PLUS Neagley

16 Sep 2026 · 50 min · 19 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Review of Prime Video’s Reacher spinoff Neagley (Episode 1, “PLUS Neagley”), focusing on whether it matches Reacher’s quality and what the season’s cult plot is setting up.

Guests

This episode is a podcast review with hosts Boyd and Steph (no external guests named in the transcript).

Key claims

The opening is visually striking (a man jumps in front of a Chicago subway train; Reacher appears briefly). Maria Sten’s Neagley/Francis Negley is praised as highly convincing and physically capable. The show’s cult-on-a-farm premise is compelling, with ties to something more sinister beyond the cult.

Notable examples

Neagley forms a ragtag team with Detective Hudson Riley (Greyston Holt), a beaten money-seeker Keno (Jasper Jones), and police worker Renee Birdwhistle; she’s emotionally linked to a man who died. Criticisms include tropey precinct dialogue/flirting and heavy product placement (Yohoo).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Exploring Neagley's Character and the Reacher Connection

0:45 to 2:56

Discussion on Neagley, her backstory, and her connection to the Reacher series.

“and it is created by Nick Santora and Nicholas Wootten.”

First Impressions of the Series

2:56 to 4:44

Initial thoughts on the first episode's visual appeal and storytelling.

“So, I am predisposed to enjoying stories, crime stories, particularly about cults, about religious cults.”

Character Dynamics and Team Formation

4:44 to 6:41

Analysis of character interactions and team dynamics within the show.

“I'd say particularly the cult setting, and she, Maria Sten is really good, very convincing in the role.”

Critiques on Dialogue and Tropes

6:41 to 7:57

Criticism of the show's dialogue and reliance on familiar tropes.

“It's hard to avoid it because it starts kicked off immediately before you'd have time to even press pause on your remote.”

The Cult Element and Its Significance

7:57 to 11:15

Exploration of the cult aspect of the storyline and its implications.

“Like he's like this immortal, unstoppable force of justice.”

General Thoughts on Prestige and Entertainment Value

11:15 to 13:32

Discussion on the show's entertainment value versus the need for prestige.

“But I understand that you kind of do need, you can't know nothing about her if you can have a literal show called Neagliela.”

Review of Neagly on Prime Video

14:00 to 15:30

Discussion on the entertainment value and character depth of the show Neagly.

“I want kind of those vivid, saturated colors.”

Public Voting and Mrs. Brown's Boys

15:30 to 17:51

Exploration of why Mrs. Brown's Boys continues to win comedy awards despite mixed reviews.

“No, I find the explanation of it much more understandable.”

Rants on Star Trek: Strange New Worlds

17:51 to 22:40

Listener feedback about gimmicky episodes in the latest Star Trek series.

“And in the first three seasons, it felt like two to three were gimmicks, and the rest normal.”

Viewer Experiences and Bluey Recommendations

22:40 to 25:41

Listener stories and recommendations for episodes of the children's show Bluey.

“Okay, I, though you have picked out three incredible episodes, okay?”
Show all 19 chapters

Critique of Ted Lasso and Slow Horses

25:41 to 28:00

Discussion about inaccuracies in British portrayals in media and viewer frustrations.

“Okay, we have two connected messages here, and the first one comes from Billy and it says, your listener noticing the police stuff in Ted Lasso reminded me of something I've vented about to my kids for years.”

The Art of Set Design in TV

28:00 to 29:30

Explore how set design impacts television storytelling and viewer perception.

“and also i think just the people who design this kind of stuff the interior design is just like it's a look sleek and sexy and you know full of mirrors so um and it works obviously televisually from that point of view.”

Graduation Traditions in the UK

29:30 to 31:28

Discuss the differences in graduation ceremonies in the UK compared to the US.

“I have one of these myself and it will, this is a sneak preview of a show we're reviewing on Monday's podcast.”

Multiverse Theories in Film

31:28 to 37:10

Delve into the complexities of multiverse narratives in film, focusing on popular franchises.

“So I take issue with that show and that whole scene.”

Dissecting 'Colin from Accounts'

37:10 to 41:44

Analyze viewer reactions to different seasons of 'Colin from Accounts' and its narratives.

“Moving on entirely, and this comes from Marcus, and it's about Colin.”

Audience Engagement and Feedback

41:44 to 42:00

Discuss how audience perceptions influence the success of TV shows.

“My main issue with nobody wants this is the title is so generic that I always forget what actual show we're talking about.”

Discussion on 'Rookie Blue' and Canadian TV

42:00 to 43:35

The hosts discuss the show 'Rookie Blue' and its appeal, sharing personal experiences.

“Hi Steph and whoever else is on with Steph these days.”

Viewer Feedback: Silo Season 3

43:35 to 45:28

Listeners express their changing opinions on 'Silo' season 3 and its surprising finale.

“No, but it sounds like something I'd like.”

Hosts Reflect on TV Shows That Improve

45:28 to 47:44

The hosts reflect on shows that initially bored them but ultimately improved, sharing personal anecdotes.

“My question for the pod is, What shows have bored and or annoyed you for most of the season, but then forced you to completely reverse ferret by then pulling everything out of the bag in the final one or two episodes?”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:07Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters. and we are gathered today very early, very early in the morning, very early in the week. It's quite an unusually early door start for us, but that's fine, you know, it's fair, because we're going to be talking about Neegley. Neegley, the character known as Neegley, and I know this because the Lee Child, presumably approved audiobooks of the Jack Reacher books, do describe her as Frances Neegley, with a G, which is not silent. However, they've made different creative choices in the show, and I'm not going to let that colour my view of this series.

0:39This is the Reacher spinoff on Prime Video. It stars Maria Sten as Francis Negley, and it is created by Nick Santora and Nicholas Wootten. And the question is, does this live up to the extraordinarily high quality of the first season of Reacher? I don't mind, yeah. Well, not only is the question, does it live up to the first season of Reacher, but also does it live up to the most recent season of Reacher, which regular listeners will know. James was up in, what's the phrase? Up in arms. Up in arms about. I mean, much like Jerry Jim himself, who is also up in arms. And even now, the fallout from that critique is, I see people on my timeline in various social medias saying, oh, James was so wrong about.

1:24Enablers, that's what they call Boyd, enablers. Yeah, Reacher, because it's just as much fun as the previous series. I mean, it's not. It's substandard. Perhaps even more. No. And you don't even notice the supposed decline in production values. So it's all fine. I thought this was potentially – so I was kind of speeding myself for this to be another kind of cheapo, you know, not fully committed set in the world of Reacher. Much like the most recent season of Reacher, as you've already said. Like you allege of the most recent series of Reacher. But in fact, I thought it was certainly the opening.

1:57It's kind of pretty spectacular, visually powerful. This guy is walking along by the subway in Chicago, and he takes all his clothes off and jumps in front of a train. It's quite a striking moment. And then the camera pans over to what's happening with Reacher and Neagly, who are involved in some kind of child kidnapping situation, which they're sorting out with a car chase and various bits of fighting, and this, that, and the other. And it was all very dazzling, I thought, the first few minutes in the opening sequence. I was impressed. Now, I have a question for you. So, I've read lots of the Reacher books, but there aren't any books with Neaglia.

2:37No. She's in some of the Reacher books, but she's not in all the Reacher books that she has appeared in in the series, if you may. So, they've definitely crowbarred her in more. They've crowbarred her in, with a view clearly to making the spin-off. But the spin-off is a television-based thing. It's not to do with the books. No, it's its own unique thing. Its own unique thing. So, I am predisposed to enjoying stories, crime stories, particularly about cults, about religious cults. And this has a kind of cult at the heart of it. It reminded me a bit of Harlan Coburn, the kind of the setting and the way the narrative unfolds.

3:15The cultiness. The cultiness, particularly, yeah, I guess. She also comes into contact with kind of new characters. who she kind of forms her own little team, doesn't she, with Detective Hudson Riley, who's like the handsome guy who is clearly kind of flirting with her. Yeah. And he's played by the brilliantly named Greyston Holt. And then there's this young guy who's like desperate for money, who's kind of been beaten up by some mysterious people, Keno, Keno, Keno, played by Jasper Jones. And she's got this woman who's working for the police, Renee Birdwhistle. who initially they have this kind of like antagonistic relationship and then she ends up helping her out and becoming part of this kind of, as I said, this ragtag team she kind of forms.

4:02She's the requisite British part of the crew, person in the crew, isn't she? Yeah, requisite British. And of course, Neagly has her own connection to the poor guy who died. She knew him and they had a kind of like brother-sister kind of relationship. And that's, so there's an issue, she's emotionally invested in it. So there's kind of like more reason than just her investigating a random crime. There is an actual personal connection. I really enjoyed this first episode. I've only watched one episode. But I thought it either, depending on your viewpoint, carried on the Reacher tradition quite well and is quite slickly made and interesting enough visually to make it feel kind of quite cinematic.

4:43and I thought the storyline and the, I'd say particularly the cult setting, and she, Maria Sten is really good, very convincing in the role. She can beat up, you know, four men in one scene and you kind of believe it. So I enjoyed it, yeah. I enjoyed it a lot. Oh, Boyd, do you know what? I couldn't agree with you more. Right, so I was immediately drawn in because the opening scene is like a naked bottom walking and I was like, this is for me straight away. Not, but attached to a mat, by the way. It was attached, but really the central part is, you know, what you're focusing on. So the naked bottom is walking.

5:20Obviously the bottom, you know, it comes to a horrible end. But still, you do get those moments. Now, oh my God, this is absolutely brilliant. This is so entertaining. Like, I love the, like, so you see Reacher in there for the first couple, in the first couple of minutes. and that's that's just a delightful little nod and it's kind of like okay it's kind of like he's saying okay you can have your own show now and have her own show she does she is absolutely brilliant in this um i love as you know i love any kind of assemble piece where they're assembling any sort of crew together and the way she does it with the um the guy from the streets and the the the cop who's whose family's kind of on the bad side some of his family's on the bad side a but he's trying to make good and then the the snobby british girl who you know really actually wants to be part of the crew this is coming together beautifully the whole thing is wrapped up and also it had a fantastic explosion in there um and a great dead body so i love the whole thing i think she's brilliant in this role um i think people are going to love it because it's so so entertaining yeah i'm feeling but i watched one of them after various difficulties last night uh and yeah i would have carried on watching more had i been able to get the screeners earlier but yeah i thought it was so she is so brilliant the only one criticism of this and i know we have to do they have to do this to get the cash but the product placement of you who in this really wowed up did either of you notice it no obviously this is england steph so in in the uk yoohoo is a glue yes that's true so in america yoohoo is like a chocolatey drink with a yellow thing and there was just too much yoohoo drinking and too much yoohoo yoohooness going on and that's my one my product placement complaint but apart from that i wanted to keep going and did you watch the sizzle reel at the end of the episode, but oh, so much good stuff to come.

7:25It's hard to avoid it because it starts kicked off immediately before you'd have time to even press pause on your remote. That is true. I think sometimes those sizzle reels are actually quite useful in kind of like deciding either way whether or not you're going to continue to watch the show. This is fine. Like, it's okay. It's not a million miles away from the DNA of current Reacher, unfortunately. I think Maria Stan is very good. The difficulty this show has for me a little bit is Reacher at the moment, we'll ignore season one, is not very good. But you have an incredibly compelling central character in that he is just unstoppable.

8:02Like he's like this immortal, unstoppable force of justice. And there's something quite cathartic and fun about watching that happen. So you're prepared to overlook a lot of the, shall we say, less good ropey parts of the show because of that central character. So what you have here, though, is you don't have that character. so this has to do a lot more heavy lifting if you'll pardon the illusion to kind of make the show work because you don't have i mean obviously have reach at the beginning but he's not a part of the show now i think that uh maria stent is very good i think francis negely is an interesting character i actually quite like the fact that that character in the books is quite roughly sketched that we don't know a lot about her background we don't know why she doesn't like to be touched really like there are illusions to things but we don't go into great detail I don't really think that I ever wanted an incredibly detailed backstory.

8:46I quite like the fact that she's on the periphery and she's a little bit mysterious and she comes in when Reacher needs her. I don't know that I needed a deep dive into Negley as a character, but you know, here we are, fair enough. I did not love the dialogue and the scenes with the cop because again, it felt very unnecessarily tropey and stuff that we've seen before. It's like, okay, you're going to have a flirty relationship with this guy who's having problems that, you know, he's got an issue at work and various things and then the person when she's at her detective agency you know she's a maverick and she's always breaking the laws it's like really i know that's kind of who negley is but also it's just i feel like i've seen this far too many times um that said i think she does a lot to salvage this and i also think what kind of works here is the cult setup which is as you say boy it's just a fundamentally interesting thing he was in a cult it's mysterious you don't know what it is when this started i wondered if they were actually going to steal die trying from reacher uh which is the second jack reacher book where he goes to it's not actually a cult it's kind of like a prepper militia group but i wondered whether this was kind of going in that direction because that's about kidnapping and this militia and whatnot and i thought that would have been an interesting way to almost like switch die trying and make it a neagly story but it actually i don't think that's what they're doing because this cult seems less like you know a militia more just like a religious cult, you know, because they're very agrarian.

10:07There's a lot of growing of tomatoes and potatoes and celery. And in the trailer at the end, for the rest of the season, we see glimpses of the mad, you know, kind of Jesus-like figure. Your cult leader. Yes, indeed. Well, I think the thing is, there's so much more to this cult. You know, I absolutely love a cult. And I think - You do love a cult. What's really exciting about this is, and I don't want to give too much away, but there's there's a crazy scene at the end where i i won't say what they they tell you is happening in it but it's absolutely crazy but it's also this farm this cult on a farm is is linked to something even more sinister outside of the cult which makes it you know inherently much more interesting than just kind of your normal run-of-the-mill religious cult where people are just in a compound this has ties to something even bigger outside which is which is clever yeah there's a strange there's a strange man doing strange things we should say yeah i'm gonna pick you up on saying you don't need to know her backstory i think it's really important to know her backstory and especially how she is related in friendship to the guy who dies i think it's really like you you you need to know and all the stuff that you're saying is tropey i think if what i suppose what i'm saying is if you're not a reach ahead like you and maybe you'll be a neely head or a neagly head depending on what you decide um you need that that's really central to understanding the makeup of this character so i think where you're you're you're such reach a core like you're you're you're throwing her away without really understanding that you need all of that is what i'm saying you need all of that for this show to her yes i think it was more i was thinking from a from a Reacher novel reader, I don't feel the need to delve into that character.

11:56But I understand that you kind of do need, you can't know nothing about her if you can have a literal show called Neagliela. I completely get that. You're absolutely right. It is tropey. I think the stuff that particularly, I think the big flaw for me is when she's in the precinct, when she's in the police HQ, and that guy, the boss who's hiring her, he is another shouty, superior detective who's angry at her for whatever reason. There's hardly even any reason to be angry with her at that stage. And he's still shouting at her in every scene she's in together. So those bits, I know what you mean.

12:29I thought they were needlessly tropey indeed, to use a word. I think this might just ultimately be where we are going to be with the show because of the people involved. Because it is Nick Santora again, I think, you know, it's going to be a lot of what the Reacher series is. Which is a shame though, because again, my feeling here is like, it's okay, it's decent, I quite like it. I may well watch more of it, but it doesn't feel super premium to me. It doesn't feel super prestigy. Like, it feels like little things. Like, there's a major plot point which revolves around some kind of vegetable that's fallen off the back of a lorry.

13:00And it's just like, it's a really kind of simplistic bit of plotting to connect A with B. Sort of deus ex greenhouse, if you will. And I was a bit like, really? Are we doing this? Like, surely there's something slightly more sophisticated we can do here to tie these things together. Like, true detective, this is fucking not, right? But it's quite fun. I would put this in the same bucket as things like The Night Agent, right? It's quite fun. It's a fairly compelling story. It's pretty silly, but it's a giggle. So I'm not saying people shouldn't watch it. I'm just saying know what you're watching before you watch it.

13:32Okay, hold on a minute. That buckwheat was essential to the storytelling, right? Clearly. Okay, I don't know whether it's because I watch this at what time? 11 o 'clock, right? Pretty late. I think, okay, we've had this argument before. This doesn't need to be prestige. This is not prestige TV. It doesn't need to have that apple sheen. It doesn't need to have any of that to be thoroughly enjoying and entertaining show, which it is, okay? I want kind of those vivid, saturated colors. I want the big explosions. I want the dead bodies. I want the connections that are actually quite easy to follow.

14:11Sometimes you cannot, do you know what I mean, Einstein your way through a series. Sometimes you just need to watch something really entertaining. And this is it. And I think if you love Reacher, you'll like this. You might pick holes in it, but if you don't love Reacher, you'll like it. Because it's a really thorough interpretation. She's compelling as a main character and she's interesting. And she does have this backstory that you want to know. I want to know why she doesn't like being touched. So, you know, I just, I think don't, you're not coming to it for prestige. You're not going to get it if you are coming to it for prestige, but it's definitely worth it.

14:51You're right. To be fair, there is definitely room in the world for shows that don't require huge leaps of kind of like concentration and you can just kind of enjoy them. I will totally give you that. So, Neagly then, with or without the silent G, which lands on Prime Video on the 16th, which is Wednesday, yesterday. Yes. It's already arrived. It's already arrived. You can watch it now. All the episodes. Which is unusual, because they don't do that with Reacher. No. Yeah. It's interesting. It's a neatly binge. Prime Video, they do it randomly. Sometimes they do put it all up, sometimes they don't.

15:26They're quite unpredictable. They're a force of chaos. Right. That is it for the review. Let's move on to the post bag.

15:36triage it's the post bag we begin with a question for boyd i think from katherine and katherine says dear team for the love of god someone please explain how the hell mrs brown's boys keeps winning best comedy at the national television awards i know it's supposed to be public votes But surely that has to be a steward's inquiry. Cathy? No, I find the explanation of it much more understandable. It reflects public opinion. The NTAs are the only TV awards in the UK that are voted for by members of the public. And so QED, literally the most – look at the ratings of Mrs. Brown Boys. There's a reason why it's been going for 20-something years or whatever and always gets Christmas and New Year special because it's a guaranteed ratings winner year after year after year.

16:30People, you know, there's a big enough movement of fandom for that show to make it the hit it has been. So whereas if it had been voted for by, you know, I don't know, 4 ,000 BAFTA members like the BAFTA czar or whatever equivalent, and then it won, you'd be like, oh, hold on. They need to have their membership revoked, right? You know, it's supposed to be people within the industry voting for the best thing. The best thing. The NTAs aren't about the best. They're about the most popular. That's the simplest way of putting it. And Mrs. Brown's Boys, in that lineup, unbelievably, is still the most popular.

17:05And yes, it's frustrating on one level. If you think that, say, Amanda Land, just for example, is 100 times better than Mrs. Brown's Boys. But Mrs. Brown's Boys has that fan base. What can you do? It's also not just the public, is it? it's a demographic of the public who is willing to vote for these things. So I don't know quite how that, you know, sections out. Well, certain publications, like, you can vote for, including Heat. So Heat readers get to vote, Sun readers get to vote. So you're saying it's your fault? That's where we're coming from. Yeah, partly our fault, yeah. But I don't know.

17:38I like to think that the Heat readers are the ones that voted for Amanda Land and the Sun readers are the ones that voted for Mrs. Brown's voice. I'm pretty sure that's the case. I've decided. Okay. Boyd has decided. We hope that has answered your question, Cathy. we have a question slash rant here from john so you know strap in this is a long one john says as a long-standing trekkie i was relieved when strange new worlds began as it felt like proper trek was back after the disappointment of discovery real star trek style episodes that made you think with brilliant casting and superb hair then the gimmick episodes arrived now once in a while this was fun most big tv series do a musical episode at some point think Scrubs, for example, so it was no surprise when Star Trek did one, and as a one-off, it was a fun episode.

18:21And in the first three seasons, it felt like two to three were gimmicks, and the rest normal. Now, as I get to the halfway point of the latest season, I cannot take it any more. The Muppet episode was the final straw. Apart from the first episode, where the crew go back in time to the time of the dinosaurs and meet a Martian Empire, which I'm surprised was never used in the OG series, it's been gimmick after gimmick after gimmick. Star Trek does Event Horizons, Star Trek does the hangover star trek does film noir now muppets in isolation they are all entertaining but every episode doesn't need to be a gimmick i can't make up my mind if it is the showrunners deliberately making rubbish episodes because one rule of classic star trek is you always have a few rubbish episodes or they took social media love for the previous gimmick episodes as a demand for all episodes to be this way or worse they saw the popularity of the orville and thought that's what people wanted because, to be blunt, Strange New Worlds just feels like the Orville now.

19:13I just want Pike and his crew to come across an anomaly that leads to problems that require them to use their brains to solve it or beam down to a planet with some society that mirrors the worst of ours so they can make some great commentary on where we are currently. For example, Space Trump would be interesting. I suppose what I'm saying is, hashtag not my Star Trek, John. Oh, do you know what? After you have that massive rant about the Muppet episode last pod, I was like, I've definitely got to watch it because I was so intrigued. But now I'm thinking it's just going to be a massive waste of my time.

19:45No, I had the same thought as well. I actually did watch the start of that episode. And then switched off. Oh, what's it like? I actually quite enjoyed it, but I get the complaints. Yeah, it is an outrageous gimmick. I like, but my taste tends towards the more outrageous gimmicky stuff that you can find in terms of TV shows, the better. So I'm kind of, I enjoy the fact that they've clearly gone bonkers for gimmicks in this season. But I will finish watching it. Yeah, I just thought, oh, I've checked that out, the Mad Muppet episode. Yeah, it sounded exciting. It is. I did get a message on social media from someone else who was actually very much enjoying that Star Trek Strange New Worlds has completely embraced absolute anarchy this season, which it absolutely has.

20:32but i i mean i'm i must admit i agree entirely with john like i you know the odd gimmick is fine but when the gimmicks vastly outnumber the quote-unquote normal episodes i feel like the show has gone off the rails a little bit because we went from this like star trek does event horizon i actually really enjoyed it was an unusual episode but it was still quite serious so i actually is that a gimmick episode i guess to an extent but actually that one i let slide but yeah the dude wears my starship one the muppets all of that stuff the film noir and then there's a soap opera episode a literal soap opera episode and i just can't even with that how does that work basically so i i haven't i haven't watched it yet it's the next one on my list but from what i understand spock's evil twin cyborg you may remember from star trek five uh is in it and it's again it's the whole thing is acted out like a like a soap opera now like a like an american daytime soap basically like days of our lives so you know starships of our lives if you will It's like I really like that.

21:26That does sound fantastic. Of course, you two would like it, yes. It's just very upsetting. What I do quite slightly respect is whenever one of these gimmicks happens, they have a policy of always having a quote-unquote scientific Star Trek explanation for why it's happening. So it's not like they're all suddenly singing. There's some weird anomaly that's making them sing, right? There's always a reason for it, which I actually quite like. So I think that's quite fun. But yeah, I just think gimmicks should be like one every four or so episodes. I think when you're slamming them in back to back, it's just, yeah, it's too much.

22:02I think in a 10 episode run, you can have two gimmicks. And I think that's it. I think that's you maxing out on that. Well, we're on about five already with this season. Okay. Did they know that this is the next season going to be the last season? It is, and it's a shorter season. So did they know that? Do you think that's why they've gone then run amok? you know just kind of perhaps Bazzel like let's have all the fun we can have while we can have it because if you look at the earlier seasons they were few and far between the kind of gimmick episodes and they were less gimmicky they do seem to have like doubled tripled and quadrupled down on them with this season and it is yeah it's quite a lot yeah I'm gonna I'm gonna yeah I'm gonna love it Boydie I'm sure yeah thanks make Star Trek serious again that's what I say right Carmen says in response to you Steph and it says get well awesome Steph what a totally horrible experience you had so sorry your trip ended in such a scary and dramatic fashion wishing you a super speedy recovery also the dignity humor and tv related spin you managed to insert when recounting the incident was also quite the marvel a great reminder of how unbelievably lucky we are to have the nhs dignity that's no word that's ever been applied it's applied to me thank you but i knew that was coming thank you very much a note here from davin and davin says hello pod have the bluey mob come after you since the admission that james and boyd haven't seen it it can be a surprisingly emotional and engaging show since it seems to be aimed at toddlers but makes enough of an effort to be more for the whole family if you've got a spare 20 minutes can i suggest checking out the episodes onesies cricket and if you want to feel old fairy tale right okay Okay, three, sorry, who's this person?

23:46What's this person's name? This is Davin. Davin. Okay, I, though you have picked out three incredible episodes, okay? So I'm going to give you guys an idea about what these episodes are about, okay? So Onesies is an incredible episode where Chili, who's the mum's sister, comes to visit and she hasn't seen her for a while. And it's about infertility. So on the surface, it's about her getting onesies for the kids and it's actually about infertility. Cricket is about being an older brother and it's so emotional. It's unbelievable. Rusty, whose dad works in the military, is incredibly good at cricket.

24:25The ending of that episode honestly gives me chills. Fairy Tale is the one about how Chilean bandit meet and it's about whether um fairy tales exist and it's an origin story and it is so beautiful um so yeah i know literally every blue episode like i'm sick to death of trying to get these two to watch it david how many episodes of bluey are there well there are there are three there are mini shows there are three seasons um and in each season how many i'm thinking i'm thinking there's like 18 20 i can't remember but there's a shitload and obviously the bluey movie is coming out so but they're they're brilliant and i would say what my recommendation is always uh to people to watch stick bird which is a fantastic episode they're at the beach in that episode um and i think that really also speaks to to being an adult and yeah it's just it's wonderful but those three that Davin has highlighted are also excellent.

25:26There have been 154 episodes of Bluey. Wow. There you go. And as you say, there are only seven minutes roughly in each though, so bear that in mind. But yeah, we have got the film next year, which I think is going to be massive, isn't it? The Bluey movie. Yeah. Okay, we have two connected messages here, and the first one comes from Billy and it says, your listener noticing the police stuff in Ted Lasso reminded me of something I've vented about to my kids for years. I'm afraid it's film, though. In 101 Dalmatians, the live-action movie, the woodland creature in the supposed English countryside included flipping raccoons.

26:05Flipping raccoons? Flipping raccoons. Billy was not happy. We do not have raccoons here in the UK. That is 100 % true, except in zoos. How is that the case? Have you ever been in the countryside, Boyd? Have you seen a lot of raccoons? Well, I've been in the countryside, but I haven't gone searching for raccoons. I think they'd seek you out. As a person who's regularly in the countryside and also as a person who had a Dalmatian, I can tell you that a Dalmatian in this country has never seen a raccoon. I can tell you that now. But, yeah, why didn't they just use squirrels? I don't know. Raccoons maybe have more personality.

26:36Especially since we do have the grey American squirrels. Yeah. Of course, it's interesting because I mentioned on the previous podcast I was watching Adults, the American comedy, which features a raccoon episode, an episode built around a raccoon invading their flat. is their flat in the uk no no it's in it's in america new york then it's fine yeah oh yeah it's accurate yeah connected to this we have a message here from paul paul the beer guy not to be confused with paul the wine guy paul says just caught up on the last pod and after listening to the ted lasso jail debacle i have to jump on a similar set problem which i find particularly frustrating apologies but i'm coming for pilot's favorite slow horses i cannot believe british intelligence headquarters is completely open plan with glass partition walls and dual monitors on each desk open for all to see although i have no evidence to the contrary i do wonder if this would contribute to the enviable double agent having so easily obtained our precious national security secrets love the pod best regards paul that's a really good point such a good point yeah but my feeling is that it is i wouldn't i i wouldn't be surprised if actually mi5hq is a bit like that because you know i think they'd probably think the last thing they'd worry about is see through windows when you know every they probably think there are other issues that they need to make sure is safe for high level intelligence gathering um as opposed to the glass windows and also i think just the people who design this kind of stuff the interior design is just like it's a look sleek and sexy and you know full of mirrors so um and it works obviously televisually from that point of view.

28:12But I wouldn't be surprised if the... I'd be interested to know, wouldn't it? We should get someone from MI5. If this was the rest of the entertainment, they'd find someone from MI5. Yeah, and they'd ask them what it's like. And then they wouldn't be able to tell us because, you know, the Official Secrets Act. But I remember listening to an interview with the set designer for The West Wing, and they were talking about, you know, how they made The West Wing look the way it is. And they were like, no, of course, you know, the Roosevelt Room does not have glass walls. You know, it's just a room. But we wanted the Roosevelt Room.

28:38You wanted to be able to see out and see across the bullpen and see the other offices, like, you want to have a sense of scope and a sense of distance to these shots, so they have a lot of glass walls. And also, they were saying, like, the Situation Room, which is where the president goes whenever there's something serious going on. They were like, you know, it's dark, there's all these screens on the wall with, like, military-looking things. It's like, it's really moody and it looks really top secret. And they said, no, like, if you go to the White House, Situation Room, it's a fucking meeting room.

29:01Like, it just looks like a meeting room. It's like all the other meeting rooms, you know. But that doesn't make good television. so you have to make it visually exciting because you can imagine if like let's be honest with our government budgets you probably go to like mi5 or mi6 headquarters and it probably does look like you've worked into sort of some sort of ancillary nhs office block like i don't imagine it's particularly high-end or you know really old 1960s staircases i don't imagine it's it's you know quite as slick but again i don't think that would make for quite as as fun a watch but i have i have I have one of these myself and it will, this is a sneak preview of a show we're reviewing on Monday's podcast.

29:37There is a scene in one of the shows that we review on Monday's podcast where you see a teenage boy graduating from high school with a mortar board and like the robes and everything. And I'm like, either I'm very old and out of touch or I'm sorry, do we do that in the UK? Cause I've never in my life seen that before. Oh no. Well, I don't want to get into something that we could discuss at length in the episode coming up, But you see that all the time. They do that all the time multiple times. In the UK, at high school. Yes. This is a thing. High school. This is the university, 100%. I have never, ever in my life seen it done in a UK high school.

30:12High school. Okay. Not that I hang out in UK high schools. It's important that I stay out of runs. Yeah. I think they do it at like nurseries, like weird graduation type things at nurseries. Hang on. With waterboards and robes. You get like toddlers taking their little hats off and throwing them up in the air. Steph, I hate to say this, I don't believe you. I'm going to do something very dubious now and find a nursery where they get the children to dress up in mortables and robes. No, maybe I'm thinking... That's interesting in high school. No, they definitely do have like graduation type things, don't they?

Read the full transcript

30:49Okay, wait for it. I've done the very, very 2026 thing and I've asked Google's AI thing. and I said do students have graduation from UK high schools and it says no no high school graduation in the UK the term graduation is reserved strictly for completing a university or college degree and this is the best bit instead of graduating students simply in quotes leave secondary school which I think is spectacular I may be being troubled by Gemini here but that is genuinely brilliant he said there are no traditional cap and gown graduation ceremonies or high school deployments when you finish secondary school in the UK.

31:28So I take issue with that show and that whole scene. That is fair. Okay. I'm just going to say, it's going to be, it's a matter of time though, because you know what? We never used to have proms and now like every high school has proms. It's the Americanification, isn't it? Of education, of these things. Proms didn't happen in my day. Yeah, you're right. They have proms now? Yeah, yeah. Oh yeah, they do. Yeah, they have proms. But often. But the annoying thing is, you could have mentioned this to me earlier, and I could have asked that person who created that show about it. Yes, you could have done.

31:59Spoiler, it's Sharon Horgan, and it's her new show. Youth. Yes. Yes, we'll get to that. Yes, that is, I felt, I watched that scene, I was like, no, no, no, no, no, this is nonsense. Because she may well have, I can imagine, can you think of like, you know those like American English schools you get? Do you know what I mean? Yeah. He didn't look like he was doing like an international baccalaureate. I'm just saying, I just want to hold, I just want to make, you know, the possibility. Right. mentioned the possibility of that. She might have heard of a high school that did do it. She may know of one, Sharon Hogan, the creator of the show.

32:31So let's give her, you know, let's give her the benefit of the doubt and let's see. 100 % somewhere in the UK, some schools definitely did that. 100%. Yeah. I agree. I think so. Anyway, question here from John. Hi all, love the pod and Steph is always right. Well, first of all, that's an awful way to start a message. continuing the conversation about multiverse stuff that Steph seems to understandably find confusing I can't be the only nerd who has found your examples not helpful Endgame and the five doctors episode have nothing to do with the multiverse concept they get over their plot holes using timey wimey stuff to use the Stephen Moffat phrase Doctor Who didn't get into multiverse stuff until the resolution of the second coming of David Tennant and Marvel didn't get into it until the Sam Raimi Doctor Strange I know that's a film conversation but hey you brought it up as to Boyd's who cares attitude I hesitate to put words in his mouth but I know his memory is not what it was I think the point he originally made was if the Monteverstere is correct then there are no consequences so why should I emotionally invest films again but if Wolverine dies in the film Logan and it was very moving why would I care if I know he's coming back which indeed he did in Deadpool and Wolverine spoiler I suppose but hey look at the movie title anyway let us hope this correspondence has now closed oh John if only if only i believe what you've done here has opened a whole can of worms is that scottish john who helps us with the animated stuff no it is not it's a different john okay a different um no you're absolutely right that is a brilliant description of my position on the matter and um you're right about the doctor who thing i know i know but yeah anyway so i actually watched end game at the weekend again um because i hadn't seen it for a while and i was like am i am i missing something that was bad timing the new version comes out in like two weeks i know but you know like i like to watch things before others you know other stuff comes up because i was like right i need to and also i was because we'd had this multiverse conversation and yeah it's i suppose i know i totally get boyd's point about it it's like it's really hard to care when you think in some verses everything's going to be fine so it's really you want you know you need like your main verse i get it but i still think it's exciting to have a multiverse universe and that's the endgame i i i think this is a kind of great i was about to say well john i think you'll find that nvm 100 is to do with the multiverse but you could argue that it's not quite that straightforward so the fact is that they do have multiple realities in endgame and there's oh when dr strange is scanning all the possible realities to find the possible outcome and he finds one outcome where they beat thanos in all the possible futures you could make the argument that he's talking about futures and not realities though in fact he is scanning realities and obviously canonically marvel uses different earths 616 whatever it is all the different versions of earth and as we've gone into fantastic four we have alternate realities and alternate earth so multiverse is very much at play but the only thing i will say to john which i think is quite funny is if you marcus and mcfili he wrote endgame and the russo brothers who directed endgame had different views on how the time travel worked one set of them and i can't remember who it was i think it was marcus and mcfili were like yes we're using the multiverse theory and which is the trousers of time theory if you're into terry terry pratchett so when you change something it creates a splinter universe and it changes reality and then the others the russos were saying well no no it's the grandfather paradox so they're able to go back in time and change the past and obviously in a multiverse model that doesn't make any difference unless you go to an alternate timeline because your timeline is your timeline regardless what you do in the past so the reason why the timey-wimey stuff in that is a little bit hand wavy is because you've got two different people who had two different interpretations of how it worked um but nevertheless canonically marvel is multiversal and had been in the comics beforehand so i think they were always going in that direction sorry john oh that's a good explanation but the the um the wolverine example is the one is a good example of expressing my issues logan has an incredibly powerful ending and you're right wolverine but then weirdly because wolverine is tonally so light years away from logan and it feels like a completely separate thing and because it's a legacy of the Fox and sort of Marvel universe as opposed to the core MCU and even Logan is to be fair as well they are both Fox MCUs and then so it's like I guess that's irrelevant because they both come from the same place like I feel a little bit like they're kind of semi-canon if you know what I mean you know and one of the reasons why the multiverse stuff is necessary because if you're bringing in things from different places and you're going to have two different sets of X-Men you almost have to be able to say oh it's a multiverse thing because otherwise how does it work and then And without the multiverse, we wouldn't have Spider-Man No Way Home.

37:07Well, is this the longest film-based discussion we've had on the policy podcast? Possibly. We should move on. John, this is your fault. I blame you entirely. Moving on entirely, and this comes from Marcus, and it's about Colin. Hi, Pilot Pod crew. This is not so much a question, more of amusing. After watching the first series of Colin from Accounts and enjoying it very much, I was disappointed to hear that the second series had received a rather cold and slightly negative reaction. Because of this, I put off watching it when it was first released, and boy that was a mistake with the third and final series now out i thought i'd catch up on the first series and get through the second i was excited to watch the third after all the praise from the pod i was even considering just watching a youtube recap of series two madness i'm so glad i didn't as it was a joy from start to finish one episode in particular took me from belly laughs to ugly crying within a matter of minutes i can't wait to finish the last series and i really hope it sticks the landing where did all the negativity around series two come from or have i just made that up in my head.

38:03Have any of you ever been put off watching a show because of a lukewarm response only to eventually watch it and realise you were missing out? We all gave ourselves the wrong opinion about Furious and now I've started watching that and it's unbelievable. So that's a massive reverse ferret. But I'm with you about the second season of Colin because I did not understand why people didn't like it. I think what it was is that the first season was just so incredible and felt so fresh and it's something new and people really excited and you know inevitably second seasons never really live up to the hype of a first season um but you have to like stick with the characters and i thought second season was brilliant but yeah i think both of you losers also thought that second season wasn't that good didn't you no no no no no no yeah boy go for it it's the second season of one of the best comedies of recent years and it took a slight dip is the most I would say.

38:56It's slightly lesser, but it's still great. Exactly. We absolutely did not. We acknowledged, I'm sure we did. I haven't gone back and listened to the tapes, but I'm pretty sure we acknowledged it. It's still brilliant. It just was a slight, just because you're in the middle bit of the story in a way, it's harder to keep giving them stuff to do and put the obstacles in the way of the romance, et cetera. But it's still absolutely brilliant. It's not a reverse spirit needed it's just uh we just thought it was slightly less brilliant than the first series yeah and i think it's the natural progression like when you have a first series where it's all will they won't they and then it ends with they will yeah then the second season is you then have to essentially fabricate problems for said relationship and it's like and that isn't as satisfying as a viewing experience so it's just the nature of the narrative arc of the show whereas in the third season we're back to kind of will they won't they again so that naturally has i think that's naturally more compelling so yeah i think i think series two of Colin was great but yeah it's the I would think the weakest of the three but still brilliant Colin from a character is quite unusual because it's eight episodes each series and that most most um comedies tv comedies are six half hours to have eight that it's a it's a lot of stuff to provide for the characters to deal with particularly and I think that particularly felt so in the second series despite it still being absolutely great yes Steph I think you're what you're right so we started off with will they won't they and then the second season is can they endure and then the third season is um you know is it forever okay which i feel and i know james disagrees with me is exactly what's happened with nobody wants this i knew i see i was going to bring that up yeah because you really really didn't like season two and um you said it wasn't very good and i i'm no no you're boring no sorry i'm hitting out right okay no right the first season was will and they endure, and then we'll see what happens in the third season.

40:51But I bet you when the third season comes out, you're going to like the second season more because it will tie things up. I'm betting you do, James. Yes, you will. We'll see. Do you think they'll have learned proper mic technique by season three? And actually to use headphones when recording a podcast? That's your real beef, if that's so. Yeah, that is quite irritating. Shitty podcasting, that's the thing that bothers me. Yet nobody wants this. And in theory, that should work well because can they endure? obviously there are a lot of natural obstacles in the way of them enduring because of like the interfaith relationship that they've got but the thing is it was just a bit boring and the thing is you got to the fact where the central characters were just by far the least interesting part of the show and the supporting characters kind of dominated it which is great that they've got superb supporting characters but i feel like it definitely wasn't uh on a level with the first season so let's see what they do with the third i still haven't finished nobody wants this series too.

41:43Nobody does want this. My main issue with nobody wants this is the title is so generic that I always forget what actual show we're talking about. Yeah, it's a terrible title. Shiksa was a much better one. Shiksa, oh my god, that was such a stupid idea. Should we call Shiksa? Okay. This is from Derek. Hi Steph and whoever else is on with Steph these days. First of all, how about the whiplash from Steph being public enemy number one with the blood-related TV debacle to now being the darling of Bramall and the general audience with her latest blood-related incident. There we go. And on the Steve question, come on, you missed the greatest Steve.

42:22Boyd, Steve Arnott. DS, Steve Arnott. I just think of him as Arnott. That's why. I don't think of their first names. Yeah. Well, me and DS Arnott are obviously on a first-name basis. Arnott's got a whole series of his own. Martin has got a series of reality shows where he goes traveling around Las Vegas. where he lives with his wife. Yeah, yeah. Coming up on Channel 4 in a couple of weeks. Yeah. That's deranged. Yeah. Okay, a message here from Amar. Amar says, I want to give a shout out for Rookie Blue as a great show set in Canada. Not to be confused with The Rookie, the star's legendary Canadian actor, Nathan Fillion.

42:59However, this is also a police procedural set in Toronto, a city where I've done a lot of photography work in the past, so always nice to see. It doesn't break any new ground, but it's really well made and has a likeable cast. Also, great reply on Pilot Plus to the comment about how you apparently flip-flop or change your minds. I think keeping an open mind like you do is important and sometimes on that particular day something just doesn't click. But you revisit it and it does and you are glad for it. I thought Slow Horses was a bit meh and gave up after the first episode but tried it again and now I think it's one of the greatest shows ever.

43:29The correct opinion Amal. So have either of you ever watched Rookie Blue? No. No, but it sounds like something I'd like. I've watched the first two seasons of Rookie Blue. Oh my God, wow. Do you know what? It actually is. Yeah, it's true. It is a police procedure set in Canada and it's a bunch of kind of intake police rookies and the kind of exploits they get into. I think it, I can't remember what year it came out but I'm going to say it probably pre-dates this podcast so there was probably less great stuff around than there is now but yeah, I watched the first two seasons of it. I did give up after that it has to be said but yeah, I've noticed though that on my TV whenever I go like Rookie Blue is being pushed quite heavily so I don't know whether it's just been acquired by Netflix or something or it's on the channel.

44:12Because it was on in 2010. Okay, so yeah, quite a bit before we started this podcast. Maybe there's going to be a crossover and we'll get Rookie Bluey. Yeah.

44:24I would 100 % watch that. A small Australian dog gets drafted into the police force. Let's make that happen. Yeah. Oh my God. Yeah, but they already have that kind of animation and it's called Police Labrador and that's also great. not police Labrador yeah are you serious there's a police Labrador animated shark yeah called police Labrador it's great it's a Labrador with a police outfit that's so good I'm in I'm in right last question for this week and this came to me on unconventionally did not come from the post bag this is someone who sent this to me on social media this comes from Summerled and it says so having had to force myself to keep watching Silo season 3 due to it being very slow, annoying, and confusing.

45:10I now have to completely reverse ferret and place this high on my best of 2026 list as they have only gone and shat the bed in a good way by ending the season with two mind-blowing episodes that have changed the game completely while explaining all the confusing things in an incredibly exciting and satisfying manner. Didn't expect that. So, if anyone has given up early in season three, I'd urge them to hang in there. It is worth it. And now I can't wait for season four. My question for the pod is, What shows have bored and or annoyed you for most of the season, but then forced you to completely reverse ferret by then pulling everything out of the bag in the final one or two episodes?

45:45While you are thinking about that, I will jump in here and say that thank you, Somalad, for sending me that because you reminded me that me and John Nugent and Ben Travis recorded a spoiler podcast for Silo Season 3 last week, and I completely forgot to edit it and put it up last week. so I'm going to do that this morning and get it up today obviously it's Monday it's recorded today so it will be up before you actually hear this but I will get that up there but we had a big old chat about Silas season 3 and yes I think season 3 is the best season so far I didn't actually find it slow at the beginning I loved this season all the way through but yes I will totally agree that at the end it shoots up it sort of hits the stratosphere in how good it is in the final couple of episodes just get it up James I will I will I'm going to edit it this morning can you ever shat the bed in a in a good way i don't think so i don't think there is a positive way to shit the bed i've got to be honest with you uh sorry samoled i'm i'm not sure that's a good thing uh on any level really so yeah no yeah i mean i don't know about um what i can say is that um it silo season three has been watched in its entirety in my house not by me but Liam watched the whole thing and said it's absolutely unbelievable but he crucially watched it last thing at night in the dark.

47:00Obviously, as we all know, Side of the Winter Show so you have to get the, yeah, close to autumn so you have to get the setting right. So yeah, I'm just trying to think of a show that I have. Do you know what? I am currently watching one of the teeny shows which I initially thought was not very good but actually now I'm well into it. I mean, I'm watching Crew Girl and I'm like, Crew Girl. Hang on, you liked Crew Girl, didn't you? I thought you liked it. I thought it was nowhere near as good as any of the other offerings that we've had. But now I'm like fully on board with it. Like fully. So maybe a little bit of that.

47:36Yeah, I plan to get back to Crew Girl at some point. It's a lesser teen show, but it still looks quite fun. There's another new teen show coming up as well. Is there? Yeah, it's Italian. It's on Prime. No, it's on Netflix. It's Italian though. But you know, it's full on. yeah i'll be reporting on that interesting to be honest i think generally speaking if a show bores me for most of the season the chances of me finishing that season are very slim so i don't think i will ever find out if it turns it around at the end because i will have tapped out long before then um but then you know as you say like it is one of these things where if you hear that it has an amazing finale or it really sticks landing which fantastic maybe that makes you persevere with it but it depends on how boring you're finding it um because i have now at this point i hate to say it officially tapped out of every single branch of the walking dead i just life's too short i can't do it anymore i'm finished daryl dixon you know uh dead city no i'm done i'm just done yeah you've made the right choice i tapped out i tapped out on that a while ago yeah i think so yeah no i haven't got the time to sit through stuff to get to there's the man who watched every episode of love rat oh yeah love rat that was only three episodes maybe four yeah that's true okay i think that is enough for this week's postbag if you would like to send in your thoughts and prayers and questions and statements and feedback and whatever else you want the email address is postbag at pilot tv pod.com we will be back in your ears on monday what are we doing on monday we will be covering the blame on itv we'll be covering youth the aforementioned graduation atrocity included that is on what was it on Boydy?

49:17HBO Max. HBO Max and then we were covering the Split Up which is on BBC. Exciting times. Who will we have on the podcast? Sharon Horgan will be on to justify her inclusion of said graduation scene. Plus we'll have Pierce Brosnan and Helen Mirren talking about the new season of Mobland. I should say Mobland's embargo has now lifted. Have either of you watched the new season of Mobland? No. It's fun. I'm liking it. It starts with lots of violence and more stuff happens. You've got Helen Mirren saying comfortable. a lot. Helen Mirren drops a veritable cavalcade of sea bombs in the very first episode alone, so that is reason enough to watch it.

49:52I'm on board. I'm on board. Excellent. See you all on Monday. Pilot out.

From the publisher

We’re back in the Reacherverse on this week’s Plus as the team see if Maria Sten’s spinoff show can successfully step out of Reacher’s man-mountain-sized shadow in Neagley on Prime Video. Plus we tackle the ongoing gimmickification of the new series of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, the Americanisation of British TV shows (looking at you Ted Lasso), and the multiversification (or not) of the MCU.

Want your messages read out as part of The Postbag? Email us at postbag@pilottvpod.com

More from Pilot TV+

All 149 episodes
PLUS NeagleyPilot TV+ · 50 min
Listen in VO