


The episode covers a cluster of geopolitical and security developments, centered on Trump’s Asia trip and a “Yalta 2.0” trilateral meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, plus fallout from the NVIDIA/Jensen Huang scandal involving alleged ties to a Chinese spy and alleged export-control evasion. It also discusses escalating U.S.-Iran tensions (drone attacks, nuclear concerns, and whistleblower claims about U.S. base security), and broader implications for AI regulation and U.S.-China relations.
No guest interview appears in the provided transcript. Hosts are Tommy Vietor and Ben Rhodes.
Not applicable (no guests).
Trump’s trilateral summit is framed as ego/pomp with little substantive payoff; Ukraine and Taiwan are notably absent from the public agenda. The NVIDIA scandal is portrayed as exposing a rupture in Trump administration AI/china export-control policy, with Commerce (Howard Lutnick) allegedly failing to enforce rules while other “hawks” push harder. A new export-control licensing rule is described as a partial crackdown on chip smuggling and China’s access via third-country data centers. Iran’s posture review and drone attacks are treated as signs the war could widen; whistleblower testimony alleges serious U.S. planning failures.
FAA/major tech outages; Megaspeed/Alice Wong; Megaspeed’s alleged role in smuggling NVIDIA chips; proposed restrictions on data-center access in countries like Singapore; Iran drone attacks on U.S. sites in Bahrain; Major Stephen Ramsbottom’s whistleblower complaint.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts Tommy Vitor and Ben Rhodes discuss recent major outages and their implications.
Hosts explore the causes and implications of recent technological outages and their potential links to cyber issues.
“So Ben, in the last couple of days, we've had a nationwide FAA ground stop.”
Discussion on Trump's meetings with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, and what the trip means for U.S. foreign policy.
“We're going to talk to you today about a bunch of different stuff.”
Exploration of Trump's agenda during his meetings, including denuclearization and its challenges.
“consequential for the future of European politics.”
Hosts analyze the implications of Trump's meetings with authoritarian leaders on global security and alliances.
“counter China, but not talking about the biggest issue when it comes to US, China, export controls, artificial intelligence.”
Discussion comparing Trump's approach to foreign relations with previous administrations, particularly Obama's.
“And we're just not going to get anything in return other than, you know, some content, I guess, Tommy, for people like you and me.”
Discussion on Trump's relations with Kim Jong-un and the implications of his meetings.
“being a lame duck is like, I'm going to be super busy.”
Exploration of the scandal involving former NVIDIA CEO and its broader implications.
“On last week's episode, we talked about reports that Jensen Wong was having an affair with the CEO of a company called Megaspeed.”
The discussion explores the timeline and implications of the Commerce Department's investigation into Megaspeed and its regulatory challenges.
“I'm also curious, like, what was the intelligence community's assessment or the actual professionals of commerce, their assessment of Megaspeed, you know?”
The hosts analyze the impact of Trump's statements on AI regulation and the resulting boom in the industry.
“Like, the night this show runs Wednesday, I'm going to be here in Rice University, my alma mater, giving a talk on AI in the age of authoritarianism.”
The conversation shifts to new export controls aimed at restricting China's access to advanced AI technology.
“So it does feel like this is kind of a, you know, a pivot point in some ways in terms of just, we've had all these outages that we just talked about at the beginning of the show.”
The hosts speculate on how China might react to new U.S. regulations and the broader implications for U.S.-China relations.
“So on Monday, the Trump administration announced a major new rule that will create a licensing requirement to sell chips to data centers in countries with high risk of smuggling.”
The hosts discuss recent developments in Iran's military strategy and actions against U.S. forces.
“Trump, you know, as we heard that clip, he says it's all handled, but we're still striking targets in the Gulf.”
Discussion on recent Iranian drone attacks and military oversight failures.
“Over the weekend, the Iranians fired a bunch of drones at U.S.”
Insights into Iran's potential threats and the implications of their nuclear program.
“And frankly, it's not like CENCOM has been particularly forthcoming either.”
Examination of Prime Minister Andy Burnham's comments on Brexit and its global implications.
“threats, but like, you just would need a gun.”
Analyzing Andy Burnham's approach to Brexit and potential future directions for the UK.
“So Ben, Burnham's going to meet with some other European leaders later this week.”
Discussion on the Senate leadership race and the differing foreign policy views of Schumer and Van Hollen.
“the position that is correct here, which is that Brexit, like the Trump election, was an insane thing to do.”
Exploration of how the Senate leadership change could affect U.S. foreign policy.
“foreign policy from that perch if you were to get it?”
Explore the contrast in foreign policy perspectives within the Democratic Party.
“gulag that Trump was sending people to at the beginning when people were a little bit tentative to engage in those fights.”
Discuss Spain's political climate and its connection to global movements.
“I'm very pleased to be joined by the foreign minister of Spain, Jose Manuel Alvarez.”
Explore how Spain has taken a leadership role in foreign policy, supporting multilateralism and human rights.
“and therefore easier to intervene, which is the democratic elections.”
Discuss the potential changes in Spanish foreign policy under a conservative government and the implications for national identity.
“because we were able to continue standing up to our values.”
Examine Spain's approach to managing migration flows and the role of cooperation with African countries.
“They say in themselves, it will be huge.”
Analyze the contrasting models of society being presented in the Spanish election regarding growth, rights, and migration.
“And even our entrepreneurs demand in order to keep up our growth.”
Discussion on the rise of the far right in Europe and its implications.
“Yeah, and it does feel like a kind of pivotal time for Europe, right?”
The hosts express solidarity and support for progressive movements in Spain.
“Well, look, I know you've got a tough fight on your hands, but Pedro Sanchez has been in those positions before and managed to pull it out.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Pod Save the World, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00The Pods of the world is brought to you by Z-Biotics. I love Z-Biotics. You know I do. I brought a few to CrookedCon. I think it saved me. It made me a much more coherent and better person on Sunday and also during lots of the different days because I will not have a drink without taking a Z-Biotics. It is a pre-alcohol probiotic drink. It's the world's first genetically engineered probiotic. Z-Biotics was engineered by PhD microbiologists to break down acyltaldehyde, an unwanted byproduct of alcohol metabolism. What you do is you make pre-alcohol your first drink of the night, you drink responsibly, and then you enjoy your next day's activities because you're feeling great.
0:38Z-Biotics has sold more than 15 million bottles and earned the trust of thousands, including us. Again, I literally will not have a drink without having a Z-Biotics first. For me, it is the most effective on those nights when you go out with friends for dinner during the week, you have maybe one drink too many, you don't want to pay for it the next day. So Z-Biotics is the way to just take care of it and make you feel better. The holiday season is officially here. And if you're anything like me, your social calendar is filling up fast. From Friendsgiving to the turkey trout the next morning, these are the moments you don't want to miss.
1:10That's why I make Z-Biotics pre-alcohol part of my routine before drinking. That's the best part of the holidays. It's being present for all of it. Try ZBiotics pre-alcohol for yourself. And if you're not satisfied, they'll refund your entire order. No questions asked. Head to zbiotics.com slash PSTW. Use the code PSTW for 15 % off your first order. That's zbiotics.com slash PSTW code PSTW. All right, all right, turn it up. This next track by Crown Royal, it's got a way of getting everybody together. So grab your people, grab a glass, and play this one loud. You got gold. So bring it, bring it, bring it.
1:50I said you got gold. So just bring it, bring it, bring it in. This track is brought to you by Crown Royal. Please drink responsibly. I said you got gold.
2:02Ben Rhodes: So just bring it, bring it in.
2:17Welcome back to Pod Save the World. I'm Tommy Vitor. I'm Ben Rhodes. So Ben, in the last couple of days, we've had a nationwide FAA ground stop. I think Microsoft has been down. A bunch of people couldn't access their bank accounts. Apple services were out today. There's reports that the NSA's communication system had also gone down. But President Trump wants you to know that he is on it. Are you concerned about all these outages? Microsoft, FAA, United, Chiefs, Thanks.
2:42Ben Rhodes: It's life. When you're big and powerful and you have all the money, things like that happen. It's fine. Hey, that's life. That's life, buddy. It's all just a coincidence. You feeling good about all this? No, Tommy. I'm buying water and beef jerky and some kind bars over here. Hannah's like literally planning Costco runs. There's text chains. People are panicking and getting calls from people who are like, do you know anyone? I'm like, no, they don't like me. I worked for Obama. They hate my guts. I hate it when they ask me that. Of course, they don't like me. Do you know anything? No. It will make it worse if I intervene on your behalf.
3:14Ben Rhodes: I do not believe in coincidences as a general rule as I get older. And I certainly don't believe in this many. It does feel like whether it's one state actor, a non-state actor or something, it's some combination of updates, AI coming online, hackers. There's a whole bunch of stuff happening. Unfortunately, I think this might be our new normal, though. So that's my reason for being a little alarmist here with the beef jerky. Yeah, I mean, look, maybe what happens is there's one outage we otherwise might not see a report about it. So then there's a bunch more reporting about outages we also wouldn't have learned about.
3:49And it feels like more than a coincidence. But also we spent the last, what, year or two being told that one of the things that AI is going to do is expose software vulnerabilities and make us all more susceptible to cyber hacks, like whatever. and then all of a sudden there's a whole bunch of like pretty weird outages and cyber issues and security issues all in a row. And it's like, I don't know. It doesn't feel like a huge leap.
4:13Ben Rhodes: Yeah. I mean, there's a lot happening at once, right? These systems are shifting to AI. AI is getting better at offensive cyber. Humans are being taken out of certain loops. Like, I think we're in a kind of technological transformation in which people forgot what the transformation is going to feel like. And so far, it's a little anxiety ridden. We got Sean Duffy and Mark Wayne Mullen keeping us safe here. Yes, I feel better about that. Me too. All right. We're going to talk to you today about a bunch of different stuff. So we got Trump. He's on the road. He's in Asia for some symmetry. And he's got a little menage a trois with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, Russian President Vladimir Putin.
4:51I'm sure that'll be a good time. We're going to update you on all the latest with the now former NVIDIA CEO, Jensen Wong. So we got his alleged relationship with the Chinese spy. But, you know, in the days since we've last talked about this, it has already had a huge impact on U.S. policy and the U.S.-China relations. So we'll walk you through that. We'll tell you about some disconcerting developments in the simmering U.S. war with Iran, some very interesting comments about Brexit from the new British Prime Minister Andy Burnham, the potential foreign policy implications of a leadership challenge in the U.S.
5:22Senate on the Democratic Party side. Interesting. And then, Ben, I want to see if you have any hope for the COP31 climate change summit that's happening right now. I can't say I do, but you were just in Turkey. So I'm hoping you could say something to me that will make me feel better.
5:35Ben Rhodes: The hopeful thing would be if you saw the people that I met with who are about 30 younger activists, policy people, who are in our Obama Foundation network, because they're all still working this thing hard, right? So the hope is in the people that are still working it. The lack of hope is in the combination of recalcitrant governments and fossil fuel lobbyists that populate the hallways of COP these days. Yeah. Well, at least this one wasn't in a petro state. And then Ben, you did our interview today. What are we going to hear? Yes. We are coming up on the Spanish election, as you know, in a couple of weeks.
6:10Ben Rhodes: And we're obviously fans of the Sanchez government in Spain. So I talked to the Spanish foreign minister about the state of the election, about the independent and progressive foreign policy that Spain has carved out on issues like Israel and Palestine, how they're dealing with migration, which has obviously been one of the issues that the far right has tried to explore, kind of the future of Europe, which is on everybody's mind, and in particular, the future of the far right and the stakes in the Spanish election as the kind of kickoff to this another year of elections that are going to be very consequential for the future of European politics.
6:45Ben Rhodes: So check that out. And if you're in Spain, Vote organized. You can do what we did here in this country. Let's keep the blue wave rolling here. Blue wave going around the world. Okay, we are recording this on Tuesday, November 17th. So today, Trump was in the Philippines for an ASEAN meeting. By the way, get ready for just a bloodbath of acronyms. I apologize in advance. ASEAN is the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, 11 countries in the region. Technically, the ASEAN meeting started Sunday, but Trump skipped all the substantive stuff, and he landed in Manila just in time for a photo op with the Quad.
7:20The Quad is what dorks call a meeting with the leaders from Australia, India, Japan, and the U.S. Then he had a little dinner. He did a courtesy call with his host, President Marcos. And then he heads to China for APEC. APEC is the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Forum. That meeting is in Shenzhen, China. That's their hub of AI and robotics work. And while there, Trump is going to have a bilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and then the trilateral meeting on Thursday with Xi and Russian President Vladimir Putin. So again, sounds like a good time. The big question I have, Ben, is what is the point of all of this or any of it?
7:54On Thursday, or before Trump left, I think it was on Monday, a reporter tried asking Trump what he wanted to get out of the trilateral meeting in particular. Here is what he described as the agenda. We're going to talk about denuclearization. Tough subject because it's very hard for any of us to say we'll get rid of our nukes, right? but especially since you do have other countries.
8:14Ben Rhodes: But we're going to be talking about denuclearization. We'll talk about Iran. We have Iran in very good shape. But we'll talk about Iran a little bit. We'll talk about my favorite subject, Ukraine. Ukraine's losing, Ukraine-Russia is losing 25 ,000 soldiers a month. So we'll be talking about that. We'll all be talking about economics and trade. My favorite subject, 25 ,000 people are dying a month. A couple of quick things. So it's notable that Ukraine is now on the agenda. I think the White House had previously said it would not be part of the conversation, which would have frankly made more sense because Ukraine's not there.
8:49The Europeans aren't there. The Chinese don't really care that much about Ukraine. Trump did not mention Taiwan. That's a win for Xi Jinping. Trump also says previously that he wouldn't raise Jensen Wang or the NVIDIA scandal that we'll get into in a minute. But it's sort of funny that like they're talking, they're going around the country or going around the world trying to pull people into this packed silica AI compact thing that's supposed to counter China, but not talking about the biggest issue when it comes to US, China, export controls, artificial intelligence. And then on the nuclear stuff, like I guess I don't get why Trump is raising expectations about nuclear talks with the Chinese, since the Chinese have been quite clear that they don't want to have them yet.
9:28But then I guess it gets back to the question, like, what do you think Trump wants out of the trip? What do you think substantively he might get out of this? Anything?
9:38Ben Rhodes: Look, we've talked before about the kind of fantasy camp quality to Trump and his officials, you know, Kash Patel going around the world on, you know, boondoggles, actually quite literally to the boondoggle ranch. This feels like Trump's fantasy camp, like he's in his lame duck final turnaround the track. And he's always wanted to be at a meeting that's like, I don't know, Yalta, except it's him and Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. I mean, I literally think this is just to satiate his ego, to have him feel like he's sitting at the big boy dictator club that he's always wanted to be a part of. Because look, sure, I guess you could have a substantive agenda.
10:22Ben Rhodes: And the issues you would focus on would be norms and rules around the use of artificial intelligence and nuclear command and control and weapon systems. Or you'd be focusing, yeah, perhaps on peace and security issues in Asia or something. But he's not going to do that. I mean, actually, it's nice to hear him raise denuclearization. The US, China, and Russia should be talking about arms control. The reality, though, is that Trump is the one that, you know, helped tear up the final edifice. I mean, for the first time since 1974, we have no nuclear arms control agreement with Russia since the New START agreement expired a couple years ago.
11:04Ben Rhodes: And China's modernizing its nuclear arsenal, so is the United States, so is Russia. But does anybody really believe that Trump and his administration is going to roll up their sleeves and do this intricate work of negotiating arms control agreements on a triadual basis with Russia and China? No. And you got—so I don't see any upside beyond Trump's ego and fantasy camp of it all. And there's real downside because you mentioned Ukraine. This is their worst nightmare, not just Ukraine, but all of our European allies. The idea that the president of the United States is going to sit down with Putin, the aggressor, Xi Jinping, who has basically kept the Russian war machine and technological base intact through the war in Ukraine.
11:43Ben Rhodes: She's on a side and it's Russia's side. He's going to sit there and talk to them about ending the war. He's going to be talking about Ukraine's future sovereignty and territories. He's going to talk about European security without them there. So there's a real cost to Trump doing this. It's going to alienate countries. It's going to make them think the U.S. is not reliable. And we're just not going to get anything in return other than, you know, some content, I guess, Tommy, for people like you and me. Yeah, I mean, Putin gets the international legitimacy of having this big trilateral meeting just a couple of years after he was kind of excommunicated from the international world because he invaded Ukraine.
12:17She gets the prestige of being at the, like, Yalta 2.0 photo. As you said, Trump gets to hang with his favorite people, the autocrats. Ukraine gets fucked. The Europeans get fucked. Taiwan gets fucked. Who knows what side deals are getting inked? Like, I guess we'll find out. And then there's going to be a bilat with Xi. I mean, I imagine there's going to be lots of pomp and circumstance and tease and photos and things that like kind of look interesting. The Chinese will probably pretend that they're going to announce a process on something that Trump wants, right? Like kill him with like more meetings and processes and dialogues, but not actually commit to anything and just string them along until there's the next Congress.
12:54I do think at some point they're going to have to decide again to extend out like the trade war detente that has just been kind of punted, you know, every six months or whatever. But beyond that, I don't know that there's much more they're trying to accomplish.
13:08Ben Rhodes: Yeah. And we should be clear, you know, you and I have been on a couple of post-midterm, or I've been on two post-midterm trips. You were on one. You know, other countries pay very careful attention to our politics. This is not news to listeners to this podcast. And everybody will have just seen the absolute pasting that Trump just took. It diminishes him. It diminishes all these clowns around him like Marco Rubio and Scott Besant. They know that Trump's days are numbered and the Democrats are on the ascent in Washington. They're probably looking to kind of dust off the phone book to find the Democratic phone numbers that they have.
13:44Ben Rhodes: And look, you know, Obama, I remember after we lost, not nearly as badly, but did lose the midterm election in 2014, part of how we dealt with that is we actually went to China right after. And the way he dealt with it is he wanted to do something very substantive. And we actually negotiated the bilateral climate agreement that became the cornerstone of Paris. And so the way that Obama dealt with being a lame duck is like, I'm going to be super busy. I'm going to be super detailed. I'm going to get some shit done. Trump just feels like, you know, again, he wants the protocol. He wants the pomp.
14:13Ben Rhodes: And yet he's this kind of diminished figure. Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin both know they're going to be sitting in their chairs after Trump's gone, you know? And so is his buddy Kim Jong-un, who's been making noises about seeing. Well, let's talk about Kim. Trump is like so desperate for another meeting with Kim. And like he keeps dangling the possibility to the press. And again, Ben, I don't know why. It's like, well, first of all, it's not clear what he would want to discuss. And the timing is like exquisitely bad after the North Koreans just stole$6.5 billion from Binance, the cryptocurrency exchange.
14:43Like, let's reward you with this meeting. I don't know how the logistics would work. Like, I guess the Chinese could send a plane for Kim and bring him to Shenzhen. Like, it's a long train ride. We know Mr. Kim prefers his train ride. That's a long train ride from North Korea to Shenzhen. Trump could fly to North Korea. He could fly to Seoul and kind of, like, drop this problem on the South Koreans. I don't think that's going to happen. But again, it's like, what's the point besides he just thinks it will get a lot of attention and the press will show up? Like, is there anything beyond that that you've seen?
15:11I really don't.
15:12Ben Rhodes: I mean, that's what's so weird about this. I mean, it's funny with Kim Jong-un of it all because, you know, I dabble in right-wing media, Tommy. Like, I know you have a similar habit. But am I missing someplace where people think it's really cool that he gets along with Kim Jong-un? No, no one. It may be that back in 2018, he did get such positive and weirdly credulous press coverage. And it's like frozen in time that that was like a win for him. And he's trying to kind of squeeze some more juice out of that lemon. But the reality is in 2018, he met to talk about denuclearization, right? The same big word he just used.
15:48Ben Rhodes: And since 2018, Kim has done nothing but accelerate his nuclear missile programs. And he's been a belligerent in the war in Ukraine. And he's stealing billions of dollars worth of cyber assets from the United States. Kim is not going to give Trump anything. So I guess he just wants to meet one more dictator for the ride. Yeah. And by the way, Kim is doing pretty well. I mean, he's got a lot of money from the crypto theft. He's also got this great partnership with the Russians, and he's helping them kill Ukrainians. So he's doing great. He doesn't need another meeting. Trump just really seems to want one.
16:27Pod Save the World is brought to you by Quince. The MVPs of your wardrobe are the pieces you can always count on, whether you're heading to work, going out, or keeping things casual. In this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy. Find something for yourself and everyone else on your list this holiday season at Quince. Quince crafts timeless, high-quality staples using premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere, 14-karat gold, and Italian leather. Their cashmere sweater started at just$60, and they also have incredible down jackets, wool coats, and accessories for the whole family.
16:58Everything is 50 % to 80 % less than traditional luxury brands because they work directly with ethical factories and skip the middleman. I've gotten a ton of things from Quince. I've gotten workout shirts and everyday stuff. I got cashmere sweaters for some loved ones in a recent Christmas. My kids even wear Quince stuff. They have great like leggings for kids. I got a great pair of shoes there. And so there's just a million different options. And when it comes to gifting, Quince has a lot more than clothing. They have fine jewelry, leather bags, hotel quality bedding, cookware, great luggage, all the things you want for someone special in your life.
17:34Give the gift of quality this holiday season and download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, please let them know it was Pod Save the World. It's the best way to support the show. This podcast is sponsored by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all-in-one website platform designed to elevate your online presence and drive your success. Squarespace gives you the tools to claim your domain, build a professional website, expand your brand, and facilitate payments all in one place.
18:08With Squarespace's collection of cutting-edge design tools, anyone can build a bespoke online presence that perfectly fits their business. Start with Blueprint AI, Squarespace's AI-enhanced website builder, to get a fully custom website in just a few steps, using basic information about your industry, your goals, and your personality to generate premium quality content and personalized design recommendations. Every dream needs a domain. Squarespace Domains makes it easy to find the best name for your business at one fair, all-inclusive price. No hidden fees or add-ons required. Squarespace provides everything you need to bring more of your dream to life, whether that means building a website or adding a professional email service.
18:44Don't wait to claim your name. Invest in your dream domain today. Head to squarespace.com for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash world to save 10 % off your first purchase of a website or domain. That's squarespace.com slash world.
19:04All right, Ben, so a lot has happened with NVIDIA CEO, now former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Wong, since we talked last week. On last week's episode, we talked about reports that Jensen Wong was having an affair with the CEO of a company called Megaspeed. That was a big problem because U.S. intelligence reportedly thinks that the Megaspeed CEO, the confusingly named Alice Wong, no relation, that she is a Chinese spy or Chinese asset of some sort. Even if she is not, Megaspeed almost certainly is involved in the smuggling of NVIDIA products to China and the breaking of U.S. export control laws. So there's a lot of problems ahead for Jensen Wong here.
19:40So Ben and I, in that episode, we said we expected the NVIDIA board to just try to whitewash this incident, you know, create a report, punt it down the road six months, and leave Jensen Wong in place. That was not quite accurate. And our team here at Pod Save the World believes in one thing, which is accountability. And they wanted to make clear just how wrong we were. So they put together this for us. So what probably happens here, they hire a law firm to do an investigation. The investigation kind of whitewashes over the problem. They release some bullshit statement in five or six months. And nothing changes, in part because he has Trump's backing.
20:17Ben Rhodes: I guess what they'll hang their hat on is that he wasn't aware of this. Thank you, Michael, for that. I was going to say, Michael or Anisha, I don't know. It feels like Michael to me. Everyone involved. Look, accountability is very important. In our defense, after we recorded, we learned that Jensen Wong was also having an affair with not one but two of his employees. So that probably helped precipitate him getting the boot. But the fallout has gone well beyond NVIDIA. It has exposed this rupture within the Trump administration about AI policy, China, and export controls. Specifically, you've got Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and the Commerce Department on one side doing some weird stuff and doing absolutely nothing to crack down on efforts to evade these U.S.
21:00export controls when it comes to NVIDIA chips. And then you've got the hawks on the other side, like Scott Besson, Marco Rubio, the trade rep, the NSC staff, who are furious at Lutnick. Here's a clip of Treasury Secretary Scott Besson throwing Lutnick under the bus on TV, and then Trump commenting on those internal tensions. Let's watch. There have been reports that there was some tension between you and Secretary Lutnick about why Megaspeed was not placed on the entity list. And I'm just wondering about the interagency coordination. Treasury, Ward, USTR and state were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the entity list for months.
21:43But Commerce has the pin. Commerce BIS has the pin. And you will have to ask them about their internal processes. Secretary Besson argued that it was Lutnick who delayed putting Megaspeed on that threat list.
21:57Ben Rhodes: He might have delayed it, but he was doing that because you could have, if you didn't delay it, if you did do something, you could have a blow up with China. We're having a very good relationship with China right now, and I understand both sides of it. So, yeah, the pissy cadaver there, Scott Besson letting him know how he feels about Lutnick. Like, why don't we pause there, Ben? What do you make of the kind of reporting we've heard about the split within the Trump administration on this policy and what it maybe tells us about Trump's approach to China generally? Yeah, I mean, first, just two quick things.
22:28Ben Rhodes: One is this backing away from Alice Wong being a spy or a Chinese asset that seems led by, like, David Sachs. The reporting was pretty specific, Tommy. It was like, you know, intercepted communications of her talking to, like, Chinese military intelligence and stuff. I mean, I don't have it in front of me, but it seemed fairly specific, never mind the fact that, you know, she was clearly worshiping her. Did you see the journal piece today that her husband is setting up massive data centers in China that are all backed with state money while he introduced his wife to Jensen Wong and was aware of the affair?
23:02Ben Rhodes: Yeah. Okay. So I'm not conceding the point there. I mean, I'm not telling him how to get married or, you know, how to live. Hey, you know, maybe it's an open marriage. It's fine. The other thing is that we were profoundly wrong. I appreciate the accountability. Same. I do wonder what the board knows, right? Because they moved very quick. And it made me wonder, you know, they may have had, whether it was his conduct at NVIDIA, whether it was the nature of this relationship. I'd be curious whether they have more information. So put a pin in that. And I think Jensen Wong could face some real legal problems going forward.
23:38If he was facilitating or turning a blind eye to U.S. export controls being broken, I mean, breaking American law, period.
23:45Ben Rhodes: Exactly, right? And the board is maybe like, oh, we don't want a piece of that. Because now there's this move to, like, bring him back, which is, you know, Trump is leading, of course. Good luck with that, yeah. Which leads to your question. I mean, this—first of all, Scott Besson, you know, soybean farmer, you know, human cadaver. It is very weird to just be that frank about, like, interagency discussions. And it does feel, though, like that is accurate. Yeah. And look, this whole Trump policy on both AI and China, like a bunch of other things, feels completely ad hoc. So, like, where I differ with Besson is I don't think this is like a normal interagency process where at multiple levels are like meetings to tee up decisions.
24:27Ben Rhodes: It feels like who's in Trump's ear? Who's doing a side deal? Who's on the take? Like, you know, Jensen Wang can make a couple calls to Lutnik and to Trump and just completely sidestep the entire U.S. government. That's part of the reason why it's so dangerous that he had this relationship is because Jensen Wang could probably call Trump and Lutnik and be like, hey, get Treasury off my ass. You know, that's not how the system is supposed to work. And so the reason that Democrats need to oversight, not just of the administration, but also of NVIDIA and Jensen Wang, is to know how this was operating.
25:01Ben Rhodes: What were their side deals? Were people around Lutnik or Trump or their families profiting off of this kind of chip business? Was Jensen Wang able to go directly from, I don't know, hanging out with a potential Chinese spy to calling the president of the United States to influence policy? This is a fucking massive, massive scandal. Yeah, and look, Besson is right there. Commerce does have the pen when it comes to implementing these export controls. And it seems like at best, commerce was captured by NVIDIA, by the AI chip industry in the U.S. And just kind of like, according to a bunch of reporting about commerce's role, I mean, commerce was aware of whatever this intelligence was about Jensen Wong.
25:42So they got past intelligence that seems to have said the CEO of Megaspeed was a Chinese spy, but commerce didn't move to cut off their chip access. Someone explain that one to me. Lutnik reportedly just repeatedly ignored Trump's direct order to put in place stricter export controls on NVIDIA chips to prevent them from getting to China. At best, commerce stopped enforcing the rules or stopped adding new names or entities to the list that bans them from getting these chips. There were all these weird reports of like wildly inappropriate interventions by political staff at commerce with the kind of law enforcement function of the Commerce Department.
26:21Usually those things are walled off from the political staff and walled off from the White House. It sounds like the undersecretary at Commerce was also talking to NVIDIA about those investigations, which is crazy. There was also, we also know that the Commerce Department rescinded the Biden era rules that would have prevented Megaspeed from like existing basically or getting these chips in the first place. And then you mentioned the corruption piece. I mean, Cantor Fitzgerald, which is Howard Lutnick's old company, is now run by his kids. They're the broker to finance these data center projects in Asia that were getting built with, you know, advanced NVIDIA chips that the Chinese were then accessing.
26:57So, like, there's so much smoke here for the oversight community in Congress to look at.
27:01Ben Rhodes: That's right. I mean, all that is spot on. And because I'd say this, like, I think this is an interesting question about, like, how flexible these rules should be about chips and AI moving out in the world because they're going to move out in the world, you know. And you don't want it to be too onerous. But on the other end of that equation, though, and this gets to your point about oversight, Megaspeed didn't look like, based on the reading I've done and I know you've done, it wasn't that hard to figure out what was going on here, right? You had a woman who'd been like a state newscaster suddenly running an AI chip business in Singapore where the chips seemed to be going in one door and out the back door to the Chinese, like exactly what you worry about without a big employee footprint in Singapore, with all this money coming from China.
27:51Ben Rhodes: And the reason I make that point is that the U.S. intelligence community, I assume, monitors these kinds of things. It is, you know, everybody's focused on like, what did Trump know? And when do you know it? I'm also curious, like, what was the intelligence community's assessment or the actual professionals of commerce, their assessment of Megaspeed, you know? Because my guess is that that was kicking around the government for a while. And so then the question becomes, was Howard Lutnick or Trump or somebody around Trump just kind of like shunting this stuff in a drawer, trying to pretend like it wasn't there because it was inconvenient to whatever interest they had with Jensen Wong, you know?
28:26Yeah, I mean, Ben, the Commerce Department's sort of timeline of what they knew about Megaspeed makes no sense. So they said they started an investigation into Megaspeed in 2024. Then they handed it off to DOJ, but they put Megaspeed on like an internal no-trade blacklist in June of 2025. but Megaspeed seemed to be getting NVIDIA chips into 2026. So the question is, why not put them on the entity list? Like that is the official blacklist of individuals or entities who can't get certain American technologies. It exists for this exact reason. For this purpose, yeah. If they were investigating, if they handed it off to DOJ for some reason, why would you not just take the official step that mattered?
29:07Like clearly someone prevented that from happening.
29:08Ben Rhodes: Yeah, and look, this is going to be two years of oversight. And it's important because it's important to trying to get the policy right going forward. And it's also important, obviously, for accountability, as we demonstrate here on Potsay the World. I would also say, like, an interesting thing is on my mind, Tommy, and super organic plug. Like, the night this show runs Wednesday, I'm going to be here in Rice University, my alma mater, giving a talk on AI in the age of authoritarianism. Like, very on brand for me. So come to Rice if you're in Houston. But the point I want to make is that the moment at the All In Pod Summit, when Jensen Wong took the phone call from Trump on speaker and just trashed the idea of regulating AI and there's Jensen Wong in the black leather jacket and then Trump goes to the UN and says, we're not going to regulate it.
29:56Ben Rhodes: We're going to call it superintelligence. I actually think that was probably like the high watermark for the complete unregulated bonanza of AI and data centers and chips. You know, like the first years of the Trump administration were like this explosion of data center construction and selling NVIDIA chips everywhere and Jensen Wang and all the weird oligarch titans getting everything they want. Since then, what have we had? We've had an election in which a backlash to data centers is a huge issue. We've had like Jensen Wang get canned because of this relationship. We have oversight coming. There's a sense of regulation coming.
30:33Ben Rhodes: So it does feel like this is kind of a, you know, a pivot point in some ways in terms of just, we've had all these outages that we just talked about at the beginning of the show. So like, it feels like we're at a bit of a hinge point. And this Jensen Huang story is weirdly, you know, from the man on speaker at the All in Pod Summit to the guy who just got canned, it feels like he's kind of a hinge of this moment of AI. I agree. I mean, look, for a couple of reasons. First of all, I mean, like, you know, the AI world seemed untouchable. And then, you know, now the king has sort of fallen. I mean, Jensen Wong was basically the king of the AI world.
31:06There is, I think, a good faith debate happening about AI and artificial intelligence chips. One side says, like, these things can create really dangerous tools, and it's a national security issue and priority. And then there's, like, kind of the Jensen Wong. If you're kind of, like, trying to be fair to him, his view would be, well, it's just a regular technology. So there's no reason I shouldn't be able to sell it everywhere. What's the big deal? Let's get the Chinese that got hooked on our technology stack. And that's like a reasonable perspective to have, but it doesn't mean you can ignore U.S.
31:35export controls or American laws. Right? And like that's clearly what's happening here.
31:40Ben Rhodes: It's such an important point because precisely because it is a fair debate to have. That's precisely why you need things like commerce to work. Right? The only way in which you can have confidence in exporting certain kinds of chips and certain kinds of technologies, if you also know that you can kind of prevent, at least slow down the diffusion of those technologies to the most concerning actors. And, you know, the Chinese military, the Chinese state apparatus would be at the top of that list. And you might accept the risk that, you know, some chips are going to Singapore or the Gulf and they may make their way around the world.
32:18Ben Rhodes: But, like, it's another thing to just kind of hand the highest quality chips to the Chinese, you know. And so we need confidence that the government can competently manage and regulate these technologies. And so that's another reason why the oversight is important. We actually need these agencies to work. Yeah. And so let's talk about what's happened since. So on Monday, the Trump administration announced a major new rule that will create a licensing requirement to sell chips to data centers in countries with high risk of smuggling. and then most importantly, it cracks down on China's ability to access advanced chips via data centers in third countries.
32:54So the kind of like quick and dirty description of what it does is it'll take some steps to prevent the smuggling of AI chips, including, you know, really ratcheting or putting big restrictions on chip shipments to certain countries that have been involved in smuggling. That will be, you know, sort of a patchwork solution because then I think you'll just have smugglers set up in other places, but like it's a good step. It'll put on major restrictions on these Chinese companies to prevent them from renting access to AI data servers and data farms in third countries like Singapore, like where Megaspeed was.
33:28And it's going to block Chinese chip designers from making AI chips at TSMC, the big fab in Taiwan. The most important one of those new rules is about blocking China's access to data centers in third countries. there is a ton of reporting that access to those data centers has been the key to China's AI development. The rub here, though, is that the Commerce Department is still going to have to implement these laws. And the press statement about these new rules said that it was, quote, written by and at the direction of the Department of Treasury and the National Security Council, which seems to suggest that Commerce just didn't want to do it, and they're trying to absolve themselves of this new rule.
34:10So Ben, it's just very weird. These rules seem objectively good. There's some loopholes. It's obviously too little too late, but like way better than where we were before. But it also strikes me as the kind of policy that has the potential to create a lot of tension between the US and China because that remote access loophole was so important for Chinese AI development. I guess the question is, how does China respond? Like, do we expect Xi Jinping to try to low-key this one and not pick a fight and just kind of like use his various sort of soft power means with Trump to kind of slowly unravel it?
34:45Or do they play the rare earths card again, right? And say, okay, you're going to cut off our access to these, you know, data centers in Singapore. We're going to cut off your access to all these rare earth materials that you need for smartphones, military equipment, everything else.
35:00Ben Rhodes: It's a good question. And, you know, I don't know. What I would guess is that Xi may want to explore how real this is, right? Like, in other words, you never know with this Trump administration whether they're going to actually enforce things and follow through on things with any degree of competence. So one scenario is they kind of play this out. He sees if he can charm Trump a little bit with the protocol over there in China with his buddy Putin and see how many trucks they can drive through whatever cracks they can find in this regime. And then if it is causing problems for them, then they can always ratchet up the rare earth again.
35:38Ben Rhodes: And that's been leverage that's worked. Again, the problem here is that a coherent policy would be working across multiple fronts. So you would be regulating the AI companies. You would be managing and regulating the flow of chips around the world. You'd be negotiating artificial norms and regulations with China. Like all these things would be working in concert with one another. and they don't have a coherent policy. And so even this thing, which feels like the right place to land, is probably just, this was the Treasury and NSC, Rubio-Besson position. And after the Jensen-Huang scandal, they kind of won out.
36:14Ben Rhodes: And so they got to announce their thing. It still doesn't feel like they can articulate what their actual approach to this technology is. And certainly not in a way that harmonizes like domestic regulation, export controls, and international negotiation with China, which is the kind of coherence that you need. Yeah, and for what it's worth, I mean, Trump is still like kind of slowly chipped away at export controls. Remember, we covered this in the past. Like Trump allowed them, allowed NVIDIA to export like the H20 chip, which was a kind of not that powerful, but still pretty powerful chip. And then the H200, which is even more powerful in exchange for the US getting a cut of the revenues for those sales.
36:52Now, the Chinese initially said, no, we won't take any of those chips. Xi Jinping said, did. But then I think they slowly agreed to take a few on board because she's ultimate goal is to ramp up China's indigenous capacity to make chips as fast as possible. The problem is it's just a really, really hard manufacturing challenge. Like, I think they'll probably get there eventually, but it's going to take some time. So if these new export rules are really put in place and implemented, I think it actually really would set back or create even more of a space between the U.S. and China in terms of like the power of our top models and theirs.
37:30It's just the question of whether Lutnink will actually let it happen.
37:34Ben Rhodes: Yeah, the compute power, it would create a gap. And it may be also, though, that what Trump knows is Republicans in Congress don't like the lax rules with the Chinese. and frankly, they're probably veto-proof majorities between the incoming Democrats and the Republicans to kind of force Trump to not allow this technology to go to China. He may be trying to get ahead of that. And look, because the reality is Trump doesn't like export controls because it's inherently designed for some future benefit. You know, like we need to deny some technology to people so that years from now we're in a better position.
38:06Ben Rhodes: Trump is like, you know, we can make money and juice the stock market by selling more chips, you know, and like that's what he wants to do. Yeah, that's right. We're going to take a quick break. But before we do, I just want to make a quick plug for our Friend of the Pod community. That's our subscription community. We got a lot of great perks. And one option now is an annual subscription that will get you all of them. So you get ad-free episodes of your favorite Crooked Pods. You get access to all of our newsletter. You get subscriber-only exclusives like Pod Save America-only friends, Terminally Online, two very fun subscription shows.
38:35And if you get an annual subscription, you get three months free compared to paying monthly. So head over to crooked.com slash friends to learn more and unlock all of the perks.
38:51Pod Save the World is brought to you by Built. Here's a question. Are you getting rewarded for paying your rent or mortgage right now? If the answer is no, you need to check out Built. Becoming a Built member means earning points on every housing payment, no matter where you live. Built points can be redeemed for flights, hotels, lift rides, Amazon.com purchases, future housing payments, and much, much more. There really are just so many different ways to redeem your bill points. You can use it to pay for a future housing payment. You can do fitness classes like Barry's or SoulCycle or Y7. There's Amazon.com.
39:23There's Lyft rides. There's gift cards at more than 120 brands. Just a million different ways you can redeem them. Built's new AI neighborhood concierge doesn't just answer your questions, it executes tasks. From paying your rent and inhaling a Lyft to booking a dinner reservation at over 50 ,000 of their partners. It handles your to-do list while automatically applying your member benefits. Here's how it works. First, you download the Built app. Second, you link any credit or debit card to the app so purchases at your local spots become even more rewarding. Then third, you ask the neighborhood concierge in the app pretty much anything and it'll alert you to exclusive member benefits near your home.
39:59And for the homeowners out there, Built works for mortgages too. Your housing payment is one of your biggest monthly expenses, so why wouldn't you want to earn points on it? Download the Built app and join the membership for where you live at joinbuilt.com slash world. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash world. Use our link so they know we sent you. Pod Save the World is brought to you by the Dissidents Mike podcast. The Dissidents Mike is a podcast about what authoritarianism actually looks like and feels like to the people living under it, presented by the Human Rights Foundation. Each episode starts with a question about power, repression, or resistance and takes you straight to the people who experience it firsthand for answers.
40:37Authoritarianism doesn't always look like what you expect. Sometimes it's a government making you disappear from all legal records. Sometimes it's a phone call to your mother that you know is being monitored. Sometimes it's the inner workings of a football club worth billions or the shirt you're wearing right now made using forced labor. The show explores stories from activists in Nicaragua, Equatorial Guinea, Russia, China, and Afghanistan to reveal the ways that authoritarians exert power and how brave men and women stand up to it. If you've ever wondered what resistance looks like against authoritarianism or how it affects people beyond the headlines, this is the place to start.
41:09Authoritarian systems can reach into our everyday lives. Each month, the Dissidents Mic brings you closer to the people challenging these systems and gives an inside look at the ways they continue to resist, even with the odds stacked against them. Listen to the Dissidents Mic wherever you get your podcasts or find it on YouTube.
41:28All right, let's turn to Iran. We are eight months into the war. Trump, you know, as we heard that clip, he says it's all handled, but we're still striking targets in the Gulf. The Department of Defense just sets a third aircraft carrier strike group to the region. So it's much a live item. Last week, Iran's Assembly of Experts asked for a review of their defense posture and membership in the nuclear non-proliferation treaty that made some experts wonder if that's kind of part of a process to get official religious permission to build a nuclear weapon. So that's fun. Over the weekend, the Iranians fired a bunch of drones at U.S.
42:05military sites in Bahrain. CENTCOM says all those drones were intercepted, but like, we never really know. The Wall Street Journal also said that U.S. intelligence believes that Iran's between 1 ,500 and 2 ,500 missiles remaining in its arsenal, so they could still do a lot of damage. Also, Ben, the 60 Minutes had a good report the other day. A U.S. Army soldier who survived a previous attack on the U.S. base in Kuwait has filed the whistleblower report, a complaint to Congress. U.S. Army Major Stephen Ramsbottom spoke to Noro O'Donnell on Sunday. He talked about how senior military commanders did not plan properly and ignored warnings.
42:42Let's take a listen to that. I brought it up twice in various meetings, basically saying, hey, I don't see how we're protected here. And how did your leadership respond? He said, we don't have to worry about protection.
42:56Ben Rhodes: That's why you're speaking up. Yes, that's why I'm speaking up. I feel this is a tactical failure by the Army, our leadership, and myself, all the way down to my level. Yes, we just, we did not plan this well, and this needs to be a lesson that we learned. Every once in a while, you might have one, unfortunately, we call it a squirter, that makes its way through. And in that particular case, it happened to hit a tactical operations center that was fortified, but these are powerful weapons. We cut in the Hegseth comments from the day after that attack, just to remind you of the lie he told at the time about a squirter.
43:34Trump's response was to complain about 60 Minutes, so he's focused on the important things. Ben, I think all of this is just a reminder that this is still an active war. It could reignite at any moment. Any comments to the contrary is just, it's lying.
43:49Ben Rhodes: Yeah, I think that another oversight priority for Democrats should be getting to the bottom of the grave damage done to our military facilities and, frankly, our partners across the region that have been serially covered up by Pete Hegshev. And frankly, it's not like CENCOM has been particularly forthcoming either. And so now that we control the Armed Services Committees and the Oversight Committees, I think we can finally shed some light on this stuff because we just don't know what we don't know. we presume and have heard a lot about the grave damage that's done, the poor planning, the incompetence of Hegseth, and frankly, down through some of the CENTCOM planning as well.
44:29Ben Rhodes: And in terms of the war, it just feels very tenuous, right? Because it feels like the Iranians are prepared to wait this out to match our escalation. That is worrying about the religious part of the nuclear program, because the previous Supreme Leader had issued a fatwa against the development of nuclear weapons, then he was killed by the United States and Israel. And so, yeah, that could swing in a different direction. There was another report we saw that got a lot of attention this week. CNN reported that U.S. intelligence said Iran is making plans to detonate a dirty bomb or chemical weapon in D.C.
45:00to target the Trump administration or Trump administration officials. Consider me a little skeptical of this one. You wouldn't need a dirty bomb to mess with Scott Besson, although Besson did get moved to a military base because of these threats, but like, you just would need a gun. Also, you know, there were some reports that J.D. Vance was going to lead another round of talks. Late last week, Trump said, nope, actually, I'm pulling J.D. out of those talks. And he said, quote, we don't need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. So it's like, it's just incoherent.
45:31Ben Rhodes: It's incoherent. And they seem to have no plan to actually end the war. I will say that the dirty bomb thing. I just, every time we're in a war, like the same report comes out that the adversary is going to have a dirty bomb. I just don't believe it at all. Like, did they get the yellow cake for the dirty bomb in Niger? I mean, yeah, yeah, yeah. It's playing the hits. All right, let's turn to some interesting news out of the UK. Prime Minister Andy Burnham gave his first major foreign policy speech earlier this week in London, and he took a major shot at Brexit. Let's listen to an excerpt of that.
46:06In the decades since Brexit, our standing in the world has diminished. Looking back, Brexit was the first domino to fall in a global move towards more isolationism and protectionism. And the saddest thing of all is this. It is exactly what our enemies wanted. Russia wanted disunity within NATO and a weaker Europe less able to counter its plans for Ukraine. As the outlines of a new global order are being drawn, we must ensure that we are at the table. In 2016, it looked a lot easier to go it alone. Today, not so much. We can't ignore this reality, nor the fact that we have a club of democracies on our doorstep, which shares so many of our values and our interests.
46:58To be frank, we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years. The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain. So a pretty accurate and stark assessment of the impact of Brexit. I just love giving your big foreign policy speech in a white bow tie.
47:18Ben Rhodes: White tie, man. Hilarious optics. I think the Brits are like just used to that kind of level of pomp and ceremony, you know, circumstance and formality in a way that like is anathema to American politics. But I don't know. So Ben, Burnham's going to meet with some other European leaders later this week. I think he'll probably cut some limited trade agreements. In his speech, Burnham also pointed to the UK's upcoming G20 presidency in 2027 and G7 presidency in 2028. as kind of moments of leadership or inflection points. So Burnham insists that he is not trying to like rerun the 2016 argument about Brexit or take actions that break the 2024 manifesto that Keir Starmer made when he ran and won in that election.
48:03But it does feel like he is kind of plowing the earth here and trying to start a public conversation about Brexit and lay out a kind of, you know, some sort of timeline or series of inflection points that could move the process forward. I think the question is, where does he want to land on this? I don't know that we totally know yet, but he's definitely gone further in, you know, pushing back on Brexit than Keir Starmer ever did or that labor has done in a while.
48:31Ben Rhodes: Yeah, first of all, I just, I dig Andy Burnham's energy. like, you know, he has kind of breathed life into what had gotten kind of more abundant in the Labor Party under Keir Starmer, including joining this fight, because he's right. I mean, you can trace a lot of Britain's problems to Brexit. It's stagnant growth. It's kind of alienation and isolation. He cited a 4 % to 8 % hit to GDP because of Brexit. Massive, right? Yeah. And, you know, like hurting probably some of the people that voted for it the most, not unlike Trump supporters. and kind of creating an identity crisis in the UK as well.
49:06Ben Rhodes: If I were to make a prediction, it seems like Andy Burnham's an ambitious guy. He doesn't have a lot of money in the Treasury to do super ambitious things. So I think he may be staking out here that my legacy is going to be a pathway back to the European Union. Now, he said that with this parliament, he's not going to do that. But what he could do is he could negotiate a bunch of things to increase trade, to kind of increase some freedom of movement and residency, the kind of, you know, steps, as you said, to plow the ground back in that direction. And then if he gets reelected, then he takes, you know, he negotiates UK's reentry to the EU.
49:46Like I, my guess is that that's what's in the back of his head, like that there is an ultimate target here of reversing
49:52Ben Rhodes: Brexit, but you can't do it too fast. He frankly probably also wants to see where the political ones are going in Europe because if like a bunch of far right dominoes start falling, that could get a little weirder. So, you know, I'm not suggesting it's a foregone conclusion, but I'm glad to see a leader, like a progressive leader, actually standing up for that, the position that is correct here, which is that Brexit, like the Trump election, was an insane thing to do. And it's been 10 years and we can, let's finally fucking talk about it. Yeah, just state the obvious. Like it has been a disaster for the UK.
50:25It was built on lies. None of the things that Boris Johnson promised came to be. Who gives a shit if Nigel Farage is upset about your comments? Like, tell people that what they're seeing with their own two eyes is true. Like, just say it out loud.
50:41Ben Rhodes: Yeah, and it gives them, like, don't let the Lib Dems take that corner. You know, like, if you want Labor to be a governing party, like, you know, stand for it. Yeah, stand for it. Speaking of standing for things, there's a leadership contest happening in the Senate as we speak. Senator Chris Van Hollen is challenging Senator Chuck Schumer to be the Democratic Party's leader in the Senate. We thought it might be interesting to look at this race from a foreign policy perspective. I imagine listeners probably know Schumer or are familiar with Senator Schumer. For listeners who don't know Chris Van Hollen, he represents Maryland.
51:11He serves on the Foreign Relations Committee. His dad was a Foreign Service officer. His mom was in the CIA in the State Department. He was actually born in Pakistan, where his family was posted at the time. In this contest, Van Hollen is actively running on foreign policy issues. So he's talking about using the upcoming government funding vote in December to cut off money for the Iran war and end the war. I think that would almost certainly mean a government shutdown. Schumer has said he wants to use that funding vote to put restrictions on the military until Democrats get to the majority and have more leverage.
51:43Van Hollen has also been a more progressive voice when it comes to U.S. relations with Israel. He has talked about needing more restrictions on weapon sales and military aid. Schumer is more in the lane of let's keep the status quo while criticizing Netanyahu. Van Hollen also wants to stop taking money from AIPAC. He also got a lot of attention earlier this year when he went—was it this year or last year? When he went to El Salvador to visit Gilmar Arrego Garcia. Beginning. Yeah, beginning in Trump. Yeah. So that was the man who was wrongly sent to the torture prison in El Salvador. Van Hollen went down there, visited him, got a meeting.
52:16It was an important moment, I think. So both Schumer and Ben Holland want to impeach Pete Hegseth. So Ben, I had the chance to interview Senator Ben Holland on Pod Save America earlier this week. It's an interesting challenge he has. He's sort of running this outside-in campaign for a position that is going to be determined only by insiders. It's like only members of the caucus that will vote for it. So he's trying to like outline his vision, get people excited about it, talk about why he would be different, but also like knows that the job is like, is representing the consensus opinion of the caucus.
52:50And if you don't do that, they will not vote for you or they'll give you the boot if you're in charge. But what's your sense of Ed Holland and the ways he could impact U.S. foreign policy from that perch if you were to get it?
53:01Ben Rhodes: Yeah, I actually think this is, you know, we obviously care more about foreign policy than the average person or even probably Democratic senator. But this is the area where I think there's actually like the clearest or among the clearest contrast between the two. Let me just say at the outset, like there are things I really like about Chuck Schumer. Like I'm from New York, like he's delivered for New York. I think he is a kind of capable, you know, manager of the caucus. Frankly, I have a lot of friends who've been in the Schumer staff, which is always among the best staff in the Senate. They're not very happy with me because full disclosure, I'm supportive of Chris Van Haan, what he's doing.
53:41Ben Rhodes: But big butt coming here. Like Chuck Schumer has just been part of this kind of defensive crouch, pro-Israel, pro-war at times consensus in the Democratic Party for a really long time. Like, you know, look, when the JCPOA, the biggest fight we had on foreign policy of the Obama years was the Iran nuclear deal. We negotiated that deal. and Chuck Schumer, like just a couple of weeks after, like before the August recess. So, I mean, this matters to nerds like you and me, like before everybody went home, Chuck Schumer, who was already then the heir apparent as leader, came out against the JCPOA in a 1 ,600-word statement that felt like every talking point that had been thrown at us from the kind of APAC crowd, you know.
54:28Ben Rhodes: That matters, you know, especially given that Trump tore up that deal, which presumably Chuck Schumer, you know, he opposed the deal. Like, well, that set us on the pathway to confrontation with Iran, you know. And I'll tell you, the only other Democratic senators who, you know, who opposed that deal were like Bob Menendez, who's in prison now, Joe Manchin, who we know well, and Ben Cardin, who's kind of another, you know, kind of conventional AIPAC Democrat. And, you know, Schumer, you know, was very critical to Daniao, which I think he deserves credit for, but has not voted in the way the majority of Democratic senators voted in the last vote to block the bombs going to Israel.
55:10Ben Rhodes: In fact, the last package of support for Israel that Schumer voted for included bulldozers. Those are not defensive weapons. So there's a real difference here because Van Hollen, this is not someone who's late to the issue. Van Hollen has been an outspoken critic of the Israeli occupation, of settler violence in the West Bank since before— October 7th. He was critical of the Biden administration for the unconditional support. So on matters of support to Israel, Van Halen is very much in a different place than Schumer. And again, I don't want to make this all about Israel, but this kind of becomes a proxy for, are you willing to kind of buck convention?
55:50Ben Rhodes: Are you willing to kind of stand against things like the war in Iran, like very aggressively? And beyond that, like you said, this is a guy that has lived in other places, knows the foreign service, stood up to Bukele and his kind of gulag that Trump was sending people to at the beginning when people were a little bit tentative to engage in those fights. So there is a pretty clear contrast. Again, I'll be the first to say this shouldn't be decided solely on foreign policy. And frankly, Chuck Schumer has been pretty solid on other aspects of our foreign policy. I just pointed to the ones where there's a clear contrast here.
56:26Ben Rhodes: And look, Chris Van Hollen being the majority leader would be a sea change for the Democratic caucus on foreign policy because usually the hawks occupy the leadership and occupy the leadership of the key committees, armed services, foreign relations, and intelligence. And so having someone who's a progressive at the top of the caucus, that'd be a huge deal for progressive foreign policy. I think it's still probably, you know, a long shot, but it's possible. And that to me is the contrast. And look, the election was largely decided on foreign policy, right? I mean, the Iran war was the biggest driver of all the kind of things that led people to be furious and want to make a change.
57:06He would also be, you know, one of the primary spokespeople for the Democratic Party in the next two years, or at least until there is a Democratic nominee in the Democratic in the 2028 primary. There are some big foreign policy fights coming up. There's this Iran funding vote. There's the Iran funding vote. there will be a lot of fights over U.S. weapon sales to Israel. There's going to be a fight over the NDAA. There's this Israel kind of merging provision in the NDAA. This was like kind of merged the intelligence and defense technology industries of the two countries. That's a fight. I don't know that Schumer wants to take on Ben.
57:42So there will be a bunch of kind of pretty important impactful flashpoints in the near future. You could also use your power to block nominees. You could use your power to hold up ambassadors, right? There's like a lot of different ways that I think foreign policy will get run through the Senate, even though Trump ultimately will have a lot of leeway on foreign policy as opposed to domestic policy where he won't be able to pass anything.
58:02Ben Rhodes: Yeah. And look, I'm glad that there'll be a Democratic leader, whoever it is. I do think there's an opportunity in the Van Hollen candidacy to kind of show a different, a Democratic foreign policy that is less defensive crouched, that is more progressive. And like, as we've been talking about this whole show, like the dividing line between foreign and domestic policy is kind of collapsing, right? The Iran war is a gas prices issue. Like AI is both the domestic and a foreign policy issue. So, you know, I think that that's lurking in the backdrop of this too. Yep. All right, Ben. So you were in Turkey recently in Istanbul for the COP UN climate summit, UN climate conference, that is.
58:39That conference is underway. I think it goes until November 20th. Recent COP meetings have left a lot to be desired. They have been light on commitments. They have been held in petro states like Azerbaijan and the UAE. This year, the U.S. didn't send a delegation because, of course, Trump doesn't believe in climate change. But Democratic governors and members of Congress did go to say like, hey, like, hold the line. We'll be there. The hope is on the horizon. Ben, I've lost all faith in the COP process, at least until Trump is gone. But like, what did you hear out there while you were in Istanbul that made you feel otherwise?
59:11Ben Rhodes: Yeah, I mean, look, it has gotten quite cynical. Even the COP process kind of captured by these armies of fossil fuel lobbyists, you know, the petro-states. Some people don't even show up. Like Chancellor Mertz of Germany didn't show up. I was talking to some of the Germans who were there. I think the argument that people would make is, first of all, this is still the framework that we have to deal with, the Paris Agreement. But that underneath that framework, people shouldn't just sit around and wait for the United— It's kind of a Mark Carney type argument. It's like, while the United States is going through its identity crisis, and while the United States and China, who we would prefer cooperated on a clean energy transition, are at odds with each other, we need to be doing everything we can to change national policies, to pursue new technologies, to build back consensus on ways to wean off fossil fuels.
1:00:08To point out in the politics of individual countries that people kind of reverted back to fossil fuels thinking that was a way of having cheaper energy.
1:00:16Ben Rhodes: Well, look at the cost of fossil fuels and that dependence in the Strait of Hormuz. Like, that turned out not to be the cheaper option, right? And so a lot of the people I talk to are thinking in terms of how can I do the most work as an activist, as a clean energy person, as a negotiator, so that we're still making progress, still keeping this thing moving. And so that if and when the United States comes back into the fold, there are approaches that they can plug into on a multilateral basis very quickly. And that there's essentially blueprints that have been designed that we can rejoin. And I think that's the argument for kind of what is still ongoing at these cops.
1:00:57Yeah. Finally, Ben, we lost some political heroes this year. And it can be hard to process that loss when there is so much going on every day. And so, you know, I wanted to play this moving tribute to one of those fallen heroes for you. This comes via a local news segment. Let's watch. Lockheed Martin recognized Lindsey Graham on Monday, honoring his decades of service to this country. Lockheed Martin leaders say they'll make sure Graham's connection to the facility is never forgotten. Naming his Greenville Welcome Center in his honor. Leaders say Monday's recognition serves as a reminder of Graham's lasting impact, and they hope his legacy will continue on for generations to come.
1:01:40So that's the Lindsey Graham Welcome Center at the Lockheed Martin facility in Greenville, South Carolina. I believe we also have a photo of the facility that we can put out that was tweeted out by his sister, Senator Darlene Graham. She said in a statement, quote, My hope is that this new welcome center, much like Lindsay himself, will bring people together, fostering strong relationships between local businesses, community leaders, and international partners for years to come. Yes, Lockheed Martin, the maker of the Hellfire Missile, famously an organization that brings people together before detonating to blow them to smithereens.
1:02:19Do you feel moved?
1:02:20Ben Rhodes: This has been a very—the entire, you know, probably last 25 years, but particularly the last year of the Trump administration, has been a very good time for the takes of your stoner friend down the hall in college who just wanted to get high and talk about the military-industrial complex. Nailed it. Because that person nailed it. I mean, Lindsey Graham was like the walking manifestation of the military industrial complex. A man who simultaneously could not find a country on a map that he didn't want to bomb. Could not find a weapon system that he wants to invest in without investing in schools and healthcare.
1:02:57Ben Rhodes: What a fitting tribute to his life's work that the welcome center at the Lockheed Martin facility bears his name. Many lobbyists will pass through those doors and feel an extra spring in their step. going to Washington, you know, to try to get more money for weapons instead of schools. I just want to say, could not be better that they will have to lobby Annie Andrews when they get there because something tells me she's not going to have anything named after her at Lockheed Martin or Raytheon or Boeing. The Lockheed Martin Welcome Facility in Greenville, South Carolina. You just can't make this shit up.
1:03:35Ben Rhodes: Can't make it up. Okay, that's it for the news portion of the show this week. But stick around because after the break, you're going to hear Ben's conversation with Spain's foreign minister. That's a big booking for us. Stick around for that. Big booking for us. That's cool.
1:03:54This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. We all have those nagging things that are taking up too much space in our heads. Maybe it's an awkward interaction from years ago, an irrational worry, or a minor annoyance that somehow becomes all-consuming. If you feel like it's time to clear up the mental clutter, therapy could be a great place to start and it's more affordable than you think with BetterHelp. Insurance options may now be available nationwide with BetterHelp. With insurance, many members pay$15 or less. Some pay$0. BetterHelp therapists are licensed, experienced professionals. They have at least three years and 1 ,000 hours of hands-on experience when they have the required education, training, exams, and practice.
1:04:30BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals. A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences in their 10 or more years of experience. An industry-leading match fulfillment rate means they typically get it right the first time. If you aren't happy with your match, switch to a different therapist at any time with no hassle from their tailored recommendations. You know you need a therapist. There's a lot going on in the world. Things are scary. People are dealing with stuff at home. People are dealing with stuff at work. Talk to somebody.
1:04:56It'll make you feel better. BetterHelp is now in network with more than 125 health plans with many copays as low as$15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the U.S., you can still get 10 % off your first month. Sign up and get 10 % off at betterhelp.com slash crookedworld. That's betterhelp.com slash crookedworld.
1:05:22Ben Rhodes: I'm very pleased to be joined by the foreign minister of Spain, Jose Manuel Alvarez. Listeners of this show know we are big fans of the Sanchez government. The Spanish government has been a bit of a progressive beacon in dark times. And there's an election coming up on November 29th. So it's a great time for the foreign minister to be checking in with us. Thanks so much for joining us. My pleasure. I do just want to begin with the election itself and then move on to some of the other issues that you've been working on. Obviously, it's a tough time for incumbents. Pedro Sanchez has been in power for almost a decade.
1:05:59Ben Rhodes: You have, as in other places in Europe, a far right led by the Vox Party, who may be in coalition with conservatives. What can you tell our listeners and viewers about what the current state of the elections are and how you're feeling about things here in the last two weeks? There are two models on which the Spaniards will have to decide. There is the model that Pedro Sánchez and his government represents, that today it's putting forward the highest economic growth in Europe by far with a historical low in unemployment and with an increase in rights, in pension rights, in the minimum wage, in scholarship, with a very strong voice in Europe and in the world, backing the European values, backing Ukraine in front of the Russian aggression, and with no double standards, standing for the same things in Ukraine and in Gaza and in the Middle East, which is international law, multilateralism.
1:07:01And on the other hand, we have those that think that confrontation is stronger than cooperation, that at the end, the law of the jungle, internally and externally, that the strongest must impose its will to the weakest. So that's the choice. And as I see it from today, more and more people understand that what is at stake is not just an alternative for four years until the next election, but it's a dramatic change in how we perceive ourselves, how we project our voice outside. And at the end, that is our coexistence as we understand it, that is at stake.
1:07:40Ben Rhodes: It seems like in this day and age, all politics is both local and global. We've seen over the last decade a lot of connectivity between far-right movements. I remember I was in Spain at one point and Steve Bannon was there visiting with the Vox party. So you have a far-right that is globalized, but you also now have a bit of a momentum around progressive parties. We saw a student movement succeed in Serbia. We saw Brazil obviously surprised the world by re-electing Lula da Silva. And then here in the United States, we obviously just had a midterm election that was a much larger rebuke of Donald Trump and validation for the Democrats than people anticipated.
1:08:29Ben Rhodes: Are you feeling like this is connected to events beyond Spain, too? I mean, we'll get into the foreign policy elements, but just do you feel this kind of global political contest as part of what's happening in Spanish politics right now? Totally. Absolutely. Yes. For two reasons. Citizens understand more than ever that everything is connected and that some of the real important decisions for their life, for their normal, regular life, are not taken anymore only by their own national parliament or national government. It's not only in Madrid where we take the big decisions. is with others, in other four months.
1:09:07Here in Europe, a lot in Brussels, but also in New York, in United Nations, and in other four months. And what's happening many kilometers away can have a huge impact on them. They know that the Russian aggression to Ukraine took a huge blow on the energy cost here in Europe. They know that the fact that the Hormuz trade is closed has a direct impact on their pockets. Therefore, they are very much aware that it's not only about national decision, but it's also about what international stance, who are your friends abroad, and what your voice means abroad, that their own life will be decided in the next four years.
1:09:49And the second thing is everyone is seeing that we have more and more external interference, whether it's through the social network or it's in period in which our societies are more polarized and therefore easier to intervene, which is the democratic elections. And for that extreme right, it's much more organized because they understand that once again, deciding is not only deciding nationally, but also internationally. And as the progressive, because we have a vision that is certainly more multilateral, Because we know that for the big, big issues, the existential one, climate change or migration management or underdevelopment, stability, peace and war, there is no unilateral solution.
1:10:42Not even for the strongest country in the world, we have to go multilateral. And also to prevent others from deciding for ourselves, we also have a tendency to agree more and to be more in contact among ourselves.
1:10:55Ben Rhodes: Yeah, I do want to talk a bit about what you've been able to do in the last few years on foreign policy, because it seems to me that, you know, Spain is really assumed more of a leadership role globally and within Europe. And I'm just curious about, you know, in the past, like, say, when I was in government, you know, France and Germany, they drove so much of the European agenda. And what I've seen you do in the last few years is take different or distinct positions on some things and really try to lead a growing consensus. So we've seen Spain out front in recognizing a Palestinian state and being critical of Israeli war crimes in Gaza.
1:11:44Ben Rhodes: We've seen Spain not go along with Trump's bullying of NATO countries to spend an absurd 5 % of their GDP on defense. You know, we've seen Spain be a voice on issues like climate change or AI, where there needs to be more, you know, a sense of more action in multilateral forms. And also, though, we've seen Spain continue to support Ukraine. I mean, have you thought of this as trying to carve out like a separate and distinct voice for Spain within Europe with building partnerships in the global south? What has informed this kind of independent Spanish foreign policy that has obviously gotten a lot of attention in the last few years?
1:12:30What's funny is that I don't have the feeling that Spain has moved from where European Union values and our vision, our multilateral and European and democratic vision has traditionally been. I could say it's more others that have moved and seems that suddenly Spain is taking their own voice. What we have done is basically two things, is to continue advocating for European Union integration. And the second thing is to not have double standards. That's basically what we have done. And when it comes to Europe, we advocated since the very beginning for backing Ukraine to make sure that war will never again be a way of settling disputes among the states here in Europe.
1:13:27And not having double standards, saying the same thing in Ukraine, there in Gaza and in front of everyone. And that's probably the big difference of Spain. And that's why we have had such a leadership role. like when it came to the recognition of the state of Palestine, because we were able to continue standing up to our values.
1:13:50Ben Rhodes: And did those issues, I mean, here in the United States, for instance, issues related to Israel and Palestine have become more prominent in our domestic politics. And frankly, one reason that Democrats won so significantly a couple weeks ago is because of the unpopularity of the war in Iran, frustration with the relationship with Israel. On some of these foreign policy issues like Spanish support for Palestine, are these political issues? Do people vote on these issues? I'll get to migration in a second, which is obviously a more complicated issue for your party. But in terms of things like Palestine or not signing on to a 5 % NATO pledge, are these part of the case that you're making to voters right now?
1:14:37Sure. And it's issues that people come up to me when I'm campaigning and they tell me it's one of the reasons why they will vote for us. And it takes different shapes. There are some people that say, I acknowledge that you have stood for my own interests, saying no to the war in Iran or making sure that you will keep an expenditure of social spending for my rights. Other things, I'm very proud of the values that you have stood for. And this is something. I like the leadership role of Spain for values. I like when you defend the civilian and international humanitarian law in Ukraine. And I like when you do it as well in Gaza, where you stay for the dignity and the justice for the Palestinian people and the two-state solution.
1:15:31And the third thing, and that's also very important, is because people, as I was saying before, understand that we have to do the right things abroad in order for them to be well inside. And therefore, they like a government that has a clear voice, an independent voice in favor, in their favor, in favor of their values and their interests. So yes, yes, certainly it's something that people give us credit for. is one of the reasons they will vote for us. And beyond that, I think they feel very comfortable with a government that have a very clear and a voice of its own for both. Because they know that in that way we defend their interests.
1:16:19We don't follow others going towards that harm their pockets. And secondly, because we project their values. They like the image of Spain being projected as someone that has no double standards, someone that is pro-European, someone that thinks that war is not a tool for foreign policy objectives.
1:16:40Ben Rhodes: And what would you say are the main differences? Like if a conservative Vox government were to take office, like what would be the contrast? How would they change things in terms of foreign policies? It will be huge. They say in themselves, it will be huge. They will change almost everything. First, I think that Spain will lose their own voice. They will follow others. They will not think what's good for the Spaniards, for the people. What are their values? How they want to be projected and perceived in the world. Second, I think they will feel comfortable with the law of the jungle. You don't stand up to the one that is stronger than you, even if it's the right thing to do.
1:17:28And third, they will look more internally in the wrong way, not going European, but just saying what is, when it goes for multilateral, what is at stake for me, only in a selfish way, not understanding that a strong Spain needs a strong Europe and that the real challenges in the world can only have multilateral solution. When they are in regional governments, the first thing they do is to cut development cooperation. And that for a country that is in front of Africa, that has a part of its territory in Africa, it's a catastrophe. Because development cooperation is solidarity, but it's also investment in the stability of our neighbors and in our own stability and prosperity.
1:18:14Just to give you an example, they don't believe in multilateralism. They don't believe in United Nations. Sometimes they talk almost as if it was something evil when it's the right way to go for the global challenges.
1:18:28Ben Rhodes: One of those challenges, of course, is migration. And so like far right parties or right wing parties everywhere, you're being attacked on migration issues. We covered earlier this year the situation in Cueta where tens of thousands of migrants entered this autonomous Spanish city in West Africa from Morocco. So we've also seen a situation recently over the weekend where a significant number of people in the Canary Islands are trying to make their way to Spain. In your portfolio as foreign minister, what do you do to try to manage these migration flows? Is there support that you can get from the European Union in doing so?
1:19:12Ben Rhodes: How much is this a situation where you have to show voters that you can have a humane immigration policy, but you can also obviously have secure and orderly borders at the same time. First is to explain something that is an evidence, but sometimes we have a tendency to forget. Spain has borders, land borders and maritime borders with Africa, which is a huge challenge because those are the most unequal borders in the world. They compare to no other borders Because it's the difference between Africa and the European Union and whatever you take, whatever parameter you take, GDP, GDP per capita, youth population, illiteracy, whatever, unemployment, the gap is huge.
1:20:01And as long as we don't close that gap, there will be migratory pressure. So we have to put that in a context. As a foreign policy minister, today I'm in Brussels and I've been talking with the Commission, with the cabinet of the president of the Commission, with the Commissioner of Homeland Affairs to join forces to try to stop this flow that is going to the Canary Island, basically from Senegal and Gambia. Another thing that I do is to have a dialogue at the highest political level with our partners in the region, the countries that are countries of emission or transit of those migrants. I'm doing it all these days with the foreign affairs colleagues from Senegal and the Gambia, for instance.
1:20:47Development cooperation, it's another important part. We engage quite a lot of funds to make sure that the youth of those countries have opportunities in their own homeland and that they don't have to emigrate by force. And finally, this is something that I do hand in hand with the Minister of Interior. We fight the mafias that do human trafficking. But we have to tell the truth to the citizens. Conjunctural problems have a solution. Structural problems have management. As long as the gap between Africa and the European Union is huge as it is, we can only manage the migration pressure. And we have also to recall that most of the migrants that go into Spain every day or in Europe do it legally.
1:21:45In regular migration, it's a small part, a very small part of all the migration flows that we get every day. And even our entrepreneurs demand in order to keep up our growth. So we have to put all that in context and continue that work. high political dialogue with the countries of emission and transit, development cooperation funds to make sure that there is an alternative to migration to irregular migrants. This joint combination of forces with the European Union and fighting the mafias that do human trafficking.
1:22:26Ben Rhodes: And so is it basically the case then that if you step back, the election is basically being contested over the fact that, you're making an argument around delivering economic growth, delivering real leadership and independence that is values-based, being obviously competent managers of government. And the other side is essentially making arguments about migration, housing, cost of living. Is that pretty much how the battle lines are drawn here in the last two weeks? The real battle lines, I would say, it's about two models of society, really two models. Because on our side, there is the economic growth, but there is also the protection of rights.
1:23:08Never in our democratic history, pension rights or minimum wage or scholarship or dependency aid have increased as much as they have done it under this government. We have the lower entrance of irregular migrants in the whole Mediterranean. So that shows that you can have a progressive policy that protects the rights of the workers and the people, that protects the human rights of everyone, including migrants, and at the same time shows that we are effective fighting irregular migration. So I would say the option to that model is a model that proposes brutal force, reducing rights. But it's all about concept.
1:23:57When you see the reality on economic growth, on how prosperity has increased in this country, on how we have the best figures when it comes to fighting irregular migrants' entrance in our country, we show that progressive policies are not only good forward people, but they are more efficient than what brutal force propose.
1:24:20Ben Rhodes: Yeah, and it does feel like a kind of pivotal time for Europe, right? I mean, you're in Brussels. You have the Spanish election. You have a French election coming up in which the far right under the National Rally Party and Marine Le Pen could do well. You have the AFD on the rise in Germany. um what's how how do you see the spanish election fitting into this question about the future of europe um uh is is do you i mean i i asked a version of this about the far right before but do you do you feel like you know i've seen you at some events the progressive movements and political parties are understanding that that we too are invested in each other's success you know both in Europe and around the world.
1:25:07Ben Rhodes: Are you feeling any solidarity from abroad in these final days? Yes, certainly. Today, President Lula was in Madrid supporting and backing President Santos. And we are the first of many elections, very important elections coming to Europe. It's us that in a few months will be the French and then later the Italian. We are talking about big countries in Europe, big economies. You know, we have this system of vote, of qualified majority, in which the population matters for your voting rights. So it can make the difference. And it will be a huge difference if the extreme right gets to power in all those parties, in all those countries.
1:25:51Because you can change how European Union behaves and acts and the values on which we are. Let's not forget that the European Union is a project of peace and multilateralism. It was meant to make sure that European countries will never again use war to settle disputes among them, to get objectives that we change. The border was a curse and you were fighting your neighbor. Now the border, it's a blessing because it's your friend who you cooperate with. That can change. And certainly the foundations of European Union are democratic values. And extreme right is all the opposite to democratic values.
1:26:38You cannot be a member of European Union if you are not a democracy. So what is at stake? It's a lot. Because the European values, tolerance, pluralism, democracy, are not just nice ideas that are for philosophy, but are the real agents of the stability and prosperity of the last decades in Europe.
1:27:05Ben Rhodes: Well, look, I know you've got a tough fight on your hands, but Pedro Sanchez has been in those positions before and managed to pull it out. I'll be honest, we're rooting for you. And you've done some incredible work the last few years. You really have. At a time when there's not leadership, obviously from the U.S., hopefully that's beginning to change now. Europe has been divided. So everybody should be watching Spain closely. We are sending you our best wishes in solidarity and we'll see what happens. Thank you. And I'm sure that the 29th, we will be celebrating together the victory of a new progressive government of Pedro Sanchez.
1:27:48Thank you.
1:27:48Ben Rhodes: I hope so. I hope so. Be quite the streak. Thank you so much. And thanks for joining us. Thank you. Thanks again to Jose Manuel Albares for joining the show. Thank you, Ben, and to the good people at Rice for loaning you to us for the episode. And we'll talk to you guys soon. Sorry for my continued travels, but I look forward to seeing you guys in the flesh of one of these days. Amen. Pod Save the World is a Crooked Media production. Our show is produced by Ilona Minkowski, Michael Goldsmith, and Anisha Banerjee. Our team includes Matt DeGroat, Ben Hethcote, Jordan Cantor, Kenny Moffitt, David Tolles, and Ryan Young.
1:28:20Our staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East. Thank you.
The Nvidia scandal deepens, Trump heads to Asia for a super special three-way with Xi and Putin, and a heartwarming tribute to Lindsey Graham.
Tommy and Ben dig into Trump’s Asia trip and why the historic trilateral summit between Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi Jinping is almost certainly going to accomplish nothing. Then they walk through the latest twists and turns of the Nvidia/Jensen Huang spy scandal, including Huang’s resignation, Trump administration infighting, and the ever-present whiff of corruption. An American soldier wounded by an Iranian attack goes public as a whistleblower, handing Democrats an opening to hold Pete Hegseth’s Pentagon accountable for its own incompetence. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham uses his first major foreign policy speech as Prime Minister to fire shots at Brexit. The race for Senate Majority Leader turns out to have some real foreign policy stakes, and COP31 in Turkey is a disappointment for anyone who cares about the planet. Finally, a touching tribute to late Senator Lindsey Graham from the military industrial complex. Then Ben sits down with Spain’s Foreign Minister, José Manuel Albares Bueno, to talk about the country’s upcoming election and what it’s like to be an increasingly lonely progressive voice in a continent lurching right.
Hate listening to ads? Become a Friends of the Pod subscriber for ad-free episodes of Pod Save America, Pod Save the World, Lovett or Leave It, Runaway Country, Offline with Jon Favreau, and more—plus exclusive content, including bonus episodes of Pod Save America. Subscribe now at crooked.com/friends, on Apple Podcasts, or through the Pod Save America YouTube channel.
You can request a transcript by emailing [email protected]. Include the podcast name, episode title, and air date. Please allow 48 hours for delivery.