I have no idea that's it this country well they probably because they probably don't have them in London because it would just be the traffic would be a fucking nightmare.

24:28That's true. But like round here, you can get a delivery robot. Oh, little robots toddling up and down sides of the building. Quite shocked me, I have to say. And then on top of that, you've got the driverless fucking cars, which are everywhere. that's mad. I mean, they are terrifying as well. So yeah. And those enormous Elon Musk, like tank type things, which look like, it's a vehicle out of Batman. Anyway, the whole thing is insane. So yeah, I'm glad James is learning all about it.

24:52Boyd Hilton:All right. So I'm going to delve into the post bag and we're going to take it as, it's going to be a tombola situation. So we're just going to see what happens. We're going to start with the first one, and this comes from Geoffrey, Geoffrey Card. And it's titled British Police Shows. Geoff says, last episode, Steph said that when police characters have an American accent, she expects a low standard of behaviour from them. And I laughed out loud. As an American, I found that to be both cutting and hilariously, tragically true. American cops and media are always depicted heroically, struggling against the strictures of their job and succeeding in spite of them, often by skirting the rules.

25:27Boyd Hilton:On the other hand, I've noticed that British police shows go well out of their way to show cops carefully and deliberately adhering to all the necessary standards because that is how a heroic cop ensures that their quarry actually ends up in prison. Everyone is always cautioned, they always find an appropriate adult, and if there's a gun, there's always a shout of, on police, because in the UK that's actually a special case. British hero cops are shown purposefully handicapping themselves so as to make sure there is no abuse of power, and as an american i find that refreshing and cool and i'm sorry gunslinging american cops but there is nothing more badass than a british constable facing an unknown enemy and whipping out their telescopic billy club oh god i'm sorry i didn't mean to offend you i think that's genuinely hilarious because it is absolutely true that like in like a police drama they get one of the little asp battens and like right you're in for it now i'm gonna give you a right good drubbing oh god yeah it is it is genuinely funny uh our police are not the same as your police they're not no they are not right okay message here from richard waller and richard says hi james boyd k and steph knowing how you all have mixed views on soaps i'd love to hear what you make of vertical dramas as you may or may not be aware vertical dramas are short scripted series made specifically for phones in a vertical 916 format with episodes lasting typically around one to three minutes they emerged in china around 2019 and later spread to america and the uk and are known for fast-paced highly dramatic storytelling with strong hooks and cliffhangers the target audience is primarily gen z and younger millennials viewers who want quick bingeable content that fit easily into short breaks and scrolling habits have you seen any of these if not i'd love you all james especially to watch one and feed back they're akin to spanish telly novellas or 80s porn in the way that they're so heightened over the top and cheesy but they have to get the emotion across instantly to keep the viewer engaged and since there's no time to develop the character due to the episode length believe it or not it's not actually bad acting it's the format and genre are these the next big thing is this the way tv is going will james become addicted to the dragon master's pleasure slave good god boyd to hidden billionaire colon in first class okay swimming my way back to you or steph my husband murdered me or perhaps just reruns of last of the summer wine keep up the great work you're still the only pod i pay for richard richard i've never heard of these that is fascinating he said they can all be found on the real shorts app slash daily motion yeah i've heard of them that they were talked about on that other podcast that I often refer to.

28:10Which we are not going to plug here. No, I'm not going to. I must stop plugging it, yeah. But yeah, it's a massive phenomenon. Incredible, particularly in like Japan and... Hilariously, though. I've never heard of them.

28:20Boyd Hilton:This was the entire business model for Queeby, wasn't it? Yes. Which died on its arse. Now, it could be that Queeby was just a little bit ahead of its time. Yeah, I think, well, I think the difference is that these are very soapy, yeah. It's very kind of heightened. And we had Rachel Brosnahan with a golden arm yeah that's true yeah but they were all over the place weren't they those things they were some of them were wildly bizarre like that others were kind of you know like i don't know intense dramas comedy they just varied it was a mishmash of all kinds of things where these this new genre effectively is is its own thing i think um and it but but i think it will eventually have an impact they haven't i don't think many people know about it here yet, no, about them here yet, about these things, but they're so big in different parts of the world that I think it's inevitable they'll come here, yeah.

29:13Were they described as a Spanish novella crossed with porn?

29:18Boyd Hilton:Yeah, basically. Just in the way they're very heightened and melodramatic, because obviously they only have a short amount of time. Okay, that sounds fantastic. Yeah, definitely. Yeah. Punchy, sounds good. I don't think this is the future of television for a great many reasons, but first of all, fundamentally if you are watching these if they're designed for your phone if you're watching it on your phone you cannot dual screen and i think fundamentally that's going to be a problem for gen z audiences in the long term because you can't look at your phone while you're watching something on your phone unless you do it in picture in picture but i don't see that's going to work so do you know i mean so i just i just don't see that working because i know it's only three minutes but it's three minutes they have to give it their full attention because there is no distraction because you literally can't do anything else because you're holding your phone so i don't say that But I feel like loads of people just have two phones now.

30:03Boyd Hilton:I see it all the time. Do you think people are dual screening, but they're watching it on one phone and then they're scrolling Twitter on the other phone? Honestly, they do. This has been a revelation after revelation. You've got robots walking the streets of Luton. Everyone's got two phones. Two phones ceiling over here. I'm just saying, I think a lot of people have two phones because they have like business phone and then like fun phone. Do you have a burner and a regular phone? One for your drug dealer and another one for your, you know. I have like a phone which I have for like childcare phone.

30:30That's why I call childcare phone, which, you know, has all the apps on it for when Gracie's being unruly. And then, you know, I have my phone phone. Wow. So I think, you know, didn't you say the other day that you didn't think Netflix was going to be a thing when that guy came in and look at Netflix now.

30:43Boyd Hilton:Yeah, I am not the bellwether for these things. You should not by any means take, I've dismissed variously Netflix, Spotify and TikTok. I've had meetings with all three of these companies. They've all pitched me what they want to do and I'd be like, I don't see anything. There's a running theme here. Yeah, there is. It really is. Whatever I dismiss, you should invest all of your savings in is what we're saying. I'm putting some money down on these novella porn things. It's happening. Sounds great. I bet you are. No, I'm sorry. I can't. But also, like, Queeby died on its arse, lest we forget. So, I don't know.

31:16Boyd Hilton:We'll see. I really hope not because it feels like, because you're crowbarring into this format, it feels like they're taking out everything I like about TV. Like, you know, realism, plot. screenwriting acting things like that okay well you know what we should just watch some and then we should then we should feedback let's do that yeah okay that that is possible we could we could maybe look at doing that let me let me uh let me note down some of the names of these things i believe um richard that i can spare three minutes for your experiment uh next question oh this is jeff again jeffrey carr jeff says by the way in the wake of your discussion of silent witness i just wanted to point out that over here in the states mariska harkotay mariska harkotay has been playing Olivia Benson for 27 seasons on Law & Order SVU.

32:01Boyd Hilton:Before the turn of the millennium, I think she may hold the record outside of soaps. Yes, she is a different kettle of fish because also her mother is Jane Mansfield. So she is, yeah. Nepo baby. Yeah, she, I mean, I mean, Amelia Fox is kind of a Nepo baby as well, actually, isn't she? But I, she captivates the screen in an unbelievable way. I love her a lot. but yes that's a very good point and of course Olivia Benson is the name of one of Taylor Swift's cats yes named after her, named after her character of course of course Terry White formerly of this part was obsessed with Law and Order SVU and indeed her yes so the cats though since Terry is afraid of all living things what?

Read the full transcript

32:48what do you mean she's afraid of all living things?

32:50Boyd Hilton:she's not a pet person I never knew that about her. Really? No pets at all? No. Okay, I'm going to text her about that. You should do. Right. This comes from Rosalie or Rosalie. I'm going to go with Rosalie. Rosalie says, Dear Pilot gang, thank you as always for an amazing podcast. You're welcome. I have loved all versions of the pod line-up and the addition of Steph is no exception. Oh, sorry. Okay, I'm going to say I think it's Rosalie. Okay. Okay, fine. Okay, Rosalie, that is really... Yeah, I love you, Rosalie. That's really kind. Thank you. I'm writing my first email to say yes, please, to the Shrinking Spoiler Special with Kate and Steph.

33:29Boyd Hilton:It is one of my favourite shows and we'd love to hear more discussion on it. I work in mental health services and usually avoid anything that is too mental healthy, in inverted commas, because I need to switch off from work. But Shrinking is my one exception because it is such a joy and so well done. The portrayal of therapists and their clients is so well observed and the portrayal by Harrison Ford of being diagnosed with Parkinson's is amazing, although admittedly through a wealthy American type lens. I would agree completely with the point that all three of you made that to really get the show you need to watch it all the way through to learn about the characters and their quirks.

33:58Boyd Hilton:I also agree that Steph would love Ted Lasso which was which was and in fact is just as good as shrinking though I can't choose between the two. Thank you for the laughs. A live show tour would be lovely please. Rosie. Okay I'm definitely going to watch Ted or as Boyd calls it Ted Lasso which is one of my favourite things about Boyd. Tedler so I'm going to watch that now because of you Rosalie I'm definitely going to watch that well not right now let's finish the podcast that is fair but yes you should definitely do that tomorrow at this Apple event there is a shrinking panel and I believe actual Harrison Ford will be there on the panel so yeah that's quite exciting you don't deserve to go there because you don't love it as much as I do and you should have you should have put me in your suitcase oh my god and remember that you promised that if there was any shrinking merch that you were going to bring it home for my beloved Gabby, a.k.a.k.

34:47Right? Just remember. Yes. Oh, do you have a foundation Tumblr for James?

34:51Boyd Hilton:Not yet. Okay. Give it time. Boyd will find one. I have faith. Yeah. I have absolute faith. I hope Harrison Ford enjoys that Q &A more than he did the time when Disney did their slate and they were doing Captain America Brave New World and they dragged Harrison Ford along to the presentation and he sat on stage and had big, what could only be described as, hostage energy. Yeah, but have you seen Captain America Brave New World? Yes. So it's not like I can't understand why. and then afterwards I saw the film and I was like oh I get it yeah here's a message from John and John says Hi Pilot team I wanted to add my two pennies worth to the working out whilst watching television discussion I was very excited to hear this being raised on last week's podcast because in short bracket S short see what you did there very good I'm with James for I too watch TV whilst exercising at home and I've been doing so since COVID when working out at home became a thing for obvious reasons having the TV on provides motivation slash an actual reason to exercise and it means that I will watch at least one episode of TV per day, giving me a fighting chance of getting through the many, many wonderful TV shows that you recommend each week.

35:52Boyd Hilton:But there are rules. One, the show must be easy to engage with. This is not the time for something deliberately paced or complicated. Two, nothing, quote-unquote, prestige. Working out demands at least some concentration, and you have to accept that you're going to miss some scenes or dialogue. So, would I watch Slow Horses or Pluribus? No chance. These are top-tier shows and far too good to risk missing any crucial scenes. But this is a time for his and hers, black doves, the rookie, or the latest superhero-slash-action nonsense. In pilot terms, you want a burger, but not a gourmet burger. Point three, nothing with subtitles, because you have to watch what you're doing while lifting weights, or you may be lying on a yoga mat or a bench, so nothing foreign language.

36:32Boyd Hilton:It can be quite limiting, but it's a hard rule for me. So there you have it. Sorry, Boyd and Steph. I'm with Team James on this one. Honestly, you should all give it a try. Thank you for the truly excellent five-star podcast. And thanks for bringing Steph back on a more permanent basis. If Kay had to instigate a job share, I can't think of a better person to have on the pod than Steph. That's not throwing shade at Beth. Sounds like it to me. Who is also great. Although, seriously, will she ever watch Friday Night Lights? That's an in-joke, Steph. Keep the pilot light on. Brackets, not the big light.

37:00I feel like... I'm feeling the love, guys. This is really nice. This is lovely. I'm very happy. You're really making my day.

37:07Boyd Hilton:But crucially, are either of you now going to start working out while watching TV? No, because Boyd and I don't exercise. We don't believe in physical exercise. Right, I see. We're not going to do that. But I agree. Yeah, you definitely can't exercise and read a show at the same time. That seems... But I like John's rules. I think that's really good. They are solid rules. But I think you do want to... I know what he means, like a burger, not a gourmet burger. Because I think you could watch a gourmet burger, like the diplomat, while working out. Because you don't need to follow that closely. But I wouldn't want to, because I wouldn't want to miss a second of it.

37:34So, yeah. Yeah.

37:36Boyd Hilton:I agree with his rules. I've been kind of polling people about his and hers. and whether they figured out the ending. And it seems to be that most women have figured out the ending and most men did not figure out the ending, which is very interesting to me. Divided on gender lines. Yeah. Okay, all men are stupid, says Steph. Right, moving on. Asif says, hi to the pilot three, or is it just James manning the inbox? Yes, it is just me. Love the podcast, and Steph is killing it in the podcast Job Share with Kate. I have just finished Wonder Man, and for me it's one of the best things Kate who's Kate that's literally what they've written I'm going to take it I'm going to take it as deliberate trolling I'm going to take it as deliberate trolling rather than no just Kate it just says the job share with Kate so Steph clearly you are now so in tech with the podcast they've even forgotten Kate's name oh I don't think so Kate is irreplaceable as we know Kate it's Kate Kate is irreplaceable As Steve says, he goes on to say, I've just finished Wonder Man, and for me, it's one of the best things Marvel has released since WandaVision.

38:42Boyd Hilton:It honestly feels criminal that Disney hasn't given it more attention, because this show deserves far more recognition than it's getting. I understand why you compared it to the studio, but I'm not convinced that's the right fit. The studio is pure, sharp comedy, whereas Wonder Man uses comedy in a very different way. Its humour sits inside a superhero world without ever feeling like a traditional superhero story. Both leads are excellent, so Ben Kingsley absolutely steals the show. but Yaya's take on Simon is fantastic he brings the right mix of charm and vulnerability the finale lands perfectly and it left me genuinely hoping we get to see these characters again whether that's in their own self-contained corner at the MCU or wider Marvel stuff this series deserves a bigger spotlight and I'd love to hear your thoughts on why it hasn't been pushed harder by Disney I agree, I think you've underestimated in fact James I hereby accuse you of doing that with your three star verdict yeah and remember boy, do you remember when he was like yeah it's fine and we'd be like what?

39:35I know, I know. And I think it is different too. I think it's a good point. Tonally it's different to the studio. It's dealing with a lot of the same types of things, of course. But it's different and I think it's really interesting. It's definitely the most interesting and inventive thing they've done since WandaVision. I agree with that. And it's definitely, I'm definitely going to finish it. I haven't finished it yet, but I'm really intrigued to see where it goes. but not intrigued enough to watch the episodes not yet as to why they haven't there are posters for all over la i have to say i saw loads of posters so i don't know whether that's just you know i don't know how they spend their advertising and marketing budget but it's very prominent here i think it feels to me anyway i wonder if it's because it's not i don't know it doesn't kind of hit you in the face superhero immediately and there it's not blockbuster-y enough do you know what i mean it's not saying i'm a basic that's what you know i'm just saying as as to boy's point it's tonally very different i really enjoyed it i think it's fantastic but maybe it's not pacey enough for people so they it just hasn't got that i don't know it but it it's it's incorrect because it's wonderful and people should be talking about it and people should be watching it um and you're totally wrong james because it's not fine

40:51Boyd Hilton:we did a we did a spoiler special actually for this we didn't have a spoiler special for wonder when we talked about it i think me chris and helen were all pretty much in a similar amon liked it a lot more to be fair and he wrote the empire review and gave it four stars uh but um we're all a bit like yeah it's good it's not great and i think if it hadn't been part of the mcu if you'd taken out the kind of big swing aspect of it it's quite middle of the road because i don't think it it does any of the things that we talked about from a kind of a you know like a hollywood satire point if he does any of those things particularly well as a comedy it's kind of gently amusing not properly funny as a drama you know the character work is quite nice that's absolutely true and i enjoy spending time with those characters so i like i get it and i get why people like it um in terms of like it being the biggest or the i say the most adventurous thing they've done since wonder vision yeah i mean of course that is true like it is it is an adventurous thing to do it's a it's an unusual thing to do but i think you've answered your own question as to why disney don't care about it or topped it all out at once and don't seem to know what to do with it because they literally don't know what to do with it because they're looking at this and we're like we don't know what this is and we don't know who it's for because if you're not into the mcu you won't watch it and if you're into the mcu you might not like it so it's quite niche in that way um so i do think they just they literally have no idea how to market this to people they should have thought about that when they commissioned it yes you would think wouldn't you it's just lazy let's just do your market research and then you know get a marketing plan together it is you know sometimes it is tricky because obviously you have different teams you have a creative team that put together a show or a film or whatnot and they bring this thing they give it to the marketing department and they look at this and be like there is no route to market for this like we don't know who the audience is we don't understand this and we don't know how to sell it and that does happen right like you know you get great things that marketing teams don't know what to do with and sometimes they do just think oh let's just dump it and see what happens and sometimes they do something like they did remember with slumdog millionaire where they marketed it as what looked like a richard curtis comedy like you know like the all the all the promotion for that totally missold what it was the materialist is another one recent film where massively missold is almost like a romantic comedy it is neither a comedy nor romantic like it's like it's it's wild that materialist is so right because i honestly thought it was going to be a romantic funny romantic comedy i was like what the this is not what it says on the box and it's completely missold by the trailer and by the you know by the posters but but but that's fine because i guess they just didn't really know how to package it and i think that's very much the case here but yeah look wonder man is fine i i enjoyed it i don't regret watching it uh three stars oh james okay fine i'm gonna pick out this message from stephen because the subject line is simply i agree with steph oh my god there's so this is like a steph post box i know and the thing is you would imagine if i had pre-triaged this you could have accused me of stacking the deck to like make you feel really good but i'm literally just pulling these up in order as they appear so i have no hand in this i feel like you're making me feel better because of what happened the other day let's not mention it but i do i am not and in case you're wondering what happened the other day steph went on to reddit i went on to reddit and i had a little cry because oh people were mean to people people were mean somebody wanted me to stop breathing and i thought that was a bit harsh i'm going to defend the redditors here and say not that i want you to stop breathing that's not where this is going in that that in the thread where they were feeding back on you stepping in for k i think more people were positive about you than were negative about you so i i think that you just you just as this human nature you fixated on the few negative comments well i had a little cry and then i felt better and i talked to boyd and boyd was very nice to me but he did say i talked very fast and then he said it's a good thing oh my god i'm in no position to criticize that i'm sorry Yes, and you know what?

44:36Someone in the office came up to me when I'd said about this whole thing, when I went on the Reddit, and I said, oh, people are being mean to me. And then someone came up to me and went, I just want to say that you know your friend James. He definitely speaks faster than you. That's what they said. So, there you go. I think, you know what? I think that's probably true, especially when he's like about to talk about foundation or something. Exactly. Well, I'm excited. I've built up philosophy.

45:00Boyd Hilton:Yeah, yeah. anyway we need to find out why why steven connolly agrees with steph okay okay come on steve currently sitting in a coffee shop too much information steven trying not to think not enough oh no okay right he's sitting in a coffee shop trying not to get frustrated but i whole heartedly agree with steph about shrinking and not being able to review it properly if you haven't watched the whole thing i wrote in before and praised the show and to demand james watched it but it raises a point about reviewing shows in their second or third season shrinking is a show which if you haven't watched every episode will not resonate with you if you jump in during the third season it is a beautiful and profound show with lots of belly laughs and it's genuinely one of my favorite shows of all time but it has me wanting to ask should the pod be reviewing second or third seasons of shows if most of you haven't watched the previous seasons it must be difficult to recommend something if you haven't followed the show up to this point also i understand the new postbag song but i missed the previous one as i used to sing along to it i'm so sorry oh by the why there's a new postbag song darren made one i heard it it's really good but yeah i missed the k song i love the k song maybe we just keep that one so stephen does have a point it has to be said yes uh it is not ideal when we review shows in their second third fourth fifth or indeed 29th season silent witness uh when we haven't watched the previous episodes because you can't it's absolutely right you cannot really do it like when i would drop you boyd and k into like season three of the wheel of time and make you talk about it it was just i mean it was entertaining for me but probably not for anyone else so you are absolutely correct sometimes though we don't have a choice and the reason i say that is like we will always prioritize new shows over returning shows like that is the general rule of the podcast but tv schedules are unpredictable and sometimes there just isn't something so we are forced to dip into the well of returning shows whether we've kept up with them or not yeah we're doing cross season two this week often though um listeners with the decision on whether to review a show if it's in its second, third or whatever season, it comes down to, does James like it?

47:00I disagree. That's outrageous.

47:03Boyd Hilton:In my defence about this week and Cross, there was nothing else. I know, but you would have very much supported reviewing it. Well, I can say I watched the whole first season of Cross, which I'm fairly certain none of you did. No. No. No. No, no, but I did watch the whole of one of the shows we're going to be reviewing. Yeah, the whole of one. I seem to tend to be doing that, like watching the whole of one of the shows we're doing. Yes, you really don't have to do that, right? No, I know, but I really loved it. Anyway. Oh, okay. Oh, God, don't spoil it. Don't spoil it. Okay, fine. Right. Interesting.

47:36Boyd Hilton:Well, Stephen agrees with you. I don't know how we can fix that, Stephen, except to say that what you're essentially asking is for me to go back to the very beginning and watch Rinking from the start, which I will consider. I've said this to you, James. I really, really feel strongly that that show will speak to you and it has an emotional depth, which I think you should try and reach. I just really, really do. And I agree. I totally agree. It's hard because you haven't got the relationships. You don't know the relationships with those characters. And so you make sweeping statements, which you have no right to do.

48:13And I feel that this is your telling off once again for it. Fair enough. It's a wonderful show. And can I just say, in season three, there is perhaps one of my favourite moments, which Boyd you would hate, where two of the characters sing a song from Les Mis in the presence of Harrison Ford. And it's so funny and brilliant and wonderful. And they sing the whole of a song. It's amazing. But we'll save that for the potential spoiler special that me and my beloved Gabby will be doing.

48:40Boyd Hilton:Why do you call her Gabby? well do you know what if you watch the show you'd know so the female the female character in the gabby is so much like k and yeah but you would know if you watch the show which you don't okay noted oh oh you mean kate sorry i was getting very confused i couldn't think oh lord right so we've gone from i agree with steph to graham wells and the subject of his message is outraged at boyd graham says dear pod i am outraged at the short shrift boyd has given video games the past two weeks first dismissing the casting of kratos in god of war and then it turns out he only dislikes corridors if they are quote unquote video game like on the back of this i suggest a new section of the pod every time boyd bangs on about reality tv nonsense like the traitors we get an equal amount of time dedicated to single-player narrative-driven games yes i know only james in the pod is a gamer at all and i don't know his preferences but i feel this is a medium of high end storytelling that isn't covered enough and there is no pilot slash empire equivalent i'm not even asking for a review of games just time appreciating that god of war is an outstanding story of a father and son coping with grief and bonding while killing a lot of gods along the way uh that ghost of yote is a story of revenge and family or that claire obscure expedition 33 deserved its record haul of awards last year whilst being an utterly mental French story where everyone is English except the flying marshmallow you meet.

50:10Boyd Hilton:That is absolutely true. Long shot, I know, but if it means less traitor's talk, I would take it. Boyd, how do you plead? Guilty. Guilty as charged. I don't get on with video games like that. Yeah, I'm sorry. Sorry, can I just say, so God of War is a video game. Has God of War been made into any kind of TV show? Is it purely a video game? Well, we were talking about the casting of it, which you of course listened carefully to when I spoke about it last week. Yes, the guy with the beard. The guy with the beard. Okay, yeah, well you would take 10 minutes to try it and then we got to it. That's the one.

50:39Got it, sorry, apologies. Okay, so sorry, Boyd, to jump in. I'm going to take exception to him saying that you're the only gamer. I'm not a gamer, but I do like adaptations. So, you know, and someone did a really good thing on one of the socials which was like mentioning other game adaptations into TV when we talked about that the other week. So I'm definitely going to watch this God of War. Boyd, the guilty one, would you like to speak now? Oh, I'll watch it. Of course. I'll watch them all. I mean, the reason I don't play video games is because it would ruin my life because it'd be another thing I've got to do, spending hours and hours and hours on it.

51:21I should be watching the rest of Cross Season 1, for example. So I just can't deal with it as a medium. I can't let it into my life, really, particularly because it would just take up too much time. So it's nothing against them, really. It's just, it's literally the practicality of it. I'm sure there's loads of brilliant ones, yeah. When I was younger, I did, I dabbled, but, you know. That's what I was going to say. Did you play video games when you were younger? Yeah. Did they have video games by that point? Oh, please. I had a Wii. I had a Nintendo Wii. I played Zelda, the one thingy bob of whatever.

51:55You know, yeah. Yeah, no, I used to play Tomb Raider. I loved Tomb Raider when I was younger. and obviously everyone plays Mario Kart. And now, because I have a Nintendo Switch, you know, you play all of those games on there. But it's mostly Mario games, any kind of Mario game. But yeah, Boyd, I could see you having a dabble with Zelda. Definitely.

52:16Boyd Hilton:Okay. Thank you. I think it's all about verticals, isn't it? You can only have a certain number of verticals in your life. And if you've got like film and TV and games, that's your lot. And you can swap out one of those in BoyzCast games for football, which is what he's done. Or you can swap out another one for, I don't know, a social life, which none of us have done. So, Steph, you apparently have got that one sorted. So, I think you can have three things on the go at any given time, but you can't have any more. Okay, let's just, hold on a minute. My social life is basically going to the parties of six-year-olds.

52:50That's basically what I do. Yeah, whatever floats your boat. Yeah.

52:53Boyd Hilton:That's absolutely fine. Okay, so you're saying that you can't watch TV, film, and be a gamer at the same time. Oh, no, you can do those three. You just can't have a fourth. So I couldn't, for example, get into football or, I don't know, have a social life. So that's off the table. Boyd, he can't play games because his three verticals are already filled. So you can't have a fourth. There is simply not the bandwidth to be really into a fourth thing. Okay, you can be triple threat, but you cannot be quadruple threat. Okay, got it. That is the rule. Okay, fine. I think that's fair. Yeah, I think we've cracked it.

53:26Boyd Hilton:That's definitely it. Right, last question before I will let Boyd go to bed. Boyd just gave her such a big yawn. He did. He checked out a while ago, let's be honest. Right, this comes from Steve Cram. And the only reason I'm going to mention this is Steve. Steve Cram. Stropping Steve, as I'm going to call you, Steve. It's just slightly passive-aggressive. I just want to check in my last email below. Might have been missed in the recent changeover of postbag duties, which strikes me as, pull your finger out, James. Come on. kate would never have allowed this to uh to to to go past right uh okay right steve let's get into it steve says happy new year all right fair enough it was a while ago uh question for the most bag how do you feel about show specific podcasts it seems every show has one these days but as they often drop at the same time as the show it seems more of a pr move than really interesting and focuses on getting you to watch the next episode with more questions than answers i have found the better podcast being the rewatch ones where a couple of people involved in the show long since finished go back with the benefit of hindsight and those i've enjoyed so far include office ladies with jenna fisher angela kinsey for the u.s office the history of curb your enthusiasm with jess and susie which unfortunately was cancelled how we made your mother with josh radnor and craig thomas are there any other good ones out there did you say jess and susie for curvy enthusiasm that's what he's written is that wrong jeff jeff jeff it's jeff so i wouldn't know because I don't watch Curb.

54:49Boyd Hilton:But he'd written Jess. No, yeah. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Have you never watched any episodes of Curb Your Enthusiasm? You know that I can't deal with cringe comedy. It's, oh, no, it's not cringe comedy. Oh, it is. Oh, my God, Boyd. How have we not been to watch one episode? Well, you know, like, it's the most cringe comedy. Yeah, I mean. Okay. It's like the apotheosis of all things cringe. Oh, so you've just, yeah, so it's making you feel uncomfortable. I can't do it. It causes me physical pain. It's intensely stressful. I can't watch The Office. I can't watch Curl. I can't even watch Succession.

55:23Boyd Hilton:I can't watch anything like that, which hinges around cringe. It's ridiculous. It's absolutely ridiculous. You're missing out on the greatest TV in history. Yeah, you really are. Okay. It distresses me. But to that question, I really liked Are You a Charlotte? Which is a Sex and the City one. I just want to think. Can you think of any others? The ones that Better Call Saul and Pluribus now ones are good. The official ones? the official ones yeah really good yeah I think a lot of them are insightful actually but I know what he means it's good I think I also like the ones where you go back and look at them afterwards as well but I think there are some very they are marketing to some extent but when you've got a creator like I keep forgetting who's the creator of Breaking Bad Vince Gilligan our close personal friend thank you our close personal friend friend of the pod yeah when you've got him holding forth about how he writes this stuff I mean, it's fascinating to me.

56:19Boyd Hilton:So, yeah. The West Wing Weekly was obviously my favourite one. I did a complete West Wing watch-along to that show, which took however many years it took, where I would not watch the next episode of the West Wing until the West Wing Weekly episode with Josh Molina and Rishi Hohe. And I really, really enjoyed that. I thought they were fantastic. And they did something which was quite unusual for these, where because the West Wing is political, they would bring in people connected to the politics of the show as well as to do with the show itself. so you would explore the issues of the episodes as well as as well as the drama of when on screen i watched the battle star watch i didn't watch it as a podcast i listened to the battle star galactic cast with mark bernard and trisha helfer and found that awful genuinely awful it was just them giggling and getting drunk and it was like it offered very little insight the ones where ron d moore were on were actually pretty good but i didn't get on with that at all the hbo last of us podcast i've listened to every episode of i thought that was really good do you know i haven't listened to there is an only murders in the building podcast which is so meta because obviously Only Murder in the Building is about the podcast, making podcasts Only Murder in the Building.

57:20But I bet you that's good because, I mean, come on, it's got to be good. Steve Martin and Martin.

57:24Boyd Hilton:If it's a bad podcast based on that show, then that's a pretty big own goal. But they can be good. I've wanted to do a Shield rewatch along to, there's a podcast called The Shattered Shield, which I've not, which I've not actually listened to. And a friend of the pod, Kobe does The Wire Stripped, which is a wire watch along podcast. I've been on that podcast, in fact, which is a lot of fun. And I need to do a wire rewatch. In fact, I've been considering, I very nearly this weekend I very nearly picked a thing to re-watch but I couldn't decide on it so I didn't do it but I am definitely circling I'm circling a re-watch at some time so but we'll talk about this on the on the main show um but yeah so I yes I've got I've got a lot of time for these these type of podcasts and if I had more time in my podcast listening life I would listen to more of them and that was from Steve Cram not the middle distance runner Steve Cram just no another Steve no a different Steve Cram well you don't know it could be it could be and maybe that's why maybe because he's running and he just he wants to listen to this on the podcast and he was upset that he couldn't yeah except we'll never know let us know steve sebastian co avid listeners are apparently oh i mean absolutely not it's a they were the competitors weren't they you see yes you see the joke i'm making there are barely barely even qualified as a joke i think it's boy's bedtime time for sleepy buys time for sleepy buys uh we will be back in your ears on Monday when we will be doing another slightly random remote podcast because uh Boydie will still be on his massive jolly Steph and I will be crammed into a little two-person sound booth not even a studio I don't know how much room is in there Steph we may literally be sitting on each other's laps because it's the only it's the only studio I could book at the time that Boydie could do during his jolly so uh there will be no video I should say on YouTube next week because there was no camera in that studio but yeah it's going to be uh it's going to be snug is all I'm saying who's in our studio james well that's because we've had to move for boydy oh boy do you want to i don't know how do i connect with the whole thing i will have to send you all the details don't worry right i'll give you that that's really annoying i bought i bought um some tiffin for you some marxisman's tiffin for our for wednesday james so you could have a little treat when we went to tiffin oh it's like a chocolate it's like a chocolate biscuit thing and it's got all...

59:34Boyd Hilton:See, I can't have it. I'm on a no sugar February. God, you're so boring. Okay, fine. Sorry. Anyway, on Monday's show, we'll be covering Betrayal on ITV, Cross on Prime Video and Small Profits on the BBC. Until then, goodnight, Boydie. Night night. Pilot out to sleep.

1:00:04Thank you.

From the publisher

For this week’s show, the team were air-dropped onto a desert island to see if they’d tear each other apart while trying to record the pod. Well, close enough as Boyd is off on a Jolly to LA and dialling in remotely and we review Jack Thorne’s new take on Lord Of The Flies. Plus the postbag reveals such arcane delights as telling-offs about Shrinking and video games, the joy of short-form episodes, telly-facing workouts, and a lot of fanmail for Steph.

Want your messages read out as part of The Postbag? Email us at pilottv@empiremagazine.com

More from Pilot TV+

All 149 episodes
PLUS Lord Of The FliesPilot TV+ · 1 h
Listen in VO