In short
Pilot Plus discusses Apple TV+ thriller crime series Lucky, focusing on Anya Taylor-Joy’s con-artist heroine, the chase structure across Nevada to California, and the show’s cinematography (desaturated desert, neon Las Vegas contrast) plus standout action (an extended in-car fight/escape).
Key claims
Lucky is a stylish, fast-moving caper with strong propulsion; Taylor-Joy’s performance is “emotional con” and physically grounded; Annette Bening’s villainy is chilling and scene-stealing; themes include breaking cycles of con artistry via a father-daughter relationship (Timothy Olyphant as her father).
Notable examples
the iconic jacket-in-desert imagery; a lavish mansion confrontation; a “Kill Bill”-like vibe; a scrunchy bob change after she’s double-crossed; a family-connection thread.
Guests
None in this episode; it’s hosts Steph Sealand, Boyd, and James, plus listener emails. Mentioned guest: Anya Taylor-Joy (appears Monday’s studio interview).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOOverview of 'Lucky'
0:45 to 1:49
Discussion about the Apple thriller series 'Lucky' and its main character.
“Coming to you live in stereo Luton Phonics, it's Steph Sealand.”
Character Analysis of Lucky
1:49 to 4:19
Exploration of the main character Lucky as a complex con artist.
“And kind of get them to do what she wants them to do.”
Cinematography and Visual Style
4:19 to 7:07
Discussion about the artistic choices and cinematography of 'Lucky'.
“Although I have to say, right, I've become, for some reason, my ex, I'm still on ex, apologies in advance for those people.”
Themes and Character Dynamics
7:07 to 11:08
Exploration of the themes of legacy and morality in 'Lucky'.
“And even in the way that she's running, he had told her to run less well.”
Release Insights and Future Content
11:08 to 14:01
Details about the show's release and upcoming interview with Anya Taylor-Joy.
“And I watched all eight episodes, I think.”
Discussion on 'Lucky' and Upcoming Guests
14:01 to 14:24
Learn about the new show 'Lucky' and Anya Taylor-Joy's upcoming interview.
“Lucky then, which is on Apple TV Plus, I want to say today.”
Plans for Widow's Bay Spoiler Special
14:25 to 14:54
The hosts discuss plans for a spoiler special on 'Widow's Bay' and their scheduling challenges.
“Okay, we were going to do, or are going to do, or may do, a Widow's Bay spoiler special.”
Blame Game for Podcast Timing
14:55 to 16:01
A humorous blame game unfolds about the timing of the podcast recording with references to various people.
“Well, and also, it's actually James' fault, because we should tell the listeners that we're recording this podcast at the frankly absurd time of 5pm on a Tuesday evening.”
Listener Mail: Steph's Widow's Bay Viewing
16:02 to 18:24
Listener feedback addresses Steph's reluctance to finish 'Widow's Bay' and her eventual experience with the finale.
“What will be the next reason she can find to avoid the torture of fixing her eyeballs on another episode of That Blessed Show?”
Discussion on Little House on the Prairie
18:25 to 22:47
The hosts discuss listener comments on 'Little House on the Prairie' and its cultural significance.
“in my house, in like my bedroom, alone and I took every single bit of it in and it was totally the right decision.”
Show all 21 chapters
Ali's Thoughts on Spoilers
22:48 to 25:21
A listener criticizes the hosts for revealing spoilers and suggests improvements for future episodes.
Netflix Preview Club Insights
25:22 to 28:01
Discussion on the Netflix Preview Club and the experience of viewing unfinished shows.
“It had around 2 ,000 members, but now it's expanded to tens of thousands of users globally, okay, to gather a more diverse range of feedback on upcoming movies and TV shows, right?”
Listener Feedback on Reviews
28:01 to 29:28
The hosts discuss listener feedback about their reviews and mention which platforms shows are on.
“I believe she means to say, I like Boyd, but she missed the first comma of the parentheses.”
Discussing Notable Shows
29:28 to 31:06
The hosts reflect on various shows that listeners mentioned, including DTF and Cape Fear.
“the show at the very beginning in the introduction and then i always repeat it at the beginning of the review as well.”
Miscommunication on Shows
31:06 to 32:47
The hosts acknowledge missing mentions of specific shows and discuss their viewing experiences.
“Both were great stories with great acting and satisfying conclusions.”
Nostalgia for Childhood Shows
32:47 to 34:25
The hosts share nostalgic memories about childhood shows and debate their narratives.
“Message from Lucy, simply entitled Heidi.”
Discussion on Animation Styles
34:25 to 36:38
A listener provides insights on animation styles, discussing X-Men 97 and the distinction between art style and animation quality.
“Silas is a 1981 ZDF adventure television miniseries based on the Danish children's book Silas Ogdensult Hop by Cecil Bodka, who kept on writing installments until 2001.”
Exploring Modern Animation
36:38 to 42:03
The hosts delve into the current animation trends and styles, referencing shows like The Wolf King.
“So what on earth would make them omit the G?”
Exploring Animation Styles
42:03 to 43:30
Discussion on various animation styles and their impact on storytelling.
“And Netflix has got a show called The Wolf King.”
Comparing TV and Movie Animation
43:31 to 46:52
Analysis of the differences in animation quality between TV shows and films.
“Well, if you watched it, then I will take your word for it.”
Listener Engagement and Suggestions
46:53 to 47:59
Encouragement for listeners to submit their animation recommendations.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:07Boyd Hilton:Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters and a podcast that has, well, is not only sitting in the sweltering heat, but is also dealing with technological issues, aka Steph's microphone, which has always been a finicky beast, I would say, but today has basically given up the ghost entirely and decided to take the day off. I can only imagine it's due to the weather and frankly, it needs a holiday. But as a result, Steph will be using her built-in Mac microphone. So it may sound like she's either A, underwater or B, currently inside the TARDIS. Say something, Steph. Let's see how you sound.
0:39Oh God, do I sound terrible? Is it really awful?
0:42Boyd Hilton:I mean, oh, it's hideous. Absolutely horrendous. It doesn't sound that bad to me, but I'm not an audio fascist. Coming to you live in stereo Luton Phonics, it's Steph Sealand. I'm so sorry. I hate technology. we will run it through some kind of de-lutenizer well maybe not or at least a de-echo filter and see if we can fix that up so it's unfortunate that you've been very unlucky this morning Steph especially because the show that we're covering this week is in fact called Lucky which you unfortunately are not but this is Apple's new thriller crime series type thing this is created by Jonathan Tropper my beloved Jonathan Tropper creator of Banshee and Warrior and seasons 2 and 3 of My Beloved Sea and it stars Anya Taylor Total Joy as we have named her as the eponymous Lucky, and she is a con artist, and she's on the run, having been, shall we say, left in the lurch, having pulled off a blag.
1:35Boyd Hilton:She is running from organised crime and the authorities. Organised crime, of course, in the form of Annette Bening, who is currently embracing her villain era with this and Dutton Ranch. But anyway, anyway, who wants to tell us about Lucky? Boydie. um okay well you you told us all about it in your comprehensive excellent that was pilot plus we hope you've enjoyed it please like and subscribe yeah um it is a very stylish pacey fast-moving caper is how i would describe it relying to a heavy extent on anya taylor total joys kind of very convincing work She's a con artist and she can basically twist anyone she meets around her little finger.
2:21Is that the phrase? And kind of get them to do what she wants them to do. She's like an emotional con artist, isn't she? That's a good description, yeah. She's an emotional con artist, yeah. So it's kind of – she's an intrinsically interesting character. This is adapted from a novel, isn't it, by Marissa Statley? I don't know if you said that. Is that correct? Yes. Yes. So I think she's done a really good job in making the character interesting and three-dimensional, because you're not quite sure. So there are moments where she really is desperate to get someone's help for her to evade the police and the gangster type people she's fallen in with, who think she's got their money.
3:02And she's absolutely desperate. And so she calls upon people to do what she needs them to do. but at those moments you're not you're still not quite sure because she does need them desperately and you're kind of rooting for her i mean you just are rooting for her and um so in those moments you're not quite sure whether she's just doing something because you know that's the that's the thing to do because she knows how to do it in terms of conning people or whether actually she's so desperate she really is desperate well she is right because she's you know she's caught in the She's let out of a car in the middle of Nevada and in the desert.
3:37And, you know, she's in a bad way. I thought it was – I believed in it. I thought it was convincing. It's quite complicated. No, it's not that complicated. There's a nice, sturdy cast of characters who are all chasing after her. And Annette Bening, I know you two are obviously fucking obsessed with Dutton Runch. Yeah. Yes. But what a brilliant late career time she's having, because she is brilliant in this. You totally believe that she's an absolute psychopath nightmare. She's having an innocence, if we can call it that. Absolutely. You're on fire, Steph, even though your mic's not working. So she could be on fire.
4:19We just wouldn't be able to hear it very clearly. She's having a netteissance, yes. and but she's so every i have to say every it's a cliche but every scene she's in she steals and it's absolutely riveting washing her and in episode two or three when she meets well so william fichner is steady indeed he is like he's like another level above of psychopathic gangster type people in the chain of uh of order in the in chain of what's the phrase i'm looking for the order of the people who are doing that stuff yeah i've completely lost it um psychopathy yeah and villainy just general villainy yeah villain chain um and there's a great scene where she goes to his lavish mansion and confronts him and that that's kind of like it i love stuff like that stuff that kind of uses you know the the california um locations really well it's visually very interesting.
5:13Although I have to say, right, I've become, for some reason, my ex, I'm still on ex, apologies in advance for those people. You are the only one of us still on Twitter. There's a few, there's a few. I'll tell you who there are loads of, in fact, this is my point. Pornbots and fascists. No, no, no, there's loads as well, obviously. They are cinematography experts, right, who I've somehow, I've somehow, I get loads of them in my feed, in my ex feed, And one of the things that I had to be arguing about was the opening scene of one of the scenes in this show. In fact, it's one of the scenes where she's walking in the desert, right?
5:51And she's carrying a jacket on her back. Iconic. Yeah. And people were complaining that it was too kind of washed out and, you know, not enough colour. And I'm like, that's the point of it. That's the artistic, creative, you know. I thought it was deliberately desaturated in the desert. But yeah. So I've really got into a whole, you know, X hole of people banging on about the cinematography of this show. And I don't know what the fuck they're complaining about, because I think it looks great. And every visual decision that it makes, I think, makes total sense. Because you see the contrast between the neon of Las Vegas at the beginning when she's celebrating with her husband.
6:33Is he her husband? He's her husband, yeah. Drew Starkey from Queer, the Queer film, the film called Queer, who's very good and that contrast between that and then she's let out in this bleak landscape which is the only person for miles and miles so I think it all made sense so I'm I'm absolutely into it I will I'm intrigued I'm riveted I'll carry on watching it and it's very good I absolutely I agree with everything you said I absolutely love you I think it's got one of the best in-car fight scenes that I've ever seen there is an extended scene where Anya is in no spoilers she is in a car and she's she has to make her way out somehow to safety to and that scene is so well shot I don't even know how they did it because you really feel in the midst of it and to go back to that desaturated desert which I thought was absolutely perfect and set her the thing about that scene is to me almost immediately felt iconic because you've got the jacket you've got this pristine jacket set against that that kind of you know the grainy landscape and she's is it a spoiler to say she's walking away she's walking somewhere okay that's not a spoiler to say she's walking she's walking she's walking um and i i love that i'm not quite i mean listen i don't want to get into why you've decided to take on all the cinematographers or why they've decided to take against this but i thought it was absolutely amazing it gave me kind of kill bill vibes it felt very uma thurman um and also once again proves my point about what happens to women on screen when we are supposed to know that they've gone slightly crazy right and they're slightly enraged because her hair which at the beginning was straight as soon as as soon as she's kind of double crossed within the first 10 minutes she gets a scrunch she gets a scrunchy bob and it all turns a bit wavy just saying proves my point once again um yeah she's fantastic in this we obviously we when we interviewed her we talked a lot about the physicality of this role dogs and the physicality of the role and one of the things that you notice straight away is that she the The director has made her work really hard to show that she is a real woman running away from danger.
9:05And even in the way that she's running, he had told her to run less well. And you get the feeling there's a scene where she's running across lorries and her arms are sort of flailing around. So the desperation of her to go from one kind of point of safety to another point of safety, the pacing is spot on with that. And yeah, I mean, Anya Taylor, not just because we've interviewed her, she was obviously wonderful. She's absolutely fantastic in this. Every expression she makes, every physical move she makes feels deliberate and it feels intended and it feels like it moves the story along. And I really, really enjoyed it.
9:46But yeah, my God, when Annette Bening arrives, you're like, oh, shit's got real. she should you're thinking lucky needs to actually be really worried now because annette benning is like the death knell when she comes there's a scene where she arrives and you're like oh shit and you feel really and i think that's kind of the genius of the way this is shot to to speak to the cinematographers it actually it does really take you along on the roller coaster ride that she's on so i'm i'm fully i'm fully on board yeah it's it's got a real propulsion to it this show
10:20Boyd Hilton:does because it's essentially i mean it's like it's like a i mean it's not mad max fury road but it is basically a chase and we go through nevada the deserts nevada to california we go all over the place but it's just constantly she is just running all the time for her life um which is a lot of fun and as you will find out on monday's show when you hear the onion taylor joy interview because she came on the podcast with us uh you know a lot of that is uh because it's all seen through her eyes and she is very much an unreliable narrator because she's literally a con artist so I think she's a really fun character it's really nice to see these kind of morally ambiguous characters but to see a very sort of female coded one rather than the very kind of like Tony Soprano Walter White type characters that we're so used to on television so it's a lot of fun it's not like I would say top tier Apple show like I really enjoyed it for me it's probably I think we at Empire Magazine I should say we gave it four stars I think that's fair it's somewhere between a high three low four I'd probably give it four, but it's definitely not up there with, I think, the best of Apple, but I still think it's a really good show.
11:23Boyd Hilton:And I watched all eight episodes, I think. So I did watch all of them when it first dropped. So I watched it a couple of months ago. So if I'm being glossy about specifics, it's because I watched it, liked it, and have since watched 100 ,000 other things and have clearly forgotten all the bits of it. I think William Fickner is brilliant in it, and he is genuinely terrifying, because I think he's a really good villain in this. I think Annette Bening as well. There's a coldness to her character. She's really quite chilling, and there's obviously a family connection in there with her as well which is quite fun but i think what really stood out for me in this is i really like the relationship between her and her father who's played by timothy oliphant and what the show explores is partly like it's a it's a you know it's a thriller and she's trying to survive she's trying to get out of hot water like that's essentially the the arc of the story but the themes here are whether or not you can break out of patterns of behavior because the point is is that her father before her was a con artist he's not a particularly good guy he's not a particularly good father and she is very much the child he raised and like each and there's the morality aspect like is she a quote unquote bad person or is it just this is the only skill set that she was ever taught from a young child she was taught the con she was taught how to you know find a mark and how to wrap them around her finger as boyd said so there's there's her kind of dealing with that kind of legacy that parental legacy and whether or not she can carve out an identity for herself which i think is quite an interesting and interesting thread in it as well.
12:44Yeah, when they were at the, they did a presentation at the Apple Santa Monica event that I may have mentioned. Oh, were you invited to Santa Monica, to go to a special event? Really? You've never mentioned it. I know. And well, I will mention it now though, because they talked about what, the father-daughter relationship, which I think is obviously the driver of the book as well, because this is a co-production with Reese Witherspoon's company. Yes. Who literally, they kind of find books that are going to be huge. This is a co-production with Hello Sunshine? Yeah, Hello Sunshine, yeah. Wow, okay.
13:16Indeed. Because it's quite unusual for them, isn't it? And yeah, it's female-driven, right? Because as we were saying, she's the traditional kind of character that you'd get played by a bloke in Breaking Bad or whatever. So I think that's what attracted her, and that's what attracted everyone to the project, was that relationship. And it does play out really well. Big week for Timothy Olyphant, of course, because he's also in The Five Star Weekend. He is. So he is constantly in demand. And has excellent hair. He does have excellent hair. Yeah, yeah. I mean, he just has hair, doesn't he? He just has hair, yeah.
13:51The bar is quite low for me, boy. But it gets to a point when a man still has, like, impressive hair when they're at a certain age, that it is just excellent hair.
13:58Boyd Hilton:It's just excellent hair. Lucky then, which is on Apple TV Plus, I want to say today. Is it today? I think it actually started yesterday. Yesterday? Yes. Wow. Yeah. And you can hear Anya Taylor-Joy on Monday's podcast when she is our guest in the studio talking about this very show. And, not to put two finer points on it, dogs. There's a lot of dog discussion at the top of that particular interview. So, be prepared. Okay, we were going to do, or are going to do, or may do, a Widow's Bay spoiler special. And we were going to do it as part of this recording and either do it separately, you know, as a separate thing, or we were going to bolt it on the end of this.
14:34Boyd Hilton:but because we've had lots of to-ing and fro-ing about the mic situation i fear we're not likely to have time so this is something we might have to record separately you might have to wait a little bit longer for the widow's bay thing we're going to try and record it this week but please do bear with us you know i think we can all agree it's steph's fault okay okay it is my fault but i'm just gonna say admin i can i can do it thursday or friday so you know okay good to know Thank you, Steph. Well, and also, it's actually James' fault, because we should tell the listeners that we're recording this podcast at the frankly absurd time of 5pm on a Tuesday evening.
15:12I mean, that's the issue at hand. Is it? I mean, it's still part of the work of day, buddy, I'm saying. We can go back and really blame. I'm chasing all back to Christopher Nolan. Yes. Because James has to watch The Bloody Odyssey and it's three effing hours long to be fair so it's actually all because of an ounce fault or
15:31Boyd Hilton:if you want to get right to it it's boris johnson's fault not for brexit but because boris johnson was at the screening i was at this point there were only about 10 of us in the screening and boris johnson was one of them and i'm saying one of the reasons why it didn't start bang on time was because he pulled up with all his you know special branch security and i twaddled in and sat in a frankly substandard seat oh boris clearly clearly can't trust you with brexit for the simple reason that anyone knows if you're going to sit in the imax waterloo the back three rows are the only viable places to sit and anywhere else is sub standard i'm so sorry and uh he's setting in the front you know an absolute absolute balance yeah yeah everything you need to know anyway anyway politics is such a good way of it's such an onomatopoeic way of describing his book i bet he was harrumphing all the way through anyway anyway enough about boris let's move on to the post bag
16:28Boyd Hilton:triage it's the post bag and the first message is for steph and it says why doesn't steph like widow's bay oh hi all surely if you like something you want to finish it yet it seems steph is finding every excuse possible not to watch the finale of widow's bay now behind in episodes to those she criticized for not watching it the only one left in England really to not finish the relief she expressed when she found out she could use watching the crow girl a program she hadn't heard of just 30 seconds previously as a further excuse to not watch any more of this series what's tangible the fact that she's gulped down six episodes of little house on the prairie all 70 seasons of yellowstone and couldn't squeeze in a program she professes to love more than close family is the genuine true crime.
17:24Boyd Hilton:What will be the next reason she can find to avoid the torture of fixing her eyeballs on another episode of That Blessed Show? Giving X-Men 97 another chance at John Craven's Newsround rewatch. It's time to stop everything, to pause the universe, to finish what you started, Steph, from Matt. Right. Do you know what? That, Matt, you are absolutely right. And even I was feeling the pressure. I was even feeling it. But can I just say, and I think I gave this as a reason and why I hadn't finished it. Okay, because I have loved, I have loved, loved, loved this series and I loved it from the beginning.
17:57And as I said, I wanted to not rush it because I wanted to sit with the finale because I think Willow's Bay gets better and better and better every single episode. And I think it's episode eight was absolutely my favorite episode, probably one of my favorite episodes ever of a TV show. And we'll get into that in our spoiler special. But I tell you what, I have finished it now and when I watched the finale, I was so happy I'd waited and watched it in isolation. I watched it on my own, in my house, in like my bedroom, alone and I took every single bit of it in and it was totally the right decision.
18:35So Matt, you're completely right but I have finished it now.
18:39Boyd Hilton:Well done, Steph. Well done. Well done for joining myself and Boydie on the Widow's Bay bandwagon. Widow's Bay. Will S. Bates is never, ever, ever going to not get mentioned on this podcast. Who wrote that email? Matt. It's very funny. Yes, he's very good. And the thing is, I was kind of feeling the pressure. And I thought, I hope no one brings up the fact that I have watched all of Little House on the Prairie, seeing as everybody seems to be ripping into Little House on the Prairie and calling it the remake no one wanted. Yeah, you're right, Matt. You're right. I take it on board. I'm sorry. okay well along those lines barbara says little house is a midwestern classic the books have more in common with the anne of green gables series than with anything by taylor sheridan they're not even sheridan adjacent love the pod of although i do miss k sometimes bob in maryland hashtag justice for bob but raised in wisconsin did we say they were adjacent they were i think we talked about how i mean i think i said if i'm going to watch a western i don't want to watch it unless Rip Wheeler's in it, and I finally stand by that.
19:41Boyd Hilton:Right, okay. I think there's not much that James and I are not bringing Yellowstone into at the moment, so I think we did possibly mention that. We probably did. But remember, Kay is on a job share, Bob. Don't worry. Don't worry. She'll be back. She'll be back in the coming weeks. Don't worry. She will return. But while we're laying into Steph, let's have another one here. This comes from Mark, and Mark says, Thanks for reading out my epistle about what real TV locations you'd like to stay in. The lovely Steph said she'd like to channel her deepest Jessica Fletcher and visit Cabot Cove, Maine.
20:09Boyd Hilton:But she'd be very disappointed because that is a fictional place. Do you know what? I thought it was, but I was going to say that. It is. And I said, I did say that. I acknowledged the fact that that is not a place, but I was saying I can't remember where it's actually filmed. It was actually shot in Mendocino, a beautiful coastal town north of San Francisco. It also happens to be next door to where The Birds was shot. So if Steph fancies paying homage to both Jessica and Hitchcock, then I'd be happy to show her around. Mark Woodruff from the USA. Mark, yes, thank you. I did know that Cabot Cove was not a real place.
20:46Did you though? I did, even though I do have a bag, which is like a Cabot Cove bag, which I'll bring onto the podcast so you can actually see it. I always assumed it was Cape Cod, because hence the kind of alliteration. No, it isn't. But I couldn't remember where it actually was. But yeah, thank you. I'm sorry if it came across as if I do believe. that Cabot Cove was a natural place. I mean, it would be amazing if it was a natural place. I mean, geographically, it is a place that exists that they have called Cabot Cove, but it isn't actually Cabot Cove.
21:15Boyd Hilton:Thank you for clarifying. Yeah. That's good. Okie dokie. This comes from Ali, and Ali says, oh, she's taken us to task. Absolutely love the bear, and I've saved last week's Plus show to listen to when I've watched it. Not had a chance to go in on season five yet, so imagine how chuffed I was to hear the massive spoiler read out from a letter on last week's Plus show. My husband and I absolutely love this show and are doing a full rewatch before going in on season five due to work commitments. We couldn't start it until last week. Luckily, he didn't hear the spoiler. So it'll still be a surprise for him at least.
21:48Boyd Hilton:Can I politely suggest a slight amount of triage with a spoiler warning in future? From Ali. P.S. I lived in Luton 2000 to 2004 when I started flying. Hope I never spilled a drink on you in Chicago, Steph. Oh, I wonder if I know Ali. Luton's not that big. What's Chicago's? Is it like your local nightclub? What is it? You've never heard of Chicago's. Chicago's is like a chain of nightclubs. I've heard of Chicago's. I used to frequent Chicago's and The Zone. Yeah. Yeah, I loved it. Absolutely loved it. The Zone is a good name for a provincial nightclub. This is the equivalent of Kudos in Watford, isn't it?
22:26Boyd Hilton:Which became, I believe, Destiny in latter years, which was the big nightclub in Watford. Yeah. And we had The Beach as well, which was also great in Luton. great nightclubs anyway what was the spoiler obviously we won't repeat the spoiler because if we repeat the spoiler we're just spoiling it again i know what the spoiler was the spoiler was hang on don't say it right no i'm gonna i'm saying gonna say it in a way that no one okay okay allude to it i said that something that happened there was no mention of something that happened in the finale before it actually happened and there was no idea of something that someone ends up doing right before do you with me and then somebody said no no if you go back and watch season four oh yes oh you're absolutely right okay yeah that is actually a massive spoiler i'm so sorry if you let that go i know i can't believe i did either it just didn't even cross my mind okay well that was idiotic apologies uh sorry ali we didn't mean to to ruin the bear for you i'm so sorry oh god i feel suitably chastened so to to punish myself i'm going to read out lee's uh message which is checks notes about 3 000 words long i'm gonna try and skip through this right i absolutely love the part it's always the first thing i queue up listening to on mondays and thursdays whenever you discuss early screeners i can actually relate in a small way to the privilege you enjoy with upcoming previews i've been part of the netflix preview club for the past couple of years which is something i've never heard of which means i get to experience that highly specific feeling of watching unfinished shows within my email address boldly splashed across the top of the screen to prevent leaks nothing quite like watching a tense hostage negotiation while my own email address hovers menacingly in the corner like i'm the one being held to ransom there's something uniquely entertaining about seeing the rough cuts before the magic of post-production sometimes there's just a small subtitle explaining what the green screen effect will eventually be like mountains to be added or you find yourself watching actors deliver intense dramatic performances while staring at a completely blank tv screen i'd like to think of it as a personality test can you stay invested in a sword fight when both swords are enabled fx to follow my recent run of previews has been incredibly strong i got to see a few great ones that are already out legends unchosen department cube bear grills island plus some as yet unreleased shows the undertow project code name i'm calling this one touch of cloth too having to fill out a five minute feedback survey at the end is an incredibly small price to pay for the sneak peeks netflix may not read the responses but i'd like to or imagine one exec somewhere quietly agreeing with my notes.
24:56Boyd Hilton:I always end up watching the shows again when they're officially released anyway, just to see the added effects, and more importantly, to check whether they took my advice that this show needs less Bear Grylls. Just need to get an invite to the Apple screeners now. James, can you recommend me to your close personal friend, Tim Cook, after Steph finally gets access? Of course. I didn't know this was a thing. Right, I'm going to give you some facts now because I didn't know this was a thing, and this is so exciting. Okay, so the Netflix Preview Club is an invite-only group of people. It had around 2 ,000 members, but now it's expanded to tens of thousands of users globally, okay, to gather a more diverse range of feedback on upcoming movies and TV shows, right?
25:35So you can't apply, but you're hand-selected based on factors like their viewing behaviour and how long they've been a subscriber. This is so, it's like a secret club. I love it.
25:49Boyd Hilton:That's genuinely fascinating. but i mean that is often what it's like weirdly i think we get that much less now it used to be i would say because when we get netflix screeners i don't think we get netflix screeners that early like i don't think i've ever had a netflix screener when it's vfx to be added or it's clearly unfinished i've definitely had apple shows and in fact i used to find that fascinating i remember watching season two of c and almost none of the effects were done like you could see like they're on a soundstage and it's all just green walls like it was it was wild it's like watching sort of like a Lars von Trier film.
26:21Boyd Hilton:It was quite extraordinary. And we got to see, and I saw a whole season of Slow Horses very early where none of the effects were done. And again, you've got the little notes like a crowd to be removed, like this door to be something done. It's really, really interesting from a kind of production point of view. It does take you out of it a little bit. But yeah, that must be very cool to be on that list. It's been going since May 2021. Really? And it was originally utilised for feedback on the 2021 hit Don't Look Up, which broke the record for weekly viewing hours with 152 million views. Interesting.
26:50This explains how they make the decision whether to actually tell people about shows or not, right? Because let's face it, some Netflix shows literally arrive almost on the day they, you know, without any advance warning at all. And it's just there. And it's just there. Or at the minimum of a couple of days, suddenly they'll go, oh, by the way, there's this thing that we're putting on Netflix. And it must be because they must gauge, to some extent, viewer interest from these thousands of people who are on this special club there. That's fascinating.
27:21Boyd Hilton:That is fascinating. They do it with us occasionally, don't they? Where you'll get like toe-in-the-water screeners where they'll say, look, can we send you a link or would you come in and watch this? And we want to know what you think of it. And often that's quite far out. Literally, that's never happened to me. Nobody cares. Do you think they pay more attention to the normies or the critics? I bet they probably won't pay more attention to the normies. No, because I'm more of a normie. You're more of a normie. No, no. Steph, you're an actual official. I mean, as well as being our PA, you are also a top critic as well.
27:53Multitasking. Yeah. Steph's in charge of microphones for the podcast. Oh, don't. Animation and microphones. I can't. I've got too many jobs now.
Read the full transcript
28:00Boyd Hilton:Yeah, but no, that's interesting. Right. Another one. Okay. Message here from Kathy. Kathy says, she says, I like Boyd. I believe she means to say, I like Boyd, but she missed the first comma of the parentheses. so it just says I like Boyd. Well that should be true for everyone. So I'm going to read it as punctuated. I like Boyd. I have also been watching mostly sports lately. Wimbledon with a bit of a World Cup but I wanted to have a bit of a moan. Your review of the Westies certainly didn't make me want to watch it but only right at the very end did you reveal it's on MGM Plus. Of all the many, many subscription channels, MGM Plus has to be one of the most niche and least essential.
28:40Boyd Hilton:Harsh. So it was a Total irrelevance for me, and I suspect many of your listeners. Can I put in a request that you mention at the start of a review which platform or channel it is on? On the other hand, I don't have Apple TV +, too many overrated solar shows. Sorry, get out. But occasionally join to catch up on slow horses. But at least Apple is one of the bigger streaming players. A few words about where it is on would help us normies know whether to tune out for a little bit. Oh, and as you might guess, I'm not a fan of hearing about how you've watched shows months before us. It's definitely giving I Know Something You Don't Know please sing that an annoying sing some voice if you read this out i know something you don't know uh as always despite a few whinges and i can't believe james's taylor sheridan session is infiltrating the empire podcast too i love the podcast and you three slash four from kathy well first and foremost i would say i literally always say what something is streaming on at the top of the show at the very beginning in the introduction and then i always repeat it at the beginning of the review as well.
29:39Boyd Hilton:I will grant you there is a slim possibility that for that one, Westy's one, I forgot to mention it in the intro because we'd talked about it when teeing up the interview. So that is a possibility. But normally I do always say we're something streaming beforehand. Why would we give that away so early on and give people a chance to tune out? Because they have a great MCM plus. Yeah, can't we? We want you to stay, Cathy. Yeah. Come on. For me, I will tell you in the end where you can watch it. I'm not going to tell you in the beginning. Think of it as some, you know, dramatic tension. Yes. Is this on an outlet that I could actually watch.
30:08Yeah, because when you're thinking about it, you're like, oh, that sounds good. Where can I watch it? That's the order of questions, isn't it? Right. Yeah.
30:16Boyd Hilton:But also, I literally do say it at the beginning of the reviews. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Do you? I thought you'd say it at the end. I do. I do. I say it at the beginning of the reviews. I also say it at the top of the show. So in the introduction to the show, I will say the three shows we're reviewing that week and where they're streaming. That's it at the top. So some people might say you're saying it too much. Some people might say I'm saying it too much. Sorry, Cathy. so I would say I know something you don't know except I don't because I literally told you at the beginning of the show right and also it should really be I know something you don't know I'm just saying that's how that should go so you're saying I'm out of tune as well thanks Jeff oh god right message here from James and James says not me obviously hello all I awaited your mid-year review with bated breath and generally you mention most of the shows I thought you would I urge you to finish DTF St.
31:05Boyd Hilton:Louis and Beef. Both were great stories with great acting and satisfying conclusions. However, there were two shows you didn't mention that I was surprised at. Maximum pleasure guaranteed. I'm just waiting for the final episode to drop, but it's been a wonderful show this summer. Great plot, original and energetic, and again, some great acting. A truly standout performance from Tatiana Maslany. Funny, fraught and captivating. The other show I have not actually seen yet, but it's top of my watch list. I've been waiting for the World Cup to end to give it a go. But now I fear maybe it's not a priority if none of you gave it even a mention.
31:37Boyd Hilton:Cape Fear. I thought Boyd might wrestle that one onto his list. Or has the initial shine given way to a slump over 10 episodes? Genuinely want to know if it's worth the best. No, no, because I listened. No, no, no. At the end, at the end, because I listened to it today, Boyd gives a big... It's in my top 10. And also you talk about the fact that Cape Fear was brilliant. And actually, yeah, Boyd does say. And we do. Yeah, we look. look, we need to hold our hands up. We all fucked up with DTF. Like, we definitely did, okay? We should mention, we have also been taken to task over DTF St. Louis by Guy from Bath, or a Guy from Bath, one of the two.
32:13Boyd Hilton:Sorry, Guy. And he was saying, also, it's great and it's been nominated for Emmys and he said he would put DTF second only to Pluribus on the list. But Pluribus wasn't eligible, right? We know. Yes, that's true. But that's an Emmys thing, yeah. I can exclusively reveal that I have watched more of DTF St. Louis. Spoiler for Monday's episode! I know, I know. and yes, I will have lots to say. Boyddy is DTF. Do you know what's so interesting? My plan was to finish that by tomorrow's recording and I'm not going to do it. That's an incredible coincidence because my plan was absolutely not to revisit it in any way, shape or form before.
32:47Boyd Hilton:So, you know, that's interesting. Maybe, maybe one day. Who knows? Right, okay. Message from Lucy, simply entitled Heidi. Hi James Boyd and Steph. I was interested to hear James talking about how much he loved Heidi as a child. I too loved the show and even named my daughter Clara as a result of it. I don't remember there being a Clara in Heidi, but then of course I don't remember the show really at all. I named my daughter Clara as a real... You didn't name her Heidi? Hold on, hold on. Clara, Clara was in Little House. Clara was the girl in Little House, I think. Well, then I'm very confused by what's going on.
33:22Boyd Hilton:Keep going. Anyway, anyway, anyway, Lucy, if that is indeed her real name, continues. it got me thinking about that and shows like it that we watched as kids in the 80s like Huckleberry Finn and Friends and Silas I don't know what Silas is uh there was much more ongoing narrative than in adult shows of that era and I wondered if the pod agrees and if so why that was looking back now I think this is what gave me a love for the style of tv we mainly see now in the shows you talk about each week although I recall even then finding the terrible dubbing odd oh oh by By the way, I've read, I said 80 shows like Huckleberry Finn and Friends and Silas.
34:00Boyd Hilton:Whereas actually, it's Huckleberry Finn and Friends and Silas. See, a comma would have killed you. I don't remember Silas. Neither do I. What the fuck is Silas? Steph, Steph, looking up. You're all right. I'm doing my PA job. Silas. Yeah, that's it. Look up what Silas was because I don't think I've ever heard of it. Silas. Huckleberry Finn and Friends I used to watch. I do remember that. Silas is a 1981 ZDF adventure television miniseries based on the Danish children's book Silas Ogdensult Hop by Cecil Bodka, who kept on writing installments until 2001. I mean, I've never heard of it. I was born in 1981, but I've never, ever heard of that.
34:44Boyd Hilton:No, I've never heard of it either. But were those shows more serialised than episodic? I don't remember. Possibly. I don't remember either. I think... Little House on the Prairie was episodic, wasn't it? Yes. Yeah. For sure. Definitely. Hundreds and hundreds of them, in fact. Yeah, and I feel like Gentle Ben was episodic as well. Oh, Gentle Ben. Yeah. I remember Gentle Ben. It was the Littlest Hobo, but, you know. Oh, no, no. That's not true. It was just as good as Littlest Hobo. No, I'm sorry. I'm drawing a line there. Nothing was as good as Littlest Hobo. Owner of one of the greatest theme tunes in television history.
35:20As is Gentle... I can't believe... Go on, then. Sing it.
35:23Boyd Hilton:How does the gentle bend thing go? Well, now I can't remember. So memorable. But they had the raft thing that was on the water where all the, you know, like, do you know what I mean? In the opening credits where he gets on. I'm loving the gesticulating you're doing while describing this. You know, he gets on that. What are they called? The rafts that go on the water. A raft. A pedula. No, no, no, no, no. No, no, no. Hold on. I'm going to like, hang on. Let me just. Oh, this is brilliant. I'm loving this. I don't remember any of these shows by the way It's actually called a flat bottomed airboat Flat bottomed airboat Across the Florida Everglades Do you remember?
36:03Boyd Hilton:Oh yeah the ones with the big fans on the back I didn't want to say the big fans on the back Because it would make me sound crazy But yeah that's those ones And Gentle Ben was on Was he driving one? This seems unlikely He was at the front of the vessel He was the coxswel Right okay got it yeah is it coxswain or coxon how do you pronounce it who's the person who said anyway let's let's move on we digress we move on let's move on from this uh okay right oh there's a couple here entitled james is right and i stand with james i think let's read those first one this comes from kenny and kenny says hi love the show i'm a pilot plus subscriber that's good otherwise you wouldn't be hearing this i want to email every show on multiple points but resist because i'm usually working anyway neagly the g is not silent i have listened to all the good reach audiobooks and neagly is pronounced as james says the dropping of the g in the show has always clanged i doubt they're going to change things with the new show so i guess we'll have to live with it cheers kenny oh cheers kenny boyd brackets no relation hold on a minute right okay i think i'm just going to go back to that conversation where we talked about the fact that you said in the show they say neely They say nearly on the show, but it's neatly.
37:16But you said it's neatly. So what on earth would make them omit the G?
37:21Boyd Hilton:Well, this is the question, Steph. This is the question that drives us. Why on earth would they make such an egregious error? Okay, I mean, I don't know. I feel like that email's made you really happy, though. Yes, it has. And I want you to be happy. Okay, fine. Let's hope this one does, too. This is from Dean. I stand with James. As I share with James an aversion to cringe comedy, I also have never been able to watch either version of The Office. probably even less episodes than him fewer i went to the pictures to see the david brent film with my son who wanted to see it and spent most of it watching with my eyes hidden by my hand cringing inside and to completely put myself beyond the power with boyd and steph i can't get away with any of the alan partridge series either this type of comedy makes me physically in pain dean uh other than my brief grammatical joke there dean apologies for that i agree with you wholeheartedly and that is exactly the uh feeling that i get when i try to watch those sings absolute excruciating pain okay yeah firstly james do not alienate your fan club i really shouldn't do that yeah hey look if anyone's a game of thrones fan i was just channeling stannis baratheon i think we can all agree it was a tv reference and therefore is allowed oh it makes me feel so sad there must be some kind of workshop that we can create to help people overcome this because i think they're really missing out grammar or no the cringe comedy because I feel like people are really missing out by not watching.
38:45I mean, God, you're not watching Alan Partridge or The Office. Come on. Oh, Steph, this has been going on so long now. I'm not going to give up the fight, Boyd. I can't. This is such great TV. I mean, there's at least a thousand memes that you're not going to understand if you don't watch those shows. Listen, he still hasn't watched Succession. What can you do? Neither has Steph, and I can tell that
39:09Boyd Hilton:because I saw the flash of guilt go over her face when you said that no i do you know what i had i will say what i did with succession okay is again i sort of semi-watched it um but i didn't really pay attention in the same way that i initially kind of watched yellowstone but didn't really watch it what you're saying is your husband watched it and you were in the room yeah and then i'd ask him questions and he was completely obsessed with it i love i love kieran colkin and obviously will ferrell's like an exec producer i was like oh this is gonna be amazing um but then i don't know it's just do you know i'm gonna go back and watch succession properly i think so yeah no i haven't watched it properly but yeah i will add it to your list i will put it on the safe list okay we have a message here a very long one from steven but i feel that it needs addressing because i know that steven echoes the thoughts of a number of pilot listeners uh when he says this is it about campus it is not okay hello love the podcast avid regular listener and subscriber here i'm writing this email to share some thoughts about the way you guys discuss animation.
40:13Boyd Hilton:I studied animation at university and work now as a comic book artist. Oh, what a cool job. It is a cool job. This email got a bit wordy, but hopefully it's worth reading for a few minutes. I don't love X-Men 97 either, but I do sometimes get cranky about the way you talk about it and shows like it. He has subheads in this email, so just bear with me. Wow, okay. First, art style versus animation. If there's one thing I want to communicate, is the distinction between the art style and the animation. The art style of the show is the character design, the background illustrations, the colour palettes, and the overall visual aesthetic of the show.
40:47Boyd Hilton:Separately, the animation is the actual movement of the characters, the visual effects, etc. X-Men 97 does not have an intentionally dreadful, in quote marks, art style, James. In my estimation, it is a gorgeous modern rendition of a classic 90s comic book style. The background illustrations and colours are stunning and sumptuous, and the character designs are clean, bright, bold, and beautiful. I think it is extremely successful at what it sets out to do. You may disagree, but I'd love to hear you discuss why you don't like the character designs, colours, background illustrations, etc. Now, on to the animation quality.
41:19Boyd Hilton:The character animations are quite simplistic. They are definitely limited in how much they can accomplish, and it can be quite lifeless sometimes. Thankfully, the special effects animations, explosions, powers, etc. are excellent. In some of the action scenes, they spend more time slash money, and the overall animation quality is really elevated but generally seen to seen the animation is competent but not spectacular i believe this may be the main reason it doesn't connect with you but would be interesting to hear you discuss okay that's the first part of the there's a second part to this but let's deal with the first part first art style versus animation steph okay i'm just gonna say right i didn't not like um x-men i i really did you did you watch the rest of it No, I also didn't watch the rest of it.
41:59But I was like, I liked it for what it was, which the animation style to me was a Saturday morning cartoon. What I would say, and I don't know because obviously I'm not an expert, is the kind of animation that I'm really enjoying at the moment is, which I know, James, you hate this film, but you know the kind of, it's like what they call like hand-painted concept art animation, I believe, in Goat. And Netflix has got a show called The Wolf King. And it's also very much more Shadow Lord. and the um oh a bit spider-versey that feels very kind of where the frames are just named several things that look very different no they don't they look the same to me they really don't i don't
42:39Boyd Hilton:think they do i think they all look spider-verse and darth maul shadow more of darth maul yeah shadow lord they've got that kind of hand-painted look about them i know i know the the style you're talking about i am to be fair does more look significantly different from the clone wars because the Clone Wars, of course, don't look like that at all, and neither do Rebels. I don't know. And I thought Maul shared an aesthetic with Rebels and the Clone Wars. But I know that kind of painterly aesthetic you're referring to. I think Arkane uses that a little bit as well, where it does have that, again, I don't know what the terminology for it is, but it has a very striking visual style, and I always associate that primarily with Spider-Verse, and also the most recent Puss in Boots, which was fucking fantastic.
43:19Boyd Hilton:That's what I was going to say, Puss in Boots. That's the kind I'm really enjoying that. Yeah, I'm not sure. I mean, like I said, I haven't seen Shadow Lord, but unless it looks wildly different to the other ones of Filoni's shows, then I don't... I feel like it does. I watched it recently. Well, if you watched it, then I will take your word for it. No, I'll happily be corrected. No, I haven't seen it, so I'm just guessing. I just assume it looks like the Clone Wars and Rebels. It may not do. Okay, so sorry, what was the question? What was the question? Well, it was more of a correction than a question.
43:45Boyd Hilton:But yeah, I totally get what you are saying here. Sorry, Stephen, that art style is something... When I say the animation is bad, yeah, I am referring to the art style. That's true. But then sometimes it's part and parcel. So you look at Invincible, the art style there is deliberately simplistic and retro and sassy morning cartoonish, which is, again, it's an artistic choice. But also the animation is a little bit janky as well in that there's a limited range of motion. It feels a bit simplistic. So that's not exactly fluid. Whereas if you take something like the Spider-Verse stuff, which, again, and I'm sure we're going to get onto this in the next section here, or you take something like arcane the animation is incredibly silky smooth and detailed and you know they don't drop frames or anything like that it's very uh you know it's more sort of sumptuous to the eye um i had this argument again with amon warman before odyssey started this morning when he was like taking me to task for slagging off x-men 97 but i think x-men 97 is a very deliberate throwback to the 1990s which is what and cartoons of this time and it was a cartoon and it was aimed at largely kids back then you know that's what they look like right like that so that's one of the reasons why it looks the way it does um the art style of the characters yeah he's absolutely right you know it is quite vibrant comic book art but i don't i don't think i would describe it as you know i don't get um a sense of awe watching it which you do with some animation so again arcane which is always my go-to forgive me for being basic i don't watch that much animation but that there's not a frame of that we don't you don't constantly think fuck me this looks gorgeous which is not something i get with a lot of animated shows i put it to you guys that we should do like an animation special and people should write in and tell us what animations yeah all right do you know what that's an interesting challenge right steven and i put a lot of pressure on you here um if you can find some preferably short uh animations that you think that would would help us understand what we need to do steven right this is this is your task give us let's say three let's give us three animations but also tell us why we are watching them what we should be taking away from it and try and find things that i won't hate because if you make me watch things i hate then i will resent you enormously so please try and avoid that it's all about james i will not steven i will thank you for broadening her our horizons and i think that i'm going to get james to send me your email because i want to know more about animation and if any of them are rick and morty or anything by seth mcfarlane we are not speaking again i happen to be working at the moment with a guy called John, who I believe James knows, because James got him in for the Foundation Spoiler Special.
46:14Yes, yes I did. Yes I know, John. So John is a lovely guy, and he is producing a session I'm hosting at the Edinburgh TV Festival. Is he now? Yes. So we had a lovely couple of meetings already, and he revealed, yeah, that he is, and he is, I love what he does, his animation.
46:30Boyd Hilton:It's true, that is true. yeah by all means john if you are listening by all means feed into this as well in fact anyone who wants to feed in feed into this and use the subject line animation education and we'll go through them and we'll we'll pick some for our for an animation special yes definitely let's do it god help us right okay but there's a second part steven's question comparing tv animation to movies if there's a second thing i want to communicate is that it is unreasonable to compare the animation quality of a show like x-men 97 to big budget disney slash pixar movies or a show like arcane which is movie quality and has a budget to match fair enough these are very different propositions i don't think you would watch an igv police drama and criticize it for not looking as expensive as june 3 except i do kind of do that quite a lot or the latest big movie blockbuster the expectations for these things are very different and tv animation should be assessed at how well it succeeds in its own context all that said i agree that the writing in x-men 97 is mostly aimed at kids and nostalgic millennials and isn't that engaging if you're looking for mature deep nuanced storytelling okay that's all thanks for maybe reading this far steven oh i enjoyed that steven it's very educational it's interesting that is interesting okay i think on where better place to end than with our animation education uh let's leave that there if you would like to send in your animation education suggestions do send them to postbag at pilot tv pod.com and if you want to send us any other thoughts, dreams, fears, questions, whatever you like, then please do so at the same address.
47:58Boyd Hilton:If you want to follow us on social media, let's be honest, only Boyd, Nazis and Robots are on Twitter. So please just come to Instagram and find us there. At James T. Dyer, at Boyd Hilton, at Steph Seaton. Do you know what? X is so over it. You know earlier when you were like, yeah, I know I'm still on X. Do you know what went through my mind? I was like, X is that a show that he's still watching that I haven't remembered about that's how far removed that is from my mind that is true that is true so far Twitter is so over anyway right okay on Monday show we will return with the delightful Anya Taylor total joy and we'll be reviewing the second season of the crow girl which is on Paramount plus there you go told you we're streaming we will also be retroactively looking at the hawk on Netflix and ride or die on prime because there is fuck all else.
48:48Have I got a ride on a guy screeners yet? Yes, you have because I asked for them for you.
48:53Boyd Hilton:We had them quite a while ago. Yeah. We're doing, you know, worst case scenario, we could just, you know, email our friend on the Netflix viewers club and see if they also get Prime stuff in advance as well. Maybe they can tip us off. Who knows? Right, that's it for this week's podcast. We will hopefully be able to hear Steph a little bit better by the next one. I'm sorry. Pilot out. You
From the publisher
We’re getting Lucky this week (literally) with Anya Taylor-Joy’s crime thriller on Apple TV, in which her eponymous anti-heroine goes on the run from both the law and organised crime. Plus, we delve into the postbag to find out such delights as the existence of Netflix’s preview club, James’ movie date with Boris Johnson and Boyd’s experiences with Huckleberry Finn.
Want your messages read out as part of The Postbag? Email us at postbag@pilottvpod.com




