


Pilot Plus review of Apple TV+ serial killer thriller Nocturne (created by Rowan Joffe). Set in a small Pennsylvania town where a serial killer is supposedly behind bars, yet bodies and even living people keep turning up. The plot centers on retired detective Jonah (Liev Schreiber) and Zassi (Zazie Beetz), an FBI agent undercover, as they reopen an old missing-kids case after one of the siblings reappears. The episode discusses whether the show is gripping vs derivative/slow, and how Stephen Graham’s character manipulates others from inside a high-security institution.
Boyd Hilton (regular host; mixed feelings; watched up to episode 3; focuses on pacing and perceived nonsense/derivativeness). Kay Ribeiro (regular host; watched only episode 1; finds Graham terrifying/compelling; likes the manipulation premise and undercover tension).
Boyd calls it slow and thin on story, with familiar serial-killer-thriller elements; Kay buys into the “puppet master” idea.
Graham’s opening “convincing” sequence from a bunker/cell; a long choking/insanity moment; undercover infiltration of Uric’s world; missing kids and reinvestigation; recurring “grubby” torchlit visuals; music by Toydrum ratcheting tension.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The hosts welcome Boyd Hilton and Kay Ribeiro, discussing Kay's recent experiences.
“I've approached that time of life where I cannot hold the menu any further away from me without it being outside of the restaurant.”
The hosts begin discussing the new show Nocturne and its key characters.
“There is a serial killer behind bars and yet bodies and indeed alive people seem to be popping up.”
Boyd shares his complex feelings about Nocturne, praising the cast while critiquing some elements.
“Yeah, because I've written it phonetically.”
The conversation delves into the pacing of Nocturne and its derivative aspects.
“I think what Elefakes is just the cast and their performances.”
The hosts discuss character dynamics and specific performances in Nocturne, including Stephen Graham's.
“And so that's why this all starts coming to the fore again.”
The hosts wrap up their thoughts on Nocturne, with differing opinions on its quality and enjoyment factor.
“I've not slugged you off of Stephen Graham.”
Discussion on a character's performance and potential comedic elements.
“And I was thinking this is like his maddest role.”
Overview of the series' source material and its setting.
“and his performance is so bad it's almost a comedy.”
Exploration of the show's pacing and its gritty tone.
In-depth analysis of Stephen Graham's acting choices and style.
“He's just insulting him by trying to do his accent.”
Discussion on the show's music and its impact on atmosphere.
“It's not like it's going to be dragged out to eight or ten episodes, as these things sometimes are.”
Listener messages discussing spoilers and viewer reactions.
“Now, I think October 30th, is that Thursday?”
Comparisons made to other series, including 'Gavin and Stacey'.
“all times, ready to take him down if he looks like he's going to spoil a show.”
Suggestions for viewers on what to watch next and insights on 'The Diplomat'.
“Miranda says, it's not actually Miranda, but Miranda says, I am one of your longtime loyal Australian subscribers who diligently listens the second any episode drops, but first time emailer.”
Unplanned discussion on 'Slow Horses' and related themes.
The hosts discuss their thoughts on the characters in Slow Horses.
“spoilers here for the recent slow horses finale and we should at some point no we haven't we We haven't done a spoiler chat for Slow Horses.”
A deep dive into the competence and flaws of various characters in Slow Horses.
“is anyone else getting rather frustrated at River being quite shit as an agent?”
The hosts read listener emails, including one regarding an ad interruption on another podcast.
“While no one would be happier than me if the endorsement deals flow towards you all, this one was a bit like Paul McCartney endorsing Bernard Matthews' turkey drummers.”
A conversation comparing The Pacific and Generation Kill, highlighting their different narratives.
“So, James, what are you thinking of this year's series of Celebrity Tracers?”
Hosts discuss plans for a re-watch of Band of Brothers and the series' impact.
“On this theme I would recommend Generation Kill, if you haven't seen it, starring Alexander Skarsgård, yes that's a David Simon show, a realistic war drama based on the more modern story of the 2003 invasion of Iraq.”
The hosts brainstorm which creative teams could improve various TV shows.
“And the city of LA is basically a character in the show.”
Discussion of a previous bet about a show and the hosts' anticipation for future episodes.
“Are you sure, because this has taken two years to arrive, the second series.”
Discussion on the informal triage system used for selecting topics and anticipation for upcoming series.
“I need to identify ones that require a little bit of thought and share them with people beforehand.”
A lively debate on the merits of 'Kill Jackie' with contrasting opinions from the hosts.
“I'm going to get you, Kate, to be the arbiter of taste on something.”
Transition to discussing the current events in 'Celebrity Traitors' and the hosts' personal takes.
“as discussed, I am now going to engage the Traitors Amnesty section so that Boyd and Kay can discuss what has been happening in Celebrity Traitors.”
In-depth analysis of the dynamics and quality of the current season of 'Celebrity Traitors'.
“That is very much what's happened, although that's an upsetting image.”
Final reflections on key moments from 'Celebrity Traitors' and predictions for the finale.
“You want them, you know, this will be remembered for having the most, a group of traitors that have been completely flown by without being barely, certainly up until now.”
The hosts analyze the success and cultural impact of the series and its star.
“Grant factor has actually been helped to because that is such an insane moment that it's become iconic and famous up and down the country, even if you don't watch the show.”
Hosts wrap up the episode, teasing future content and reviews.
“The secret is that when James says we've got to rearrange the podcast with half a day's notice, which happens quite a lot.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Pilot TV+, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:07Kay Ribeiro: Welcome to Pilot Plus, your extended guide to every show that matters. And before we get into this week's review, which is, of course, Nocturne on Apple TV Plus, the new serial killer thriller by Rowan Joffe, we should say that we are joined here by Boyd Hilton. Obviously, that's not exciting. We're very used to Boyd being here. But also, Kay Ribeiro is back with us. Hello, Kay. Hi boys, how are you? This is very exciting morning. He's giving me a pointer, are you giving me a clap? Yeah, a lot of clapping, a lot of clapping. Yes. Have you been, Kay? Please tell us everything that you've done in the last however many months, in the next 30 seconds.
0:40Well, listen, the biggest breaking news, James, that I think you'd be interested in, not, is that I think I need to get reading glasses.
0:47Kay Ribeiro: Yes. Wow. It's finally happening. It's that time. Is it that time? Wow. I've approached that time of life where I cannot hold the menu any further away from me without it being outside of the restaurant. Are you okay? Because you also have quite short arms because you're not that tall. So I have an advantage because I reckon I've got at least another six inches on you arm-wise. That's true. Yeah, exactly. I am held back by my short arms, my exceptionally short arms. Like a T-Rex. Yeah. So next time you see me, I might have spectacles. You have little specks on. Yeah. What will they be like? Pink frames?
1:19Kay Ribeiro: I don't know. I do love an accessory. So I don't know. Maybe I'll go wacky up. Dane Medna kind of look? Yeah. you should get you should get little TV screens like little square TV screens as your glasses to be on brand I think Boyd should have those I might go yeah I might try a few on and send it to the group chat and see what you think do something by straw poll I'm pretty sure with the size of Boyd's TV he will never need glasses to watch it I do need glasses actually funny enough yeah I need the lightest so yeah that's my big news okay well exciting thank you very much for joining us it's lovely to have you back here but we should talk about the show at hand which is Nocturne as mentioned created by Rowan Joffe airing on Apple TV Plus and starring Liev Schreiber as a retired police detective, Zassi Bates as his kind of goddaughter, who's also an FBI agent, and Stephen Graham as a very softly spoken serial killer.
2:08Kay Ribeiro: And it's very, very creepy. This is a small town in Pennsylvania. There is a serial killer behind bars and yet bodies and indeed alive people seem to be popping up. Now, Boydie, you've been watching this for a Wild because you mentioned this on what we've been watching some weeks ago. Now, you didn't say what you thought of it, whether you liked it or whether you didn't, though I put it to you, Boydie, that you would not have watched multiple episodes ahead of time had you not been enjoying it. Is this true? Kind of. Oh! I have, yeah, I have complicated feelings about Nocturne. Yeah. I'm not exactly sure where I stand on it because on the one hand, it's got a gripping story.
2:48It's got an incredible cast as you said Leo Schreiber Zazie Beats Stephen Graham Bill Camp let's not forget Bill Camp who's one of the great supporting cast members of all time he often plays a cop and he's in the Night Of the classic El Campo El Campo
3:07Kay Ribeiro: we should say just for the record it is Zassi Bates is it? yes Zassi Bates also can I listen I spent a lot of time as you can imagine yesterday just really watching YouTube to see how these names are said. And actually, it's Zessie. Just so you know. She says Zess. Yeah. Are you sure? Well, it came out of my mouth. I don't know. Can we trust her? Interesting. So I watched an interview that she did. She was with Michael Pena and Michael Pena called out the interviewer because she pronounced her name three different ways in the space of about 20 seconds. Like, what is happening? And I thought when she said it, it was Zessie Bates.
3:42Kay Ribeiro: You're saying it was Zessie. Zessie. Yeah, because I've written it phonetically. She went Zessie Bates. Why don't we just stick with Zazie Beetz. Yes, yes, Boydie, that's definitely the way to go. Yeah, go on then. Yeah, and obviously, Rory Culkin, let's not forget Rory Culkin, has a key role. Do you know what's funny? I didn't recognise Rory, I don't know what Rory Culkin looks like, but he has that, that distinctive Culkin-osity to him. Yeah. The second he walked on the screen, I was like, that's a Culkin, that is a Culkin. Yeah. It's not the Home Alone Culkin, it's not the Succession Culkin, it's the other Culkin.
4:14It's the other one. But he's, he's good in it. And it's got this opening sequence in which Stephen Graham is basically in a bunker in the basement of a high security institution. And he somehow manages to convince people to carry out crimes without him stepping foot.
4:37Kay Ribeiro: He's speaking very softly. I think it's ASMR. Yeah, maybe. and he has all kinds of ways of wheedling his way into the minds of these people. That's the power of Stevie G. It is the power of Stevie G. This is, of course, the first thing, proper big thing he did since adolescence, by the way. This was the next thing he did straight after filming this. So it's got this kind of enticing serial killer idea that he can somehow manipulate people like that. So on the one hand, I'm compelled by it and I'm enjoying it. But on the other hand, gnawing away at me is the distinct notion that it's a load of absolute nonsense.
5:22And not only is it a load of absolute nonsense, but it's so reminiscent at times of Silence of the Lambs that you half expect Stephen Graham to start talking about father beans and a nice guarantee, basically. And I can't escape the idea, the fact that there's so many elements of it that we've seen before in serial killer thriller narratives, TV shows and films, that it's unbelievably derivative. It's extraordinarily derivative. And I'm not even sure if Stephen Graham is doing that brilliantly. I don't know. I'm just – I'm enjoying it. I'm being entertained by it. This is very bold. I'm enjoying this.
6:00I almost can't bring myself to say it. Going toe-to-toe with the Graham. How many did you watch? Because you were watching it a while ago. I'm on three. I've done three. Is it six total, is that? I think it's six total, yeah. And it's also quite slow in a way. Things take a long time. It takes quite a long time for Zezzie to be installed in the institution. That happens at the end of episode two. And it kind of picks up. There's one sequence which is just watching Stephen Graham on his own, in his cell, kind of choking himself. And that seems to go on for about five minutes. I think it's in episode two, and that's intercut with what other characters are doing.
6:41And I was like, I'm not sure if we need this ratcheting up his insanity. I think we've got the idea from the very first sequence what this guy is like and what he does, etc. But I can't deny that I'm absolutely going to finish it, and I will carry on watching it, and I'm enjoying it. But it's kind of like a pretend gourmet burger of a serial killer thriller. I'm not even sure if it's that gourmet. It's just incredible people in it. It might just be a burger. I think the gourmandness comes from the cast. Yeah, no, exactly. I agree. The cast is so good, but it's really like, but you know, Liev Schreiber spends his whole time just moping around, being kind of mumbling quite a lot.
7:23Zezzi is probably, is very watchable and likable. But yeah, I am confused and bewildered. It's not, put it this way. By no means is this an out-and-out smash work of genius that you might expect from the cast and the creators. But even Smoke, I'll compare it to Smoke for a bit, which is one of my favourite Apple TV limited series of recent times. And Smoke was absolutely, for me, a gourmet burger. And almost like half and half, it was half ridiculous, bonkers, and half brilliant. And it was so compelling and gripping and so much fun. This is almost not quite as much fun, but almost. And it's not quite as bonkers, but almost.
8:05And that's how I'm feeling about it. Do you think the primary thing for you is the pacing? Because it is so slow. Yeah, exactly. Because Smoke was at least, like it was very paced. Yeah, absolutely. And we had way more episodes. Yeah, there's a lot more going on. Story-wise in this, it's quite thin, the story in a way. You know, you're not following. there's there's bill camp kind of rousing his crew his his cops to kind of help re kind of restart the investigation so basically like there's two kids that disappeared one of them comes back and that's the that's the driving force behind reopening the investigation into what who the hell how the hell stephen graham's character is doing what he's doing um but it doesn't feel like there's huge amounts of going on all over the place as it did with smoke like smoke had so many different um tentacles to it um it was constantly fascinating this doesn't feel like that either, no.
8:54So, but I am entertained by it. I can't deny it. But yeah, I think you're right. I think what Elefakes is just the cast and their performances. Because even, you know, Stephen Graham phoning it in, I'm not saying he is, but if he is, in theory, phoning it in, he's still incredibly compelling to watch. I mean, to be fair, in the role he has, he could only phone in. He couldn't, yeah. That's a good point, yeah. He's literally not allowed out. Yeah, exactly. So, yeah, I have mixed feelings. as I hope has become clear. Oh, abundantly so. Listen, I do take a lot of your point. I do think it is slow.
9:31I think a lot of this has been seen before. I disagree. I think Stephen Graham is great in this. I mean, his accent does slip a couple of times, I think. But I think he's so menacing and terrifying in this. I think he said in interviews, he was really searching around for what the next role should be after adolescence because obviously he wanted to make sure it was the right role. I think this is a good role for him. I think he's terrifying. And yeah, okay, I agree that things are quite slow, but those first scenes in which he's able to convince a fellow patient to take their own life, I found it, okay, you could say it's ridiculous, but actually I think it goes to show how powerful this man is, that he's so manipulative.
10:19And I don't know, I've only seen the first episode, but I could believe that he is the puppet master and he can control these people. And I'm sure a man like him could find a way of communicating with the outside world. And so the whole thing is, I don't know if we said, but there are some missing kids. Liev Schreiber had been searching for them, hadn't been able to. It was one of the cases that he was unable to solve before he retired. And one of the boys of the siblings appears. It's one boy, one girl. Anyway, the boy appears and then everyone starts reinvestigating the case. And Jonah, Liev's character, thinks that Yurik is responsible.
11:00And so that's why this all starts coming to the fore again. And I actually can see that - Thanks for explaining that. I should have done myself, obviously. No, but I can see that he could be that. So I bought into it. That's what I'm trying to say. Unlike you, I sort of bought into it a bit more. and I found his performance incredibly menacing for the understated nature of it and the kind of softly spoken voice and the long pauses in the gap it just ratcheted up the tension so much so in fact I actually because I'm more of a nervy disposition I don't think I will you know if I had more time I perhaps would but I yeah it's it's it's incredibly ted I think it's incredibly compelling um i do want to know how he has done this because he must he must be responsible otherwise this whole thing is a moot point so i do want to know it i think we can assume it's like a how done isn't how has he done it wrong yeah i don't think there's much doubt that he's heavily involved in bad things i thought saga bauer played by zessie is a great character as well she brings a dynamism to it as well um because she's an undercover agent so the fact that she has to go in to sort of infiltrate Uric's world is exciting.
12:13And also I want to shout out, I think Rory Culkin is great in this. Yeah, yeah. As the sort of sacrificial lamb. He's a psychiatric nurse who is sort of drafted in to attend to Uric. And yeah, those scenes, I was like, did I put it on mute so I didn't get too scared? I can't confirm what I'm saying. Yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah. For everyone else, yeah, for regular viewers, this isn't going to be as tense it was for me. I've just got a particularly nervous disposition. But yeah, I enjoyed it. But I can see all your sort of criticisms of it or discerning points. But I think for viewers at home, I think it's still an enjoyable watch.
12:55And I'm not standing here slugging off Stephen in the same way that you are. Don't, I'm not, I've said if, I've not slugged you off of Stephen Graham. I'm teasing you. Boyd, he came for Graham. Oh my God. No, no, I lost Stephen Graham. It was a drive-by. I love Stephen Graham. He can do almost no wrong.
13:11Kay Ribeiro: Yeah, except when he looks back at the transcript, phoning it in. No, no, no, no, no. I said if. No, he said if. We're doing Boy Day's legs a bit. He's absolutely not phoning in. Do you know what? He reminded me of, there was a show called Action Time. Do you remember Action Time, which was Tom Davis's first thing he did after Murder and Successful, right? Was it a comedy? It was a comedy. It was an hour and an hour. You're comparing Stephen Graham's performance in this to a comedy? Let me finish. Let me finish. It was an out-and-out comedy, like a piss-take of James Bond stuff and loads of different things.
13:41Vicky McClure was in it. But in one episode, Stephen Graham is in it as a kind of a bit of a psycho, like a professional – I think he plays a professional assassin, but he's in a glass-encased kind of jail cell, which is very much invoking Skyfall and Science of the Lambs and these things. And he goes bonkers in it. And I was thinking this is like his maddest role. So this extended version of it. His cameo. Not only that, I was there on the day doing a set visit when he was doing this role, and he was really throwing himself into it. So he kept reminding me of that. And what I would say is, what struck me, halfway through episode two, there's a scene in which all the people in the institution kind of gather to hash out things.
14:21And one particular character gets furious, right? And I thought he was quite funny. This character's quite over the top. He's one of the wardens, basically. I don't know if you've met him in episode one yet. but he is completely bonkers and over-the-top character and quite funny. I was amused by him. And I was thinking, if they just tweaked the script and the performances just slightly, if they just slightly switched, moved that switch one iota further along into the comedy realm, you've got a really funny comedy piss take of serial killer thrillers. That's what I thought about this show. I think this is not quite the justification in the defence you think it is.
14:58It's more like a double down.
15:00Kay Ribeiro: Well, I'm not saying it is. I'm just saying that's what I'm asking. Just to sum up, Stephen Graham is phoning it in and his performance is so bad it's almost a comedy. Right, okay, this is good to know. You're misphoning me, but, you know, I rely on the listeners to have good faith in exploring one song. We don't know long on the Graham's Christmas card list. Yeah, clearly not. We should mention, though, that this, Leif Shriver plays Jonah Lynn. These are, of course, based on their Unalina novels, which are a series of Scandi crime novels. This is based on two of them, actually, Lazarus and The Sandman.
15:29Kay Ribeiro: and these are written by a husband and wife team alexander and alexandra and darill presumably forged from the shards of narsil but they uh they write under the pen name lars kepler so yeah it's and i think that scandiness does come through quite strongly and obviously explains why they've said it in this sort of rural pine strewn pennsylvania landscape i think this is actually really good um i watched three of these but partly because i kind of feel like you can't get a handle on it from the first episode and i'm not 100 sure you can get a handle on it from the second episode i think it takes a little while because there are there are lots of wheels in motion there's an undercover operation there's them obviously trying to get to grips with what's actually going on there's a whole thing involving tree trunks um and yeah indeed it's the title sequence of your yeah and it's it takes a while to get to grips with that i think it has a quite it's to scan weird it has a nice grubby quality to it like especially when you go to the places where for example the the kind of people who've been kidnapped have been held and stuff like it's got it's really dark and like you can't almost not see anything lit by torchlight and it's really disgusting and yellowy and grim yeah and it has a really kind of grubby quality to it but it's it's seven it manages to be seven it has a lot of finch-esque qualities i'll certainly grant you that um stephen graham's performance i guess i think will probably be slightly polarizing because obviously he's you know he's not playing scouse he's in pennsylvania he's playing in american accent but he deliberately takes that very soft very melodious sort of mellifluous speaking voice and as you say body there's there's no small anthony hopkins in that performance i think as well like he's very articulate and softly spoken but with this overwhelming kind of pull of menace which kind of radiates from him did you did you get some scouse in it as well did you hear that i well but that may just be me because i'm so used to hearing that from him there was certainly a couple of words where it's like you know it's like fucking hell and you're just like oh i think you're slagging steven graham off more than me well only during the moment he was finding it He's not slagging him off.
17:38He's just insulting him by trying to do his accent. That's different.
17:41Kay Ribeiro: To be fair, I think it's more just I'm projecting because I'm so used to hearing his voice being scouse. But I think it's a fascinating performance. And I think there's probably more to come from that. I suspect we'll get to see another side of that character. Because what we have not really seen a lot of is... It's all menace. It's all the promise of menace without overt violence. He doesn't really do anything scary, but it's kind of pregnant with threat. The music. Can we mention them? Because, yeah, there's a bit in that. You're right. I thought episode three is a bit of a game. Episode three, it kind of, all the elements come together in episode three, and it does start to get, the pace picks up as well.
18:24It does, yeah. It is polarizing, but it's still really entertaining. It's fun. How many episodes are there in titles? Six. Okay. Yeah, so not that many. It's not like it's going to be dragged out to eight or ten episodes, as these things sometimes are.
18:41Kay Ribeiro: I know what you're saying about the pacing. It is deliberately paced. But I think, again, whenever you get these quite slow-burn crime novel adaptations, they tend to have that quality, and I quite like it. I rather like that slightly more deliberate bit where they eke it all out. Can I tell you something else I liked? Go on. Sorry to interrupt. In the first episode, I like the use of a curtain by Jonah Lynn's character in his cabin. Oh, yeah. Not as upsetting as the use of the curtain in Fallout. Oh, my God, James, Fallout! I can't believe we've used it. Oh, my God, I've forgotten about that.
19:19No, he absolutely does not abuse a curtain in the same way. It's just that a curtain is, yeah, it's such a small detail. It's not a big deal, but I just liked how it was almost like a bit of a Paul Daniels moment. The curtain drops. You're like, oh, right, okay. yeah no he does not oh god that's gross I can't believe you brought that back into my mind sick oh that's why I meant to mention the music yeah the music which is by Toy Drum who do they're kind of like a musical duo I think they do Slow Horses with Daniel Pemberton and other stuff the music is really ratchets things up like sometimes there's nothing really happening there's just Stephen Graham sitting there in his cell kind of looking menacing and then it cuts to you know Liev Schreiber looking mopey and the music is like ratcheting it up to the full.
20:04Why do you think I had to hit mute?
20:05Kay Ribeiro: Yeah, fair enough, yeah. Yeah, but it's fun. Okay. Nocturne then, which is on Apple TV+. When, Boydie? Now, I think October 30th, is that Thursday? Oh, no, Friday. Friday. Bit of live calendar work for you there. Yeah. Excellent. Okay, it is time for the post-pack.
20:37Kay Ribeiro: let us see what we have here we have a message here from john and john says hello hope you're all well there you go that's nice formal start to the uh to the missive thanks john how are you yes uh just been listening to the latest episode and boy did a little something which i see and hear a lot of but now it's been taken to a new level it is long but a thing where people say spoiler alert and then in the same breath reveal a spoiler boy when discussing carrie recently decided to switch it around revealing the spoiler and then saying the words spoiler alert immediately afterwards sheesh what sort of a chance does that give us it's like being a jury member in a courtroom drama when the judge reprimands the attorney and turns around and says jury will disregard those remarks anyway can you please stop doing it or at least bring back the spoiler klaxon thing oh i'm sorry whatever it was yeah okay generally speaking i think when when there is a kind of when someone says oh spoiler alert or spoiler for thing we do tend those do tend to be it's certainly in my judgment generally quite mild ones because if they were not mild ones you just wouldn't hear it as as would have been evidence earlier this episode when we cut down to spoiler yeah um but yes yes we don't worry i have a team of highly trained snipers with boyd in their crosshairs at all times, ready to take him down if he looks like he's going to spoil a show.
21:56Yeah. I mean, even though things are in the trailer and literally in the press release and literally the first scene of a show. See, he's unrepentant. He's unrepentant. Absolutely. Me and Mark Kermode. Mark Kermode did a massive spoiler the other day for a film. I was thinking, oh my God, if James had been there, he would have ordered him to cut that out. I'd have gone, Mark,
22:19Kay Ribeiro: no! Stop it! another one for you boydy this one comes from mark and mark says despite agreeing with boyd the season two wasn't as good as season one i couldn't help but notice the irony of boyd criticizing the boringness of the central couple he's talking about nobody wants this by the way oh of criticizing the boringness of the central couple when he wrote a book about gavin and stacy the quintessential boring couple that nobody cares about but the supporting characters around them are great. Actually, do you know what? I did a gasp because I thought he was talking about Nessa and Smithy. And now that it's just landed, yeah, they are a boring couple.
22:59Yeah, they were just kind of a pedestrian, okay couple, but it was all the peripheral characters that were more interesting. I agree with this caller, this listener. Yeah. I still maintain Gavin and Stacey more interesting than the central couple in Nobody Wants This. so have you watched the full third series not the full no full no I'm halfway through I've just finished
23:24Kay Ribeiro: episode six I'm on the episode where they go to New York I won't say who spoiler didn't say who Boyd I'm enjoying it more than the second series yes it is better than the second series yeah I think it has picked up yeah but to me like I suppose Gavin and Stacey as we're saying for example Saoirse and Morgan Morgan are far more interesting than, you know, the Bengals. Yes, they are. And also, I have to say, like, I know he's a rabbi, but he's not a saint. Like, why does he not get more irritated by some of her ridiculous behaviour? Yeah, because he's the straight guy. He's just such a pushover.
24:04He's too much of a pushover. He's too much of a nice... I just don't believe that in every scenario, as James would say, that that would happen.
24:11Kay Ribeiro: You want to see his dark side? I want him just to get a bit cranky with when she's being a complete nightmare. you know just because i just think that's what happens in real life i don't think anyone would unless do you know what we'll do an experiment the rest of the episode i'll be as much of a nightmare as she is and let's see if you can indulge me but but how will we tell the difference i literally set you up i set you up and you knocked out of the park well done yeah i'm gonna try on some incredible diva behavior for this week's podcast and we'll see what happens oh my god am i her oh god is this how i find out i'm an awful monster if you don't know which one of the people in the room is the Joanne, you are the Joanne.
24:49That is, that is, I'm trying to think of someone in Salt Lake to compare you to in the show and there's no one worse than hers.
24:56Kay Ribeiro: Right. Let's have a message here from Miranda. Miranda says, it's not actually Miranda, but Miranda says, I am one of your longtime loyal Australian subscribers who diligently listens the second any episode drops, but first time emailer. I've just finished this week's Pilot Plus, only to have realised I missed the deadline for Diplomat Chat. Please, no, we must have more and a spoiler chat, pretty please, because I'm just dying to hear you talk about that table scene and epic cliffhanger. All that aside, I actually do have a question, which is, what the hell do I watch now? The Diplomat was so good that I just can't seem to land on anything else to watch, which is as good, but I want that energy again.
25:39Kay Ribeiro: Because I usually agree with James on many of his rantings, I decided I should probably try The West Wing. I have to admit, I struggle with dated TV shows, so I've always been apprehensive to begin. So far, I've only got through episode one and did find the musical score and some lines a bit cheesy. How do I get past this to be able to continue and enjoy it? As an aside, I was initially surprised that Billy Crystal was in the show, only to realise it was in fact a very young Bradley Whitford. Thank you for always hanging shit on each other, that sounds upsetting, and making me laugh while I go about my days with an eight-month-old baby testing my patience.
26:14Kay Ribeiro: Miranda. oh I like that instead of feces flinging hang in shit yeah that's me and Lisa Kay have you watched the new series of The Diplomat no I haven't yet so don't I don't want to hear is it because is it because Steph poisoned you against it is that what happened no I love The Diplomat except for that ridiculous running they did which is insane like I still I mean what was that about anyway no so I haven't yet Stephen Graham's not doing any running is he he's locked in boy it wouldn't matter if he was running or not you wouldn't see because of course he's phoning it in I didn't know that Graham's such a trap I think each podcast now should come with a quote of the podcast episode and I think that's it.
26:49If he was phoning in, which he's not, that's the point. You can't reverse-fail it now. You said it. Phoning in is comedy performance.
26:57Kay Ribeiro: I've been called Joanne. There's nothing worse. I'm carrying my own cross. You have to carry this one now. Yeah, that is fair. The West Wing struggles are real though because you have to bear in mind the West Wing debuted in 1999 and it was a network show so it will have a very different sort of like tempo to uh modern streaming series i will say on the music snuffy waldon's score changes as it goes on i can't remember how many episodes but you'll hear it in the title music um it begins with like it's all synthesized the music is and then they get a full orchestra at one point and then it stops being quite as a cheesy is the person's name snuffy yes wg one step away from snuffleupagus it is very much like that um but yeah but it is different and i think you know watch a few episodes of it it does feel a bit twee because modern politics isn't like that and they're giant crt monitors on their fucking computers um but it's it's wonderful keep watching it uh it's it's it's very good uh okay let's see what else we have got here a slow horses question from brad and brad says hi team and this is for no then there are no spoilers here for the recent slow horses finale and we should at some point no we haven't we We haven't done a spoiler chat for Slow Horses.
28:10Kay Ribeiro: Let's do it now. We haven't done a slow... We're going to do an impromptu Slow Horses spoiler chat. Well, I've got things to say. That's all I'm saying. Well, Boydie gets upset when I spring things on him last minute. But obviously, I didn't spring this. So I think this is my get out of jail free card. Boydie, I will leave you as a deciding factor on this. No, we're not doing it right now. We can't do it right now. Okay, fine. Sorry, Kay. We're halted, horses. And we should do a Diplomat 1 as well. It's been stopped in our tracks. We have. We have. But anyway, without spoilers, Brad says, is anyone else getting rather frustrated at River being quite shit as an agent?
28:41Kay Ribeiro: It comes across as he constantly gets saved by luck or other people. It's at a point where it's distracting as you're waiting to see how he fucks it all up. I'm sure he started off much more competent. No, I don't think so. I think he's always been incompetent. Yeah, I think that's a key part. I don't think he's incompetent. I don't think he was originally. He might be a bit more now, but to be fair, in this series, he has gone through a lot. and he sustains quite a few injuries. I mean, that's not necessarily the reason for his incompetence, but it probably holds him back somewhat. I think he thinks he's competent, isn't it?
29:17He thinks he's better than he is, yeah. He thinks he's better than he is. He thinks he is better than all the other slow horses. But I think Jackson Lamb constantly points out all the failures that he has. And so he's not, maybe incompetence is the wrong one, he's definitely not accident-free. he's quite you know he definitely a lot of his decisions are the wrong decisions put it that way i think throughout there's a sliding scale for all the horses though right so he's not as bad as um
29:42Kay Ribeiro: what's the computer guy called see i'm not sure so see this is the thing with slow horses like the whole point is they get exiled to slay house but the bad fact is they're not bad at their jobs they're all very good at their jobs but they're all horribly flawed so river's massively egocentric and massively arrogant and just looks uh leaps before he looks as it were uh and that's i guess his thing roddy ho is extraordinarily gifted at what he does which is kind of like cyber security things yes but he's a raging bellend and in the field he's not as good yeah and even standish who's like an alcoholic and is all over the place is again very competent i would say weirdly and much as i hate to say it the only one who i think might be a bit incompetent is shirley dander amy fion edwards character who historically and khanif kiawan's character may he rest in peace he was also I would say a little bit incompetent as well but most of them are pretty good yeah you're right I think Shirley is because Coe is another one again interpersonal issues but also a machine yeah oh I've got so many thoughts about the finale but we'll have to wait well obviously we've been banned from doing a spoiler chat by Boydys yeah we've been yes you have the dictator has spoken right we have a message here from Guy and Guy says shortly after finishing the pod in which Steph was upbraided for plugging phone chargers, I began listening to the Conan O 'Brien Needs a Friend podcast and an ad interrupted it.
31:07Kay Ribeiro: An ad interrupted it with, this is James Dyer for the Pilot TV podcast, who went on to sell the benefits of the BBC iPlayer, especially Celebrity Traitors and its post-match analysis show, followed by The Reluctant Vampire. Wait, wait, wait, wait. What? James, wait, this is real. You did an advert for that. I will continue. While no one would be happier than me if the endorsement deals flow towards you all, this one was a bit like Paul McCartney endorsing Bernard Matthews' turkey drummers. James, did you do it, right? This is real. I can neither confirm nor deny that I may have done an advert for the iPlayer.
31:46The show that you often stop us talking about, Traces, you were doing an advert for that, which you refused to watch.
31:52Kay Ribeiro: Yeah, that's basically what happened to you. I will never take any stick from you again about hosting stuff, talking about stuff, all that kind of stuff. Oh, dear. You know, I just go where they send me, Kate. I go where they send me. Unbelievable. They detonate a bellend and it just goes on somewhere. Yeah, that's exactly what happened. The other weird thing is I listened quite regularly to that podcast, to Conan O 'Brien Leads of Fred Podcast. And I've never heard – Do you think he screamed it out? Like your brain just refused to accept that it was real and he just deleted it. If you suddenly popped up in that, I'd be absolutely stunned.
32:26So I've definitely somehow managed to – that hasn't happened to me yet, that that ad hasn't popped up in my listening to that podcast. Well, keep an ear out for it.
32:34Kay Ribeiro: Yes, I will, yeah. So, James, what are you thinking of this year's series of Celebrity Tracers? Oh, yes, the best. So good. I mean, the traitors are just so traitorous. But I would say more traitorous than in previous iterations, like the most traitorous. That's what I think. Oh, and lest we forget, it's full of celebrities because, you know, it's celebrity traitors. So you've got traitorous traitors and celebrity traitors. It's got everything. Everything. We could do a spoiler special about that. What do you think? Oh, I think it's brilliant. And the last episode was one of the all-time great episodes.
33:11Kay Ribeiro: Hang on, the last episode hasn't aired. No, no, I meant the last episode that we've seen. I was going to say, I thought you were about to spoil the traits. No, no, no. No, I can do it. Have you seen the last one? No, no one's seen it. they show it as live um i've got thoughts on the trace as well but i know we can't talk about it you know what you know what in the in the interest of having you here and i'm always delighted to have you okay at the end of this episode i'm going to i'm going to yes beep it out darren i'm going to i'm going to have a traitor's armistice at the end of this episode where we will agree an allotted time where you and boy can be boring about the traitors at the end so people can switch off okay okay and if Boyd isn't listening then you can maybe drop some slow horses spoilers as well this comes from Lauren and Lauren has thoughts about Band of Brothers apologies as I am uncharacteristically behind with the pod so the conversation may well have moved on a bit spoiler it hasn't I just wanted to write to advocate for the Pacific after your recent discussions I had a very different experience with this show as I actually watched it before I ever saw Band of Brothers.
34:18Kay Ribeiro: That's unorthodox. I think the comparison is really the issue as Band of Brothers follows a cohesive linear camaraderie narrative. And I do think it is a masterpiece. Obviously, the war in the Pacific was very different from the war in Europe. And the series The Pacific highlights these differences whilst following three real-life Marines during the sprawling disjointed island hopping story. The war in the Pacific was chaotic. The jungle setting was claustrophobic. and for the soldiers this created an experience that was unrelentingly alienating emotionally. This was much more of a study about how the unrelenting carnage was so dehumanising that it broke the human mind.
34:50Kay Ribeiro: Definitely worth reappraising, it was also my introduction to John Bernthal. On this theme I would recommend Generation Kill, if you haven't seen it, starring Alexander Skarsgård, yes that's a David Simon show, a realistic war drama based on the more modern story of the 2003 invasion of Iraq. It shows events through an unglamorised lens and is considered by many who served during the Iraq and Afghan wars, including my husband, not mine, hers, to be the most realistic drama set during this period. It was developed by David Simon and Ed Burns and is a very different beast, focusing less on showing the characters as heroic and more on covering institutional dysfunction, the disconnect between ranks and the confusion, mundanity and ambiguity of this particular job.
35:31Kay Ribeiro: It has no score and avoids using cinematic manipulation and cliches to affect the emotion of the viewers. Despite this and the effort it takes to watch it i have to be honest it is an incredible show sorry for the essay lauren god that's a great email lauren have you seen uh have you ever watched generation kill boydy yes that is a brilliant email but i have to say i found a bit of a slog yeah um you know i have to admit it's a hard watch it is a hard watch because it is so pure and it's you know the no music real the realism is so oh my god real that um that it's tough watch yeah so i i didn't persevere with it i have to admit i don't think i finished it but yeah that's i mean i didn't either to be fair it was a long time ago it's an old yeah uh it was in the noughties i believe that came out um but um the pacific thing is an interesting one because i struggled with the pacific partly for that reason though i never really crossed my mind that it was maybe more emblematic of that conflict than band of brothers was of the european conflict um i just found it quite hard to follow um so i've not gone back to but i did i definitely am so kate in case you didn't know we are this is Steph's doing.
36:38Kay Ribeiro: We are at some point, and when I say we, I basically mean me and Steph, because Boyd will have none of it, but we're going to do a Band of Brothers re-watch and re-appraisal. Ooh! Do you know what? I haven't actually seen it the first time. It's very good. It's very good. It was one of those kind of must-see things in the very early, I can't remember if it was 2000, 2001, one of those. But yeah, really, really good. Incredible cast, all of whom are now very famous. But yeah, it's a really good show. I might simultaneously watch it. you can join us join us Kay join us in our rewatch that Boyd is Boyd Cotting I mean I'm just a busy man you know I can't he's a very busy man he's a very busy man yeah I mean I've got to get through another like three seasons of Mayor of Kingstown before I can do that though so you know it's on the sofa list is what I'm saying paracies yes this comes from Rich and Rich says afternoon podsters I've recently been thinking if we could parachute in the creative team from one show into another to greatly improve it which shows would be great candidates My current thoughts are the team from Bosch taking over Reacher.
37:40Kay Ribeiro: They know how to make things cinematic. They love the music. And the city of LA is basically a character in the show. All elements that would really help Reacher. I see Jed Mercurio maybe taking over Doctor Who. So that's another one. What do you think? Who would you swap? It's not really a question that I can fairly spring on you without any time for you to prepare for this. But I do not. You monster. we're going to review it in the next episode Sherlock and Daughter I would parachute the makers of actual you know the Benedict Cumberbatch actual Sherlock into Sherlock and Daughter this is a spoiler are you spoiling the podcast Kate I feel like this is a spoiler you have spoiled what you think of Sherlock and Daughter you say Sherlock and Daughter is not as good as Sherlock I'm hearing from Kate the performances are phoned in it's basically comedy she didn't like it well at least I've given an answer guys or I'm just trying to think who we could who we could since Boyd hated Nocturne who we could parachute in thank you yeah I'd parachute Gavin and Stacey into nobody wants this Joe Barton Joe Barton you could parachute in I think that would be a good shout oh could we parachute Joe Barton into almost anything well we're parachuting Joe Barton into this particular podcast because he's going to be in the studio for the next episode we're recording in the studio tomorrow that's very exciting how many doves have you seen all of the doves all of the doves Buggers.
39:03Yes. No spoilers for Black Doves season two.
39:07Kay Ribeiro: And indeed what we think of it because it is also embargoed. Before you continue, now, Boyd, you won't remember this, but you and I had a bet on the pod. I said the new series of Black Doves would be this year. And you said, you're crazy. It's not going to happen. And we had a bet on it. Did you? Yep. We did a golden nugget, but I'm happy for you just to take me out for lunch. I'll take you out for lunch anyway, but I don't remember this bet. Well, how did that happen? Okay, fascinating, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, because I was going on about, oh, I want the new series, new series, oh, hopefully next year, and you're like, absolutely not.
39:39And so we put a bet on it. So I just want to, everyone's listening now, so you're going to have to make good. Wait a minute, wait a minute. Are you sure, because this has taken two years to arrive, the second series. Are you sure you're not confusing it with the year last year when it didn't, wasn't it? No, no, no, because I said it at the end, before I left the pot, like full-time, I said it before I left, and you said, it won't be this year, I need 2036. It'll be more than two years. What kind of idiot am I? Don't let me call back the audio. I'll get Darren to trawl through the archive if you want.
40:07I might have to trawl through the archive. I find this very difficult. Why are you being such a weasel? You're just going to pay off. Weasel? Wow. Just pay off your debt. In fact, the reason why I know, well, I can't tell you why I know, because I might have actually, you know, I've just talked myself into a conversational cul-de-sac. Let's see.
40:21Kay Ribeiro: Oh, that sounds intriguing. Now I'm paying attention. I wonder what's happening now. Okay. Oh, God. I've now made the bet null and void. What a dickhead. I might have at some point been chatting to Joe Barton and I might I might have then known that it was definitely going to be this year and so anyway oh insider trading no after the bet had been made after the bet oh I see that's that's convenient yeah you had a sideways date with Joe Barton it wasn't a date it was an online communication because I wanted to know because I was desperate for the series to come and also and also side note desperate to win this bet and like can we just take a moment here to recognize a genuinely admiration worthy superior level entitlement i want more episodes so i'm going to email the showrunner and demand them and find out when they're coming don't know no no don't cast me in that light even me and boy don't go that far no he there was a story he put a story you know one of one of his stories and i just happened to reply to that and then and then i was just like oh by the way please say that you know it's coming up and then when he confirmed it I was so smug because I thought yes this boy doesn't know and he said it's not going to be this year and I can now get a well it was originally a pound coin as I say but now it's going to be a full lunch now it's become a whole meal it's become a nice one lunch at the Ivy the Ivy the OG Ivy or just the OG Comet Garden yeah OG Comet Garden Ivy okay alright thank you looking forward to it we can discuss this with Joe when he comes in tomorrow into the studio by the way yeah Rich I should apologise to you for not giving you proper answers to your thing.
41:58Kay Ribeiro: I need to get in the habit. This is the next level of the reformed triage system. I need to identify ones that require a little bit of thought and share them with people beforehand. That's something I need to do. James, I don't think any triage system has been used today. I've got to say. No, I am just winging it at this stage. Not even your basic bullshit triage system has been employed. No, no, I'm just reading what's in the postbag. Basically, I like to, it's like a tombola. I'm just delving in and I'm pulling out what comes out of it. yeah yeah yeah i've made that fun well done in answer to the question i'd love to see a slow horses black doves um crossover imagine that oh yeah that'll be fantastic but also would work tonally so well yeah because i was i mean obviously we cannot talk about the new series of black doves because it is embargoed but i was watching let's just say black doves the show and i'm not going to be season specific and say what i really like about it is that it has the like the actual plot is quite serious and thrillery, but it's delivered in the same way that Slow Horses is, with so much wit and humour and fun that it kind of skips along.
42:59Kay Ribeiro: And the use of London as well. Yes, yes, yes. Locations. The locations are extraordinary. But yes, I'm sure we will get into that when we chat with Joe tomorrow. By the way, when you introduce him tomorrow, can you do me a favour? Can you introduce him as a famous fan of a mid-table football team? famous fan of a mid-table football team. I may need you to remind me of that. I'm sure Joe will love that. Oh, God. Cue half the podcast being about Arsenal and Spurs. I think it's going to happen. It's going to happen. We'll touch on that. It will happen. Okay, let us see where we are. Do you know what?
43:33Kay Ribeiro: I'm going to get you, Kate, to be the arbiter of taste on something. Oh, my God. This has never been said to me on this podcast. Yes, indeed. This comes from John Armstrong, and John says, Hi, all. James, you are not going to like it, but Steph is right again. yes kill jackie is absolutely fine not prestige tv but good entertainment i would put it alongside the gentleman katherine zeta jones is eminently watchable daniel inges is a lot of fun as a lawyer out of his depth and if you do the rest of the episodes it has some emotional depth as well thought there was a bit more fridging than i prefer good needle drops and a solid northern soul reference in episode three now okay i'm gonna ask you to be the arbiter of taste except i i know you're just going to say, I have not watched Gil Jackie, aren't you?
44:16Kay Ribeiro: So you will not be able to. But have you watched it? Did you like it? Well, James, not for the first time. You've made an ass out of you and me because you've assumed, and I actually have watched the first episode. Oh, good. Excellent. What do you think of it? I enjoyed it. I thought I really liked her in that role, Catherine Zeta-Jones. I liked seeing her in that kind of, you know, the same way with Keely Hawes in The Assassin. I liked seeing these actresses taking on these badass roles. And I enjoyed it. I didn't think it was... I don't think it was... Did you think it was bad, James? or boring or I believe the term I used was rubbish oh no it's not rubbish you're rubbish but no I thought it was decent I enjoyed it I didn't think it was diabolical I thought it was perfectly decent yeah okay and I particularly liked her in it Catherine Zeta-Jones Death by Tom Jones that was the only part of it that I thought was and do you know I was about to say that's the only part I enjoyed I didn't enjoy that either so why are you being such a curmudgeon I don't know it's my natural way that is it for this week's postbag if you want to send in your messages, it is postbag at pilotTVpod.com.
45:17Kay Ribeiro: Now, as discussed, I am now going to engage the Traitors Amnesty section so that Boyd and Kay can discuss what has been happening in Celebrity Traitors. So, as is my understanding, every episode except the last one has aired and therefore this discussion will cover... No, the last two. If this goes out on Thursday, that Thursday evening will be when? I mean, obviously I knew that. Being the spokesperson for Celebrity Traitors, I obviously knew that. It was a test. It was a test. I was just making sure that you were listening. Do you even know what the iPlayer is? Of course, Boydie. It's the home of celebrity traitors and things like The Reluctant Vampire and Time and other great shows like Blue Lights.
45:53Kay Ribeiro: I'm honestly cringing for you. This DVD voice, I've now got to run off and listen to the new episode of Conan O 'Brien Needs a Friend. To be fair, he has got a good advert voice, but it's more I'm cringing at his hypocrisy. He's a rank hypocrisy. I don't know what you're referring to. In fact, do you know what? Lunch is on James with the money he lent from this. Oh yeah, that's a good switch. You can take a place to the IV. You assume I get paid for any of this. In the new episode, by the way, Conan O 'Brien's new episode, Olivia Colman's on. He's on a run of brilliant episodes. Olivia Colman's on this week.
46:24Talking Wicker, a.k.a. Fifty Shades of Hay. Exactly. Have you seen Wicker yet? No.
46:29Kay Ribeiro: Oh, okay. Fine. I feared I would get a splinter. Anyway, his show is brilliant. It's even more brilliant if it's got James popping up doing voiceover work. um that is brilliant yeah um right what were we gonna say yes yes we were gonna say celebrity traders so you can you can feel free to to okay a few minutes do this thing i should say for those of you who do not want to listen to this feel free to go yes i know that you're feeling oh my god amazing this is this is brilliant james feels he he has to give permission to the listeners to stop listening they need they need it they need they need to be allowed to go you know it's like school you know like when you when you say right class you've run the bell the teacher has to say when you leave.
47:08Kay Ribeiro: No one's allowed to turn off the podcast until they're given permission. James has rung the bell end. That is very much what's happened, although that's an upsetting image. Right, okay, go for it. Of course. Obviously, as the official spokesman for the show, I shall be listening very, very carefully. Yeah, sure. He goes on mutes and starts doing his emails. Right, Boydo, overall, what do you think of the quality? Do you love it this year as much as you loved it last year? Pretty much. I think it's been a bit different because the traitors have been so all power are formed, dominant, and I mean, as in, you know, they haven't laid a hand on them, you know, since the early days, since the current trio of traitors was formed, if you like, because it's James Acaster and joined.
47:51Maya Jarma and Kenny. And Kenny, of course, the greatest traitor of all time, certainly in the celebrity world. He's fantastic. He's so brilliant. Maya Jarma is also brilliant. So that trio is so firmly entrenched. and I think the peak moment when it was proven just what a brilliant job they're doing and how utterly, dementedly misguided the faithful are came in the 8th episode of 10 last week when the three of them were picked as being the most trustworthy, one of the legendary moments in Traders history that we're the last to discuss. You couldn't make that up. It was amazing. This is not up to date, especially by the way, James.
48:31This is quite non-up to date. Anyway. Good to know. I mean, of course, I do know. Yeah, that was such a funny, insane moment that summed up just how, and I can't see a way, you know, unless they bring in some radical new element to it in the penultimate, in the final two shows. Unless Richard E. Grant climbs the turret and comes back and spools it for everyone and just tells them who the traitors are. I mean, it could just be those three, you know, like walking off with the prize. I think there are further twists. I think I saw Claudia or someone involved in the show in The Guardian on Saturday saying, you know, there are surprises to come.
49:07And obviously they would say that anyway. But I think if you make a point of saying there's surprises to come, then there have to be some surprises. I think there has to be because it's an extended finale as well, isn't it? It's longer. Yeah, yeah. That's right, yeah. So, oh, I've loved it. Absolutely. It's different. It's been different to the first one. But that's what you want. You want them, you know, this will be remembered for having the most, a group of traitors that have been completely flown by without being barely, certainly up until now. Unless suddenly someone in the Penaltim episode, for example, suddenly decides to, there should be heat on one of the three to use traitors' parlance, then it will forever be remembered as just the series in which the traitors were untouchable and completely, you know, did such a superb job.
49:52I have enjoyed this series right I think my enjoyment increased on that episode that you talked about where they were all deemed to be the most um trustworthy and then they did that shield task building the shield task which was so I mean first of all James A. Hester refusing to get take part and then the creaking floorboard so at that point I started to enjoy it much more overall I'd say I haven't enjoyed it as much as last series it's been less I've been less obsessed and I put this down to the traitors are good now but the whole thing like I love I really liked Richard E. Grant and it was really funny obviously with him declaring he was a traitor and it was a funny moment right it's the moment of the series probably yeah but actually it was quite annoying because then he went out too quickly and we wasted the opportunity of having him I think if he was in the series still it would be even more memorable and even you know bigger moments and another thing that I think is a error and I don't know how they can stop this but I do think it's something that has taken away my enjoyment is having someone who so vocally and obviously doesn't want to be a traitor is really frustrating because actually up until that challenge where they um you know they were voted the three most uh faithful people I mean talking about calling it in James was and it's like you know you want traitors to be all in and excited and like they were last year and his sort of oh I'll play it as a faithful and I'll and but I will try and help it's just it just has I for me he's taken away some of my enjoyment of it but I think you've got a separate he's been incredibly annoying yeah I agree with you it's incredibly annoying that he's entered a show in which you're part of the part you might become a traitor and you might have to lie and obfuscate and he's and he went through and all the period yeah when he's in when he's talking about how painful it is for him to have to look.
51:42That's bullshit. But what I would say is that doesn't spoil my enjoyment of the show. That just has an interesting... It's been an interesting thread. Yes. And now, by the point we're at now, he's fine with it, right? He's fine with being a traitor now. Well, he is and he isn't. I mean, he... Oh, no, I think he's now arrived at a point where... Yeah, but he's not going to do anything maverick. He's not going to really relish it. He's going to just... But that's actually... Yeah, I don't... I think that adds to the layers of interest because it's a different way. If everyone was the same, if everyone's reaction to being a traitor was the same.
52:15No, of course. But it's actually worked out brilliantly for the traitors because he's gone completely under the radar again because he's behaving exactly as he was before he was a traitor. His behaviour has been the same all the way through, and I think that's totally worked in favour of the traitor. So for me, it's made it even more interesting. So he's irritating. I find it annoying. him annoying what the approach is taking but as in the interest in the show I don't think it's diminished that at all for me I'd say it was untenable for me until Kenny turned up because then he's made him and Maya together are greatest traitors and I think he's helped ramp up the situation oh completely because otherwise Maya was like doing all the heavy lifting and I don't think it was fair or particularly entertaining to watch but yeah but we've had those three for a while I don't know how many episodes anyway the two other things I want of note okay I want to say is that I was obsessed with Gerry Hall yeah my boys I thought she was great fantastic never knowing what's going on and yeah it was a blow when she went but also I've been on a journey with Ross Kemp so when he first started not many people say that yeah when it first started I was like was he in Afghanistan or Iraq he's a parody of himself yeah you know when he was saying to Claudia once you've looked in the eyes of the cartel I was like oh my god please have a word did you see Did you see the Traitors Uncloaked episode with him in it?
53:42No. Oh, my God, you've got to see it. He literally starts the discussion by saying, I've faced people in Iraq. And he lists all the country, and Afghanistan, and Iran, and Kazakhstan. He literally lists with a totally straight face. He's not joking. The people he's met in his time making documentaries about extreme. And it's so funny. His lack of self-awareness is so brilliant. He is the David Brent of the show. He completely is. He's a modern celebrity, really. He is. And so at first I was like, oh, God, this is ridiculous. You know, when he was talking to Claudia about, you know, the cartels and stuff, and then his over-the-top reactions at the round table when they won, you know, like testosterone.
54:26However, do you know what? So, James, basically Ross Kemp was being played by the traitors. So they were putting heat on him, making him seem like he was a traitor. And he was like almost drowning in a pool of his paranoia because he was like, I'm not a traitor. And the more he said it, everyone was thinking he was. And he was like close to combusting. And do you know what happened then, Boyd? I actually started to feel sorry for him. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because he was so crestfallen and so devastated that people would think that he was like... Yeah, he still is. Yeah, he still is. And so that's my journey with him.
54:52I've actually started to feel sorry for him. Well, there's no point in even addressing James at this point. He's not going to, he's not engaging. Well, Boyd, obviously I know all this naturally. So I don't need to hear about it
55:01Kay Ribeiro: because I know it. Doing your voice over ads. I was trying to help him out for future endorsements of traitors to make it. The one person we haven't mentioned, the one person who at this point in time, and by the time this goes out, actually, well, it'll be the day of the penultimate episode. But I think what could happen is Romesh could hold the key because he's stood back in terms of trying to work out who the traitors are. And I think he might be the one who takes at least one or two of them down in the final. Yeah, I think so. Yeah, he's smart. He's doing the workings in the background. Yes, and the fact that he's made it this far has also added to the entertainment value.
55:38He's been as good value as we'd expect, as huge fans, and let's face it, friends of Ramesh Rangir Nathan. And he's delivered 100%. And I think he, yeah, I'd be fascinated to know how he works in the last two episodes. Yeah. I do wish Rob had stayed in longer. That's me. Yeah, but... That would have been nice. Yeah, it would have been nice, but it's not. I still think I think this is the more I think about it now that we've had this discussion the more I think it has been a brilliant series different to the last one we should say also Boyd hosted the Tracers launch I am in the pocket of big Tracers yeah that's true both of them James and Boyd are I'm the only faithful yeah that's true you're right yeah so yeah can't wait to see what happens in the last two episodes it's going to be absolutely brilliant and it is a mega we should say a mega you know gigantic phenomenon 15 million people watched that first episode.
56:28So I think the Richard E. Grant factor has actually been helped to because that is such an insane moment that it's become iconic and famous up and down the country, even if you don't watch the show. So I think that has made it an even bigger hit, really. I think it's been worth it, if you like, for him to exit early because now you've got, you know, 15 million people fucking watching it every week. Kind of because of that, because that was such an outrageous thing to begin with. I think it's had an incredible effect. So, yeah. The show is bigger. even than this podcast.
56:59Kay Ribeiro: Is it now? Not possible. It has been a delight listening to you talk about celebrity traitors. And if you're loving all the betrayals and backstabbing inside the cast, you'll certainly enjoy watching Ed Gamble and guests discussing it all in the Celebrity Traitors Unclosed, which provides an essential debrief after every show. Ridiculous. So now we know. The secret is that when James says we've got to rearrange the podcast with half a day's notice, which happens quite a lot. He has to go in to the studio and do something vague. What he means is get lucrative cash for these fucking voiceovers about a show he's never seen in his life.
57:37I don't know what you're talking about. I'm an expert on all things traitor. The lack of self-awareness here is really giving shades of Ross Kemp. I am the Ross Kemp of this podcast.
57:45Kay Ribeiro: Similar vibe as well, actually, now that I think about it. Thank you. Let's not get baldest. I believe we're done with this episode of the Pilot TV podcast, even if we have been phoning it in. We will be back in your ears on Monday with the main show. Darren, can you take me out? We will be reviewing Sherlock and Daughter, which we already know what Kay thinks about. There's no point doing that. We will be reviewing Tall Tales and Murder and Yaga. Yes, indeed. And Joe Barton will be on the podcast talking about Black Doves season two and presumably mid-table football. Exciting times. See you then.
58:19Kay Ribeiro: Pilot out.
58:23You
We’re faced with a terrifying psychopath this week… and not just because Kay Ribeiro returns to the fold, but because Stephen Graham sheds his scouse tones and moves to Pennsylvania to play deranged (yet softly spoken) serial killer Jurek Walter in Nocturne on Apple TV+. Elsewhere, Boyd performs a drive-by on a national treasure, the postbag offers up musings on The Pacific as well as James’ rank hypocrisy and normal pod rules are suspended for a Celebrity Traitors amnesty period at the very end of the show. Apologies in advance.
Want your messages read out as part of The Postbag? Email us at [email protected]