1. Podcasts
  2. Politics Weekly UK
  3. Why is Labour risking a row over migration?
Politics Weekly UK

2 Nov 2026 · 21m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

Why is Labour risking a row over migration?

In short

Politics Weekly discusses Labour’s migration plans and why they may trigger internal conflict, alongside a separate controversy over UK slavery/apology and reparations ahead of the Commonwealth summit.

Guests

Pippa Carrera and Kieran Stacey (Guardian Politics Weekly hosts). No external guests are interviewed in the transcript.

Guest backgrounds

Carrera and Stacey are Guardian political journalists presenting analysis of UK politics and migration policy.

Key claims

Andy Burnham is absent from the Commonwealth trip while Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood announces migration changes; Burnham’s earlier openness to a formal apology for slavery (but not reparations payments) has “opened a can of worms” domestically. Mahmood’s plan would raise the qualifying period for indefinite leave to remain from 5 to 10 years (15 for some care workers), with retrospective elements aimed at the “Boris wave” (1.6m arrivals, 2022–2024).

Notable examples

Care workers’ 15-year rule; Home Office estimate of £10bn cost; Labour MPs like Angela Rayner opposing care-worker changes; CARICOM’s 10-point reparations agenda and figures cited up to $7 trillion.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:22

Introduction to Migration Plans

Discussion on the Home Secretary's upcoming migration plans amidst PM's absence.

“The Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood will unveil her controversial migration plans this afternoon while the PM is conveniently on a plane to Antigua.”
1:40

Andy Burnham's Controversial Apology

Exploration of Andy Burnham's comments on historic slave trade and reparations.

“This is Politics Weekly for The Guardian.”
3:48

Debate on Reparations and Historical Context

Analysis of reparations debate, including perspectives from Kemi Badenoch and historical context.

“but it has also opened up a massive can of worms back here at home.”
6:00

Migration Policy Changes and Impacts

Discussion on proposed changes to migration policy and impacts on care workers.

“and that could be in international courts, which could put the UK in a much more difficult position.”
7:54

Economic Implications of Migration Plans

Debate on the financial implications of the new migration proposals and responses from Labour MPs.

“And let me just take you through some of the stats.”
14:00

The State of Global Politics

Exploring the current crises driving political unrest and the rise of fascism.

“Around the world, politics is in a tense, dangerous place.”
15:58

Kieran and the Labour Party's Migration Policy

Discussing the implications of Labour's migration policy announcements and internal party dynamics.

“Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility, and offer price may vary.”
16:46

Internal Conflicts Over Migration Policies

Examining the tensions within the Labour Party regarding migration policy and member reactions.

“Now, Kieran, Andy Burnham is, of course, not going to be around for this announcement.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Politics Weekly UK, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Pippa Crerar: This is The Guardian.

0:30Pippa Crerar: 20 % off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash audio. One purchase equals one donated. Always. Cash Now, More Later from Opendoor

0:41Kiran Stacey: gives you cash up front for your home plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide.

1:02Pippa Crerar: Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary.

1:14Kiran Stacey: To settle in this country forever is not a right, but a privilege, and it must be earned. The Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood will unveil her controversial migration plans this afternoon while the PM is conveniently on a plane to Antigua.

1:31Pippa Crerar: How big could the backlash be? And what does the PM's absence tell us about how much he cares about migration? I'm Pippa Carrera. And I'm Kieran Stacey. This is Politics Weekly for The Guardian.

1:42Kiran Stacey: Well, Kieran, a plane took off at the crack of dawn from Stansted this morning on its way to the Caribbean.

1:50Pippa Crerar: Very nice.

1:50Kiran Stacey: Because obviously it's the Commonwealth Heads of Government summit there. But it was missing a key person.

1:56Pippa Crerar: You?

1:56Kiran Stacey: Well, obviously, I'd have loved to have been there. And in fact, we should talk about that in a moment, how the Prime Minister's gone without a pack of journalists. But it was missing the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, because it flew up to Manchester to pick him up and then headed to the Caribbean.

2:10Pippa Crerar: OK, so for those people who think that Andy Burnham doesn't care enough about green issues, that's a cross in the box there.

2:17Kiran Stacey: So over the weekend, in anticipation of getting on that flight to the Caribbean to the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting, Andy Burnham wrote a piece for us in The Guardian, which I wrote up, in which he basically said that he'd be open to discussing the issue of the UK offering a formal apology for its role in the historic transatlantic slave trade. He also gave what I think you could probably interpret as a personal apology, crucially, not a state apology, where he talked about his sorrow and regret for the pain and suffering of millions of people. But crucially, he rejected demands from Caribbean countries and campaigners for the UK to pay financial reparations for its role in the slave trade.

3:03Kiran Stacey: This, I think, was designed primarily to avoid another kind of rocky summit like Keir Starmer experienced two years ago in the South Pacific, where he turned up to Chogham and was warned in advance, actually, that reparations were going to be on the agenda, that the Caribbean countries in particular that have been pushing it with the support of some African nations were going to sort of try and put pressure on the UK. And he seemed to be like incredibly unprepared for it. He said, no, it's not going to be on the agenda. And then obviously it was like the main issue that anybody wanted to talk about, whether it was formally on the agenda or not.

3:39Kiran Stacey: So I think Andy Burnham's trying to sort of set out a slightly different approach, trying to get ahead of it. And his comments have been welcomed by Caribbean leaders as a starting point. but it has also opened up a massive can of worms back here at home.

3:52Pippa Crerar: Yeah, well, Kemi Badenoch says that his comments now open up the question of whether there should be reparations. It's also opened up philosophical and historical arguments, not just about slavery, but about the British Empire. And Kemi Badenoch was touring the TV studios over the weekend insisting that the British Empire was a good thing. I'm not entirely sure she wants to spend her time having that particular debate.

4:15Kiran Stacey: She loves the culture war, though, as we know.

4:18Pippa Crerar: I slightly wonder whether she's got sucked into something that actually she doesn't really want to be spending time focusing on. But she's probably, you know, if you were to poll people, I'm sure that the British public would not be in favour of reparations. We should just point out, though, that when we talk about reparations, we don't necessarily mean like some great massive sum of money. There are talks about kind of extra support for education, debt relief. there's returns of you know some important items from museums in britain to their original countries all of that can count as reparations rather than just a kind of one-off payment but

4:57Kiran Stacey: there is a 10-point plan from caracom which is the group of countries that are that are pushing for reparations and the first of these is for a formal state apology and the 10th of these is for a financial payment yeah and there's been well they haven't put a figure on it there has been various bits of work done by academics and by campaigners over the years, which suggests that you could be somewhere in the region of$7 trillion upwards. So it's a huge amount of money, which would obviously bankrupt the UK and practically is not something which anybody really thinks is possible. But CARICOM's point is that there's a series of other measures that could be introduced up until that point.

5:39Kiran Stacey: And it's certainly something which some particularly left-wing Labour MPs, people like Diane Abbott, Clive Lewis, have called for, and that governments over many years have resisted, not least because there is some concern in Whitehall that if you start off with a formal apology, then you open the doors to legal action potentially, and that could be in international courts, which could put the UK in a much more difficult position. And I thought it was really interesting how Kemi Badenok was saying, well, if you're going to ask the UK for financial reparations, that you also need to look at the African nations, in some cases the leaders involved in basically exporting people, and also some of the Middle Eastern nations which were heavily involved in slave trading.

6:23Kiran Stacey: The difference being, of course, that these African countries, many of them were part of the British Empire or the French and Spanish empires, and therefore they were subjugated anyway and were potentially just doing what their colonial masters expected. And Kemi Badenoch has said, look, Tony Blair apologised 20 years ago for the UK's historic role. Why does Andy Burnham need to do it again? In fact, I was looking earlier today at a piece that we wrote in The Guardian almost exactly 20 years ago on this apology from Tony Blair and it included criticism for him not actually issuing a formal apology.

7:00Kiran Stacey: It was more sorrow and regret, if you like. So it's a very dark period. People obviously argued that the UK did a huge amount to abolish the transatlantic slave trade, but they were also key instigators of it in the first place. And I think there are lots of people who feel very, very uncomfortable, understandably about that.

7:19Pippa Crerar: Where I think this is important, apart from the kind of detailed debates about how long back in the past you go when you're looking for who should be to blame for what, is that we are not good in this country about talking about the legacy of empire. Every so often there's an attempt to do so. Somebody will write a book. We have a public conversation about it, but it is not woven into the curriculum like it is in other countries, like other countries kind of confront their history. We are very bad at it. And it just really interested me to see Kemmy Baden-Ock saying that the British empire was a good thing.

7:53Pippa Crerar: I don't think you would see that in many other countries with large empires. And let me just take you through some of the stats. You know, she says it was a good thing people talk about, for instance, the Indian railways as one of the great legacies of empire. Well, India is a country I do know a little bit about. India, back in the 1750s, before the British Empire, contributed about 25 % to world GDP. After the Brits left, it was 4%. India, millions of people were starved as a result of British policies under Winston Churchill in Bengal. In the 20 years after the Brits left India, infant mortality went down sanitation improved the economy improved life expectancy improved almost every measure of quality of life got better after the brits left and that is the kind of conversation we're just really bad at having in this country and kemi badenock again is kind of shutting it down that

8:48Kiran Stacey: was exactly the sort of argument although for african and more recently obviously uh caribbean nations that we'll be hearing a lot of in the next few days however we won't be there ourselves we We're very lucky at The Guardian that we've got a Caribbean correspondent, brilliant Natasha Duncan, who's going to be on the ground for us in Antigua. But Andy Burnham, rather unusually for a British prime minister, hasn't taken a press pack with him. A large group of journalists who cover politics day in, day out, normally travel with the prime minister. Instead, he's taking a small pool of reporters, which means that the scope of questions will be limited and opportunities to hold the prime minister to account, for him to be transparent about what's going on there on the ground in the Caribbean will also be limited.

9:30And that's something that, you know, we, me personally, as a political journalist,

9:35Kiran Stacey: but we as The Guardian as well, feel quite strongly about that we need to be given the opportunities to have that sort of access and to report on our Prime Minister when he's representing the UK overseas, you know, with issues of such magnitude. But while he's away in the Caribbean, back home, Shabana Mahmood, his Home Secretary, has been left to make one of the most difficult announcements probably of Andy Burnham's time in government so far. And I think quite a lot of people will notice the fact that he's not sitting next to her at the dispatch box when she makes her a statement this afternoon on her plans for migration, specifically on indefinite leave to remain.

10:13Kiran Stacey: So it's a year Kieran St. Jabana Mood first made her policy announcement about the The qualifying periods that would be required for people to get ILR is currently five years. And the plan would be that it would go up to 10 years for most people, although 15 years for some of those in lower skilled occupations. That immediately kicked off a big debate around care workers. Obviously, the UK social care system is on its knees. And part of that is about having people that are able and willing to do those sorts of jobs, very reliant on care workers coming from overseas. There's also concern among some on the left that the plan for some of these policies to be brought in retrospectively are not fair.

11:00Kiran Stacey: And the reason they're being brought in retrospectively is to address what's become known as the Boris wave, the large numbers of people, 1.6 million people between 2022 and 2024 that arrived in this country who by 2027 would qualify for permanent status under the existing plans. That's a huge number of people. Potentially, it would cost the state a huge amount of money. Of course, there's arguments about what people also contribute to the state. So these were Keir Starmer's plans. Andy Burnham said he would be bringing a new pair of eyes to them when he took over as prime minister. And indeed, at party conference, Shabana Mood, as well as announcing some refugee settlement schemes, also signalled that there might be a potential rethink, acknowledging that some elements of the reforms were not seen as fair.

11:45Kiran Stacey: So we're going to hear the final decision today.

11:47Pippa Crerar: Yeah, we revealed back in the summer that this was something that Andy Burnham was considering watering down because he was making a big speech on the care sector and how he wants to set up a national social care service. And the obvious question that followed from that was, well, what are you going to staff it with? Who are you going to staff it with? Because if you see a sudden departure of a lot of care workers out of this country because you've changed the route to settled status, then you're simply not going to be able to achieve your own plans. And that is why we are now talking about exempting care workers or potentially changing some of the rules for care workers.

12:23Pippa Crerar: Let's just kind of run through the details of what these plans say. Basically, at the moment, you have to wait five years, as you say, Pippa, from coming into the country to be eligible for settled status. And that allows you to remain here indefinitely and get access to public funds, including benefits. What Shabana Mahmood wants to do is make that five years a default 10 years, including, as you say, for people already in the country. But for care workers specifically, make it 15 years. And one of the reasons they want to make it harder for care workers rather than easier than other sectors is because a lot of these people will, once they get recourse to public funds, claim universal credit.

13:00Pippa Crerar: And the reason for that is wages are so low in the care sector that they have to be topped up. Their wages have to be topped up to be able to basically live in this country. So Shabana Mahmood is right and the Home Office is right that this will in the short term be a net drain on the public finances.

13:17Kiran Stacey: This is 600 ,000 people in that two-year period that I mentioned who came in. Well, 600 ,000 care workers and their dependents. So that is a total number. So that's a big chunk of people.

13:28Pippa Crerar: Home Office says it will cost£10 billion. I mean, that's a pretty high number. There are think tanks out there. The IPPR this morning was saying actually there's a net benefit to the economy only over the lifetime of those people. You know, it's difficult for politicians to think in entire lifetimes when they're facing a fiscal crunch as it is. So you can understand why the Home Office is trying to change it. But Labour MPs are not happy.

13:52Kiran Stacey: OK, well, let's pause here for a minute. When we come back, we'll talk about how these plans might be welcomed or not by Labour MPs and beyond.

14:06Kiran Stacey: There's no such thing as democracy. What there is is performance.

14:10Pippa Crerar: Around the world, politics is in a tense, dangerous place.

14:14Kiran Stacey: We understand fascism to be a response to crises, and it always is. It always emerges in moments of systemic crisis.

14:22Pippa Crerar: From the rise and rise of the far right and Silicon Valley bros, to the cost of living crisis and the climate emergency. How do we make sense of it all? All politics is identity politics. It's just when people do it on the lines of race that it gets naff. In the new series, I speak to some of the biggest thinkers on how we got into this mess and how we get out of it. That to me is not endorsing different points of views. It's not platforming dangerous views. It is understanding human beings and their motivations and their intentions. From The Guardian, this is Radical Thinking with me, Adit Chakraborty.

14:55Pippa Crerar: Out now in your Politics Weekly feeds.

15:01Pippa Crerar: 500 orders a month was manageable. 5 ,000 is madness. Turn fulfillment chaos into total calm. ShipStation is the all-in-one platform to run your shipping operation as you scale. Sync inventory from everywhere you sell. Put warehouse workflows on autopilot. And lock in the lowest rates from 200-plus parcel carriers and 50-plus freight providers, saving serious money while getting packages out faster. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days.

15:31Kiran Stacey: Cash Now More Later from Opendoor gives you cash up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now, this is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash Now More Later, now available nationwide.

15:54Pippa Crerar: Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility, and offer price may vary.

16:28Pippa Crerar: One purchase equals one donated. Always.

16:45Kiran Stacey: Welcome back. Now, Kieran, Andy Burnham is, of course, not going to be around for this announcement. Some of his MNPs might be a bit unhappy that it's happening when he's out of the country, Because, of course, this is something that we were expecting the first week back after the summer. And then several moments since that we've been anticipating the announcements to come. Is it just coincidence that he's, I think some of them will be asking whether it's just coincidence that it's happened when he's not here to answer questions about it. But it is undoubtedly going to be one of the trickiest policy moments of his time as prime minister so far.

17:21Kiran Stacey: I mean, these announcements were first made down to Keir Starmer, as we said, a year ago. And the political backdrop more broadly is different. Then reform was much more of a threat. Lots of Labour MPs were very anxious about any policy to do with immigration and how it would go down mostly in sort of some of these red wool seats with very, very small majorities. and as such, Shabana Mahmood with her sort of brand of blue Labour politics, a very sort of what she would describe as pragmatic approach to migration. Some in the Labour Party feel that she's quite to the right on migration. There was maybe more of an appetite amongst a sort of a big chunk of Labour and peace for sounding tough.

18:00Kiran Stacey: Now that Andy Burnham's come in and has sort of reunited that progressive coalition and also reform is obviously experiencing its own troubles at the moment, it's obviously fallen hugely in the polls. There's a feeling inside the Labour Party that that gives them the space they would feel to be a bit more progressive when it comes to migration. And we heard a little bit of that, as I say, from Shabana Mahmood at conference when she was talking about resettlement routes in. But there will still be a lot of what she announces today, particularly the retrospective element that the unions and that some on the left of the party feel very uncomfortable about and still don't think that it's fair.

18:39Kiran Stacey: And given that reform are not quite seen as being as much of a current threat as they were a year ago, that may give some of those Labour MPs who are really concerned about this the courage to maybe speak out a bit more than they might have done a year ago.

18:53Pippa Crerar: Well, it already has. I mean, Angela Raynaud is out there on the record talking about how she opposes the changes to care workers. That was both before she came back into the cabinet and after. She's doubled down on that position. She's made it very clear. You and I were talking to Miata Fambula at a conference, the Energy Secretary, who interestingly comes from a family of refugees. And she was talking about just how tough she thought that these changes would be for people already in the country. So in a way, Andy Burnham coming in has given people, even at the very top of government, license to talk openly about their reservations about this policy.

19:26Pippa Crerar: And we should say as well, it's not just this policy. It's a lot of what Shabana Mahmood is trying to do with the migration system. So we wrote a story last week saying that many ministers were concerned about asylum policies in particular and the fact that the government is changing its legal duty so it no longer has a duty to stop asylum seekers falling into destitution. And they worry that that could actually add to homelessness. In fact, there was a major row about this in the previous government where two ministers, one of whom was Miata Fambula herself, tried to get some details out of the Home Office on what this would mean for homelessness and were basically denied those figures.

20:05Pippa Crerar: But it's interesting that we're hearing about all of this now under Andy Burnham. And I do suspect that's because those people who have been quietly opposed to Shabana Mahmood's plans now feel like they have license to speak out. And that's going to be difficult for Burnham to kind of put back in its box.

20:24Kiran Stacey: Yeah. And this is likely, of course, to rumble on beyond just today. And inevitably, you've got Prime Minister's questions on Wednesday and there'll be other moments in the weeks ahead where MPs will have a chance to challenge him directly when he will be in the room. There is not any primary legislation required or any votes expected on these plans. So there's not necessarily going to be a big showdown moment where Labour rebels are lining up on one side and the government's lining up on another. But if we've learned anything about politics in recent years, is that MPs find a way to make their discontent known on the floor of the House of Commons, whether that's through opposition day debates, whether that's through very clever amendments to other legislation on a similar theme.

21:09Kiran Stacey: So it is unlikely to go away and burn him just because Shibana Mahmood has announced it doesn't mean that that's the end of the story. I think also a lot of his own MPs will be wanting to know what he really thinks because none of us are entirely clear, right? I mean, I remember sitting in a car with him in Makerfield during the by-election campaign, talking about migration and him praising Shibana Mahmood and saying he thought she was doing a good and very difficult job. and reminding me that he was Tony Blair's minister for sending people home, as he put it. I don't think that was his formal title at the time, but just a sort of a gentle reminder that he wasn't afraid of actually coming across as quite tough on migration.

21:49Kiran Stacey: And then yet the only comments we've had from him in recent days is in an interview he's done with ITV, where he told Dan Hewitt, the journalist, that he just reminded him that numbers were coming down, both legal, regular migration, which is approaching zero. And there's a whole big economic question there that we should get into another time on the impact of that. But also irregular migration. The numbers, of course, small boats are falling, but really didn't sort of give away any particular insight into which way he was leaning. So it feels like there's a bit of a moment of reckoning still to come with the prime minister and what he himself thinks is the future for this government's policies of migration.

22:32Pippa Crerar: Right, well, look, that's all from us today. Thanks for listening. If you haven't already, please like and follow Politics Weekly to make sure you keep getting our episodes in your feed. And if you enjoy the podcast, then why not leave us a review? And also keep your emails coming. If you have any questions about Shabana Mahmood's plans, please email us on politicsweeklyuk at theguardian.com. This episode was produced by Madeleine Flack. Music by Axel Kukutie and the executive producer Ismaz Ebtaraj. Bye-bye. Goodbye. This is The Guardian.

23:25Pippa Crerar: and over 200 other marketplaces, integrations, and carriers within one platform. Manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all in one place, automatically. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free.

23:44Kiran Stacey: Cash Now, More Later from Opendoor gives you cash up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now. Pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now more later. Now available nationwide.

24:07Pippa Crerar: Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary.

From the publisher
As home secretary Shabana Mahmood announces her controversial migration plans, Pippa Crerar and Kiran Stacey discuss the political context that has led to this announcement and why the timing for Andy Burnham – who is out of the country – is very convenient for him. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/politicspod

More from Politics Weekly UK

All episodes